Ray William Johnson: True Story Podcast - The Con Man Who Faked His Own Death - The Samuel Israel Story

Episode Date: November 15, 2025

Samuel Israel III was a New York hedge fund manager who founded the Bayou Hedge Fund Group in 1996 and orchestrated one of the largest financial frauds of the early 2000s. After years of falsifying trading records and using a fake accounting firm to hide losses, Israel’s $300 million Ponzi scheme collapsed in 2005 when investors tried to withdraw their money. Facing charges of fraud and conspiracy, he was sentenced to 20 years in prison. In a bizarre twist, just before reporting to prison in 2008, Israel staged his own death.

On December 12, Disney Plus invites you to go behind the scenes with Taylor Swift in an exclusive six-episode docu-series. I wanted to give something to the fans that they didn't expect. The only thing left is to close the book. The End of an Era. And don't miss Taylor Swift, the era's tour, the final show, featuring for the first time the tortured poets department. Streaming December 12, only on Disney Plus. So this guy is dead. Or, or maybe he's just faking the whole thing.

Now the guy's name is Samuel. And Samuel's 36 when this story starts and he's living in New York. But here's the thing about Samuel. He works as a traitor at some big firm on Wall Street. And he comes from a wealthy family that's already made of fortune. So Samuel feels like he's got a reputation to live up to. He wants to make as much money as his family did. and nothing is going to stop him, not even the law.

So one day in 1995, he decides he's done working for other people. He wants to do his own thing and start his own hedge fund. So that's what he does. He quits his job and he starts one. But Samuel runs into a problem. His hedge fund is brand new. And if people are going to hand their money over to him, he needs a good reputation. Like people need to trust him.

So he decides the best way to get him. a good reputation is to just fake it. So he starts lying. He lies to investors, he exaggerates his work history and his past roles at other companies. He tells potential investors that he's managed massive sums of money before when he apparently wasn't. And surprisingly, this actually works. People believe him. I guess he must be a good bullsh-shoulders because investments start pouring in. By 1996, Samuel raises a whopping 300, million dollars for his hedge fund. And so now, now that he's in charge of all this money, for some reason, he decides to take things even further and tell a much bigger lie. He starts

telling his investors that he's developed a unique special trading system, one that's so effective that in a decade it could turn that $300 million into $4 billion, which would be roughly like a 30% annual return, which is just ridiculous and unheard of. Like this should have been a massive red flag to these investors. But I guess these investors don't really think that deep about it. They're just like, okay, sounds legit. And so everything looks good. Investors are happy and the hedge fund appears to be making money. So now with millions in the bank, Samuel sets himself up with an extravagant office with nice new computers, expensive decor, and he's even got an aquarium filled with exotic snakes.

And he himself is living large. Like he buys himself a new boat and multiple cars and he rents a big ass mansion for $32,000 a month. Damn. Not to mention, bro, is also drinking and doing a lot of drugs and just having the time of his life. Good for him. But then, more time passes. And it's now 1998. And something crazy happens.

Samuel's hedge fund suddenly suffers a major loss. and some of the investors' money gets wiped out. But instead of coming clean, Samuel decides to hide these losses and lie to his clients. And he starts covering everything up and making it look like his business is going fine. Because the truth is that his unique special trading system isn't really working. It's in fact losing everyone money. So Samuel starts falsifying reports to cover it all up. And that is when he turns to this guy, Dan Marino.

Dan Marino is an accountant who works with Samuel. And together, they create their own fake auditing firm to make all the hedge funds finances look legit and profitable. And believe it or not, this actually works. They make their fake reports look all professional and convincing, and no one seems to suspect that anything shady is going on behind the scenes. So with these fake reports making every single, look good, more investors start pouring in. And pretty quickly, Samuel starts operating the hedge fund

as a Ponzi scheme, using new investors' money to pay off the old investors. However, even running it as a Ponzi scheme, Samuel's hedge fund still keeps losing his investors money. Jeez, this guy is really bad at this. In fact, by 2002, the hedge fund had lost around $55 million. of investors' money. And so now, Samuel, he's running out of ways to keep this scheme going. And here is where the story gets really wild. Because it's at this point that things in Samuel's life start falling apart. Not only is he running out of ideas to keep his hedge fund afloat, but he develops chronic back pain, and he starts taking painkillers to help with that, and he gets all addicted to the painkillers. This is not going to end well for him. But then, in

2004, he finally gets a little hope. He meets a man who promises to help turn things around for him. This guy, Shea. And Shea is actually a con artist. But he doesn't tell Samuel that. No, no. He tells him that he is an ex-CIA officer who knows about some top secret government investment projects that only very few people know about. Not only that, but he claims that if Samuel invests his money with him, that he will double it in just two weeks. And crazy enough, Samuel believes Shea. He's like, wow, two weeks? And like you would expect someone who had been a trader for over a decade to not fall for a scam like this,

but I guess at this point in the story, Samuel's just really desperate. So he wires Shay $10 million of investors' money. Then he wires him even more. And within weeks, he empties all of the hedge fund's accounts, and he transfers nearly $150 million to Shea. So what does Shea the con man do with all this money? Well, he of course disappears. And that is when Samuel realizes that he's been conned.

And with no money left and no way to pay his investors back, he decides it's finally time to shut everything down. So he writes a letter to all his investors saying that he's closing the hedge fund because he wants to spend more time with his family, but he tells them not to worry that he'll send them all their money back soon. But, of course, he can't send them all their money back. He doesn't have any of it. He lost a bunch of it trading,

and he lost the rest of it when Shay the con man ran off with it. But whatever, Samuel sends this letter, and then he goes completely off the radar. And some time passes. And at some point, his investors start to realize that they never got their money back. And they start wondering if Samuel, rip them off. And so they start freaking out. And soon enough, multiple federal agencies get involved

and they start investigating his hedge fund and it doesn't take long for them to realize that Samuel had been running a big, fat Ponzi scheme all along. And so by 2005, the feds track him down and bam, they arrest him. Here's his mugshot. And ultimately, he pleads guilty to fraud and he's sentenced to 20 years in prison. So now it seems like he's going to be locked up for good and he'll finally have to pay for the crimes that he's committed. Until. Okay, now here's the thing about his sentencing.

At the time, Samuel is struggling with some health problems. So the judge actually decides to be lenient and he allows him to remain free for about two months before reporting to prison, you know, in order to get his affairs in order. But see, Samuel, he doesn't, want to spend the next 20 years of his life locked up. He's got a whole other plan in mind. He decides to fake his own death and disappear and start a new life somewhere else. So on the day

that he's supposed to turn himself in to report to prison, he just doesn't show up. Instead, he drives to a local bridge and he writes suicide is painless on the dusty hood of his SUV, suggesting that he's about to unalive himself, and then he just disappears, making people think that he jumped off the bridge. And then later, police find his abandoned SUV, and they assume that he unalived himself, and they send the rescue team down to recover his body and everything, but days go by, and they don't find anything, nobody, or no other sign of Samuel.

And that is when they realized that he had actually staged his death, and that he is really on the run. And so they release a warrant for his arrest, and three weeks go by. And Sam finally just, I guess he just gives up and turns himself in. So on top of his original sentence, he gets an extra two years for trying to escape.