Real Dictators - Introducing: Detectives Don’t Sleep - The Nazi Art Mystery (Part 1 of 3)

Episode Date: April 17, 2023

The makers of Real Dictators present a brand-new podcast: Detectives Don’t Sleep. Step beyond the police tape to shadow the real detectives who worked history’s most intriguing cases. In this tast...er episode, we’re hot on the heels of international art detective Arthur Brand. He is hunting down a pair of lost statues… Two giant bronze horses that were once beloved by none other than Adolf Hitler. But a case of missing artworks quickly spirals into something far more dangerous - a deadly neo-Nazi conspiracy… If you enjoy this taster episode, search ‘Detectives Don’t Sleep’ in your podcast app and hit follow to get new episodes every Tuesday. Part 2 of the Nazi Art Mystery is live now on the Detectives Don’t Sleep podcast. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

Transcript
Discussion (0)
Starting point is 00:00:00 Hi listeners. While the team puts the finishing touches to the next season of Real Dictators, here's a taste of a brand new podcast from Noisa. If you enjoy detective shows and crime mysteries on TV, then you will love Detectives Don't Sleep. It's the new Whodunit podcast. Detectives Don't Sleep takes you beyond the police tape to shadow the real detectives who worked history's most intriguing cases. The show features true crime stories from all over the world and from different historical periods. In the Taster episode you're about to hear, you'll be hot on the heels of international art detective Arthur Brand. He's hunting down a pair of lost statues, two giant bronze horses that were once beloved by none other than Adolf Hitler. What starts as a case of missing artworks soon snowballs into something else entirely, a deadly neo-Nazi conspiracy.
Starting point is 00:00:56 If you enjoy this Taster episode, search Detectives Don't Sleep in your podcast app and hit follow to get new episodes every Tuesday. Or listen at Noiser.com. Part 2 of the Nazi Art Mystery is live now on the Detectives Don't Sleep podcast. It's February, 2014. As his plane touches down at Pisa Airport, Arthur Brand shifts uncomfortably in his seat. At 6'3", he has to squeeze himself into the limited legroom available on a short-haul flight. He's impatient to be on his way, but the fastened seatbelt sign is still glowing.
Starting point is 00:01:46 Arthur is a freelance art detective, an expert who specializes in recovering stolen artifacts and exposing forgeries. His resume is impressive and wide-ranging. For example, in 2008 he helped recover treasure dating from 250 AD that had been looted from an archaeological site in Peru. The find made headlines around the world, with more than a thousand objects worth over 60 million euros in total. You may have heard of it. million euros in total. You may have heard of it. At 45, the bespectacled Dutchman may not be the archetypal detective in a trench coat and fedora. He seems more used to the inside of an art gallery than the mean streets, but it would be a mistake to underestimate Arthur. He's worked with Scotland
Starting point is 00:02:41 Yard, the Italian Carabinieri, the Dutch, German, and Spanish police, Interpol, have his number on speed dial. The reason he's so much in demand is that there just aren't that many people who do his job. As he himself jokes, I am the best art detective, but I am the only art detective. Some call him the Indiana Jones of the art world. If the story you're about to hear is anything to go by, it's an apt description. As soon as the seatbelt sign goes off, Arthur springs to his feet.
Starting point is 00:03:19 All around him, the other passengers are taking their belongings down from the overhead lockers, excited that their holidays are about to begin. But Arthur is traveling light. He's determined to be on the soonest possible flight back to Amsterdam. He's not here for the sun or the ice cream, or to appreciate the countless Renaissance masterpieces that Tuscany is home to. The truth is, he doesn't really know why he's here.
Starting point is 00:03:47 The whole trip may be a wild goose chase, which is why he's keen to get it all over with as quickly as possible. It all started when he received a tantalizing call from a former art smuggler named call from a former art smuggler named Michelle Van Ryn. These days, Van Ryn is going straight and spends his time tipping off various police forces about potential art crimes. I'm onto something amazing, really mind-blowing. Take it from me, it'll never get any bigger than this, Van Ryn had said. Arthur was intrigued. I mean, wouldn't you be? But Van Ryn had refused to give away more over the phone, insisting that they meet in person. Arthur has known Van Ryn for about 15 years. When he first started out in the art world, Van Ryn saved him from making some costly mistakes. He was a useful contact to have, not least because of his criminal connections.
Starting point is 00:04:53 Arthur is one of the first off the plane. A few delicate wisps of cloud are painted onto an intense blue sky, creating an effect that Titian would have been proud of. Van Rijn has arranged for a driver to pick Arthur up at the airport and deliver him to his home in Livorno, 22 kilometers south of Pisa. It's a hair-raising journey, but Arthur is delivered in one piece. He approaches the doorway of a five-story apartment building and scans the residents' names. As he expects, the name Van Ryn is not on the list,
Starting point is 00:05:37 though this is the address he's been given. Since turning police informer, Van Ryn's made many enemies, some of whom have made no secret of their desire to see him dead. Arthur presses the bell for Professor Richardson, Van Ryn's current alias. Van Ryn's assistant buzzes Arthur in. Arthur enters the cool, dark interior. Everything seems peaceful, but the man he's about to meet is a seasoned risk-taker. He's survived a mafia assassination attempt and being shot at by Yugoslavian gangsters.
Starting point is 00:06:20 Whatever he's mixed up in, danger is never far away. Whatever he's mixed up in, danger is never far away The sensible thing to do would be to turn around, walk away And get the next available flight back to Holland Not for the first time in his life, Arthur Brand doesn't do the sensible thing Though he has no idea what he's getting into He keeps walking. Ahead of him lies a year-long journey full of twists and turns, danger and deceit. He'll meet shady art dealers, be kidnapped by mysterious femme fatale, make small talk with a neo-Nazi,
Starting point is 00:07:07 femme fatale, make small talk with a neo-Nazi, chase down communist criminals, and doorstep Himmler's daughter, as he follows a trail that takes him ever deeper into a sinister hidden world. He'll start the journey believing he's looking for a missing artwork, and end it thwarting a modern-day Nazi plot. My name is Mark Dodson, and welcome to Detectives Don't Sleep. Each week, we'll shadow the world's most remarkable sleuths, real detectives who worked extraordinary cases. real detectives who worked extraordinary cases. This week, we're hot on the heels of international art detective Arthur Brand, as he begins the search for a pair of lost statues with a dark history. But a simple case of missing art quickly spirals into something far more dangerous.
Starting point is 00:08:01 A neo-Nazi conspiracy. From Neuser, this is part one of the Nazi art mystery. far more dangerous. A neo-Nazi conspiracy. From Noiser, this is part one of the Nazi art mystery. And this is Detectives Don't Sleep. When Michelle Van Ryn sees Arthur,
Starting point is 00:08:23 a broad smile spreads across his face. With his weathered features, grizzled beard, and unkempt hair, Van Ryn has a slightly piratical look. Though Arthur's own description of his old mentor is, the devil and a saint in one person. Arthur's keen to get down to business. He asks Van Ryn why he's dragged him all this way. Suppose some sensational artwork turned up, Van Ryn teases, something no one was looking for
Starting point is 00:08:57 because everybody thought it had been destroyed in the Second World War. Arthur has a good idea what Van Ryan might be referring to. If this is about the Second World War, it's probably something to do with the many thousands of artworks looted by the Nazis. Van Ryan turns on a projector and treats Arthur to a slideshow. Arthur sees a succession of black and white photographs of Hitler's Reich Chancellery, a monumental government building designed by Albert Speer. The Reich Chancellery came under heavy bombardment from Russian artillery during the Battle of Berlin. The ruins were demolished after the war. Images of the colossal sculptures installed outside the Reich Chancellery flash up. Van Rijn explains that they were works by Hitler's favorite sculptors,
Starting point is 00:09:52 Arno Brecke, Fritz Klempsch, and Josef Torek. Hitler had called for a new art to promote Nazi racial ideology. This was intended to replace the decadent modern art that had flourished during the Weimar Republic, art which Hitler condemned as Jewish and degenerate. One slide shows two immense male nudes by Brecke, standing guard at the entrance to the Reich Chancellery. They represent the twin pillars of Nazism, the party and the army. The next shows a work by Josef Torak, two monumental bronzes called the Striding Horses. They occupied pride of place in front of Hitler's office. Every day, he would look out of his window and gaze at them, taking inspiration from their huge, strutting forms. Like all the sculptures in the Reich
Starting point is 00:10:54 Chancellery, the striding horses were destroyed when the building was reduced to rubble. At least, that's what everyone had assumed. At least, that's what everyone had assumed. As the next slide clicks into place, Arthur can scarcely believe his eyes. It's another image of the striding horses, but unlike all the previous slides, this one is in color. Taken inside a nondescript interior, it shows the horses standing on wooden pallets with a plastic curtain hanging behind them. Two men in modern dress pose in front of the gigantic beasts. It must be a recent photograph, which can only mean one thing. Are you telling me these horses still exist? Arthur demands. Van Ryan shrugs. They
Starting point is 00:11:47 could be forgeries. Van Ryan explains that he was sent the color photograph by a Dutch art dealer called Stephen, who claims that the statues shown in it are the original striding horses by Torak. Stephen, who lives in Antwerp, is representing the current owner of the horses. He's revealed to Van Ryan that his client is the member of a prominent German family, which in the past had links to the Nazi party. He initially approached Van Ryan to find a buyer for the horses, insisting that the deal be kept secret because legally, the horses are the property of the German state. Van Ryan had gone along with Stephen's proposal, hoping to recover the artwork for the government. But Stephen got cold feet and backed out of the
Starting point is 00:12:40 deal. In this kind of highly sensitive, not to say illegal, transaction, it doesn't take much to spook either side. Van Ryn just doesn't know why Stephen pulled out. He can only guess that Stephen doesn't trust him anymore. Now, Van Ryn wants Arthur to pick up where he left off. Now, Van Ryan wants Arthur to pick up where he left off. Arthur's skeptical. The statues in the color photograph must be forgeries. This could all be a giant waste of time.
Starting point is 00:13:20 Van Ryan argues that even if they are forgeries, it's still worth looking into. The seller, who is most certainly an ex-Nazi, or someone with Nazi links, is asking millions of euros for the horses. Is it right that they should profit from this illegal sale? Van Ryn's plan is essentially to scupper the transaction, which will prevent a fortune falling into the hands of Nazis. It's a powerful argument. Okay, says Arthur. I'll give it a shot. As Van Ryn shows him out, he gives him one last chance to change his mind. Those ex-Nazis and their sympathizers are extremely dangerous, he warns. Arthur can't help wondering if that's the real reason Van Ryn wants to involve him. If Arthur is the public face of the negotiations,
Starting point is 00:14:14 he'll be the one with the target on his back. It's hardly a reassuring thought, but by now, it's too late. Arthur is already hooked. Hi again, listeners. If you're enjoying this Taster episode, find Detectives Don't Sleep in your podcast app of choice and hit follow to get weekly episodes. Part 2 of the Nazi Art Mystery is live now and waiting for you. Back in Amsterdam, Arthur has a meeting with his two partners at Ardias,
Starting point is 00:14:58 the research bureau he set up in 2011. The firm acts as consultant to art collectors. If you're spending a million on a masterpiece, you may want to be sure that it's genuine and not stolen. According to the CIA, art crime is the fourth biggest criminal enterprise in the world. Tens of billions of dollars change hands as forgeries, stolen artworks, and looted antiques are traded on the black market. It's hardly surprising when you consider that the value of a single stolen Vermeer is around $300 million. Ardeas specializes in guiding buyers through this potential minefield. They also have a high-profile sideline, investigating heists and recovering lost and stolen artworks.
Starting point is 00:15:48 It's an interesting field to work in, though sometimes the risks can outweigh the rewards. Not surprisingly, organized criminals aren't too happy about having Ardia's meddling with their business dealings. When Arthur tells his partners about Van Ryn's proposal, they're reluctant to take the case on. In their view, the horses in the recent photograph are clearly forgeries. One partner digs up a video clip shot soon after the fall of Berlin, showing the rubble-shroon wasteland that the Reich Chancellery was reduced to. It's impossible to imagine anything surviving that level of devastation. Arthur argues that
Starting point is 00:16:34 there could still be something worth investigating here. Maybe they're not the original statues. Even so, Josef Torak could still be connected to their creation. Arthur finds a photograph of Torak working on a plaster model for a tabletop version of one of the striding horses. Torak made five of these bronze miniatures, perfect copies of the colossal statues outside the Reich Chancellery. He gave the many horses, each around 40 centimeters high, to five prominent Nazis. What if one of Torak's little horses had fallen into the hands of a modern forger? But pieces like this aren't available on the open market. Which means
Starting point is 00:17:27 that someone with close ties to a high-ranking Nazi must be linked to the forgery. It's further evidence that the people behind this transaction
Starting point is 00:17:38 are Nazi sympathizers. For Arthur, the big question is why are they trying to sell the forgeries now? He has a theory, one that he can barely bring himself to voice. In the 24 hours since visiting Van Ryn, Arthur's been doing some intense research. He's dug up information on a highly secretive organization called Silent Assistance. It was founded after the war to help former Nazis escape from Germany, men like Adolf Eichmann, one of the architects of the Holocaust, and Josef Mengele, known as the Angel of Death because of the deadly experiments he carried out in Auschwitz,
Starting point is 00:18:27 it's rumored that silent assistants helped them both flee to Argentina. One of the leading figures in silent assistants is an elderly woman called Gudrun Borovic, maiden name Himmler. Her father was Heinrich Himmler, the former commander-in-chief of the SS. Since the war, Gudrun has devoted her life to restoring her father's honor, as she sees it. In Arthur's view, the so-called Nazi princess may well be linked to the Ford statues. As he explains to his partners, well be linked to the forged statues. As he explains to his partners,
Starting point is 00:19:11 I wouldn't be surprised if one of the five little horses, one of which was likely used for the forgery, had been given to Heinrich Himmler. But if silent assistance is behind the sale of the forged horses, what do they need the money for? Arthur believes they're raising funds to finance something big. Their main work is helping ex-Nazis get out of the country. By now, most of the original old comrades, as they like to call themselves, are dead. But Arthur assures the team that silent assistance is still very much alive. is still very much alive. One unsavory aspect of the organization's current operations is to fund the legal defense of Holocaust deniers. They're also busy growing a new support base to spread their fascist ideology.
Starting point is 00:20:02 Throughout Europe, there's been a rise of fanatical neo-Nazi groups. Silent assistance is fueling that wave of hatred. And to make matters worse, this new generation of Nazis is turning to violence and terrorism. Between 2000 and 2007, a group of German terrorists carried out the so-called kebab murders, killing 10 Germans of Turkish heritage. Two of the perpetrators killed themselves. But the third, a woman, is currently on trial for her part in the murders and other terror attacks. It's one of the biggest trials in German history. attacks. It's one of the biggest trials in German history. Arthur can't prove that silent assistance is funding the woman's defense, but it's just the kind of cause that the group is committed
Starting point is 00:20:53 to supporting. If they are involved in this case, they'll need money, and the sale of the striding horses, whether fake or genuine, would generate a massive injection of cash. This is huge. As one of Arthur's partners says, if there really are former Nazis behind these forged horses, then I'd like to know what they intend to do with those millions. The team discusses strategy. For now, Arthur is against approaching Stephen, the art dealer who is representing the sellers.
Starting point is 00:21:39 He's worried Stephen will connect him with Van Ryn, as it's widely known in the art world that the two have worked together in the past. Instead, Arthur proposes they make contact with neo-Nazis directly. Alright, now let's just pause for a moment here and take all this in. What started as a fairly standard case involving forged or missing art has now turned into something else entirely, a secret Nazi conspiracy. Arthur isn't just trying to track down some lost sculptures. He's gearing up to thwart an extremist plot.
Starting point is 00:22:18 It's not going to be easy, and it'll certainly be dangerous, but it's their only hope of getting closer to whoever is offering the horses for sale. But the question is, how? How do you infiltrate neo-Nazi circles? Arthur thinks he may have a way in. He remembers meeting a diamond merchant who happens to be friends with a prominent neo-Nazi. meeting a diamond merchant who happens to be friends with a prominent neo-Nazi.
Starting point is 00:22:51 What makes the friendship even more unusual is that the diamond merchant is Jewish. Arthur calls Ephraim Levy, the Jewish diamond merchant. Levy gives him the telephone number of his neo-Nazi friend, a man called Horst. Horst is cagey on the phone. Then again, so is Arthur. But when he mentions Ephraim's name, the neo-Nazi warms up.
Starting point is 00:23:21 He agrees to meet. Arthur takes the train to Munich, where Horst lives. He visits him at his apartment in a well-to-do neighborhood. Horst is not what Arthur expected. He's dressed like a respectable businessman, not a skinhead thug. However, Arthur wonders about the silk scarf tied firmly around Horst's neck. He suspects he's wearing it to conceal Nazi-related tattoos. Horst shows Arthur into a mahogany-furnished study, gesturing for him to take a seat. Arthur glances down at the coffee table, where he spots a first edition of Mein Kampf next to the guestbook from the 1935 Nuremberg Rally. It seems that Arthur's on the
Starting point is 00:24:16 right trail. These are extremely rare items. Things like this, they don't come cheap. This man is clearly a serious collector of Nazi artifacts. If anyone knows about Hitler's favorite statues, it's likely Horst does. But Arthur doesn't want Horst to know. He's specifically looking for the horses. There's a chance Horst could alert the sellers, causing them to withdraw the horses from the black market. Instead, he simply tells Horst that he's looking for dealers in Nazi memorabilia. Horst is wary. He believes his apartment is being watched by the BFV, Germany's Secret Service. Maybe he's just naturally cautious. Or maybe he's paranoid. But it seems he doesn't quite trust Arthur yet.
Starting point is 00:25:10 Arthur asks Horst how he knows he's being watched. There are people in the army, the police, and the Secret Service who sympathize with our views, Horst says. Nazis in the police force may sound far-fetched, but there's evidence to support Horst's claim. On December 7, 2022, an attempted far-right coup came to light in Germany. As the New York Times reported, members of the conspiracy included an active-duty soldier, a former officer in the elite special forces, a police officer, and at least two army reservists. Eventually, after a couple of whiskeys and a cigar, Horst begins to relax. He tells Arthur about a secret trade in pillaged Third Reich artworks and memorabilia carried out by the Stasi, East Germany's secret police, after the war.
Starting point is 00:26:11 It was all done with Moscow's approval in order to raise Western hard currency. Think about this. The agents of a communist state selling notorious fascist items. Oh, and there's more. The Stasi even set up their own art dealership, operating out of an East Berlin hotel. Western collectors with an interest in all things Nazi could call up and place their orders.
Starting point is 00:26:42 Since the fall of the Berlin Wall in 1989, the Stasi no longer exists. Their art dealership, Kunst und Antiquitäten, ceased trading. According to Horst, the big players now are the descendants of former Nazis. It seems a good moment to ask Horst about Gudrun Borovitch and her organization, Silent Assistance. Still careful not to reveal the real reason for his interest, Arthur asks if she could be involved in the Nazi memorabilia trade. The question provokes a strange response from Horst. He grows misty-eyed as he thinks about Himmler's daughter. In our circles, Frau Burwitsch is a saint, he tells Arthur. But he warns him never to mention
Starting point is 00:27:35 her name again, for his own safety. That kind of sounds like a bit of a threat, don't you think? Now Arthur's worried he may have blown it. Then Horst writes down the address of a cafe in Munich. He tells Arthur to go there and ask for Dr. Annenerbe. Leave your contact details. If you're lucky, someone will get in touch. With that, the meeting is over. get in touch. With that, the meeting is over. Out on the street, Arthur breathes in deeply. The fresh air is a relief from the oppressive, smoke-filled atmosphere of the neo-Nazi's apartment. He looks around. Is he being filmed right now, as Horst claimed? Or is he just letting the other man's paranoia get to him? These neo-Nazis are a suspicious bunch, clouding themselves in secrecy and anonymity. Take the name Horst has given him, Dr. Ahnenerbe.
Starting point is 00:28:40 It's obviously fake. Ahnenerbe means ancestral heritage in German. It's a word with strong Nazi associations. Project Annenerbe was set up by Himmler in 1935 to provide a bogus scientific basis to Hitler's theories of German racial superiority. Arthur's nervous about meeting anyone calling themselves by that name.
Starting point is 00:29:07 But if he wants to get to the bottom of this mystery, then he's going to have to sit down with some very unsavory and possibly dangerous people. Arthur follows Horst's instructions, leaving his hotel details at the Munich Café. He doesn't reveal his name, however. Two can play at this cloak-and-dagger game. Arthur waits in his hotel room for three days, but hears nothing. It seems the mysterious Dr. Annenerbe doesn't want to talk. Tired of being cooped up, Arthur leaves the hotel to visit the Haus der Kunst, the art gallery built by Hitler to house the propaganda art he loved. One of Torak's original horses
Starting point is 00:30:01 was once displayed there, before it was installed in the Reich Chancery garden. There's no sign of it today. That evening, after dining at Hitler's favorite restaurant, the Asteria Bavaria, Arthur is walking back to his hotel. A cold mist swirls around him, making the darkness even gloomier. He's feeling dejected. The trail has gone cold. He's beginning to think that the trip to Munich has been a big waste of time. Just then, a car pulls up beside him, a black Mercedes.
Starting point is 00:30:40 The tinted passenger window slides down, and a male voice, politely but firmly, directs him to get in. It's one of those pivotal moments in an investigation. Everything hangs in the balance. If he doesn't get in, he could miss out on a vital opportunity to find out about the horses.
Starting point is 00:31:03 If he does get in, who knows? He could even be putting his life at risk. What would you do? Of course, Arthur being Arthur, he gets in. He hears the central locking click shut behind him and immediately regrets his decision. He tries to get out, but realizes he's trapped inside the car as it speeds away. He glances at the driver, but it's hard to see his face in the dark interior.
Starting point is 00:31:37 Are you Dr. Ahnenerbe? he asks. The man doesn't answer. Arthur peeps through the window as they speed along Munich's streets. He's looking for landmarks, trying to find out where he's being taken. But it's night. He soon becomes disoriented. Either you tell me where you're going, or you let me out of the car, he demands. Again, there's no answer.
Starting point is 00:32:04 By now, Arthur's eyes have grown accustomed to the dark. He can see that the man driving him is a physically imposing individual, with a broken nose and a thick neck. It looks like he could handle himself in a fight. Suddenly, the Mercedes turns into the entrance of an underground parking lot. Arthur's seen enough thrillers to know that underground parking lots are often the scene of gang shootouts and brutal murders. The graffiti and flickering lights add a sense of menace. The driver steers the car to the darkest corner of the concrete labyrinth. He kills the engine, cutting off the bright beams of the
Starting point is 00:32:47 car's headlights. A dark, uneasy silence descends. Arthur turns in his seat as a glass panel separating off the rear seats drops down, releasing a faint whiff of perfume. A husky, female voice orders him to keep looking straight ahead. So, this must be Dr. Ananurba. But before Arthur can ask, she has questions of her own. Who are you, and what do you want of me? Arthur has a cover story prepared. He still doesn't reveal his name, but says he's representing a wealthy collector based in Argentina, the son of a high-ranking German officer who escaped to Patagonia after the war. His client is interested in unique Nazi memorabilia, in particular the works of Torak, Brecke, and Klimsch.
Starting point is 00:33:48 He hears Dr. Annenerbe light a cigarette. From the smell of the smoke, menthol. Judging by her next question, Arthur may have made a tactical error trying to conceal his identity. It seems Dr. Anunerva has done her research. Her brand. What do you really want from me? How does she know his name? Obviously, his reputation as an art detective precedes him. That's the one drawback of being good at what he does, fame, especially in the art community. Arthur decides to drop the pretense of having a rich client with Nazi parentage and claims he himself is the one fascinated by Nazi memorabilia. It's big business, after all. He's still wary about telling her what he's really looking for.
Starting point is 00:34:46 The missing horses are such a sensitive subject, he's frightened of scaring her off. But all thought of subterfuge goes out of the window when Dr. Ananurba asks, why should I help you find Yosef Torak's striding horses. Arthur is stunned. The woman explains how she worked it out. The Torak horses have just been offered for sale in the illegal circuit, and suddenly Herbrand turns up? That can't be a coincidence. Arthur is forced to admit she's right. he is looking for the horses. Dr. Annenerbe is dismissive. Doesn't he know they're forgeries? She explains, the trade in top Third Reich items take place in a small closed world.
Starting point is 00:35:37 Since the early 1970s, I've been doing business with families of certain prominent Nazis. If those horses had been real, I would have been the one selling them. It's an odd boast, but he confirms what Arthur and his partners already know. Now Arthur has to be careful not to arouse Dr. Anunerba's suspicions even further.
Starting point is 00:36:07 He can't afford to tell her the real reason he's interested in the statues, to expose the far-right group he believes is behind the sale. He turns the conversation to the miniature horses made by Torak, arguing that they were used as the models for the forgeries. Dr. Annenerbe is impressed. She had independently come to the same conclusion. In all her years dealing in Nazi art, she has only ever seen one of Torak's little horses. It was bought by a Belgian collector. She can't remember his name. Arthur slumps back in disappointment.
Starting point is 00:36:50 A promising lead has come to nothing. And in the most depressing of places, an underground parking lot in Munich. He has the feeling that Annenerbe has been playing a game with him all this time. Why else would she ask him questions to which she already knew the answers? It's obviously some kind of test. And it seems Arthur has passed. Dr. Ananurba tells him that she may have an address for the Belgian collector, which she promises to email him later.
Starting point is 00:37:29 Arthur can only think that it must have been what he said about the miniature horses that persuaded her to cooperate with him. Making that connection prove to Annenerbe that he's no fool. Arthur's heart is thumping as he's dropped off back at his hotel. One short ride has taken him through a whole range of emotions, from fear to exhilaration. But more important than that, it's taken him one step closer to finding out the truth about Torak's horses. True to her word, Dr. Annenerbe sends Arthur the details of an address in Brussels. Arthur takes the train to the Belgian capital to follow up the lead. He finds the address that Dr. Annenerva gave him and rings the bell. But the current occupant of the house
Starting point is 00:38:27 tells him that the man he's looking for moved out a few months earlier, leaving no forwarding address. Just to be sure it's the same man, Arthur asks if he was a collector of Nazi memorabilia. Not surprisingly, he gets the door slammed in his face. Arthur heads back to Amsterdam to decide his next move. He consults the Belgian land registry in hope of tracking down the previous owner. But the records are incomplete and hard to decipher. It seems to be the end of the road, or at least time to put the search for Torak's horses on hold. But try as he may, Arthur can't stop thinking about the horses. All the unanswered questions
Starting point is 00:39:19 that hooked him in the first place keep going round and round in his head. Are the statues genuine? Or clever fakes? If they're fake, who's behind the forgeries? Who's offering them for sale? And what do they intend to do with the money? It's this last question especially that keeps him awake at night and won't let him give up on the case. It keeps him awake at night and won't let him give up on the case. Then it comes to him. What if the guy who slammed the door in his face was the collector he was looking for? Maybe he shouldn't have bandied around the phrase Nazi memorabilia quite so loudly.
Starting point is 00:40:01 Arthur makes another trip to Brussels. This time, he shoves his foot in the door before the owner has a chance to slam it. Reluctantly, the man lets him in, if only to stop Arthur calling out Nazi memorabilia loud enough for the neighbors to hear. The man, whose name is Meis, admits that he is the collector Arthur's looking for, but he denies he's a neo-Nazi. In fact, during the war,
Starting point is 00:40:34 his grandfather was taken hostage by the German occupiers and killed in retaliation for an act of resistance. The more Meis found out about his grandfather's death, the more fascinated he became with this period of history. Mice shows Arthur his extensive collection of Nazi-era paintings and artifacts, but Torak's miniature bronze is nowhere to be seen. Perhaps Dr. Annenurba was wrong.
Starting point is 00:41:06 Or maybe Mice has sold the sculpture? But Mice is a collector, not a dealer. He doesn't strike Arthur as the kind of person who would part with such a rare object for any amount of money. Unless it's been stolen, it must be hidden away somewhere. Another possibility occurs to Arthur.
Starting point is 00:41:30 Could Mice himself be mixed up with the sale of the horses in some way? For all his denials, perhaps Mice is maybe just as much a neo-Nazi as Horst? I mean, after all, if you were involved in an illegal Nazi scam, you'd naturally lie about it to a stranger. Arthur has to find a way to get mice to reveal whether or not he has the miniature. But if he asks him outright, he's afraid the shutters will come down. He opts for a more devious way to get the information out of him. He points to a painting by Hans Schmitz showing a propaganda scene of an Aryan family
Starting point is 00:42:18 seated around a table. Arthur tells Mice that he recognizes the painting from a newsreel clip he's seen of Hitler visiting the gallery where it was housed in 1939. He goes on. A few seconds after Hitler is shown passing that painting, you see him walk past a bronze horse sculpted by Josef Torak, one of the pair that were later placed beneath his study window in the Reich Chancellery. Meis takes the bait. Impressed by Arthur's knowledge, obviously keen to show off to a fellow connoisseur, he takes Arthur into the bedroom, saying, I shouldn't really let you in, but I trust you. Arthur's eyes widen in amazement as he sees what's standing on the bedside table.
Starting point is 00:43:16 A bronze miniature of one of Torak's horses. He may not have found the colossal sculptures that were outside the Reich's chancery, but this could be the closest he'll get to them. Mice lets Arthur pick up the object. It's a strange sensation. The horse is heavier than he expected, and there's no denying it is a beautiful work of art. Mice is evasive about how he came by his horse, but he's keen to impress Arthur with his provenance. He opens up a picture on his laptop showing the inside of Torak's studio with a miniature horse positioned between the legs of one of the giant originals.
Starting point is 00:44:04 The horse Arthur is holding appears identical in every way. Could it be the one used to make the forgeries? Arthur asks Mice if he's ever lent his precious figurine to anyone, say another collector. Mice laughs. The very idea is ridiculous. What's to stop them from making a forgery and keeping the original? So are there any more of the miniatures in circulation?
Starting point is 00:44:34 Mice doesn't think so. If there were, he'd know about it. Arthur believes them. His elation at finding the bronze miniature is replaced by despondency. This really does feel now like the end of the road. The conversation moves to fakes in general. Conversation moves to fakes in general. Mice now shows Arthur an image of a burnt greatcoat he's been offered,
Starting point is 00:45:11 which is supposed to be the one Hitler wore in the bunker. Mice is convinced it's a fake. He seems eager to show off his own detective skills to Arthur. He opens up a video clip of Hitler in the Reich Chancellery Garden, just before he went into the bunker with Eva Braun. The footage shows Hitler awarding the Iron Cross to members of the Hitler Youth. Hitler looks like a defeated man, one who knows that all the future holds for him is death. Like a true collector, MICE is focused on the coat Hitler is wearing,
Starting point is 00:45:49 pointing out the difference between it and the one they've just been looking at. Arthur is familiar with the footage. He's watched it countless times before. But now, he spots something that he's never noticed before. Something no one else in the he's never noticed before. Something no one else in the world has ever noticed before. He gets Mice to pause the video and rewind it a few frames.
Starting point is 00:46:17 Then he leans in to get a closer look. It's true. His eyes don't deceive him. The horses are not there. Arthur tries to keep a lid on his excitement, but the significance of what he's discovered blows the case wide open. The film was shot on March the 20th, 1945. The Battle of Berlin didn't begin in earnest until almost a month later. As the black and white newsreel makes clear, the Reich Chancellery is still standing. And yet, the horses are already gone, which can mean only one thing. Hitler had them removed before the Russian artillery reduced his headquarters and everything in it
Starting point is 00:47:06 to rubble. Arthur's pulse is racing. He hardly dares make the next logical leap. If Hitler got Torak's horses out before the Reich's chancellery was destroyed, the chances are they survived the war. Which means the statue shown in Stephen's color photograph could be genuine after all. Could it be? Arthur is convinced of it, and the hunt for the horses is back on. If you want to know the full story behind Arthur Brand's incredible investigation into Josef Torek's missing sculptures, be sure to check out his book, Hitler's Horses. It's filled with loads of first-person detail that we weren't able to cover in this series.
Starting point is 00:47:59 Pick it up wherever you get your books. In the next episode of Detectives Don't Sleep, we follow Arthur Brand as he continues his search for the missing horses. We travel with him to the site of a former Red Army barracks in East Germany. Will he find proof that the horses were once there? Or, more importantly, a clue to where they are now.
Starting point is 00:48:26 We share his excitement as he makes breakthrough after breakthrough, and share his fears that there are powerful forces who don't want him to find the horses. Is the case too big for him to handle on his own? If so, who can he turn to for help? Join us as we piece together the puzzle. And don't miss our special extra episode in which we talk to Arthur Brand himself. Hear the truth about the hunt for Hitler's horses straight from the horse's mouth. Thanks for listening. If you enjoyed this episode, then you can hear part two of the Nazi art mystery right now.
Starting point is 00:49:13 Just search for Detectives Don't Sleep in your podcast app and hit follow. New episodes every Tuesday.

There aren't comments yet for this episode. Click on any sentence in the transcript to leave a comment.