#RolandMartinUnfiltered - Deconstructing Trump's town hall lies; COVID Herd mentality? Charlamagne talks Black Effect Podcast
Episode Date: September 17, 20209.16.20 #RolandMartinUnfiltered: Roland deconstructs Trump's town hall lies; COVID Herd mentality? Crazy a$$ white man in London gets knocked out with one punch; New round of anti-Trump ads stings #45...; Charlamagne the God talks Black Effect Podcast Network; We remember jazz critic, Stanley CrouchSupport #RolandMartinUnfiltered via the Cash App ☛ https://cash.app/$rmunfiltered or via PayPal ☛https://www.paypal.me/rmartinunfiltered #RolandMartinUnfiltered Partners: 2020 Census In America, everyone counts. And the 2020 Census is how that great promise is kept. Respond today online, by phone or by mail and help inform hundreds of billions in funding for education, health programs, and more. Shape your future. Start here at www.2020census.gov. #RolandMartinUnfiltered Partner: Ceek Whether you’re a music enthusiast or an ultra-base lover. CEEK’s newly released headphones hear sound above, below and from multiple directions unlike traditional headphones where users only hear sound from left and right speakers. Be the first to own the world's first 4D, 360 Audio Headphones and mobile VR Headset. Check it out on www.ceek.com and use the promo code RMVIP2020 #RolandMartinUnfiltered is a news reporting platform covered under Copyright Disclaimer Under Section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976, allowance is made for "fair use" for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research. Learn more about your ad-choices at https://www.iheartpodcastnetwork.comSee omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
Transcript
Discussion (0)
This is an iHeart Podcast. Taser Incorporated. I get right back there and it's bad.
Listen to Absolute Season 1, Taser Incorporated,
on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts.
I'm Clayton English.
I'm Greg Glott.
And this is Season 2 of the War on Drugs podcast. Last year, a lot of the problems of the drug war.
This year, a lot of the biggest names in music and sports.
This kind of starts that a little bit, man.
We met them at their homes.
We met them at the recording studios.
Stories matter and it brings a face to it.
It makes it real.
It really does.
It makes it real.
Listen to new episodes of the War on Drugs podcast season two on the iHeartRadio app,
Apple podcast, or wherever you get your podcast.
We asked parents who adopted teens to share their journey.
We just kind of knew from the beginning that we were family.
They showcased a sense of love that I never had before.
I mean, he's not only my parent, like, he's like my best friend.
At the end of the day, it's all been worth it. I wouldn't change a thing about our lives.
Learn about adopting a teen from foster care. Visit adoptuskids.org to learn more.
Brought to you by AdoptUSKids, the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, and the Ad Council. Today is Wednesday, September 16th, 2020.
Coming up on Roland Martin Unfiltered.
Oh, my Lord.
Last night was live Ocella, Lollapalooza.
It was just a lie fest.
Last night was not an ABC town hall.
It was an absolute lie fest.
It is perfect for our Trump Lies Matters segment.
We're going to break down all the lies.
I think the only thing that probably was truthful last night was when they mentioned his name.
Also, Donald Trump talked about a herd mentality.
I think he meant a herd immunity.
We have an infectious disease specialist
to explain what that means and why he's an idiot.
Charlamagne Tha God will join us for our Tech Talk segment
sponsored by Seek.com to talk about
his Black Effect podcast network in partnership with iHeartRadio. Also,
ooh, a crazy-ass white man in London got knocked the hell out, running up against three brothers.
Y'all didn't end well. One punch. Also, a new round of anti-Trump ads to show you. Plus, we remember jazz critic Stanley Couch who passed away.
And, folks, the mayor of Rochester bounces the black police chief
because they try to hide information about the death of the black mentally disturbed man.
We'll give you those details.
It is time to bring the funk on Rolling Rock Unfiltered.
Let's go.
He's got it. Whatever the mess, he's on it. give you those details. It is time to bring the funk on Rolling Rock Unfiltered. Let's go. From sports to news to politics With entertainment just for kicks He's rolling With Funko Roro, y'all
It's Rolling Martin
Rolling with Rolling now
He's funky, he's fresh, he's real
The best you know, he's fresh, he's real the best You know he's rolling, Martel
Martel
All right, all of you parents out there,
how many of y'all, how many of y'all
have had this look when your kids start talking?
This is the look that you make when you know your kids lying their ass off.
And they just keep lying.
And this is how you keep looking.
And in your mind, you're like, at some point, are these fools going to stop lying?
That's exactly how I looked last night for two hours at the ABC News Town Hall in Pennsylvania with Donald Trump.
Roll it.
Y'all, it took place at National Constitution Center in Philadelphia. 90-minute town hall special.
Uncommitted voters had the opportunity to ask Donald Trump their questions on issues ranging from coronavirus pandemic,
economic recovery, protests, and racial injustice.
Okay?
So that's what took place.
George Stephanopoulos was the moderator. I feel for man George Stephanopoulos because the lies were coming so fast and furious.
I thought Ving Rhames was going to walk in at any time.
I thought the whole cast, Tyrese, I thought everybody, Michelle Rodriguez.
I thought they all were going to walk in because I'm like, how much faster can these lies go?
Like, really?
Can they just keep going?
So let's just deconstruct all the lies.
Black woman with a preexisting health condition asked Donald Trump what are his plans to protect people like her.
Roll it.
Mr. President, I was born with a disease called sarcoidosis. And from the day I
was born, I was considered uninsurable. That disease started in my skin, moved to my eyes,
into my optic nerves, and when I went to graduate school, into my brain. When it hit my brain,
I was automatically eligible for disability for the rest of my life.
I chose instead to get a bachelor's degree, a master's degree, a PhD, and become a professor.
It's great. It is great, except I still have similar health care problems. It costs me,
with co-pays, I'm still paying almost $7,000 a year in addition to the copay.
And should pre-existing conditions, which Obamacare brought to fruition, be removed?
No.
Please stop and let me finish my question, sir.
Should that be removed within a 36 to 72- period without my medication I will be dead and
I want to know what it is that you're gonna do to assure that people like me
who work hard we do everything we're supposed to do can stay insured it's not
my fault that I was born with this disease it's not my fault that I'm a
black woman and in the medical community I'm minimized and not taken seriously.
I want to know what you are going to do about that.
So, first of all, I hope you are taken seriously.
I hope you are.
And we are not going to hurt anything having to do with pre-existing conditions.
We're not going to hurt pre-existing conditions.
And, in fact, just the opposite.
If you look at what they want to do, where they have socialized medicine,
they will get rid of preexisting conditions.
If they go into Medicare for All,
which is socialized medicine,
and you can forget about your doctors and your plans,
just like you could forget under President Obama.
He said, you can have your doctor, you can have your plan,
and that turned out to be a lie.
Obamacare is too expensive, the premiums are too high. It's a total disaster. You're going to have new health care and the pre-existing condition
aspect of it will always be in my plan. And I've said that loud and clear. But you haven't come up
with it. And we got rid of the individual mandate, which essentially ended Obamacare. Y'all, this fool actually said that Biden-Harris wants to end pre-existing conditions.
Y'all, that's the most important part of the Affordable Care Act that Joe Biden was a part of when he was Obama's vice president.
So how in the hell is the guy who helped create the bill now want to end the very thing that's
in the bill?
That's a damn lie.
That's a lie.
Donald Trump said, no, we don't want to get rid of that.
But right now, as George Stephanopoulos said, no, we don't want to get rid of that. But right now,
as George Stephanopoulos said, you're at the Supreme Court right now trying to completely get rid of the Affordable Care Act. That's what he said. That's what Donald Trump said, y'all.
It's unbelievable when you look at what this dude is doing, constantly trying to weaken protections of the Affordable Care Act, wants to get rid of it completely.
He did not essentially end Obamacare, as he stated.
The Affordable Care Act still exists.
It still exists.
Trump also suggested that Biden agreed to adopt what he calls socialized health care advocated by Senator Bernie Sanders.
No, he didn't.
He actually rejected that.
Roll it.
But when you say that Biden doesn't want to do it, everybody else does.
Bernie does.
He agreed to the manifesto, as I call it.
The agreement with Bernie is that you're going to go to socialized medicine. He agreed to the manifesto, as I call it, the agreement with Bernie, is that
you're going to go to socialized medicine. If you go to socialized medicine, well, he agreed.
Fact, Biden does endorse the public option to allow people to opt in to a Medicare-like
government insurance plan, but he has not agreed to anything, and he has spoken against Medicare for All, which Senator Bernie Sanders supports.
Biden and Sanders went at this to the Democratic primary.
So how in the world has he agreed to something that he was absolutely against?
That lie completely out the window. A man who voted for Donald Trump
and considers himself a conservative,
pro-life and diabetic,
asked Trump why did he
throw vulnerable people under
the bus. He felt Trump was doing a great
job at responding to the pandemic
until around May 1st. Again,
Donald Trump lies.
Supplied governors, including this state, with equipment like nobody's ever gotten.
We were short on ventilators because the cupboards were bare when we took it over.
And we're now making thousands of ventilators a month, many thousands.
And we're sending them.
We don't need them in our country anymore.
Not one person that needed a ventilator didn't get a ventilator.
Everybody got a ventilator.
And they're very, Paul, they're very complex.
They're very hard to make.
But we're making out tens of thousands a month and sending them to other countries who are in dire need of them.
So I feel that we've done a tremendous job, actually.
Donald Trump claimed that the cupboards were empty of ventilators when he took office is an absolute lie.
There were 16,000 ventilators available in the government stockpile when he took office.
A spokesperson for the Department of Health and Human Services confirmed in late June that there had been about 19,000 ventilators in the national stockpile for years.
16,660 of the ventilators were ready for immediate use
in March of 2020.
That, folks, was an absolute lie.
George Stephanopoulos asked Donald Trump
if he made the wrong decision
in praising the president of China early on during the coronavirus pandemic.
I don't think I did. We just finished a trade deal.
We just had the largest order of corn in the history of our country last week.
The largest order of soybeans, largest order of beef, because they know I'm very unhappy.
They know he said he was doing a good job.
And now you're blaming China.
No, I didn't say one way or the other.
I'm not saying one way or the other.
At the beginning, before anybody knew what it was, I spoke with President Xi.
And he said, we are doing it well.
We are having it under control.
And I was very open with that.
He told me that it was under control, that everything was.
And it turned out to be not true because it wasn't under control. It went all over the world, 188 countries.
So I didn't say anything bad about President Xi initially because nobody knew much about the
disease. Nobody knew much about the disease. That is a damn lie. His own intelligence told him about it.
Donald Trump repeatedly praised China's president.
CNN identified at least 37 separate instances since January where Donald Trump praised China.
Pull it up.
January 24th, China has been working very hard to contain the coronavirus.
The United States greatly appreciates their efforts and transparency.
It will all work out well, in particular on behalf of the American people.
I want to thank President Xi.
Really?
But you said you didn't praise him.
That looks like praise. John Bolton said the reason he didn't is because he was so desperate to complete the trade deal,
he did not want to criticize China.
Donald Trump lied again.
Here's the next lie.
A young black woman who never voted before asked Trump why did he downplay the virus.
And he said this.
Hi, my question is, if you believe it's the president's responsibility to protect America,
why would you downplay a pandemic that is known to disproportionately harm low-income families and minority communities?
Yeah, well, I didn't downplay it.
I actually, in many ways, I upplayed it in terms of action.
My action was very strong.
Because what I did was with China, I put a ban on.
With Europe, I put a ban on.
And we would have lost thousands of more people had I not put the ban on with Europe. I put a ban on and we would have lost thousands of more people had I
not put the ban on. So that was called action, not with the mouth, but in actual fact, we did a very,
very good job when we put that ban on. Whether you call it talent or luck, it was very important.
So we saved a lot of lives when we did that. Joe Biden was talking about in March about it's totally over-exaggerated.
So Donald Trump didn't downplay it?
Listen to this.
This is what, this is an ad from Midas Touch using the audio of Donald Trump talking to Bob Woodward of the Washington Post in his own words, downplaying coronavirus.
It goes through air. You just breathe it. That's how it's passed.
He knew it could cost him votes.
It's more deadly than your strenuous flus.
He knew it could cost him ratings.
Turning out it's not just old people, Bob.
Yeah, exactly.
Young people to plenty of young people. He knew it could cost him popularity. So Donald Trump hid the truth about COVID-19.
It's a little like the regular flu. If you're healthy, you'll be fine. Children handle it
very well. This is their new hoax. It's going to disappear. And cost more than 200,000 people their lives.
Be calm.
It's really working out.
I think we're doing a really good job.
He lied.
People died.
I wanted to always play it down.
I still like playing it down.
Plain and simple.
Midas Touch is responsible for the content of this advertisement. I wanted to always play it down. I still like playing it down. Plain and simple. Midas Touch is responsible for the content of this advertisement.
I wanted to always play it down. I am still playing it down.
His own words. He lied.
He also lied when he said he had a travel ban from China and Europe.
No, he didn't. He restricted travel. There was never an outright ban.
Both the restrictions made exemptions for travel from U.S.
citizens, permanent residents, many of their families, and some others. In addition, no evidence was found of Joe Biden saying that the pandemic was totally over-exaggerated. However,
Biden did say late February and early March that people should not panic about the virus was also noted by
Breitbart News that Biden said that the coronavirus is a serious public health challenge.
More lying. George Stephanopoulos asked Donald Trump, how does he respond to the people
who were in top military positions who said he's unfit for office. These are people that I let go.
These are disgruntled former employees,
to put it in a nice way,
a term people would understand.
Mattis was a highly overrated general,
didn't do the job, didn't do good on ISIS.
I took over 100% of the ISIS caliphate.
I had the people that I wanted in.
Mattis was fired, as you know, by President Obama,
and I fired him also. He says
he resigned. Trump didn't fire James Mattis as defense secretary. James Mattis resigned in
December 2018 because of the differences in policy with Trump. In Mattis's resignation letter,
he said that Trump deserved a secretary of defense whose views were better aligned with the president's.
That actually happened.
So he lied about that.
He lied.
A young man who voted for Donald Trump last election asked what does he plan to do about police reform
without sacrificing public safety?
Listen to this.
The governor, frankly,
what happened in Minneapolis was pretty amazing.
Unfortunately, this went on for a week or a week and a half before he allowed us to bring in the National Guard.
When we brought in the National Guard, everything stopped.
The crime was gone, meaning the whole thing.
But by that time, a big portion of the city was burned down.
We're talking about Minneapolis.
In Seattle, we let them know we're coming in.
They took over a big chunk of the city, 20% of the city.
Y'all, that's such a damn lie.
In June, protesters set up a self-proclaimed autonomous zone in Seattle.
It covered six blocks. protesters set up a self-proclaimed autonomous zone in Seattle.
It covered six blocks, not 20% of the city.
Oh, Trump taking credit for the National Guard in Minnesota saying, after a week, we sent him in.
No, you didn't. He lied.
Democratic Governor Tim Walz activated the National Guard two days after the
protests began. First of all, Donald Trump can't send in the National Guard unless the governor
requests. The governor can call him up. Now, it was more than seven hours before Donald Trump publicly threatened to deploy the guard himself when the governor actually deployed the guard.
More lies.
Stephanopoulos said that people at the top of the economic ladder who own stocks are doing well.
Trump then said this.
Stocks are owned by everybody. I'M NOT GOING TO SAY ANYTHING ABOUT THE STOCK MARKET. I'M GOING TO SAY SOMETHING ABOUT
THE MARKET.
TRUMP, BEN SAID THIS.
STOCKS ARE OWNED BY
EVERYBODY.
THEY TALK ABOUT THE STOCK MARKET
IS SO GOOD.
THAT'S 401Ks.
I'M MEETING PEOPLE WITH AS LONG
AS THEY DIDN'T SELL WHEN THE
MARKET WENT DOWN WHEN WE FIRST
REALIZED THE EXTENT OF THIS
HORRIBLE THING FROM CHINA. SOME OF THEM ARE DOING BETTER THAN THEY WERE DOING BEFORE THE PANDEMIC CAME. doing some of them are doing better than they were doing before the pandemic came so that 30 if they if people held on to their stocks and remember this because i noticed you say wealthy
sure wealthy but you have people that aren't wealthy but have done well because of the stock
market another lie stocks are not owned by everybody in the poll done by gallup earlier
this year 55 of american adults reported owning stock this year.
That's the same percentage as last year.
Y'all, half of the country does not own stocks.
It's a lie.
It's a lie.
Not every person in America has a 401k.
There are a significant number of jobs out there that have no 401k.
That's a lie. A black pastor who voted for Jill Stein in 2016
asked Donald Trump about racial inequalities and when was America ever great again for black people.
Hello, Mr. President. Good. You've coined the phrase, make America great again.
When has America been great for
African-Americans in the ghetto of America? Are you aware of how tone deaf that comes off to
African-American community? Well, I can say this. We have tremendous African-American support.
You've probably seen it in the polls. We're doing extremely well with African-American,
Hispanic-American at levels that you've rarely seen a Republican have.
If you talk about make America great, if you look at just prior to, and I'm talking about for the
black community, you look just prior to this horrible situation coming in from China when the
virus came in, that was probably the highest point, home ownership for the black community.
Home ownership, lower crime,
the best jobs they've ever had, highest income,
the best employment numbers they've ever had.
If you go back and you want to look over many years...
Stop it, stop it, stop it, stop it.
I cannot let... Just pause it, pause it.
I cannot let this man just lie.
First of all facts facts
2019 black homeownership dropped to 40% its lowest since 1968, it did go up to 44% by January 2020.
Donald Trump said, highest ever.
Lie.
Black home ownership rate was nearly 50% in 2004.
He's lying. He's lying about black home ownership rate. Those
are the facts. Donald Trump is a liar. Press play. That was the best single moment in the history of
the African-American people in this country, I think.
Stop. That was the best single moment ever in the history of America for black people. See, this is where liars lie.
For Donald Trump, he's defining how great things were for black people solely based
upon the unemployment rate, which by the way was double that of white people.
But you notice how he will say, before coronavirus, no, no, no, no.
Look, this ain't going to corral.
You can't get to say, I'm going to skip over the fish and I'm going to get me some chicken and I'm going to skip over the carrots and I'm going to get me some some green beans over here.
See, you got to take all of it.
So Donald Trump wants to isolate.
Oh, no, no, no, no.
Before coronavirus.
What's the black unemployment rate today?
14 percent.
What was it when you became president?
7.2 percent.
That means during your term, the black
unemployment rate has doubled.
Doubled.
14%.
Doubled. Nice try,
but you're lying.
Press play. I would say,
well, I mean, your statement is they'll make it great
again. So historically,
the African American experience, especially
in these ghettos that have been out of red line, historically the African-American experience that we see in the African- American community, it's not going to be great again.
So historically, the
African-American experience,
especially in these ghettos that
have been redlined, historically
these ghettos that have
systemically been set up and
treated the way that they have
been, the conditions of the
drugs, the guns and everything
else that actually created the
symptoms for what we see that
you profess to be just the
democratic cities themselves, these things have historically been happening
for African Americans in these ghettos,
and we have not been seeing a change.
Quite frankly, under your administration,
under Obama's administration, under Bush, under Clinton,
the very same things happen, and the very same systems
and cycles continue to ensue.
And we need to see,
because you say again, we need to see when was that great?
Because that pushes us back to a time in which we cannot identify with such greatness.
And I mean, you've said everything else about choking and everything else, but you have yet to address and acknowledge that there's been a race problem in America.
So if you go, well, I hope there's not a race problem.
I can tell you there's none with me because I have great respect for all races, for everybody. This country is great because of it. But when you go back six months and you take a look at what was happening, you can't even compare that with past administrations. When you look at income levels and a lot of things because of the job situation where they had the lowest income, the best the best unemployment numbers they've ever had, the black community
by far.
And that was solving a lot of problems.
And you know what else it was?
It was bringing people together.
I was starting to get, just before this was, you know, we were having a long run of success,
I was starting to get calls from Democrats that, hey, it's starting to work.
Let's get together.
People that you would never have thought this would have happened with.
There was going to be unity.
But unfortunately, that was hurt because we got set back.
But now, I think next year is going to be one of our best years economically.
But income equality is still up.
But income equality is higher.
So, I mean, jobs can be produced.
But at the same time, in a lot of these big major cities where African-Americans are underserved, under-resourced, that's an $8 job.
It does not mean that they can necessarily afford to live where they have to live or where they've been living at for the last 20 years.
Well, the income inequality, which I agree with you is a problem.
I always agreed with that.
But if you look under President Obama and Biden, the income inequality was phenomenal.
It was record-setting.
It was terrible. It was record-setting. It was terrible.
It's getting worse now.
Well, we're talking about a plague coming. And before the plague,
we were doing very well. Now, we will soon be doing well again, because we're going to have
a fantastic third quarter. You're seeing the numbers come in. I think you're going to have
a GDP that's mid-20s and maybe much higher. Somebody said 35. I don't know. These are all records
we're talking about. And you're going to have a very good economically, you're going to have a
very good year next year. But I agree with a lot of the things you say, but you have to look back
because we really had it going well. Had we not been hit by this horrible disease that came into
our land and all over the world, by the way, came all over the world, we would be in a position where I think income inequality would be different. It was
really getting there. We were really driving it down. We have to move on. But even before the
pandemic, the average black family was earning half of what the average white family was earning,
even if you hold education. I can only compare it to the past.
The the African-American, the black community was doing better than it had ever done by far,
both in terms of unemployment, homeownership, so many different statistics, even in terms of there is still a gap between blacks and whites. I mean, there was a gap, but we were doing a good
job. It was getting better. And then it was artificially shut down by this disease
that came onto our land.
Absolute lies, top to bottom.
Oh, it was getting better.
It was getting better.
It was all Obama.
Did he forget about the financial crisis
that happened under President George W. Bush
that Obama and Biden
inherited and had to dig America out of? Oh, I'm sorry, that didn't happen? Oh, so only calamities
affect you. So you want to have a discussion about what happened before COVID?
Do we want to talk about the fact that, and we'll discuss it later, 75% of the children who
have died from COVID are minorities?
Do we want to talk about the disproportionate impact of black people dying, being infected
due to coronavirus?
Oh, so you don't want to talk about that?
Oh, I thought so.
Okay. Trump was asked about the racial injustices and what can be done to address them.
Listen to this.
Hello, Mr. President.
Martin Luther King Jr. once famously wrote,
Injustice anywhere is a threat to justice everywhere.
In the light of the ongoing protests surrounding the deaths of George Floyd, Breonna
Taylor, and the recent shooting of Jacob Blake, do you feel racial injustices are occurring in
this nation? And if so, what can be done to address them? Well, I think they were tragic
events. And I do feel that we have to also take into consideration that if you look at our police, they do a phenomenal job.
You'll have people choke, make mistakes.
Stop right there.
Pause it.
Wow, they were tragic events.
Oh, but the cops are doing great.
Forget George Floyd.
Move on.
Move on.
Oh, just Jacob Blake.
Move on.
The cops are phenomenal!
They're awesome! They're fantastic!
Play.
And they happen. It happens
where they have to make a fast decision
and some bad things happen.
And you also have bad apples.
But you have 99%
great people. I know the police forces
very well. I think almost every one of them,
if you look, I've been endorsed by so many of them. And these are great people. I know the police forces very well. I think almost every one of them, if you look, I've been endorsed by so many of them. And these are great people. And I will say this,
if you're going to stop crime, we have to give the respect back to the police that they deserve.
They've done a fantastic job in so many locations, but then bad things happen. Look at New York.
So it's just damn people who've gotten shot.
Oh, we got to give respect back to the cops.
We got to respect them.
We got to, you know, we got to show them some love.
We got to just give them all the respect.
Completely ignored her question.
Completely.
Oh, 99%.
The cops are great.
They're just fantastic.
They're amazing.
Please play. Police play.
New York. New York was a very safe city. Rudy Giuliani did a fantastic job.
The city was safe. And then all of a sudden we have a mayor. He starts cutting the police force.
And crime is up 100%, 150%. I saw one form of crime up 300%.
So I think it's very important, whether you talk Seattle,
where they have very good police,
but they're not allowed to do their job.
You have to allow the police to do their job.
I agree with you, those events are terrible,
but we have to allow the police to do their job.
Otherwise, crime is going to soar.
Oh, those events are terrible,
but we've got to let the cops do their job.
Lie after lie after lie after lie after lie.
The health care lies.
I mean, he sat here, George Stephanopoulos, questioning about health care plan.
Oh, no, no, no.
We're going to be signing one.
Huh?
I'm sorry.
What?
George Stephanopoulos said,
wait a minute.
You told me a year ago you were going to be signing one
in three weeks.
He then said,
wait a minute.
In July, you told Chris Wallace
you're going to be signing the health care bill in two weeks.
So, oh, no, no, but George, no, George, George, we are.
George, we are. We're going to be signing one.
Hold on. I'm confused. I'm just confused.
Which which one is it? I'm just confused.
Which which one is it? I mean, confused. Which which one is it?
I mean, folks, we just saw lie after lie. I mean, PolitiFact talked about four Pinocchios.
I mean, my God, they went through this whole deal laying out lie after lie.
Let me just bring my panel right now. A. Scott Bolden, former chair of National Bar Association Political Action Committee.
Robert Petillo, executive director, Rainbow Push Coalition,
Peach Tree Street Project,
LaVertoria Burke,
NNPA.
Robert, I'm going to start with you.
I'm just...
Robert, I'm going to start with Robert.
I'm just crazy.
Trump, we have 20%
of the cases because of the fact we do much more
testing. If we wouldn't do
testing, you wouldn't have cases. You would have very few cases. Oh my God. That's just,
that's just put a fact say that that's just flat out lie. I mean, you know, oh,
Fauci said we've done a great job. The whole deal with president G and the whole deal with mask.
Donald Trump, Joe Biden said I was xenophobic because I put the ban on and I thought that
was a very unfair By the way,
he's totally taking that back. Actually, Biden
didn't say that.
He didn't say that. I mean, just again,
again, just constant lies.
Yesterday was a lie fast. Go ahead, Robert.
Well, Rowan,
as I always say, I think chasing
Donald Trump's lies is a
quixotic voyage at best.
If people cared about Donald Trump lying,
he wouldn't have got elected last time. So the idea that somehow tracing down and fact-checking
every lie that he tells is going to be an effective electoral strategy, I don't know
how effective that is going to be. Because while we spend an hour breaking down each and every
syllable of what Donald Trump says, I have no idea what Joe Biden did yesterday.
I don't know where he campaigned at. I don't know. He hasn't come on this show. He hasn't come on my show. He hasn't done a circuit of black radio. We haven't seen those mail pieces.
They've just started airing ads targeted at African-American men. So while Trump may lie,
it gets him on TV continuously in the news cycle. It's as if Trump is running against Trump.
So when you're running against yourself,
that means you can completely control the narrative,
and the other party in the arena just becomes a junior partner.
So I think regardless of what Trump does,
as long as he dominates that news cycle,
as long as he gets that $3 billion in free media that he got in 2016,
then this is advantage to Trump.
So whereas
some people are put off by the lie, other people listen in sound bites and 30 second bites on their
phone that if he can have a plausible answer, that's all the fat chicken they're going to do.
So then this is still a net positive for Trump. Actually, I disagree, Lauren, because the reality
is this here. And again, this is the strategy that Joe Biden should employ in every single debate.
When Trump lies, he should say, that's a lie.
When he lies again, he should say, that's a lie.
When he makes up, he goes, another lie.
He shouldn't use the word falsehoods.
He shouldn't say malarkey.
He should say, right there is a lie.
And that's another lie.
And that's another lie.
And that's another lie. And that's another lie. And that's another lie. That is the only way.
Okay, when Donald Trump got checked last night by voters,
he started stumbling and bumbling.
That's the only way.
You have to call the lies out.
Otherwise, if you don't call out lies, Lauren,
and you allow them to stand and only discuss your record,
then you give the impression that what he's saying is true.
Well, then that's the game
that he's playing. Donald Trump is well aware
of the fact that there's 5 or 6 million
people watching every time this happens.
Last night it was 3.8 million.
So he's playing the game he always plays,
which is he figures a certain percentage
of the people watching don't know
that what he's saying is inaccurate.
He can get it out there
into the narrative bloodstream. He can just sort of keep talking. And if the anchor, if the person
who is moderating the discussion doesn't step in and stop him, which unfortunately can't be
his opponent, although I think at the debate we will see that happen, it requires someone
standing there, whether it's the person asking the question
or the journalist moderating the debate. It requires somebody to check him right then and
there. We've already seen in the White House briefing room multiple times that when he gets
checked in real time, he can't withstand that. He's very not good because I'm sure he spends
most of his life with a bunch of yes people around him that don't say anything to him,
corrective. So that is the moment that you have to have that you can kind of move over and over
and over. But Donald Trump is playing the percentage. He figures, I can just straight
out lie. I get it on TV. My supporters here, we understand that, you know, 80 percent of the
electorate is pretty much locked in in almost any election. So the 20 percent that may or may
not be undecided is the only group that you're talking to anyway.
Interestingly enough, he lost to two reality TV shows
last night in the ratings,
America's Got Talent and Big Brother.
But he still knows that 4 million people are watching.
So if he just gets it out there,
he just says whatever he wants,
because he understands that even though he's lying, a lot of these clips get replayed again and again.
And in his head, in his PR world, that's a win.
Oh, this is the Scott.
This is the Project Lincoln ad they dropped specifically about Don Trump's health care plan.
What we're doing is we're going to be doing a health care plan, pre-existing, protecting people with pre-existing condition.
We're going to be doing a health care plan very strongly
and protect people with pre-existing conditions.
You're arguing in the Supreme Court right now to strike it down.
That would do away with pre-existing conditions.
No, so we can do new health care.
Do we run Obamacare well and do a good job and do the best,
even though it's never going to be very good?
We have run it so much better than Obama ran it.
Obamacare was a disaster.
Last year, you said the health care plan would come in two weeks.
You told Chris Wallace.
And that turned out to be a lie.
Scott, I understand Robert and Lauren's point, but I'm telling you, I believe the way you deal with Donald Trump, Joe Biden, you say lie, fact, lie, fact, lie, fact.
Here's the deal. You cannot rely on any moderator.
If you're in debate, you can't rely on any of the moderators to fact check in real time.
You have to be armed with the information yourself.
And this is one of the reasons why I criticize a lot of these television anchors when they are not fully prepared in real time for the lie.
And so the lie goes out. When I was on CNN, I used to bust cats all the time because I was always prepared.
And I would go, that's a lie.
That's a lie.
What you just said is a lie.
Because you got to hit them right there.
Otherwise, if you allow the lie to stand, the person at home goes, well, no one said anything.
He didn't say anything.
And the whole deal, let's wait for the fact check after the debate.
No, hell no.
You got to hit the lie on the spot.
Yeah, and you've got to hit every lie.
It's like putting a trial together.
I'm a trial lawyer, litigator.
And so one of the rules of litigation is if someone writes a brief and misstates the fact or basically lies an oral argument, you check them right then and there.
And you reserve time to do it.
But you've got to be really prepared to cross-examine Donald Trump, because the best
interviews are when he gets checked, right? Then he goes into la-la land. I disagree with Robert
on this. We're not chasing his lies. We're checking his lie. And while that 40 percent
of his voting support is going to support him no matter what,
there are a lot of undecideds. They're independents. They're suburban women.
There are Democrat. They're Lincoln Republicans who listen to this nonsense and either reject it, especially on covid,
because everyone has a friend or family member that's been affected by this,
whether it's economically or health-wise. And so when he lies about COVID, he drives the narrative
not of telling the truth, but he drives the narrative of lying about it and waiting 70 days
to address it, and then the repercussions of the results that his lies have turned deadly now.
That is such a powerful message to the average voter, because we've all been affected by it.
He cannot outrun these facts and these lies that he's put on the table.
And I think this election is a bottom line proposition on how he handled COVID, how he lied about it, and how it's affected
his decision. His decision have affected us, not only health-wise, life and death,
as well as economically. So whatever he says pre-COVID that came in from Asia,
we're dealing with his America and how he's handled it, how he's managed it.
And he gets a failing grade.
And whether he fails now in our minds, but at the ballot box, that failure is going to show up.
It's got to because it's dominated each of our lives in different but very powerful ways.
The reason, and again, first of all, we know he is going to lie with impunity.
We know he is going to make stuff up.
We know he is going to take credit for any number of things.
But this is one of those moments where you have to be willing to punch him in the face at every turn.
And see, Robert, Biden can say, that's a lie. Here's fact. And this is
what I'm going to do as president. You have to do that. But if you are relying on a third party to
do it, you're going to miss the opportunity. And let me tell you something right now. If,
if he hits him, if Donald Trump lies 20 times in a debate, I don't care who you are. If you're
sitting there watching it and you're like, damn, he's, he's hitting that lie, lie, lie, lie, lie.
You are diminishing the person.
And then you say, no, no, you're going to stay here.
You're going to tell the truth.
You're going to tell the truth.
If I'm Joe Biden, I'm saying, did you inherit an economy from me and Barack Obama that was on the upswing?
Yes or no?
See, to me, you've got to be aggressive with it.
I think in 2016, Hillary Clinton sort of was too.
No, no, no.
You can't leave anything to chance with a brutal thug.
That's right.
You're running against a gangsta.
Go ahead, Robert.
Roland, I would love to be as young and idealistic
as you are and have that much faith in the
American people, but we've had a
game show host for president for the last four
years, and I think, look,
McDonald's doesn't make good hamburgers.
Hamburgers are nasty, unless they want to advertise
on the show, in which case they're delicious.
But, look, the hamburgers ain't good. So instead of making the hamburgers good,
they put a billion dollars into commercials
to make you think that the hamburger tastes good,
and then your kids fight you to go eat those hamburgers.
That is exactly what Donald Trump does.
It doesn't matter about the product.
It doesn't matter what comes out of his mouth.
He's calling into Fox & Friends once a week now
just to make sure that he's always getting the best care.
But Robert, he's doing that because he knows there won't be pushback.
The reality is this here.
Every time he's had pushback, he begins to stumble and bumble.
So what I'm arguing is you can't allow the lie to go uninterrupted.
You got to put him on the defense. And the best
way to say, lie.
Lie. Lie.
Lie. Lie. Lie.
Look, we offered, we
called Paris Denard to come
on today's show. His ass said
no. Why do you think his ass
said no? Because I would have hit his
ass with, lie. Lie.
Lie. Lie. There's a reason why Bruce Lavelle said no. Because I would have hit his ass with, lie, lie, lie, lie.
There's a reason why Bruce Lavelle
won't come on this show. Oh, he'll run
to CNN because CNN ain't
going to hit his ass like I'm going to hit him.
He'll run to Fox, boom, lie,
lie, lie. Ashley
Bell not going to come here because
I'm going to hit his ass with, lie, lie.
They don't want to be
forced to defend lies.
So the best way is don't even come on.
And I'm just saying, I'm just saying, Lauren, I'm telling you, Democrats better be real
aggressive in those three debates.
And at every turn, if you're soft shoe and try to do a cute little dance, no, that ain't
how you deal with thugs.
You got to bust a bully in his mouth.
Well, I do think you can probably count on Joe Biden to be aggressive.
What kind of messes this up a little bit, of course,
is the format of these so-called debates.
A lot of them involve a toss back and forth from the anchor to the candidate,
candidate back to the anchor.
You got to screw the rules. You got to screw the candidate back to the anchor. You gotta screw the rules.
You gotta screw the rules.
Trump ain't gonna abide by the rules.
I'm telling you.
When it's his turn, he lie. This is what you do.
Lie.
He lie again.
Lie. Sir,
please don't interrupt him.
Sir, please don't interrupt. Tell him stop lying.
That's just how you got to go.
Right.
Yeah, no, I know. Well, that, I think, actually is what Biden is probably likely to do.
And we know Harris is going to do it.
You can't have 20 million people sitting watching that and have it go unchecked.
Frankly, when I look at moderators, I know Chris Wallace is certainly not going to let it happen
because his entire style
is based on checking people
when something stupid is said.
And Chris Wallace has absolutely no
problem stopping the entire production
to do that. But you
got to have people who are assertive.
It can't be Nora O'Donnell and Gayle King.
It can't be infotainment anchors.
It can't be any of that stuff.
And it does have to be an opponent standing there and checks in.
But the game, you know, all the people that you mentioned that can't go on a show where they get fact-checked,
that's the name of the game.
And that is a PR strategy.
Yes.
To use somebody else's platform to lie on.
To use somebody else's platform to lie on is a strategy.
And Republicans do it all the time.
Again, all I'm saying is this here.
Look, do I think Senator Harris is going to do it?
Oh, yeah.
Now, the difference is here.
Mike Pence is a smoother operator than Donald Trump.
Mike Pence is going to talk in that very nice, easygoing, Midwestern manner, and he's going to sit here.
He's not going to be as combative.
The best opponent, look, as somebody who has done this for years,
I'm going to tell you right now, that's what I look.
Look, I destroyed Glenn Beck so bad on CNN.
I wish, I wish I had access to the CNN video library so I could show y'all.
I destroyed Glenn Beck so bad.
Glenn Beck said the next day after the debate,
Sam Feist, who was now the Washington, D.C. director,
he came running out.
That was great.
Yo, Glenn Beck was like, oh, hell no.
They tried to get me and Glenn Beck to debate the next day.
Glenn Beck said no.
He wasn't available all day.
Then Glenn Beck said, for damn that,
I ain't going on CNN against nobody.
I will only go on if it's by myself and Wolf because he could not withstand the heat.
And I was smacking the shit out of him, Scott.
And he couldn't handle it.
And he was like, yo, I ain't never debating him again.
That's why you never saw me on
Beck's show. He never came back
because the moment he's like, he
said something, I started laughing.
And remember, he took my hand and he said,
oh, I'm glad you're so dismissive. He said, I'm glad you're so
dismissive. I said, no, go ahead and finish your point.
I'm going to deal with you in a second.
Well, we don't have the video,
but I can guarantee you, I go back to the litigation
scenario and the cross-examination.
If you had Donald Trump on the witness stand, right, and you cross-examining, you can't get into this philosophical policy debate.
You have to keep your questions short to the point and in response to his questions.
But most importantly, you've got to be very well prepared.
You don't have to memorize the fact.
You have to know the fact.
Right.
Know lying.
And as soon as he starts lying, you check him.
Short, direct, powerful statement of either denial or that you're lying and quickly why you're lying.
December 7th, you said X, Y, and Z.
And that's how you control a witness in the courtroom or in a deposition. You got to do the same thing if you're Joe Biden, because if you
don't, then you let the narrative run its course. You got to control the narrative with him and
never let him go. Never let him get control of. And that's why, and that's why, Robert,
I hear you when you talk about your policies and what you want to do. But the reality is,
we know this election is pretty much set. What you have to do is you have to be in a constant state of
exposing and not, and see again, Democrats want to give paragraphs. Republicans operate by bumper
stickers. And this is why, this is where it has to be quick fire back. And I, and I think again,
and this is also where Robert, if you're Joe Biden, you got to say, Donald Trump, you lied to those people in the Midwest.
You lied to people in Indiana.
What happened to those carrier jobs you promised and went back to Mexico?
What happened to these jobs?
You lied about that.
You got to reinforce the narrative.
Otherwise, you're going to sit here and be playing his game because he wants you to get in the back and forth.
No, no, no, no. You've got to gut his ass at every time.
I want to talk about this other thing that happened in the debate, y'all, where Donald Trump brought up.
Just play the audio, y'all. This Lord. The waiters. The herd. The herd. The herd.
Y'all had a video. Listen, watch this, y'all. Watch this.
Okay, and it is going away, and it's probably going to go away now a lot faster because of
the vaccine. It would go away without the vaccine, George, but it's going to go away a lot faster.
It would go away without the vaccine? Sure, over a period of time. Sure, with time.
It goes by. And many deaths.
And you'll develop, you'll develop like a herd mentality it's gonna be it's gonna be heard developed and that's gonna happen that will all happen but
with a vaccine I think it will go away very quickly gotta take a quick I really
believe we're rounding the corner and I believe that's true as you know dr.
Fauci disagrees with that well I mean but a lot of people do this I do agree
with me you see that's what you asked him who.
So, let me bring up Dr. Alexia Gaffney, an infectious disease expert.
Doc, Doc, this fool just said, even with the vaccine, it's just going to go away.
Viruses just don't just go away.
No, they don't, Roland.
I mean, if you're going to jump out of your lane, at least speak the right language.
It's not herd mentality.
It's herd immunity.
And it would take for at least 70 percent of the United States population.
You're talking about 200 million people to become naturally infected with COVID or vaccinated
in order for us to gain or develop herd immunity. But the problem is, is
talking about natural herd immunity means that you're just willing to risk more than the approaching 200,000 American lives we've already lost in order to achieve herd immunity.
I want you to hold that point.
That was a guy.
He's in a tweet out.
And he let me let me switch.
I want to show this, y'all.
And I just want to get your thoughts on this, because on this whole notion of herd immunity.
This is what he, hopefully I can show it.
This guy, Kyle Felster.
Kyle is a, he's a breaking news editor at CNN.
This is what he said.
There are approximately 328.2 million people in the United States.
To get the low end of herd immunity, about 60% of the population must catch COVID.
That's about 196,920 cases.
The current U.S. death rate is about 2.96%. So that means in order to achieve
herd immunity, we would have to accept 5,836,679 deaths.
Unacceptable. unacceptable so so is that calculation correct that we would have to so to accept her immunity
we would also have to accept not just the covet infections but the covet deaths that come from
her immunity and that's a conservative number you you know, 5.8 million.
I'm calling it conservative because if you had that many deaths, imagine how many people are going to require hospitalization. We didn't see peak numbers of COVID all over the United States at the exact same time.
But where we had hotspots and epicenters, our health systems were overwhelmed.
If we stop everything, we don't do anything
to prevent the spread of the virus
in a ridiculous attempt to achieve natural herd immunity,
we will completely overwhelm our healthcare systems
and we will lose even more American people
as a result of this virus,
way more than that number is predicting, because
that number is based on perfect circumstances. Being able to treat those that need to be
hospitalized, being able to give everyone who needs it critical care, and we already saw what
could happen when our systems become overwhelmed, that is not something that we want to see happening
nationwide simultaneously.
This is it. So first of all, just explain this herd immunity. There are a number of people who keep saying that's the only way we can do this. They also are suggesting that if you do herd
immunity, that once you get it, you can't get it again. That's that's not true.
No, it's not true that once you get the virus, you can't get it again. That's not true. No, it's not true that once you get the virus,
you can't get it again. Probably a small proportion of people who have been infected
will get reinfected. But the reality is we don't know. This is our first time dealing with COVID-19.
It's a brand new infection, even though we are eight months in in terms of our knowledge of
this virus. But there's still a lot to learn as things progress and evolve.
So the concept of herd immunity is that if the majority of your population is immune to an infection
that is communicable or contagious from person to person,
whether that immunity comes naturally or whether that immunity comes via a vaccination,
then you protect the overall population or community or herd,
because with less and less individuals susceptible to the infection,
then the people who haven't been vaccinated and the people who haven't had the
infection are protected because you stopped the spread or propagation of the infection.
So that number needs to be around 70 percent. But we already talked about how many lives would be
at stake if we allow 200 plus million Americans to become sick with this infection. So we need to continue our
social distancing. We need to continue to isolate. We need to continue to wear our masks. We need to
continue hand hygiene. We need to continue to avoid large crowds. Everything that we have been
doing up until now needs to continue, and it will need to continue even when we have a vaccine available for some time.
I've got to ask you about this here. The CDC director, Robert Redfield, testified today about the importance of masks. This is what he had to say. mask is more guaranteed to protect me against COVID than when I take a COVID vaccine because
the immunogenicity may be 70 percent. And if I don't get an immune response, the vaccine is not
going to protect me. This face mask will. I might even go so far as to say. Your thoughts about that?
What he just said. Yeah. So is a mask better than a vaccine of comparing apples to
oranges? You know, we still will need to continue to take the isolation and social distance
precautions, even when people begin to get vaccinated, because the reality is not everyone
is going to get vaccinated and there's no such thing as a
perfect vaccine. So if you're talking about only a particular proportion of the population getting
vaccinated and then the vaccine having efficacy or protecting 70 percent of the people who receive
it, there's still some significant gaps that we need to keep in mind. And so we will still need to continue to wear our mask.
Nothing in this pandemic situation is a get out of jail free card.
So we really just have to be vigilant and we have to let this thing, in a sense, run its course, but not run a court, run its course like take off your mask, go do what you will, return back to life and see where the cards fall.
That's not what we're talking about here. It really needs to be a mass effort and it needs to be a concerted effort.
Everybody needs to be doing the same thing to protect themselves as well as protect one another from the spread of this infection.
I got to ask you this here. What do you make of the CDC director saying a vaccine is not going to be ready
for the American public until 2021?
Donald Trump has a news conference
that comes out and says,
oh no, he was mistaken.
The CDC director was mistaken.
It's going to be ready in a month or so.
Yeah.
So the vaccine trials are still underway.
And my understanding of what
these vaccine companies are doing,
concurrent with studying these drugs, they are producing doses of the vaccine. That is
atypical. Typically, a vaccine is studied. It is checked for efficacy, meaning does it cause an
immune response? Does it protect the people who received it? It's checked for safety, right?
Do people have bad side effects?
Are they terrible side effects?
Are they side effects that we can accept?
Like what's the risk versus the benefit
of receiving the vaccine?
And if the benefit far outweighs the risk
and you're not endangering people by giving the vaccine,
then you go into production.
Now the vaccines are starting to be produced,
but you will need billions and billions of doses of this vaccine
to protect the population worldwide.
And it takes months to produce a vaccine,
even when the studies are successful and tell you that the vaccines work. So he's really
speaking lies. I'm going to just stay on the path that you're on, lies. You know, he's saying things
that are not scientifically possible. But that's what happens when you jump out of your lane. He
needs to let the experts speak so that we can receive the truth
and so that people continue to do the right thing. Giving people false hope, telling people to let
their guard down, you know, making light of the situation is dangerous. And we are seeing the
consequences of this over and over and over again. Well, the expert did speak, but then he's
contradicting the experts. And that's part of the problem. Doc, we certainly appreciate it. Thank you so very much for
joining us. Thanks for having me on. All right, then. Robert, you asked, you don't know what
Joe Biden is doing. Joe Biden did speak about the issue of vaccines today. This is what he had to
say in his news conference. Long briefing with seven of our nation's top public health experts on the state of the pandemic,
the steps we need to curb the spread of the virus,
and the challenges of distributing a safe and effective vaccine once one is identified.
Before I turn to those issues, let me say a few words about the President's comments last night. Even before acknowledging to Bob Woodward
on tape that he was fully informed on the gravity of the danger related to COVID-19,
he refused to warn the American people. Again last night in Television Town Hall,
the President revealed in no uncertain terms the lack of seriousness with which he continues to take this pandemic.
Nearly eight months after this crisis, on the doorstep of 200,000 American deaths,
President Trump was refused once again to take responsibility or to take action.
By his own admission, he continued to lie about COVID-19. He doubled down on the
catastrophic mistakes that he's made. And perhaps worst of all, he made clear that he still doesn't
have a plan to bring us out of this crisis. He even said, and I quote, a lot of people think
that masks are not good, undercutting the easiest, most effective means we have for reducing the spread of this
disease. This virus is still taking nearly a thousand lives a day. The forecasts show
that those numbers are likely to climb this winter. But incredibly, Donald Trump insists
that he wouldn't have done anything different. Not one thing. Last Friday, we learned that another one of the thousands of Americans died due to this virus, and it continues to rise.
And the very same day that we reported a thousand deaths on Friday, and the very same day Canada reported that not one person died of COVID-19 in Canada.
Trump wouldn't have done anything differently. If you're a parent in America
preparing for another day that your child can't attend school, if you're grieving the loss of a
son, a daughter, a mother, a father, husband or wife, if you're a small business owner who's on
the brink of total bankruptcy, who can't open or can't go back to work because the virus still is spreading in your community.
How does it make you feel to hear the president say
he wouldn't have done anything differently?
And if he gets four more years,
why should we expect anything to change?
All the president had to offer last night, President Trump,
was the same weak and feckless inaction, the same lies and empty promises that we've seen
from the very beginning. He still won't accept any responsibility. He still won't offer a plan.
And last night, he repeated what he said so many times before that even if he continues to offer only failing indifference,
someday the virus is going to go away by a miracle. Even if he does nothing, it's going to
go away by a miracle. It won't go away like a miracle. In fact, even if it get even to get a
vaccine will not be available for most populations or well into the 2021.
You know, so we're heading into a very dangerous autumn. The fact that the University of Washington
model, which the White House has previously touted, projects that cases and deaths are going to spike this November and an additional by 215,000 Americans. They say
they're going to die. It began to spike in November, but by the first of the year,
215,000 will be dead, additional. That's more than have already died.
We need leadership right now to prevent that from happening. The same university the model shows,
the University of Washington model, shows that if there's universal masking, these deaths could be projected, deaths could be in North Carolina. We're seeing it happen. Joe Biden
and Senator Kamala Harris stepping up their events. Biden has spent time in Florida. He is
trying to shore up support there when it comes to Latino voters. New poll is out. Also, Scott,
I'll start with you first, showing that Joe Biden is doing better among white voters, especially even non-college
educated white voters happening there as well.
One of the reasons why he's leading in polling there in Wisconsin, Pennsylvania, and Michigan
as well.
And so it's very interesting when you start looking at these various numbers, also polling
coming out, showing the Senate candidate in Maine
with a 12-point lead over Susan Collins.
Democrats are leading in Arizona, leading in North Carolina.
Also, tight race in Montana.
The reality is that Democrats could very well get control of the United States Senate.
Why is that important?
Just today, Mitch McConnell has pushed through six more federal judges,
eight federal judges this week. Donald Trump last night said
they hope to hit 300 by the end of the year. And so this is where the rubber meets the road now
when it comes to driving turnout. That is going to be the difference. It's going to come down to
how many people on your side gets turned out versus the other side. And those who believe that the anti-Trump effort or initiative or excitement isn't enough to win,
you just ran through some numbers 47 days out where in North Carolina and in Maine
and other Republican strongholds that there's a lead to be had there.
Not only is Donald Trump losing because of his lies and because of COVID, but it's spreading
to Senate races and House races, which is really important. 300 federal judges,
and most of them young and incompetent, is going to mean generations of bad decision making or at least
influence in the judiciary. It is incredible, which means that we need a new Senate majority.
And the only way we're going to get that is to win that Senate. We've got to remain competitive
in Georgia and North Carolina and Arizona. But you're right. It's a ground game.
If we got a ground game and a get out the vote effort, not just registration,
but if you're an average voter and you want to do something because you care about the future of this country and that this is a consequential election, then instead of you going to the polls,
don't go alone. Take three, four, five people. Go back several times and take people
to the polls to vote, because it's the only way you can ensure that we win this election,
because we're not just running against Donald Trump and the GOP. And I've written about this,
and I've said it on this show. You're running against Russian interference. You're running
against the GOP and Donald Trump. and you're also running against voter suppression.
And so we can't take anything for granted.
I don't care what the polls show.
I don't want to read another poll.
All I want to do is read the results on the evening of November 3rd or the two or three,
four, five days afterwards, because we've got to have a clean race and a big win, because
if it's close, Donald Trump's not going to
go quiet. And I've said that for the last four years. He's not going quietly, and he
doesn't care about a constitutional crisis. He doesn't care about what the military says
or does. That's why winning the Senate and the House is really important, too, because
he won't have the Senate to backstop his nonsense about voter fraud and mail-in fraud and what
have you. So there's a lot on the line here.
And so we have to be vigilant and take people to the polls
and ignore whatever the polling says right now.
Robert, when we talk about what's happening,
Democrats in Michigan are concerned because the Biden campaign
is not doing door-knocking, Republicans are.
They say that the Biden campaign, they say they are using text messages,
they're using phone calls. General Malley said they've reached out to some 2.6 million folks
there as well. This is just a different election. The reality is everything that you thought
beforehand, how you're supposed to do it, goes out of the window. The Biden campaign is concerned
about people contracting coronavirus, those things along those lines.
What do you make of, again, these these this fear of Democrats?
They could lose Michigan again by having Trump signs all over the place, not seeing enough Joe Biden signs or people wearing the gear.
I mean, it's just it's one of those things that you've got to make a call in terms of how you're going to do it.
And then coronavirus is a real fear.
Well, you know, that's how I cut my teeth in politics, doing grassroots're going to do it. And then coronavirus is a real fear.
Well, you know, that's how I cut my teeth in politics, doing grassroots initiatives,
knocking on doors, you know, grassroots campaigning, field director for a statewide campaign when I think I was about 22. So I very much feel that you have to do that in-person
touch for campaigns. Text messages are one thing. Emails are one thing. But you have to have that
person-to-person connection. And frankly, right now, Democrats are fighting this fight with one
hand tied behind their back. Because while they're following all the rules, they're doing all the
public safety protocols, no large rallies, making sure to wear masks, socially distancing, no in-person
voting, voter contact, no field game.
Donald Trump's not playing by those same rules.
So right now you are fighting with one hand tied behind your back, completely ceding the
entire ground game to Donald Trump out of precaution.
And we're 47 days out.
And right now, just like in boxing, the tie goes to the aggressor.
And it seems like Donald Trump is the aggressor in this election for a more aggressive ground game, a more aggressive grassroots campaigning, a more aggressive media strategy.
Even a clip you made of Biden was just Biden talking about Trump.
The election is completely about Trump and the tie goes to the when you look at how people are responding to this election,
University of Georgia is amazing how they're perfectly fine with football,
but they won't have an early voting location on the University of Georgia campus.
Wow. I wonder why.
I keep telling people these Republicans don't like all of these college students, white college students,
who are voting Democrat.
That's sort of the game that they've been playing.
This here was the statement they sent out today.
Due to the concerns about long voting lines and insufficient indoor space required to maintain social distancing
necessitated by the COVID-19 pandemic, the university determined early this summer
that there will be no on-campus voting site at the Tate Center this fall. Those comparing this matter to a football game should be able to
recognize that football games will be played outdoors but we will still
require social distancing by substantially reducing capacity in the
stadium. We have eliminated tailgating as well due to a desire to keep the campus
as safe as possible and limit visitors during the pandemic. Students will still be able to vote at other locations, including one in downtown Athens, to which
the university will provide a shuttle service for student voters. What I don't understand, Lauren,
is you got a damn basketball arena. That not big enough to have an early voting location?
Hell, if you're going to do early voting location, this football stadium is not going to be open
every single week. Let them vote inside the stadium.
Well, obviously, everybody knows the game in Georgia.
Obviously, what we saw with Stacey Abrams in the election, effectively being stolen.
There's a Senate seat that is in contention in Georgia as well.
They're not even really hiding it or trying to feign what they're actually doing.
It's just right in your face face right there for everybody to see.
The problem for Donald Trump and the Republicans on the map writ large, though, is that I'm not seeing where Donald Trump wins states like Pennsylvania and Wisconsin and Michigan.
You know, maybe he wins Florida. OK. But if you look at the map, I would be very shocked.
You know, we have to remember that that and obviously we respect the Electoral College
and all that.
You have to remember that Hillary Clinton barely, barely lost.
They lost because they didn't listen to anybody with regard to Wisconsin and Michigan.
And she got more than, you know, two point eight million. But of course,
she still lost. I would be shocked if Biden was not able to at least duplicate those numbers and
should be able to surpass them. I thought Robert just made a good point, though, that rambling
thing that we just saw with Biden just sort of talking on and on and making Trump the narrative
is playing on defense and not offense, there is some
logic to this idea that Biden should just sort of check out and watch and understand
the fact that this is all a referendum on Donald Trump.
Yeah, you can play that to some extent.
And I understand that play because 200,000 people, we're about to have 200,000 people
dead of COVID, you know.
And of course, to say nothing of the millions,
over 40 million employed,
one would think that this entire thing,
of course, would be a referendum on Trump.
But, you know, to the point before,
I actually think that Trump
is going to make a scene
whether he loses big or not,
whether it's close or not.
He's going to try to pretend
that it was stolen,
and he's going to try to throw that
up into question.
I don't think that, I really think the Republicans are Republicans will lose the Senate. We see a few races,
obviously, Colorado and Maine, where it's kind of they're down by a lot, the incumbents,
the Republican incumbents. And I think that's going to play a big role in the discussion
right after the election. But this entire strategy has to switch to early voting and mail-in ballots. And they are showing, actually, that text messaging has an 80 percent
open rate. So text messaging has been a big deal this particular cycle, given COVID. But Democrats
do have to get serious and figure out their door-knock strategy, because they can't just
kiss that goodbye. So it will be interesting to see what Biden's people do. But they are getting to worry me because I'm hearing some things that I heard back in when
we had Hillary running. And that that is worrisome. One of the things that Ohio Supreme Court,
they ruled that the secretary of state cannot limit counties to only having one mail drop box.
Republicans have been attacking one of the Democratic judges.
Scott, this is unheard of.
The Ohio Supreme Court Chief Justice, a Republican, is blasting the state Republicans for their attack on that judge.
Judge Chief Justice Maureen O'Connor of the
Supreme Court of Ohio.
I condemn in the strongest possible terms both the statement released by the Ohio Republican
Party on September 15th, 2020, and its unsigned authors.
The statement disparages the integrity of Franklin County Common Pleas Judge Richard
Fry.
The publication accuses Judge Fry of colluding with the Ohio Democratic Party and labels him a partisan judge. Every one of Ohio's 722 judges,
800 magistrates, and numerous active retired judges should be greatly concerned and voice
their dismay at the irresponsible Republican Party allegation that politics control the
judge's decision. This is a blatant and unfounded attack on the independence of the Ohio judiciary.
Republicans, again, are masters at voter suppression.
They don't want additional mail drop boxes,
and this is how they weaponize secretaries of state.
We saw it with Brian Kemp in Ohio.
We saw it, excuse me, in Georgia.
We previously saw it when Ken Blackwell was secretary of state in Ohio.
Of course, we can go all the way back to 2000.
Catherine Harris in Florida and numerous other states.
These are the games they play in order to try to cheat to win.
Yeah, but the accusations against the judiciary, I'm not surprised.
Even though we have elected judges and was a Republican chief judge of the Supreme Court in Ohio,
the judiciary has got to remain independent and have its integrity. And so this is the strongest statement the chief
judge could make. Damn the politics, if you will. And he's absolutely right about that.
This is the Republicans' efforts to legalize voter suppression, we've talked about their efforts in North Carolina, South Carolina, Georgia, Florida, and even in Ohio.
Ohio is such an important swing state and in the heart of America.
You've got to come out against that.
What's amazing to me is that there's not more outrage from Republicans and Democrats about the Republicans who want
fewer people to vote than an expanded voter population that makes all the sense in the
world.
It's such a fundamental constitutional right.
You actually have a political party, an important one, a big one, one of the two major parties,
who actually want fewer people to vote
because their ideas are not that popular.
It is anti-American.
It's anti-Constitution.
And yet that is a premise of the Republican Party.
All of us should be outraged with that.
All of us.
But the reality is this here.
They're going to do what they do, Robert.
And I keep saying this here.
You got to go with the scene
from Remember the Titans. You got to leave no doubt.
You have to bury
every Republican in every
state. You must bury them
with a wide margin.
I'm not talking
winning by 10, 20, 30, 50,000,
even 100,000. I'm talking about
you trying to run up the score.
You got to run up the score in North Carolina, in Georgia. You got to run up the score in Florida, in
Wisconsin, in Pennsylvania, in Michigan. And if you're the Biden campaign, Biden-Harris campaign,
you're going to be aggressive as hell. You're going to be putting money on the streets.
You're going to be pushing every get out the vote group as well, because you have
to leave no doubt because Trump and the Republican Party are going to try, if it's close, they're
going to try to do what they did in Florida in 2000 to throw out 10, 20, 30, 50, 100,000, as many
ballots as possible in order for them to steal a victory. You're completely correct. And
remember, we have two Senate seats up for grabs here in Georgia, Pastor Warnock running for one
and John Ossoff running for the other. And part of what I think Democrats make a mistake is they
still have this idea that they're going to get their voters back. Those 1960s to 1980s Democratic
voters, the truck drivers, the Rust Belt voters, the
working class white voters.
And at the same time, you look at a state like Georgia, where you have a 35 percent
African-American population, 10 to 12 percent of the Hispanic population, 53 percent of
the state is female, one of the largest LGBTQ populations in the country.
Get those people to vote instead of trying to get those rednecks in Brunswick to come back to the Democratic Party on economic anxiety issues.
Campaign to the people who will vote for you.
Remember, Donald Trump won states that include cities.
Yeah, yeah, Donald Trump won states that include cities like New Orleans, Houston, Philadelphia, Detroit, Gary, Indiana, those are states that Donald Trump won, Charlotte, North Carolina,
Atlanta, Georgia, Miami, because you're not motivating your people who are in these urban
areas to turn out in record numbers. If Hillary had gotten Obama 2012 numbers, she would have won.
If Biden gets Obama 2012 minority turnout numbers, he will win. But they're not putting that work in.
And as I said, I have not seen Joe Biden sit down on this show of Roland Martin
to talk about what he wants to do for the black community.
Not sit down with Carter Bean.
No, no, no.
Back him to the poll.
He's got to drag.
Wait, wait, wait.
Let's be clear.
One second.
Invitation is in, not only for Biden, as well as for Harris as well.
We're trying to lock that down.
So that is happening. I got to throw this out. First of all, first of all, you know
what time it is. I haven't done this in a while. Whoa! Hey! You don't live here.
I'm uncomfortable.
All right, y'all.
White boy in London after the ass on the subway.
Check what happened.
Someone did jump in.
Kiki's hating.
Violence! Violence!
Oh my God!
You don't know about that EDL stuff.
What the f*** do you want about it?
EDL stuff.
What is EDL stuff?
Roll with the EDL stuff.
I said roll with the EDL stuff!
You're a person then, isn't it?
Yes!
You're f***ing your own time.
Why do you have to shout?
Why do you have to shout? Shouting does not make a point. Yes! You're a lozier! Wipe out the shower!
Showering does not make a point!
You just eat the other stuff!
You're a drudger!
Wow boys!
Wow boys! Boy! What up boys? This is the first group, man. What's up boys? What?
I've got purses.
Oh.
I'm trying to get a picture of you.
What?
I'm trying to get a picture of you.
I'm trying to get a picture of you.
You're so cool, man.
Yeah, you're lucky I have a
I'm gonna be posting it today.
Trust me.
What have I got to be?
The next station is that.
What have I got to be?
The sign says, between the train and the platform.
Change here for the circle.
It's just northern and...
This is my home. You're all going back.
You know it as well.
You're all back the way I'm going.
You know we are going back. Go on, go on. Keep going. Oh
You're black? What is that? Oh my god!
Get off the area!
What is black people with anything?
What is black people with anything?
Shut up!
This is popular!
This is...
Less than enough! Less than enough!
LESS THAN ENOUGH!
... Defend the fun! Lesson in us! LESSON IN US! I think he's still asleep.
I think he's still...
Lauren, I'm telling you.
I'm telling you, these people,
they act a fool.
They act a fool.
I mean, one punch,
and the brothers are like,
say, bro, say,uh, OK, we done.
Yeah, and it kind of reminds me of sort of a UK version.
Say it again, Lauren.
Say it again.
I said it was a UK version of what you played the other day.
I think it was in a 7-Eleven with a guy running his mouth.
And he called the guy boy and said, you know, what are you going to do about it?
Not a big fan of assault and violence, but, you know, it's a piece of advice that a lot of people need to understand.
You can make any decision you make you want.
You can do anything you want.
You can make any decision you want. You can say what you want, but you have to be ready for the consequences of what you say what you do and that is uh you know with this video with the ability to have a camera on
like everything with regard to our cell phones we're getting kind of a window into a lot of
things that happen in society but that was like a replay of what showed i think it was about three
shows ago with the uh the young guy in the in the store yeah all right same thing i mean just like
scott you kept telling me like oh no this is sight and violence no i keep telling you
okay i changed my tune now having seen yes is one of my favorite sections of your show.
Let me just say this.
I don't condone violence.
I still don't.
But I understand.
Yeah, I understand.
I understand.
Robert, they're going to learn.
They're going to learn.
Stop messing with people.
Well, look, you know, play stupid games,
you win stupid prizes.
So I think they've learned this lesson.
And those black dudes,
they were like Wakandan or something.
Those were some of those war dogs.
So he picked the wrong ones.
I mean, he probably should have figured out
halfway through that soliloquy
that things weren't going to end well.
He probably should have got off one stop earlier.
But I think part of what we have to teach
in our history, because we spend so much time teaching the nonviolent parts of black history.
There's a lot of people into believing that throughout our entire heritage, all we did was, you know, sit and pray and sing songs and stuff.
No, you had the Stonewall Rebellion. You had John Brown. You have the original Cassius Clay.
Look up a lot of our history and find out exactly what happened and the battles that took place.
And maybe people have a different opinion when they decide to make these sorts of speeches in public.
All right, folks.
Real short break.
Hold on.
Let me ask you a quick question.
No, I got to go to the next break.
I got to go to the next.
What?
I got to go to the next guest.
I got to go to a short break.
When we come back.
Do you have a right to hit somebody if they call you the N-word in public?
Yep.
Yes or no?
Yep.
That's your answer.
All right, folks.
That's called verbal assault.
Got to go to a break.
When we come back, we're going to talk with Charlamagne Tha God about his new black podcasting network.
That's next on Roller Martin Unfiltered.
Turn off your 2020 sensors and include everyone who lived with you as of April 1st.
Kids, uncles, anyone.
They don't even have to be family. Now remember,
this count helps inform where billions in federal funding goes each year. So shape your future and
start here at 2020census.gov. All right, folks, you hear Charlamagne Tha Guy on The Breakfast Club.
Now he has a new venture in partnership with iHeartRadio, and that is a black podcasting network.
It is called the Black Effect Podcast Network.
He joins us right now
charlemagne what's up roland what's up my brother how are you sir doing great so black effect
the name where did the name come from oh man the inspiration was a song off jay-z and beyonce's
album um the everything is love project that people slept on by the way they had a song called
the black effect and you know the hook was like, I'm good on any MLK Boulevard.
And Jay-Z is a black man who's an inspiration to me
on so many levels, but especially for what he does
on the business end.
And so that's simply that.
I saw that title, and I was like, oh, he made it a hot song.
I'm going to make it a hot company.
So you say make it a hot company there.
One of the questions people, when you first made the announcement, people saying, oh, you know, do you actually own this?
Or can we say partnership?
That's one thing that people are tweeting.
They're like, oh, Charlamagne, he don't own it.
I heart owns it.
Yeah, it's a 50-50 joint venture. And, you know, that means that I own 50,
you know, I own
the majority of the
network. And if you go look
at the trademark, which a lot of people
did, which that's when I knew that Twitter just goes
way too far to either prove
you right or prove you wrong. People
were actually digging up the trademark and they started
a trademark, you know, Black Effect Radio
and Black Effect Podcast back in
August of 2019.
So, yes, I am
the majority owner of the Black Effect Podcast Network.
So, in these...
So, that's not 50-50. If you're the majority,
you got majority.
Oh, like...
I don't want to discuss... Yeah, like, F it.
Like 51. Right. Well, 51 is majority.
Gotcha. Gotcha. All right. So, what areas want to discuss yeah like effort like 51 right well 51 is majority gotcha gotcha all right uh
so uh that uh what what areas are are different folks with the podcast you've already announced
uh the people who you are who are going to be launching uh with it and when does it launch
it launched actually the first episode the first show launched this tuesday uh Smith Sr. cut to it
because Steve was ready to go.
You know, Steve had a bunch of podcasts in the deck.
Steve Smith Sr., the former NFL wideout.
The former NFL wideout.
Next minute, I'm the basketball player.
The what?
Next minute, I'm the basketball player.
Oh, no, no, no, no, the Steve Smith Sr.
I'm sorry, Steve Smith Sr.
I apologize.
Steve Smith Sr., the former Carolina Panther,
one of the best trash talkers ever in the league.
So he dropped two episodes this week of his show called Cut to It.
He's got Malcolm Jenkins on the second episode,
and that's available right now.
And we're rolling out All the Smoke with Matt Barnes and Steven Jackson.
They come out this week because their show starts on Showtime this week,
so we're dropping their podcast to coincide with the show that they have on Showtime, All the Smoke.
Obviously, podcasting has exploded.
One of the reasons we did this show, a digital piece, because, again, linear or terrestrial is not really how people are just getting information i mean the reality is if you look at uh that your listeners aren't listeners on the breakfast club and then you compare to
number of youtube followers you guys have as well i mean the reality is the digital space
allows for far more creativity you don't have the same gatekeepers if you will as you do with
with terrestrial or linear television yeah i, I mean, the main reason that I love podcasts
in particular is because I feel like they take
the best attributes of radio and magnify them.
You know, the best attribute of radio to me
was always the personalities.
You know, over time that got lost
because radio wanted to focus on the music, you know,
and they made the music to star.
So a lot of radio stations became jukeboxes and, you know, personalities.
We kind of just became announcers.
Not me.
I've always focused on being a personality, but a lot of guys are just announcers and
a lot of women are just announcers.
They do the time, they do the temperature, they introduce the next songs.
They keep it moving.
Podcasts take just that personality and it's literally them for an hour.
It's literally them for two hours.
And I've always been a person, a fan
of talk radio, so podcast
to me, just take the best attribute of
radio and magnify it times ten.
Well, I'm glad you made that point about talk radio.
As we're talking, we're going to roll the promo video
you guys have for the network.
Go ahead, guys, roll it.
It's interesting. I remember a few years ago, I was
talking with Alfred Liggins,
who is the CEO of Urban One, and we were talking about –
and I mentioned, I said, look, Radio One needs to go into podcasting.
My whole deal was you're getting rid of your talk radio stations,
and this is the perfect way to do that, but you're getting rid of the stations.
They weren't interested, and the reality is that you're know, you're starting that you're starting starting this deal here.
Thank goodness being African-American. But the things I keep saying is we've got to have black folks with ownership of controlling our narrative and telling our story,
as opposed to what we consistently have is that, frankly, majority majority control of white America, reaping the ad dollars, reaping all the money,
and we don't actually control it ourselves.
Yes, and that's one of the other things I love about podcasts.
The reason I love podcasts is because when it comes to the ad revenue,
that is something that the host of that podcast,
when they partner with a platform, can get the majority of.
Even if you have your podcast independently, if you get with some of, you know, even if you have your platform,
I mean, your podcast independently, if you get with some of these advertising companies that
sell podcasts, you'll still get like 70%, you know, 75%, but it's just good ad revenue splits.
And I mean, Roland, you know, as well as I do, that's where the money's at.
Oh, absolutely. I mean, I mean, I mean, the reality is, look, I've, I've done radio.
I did a midday morning drive show, WVON Radio in Chicago.
I was on the Tom Jordan Morning Show.
I had my own radio show as well.
And look, worked at CNN, worked at TV One.
But the reality is here, when I am having conversations right now, I mean, look, I locked down a six-figure deal today with somebody.
When I'm having conversations with somebody, ain't no middleman.
They're not talking to the salesperson or the marketing person and the business people,
and then they come over here and I get a little piece over here or get an appearance fee.
No, no.
I'm having a direct conversation about the money.
Absolutely.
I mean, I've been doing radio for 23 years.
I didn't start getting any piece of ad revenue until The Breakfast Club became a nationally syndicated radio show.
So we've been syndicated for like six, seven years now.
So I never got any ad revenue in my whole 23 years of doing radio until, you know, six years ago. So think about that. With a podcast network, these hosts of these podcasts
are coming out the gate getting ad revenue.
That's something that I didn't have the luxury of having
when I first started in this audio business.
It's also freedom.
It's also freedom.
And the reality is that you don't, I mean,
you can put rules in place if you want to.
But the reality is there are no rules.
When you talk about the digital space, podcasting to me, or just like on the digital side,
it's sort of like if you've got a show on HBO and Showtime.
Yo, whatever flows, flow.
And then now if your audience says, yo, we don't like all your cuts,
then you can decide, hey, we're not going to do that.
But it's the freedom, two things, freedom and flexibility.
Two of the things that, two words that I've always lived by since I came into the business as a graduate of Texas A&M University,
that when a company was limiting my freedom and my flexibility, that's when I said I got to bounce.
Absolutely. Absolutely.
And listen, that's one of the reasons I love I heart so much.
I love I heart because I've been there for almost a decade. It'll be a decade.
Just assemble. And, you know, they've they've always allowed me that. They've always allowed me that when it comes to, you know, the guests that I want to have on the show,
the conversations that we want to have on the show. They've never came and said, hey, y'all are just a hip hop radio show. Focus on that. It's like we we stretch the gamut from social justice to politics, to comedy, to mental health and mindfulness, to spiritual leaders, faith leaders.
We're able to be creative and have that flexibility.
And that's why I thought that they were the perfect partner for what I wanted to do with this podcast network. There was a lot of, it was always interesting when you start dealing with
what happens in the whole social media space in terms of when people get caught up
in beefs and all this sort of stuff like that.
I posted the other day, I was like, look, I listen.
You and I talk.
We've talked about a number of other things offline over the last couple of years.
I've been to Breakfast Club as well.
When I commented the other day on Joe Button, people, uh, offline, uh, over the last couple of years, I've been the breakfast club as well. Uh, when I commented the other day on Joe button, people like, Oh, here's my, here's my biggest
problem. This is my biggest problem. And all these other people who I think would draw the talking,
the reality is there are people in all of these spaces who do different things.
Y'all show us on our heart. Guess what? That's cool. That's no different than Robin Roberts being on ABC.
There are folks, look, my show, I'm independent.
I'm independently owned.
We've had independent record labels,
and we've had individuals who've had record label deals.
Master P had his own company but had a distribution deal.
Other folks had record label deals.
What I'm trying to get our people to understand
is to stop getting caught up in mess,
stop wanting to see him be spectators like, ooh, who fighting who,
and to learn what people are doing who are talking about controlling their own fate.
That, to me, is the most important thing.
I just think there are a lot of people who just spend too much time on mess as opposed to, no, no, no.
How are people moving things forward? No matter what lane you're operating in that,
that that's important to me because what I'm seeing is in this moment,
in the aftermath of George Floyd, this is, this is the third reconstruction.
This is the moment where we should be saying of any moment in our lifetimes.
No, no, we're demanding ownership and a much larger piece of the pie.
I agree with you 100%.
You know, me and Reverend Barber talk about this being a new reconstruction era.
And I think that's the main thing we all have to do, right?
Like you're either going to do, you're either going to listen to one or two people.
You're going to listen to the people who aren't doing it, try to tell you how to get it done. Or you're going to listen to the people who are doing it, you know, tell you how you can do it
too. And guess what? Even if I tell you, you still may not do it because you're not me. You're not
Roland Martin. Like our, our, our paths are different. You know, our, our experiences are
different. The way we got to where we are now is different.
So we all have our own individual leverage and you have to use it.
You know, I'm not I'm not mad at the way anybody does anything.
I think that sometimes, you know, when you're a personality, a media personality, you get on your podcast, you get on your radio show.
And we have conversations that we might need to be having amongst each other. You know, and I think that's where, um, that's,
that's where it gets tricky because we're inviting everybody else in to
conversations we should be, be having amongst each other.
And we all do that, by the way, you know, like, like, like I might do it to Joe.
Joe might do it to, you know, Gillian Wallow. Like we all have, it's like,
it's like discussing basketball. It's like, Oh,
this person got a deal over here,
that person got a deal over here,
or this person's contract looks like this.
It's just that we got to make sure
we know what we're talking about
if we're going to speak on certain things.
That's all.
Yeah, I mean, like, I've had people
who come to me and they say,
well, you know, man, you should be doing this, this, this.
And I'm looking at them going, no.
In fact, I mean, I had a very prominent individual who
you and I both know
who said, man, this interview was great.
We need to take these clips and break it apart
and send it across the internet. I was like, nah,
we good. He was like, yeah, but
young folks don't look at long
clips. I went,
actually, this is our time
spent viewing on our show.
I said, this is the revenue that we're now generating
from those very same clips and how we've tripled it in the last five months.
And the person was like, oh, damn.
So I was like, yeah, in your mind that, and again,
there are people who do short clips.
That's what they do.
They do the 30 second, 60 second.
But the reality is we purposely do a two-hour show
because our time spent listening
is higher than some other people.
We got people who are watching 9, 12, 15,
18-minute, 20-minute videos.
So that dispels the notion. That's why I said,
hey, if you want to do what you do, go right ahead.
But trust me, it's working fine for us.
Yeah, is that something that that person
is doing theyself or is that something
they saw working for other people?
Yeah, they do it, but their motive
is different. Okay, okay.
Okay. I mean, YouTube
is your platform though, Roland. I mean, it depends.
Like, if you're trying to, you know, use your
social media page to get people to come back
to your YouTube, yeah, I can see why
they might ask you to, you know, shorten the clips and put them on social media, but I people to come back to your YouTube yeah I could see why you know they might ask you to you know shorten the clips and put them on social
media but I I know people come to you for YouTube that's the platform that
right you know you're cultivating you got to do it the way you want it to and
what they don't realize is with YouTube the video needs to be at least 10
minutes so we can drop for commercials in it it's the studying of the and that's the that's
the thing that i want to talk to you about real quick because i know you got to go people need to
be students of the business to learn the business as opposed to getting caught up in man i got you
know like instagram i got 545 000 instagram followers yeah but instagram has no monetization
program so you can load all
this up on Instagram, but it's
actually not making you money unless
you have a product that you're selling or
it's driving you elsewhere.
So it's not getting caught up in the hype of
your numbers. It's how
can you monetize this thing?
That is very true. I mean, what
you said about studying the game
is the key because what I like to do is I like to see what's missing in the marketplace.
You know, I don't like to see I don't like to do what everybody else is doing.
I got like two, two, three years ago because I've always I've always been a part owner of a podcast network, the loudspeaker network.
You know, rest in peace, my man, Combat Jack, salute to my guy, Chris Moreau.
So I've always been a part owner for like the past six years in the loudspeaker network, you know, rest in peace, my man, combat Jack, salute to my guy, Chris Moreau. So I've always been a part owner for like the past six years in the loudspeaker
network.
So I was just literally just watching the landscape of what all of these
various podcast networks were doing. So I saw what Gimlet was doing.
I saw what, you know, Bill Simmons was doing with the ringer.
I saw what anchor was doing.
So when they started getting these hundred million dollar deals,
$200 million deals, $200 million
deals, I wasn't surprised because I knew that they had
all of this IP
under their network. So I just sat back and started
thinking to myself, like, man, why
don't we have
a black
podcast network?
I think about BET in the 90s.
I wanted to create...
I want this to be to the audio space what BET was to TV in the 90s.
That was always my mindset when I was, you know, developing this and putting this together.
It literally came from just studying the game and realizing, okay, that's what's missing in the marketplace right now.
Well, you're absolutely right.
And, in fact, it's so funny.
You know, Jay Feldman, my former EP,
when we started this, Jay was like,
DeRoy, you should do audio podcasts.
And I was like, nah.
And he kept, he was like, why?
And I said, well, actually, you know,
I created the first black news source audio podcast
in 2005.
Then I did a video podcast in 2006.
And I said, I've already done it.
And he was like, yeah, but that was a podcast in 1.0.
I'm like, yeah, but I've already done it.
I knew I wanted to create a video show with, to your point, nobody else was doing.
And so I was like, if we're able to create this beachhead and then build it from there,
then all of a sudden we're doing something that nobody else is doing.
And that's really what the month of April was.
And then what happened?
Fox Soul comes out after that.
Then ABC, CB, all these people, NBC launches a digital news deal.
And so now, but we're still, again, the only ones that's black-owned, that's independent
in the space.
And that's the whole point. When you're able to carve out your niche, then you're able to build something.
Final thoughts. Yeah. First, the market is very important.
You know, I saw I think today Amazon launched that they're doing a podcast network and they have like DJ Khaled and Will Smith over there.
And if I'm not mistaken, it's with LeBron James Production Company,
you know, Spring Hill, you know?
So I just feel like, you know, it's good to be,
it's good to be first to market, you know?
Like I said, BET in the 90s is my motivation.
I don't think we give Bob Johnson enough credit.
Bob and Sheila Johnson.
Bob and Sheila Johnson.
I mean, that's still to this day
the largest black exit of any entrepreneur.
I think it was like $3.2 billion.
Yeah, $3.3 billion.
I'm going to be breaking down
next week, though,
because if you read
Brett Pulley's book,
BET should have been sold
for about $10 billion plus
because I'm going to give you
this real quick.
And I'm going to just give you this
and probably because you have iHeart as a partner,
this speaks to it.
In the book, BET was getting $1,500 for a 30-second spot
when MTV was getting $8,000.
Sumner Redstone and Mel Carmisen said,
oh, if we bought BET, we could now start getting $8,000.
They were devaluing the black viewer
compared to the white viewer on MTV.
Had BET been getting the 8,000 instead of the 1,500,
BET would have been worth five times more
what they would have been generating
from the advertising revenue.
So the battle that we have right now,
even with what you're launching and what I have,
is to say to these ad agencies, don't y'all devalue the black customer like you have been doing.
You pay fair market value.
So in podcasting, don't say, well, because Joe Rogan's audience is white or Bill Simmons is white, they are more valuable than Charlamagne's audience or my audience.
That's the next beat. That's the next battle that we have to confront
these agencies over.
Yeah, I think these ad agencies know now
that black is gold.
You know, back in the 90s,
hip-hop was still being kind of looked at
as a niche thing, you know,
as a flavor of the month kind of thing.
So I think that's why...
And don't get me wrong, they still do devalue the black dollar,
but I think we have a lot more respect for it now.
I think so, especially right now in this current moment.
It's a little more respect, but the next piece,
and trust me, we'll talk offline about this,
is when it comes to getting those dollars.
Look, $100 billion is spent every year
when it comes to advertising.
I'm asking the question,
how much of that is going to black-owned media?
Not black-targeted, black-owned media.
Because the federal government
spends $5 billion a year on advertising.
Black media gets $35 million.
Yeah, and you know what's interesting?
91%.
These ad agencies,
they'll ask that question nowadays, too.
They want to make sure that the platform you're on is really black-owned.
Yeah, so.
Oh, so, yeah.
Well.
Absolutely.
So congratulations on it.
We'll be watching it.
Good luck and chat soon.
Thank you, Roland.
I appreciate it.
Thanks a bunch.
Folks, got to go to a break.
We'll be back on Roland Martin Unfiltered in just a moment.
As our community comes together to support the fight against racial injustice,
I want to take a second to talk about one thing we can do to ensure our voices are heard,
not tomorrow, but now. Have your voices heard in terms of what kind of future we want by taking
the 2020 census today at 2020census.gov? Now, folks, let me help you out. The census is a count
of everyone living in the country. It happens once every 10 years. It is mandated by the U.S.
Constitution. The thing that's important is that the census informs funding, billions of dollars,
how they are spent in our communities every single year. I grew up in Clinton Park in Houston, Texas, and we wanted new parks and roads
and a senior citizen center.
Well, the census helps inform all of that
and where funding goes.
It also determines how many seats your state will get
in the US House of Representatives.
Young black men and young children of color
are historically undercounted,
which means a potential loss of
funding or services that helps our community. Folks, we have the power to change that. We have
the power to help determine where hundreds of billions in federal funding go each year for the
next 10 years. Funding that can impact our community, our neighborhoods, and our families and friends. Folks, responses are
100% confidential and can't be shared with your landlord, law enforcement, or any government
agency. So please take the 2020 Census today. Shape your future. Start at 2020census.gov.
Hi, I'm Shanice. You got just one vote, so use it.
All right, folks.
Do we have we need these interviews with various folks about the importance of voting.
Do we have the Lisa Ray video ready?
OK, play it.
Let me say this.
I've always voted because my mama made me to.
Made me to.
But the first time I really gave a damn,
honestly, Clinton.
Bill Clinton.
Yep.
92.
Yep.
I used to vote for who my mama voted for.
So you, so growing up, that was practice.
She voted.
Did you ever go to the polls with her when she voted.
And so she'd say, look, we're going.
She would make me sit and watch the different speeches that they would have throughout the time.
And then I assume as a kid, I would go in and out of, what is this?
And why?
You know, da-da-da-da-da, kind of thing.
And as I got older, she wanted to make sure that my vote counted.
So it was like, come on.
And it was like, okay.
All right, folks, bring our panel back.
Robert, Lauren, as well as Scott.
Y'all all there? Yep. The conversation we just had with Charlemagne is an important one because I continue to insist, Robert, that we have to
control the narrative. And if we don't, we're going to be asking somebody else to tell our story.
You're completely correct. And one of the things I think we have to remember is that America and
Western civilization in general has a well-worn history of white people getting rich off of black
intellectual property, off of black hard work, out of black art and music and dance and performance
and intellectualism.
And so we're not able to step out and create platforms for ourselves,
create indices for ourselves.
Just as Reverend Jackson did with the Rainbow Push Trade Bureau
and many of the other Saturday morning broadcasts,
which was revolutionary at its time, to ensure that we control that narrative,
we control the revenue, because then you can bring on black camera companies.
Then you can bring on black camera companies and you can bring on
black production companies. You can bring on black caterers, black limo services. So the
economics of controlling your own narrative, controlling your own intellectual properties
is always going to pay off more in the long run. You ain't going to get rich working nobody's job.
Lauren, the point I made about advertising is important because that's really how the business operates.
And if we are being devalued and not getting our fair share, we can't grow.
We can't build capacity. We can't hire more people.
And so that's the thing. And what also has to happen is other black media companies can't be taken far less because that then sets the table.
They say, well, we gave so-and-so that. I'm like, well, ain't my problem.
They devalue themselves.
Yeah, so many companies negotiate from a position
and negotiate against themselves
and actually bring down the market value
by accepting cheaper deals.
And obviously, ownership and control
is the entire ballgame.
We do in this country, African-Americans set the culture.
You know, we are the ones that create culture so many times and don't get paid for it.
And we actually, I remember one time in the green room a few years ago when the show was
on TV one, there was a musician there.
I think it was a barbershop.
There was a few musicians in the green room
and I was trying to figure out why it was
with the technology that we have now,
why it was anybody needs a record company.
Because if you have your own,
if you have your own,
you used to be distribution was the reason
and you needed them for distribution promotion and
Now I'm not too sure why anybody needs a record company other than the tape money from the artists to do all the work
Which has been the tradition of record companies in America. Well, that's it
Well, that's it that first of all and what you what they did was remember that was a point when you had a lot of
Record labels, but then the majors are like, oh, but Motown and others are like,
no, no, no, hold on.
So we got to change the game.
So now we're going to say, well, forget the music business.
We're going to control the distribution.
So if you saw that Master P special that was on BET,
remember, Master P had a record label, but he cut a distribution deal.
Now, it was interesting watching all these white execs
with, I think it was Priority Records,
which was the distribution company.
They made no music, but they controlled the distribution.
And so Master P, and I was sitting there watching,
and I was kind of like,
why in the hell he got to cut a deal with them?
And so that's the game.
That's the game in terms of, oh, same thing in movies, okay?
People talk about, Tyler Perry got his own studio.
No, no, no, no, no.
Who controls the distribution of the product?
Lauren, go ahead.
I was just going to say that the distribution now is so easy
because we're dealing with digital files,
which I thought it was always funny that Apple kind of hoodwinked us
into everything
had to be controlled through the iTunes marketplace, if you will.
Like, it used to be, remember when the kid from Napster created that platform where anybody
could download and listen to music, period?
Of course, they sued him and they stopped him.
Then they controlled it back into iTunes.
But when you think about it, if you're as talented as Beyonce and Jay-Z,
your distribution is a downloaded file. So I'm always wondering why people don't just go around
that. I don't know enough about music to know the answer. I'll explain to you. I'll explain to you.
And Scott, your lawyer is very simple. And as is here, people want to congregate in certain places.
And so what they've done is the distribution model today is where the people already are.
OK, so now it's if you're Apple, they have millions of these devices.
So they have communities that are already built in and they've made it
easier for you simply to go click. I bought it. And so the consumer's like, I don't want to have
to go to here, to here, to here. Can I just get it all in one place? But what, what, what, what I'm
arguing, which is what I argue when, um, I argue about this when, um, I was talking about boozy
the other day, Scott, and Instagram.
He's begging to get back on Instagram.
I'm like, Boozy, this is real simple.
If you actually take, because he said he was going to pay Instagram $100,000 and let him back on their platform. I was like, Boozy, why don't you take that $100,000 and give it to a black developer?
And you can actually create your own social media platform and tell your fans come
check me out right here the dip what they've done is and trust me not now now here's the deal
somebody right now is watching scott and they're saying well yeah roland you're on youtube facebook
and periscope for a short while because what you have to do is what the artists have done you get in build your name
up you all of a sudden you create the resonance now now if you're beyonce or drake or you actually
don't need the record labels because you can actually create your own ecosystem that's really
what's at play so they want to control the access by saying we've got
millions of eyeballs is easier over here. And that's why Apple is getting sued because they're
saying, if you put any in in-app purchases, we got to get 30 percent. And the company's like,
why the hell I got to give you 30 percent? Right, right, right, right, right. You know, this is a complex issue because we are so programmed as black people to believe that bigger is better.
Or there, the majority's ice is cold.
If you're going to be an entrepreneur and you're going to lead and build, and what you're talking about, Roland, you've been talking about even before it became popular.
You've got to believe in yourself.
Take that risk, right?
You had a post a week or two ago about this show
and how two or three years ago you said,
I've got to go, I've got to do this now,
I've been wanting to do it.
And we have to be fearless as entrepreneurs, right?
And be aggressive and
believe that this market, black or white, will support us if we have a great concept, precept,
or a great product, if you will. We got to protect it. And then black people got to support each
other. See, we still have this inferiority conflict when it comes to entrepreneurship.
Not all of us, but a lot of the consumerism
that black people engage in. People ask you all the time, well, you know, you're not on one of
the network, you're not on cable. Well, you don't want to be on cable. You got a great product right
here. You get any guests you want to come on and you got a great following, but you got to be
fearless and take that leap of faith, right? Obviously, you believe in God, but you got to do
that if you really believe in yourself. And so often we say, well, I'd like to do that, or I'd
like to do that, but you got to be willing to take the risk. And so many of us don't take that risk,
or black people think they shouldn't follow you or watch you because you're not on one of the
networks, right? People get their news, the majority, from
the platform, other platforms.
They're not just three or four
news stations anymore.
Who cares about the cable stations
when you can get stuff online?
I got $20, 25 years old,
26 years old, and they'll tell you,
where do you get your news from?
I do. Instagram,
I get it off the internet, blah, blah, blah.
Twitter, Facebook, that's where the majority of people are getting their news. I don't even get
a newspaper anymore. I don't know how many other people do. And so you got to be fearless,
but black people have to support us in these various platforms. And we got to be fearless
in what we set up and believe in ourselves.
Yep.
That's it.
Scott,
Robert,
Lauren,
I certainly appreciate you being on our panel today.
Thank you so very much,
folks.
I just want to read some of the letters here.
We got this letter here from Rosalind Fluker Powell.
She said,
I just happened upon your show the last three months because I now have
unlimited interest on my smartphone.
They were informative, educational,
thought-provoking, and entertaining.
I am addicted, so I certainly appreciate
it. We got a note here on the side.
Simply said, Mr. Martin, thank you.
This is from
Larry and Gwen Mitchell. Thank you for opening
my eyes to what's going on in the world
around me. We have joined the Bring the
Funk fan club. This is
Zeke Shabazz.
Roland, say hello to your panel.
I watch your show daily, and it's good to know that your voice will never be silenced.
By the way, the beginning of this very short letter is saying, what's up, Roland?
He said, pup, just keep doing what you're doing.
Talk to you later.
Bye.
We have a note here.
This is from Brenda DST Perryman.
She's a Delta.
I pray this will help with your movement. Stay strong, my brother. From Brenda DST Perryman. She's a Delta.
I pray this will help with your movement.
Stay strong, my brother.
And it's just simply, the card says, thank you, thank you, thank you.
I love this here from Erna Lisa Lovett and her daughter, Nisha Lovett.
I'm sending $100 for membership for myself and my daughter, Nisha. She is 26 years old.
I need her listening to your broadcast
and become more active in her blackness.
I've been watching you for two years.
I love what you're doing.
Thank you for your passion.
Continue to allow God to use you.
And so, again, I certainly appreciate that letter there.
Let's see here.
Elton Hooper Jr. with StopTheInjustice Now.org, founder, CEO.
Keep on keeping on with your good work for the black community.
This is a short note. Thank you from Detroit. So we appreciate that.
To Mr. Martin, I'd like to thank you for all the great unfiltered shows.
Love them every night when I'm at work. I have time to watch them. Keep up the great work.
Yo, you better do your work. Stay on the crazy-ass white folks, the ones who think that we're
supposed to take crap from them. Thanks again, Joseph Leith, again, who contributed about $150
to our Bring the Funk fan club. Last one I'm going to read today, James Bond Sr. I watch a
Black news show every night. I really appreciate listening to black news and all the professional men and women that you invite. I'm very proud of what you do for the
black community. I used to get so angry when the white news did not give the black community all
the news. Please keep up the good work and I'm going to continue to watch your show. I've learned
so much from the new show. I'm donating $25 to help you keep this new show going again. Thank
you very much.
Folks, I appreciate all of these notes.
I'm going to read some more tomorrow.
If y'all want to join our Bring the Funk fan club,
more than 12,000 of you have joined our fan club.
Our goal is to ask you to give $50 each.
If you're on YouTube, you can give right through on YouTube.
$50 each, $4.19 a month, $0 13 cents a day. Your dollars make it possible for us to do
this. Also, I want to let y'all know the three presidential debates will begin this month and
in October. Your dollars will help us. We're going to have debate coverage of those debates.
So you can ignore those cable news shows for post-debate analysis.
We're going to do it right here to give our perspective and our analysis.
That's why your dollars matter.
Cash app, dollar sign, cash app, forward slash, dollar sign, RM unfiltered,
paypal.me, forward slash, RM unfiltered, venmo.com, forward slash, RM unfiltered.
You can send a money order to New Vision Media, NU Vision Media, Inc., 1625 K Street, NW, Suite 400, Washington, D.C., 2006.
And to join our fan club, if you want to, we want you to, of course, subscribe to our YouTube channel.
Turn on your notifications so when we go live, it notifies you.
Be sure to watch our clips on YouTube as well.
That generates dollars for our
show. Again, if you're on YouTube, nearly 4,000 of you right now, y'all can give right there on
YouTube or y'all can go to RolandMartinUnfiltered.com. You can pay using a square credit card as well
or PayPal, Venmo, or Cash Out. Let me give some shout outs here. These are the people who have
given on Venmo 50 bucks or more. You get a personal shout out here. These are the people who have given on Venmo
50 bucks or more. You get a personal shout out. Robert Young, Karen and Calvin Kidd,
Renee Allen Fulton, Terrence Jackson, Stephen Franklin, Sandra Nixon, Nicole Alexander,
April Motley, Ty Carter, Pashtah Tate, Preston Cherry, Kimberly Hunter, Danielle Cumberbatch,
Janice Martin, Jean Patrice Willoughby, Emmy, Bob Manuel, Donna Gibson, Latrice Reed,
Joycelyn Williams, Robert Young, Rick Nolan,
Pamela Jones, Juanita Wiggins, Adrian Stevenson.
These are the folks who sent checks in.
$50 or more, you get a personal shout-out.
Jean Howell, Romilly Adams, Fendrick Bush,
Ang Lee Love, Dolores Jones, Edna Sanders,
Kimberly Nash Williams, Everett Totris,
Linda Graham Swanson, Delbert Hudson, Roderick Ballot, Lorraine Calhoun, Gail Artis, Denise Isaac
Tolliver, Jerry Connell Williams, Beverly Caldwell, Carol McKee, Brenda Johnson, Cidar
Printing, James Gurin, Jerry Lummings, David Famous, the Jack Yates Class of 1972.
You didn't put your name on it. You just put Jack Yates Class of 1972. You didn't put your name on it.
You just put Jack Yates class of 1972.
I'm a martyr.
I appreciate it.
I'm class of 87, though.
Jerry Arhen, Chandra Drayton, Michelle Hammons, Douglas Carrington,
Susie Banks, Randy Dotson, Mary Robinson, Sharon Rogers,
Billie Jean Feagin, Lorene Calhoun, Calvin Cunningham, and Greta Master.
And so I thank all of you who have contributed to our Bring the Funk fan club.
Thank you so very much.
Hey, Henry, zoom out.
So I shouted out Michelle Hammonds, y'all.
So I wore a shirt yesterday from Tammy Green.
So Michelle Hammonds made this T-shirt, and I'm wearing it today.
I'm going to go ahead and just stand up.
All right, so go ahead and zoom in on it.
Zoom in on me.
So you see what Michelle did was so michelle had this shirt made she put uh roll up a hashtag roller martin unfiltered daily digital news here at the top uh you see here she so she put these
are all the slogans i use on the show so bring the funk what the hell? Tried to tell you the right kind
of black. Soledad talked
about that. It's about damn time.
So Michelle, thank you very
much for sending me a couple of these
shirts. I certainly appreciate it.
And of course, the last one you see
right over here is how we're going to end the show.
I'll see y'all guys tomorrow.
Holla! I know a lot of cops.
They get asked all the time,
have you ever had to shoot your gun?
Sometimes the answer is yes.
But there's a company dedicated to a future
where the answer will always be no. This is Absolute Season 1, Taser Incorporated.
I get right back there and it's bad.
Listen to Absolute Season 1, Taser Incorporated on the iHeartRadio app,
Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts.
I'm Clayton English.
I'm Greg Glott.
And this is season two of the War on Drugs podcast.
Yes, sir.
Last year, a lot of the problems of the drug war.
This year, a lot of the biggest names in music and sports.
This kind of starts that a little bit, man.
We met them at their homes.
We met them at their recording studios.
Stories matter, and it brings a face to it.
It makes it real. It really it. It makes it real.
It really does. It makes it real.
Listen to new episodes of the War on Drugs
podcast season 2 on the iHeart
radio app, Apple podcast, or
wherever you get your podcast.
Here's the deal.
We gotta set ourselves up.
See, retirement is
the long game. We gotta make
moves and make them early.
Set up goals.
Don't worry about a setback.
Just save up and stack up to reach them.
Let's put ourselves in the right position.
Pre-game to greater things.
Start building your retirement plan at thisispretirement.org.
Brought to you by AARP and the Ad Council.
This is an iHeartVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVotersVoters