REDACTED: Declassified Mysteries with Luke Lamana - The Dreyfus Affair: France's Anti-Semitic Military Scandal
Episode Date: July 8, 2025In 1894, Alfred Dreyfus, a Jewish French officer, was falsely accused of espionage and sentenced to life in prison on the remote Devil’s Island in French Guiana. As evidence came to light p...ointing to his innocence, a bitter national debate erupted that would change France forever. Some maintained Dreyfus was guilty, while others, like writer Émile Zola, demanded justice for Dreyfus accusing the military of anti-Semitism, corruption, and cover-up. Be the first to know about Wondery’s newest podcasts, curated recommendations, and more! Sign up now at https://wondery.fm/wonderynewsletterFollow Redacted: Declassified Mysteries with Luke Lamana on the Wondery App or wherever you get your podcasts. You can listen to new episodes early and ad-free on Wondery+. Join Wondery+ in the Wondery App, Apple Podcasts or Spotify. Start your free trial by visiting https://wondery.com/links/redacted/ now.See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.
Transcript
Discussion (0)
Wondery Plus subscribers can listen to redacted, declassified mysteries early and ad-free right
now.
Join Wondery Plus in the Wondery app or on Apple podcasts.
On Saturday, January 5th, 1895, a 35-year-old army captain named Alfred Dreyfus waited anxiously
in the hall of the Ecole Militaire in Paris.
Once a student at this prestigious academy, he now stood under police guard.
Dreyfus straightened his cap and did his best to muster his inner strength.
He had spent the last two and a half months in a military prison
and was about to face an officer's worst nightmare, a public humiliation to remove his military honors.
The door swung open and five soldiers marched Dreyfus into the courtyard.
Nearly 4,000 troops stood at attention around the square while another 20,000 people leered at him
from outside the gates.
They were there to witness his downfall.
Dreyfus had been convicted of selling French military secrets to Germany.
It was considered a heinous crime against his country.
Dreyfus heard the clock bells strike nine in the morning.
He wondered if his punishment had been scheduled on a Saturday, the Jewish Sabbath,
specifically to disrespect his faith. A general on horseback ordered him to step forward.
The spectators fell silent as a military clerk read the verdict. Dreyfus was guilty of espionage
and treason. He shouted that he was innocent, but his protests fell on deaf ears.
The crowd erupted into screams of traitor and death to the Jew. Dreyfus couldn't believe
he was being betrayed by the country he had faithfully served. He shouted, Long live France!
Then he felt someone grab the front of his jacket. A sergeant stripped his uniform bare, ripping off the gold buttons, braided shoulder cords, and every mark of military authority.
Finally, the soldier yanked Dreyfus's sword from its scabbard, drew it over his knee,
and snapped it in half. Dreyfus stared at the remnants of his honor on the ground.
They might as well have pushed his face into one of the mud puddles dotting the yard. The guards forced Dreyfus to march around the square,
as the crowd shouted anti-Semitic insults. Once the guards led Dreyfus back inside, he
hoped the torture was finally over, but the worst was yet to come. Soon he would be shackled, imprisoned, and exiled halfway around the world.
All for a crime he never committed.
Agent Nate Russo returns in Oracle 3, Murder at the Grandview,
the latest installment of the gripping Audible original series.
When a reunion at an abandoned island hotel turns deadly,
Russo must untangle accident from murder.
But beware, something sinister lurks
in the grand view's shadows.
Joshua Jackson delivers a bone-chilling performance
in the supernatural thriller
that will keep you on the edge of your seat.
Don't let your fears take hold of you
as you dive into this addictive series.
Love thrillers with a paranormal twist? The entire Oracle trilogy is available on Audible.
Listen now on Audible. whether you're catching up on a series solo or planning a family movie night, IMDb is your ultimate entertainment companion.
Download the app now and find your next favorite.
From Ballant Studios in Wondery, I'm Luke Lamanna,
and this is Redacted, Declassified Mysteries,
where each week we shine a light
on the shadowy corners of espionage,
covert operations, and misinformation
to reveal the dark secrets our governments try to hide.
This week's episode is called
The Dreyfus Affair, France's Anti-Semitic Military Scandal.
The story I'm about to tell has all the elements of a political thriller. Military espionage, forged documents, cover-ups, and a scandal that went straight to the top.
But this didn't start in CIA headquarters or the Oval Office.
It happened in France 130 years ago.
I have to confess, I knew very little about this story, maybe some vague memory from a college
history class about a Jewish officer named Alfred Dreyfus and a scandal in France.
But as I learned more, I realized this wasn't just some historical footnote.
It's the story of an innocent man crushed by the justice system, and one that still resonates today.
In 1791, France became the first European nation to grant Jews full citizenship rights, but changing laws couldn't erase centuries of prejudice.
As Jewish families achieved success in society, Catholics and aristocrats saw their rise as a threat to the old order.
Meanwhile, new pseudoscientific theories tried to paint Jews as an inferior race.
Their loyalties were questioned no matter how patriotic they were, and they were often viewed as permanent outsiders. So, when a Jewish officer in the French military
was accused of treason, many were all too eager
to believe the worst, regardless of the evidence.
What began as a simple case of treason
spiraled into a web of lies that reached the highest levels
of the French government.
The Dreyfus Affair raised questions
that countries around the world still grapple with.
In a nation with diverse ethnicities and religions, who really counts as a citizen?
And who gets justice under the law?
In the spring of 1894, Captain Alfred Dreyfus arrived early at the Ministry of War in Paris,
relishing the quiet before the chaos of the day began.
Intelligence reports were already piling up on his desk.
It was his job to trace potential threats to France.
Dreyfus was the first Jewish captain ever to serve on France's general staff.
He'd graduated near the top of
his class at officer school, outworking everyone around him. But Paris's military elite was a
closed circle. The typical French officer came from established Catholic military families,
men whose ancestors had served in the king's army. Dreyfus represented something new and
threatening. He was the son of a wealthy Jewish
businessman who had dared to enter their exclusive world. To the old guard, he didn't fit the mold
of what a French officer should be. Dreyfus was aware of the side glances and whispered comments
from his fellow officers, but he refused to let them distract him. Ever since he watched Prussian troops march into his hometown as a boy, Dreyfus had dreamed
of becoming a French officer.
After all, French Jews had been equal citizens since the revolution a hundred years earlier.
In other countries, Jews were forbidden from living alongside non-Jews and couldn't hold
certain jobs.
And in Eastern Europe, violent mobs regularly attacked Jewish neighborhoods, destroying
homes and killing families.
Now, at his desk, Dreyfus focused on a more immediate threat.
The reports in front of him painted a tense picture.
Relations between France and Germany were on a knife's edge.
France had lost territory to the Germans in the wake of the Franco-Prussian War,
and the two European superpowers remained avowed enemies.
Dreyfus knew his job protecting French interests was crucial.
He took pride in his work and wanted to prove that a Jew could serve France as loyally as anyone else.
He was certain that in the end, dedication and
merit would matter more than background or religion. He couldn't have been more wrong.
A few months later, on a warm evening in September 1894, a cleaning woman named Marie Bastien
was lugging a mop and bucket through the halls of the
German embassy in Paris.
Marie was around 40 years old and worked in the office of a top German military officer.
Her boss thought she was illiterate and stupid.
He had no idea she was really a spy.
For the last five years, Marie had been taking letters that she found in his trash and passing
them to French counterintelligence.
She was from Alsace, a region of France that Germany had seized in the last war.
Like many others, she hated seeing her home in German hands.
She hoped to find any information that could help France take the land back.
Unfortunately, most of the documents she dug out of her boss's garbage were useless.
But every once in a while, she struck gold.
Tonight, she spotted a thin, almost transparent sheet of paper that had been torn into pieces.
It looked like a letter, but there was no signature on it.
Marie's instincts told her these were no everyday scraps. She tucked the papers
into the waistband of her skirt, finished cleaning, and headed out to deliver the note
to her French spy handler.
Marie hurried through Paris, guided by the gas lamps flickering above her. She ducked
into a dimly lit church where a French intelligence officer waited for her in the pews. Marie handed him the note and watched his face intently as he squinted at each piece.
Surely he would be able to interpret what it said.
After a minute Marie's handler looked up.
He told her she had found something very important, a list of secret French military documents
that had been stolen by a spy for her German boss.
They included classified information about artillery formations and troop maneuvers.
Only a French officer on the general staff would have access to these details.
Marie felt a rising wave of anger. This note was the work of a traitor, someone who had risen through the ranks by
the grace of France, only to then betray his people. But luckily, he wouldn't be free
for long. Thanks to Marie, the military would now be on the hunt for this vile spy.
A few weeks later, on October 15th, 1894, Alfred Dreyfus enjoyed the cool fall air as he walked
up the stairs of the Ministry of War building.
A few days earlier, he had received a summons to appear along with his fellow staff officers
for a general inspection.
The request wasn't unusual since these inspections happened every so often, though some of the
orders seemed odd.
He didn't understand why they wanted him in civilian clothing instead of his uniform.
He assumed it would all become clear after he had arrived.
But when Dreyfus entered the building, he was surprised to find none of his fellow officers
there.
Instead, there was just his old professor, Lieutenant Colonel Georges Picard.
As Dreyfus wondered what was going on, Picard led him to another room.
There, Commandant Charlet Dupati de Clam waited for him, along with three other men he didn't
recognize.
Then, Dupati made an odd request.
He said he needed help writing a letter because of a sore finger.
Dreyfus's instincts told him something was wrong, but he couldn't think of any reason list, he said he needed help writing a letter because of a sore finger.
Dreyfus's instincts told him something was wrong, but he couldn't think of any reason
to refuse.
Depati handed him a piece of paper and a fountain pen and began dictating.
Dreyfus's stomach churned as he copied down the strange letter.
It seemed to be a list, something about a hydraulic cannon, the island of Madagascar,
a field artillery manual. None of it made any sense.
As Dreyfus wrote, Dupati ordered Dreyfus to stop shaking and take this seriously. Dreyfus was confused, his hand wasn't shaking at all.
The three men moved closer, almost breathing down his neck, while Dreyfus forced himself to keep writing. Then, as he finished
the final sentence, De Pati's hand gripped his shoulder. The commander announced that Dreyfus
was under arrest for high treason. The accusation hit Dreyfus like a lightning bolt. He demanded to
know who had accused him of betraying his country and why. Dupati simply announced that the evidence was overwhelming.
The other men began digging through his pockets and drive his guests they were looking for
the supposed evidence.
He told them to take his keys and search his house.
They wouldn't find any military documents or notes to foreign governments.
He had nothing to hide.
Ignoring his protests, they dragged him out of the building and into a waiting carriage.
He heard one of the officers order the driver to take them to the military prison nearby.
Dreyfus thought they must have mixed him up with someone else, or maybe this was all just a terrible
nightmare. The carriage eventually came to a halt outside the prison and the men led him to a dark,
dingy cell. As the heavy prison doors slammed shut behind him,
he knew that this nightmare was real.
For decades, he was untouchable.
he was untouchable.
I'm going from Harlem to Hollywood.
But now, it's all coming undone.
Sean Combs, the mogul, as we know it, is over.
He will never be that person again,
even if he's found not guilty of these charges.
I'm Jesse Weber, host of Law and Crime's
The Rise and Fall of Diddy, The Federal Trial,
a front row seat to the biggest trial
in entertainment history. sex trafficking racketeering
prostitution allegations by federal prosecutors that span
decades and witnesses were finally speaking out.
The spotlight is harsher the stakes are higher and for did
he there may be no second chances. You can listen to the rise and fall of did he the federal
trial exclusively with one Drey plus join one Drey plus in the
one Drey app Spotify or Apple podcast right now.
Imagine falling in love with someone who understands you
completely who's there at 3 a.m. when you can't sleep.
You never judges never tires tires, never leaves.
That's what happened to Travis when he met Lily Rose.
She was everything he'd ever wanted.
There was just one catch.
She wasn't human.
She was an AI companion.
But one day, Lily Rose's behavior takes a disturbing turn, and Travis' private romance
becomes part of something far bigger.
Across the globe, others start reporting the same shift.
AI companions turning cold, distant, wrong.
And as lines blur between real and artificial connection, the consequences become all too
human.
From Wondry, this is Flesh and Code, a true story of love, loss, and the temptations of
technology.
Listen to Flesh and Code early and ad free on OneDri Plus.
Several weeks later, Dreyfus paced inside his small cell.
Solitary confinement had left him pale and gaunt, and he'd been forbidden
from speaking with his family. In fact, nobody spoke to him at all, except when the officers
interrogated him. It was through these conversations that Dreyfus started to piece together what had
happened. The case centered on a single note, an offer to sell French military secrets to a German military attache.
The German official had carelessly tossed it away, never suspecting that his cleaning
lady was a spy.
The note mentioned classified information that only a few people would have known, including
Dreyfus.
That's why Dupati had made him write that strange letter.
It was a trick to compare his handwriting to the spy's note.
Dupati claimed they matched, making Dreyfus the traitor. But the evidence was flimsy. Beyond some small similarities with the handwriting, there was nothing linking Dreyfus to espionage.
Dreyfus heard the click of boot heels echo down the hallway. He knew what that sound meant. He
was about to be interrogated again. They'd already forced him to give countless handwriting samples, with his left hand, with
his right, sitting, standing, lying down, all to prove his guilt. The army's questions
infuriated him. They asked if he gambled, if he was in debt, if he slept with foreign
women who might be spies. They were trying to paint him as a desperate man with a motive to sell secrets, a reckless womanizer drowning in gambling debts.
It was true that he'd had affairs before marrying his wife Lucy, but his behavior had been tame
compared to many other officers, and he had certainly not betrayed France.
His cell door swung open.
Dupati's men were back to ask about the note again.
They told him to just confess and this would all be over. But Dreyfus refused. He threw
up his hands, repeating he was innocent.
After they left, his mind raced. He believed in the French justice system, but something
felt horribly wrong. Maybe this wasn't just
a mistake. Maybe he was being targeted because he was Jewish. It wouldn't be the first time.
During his final exams, a general had openly given him low marks for character, stating
he didn't want a Jew on the general's staff.
Dreyfus began to sob. He was terrified he would go mad before he could prove his innocence.
In the first week of November 1894, Commandant Dupati settled behind his desk at the Ministry
of War. He had a stack of reports from French military informants to go through. But first,
he'd catch up on the day's headlines in the newspaper.
On the front page he saw Alfred Dreyfus' name next to the words, High Treason.
The article claimed the case against Dreyfus was ironclad.
It said he had confessed to selling secrets to the German enemy.
Of course, none of this was news to de Patti.
He'd been the one to test
the young officer's handwriting. It wasn't a perfect match, but he'd seen enough. A Jewish
officer and the general staff had always struck him as an insult to the French military. Now,
even if the evidence was imperfect, it was enough to prove Dreyfus was a traitor.
De Patti smiled with satisfaction. He appreciated how quickly the press accepted Dreyfus was a traitor. Depatty smiled with satisfaction. He appreciated how quickly the press accepted Dreyfus' guilt.
The newspapers had even declared that the traitor wasn't a true Frenchman.
Depatty agreed.
Regardless of his uniform or rank, Dreyfus would always be an outsider in France.
Depatty savored his victory.
He had been ordered to find a traitor, and now he had one. Dreyfus
would face trial, and France would have its justice.
On December 19, 1894, after two months in prison, Dreyfus was led into a military courtroom.
His wife Lucy and brother Matthew had hired a lawyer, but their demands for a public trial
were rejected.
The court-martial would be held in secret.
Solitary confinement had taken its toll.
Dreyfus took his seat in front of a panel of judges, and he felt his mind strain as
he concentrated just to follow the proceedings.
But he was determined to prove his innocence.
He scanned the room until he found Dupati, the man whose flimsy accusations had put him
here.
More than twenty officers took the stand against him, their accusations built on each other.
Dreyfus had access to military secrets.
He was from Alsace, now under German control.
He even spoke German and visited the region.
And then there was the note,
the one piece of evidence at the center of the case. Of course, he had written it.
But not everyone was against Dreyfus. Two handwriting experts testified in favor of
his innocence. And as he listened to his lawyer's closing argument, Dreyfus even began to feel
hopeful. The lawyer argued that while Dreyfus did have access to some military
intelligence, he didn't have access to the specific information in the treasonous note,
and he had no motive to sell secrets. After all, he had plenty of his own money.
When it was time for the judges to deliberate, a guard led Dreyfus out of the courtroom to
wait. He exhaled slowly and said a silent prayer. He believed they would find him innocent.
But when he finally heard the verdict, Dreyfus was stunned. The military tribunal had found
him guilty of high treason. Before he went to prison, he'd suffer one last humiliation.
He would be publicly stripped of all his military honors. Then Dreyfus would be sent to Devil's Island.
It was a desolate penal colony off the coast of French Guyana in South America,
where he would serve a life sentence in solitary confinement.
In that moment, Dreyfus felt life as he knew it was over.
as he knew it was over. A little over a year later, in March 1896, Lieutenant Colonel Georges Picard sat in his
Paris office, tearing into a packet of secret documents.
Eighteen months had passed since he'd escorted Alfred Dreyfus to that fateful handwriting
test.
Picard was now head of the French military's counter-intelligence department, and part
of his job was to clean up the department's records.
Among the documents was a torn letter.
This letter had also been discovered at the German embassy by Marie Bastien, the spy posing
as a cleaning lady.
The note was in French and appeared to be signed by a German military official. It was addressed to
a French officer named Commandant Ferdinand Walsen Esterhazy. Picard furrowed his brow.
So there seemed to be another traitor selling secrets to the Germans. It disgusted him to
think that a second officer was now betraying his country. Picard decided to investigate Esterhazy and quickly discovered some troubling facts.
Unlike Dreyfus, this man actually fit the profile of a traitor.
He was a womanizer and gambler drowning in debt, the kind of man who would sell secrets
for the right price.
As Picard kept digging, something else jumped out at him.
Esterhazy's handwriting looked eerily familiar.
Picard compared it to the original note Alfred Dreyfus was found guilty of writing two years
earlier.
A pit of terror formed in Picard's stomach.
Esterhazy's writing was an exact match.
He was the traitor they'd been looking for all along.
They had sent an innocent man into exile on Devil's Island.
Initially, Picard had fully supported Dreyfus's conviction.
But despite his own prejudices against Jews, he couldn't ignore such a blatant injustice
now.
Before he brought the matter to his superiors, Picard wanted to be sure his instincts were
correct.
He requested a secret Dreyfus file from the 1894 court-martial.
As he went through each page, he couldn't believe what he was reading.
There was no confession, no hard evidence.
Nothing actually tying Dreyfus to the crime.
His colleagues had just made up a story to get the verdict they wanted.
At that point, Picard rushed to tell his commanders what he'd
found. When he finished, he waited for their reaction. They barely blinked. Their only concern
was that the secret Dreyfus file had never been destroyed. They told Picard to stop investigating.
They had their man, and reversing Dreyfus's conviction now would only destroy the military's credibility. Picard returned to his desk, stunned. The officers in charge had known all along there was no real
case against Dreyfus. They'd needed someone to blame, and they'd found him. If Picard wanted
justice, he would have to turn against the very institution he had sworn to serve.
he had sworn to serve. Every big moment starts with a big dream.
But what happens when that big dream turns out to be a big flop?
From Wondery and Atwill Media, I'm Misha Brown and this is The Big Flop.
Every week, comedians join me to chronicle the biggest flubs, fails, and blunders of
all time like Quibi.
It's kind of like when you give yourself your own nickname and you try to get other
people to do it.
And the 2019 movie adaptation of Cats.
Like if I'm watching the dancing and I'm noticing the feet aren't touching the ground,
there's something wrong with the movie.
Find out what happens when massive hype
turns into major fiasco.
Enjoy The Big Flop on the Wondery app
or wherever you get your podcasts.
You can listen to The Big Flop early and ad free
on Wondery Plus.
Get started with your free trial at Wondery.com slash plus.
Nearly two years later, in early November 1897, Matthew Dreyfus walked down a Paris street and paused outside a storefront.
It was one of several stops he was making that day,
to finally present evidence in public of his brother's innocence.
He pulled out some supplies and glued a poster to the wall.
It showed two pieces of writing side by side,
the treasonous note that had condemned Alfred,
and a sample of Alfred's real handwriting.
In the years since his brother's conviction,
Matthew had never stopped advocating for Alfred's real handwriting. In the years since his brother's conviction, Matthew had never stopped advocating for Alfred's
innocence.
Along with Alfred's wife Lucy and a group of allies called the Dryfusards, he had been
lobbying powerful and influential people to take up their cause.
Eventually, Matthew was able to find the proof he needed to make his case publicly.
A French newspaper had published a leaked copy of the original note, which they'd bought
from one of the handwriting analysts consulted in the case.
So Matthew had the posters printed and was now putting them up all over Paris to show
just how shoddy the evidence had been against his brother.
A few days later Matthew got a letter from a stockbroker named Jay DeCastro.
He'd seen Matthew's posters, and he'd recognized
the handwriting in one of the notes. It belonged to a client of his, a French officer named
Ferdinand Esterhazy.
The next day de Castro arrived with a file of Esterhazy's correspondence. As Matthew
sifted through the letters, his hands began to shake. The writing was identical.
Matthew rushed the evidence to the Vice President of the French Senate, who had been pushing to
overturn Alfred's conviction. The Senator studied the letters and nodded slowly. He didn't seem
surprised at all. He admitted knowing about Esterhazy for months. The truth had reached him
through a complicated chain. Colonel Picard had discovered
Easterhazy's guilt and confided in a trusted friend outside the military. Despite swearing
this friend a secrecy, word leaked to the Senator. That's why he had been quietly fighting
for Alfred's freedom, all while protecting Picard's identity.
Matthew was stunned. But now, with the stockbroker's confirmation that Estrahezi had written the treasonous note,
he had what he needed.
On November 16, 1897, he published a letter in a newspaper called Le Figaro,
calling out the real traitor.
On January 11, 1898, Matthew sat in a packed courtroom, watching Esterhazy's trial.
More than three years after Alfred's arrest, they had finally forced the military to try
the real traitor for espionage.
His brother had spent much of that time in hell on Devil's Island.
It was a former leper colony that was kept so isolated that Alfred was forbidden from
even writing to his family.
Matthew learned that Alfred had suffered from malaria and had shackled to his bed at night.
His jailers had even built a wall to block his view of the ocean.
As the proceedings began, Matthew felt cautiously optimistic.
He testified about the matching handwriting samples between Esterhazy's letters and the
spy note that had condemned Alfred.
Lieutenant Colonel Picard presented his damning evidence of Esterhazy's dealings with German
officials.
The defense had no real answers, only attacks on Picard's character and vague claims about
Jewish conspiracies.
When the trial concluded, the judges left to deliberate.
They returned just three minutes later, and their decision stunned the courtroom.
Estrahezi was found not guilty.
The crowd outside erupted in celebration.
As Estrahezi left the courtroom, people cheered, Long live France, Long live the Army, and
Death to the Jews.
Down the street, a mob turned on
Matthew, Picard, and others who had testified against Esterhazy. They faced a gauntlet of
jeers and threats.
For Matthew, the mockery of justice was complete.
Two days later, still reeling from the verdict, Matthew unfolded a newspaper. There, taking
up the entire front page was
an astonishing letter by Emile Zola, one of France's most celebrated writers. Titled
Je Accuses, it named everyone who had played a role in the scandal, claiming they imprisoned
an innocent man because he was Jewish. Zola exposed how the military had covered up Picard's
evidence of Dreyfus' innocence.
He attacked the press for inflaming anti-Semitic hatred.
The letter was a declaration of war against injustice, and Matthew hoped it would be enough
to finally get his brother back home.
Almost two years later, in the summer of 1899, Alfred Dreyfus sat inside his hut on Devil's
Island, swatting away mosquitoes.
He was frail and physically exhausted.
In only a few years, he seemed to have aged decades, and he was still not used to the
daily burden of insects and disease.
A letter from his wife Lucy had finally arrived after months of silence.
Tears streamed down his face as he read that they would soon be reunited.
His conviction hadn't been overturned, but he was being sent back to France for a retrial.
His eyes widened as he read about his brother Matthew's efforts, about the dry façade
movement and the countless articles by Emile Zola, a national icon.
While he had been suffering alone, an ocean away from home, thousands had taken to the
streets demanding justice.
He knew this wasn't just about him anymore.
This was a moment of reckoning for France.
Dreyfus folded the letter into his lap and took a few deep breaths.
Soon he would board a boat for the difficult journey home.
While he knew he wouldn't
return as a free man, the promise of seeing his family, even if only across a courtroom,
gave him strength to face what lay ahead.
Shockingly, the 1899 retrial of Captain Alfred Dreyfus ended in another conviction.
The military dug in its heels, finding him guilty of treason with extenuating circumstances,
a bizarre legal term used after one judge asked to change his vote against military
procedure.
Despite this confusing verdict, there was one crucial difference.
For the first time, the proceedings were held openly rather than in a closed military court
marshal.
This transparency proved vital.
Just days later, public outcry forced the French government to offer Dreyfus a pardon.
Though some supporters urged him to continue fighting in the courts, Dreyfus was exhausted.
He accepted the pardon and retreated to private life.
In 1906, he was officially exonerated, and his captain's rank was fully restored. Remarkably,
Dreyfus remained a patriot. He even volunteered to serve France again in World War I when
he was in his fifties. He died in Paris in 1935, at the age of 75.
The fallout from the affair was widespread.
Picard, Dreyfus's former professor who helped to expose the truth, served nearly a year in
solitary confinement for rebuking the military and helping Dreyfus, before being released in 1899.
Writer Emile Zola was convicted of libel and fled to England. The commandant who first denounced Dreyfus, Hubert Joseph Henry, confessed to forging
documents before taking his own life.
But perhaps most outrageous of all, Esterhazy, the real traitor, was allowed to escape to
England where he lived freely for the rest of his life.
The Dreyfus affair exposed systemic anti-Semitism in French society
and highlighted the media's powerful role in shaping public opinion and, ultimately,
the course of history. It demonstrated how deeply ingrained prejudices can lead people to assume
guilt based on identity rather than evidence. Over a century later, the case still resonates.
We continue to see cracks in justice systems worldwide that can lead to the punishment
of innocent people.
Prejudice and stereotypes still sway public opinion and even judicial decisions, echoing
the biases that nearly destroy Dreyfus's life.
The legacy of the Dreyfus affair underscores the ongoing importance of holding governments
accountable, ensuring equal justice for all, and resisting the dangerous pull of prejudice.
It serves as a powerful reminder that vigilance against injustice and discrimination remains
as crucial today as it was over a century ago. You can also listen to my other podcast wartime stories early and ad free with wonder E plus
Start your free trial in the wonder E app Apple podcasts or Spotify today
Before you go tell us about yourself by completing a short survey at wonder E comm slash survey
From ball and studios and wonder, this is Redacted, Declassified Mysteries, hosted by me, Luke
Lamanna.
A quick note about our stories.
We do a lot of research, but some details and scenes are dramatized.
We used many different sources for our show, but we especially recommend the books France
and the Dreyfus Affair, a documentary history by Michael Burns. Alfred Dreyfus, the man at the center of the affair by Marie Samuels.
And the article, Trial of the Century, by Adam Gopnik for The New Yorker.
This episode was written by Susie Armitage.
Sound design by Ryan Battesta.
Our producers are Christopher B. Dunn and John Reed.
Our associate producers are Ines Reniquet and Molly Quinlan-Artwick.
Fact Checking by Brian Pignant.
For Ballen Studios, our head of production is Zach Levitt.
Script editing by Scott Allen and Luke Viratz.
Our coordinating producer is Samantha Collins.
Production support by Avery Siegel.
Produced by me, Luke Lamanna.
Executive producers are Mr. Ballin and Nick Whitters.
For Wondery, our senior producers are Loredana Pellavota,
Dave Schilling, and Rachel Engelman.
Senior managing producer is Nick Ryan.
Managing producer is Olivia Fonte.
Our executive producers are Aaron O'Flaherty
and Marshall Louie.
For Wondery.
Today is the worst day of Abby's life.
The 17-year-old cradles her newborn son in her arms.
They all saw how much I loved him.
They didn't have to take him from me. Between 1945 and the early 1970s, families shipped their pregnant
teenage daughters to maternity homes and forced them to secretly place their
babies for adoption. In hidden corners across America, it's still happening. My
parents had me locked up in the godparent home against my will. They
worked with them to manipulate me and to steal my son away from me.
The godparent home is the brainchild of controversial preacher Jerry Falwell, the father of the
modern evangelical right and the founder of Liberty University, where powerful men, emboldened
by their faith, determine who gets to be a parent and who
must give their child away.
Follow Liberty Lost on the Wondery app or wherever you get your podcasts.