Real Time with Bill Maher - Ep. #465: Colion Noir, Michael Pollan
Episode Date: June 23, 2018Bill’s guests are Colion Noir, Michael Pollan, Josh Barro, Michael Smerconish, and Neera Tanden (Originally aired 06/22/18) See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information. Learn more about your... ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript
Discussion (0)
It's something else here now.
Something new.
From exclusively on Paramount Plus.
It's the series Stephen King calls Scary as Hell.
Everything here is impossible, but it's also real.
Sci-fi vision calls it the best show streaming right now.
We're running out of time and we still don't know the rules.
Don't miss what the movie blog calls something you need to watch.
Saving those children is how we all go home.
From binge all episodes exclusively on Paramount Plus.
Welcome to an HBO podcast from the HBO late-night series, Real Time with Bill Ma.
That's the real part.
No, I know why you're happy. It's summer.
And, you know, it's summer when kids become just like the president.
They have no class.
Really? You had to think about that one?
But this is the week when we found out, I guess this is good news, comparatively,
that there is a place that most Republicans will not follow this precedent.
Kidnapping children.
So, molesting them in Alabama was okay, but, you know, you have to draw the line somewhere, ladies and gentlemen.
So I said some Republicans, 55% of Republicans still support these separating the family policy because of their family values.
Life begins at conception and ends at the Rio Grande.
That's what they believe.
Zero tolerance.
That's what Trump keeps on.
That's what this crowd wants.
zero tolerance for immigration and also
zero tolerance for knowing what the
hell they're doing
because they don't. I can't
remember all the lies
that they told just from the beginning of
this week. This guy moves so fast.
Only I can fix it.
Only Congress can fix it, Mike.
To here's an executive order, I fixed it.
That's right. He signed an executive order
that revoked the policy that he started.
He...
See...
He's the arsonist fireman.
He's the guy who congratulates himself
for saving the toddler in the pool that he pushed in.
Have you ever seen a president who more creates his own crises?
I've got to call him President, hold my beer.
That's really what...
Nobody would be stupid enough, sir, to put babies in prisons.
Hold my beer.
This is, for the right-wingers,
not an easy policy to defend,
but, boy, that is one thing they fall in light.
Laura Ingram said these camps or jails or cages,
the kids were, quote, essentially summer camp.
Yes, summer camp.
They're doing arts and crafts, that's what they're doing.
Well, they're stitching Ivanka's handbags,
but it looks like arts and crafts.
Cages, tents, is summer camp?
I guess Anne Frank was on a staycation.
It was really too far when Steve Ducey on Fox and Friends went over the piano and started playing,
Hello, Mata, hello father, here I am in Camp Tustada.
I mean, oh, yeah.
But there is an uprising.
There's a new lawsuit on behalf of the migrant children that says that some of the kids were drugged to control their behavior.
So just like our public schools.
But really, there is a little bit of an uprising.
People are realizing they can fight back in different ways.
The airlines, a lot of the airlines,
have said they're not going to transport children
that were separated from their families.
American Airlines said this is against our corporate values,
and also your crying children
are drowning out our regular customers' crying children.
Now, you saw Melania went to visit the detention center.
Well, they had a camera in there,
and all you heard was, please help.
I want to go home.
And finally, one of the kids said,
pull, put yourself together, lady.
No, so Melania, you know this.
This is the, but everyone's talking about.
Lonnie went to visit the kids
who were separated from their families
on a mission of mercy with a jacket
that had big letters on the back
that said, I really don't care, do you?
I really don't care, do you?
Isn't it great when our first ladies go through
their angsty teenage phase?
And of course, people said the optics of this
when you're on a mission of caring.
to wear that jacket. But in fairness, come on.
When has Melania ever known what's going on behind her back?
Well, you know, the right-wing media said this was fake news
because she only wore the jacket on the plane getting on and off,
not around the kids. The coat was for us.
With the kid, she totally pretended to care.
And trust me, this is not the first feeling she has faked.
Okay. We've got a great show near attending, Josh Barrow.
And Michael Srikhanesha here in a little bit
speaking with author Michael Pollan.
But first up, he's an attorney and the provocative
gun rights enthusiasts who hosts NRA TV's noir
Collian Noir, right over here.
Absolutely, pleasure's all mine.
I have seen your videos many times.
You're very good at what you do.
Thank you.
I am not a gun lover.
Now, if I say the term gun nut,
I hope you realize that is not an insult.
I don't take it as one.
Good, because I don't mean not like you're crazy.
I mean like something you really love to do.
Yeah, I'm incredibly passionate about it.
I'm a drug nut.
So you said.
Yeah, I mean a pot nut, not all drugs.
Just the ones I can get my hands on.
Okay.
Jesus.
But when I watch your videos, you know,
very often, you know, at the end,
you kind of have a smirk like,
I laid it out, and you know what?
You kind of earn your smirk.
Because people like me who don't really like guns,
we don't know much about guns.
And the theme with you, really, I think, is like,
it's annoying, isn't it,
that people who talk about guns
and don't know about guns,
are not restrained by their lack of knowledge.
What are the misconceptions that bother you the most?
Well, there are two dynamics, right?
There's the actual physical component of the gun,
and then the individuals as we've termed gun nuts, right?
So there's that aspect of, say, for instance, semi-automatic, right?
Yeah, tell me about that.
Fast majority of guns.
Almost all of them are semi-automatic.
Almost all guns.
Right, I heard you say that.
I didn't know that.
Yeah, I didn't know that.
And so that stuff you would learn
after you follow the rabbit down the hole, so to speak.
And semiotic meaning you have to pull the trigger every...
You pull the trigger once, you get one bullet.
Right, and that's almost all guns.
Pretty much, yes.
Not just the...
They seem to be obsessed with the AR-15.
Yes.
So with the AR does not stand for assault rifle.
That's a common misconception.
Right.
The AR stands for Armolite rifle,
which is the name of the actual rifle.
And it's a semi-automatic rifle
in the sense that you pull the trigger once,
you get one round.
So why do people think liberals, let's be honest,
why did they think that getting rid of the AR-F?
15 would go so far to solving this problem and tell me why it wouldn't.
You know, as the saying goes, optics is everything, right?
Right.
There's a certain theatrics that comes with guns in general, right?
Especially when you start talking about things like the AR-15.
With the AR-15, you see it as big.
You're usually, most people who aren't too familiar with guns,
they usually know about them by way of movies.
So you see the movies with all the bad guys,
spraying and praying, doing all these crazy things with the firearms.
And then you see that in reality, and you're like,
oh, my God, I don't want those anywhere near me or on the streets.
And so what ends up happening is they take that and then they see it and it's like, well, they don't know much.
The knowledge base is not very high.
So what they end up doing is they start feeling, right?
Because it evokes a feeling.
There's the theatrics behind it.
They're loud.
There's a muzzle flash.
You know, all of those things.
And it can be scary.
Which is the movies we like.
Exactly.
There's a lot of hypocrisy there.
If guns weren't so popular, why do they dominate movies as much as they do?
Because there's a fascination there too.
People like, yeah.
It's kind of like going to an amusement park, right?
And that's what I say to gun nuts.
Like, just be honest and admit that you love guns, and it's sort of a vice in that, like, you know, gambling, alcohol, drugs.
These are all things that have some collateral damage that I am willing to live with because you can't tell me that I can't smoke pot because some people will be hurt by it.
You know, you can't organize society around what some people might do or be hurt by completely.
So you would admit that.
You just like guns.
You like holding them.
You want to have sex with them?
Well, it's multifaceted, right?
So there's an element of recreation there.
There's an element of sport there.
There's an element of protection there, right?
And then there's an element of philosophy with regard to what this country was founded on.
So it's incredibly multifaceted.
So it ends up happening is a lot of people who don't really know much about firearms have a very myopic view of them.
And the only lens that they see them through are the bad things that are done by bad people.
I feel like it's self-reliance a lot too.
Absolutely.
Isn't that what you feel? I get that from your videos.
Well, it's self-reliance based on reality.
Right, that you don't trust the cops to show up.
It's not that I don't trust the job.
And if they do, they might shoot you.
There's always, there's a possibility for everything, right?
Right. But that's not my main concern.
My main concern is that in the moment, right, whenever something arises where I may have to defend my life,
I wouldn't be in a position to do absolutely anything possible I can to make it out of their life,
along with the people I love, and anybody else who seems to be around that.
that I care about.
Right.
But I had Killer Mike here about a month ago,
who was on your show and got in a lot of trouble
for talking about guns.
No, he got a lot of trouble for just being on my show.
For just being on the show, right.
But you guys made some interesting points
about how it's very easy for people
who live in safe neighborhoods to talk about gun control.
It's a whole different story
for some other folks who don't have that luxury.
I think one of the things that ends up happening
when we start talking about some of the gun control measures
that people are pushing,
is how they disproportionately affect people who are in lower economic environments
and in environments that have a higher level of violence, right?
And so, like you stated before, I can live in a gated community,
have a security guard outside.
I'm going to feel relatively safe.
Even then, something could still happen.
But if, say, for instance, I'm a single parent mother,
and I live in an inner city somewhere, and I'm working two jobs,
and I can't afford a car, and I have to walk late at night
and when I get off work at night and walk back home.
Or if I'm at home with my kids in an environment,
where there are home invasions, right?
I, as a woman in that particular situation,
and just anyone, I don't want me protecting my life
to be a competition.
I want it to be as lopsided as possible
because I'm not the one threatening someone's life.
I'm going about my life and someone's trying to interfere with that.
And so I want to be in the best position possible
to guard against that.
Right. And I am sympathetic to the argument
that if you're in a horrible situation,
it would be a good thing if a good guy had a gun.
Absolutely.
And we've seen many times, and I know you think that they don't report it.
I don't think they report it enough in comparison to...
Right.
But my question is, where does that lead?
We can't go back to the Old West, where we're all strapped all the time.
But we are.
Well, I'm not.
I'm sure there are guns somewhere around here.
I hope so.
You're right.
Yeah.
But not everybody.
Because everybody can't do it.
I mean, you don't really want teachers.
themselves to have guns, do you?
I honestly don't have a problem with arming teachers.
But teachers aren't there to be...
Come on.
There's a contingency.
This is where the NRA loses me.
I mean, they lose me...
It loose me in a lot of places.
But a place like that, that does seem unreasonable.
I can understand a guard at a school.
And I think if the Parkland guard who didn't do his job had done his job,
we would be having a different debate.
Absolutely.
But not teachers.
But see, here's the thing about that.
With respect to this conversation, one of the biggest issues that I've seen is that
that we've all kind of separated into our separate corners
and kind of just lob attacks at each other.
We all agree that we want to find a solution to these issues.
We all agree with that.
We just differ about how we go about it.
So I can respect your position and not wanting to arm teachers.
The way I look at it is when I look at some of these mass shootings
that have happened in the past, a lot of these teachers
had to sacrifice themselves to protect their students.
And so my mind goes, well, why not put them
in the best position to fight back against
the evil person that comes into the class.
And instead of making them,
instead of being sacrificial lambs,
they're fighters now.
And they're willing to die for these students.
So why not put them in a position to fight for?
Because they're teachers.
They don't want to have that job.
Any more than the guard wants to teach physics.
You're absolutely right.
But the moment somebody walks into that classroom
with the gun and starts shooting their kids,
they don't have an option.
So the only options they have is either sacrifice themselves or fight.
What about background checks?
Now, 20% of the people in this country
get their guns without having to pass any
sort of criminal check.
And when you say that, give me
some basis behind that. Are you talking
about private sales? Yeah, I mean, they get them
from a relative gives them to them, or
it gets passed down, or a
gun show, or something like that. And the
NRA used to be for closing all those
loopholes. Yeah, Wayne
LaPierre. Loopholes.
Loopholes. Well, when you say
loopholes, what do you mean?
Well, here's what Wayne...
I'm going to ask you with this,
because it's funny,
because when most people think of an NRA spokesman,
they don't think of you.
Okay, fair enough.
They think of Wayne LaPierre.
Okay.
And I like to fuck with people's minds.
Wayne LaPierre in 1999.
We think it's reasonable
provide mandatory instant criminal background checks
for every sale at every gun show,
no loopholes anywhere for anyone.
What changed?
Yeah, but when you go to a gun show
and you purchase a firearm...
Is it really a show?
What would it be?
I don't know,
because I never been.
Would you call it tactical masturbation?
I would not.
No.
I'm good with regular masturbation.
But a show, it sounds like Annie Oakley.
It sounds like, you know.
Still a show nonetheless, right?
But it's really a sale, right?
Isn't that what a gun show is?
I mean, yeah.
You can go there and you can buy guns.
But why do they call it a show?
Well, because when I first went to a gun show, I treated it as such.
Really?
You went there because what it is,
it's an aggregation of a bunch of guns that you normally...
But what is...
Wouldn't it be good if we had 100% of people who got a background check?
Wouldn't that be good?
Sure, but how do you go about doing that from a private cell standpoint?
Well, I don't know.
I mean, I know you're against any sort of registry because you think that leads to confiscation.
Well, it has before, though.
In America?
No, in America, that's what we're trying to prevent.
But it has happened in places where people use as examples of shining beacons of what we should do,
gun control-wise, here in America.
I can't imagine a country that loves its guns as much as this country.
I mean, we have almost half the guns in the world with 4% of the population.
I can't imagine anyone ever trying to take away people's guns.
And if the people who were taking away the guns were doing it,
they're usually the people who like guns.
They're law enforcement.
I can argue with that.
Yeah.
Look, I'm a little more gun reasonable these days, now that Trump is the president.
But I still think if people came after me to get, even if I fired back,
then they could come back with always superior.
fire, the government is always going to outgun you.
Okay, so why fear...
Well, so if the second amendment, if you understand the Second Amendment was written, right,
to protect us and be in a position to fight off a tyrannical government,
so then why not provide us with the same weapons?
If the guns that I have now are not going to be enough.
Actually, Gary Will says...
He says, the Second Amendment, listen to this.
I want to get your reaction.
Okay.
Shows it just how far the poison of slavery pervaded the Constitution.
He says, the Second Amendment was not meant to let individuals
prevent federal tyranny, how could it,
by training rifles or handguns on the Army, Navy, and Air Force?
It was meant to guarantee militia
to handle the state's internal problems,
especially the problems of a large slave population.
That's a big reason why we have the Second Amendment.
We needed it to keep the slaves.
Here's the irony behind that.
We actually used the concept of Second Amendment
to revolt against a country that was oppressing us.
Right.
right and then in the same breath
because of the purity of the language of that
Second Amendment I now
sit before you as a gun advocate
with the ability to carry a gun
I don't want to make you mad
now you're great at talking about this I appreciate
you coming up giving us your bad view
Koliang Noir
thank you very much
all right let's meet our panel
okay here's the host
of the Michael Smirkanis program on
on Sirius XM radio and author of Clowns
and Left of Me Jokers of the Right American Life
in columns Michael Smirkanish
How you doing, Michael?
Thank you.
He is the senior editor at Business Insider
and host of KCRW's
All the President's Lawyers and Left, Right, and Center podcast,
Josh Barrow.
Barrow, please...
Would you please change your first name to Wheel?
Yes.
Then I would remember you.
Wheel Barrow.
She is the president and CEO of the nonprofit organization
Center for American Progress.
Nira Tandon is back with us.
Great to see you.
And don't forget to send us your questions
for tonight's overtime.
so I can answer them after the show on YouTube.
Okay.
So I want to ask about Republicans tonight
after the week we've had,
because, you know, for many years,
I've tried not to make them mad when they say,
look, we all want to solve problems.
We just have different policy methods.
And it stops me from saying,
wait, it just sounds like you don't have as much compassion as we do.
And then this week comes along.
And, you know, Donald Trump said today,
we can't be swayed by phony stories of sadness and grief.
And he uses kidnapping kids as a negotiating strategy.
And the Homeland Security person after this week,
during this week, goes to a Mexican restaurant for dinner.
Corey Lewandowski is hearing about one of the saddest cases
of one of these kids on the border end goes,
and Melania with her jacket,
I don't know what that was all about.
But it doesn't add up to make me think, oh, right,
We just have policy differences.
It does make me think you don't have as much empathy as we do.
So there I said it.
This is how Trump won the nomination.
He was awful in various ways that shocked the other people up on those stages
and debates with him in the primary, you know,
saying that, you know, he likes war heroes who don't get captured,
effectively calling Ted Cruz's wife ugly,
doing a wide variety of these things that were just like...
That play well.
Yeah, or well enough with a large enough fraction of the Republican base.
And, you know, you look at this child separation policy, and it polls terribly,
and it polls only okay with Republicans.
I mean, you said 55 percent, but 55 percent is low for a policy
that a Republican president is doing among Republican voters.
So a substantial chunk of the Republican Party did not want this sort of cruelty,
but a lot of them did, which is how he won the nomination,
and then a lot more of them decided, you know,
well, I will put up with that if the alternative is Hillary Clinton.
And he's decided that this is what shows toughness.
He talks about how important it is to be tough,
and I think voters have, like, sort of a wide variety of conformity.
ideas about immigration. They want toughness. They want enforcement. They also want empathy.
And sometimes those ideas come into conflict. And I think Donald Trump appeals to one side of that.
I think he's gone much too far this week and has put off a lot of people who, even things like the Muslim ban,
polled a lot better with a lot of people.
I mean, we can have a policy debate, but what's really happening in America right now,
I mean, as we speak, is children do not know where their parents are.
Right.
As they're going to bed tonight at the hands of the government deciding our government has perpetrated a policy that is basically designed to terrorize these children and their parents.
They do that in all of our names.
I think Donald Trump had a strategy to take those kids hostage, to get his wall or to do other things about immigration policy, but the country has risen up in utter disgust.
parents around this
and that's why
that's why he's done
these belly flaps or whatever it is
on Wednesday he's stopping
the policy today he's attacking
Democrats and immigrants but where will it be
in November? I think the issue that needs to be said and I
would never defend the breakup of these
families the way that it's taking place
but we do have a problem at the border and it was
not of his creation we've got a problem with
porous borders that caused 20,000 apprehensions
to jump to 50,000 just within the past year.
And I think it's important that people not allow their hostility, their antipathy toward
the president and the pro-publica sounds of those crying kids to overmask the problem
that we really have.
What drives, though, Bill, I want to say this, what drives the lack of empathy that
you're referring to is demographics.
I think it's concern in certain quarters about their diminishing role in our society.
The truth is that American kids, the youngest,
kids today don't look like American elders, and by 2045, whites will comprise less than 50% of the
population. And I think a lot of the bad behavior that you're referring to is preying on people's
anxiety about those numbers.
Yeah, but I just say it's absolutely the case. It's absolutely the case that Donald Trump
has sown racial fears. He attacks different groups, the fact that it used infestation to describe
immigrants, that's, you know, essentially what authoritarian dictators have done, but other minority
groups.
I hear that.
I just think, look, the vast majority of Americans oppose this policy because children should
not suffer by the hands of the U.S. government.
But can I get at the...
What I think was the...
For me, the elephant's in the room this week, because the media really just covered this
one story, and they never mentioned the drug war.
and the drug war is at the heart of this.
The reason why people, even when they know they're going to be facing horrors like Donald Trump at the border,
are still willing to make that trek, is because their own countries are just unlivable.
It's pretty amazing that El Salvador, I think, is the most violent country in the world,
and Honduras is second of the whole world.
So they're out doing Afghanistan and Syria and Venezuela and some other really nasty places, Darfur.
Are you kidding me?
Our interdiction in Mexico and Colombia has caused the rerouting of the drugs through Central America.
It's created this horrific environment.
I know where you're headed because you've been on this for a long, long time.
I think the nation is getting ready for the kind of conversation that you want to have
because of the scourge of opioids and heroin in all communities.
I couldn't have noticed that our neighbor to the north legalized pot this week.
Right.
Oh.
But, you know, Donald Trump said Mexico's doing nothing for us except taking on money and sending us drugs.
Well, there's an answer to that.
Stop buying their drugs and sending them the money.
Because it winds up in the hands of these gangs
who take over the country as a narco state
and make life unlivable.
And of course, people will do anything to get away from that.
Anything.
Until you deal with the drug problem,
you're not going to solve the border problem.
But we're not ready for the conversation
that you're trying to have here.
We're ready to have the conversation on marijuana,
but that's a small fraction of the overall business
of these drug cartels.
If you were to legalize cocaine and hands,
heroin and methamphetamine, which you would really have to do to completely end the need for this
interdiction stuff. You'd need a system that would be very different from the way we deal now with
legal alcohol, that we can deal with legal marijuana. Because the price would fall so much
in a fully legalized supply chain. And nowhere else in the world has done this. You have places
where it's legal to own and possess drugs and to use them. But to actually legalize the whole
supply chain, you'd have to do something like you could have a government monopoly for it. There
are things you'd have to do to prop up the price and to control problem use. Because if you
legalize these drugs, I mean, there's 17 million
people with problems with alcohol in the U.S.
Do we think that cocaine and
heroin are either less fun
or less addictive than alcohol? You could have an
enormous increase. I think heroin is less,
so yes. I don't think a lot of
people just, if you legalize it, if we
legalize heroin tomorrow, how many people
would start shooting up and sticking a spike
in your arm? There's been an immense
increase of heroin. Some nice honest people
applauding there for
being on heroin. I'm not saying we're ready for legalization.
I say we're ready for the conversation, and
And what has changed it is the opioid epidemic and heroin is something that you used to see on television.
Now everybody's within one degree of separation from having a person who's at risk.
Well, okay. But...
I mean, I think that actually, I agree with that point, which is essentially the opioid issue is one in which we're decriminalizing.
Now, I think it's really weird that we have something that affects white people and it's decriminalized.
And you think of it as a public health crisis.
But maybe after that, we will applaud.
more broadly, but I mean, that is a big challenge.
Everything seems weird until you do it.
You know, hey, let's all be amateur cab drivers.
Sounded weird a couple of years ago.
You know, let's hate Canada and love North Korea.
Sounded weird.
It's still weird.
It's still weird.
It's still weird.
But, you know, zero tolerance is what Trump keeps saying.
And zero tolerance, of course, was also the policy with drugs
for so many years in this country.
And I just want to say zero tolerance is always
a stupid idea. It's just another way of saying zero thinking.
The left is guilty of it too. They have their own zero tolerance pets.
You know, they have their own... Okay. Yeah. No, I'm just saying zero tolerance never really
works out. I don't think. You're right, but it's a good soundbite and nobody wants to be the
candidate running against zero tolerance. It's a mic drop. Zero tolerance, boom.
And it pulls well because people don't think about tradeoffs. It pulls well at the same time
that various compassionate measures, like a path to citizenship and amnesty for legal immigrants, they also
poll well. You ask people about things on both sides of the questions and they'll say, yes,
basically do everything without thinking about, you know, what the costs are, like what it would
be like if we had zero tolerance for speeding or anything else. But think about this past week.
I mean, basically what we've experienced, this disaster is a product of a zero tolerance policy,
which they basically thought, hey, we're going to, you know, rip these families apart and it'll
deter people. That didn't work. We're going to rip these families apart and use it as a
bargaining chip for a wall in a legislative
negotiation, that's been rejected.
I think the challenge with zero-talent's
policies, as they are with
drugs or crime, etc.,
three strikes, is when you see the consequences,
it's a disaster, and that's what we have to
recognize. And also, let's
remember that
Republicans
basically don't want
to do policy. There's only
one party that does
policy. Like,
the wall... I would agree.
Right. The
wall. It's just like a great idea.
They do better when the Democrats are in power.
Because then they can have their stupid ideas
and pretend that they're not
being enacted because
the Democrats are blocking it.
Repeal and replace when they never had an idea.
You know, this nonsense this week.
They don't do policy. They don't
know how and they don't care. And this is
where Trump's incompetence ends up interacting
with his malevolence. Basically, you know...
Michael is right that there's
a real problem at the border and
there are real tradeoffs to be had there. A lot of
people seeking asylum will not end up qualifying for it. You're going to have to make tough choices in a lot of cases.
But the infrastructure that you would have to build around doing these things, if you want to process the asylum cases faster, so we don't have to let a lot of people into the U.S. for north of a year waiting for a hearing, you'd need to hire more judges.
The president says he doesn't want to do that. He says he doesn't understand why we need judges. It would be a logistically complicated policy thing to do. He doesn't have an interest in doing that, and so that actually ends up worsening the effects of this sort of nasty thing he does.
Right. And if we legalize drugs, by the way, on that score, we would have, obviously, take place under a different administration.
Here's what Jeff Sessions said about the opioid problem.
We think a lot of this is starting with marijuana. Wrong.
We think doctors are just prescribing too many opioids.
Sometimes you just need to take two buffers and go to bed.
There's where we are on drugs.
Okay. So everyone is talking about this jacket, that Melania wore, and it said, I really don't care to you.
There it is. She's wearing it
and there is it in the catalog.
And I think in her defense, she has
a lot of racist sweaters that were in the
wash that she could have.
But she didn't.
But honestly, I don't know if you've been in
Melania's closet, I have. And
there are some worse things
that she picked out, actually, one of the
best. Like, here are some of the things she could have wore.
She could have wore, I'm sorry, you must
have been confused with the Slovenian catalog
model who gives a shit. That was another
She could have picked that one, and she didn't.
My other coat is made of 101 Dalmatians.
Would have been a terrible choice.
My pockets are loaded with Perel.
Oh, that's...
Think you're living in a cage.
Try being me.
Oh.
She could have picked this one.
That's Mrs. Hitler to you.
Don't blame me.
I'm feckless.
Don't talk to me before I have my blood.
If you read this, you're too close.
Yeah, that would have been nasty.
And I like this one the best.
I voted for Hillary.
Okay.
I did that for you.
Who's the author of How to Change Your Mind
What the New Science of Psychedelics teaches
that's about consciousness, dying addiction, depression, and transcendence?
Michael Pollan.
Michael Pollan's here.
Perfect guest for this discussion.
Yeah.
If you're looking to convince someone to do more drugs,
you have come to the right place.
And we were talking about drugs,
and your book is about drug.
know you as a food guide. Now, why
the change? Did you just pick the wrong mushroom
one day? Is that the...
I thought there were chanterelles I was putting in
that omelet. You have to be careful, right?
You do. Oh, picking mushrooms, absolutely. I remember doing it once.
They grow in cow shit. They do. That's right.
Those are the safer ones to pick. There are other ones
that you can really kill yourself if you.
Don't do it yourself.
So, no, I've always been interested
in our engagement with the natural world. How nature changes us,
the things we take into our bodies, how it affects
our health. And so for me, it seems more continuous
than not. Part of the spectrum, right? And one of the really
interesting things all of us use plants for
and fungi is to change consciousness, right? Whether it's
coffee or... Fungi is mushrooms. Right, right.
Or chocolate. I mean, and this is a universal
human desire that I've always been curious about. Well,
I wouldn't say chocolate changes our consciousness. It does in subtle ways.
Oh, shodder. Yeah. No, it's got, well, it has caffeine in it
and it has another thing that kind of gives you a little lift.
You know POT's legal now, right?
Yeah.
They've got some shit that would really...
Yeah.
No.
So, but psychedelics, obviously, are a much more radical form of consciousness.
So about LSD.
LSD and psilocybin, DMT, Iowaska.
See, I feel they're so different.
I never did Hiawatha, but I did...
I've certainly done...
Well, I don't know if I did acid.
You know what?
I did something that somebody sold to me and Sud was asking.
That's the problem.
That is the problem.
You can't, if you have prohibition, you can't regulate it.
Yeah.
Timothy Larry once said to me, of course, before he died.
From the grave, he said it to me.
He still, Tim, are you there?
Hello?
He said, there really hasn't been acid since Owsley, the original maker.
Yeah.
Well, at a certain point, the mob moved in on acid in the hate.
The mob?
Yeah, they were four hippies selling acid in San Francisco in 1967.
And one was killed horribly hung up from a tree.
A second was killed.
The other two realized bad business.
They left.
The mob got in, and the acid was never the same.
Right.
I don't think it was acid because they can tell you it's anything.
Right.
But it was something.
I mean, it wasn't good.
As good as it should have been.
But you're saying real acid, which they experimented with in the 30s and 40s,
really helps a lot of people with stuff like PTSD, right, and anxiety and depression.
Alcoholism.
Alcoholism.
Yeah.
How does it do it?
So what I was surprised to learn, I thought psychedelics began in the 60s, but there was a very
rich history of research in the 50s, late 40s, using LSD psilocybin, the ingredient in magic
mushrooms to help people deal with serious problems.
We don't know exactly how it works, but it seems to lead, when it works, there is a profound
experience of ego dissolution, sometimes called a mystical experience. People's sense of their
ego or self dissolves temporarily. And when this happens, you're freed of various patterns of thought.
The brain kind of reboots. And this single experience, and it's important to understand that
the way these drugs are being used in therapeutic settings, very different than the way you use
them or, I don't know about you guys.
But, you're on.
By the way,
that was private.
We put something in your water tonight.
It's going to make the second half of the show
a little more of the water.
Yeah.
It's a very different thing.
It's a guided experience.
You're with a therapist the whole time.
They prepare you very carefully.
Oh, that's not fun.
Talk about a buzzkill for a trip.
You're with a therapist the whole time?
Thanks, Dad.
No.
Thanks.
They tell you what to do if you get into trouble.
Basically, they encourage you to surrender.
Because when you feel your ego dissolving, it can be really scary.
It's a death.
And so they tell you to go with it, relax your mind and float downstream, as John Lennon advised.
And then during the experience, which you're lying down, you're wearing eye shades.
So it's a very internal voyage.
You're listening to music on headphones.
And they're there with you the whole time in case you get nervous or freak out.
in some way. And then afterwards,
you come back the next day
and they help you integrate the experience,
figure out what it means, and apply it to
your lives. People come up with these radical
new perspectives on their own lives
that allows them to change.
You? It happened to you? Yeah. Oh, yeah.
And what was, what changed? What was the perspective?
How were you different before? How was your life actually different?
It's really hard to articulate, but I did have
on a high-dose psilocybin trip guided. I had an experience
of complete ego dissolution. I looked
out and I saw myself painted over the landscape.
I was just like butter or paint out there.
But I wasn't troubled by this at all.
There was another eye that suddenly manifest
that was very kind of fine with whatever happened.
And it made me realize for the first time
that I'm not identical to my ego,
that there's another ground on which you can stand.
And that turns out to be a very powerful idea.
Most of us are slaves of our egos.
See, I didn't have that experience with mushrooms.
And I did mushrooms all over.
You didn't take enough.
Oh, I've definitely...
I've taken...
Mushions have done many times.
It's a laughing drug to me.
You don't find yourself just laughing uncontrollably?
No, it's about context.
Because, I mean, again, I was having this inner trip.
I wasn't, like, the senses were not coming in.
It was dark.
I'm just on the floor.
Yeah.
Just, really?
No, like, literally on the floor.
And, like, everything's funny because, like,
everything that is normal in your life when you think of
is hysterical as it doesn't make sense.
Like, most drugs make...
horny. But like not mushrooms.
It sex seems like, why would I do that? Why would I
make my penis get bigger and put it inside of a person?
Really, that's what mushroom, like,
like with everything.
It makes me deconstruct everything.
That's one of the new perspectives I was talking about.
Right.
Your sex addiction addiction has been cured.
It's not an addiction and don't need no curing.
All right. My last thing is microdosing.
A lot of people these days are talking about microdosing,
which is a little bit of LSD.
Right, like a tenth of the normal dose.
And they take it during the day.
I mean, they're not like, yeah, they're not the lizard king,
they're just out doing their normal thing.
What do you know about that?
Is that something you recommend?
So, no.
We don't know.
Thanks for coming.
All right.
There's a lot of anecdotal evidence that it helps people,
makes them more creative, makes them less depressed.
But I looked into it.
There's no research at all.
We've never done a study, a controlled study.
It's getting underway in the next year or two, so we may learn more.
It strikes me as a funny thing that we've taken this drug
that is so transformative and disruptive,
and we've turned it into, with microdosing,
just another productivity drug,
make you a better cog in the machine.
Right. Like coffee.
It's like, what would capitalism do with psychedelics?
Microdose.
That's why they love coffee.
Back to work.
And tobacco.
Right.
Okay.
Before I run out of time on this panel, I want to talk about Steve Schmidt.
Steve Schmidt's a frequent guest last week on this show.
On this very show last week, I was saying times are so desperate right now that you can't be that kind of Republican who just says,
I'm not voting for the Republican.
I'm writing in my wife, or
Betsy Ross, or, you know,
Ronald Reagan or Donald Duck.
And Steve Schmidt,
I don't know if he heard me, but he stepped up,
renounced the Republican Party this week.
He said,
this independent voter will be aligned
with the only party left in America
that stands for what is right
and decent and remains fidelis to our republic,
objective truth, the role of law
and our allies. That party is the Democratic
Party. Now, this is the guy,
who was...
Yeah.
This is John McCain's campaign chairman.
This guy who's been bleeding Republican for decades.
And why aren't the others seeing it that way?
I don't know, former Republicans.
Look, I did it eight years ago.
I mean, in...
You did that years ago.
In 2010, after 30 years of loyal service to the GOP,
I got out.
And I served in a low-level capacity
for President Bush, the five.
So, I mean, I was hardcore and involved and became one of the 45% of this country, according to Gallup, who are eyes, who are not D's, who are not ours.
And I'd like to see more people go that route.
I found it very interesting that he said that he now has this loyalty to the Democratic Party, but his registration is that of an independent.
What needs to happen in this country are fewer closed primaries, a place on that debate stage for an independent candidate for president, and break the log jam as it.
two-party system.
See, I disagree with that.
So I left the Republican Party in 2016,
which I was in it for far too long,
but part of why I stayed in the party
is I don't really believe in being an independent.
I think political parties are key vehicles
through which policy is made.
You don't have to agree with everything a party does
to want to be a member of it.
You go, you join, you try to get them to move in your direction.
So I didn't leave until I was ready to become a Democrat.
And so I think people do need to choose,
and I think Donald Trump is an excellent reason
to leave the Republican Party if you haven't already.
But on...
At some level, I sympathize with these people who, because I'm a political moderate,
and so I could sort of live equally well in either party.
A lot of these people, they're conservatives.
They don't want the things that the Democratic Party is going to be done,
except for not do all the incredibly stupid things Donald Trump is doing.
So that's not a super appealing reason to be a member of a party,
so I sympathize with them, but ultimately elections pose us with binary choices.
And Donald Trump is...
In this country.
In this country, we really only have the two choices.
Right.
We've tried many times to change it.
and if we were a parliamentary democracy, it would be different.
But third parties just wind up making the better party lose too many times.
So I mean, I don't buy that.
I mean, I have radio listeners who hold me singly accountable for the election of Donald Trump
because I admitted on the air that I didn't vote for him and I didn't vote for her either.
I voted for the libertarian ticket, and I'm still proud of that vote.
And I say, take it up with the 102 million who were eligible.
and didn't go out and exercise the franchise.
See, every single person can say that.
I guess we're, I think what I really respected about Steve Schmidt
is he looked at this week and said,
babies in cages is too much for me in this party.
Right?
And it was, and I think the reality is, as we had to November,
it is a binary choice.
Either you're voting for a Republican Party
who has no check on Donald Trump,
or you're voting for the Democratic Party,
which is a check on Donald Trump.
That is just the choice people have.
And if you vote,
if you write in Mickey Mouse
or you write in Jill Stein
or whatever, no, no, I hear you,
I hear you, but I'm just saying... But the effect is the same.
Then you're actually, you're just take it,
you're basically supporting the Republican Party.
And Michael Bloomberg said he's giving
$80 million, which is great
to stop Donald Trump. The Koch
brothers are giving $400 million.
Where are the billionaire
liberals? Because
Sheldon Adelson and that crowd,
they give in the tens and hundreds of billions,
the Koch brothers.
Here's our side.
Bill Gates worth 91 billion.
Jeff Bezos, worth 141 billion.
Zuckerberg, who should feel guilty
for helping Russia
slide Trump into the White House.
He's worth 73 billion.
There are contributions in 2016
were under a million.
What? You know,
I'm...
Cheap fucks.
You know what?
These...
The liberals...
I went through this in 2012
when I made that
million dollar donation
to Obama, to let people know.
You have to get in on this...
The game is being played
on the million dollar level.
It won't do
when you're worth $141 billion
to write a check for $250,000,
you cheap fuck.
And I think it's...
It's going to be a lot worse the cycle
because Republicans passed a tax cut
which gave a lot of people money, and now he wants to return on investment.
That's right.
You know, they're basically, I'm sure there's been a lot of hand-wringing or arm-twisting or
whatever to say, now you have to give us money to keep us in office.
The whole thing is a scam.
So, you know, this is not the solution.
The solution is not to say, I see your Aedelson and I raise you, Zuckerberg, because
it all ends up in these 501C-4s, dark money, it's hidden, we vote.
We have no idea who has paid to influence the vote that we're about to care.
And that's got to end.
And you end up with a more politics that's more driven
by the preferences of billionaires. And I'm happy about
what Bloomberg is doing, because I think he's a politically
smart guy. I think he has a smart plan about how to spend this money.
But a lot of these billionaires, they spend
the money on vanity projects. We, you know, we see
what Tom Steyer is doing with these nonsense ads
about, you know, impeach the president.
It's spending all this money to get Tom Steyer's face
on television. And then on the Republican side,
they spend a ton of money. A lot of it, I think, not spent
very smartly. I would rather see Bill Gates spend his money
doing the excellent work that his foundation is doing
on public health. He can do both.
I got $90 billion.
But I don't want the Democratic Party
that goes out there and figures out,
like the Republicans do with Sheldon Adelson,
let him write their agenda.
The only good thing I would say really quickly about this
is just that our votes are counting against the money.
People are voting.
Democrats are voting.
Progressors are voting at higher levels.
Money matters.
Let's not fuck around.
Okay.
So I have one minute.
What's the deal with the jacket?
What was she doing?
The jacket's from Zara.
There is no way that Maloney.
Trump shops at some of the
This wasn't just in the closet.
I think it's honesty.
I think she was literally saying
the White House doesn't care about these kids.
No.
The Dodger doesn't care about the kids.
He doesn't care about the kids.
But that's what the jacket said.
She didn't wear it to the kids.
She caught a raft of shit when she wore the stilettos
to go to the flood victims in Texas.
I know, but this is not stilettos.
This is a message.
To say, I'm going to be me.
Well, you know, why?
But you don't know that for a fact.
That's your guess.
That's your guess.
It was a message to the media.
She said I don't care. They don't care about these kids, obviously. I think it's truth-telling.
Okay. All right. Thank you, Pat. All right. Time for New Rule.
Okay, New Rule, the woman who got her head stuck in a truck tailpipe at a country music festival,
and this guy who got his head stuck in his mailbox must start dating.
I want you two to get married just for those mornings when he says, I'll get the mail,
and she says, I'll start the truck.
New Rule, someone has to tell the South Korean.
soccer coach who switched his players' numbers in training to fool a Swedish scout
because he says Westerners can't tell really tell Asians apart. Hey, that's racist man.
You don't think we can tell Li Zhang Fram from from Oban Suk? New Rule, if you're the guy
in the next stall, don't strike up a conversation. You may consider this a social situation
and a chance to make new friends. I'm just looking for a quiet place to sit until someone
at the table pays the check. New Rule, now that U.S. New Rule, now that U.S.
Uber wants to use artificial intelligence
to determine how drunk potential passengers might be.
They have to answer this question.
What are you? My mom?
I got an easier way for you to tell if your passenger is drunk.
They ordered an Uber.
New Rule, if you work in the Trump administration
and you're responsible for separating kids
from their parents at the border,
maybe don't eat at a Mexican restaurant for a while.
Even if you didn't get heckled out of the place,
are you really going to enjoy?
those enchiladas, because trust me, that's not crema.
And finally, new rule, anyone who went apeshit
the last two weeks, because I said going through a recession
would be worth it if it undermined Trump's popularity,
has to enroll in college and take a course in perspective.
A recession is a survivable event.
What Trump is doing to this country is not.
Democracy is about to go the way of the dinosaurs
because we've been taken over by a dodo bird.
So, let me read.
Repeat, recessions are survivable events.
We survive one every time a Republican is in the White House.
Every Republican president since Teddy Roosevelt has presided over a recession,
four Republican presidents had two of them, and Eisenhower had three.
The United States has survived 47 recessions at all.
And since the Great Depression, we've never gone more than 10 years without one.
Another recession is coming.
Not because I'm rooting for it, because someone...
someone passed a giant tax giveaway to the rich
that added trillions to the debt
and started a trade war for no reason
and deliberately sabotaged the Affordable Care Act
and rolled back the rules for banks
so they can once again gamble with our money.
Those are actual policies
from men with real power.
As opposed to me who just made a wish.
I just made a wish.
What am I a genie?
But you would never know that
from the right-wing nuttysphere.
where this made me a bigger threat to our national security than Canada.
Laura Ingram said he wants an economic collapse to get rid of Trump.
But I didn't say economic collapse.
I said recession.
For the record, I'm against reducing us to the point
where we're foraging for food and trading blowjobs for candles.
Yes. I am. I'm against that.
Alex Jones tweeted,
Bill Maher is worth $100 million,
but he says we should crash the U.S. economy to stop Trump.
And when is he ever strayed from the facts?
And then everyone on the right said,
I had $100 million.
And all I have to say about that is,
I do?
That's awesome.
I'm out of here.
Sarah Palin tweeted to her follower
that I was out of touch.
And Wayne Allen Root said,
he doesn't care if your kids starve.
Mike Sernovich said,
suicides increased during recessions.
Bill Moore wants people to die.
Yes, specifically Mike Sernovich.
I want him to put his head in the oven
so starving kids confuse it for food.
No, I don't want that.
I don't know who the fuck you are,
Mike Sernovich, but I want you to live a long,
healthy life and get the help you so desperately need.
But this accusing me of wanting people to
starve and die is pretty rich
coming from the party that has never been shy
about actually enacting policies
that starve and kill people.
Taking away health care,
cutting Medicaid and food stamps
and the children's health insurance
program, forcing government shutdowns.
This month's Journal of the American Medical Association
says the Trump Environmental
Agenda is likely to cost the
lives of over 80,000 Americans.
So there's that.
And I guess those
claiming that I would come out unscathed in a recession must have missed the episode
with Elizabeth Warren from the last recession. You know, before the crash, I had most of my
savings in Lehman Brothers. Oh. I don't have a question. I just want you to hold me.
Okay. Because some things are more important than money, and one of them is living in a country
that reasonably resembles the one that existed from 1776 to 2016.
In a situation, this grave, it is not crazy to use economic manipulation.
That's what sanctions are.
We pinch countries in the pocketbook, so they'll act better.
Just think of this as sanctions against ourselves.
Although, again, I can't really make a recession happen, even with my 100 million.
recessions happen and we always recover,
but fallen republics don't.
Rome fell, and they still haven't fixed that stadium.
I'm not rooting for a disaster.
The disaster is already here.
If a recession is what it takes
to make Donald Trump not so cute anymore,
then bring it on.
Because seriously,
one of the problems with a roaring economy
is it tends to make people put up
with a bad president.
It's like great sense.
sex in a bad relationship.
When the sex is good,
all the annoying things your partner does
are forgiven. That's
what we're in right now, the good sex
economy. I just
want America to say about Donald Trump
what everybody in a relationship says
when the hot sex wears off.
What the fuck am I doing with
this person?
So, show, I'll be at the Windstone World Casinoa
back in Oklahoma, July 6th
at the Brady Theater in Tulsa, July 7th. That's my
HBO special.
at the Mirage in Vegas, July 20th and 21st.
I want to thank Michael Smokhanis, Josh Barrow, Barrow,
near attend, Michael Fallon, and Collian Noir.
I'll get it one of these times.
Join us now for overtime on YouTube.
Thank you, ladies and gentlemen.
New episodes of Real Time with Bill Maher every Friday night at 10,
or watch them anytime on HBO on demand.
For more information, log on to HBO.com.
