RHAP: We Know Survivor - Best Move Ever! Heroes vs Villains, Ep 10: 15 Years Later

Episode Date: April 22, 2025

A special episode deserves a special feed drop, but don’t miss your chance to relive the rest of this legendary season with Rob and Josh. Become a patron today and join us for the full adventure!...

Transcript
Discussion (0)
Starting point is 00:00:00 It was 15 years ago tonight on a night just like this when it sounded like Parvati saying, you know what Jeff I think it would be downright depressing to sit and watch green bananas turn yellow without my debaucherous little villains and that's when Parvati played two idols in a most historic night of Survivor Heroes versus Villains, April 22nd, 2010. And we are here to talk about a 15 years greater with Josh Wiggler. Josh, how are you?
Starting point is 00:00:36 I'm doing quite well. Parvati Shallow, famous for having excellent banana etiquette. Mm-hmm, nailed it. Nailed it. Yes. Nailed it. Nailed it. Yes. Crushed it. And here we are in a very special episode of our Heroes vs. Villains 15-year rewatch.
Starting point is 00:00:54 One that we are giving away for free. We're not waiting for this one to ripen. We're giving it straight to you. Nice and green. We had two feeds, right? So we may as well use them both. We've got the patron feed for the RHAP patrons and we've got the main feed for everybody else. Why not use the both of them to increase our odds of people finding out about you and I every single week talking about survivor heroes versus villains 15 years later in the patron feed for RHAP's patrons. Yeah, it's been so nice to get to do this to go back in time 15 years ago to the season that really
Starting point is 00:01:36 created RHAP as we are sort of like on the precipice of another big survivor anniversary. So the timing felt like that this was the right project to do. And here we are at maybe the highest high that we have here in, perhaps in Survivor, but certainly in Survivor Heroes versus Villains. Yeah, for a very long time at the very least, I think that this was considered the height of the show. I'll be very interested to have that conversation
Starting point is 00:02:05 with you now, 15 years after the fact. I think it's gonna be a really fun conversation today. How many people do you think are looking at this podcast and hearing this news that you and I have been recapping Heroes vs. Villains 15 years later for the past 10 weeks or so now? Or you got some explaining to do. And then you look at them and we say,
Starting point is 00:02:26 secrets, I got my secrets. Yeah, so I think that maybe people knew that we were doing it, but hopefully that people are getting a chance to check it out here by putting this one out on main, as they say. So here we are, get a little bit of a sense of what we're doing, because we haven't really been doing just a straight recap.
Starting point is 00:02:45 We've sort of been looking back at what happened 15 years ago and sort of like giving additional context, certainly from when we recorded the evolution of strategy, which was, believe it or not, 10 years ago. Every time you say it, I think I get just a day closer to death, literally. I mean, I think that's probably just true, but I just like in my heart,
Starting point is 00:03:05 I age like 10 extra years. Josh coming up this fall, okay, listen to this. I'm so nervous about what you're going to say. So it will be 10 years from Survivor Second Chances. There will have been as much time from when we did the evolution of strategy to second chances from actually, it's even longer because we started a year ago from when Survivor started to Heroes vs. Villains. That's wild. That's so wild. Even longer because they took a year off for COVID, right?
Starting point is 00:03:40 I'm getting confused. I'm getting confused. They took a year off for COVID. Cut this part out of the podcast. It'll be all Kailish math. It'll be, it'll be 10 years since I first went out on location, which feels that feels crazy to me as well. Yeah. So lots of historic events here. As Survivor celebrates its 25th year as heroes versus villains celebrates its 15th. The Evolution of Strategy celebrates its 10th. What is this the fifth the five-year anniversary of? Anything fun?
Starting point is 00:04:11 From 2020? Not a ton. Kind of a down year. Yeah. Five years since Winners at War. Oh great. Positive spin. We got it. That's why the big bucks. Yeah. Right. Well, we are so glad you're here if you're here for the first time and you want to come along for the ride. Check out everything that we have going on over robinswebsite.com slash patron and become a part of this great reality TV community, people connecting around the world around these crazy shows and looking back at 15 years back to Heroes versus Villains. And where we left off was the previous episode was all about JT's big blunder.
Starting point is 00:04:57 And the show really presented it as such coming out of last week's episode. Including in the preview leading up to it, Jeff Probst like, next week on Survivor, this fricking guy. That's like basically the trailer is like this idiot. Look, look what this guy's got to do. And then it's just cutting to JT going, I'm going to give her a smile. And so like, there's no tension going from that trailer to the next episode of like,
Starting point is 00:05:23 yeah, he's going to do that. And that's going to be bad that trailer to the next episode of like, yeah, he's gonna do that and that's gonna be bad. This episode is, this episode's the punchline, I think. Like that's the setup, this episode's the punchline, this episode gives us JT performing or I think suffering the consequences of one of the biggest own goals in reality TV history, let alone survivor history. Mm-hmm. Yeah. And so there's so much intrigue coming into this where we have
Starting point is 00:05:52 this merge where I have so many questions for in the real time about this, where there's classic scenario, it's the final 10, we merge five heroes and five villains and JT has given Russell the idol and I think that there's just so much hopium going on from JT's part that of course he can't even consider the fact that maybe what he thought was going to happen is not actually happening because Sandra comes in and says Rupert you gotta believe me I'm telling you don't listen to Russell he didn't and Rupert for like a little bit
Starting point is 00:06:32 like wow is that possible like Russell be lying but everybody's like get out of town Rupert it is an awful look for the heroes that the one who's like, I don't know. I think this might be a big mistake is Rupert. Rupert is the brains of the operation at this moment in time.
Starting point is 00:06:58 Everybody else thinks we're good, we're clear, but Rupert, he smells something fishy. Yes. And not like when Sandra dumped out the bucket from... That was actually after Rupert got voted off. Yeah. Sort of like that though. Similar to that. And it's just so interesting that, you know, Rupert and Sandra have this great relationship where they have played in Survivor Pearl Islands and Sandra comes and says, hey, you can't trust Russell.
Starting point is 00:07:25 He's a liar. And they're still like, mm. But what if he's not? But what if he's not? But at this point, even if he is, which he is, what are you gonna do about it? You gave him the thing. JT can't like go back up to him and be like,
Starting point is 00:07:43 hey, you know, I'm so really sorry. I thought that you were a good guy and I thought that maybe you were at the bottom of the line, so I gave you the idol. But I just't like go back up to him like, I was really sorry, I thought that you were a good guy and I thought that maybe you were at the bottom of the line so I gave you the idol but I just found out from Rupert that Sandra told him that you're actually the head of the bad guys alliance so could you actually give him my idol? Yeah, that's a fair point. It's done. You did it. You already did the thing. You did the thing. You stole the car. You took it on the highway. You can't return it to the owner and say,
Starting point is 00:08:10 actually, can you not get me in trouble for this? You're going to prison. You're going to jail. At least for a few nights. So I think JT, he broke, he did it. He did the thing. It's already done. JT, he broke, he did it. He did the thing. It's already done. Should, what else is there to do?
Starting point is 00:08:30 Should the heroes have voted out Russell? Yes, yeah, I think so. I think that that's the move here because Sandra is saying, I'll do it. I'll vote with you guys. Like if we could get rid of Russell, let's go. But at multiple points in this merge, she's going to offer that up.
Starting point is 00:08:53 But here, if they take her up on it, so what? Then they are the six that they need, it's done. You know, are they just afraid that Russell is going to use that idol? I guess like that makes sense, but if they're able to just be like- No, they think Russell already used the idol. They think that Russell is going to use that idol? I guess like that makes sense. But if they're able to be like Russell already use the idol, they think that Russell used the idol at the previous tribal council. But not at the point that like, well, I guess like still at the point
Starting point is 00:09:14 where Rupert is saying like, I don't know, I kind of think he's a bad dude that they're still kind of like, you know, buying into it. But in the world where they're voting out Russell, do they not think that like he still has the idol and he's duped him? Well, I think that it would really come down to them believing Sandra. And I think that what we don't ever really get clearly
Starting point is 00:09:38 in the episode is that did Sandra kind of do like a half measure. She goes to Rupert and she has that one scene with Rupert. She's like, Hey, nobody can see if I'm talking to you, but don't believe Russell. He's a liar. He's with the women and Rupert is like, Oh, she's saying what I think she's saying. That's not good. But later on in the episode, you have that great confessional. When Sandra says, when I first got here I tried to tell Rupert that Russell is running this whole show and anyway we talked really really quick
Starting point is 00:10:09 and that was it. I don't want my big mouth to get me in trouble. I still want Russell out bad but right now I'm stuck with Russell. I'm stuck with Russell. I'm stuck with Russell. Such gravitas from Sandra there. So I don't know if she was like pounding the table. I'm stuck with Russell is the name of a horror movie, by the way. Like that is. Knock, knock. I'm here.
Starting point is 00:10:36 The hands that rocks the cradle. Well, listen, we cannot possibly be about to embark on the discourse of, should Sandra have done more here? Right? Like, it works out totally fine for Sandra. It does work out totally fine for Sandra. I guess that I'm trying to give the hero some grace, ultimately.
Starting point is 00:10:59 It's not so much that I am like condemning Sandra for how she played this. That my question and because in that if Sandra like does like a full flip against the villains, maybe poverty doesn't play the idol on her. Like maybe poverty is like, you know what, Sandra, you want to be with the hero so bad. Fine. That she won't she doesn't get an idol played on her in that spot. But. It's interesting But it's interesting. It's interesting.
Starting point is 00:11:27 So let's play this out. In the world where, like, if Sandra really, really wants to get Russell out here, and she's like, but I'm too scared. I'm too afraid to do this. Rob, by the way, have you watched the first episode of season two of the rehearsal yet? No.
Starting point is 00:11:43 The Nathan Fielder HBO docu-series comedy. Yes, he is like a wretchedly cracked individual. Like an actual comedic genius in the super villain is Nathan Fielder. And it seems like the premise of the season, this season is that he's exploring why plane crashes tend to occur. Like what is the thing that is the most chiefly responsible, the most chiefly responsible ingredient for plane crashes? That's in theories.
Starting point is 00:12:20 His thesis seems to be because oftentimes the co-pilot who doesn't have enough power or thinks they don't have enough power doesn't speak up against the captain because they're afraid they're gonna get in trouble. They're afraid they're gonna get yelled at. I believe that, I think it's in one of the Malcolm Gladwell books
Starting point is 00:12:41 that they say that that's an issue. And I forget it was like which country really made it so that everybody had the authority to speak up. Is that referenced? That sounds right. And if that sounds intriguing to you, the rehearsal is all about it. It doesn't turn into a plane crash for Sandra,
Starting point is 00:13:03 it turns into a plane crash for the heroes here. But if Sandra just speaks up and takes control of the of the flight, the levers and the wheel thingies and the stuff that you use to fly a plane that all still looks like it's just the 1970s. How does it still look like that here in 2025? If she just takes control of the thing, maybe she saves the plane, which is the heroes packed into this little jet. But instead she doesn't speak up, heroes crash and burn, she ends up walking away from the
Starting point is 00:13:36 fire a million dollars richer, so she's got nothing to regret. But if instead of just having this casual conversation with Rupert and she instead as they're all feasting on ham and dried ham like a pig's head. It was like it was wild that that was in a box in the hot sun. It doesn't seem safe. Wait for these guys to show up with a key so that like hot ham. Do you think that we had takes on the pig's head in a box? Had to, had to. Check the receipts, we had to have,
Starting point is 00:14:10 that ham felt like seeing an old friend. Seeing the ham on the screen again felt nostalgic for me. So we must have talked about the ham. But if over slices of ham, Rob, if she says, poverty's first professional and survivor was, is that kosher? Assuredly, that was not. That was not kosher.
Starting point is 00:14:32 That was not kosher. Ethan's on, would not have been able to eat it according to Big Tom. If Sandra says, everyone, I got an announcement to make. Russell, he's the bad guy. And she just blows it up right there. What happens? Are we just not there in survivor history?
Starting point is 00:14:51 Is that just not where we're at? I was just saying, it might be a nine to zero vote for Sandra at that tribal council. I guess my question is, did Sandra walk it back to Rupert at any point? Was Rupert pursuing this, and did they walk it back to Rupert at any point? Like, was Rupert pursuing this and did they walk it back or did Sandra just sort of make herself small after that moment where she was like, you know what?
Starting point is 00:15:12 I'm saying I'm doing too much here. I'm just gonna let them do what they're gonna do. They'll see and I'll have a chance at a different point to go against Russell. Yeah. I think it's more that. The way that she describes it, it sounds like she said the thing, she walked the thing, like not that she walked the thing back, but that she didn't feel like safe saying it again.
Starting point is 00:15:34 And the heroes feel like, OK, well, we've sort of like Russell proof this. We're just not going to tell Russell who we're ultimately going to vote for. We're going to give him a different name and then we'll see if Russell votes with us or if Russell ends up doing his own thing, then we'll know everything we need to know about Russell. So I think that's what we'll solve it. Let's give Russell a fake name, that'll smoke him out.
Starting point is 00:16:01 That'll be all we need to do in order to mitigate that. Because they don't realize he still has that idol that they think that he's, they do believe that story that he tells them, which is you can like, I still need to play on the clock tower. Like their, their, the, his mechanics. And I know we've talked about this, that him and poverty both played an idol at the same time. And then he says, him and Parvati did not vote on the revote. And we saw in Survivor's Second Chances that they actually would vote on the revote, which we did not know at the time that we recorded
Starting point is 00:16:33 the evolution strategy, how the events would happen. Do we think that Survivor knew that that's what they would do either? Could they have even envisioned such a scenario at this point? Perhaps not. Perhaps not. Perhaps not. Yeah. And then Russell claimed that then all of the other women voted together. They couldn't vote for Russell. They couldn't vote for Pabarty.
Starting point is 00:16:53 They voted out Courtney in that scenario. And that's how Courtney got voted out. Yeah. Yeah. So hook, line and sink are from the heroes, especially from JT, who repeatedly through this episode, I believe he says the phrase, not a chance in the world twice. When he's like, do I believe that Russell could secretly be the head of this alliance?
Starting point is 00:17:20 Not a chance of the world. No way, absolutely not. He's a good old boy. That's particularly damning where he's like laughing about Rupert and he says that there's a reason I've been doing Rupert's strategical play for him thus far because he needs to be told how to vote by someone he can really trust and let that be done. That's hard. That's hard. Rupert, do you believe what Sandra told you
Starting point is 00:17:46 or do you believe the obvious truth? Come on, Rupert. The obvious truth, the obvious truth. Wake up and smell the coffee, my guy. That Russell is on our side, is the obvious truth. Yeah, he says, do I believe it? No, but not a chance in the world, but you never know. You can't have it both ways. You not not a chance in the world, but you never know. You can't have it both ways.
Starting point is 00:18:09 Yeah, not a chance in the world, but you never know. But you never know. I think you got to say, like, tiniest chance of the world. And then you could say, but you know, you never know. But if you're like it's you can't go both ways. The door doesn't push and pull in this scenario. Yeah, but Rupert is though, he loves, he really finds himself in these episodes, and we've seen it almost in every single episode. He loves to do the confessional of the contrarian.
Starting point is 00:18:38 Everybody's thinking one way, and Rupert will love to give you the confessional of like, everybody says this, I don't know. I don't know about that. Yeah, you know, like down to like when they were, they wanted to vote out James. He's like, James is loyal. He's loyal.
Starting point is 00:18:59 Colby is not. Yeah. So whatever is the consensus, like Rupert will like always give you like that you know doubting Thomas sort of like he doubted Thomas he helped vote him out Thomas Westman yeah and JT Thomas and JT Thomas is Rupert like this is this like the most annoying kind of person like the person who's like, the old, like no solutions being offered. None, zero, just like everybody thinks this, but I don't know.
Starting point is 00:19:33 All right, Rupert, then what would you do? Where's your plan? Yeah. What do you think? No, Rupert's never really led an alliance in his career on Survivor. Like he's really just always been kind of a number. Like it's like an outspoken number,
Starting point is 00:19:48 like a mascot at times. Can you refresh my memory of what it was like on the Drake? What were the dynamics on the Drake? So I feel like that early Drake was really like, you know, famously like Burton is sort of like with Sean Cohen sort of like by his side or sort of it was like Burton. What was Sean Cohen?
Starting point is 00:20:10 Jebediah Kovac? Jebediah Kovac, according to Johnny Fairplay and Michelle, like it was sort of like Jebediah Kovac in 10 years. But it was sort of like that it was presented. Oh, this was high school and they were sort of bullying Rupert and he was the one who was like, they're all being like that. And I'm just a little, a little kid that they're being mean to and getting picked on. And then, but he befriended, you know, Sandra and Krista. And then they kind of had their own thing. Then they want to throw a challenge. He's
Starting point is 00:20:41 like, that's a terrible idea. I would never throw a challenge. Yeah. And then he goes, he goes to the other tribe. Then he completely like helps build up the Morgan tribe also. Yes. That's right. That's right. Yes. And then he comes back and then Johnny Fairplay has the plan to vote for him. And then he comes back and he's mad. He's mad. Who voted for him? Yeah. Who voted for me? But right, and then he's like trying to like broker like a peace treaty with Andrew Savage, I think after the merge. Yeah, so he's just never quite been good at it.
Starting point is 00:21:13 Yeah. Survivor. He's never quite had like his group of people that he is able to like inflict his will upon. Yep. At best, people tell him what to do and he goes along with the plan. What is our interest level in Rupert 5.0?
Starting point is 00:21:35 Rupert 5.0 for 50. First River 5.0. Yeah, you know, that was a name that I felt like that was a little bit floated, like conceptually, but it's not a name that I've seen a lot of smoke around in terms of a Rupert, you know. Well, you're not going to see Rupert's like social media activity being particularly weird. He's locked out of his account. Yeah, that's true. I don't think I've seen too many rumors about Rupert return.
Starting point is 00:22:05 Rupert, yeah. Anyway, there's a lot of talk about Rupert. Let's shift the conversation to some of these other people in this episode, because this really is Parvati Shallow's big, spectacular play. And this episode, this episode, Rob, is a roller coaster for Parvati Shallow. Hythin Lowe's here in this episode. Certainly, and she gives us the title.
Starting point is 00:22:32 Bristana Nandrata, the lady of the hour. Right, Going Down in Flames is a quote from Parvati. She talks about how the Heroes tribe is going to be going down in flames once she goes over there. They don't know yet. They're gonna get picked off one by one. And so she has the idol from the last episode. And, you know, it's... Maybe this is Parvati's finest hour across her Survivor playing and reality TV career.
Starting point is 00:23:05 It does at first seem as though she's not fitting in in this new merge tribe that she does seem to be sort of like taking herself out of things. And it's sort of like twofold where it's a good social read from her that she does feel like she's not welcome. I don't know if she necessarily Plays it correctly in terms of she kind of doesn't do anything to change it But at the same time that it all works out in her plan of that I think that I again, I don't know from Parvati how much of this was all predetermined of, okay, well,
Starting point is 00:23:50 I'm not feeling... I think that she's a more instinctual player than she is somebody who's seeing the chessboard and thinking moves ahead. She isn't feeling like she is being received well. She seems to kind of voluntarily separate from the group and then because of that it sort of like perpetuates the fact that you know she's feeling like she is going to ultimately get the votes but she does not know yet at this point that she is going to ultimately get the votes. But she does not know yet at this point that she is going to get that second idol from Russell.
Starting point is 00:24:28 She doesn't know what the immunity challenge is going to be. So it's hard for me to think that she had this all cooked up prior to the next couple of days events. So I guess a question that I'll ask is, so reset the cover story. So Russell is going to tell Colby and JT and Rupert about the night before and why Parvati is still around. And his story is that he and Parvati stand up at the same time, both play their idols, and that everyone had voted for Parvati? No, everyone voted for Russell and Russell's one vote was for Parvati.
Starting point is 00:25:06 Got it, okay, got it, okay. So I was gonna say, is she coming in trying to pretend she's on the outs with her fellow villains? I mean, perhaps it could just be as simple as that she has an idol and maybe she's feeling like, hey, everybody's voting for me tonight and this is going to be... Let me draw the heat.
Starting point is 00:25:25 Yeah, I'm going to ultimately not try to ingratiate myself to the heroes and that I know that I'm going to get the majority of the votes and so I'll play my idol and then that's how we're going to get the numbers. So that I do think that she probably was thinking that. But I also feel like when she's like, nobody likes me, everybody hates me, better go eat some worms. Like the truth is that it's really it's like Colby and Rupert and JT are probably the ones who are frosting her out. Right. She's going to have pleasant interactions with Amanda until she clocks Amanda. And Candace was her old white person White person tribe. I'm, you know, you know, these white people stick together. Right. You know, so like, you know, Parvin Candace, they've got it. So like, like she has this.
Starting point is 00:26:17 Parvati Candace, do it for the white people. Do not say white power in Jonathan Penderenter voice right now. Do not do it. Don't do it. That's our old tribe. Don't do that. Where's Flicka? Don't do it. Uh gosh, Flicka. I forgot about her. Um, so like she's just out with like these three nasty boys, you know, like these these these three nasty boys of Stinky Rupert, slowly deflating Colby and lovesick JT, right? Like in love with Russell. So is it really that bad out there? I don't know. Like, there's also the whole thing about like, you guys are coming into our house and you're not wearing shoes
Starting point is 00:27:07 and like you're eating our nanners. Like, the heroes are very, like those three guys are very protective of their stuff here at Heroes Beach. And Parvati, I think really excels at that, you know, people fall in love with Parvati. And I don't mean like literally, but they fall under her spell.
Starting point is 00:27:29 And then once they're under her spell, she really knows what to do with those people. But I do think that in her reality TV career, if there is going to be like a, Parvati, I think one of the things that is a struggle for her, if the people are resistant to her spell, I feel like that she does have a hard time
Starting point is 00:27:52 of winning that person over who is not under the gravitational pull of her charm. Right, that's like how Chris O'Donnell resists poison ivy in Batman and Robin. Rubber lips are immune to your poison. Yes. Yeah. So these boys are wearing rubber lips.
Starting point is 00:28:15 Yeah. Now in this instance, like Parvati has two little green men in her pocket that are going to ultimately save the day for her. But there's like the little aliens, right? Yes, they're like the claw. Ah, but poverty really, I'm trying to think of the time in her career where she's able to just as the flip, the flip people against to go the other way.
Starting point is 00:28:43 Yeah, I don't remember traders well enough to know what that was like for her. Is there anything where she's able to turn opinion on her? I mean, Eric Reichenbach gives up the necklace, but I'm not sure necessarily he, I guess that's kind of in that category. Sort of, but we've relitigated that,
Starting point is 00:29:02 and I think her role in that is not like that's that's really big. It's not simple. It's a multi pronged move. You know, like we can't just like lay that totally for for Parvati any more than you could totally lay it for Saree or any of them. So, yeah, I'm trying to think someone's listening to this being like, you idiot. Yeah. And maybe either way, Parvati Parvati, the things that she does great, she is maybe the best ever at. So we can't nitpick some of the things that she's not as great at.
Starting point is 00:29:36 That's not her game. And so she ultimately is going to feel kind of left out. Boy, these heroes get in such a snooty mood over their eating breakfast. And Parvati goes to eat a bit. And they have like literally a hundred bananas. It feels like they have like an infinite supply of bananas. Like frankly, I don't remember how we felt revisiting this
Starting point is 00:30:08 once upon a time, but James is like, I didn't realize there was such a thing as banana etiquette guys. Like I didn't think this was a big thing. And like. Banana etiquette Josh was like, hey Josh, you're going to get a banana. Why don't you ask me if I would like a banana too?
Starting point is 00:30:23 That's banana etiquette. This is a totally different thing. Yeah, I mean, I think that you guys have a healthy supply of bananas. I think people could just eat them. It looks like you could probably just eat them. Has anyone ever screen capped and counted how many bananas the heroes had at this moment in time?
Starting point is 00:30:42 Easily over 50. And to quote Danielle, when the bananas are brought up at tribal council, she says she wanted to have one from the plethora amount that we have. Yeah, they have a plethora amount. Yeah. So Survivor has a plethora amount of seasons.
Starting point is 00:31:02 Yeah, that's what El Guapo says. Do you know what that's from? Nope. It's from the Three Amigos. Oh. Are you familiar with that? I'm familiar with the Three Amigos, but I think I probably only saw it once when I was a boy.
Starting point is 00:31:19 Yes, that the bad guy is El Guapo. And I forget, he's asked a question of, and he asked like, would you say that I have a plethora of, I forget what the thing is. And I am Mandela affecting so hard right now. Like we had this, we talked, this one we talked about, didn't we? Yeah.
Starting point is 00:31:43 This feels like we did this. So I, probably in the. This feels like we must have had a plethora amount of conversations about this exact thing. Yeah. El Huapo. He said yes. That Hefe tells him he has a plethora of piñatas.
Starting point is 00:32:06 And El Juapo asks for a definition. He doesn't understand the word. What's the definition he receives? Does he get one? I don't know, but here's what Danielle says. I don't think we should be penalized for wanting to cook a plantain, considering the plethora amount that we have.
Starting point is 00:32:24 Yeah, the plethora amount. Yeah. For those of you just joining us in the Patreon feed, check out the plethora amount of Patreon podcasts that we have waiting for you right here at robinswebsite.com slash patron. Let me tell you who understands the assignment, folks. That would be Robert K. Cesternino.
Starting point is 00:32:46 Yeah. A plethora amount of podcasts under his belt. He knows the score. Okay. Well, all right. So I want to go to the immunity challenge, and this is one that, perfect timing, and we get to our immunity challenge,
Starting point is 00:33:00 and it happens to be the challenge we've been talking about quite a bit this week, get a grip, which is a challenge that we saw featured, and it happens to be the challenge we've been talking about quite a bit this week, Get a Grip, which is a challenge that we saw featured but six days ago on Survivor 48, where Jeff Copes called it, perhaps, Survivor's most iconic challenge. You agree with that, that this is Survivor's most iconic
Starting point is 00:33:20 challenge? I do not. I do not agree with that. Yeah. Is it a Mount Rushmore challenge? I don't think it's top four. Is it top 10? I think that it's probably somewhere between 10 and 15. Okay. What is the Mount Rushmore of survivor challenges?
Starting point is 00:33:36 I mean, I think that, I've talked about this a lot in some of the other podcasts, but I believe that some of the Mount Rushmore of survivor challenges are challenges that they often don't do anymore, and I think that the most iconic Survivor challenge is Hands on a Hard Idol. Yes, Hands on a Hard Idol is the answer, for sure.
Starting point is 00:33:53 Auction? Is the auction a challenge? I think it's more of a reward. I wouldn't say the auction is necessarily a challenge. Yeah, yeah, I think I would. Blindfolds? Blindfold challenge? I think thisfolds. Blindfold challenge. I think this is better than blindfold challenge.
Starting point is 00:34:08 Yeah, yeah. It's great, you know, it's always good TV. It always looks real difficult. Yes, but Jeff is on one in this because we- He hates these people, Rob. He does not there for this. He does not like that people are stepping down from the challenge. And maybe that speaks to what we see now in modern day survivor
Starting point is 00:34:33 with this challenge, where they've made it like impossibly hard so that people cannot actually do it. And I think he prefers that to people stepping down because first off, Sandra and Colby are the first people to step down. Giggling like little kids, right? These are, it's like giggling like a bunch of like little three-year-olds who are like discovering speech for the first time and are saying like,
Starting point is 00:34:56 duty at each other. It's like Colby and Sandra hopped down, they're like, you ready? On three, one, two, three, duty. And then they hopped down and Jeff's like, what ready? All three, one, two, three, duty. And then they hop down. And Jeff's like, what are you kids doing? You seriously doing this? Hopping down right now?
Starting point is 00:35:12 Colby? Colby? Really, Donaldson, you're out already? I was like, yeah, it was my thing. Wasn't feeling it. Duty is power. Colby is not. Yeah, Jeff even rakes Colby over the coals in his EW blog that he wrote.
Starting point is 00:35:28 He said, once again, Colby. For those just tuning in, we love to check back in on Jeff's EW blog. Yes. Jeff blog during the season. He said, once again, Colby drops out of another challenge. I think he's been one of the biggest surprises. And many would probably say one of the biggest disappointments of the season. Yeah. Which one, Jeff? Which one might say? Yeah. Who's the one?
Starting point is 00:35:51 Yeah. And so the immunity challenge comes down to Parvati and Danielle. And so Danielle knows Parvati as the idol is like, Hey, let me take this one. And then Parvati says, all right, sure. She steps down. They don't even put on a performance about this. There's no illusions. Just Parvati gets off the pole.
Starting point is 00:36:17 And Danielle, is this the behavior of a captain of sports? I don't know. I think they're really in this together. And you'll see Lorenzo saying, Parvati, could you let me win? of a captain of sports. I don't know. I think they're really in this together. saying Parvati, could you let me win? Could you? Yeah. Could you just let me win? She's the lady in waiting also.
Starting point is 00:36:33 But also Parvati, we know has just in survivor micro-nesia. She is also this is the challenge, I believe, when Ozzy gets voted out. Is that when Ozzy or is that is that when Ozzy gets voted out or when Princesszy gets voted out. Is that when Ozzy gets voted out or when Princesska gets voted out? I don't remember how I got voted out. It's too traumatic and I can't go back to that time in my life. 10 years ago you spoke about this
Starting point is 00:37:00 and you don't even recall? Yeah. Where's Princesska? So, right? Is this, did they do that in Ornbo? Or was that the hand over the head? Am I? I have no way of telling you this. No, I guess they did not do this in my religion.
Starting point is 00:37:20 I guess this is, because so much had been made about poverty and the footholds here. You see Parvati in a very unusual stance, but I think that a lot of people may be Mandela effect that Parvati won this challenge, and this is her only time competing in it. I absolutely, in my heart of hearts, believed watching this episode
Starting point is 00:37:40 that she was gonna win this challenge. Yeah. She didn't. She does not win this challenge. I just think of her as winning this one. I think she could have, but ultimately Danielle wins this challenge, and so that sets up that Danielle is immune.
Starting point is 00:37:52 And so we have like these great two scenes in this episode where Amanda and Parvati talk. And so this is so much fun to go back and revisit where Amanda first tells Parvati that, I wish there was some way we could work together. Yeah, you got your idol, right? Play it. Play it on yourself. You're in danger. And Parvati says, girl, you see her ears. And poverty says, girl, you see your ears. Mm-hmm.
Starting point is 00:38:26 I played with Amanda. She's lying. And I'm not gonna get played. Yeah. She won't do it. So. She's not gonna play that game. Do you like their secret handshake?
Starting point is 00:38:41 Was that a throwback to Micronesia? I don't recall. I mean, I thought that the- I remember you doing like stir the pot. That's what I remember, the secret handshake. But here they say, all right, secret handshake. And what they do is they like do like, sort of like a high five and then like a boom and pow.
Starting point is 00:39:00 And I feel like that's kind of just handshakes. Yeah. It's kind of giving a little Michael Scott to me. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. This is definitely not a new era handshake. No it's not.
Starting point is 00:39:15 Definitely not. The wait is over. The NBA season is here and FanDuel is the place to bet on all the action. I'm talking everything from point spreads to money lines to player props. You can even pick who's going to win it all. Whether you're betting on a breakout performance or an underdog victory, tip off the season right with North America's number one sportsbook. Just download the app and bet on the NBA all season long.
Starting point is 00:39:39 Please play responsibly. 19 plus and physically located in Ontario. If you have questions or concerns about your gambling or the gambling of someone close to you, please go to connectsontario.ca. Parvati in the first conversation with Amanda is like, you know, Parvati is trying to open up to Amanda. Amanda's like, I wish there was some way that we could work together, but I don't know.
Starting point is 00:39:59 I don't think there's anything there. Simply cannot, just not gonna be able to do that. And so Parvati's radar go ding ding ding ding ding ding ding. Liar, liar. Yeah, so she's definitely reading Amanda as inauthentic here, but then after Parvati steps down from the challenge, really that does a lot of things for Parvati, and so it really works out in Parvati's favor to some degree where when she steps down
Starting point is 00:40:29 Everybody's like I didn't like how Parvati stepped down I think there's maybe she does have an idol and then ultimately that they're saying like, okay Well, maybe we shouldn't put the votes on to Parvati Right. And so in doing that, she allows for the probability that she's not going to receive the votes, that the idol really ought to go somewhere else. Yeah. So in this sequence of events, okay, Parvati,
Starting point is 00:41:06 based off of what we, the order that we see it, okay, so after the challenge, then Sandra realizes she's stuck with Russell. Russell is going to give the idol to Parvati. Yeah. How often do you think Russell replays that in his head? Today. I don't think that Russell revisits mistakes like that. Well, probably not verbally,
Starting point is 00:41:35 but does he non-verbally return to those mistakes? I don't think that Russell thinks about things he did wrong. I just don't think that he does not do that kind of self-reflection. Introspection. things he did wrong. I just don't think that he does not do that kind of like self reflection. Introspection. I think Russell did it. I played a perfect game. I did everything right. Can we do it on his behalf? Because maybe he should like, you know, we're laughing at JT giving an idol away. Russell gives his idol away. Why does Russell, oh because I guess he feels like, okay well I need to keep my cover,
Starting point is 00:42:08 but he's already not writing down the name that the heroes, well he doesn't know that they're testing him. So. Right, but he's not gonna do it anyway. He's not gonna do it anyway. So I don't know why, kind of a half measure from Russell. He's giving her the thing, like he's giving her the move. Like here's the move, you've got the idol,
Starting point is 00:42:26 you're gonna get to play it. Like Russell is all about pizzazz. Like this is an opportunity for Russell to stand up and be like, heroes in another world, it could have worked out. JT, thanks for the guillotine snap, you know? And then like he plays it and JT goes. That they vote for Jerry.
Starting point is 00:42:47 I think that Parvati plays the first idol on Sandra. So if she does play the idol on Sandra, if Russell hypothetically plays the idol on Parvati, Jerry still gets five votes. We go to some sort of tiebreaker. For sure, I mean, I think that this all plays incredibly differently if Russell holds on to the idol. I don't think that Parvati plays an idol on somebody.
Starting point is 00:43:11 I think Parvati gets protected by Russell and like- Russell might go home in that scenario because that now that, okay, so in that scenario that Jared, if it's a deadlock tie, okay, and then five to five, and then we have our revote and it comes back five to five again, now, well actually- Should we talk it through? Are we talking it through? I'll talk it through.
Starting point is 00:43:36 So I think that- No, I mean, is that what's happening in Survivor at this point? No, I think that, well, I think that they have to either vote for Jerry or for JT again. Okay. And then so I think we have, we have our deadlock, right? I don't think that like somebody's flipping in that scenario. I mean, maybe Sandra is like, Hey, I'm not drawing a rock. Although Sandra's already had an idol played on her. So what does she care? So she would be the
Starting point is 00:44:03 most likely person to flip. But then I think it ultimately would go to rocks in that scenario where everybody would draw rocks except for JT. And then so four heroes would draw rocks and the only villain that would draw rocks then would be Russell. Yeah, but those are, those are decent odds for Russell. Decent odds for Russell.
Starting point is 00:44:24 He'll play that game. Yeah. He'll odds for Russell. He'll play that game. Yeah. He'll take that hand. He'll take that bet. Probably an 80% chance that one of the heroes goes home in that spot. But yeah, definitely would have been a weird season 20 travel council.
Starting point is 00:44:35 Yeah. And I think that that's what we would be saying about it. It's like, that was weird as opposed to that was something else. Oh my god. Yes. And so Parvati has a great moment. And she has like this self-realization,
Starting point is 00:44:51 a great confessional that she has. She says, Russell just gave me his immunity idol. So that makes me safe tonight. And I have my own immunity idol. So that makes me safe for the rest of the game. So at this point, she's not even talking about like what she's gonna do. So I have two little green men protecting me and apparently everyone else in this game is like
Starting point is 00:45:08 desperate to get rid of me and they said I'm the most dangerous player out here. So I don't know. I guess they're right. I didn't really think that they were right until right now. Now I really think they're right. Yeah, it's a nice moment when when you realize that you've got all of that power within you. Like, it's you. It was always you, Parvati. This is like her chosen one moment. And Amanda says to her, like, hey, definitely play the idol tonight.
Starting point is 00:45:39 Yeah. Definitely on the damn ground. You scumbag. You stepped on my joke. Sorry. I hope you get bit by a crocodile. Damn scumbag. Yeah.
Starting point is 00:45:50 How many times have we said damn over the course of the last 10 years, followed by, no, preceded by chicken? So many. Yeah. Damn. But Parvati realizes that Amanda's saying, play around just in case, just in case. And Amanda's like, oh, my head hurts. Yeah.
Starting point is 00:46:11 What is happening? Not the best acting of- Smell Blue Crush 2. Yeah, yeah. Tell you that right now. Is that her big thing, Blue Crush 2, BC2? Yeah. What else has she been in?
Starting point is 00:46:28 A lot of Survivor. Commercials? I don't know if she's done a lot of commercials. Wasn't she in some sort of jeans campaign? Jeans campaign? I thought she was recently in a bridal catalog. I thought there was something about jeans. I don't know why she was in jeans. But I don't know. Maybe not. I can't really recall. Yeah. I don't think that
Starting point is 00:46:57 Amanda trying to snow Parvati is really like the thing. What, and also like, what does Amanda, like, Amanda and everybody else like on the Heroes Chib, weren't they kind of like starting to get a little annoyed with each other with sort of the discourse about like those previous nine days? Yeah. Should she have just done the obvious thing and be like, you know what Parv?
Starting point is 00:47:24 Let's just do it again. Let's run it back and like actually do that. Yeah, I think that this is like one of those great unsolved mysteries of I think that there was like some wedge between Parvati and Amanda going into Heroes vs. Zones where they were not necessarily on the same page. Got it. OK. I feel like that that Amanda had been replaced with Danielle DiLorenzo.
Starting point is 00:47:45 Yeah, new girlfriend meme with Danielle. So the storyline of the bananas is, we mentioned it a little bit, but it is just such a funny backdrop to this episode. This is from Rupert and everybody complaining about Parvati and Danielle eating all the bananas. They're a greeny ass, eatin' ass, pain in the ass tribe. They're a greedy ass, eatin' ass, pain in the ass tribe. Excuse me, what are they eating? They're a greeny ass, eatin' ass, pain in the ass tribe.
Starting point is 00:48:24 Wow, hell yeah. I in the ass, try it. Wow. Hell yeah. I'm not gonna kink shame. Yo, Heroes vs. Villains is wild. I hope they weren't eating Russell's ass. Because he's got to wash that in the ocean first. That's true.
Starting point is 00:48:40 Again, no, sorry. You know what? No kink shaming. I don't know. You're a greedy ass. Eating ass. Pain know what? No kink shaming. I don't know. You're a greedy ass. Eating ass. Pain in the ass.
Starting point is 00:48:48 Pain in the ass. Yeah. Wow. And at tribal council, they get into the full on. We mentioned that Danielle with the plethora amount. It's the ripe bananas. We have ripe bananas all the time. But we let them ripen But we let them ripen. What a flex. We let them ripen.
Starting point is 00:49:07 We have ripe bananas all the time. You know what's so great about this? I think like, let's see if we can follow this line. Let's say we let James eat all the bananas, okay? Okay. James eats all the bananas and none of the ass, just the bananas. So the bananas go down, we lose them, all the bananas are eaten, we get to the
Starting point is 00:49:29 merge. bananas aren't really an issue anymore. Is Rupert able to focus up? Wake up Rupert? Are you able to convince these people that Russell's the bad guy? Is he is he off his game? The only person with the correct information on the heroes tribe because he's just seeing red. He's just seeing yellow. All he can see is ripe, ripe yellow banana. If they had just let James eat them and the Nanners are no longer a thing, what happens?
Starting point is 00:50:00 He can't help it. He's all in on the bananas. At the end of the day, it's always a banana that gets us. Yeah. Josh, do you remember your first reaction to seeing this? Do you remember the real time of this moment of like, were you... No, not anymore. Did you feel like you knew what was coming?
Starting point is 00:50:20 No, I have no real memories of it anymore. I have some indelible survivor memories from watching the show, but this is not one of them anymore if it was once upon a time. Do you? No, I don't really remember where I was watching it, and I do remember that in the real time, that same week that this episode aired,
Starting point is 00:50:41 April 22nd of 2010, Nicole and I went to dinner with with Parvati and James and Jenna and Ethan. And I think that that and maybe Shane Powers might have made an appearance also that night. Yes. At your house? Not at my house. We went to a dinner, we went to, I believe, the Geisha house owned by then Mike Boogie. And we had a dinner there. I think it was like the first time that Jenna Moraska and Parvati had met. This was the first for them.
Starting point is 00:51:18 And then did you all watch their show? No, this was like Friday. This was that, you know, the show was on like Thursday and maybe so it might've been that, I guess it was maybe the next This was that you know, the show was on like Thursday and maybe so it might be that I guess Wasn't maybe the next day. Okay. Yeah. Yeah. And so do you not that sounds like a pretty legendary dinner to not remember the details I remember the dinner the details of the dinner more than the dinner the details of watching the episode Yeah, can you tell us any of the deets the Terry deets of the dinner or should that stay in the past? Um, Yeah, it was a nice time.
Starting point is 00:51:47 I had not seen Jenna and Ethan in a minute. In a while. Yeah. Yeah. So it's nice to see them in person out and about. And James was a lot of fun. And I remember asking Parvati, like, how did you know? How did you know to do it? She's like, I just like I knew Amanda and that was it.
Starting point is 00:52:07 That was, she knew what to do. Yeah. You were friends with Parvati at this point? Not really. I don't think I had ever really had a one-on-one. I think I had, you know, I don't even know if she knew who I was. Yeah.
Starting point is 00:52:21 If you ever get the chance to speak with her again on the podcast, Rob, can you ask her what her memories of the Geisha house are? I mean, in general or on this night? I guess in general, but specifically on this night is really what I'm asking. What are you looking for? What was it like with her, like sitting with Shane Powers?
Starting point is 00:52:41 Shane Powers who met us at the bar, like later on at the bar later on. Fly on the wall to be at the Geisha house 15 years ago with Parvati and Shane. Just fascinated. Again, Shane was not at the Geisha house. He met us at the bar. I'm really trying to locate him at the Geisha house.
Starting point is 00:52:58 Yeah. Okay. Well. Why didn't he get the invite to dinner? I don't know. They called him later. Okay. I was not connected with all these people at that point in time. Okay, well. Why didn't he get the invite to dinner? I don't know, they called him later. Okay.
Starting point is 00:53:06 I was not connected with all these people at that point in time. Yeah, so what were you feeling? You were like, wow, look at all these people. No, cause you didn't really, you were still like, you were just getting back in. You were just reunited. Well, it was Jenna and Ethan were coming into Los Angeles.
Starting point is 00:53:19 And so that I was, you know, had been in, you know. More focused on your friends, yeah. Yeah, and you know, I think that Ethan had just, that it was the first time Ethan had cancer. I think this was also like, sort of like the first time Ethan was back out and about. Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. After going through cancer.
Starting point is 00:53:37 Because I feel like at the 10 year anniversary party, people were like sending like, goodwill wishes to Ethan. So I think it was the first time. And then I think that, and then he had a relapse and then he had to go through cancer again after that. But this was the first time. So in the real time though, in the podcast, I spoke with Richard Hatch the day after this episode.
Starting point is 00:53:59 Unbelievable. What did Richard have to say about all this? He was not a big fan of Russell Hance. Well, that, you know, there's only room for one RH on Survivor. Are there how many RHs are there on Survivor, would you guess? Probably at least this is going to be another one, right? I think. Yes. Probably at least, this has got to be another one, right? Dig.
Starting point is 00:54:29 Tristan Mithal's in the chat. Yeah. Okay. But you know, Richard Hatch, I think was like in rare form, you know, he was always good on the podcast. Yes. Yeah. Wellness check on Richard Hatch?
Starting point is 00:54:45 I'd be up for it. I mean, he was just on House of Elements. Should we float the idea of wellness check on Maine right now? Could be interesting. Let me see if I could pull some of his more interesting thoughts. Just to pilot it out real quick.
Starting point is 00:55:03 So wellness check is an idea that Rob and I have been tossing around of Like just reaching out to some of the people who like maybe should we have them on the podcast? Yeah No, but like don't we want to reach out to them and just see like are you good you okay? What's going on? Yeah, you want to hear what Richard Hatch had to say about Colby. Yeah, I would love that Okay, let's see if I can See if I can play. Bring this up. Let's see. I had the same the same problem as the last time I tried to do this. Okay, let me try it. Try it one more time and see if we can get it. I have the the whole thing transcribed. Okay. And so trying to play my play my transcription here
Starting point is 00:55:48 Okay, I asked question of all right. Let me ask you but what do you make of Colby this season? Wow, how about You know if I you know, some people read books to go to sleep I if you know some people read books to go to sleep well so that i think really what's what's going on but what i mean just still not in the game a look i like colby i played with them on uh... the all-stars but even on the all-stars
Starting point is 00:56:15 i i i sat with him and i talked with him very clearly about what was needed and he and kathy uh... i expressed to them listen if you get rid of me, you two are going next. You know, I realize you've been warned that I'm a threat, but I know how to play the game and sticking together, I can take you much further than you'll ever, anyway. He just doesn't, he doesn't have as a good handle
Starting point is 00:56:43 on what you need to do to play. Yeah. Yeah, as evidenced by this immunity challenge. You didn't have a good foot tool either. Yeah, let's see. Oh, I think- The thing for foot tool? Okay, oh, Richard Hatch was not a huge fan of Coach.
Starting point is 00:56:59 You wanna hear what he had to say about Coach? Yes, of course I wanna hear what Richard Hatch had to say about Coach. Okay, let's see. Here's, Richard Hatch about Coach. Let's see. This was at... Okay. Yes, okay. This is going to start off with that he likes Tyson. Oh, a favorite. You know, I liked Tyson's crass kind of directness.
Starting point is 00:57:29 Yeah. I really, really, I really liked that just personally to watch how he would say what he was thinking about other players. And I think that's a gift that a good player gives to viewers is to talk to the camera kind of, kind of directly and brusqu possibly about the people around them and and put it put it out there i mean if they're acting like idiots and moron say so you know not to their faces but to the camera so that viewers know what you think it
Starting point is 00:57:55 and i love that about uh... about tyson i i like rob just as a person but i thought he was kind of overdone in the game to i thought it wasn't subtle enough coach made me nauseous every there and i'm glad to see him go yeah that man who might that in person to any actually seems
Starting point is 00:58:15 finding and and and writing could carry on a conversation i don't know what the hell happens to a month to get on the island because i don't think i've ever seen anyone dumber in my entire life. He's absolutely pathetic to watch what he does in the midst of the game. I mean, do you disagree? Well, do you? I think that's a little bit of a hard take on Coach. Yeah. I don't think I've seen anyone dumber in my entire life. I think that's a little bit of a hard take on Coach.
Starting point is 00:58:45 Yeah. I don't think I've seen anyone dumber in my entire life. He makes me sick. He made Richard Hatch do it. Richard was so hard on Coach. Wellness check on Richard, are you still not? Maybe we could like heal the rift between him and Coach. That's a great iteration of wellness check
Starting point is 00:59:04 where like wellness check is also like, like checking in on like relationship statuses. So you get repeat guests. Yeah. You know, like you could get Boston Robin Russell, but then you can get Russell and Richard, you could get Richard and coach. This would be riveting series. Our highly problematic wellness check podcast on our. And also this appearance that Richard Hatch did in April of 2010. I mean, I think that this is he had been recently out of prison. And so this was like kind of a big get for me to have on the podcast.
Starting point is 00:59:38 Yes. Yeah. Yeah. But you knew Richard. I knew I sure I knew him. You were on the pre jury trip with him and zero time with him. I spent. Sure, I knew him. You were on the pre-jury trip with him and spent zero time with him. I spent some time with him. And I got to see a little bit of what he's like outside of the show. But he had then, in 2005 or so, he had gone to jail. And then I think he had just gotten out
Starting point is 01:00:02 of prison around this time. I think actually he, that he tells the story about that. He tells one, shares the story from his time when he was away. Let me see if I could play that clip real, real quick. Asking him about that he talked about how he has seen all of the shows and he never missed an episode even when he was in prison. Yeah, I've seen them all. I really do love the game and people think, Oh, well you were in prison. Well, believe it or not, we have TVs. There are televisions. They're the best babysitters on the planet. Is survivor popular in prison?
Starting point is 01:00:47 No, there's a really phenomenal, interesting dynamics that go on there. You have to kind of establish a certain hierarchy, and then you have to have influence over what gets put on the television. And I was able to get it done. I mean, it's a whole other game of Survivor. Yeah, I was just going to say that. and i was able to you know to get it done it's a whole other game of survivor or that uh... or anything you know we would have
Starting point is 01:01:09 with these aluminum benches in this big room there'd be six television hanging from the ceiling and so yet one and that you would get committed to have survivor on it and you know you hear people screaming about all the sports games on and you're trying to hear your show i mean it was really not uh... you know, the ideal place. But I have seen all episodes. Yeah.
Starting point is 01:01:33 Might be easier to hear than some of these watch parties that are out there. But that you think you think that people would have an easier time watching an episode of Survivor and understanding it in prison than at a live show? I thought we were trying to sell our product today, Rob. I'm not even in the RJP live show. Every city in America has all these watch parties. Come join the Patreon. You can get early access to our live shows.
Starting point is 01:02:03 It's not as good as watching Survivor in jail, but almost. Yeah. All right. Almost. Josh, anything else that you want to say about this hour of iconic television? Have we given enough flowers to Parvati for the move?
Starting point is 01:02:19 Have we talked enough about once upon a time, at the very least, Rob, this is talked about as like the best move in Survivor. Is it still? Is it still the best move in Survivor history? I am not qualified to weigh in. I have to ask you, what do you think? So this is a huge move.
Starting point is 01:02:40 I think that there are some, and you know, this is what we always used to talk about. I think we talked about like, was this the dumbest move in the survivor history also JT giving the idol to Russell I think that the challenge is do you make this move and do you win the game because you make you make this poverty had a lot of different ways that she could have played this poverty does not even go on to win this season. So I think that that sort of like docks points for me in terms of this was not even a game winning move for Parvati, it's maybe a game winning move for Sandra in terms of, I mean, but she doesn't even end up
Starting point is 01:03:19 getting votes. So this is certainly a dazzling move and perhaps the most ambitious and dazzling move that had ever been attempted to this time. But I think I would I would struggle to call it the biggest move. And we have to also define what is a move. Like I feel like that Tony getting woo to take him to the final two to to me, is probably the biggest move. I mean, Richard Hatch had a similar moment in Survivor Borneo, where he gets Kelly Wigglesworth to take him when he steps down from the iconic Hands on a Hard Idol. So I feel like that either of those things
Starting point is 01:04:00 are bigger moves in that I do this thing and I win the game, or if I don't pull this thing and I win the game or if I don't pull this off I lose the game. Yeah. That's sort of like the but in terms of like the most spectacular, I feel like there's a different modifier that we need to use here of like this like spectacular thing that nobody had thought of doing before that poverty is able to do to, you know, great accolade. It's really the crowning moment. I mean, maybe her winning in Micronesia, but I feel like that this is even above that. If you were going to make the all time greatest poverty moments list.
Starting point is 01:04:38 Let me see if anybody's made that the all time greatest poverty. Let me just see. Okay. Greatest moves in Survivor history. Let me just see what the conventional wisdom is, and then see if that is a Parvati's greatest moves. I mean, I wrote a very dated version of this in 2014, so I hope that's not the top result.
Starting point is 01:04:56 Yeah, let's see. The screen ran from 2021 best strategic moves ever on Survivor, but I'm not sure this is, this one isn't really ranked. Oh, it's just like a gaggle. Yeah. How about- You know what's so, this is good content for us. We should do this.
Starting point is 01:05:16 We should figure this out. We should have, I think it's time to decide what's the best move in Survivor history. Yeah, I think that that's very interesting to try to figure out. I think there's a lot of debate on that. Because there are a lot of great moves, but were they game-winning moves?
Starting point is 01:05:38 Right, right. Does a move need to be game-winning for it to be the greatest? Like if, and you have this with, I know you're not a football guy, in terms of like, if you were gonna do the, you know, 25 greatest plays in NFL history, that there are sort of like these like
Starting point is 01:05:54 amazing regular season moments, but then probably, you know, these great moments come from like things that like won a playoff game, like the Immaculate Reception or the David Tyree helmet catch, where these things that they were huge plays that happened in the biggest moment. Now this is the winners, oh I'm sorry, this is Heroes vs. Villains. So this is kind of like in the Super Bowl, but it's not in a winning effort by Parvati.
Starting point is 01:06:22 No, no, no. But is it the most hassling? It really, I think through 20 seasons, is just truly spectacular. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Would love to hear the takes from the peeps. It is really great to revisit, and seeing the heroes realize what's happening is really tasty.
Starting point is 01:06:45 JT, for all the jokes you could make at his expense through all of this, like he's a really good sport on his way out the door. Like good move to Russell, shakes his hand. He's humble about it on in his final words, but then he goes on to say, never trust a villain and never trust women. You can never trust women. It's like JT. My thing started the next episode say, never trust a villain and never trust women. You can never trust women.
Starting point is 01:07:05 It's like JT, no. My thing started the next episode, so I did not get the never trust women. No, JT, no, no. Yeah, JT Thomas does not believe women. Mm-hmm, what are you gonna do? Not good, not good. All right, Josh, what's coming up for you?
Starting point is 01:07:20 Oh my gosh, well, we're having a great. By the way, if you enjoyed this and you wanna hear more of this nonsense, drop us at website.com slash patron. There's a ton of great stuff. I've never heard, and nobody's ever told me to my face, you know, I deeply regret becoming a patron. I've never heard that.
Starting point is 01:07:36 No. To your face. To my face. I've never heard it to my face. I've never even heard it like implied. I've never heard it anecdotally at all. All I've heard is, oh my gosh, my life changed. I became a patron of RHAP.
Starting point is 01:07:52 Yeah. And maybe people are like, well, you know, I'm not really keeping up with Survivor anymore. OK, so that I get it. But nobody's ever like, yeah, that was a huge mistake. Yeah. To become a patron. I've never heard it. I've never heard it. What I've heard instead is like, you know what happened to me? I became a patron of RHAP,
Starting point is 01:08:13 and I made so many friends. I got to talk about my favorite shows with so many people. I got access to exclusive podcasts, such as the Five for Five, where Rob and Nicole talk with each other like it's the classic 15 years ago survivor, but with fewer phone buttons getting pushed in the audio. Much better audio than we had back then. Yeah. I've heard people say, I became a patron of RHAP and becoming a patron of RHAP made watching all of those international reality shows so much easier. It was very easy.
Starting point is 01:08:58 So much easier. I've heard recently that I became a patron of RHAP and I got an incredible new podcast feed that collects all the greatest postseason interviews Rob has conducted with the various survivor players. Yeah, we have just put together a brand new playlist to make it so easy for everybody who wants to listen to old Survivor interviews from post-game interviews that I've done. We've put together, I think it's like 90 some odd Survivor post-game interviews that I've done over the years.
Starting point is 01:09:38 It's a big, it's a big, beautiful playlist. It's a plethora amount of post-game interviews. Yes, and nobody said, I became a patron and it was... Big mistake. You shouldn't have done that. Nobody became a patron and said... Never! Ah, this is too...
Starting point is 01:09:57 No, never. So become one, become one today. You become a patron of RHAP. You get like early access to info. Like if you were a patron of RHAP, you might get like early info on like the Wandoff is coming back for one night only for Survivor 48. The one night only Survivor 48 Wandoff. You know, we're telling you all that now here on Maine for free but if you're patron you get you get info like that all the time. Yep
Starting point is 01:10:32 okay all right time so that's what you get when you become a patron Josh what's coming up for you? What's coming up for me is I'm about to sign up to become a patron of RHAP by going to robhasawebsite.com slash patron. All right. There you go. Anything else? I'm just very, I'm very excited about what we just discussed and what we just watched. And I'm very, very eagerly awaiting the fall, the further fall of the heroes. And not the autumn. As we know, autumn can wait.
Starting point is 01:11:06 It's like really nice out now. Yeah. It's like in the seventies today. Nice. Things are heating up in 15 years ago and now, okay? Yeah. All right. We got a great interview with Kelly Wentworth
Starting point is 01:11:18 also from Monday night club condo, plenty of stuff when I'll be back with Stephen Fishback after the episode on Wednesday night. Thank you so much for checking out our episode looking back at one of Survivor's most iconic nights. Take care everybody, have a good one. Bye!

There aren't comments yet for this episode. Click on any sentence in the transcript to leave a comment.