Scamfluencers - Martha Stewart: The Homemaker Hustler Part 2

Episode Date: January 15, 2024

In the summer of 2003, Martha Stewart is indicted for obstruction of justice and lying to investigators. She stubbornly maintains her innocence and vows to fight the charges, but her cover-up... falls apart during a messy and humiliating public trial. She and her stockbroker are facing prison time, but she’s determined to come out on top – no matter what it takes to get there.See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.

Transcript
Discussion (0)
Starting point is 00:00:00 Hey, Pride members, you can listen to scamfluencers early and add free on Amazon music. Download the app today. This is the second episode in our two-part series on Martha Stewart. I promise you, it's worth it to start from the beginning, so if you haven't heard part one yet, do that first, and then come back. I'll be here waiting for you. Sarah, are you like me? I wonder what you're gonna do. Sarah, are you like me? We're really afraid of prison.
Starting point is 00:00:28 Like, I think I'm out at a lot. I think I watched maybe too much to get it straight as a kid. Yeah, I'm definitely really afraid of prison. It's the exact same reason I watched so much beyond the scared straight. Fair enough. Well, I asked because in our last episode,
Starting point is 00:00:44 Martha Stewart was feeling the heat for lying to federal investigators. Our champion of cream-colored napkins and elegant sunflower arrangements, it's known for a lot of things, but the centerpiece of her reputation isn't so glamorous. Let me take you to the time Martha Girlbost so hard that she ended up in prison. so hard that she ended up in prison. It's June 4, 2003, and Martha Stewart is being chauffeured through Laura Manhattan in a black town car. It's a rainy afternoon, but she's prepared for the storm. She's wearing an off-white trench coat
Starting point is 00:01:16 over a gray double-breasted blazer. It's giving J. Crew meets Commander-in-Chief. She's 61, but with her layered blonde bob and perfect skin, she looks much younger. She's not far from the headquarters of her company, Martha Stewart Living Omnimedia, but this morning's destination is a federal courthouse. When her car pulls up, Martha is swarmed by shouting reporters. Martha Stewart, please tell you an exact — Martha brushes past without saying a word.
Starting point is 00:01:45 At a news conference earlier that day, U.S. Attorney James Comey announced that Martha and her stockbroker, Peter Buchanovic, had been federally indicted. Now, she's not being indicted for insider trading. The SEC is charging her for that. Instead, the feds are going after her for attempting to cover up the trade.
Starting point is 00:02:03 The official charges are obstructing justice and lying to investigators. Here's how Komi broke it down at a news conference. This criminal case is about lying. Martha Stewart is being prosecuted not because of who she is, but because of what she did. It is crazy to remember James Komi existed in a different context outside of Trump. Yeah, he used to said like another job. Well rumors have been swirling
Starting point is 00:02:28 about Martha's potential role in an insider trading scandal for about a year and a half now. And the media cannot get enough. She's been parodied on late night talk shows and in the tabloids. Just last month, she was portrayed as an insufferable tyrant in a made for TV movie starring civil shepherd,
Starting point is 00:02:45 like in this scene where she's on the set of her cooking show and starts freaking out over Lime Beans. I'm sitting here talking about Lime Beans and there aren't any. Someone in my staff forgot to put out the Lime Beans. Excuse me. Why is everyone here so stupid? Put this in the criterion collection, brilliant.
Starting point is 00:03:06 Would it surprise you to know I've seen this movie so many times? I have never seen this, never heard of it. We'll watch Too Night. It's a classic. Well, despite all this ridicule, Martha has stubbornly maintained her innocence, which is exactly what she does today
Starting point is 00:03:20 when she pleads not guilty. But this indictment is a serious blow to her company and to her reputation. After she leaves the courthouse, her company announces that she's stepping down as chairwoman and CEO. But Martha is still staying on as chief executive officer and she'll continue to rake in more than a million dollars annually.
Starting point is 00:03:40 Plus, she's still the company's controlling shareholder. The day after her indictment, Martha launches a new kind of media venture, a website called MarthaTalks.com to share updates about her legal battle. She writes an open letter and allows her fans to send her emails. She also takes out a full-page ad in USA Today to double down on her message of innocence. Martha is pulling out all the stops in her media blitz, but she knows she's about to lose control of the narrative. And when she does, the uncomfortable truth will finally come out.
Starting point is 00:04:16 I'm Afroher. I'm Peter Fragerpan. And in our new podcast Legacy, we explore the lives of some of the biggest characters in history. This season, we delve into the life of Pablo Picasso. The ultimate giant of modern art, everyone has heard of or seen a Picasso work. All the Picasso brand on something. But a man with a complicated, difficult, personal side too,
Starting point is 00:04:39 that makes us look at his art in a different way. He was a genius and he was very problematic. Follow Legacy Now, wherever you get your podcasts. You can binge entire seasons of Legacy Add Free on Amazon Music, or by subscribing to Wondery Plus on Apple Podcasts, or the Wondery app. Now streaming only on Freebie. You invited my ex-fiancé to Christmas.
Starting point is 00:05:04 You know, I really should go. You're not going anywhere. Bring on FreeV. You invited my ex-fiancé to Christmas. You know, I really should go. You're not going anywhere. Bring on the games. My family will work up the courage to ask you to leave before Christmas morning. You want a bed? Starring Layton, Mr. and Robbie Amel. You're gone.
Starting point is 00:05:16 Where you're gone? Ex-Mess. Now streaming only on FreeV. From Wondry, I'm Sachi Cole, and I'm Sarah Haggi, and this is Scanflinkers. In our last episode, we followed Martha Stewart's rise from stockbroker to self-made billionaire to one of the biggest celebrities on the planet. And her fame only got bigger when she became the center of an insider trading scandal that threatened to destroy her company, her reputation, and her relationships. Now, Martha, her stockbroker Peter, and their friend Sam are facing prison time.
Starting point is 00:05:58 But Martha is determined to come out on top and leave even her closest allies in the dust. This is Martha Stewart, the whole maker hustler, part two. About a week after Martha's indictment, Sam Waxel stands before a judge in the same Manhattan courthouse. He's 55 years old and dressed in a dark blue suit. Sarah, what do you remember about Sam? He's a guy who developed the cancer drug that hasn't been released yet, but has a lot of buzz. And most importantly, he's the one who's committing insider trading. Yes, great, full marks. It's been about a year since Sam was charged with 13 counts of securities fraud, conspiracy,
Starting point is 00:06:43 perjury, and obstruction of justice. At first, he maintained his innocence, just like Martha did. But eventually, he admitted to transferring tens of thousands of shares of his company's stock into his daughter's brokerage account and then telling her to sell. He also admitted to telling his daughter to lie to SEC investigators last year. Here's what he says to 60 minutes.
Starting point is 00:07:04 Because I actually believe that we could rectify the situation with the FDA very quickly, I didn't think I was going to get caught at all. But now, Sam's facing significant present time. He's been doing everything he can to show that he's learned his lesson. He even wrote the judge a six-page letter that reference Al-Berakemu's the stranger and the Talmud.
Starting point is 00:07:25 But it's not just Sam writing letters. He also rallies more than 120 of his friends and family members to do the same. Some of them are even written by cancer patients who are hopeful about Erbatox, the drug that Sam helped develop. It's the one that tanked Imclone's stock when it didn't get FDA approval.
Starting point is 00:07:42 Other letters are written by high-profile New Yorkers, like a retired justice on the State Supreme Court and the actress Lorraine Braco, who is currently starring on a little show called The Sopranos. You know, there are episodes where celebrities randomly pop in and like it kind of makes sense, but Lorraine Braco? Yeah, Lorraine Braco. Well, in the courtroom, Sam delivers a heartfelt monologue for the judge, saying, yeah, Lorraine Braco. Well, in the courtroom, Sam delivers a heartfelt monologue for the judge, saying, quote,
Starting point is 00:08:07 I know that life begins on the other side of despair. He says he really tried to help cancer patients, but the judge isn't buying any of it. He finds Sam $3 million and hands out the maximum sentence, seven years and three months behind bars. The night before he goes to prison, Sam throws a let's party like it's my last night of freedom bash.
Starting point is 00:08:29 At his loft in Soho, he hands out $600 magnums of Chateau left-feet Rothschild to guests, including Sarah Lorraine. She reportedly tries to comfort Sam by telling him lots of inmates use the prison payphones for sex. Rumor has it, Sam then propositions the women up a party. If I call you from jail, can we have phone sex?
Starting point is 00:08:50 Is this her experience from being in like, good fellows and the sopranos? She's like, yeah, trust me, I did my research, this happens all the time. Well, at one point, Sam's phone rings. And after he hangs up, he reportedly announces to the party that Martha herself called to send her regards.
Starting point is 00:09:09 While her friends are guzzling champagne, Martha is laying low. And she's likely thinking about her own future. She's always been the queen of everything clean and tidy, but her messy public trial is about to air her dirtiest laundry. About six months after Sam reports to prison, Martha and her co-defendant Peter go to trial. It's late January 2004, and reporters from all over the country crowd into the courtroom every day,
Starting point is 00:09:36 desperate for the drama. But the truth is, the trial has been pretty boring so far. One reporter even describes the finance heavy proceedings as excruciating. But that all changes in early February when 28-year-old Doug Fenuel takes the stand. You might remember Doug from our last episode. He's the Ben Affleck look alike who used to be Peter's assistant and Mara Lynch, but not anymore.
Starting point is 00:10:00 Both of them were fired in the wake of the insider trading scandal. Up until a few months ago, Doug backed up Peter and Martha's cover story. He insisted that Martha had always planned to sell her shares of Imclon when the stock fell below $60. But after the government charged Doug with aiding in the cover-up, he flipped, and agreed to cooperate in exchange for a lighter punishment.
Starting point is 00:10:20 To Doug, taking the fall for a client just wasn't worth it, especially when like Martha, who he actively disliked. The tabloids had a field day. A lowly assistant getting revenge on his wealthy boss and their most famous client, headline gold. Suddenly, Doug was America's sweetheart. You know, I remember looking at a photo of Doug and he's a beautiful man, and now he's America's sweetheart,
Starting point is 00:10:44 you know? We love a bad boy gone good with a great jaw Doug and he's a beautiful man and now he's America sweetheart, you know? We love a bad boy gone good with a great jawline, that's for sure. Well, now on the stand, Doug talks about the day his boss, Peter learned that Imclone stocks were about to trend down. Doug says that Peter called him and told him, quote, oh my god, get Martha on the phone. So Doug did just that. And then on Martha's instruction, he proceeded to sell nearly 4,000 of her shares of Imclon. This directly contradicts what Martha and Peter have been telling investigators.
Starting point is 00:11:13 Doug also says that he initially lied to the FBI and the SEC because Peter bribed him, offering him a paid vacation, an airline ticket, and additional pay. Peter's defense attorney tries to discredit Doug by bringing up his drug use. Doug admits to using cocaine, ketamine, and ecstasy, though never well on the job.
Starting point is 00:11:32 So you're telling me that a guy in stocks isn't snorkeling coke all the time? Yeah, please. I saw Wolf of Wall Street. Seems like it's the norm. Well, the defense also tries to paint Doug as someone with a vendetta against Martha. They ask him to read from emails he sent during his time at Maryland.
Starting point is 00:11:49 In one email to a friend, Doug described an early phone conversation with Martha by saying that he had, quote, never ever been treated more rudely by a stranger on the telephone. Sarah, can you read the rest of his email? Yeah, he says, she made the most ridiculous sound I've heard coming from an adult in quite some time. Kind of like a lion roaring underwater. I laughed, I thought she was joking. And then she yelled, Merrill Lynch is laying off 10,000 employees
Starting point is 00:12:15 because of people like that idiot. And then she hung up. I feel like he probably has dealt with so many difficult people that it's kind of weak to make it seem like you had a personal vendetta against her. Yeah. And like the other thing Sarah is that the strategy just kind of backfires, right?
Starting point is 00:12:33 The defense is trying to show that Doug is biased against Martha, but they just end up reinforcing Martha's reputation as a jerk. And Peter's lawyers don't stop there. They also bring in an email Doug wrote wrote to his boyfriend, where he said, quote, Martha yelled at me again today, but I snapped at her face and she actually back down. Baby put Miss Martha in her place. Brave. Doug is so brave for that. And you know what? She probably respected it.
Starting point is 00:12:59 Yeah, she probably did. Doug isn't the only one to shake up the trial. One of Martha's oldest friends testifies that she remembers Martha saying, not too long after dumping her in-clone stock, quote, isn't it nice to have a broker who will tell you things? And Martha's former assistant
Starting point is 00:13:15 breaks down sobbing on the stand after saying she saw Martha tamper with evidence. About a month later, the jury reaches a verdict. They find Martha and Peter guilty of conspiracy, obstruction of justice, and lying to federal investigators. Martha's daughter Alexis is so shocked that she faints in court. Doug manages to avoid prison and probation. He gets off with a misdemeanor and a $2,000 fine for accepting a payoff from Peter during the investigation. He gets teary-eyed as he apologizes to the courtroom and reads a prepared statement. He says, quote,
Starting point is 00:13:48 �Basing an aggressive legal assault on my character, I didn't believe that the truth would carry enough weight to be heard clearly, particularly against rich and powerful people. I was wrong, and for that I'm immensely grateful. And more importantly, baby has put Martha in her place. It's a cloudy Friday in July of 2004, about four months after Martha was found guilty. She stands on the steps of the courthouse looking uncharacteristically exhausted. She's wearing a black-collared suit jacket
Starting point is 00:14:18 and modest diamond earrings, and her hair is a little less than perfect. She's just been sentenced to five months in prison, followed by five months on House Rest. It's actually the minimum sentence she could have received. The judge went easy on her after reading more than 1,500 letters of support, including from Rosie O'Donnell and Bill Cosby. What a time.
Starting point is 00:14:39 I mean, we were more innocent then. We were more innocent then, but it is like, yeah, of course Martha Stewart can get 1,500 letters. She's Martha Stewart. It doesn't mean what she did is right. Well, Martha Starr is straight into the camera and tells reporters. Today is a shameful day. It's shameful for me and for my family. What was a small personal matter? We came over the last two years and almost fatal circus event of unprecedented proportions. Oh, come on. It wasn't a small personal matter.
Starting point is 00:15:12 Like you're extremely famous and you did insider trading. You know that's what happens when famous people break the law. Yeah, that's a goofy response. And Martha Stockbroker, Peter got the same sentence, five months in prison, and five months of home detention. But unlike Martha, he'll have no job and no company to come back to after prison. He tells the judge that it's been a horrible ordeal for him and his family, and he deeply regrets the sorrow this case has caused them. But you know what, Martha doesn't seem sorry at all. She takes to her website, MarthaTalks.com,
Starting point is 00:15:46 and she posts an early draft of a letter she wrote to the judge prior to her sentencing. Sarah, please read a bit for us. She says, To believe that I would sell to avoid a loss of less than $45,000 and thus jeopardize my life, my career, and the well-being of hundreds of others, my cherished colleagues and partners
Starting point is 00:16:05 isn't very, very wrong. I mean, when she puts it that way, yes, it does sound like why would she do that for a relatively small sum for a billionaire, but I have a feeling she's more in it for the game than she is the actual gains. Do you know what I mean? Yeah, I mean, like $45,000 is like a joke for sure.
Starting point is 00:16:26 Yeah, and maybe that's the biggest shame of all, that it was such a small amount of money and she got caught. Yeah. While Martha spokesperson later says that this draft of the letter, in which Martha also calls Sam, quote, a big crazy, was posted to her website by accident. It's quickly replaced by a version that instead reads, because I intend to appeal the verdict, it is inappropriate for me to discuss the facts of my case in this letter. But about two months later, Martha makes a shocking about face. She requests to begin serving her prison sentence immediately, even though she's still waiting on her appeal to
Starting point is 00:16:59 be heard. She gives the most Martha explanation imaginable, but if she surrenders now, she'll be released in time for the spring planting season. See, this is why she's a billionaire. She has her priorities straight. She knows how to make money and she knows what's needed from her. Correct. But Martha later admits to an ulterior motive. She's got two TV shows booked and she needs to shoot them in the spring if they're gonna air the next fall. She's eager to put these troubles behind her and get back to running her media empire. She reports to prison in Alderson, West Virginia in early October 2004, and thus begins Martha's half year of government mandated rest and relaxation. Margaret Roach is in her late 40s with shoulder length brown hair and bang swept to the side. She's the editorial director at Martha Stewart Living Omnimedia,
Starting point is 00:17:51 but her job has taken some unexpected turns lately, like today. It involves playing a game of scrabble with her boss, who is being held in a minimum security present about 500 miles away from their Chelsea office. But this campus looks more like a university than a prison, with its colonial-style brick building, manicured lawns, and big shady trees. Martha pretty much treats it like a home-up state. She's just constantly inviting guests. I mean, they don't show you this on beyond-scared straight. No, this is not what happens in that show.
Starting point is 00:18:25 Margaret and Martha are playing Scrabble in the visiting room when Martha suddenly jumps up from her chair and shouts, wall dog. Margaret is startled, but none of the prison guards bad and I. This is apparently normal behavior for their most famous in-mate. Margaret cautiously follows Martha to the wall, where she watches her boss bend into a modified version of a downward dog. Martha tells Margaret that she's gotten really into yoga lately. She's even been teaching classes to fellow inmates. She's also learning pottery,
Starting point is 00:18:54 picking dandelion greens, and collecting crab apples from the trees. A fellow inmate tells the New York Post that others would have gotten punished for picking apples, but not Martha. are posts that others would have gotten punished for picking apples, but not Martha. In the March 2005 issue of Martha's Stuart Living, market rights an unusually long letter from the editor. In it, she praises Martha for refusing to let prison get her down. Can you read this excerpt? It says, She is indeed ready to get planting, having ordered her seeds and made extensive to-do lists,
Starting point is 00:19:23 just as she would have done in any winter. That's a thing about Martha. She's always Martha and never idle or distracted or down. This sounds like something a cult member would write about their leader. Well, Martha has managed to remain herself even in prison. But the people she's left behind don't have that luxury. Wednesdays on CBC. until she's left behind, don't have that luxury. time detector. You need to stay out of prison. There are partners in solving crime. Am I caught? You're on a car. You have a badge?
Starting point is 00:20:06 Not yet. A gun? Su. Not ever. Wild cards. New episode Wednesday. Watch free on CBC gem. Hi, I'm Anna.
Starting point is 00:20:18 And I'm Emily. We're the hosts of Wondery's podcast, Terribly Famous, a show where we bring you outrageous true stories about our most famous celebrities. Our later season is all about the Catwalk Queen, Naomi Campbell. The years Naomi had to fight to be treated barely in an industry that was overwhelmingly white. That drive saw her break down barriers and reached the pinnacle of high fashion, but it also got her into some dangerous situations when it spilled over into an anger she couldn't control.
Starting point is 00:20:49 In our new season, Naomi Campbell's model behavior, we tell the story of how a young girl from South London became a trailblazing black icon, but had some very public falls of how she stood up to the British tabloids and one, and then lent she had to go to to be the first black woman in history to make the cover of French vogue. But, she risks losing it all when her explosive behaviour lands her in court. Follow Terabie Famers wherever you listen to podcasts, or listen early and add free on posts will the one to react. It's just after midnight on a Friday in March 2005, a motorcade rolls up to the tarmac at a small airport in West Virginia. The door of a black SUV opens and Martha steps out.
Starting point is 00:21:45 After five months in prison, she's been released and is heading home to Bedford, New York. She's wearing jeans, healed boots, and a gray knit poncho. Martha smiles and waves to reporters and cameras, and she makes her way to a private jet. The photos of her boarding the plane instantly become iconic. Sarah, can you describe this one?
Starting point is 00:22:05 This looks like when someone is released from like a foreign-hosted situation and they're being sent home. This makes her look like she was a victim to something. Yeah, like a prisoner of war. Well, it's the early odds. So once Martha gets home, she simply has to post some reflections on her blog.
Starting point is 00:22:25 She writes that prison has been, quote, life altering and life affirming. Martha takes the week into decompress, but on Monday, she's right back to work with a new accessory, an ankle monitor. She pairs it with a brown suit, gold jewelry, and high heels. She's on house arrest,
Starting point is 00:22:41 and she can spend more than 48 hours a week outside of her home, so she makes every second at the office count. When she walks in the front door, hundreds of her employees rush over to her and start clapping. She beams from ear to ear and blows kisses to the crowd. A few reporters have been invited under one condition. No questions. Martha gets a little teary eyed when she tells her audience that while in prison, she read, reflected,
Starting point is 00:23:07 and quote, learned a lot about our country. Oh my God, give it a rest. Well, Martha tells her staffers that they're all starting a new chapter together. She wants to meet women where they are, whether that's in a Connecticut farmhouse or in a West Virginia prison. She says they're going to inspire new audiences
Starting point is 00:23:26 who might think things like homemaking, cooking, and gardening seem a little superficial. At one point, she holds up the poncho she wore the night she left Alderson. She says it was knitted for her by a wonderful lady she befriended there. It's a symbol of this new, down-to-earth Martha. Over the next few months, she sets out to remake her images
Starting point is 00:23:46 in every woman. And to do so, she reportedly works 80 hours a week and sleeps just four hours a day. She allows her magazine staff to mention the word microwave for the first time. And she announces plans for a TV show where she helps down on their luck women get back on their feet while renovating a home together.
Starting point is 00:24:04 This show never actually happens. In part because Martha's probation rules prevent her from hanging out with felons. But Martha does start shooting her apprentice spin-off for NBC, which airs in September 2005 just six months after her release from prison. And Sarah, I know you're going to like this. One of the contestants on Martha's apprentice is a young Bethany Frankl. As you know, she will go on to even bigger reality show fame as a real housewife of New York. I really did not know this at all and I'm terrified. It sounds about right to me. Well, around the time the show airs, Martha sits down for a bunch of interviews to
Starting point is 00:24:41 promote it. But understandably, all anyone wants to talk about is prison. Like when Terry Gross asks Martha, if prison was actually kind of relaxing compared to her daily grind, Martha is not amused. I'm really over prison. I can think about it privately. But to talk about it day in and day out is more tiresome than I wish. I am on with my life. Martha's rehabilitated image is a delicate house of cards.
Starting point is 00:25:14 And one of her former friends is getting ready to knock it all down. It's the fall of 2006, about a year after Martha's spin-off of the apprentice heirs. Peter has been out of prison for two years, and he's living in a townhouse in Manhattan. He's in his mid-40s now, but he's still got a full head of dark blonde hair and manicured eyebrows. One day, he picks up the September issue of Harper's Bizarre. Martha is interviewed in it, alongside the headline, The Seductive Side of Martha. The spread includes photos of her draped across a gold couch,
Starting point is 00:25:48 wearing an Eve Saint Laurent top, and Harry Winston diamonds. Peter is disgusted when he sees the magazine article, but it's not the headline or the costuming that he's comming about, it's something Martha said in her interview. Sarah, can you read what she told the magazine? Yeah, she said, I honestly don't remember exactly what I was prosecuted for.
Starting point is 00:26:07 Martha! Yes, you do! Well, Peter, honestly, can't believe it. You lost everything trying to cover for Martha. His career, his connections, his freedom, all gone. And now, Martha dares to claim that she can't remember what exactly she was prosecuted for. Peter is so upset that he decides he needs to tell his side of the story. So he sits down with a reporter from the New York Times. They meet at a white tablecloth Italian restaurant on the Upper East Side and
Starting point is 00:26:37 Peter tells the reporter that his immune system has been destroyed from years of stress. He served the same amount of time as Martha, but his prison stint was far more brutal. While she was doing yoga and picking crab apples near the countryside, Peter was doing hard labor at a prison camp on an air force base near Las Vegas. Both Peter and Martha were assigned to minimum security prisons with mostly other white
Starting point is 00:27:00 collar criminals. So it's unclear why his experience was so different from hers. He tells the New York Times reporter that he's still wrecked by it, mentally, emotionally, physically. He says he suffers from chronic allergies and has such severe bronchitis that he often has to stop to catch his breath when climbing stairs. He says, quote, I'm chronically sick and chronically unemployed and without any specific plan about how to proceed next. Yeah, I do feel for Peter because like, this is his actual job that was affected,
Starting point is 00:27:30 but Martha was just dabbling in stocks, like she still has her whole career and she's still gonna be famous. Yeah. And Peter was also really loyal to Martha. He pledged not guilty right alongside her, even though he probably would have avoided jail time if he pledged guilty. And of course, if she'd just taken the plea bargain she was offered, both of them would
Starting point is 00:27:49 have avoided that trial in the first place. Peter also says the SEC slapped him with a $75,000 fine, all for a trade that he himself made zero money on. At one point, he says he was so strapped for cash that he called Martha's daughter Alexis, and asked if Martha would help pay his legal fees for the trial. He says Alexis told him, quote, no one here feels we owe you anything. Peter is still stewing over Martha's post-prison comeback, and won't be long before he'll have something else to feel better about. His former client, Sam, is plotting a post-prPrison renaissance of his own. It's a Friday evening in October 2008. Sam has recently been released from prison after serving just five years of a seven-year sentence. He's nursing a cup of tea in the lobby bar of the
Starting point is 00:28:37 car liel, a luxury hotel and apartment building on the upper east side. He's here with one of Imclon's former board members, Richard Mulligan. Richard's got a beard and thin brown hair combed to one side. He's a Harvard professor and a pioneer in the field of gene therapy. Sam and Richard have been meeting just about every week since Sam got out of prison. Unlike Peter's time behind bars, Sam's wasn't so bad. He's compared to a bad sleep away camp. He stayed busy playing basketball, tennis, and softball, and, apparently, by reading the entire Western canon of philosophy. He wrote two novels and a memoir. Sam got a sentence produced by participating in a rehab program, which seems to be a get out of jail sooner card for a lot of white collar criminals.
Starting point is 00:29:22 Now, he's living in a halfway house in the Bronx, and he and Richard have a lot to celebrate. Imclone has just been sold to pharma giant Eli Lilly. The deal is worth a whopping $6.5 billion, and Sam still holds options in the company, so he's just minted a fortune. But the real kicker, Eli Lilly mainly bought Imclone for air betucks. That's the cancer drug that caused
Starting point is 00:29:46 this whole insider trading fiasco in the first place. The irony is, just seven months after Sam went to prison, air betucks did get FDA approval for treating colorectal cancer, and it's been a blockbuster drug ever since. That is poor timing. It's brutal, isn't it? Well, Sam has been vindicated. The drug he fought so hard to develop and swore would drastically improve people's lives is actually doing just that. But he's not one to sit back in cash in. He wants back in the game.
Starting point is 00:30:16 So he and Richard start taking meetings with investors about a new business they want to start. He later tells New York Magazine, quote, it says if I wasn't gone a day. Sam's got a new lease on life. Meanwhile, Martha's about to escalate her comeback with the help of
Starting point is 00:30:31 an unlikely new BFF. It's November 2008, about a month after Eli Lilly agreed to buy Mclone. Martha is washing potatoes in her modern farmhouse kitchen, which is actually the set of her TV show Martha Stewart Living. She's about to introduce today's guest, but she's really building up the drama. She says they first met backstage at the David Letterman show, and they hit it off
Starting point is 00:30:55 immediately. And then she flashes this photo of them together. Oh my god, I'm sorry because I Oh my god. I'm sorry because I remember this so well. It's a photo of her and Snoop Dog backstage and she's smiling and he has sunglasses on and this is like, oh my god, rapper with Martha Stewart. I know. Oh. Well, Snoop strolls onto the set and greets Martha with a kiss on the cheek. They spend the segment cooking mashed potatoes while flirting intensely with each other. And later on her blog, Martha continues gushing over Snoop. She writes a post translating what she calls his secret code, and Sarah, yes, you will be reading some of this to me. Okay, she says, crack a lackin means get something poppin. Chuuuch!
Starting point is 00:31:43 Means take a god everywhere you go and everything will be alright. All hood means all good. Ball till ya fall means get as much money as you can before you die. I can't express how much I loathe this and how I feel like I deserve compensation for reading that out loud. Well, that's what the money is for as Don Drey persists. But on the surface, Martha and Snoop are total opposite Sarah. It's exactly what you hate about this. She's a former model and stockbroker from New Jersey. She rose to fame as a new kind of homemaker. And Snoop is a platinum
Starting point is 00:32:23 selling rapper from Long Beach who once stood trial for the murder of a rival gang member. But at this point in their lives, they're both savvy business people with extreme wealth, which means they got more in common than not. And Martha probably starts to realize it's not such a bad thing. She decides she's done toning herself down for the cameras. With Snoop as her guide, she's ready to embrace her totally shameless, volatile, you fall, era. And she doesn't care who she screws over in the process. This is the point where things stop being about Martha, the company, and start being about
Starting point is 00:32:56 Martha, the very rich and famous individual. In 2009, Martha Stewart Living Omnimedia reports a $14 million loss. That same year, Martha takes home a $10 million salary. She also gets a $3 million retention bonus for renewing her contract with her own company. It probably helps that Martha sprinkled her friends on the company's board, like her former hairdresser. At one point, two board members allegedly challenge her compensation. And according to New York Magazine, she asks them to resign. It's so crazy because this episode isn't one of the worst scams. You know, all things considered.
Starting point is 00:33:35 But this has made me dislike Martha Stewart in a way I didn't know was possible. Yeah. Well, you're not going to feel great about her after this. Because while her company is deep in the red, Martha is living large. And she doesn't care who knows it. She tweets of a going to Diddy's birthday party and post photos of it on her blog. Here Sarah, take a look at how she captioned some of these photos.
Starting point is 00:33:56 Oh my god, okay, well, here's a photo of her with Anthony Anderson. And the caption is, Here I am with Anthony Anderson, actor who was a guest on my television show, we made beautiful stone planters together. I'm eating a delicious grape popsicle. Another photo is of her and a black man and she's attempting to do a gang sign,
Starting point is 00:34:21 but she's really doing this holding up her hand in a claw. She's holding up her hand in a claw. She's holding up her hand in the claw and the caption goes, Hala at me. And the last photo is truly unfortunate. It is of her and Harvey Weinstein and the caption says, my friend Harvey Weinstein. Not one thing has aged poorly in there, certainly. By 2010, Martha starts throwing things at the wall to see what'll stick. And it seems like she's game to do anything as long as it means maintaining cultural relevance. Not long after Ditty's party, she pole dances on her TV show and even plays a version of herself on the Simpsons.
Starting point is 00:34:58 But things are going so poorly for her company that reporter starts speculating about whether she'll be forced to sell it. By 2012, the Martha Stewart show has aired its last episode, and Martha Stewart omnimedia reports a roughly $50 million quarterly loss. The company announces it'll lay off 12% of its work force and discontinue at least one of its print magazines. Things are looking bleep for her army of employees, the Martha herself isn't sweating it. Maybe it's her new friendship with Snoop, or maybe Martha's finally grown tired of pretending to be something she's not. Innocent, charitable, or even nice, she's on the verge of yet another big renaissance. And this time, it's no holds barred.
Starting point is 00:35:42 Being an actual royal is never about finding your happy ending, but the worst part is, if they step out of line or fall in love with the wrong person, it changes the course of history. I'm Aresha Skidmore Williams, and I'm Brooke Sifrin. We've been telling the stories of the rich and famous on the hit Wonderree Show even the rich, and talking about the latest celebrity news on Rich and Daily. We're going all over the world on our new show, Even the Royals.
Starting point is 00:36:08 We'll be diving headfirst into the lives of the world's kings, queens, and all the wannabes in their orbit throughout history. Think succession meets the crown meets real life. We're going to pull back the gilded curtain and show how royal status might be bright and shiny, but it comes at the expense of, well, everything else. Like your freedom, your privacy, and sometimes even your head. Follow Even The Royals on the Wondery app
Starting point is 00:36:32 or wherever you get your podcasts. You can listen to Even The Royals early and add free right now by joining Wondery Plus. Now I feel like a... For years, Martha's strategy had been to avoid talking what her time behind bars, but not anymore. In March 2015, exactly a decade after her release from prison, she decides to go on Comedy Central's roast of Justin Bieber, and rather than shy away from her criminal record, she fully embraces it. Sarah, gird your loins.
Starting point is 00:37:10 You see, when I did my stretch, all the hood rats on my cell block wanted to break off a piece of Martha Stewart's ass, so I decided some bitch needed to get got. You know what? I don't think it's funny at all. It's just like the lowest. Yeah.
Starting point is 00:37:27 Absolute, lowest hanging fruit, Martha likes. That's so stupid. I love it. I'm sorry, you don't get a hood pass because you went to prison. Well, three months after the roast, Martha does something radical. She sells her company. Sequential media, which also owns brands from Justin Timberlake and Jessica Simpson,
Starting point is 00:37:48 buys Martha Stewart living omnimedia for a reported $353 million. It's just a fraction of what it was worth during its heyday, but the terms of the deal couldn't be sweeter for Martha. Under her new contract, she'll continue to get a multi-million dollar salary. Plus, according to securities filings, she'll get 3.5% of their gross licensing revenue for the rest of her life. Martha spent decades working to keep her own company at the top.
Starting point is 00:38:16 Now, she's finally free from the prison of her own creation, free from IPOs, advisory boards, and CEOs scrutinizing her salary. She's come to realize that in a new media landscape, she's more valuable on her own. She's got the name recognition and without a board of directors breathing down her neck, she can pivot to meet the moment and make even more money. Martha Waste, no time getting paid to do what she loves best.
Starting point is 00:38:41 Hanging out with Snoop in the kitchen, that's the premise of their new show on VH1, which airs a gear after the roast of Justin Bieber. It's called Martha and Snoop's pot-leg dinner party, and it is exactly what it sounds like. They host celebrity guests like 50 Cent, Lance Bass, Seth Rogan, and Post Malone. Martha reportedly takes in $1 million for the first season.
Starting point is 00:39:03 The show gets renewed twice, and it even has a spin-off series which ends in February 2020. When COVID lockdown started a month later, Martha sees a perfect opportunity for a new TV show. She decides to invite cameras into her bed for New York estate and showcase some of her cooking, gardening, and DIY projects during quarantine.
Starting point is 00:39:22 Celebrity guests on the show include Lorraine Braco. Right before the show airs, 78-year-old Martha posts a seductive selfie on Instagram. Sarah, do you remember when she did this? Yeah, I remember it. It's like that pool selfie from like the good angle portrait mode. She's wearing full makeup, you know, she looks very saltry and she looks incredible.
Starting point is 00:39:44 But again, I just don't see this as virtuous full makeup, you know, she looks very sultry and she looks incredible. But again, I just don't see this as virtuous at all, which is kind of how it was received when it came out. Everyone was like, Martha Stewart looks incredible. I stand so hard and it's like, yeah, she's filthy rich. She will look incredible until she dies.
Starting point is 00:40:00 You should look that's good if you have that much money. In May 2023, at the age of 81, she produces an even bigger viral moment when she appears on the cover of Sports Illustrated Magazine. Martha becomes the oldest woman to do so ever. The magazine hails her as the original influencer. Almost two decades after her prison stint, Martha is finally experiencing the cool girl Renaissance
Starting point is 00:40:23 she always wanted. She gets a series of TV shows on the Roku channel. She starts her own podcast with I Heart Radio, releases a line of CBD gummies, collaborates with Snoop on a branded big lighter, and even opens a restaurant at the Paris and Las Vegas. I've been to that restaurant. I went with Jen, our producer. Did you have a great time? You know, that's really what put me off of Martha.
Starting point is 00:40:53 It was like going to a cult business. They could not stop talking about her like they were scared of her. She was right behind them. Well, as for Sam, the founder of Imclon, things are going pretty good for him too. His LinkedIn lists him as the chairman, CEO, and president of a new biofarmer corporation. He's also a frequent commentator on Fox and CNBC discussing Pharma and Finance. And speaking of finance, Doug no longer works in it. According to his LinkedIn, he used to work at Gawker as the chief of staff of technology and products.
Starting point is 00:41:23 He now works in tech, and he will go down in history for putting Martha in her place. As for Peter, Doug Swarmer Boss, he found a second act in 2008 as a CEO of an anti-Jewelry company called Fred Layton. They gave only last year to about a year, though. His role was axed after the company did some reorganization. It's not totally clear what he's up to these days,
Starting point is 00:41:44 but he seems to be having a good time, at least according to his public Instagram. He's posted photos from New York fashion shows, symphonies, and book signings. Honestly, he looks like a fun hang. Unfortunately for him, he still has to deal with C. Martha on magazine covers. Sarah, I feel like this episode made you hate Martha Moore, which I kind of thought would
Starting point is 00:42:07 happen, but not at the severity that it has. Yeah, big time. And it's not even necessarily tied to her crimes. It's such a symbol of how gross celebrity culture is and can be, especially if you're a beautiful white woman. Yeah, the funny thing about the Martha stuff is she kind of became like a weird martyr, but she definitely did something wrong.
Starting point is 00:42:35 She didn't have to serve very much time for it. Her life improved. I mean, I wonder what her business would have looked like have this not happened to her. Like what would she have to show for it? Yeah, this was like one of the best things that happened for her career. It was becoming stale and going to prison.
Starting point is 00:42:52 It made people look at her in a totally different way and just even pay more attention to her as someone who represents this very traditional way of living and she ran with that. I feel like you have a lot of thoughts about Martha choosing to align herself with black artists after she gets out of jail. Like, there's something like she thinks it's funny,
Starting point is 00:43:14 but she also thinks it's like sexy to her old audience and she's getting in a new one. There's so much to unpack, but I will focus on this one thing. It's this idea of aren't black people and black men and rappers so scary? And me, this little white lady who teaches you had a full napkins found some common ground
Starting point is 00:43:36 with Snoop Dogg, and it's because I went to prison. It just kind of goes back to this whole thing of her being able to leverage this. In part because she's such a smart business woman, of course she is, but also she's a white woman and it's funny and it's cute and that just doesn't happen to anyone who not only is not white, but anyone who is poor or not Martha Stewart or famous. And it's just like, it's so crazy to me that everyone made it seem like she did nothing wrong.
Starting point is 00:44:10 No, she definitely did. And if she really learned anything in prison, she hasn't translated that into anything broader outside of herself and ways to make money. Like, I don't see her being a lifelong advocate of prison reform or abolition or people who are wrongfully accused or anything. She saw a way to make money and that's all she went for. I feel like the thing people miss about Martha is also,
Starting point is 00:44:33 she didn't actually go away because of insider trading. She went away because she was lying to federal investigators. And like the drug that Sam was trying to develop was actually effective and successful. And this is a story about people who are just impatient. They think they're entitled to like legs up across the board
Starting point is 00:44:54 that they should be able to say what they want and do what they want. And again, it's like they just thought they were smarter than everybody. They thought they could game the system. It's so lousy. Yeah, I mean, rich people exist in a world that we don't, and they get away with so many things that people get in trouble for. And I think the biggest injustice to them was that, you know, this kind of deception leaked into the normal regular world.
Starting point is 00:45:21 Like, wait a second, normal people don't understand. We do this shit all the time. Why are we getting caught right now? Wow, Sarah. This has been a crack-alack in conversation. TURK! That's all I have to say, you know? Hey, Prime Members, you can listen to Scanplencers, Add Free on Amazon Music.
Starting point is 00:45:42 Download the Amazon Music app today. Or, you can listen Add Free with Wondery Plus and Apple podcasts. Before you go, tell us about yourself by completing a short survey at Wondery.com slash survey. This is Martha Stewart, the Homemaker Hustler Part Two. I'm Satji Cole. And I'm Sarah Haggi.
Starting point is 00:46:04 If you have a tip for us on a story that you think we should cover, please email us at scamplencersatwonderery.com. We use many sources in our research. A few that were particularly helpful were the comeback that wasn't by Benjamin Wallace. And Sam Waxel was right all along by Robert Colcker, both in New York Magazine, and no remorse, no regrets, no worries for Martha by Constance L. Hayes in in New York magazine, and No Remorse, No Regrets, No Waries for Martha, by Constance L. Hayes in the New York Times.
Starting point is 00:46:28 Our senior producer, Jen Swan, wrote this episode, additional writing by Us, Sachi Cole and Sarah Haggi. Sarah Enny is our story editor and producer, and Eric Thurham is our story editor. Fact checking by Will Tavlin, sound designed by James Morgan. Additional audio assistance provided by Adrian Tapia. Our music supervisor, Iskawquez for FreeZonsing. Our coordinating producer is Desi Blaylock and our managing producer is Matt Gantt. Janine Cornelow and Stephanie Jen's are our development producers.
Starting point is 00:46:53 Our associate producers are Charlotte Miller and Lexi Peary. Our producers are John Reed, Yasmin Ward and Kate Young. Our senior producer is Ginny Bloom. Our executive producers are Jenny Lauer, Beckman, Marshall Louis, and Aaron O'Flarity for Wondry. Hey, I'm Michelle Beetle. And I'm Peter Rosenberg. Hey Peter, tell the people about our new podcast. Right, it's called Over the Top, and we cover the biggest topics in sports and pop culture
Starting point is 00:47:27 using royal rumble rules. That means we'll start with two stories. Toss one out on its ass and dive into the other stories with ruthless aggression. Oh, but it never stops because every 90 seconds after that. Oh God, whose music is that? Another story comes down to the ring. The new The new The new The new The
Starting point is 00:47:46 new The new The new The new The new The new
Starting point is 00:47:54 The new The new The new The new The new The new The
Starting point is 00:48:02 new The new The new The new The at free right now by joining 1-3 plus. For the record, this is not a wrestling podcast. No, no, but it is inspired by wrestling. Is it everything inspired by wrestling, Beetle? Fair point. Yeah!

There aren't comments yet for this episode. Click on any sentence in the transcript to leave a comment.