Real Time with Bill Maher - Ep. #423: Elizabeth Warren, Ernest Moniz
Episode Date: April 29, 2017Bill’s guests are Elizabeth Warren, Ernest Moniz, Nick Hanauer, Rob Reiner, and Tara Setmayer. (Originally aired 4/28/17) See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information. Learn more about your a...d choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript
Discussion (0)
Don't miss the Devil Wears Prada 2 in theaters.
Merrill Street, Ann Hathaway, Emily Blunt, and Stanley Tucci are back.
In light of the recent scandal, I'm here to restore your credibility.
I did not hire you, and all I need to do is bide my time until you've failed.
On May 1st, I'm going to make something of this job.
Rain.
Be the bridges I burn.
Night my way.
Forever.
I just love my job.
Get tickets now.
The Devil Wears Prada 2 in theaters May 1st, directed by David Frankel.
There's something else here now.
Something new.
From exclusively on Paramount Plus.
It's the series Stephen King calls Scarious Hell.
Everything here is impossible, but it's also real.
Sci-fi vision calls it the best show streaming right now.
We're running out of time and we still don't know the rules.
Don't miss what the movie blog calls something you need to watch.
Saving those children is how we all go home.
From binge all episodes exclusively on Paramount Plus.
Welcome to an HBO podcast from the...
HBO late month series, Real Time with Bill Ma.
Hey, give yourselves a hand for getting through
100 days of Donald Trump.
Right? A hundred days of Trump.
It's like Lent if we all gave up reality.
Yeah, they're big on this 100-day mark.
Some people, of course, are disappointed at his lack of accomplishments.
Vladimir Putin.
All that work for nothing.
But you know who thinks Trump is doing a great job?
Yeah, it's Donald.
I know.
Who would have thought, Donald Trump,
a reporter asked him to grade himself,
he gave himself an A.
Ooh, who would have knocked me over with a feather?
Donald Trump giving himself an A.
And you can trust that grade
because he used to own a fake university.
But he...
The White House this week put out a list of his accomplishments.
And most of them were not accomplishments.
Like, on the list was partnering with the private sector.
Yeah, that's what government does.
an accomplishment, got all my kids' jobs.
Not really something...
One of them just said, word for word, I'm quoting this,
women and space exploration.
Yeah, Trump...
Trump knows about women and space.
His wife lives 200 miles away.
You know, it's a lot of space.
Honey, we need space.
But it's so telling, he gave an interview today,
and he was very revealing.
He said, this is more work than my previous life.
I thought it would be easier.
He said that, yeah.
Who knew?
Nobody knew.
Nobody knew that presidenting would be so hard.
It looks so easy in the movies when Morgan Freeman does it.
I didn't know.
He doesn't.
Here's what he said he doesn't like.
He's isolated.
He misses driving.
And when you say stuff, people check to see if it's true.
Winy little bitch.
Isn't he just...
But there does seem to be a pattern emerging here after 100 days that we could see.
First, Donald Trump pulls shit out of his ass and says, so easy to fix.
So easy.
Then, phase two, nobody knew.
Nobody knew it was hard.
And then phase three, we go back to what Obama was doing.
Trade with China.
to that. ISIS, go back to that policy. The Iran deal. Go back to that. Health care.
NAFTA! All the campaign, all he talked about was not the worst deal ever. Fucking disaster.
Now...
You know what happened this week? He talked to the Mexican president. He talked to the Canadian prime
minister. Nafta's back on. Same thing happened when he talked to the Chinese president.
Suddenly we're on their side. He's like the Manchurian candidate.
But you don't even have to hypnotize him.
Just tell him he's pretty.
You're all in.
But plainly, we have this president who knows nothing,
didn't know anything about any of the issues,
not about the basics.
And I mean the basics, like how a bill becomes a law.
How many branches of government we have.
I mean, he didn't know what Brexit was.
He didn't know who the Kurds were.
He didn't know what the nuclear triad.
It's like the president is a big.
with a mobile over his head.
He's just learning about the...
Ah!
Did you only do this week he bust?
The entire Senate.
Did you see this?
Over to the White House to get a briefing on North Korea?
The entire Senate.
Or as Sean Spicer said,
over a million senators.
But, you know, this was supposed to be
the super top secret briefing the entire Senate.
At the beginning of the week,
the administration was all they could talk about.
They trumpeted it.
This was a very serious stuff.
All the senators.
The memorandum came out of the White House said
the Senate will be addressed by the chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff,
the CIA, the Secretary of Defense.
Then Rex Tillerson will speak,
because there's a first time for everything.
And then the president will talk.
About his ratings on the apprentice
and Ivanka's new line of strappy sandals
and the time he won the electoral college.
Cake will be served, and it will be the best game.
A lot of people are already saying
it's the greatest cake in the history of the world.
Mental illness is sad, ladies and gentlemen, I think it's...
And if you need proof of that, he unveiled the tax plan this week.
I don't have time to go into the details.
Just suffice it to say,
the wealthiest people in America
are finally going to be catching a break, ladies and gentlemen.
Isn't that awesome?
Tax plan?
What a charitable word for it.
It was one page with no math.
I'm not kidding.
That's the tax plan.
That's not a tax plan.
That's a resume for a manager at Chuck E.
You know what they said?
They said, well, it's rough.
Rough.
I mean, there's rough.
And then this is so rough it needs a safe word.
And the Treasury,
Secretary, Steve Munchkin, said,
He...
Something like that. I can't pronounce anything.
He said he wants people's taxes to fit
on the back of a postcard.
And on the front of the postcard,
an ad for 25% off on Ivanka Strappy Sandals.
They're really pushing those sandals.
All right, we've got a great show.
Rob Ryder, Tara Setmeyer, and Nick Hanauer are here
and a little to be speaking with former Secretary of Energy,
Ernest Moniz.
But first of up, she is the author of This Fight
Is Our Fight, the Battle DeSate.
America's middle class. Senator Elizabeth Warren.
You love California, you know? It's the last liberal bastion.
No, come on. Come on. People all across this country are energized right now, and I want to tell you
something. Yeah. They may be all energized across the country, but all across the country,
they don't have a Democratic governor, Democratic senator, Democratic parliament. We are
where liberalism is at the forefront. You've got to admit that.
So, look, I actually see this a little differently.
The way I see it right now is that look at what happened on health care.
I want to say thank you to everybody in this audience, everybody out there who called or wrote a letter or emailed or Facebook,
because we beat back the biggest assault on health care in the history of America.
And it didn't happen because we had enough Democratic votes in the House or in the Senate.
What we had are our voices.
And we got out there and made them heard in Washington.
to me and tell you empty words.
Yeah.
Okay, so let's talk about your book, first of all.
Oh, let's do that.
No, no, we don't want to forget that important thing.
And it's an important thesis you have,
which is about the middle class and what's happened to them.
And let's be honest, it started with Reagan.
Peace and blessings be upon him.
But it began, I mean, you talk about the period from 1980 to 2015,
where the middle class was before,
the middle class was after 1980. Tell us.
So, let's do the first part. And then it's 1935, coming out of the Great Depression all the way to 2016.
Year after year after year, basically GDP goes up, America gets richer. It's a good story.
But divided into time period one, time period two, 1935 to 1980. What happens during that time?
We have regulation of the big banks, giant companies, we enforce antitrust rules, put a cop on the beat
on Wall Street, have glass Stiegel in place,
and progressive taxation and make a lot of investments.
GI Bill?
That's right, in opportunity, in education, in infrastructure,
in research, scientific research, medical research.
And so, GDP's going up, 1935 to 1980,
the 90% of America.
Everybody outside the top 10%.
The 90% gets 70% of all the insurmount.
income growth in America. And that happened across the board. It happened. Americans participated.
The pie got bigger and we all got a little more to eat.
1980, what happens then? Ronald Reagan, deregulation, fire the cops on Wall Street, and the big one.
Cut taxes for those at the top and then invest less in education, in infrastructure, in basic research.
GDP keeps going right on up.
This is the long arc story in the book.
GDP keeps going right on up, and how do the 90% do?
They get 0% of the new income growth.
Nearly 100% of new income growth in this country goes to the top 10%.
That's why I wrote this book is because we've got to get in there and fight back,
and that's what this book is about, about how we're going to make that.
Well, let me fight back a little.
All right, I'm ready.
Because 1980 to 2015, there's some Democrats in there.
Oh, no kidding.
Two terms of Barack Obama, two terms of Bill Clinton.
And sometimes when they controlled the House and the Senate, too.
So what happened there?
Don't the Democrats bear some responsibility for that?
Aren't they supposed to put the brakes on this?
Absolutely.
No, look, it worked both ways.
1935 to 1980.
We also had some Republicans who were,
like Eisenhower, right? And Nixon, who actually is the guy who started the Environmental Protection Agency.
Right. And the Consumer Product Safety Commission? Great guy.
Solid. Solid. You know, I never thought, but this president is making Nixon actually look. Bush looks good next to this. Yeah, exactly. I look at old clips of Bush, and I'm like, wow, I wasn't scared of him.
Those were the days. Right. But that really is the point. These are long arc movements.
And basically what we've done in America is we've tried two different theories.
This is kind of the thesis of the book.
We tried the one where you use progressive taxation, you use some sensible regulations to make sure the playing field is level.
You know what?
We've built the greatest middle class on the face of the earth.
But I can see why the real Americans out there, the Trump voters, say a pox on both their houses.
Because this trend you're describing was not interrupted by Democratic administration.
Well, it was slowed down some by Democratic administrations. And I want to be fair here. Democratic administrations are the ones who put some of the brakes on who did somewhat more antitrust enforcement. And let's keep in mind, it's a Democratic administration that went for universal health care with Obamacare, or at least pushed in that direction, and Dodd-Frank and Bill, my personal favorite, the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau. Yes.
So now, okay, so now we have another Republican.
president who just
presented another tax plan which is
I mean I've seen Republican tax
plans like this but not quite as
brazen because this one doesn't even pretend
it's just about wouldn't it be
great if rich people didn't pay taxes
right but he's
going to go to a rally in
Harrisburg Pennsylvania tomorrow
and tell his fans
all about this about how his
kids are not going to have to pay taxes because they get
rid of the estate tax and they're still
with him they're not with you
Explain to me what that disconnection is.
Actually, I'm gonna push back.
I disagree with you.
Well, his fans are not with you.
Hold on.
Come on.
When we talk...
They don't like you, Pocahontas.
When you talk about what's really the basic pieces of a progressive agenda,
raise the minimum wage,
expands social security,
reduce the cost of college,
so people don't get crushed by student loan debt,
more, not less regulation of financial institutions.
No, hold on to say.
Progressive taxation, make those at the top pay their fair share.
America, Democrats, Republicans, independents, libertarians, vegetarians,
Americans, by about two to one, are with us on that.
The progressive agenda is
America's agenda. We cannot
forget that. And we cannot
apologize. This is the disconnect I'm talking
about. I agree with you. They're
with you on the issues and then they
vote for him. Well, then we got... So what
is that problem? And now
I'm not a politician. I don't know if to be nice. I say
people are stupid all the time.
So let's not say that
today because you are a politician. But
don't they bear some burden
for not the people, for not
looking into this a little more closely
and seeing who is really on their side.
I mean, Donald Trump ran as a populist.
And now he presents
his tax plan. Two Goldman Sachs guys
get up there. Thank God we didn't elect Hillary
with her Wall Street connection. Yeah, exactly.
And present this plan
on one page that basically
is, you know, let's give all the money to the rich
people because they always do what's
right with it. You know, they
thank God for the rich people. Because they
take that money, they put it back. It trickle
down on you, you lucky bastards.
We've seen this before.
The voters have seen it before.
His voters are not young.
They live through it. How come
they fall for the con?
So, look,
I think that Donald Trump
tapped into a real anger
in America. People are
angry, and let's face it, they are right
to be angry. They are angry
over the fact that young people can't
get an education without getting crushed
by student loan debt. They are
angry. But it's misplaced
if they vote for him and not
you. So...
This is... How do we solve that
problem? So... We all
agree the anger is
justified. Okay.
But they're... But let's do it.
The first step is
our sign has to acknowledge
the anger and has to say
yeah, people are angry and they
are right to be angry. This is what I talk about in this book.
Everybody has to stop and say
There is anger and there is good reason for much of this anger. A lot of those real Americans think that only Trump cares about them.
Yeah.
And that Democrats only are into identity politics. And sometimes it looks that way.
Look.
And since the Democrats lost every election and they don't control one branch of government, shouldn't, doesn't it behoove them to look at that?
This is the reason I wrote this book.
Okay.
I wrote this book. I mean, this is my life's work.
I know.
This is, you know this.
This is what I've worked on forever.
And it's what happens to working families.
You know my background.
You know my background.
Yes.
You know my background on this.
Yes.
And you know where I come from and you know that it is the fact.
Here I am.
I am the daughter of a janitor who ended up as a professor at Harvard Law School and as a United States senator because America invested in America.
I'm deeply grateful for that.
I recognize.
I recognize that those opportunities today are lost.
They are gone.
And so the question for me is how are we going to rebuild that America?
How are we going to get enough people together to say that democracy is going to work again,
that this is not going to be a country run by and for rich people only?
It's going to be a country run for the rest of us.
I know.
I do my best in this book to talk about how we make our voices heard.
how we come together and how we fight back.
In fact, I'll tell you something,
this book ends on a very hopeful note.
It ends, I went to Trump's inauguration.
I watched.
I wanted to see it.
I wanted it burned into my eyes.
You know?
My view on this was if there was ever going to be a moment
where I was like, oh, I'm too tired to get up.
All I had to do is close my eyes.
I'm like, oh, God, I'm up.
I'm up.
I'm ready.
I'm back in the fight.
But the next day,
It's the next day when the world changed.
When the history of this time is written,
sure, it's going to be about Donald Trump's election,
but you know what it's going to be about?
It's going to be about the day of the women's march.
It's going to be about the day we made our voices heard.
And here's the deal.
We have real evidence that it matters.
In the fights over health care,
remember how the Republicans in the House,
60 plus times, had voted to repeal
Obamacare? You remember how Donald
Trump said, on day one,
right? How many times did he say?
On day one, we're going to repeal
Obamacare. Okay, so we lied once.
Yeah, exactly.
Exactly.
But here's
the deal. We really
didn't have the votes in the House of the
Senate to stop him. Right.
What stopped him was enough
people across this country, and
not just Democrats, who
got engaged in the fight, who started
talking about, are you
kidding me? You mean you want to change the law so you could discriminate against people with
pre-existing medical conditions? And when they actually saw the plan, not 24 million people off
health care coverage, raised costs for middle class families, so you can give a tax break
to those at the top, a handful of millionaires and billionaires? No way. And so I get it that
the first version of Trump care failed, because for some Republicans, it was not brutal
enough. But here's the deal.
The rest of the Republicans
were not willing to follow them
over that cliff. And the reason
is because people around this
country made their voices heard.
We've got to tap into that. We've got to
magnify that. And they need a leader.
You know, I have to say, you know, when you talk,
people get very excited. When Hillary
stopped talking, they got excited.
So
Donald Trump
Donald Trump
Donald Trump today was
talking about running against you next time.
No pressure.
Senator Elizabeth Warren, everybody.
No pressure.
Thank you for making the flight of everyone.
I don't know how you do it.
Elizabeth Warren.
Thank you.
Let's meet our panel.
Okay.
No pressure.
I don't like to put pressure on people.
Not at all.
I like them make their own decisions.
All right.
Let's meet our panel.
He's an entrepreneur, activist,
and author of Gardens of Demandum.
Democracy. Nick Hanauer is back with us. Hey, Nick, how you doing? Good. Thank you,
good to see it. She's a former congressional staffer who is now a conservative
commentator. Tara Setmeier is willing to come here to the liberal California. And he's an
activist, actor, an award-winning director of Spinal Tap, Princess Bright, stand by me so many others.
Rob Reinger! Don't forget to send us your questions of the tonight's overtime, so can answer
them after the show on YouTube. Okay, so 100 days. Boy, the press loves that.
benchmark, I guess it means something. And let me just ask about this tax plan.
Before we get into the details, the one-page thing. They had a hundred days.
What happened during the first 99 and a half days?
Apparently they did not study. It's like a kid who forgot to do the assignment
and wrote it on the bus, on the way to school. These are supposed to school. These are supposed to
smart Jews.
From Goldman Sachs.
And this is...
You have a group of people
who have no idea how to govern.
They don't understand public policy.
They don't understand how this country
interacts with the rest of the world.
There are people that have never held these jobs
who, for the most part,
want to destroy the very agencies
that they're...
that they're representing.
So there was an article.
I wonder why this happened.
In Politico, a, I don't know who this is,
but they're quoting a senior White House official who said,
I kind of poo-pooed the experience stuff
when I first got here, but this shit is hard.
And he didn't mean that he needed a stool softener.
He meant that the work itself was hard.
I see what you're saying.
It's a family show.
I get it.
I'm sorry, Bill.
Wait, it's not a family show.
I'm sorry.
I'm sorry.
It's mostly...
Go ahead.
No, I saw that, and I thought to myself, what the hell have you people been doing
this whole time?
For those of us who have been involved in politics, who have worked on Capitol Hill like
I have, who have been in government to understand how things work, whether it's on a
local level or not, how do you not know the enormity of the White House?
And the fact that there's so many people that have surrounded Trump, it's bad enough
that he didn't know what the hell he was doing, but he surrounded himself with
people who didn't know what the hell
they were doing. And now here we are. And Trump is going around saying, I had no idea. I missed
my old life. And, you know, it's like he's in over his comb over.
But that...
Yeah. All right. All right. He's got money in. He's so sorry. He's got it in.
It's amazing how so many of the Republicans are on our side now. Because he's so odious.
This is like, you know, a gold mine and all you have to do is stick your shovel in and it just rains gold.
I mean, for you guys, it's like, I mean, it's a good and bad, you know.
We love that you can get those less and you're the best at it,
but it's also at the expense of the entire country.
And, you know, it's not so much a plan as a cliche.
What really struck me is it was like they photocopied talking points
from the Heritage Foundation, AI.
It was just...
No, I wish they had it.
No, yes.
We could be real policy.
We can discuss that.
This is just not nice.
I have it here in my hand.
The first three things it says,
grow the economy and create millions of jobs.
Magic dust.
Magic dust.
Check?
Simplify our burdensome tax code.
As if the Americans can't distinguish between three and seven.
Oh, you're talking about the tax brackets?
Yeah, it's just so nuts.
First of all, we need more tax brackets, not less.
Yes.
The idea that someone who pays $250,000, that's the highest.
bracket also pays the same as someone who makes 10 billion yeah right that's preposterous
preposterous okay or even i would even say that we could discuss having a flat tax would
no no no that's simple we can simplify the tax code you need to tell me that that the american
people don't need to simplify the tax code for them i mean it's a nightmare you can make a simple
tax code without nothing giant that flat tax is another giant giveaway to the rich people why do you
want to do that well it depends on i didn't say i necessarily agree
Are you a rich person?
I'm far from rich.
I'm not in the top of a cent.
You guys are.
I'm not.
I'm probably the poorest person on the shadow right now.
Take it from the rich guys.
So we have more money.
Wait a minute.
I don't have a problem with you guys earning more money.
We live in America.
Good for you.
I don't understand.
But also the idea that this is not paid for and it's going to blow the mother of all holes in the debt.
Come on, Republicans.
I think I say,
see a pattern here.
They run up everything
on the credit card. They could give a shit
about spending when they're in office.
As soon as the Democrat takes over,
what, we don't have any money.
The Democrats seem to take over
and then it's up to them
to put the House back in order.
I don't know what Democrats have decided
to be physically responsible.
I will be fair. Didn't Reagan?
No, no. No. And Bush did it too.
And Bush did it too.
So isn't that a pattern?
Yeah, no, you ran up the deficit bullshit.
And also we were in wars, too.
And with Reagan, similar thing,
where we built up the military.
And didn't Clinton?
Didn't Clinton give you a surplus?
Yeah.
And balanced the budget.
No, no.
Yes, he did.
He left a big surplus.
Bill Clinton wasn't responsible for that.
Bill Clinton's first budget was voted down 99 to zero
when he had Democrats in office.
Wait, wait, wait, wait, wait.
Bill Clinton, let me finish.
Bill Clinton became a centrist.
Sorry.
Sorry.
And he cut a lot of deals.
Sorry.
And that's what happened.
When he left office, we had 22 million jobs,
and we had a surplus.
You can't argue the facts.
Thanks to the Ronald Reagan.
No.
And thanks to Republican principles that Bill Clinton signed on to.
He gets a credit because he was president, but it wasn't his policy.
All right.
All right.
Shut up, everybody.
I just want to, I just want to bring one other elements into the discussion of our economy,
which is health care, because that is...
This seems to have been forgotten
since we started to tackle health care
around 2008.
When everybody on both sides of the aisle agreed,
we have to do something.
The status quo is not acceptable
because it's going to bankrupt us.
That seems to have gone away.
We seem to have now made the curve
more in our favor.
Okay, so they didn't get their first
health care repeal pass,
the Trump administration.
Now they're trying to,
again. Didn't happen today.
By making it. Even more heinous.
Okay. But it's connected to this
tax cut. I don't think
that's what people realize is that they wanted
to give this tax cut to the richest
people. And I've always said this.
Obamacare is paid
by rich people. It is
an income industry. No question
about it. No question about it.
And for their tax, wait a second.
20% tax that have to pay for that too. So small
businesses are hurt by the Obamacare tax.
But small businesses are mostly rich people.
No, they're not. Tell that to the mom and pop stores that have to pay taxes.
It's doing $2 million a year. No, that's not, no, we're not talking about that.
We're talking about the small businesses that have under 50 employees that are being killed by regulation and taxes like that.
They are not being killed.
Well, you're not a small business owner.
I have run 35 different kinds of businesses.
35 different kinds of businesses.
Why can't you make one work?
But I'm fun.
Some of them did.
Businesses in this country thrive when sales go up, not when taxes go down.
There is absolutely no correlation to growth.
That is not true.
It is not true.
It is not true.
It's a very interesting discussion, save it for CNN.
Here's what I was going to ask.
Okay, so we know Obamacare is mostly funded by rich people.
So Trump gets into office and he says,
we want to give the rich people, the top
1%, a giant tax cut.
But we don't want it to bust the deficit.
Where can we find that money?
Where, where, where?
Oh, yeah. The money we're wasting
so that poor kids can see a doctor.
That's how cold these
motherfuckers are. Absolutely.
Absolutely. Absolutely.
They are connected.
The money for the tax cuts
comes from taking it from poor Americans
who got help.
Trump care is a tax tax...
That is true.
That's true.
That's true.
It's the poorest Americans
already qualify for Medicaid
and you're not,
no one's taking Medicaid away
from the poorest Americans.
And Medicaid and Medicare, they're not.
They're not.
They are not going to do that.
That is part of that, listen.
Oh, my God.
You got, I mean, maybe,
apparently no one on your understanding
Medicaid works,
but that's not,
that's not what's going to happen here.
Wait, what are you talking about the Medicaid expansion?
People are being moved off the Medicaid.
They've cut Medicaid expansion.
Yes, so that people can afford their own health care, so the government isn't paying for it.
Have you ever been to a Medicaid clinic?
I don't think so.
Yes, I have.
Yes, I have you?
Yes, I have.
And so have I when I was younger.
Many, many times.
I don't want the government running up.
I don't like people telling me what I did and I didn't do.
That's the free clinic.
Oh, yes, that's right.
That was my duty during the Vietnam War.
But the answer to protest about the politics behind this, like why Republicans are unable to do this now.
We've had seven years.
of carping about this, and Elizabeth Warren
was actually right, we passed in the House,
multiple bills, repealing, because it's easier
to be against something, but now that it's time
to actually do it, you have a lot of moderate
Republicans that are in purple districts that
took the Medicaid expansion money in Obamacare
going, holy shit, we're going to lose our seats
if we vote for this. And there was actually
reports on that, as of recent as yesterday,
that many moderate Republicans are going,
we can't do this because it's going to cost us
our seats. And then Donald Trump's in a lot of trouble
because Democrats... The guy who's writing...
The guy who's writing the health care bill.
Paul Ryan, can I just quote you, Paul Ryan?
He doesn't even know what insurance is, let alone how to fix health care.
This is Paul Ryan. Listen to this.
On the fatal conceit of Obamacare, his words, young and healthy people are going to go into the market and pay for the older, sicker people.
Yeah.
Yeah, called insurance.
They're going to pay for the person, you know, who gets...
They're going to pay for the person, you know, who gets breast cancer.
are in her 40s or who gets heart disease in his 50s.
Exactly!
Yes.
And then when you are 50, you will get it.
That's exactly right.
This is his problem with it.
He has no idea.
So, let's not pretend that Donald Trump is not the only stuttering moron.
Trump care is a perfect healthcare system if you are rich, if you are young, and if you are perfectly healthy.
Everybody else is screwed.
I'm all screwed.
Everybody else is screwed.
Well, two out of three, Ed.
Okay, so listen, you all know who Steve Bannon is, right?
Do we have a picture of Steve?
Oh, yeah.
Great-looking guy.
The Chief Strategist...
He doesn't have his dark suit on, though.
He's not a good-looking man.
It kills me that he got some money from Seinfeld.
That's right, because that was Castle Rock.
That's our company.
That's our show.
Right.
He's got some money from Seinfeld.
I feel bad about that, and then my wife, Michelle, took the picture of Trump
on the cover of the art of the deal.
So we both are atoning for what we've done here.
Well...
It kills me more that Steve Bannon's taking money from the taxpayers as a government employee in the White House.
I think that's worse.
All right.
Anyway, so he used to be head of Breitbart News, right?
Which Trump is one of the organs that he reads, and now they run the government.
And they're an arch-conservative site.
But listen to how conservative they are.
Bright-Nart-Bart News denied media credentials to cover Congress.
That is very rare.
You have to be so partisan for these people to say, you can't even cover us.
So we wanted to see how partisan they were.
We looked at, because you're a big time director.
They have movie reviews on the Bright Bart News.
I'm not kidding.
Look at some of the reviews they have of movies.
And I think you see, they reveal how conservative.
They are like hidden figures.
Did you see Hidden Figures?
Oh, I love Hidden Figures.
Great movie.
That's a great movie.
Here's the Bright Bart News Review.
Astronauts survive despite affirmative action.
That is...
Aladdin, unvetted Muslim hijacks Ruff.
That is...
Please, that is not...
They've got some of yours in here.
Misery.
Resourceful homemaker provides non-governmental health care.
A few good men.
Another one of years.
A real American hero fights to keep Guantanamo Bay open.
Sean Spicer says,
You can't handle the alternative.
The Great Dictator.
least he never gassed anyone.
Oh, that's...
That is...
Annie, like
Melania Trump, a hungry little girl
has her life change forever by a bold
billionaire.
Gone with the wind.
Washington's burdens of
regulations interfere with the
Southern economy.
Titanic.
Stupid Al Gore's precious glacier kills everything.
Shoshank Redemption,
prisoner reminds us that even with just a spoon,
white people do amazing things.
Oh, and when Harry met salary, another one of years, Rob.
A beautiful control freak blonde fakes an orgasm
for a neurotic Jew.
Two thumbs up, say Ivanka and Jared.
He is a nuclear physicist and former U.S. Secretary of Energy
under President Obama, Ernest Moniz.
Hey, Secretary.
How are you, sir?
Great to have you here.
Thank you very much.
All right, so you are a nuclear physicist.
What do you have to do that?
Isn't it interesting the way science is kind of sexy now?
And there was a march on science recently, right?
March for science.
March for science.
What did you make of that, and what is your outlook for the next four years, if Trump makes it that far, in an anti-science environment?
Well, the March for Science really was a recognition that so far, what the administration proposed,
will really undercut the research, the scientific enterprise that has been the basis of our economy since World War II,
not to mention advancing environmental concerns, et cetera.
However, I think the March on Science really also had a very, very strong undercurrent
of just saying enough with this war on facts.
I have to say, let me make it very clear.
This administration did not start that, but I think they have really exacerbated this,
and I cannot say how concerning this is.
because in the end, having facts and, by the way, scientific laws, they are laws.
They're not ideas.
And in the end, democracy depends upon having facts.
You can disagree on policies, but you can't disagree on facts.
Well, that's not true anymore.
They can and they do.
No, but I think the March on Science was about that.
By the way, I think the turnout might have been comparable to the inaugural crowd.
But now, as head of the Energy Department, which, you know, the current energy, we don't want to,
I know you're too much of a gentleman to make fun of him, but Rick Perry, the former governor of Texas,
who wanted to get rid of the Energy Department and did not know what it did, is now head of the Energy Department.
And he was on Dancing with the Stars.
Okay.
It's okay.
But I must tell you...
Can I comment, Bill?
Please do.
Can I just let me make the point that governor, now secretary Perry,
look, he has looked into it,
and he has been made very strong supportive statements
about science and innovation.
However, here's the disconnect and the confusion.
On March 8th, he put out a tweet
praising a particular program called RPAE,
which has been the face of innovation in energy technology.
A week later, the O&M.
B puts out this budget says, no, why don't we just zero it out?
So these disconnects are just creating havoc.
Also, when there was a doubt, he gathered a lot of people in a stadium and prayed for rain.
What's wrong with that?
Well, did it work?
Yeah.
Of course, fucking not.
Did it work?
No.
I mean, eventually it rains.
You know, of course.
But, but I,
I must tell you, like the two things that I worry the most about, killing us all, the environment,
and that's the slow death.
And the other one is, of course, terrorists getting a hold of a nuclear weapon.
So I do worry about the fact that, I mean, you were a nuclear physicist in charge of the nukes.
He only found out nukes were part of the department he was heading.
He has a BA in animal husbandry.
So let me ask you this question about nuclear, because I'm worried about nuclear.
And I know I've been back and forth on this issue, but I know you think we need nuclear power.
But, you know, Fukushima happened in Japan in 2011.
And let me read you some of the facts about what's going on in Fukushima.
It caused the evacuation of 150,000 people.
Six years later, 80,000 are still displaced.
188 billion so far.
It could last as long as 40 years, they say.
And, you know, they thought it would be all over by now, and it's not.
They just don't seem to be able to control this problem of a nuclear facility that went bad.
Why do you still want us to have nuclear power if this can happen?
Well, first of all, I don't want to get into a long Fukushima issue, but I do want to point out.
Why? You're the Secretary of Energy.
Okay, fine.
Well, then we will.
What do you mean?
All I want to emphasize, and this is...
I don't want to talk about politics tonight.
This is...
This is not...
Your point is still right,
but I do want to emphasize that Fukushima
was not an issue of the nuclear technology.
Now, having said that, let me say,
what it is about is carbon emissions.
What I have said always is that...
But a nuclear plant, this happened to a nuclear plant.
Correct, correct.
So the lame...
And so therefore, it does show the risk if you don't obviously manage the situation properly.
But let me just say that, number one, to me, it's about carbon emissions.
Number two, it's a fact that nuclear is the biggest carbon- avoiding technology we have in the United States.
Right.
It's true in many countries.
Number three.
But there are other carbon-abiding technology.
Yes.
And the solutions, exactly.
And the solutions to the climate mitigation challenge,
will look very different in different places.
Some places it will include nuclear, some places it won't, and that's fine.
I'm saying we need all the tools.
Fourth, we are developing new technologies, especially smaller technologies for nuclear,
that are very, very good in terms of passive safety.
The question is, will their financial performance allow them to compete against solar, wind, with battery
storage and natural gas.
That's the real issue.
You'll have to work harder after the show when we're drinking to convince me.
All right.
I want to switch gears for a second to talk about this is the weekend.
That is the 25th anniversary of something that for us, Angelinos, was a big event,
which is the L.A. riots after the famous Rodney King beating.
About a year later, the cops who did that were put on trial and they were acquitted.
And for anyone who has ever lived through a riot,
it spreading and you can watch
it on TV, approach your house.
It's not one of my favorite memories.
You must have been here for that too, right?
Yeah, I was. And as a matter of fact,
trying to get home
after, I mean, the whole city
exploded. I mean, the whole
city, you couldn't move in Los Angeles
because of that. I mean, it was
horrifying. And
especially since
we've seen
progress
being made in race
race relations, starting with
Brown versus the Board of Education,
Loving versus Virginia, the Civil Rights Act,
the Boating Rights Act.
We've seen a lot happen. We've seen
ourselves move backwards.
And we seemed after that to
kind of get on a glide path
doing better with race
relations. We were talking about this backstage.
And it culminated in the election
of an African-American president. And I
think we all felt good about that,
that we were moving in the right direction.
And then this man comes
along and runs for president and unearths this racism that has been bubbling up under
and certainly came out to the fore during the Rodney King time, and it's now given voice to it,
not just a dog whistle, but a bowhorn.
And a lot of the...
Before that, though, I mean, you saw polling during the second half of Barack Obama's presidency,
that race relations people felt they were not getting better, and even, which was surprising
for many, because they thought with the election of Barack Obama, then, oh, I guess he's the post-racial
president and all that. But by the second part of his term, that was starting to change because of
some, you know, certain policies and things were happening. And then obviously Ferguson happened,
which didn't help the situation. And then, you know what happened with social media and they
got the police on camera. Yeah. What amazed me about this anniversary coming this weekend is just
in the LA Times this week. This is this week. Listen to this. The Los Angeles Police Commission
voted Tuesday to, quote,
require officers to try
whenever possible
to diffuse tense
encounters before firing
their guns.
Wait, this is just...
That's new?
Let me read it again.
Require officers to try
whenever possible to diffuse tense
encounters before firing their guns.
They're just coming upon this policy now?
Well, that's part of the continuum of force.
I mean, I can't.
come from a law enforcement family. My grandfather
was captain of our police department in my hometown.
I'm married to a federal law enforcement officer.
So I'm very passionate about this issue.
And I see it from both sides.
As a woman of color, I look at
I understand some of the
sensitivities in certain communities with the
police officers, which why I'm a big proponent of community
policing, citizens, police academies,
things like that should start in elementary
schools with kids so that you know that
the police officers are not your enemy. But at the same
time, there are bad cops
out there, and we can't ignore that either.
not the bad cop issue. This is the
police commission saying our official policy
as of Tuesday is
just don't empty your clip at the
first sign of trouble. But most police officers do not
do that. But clearly, I just don't
do that. And for people who have no idea what it's like,
I've seen it on Facebook.
No, videos don't always tell
the truth. For people who have no idea what it's like to do
a traffic stop and have no idea what that person is doing
what you're walking up on, traffic stops are the
second most deadliest can count for all.
officers. They were not, it was not conscription. They picked that job. Yes. Dangerous job. Yes, dangerous job. But it can't be that the community is there to protect and serve them.
But for the majority of people, it's not that way. The majority of police officers are there to protect and serve and they're good people that do this. And we need them. Because we found out during the riots.
What happens when you don't have them. Right. And so what happens when you break down, the relationship between community and law enforcement, you have anarchy. And no one wants that. But we need to be
to our police officers out there and respect
what they do every day and not demonize
them because of the bad acts of you. Thank you for the
filibuster. It's time for new rules, everybody.
New rules.
Okay. New
rule, if Trump wants to pick a fight with Canada,
he has to come up with a better reason than
they're killing us on Canadian softwood.
If you hate Mexicans and you hate lumber,
just bomb Home Depot.
And if you can't stand
Canadian Softwood,
would take out Justin Bieber.
New Rule, any guy who spends $425
for these pre-dirty jeans
must be prepared to answer a lot of questions
like, what's wrong with you?
This look doesn't say, I'm a working man,
it says, my Chipotle Burrito just backfired.
New Rule, if you want to reach people
who can afford to buy a house,
don't advertise where they wait for the bus.
You're in real estate.
What part of location, location, location,
don't you understand?
This doesn't say, I want to be your broker.
It says, when you think of me,
think of a crackhead sitting on my face.
Oh, man.
New Rule, Brooklyn's taco squirrel
and Manhattan's pizza rat
have to get together for lunch.
It'll be an internet sensation.
Plus, it'll give you two a chance
to talk shit about that asshole,
cronut,
raccoon.
New Rule, if you take Movantic,
the drug to treat opioid-induced
constipation,
you can't also use
medical marijuana.
I'm no doctor, but come on.
Either shit I get off the pot.
And finally, new rule,
liberals have to stop trying to win
over Trump voters with facts.
You're wasting your breath
and you're going to need it because the air is
not getting any better.
Just look at these 100 days headlines.
No regrets, Trump voters, unanimous.
The myth of this disillusioned Trump voter.
Even voters in liberal Massachusetts are sticking with Trump.
Numb skulls find a whole new level of numb.
All right, I made that last one up.
The point is, Trump supporters aren't changing their minds
because the problem isn't in the mind.
It's lower.
It's emotional.
Stop clinging to the false hope
that if we just share this Facebook story
about the time that he tried to have lunch
with Frederick Douglass or high-five Stevie Wonder
or criticized Obama for playing golf
and now he plays more golf,
you're preaching to the yoga studio.
The jury is in.
He looks and acts like a man
who's been painting his face with orange lead for 40 years.
His people know they don't can.
He could have Anne Frank's skeleton in his closet.
They'd all vote for him again.
The question is, why?
Why do they stick with him?
I think it's because of a gut feeling
that the world has changed and they don't like it.
And Trump is going to change it back to the way it was.
When a real American could flip around
looking for a radio station
and not have to hear mariachi,
music. The media keeps saying
that the thing that got Trump elected
was economic anxiety,
but it's really more change
anxiety. I ain't no racist.
But why does
America need to have a black Santa Claus?
Does everybody have to do everything?
Now, I think
I speak for most liberals when I
say, I'm okay with black Santa.
I don't think it's going to make the little
drummer boy start cutting himself.
But to
Trump voters making Santa Black is unthinkable.
It would be like making Jesus Middle Eastern.
This is why building that stupid wall
is still the key issue for them, because it represents
keeping out, not just immigrants, but everything that's new and different
and scary and unfamiliar.
You guys probably agree with me that it's kind of cool
that you can write a musical in hip-hop now, like Hamilton.
And I'm okay.
with seeing this guy playing this guy.
But Trump voters don't want to see
that the founding fathers have been funkified.
Ain't Broadway supposed to be the Great White Way?
And while we're at it,
does everyone in baseball have to be Mexican now?
Lopez, Hernandez, Martinez, Fernandez, Ramirez,
when did the Yankees become the parking lot at Home Depot?
And what is it with men kissing on the kiss cam?
And did I mention Bruce Jenner has tits now?
See, that guy, my new character.
That guy got used to having the whole country always bend over backwards to make him feel comfortable.
Trump voters, they're not exactly racists.
They just think everyone who's not white is doing it to show off.
You know, in the 50s, if you were an actor named Chewetel, a Geophore, you play.
vacated conservative snowflakes
and bent over backwards for them and changed your name
to Chip Egan.
Chip Egan, starring in that new movie with Dan Houston,
Lily Nile,
Mark Allen,
Schinger McGraw,
and Gail Smith.
If you ask a Trump voter,
what exactly it means to get their country back
or make it great again,
and they can't tell you specifically,
but they know the Hollywood Squares
was never supposed to be remade on TV
and look like this.
If we just would build that wall,
black people would stay in their cubicles.
Paul Lynn never came out of his cubicle.
Or the closet.
All right, that's our show.
I'll be at the Civic Center in Des Moines, May 7th.
Walt Disney in Orlando, July 8th,
and at the Ruth Eckerd in Clearwater on the 9th.
I want to thank Nick Hanauer,
Teresette Meyer, Rob Reuter,
Ernest Woodies, and Elizabeth Warren.
Join us now on YouTube.
Thank you very much, folks.
Hey, such a young man.
Is he still on our team?
I think so, yeah.
Oh, right.
Maybe he's part of the whole.
New Rule, let's all raise a glass to Larry King,
a true giant of radio and television
on the 60th anniversary of his very first broadcast.
60 years.
Think about it. When Larry signed on in 1957, President Trump was just a horny 10-year-old.
Trying to bluff his way through fifth grade, and look how far we've come.
Larry played records on the radio in Miami Beach.
Now records are gone. Radio is going, and thanks to climate change, so is Miami Beach.
Larry didn't wear suspenders as a fashion statement.
He wore them because no one had invented the best.
And the elastic waistband was just a theory.
Larry was paid $55 a week in 1957,
which is enough money to afford over 13 wives.
He's done over 40,000 interviews since then
with everyone from Moore-Marcadha Daffey to Chloe Kardashian,
and he's still finding jewelry in the cracks of the couch.
Larry, old friend, thank you for 60 years of making
insightful, fascinating broadcasting
look effortless, and for making
all of us always look forward to seeing
you and for giving guys like me
a mark of excellence to shoot for.
Here's to 60 more, my friend.
Okay.
Ernest, how confident
are you in the ability of the Iran deal
to contain Iran's nuclear
threat? I'm quite confident.
You worked a lot on that, right?
Indeed. And the reason
is something that has seldom talked about.
The deal puts in place
verification measures
that are completely unique
and apply to this deal forever.
Donald Trump said it's maybe the worst
deal in history of the world
because everything he thinks of
is the worst in the history of the world.
So is it...
This is another case where...
But he's...
I love the fact that...
Information would help.
You've got the Secretary of State Rex Tillers
saying that so far
Iran has been complying with the deal.
And on the same day,
you got...
Trump's saying, we've got to get rid of it.
It is amazing the way, like I said, in the monologue,
they start off with nobody knew, and they come back to,
boy, I guess what Obama was doing is actually the best, you know,
there's no great answers.
There's no great answers out there.
Can I add?
We see what happens when you don't get in early enough and, let's say,
not get North Korea stopped before they have a nuclear.
The problem, though, is that with North Korea,
you don't have as many players that you were able to put together.
the Obama administration put together a great coalition to put pressure on Iran.
Right now, we basically only have China.
Yeah.
And that's all we have to put pressure on North Korea.
So that's all tricky.
Tara, do you think more sexism exists on one side of the aisle, or is it a bipartisan problem?
Well, obviously, it's somewhat bipartisan.
We know Bill Clinton.
Sure, absolutely.
But did you ever work at Fox News?
Have you ever been called hot chocolate?
Well, I would actually probably be called like mocha, mocha machado or something,
given my, not chocolate, but no, not at Fox News anyway.
But I have appeared there and I had appeared on Bill O'Reilly show years past,
and I hadn't experienced that, but I do have friends that have been over there.
And, you know, there was a very problematic culture, obviously.
But I think it also is a reflection of the generation of the people who ran it.
You know, when you look at guys that are at...
that age. The asshole generation?
The Mad Men generation. But yeah, I mean, that was, they come from a time where it was okay to slap the...
Slap your...
No, I mean, it's, I think there was...
That's the last okay prejudice.
Yeah.
I don't, wait a minute.
I'm not saying it was okay.
Oh, yes, you were.
No, I mean...
How am I saying it's okay?
I'm saying that it's reflective.
You asked the question one.
I know, but you're...
I feel like you're...
I'm saying that what happened at Fox News is an example of a generation where that was
And now when you see the way that the result of it, the generation now is saying like, that's not okay.
We've seen a lot of advances.
And so I think you're going to see less and less of this kind of overt sexism.
It's not over with.
But, you know, there's progress is being made.
You see that people are paying a price for it.
Okay.
Nick, do you think there are...
Yeah, and more women are coming forward.
Yeah.
Nick, President Trump spoke at the NRA today.
Yes.
Do you think there are avenues to make progress on gun control?
Yeah.
I mean, and I'm deeply involved in that issue, and there's a tremendous amount of opportunity to make progress on gun violence prevention in cities and states around the country.
And the only way that we will make progress on those issues is in cities and states, and we passed background checks in Washington State.
We passed extreme risk protection orders in Washington State.
And there's stuff going around the country, and there's a lot of progress.
that can be made in that ways.
But not federally.
Forget it.
But to be clear, if you want to build a movement,
you have to start in cities and states.
Whether it's the $15 minimum wage,
marriage equality, pot legalization.
If you want to change a culture,
you have to do the hard work
of changing hearts and minds in localities first.
Okay.
Is it unseemly for former President Barack Obama
to earn $400,000 for an upcoming speech
to Wall Street?
He's doing two speeches, each for 400K, one to Canter Fitzgerald.
I wish he had spent a month building houses for poor people with Jimmy Carter.
Well, he was a community organizer, right?
I guess he figured he paid his dues with that.
Personally, as long as he's not running for office again, I don't care how much money he makes.
If people want to pay him that, it's a free market value, who cares?
I don't have a problem with this.
And I think that people, a lot of the people who are being righteously indignant about it
are also people who make lots of money doing what they do.
So I don't understand.
But wait a second.
The current president is trying to undo all of his Wall Street regulations.
And then he goes to Wall Street and takes to an...
Isn't that what sort of cost Hillary the election?
Are those horrible speeches she made to Wall Street?
And she wouldn't release the transcripts of it.
Because she wouldn't release the transcripts.
No, no, but the difference is are you in the pocket of Wall Street?
Right. She's running for office.
He's not running for anything right now.
And he's not going to.
Now, Michelle Obama might be a different story.
She could be prepped.
She's not right.
She doesn't want it.
For the most part, I don't have a problem with this.
It kind of looks like when he's on our team, we're okay with it.
No, no, I don't feel that way.
I mean, if he were running for president, I would have.
And in other words, if there was a time lapse and he had done those speeches,
then I do have a problem with that.
Because then you get into the whole area of conflict of interest,
which this administration is just one big,
ball of conflict of
interest. Yeah, of course it is. But you could say
that when a guy
is president, he's looking ahead to
that $400,000 payday
and he's not going to get it. If
while he's president, he's going to do
something that's going to piss them off.
So isn't the best thing to do? Take your
$10 million book deal.
Can't you live on that? Yeah, well...
That's up to his choice. It's individual freedom.
If he wants to do it. It is. It is.
It's able to do it.
There's also... The truth is
is that the country is being torn apart
because a few people are doing well and most people aren't.
Right.
And this is the canonical example of that.
It's just such a pure expression of that.
I'm surprised.
I'm a capitalist.
I just have a problem with it.
I don't know when America became,
I covet my neighbor's success country.
This is a country where you could come from nothing and be something.
That's not what it is.
It is.
It is not.
It is not.
If he is not going to run for office again,
he's a private citizen and someone's willing to pay him $400,000 to pay his speech.
I don't care if as long as low laws are broken, that's fine by me.
That's America.
You know what?
It's never about eating.
Nobody hates anybody else's success.
I don't know about that.
A lot of people, there's a lot of class warfare.
Why?
What are you saying?
Oh, I think a lot of people hate other people's success.
Oh, you're talking about show business?
Fuck you.
That's what I thought you meant.
That's what I'm talking about.
Politics, too.
I've got news for you.
Well, thank you very much, everybody.
We're a great audience.
Great paddle.
And I hope you have a great.
Catch all new episodes of Real Time with Bill Maher every Friday night at 10 or watch
them anytime on HBO On Demand.
For more information, log on to HBO.com.
