Ray William Johnson: True Story Podcast - The Biggest Scandal in Horse Racing History

Episode Date: April 20, 2025

The Fine Cotton racing scandal is one of Australia's most infamous cases of horse racing fraud, involving a horse switch scheme gone disastrously wrong in 1984.A syndicate of gamblers, led by John Gillespie, planned to substitute a slow racehorse named Fine Cotton with a faster, lookalike horse named Bold Personality to win a race at Brisbane’s Eagle Farm Racecourse. The idea was to bet big on the long-shot and cash in when the faster horse won. However, the two horses looked nothing alike, so in a last-minute panic, they dyed Bold Personality’s coat and used hair dye and white paint to fake identifying markings.

Nothing brings people together quite like Team USA at the Olympic Winter Games. From NBC Universal's iconic storytelling to the innovative technology across Xfinity and Peacock, Comcast brings the Olympic Games home to America, sharing every moment with millions. When Team USA steps onto the world stage, people aren't just watching. They're cheering together. This winter, everyone is all on the same team. Comcast, proud partner of Team USA. Badlands, now streaming on Hulu and Hulu on Disney Plus.

Here, you're not the predator. You're the prey, prey, prey, prey, prey, prey, prey, prey. Critics are saying it's epic, stunning, and breathtaking. Many have come here. None have survived. Predator Badlands, now streaming on Hulu and Hulu on Disney Plus, rated PG-13. So this guy is about to pull off one of the biggest scandals in horse racing history. Now the guy's name is John and John is Australian and bro is just kind of a turd.

He's always trying to con people, he's been convicted a ton of times for it and now he's in prison. But one day in 1984 he's chilling in his cell or whatever and he comes up with a crazy idea to con a ton of people and make more money than he's ever made in his life. He's going to finesse a horse race. So, as soon as he gets out of prison, he buys a really fast racing horse, a horse named Dashing Solitaire. Then he buys a slow-ass racing horse, a horse who's terrible with a bad racing record and who's never won anything. This horse, named Fine Cotton.

So now he's got a fast horse and a slow horse, but the important thing is that they both look like. And his plan is to enter the slow horse, the one with a bad racing record, into a big horse race, so that the odds stack up against it. Then at the last second, he's going to swap out the slow horse for the much faster horse. Then the fast horse will win the race, and he'll make a ton of money by betting on himself. Not a bad plan. What could possibly go wrong? Well, a lot can go wrong. So he and some goons of his, they enter this slow horse, finally, cotton in a big upcoming race and John well he's not the smartest guy a smart guy would enact this plan and not tell anyone about it for fear of getting caught

but that's not the kind of guy John is John is out here blabbing and telling all kinds of people he's got this scheme going on including some very powerful people and allegedly some mafia types so all of these people including the mafia types they know he's pulling this scam, and they're all about to bet on this horse and make themselves some money. However, a few days before the big race, they run into a problem. Dashing Solitaire, the fast horse, the horse that's supposed to win him the race, he's just chilling outside in his corral doing horsey things, whatever horses do.

And suddenly, boom, some wild kangaroos appear out of nowhere. And dashing Solitaire is like, oh shit! And he gets spooked, and he runs away. and kapow, he gets tangled up in some barbed wire. So now he's injured and he can no longer compete in the big race, so dashing solitaire is out. And so John is like, damn it, now what am I going to do? The race is in a few days and I need to find a fast horse.

And like all these powerful people are now involved, including the mob, and they're expecting to bet on this. So like he can't back out now. So with only a few days to go, the clock is ticking and he's got to find a new ringer. So he looks around for anyone selling horses. And boom, he finds one. This horse named Bold Personality. So John buys Bold Personality because that's pretty much all that there is available on such short notice.

But here's the problem with bold personality. Remember, these two horses are supposed to look alike so that he can swap them out at the last minute. But bold personality looks nothing like fine cotton. Fine cotton is a dark chocolate brown, almost black, while bold personality is a much lighter brown. Also, fine cotton has white hair around his feet, the way a cat would have socks. But bold personality doesn't have socks. And John, he's not worried. He's just like, no problem.

We'll just die the horse. So then one night, he and two of his goons, they buy a ton of Clareol women's hair dye, and they rub it all over bold personality, hoping to change the color of his coat to be the same color of fine cotton's coat. The thing is, horse hair is not the same as human hair, and the dye reacts to it differently. So the next morning, they wash out all the dye,

and they see that bold personality is now bright, orangish red. And so they're like, oh, shit, what are we going to do now? Our horse is orange. And so they get a bunch of shorthy. shampoo and they spend hours shampooing out the dye the best they can and they get bold personality mostly back to his original color and after some debate i guess they decide that no one will notice bold personality is a different shade of brown than fine cotton let's just make sure he has the white socks and so how are they going to give their horse white hair around his feet spray paint and so

they go get some white spray paint and they paint the area around his feet white and it looks all sloppy and there's like paint dripping down on the hooves and they try and wash it off but it doesn't work and so they're just like ah fuck it and they end up wrapping his hooves in bandages to cover the bad paint job that they just did until they can get into the race and so then finally the big day comes the day of the race and john and his goons they head off to the racetrack in brisbane with their spray painted horse bold personality in tow and so they get there and they check in with spray-painted bold personality, and they're all like,

this is my horse, fine cotton. And bold personality, aka fake fine cotton, actually passes the pre-check where they inspect the horses. I guess they don't notice any of the spray paint. But whatever, John and the guys are now home-free. And Fine Cotton, the real Fine Cotton,

he has such a bad racing record that the betting house calculates his odds of winning at 33 to 1, which is great because for every dollar that John bets he'll get 33 back. And so they all bet on their horse. And now all they need is for fake fine cotton to win the race. Here's the thing about this race. This particular race is actually a special race made for some of the older, slower horses in a different category, once who have a track record of never winning. So fake fine cotton, who is a very fast horse, should be able to win this

with no problem. And so boom, the race starts and all the horses take off and fake fine cotton immediately runs all the way to the front of the pack. No problem. And he is neck and neck with another horse, but he can't quite pull ahead. One of the other horses ends up actually being pretty fast. And John and the other guys, they're all watching from the sideline like, go, go, win. I don't want the mob to unalive me. And this race, it stays tight, like really tight and the two horses near the finish line and fake fine cotton still can't pull ahead and they end up right next to each other neck and neck and then boom they cross the finish line and it's so close that it's actually a photo finish bold personality aka fake fine cotton is the one right here and he

ends up winning and so now john his crew and everyone who he told about this scam is about to be rich Until. Fake Fine Cotton, aka Bold Personality, he won the race, but it was still a pretty tough run. And Bro is sweating like crazy now, like someone who just ran a race tends to do. And so he's sweating and spectators in the audience they notice something is off about him. Like it seems like there's white paint dripping down his hooves. Well, isn't that weird? And by this time, word has spread around the track that Fine Cotton

Well, he isn't fine cotton at all. He's actually a ringer, or a ring-in, as they call it, because John's dumb ass told so many people. And so the crowd, they get mad, and they start chanting, Ring-in, ring-in! And they're all calling for the stewards to come inspect fake fine cotton. And the stewards notice all this paint on his hooves, too, and they can't let this slide.

And so they're like, stop the payouts! And the track stops paying out the winning betters. until they can get all of this sorted out. And so the stewards give a full inspection of fake fine cotton, and they ask John for fine cotton's papers. And of course, John doesn't have them, and fake fine cotton fails the inspection, because it's a different horse.

And boom, he is officially disqualified, and the horse that came in second place is actually declared the winner. While John, his goons, and everyone else he told, didn't win any money. And so eventually, bam, police arrest John. Here's a picture of him in real life. And he gets four years in prison and a lifetime ban from Australian horse racing,

while one of the other guys gets six months, and another guy gets six months, and another guy gets eight months. That is wild.