Real Time with Bill Maher - Ep. #469: Preet Bharara, Adam Conover
Episode Date: August 18, 2018Bill’s guests are Preet Bharara, Adam Conover, Jennifer Granholm, Charlie Sykes, Jonathan Swan. (Originally aired 08/17/18) See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information. Learn more about your... ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript
Discussion (0)
Welcome to an HBO
podcast from the HBO
Late Night series, Real Time with Bill Maugh.
We've got a big show.
Okay, okay, all right, set the fuck up.
I'll get to it.
Jeez, I'm glad you're keeping your chin up.
What a depressed crowd, huh?
Well, not such a good week for the president,
on the other hand.
Man, he lost his one black friend.
Yes, if you have spent your life as an American
refusing to know who Amarosa is,
well, now you're fuck out of luck
because she's got a book to sell
and it's about her time in the White House
where she was there for 18 months,
I believe her official title
was Assistant Secretary for Throwing Shade.
And boy,
oh, and boy, is she.
She has a lot to say about Donald Trump.
There, and he said, she said, boy, he is a racist,
and he suffers some dementia.
And he said, she's crazed and crying
and a low life and a dog.
And Putin said, I can't believe I have to collude with these people.
You know, let's not forget that Amarosa
did defend Trump a million times, lied for him.
After the election, she said,
all his detractors would have to bow down before he.
Donald Trump. I don't care. She's our asshole nap.
I'll take anything I can get, gladly.
But really, this is where we are, this is where the reality show people are now
the reality. And you don't want to watch. You can't turn away. It's like watching
Earthworms mate or a hobo jack off in the alley. I don't want to look at it, but...
to hear it. Amarosa has tapes. Did you hear the one, oh God. Did you hear the one where she's playing, where she's talking to Trump after she got fired and telling him about to play that tape?
General Kelly came to me and said that you guys wanted me to leave.
No, I, nobody even told me about it.
Wow.
Aside from everything else, what a pussy piece of shit he is.
Can't even, I didn't know it. They run a big operation here. Boy, if I ever,
ever find this president of the United States guy?
I'm going to find out what he...
And so vain, she says in the book
that he immediately put in when he could be in president
a tanning bed that he uses every day.
Oh, big mix-up one morning.
Rudy Giuliani was getting into his coffin.
And Trump was getting out of the tanning bed.
And luckily, Maloney had just come out of her sensory deprivation tank.
So she...
Oh, yeah, that's it.
Malani in the book, I'm rosa.
of Melania plans to divorce him
as soon as the term is over, and she said
she's taking the kid.
And Trump said,
we have a kid?
Uh...
She also says he drinks eight
Diet Coke a day, which caused
dementia, which I think is probably true.
Uh, but Diet Coke, come on,
it's working. He does have the body of a Greek god.
I'm sorry, he has the body of a Greek diner.
But, here's my favorite.
She says...
Um, Mara Rosa says,
in Trump once in a black
church and she got up to do so
and he grabs her arm and says,
you can't leave me here with these people.
You know, Christian.
Oh, yes. He's got such a
deaf touch with race, this president.
I see, Aretha Franklin passed away, I'm sure
you heard. And, of course, this guy says,
yeah, she worked for me. She worked for me.
A complete lie. This guy cannot say
rest in peace without lying.
Trump said he was
going to tweet his favorite Aretha
song, Respect. But he couldn't remember
how to spell it.
There's a couple of actually important things going on.
Two Russian supersonic nuclear bombers did a flyby right over Alaska.
Of course, Republicans demanded an investigation into the radar that detected them.
No, they were so close.
Sarah Palin said she could see them from her meth lab.
And finally, I just have to bring up this story again because it's in the news.
Remember the baker in Colorado?
would refuse to make a wedding cake
for the gay couple, went all the way to the Supreme Court.
Right, now he's back in court
because he wouldn't bake a cake for a couple
celebrating or somebody celebrating
gender transition.
I got a couple of questions.
One, is there only one bakery in Colorado?
And also, I see a big
business opportunity here.
I'm going to move to Grand Junction, Colorado,
and open a store called Bang,
Whoever you want cakes.
All right, thank you very much for that great show.
Jennifer Brand Home, Jonathan Swad, and Charlie Sykes are here.
And a little later, I'll be speaking with the guy who ruins everything, Adam Kanover.
But first, he is the former district attorney for the Southern District of New York.
He hosts the Cafe podcast.
Stay tuned with Preet Prit Barara.
Hello, sir.
How are you?
Great to meet you.
Good to meet you.
Good to have you.
All right.
Such a silly monologue, such a serious person.
I enjoyed the monologue very much.
Oh, wow.
I can't say those things.
No, you can't.
Well, you can on...
Now I can.
Yes, now you can.
You're free from you.
You had a big job.
You're the U.S. attorney for New York.
I always said the U.S. attorneys are like the senators of the justice system.
There's about 100, right?
Yeah, sort of.
Okay.
But sort of more like the governors.
Okay.
We're the masters of our domain.
Masters of...
And New York.
Tell us why New York is more important probably than any other do.
Well, so there are four districts in New York, southern, eastern, northern,
you know, following the directions.
I was east or northern district of New York.
Wall Street?
Wall Street.
It contains lots of businesses.
It has gangs like other districts have.
And it also is probably the greatest target in the country for terrorism.
That's where 9-11 happened in part.
So we're always focusing on those kinds of issues.
And also it has probably the most media presence of any place in the country.
So anything that happens in Manhattan and the surrounding suburbs gets a lot of attention.
Comey had your job.
Giuliani had your job.
Giuliani did have my job.
What do you make of Rudy Giuliani and...
by wider extent, the whole Republican Party right now.
I don't know what your politics are.
You're a serious public servant.
That's secondary to what you do.
But you must have seen a different Republican Party
until two years ago, as we all have.
Yeah, I mean, those are separate questions.
What has happened with Rudy Giuliani
and the Republican Party?
I guess they sort of overlap a little bit.
Look, Rudy Giuliani was...
Well, they're both being...
They're both enablers for a traitor.
What's the difference?
Well, Giuliani is supposed to be a professional lawyer.
And for six and a half years, I did it for seven and a half, he did it for six and a half years was the U.S. Attorney in Manhattan for the Southern District of New York.
Had a great reputation.
Some people thought he went too far in some cases.
But he was a trial lawyer by training and understood what integrity, I think, in speaking about cases in court and outside of court, meant generally.
but some of the things that he's saying, just viewing him as a former colleague,
and he was very nice to me when I took the job.
I had dinner with him to get some advice from him.
And in recent times, I think he's taken on an aura of someone who doesn't remember what the truth is,
doesn't remember what he said about issuance of subpoenas 20 years earlier,
who doesn't remember that the people he used to work with,
including folks in the FBI, who helped save New York and people in law enforcement,
save New York and find the bad guys.
he now calls him stormtroopers
because he's trying to protect a particular president
not in the way that he was trained to do
and not in a way that he trained generations
of federal prosecutors to do
so I gotta tell you it's fairly disconcerting
so I saw you when I said traitor
you looked like you were uncomfortable with the word
tell me why we're not saying that word more
because I mean we are being attacked by Russia
even presently you would agree with that right
that's my understanding okay well if the president
is taking the side of the people attacking.
And he's certainly doing that
when he goes after the people
who are defending us from those Russian people.
He belittles them. He criticized them.
He threatens to arrest people like Jim Comey.
You're on one side or the other.
Why do we shrink from that word?
Trust me, I've been a pretty vocal critic of the president
in various forms.
I think he's leading a corrupt government.
I think he's doing a lot of things,
both corrupting people,
corrupting institutions,
corrupting processes,
corrupting even the meaning of the truth.
But I could have said that about George Bush.
Well, no.
I could have said he was a corrupting guy.
But I wouldn't have said he was a traitor.
There's an order of magnitude difference.
I think that, yeah, look, the word,
the words treason and traitor
have particular legal meaning.
And so maybe I'm an overly careful,
recently former prosecutor
who wants to be overly careful at this moment.
Maybe not.
And if people want to call folks traitors,
I guess that's fine.
The worry I have sometimes, just as a private citizen now,
not speaking as a lawyer,
is you can subject yourself to criticism
if you are sort of overstating,
and I'm not saying you necessarily are,
but if you're overstating what other people have done.
And it allows folks to be dismissed a little bit more out of hand
when people yell treachery and treason.
Wow, they don't worry about that, and they're winning.
I mean, he's purging,
the ranks
of the FBI.
He's going through them one by one.
It's like I keep saying slow-moving coup.
Some people said this week it was like the Saturday Night
Massacre, but slowly.
He's slowly going through the ranks.
I mean, he got rid of, I think,
I saw seven of the eight people
that Jim Comey had in his office
to corroborate, as corroborating witnesses,
what Comey was telling them
about his meetings with Donald Trump.
What would your office look like?
If seven of your eight top guys,
guys were gone.
It would still be pretty good, actually.
Really?
Yeah, because you know what?
So that's a deep, deep state you got?
By deep state, if you mean professionals who are consummate professionals...
Oh, my hero's the deep state.
Who understand what continuity means, you understand what the Constitution is.
Right.
Who don't care about party, who don't care about politics, and just do what's right and honor the law and honor the Constitution.
Then God bless the deep state.
But he's purging.
Okay, so...
So you could lose your...
top eight people. How many could you lose?
It would not be great to lose your top eight people.
No, I don't think so. It's good to have the top managers. But what people need to understand is,
so by the way, I think that the new FBI director is an honorable and good person. I think
we accidentally got a great person to be the head of the FBI. I think he could do better.
I think he could defend the institution better. I think you could speak up about the kinds of
things Trump is doing more. But I think what you have happening here, both with Rod Rosenstein
and with Chris Ray, who's a director of the FBI and some other folks. And I don't
I don't necessarily love it,
but they're sort of walking a line
between trying to defend their institution
and do what is right
and also placating a guy
who freaks out and gets angry and upset
and could fire you on a whim.
So some people might call, and I get it,
some people might call that weakness
and say you've got to stand up to power,
some people might say,
but for me being here,
then things would be a lot worse.
I think there are lines,
and I think when we had Admiral McRaven this week
who doesn't serve in government,
I believe it, who comes out and says,
you know, as a quiet guy who wrote a book about how you should make your bed, right,
and how little things are important,
when he comes out and supports in solidarity,
someone like John Brennan,
who out of peak and whim and anger and retribution by the president
taking away his security clearance,
that's the kind of thing that matters.
And maybe we need to see more of that
from not only people who were in government now
and serving in the executive branch now,
but also members of Congress.
I know you care a lot about norms, right?
This is...
This president doesn't care about norms.
If you don't write it down,
he will just go ahead and say,
I can pardon myself, or I can know...
He has ways of being petty
nobody even thought of.
Nobody even, right?
Nobody even thought of
withdrawing people's security clearances.
No, the founders did not appreciate
that there was going to be at some point.
You know,
they worried about a lot of things, and they worried about self-interest,
and they worried about, um, you know, self-dealing.
And not living under a king.
Yes.
He wants to arrest Amarosa.
And why?
I don't know.
We'll figure that out later.
Because she spoke out against him.
I know.
But that's, but again, this is not something we can just say, well, I will wait all the facts to
commit.
I just think everyone's too calm about this situation.
I don't, I just don't, I just don't get it.
Look, there's the old saying, right, if you're going to go for the king, you got to kill the king.
Right.
So it's fine to engage in this rhetoric.
Yes.
I mean, I surprised the secret.
Because really.
The Secret Service, please don't come.
Yes.
Because they will do that because they're crazy.
Well, I used to work with the Secret Service and they're not all crazy.
Not them.
He.
Look, the rhetoric is fine and I think there's an important role.
I'm a private citizen now.
And I talk about these things.
You talk about these things.
There's an important role for anyone.
in the public sphere who has a microphone
to talk about these things, but
the people who are going to make, you know,
a difference other than at the ballot box, which is
probably the most important thing, so not to, you know,
downplay that.
But the Mueller investigation, you know,
Bob Mueller can't stand up and say,
treason in an interview, he's got to collect the facts.
He doesn't say anything in an interview. Yes, that's the point.
It's up to the Democrats.
Rudy Giuliani's on TV every day.
They get their story out, but we don't
get our story out. Yeah, but does anyone listen
to what Rudy Giuliani says?
Unfortunately, they do.
Yeah.
He's all over TV.
Just because you're on TV doesn't mean you're believed.
Just because you're on TV doesn't mean you have credibility.
Just because you're on TV doesn't mean you're doing a service to your client.
But he muddies the waters.
Would you disagree with that?
That's what they're good at.
That's what they're good at.
We've got to get good at something.
Yeah.
But I'm not sure.
I'm not sure that I know you're not saying that if they muddy the water, you know, when they go muddy, we go muddier.
No, but I don't think, right?
No, but we are bringing, not even a knife to a gunfight.
We're bringing a covered dish.
And it's just got us.
Anyway, I'm glad you're around
and I hope you get back in the game.
Thanks very much.
All right, thank you.
Freed for our...
Thank you very much.
Freed our panel.
The Weekly Standard and host of the podcast, The Daily Standard.
Charlie Sykes is with us.
Charlie, we're a big liberal favorite.
It's good, huh?
He's a politics reporter for Axios.
Oh, I see this guy in TV all the time.
Now we got him.
Jonathan Swann.
Jonathan, how are you born?
And she is the UC Berkeley professor
who was the Democratic governor of Michigan,
a great tribune for your party.
Jennifer Granholm's here.
Send us your questions for tonight's overtime
so they're going to answer them after the show on YouTube.
Okay, so I just can ask the question again.
Why can't we use that word treason?
We're under attack.
I mean, three Democrats this week,
the opponent of Rohrbacher,
Bill Nelson in Florida, Claire McCaskill,
all said the Russians tried to get into their shit.
As I said, we're purging the FBI,
pulling security clearances of former CIA directors
and the people who kept us safe since 9-11
and for the last 30 years.
I don't get it.
If you're fighting the people who are fighting us,
what do you call it?
I think it's treason.
I really do.
Oh, great.
I understand why Democrats who are running right now
in swing states don't want to use that language,
But I think that we have the remedy, as Preet just suggested, at the ballot box in November.
We saw this week that the number of the turnout among Democrats was much greater than it was among Republicans.
There is a wave. I think it's a blue wave, but we've got to work the wave.
Yeah, I heard that before.
I know, but we got to work it. That's what I'm saying.
And this issue about this slow-moving coup that you describe is one issue, not the only issue.
but it is a huge issue.
It is kind of the only issue.
No, well, I mean, it is what I say.
It is kind of the only issue.
It's our country.
But let me just say, people in the Midwest, etc.
Make it an issue.
This is the problem with Democrats.
They don't make it an issue.
They are making, but people are saying that what's more important to me is the fact that the Trump
administration today is messing again with Medicaid and is going to throw hundreds of thousands of people off in their second effort at it.
That affects them deeply.
And Trump has been made.
very successful in suggesting that this is a hoax.
Let's go for both, but let me just tell you,
not to forget the meat and potato bread and butter issues, too.
I don't know.
I hear Democrats all the time say,
we have to know, people don't want to know what we're for.
How about democracy?
Yeah, totally good at.
How about standing up for the rule of law?
Look, I mean, what, I think there's a danger in dialing up the rhetoric to 11
before we get all the evidence in.
When Bob Mueller comes in with all of the stories,
you want to have a word to say, okay, this is something new that we have learned.
But, I mean, I don't know that this was a turning point this week,
but when you saw those patriots and warriors, you know,
all of the intelligence community step forward and basically call out the president.
You know, this is one of those extraordinary moments.
You know, each and every one of them, you know, could kick President Bonespurs ass, every one of them.
And for, it's one thing for, you know, you know, the president to diss John McCain.
But now, you know, Trump world now has to try to discredit, you know, people who are, you know, heroes who have served this country for decades.
Now, before we use the word treason, and we may get to that word treason, just wait for the evidence, because there's going to become a moment.
Don't burn through it too fast.
Okay, I watched this documentary this week called Active Measures.
Yeah, no.
You've seen it.
It's coming out next week.
I think we have the director on soon.
And there's also a book out called House of Trump.
of Putin covers the same territory.
I'm sorry, but it's super obvious already.
He is a Russian asset.
This has been going on since the 80s
they were targeting for this.
And Bob Mueller's report is just going to be
what this movie and this book is.
Yes.
Well, you hope so.
With even more, it is.
It's going to be foolproof.
I'm not saying that's going to get him out of office.
But it's pretty clear to me
that he couldn't get money anywhere else
because among his other fine qualities,
he's a deadbeat.
He was in with the Russian mob
for... You know all this stuff.
And cut to the hookers peeing in the bed.
There's a very good chance
that this Mueller report is going to
disappoint you. I disagree.
Well, I know
that what you expect is this clear line
between Trump and the Kremlin
and that there were
quid pro quos, money
for this, favors delivered,
you know, signed sealed and delivered.
I think there's a good chance
you won't get that, that it won't be such a
clean document. They already have it.
It's fine. No, no, it's fine.
The Trump towers were money laundering
operations for all these Russian oligarchs.
So it's...
You do this, or you know this.
You do this reporting. So there's no question
that most of the big money
that was coming, you know, for these people
buying the condos were Russians.
But what your, what the missing piece of the
is what did he promise, say, what commitments did he make privately?
And I don't know about you, but I want to know the answer to those questions.
I want to know what he said.
And so far we have a meeting that Don Jr. took in Trump Tower, set up by some sleazy
music entrepreneur.
We also have everybody around him, Manafort, Flynn.
All these people were all cute, Rex Tillerson.
Why did they change the Republican, the whole platform?
Why did they do that?
But all these people around them were people with massive Russia connections who are into Russia.
Well, that's...
But I don't think we're disagree.
I'm just saying, I don't think we're disagreeing.
I'm saying there's clearly a lot of smoke there,
and what I'm saying is the final report may not deliver you the kill shot that you want.
It's going to be a political process.
And don't underestimate, you know, the president's possible success in obstructing this investigation.
I mean, the one story that is playing out in plain view is,
We're not speculating.
Is the president trying to obstruct this investigation?
Of course he is.
He's been doing it all along.
And what he is doing right now is he's creating an enemy's list.
And one of the interesting things about this enemy's list is how many witnesses,
corroborating witnesses to this criminal investigation are going on right now.
So, yeah, at some point you may get to the, you know, get to the word treason.
But right now, what you're seeing is this fundamental attack on, you know, liberal constitutional democracy,
the rule of law and the obstruction of justice.
You're seeing that in plain sight.
You are seeing the subsisting.
in plain sight, then why is there no Republican with a backbone in Congress that we're saying...
Oh, that's the easiest. I mean, let me take you...
If it's in plain sight.
I mean, let me take you inside that this is all I do every day is talk to Republicans on the Hill.
They are, they are shit scared. They are shit scared because they see the polls.
Then they should be shit out of office.
So what they should do.
We can all, like, everyone can feel good about themselves in class.
about themselves and clap. But all I'll tell you is Trump is the most, let's just deal in reality.
He is the most popular president among Republican voters in the last living memory.
More than Bush after 9-11 now. So like, we're talking like 65 million people voted for him.
It is mind-boggling. But you know what? There is a moment where you have to stand up even with
the polls and say, we are not, thank you to you. We're not a constitutional potted plan.
So this is an historic moment. And history is going to look back on this. And when people,
say, well, you know, what did you do when the Constitution was being undermined, when this
investigation was being obstructed, when the president of the United States was engaged in
the dealings? Well, I was looking at the polls. It's not going to be a tremendously compelling
defense. And also to just the rank and file, Republicans out there, this is your guy, a guy who
is willing to decimate America's security apparatus? Because they're onto him. That's why he's
doing it. They're onto him. So he's willing to throw them under the bus, the people who keep us
I mean, Jonathan had a story this morning in Axios that said that basically what Trump may be doing is pulling the security clearances of the entire Mueller team, effectively completely disabling them from doing their investigation.
So Mark Warner, Senator Warner, is going to be introducing some legislation on Monday saying that the president should not be allowed to willy-nilly pull away security clearances.
And let's just see how many Republicans will support.
Exactly.
So what the hell?
If that's not creating an enemy's list
where you are trying to silence them
and then Republicans being quiet
and accomplices to this slow coup,
I don't know what is.
And by the way, a few days before the election,
2016, Representative Michael McCall
of Texas Republicans
talking about Hillary's email server,
he said, now we find out
very likely that foreign adversaries
from other nations got into a private
server, a lie, of course.
This is, in my opinion, quite
frankly, it's treason.
So her email server was Trees.
They're not afraid to do it when it's bullshit.
We shouldn't be afraid to do it when it's real.
I just want to...
I want to show the Andrew Cuomo tape.
Andrew Cuomo stepped in political shit the other day
when he said, we're not going to make America great again.
It was...
Show the tape.
He says it better than I could.
We're not going to make America great again.
It was never that great.
Yeah, that's how Democrats handled patriots.
Here's how Republicans do it.
You see,
stop overestimating
the intelligence of the American public.
Just hump the flag.
But...
Send the memo.
Send them an email on that one.
That's not that hard, right?
Yeah. No, he blew it.
I mean, he blew it.
I know what he meant.
And when you go into the details, it's right.
But this is going to...
And he's apologized.
Let's just be clear.
You walked it back.
It doesn't matter.
No, but that's the point is it doesn't matter.
Because they will amplify it no matter what.
I remember I was covering the Democratic Convention in Philadelphia in 2016.
I remember going, they have all these stands selling merchandise,
and they had these T-shirts, had Hillary Clinton,
and that said, America is already great.
I thought, who the hell is going to vote for that?
Right.
But that's a lot better than Cuomo.
I mean, Cuomo's statement, and this is just weapons-grade political stupidity.
I mean, when you're doing this.
It is like walking right into the White House and saying, you know, let me live up to every stereotype that you want a Democrat to do.
And one of the things the Republicans are very, very good at is weaponizing these quotes.
I mean, remember when John Kerry said I was, you know, four, before I was against it?
Oh, this will have a shelf life of...
Obama just said, remember, you didn't build this?
He was like talking about a highway.
Okay, but of the millions of words that you speak as a public official, I mean, I screwed up so much.
many times. Not like that. You've never, I'm sure, screwed up in saying anything publicly.
It doesn't matter. I'm not a politician. Right, right. It doesn't matter so much for you. And I don't
care about screwing up. I'm trying to get at the truth, which is not what the politicians are doing.
Well, I mean, I don't know about that, but I do know that we screw up a lot. And that those
screw ups end up being how you are defined. Right. But the biggest screw up would be to
rally around and defend that and say, well, he's right about all of this. Because that is exactly
the debate that Donald Trump wants to have.
But he did back it off and it apologized
and it's not what he meant.
Not that we are not divided enough, but we found
out this week that we're even divided
at the movies because the Oscars are
coming out with a new category called
Outstanding Achievement in Popular
Film because apparently
the films that win the Oscars,
the Art House films, like the
Fishfucker movie this year.
You never remember that was. I always
call it the fish gold water.
What is it?
The shape of water.
The shape of water.
God damn it.
Okay.
Anyway, no one goes to see that.
They go to the big blockbuster movies and so no one's watching the Oscars anymore.
So the Oscars are basically saying, okay, here's an award for the crap you babies actually watch.
And so they, but, you know, they're going to try to put a fig leaf on the popular movies and combine them, I think.
That's what, because they still want to have an Oscar kind of movie.
So we've got a hold of some of the posters and stuff coming out.
Trying to have it both ways.
Like, look at this.
Ernest goes to Brokeback Mountain.
That's not going to fool.
Anybody, is it?
No country for Ant Man.
That's...
Free billboards outside Big Mama's house.
Shrek spear in love.
That's...
Oh.
Harold and Kumar go to the Dallas Buckeers.
Medea.
Medea kills a mockingbird.
One of the ones that...
Guess who's coming to dinner?
Hint, it's Thor.
Teenage mutant Ninja Gandhi is...
And the gods must be crazy rich Asians.
All right, he's the writer, comedian, and star of two TVs.
Adam Ruins Everything.
Please welcome Adam Cunover to the show for the first time.
You, what a great pleasure to meet you.
Oh, it's a pleasure to be here.
I had to have you, Wad, because...
Now, we've never met, right?
Never.
Right.
It's our first time ever speaking.
Right.
And that's why I'm doing this magic trick right now.
Oh, my gosh.
We've never met.
They always say that the music, no.
But I want it, because I think the conceit of your show
is really so smart.
Adam ruins everything.
And when you say ruins, I relate to that,
because sometimes I ruin things.
It's my job.
I tried to ruin Mars once,
because I thought going to Mars was stupid.
I also think it's kind of stupid, yeah.
It's very stupid.
It's just a little bit, it's great in an abstract sense,
but it's not like first on my list of things I want to do.
There's no air.
I'm out.
Oh, you just personally don't want to go.
There's no air and no atmosphere,
and it's 300 degrees below zero.
Yeah.
Yeah, I'll stay here on Earth.
Okay.
But yeah, but I get that when you ruin things
by telling the truth.
It's very hard to do both to tell the truth
and not be considered a meaning.
Well, that's what our show does.
You know, on our show, I dispel common misconceptions.
I tell people the awful truth about,
you know, everything they thought they knew.
but, you know, my character on the show is sort of like
kind of an asshole who everybody else hates,
and that makes it work comedically somehow.
That's a character, huh?
Yes.
That is what I tell myself at night, yes.
You are such a good actor.
Thank you.
No, no.
But so let's go through some of the things.
Because some of them were things that I also had attempted to ruin,
like labeling fish.
I saw you do one night, and I was like,
Oh, I must blow the lid off labeling.
People are not aware that fish fraud is a rampant problem in America.
It's true.
When you go out to a restaurant, especially sushi restaurants, like, for instance, white tuna,
when you see that on a sushi menu, that is almost never white tuna,
because white tuna is a relatively rare fish.
They killed them all.
Yeah, yeah.
And also, there's, like, very poor standards.
Almost no one's auditing these fish, you know, which is, again,
not first on my list of things I want to correct about America,
but it's something you might want to know before you got me.
I enjoy busting waiters when they say,
we have the Chilean CBS.
I guess, no, you don't.
Yeah, it's tilapia.
It's, fuck, it's whatever you fucking found down there
and brought, dragged in, it's fresh.
Fresh, it was caught in Alaska.
You made it swam here.
You look at that menu.
You crazy, you know, for instance,
there was no such thing as Chilean CBS.
They made it up.
You, it's true, I believe that was,
it had a, I figure what the name of that one,
it had a worst name.
There was a name called, I think, the slime head they renamed
the orange ruffie.
Right.
If you look at the menus now,
it could just say tilapia, tilapia, tilapia,
pink tilapia, red tilapia.
Exactly.
The hell with treason, this is what's important.
Yeah.
Another one, a topic we have coming up on our show
this year is about how avocados,
which are a hot new food in restaurants,
or not, you know, they're not that new,
but it's millennial thing.
They're on top of everything.
They're on toast, they're on salads.
A thing people don't realize about avocados
is that when you buy them,
you're actually indirectly to directly
supporting Mexican drug cartels
because the reason that we have so many avocados
is because of the way trade restrictions were loosened.
But as a result of that,
cartels got into the avocado business.
And now when you buy a Mexican avocado,
some of the money is going directly
to these brutal groups.
And since you can't get California avocados year-round,
like, if you want avocado toast, you're fucked.
There's nothing else in here.
It's like blood diamonds.
It more or less is, yeah.
And it just goes to show how we have a much more complicated relationship
with those groups than we think we do.
We're supporting them in all sorts of ways.
Enjoy your brunch this week, hipsters.
See, this is why people hate us.
You can't be liked and say the story.
No, that's okay.
They like you eventually.
They may, at the moment, but it's like a great teacher.
At the moment, oh, he gave me a lot of homework.
And then a year later, he taught me how to write.
Right.
Here's the thing I'll say about the show is that the superficial pledge of it is that I ruin things and that I bother people.
But ultimately, our show makes me very optimistic because the reason our show has had what success it's had is because the audience really likes to learn.
Exactly.
They really do.
Yeah, and it's when you hear that information, it's momentarily uncomfortable.
But then after you've actually gotten it and it's changed your worldview, you're like, oh wow, now I feel more empowered.
You want to go tell your friends, you know?
I have learned things.
I like it when I can actually learn things.
something. And what I learned from your show
that I never knew, it sort of applies not
to make everything about Donald Trump, but
I never knew this before
I learned it from you. There is no such thing
as the alpha male. Yeah, yeah.
I always believed in the concept of the alpha male.
This is one of the most... Hoping to be one one day.
I mean, look,
this is one of the most pernicious
pseudoscientific ideas that's
out there. A whole, you know, especially
like, you know, internet, like sort of these
crazy men's rights people have, like, made whole
bodies of, like, philosophical thought based on
well, there's two types of men, there's alphas, and there's betas.
And like, alphas get all the women, and they have all the success,
and betas are, you know, me.
But there's no scientific basis for this concept.
The idea originated from wolves, from the alpha wolf,
but the original wolf researcher who coined the term
later realized he was wrong,
and he had just been observing parents and children,
and the parents were dominant,
that there weren't actually, there wasn't an alpha-beta hierarchy.
And he tried to get his own book taken off the shelves
because he was like, this idea is horseshit,
I'm sorry for saying it, but it had taken on.
What a stupid researcher.
Well, no, no, I mean, scientists make mistakes.
I can't tell the child from the adult wolf.
I'm not a researcher.
I think I could do that.
I think I could tell which is the cub and which is the parent.
All right.
So one of the things I've spent a lifetime ruining
is religion, of course.
Sure.
And that's it.
I never used to get applause for that.
See what I mean?
Everything comes around.
Yeah.
A lot more people who believe that now.
And, of course, this week we had some very bad news for the Catholic Church.
Are you Catholic?
Sorry.
Charlie, you Catholic?
I'm a pretty bad one.
Oh.
Well, not worse than me.
But it's, you know, over 300 priests, over 1,000 victims.
This goes back quite a ways.
But I'm going to just say what I've said many times about the subject.
If it was anything other than the Catholic Church,
you heard this about Jiffy Loeb.
If you read in the paper, at Jiffy Loeb,
over 300 technicians were found guilty of molesting
over 1,000 children.
Would people still go to Jiffy Loeb?
It's amazing how they get away with it.
It's like, well, let's go to church and straighten this out.
Let me just see.
There is one way that is a surefire way
of stopping this ridiculous cover up
and this tendency toward protecting.
What you're going to say?
And it is, ordain women and let priests marry.
That's it.
Why are we...
Well, there's actually another way we could stop it.
Make the priests wear body cans.
Put it right in the cross.
What on earth would you want that footage for?
Well, I mean, you know, just like with the police,
they would think twice before they did something shitty.
Here's the problem, though, is that it's not as...
People seem to think that priests, for some reason, that the occupation causes them to become predators.
But what I've read is that what predators will do is they'll work their way into any social position of privilege where they're allowed to work with children and be sort of morally unquestioned.
And so, like, football coaches are another example.
That has the same social characteristics.
Football coaches can get married, right?
It has nothing to do with religion there.
Right.
It's just, and the problem is the institution.
If you create a situation in which, you know, people have access to children unfettered this way, you have a reason.
responsibility to make sure that you're not allowing vermin like that in your institution to sit there and
testify. Absolutely. It is a structural issue. It is a structural issue. There's a few parts of the story
that I think we're getting missed in some of the coverage. One is that we talk about that number of
300. That doesn't, that's not even in the universe of what the real number is. I mean, that is
the documented number when they subpoenaed. I mean, we don't know the scale of, of, of, of,
of what we're talking about.
And the other thing that really struck me
is just the resources required
to actually get to the truth.
I mean, the church stonewalled them at every step,
and it required the Boston Globe,
a full investigative team previously,
and now we have an attorney general
and the apparatus of the state.
The church is not making this easy.
It's still not made it.
And they apologize and they say how terrible it is,
but they never say it before they're caught,
which is the terrible thing.
And they don't say it after they're caught.
Kind of like the Trump and a statement.
It's a systemic cover on the cover-up.
Understand that if you are actually a Catholic,
you know, this is much more horrific than if you're not.
I mean, trust me, I feel more, you know, passionately about this than you do
because this is the church that claimed to be the body of Christ.
And, you know, yes, you know, the celibacy has failed,
you know, not having women in the church has failed.
But I'm saying that because this is reformation-style scandal.
This is not something that can be dealt with by a commission,
by an investigation.
This is a church that needs an enema.
And, and...
I mean, it is, it is.
And, uh...
And this is why I'm a bad...
There's a lot of people in that church who would enjoy it.
So let's...
Maybe that is not the best solution, right, Anna?
Okay.
All right, I want to talk about...
I want to talk about...
I will never live that.
Okay.
I...
No, it's...
I will never...
You just...
You just...
You just...
You just...
You just...
I'm not officially excommunicated.
All right, I am.
So I wanted to talk my free speech for a minute
because Alex Jones, who is not my friend
and who tells crazy lies about me,
is thrown off Twitter, I think, and Facebook
and a few of the platforms, I think he's gonna...
Thank God!
Well, if you're a liberal, you're supposed to be for free speech.
That's free speech for the speech you hate.
That's what free speech means.
We're losing the thread of the constant.
that are important to this country.
If you care about the real American shit,
or you don't. And if you do, it goes for every side.
I don't like Alex Jones, but Alex Jones gets to speak.
Everybody gets to speak.
Sure, but he doesn't necessarily get to speak
on Facebook or Twitter.
No, I get that.
If a guy goes out, and this is not opinion,
if he engages in vile slandered and fabrication
about children who were murdered at Sandy Hook,
and he harasses the parents of children
who were murdered at Sandy Hook,
That's not...
You know what?
Facebook, Twitter,
none of them have an obligation
to provide him a platform.
I understand that.
They're private companies.
And even more importantly,
this is not the Internet of 1996
where he put up a website
and he's using like the public pipes.
Like these companies, Facebook, YouTube,
Twitter, these are the majority
of time Americans spent on the Internet, right?
We're talking, for the Internet,
this is ABC, CBS, NBC, right?
And they're making money off of him.
They're running ads against him.
So, you know, I agree with you about free speech,
and that's of concern to me as well.
I also don't think those companies should be profiting
off of what he's saying.
And so I applaud them.
We all agree on that.
That private enterprise does not have any obligation.
If you make a T-shirt that says,
your mother sucks cocks in hell.
They don't have to sell it at baby gap.
You know, we get that.
But I'm just saying...
That's pretty much the same thing we're talking about here.
But it's, but yes, I understand.
But I'm just saying, as a concept, we have to understand that the way to get rid of hateful things is to the sunlight best disinfectant.
And a good example is, wait a second, the alt-right rally.
Alt-right two, the Nazis, remember last year in Charlottesville, they had their rally again?
20 people showed up, okay?
Not because we outlawed it, but because we let it happen the first time.
And these mental midgets found out, oh, it's not so great when you do this in public, because then you go back to the office.
and people don't like you so much.
Yeah, but Steve Bannon, Steve Bannon's on television tonight.
Yeah. And what, and what you...
So, I mean, the Albright hasn't disappeared.
And what the YouTube algorithm was doing was funneling people to Alex Jones.
Like, the YouTube algorithm is the crossing guard saying, hey, everybody, there's a rally, you know, let's all go to the rally.
And, like, bringing people to the United the Right.
The problem these tech companies are having is they don't know where to draw the line.
They know there are lines, and they're scared of their own shadow.
They, I see them.
Like, the tech execs come to Washington, D.C., where their tails between their
legs, desperately trying to have these off the records with us reporters.
What can we do to, you know, be more, you know, feeling?
And they're squeezed from all ends.
They're scared of conservatives because conservatives have these things,
oh, they're banning, shadow banning us.
And they're scared of the left because the left saying, you know, clamp down on
anyone who says anything offensive.
And they're scared of their own shadow.
They're in a crouch and they don't know what to do.
Well, except for that they do need to act to at least uphold their own terms.
of service, which is what they're doing.
But they keep changing.
Right, but they do.
But they do.
But here's the concern I have to your point, Bill, about more speech, which is your point, right?
On these platforms, in 2016, 44% of people who identified as left of center did not post
anything about politics on their social media feed.
44%.
On the Republican side, on the conservative side, it was only 8%.
Why didn't they post?
Because they didn't want to be trolled, harassed.
or abused. These platforms, yes, they are quasi-public squares,
but they have an obligation to make sure that people are not harassed
when they use them. And that's why I think this is an important step.
It's only a weak suspension for Pete's sake. It's not like it was the end of the world.
But they have an obligation.
Like a timeout?
I mean, the Twitter thing is just ridiculous.
He's going to have Alex Jones off Twitter for a week, so he thinks about what he's done.
I mean what? Like he's some sort of a, you know, nine-year-old who,
who is, you know,
who say, hey, I'm really sorry about that.
Yeah, the kids really are dead.
I mean.
Okay, all right.
Well, I am cute.
Just don't forget that.
All right.
Thank you, panel.
It's time for New Rules, everybody.
New Rules.
Okay, New Rule, the people at the White House
who let a reality show villain bring a recording device
into the White House Situation Room
have to answer the question,
you do know that that room is not named after the situation.
New Rule, stop telling me that this or that video game
video game has a great story.
Really? Because if Tomb Raider
were a novel,
it would read
like this. I find myself
in a jungle. I look to the left.
I look to the right.
I walk forward.
I come to a ravine.
I think I can jump over it.
I jump over it.
Now I'm on the other side.
I look to the left.
I look to the right.
I walk.
forward. See, not really a great story. New Roll, France needs to stop getting so
worked up about their new open-air urinals. Our country has had these for years.
Oh. They're called phone boots.
New Roll, if you take part in the La Chona Challenge, the viral video craze,
where you get out of your moving car and dance alongside it, I have to thank you
for making an otherwise bleak summer a little more.
fun. I'm kidding, you're a fucking idiot.
New Rule.
If Fox News is going to run as they did a tribute to
Aretha Franklin featuring a photo of Patty LaBelle,
they did that.
B.E.T. must run this tribute to Barbara Bush.
And finally, new rule.
Someone else to explain how one side sees this man
is the most prolific liar in history,
And the other side says, I like him because he's authentic.
President Pinocchio averages seven and a half lies a day.
And yet his followers all say the same thing.
He tells it like it is.
He speaks what's left of his mind.
We have never seen anything like this.
A man totally insecure, yet supremely confident.
Not a politician, but also the most politician ever.
Bald, but with a full head of hair.
Trust me, Trump is not concerned that Amarosa has some recording that will blow his cover.
Because he has no cover.
He's like the water supply in Flint, Michigan. No filter.
And the damnedest thing about that is it's actually kind of refreshing.
Because in an age dominated by the professionally offended,
we secretly envy the man who is able to speak his mind.
Trump saw a nation exhausted from political correctness and said,
you want warm and fuzzy, stick your dick in an ug boot.
Whereas the rest of us really live two lives.
There's the real us, the person in the kitchen or a bar,
who speaks like a human with trusted friends.
And then there's what I call our avatar.
Our avatar looks and sounds like us, but it's not really us.
It's the persona we adopt in any sort of public sphere,
which now includes your followers on Twitter and Instagram
and thousands of people.
friends on Facebook and, you know, bad things go viral, so everyone fears any misstep that could
cause America's pearl clutches to point and scream at you like the end of invasion of the body snatchers.
Think of all the people who've lost job offers because there's a picture of them that got posted
holding a bong or having a dick drawn on their face when they were passed out, which I think should
get you more job offers because being passed out tells employers,
when I do something, I do it 110%.
Americans today crave any kind of authenticity
because our avatars are just so full of shit.
A few weeks ago, the actress Amber Heard
forgot to turn her phone on Avatar Mode
and tweeted what was actually good advice for actual people.
Just heard there's an ice checkpoint in Hollywood.
Everyone better give their housekeepers nannies
and landscapers arrive home tonight.
No, so offensive,
because we all know there's so many Jewish gardeners out here.
I wonder if there was a Hispanic man that night
sitting in the back of a patty wagon thinking,
at least no one assumed because I'm a gardener, I'm Latino,
that would be the real tragedy.
Isn't it ironic that we elected Trump
because we were so sick of politicians
who were inauthentic, who were all avatar?
Isn't that why people hated Hillary?
But then we became the politicians.
Everyone's social media persona now
is like a candidate running for office.
Holding babies, doing photo ops,
making sure every statement is carefully sanded down
so as not to upset anybody.
Facebook should be called to Facebook.
It's funny in movies.
Avatars are more interesting versions of ourselves,
flying around doing whatever they want,
but your avatar on Facebook
isn't better or stronger
or faster than you are. It's just prissier.
It's great superpower
as it remembers birthdays.
Folks, if you want to know
who someone really is,
ignore their avatar and check out their
web browser history.
There's a book out called Everybody Lies
that's about what we search for on
Google, and according to the author,
quote, 30% of people exclusively
watch stuff that you would find disgusting.
Look at a list of popular porn categories.
Cuckold, cheerleader, stepmom,
double penetration, cream pie, tentacle sex.
Sounds like we're...
Sounds like we're playing password for perverts.
Things your husband wants, but you don't.
On Facebook, women's top terms for describing husbands
are the best, my best friend,
and amazing.
But when women type in,
my husband is on Google,
the top three results are mean,
annoying, and gay.
You have to wonder
if the more bland
we make our public avatores,
the more weird
we want to be at home.
Anyone who works that hard
to appear moral in public
is usually a freak in private.
It's a theory
I don't have much evidence
to support
except for every evangelical
pastor ever.
All right, that's our show.
I'll be at the cross.
Times Theater in Syracuse, October 7th.
I want to thank my guests for putting up
at this dirty show.
Charlie Sykes, Jonathan Swan,
Jennifer Granholm, Adam Cunover,
and Creek Marrera.
Join us now for overtime on YouTube.
Thank you, folks.
Catch all new episodes of Real Time
with Bill Maher every Friday night at 10
or watch them anytime on HBO on demand.
For more information,
log on to HBO.com.
