Relatable with Allie Beth Stuckey - Ep 1261 | Lies Your Therapist Tells You | Greg Gifford
Episode Date: October 31, 2025Allie interviews Dr. Greg Gifford, exposing secular psychology’s lies about depression and ADHD. Discover the biblical mind-brain distinction and how to rely on Scripture when anxiety creeps in. Rej...ect self-worship and embrace Christ’s sufficiency for true healing. Join us to dismantle mental health myths and live transformed by God’s unchanging word. Watch the full replay of the 2025 Share the Arrows conference exclusively on BlazeTV today. You can get a discount on your BlazeTV subscription now by going to BlazeTV.com/Allie. Buy Allie's book "Toxic Empathy: How Progressives Exploit Christian Compassion": https://www.toxicempathy.com/ --- Timecodes: (00:00) Introduction (05:20) Brain vs. Mind (14:00) The Inner Person (20:00) Diagnosing Mental Illness (27:15) The Lie of Self-Fulfillment (34:20) ADHD Symptoms (44:15) Depression and Anxiety Symptoms (55:20) Lies Our Therapists Told Us (01:01:35) Biblical Counseling --- Today's Sponsors: Good Ranchers — Go to https://GoodRanchers.com and subscribe to any of their boxes (but preferably the Allie Beth Stuckey Box) to get free Waygu burgers, hot dogs, bacon, or chicken wings in every box for life. Plus, you’ll get $40 off when you use code ALLIE at checkout. We Heart Nutrition — Get 20% off women's vitamins with We Heart Nutrition, and get your first bottle of their new supplement, Wholesome Balance; use code ALLIE at https://www.WeHeartNutrition.com. Cozy Earth - Go to CozyEarth.com/RELATABLE and use code “RELATABLE” for up to 40%! Pre-Born — Will you help rescue babies' lives? Donate by calling #250 & say keyword 'BABY' or go to Preborn.com/ALLIE. Concerned Women for America — For a donation of $20 or more, you will get a copy of their new book, written by the CEO and President, Penny Nance, "A Woman's Guide: Seven Rules for Success in Business and Life." Go to ConcernedWomen.org/Allie for your copy today. --- Episodes you might like: Ep 611 | How Woke Ideology Has Ruined Therapy | Guest: Dr. Sally Satel https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/ep-611-how-woke-ideology-has-ruined-therapy-guest-dr/id1359249098?i=1000559621694 Ep 963 | The Dangers of Gentle Parenting, SEL & Empathy | Guest: Abigail Shrier https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/ep-963-the-dangers-of-gentle-parenting-sel-empathy/id1359249098?i=1000648254377 Ep 983 | What Doctors Aren’t Telling You About Antidepressants | Guest: Brooke Siem https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/ep-983-what-doctors-arent-telling-you-about-antidepressants/id1359249098?i=1000652056518 Ep 1031 | Psychiatry Is Killing People | Guest: Dr. Roger McFillin https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/ep-1031-psychiatry-is-killing-people-guest-dr-roger/id1359249098?i=1000661830317 Ep 1193 | A Balanced Approach to ADD Medication | Guest: Dr. Daniel Amen https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/ep-1193-a-balanced-approach-to-add-medication-guest/id1359249098?i=1000709326763 --- Buy Allie's book "You're Not Enough (& That's Okay): Escaping the Toxic Culture of Self-Love": https://alliebethstuckey.com/book Relatable merchandise – use promo code 'ALLIE10' for a discount: https://shop.blazemedia.com/collections/allie-stuckey
Transcript
Discussion (0)
Your therapist is lying to you and they might actually be making you feel worse.
Today, we are going to discuss the difference between an actual biblical counselor and what
God's word says about mental illness and secular psychology, which tells you to focus on the
self and actually may enlarge the problems in your life. This is a fascinating and super encouraging
discussion with a licensed biblical counselor.
And the author of the book Lies, my therapist told me, Dr. Gifford is an incredible resource
when it comes to the biblical understanding of the mind and the brain.
This episode is brought to by our friends at Good Ranchers.
Go to Good Rangers.com.
Use Code Alley at checkout.
That's good ranchers.com.
Code Alley.
Dr. Gifford, thanks so much for taking the time to join us.
Can you tell everyone who you are and what you do?
Yep. Well, thank you for having me, first of all. My name is Greg Gifford, and I'm a professor at the
Master's University in Southern California. I teach primarily in the School of Biblical Studies,
but we do languages, theology, biblical studies, and biblical counseling is my specific emphasis.
So it's like a field where we use the Bible to try to help people in the counseling process.
And I'm sure we'll talk more about that.
Yes.
I also am a pastor at Faith Community Church.
in Santa Clarita.
I've been there for 12, almost 13 years.
I love that fellowship.
And that's my people.
Yeah.
And I think probably the best thing, like the personal stuff, is I married my high school
sweetheart, and we've been together 20 years with three boys.
That is awesome.
Okay, so Dr. John McArthur was on this show a couple times,
and he made waves a few years ago, and he probably said this multiple times.
whenever he would talk about psychology or psychiatry,
and he would talk about things like depression, anxiety, PTSD, and all of that.
And of course, he believed that there were, you know, spiritual applications and spiritual remedies that could be given to someone
and also really criticize secular psychology, since psychologists typically in general deny the existence of a soul.
They don't have the fullness of understanding of what a person made in the image of God needs.
What is your take on that is someone who is an expert in biblical counseling?
You've also talked and written a lot about things like PTSD.
How should we think of that?
Yeah, I mean, there's a couple of categories in that.
First of all is the reality of what's being called mental illness.
And you have to think through can your mind get ill and the ubiquitous nature.
So it's everywhere.
What we're facing right now is an epidemic of one out of five people are
diagnosed with a mental illness, one out of five. The top are depression, anxiety, ADHD.
So as a Christian, to be discerning, we have to say, what really goes into that? Like, what is
depression, biblically speaking, or what is anxiety, biblically speaking? Are they diseases of your
mind? And what is your mind? Yeah. So that, for the listener and for us, like, we just have to
start to say, okay, so is depression a medical issue or is there something else that could be
contributing to it? Is anxiety a medical issue, a disease that needs treatment? Or is there something
else that could be going into that? And that is, that's the first category of that conversation.
And that's where I've tried to speak truth graciously from the word. There are people that are suffering
and we want them to hear the truth of scripture that can set you free. The second is the category of
psychologist that you mentioned.
This should be really weird to a believer that I would go to an unbelieving therapist who doesn't
believe in the soul, doesn't believe in the gospel, doesn't believe in redemption, forgiveness.
And I would go to them with the most personal details of my life.
And it's like, wait a minute.
They have some fundamental worldview problems.
How am I going to be truly helped?
Like, helped at the root level.
So Dr. McArthur did have.
At times, he critiqued that whole ball of wax.
Yeah.
And what I've tried to do is to parse out, okay, which category do you want to talk about?
Is it the mental illness stuff?
Is it, do Christians go to secular therapists?
And in each of those, the Bible is the answer.
So trying to point people back to what does the scripture say.
And for a lot of believers, we're kind of fed up with the secular therapeutic, like,
wedging its way into my life and then wedging its way into my life.
and then wedging its way into my kids' lives.
So we're wanting better answers right now.
And I think the Bible has those answers.
Yeah.
Do you distinguish between the mind and the brain?
Oh, please.
Oh, absolutely.
Like that is my mantra.
And I appreciate you asking the question.
So absolutely.
As the mind and the brain go,
as your understanding of the mind and brain go,
so goes your treatment of all the mental illness
and mental health issues.
So biblically, it's really easy,
to settle, and most Christians are familiar with Romans 12, verse two.
Read it too.
Yeah, please.
I wrote the word that I spelt coffee on yesterday.
Is that the renewing of the mind verse?
I love this verse because most Christians are familiar with it.
Like, take us back to our Awanida's, and here it is.
Do not be conformed to this world, but be transformed by the renewal of your mind, that by testing,
you may discern what is the will of God, what is good and acceptable and perfect.
Okay, so God is actually transforming Christians presently, and that is the work of sanctification.
Here it says, by the renewal of your mind, the reconformity back, the restoration.
But mind here is the immaterial mind.
It is the seed of your intellect and cognition.
That's where reason and thoughts come from.
What is God actually doing when you were saved and when I was saved?
God is capacitating us and our minds to be renewed and transformed.
But our brains are different from our minds.
Our brains are part of our outer person.
They are housed in our cranium.
We can study them like any other organ,
but your brain and your mind are not the same thing.
And biblically, what's God doing here?
He is not renewing your brain.
He is renewing your mind.
And this is an odd thought, but it's true.
Yeah. We're both in our 30s. Our brains are deteriorating.
Mine probably faster than yours. And when we think of the way that the outer man can waste away, my brain can deteriorate and my mind can be renewed, even though I may have, you know, an organ of my brain issue.
So Christians have to start to think through brain versus mind. What are we talking about, first of all?
and then you can start to connect the dots to chemical imbalances, mental illnesses or diseases.
Is this an issue of my brain or is this probably more an issue of my mind?
Quick pause, tell you about our first sponsor for the day.
That is WeHeart Nutrition.
Y'all, they just came out with two new products that I'm super excited about because I've
been using all my WeHeart Nutrition supplements for coming up on two years now and it's
been total game changer for my health.
But now they have an immunity supplement, which I've been taking, because I've been using,
my body has just been like fighting, trying to fight like some kind of cold for the past week or so.
But I also, I credit my WeHeart nutrition for not actually getting full on sick yet.
And then I added in this immunity supplement, which I really think has helped me a lot.
And then also they have a probiotic, which I've been so excited about.
That is the one supplement that I've had to go somewhere else for.
And now they have an amazing probiotic and just like every other product they have.
All of their ingredients come in the most bioavailable form.
that means that it is the kind of ingredient that your body can actually absorb.
That is not true of all supplements.
Sometimes you're just paying a lot of money to take these pills that aren't actually
helping you, but your body is actually absorbing wee heart nutrition.
Even the packaging is so high quality.
And of course, the best part is that this is an unapologetically Christian, America-loving,
pro-life family-owned company.
Kristen and Jacob are so awesome.
They are the real deal.
So get your supplements from WeHeart Nutrition.
It will help your health so much.
Go to Weheartnutrition.com.
Use code Alley for 20% off.
That's weheartnutrition.com code Alley.
If we were to think of the brain and the mind as two circles, like in a then diagram,
there's a lot of overlap between the brain and the mind too, right?
So I'm kind of putting you on the spot here.
And you can tell me if this is not how you would organize it or not how you would think of it.
Brain, mind, two different entities, but a lot of what is in our mind is housed in the brain, right?
What would you say is a component of the brain that's just the brain?
What would you say is a component of the mind that's just the mind?
And what is in that middle part that the brain and the mind share?
Does that make sense?
Yeah, it does.
So what does the mind do?
Let's start with that.
Yeah.
The mind is immaterial.
Your mind will continue to exist after your brain has deceased.
So when I am brain dead, there are diagnosable criteria to establish that.
My mind will continue to exist until the resurrection.
So then practically we know my brain is not the source of my thinking.
I almost wish it were because you could like medicate it or you could treat it,
but my brain is not the source of my thinking.
That comes from our immaterial person.
So just consider the implications of that for a second.
It's like your reason, your intellect, all of that comes from your.
mind. But we do have the science of the brain that tells us how thoughts are formed and how
memories are formed, right? Yeah. Can they demonstrate causation? Or does the brain respond to what
the mind is doing? Chicken or the egg. Okay. Right? Think about that. You know, I think I understood
this more. I remember as a child thinking about the people who don't believe in a soul and don't
believe in God. And I remember having this just like it just hit me. How could you not believe this?
Because then who would I be? I wouldn't have this personality. I wouldn't be who I, who I am without a
soul. And I kind of had forgotten about that. But it almost seems like that's what you're saying.
Are you saying that the mind and the spirit are two very similar things, if not the same thing?
Right. I am. Okay. Because that's, first of all, it doesn't matter what I say, but that's what the Bible says.
Yeah. The Bible's going to say, you're
soul, your spirit, your mind, and your heart are all part of your immaterial person.
Yeah.
And the most used term is heart, especially in the Old Testament.
So your entirety of your immaterial person uses those terms interchangeably.
And I am not a person who thinks you can divide them out.
I know some people it's dichotomy or trichotomy or something like that.
But it seems like the Bible is more talking about your inner man versus your outer man.
So your inner man is the source of those things.
And it's just so it's easy.
So like if I died right now, my brain would cease to work,
but my mind would still be functioning in my soul,
in my immaterial soul, as I'm in the presence of the Lord,
2nd Corinthians 5.
So the brain then, like, what is the brain?
Well, I do my best not to dabble in medical science,
so I'll try to stay at like the 30,000 foot category.
But it is that organ that is responding to your inner person.
It's the control center of your outer man.
It's like your physical heart in that way.
So what is it doing?
It's not causing my thoughts.
It's not determining my thoughts.
It is more like a filter biblically
of what is happening in my thinking.
So this was a fascinating thing to me.
I was talking with a guy after an ACBC conference
and he had to use sign language.
I don't speak ASL.
There's a translator in between us
and I didn't do a good job of articulating
what does the brain do? And he said, but what about
Alzheimer's, dementia,
traumatic brain injuries? Like, what about those,
Gifford? And I was like,
well, what those are
is those are, your brain is damaged
and it is affecting or influencing
the way that your mind expresses itself.
But it's not causing it.
Causation comes from the mind.
So can you experience a concussion
or a TBI or something? And it influences
is the way that your mind is expressing itself. No problem. Or maybe we've, we've kind of met that person
in Alzheimer's where they start to become kind of mean or agitated. Biblically, they were that all
along. And what Alzheimer's is doing is removing the filter. What dementia is doing is removing that
filter of your brain. So where does it come from? Biblically, where does it come from? It comes from
your inner person. And the outer person is rested, well,
unrested, your physical body is healthy, prepared, unhealthy. Yeah, I see the wheel's turning. So what's you got?
Well, I'm curious about that. And I don't have as much expertise as you do. But different things like dementia and Alzheimer's, I mean, things that happen in our brain can affect the things, I think, can affect the things that we say. I know that hormones can affect our moods and can even affect our perception of things so that we react in a particular way that might not be in alignment with the Bible.
or in alignment with reality.
So when you say the person who with Alzheimer's becomes irritable and that was who they were
all along, it's hard for me to believe that that is necessarily true.
Maybe it is true in some cases, but is there not something about Alzheimer's that would make
a very typically sweet and kind person just that it would irritate something in them
that would actually make them seem more bitter than they actually.
actually are. Does that necessarily mean that their mind is? Totally. Let me share a couple of
thoughts with you, then answer that directly. So where does our thinking come from? You know,
the Bible teaches the mind. Where does our actions come from? Proverbs 423, our heart. So we guard it,
we keep it from it for the wellsprings of life. What's the epicenter of why I do what I do?
It's my immaterial self. And I have to
reckon with that. But to your point, can those physiological things be an extreme encouragement?
Absolutely. Like absolutely. Can Alzheimer's, dementia, hormones, even sleeplessness, poor nutrition,
pain? Can those things be an encouragement? Yes. But those things are never the determiner
because my actions, my emotions, or think of my words, those are all an overflow of what's coming
from my heart and my inner person.
So I want to make sure that we give a space and say, yeah, totally.
A person can be really, really, really, really encouraged to be irritable.
By a physiological force.
By a physiological thing, totally.
But not caused.
If we're using anger in the biblical, if we're using irritability as anger in the biblical context,
a Christian cannot be caused to sin by their body.
Right.
Okay.
Interesting. I never heard it. I never heard it described like that.
Next sponsor is Good Ranchers. So Good Ranchers has a deal going on for Thanksgiving.
Join Good Ranchers every Thursday night for a simple but meaningful challenge. Sit down,
share a meal with your family or with your friends, with someone, with neighbors, coworkers.
This is your chance to step away from the rush of everyday life and to connect with those around you.
They're really passionate about the American dinner.
table and making sure we are having meaningful conversations that we're not just busy and go, go,
go all the time and looking at our phones, but really connecting with the other image bears of God
in our life. And the best part of this, one table will win a free Thanksgiving ham just for sharing
a photo of their Thursday night dinner on their Instagram story using the hashtag back to the table
and tagging Go to Ranchers. So make sure you do that. Also, if you haven't subscribed to Go to Ranchers
yet get your box of all American meat to your front door every month.
We rely on Go to Go to Ranches every night in this Stucky home.
It's so good and I love supporting this American industry.
Go to Good Ranchers.com.
Use code Alley for $40 off your order.
That's Good Ranchers.com, code Alley.
Why is this differentiation between the mind and the brain so important for how Christians
understand things like depression or PTSD?
Yeah, good.
because in 20 whatever we're in now 2025 we can think darwin for naturalism becoming the dominant western
worldview and everything has a medical explanation and we default to body must have an issue and we don't
always default to what's happening in my inner person in my soul so we have medical sounding terminology
that is starting to be used of an immaterial entity,
which is our mind.
Mental illness.
Right.
Or mental disease.
Yeah.
But think of it this way, Allie,
and those watching,
like, when you go to a psychiatrist,
what type of medicine do they actually do?
Just like, don't trust me, like, Google it,
go to a psychiatrist.
Like, seriously,
they're going to have you verbally describe what's taking place,
and they are not empirically.
diagnosing you based off of vitamin deficiencies, brain scans. So you can leave a medical doctor's
office with a medically sounding label about your mind, and there was no medicine that was practiced
to diagnose you for that. That's a really good point. And I've had a lot of people on who are
skeptical about this whole chemical imbalance thing that we hear like a serotonian deficiency.
But they're never measuring that. Like they're not doing blood work to say, oh, yeah,
you're low on serotonin.
Right.
You talk to someone and they tell you.
And like what other form of illness do we have where the doctor is like, oh, I can just hear
it in your voice, you're vitamin D deficient.
Like no doctor does that.
They test your blood.
100%.
But for mental illness, they just, I don't know, feel it in your aura, which is superstitious.
Right.
So if you were like, hey, doctor, I think I have thyroid issues.
Right.
Then they would be like, okay, well, let's look.
And then they're going to test.
But when you go to a psychiatrist.
and you say, hey, I think I'm depressed, they're going to say, well, do you feel sad? Do you struggle
with motivation? And it's like, wait, wait a minute, you're a medical doctor. Like, don't you want to do a
scan? Don't you want to study my brain? You're going to look at neurotransmitters. So we're, how did,
the real question is like, how did we become okay with that? Right. Because that's more interested,
like, why don't we just laugh at that person doing that? And that gets back to the naturalistic worldview
that we start with, that we think in terms of there must be a body.
problem. This medically trained doctor is telling me that I have an illness of my mind or a disease
of my mind, so I must have that. Yeah, that's interesting. And it's actually a lot more dangerous
to give someone, potentially psychosis-inducing drugs than it is to give someone thyroid medication
that they don't need. Right. And yet we accept that is totally scientifically a viable option.
Right. Or think of our kids, too. Yeah.
school psychologist says I think they have this thing.
Usually for guys, it's ADHD and it's like, for girls, it's anxiety.
And then now all of the sudden, like, we have no medical evidence, no medical testing, no medical proof.
And now I'm putting my kids on psychotropics.
And I haven't just paused to think like, wait a minute, like, how did they actually diagnose
and how do they know this is a problem of the body and not the immaterial self?
Like that is the crisis that we're at.
so how could we not have diagnoses growing right how could we not have children being diagnosed as
early as three four years old with mental illness like how could you not because you have no
objective criteria by which you can diagnose mental illnesses yeah that's so interesting and another
consequence of the psychology world in general just not believing in the soul and not believing
and at least a higher power and objective morality is that everything
goes back to the self.
Like everything goes back to like you are both the problem and the solution at the same
time, which is completely illogical.
And I'm wondering what you think about this.
I saw this quote in East of Eden, the John Steinbeck book for those out there who don't
know that.
And he was talking to someone who was very depressed after they had a loved one die.
And he said, I'm paraphrasing.
But basically, you have to go about your life as if it is a play.
You don't feel it, but you have to do what you have to do, and eventually it will become real.
And I just thought how different that is from most of psychology, which tells you that the most important thing is to, like, be authentic, to feel what you really feel, and then to tell people how you really feel and to constantly focus on your emotion.
And that's the only way to heal.
That's the only way to get better.
It's all about empowering the self, knowing the self, discovering the self, and like presenting the true self to the world.
and east of Eden is not the Bible,
but I just thought maybe that does just go to show
how wrong we've been when it comes to healing
and dealing with the brokenness inside ourselves and the world.
Maybe the self can't be both the problem and the solution.
Yeah, we can definitely be the problem, for sure.
Yeah, but at the same time.
Yeah. Yeah. Yeah, that's humanism.
And so now, okay, so unbelieving psychologist,
doesn't believe in God, doesn't believe in Jesus,
doesn't believe in the gospel, what is it that they're going to help a believer do?
Seriously, like, just let's make it that easy.
Focus on yourself and your problem.
Now, iatrogenesis, think of iatrogenic.
I can create my own problems unintentionally.
You want to create your own problems.
Focus on how you feel every day.
The Bible sets us free from self-worship.
lovers of self second timothy three i gotta read this for you okay in the in times they will be
lovers of self-love that's the only place we see self-love thank you it's an indication of evil right so
instead of saying self-love is the remedy think of it as the problem that i'm trying to repent of
so the days are going to get worse timothy you be faithful hold fast to the word people will be lovers of
pleasure, lovers of self. Okay, so then carefully start to think that through. If my therapist,
counselor is telling me to love myself more and they're trying to make me this solution here,
I'm going to be more miserable. And just like, let's watch it unfold. The generation under 25
have never had so much depression and anxiety. Right. So it's like a self, we are creating the problem,
and then we're trying to come up with solutions to fix the problem. And the solution, and the
solutions themselves are making the problem worse, focus on yourself. So from a Christian angle,
we are here to glorify God and make much of Him. Our life is not for ourselves. In fact,
the call to discipleship is to deny yourself to take up your cross and to follow Jesus, Luke 923.
So what is it? Self-denial is an integral part of being faithful. And if I focus on self,
of course it's going to get worse. Of course I'll have more problems. And then now I'm going
to someone with a naturalistic worldview,
and they're using medical-sounding labels
when it's not really a medical issue in the first place.
Next sponsor is Cozy Earth.
All right, related bros and related gals,
but especially related bros who are listening or watching.
For Christmas, your wife, I promise,
she will like comfy pajamas.
There are some women who might not like flowers.
There are some women who might not like a bottle of champagne.
I don't know a single woman who doesn't like comfy pajamas.
Maybe you get her something else is on her list too, but I promise she will thank you for comfy pajamas or loungewear from Cozy Earth.
I've got my pajamas from Cozy Earth.
I've got my loungeware from them.
I love them so much.
They are so soft, so luxurious, so breathable and well made.
That's true of their sheets.
That's true of their towels.
I know when my bad doesn't have my Cozy Earth sheets and I don't like it.
And I always pick my Cozy Earth towels.
Their products are just top notch.
They're amazing.
go to cozyearth.com, use code relatable, and you will get 40% off. 40% off. That's amazing.
Cozyearth.com code relatable. I think Christians buy a lot of that stuff too, because we hear a lot,
especially in like the women's Bible study world. And this is what I wrote my first book on.
We hear things that sound almost biblically true. Like you're enough. You're perfect the way you are.
give yourself grace, all of these things that almost sound good.
Well, Jesus said to love your neighbor as yourself, so that's a command to love yourself too.
It almost sounds right.
And of course, it feels good.
But you end up at the same place where the secular world ends up, which is the self.
And believing that this path of self-discovery and self-fulfillment is going to make you happy.
And you're saying it does the opposite.
Yeah.
And just think how seductive that is, though.
like, Jesus came to save me, God love me so much. And you're like, wait, like, hang on.
Like, is the emphasis God's glory and you being restored through the work of Christ to glorify God
or that God couldn't live without you? And that is why he sent Jesus. So it's like, who's being
exalted in the narrative of the gospel? It is the glory of God in the name of Jesus Christ. It's not me.
So then I can Christianize self-love and say, God love.
loves me. I am so valuable. And if I'm not careful, then it starts to be an exaltation of me again.
Yeah. And it's so seductive because it's like legitimized, you're seemingly legitimized with
scripture. So if you're going to love your neighbor, you have to first love yourself.
Mm-hmm. If I'm going to love my neighbor like I love myself, I have to love myself.
But the inherent problem is that who is getting the glory? Do we get the glory or does God get the
glory? Yeah. Right. And it's not really a command to love ourselves.
It's a given that we love ourselves.
We're born loving ourselves in the same way that we're born seeking our own interests.
Like we cry for food.
We cry to be held.
From the very first moment, we are interested in what we need.
And that's not a bad thing.
I think God created us with a survival instinct.
We know what we need to survive.
It seems to me that Jesus is saying in the same way that you naturally seek to meet your own interest and needs,
seek to make the interests and the needs of other people.
Not as high as your self-esteem is, make sure that other.
people self-esteem is just as high. And that, I think, is how we're interpreting it. And if that's
the case, you're going to be waiting a really long time until you love someone else. It's like,
oh, I hated what I looked like in my outfit this morning. So sorry, kids, like breakfast is on you.
Like it's just we, like you said, I think the point of glory is so important because I can say,
okay, I woke up this morning not feeling great about myself. And maybe I'm not in a good mood or
whatever it is. It's like keeping me down. But because, because,
Christ is in me and because his love never changes and because he died on the cross and his
sacrifice like is is fixed like that gives me the power to love other people it's not about how
I feel about myself that's actually a lot more freeing than thinking that my love for other people
is dependent on my own love for myself right and I don't fault people first of all I don't want to
sound like just a crumudge and it's like you know stop focusing on yourself because we're
were raised in a culture that has exalted our feelings.
Yeah.
And you know you best.
And who am I to judge you?
Like that is the zeitgeist of our age.
Truth is in you.
Your feelings are authoritative.
So then that starts to be kind of the solution as well.
It's like, well, I want to feel better and I want to feel better about myself.
That's the singular next step for me to thrive.
Okay.
But we know according to the scripture that God,
God's word is the truth, not what's going on in my inner person. And my feelings matter,
but they're not authoritative. In fact, I can have wayward emotions and feelings. So then you turn
that corner and you say, God sets me free from myself to worship him. And when I do that, I am the
most satisfied person I can be. Psalm 1611. Like the pleasures are not at my right hand.
They are at the right hand of the Lord. And when you think of,
contentment as a Christian.
It is not where you've learned to be true to yourself and listen to yourself.
You learn contentment by being obedient to the Lord and then he changes your will,
Philippians 213.
So you really, you want what God wants.
That is true contentment for us.
So I'm never satisfied when I focus on myself.
Yeah.
Never.
I'm more miserable.
I'm grumpy.
You know, like everything has to make me happy.
And then it never does.
I hit traffic again. I get woken up early. Like it never does. But whenever I'm living for the
glory of God, I'm free because it's not about me. It's about making much of him. And all those
inconveniences to my life can actually help me better glorify the Lord than if I lived at perfect
ease with no problems at all. I mean, that's the beauty of the gospel and the Christian worldview.
And it is so counter to what modern psychology tells us. And by the way, people are accessing modern
psychology, not necessarily by going into a psychologist's office and paying them $100 an hour,
but on Instagram, on TikTok, because there are- Chat bots, too.
Yes, yeah, which is scary to think about. But there's a lot of psychology influencers out there, too,
or memes or whatever, and people are imbibing this idea that, you know, there are two things
that you can do if you're depressed, and one is to lean more on your own understanding and to
lean more into how you feel about yourself, but then also cut out all of the things that are
making you sad. Oh, this person, you know, is asking too much of you. Your boss expects you
to work hard and come into the office. Well, all of these toxic things, or it's the patriarchy,
or it's capitalism, or it's advertising, or it's this system or this person. And it makes sense
when you think that it's an anti-Christian worldview, for Christian, the sanctification is not
necessarily asking God to remove all the hard things from our lives. It's asking God to help us
endure them with grace and perseverance in a way that makes us look more like Christ. We're denying
ourselves, as you said earlier, whereas modern psychology is asking us to deny everyone else.
Right. And just to make sure my position is clear, and I'm very open to your thoughts on this,
my reading of the scripture is that it is God-centered and our life is about glorifying him.
And God can even use my emotional struggles to help me depend on him more.
Whenever I'm anxious, I have to fight to trust him.
Whenever my mood is depressed or melancholic,
like I have to cling to the promises of Scripture and hold to them to use Bridges,
Jerry Bridges' words.
So I am not saying be miserable, but just grind and glorifying God.
Yeah.
But me being free of depression and anxiety is a secondary goal.
it's not the primary goal.
The primary goal is to glorify God.
And then I have to think through
what does the Bible say about those issues
and how can I respond to anxiety
or depression or ADHD
according to the scripture.
So it's still there.
I don't want anyone to hear this or listen to be like,
Gifford just believes that you should be miserable
and glorify the Lord.
No, I'm saying that glorifying God is number one
and then addressing whatever emotional,
relational struggle you may have.
That is your secondary goal.
Okay, well, let's talk about what that looks like specifically.
And if we can start with ADHD, because I think that's the most, like, interesting one.
The Bible has a lot to say about being sad and distressed and fearful and anxious.
But I'd be interested to hear, like, how would you work through with someone with ADHD using scripture?
Okay, so first of all, think of what we're calling ADHD attention deficit hyperactivity disorder.
Lots of symptoms in one umbrella.
Fidgety, hard to focus.
Seriously, it's like kids that get up and they're kind of rambunctious.
You have girls, I have boys, and boys are just different.
Like I've never, my boys are a little maybe rambunctious.
Like I don't walk in on them playing house and like neatly building a Lego set.
Like they're wrestling, they're bouncing the ball in the house.
And those that are most diagnosed with ADHD are boys.
and it's junior high.
So then you think through that,
it's like, oh, that's an interesting thing to consider,
11, 12 years old.
Where do they struggle most?
School,
sitting in one place for six, seven hours a day.
Okay.
Then you think through the girls that are their age,
some have already gone through puberty.
They're like a foot taller,
as weird as that may see.
You pick up your son in fifth grade
and you're like,
You guys are in the same class?
Like, what's happening here?
So then you have these boys that are rambunctious,
wily, not sitting still,
and the immediate leap is,
well, they must have a disorder.
Let's have them talk to the school psychologist.
Let's get them tested.
Okay, I don't fault school psychologist,
and I don't fault trying to find resources
for boys that are rambunctious.
But do they have a medically verifiable problem?
That's the real question.
Can we scan the brain?
Can we do lab results?
and there will be some watching this that says, yes,
there's brain chemistry that corresponds to those with ADHD.
And then I would say, great.
So let's diagnose based off of brain scans and not symptoms.
Which some doctors do.
Very few, but some do.
Let's do it.
Okay, so is hyperactivity a disorder?
Is being fidgety a disorder?
Or is that a gifting that you have?
So think of 1st Peter 4 in Romans 12.
everyone in the body of Christ is given gifts, strengths, weaknesses that we have.
There are some that are just not the school type.
That's not them.
They don't thrive in that environment.
They're very active.
They are very like, go, go, go, go, go.
And their mind never rests.
Looking back, I see a lot of CEOs or executive directors.
And it's like, man, if they had ADHD whenever you were a kid, you would have been diagnosed with it because you're Bing, Bing, Bing, Bing, Bing.
Yeah, I've definitely.
seeing that and some like very successful people.
They can hardly even look like look you in the eyes sometimes because they're thinking about
a million things, but they're very good at what they do. Yes. Right. So is that a is that something
that has to be labeled and treated? Right. Or do you find the area to set your giftedness free?
It's like you're probably not going to be a librarian. Yeah. Fair's right. Like is that a sin? No.
Yeah. Would you be miserable if we made you go to a cubicle and type in Excel all day? Yeah. You would be
absolutely miserable. Yeah. So go be a park ranger. Go be an entrepreneur. Go work with your hands.
Go build your own business or nonprofit. So how do you work with someone with ADHD?
I think for a lot of the diagnoses, give them time to mature, give them a time to grow up,
encourage them to do things that are hard and to persevere. And you can't always do the things that
you love and eschew the things you hate. But do you have to take meds? Right. It's a Christian liberty,
and I'm not going to say you absolutely cannot. Yeah. But I am going to say you want your
sons and some daughters, you want them to learn the life skills that go into denying yourself
and not depending on a medication that's going to help them focus. Yeah. But can you use it? Totally.
you can use it in a God-honoring way when you've obtained those meds legally, you could do it.
But help them mature first and help them grow and then steer them towards somewhere where they can
really thrive with their giftedness instead of the librarian, the accountant, the very sedentary
positions that will just probably make them crazy, seriously.
Next sponsor is Preborn.
If you've been wondering how to involve yourself in the pro-life movement and you don't know where
to start, start with Preborn.
Their network of clinics across the country help save baby lives.
And they serve mothers by giving them the resources and the information that's necessary for these women to make a life-affirming decision.
They offer free ultrasounds.
And they know that when a woman actually sees her baby on the ultrasound screen, she is so much more likely to choose life.
So by partnering with preborn, you are literally saving lives.
You are serving these moms and dads.
You are protecting these precious image bears of God.
and all you have to do to get started is go to preborn.com. You could go to preborn.com slash
Alley. Donate whatever you can. If you donate $28 that covers the cost of a life-saving ultrasound,
but whatever you can give right now, it helps save a life. Go to preborn.com slash Alley. That's
preborn.com slash alley. I think just like with everything that we do, we have to assess our
motives behind it when it is an area of Christian liberty. In this case, obviously, the Bible doesn't
say you shall not do a brain scan and treat with medication, something that is an actual diagnosed
ADHD. But I think all of us need to ask. And as a parent, I can understand this. If you have a
child that is having a really hard time in school, your other kids aren't, their friends aren't.
You're watching them up on stage. Everyone else in the, you know, and the Christmas recital is
doing their job and doing the motions and singing, your child is running around on stage. Like, I can
understand as a parent, oh, that's difficult. And you might feel like, well, I'm helping them
by giving them this medication. But I think we all need to ask some questions. Is it really for
them or is it for you? Totally. Is it because they are actually having a hard time? Or do you just
feel awkward and uncomfortable? And is it also just making your job as a parent harder? Is it
because maybe you don't want to homeschool? Is it because it takes longer to discipline and talk to
your child, longer to get out the door. And those might all be real difficulties, but they also may be
opportunities for sanctification, not necessarily psychiatric drugs. Right. On the parents part.
That's what I mean. Yeah, you're growing as a parent. Exactly. And sometimes I think that's just,
that's the most difficult part is the patience that's required of us as parents. And yes,
it might make it easier for your child to sit through seven hours of school. But to your point,
is that the goal?
Like, is that really the goal?
Is that something that's necessary for them
or is it something that's necessary for you?
Yeah, and I don't fault schools
because schools actually have to get a diagnosis
to get them private tutors
and more resources or an educational assistant.
So the school's not trying to,
you know, we could paint public schools
as being evil and some are,
but there's also a legal requirement
to get tested and diagnosed with ADHD
ADHD to get you a smaller room
and less students in the class.
and an educational assistant or specialist there.
So then the school's saying,
well, we got to get you tested
to get you out of 30 person-sized classes
and get you the attention and resources that you need.
Right.
So they need that diagnosis to unlock all these resources.
So I don't envy that position,
but as a parent, you should still be discerting and say,
hmm, but I don't know if that is the real issue.
I don't know if that's really going to help.
Mm-hmm.
And that could be hard to do.
It's hard to assess how you're doing as a parent
and all of the things that, like, you might need to change in order to, like, better accommodate
the personality and the strengths of your kids.
I love what you said about thinking about those differences as strengths and not something
that needs to be stifled or medicated necessarily.
I don't think that a lot of us probably think that way, even about our own selves, but I had
probably every teacher my parents would say, tell my parents that I had ADD because I couldn't
stop talking in class, but now I talk, you know, for a living. And so, yeah, I'm really glad that
I look back and I'm really glad that my parents said no to that. Because what if I didn't do
what I do now? Right. So think of your giftings, right? The Lord's obviously blessing your work and you
have this huge impact through your words, through a mind that is sharp. What if at your earliest of years,
you self-conceptualized as having a disorder, ADHD? So what if your parents said, okay, like,
If you want to get her tested, let's get her tested.
And then you got a diagnosis.
And then now you start to hear what you can't do because you have ADHD.
So that's an extremely detrimental side effect of the mental illness movement over diagnosing is kids self-conceptualizing as their diagnosis from very.
So you would have learned from puberty that you can't do things.
So your parents gave you that sweet gift of saying, nope, we're going to be.
protect her and we're going to help her thrive in what she's good at and then here you are.
Yeah. And I never did get an A in math and that's okay. Me neither. Yeah, because I don't use it.
Okay, so depression anxiety. So we talked through ADHD for those who are like, look, Dr. Givert,
I hear you, but they're thinking, I'm depressed. I can't get out of bed. I can't do it. You're
telling me this is a problem of the mind. I don't know how to pray more and read the Bible more than
I already out. Yeah, totally. No one should hear this, watch.
this listen to this and think i'm saying depression doesn't exist because i'm not saying that and no one
should hear this watch this listen to this and think i'm saying anxiety doesn't exist because i'm not saying that
i've never said that in the book i don't say that on my podcast i don't say that i've never said those
things what i'm saying is let's start to to uncover what's going on in depression if there are
physiological issues, vitamin deficiencies, thyroid issues, there's something going on with my
brain, maybe there's actually a cyst or something growing on the organ, and it's affecting me in
some way. It's affecting mood regulation in that way. You would say affecting your mind in a way
that encourages you to sin, but does it cause you to sin? Yep. Because we know Roman 6th, we're set free,
and we have God's spirit indwelling us, 1st Corinthians 619, so I can't, I can never once say my body
made me sin. Yeah, that's good. It does get murky in terms of what is, was that a true sin or was it
not a true sin, you know, but, but we know that line is clear. Yeah. Okay, so if I don't have any
known physiological problems, doctors can't find anything, there's nothing going on in the organ
of my brain, thyroid looks great, all my blood work comes back and it looks nice, then maybe just maybe
I should be open to what's happening in my mind. What am I thinking about? What am I thinking about?
about. What am I putting my hope in? Why, why am I disappointed and so discouraged? Did something change in
my life recently that was not physiological, but was circumstantial? And that's what triggered this
depression. Then you're not talking about a biological problem at all. You're actually talking about
a spiritual problem. Okay, so here, it's like, okay, well, Gifford, like, kick people while they're down,
man. That's not what I'm saying. I am saying, you can be hopeless. And that's not a biolns.
problem and what is the solution to that. We want to take you back to the nature and the character of
God and his promises. We want to set you free that God is faithful. Second Corinthians, one, he's the God
of all comfort, that His mercy is unending for you, that even in the low point, if someone's watching
this in bed right now, even in that low point, God draws people out of the mud and the muck and
the mire, and he sets them on a firm rock, which is himself.
that is the hope that people need.
An antidepressant can't touch that.
We need to behold the glory of God,
not behold the glory of our problems,
not behold the glory of ourselves,
not behold the glory of psychotropics.
So if there is no physical issue,
would we at least be open,
at least open,
at least consider what may be happening
in our inner person
that's contributing to things like depression
in that way.
Makes sense?
Yeah, it makes sense.
Abigail Shrier, I don't know if you've read her book, Bad Therapy.
She's great.
She came on this show to talk about it, but she also went on Joe Rogan and she talked about
like one of the key features of depression is often just a constant dwelling on your own problems,
which to me would be one of the problems of psychology because what I hear from popular
psychology is that that's how you heal your problems, is constantly talking about them
and thinking about them.
Right.
That's one problem I have like with SEL in school because especially for kids, like this focus on the feelings and the problems and the concerns that you have.
I just don't know if that's healthy.
She brings that up in bad therapy.
She says start class every day by asking your students how they feel and you're actually going to make them feel worse.
Yeah.
And it's like, Shriar's not arguing for a biblical worldview, but there is something correct about that, which is a self-centered world.
view makes me more miserable, like we were saying a few minutes ago.
So can you be encouraged to be myopic?
Yeah, absolutely.
And that's where some of our teachers are totally out of line by asking our students
the wrong kind of questions.
It's almost like you're leading the witness to a degree.
Yeah.
And anxiety.
Yeah.
How do we think through that biblically?
Okay, so I would have different than depression.
Let's use the term.
that comes from the scripture. But then I do think there's a cultural term that younger people will
use that's more like stress. The term from the scripture, anxiety, Philippians 4-6, Matthew 6,
Jesus says, do not be anxious. Okay, so it's pretty clear that Jesus is focusing on anxiety as a matter
of having little faith. So what's the remedy to anxiety? Well, consider the lily.
please consider the birds god feeds them god clothes them and god knows your needs as well so what is
anxiety definitionally it's like an over-concern i'm too concerned worry some of you's fear
interchangeably but worry seems to be a better modern to english equivalent if that's what you're saying
anxiety is then the bible would say that is a sin to repent of and why is that because we're not
placing our faith and trust in the Lord and practical things like food and clothing. So the solution is
turn from that like we would any other distrust of the Lord, repent from that, and then now behold
God as your provider who's good and wise and loving. And the grass of the field reminds us God's a
provider. Seriously, the birds remind us that God doesn't forget us. So there's another category
that I find younger people use, which is they'll say they're anxious in a way that older generations
would say they're stressed. So it's like, how is your week? It's like, oh, just so anxious, so much
going on. But they don't really mean like, I'm failing to trust the Lord. They mean something like
I'm kind of overwhelmed. And in that way, it is kind of confusing. The first time I said in class that
anxiety is a sin, like, you could feel the breath of my students like gasp. Like, where is this guy from?
Yeah.
And I was like, wait a minute.
Like, is that a thing?
Like, do we have to tease that out?
And we did.
And I learned that they were using anxiety like overwhelmed.
Yeah.
So can you be stressed and not be anxious?
I think you can.
Can you be burdened?
Second Corinthians 4 struck down, perplexed, all those things and not be anxious.
Yeah, I think you can.
But if we're talking about anxiety, the solution to anxiety is to learn to trust the Lord
in the practical things you're struggling with.
Is it your kids?
Is it your health?
Is it your career?
Is it your money?
Consider this atheism.
When we talk about anxiety,
anxiety is a mild form of atheism.
Kevin Carson, undergraduate prof,
told me that and I was like, yeah, that's it.
You're totally right.
Because I'm not seeing that God's in total control
and he's good.
and wise.
And when I know that God's in control, he's sovereign,
and I know that he's good,
meaning he's not this evil dictator,
then I trust him and I'm not anxious.
Like, why would I be anxious?
God's got this.
He's in total control and he's good and he's wise and he knows.
So your anxiety and my anxiety,
and I could be a man who is prone toward anxiety.
It's actually crushed by a big view,
a transformative view of who the Lord is.
And then I learned to practically trust him in the areas that I'm struggling with.
Seriously.
Yeah, that's really good.
I remember there's a quote.
I'm going to paraphrase it by C.S. Lewis, who said something along the lines.
I'm worrying about the future is like picturing the future without God's grace in it.
Because if God's grace is in the here and the now with us, everyone hears about those moments where some Christian goes through awful tragedy.
and everyone around them is like, how are you so at peace?
Like, obviously you're sad, but you don't seem distraught.
You don't seem completely destitute.
And obviously the grace of God met them exactly where they were.
But when we picture some future events, some catastrophe, our spouse dying, our child's getting diagnosed with cancer,
one, we can't control that.
So that is, I think, a large part of where the anxiety comes from, not only that it's going to happen,
but that we can't do anything to stop it.
But then also we're picturing that moment without God's grace there
because we're thinking about a hypothetical
and God's grace is only real.
And so I think that also just stirs in us
a lot of unnecessary worry,
which I think Satan, you know, he likes that
because, of course, he likes to imagine a world
without God's grace in it.
I also think 100% on all that you're saying.
So when I'm tempted to be anxious,
I want to know.
Like I just want to know.
Yeah.
And then I co-mingle that with the Lord blesses the plans that I establish.
You want to be intentional.
And then before long, I am trying to control things that are not mine to control.
Yeah.
So the worship of control becomes really who you functionally are living for.
And it's not the worship of God.
And then when I can't control it, I'm anxious or fearful.
Last sponsor for the day is concerned women for America.
From Congress to your children's schools,
there is a cultural war raging across the country.
And you guys know it.
You see it.
And maybe you're ready to step off the sidelines,
but you don't know what to do or where to go.
Well, there have been organizations that have been working
to advance the cause of liberty and the family and the sanctity of life for decades.
And an amazing organization is concerned women for America.
This is a coalition of conservative.
America-loving, God-loving women across the country who are advocates in all spheres of society
and government to make sure that our children are protected. They are fighting against sexual
exploitation, the sanctity of life, the cohesion of the family, and so much more. They train
women to become grassroots leaders, speak into culture, pray, testify, and lobby. Penny Nance is
the president. She's got this incredible book, A Woman's Guide, Seven Rules for Success in Business and in
life. All you have to do is donate $20. They'll send you a free copy of that book. Go to
Concernedwomen.org slash Alley for your copy today. That's concernedwomen.org slash alley.
What other lies have our therapist told us?
Ooh. What other lies have our therapist told us?
So mind brain is important. Medicalizing the mind is the next lie that we want to cut straight
as Christians, we are doing our best to then dissect what is it that we're facing with God's
word. So if it's depression, anxiety, ADHD, take each of those, seriously, run them through
what the Bible says about what you're experiencing. And if there's no physiological problem,
then start to develop a worldview that the solutions are coming from the scripture,
not from the secular therapeutic.
And even if you do have a physiological problem,
that doesn't mean it's only physiological, right?
Because it can intersect with the mind,
which means, like, God's word has an answer for that.
Yeah, I think of stress, right?
Like, there are those that respond to stress by sleeplessness,
losing hair, can't eat.
And you're like, is that a gastrointestinal problem?
Yeah.
I would love to think I could eat sweet potatoes and I trust the Lord and my body's completely
restored.
But I have to learn that, no, I must grow in trusting him.
So I'm at peace.
And then that affects my body as well.
So we want to emphasize, yeah, your body can encourage things, but your inner person can
also encourage things within your body.
So as Christians, we're not neglecting one or the other.
but the current tendency, and this is the lie we have to face in the churches, it's not all a body
problem.
Right.
Like that, let's cut that straight.
It's not all, if there's no evidence that it's a body problem, then let's just be open to the fact
that there's a soul problem here.
Yeah.
I think that, like, it goes back so perfectly to the beginning of this conversation, because I'm
thinking of some examples in my own life.
Like, there might be a particular set of circumstances that actually makes you stressed.
It makes your body stressed.
It makes your palm sweaty.
It makes your mind or brain start raising, whatever it is.
Like you really do feel you have butterflies in your stomach, all of this stuff.
But it's not making me be irritable.
It might encourage me to snap at my family or to be rude to someone or to cut someone off in traffic because I want to get where I'm going.
And from the outside perspective, it's totally understandable for me to act that way.
But it is not making me sin, and I'm so responsible for that sin.
Because, of course, one of the fruit of the Spirit is not self-love, but self-control.
And the Holy Spirit, it, you know, indwells us and can direct the mind no matter what's happening in our physiology.
And like you said, it doesn't mean that our physical circumstances and body doesn't matter and that it can't affect the mind.
But Christians have to be thoughtful enough to remember the presence of the Holy Spirit, right?
and the huge power it has in our lives.
And we're not, you know, we're not dominated by the prince of the power of the air anymore.
So, Ali, some listeners are going to hear them like, are you serious?
Like traffic can't make me angry?
Is that what you guys are saying?
And they're going to feel a burden by that.
And I think we have to say, yeah, you should feel responsibility, but change can happen.
God forgives if we repent.
So instead of me saying, I'm controlled by my anger.
and as men, we can feel legitimized in our anger.
Instead of me saying, like, I just have to be an angry dad, an angry husband,
I can say, you know what?
God calls me to bear responsibility for it,
but then he promises that he will forgive me,
if I confess, 1 John, 8 and 9,
and that he will give me the resources I need to change.
I don't have to be that anymore.
So don't feel the burden of like, oh, man, that's a lot.
Allie, Gifford, you're killing me.
It's like, no, feel the first.
freedom that you can change. Transformation is the idea that you are completely new.
Like that's what a beautiful concept. Not managing the symptoms of. You don't have to be that
anymore. So don't hear like own your sin as this heavy guilt. Hear like own your sin,
yes, but you behold the glory of Jesus, not the glory of your sin. Hebrews 12, look to him.
in your fight against sin you don't focus on your sin you focus on jesus and that brings you freedom
from those things another thought for you lies that therapists are um Christians just think this through
what is repentance what is repentance mean practically change of mind change of mind not change
of brain. If you're unrepentant, Romans 128, you have a calloused mind. Or you have a defiled mind,
Titus 115, that's said of false teachers. Scary thought, but your mind can actually be hardened,
your mind can be calloused. Okay, so why does that matter? Christians, let's just think this through
carefully. If you're going to an unbelieving therapist for help about the most personal matters of
your life, you could literally be sitting across the desk from someone with a hardened, calloused,
defiled mind trying to help you with your most personal intimate problems. In what world does that
make sense? In what world? That's plan C, or that's plan D. But plan A is that I could find somebody
who would use God's word as the source and authority to really help me with the root of what's going on here.
Yeah, I thought.
Well, I was going to ask, for those who don't know, what is the difference between a licensed biblical counselor and someone who is just a Christian therapist?
Yes, good.
The difference between biblical counseling and Christian therapy or Christian counseling is a question that I get.
pretty regularly. So I host a podcast called Transformed and listeners will write in and say,
does that mean anyone that uses the Bible as a biblical counselor? And the answer is the difference
comes down to what's the source and the authority. Love Dave Ramsey. I've used his plan,
but he'll typically grab a proverb and then use that one proverb to develop a whole structure of debt
and managing your personal finances. In the counseling world, it's like that as well. It's like we have 99%
Rogers, 99% Freud, and then a proverb that's kind of dropped in there somewhere.
Right. And you're like, wait a minute. Like that's Freud's anthropology, what he believes
about people. That's his satirology about salvation and sanctity. And then we have a proverb
that's dropped in. That's Christian counseling because the counseling is not coming from the Bible.
There's a Bible verse that's used. Whereas biblical counseling is attempting to take God's word as
both the source and the authority. So the whole structure is built. You interpret people.
through the lens of scripture. You interpret their problems through the lens of scripture or the
solutions through the lens of scripture. That is an outworking of our commitment to the
sufficiency of scripture, which is the Bible has the answers that we need. And will someone who is a
biblical counselor have, like, licensed biblical counselor under their name? If there's someone
out there that's looking for that, like how do they find that person? I think you do need to be
discerning about that because some people will just kind of hang a shingle out and say,
biblical counselor, I got a Bible. And that's great. We appreciate well-intended, compassionate people.
But you are looking for a level of training. You know, I teach at the master's university where we have
bachelors all the way up to doctoral degrees in this. So training, education that corresponds
to being equipped for that. And then there is a certification process called the Association of
Certified Biblical Counselors. That's the organization. And they actually train you, test you,
observe you in counseling to ensure that you can implement what you've done. So it is very possible
to get a degree but never have actually counseled people or met with people. So you have all the
knowledge, but not the skill. So look for someone that has education, yes, Master's University,
or I'm looking for someone that's ACBC certified. And if there's listeners that are interested,
like email me and I'll point you to the, there's a different, it's like a map, an interactive
map that can show you biblical counselors in your area.
That's really good.
I think for people, I'm just thinking through this myself.
Like if I were sitting across from a therapist, and maybe this can only be deduced over
time, but someone who doesn't believe that, like, we are born simple and that we are sinners
or that we don't need a savior, or doesn't acknowledge the need for salvation or sanctification,
like once you start to see that, that a lot of psychologists believe that you are inherently good,
inside, that's when you'll see, like, the big difference in the wisdom that they're going to give you.
And that's when you should walk out if you haven't already.
Imagine being super, like, vulnerable.
And then the therapist psychologist says, yeah, you deserve better.
You're great.
And you're like, I am great.
You know, like, they shouldn't treat me like this.
Happens every day.
Right.
Yeah.
Wow.
I just thought about something else and we don't have time to do it, but we don't have time to get into this.
So maybe you'll have to come back and I'll leave everyone on a cliffhanger.
But you're talking about how like, okay, depression, anxiety.
We're talking about how that's not typically diagnosed using blood work or a brain scan.
And yet they'll tell you, you know, unequivocally that you have low serotonin or something.
And the only other thing I can think of that we do that with is like transgenderism is that you hear someone talk and you're like, yes, your brain is a female brain.
We're not doing brain scans.
Like we're not testing hormones.
not that that would indicate that they're born in the wrong body, but again, they are being given
something to change their body based on like a totally subjective and politicized evaluation.
And I just am thinking now how much of the psychotropics that are given are based on that kind of
politicized, psychologistsized, totally subjective reasoning.
And it actually is changing people's brain in a way that can affect their mind in very dangerous ways.
symptom-based diagnosing.
Yes.
I'll add one more for the teaser.
There's also a group of people that have food allergies
that do not have a medical proof.
And you ask yourself like,
I didn't know that.
If we talk about food allergies,
a self-diagnosed food allergy,
I'm gluten-free, I've never been tested,
there's no test that proves it.
That's interesting because I'm now describing my own health.
I'm describing my own gastrointestinal problems,
and yet there's not an enough.
necessarily medical evidence for that.
Like it's a fascinating concept of, is that true or is that not true?
The self-pathologizing.
Right.
The crunchiness.
Yeah.
Well, that has been, yeah, it's interesting.
We could have a whole other conversation about that.
That when, like, it does seem that nowadays when, like, the patient walks in, like, we're
able to self-diagnose and then they can just give us the medication that we're asking for
because we are directly advertised to by the pharmaceutical company.
And I'm pretty sure we are the only country, if not one of the only countries in the world, where we get that direct to consumer advertising of. Isn't that fascinating? Yeah. We diagnosed ourselves. We just need the doctor to write the prescription. Yeah, I saw this commercial for Wellbutrin.
All right, well, web-imded it, you know, and this is what I have. Yeah. And if the doctor disagrees with me, then I reject that. Yeah. Wow. What a dangerous world we live in. But all the more need for actual biblical counsel that comes.
from the Word of God that comes from Jesus who doesn't change, Hebrews 138. And that is a comfort
when it seems like everything else is giving way. Jesus Christ is the same yesterday, today, and forever.
Amen. Amen. Okay, everyone can buy your book. Why is my therapist told me wherever books are sold?
Right. Whatever they want. And you have a podcast that's called transforming. Yeah, so transformed. If you just
Google transformed, you'll find me. It's part of Fortis Institute where I'm a fellow.
Okay, awesome. Thank you so much, Dr. Gifford. I really appreciate it. Thank you.
No
