RHAP: We Know Survivor - Survivor 50 Mid-Season Mailbag

Episode Date: April 21, 2026

Survivor 50 Mid-Season Mailbag Survivor is deep into its milestone 50th season, and Rob Cesternino teams up with Brandon Donlon for a special Midseason Mailbag episode that brings fans right into the action. The hosts get candid about the emotional highs and game-shaking twists following the double Tribal Council, including who might have survived if the vote order was different and how the season’s big risks are paying off—or missing the mark. With a tidal wave of mailbag questions on everything from alliance dynamics to possibly controversial twists, Rob and Brandon break down how the double duos twist changed the game’s course and why certain Survivor legends like Coach and Chrissy faced tough exits. The discussion digs into the difference between new era and old-school players, touching on trust, reputation, and what might have happened if familiar faces like Jesse, Carolyn, or Earl returned. The pair also question how winners fit into the fabric of season 50, and whether Rizo’s social game can earn him legendary status beside Cirie. Game strategy is at the forefront as they weigh Jonathan’s mentorship from Boston Rob, the ongoing Rizo vs. Cirie question, and the evolving jury dynamics shaped by twists like the Billie Eilish boomerang idol and the polarizing blood moon. Plus, the duo imagines future seasons: should all-returnee casts have 24 players, or is Survivor ready for another evolution in format? – Reactions to the double duos twist and who would have survived different vote scenarios – The impact of tribe composition and returning winners on season 50’s dynamics – Debate over the luckiest player since the blood moon twist – How Rick Devens stirs chaos at Tribal Council – If Rizo can reach “legend” status by helping—or betraying—Cirie With alliances shifting and twists still turning, the episode leaves burning questions on the table: can Rizo find his place among Survivor’s greats, and will the current cast’s big swings become blueprints for future seasons? Tune in to see how the fans’ voices—and the game’s biggest moves—are shaping the fate of Survivor 50. Chapters: 0:00 Welcome and Midseason Mailbag Intro 1:00 Double Tribal Twist Reactions 3:05 Fan Sentiment on Game Twists 6:04 Predicting Who Gets Voted Out First 7:14 Would Rob Survive on Season 50? 13:00 Should Season 50 Include Winners? 15:23 Jonathan’s Game and Boston Rob’s Mentorship 19:09 Rick Devens’ Tribal Council Showmanship 22:25 Joe’s Voting Dilemma This Season 25:44 Rizo: Best Back-to-Back Game? 28:38 Is Coach’s Downfall Due to Rizo? 34:15 Which Voted Out Player Is Missed Most? 36:07 Should Returnee Seasons Use 24 Players? 41:31 If Cirie Wins, Mount Rushmore Changes 43:34 Who’s Luckiest This Season? 46:21 Rizo’s Legacy: Loyal or Betrayer? 52:16 Best and Worst Season 50 Twists 58:11 How Survivor 50 Handled Ponderosa 59:27 Lessons for Survivor 51’s Production 1:01:11 Should Survivor Return to 39 Days? 1:06:56 More Returnee Seasons in the 50s? 1:14:56 Hopes and Fears for Survivor 51 To pre-order Rob’s book, The Tribe and I Have Spoken, visit www.robhasabook.com Never miss a minute of RHAP’s extensive Survivor coverage! LISTEN: Subscribe to the Survivor podcast feed WATCH:  Watch and subscribe to the podcast on YouTube SUPPORT:  Become a RHAP Patron for bonus content, access to Facebook and Discord groups plus more great perks!

One day, you're negotiating with suppliers. The next, you're installing a shelf in the back room. Running a business means moving in many directions all the time. TD's new small business banking accounts are built for how your business moves. It's how we're making banking more human. Hey, everybody, what's going on? Rob Sisternino, back for it's mid-season mailbag. I love the mailbag.

I love anything where we get to talk to the listeners, hear what they're thinking about, and weigh in about it. So these are some of my favorite podcast to do, and I am so excited to get to catch up with the man who's gone through all of your emails or mailbag submissions. It's Brandon Donnelly. Brandon, how are you? Who are you looking for? I was looking for who you were talking about. Who knows.

I'm excited to talk to? Should this have had a celebrity guest? Should we have had a celebrity guest come and do this? I think that maybe we could have a celebrity guest pop in, maybe like a Zach Brown type. A Nick Brown type. I would love that. That's a big get. I don't know who we get at this hour.

We're recording pretty early, but maybe people are up. Yeah, it's 8.41 a.m. as we are recording here on a Monday morning. Did you have the Sunday scleries last night before you were prepping for this podcast? A little bit. I mean, not to be behind the curtain, but if you work at this establishment, which you and I both do, I mean, it's your establishment. We don't, like, there's nothing going on in the morning. We don't have to do things this early in the morning. So seldom, I'm very spoiled it, seldom do I have to, like, get up and be ready for something.

The morning is typically when I have the most free time in the podcast day. And so I end up like, I really do enjoy the morning. But we're traveling, we're taking the show on the road to Toronto. So it's a busy Monday here today. So we're up early and Adam for our big mailbag. We're going to do Club Condo Monday night for the patrons, a special 420 ClubConn. though, should be a memorable one at that. So here we are.

It's a mid-season mailbag. A little past the mid-season, but big turning point in the season happened this week with the double tribal council. Did you weigh in, have you said anywhere whether you like the twist or not? No, I loved it. I had heard about it a week or two prior,

and I was a little bit nervous. I thought it was people would hate it. And I do think the same thing that everybody is saying is it's 100% results the pendant that we all liked it. I mean, I think about the last Big Brother season, which I don't have the details, super right, but Rachel goes in that big twist as the first dream member.

I'm sure if it knocked out somebody that everybody universally didn't like, we wouldn't think about it in the same way. Yeah, or was a net neutral. But this, I really enjoyed it, and I do think it could work in future seasons. I think people are now prepared for it, so maybe you save it for a little bit. But I liked it. I thought it was a lot of fun. So, all right.

Fun stuff. We got a lot of mailbag questions. Why don't we jump into it? By the way, was there one theme that you took away from reading the hundreds of questions that we got? No, a lot of people are very in on this double duos twist, which I think it was called, which I was surprised by. I think the Zach Brown reaction a few weeks ago was, I think the fans that this show is in the hands of have been so frustrated. the past couple seasons with not liking XYZ. And I think they were waiting to not like something, which I think to Zach Brown is everybody was like, it's like when you go on vacation with your partner,

who you were like annoyed at beforehand. You're like, you're waiting for them to mess something up. And then they do a little bit. They're like, oh, see, I got you. The first two weeks were so good, I think also. Was that Zach Brown the third week? I think fourth? Fourth?

Okay, yeah. It was, right? Was that the episode that Q went home or the episode that, yeah, I think it was the fourth episode. Yeah, I think so Q went home episode three And then it was the Mike White episode They lulled us into a sense of security We thought we were flying this whole time

And then they were eating And then they did, they ate fish Caught by Zach Brown famously But I do think that this was something That I think they took a risk And we've said these on previous mailbacks We're all in on risk The new era has been branded

It's about risk But there's not a ton of risk in the format And they tried something new And I loved it A couple of questions, which I want to start with this because I'm curious from your take. Chrissy gets voted out over coach. They let Chrissy go. They get coach the moment.

Do you have any interest in the other five pairs deciding who would have gone first? Who would have gotten the first vote out? How would they do that? But they'd like show, like, straw poll of like raise your hands if you want coach to get voted out first. Raise your hand if you want Chrissy to go first. I mean like Tiffany and Joe have immunity. But if they would have gotten voted out, who gets who gets snuffs before whom and not Tiffany and Joe? Oh, Christian and Jonathan.

Okay, so if we do Christian and Jonathan? Christian and Jonathan. I think that Jonathan goes first. And we're saying they just do it based off of like, who has the survivor resume? Sure. Who's the more iconic survivor? Is that what they base it on? I think Rick and Aubrey.

I think that's an easy. Can I say one thing about the Chrissy versus coach of who got the torch stuff first? From what I understand, and this was reported. I think it was in, maybe it was Dalton Ross, it might have been Tyson that coach said that Joe would not write coach's name down, that he, that he only wrote down Chrissy. So maybe did Chrissy get one more vote than, then coach did? And they just, they made Joe go back, allegedly, and write down coach's name.

Was it just that Chrissy really did get more votes than coach did? They were like, you know what, fine. Joe, you win. Yeah, Joe, we'll make Chrissy go first. that is funny if they asked everyone. Does everybody have a strong feeling of who should go first? Okay. And then for the other pairs, I'll go through it.

I think Stephanie and Ozzy is a tough one. I think they'd probably make Stephanie go out first and Ozzy second. Emily and Risgod, I hate to say it, Emily. And I feel like I see a theme here. Ladies first. That's what they should have said. Ladies first, Chrissy, you go. Because they say, oh, we're being polite.

It's not a sexism thing. It's called chivalry, okay? We're being ladies first. Women and children first. You get voted. It's like the Titanic. And so I think that they probably have Emily go before Rizzo. Rick, you know what?

Rick and Aubrey, I feel like maybe they have Rick go first. That's Rick goes. I think that's the only one where Rick goes first. Rick goes first. And then was there, Tiffany and Joe, I think, I think that they have Tiffany go first and then they do Joe's second. So it seems like a trend.

Unfortunate trend, but it's polite. You're right. It's polite. It's what you prefer. All right, we've got plenty of questions. We asked for questions on TikTok and YouTube as well as Instagram. And we got, you know, over 100.

So, you know, we're flying. But we'll start with friend of the podcast, Betsy Borsed. Betsy says, seeing how the season is gone and the strategies that players have come in with, how do you think you would have done if you were on season 5th?

I have thought about this a little bit. And when I looked at the cast, I had more reservations where that, you know, in the doctor strange of it all, that maybe in the multiverse, there's a world where instead of going on the traders, I go to Survivor 50. It's, there was a non-zero chance.

It could have happened. I think that when I saw the cast, And I thought about it. I'm like, wow, I am the song of ice and fire. You know, I am the person I am from the old school, but I know the new school. Like, I'm the only person I have a connection to every single person that's played this game. And I'm going to be basically, you know, really set up well, based off of how I see the perception of the Christians and the Ricks and Emmys and where they're sort of like thought of like, ooh, the schemers. these people, the middle, I kind of feel like that I might have just been painted with that brush where I think that it would have been, stop me if you heard this one before,

a little bit of my reputation preceding me. And I think it's not necessarily a fair reputation because I think that I'm nothing but a loyal person. I mean that there are so many different places in my life that I could point to. where I just out of loyalty and obligation, I'm doing things. So I'm not somebody who's just like cutting people willy-nilly. Do you think you would have been more embraced by a particular side of the newer a versus old era?

Do you think one side would have tried to grab me more than the other? I think that they would have received me well. I think that there might have been people from the new era that were open to working with me, but I kind of feel like that I would be a little bit, like people like giving me the side eye, like Q, who's my favorite? But I think it would be like, hey, keep an eye on him.

We can't trust him. He knows too many people. It's interesting that the old era side, they really brought back like a very, you know, maybe sans serri. and I would even include Ozzy in this, they brought back a very similar type of survivor player which you are not that.

Like I think the older, there wasn't a you representation in that. And then once you get to your 30s, you get your Rick and Christian. But that first half is there's no you there. Yeah. So, yeah, I think it would have been fun. I really thought that in the casting process

when I was talking to them, I was like, okay, maybe they're looking for like somebody from the old school who's really going to be able to like keep up with the new pace of the game. But I think that that's probably overstated. I really say it's not that complicated. Even Colby was like, all right, we're doing this, we're doing this.

Yeah. Nobody's like in over their head. No, people, you know, acclimated quickly. And you would be teaching people also. I think they would try not to be teaching people. Think that'd be a mistake. I mean, they'd be asking. You know, it was one thing of like, you know, on the traders,

like, hey, Tara Lipinski, like, hey, you know what? Sometimes when you go for the shield, they're going to, like, I think that there was a role there, but I don't think that that would have been such a smart idea on some of Marlop 50. I'm excited to see how the rest of the older folks, how they keep going. It's crazy we have older, you know, it does feel like, you know, now this is the second legend probably we've seen voted off. Is that fair after Colby and now coach? You know, we have a couple of them.

And it does feel like such a bigger thing where I do wish there was more of that tier that came out. But I don't know. You know, I said to Colby when we did the exit interview that I was like, hey, Colby, congratulations. This is before we turned the call on. He's like, I don't know. I didn't do that great. I'm like, hey, you went out there. You didn't look like an idiot.

And you got a great send off. Like this was in like the highest percentage of outcomes. Yeah. Maybe you could have won the show or been the you should have won guy. But after that, you know what? I really, I don't know if I told you this, that like, I really felt like that my dream for Survivor 50 was, I go out there and I, and I, like, I make a couple moves and then I get medevaced.

And then I'm just like, go off into the sunset. I would have been like, oh, he could have won. He could have won. Yeah. Universal approval. He could have won. Yeah. People are clamoring for your return.

Yeah. There's not a bad, you know, the 24-person cast, it does, like, Penner, Heroes versus, fans versus favorites. Like, all right, good luck. Good luck, everybody. And then he comes back. Good than me.

Yeah. I think the 24-person group really lends itself well to, like, the jury phase of the game not mattering as much. I think, like, the Australian Survivor seasons do this well, where they bring people back for the All-Star season, season five,

that went deep into the pre-jury, but not quite the jury. Just because it feels like a different, the traders feels like that also, where there's no, like, I got to make it by this point, you know, which I get, you know, in a normal Survivor season, nobody wants to not make the merch.

You want a moment. You want a moment. You want a moment. Get on screen. You get on screen. So I think I would have taken the Kyle edit. Maybe like get like a couple, maybe make it to the swap and be Kyle. Yeah.

And, you know, everybody wants Kyle back. Yeah. And we have a question about Kyle that I will read here. Her Majesty Velvet wants to know. Yes, your highness. Do you, praise B. Do you think there should have been winners on Survivor 50? Who would you prefer in the spots of D, Kyle, and Savannah?

So I think that's easy. Jesse and Carolyn bring them back. I think that the more interesting thing is that they started with no winners, and they weren't going to bring back anybody from season 40. But then it seems like at some point they made the pivot of like, oh, what if we, but what if we did have winners? And then they ended up with D and Kyle and ultimately Savannah. and Marianne was in the mix.

But in talking to Jeremy Collins, he also said that he was in the mix. And he would have been maybe the one person from season 40 who ultimately was here. I wonder if maybe instead of like there's three winners and they're all people from the new era, I think that maybe what if they ended up opening it up and then go back to,

what if we had a couple of winners from the old era that we didn't end up bringing back for season 40. And I think that they would have eaten with Earl. I think everybody would have been so excited to bring Earl back. I know that they went pretty far down the road with Sean, but I know Vesepia had wanted to come back. But what if you maybe had four winners, two from the old era,

two people who have never played, like winners in their second chance from the old era? I think that maybe instead of no winners, you could have found a couple of winners who you didn't bring back. Yeah, the original king of Fiji. Would have been a great place to have him come back. And based off of the reaction to the challenge, people would have been psyched if Chris Underwood came back in this season.

I know you have a couple of people from the edge, but I think people would have been pretty pumped up for Chris Underwood. Yeah, I think that, you know, I would have been pumped up for Chris Underwood on Winters of War. I was a listen, I'm ready to see him, you know, and he's really good at these. these games. He's like really, really good. So why not have them back out? And you know, based off of like a couple days, listen, the theme was not on trial.

He came back and really was like pretty fired up. Yeah. It's an interesting point there. Abby Barnett wants to know. What specifically do you see Jonathan implementing that comes from Boston

Rob's mentorship? Yeah. Do you think Rob would have made a similar alliance in this spot? So this is interesting to just think about Boston Rob as a mentor for Jonathan because typically they're not really similar type players in terms of how they're acting. Hey, Jonathan, you know, let me give you a midseason, midseason report card on how you're doing. Because Rob doesn't ever play from the.

middle. And I feel like that Jonathan, he's so big and so large in stature, but I feel like his game is a little bit trying to not be seen as the leader. And for Rob, I'd rather die than not be the leader, okay? I'm leader. I'm in charge of this thing. Whereas I think that Jonathan's game has been much more of like, hey, I like having coach out as the leader, and I'm going to sort of just be like a good soldier who's sort of trying to manipulate things a little bit more from the sidelines, and people don't realize what I'm doing. And so that to me is interesting. Based off of some of the advice that Rob gave to Jonathan, he seemed to have, like, really

give him advice of like, hey, don't look unhappy. don't look like you're pouting. And hard to say, because I don't think we really see that in the downtime. I think that that's probably where that stuff manifests itself. I think it's going to be interesting for Jonathan here. We'll see how this shakes out after. We saw the last moments of the episode, Jonathan pointing back at Rick Devon saying,

hey, you're showing your true colors too. and so there is a world where Jonathan now has to play from the bottom. I think he did a good job playing from the bottom the last time that he was in this position in this season after the Charlie Blindside, where he kind of went back to D. And I think that maybe that's a good spot for him if he continues to sort of, it like forces him into the humble Jonathan of like trying to be, you know, hey, whatever you say, I think that people like him when he's doing that. I think that when he is in a position of power, which is sort of like the opposite of where Rob wants to be, I think when

he's looked at as the person who is in charge and running things, I think that combined with his stature, I think makes him a little bit more of a person that people really rally against. Not that we've seen that really in his survivor tenure. I mean, he went to the final four in his first season, but I think he's easier to look at as he's big, he's in charge, he's running things, and I think that in a way, he really needs to be playing from the bottom, but people not thinking that,

or him to actually not be on the bottom, to people feel like he's at the bottom? Does that make sense? Absolutely. what do you think of that that true colors comment from him because Rick Devons that is prompted by Rick Devin saying like you can see where the alliances are in this group and then Jonathan says you're showing you true pros I couldn't get how we had that leap from by the way nobody gets people more annoyed at tribal council than Rick Devons when we go back and look through his career like Rick Rick Devin's like see this is what I'm talking about I'd be like shut up Rick and And why do you think that is? What is it the showmanship about it? About him?

I think that he really uses tribal council to be able to like, force the narrative of what he's trying to like, see, I told you all these people are they're doing it. And he was doing that during this tribal council. He wants to use tribal council to expose alliances. Which is interesting. And we just had John and Ali on the podcast. and these have challenges that would expose the alliances. But I think Rick, in these live tribal councils, he likes to set them off.

He thrives in chaos, Rick Devons. And then he likes to point to the live tribal council as, see, this is, look at, look at these people. Like, it's clear they have an alliance over there. See everybody? And so it's interesting, right? There's not a lot of people who do that. But he did get that rise out of Jonathan and, I think that Rick is trying to use that

to sort of like damn this alliance and sort of say like, hey, it's clear. These people have revealed themselves. They have an alliance. But I think Jonathan's like, yeah, and we know who your alliance is too. I think that that's what Jonathan is trying to say there. You got advice from Boston Rob,

pre-traders. You didn't follow necessarily, but you interpret it as, you know, for your own situation, you kind of, you know, filtered it through what would work for you. Do you see Jonathan following advice that you think he also got similar advice? So, you know, in the same way, that's a good question. In the same way that Rob gave me advice, that was not what he would do.

I think it's a, maybe I'm being a little, you know, over simplifying things to say that Rob's advice for Jonathan was to play like Rob, because the advice that Rob gave to me for the traders was, hey, Sustanino, don't talk to anybody. Shut up. Just talking, just be funny in the confessional. That's it. And look, that was good advice, but it wasn't what I wanted to do. You know, I wanted to, I wanted to go and I wanted to play.

I didn't want to just be, do nothing. And for Jonathan, I think that his advice was a little bit more of, think about the game in the big picture. And I think that Jonathan is following that. And I think that we'll see if Jonathan can make the adjustment. This is the second time this season that Jonathan is on the wrong side of the vote. And so we'll see if Jonathan can, again, make a pivot and figure out a new plan instead of just like barking and being hot with Rick Devons back at camp. If he can figure out a way to maybe turn this back around on Rick.

and by proxy Christian and Emily I saw a meme on Twitter of every vote that Joe has done all season and he's holding up each vote and the caption is something to the degree of like Joe did not want to vote for any of these people that any of the five times he went to travel council and yet he votes for them every single time

where do you go for how do you course correct from that do you think at this moment I think that that in itself is a course correction because I think that in survival 48, I don't know if Joe would make any votes that he didn't feel like making. So I think that Joe is an interesting position. I've been excited for Joe all through this season where I like Joe as being the person who is having to do things against his will as opposed for Joe dictating the will of the

season like he did in Survivor 48. I want him to fight more with Rick Davins. Remember when he fought with Rick Davins? Yeah. Remember how fun that one? He was annoyed with Rick Devinz at the live travel council. Everybody's annoyed with Rick Devon. I'm not.

I love Rick Davins. You either. Will wants it. Rick Devons that is Rorschach tests. You know, there's only two types of people in this world. People that love Rick Devons and people that are just so irritated with Rick Devinz. That's it. That's what Jeff says about coach.

Yeah, that's the litmus test for his. It's true about Rick Devins also. But what side is the survivor fans on? The Survivor fans love Rick Devin's or not like Rick Dobs? I think they love Rick Devin's. If you're following the same coach test. Yeah. I feel like that for the most part,

and I don't want to say that this is all people, it feels like that the survivors themselves tend to get more annoyed with Rick Devin's. Whereas out in the world, I don't know if there's a lot of anti- Rick Devin's people who are just annoyed with him for existing. and you know what Rick Devon's got some we know them

you're out there yeah Rick Devin's got a moment he's leaving season 50 with a moment pretty good good moment if that's the limit test for a successful season 50 run he got a moment and they had to do this at this point in time that

even though it was maybe not the most optimal moment to do it that they got something out of this idol that had been hidden at tribal council the whole season I do believe that they were not going home at this tribal council no matter what. It seems like that there is enough corroborating reports that Coach and Chrissy both said, it was 50-50, but for everybody else,

I think that there seems to be some implication that Coach and Chrissy were going home at this tribal council no matter what, and that the Rick and Aubrey Idol play certainly maybe changed a vote or two at the live tribal. but did not change the course of what was going to happen. And maybe not optimal in the moment, but we haven't seen the fallout from it. They can maybe course correct from there. So who knows?

Local news is in decline across Canada, and this is bad news for all of us. With less local news, noise, rumors, and misinformation fill the void. And it gets harder to separate truth from fiction. That's why CBC News is putting more journal, in more places across Canada. Reporting on the ground from where you live, telling the stories that matter to all of us.

Because local news is big news. Choose news, not noise. CBC News. Frozen lasagna, medium power, 15 minutes. Sounds like Ojo time. Let's play. Feel the fun with Play Ojo. The online casino with all the latest slot and live casino games.

What you win is yours to keep. With no wagering. requirements, instant payouts, and no minimum withdraws. Hey, I just won. Woohoo! Feel the fun Play, oh Joe. Honey, forget about the lasagna. Let's celebrate! 19 plus Ontario only, please play responsibly. Concerned about your gambling or that of

someone close to you, call 1-86-531-2600 or visit conexontario.ca. The ride that steals the spotlight every time it hits the road? That's the Volkswagen TIG one. Its sleek exterior makes a first impression you can't ignore. Step inside to find available full leather seats and wood accents. Under those hood, the available 201 turbocharged horsepower engine gives it a fun to drive edge.

The refined Tiguan, you deserve more style. Visit vw.ca to learn more. SUVW, German engineered for all. Will wants to know, is Rizzo playing the best game of any back-to-back player we've ever seen? So it's a great question. It's a great question. We have to see ultimately how it ends. Who would we say has played the best back-to-back?

game. Would we say it's Russell? Russell or Amanda, right? Oh, Amanda is interesting. The only two that you can make the case for. Yeah. Rupert is there. Might not be him. I mean, don't tell him. Don't tell him. Don't tell him. Did Amanda play better back to back in 15 and 16 where the one flaw with Amanda, the flaw, was just that she didn't end up getting the jury votes. in the Todd Final Tribal Council is legendary. I don't remember, other than the Natalie Bolton question, I don't remember any like particular points about Parvary's Final Trable Council in Micronesia. I remember, I remember some of the jury questions more so than I remember how they were answered.

I remember Ozzy also coming in and, really professing his love for Amanda, right? I saw a fan came the day of that moment. And you think that it's going to be, they show Ozzie making the speech and it's all dark and you think it's going to be Amanda. But then it's Shambo. It's an Aussie and Shambo, like, love thing.

I liked it. I have, we'll watch it on GlypCon. Yeah, so I think Amanda is interesting. I'm not sure that Rizzo would have won his final tribal council in his first season. And Amanda did play, you know, There are different facets to Amanda's game that Rizzo doesn't necessarily have,

like the ability to win challenges. Amanda was not a strategic slouch. So I'm going to say that Amanda does have the high bar. I think that's pretty good. What do you make of coach in the exit press saying that they were disadvantaged by Rizzo again? When he was disadvantaged by Russell, also, it was just an interesting, you know,

and I think he kind of, and forgive me if I'm misconstruing, this, but I think he puts the onus of that on, I think he said, what, Genevieve and Colby's really love Rizza, like, don't worry about Rizza, which is interesting that he was, you know, he says that. I love that guy. Yep. I'm sorry, Surrey has duped to Stephanie so many times, but it seems as a coach got duped again by the non-entity. Did coach or did Genevieve and Colby, and they told coach to trust him? It's true. No. Yeah, I guess so. I think that, I think Rizzo was not the problem for coach.

You know, maybe that was not what went wrong here. He wasn't one Riz God away from all of this. In the way that Russell was the undoing of the villains tribe in Heroes versus Villains, you know, that coach brought in Riz God into the four horsemen, but that was not the ultimate downfall of coach. Have you ever secretly given somebody a note, coach gave the note to Colby. Have you ever given a note to somebody inconspicuously?

Secretly given a note to anybody? I don't believe so. I can't think of a moment where I... Would it be fun to give a note? Would it be fun to give a note? The note is so permanent. I think maybe I'm so scarred from J.T. in Heroes versus Villains where when the note ends up then being found, have you given anybody a secret note? I think, I mean, you used to have had notes in class. I mean, you used to have notes in class, right? You were passing notes back then. Yeah. I think that's the only time that I've ever had to inconspicuously give a note. Just a little slide across the table, you know? And what did it say? Who knows? Nothing important. Try to give notes to people, but pass notes. How do they go? Not well. Not usually. Usually people are like,

uh, I, you know what? Don't appreciate the note. Like, okay. That's not what Colby said. Colby, I didn't. Colby probably appreciated the note, but then he got to Rizzo and he's like, oh, I love Rizzo. You know what? You said this with Andy. And good for Rizzo,

that he's, you know, that people were, he's back against the wall. People wanted him out and, and look at him now. That's exactly what I was going to say. Closing it on Amanda Kimmel for the best back-to-back returning.

He really, he really has something about him that everybody, like I think it's really a testament to him that not only has he captured everybody on the island. Yeah. But also off of it, the people who weren't in for 49

that was that small number, everybody's in on the Rizga. I said this the other day, but you don't listen to every podcast. I don't know that. Not you. I'm talking to the listener at home. But if you would have,

then maybe a year ago just wrote this down on paper, like there's going to be a guy. He's going to give himself, he's going to talk in the third person. He's going to give himself a nickname, which is Rizgat. He's going to,

refer to himself as the man, the myth, the legend. He's going to have like a, he's going to say this in confessional a lot. And then his vibe is like try hard superfan. And he's going to just talk about himself as one of the all-time greats, really from jump. And you would have said, people are going to hate this guy. This is going to be the most hated survivor contestant of all time. and he seems to have almost universal popularity. It's incredible.

It's really, it's something. It's something to behold, and I'm so, I'm so thrilled for him. I mean, he is so like... Yeah, it's just that he has like, like, just a sheer likeability. People really enjoy him, and so I'm thrilled for him.

I'm so thrilled, yeah, that's exactly, you know, I'm so thrilled to see, you know, somebody on Reddit, I think I read a comment that was like, it's like he wrote himself like into the fan fiction of what Survivor 50 is. It's like he dreams about it for every, you know, however long. And then he's just, he's there. He showed up.

Yeah. And he's, he has agency. I mean, he's not just there. He's a creative character. He's really. Yeah. That's very funny. That's very, very funny.

Yeah, he's living the dream. I'm so, I'm so thrilled for him. And I do think, like, if he gets to the end with, I think that the hardest thing for him is going to be the same thing with like, was it Nick and Michelle, um, when is it war of, the older folks don't want to vote for the young person. I've talked about this. And that was my take originally,

but I think that that might have been a little bit more, the case in second chances and in season 40, where in season 50, I'm not sure necessarily how many parents and older folk there are on this jury. When we take a look at, like, the cast, there's not a million parents that are on this jury. you have just from the people who are going to be on this 11 person jury and in the final three. Obviously, Ceree's a parent, coach is a parent, Christy's a parent.

And I'm trying to think of Christian is a new parent. Rick Devons is a parent. But it's not like that 11 of the 13 are people that were. It was only, you know, Michelle and Nick and Wendell and Sophie were like the only people that were like, in that Winners at War pool, and maybe I'm forgetting like one other person who were the only people who were not there doing it for a family.

I do wonder, though, I think maybe I am assigning parent to just the older folks that I think may not want to vote for the young, young person. And I do wonder if his path to winning is bringing the older folks, like eliminating as many older folks

as you can on the jury from that side. Your Stephanie's, your Joe's, your Jonathan's, and then bring, I guess Jonathan's not an older person, but he's affiliated with that. I think Chrissy and Coach are not going to be Rizzo voters under, just going back to where, when Chrissy pulled Jonathan aside and said about Camilla and Tiffany and D, and she said to Jonathan, they're not voting for you.

You know, I kind of feel like I want to pull Rizzo aside. They're like, yeah, Coach and Chrissy, they're not voting for you. It's not happening. Who do you miss the most that has already been voted out? Who do you wish that we could have seen do this where we are right? now. Well, you know I love Q. So I almost feel like it's not fair to say Q. And I think Jenna Lewis would have been pretty dug in in terms of what she's doing. I think you could imagine Savannah in this situation of like, hey, I got to win the challenge. Like I kind of feel like I could see her sort of like being

with Tiffany. Maybe she's sort of like not connected to as many things. I think that Charlie would have been fun as a mischief maker. Certainly, we miss Mike White and what he could have brought to the season. Who else? Who am I missing? Well, you know what? I'll say Camilla. I'll say it was Camilla because I really felt like that Camilla was that it was a tease.

I thought that Camilla had a chance to play in season 50. The game that she could have been playing in Survivor 48, where she's a swing vote. And I don't know if she would have been bouncing between the sides, but I think that maybe Rizzo ends up taking on that spot here along with Surrey and Ozzy.

But I think that Camilla just could have been that under the radar operator where it would have been fun to see what havoc she could have wrought in this season. And I would have loved to have seen her and Joe back together. I would have loved to have seen what happens with her and Joe. Yeah.

having to work together again. Them as a duo in that challenge would have been very fun. Mike Duval wants to know. Given the mostly positive response season 50s had so far, should all returning player seasons have 24 castaways from now on? 24 is a lot, right? We had to have a blood moon. We're chasing it the whole way through.

I don't know, 24 is a lot. It's just that we're sort of beholden to having the tribes, be divisible by certain round numbers. So I don't think that 24 is a good number for 26 days. Could we do it? Could we do

what if we did 21? I mean, it'd be a get to sort of like gender imbalance, but you know, like if there was sort of like some shrimpy guys, but more jacked gals, I don't know if that's I don't know if that's

politically correct term to shrimpy guys and jacked gals. But who says no? That's the theme of 51. You know, you end up with 21 players. How about that? I like it. I think this presents a unique thing in Survivor

that we haven't seen in a long time where they've now tried something new that they are like a format change, that they are going to now do something. Like we haven't seen since 40 to 41. you have 20 people to 18 people, and there's been 18 people, and now we're going to do 24 to say a different number. It's an interesting time for them to make a change

that they could potentially be sticking with. I mean, we have no proof that season 51 isn't 24 people. I guess we, like, that has... I'd be really surprised to be 24 people and new players, which very quietly, Survivor 51 is underway filming. We know almost nothing of what they're doing in Survivor 51. It's not been reported anywhere that I, I've seen.

So who knows what the, the Survivor 50s have very quietly kicked off. I guess the 50, they kicked off with season 50. But the, you know, I don't know what you would call this. If you had to guess. Most 50 era has kicked off quietly. The newer era. The newer era. Do you think at this hour we have three tribes or do we have two starting tribes for season

51? Man, I hope it's two. They're like, that would just be such good vibe. if they were like, hey, word on the street, Redmond is reported that it's two tribes for season 50. Would be a dream. I don't think it's a dream that we're going to, I think it's like Susan Boyle Street.

Manifested inside Survivor. Come on. I mean, it's going to be days. I'm surprised we don't already know because it has started, presumably. So it should be any day now, but really I hope it's too so bad. I don't think it's two, but I hope it's two. And if it's, if it's three, then I hope it's not red, yellow, and blue. I hope there's something different.

I don't care about the colors. I don't care about the colors. I care about the colors. It's been the same colors this whole time. You know what I mean? From 41 was randomly different colors, but 43 to 49 is just, is, is business as usual, you know? Throw something fun in there. Give me the best season with the worst merge buffs and tribe colors.

I don't care. Jack, this is a funny comment that somebody, Jack wanted to know what color do you think the Vatu buff was? To you, what color is that buff? Hmm. I think I'd need like a color chart to identify it. I think that, so I saw that was it magenta or fuchsia? I think it was magenta or let me search in our document here.

It was magenta or purple or? I wouldn't say it's purple. Oh, I would lean that's purple. No? No, it's more like a reddish purple. not quite cranberry. I love the cranberries. Fuchs is more pink, right?

So... Yeah, so they said, what's Batu's color? Pink, purple, or magenta? I guess magenta. Out of those options. Yeah. Yeah.

I need a box of crayola in front of me. With the sharpener. Let's find a different question. My name is not Maria. Okay. What's your name? If Surrey wins this season, do we have to officially change the survivor

Mount Rushmore? Who comes down? I think that we... We stopped the Mount Rushmore. I think Mount Rushmore is over if Surrey wins the season. I think it's like a Fab Five, and I think it's...

I don't know, who could you take out of the Mount Rushmore? I know people say, well, Boston Robb took him four times to win. He's the Babe Ruth of Survivor, and it doesn't matter, You know, oh, Babe Ruth played against the, you know, people that weren't full-time baseball players and that they, you know, it was just a bunch of whatever, like, like, white guys were around in 1920. Doesn't matter. You know, Babe Ruth is still the Bambino and you can't take Boston Rob out of that Rushmore.

You're not going to take Parvety out. You're not going to take Sandra out. Tony won twice. And you just have a Fab Five. That's it. Yeah, a fat five. I like that. I think a fat five is fine.

Yeah. And they all bring different things to it. I think that in Surrey, you have certainly like, you know, certainly like a different type of social game than Parvety has had. So it brings a lot to it. I don't think you kick somebody out of Mount Rushmore. I saw a clip that I believe Trojan shared on Instagram where he's quoting Sarah. Lascena. This is the other day. But Sarah Lascena said, I think, I guess I have a Boston Robb. It's like, if you, you know, you play four times, you win. If you get married four times,

are you good in marriage? Was Sarah Lassina's quote. Likening that to playing Survivor for, like, if you get to play four times, but I don't know if that's an equitable. I don't think that that's really the same comparison. I don't think that that the same. I didn't say. I mean, he played Survivor twice and got married. I mean, what does that say? It sounds like he's really good at some of those things. He's so good at Survivor that he got married. Not a lot of us can say that. Yeah.

So I don't think that your like survivor winning percentage is, you know, similar to, you know, the number of times you got married. I think it may be... That doesn't... In professional sports. So if you went on, you went on, like, one date and got married, like, again, I don't know, maybe you have the... You're the best...

picking dates. But nobody in football is penalized. If you play three seasons and you get to the Super Bowl once. With all due respect to Lascena, I don't think that that is really an apt, friends of the show, an apt comparison to compare. If you're interested in the clip, listeners, go on Troy Zand's Instagram. I think that's where I saw. I think it's a real like apples and donuts situation.

And I love both. could use either right now. Apple donut. That'll hit. My favorite. Sweet Rye Guy wants to know. Who has been the luckiest player this season? Who's benefited the most from all the twists and randomness?

I talked a lot about Genevieve as being the most unlucky of the players. But I guess who's benefited the most from the luck? Who's been having lucky breaks? let me just go back to the Blood Moon and just the configuration. Is it possible that it's the opposite side of the coin as Genevieve? Like, could it be Aubrey? Could I just talk that through here for a moment? Not to take anything away from Aubrey's skill.

Has she benefited the most from luck? She was the recipient of a Billy Elish boomerang idol when she looked to be somebody who was likely going to get voted out. She played on a tribe where in Vatu, either her or Angelina would have likely have been the person who got voted out, that by way of twists, that they didn't do any other double tribal councils. Though one time that she would have been vulnerable in the pre-merge, her tribe was the only tribe to not go to tribal council.

it was what Kalo and the, I think Nuvatu, which was the, you know, Christian Ozzie Emily group that went to tribal council. Again, she gets a very favorable draw in the blood moon where it ends up being maybe the one draw that would have taken out Genevieve. and then in the post-blood Moon, you know, she ends up being the, you know, tied to Rick Devons on the night that he's going to do his fake idol play shenanigans. And so I would not say that Aubrey has been incredibly lucky, but if we're looking for one person who's benefited the most from luck, I think Aubrey is a pretty good person to guess.

And tracks. And it balances out Genevieve's. such bad luck that a lot of that was tied to Aubrey also. Yeah. With luck, I really think about who did not go to tribal councils when they could have been voted off and was the recipient of things. So I'll say it was Aubrey,

but I don't want to take anything away from the game Aubrey's played so far, but if we're looking for one person, I don't think you're going to find somebody who's better than Aubrey. Yeah, I agree. William E. Docs wants to know, can Rizzo achieve his desired legend status

if he helps Surrey win the game? And what is his legacy if he betrays Surrey? To me, the legacy if he betrays Surrey is the much more interesting question of what does he become if his story arc this season is that he comes back, he works with Surrey, Surrey is on the precipice of potentially the survivor win that we as fans have watched for 20 years.

And we are on the stepping stones of that culmination and coronation. And here comes R-I-Z-G-O-D-R-G-G-God Baby with the rugpole at the final four to say, hey, it's got to be me. I told you. I'm here to win. I'm here to be the legend. And I think that that would be really interesting to watch how he is, that moment would be received. And then if he does not go on to win after that, where it's, hey, you did this.

I think it's one thing if he does that and wins. And I think it's another thing if he makes that move and doesn't win. And so that, I think that that would be a hard pill to swallow. I don't think that that is what will happen. I think that he is a useful ally for Surrey. I think that he ultimately works towards getting her closer to that goal. I think that his edit has been very positive. He's not getting this big villain edit in the season.

So I don't think that that's where we're headed with this. But that would be, I think, the most interesting scenario. If he ends up being a loyal ally of Surrey and then ultimately she wins the game, I think he's set up pretty well to come back and play for a third time in the next couple of years. I think that he continues to be very positively received.

I don't think that there's any... I think even now he's coming back for a third. I don't know if he can botch that at the rest of this. I think about in Winners of War, Denise takes out. Sandra at that one tribal council just for the moment of like taking out Sandra yeah it was a moment and then nothing ever had like the queenslayer the queens we don't reference the queen slayer no why it was there it was COVID it was a sad night

it's like the day the world shut down but nobody we don't like that's not it didn't leave the legacy I probably got voted out in that episode too she did that was yeah and I that was I think the March 12th or 13th that I'm remembering right maybe I could I think you're a little off I think it might have been the next week after that. Was it the next week? I remember the, I was flipping between that and the mass singer, but I won't bring that. Yeah, because we did the live show was scheduled March 11th of 2020.

And Boston Rob got voted out that night. And it was a weird night, I'll tell you. And then we were starting lockdown. And then I think that might have been the first Wednesday in lockdown. Oh, oh, so I'm sorry. And I'm forgetting. That March 11th show, that happened. That's still...

Oh, it happened? It happened. Lots of elbow bumps that night. We got to bring that back. People love that. People love the elbow bump. Stephen Fishback was the first to know. Like, a week before, he's like, I'm not going out.

I'm not coming. Yeah. He's like, uh, okay. He's still not. He's still not going on. He still isn't all the way back. I was like, we kind of need you. He's like, I'll out.

You figure it out. And we did. We're so back. Yeah. Sarah Desmond wants to know. This really made me laugh this question. Is Jeff saying Survivors ready, with an apostrophe in Survivors, or Survivors Ready, go?

Is the show ready, or is he getting the players in place? Like, get set. I don't even think I understand the question. So is Survivors ready? Like, is he asking, like, the production if they're ready? because I think they would do that off camera. Yeah, I mean, I've never once had the thought about it, but I want to extrapolate on it.

So is Survivors Ready, the way that it means that. Like, there's no debate that it means Survivor's ready. But Sarah Desmond is asking, is Jeff teeing up, is Survivor, like, is the show, like, if Phil Keogun were to say, the Amazing Race, like, is the Amazing Race ready, if that makes sense? Like, is the whole production ready? I think that's what Sarah doesn't.

I don't, I don't, that's how, I'm interpreting it. Is survivors ready the way that we all understand it to mean? Is there some other interpretation of survivors ready? Is Jeff saying survivors with an apostrophe? Survivors ready. That means like is survivor ready? Like is dinner ready?

Like is is survivor ready? I think is what Sarah Desmond means here. But it doesn't mean that Sarah Desmond. Like it's never meant that and it doesn't mean that. But I'm so curious. about how you, like, I've never had the thought that you, how you got there. And I really like that. Yeah.

So now when he says it, we should all think, hey, Survivor is, right. Are we ready? Let's do Survivor. We're not ready. We're not ready. Wasn't ready for that, Sarah, Desmond. Stephanie S3-062, what in the hands of the fans' twist has been the best and worst so far? So are we saying, like, just overall, as the, the whole, the, the, the, the, the, the,

season as a whole, what twists have worked or what things did people vote on have worked? I interpret this as what twists they put in have worked about. I'll just give you, I'll tell you what I think has worked in this season and we could decide whether or not the fans voted for any of these things that are working or not working. Obviously, the double duos twist, we felt like that. That worked. People like that seems like that almost universal feedback. Something else that I think has worked that I have. liked has been the return of Exile Island, sort of like a little bit snuck in there. It has not really been a Ballyhooed thing that fans voted on.

Do you want Exile Island or not? But I feel like that almost all of the Exile Island segments so far this season, I feel like have worked. I am much more pro Exile Island than pro journey in terms of being of a fun, part of the show when people get sent to exile island we like that it's you are kind of like you like it going to

exile island now. It used to be when they started exile island it's like you would cry I don't want to go to exile island. Sometimes you cry on exile island but now you go to exile island it's like woohoo vacation Yeah I can't get voted out. Yeah it can't get voted out

it's the only place where I'm safe is exile island I also I'm in Survivor and always have been in Survivor for the character development. I'm not strategy-minded or focused, and I think that it gives a lot more personal when you're there, and even in the early days of Exile Island, it was giving personal where...

And John and Alia said this also, is like the challenges, they used to kind of move the plot forward. Like, the interpersonal challenges would cause conflict when you got to camp, which I thought, like, that to me feels like such, like a miss to not be doing that all the time. And I think Exile Island, you know, whether you learn something about you or you learn something about, you know, you're only by yourself for 24 hours and you rethink the plan and you come back. Like Dan comes back and does Dan's funeral and Big Brother, you know, you work it.

I want more of that. Yeah. So that's been good. I'm trying to think what was bad. Nobody liked the Blood Moon. Nobody, but the Blood Moon could be tweaked. I like the essence of the Blood Moon. but I don't like the people

who left in the Blood Moon. Yeah, I think where the Blood Moon could have been better is maybe this is where the double duos twist ended up working. I think let them pick

what their groups of five are going into the Blood Moon. And I talked about having like a draft or something like that or you pick the order in which you want to join those teams.

But I think if the teams were a little more self-selected as opposed to randomly draw rocks out of the bag, I think that people would have hated the double duo's twist if it would have been

all right, everybody reach into the bag, and then here is your randomly assigned person, and then you're randomly assigned person you are going to be voted out of the game because you're attached to them. I think that people would have not liked that. No, and I think that lends itself to experiencing the Rachel Riley on Big Brother situation

where you lose people you really want. And not that there are people, like people love coach, people love Chrissy. I think that this just worked out. I think that the onus is also put on them for you guys picked this. You wanted to run it together. Right, right.

So what other twists have there been in the season? Like, Zach Brown wasn't a twist. And it wasn't something that was voted on. No, no, no. And if it was, we wouldn't have picked it. Billy Elish, I guess the idols, that was something. Yeah, I guess the Billy Elish, Boomerang Idol, I think, I like the idea of it, but I've said,

I think that Billy Elish, Boomerang Idol was a flop where it never got boomerang back, you had where Genevieve found idols, had none. So I think overall that Billy Elish boomerang idol did not work. Yeah, I think that's a dud. And I'd be curious to see that in a new player season if we want to run it back and try again with people who don't know each other. I think we're good. I think we're good. You're done. We're done. Billy Elish can.

And again, friend of the podcast, Billy Eilish. But her idol didn't do anything. Why would we bring it back? I think we try. I think we try one more time. We see if it, if it at. And I do think, doing it with new people, I think, is a little bit interesting of you're going off first impression and not anything outside of the game. I think that's maybe one. Maybe it's sort of like somebody goes on a journey and they, they don't get a immunity idol.

They get the Billy Elish boomerang idol. They could send an idol to somebody. Yeah. I think they really, they really, I don't want to use the phrase that I want to, they really, they really like. They really, like, wasted Ghost Island. You know what I mean? I was going to say it. If you guys want to skip ahead.

But I was going to say, like, blew their load. Like, I feel like, you know, yes. And I didn't want to be here. I didn't want to do what we're doing here. But Ghost Island, I think, was such a great thing that I wish we could do more. You know what I mean? Like, 51, 52, we just have the building. There was only one.

And it's like, oh, we forgot to pick it up. Like, it's just, it's here now. I think that's really. And that's great. Yeah. Yeah. Shout out to that guy from Arrest of Development. Mm-hmm.

Tobias? I have more questions. You want to do more questions? He blew himself? Yeah, that's where I was. I had a plan for where we were going, as this is all planned out meticulously. Somebody asked, Rach P. Rage P.

R. P. H. P. C. C. I don't know what that. It's spelled R-A-C-O-C-K. You know, that's how I'm breaking it up.

Like, Stephen did in that challenge with the phone number. Can you please explain the Ponderosa set up this season? Are there two groups pre-jury Ponderosa and post-Jory Ponderosa? I can answer that. There are. And then I think the pre-jury was at where the jury goes and then they moved them. So they all stayed in Fiji the whole time.

Yeah. Other than that, I can't explain it much more. I think that they were concerned that people were going to go back and be on social media. This has happened before in All-Star seasons. I think that famously in Survivor's Second Chance, I think Vetus came back and left early from Ponderosa and then was on Facebook or something like that. And people knew that he was back early.

And so they broke up the Ponderance, with the hope that if we keep them segregated and keep them in Fiji the whole time, then they'll all come back and then no one will know who got out early. That was the plan. That was the hope. That was the hope of life.

Got to keep hope alive. Even when it's not making sense. Michael Horn wants to know, season 51 filming now, are there any lessons from season 50 that you think Jeff and the production will take with them to 51, which is about to start filming? Hard to say what lessons that they have taken away

or not taken away. I think that a lot of them probably have to do with the returning player seasons. Can you think of anything that is a lesson, you would say, that they took away from Survivor 50? I do think that. And I think that I've talked before about like the traitorsification of Survivor, where the traders, it's on for eight weeks a year, and it really feels like an event. Where I think Survivor somehow along the way, it's twice a year. a lot of the shows that were twice a year

Dancing with the Stars, The Amazing Race, a lot of them have now diminished to one a year. The Mask Singer is now one a year also. And I think that Survivor has a little bit lost where it's a constant, and we all love that it's a constant, has lost the eventness of it, where season 50 feels like an event.

You know, we have the marketing collateral and then everybody's on, you know, Jimmy Fallon and we're, Gayle King is talking to whoever the day after they can put it out. I think that's really special. And I don't know how you do that twice a year without making them feel unique from one another. And I hope that this is the case where 51 and 52 do feel like different things

where you can get excited about something that isn't bringing your people back. Yeah. Where it's always going to be exciting to bring everybody back. But if you can make when you're doing business as usual feel great, then I think that's a win. That's interesting. And the business of usual, I think that there is like a real business to the survivor machine of it is something that's a staple on the CBS schedule. as it has been for 25 years.

They really program around it, really anchors the Wednesday night. But what do you think about? What if instead of a, you know, we do two 26-day seasons of Survivor, one in the spring and one in the fall, if we, Survivor announced that, and to my knowledge, this is not what they did, but if Survivor 51 was going to be 24 players, 39 days, and, and, to my knowledge, one survivor a year. What do you think? Are you in on that?

I got goosebumps. I'm in. I think we should do that. I think we're at the point now. Let's do it. Let's do it. Why not do it? Let's do it.

I think you're seeing such an engagement, and this is just my own TikTok. Like, my algorithm is very much this because we're all here, but there are people organically talking about survivor that otherwise are not. It really, really feels, special in a way that

this is my favorite thing in the world, but it hasn't felt like this in quite a long time. So let's preserve it and let's do one. Let's do one and make it really good. One really big Survivor season a year. How many episodes would it be? Was it still only 13 episodes? Maybe you do a couple more weeks. It's weird now where is it fitting in the schedule? Are we still

bound by spring or fall? The big super survivor season, do you think that Survivor is more Like, there's more juice in Survivor in the fall or the spring? I want, and again, it doesn't matter. Like, anybody can switch at any given time. But either the Traders is spring, maybe you do it in the fall. And then you have Big Brother in the summer.

Like, maybe that, you know. I think that if you were going to do it once, okay? And I wonder, and you have Big Brother in the summer. So you probably wouldn't do it there, even though the original Survivor, DNA was a summer show. I think that it's maybe the February slot and do it February to May. And I think that sort of like it culminates with the end of the summer or the end of the spring and May sweeps. Because if you're CBS and who knows, you know, where the network rights change, you have football in the fall.

You have a lot of stuff, even though they don't have any primetime football on CBS. like I think you kind of have you have that to kind of really hang your hat on but I think that in the spring you don't really have as well I think they do have you know March Madness but other than that Survivor could be like a really

you know if you had one super survivor season I think you probably would want it in the spring and have it there yeah yeah I mean I arbitrage and do it two hour block you know forget 90 minutes

you know, that we're going to do now these two-hour episodes. So you kind of get a little bit more of programming out of it with the third, you know, your longer season and the one big season of Survivor. Yeah, I mean, is this the Australian Survivor? I don't know how long Australian Survivor is, but they do something similar. Australian Survivor, I think, is 40 some odd days, maybe 40, maybe 48. Don't quote me on that. but I just think that there's two, like,

it feels so much in the lineup and in the ad slots that I think that nobody, like, I think the ratings would have to really go down for them to consider this. And I don't, I mean, this isn't a Big Brother podcast, but a Big Brother would do too smaller a year. Would anybody like, like, is, are people clamoring for that? Do people want that? I think Big Brother feels so, like, fun because it's the one time. Yeah, they even have shortened Big Brother

in these last couple seasons. Is it sure? Like, the season that Surrey played on was 100 days. And maybe that's what really has like a hardened Surrey for this was 100 days of Big Brother. Whereas now, I think those last couple

of Big Brother seasons have been in like 80-some odd days. They shortened it for about two weeks. Yeah, I wonder if, I mean, that's a different podcast. I wonder how much that makes a difference in the people who play, you know, the last two weeks of that. Like, it's like the last, you know, 13 days of... It's brutal. It's brutal. For everybody involved. But poor Taryn has to, like,

those two weeks when, like, days after day 85, it's a lot. Yeah. Is it the last couple days of school where you're not really learning, but you still have, like, the formality of the, you have to go to last, you know, June 13 to whatever. We're still here. It's not over yet. Nothing happens. They played, they, they, they stacked blocks today. And why were they doing that? Is that a challenge? No, just for fun. For fun.

They didn't have nothing to do. They give them like a deck of cards at like that point in time. It's like, it's like inhumane for everybody involved. Yeah. Really, really bad. Yeah. You want to do one more question? Sure.

Given the exuberance, this is from and, and Tang is a lot of letters. And I don't think it's any, I don't think it's anything. Give them a new name. Give them a new nickname. Be coach. Give them a nickname. name. Oh, I don't know. I'm trying to do like a coach nickname generator. The wind, the wind hammer. The wind hammer, right? Yeah. I think that's a restaurant in Summers Point, New Jersey.

Sounds delicious. The wind hammer said, that's the wind jammer. Given the exuberance the survivor community has had for this season, should we expect a higher frequency of returning seasons in the Survivor 50s? I have to think so. And in the 50s of the years. It's just the easiest thing that they could do to get everybody excited. There's more media coverage that the fans are excited. There's more energy going into the season. Other than the fact that I think that when Jeff took over the casting in Survivor 38, and this is something that I do talk about in my brand new book,

The Tribe and I have spoken, available everywhere on May 5th, pre-order at robinsabook.com. We have a great incentive for people who pre-order that we have the ultimate rights of passage for everybody. We talked about every single one of survivors, 751 players in the pre-order bonus, robinsetbook.com. But thank you for that. But so Jeff takes over the casting in season 38 after Lynn is let go by Survivor. And I think that they got so excited by, hey, we're going to put our stamp on the people that are coming into Survivor, and they didn't really get the chance to do that with 39 and ultimately 40. And it was like, hey, we've got the new era casting machine going.

And they were like, oh, we're finding all these great people and we're telling all these diverse stories and this is great, great, great, great, great, great, great, great. And I think that they didn't want to stop of that they, like, oh, we've got so many people. We've got to get them all in. And we're finding all these people. They love Survivor. We've got to get them on the show. And I think that they were so in love with that,

that I think that that prevented them from doing the returning player season. And then there was even like, well, I don't know, maybe the old era is over. Maybe we're never going to bring back anybody from the old era. And they got close enough to 50. We're like, okay, 50 will just be the returny season. So I think they just totally got away from that. But I have to think after the response to 50 and seeing everybody come back, Like, I really do think we're going to have more returny seasons.

Let me ask you this question, okay? Between Survivor 50 and Survivor 60, so nine seasons, 51 through 59, how many of those seasons will have returning players? Clip this for five years from now. I think. Wow, how cool will it be five years from now? Shout out to everybody in the year, 2013. Oh, God forbid. I hope we're still doing this.

I think you'd have to hope. Australian Survivor had the right idea. I think Brandon's hair will be in 2031. It's too long. I couldn't get in to get my haircut before Toronto. So everybody who goes, you're watching this Monday night. You'll see this on Tuesday morning whenever I see you. Australia's right idea.

Prayers up to Brandon's hairline for 2031 also. This isn't going anywhere. This is like, Jack. You're staying until... You're locked in. You're calling your shot. I'm locked in. Okay.

This isn't going anywhere. I would be so sad. You do four and then you do a returning season. Let's get us to 55 and then let's do 60. Is you have 51, 52, 53, 54. New people are 55. So you think just one returning player season between 51 and 59? I, yes, but I also think let's throw some people in the other ones.

We had talked about this in the mailbag. Mix it up. For the season. The question is number of seasons between 51 and 59 that will have returning players. Give me three final answer. Okay. I'll take the over. I think that we have, I'm tempted to say five, I'll say four.

Four times between 51. Five feels high. I wonder if it is. Even four feels high. Yeah. I think that maybe we do at least one all returnies between 51. and 59. And I wonder if we do a couple

captains. Captains? Again, I love the idea. You know, four people come back or a tribe of returnees. We had said this in the last mailbag is I hope we get less rigid with who can cut,

like just bring, you know, you see two people you want to bring back and just bring it back. They don't even have to be captains. Like, it doesn't have to be anything. The way that I think we cited this is Australian Survivor does this super well where it's just whoever,

It's like Willie Wonka's golden ticket. It's like, you're here too for whatever. Yeah. Like let's like just come up with like two, you know, random. Like we're going to bring back Say and Jolensky in a season. Like are they going to have like this huge unfair advantage over the 16 other new players? No. And they like the captain's seasons of your is they come in on a separate boat.

Don't even put them on the separate boat. They're in the same, but they do the same pregame. They're in the same. everybody else. They're just playing again. Yeah. Why not? It's like what Bruce did for 45 is he didn't, you know, he didn't come in on a helicopter. Although we would have loved it.

He, I think that that's the way to do it is just throw a couple people in when you see fit. Yeah. I think it makes it fun. Whatever. Just bring them, just like, well, let's have fun. Let's have fun. And Jolensky on season 51 or 52, he could be there.

I haven't heard from him. Have you talked to him in the last three days? I don't talk to Jolinsky as regularly as I would like. Sure. He's a couple times in a way, and it is 9-25 in the morning. I would call him. He has not texted me, but he could be there. We don't know.

I did go to the Super Mario Galaxy movie yesterday. Is this a connective thought to Jolensky? No, just in general. I'm talking about my schedule being a bear. How was it? You know, my kids enjoyed it. You have said previously... Three point five stars out of five.

I resisted the urge to listen to a podcast during the film. That's what I was going to say, is you will, you've said pop an AirPod it. Yeah, I will, I have done that in the past, did not do that for this one. But did go to a 9.40 a.m. showing. Oh my God. Really?

I love that. Yeah, they have that? There's a movie theater and they have very early. It's the best. I took my kids. Like we let Nicole, like, hey, let mom sleep in. Guys night or guys day. Hey, we're up.

We're up. We're going to the movie theater as we're going to a 940 showing out by 1130. And we basically, there was like maybe three other parents with children. Like almost everybody had their own row. a couple of empty rows like we rent out the theater for ourselves

can you get snacks at that hour sure they're making popcorn down paid $30 for two small popcorns

and two icys you got to do it anytime anytime you got you could really

for what is probably about nine cents of raw material pay $30 at the movie theater

you can't pass that up. Yeah. The movie theater has gone into a subscription model with your AMC and your regal, what have you. They really should make just like the Panera has the sip club

where you just pay $10 and you get a, you get unlimited drinks. The movies should do that too. Not that lemonade that killed people, right? They still have that? No, no, not the zapped lemonade to what they call it. You don't want that.

You don't want the zap lemonade. I can use one. I'm very tired. I can use one right now. Yeah. Shout out to Mike Chissel. Got a picture with him. He was really nice when I met.

Yeah. Anything else on your mind as we head into the home stretch of Survivor 50? No, I mean, I'm so excited to see what happens. I'm so excited to see Jimmy Fallon and your buddy, Mr. Beast. I'm excited to see what they're going to do. The Jimmy's. I really, really, the Jimmy's. I'm excited for season 51.

I can't wait to learn about what's season 51. And I think that that is, we had a clip that you said on this podcast that did very well last fall of like that's the most important season of this X amount of time. And I really do believe that. And I think that if it's 51 and if it's as business as usual, I feel like a lot of people will be bummed. So I hope they do. I hope they do something. Survivor 51 is truly in the Schrodinger's cat situation. It's like, you know, what's in Mr. Beast's box?

Is it something awesome or is it going to totally suck? And at this point in time, it's really like you could just keep refreshing social media. At some point, I think we'll know the gist of what Survivor 51 is going to be about. It's going to be so telling when that happens. It'll either be like, yes, or it'll be, oh, this is a very bad sign for the future of Survivor. And it's very tense. What do you think that? What's the feeling if you see that it's the same, the same thing?

Like what, like, I feel, and I have no ownership over this. Like, I, like, it is, you know, but I would feel so like, maybe not listen to is the wrong phrase, but I would feel so let down if that was the case. I think that the direction of Survivor would be a little bit more of like, hey, this is comfort food. this is just you know what you're getting, just tune back in. It's going to be the same survivor that we've been doing. You know what this is. I kind of like the idea of them taking

a bit of an ambitious swing here and going for the upside play that is going to keep Survivor really exciting going into the 50, but that could be a monkey's paw also. You know, they could do something that's so off the wall, you wish that they would have left it alone. No. I don't, I really, and clip this. I don't think there's anything that could be that

for me. Like, I, I, I, that is, that's, I'm telling, I'm giving myself a note. Yeah. Note to self. I think there's no, there's no thing that they could do that's new that I would be upset over.

I'm game for a new thing. I don't know what they would. Careful. Careful there. The Blood Moon was a new thing. You know, it could be, you just don't, don't break the game. Like, do whatever you want with the casting and the theme. That's fine.

That's fair game. Don't play with the votes. Don't play with the structure of how the game works. Keep that the same and play with the things that are. on the periphery, play with the people that are going to be in the show. Keep the game.

Yeah. Yeah. I agree with that. The game is fine. I think that it... Yeah. It's hard to unring the bell of the lost vote. Like, it's crazy to imagine a world where we're not journeys and losing boats and what have you. But I would

love to imagine the world where we ease up on that. And I think that, yeah, I mean, best moments of the show come from interpersonal. Really, and I've said this before, but the only moment from the new era that anybody constantly references that is broken

through is Liz with this Applebee's that has nothing to do with anybody's vote or the game or what happens. That's the moment. And I think that's a testament to, it's hard to make that happen again, but we can put people in positions where it could. Here's the thing about bigger

tribes. You have more people in a tribe, more opportunities for interpersonal conflict, and I think that at the end of the day, that's what drives the show. So let's try to find ways to keep that happening. Absolutely. Yeah. Okay. All right.

And I'll be here to see it. Brandon Donlin, what's next for you? Nothing. We have a meeting. You're going to Toronto. We're going to go to the meeting. We're going to Toronto. I went for the Rift, but we are going to be in Toronto for the next couple of days, and we'll see you there.

Listener, if you're there. Should we tell them to tell them to tell them to tell you? tell us something? What should the code word be? What was that? People are going to be telling you a lot of stuff. Yeah, what was that user's name? Oh, the windhammer? No, not that one. No, what user's name? That was the user's name that I made them a nickname.

Yeah, that's true. But there were earlier ones. What were you going for? Yeah. So, I'll just say hi. We'd love to hear from the listeners. and let us know what we could be, much like Survivor, we are always looking to improvise on the, maybe not like Survivor. We'll find that that's not like Survivor,

but we are always looking to try to make the format of the podcast more enjoyable to you. So let us know if you have any thoughts on that. We'd love to hear your comments. And of course, the book is on the way. We are just a couple of weeks away from the launch of the Tribe. And I have spoken.

I hope you're not tired of me. talking about it yet because this is just the one chance that I ever have to launch a book. And so if you haven't preordered yet, Rob has a book.com. I think you're going to, Brandon, you've checked out the ultimate rights of passage. Do you think that that is a worthy pre-order bonus? Oh, yeah, in a big way. I won't, I haven't seen my, I don't, I want to be surprised of my own situation. So I haven't scrolled that far in the document. But I've seen, I've seen, I've seen, a couple of the early ones and they're good. I mean, it's magical for, for,

for somebody like your boy who loves this so much, it really is, it's so, so fun. And I know a lot of people have asked, how do I get the pre-order per? I've pre-ordered the book. How do I get the bonus chapter, the digital bonus chapter? Go to Robbiz website.com slash pre-order perks,

and all of your questions will be answered there and you'll be able to sign up for the pre-order digital bonus chapter of The tribe and I have spoken. Thank you so much for joining us for the mailbag. Great job of putting it all together, Brandon. Take care of a good one. Bye.

I'm always looking for those tips and tricks to help optimize my life. Ways to save money, travel better, and make life a little easier. That's why I love all the hacks. The podcast hosted by Chris Hutchins, that's all about practical tips you can actually use. Every episode breaks down strategies around personal finance, productivity, travel rewards, career growth, all the stuff I wish I learned earlier. What I like is that it's not hype or gimmicks. It's real advice you can apply right away. And honestly, if you like optimizing anything in your life, this show is for you. So when you support podcasts like all the hacks, you're supporting

creators who are putting in the work to bring you useful, actionable content week after week. So if you want smarter systems for everyday life, check out all the hacks wherever you listen to podcast or head to chris Hutchins.com slash promo to learn more.