Science Friday - Why Painters Are Obsessed With The Duck Stamp Art Contest

Episode Date: September 30, 2025

In mid-September, artists from around the country convened in Laurel, Maryland, for one of the splashiest events in the wildlife art world: the Federal Duck Stamp Art Contest. At the annual event, artists compete to have their excruciatingly detailed waterfowl painting appear on the Federal Duck Stamp, which is a waterfowl hunting license. This year, Digital Producer Emma Gometz was there to watch the duck drama unfold. They join Host Flora Lichtman to explain why artists take this competition so seriously, how duck stamps support conservation, and who took the crown this year.Read our article about the 2025 competition.Plus, Interlochen Public Radio reporter Claire Keenan-Kurgan shares the story of a volunteer group determined to bring one of the world’s rarest flowers back to a small river island in Illinois.Guests: Emma Gometz is Science Friday’s Digital Producer of Engagement. They write SciFri’s “Science Goes To The Movies” series and are a journalist and illustrator based in Queens, NY.Claire Keenan-Kurgen is a reporter for Interlochen Public Radio in northern Michigan.Transcripts for each episode are available within 1-3 days at sciencefriday.com.  Subscribe to this podcast. Plus, to stay updated on all things science, sign up for Science Friday's newsletters.

I'm Flora Lichten, and you're listening to Science Friday. Later on the show, when an ultra-rare flower disappeared, some volunteers took matters into their own hands. They were really excited to see this flower, and they get there, and they can't find it. But first, we're turning our attention to a brutal cutthroat competition, complete with infighting on social media, favorites and underdogs,

and above all, participants, obsessed with their craft. I would compare it to American Idol, right? It launches you on a career path that you maybe never thought possible. It's always been kind of like a secret society. I'm really nervous. This has been a part of my life since I was 11. Most kids are into football or baseball. This was my sport.

It's an addiction, but it's like the best kind of addiction. The addiction is painting ducks. You may have missed it, but around a week ago, artists convened for the splashiest event in the wildlife art world, the federal duck stamp art contest. Here to explain why artists take this competition so seriously, why this program is one of the most successful conservation efforts in the U.S. And the question on everybody's minds, will the person who's won six times take the crown again? Here to explain is our digital producer Emma Gomez, who is at the contest this year. Hi, Emma.

Hi, Laura. Let's start with the basics. What is the Federal Duck Stamp Art Contest? Yes. So the Federal Duck Stamp Art Contest is the only juries art competition that is run by the federal government. And the idea is artists from across the country have a limited number of huntable waterfowl that they paint as they naturally would appear in the wild. They paint it on a canvas and that image must be. strictly seven by 10 inches. They mail it to this office of the duck stamp. They collect all the paintings, and then they get together a group of judges who are experts in wildlife painting, stamp collecting, wildlife conservation, hunting, and those judges vote on the very best painting, or at least their idea of the best painting.

And, yeah, that painting goes on the federal duck stamp, which is not a postage stamp. I should get that out of the way now. But it is actually a stamp that accompanies a state hunting license. So you get your state license and then you put the federal like hunting stamp on top of it. And that has a wonderful picture of a painting that usually hundreds of artists have fought to put on that stamp. So it's a very pretty sticker that denotes that you have the right, the federal right to hunt these birds? Yes.

Usually it's an absolutely gorgeous scene with like morning lighting or dew or something like that. So really it is a very beautiful sticker. And then is the goal to raise money? Why does it exist this contest? Yes. So it came about like right after the Dust Bowl when waterfowl populations just completely fell off a cliff. because there was just less water, wetlands, places where they can reproduce, find food. And so there was this cartoonist named Jay Ding Darling who was appointed to be part of what is now the Fish and Wildlife Service.

And he came up with this idea to have this duck stamp that you buy to make basically a fiscal contribution to the success of wetlands and migratory birds. So if you're going to hunt them, then you're going to pay a small fee to, support the lands that they live on, the lands that you hunt on. And then it's, you know, just kind of a win-win for everyone. So really it's sort of just a way for hunters to give back to the wildlife refuges. Ninety-eight cents for every dollar you spend on a federal duck stamp goes straight to buying or leasing lands that are important for migratory birds. And that's where the Fish and Wildlife Service takes care of those lands and helps make sure those birds stay kicking.

Has the duck stamp raised a meaningful amount of money over the years? Yeah, absolutely. So, you know, they like to say that it's one of the most successful conservation programs in the United States, and they are definitely not wrong. They've raised $1.3 billion for these wildlife refuges, and over 6 million acres of land have been preserved through the program. So that money, it's independent. of like Congress or like voted upon federal funding. So it really is like people giving back.

Crowdsourced. Yeah, exactly. Okay, so this contest just happened. You went to Maryland to witness it. Set the scene. It is such a niche community. Like a lot of them have been doing this for like 30 years or something like that. So there were a lot of people who were there. that were just old friends, chatting to each other, scrutinizing the paintings. But there was definitely this air of like gulp, like the big judging is coming. Like, my painting, like it's going to be struck down, looking at the other competition and being like, who's my main opponent here? So there's an audience of like 100ish people staring at the judges who are staring at the paintings.

And you just watch as one by one each painting is decided in or out. in or out of the competition. So we spent four hours in a silent auditorium watching the judges just make those choices. This feels like a Christopher Guest movie to me. Like this is the one that Christopher Guest needs to make after Best and Show, you know? Yes, definitely. There should be more duck stamp related drama out there, I think. Okay, what about the artist themselves?

What's in it for them? Yeah. Yeah, so a common misconception is that there's like some big cash prize for this. The only reward is exposure. However, for wildlife artists, this is a really big deal. Somebody described this competition to me as the Grammys of Wildlife Art. Like, yes, you don't get money if you win, but it definitely means something about you. And if it's on a duck stamp, of course, you have stamp collectors, you have enthusiasts who are really into the art. So if you win, you sell merch, you license the image to get it printed. You can spin this win into an entire career. And that is what a lot of artists who are kind of professional duck stamp winners have done. So it definitely turns into money for the artist if that's what they are inclined to do. Let's talk about the reigning dukes of duck stamp art, the Hotman brothers. Tell us about them. Yeah. So they're three brothers, Jim, Joe, and Bob. And they're big, into, wildlife. They're all professional painters, and they have been doing this competition for a super long time, 40 years, I think. Each one of them has won the competition multiple times. Jim Hotman has won the most out of the three. And they're also avid hunters. Like, they

totally camouflage themselves to take perfect pictures of these ducks and their wild natural habitat. And then they're kind of also like an artist colony in the sense that when they're painting, They're like giving each other feedback and like making each other's paintings better. They're competing with each other. And they're just like at the top of this game. Well, what makes their paintings good? That's an interesting question. So they're really, really good at capturing the animals in a way that doesn't really push it beyond this natural way you would really see them.

Neutral and natural. Yeah, I think so. Neutral, natural. Okay, I feel like online people may be aware of this, but there is also this younger artist who basically went viral for posting about their paintings for the competition. Let's hear from them. Hello, duck people. It's Keir Sabin who paints those ducks.

And last year, I did not do well. But we're going to do better this year. And you're welcome to watch along. This duck stamp season is going to be a big one. And I'm determined to make my name, one to fear. What does the duck stamp bar community or the organizers think about, social media? Yeah, so there's definitely some grumblings from like the old guard, the more traditional, like very offline wildlife artists that this could potentially make the competition

unfair because if Kira's art becomes so well known before the competition and a judge recognizes the artwork and votes them in because they love their video content so much like that could make the competition unfair. But I think overall, artists and the organizers are like are really happy that their videos are drawing attention to the competition because ultimately it's a conservation project and we want people to be buying those stamps and getting excited. So I know everyone listening is desperate to know who won the competition. Was it the up-and-comer? Was it the person with the social media following? Was it the reigning champ Hotman brother? So let's deliver the big reveal.

Ladies and gentlemen, our first place winner is Jim Houtman from Chaska, Minnesota. This is the first person who has won this contest seven times. Are you here? Okay, Emma, what was it like in the room? Because I feel like it was a little grumbly. It was a little muted, that response. It's a lot of anticipation for. something that is so expected, I think. So the first place being Jim Hotman was very funny,

I think, for people who are in the know because it's like, ah, there he goes again, winning, as always. But it was beautiful because he's great at what he does. And I don't know, I think that everybody afterwards was just like, wow, like he keeps doing it. He can't keep getting away with this. But he does because he's amazing at what he does. And when I ask people afterwards, what is the secret sauce? And they all were like, well, he's an amazing painter. And I don't know, maybe we'll get a new Picasso of duck art to come on and topple him.

And then that will be the person to beat. But right now, Hotman's stock is up. Okay. In a Christopher guest movie, you know, the Terrier wins, right? The underdog prevail. That's not what happened in Maryland this year. In your opinion, what is the moral of this story? Hmm.

Well, win or lose, it is about conservation, and it's not just about the artist's paycheck. Like, yes, there are quarrels. Is it fair? Why is this guy keep winning? My art is good. No, that art is better, da, da, da. But overall, everybody I met was just so passionate, so kind, so supportive of the community. And it's not really about the artist's paycheck.

It's about the duck's paycheck. And they're cashing it out. Thank you, Emma. Thank you, Flora. Emma Gomez, digital producer for Science Friday. And if you, like me, cannot get enough, you can read Emma's article for the full story and take a gander at the photos of the winning painting at sciencefriiday.com slash duck stamp. Do not go away because coming up after the break, a botanical. comeback story. They had to do these rolling bonfires across the island, which were basically

like trying to simulate a fast-moving wildfire. One of the rarest plants on the continent is found on this small spit in the middle of the Kankakee River in Illinois, about an hour south of Chicago. The plant is called the Kankakee-Mallow flower, and for years, plant enthusiasts made trips to the island to document this rare flower. Then one day, a group of pulled up and what they saw shocked them. Here to tell us the rest of this tale is Claire Keenan Kiergan of Interlock and Public Radio. She reported the story for the podcast Points North. Claire, welcome to Science Friday. Hi, thanks for having me. Okay, so finish the story for us. What did that group encounter on this little island? So it's a group of botanists. They were from the Illinois

Native Plant Society. So they were really excited to see this flower, you know, one of Illinois's most famous native plants. And they get there and they can't find it. They pull up to this island. And it's totally overgrown with invasive honeysuckle, which just totally crowds out other plants. And some people who were on this trip told me they could barely even get out of their canoes. That must have been a devastating moment for these botanists. Yeah. And I think they knew that the island might be a bit of. overgrown. It had been many years since anyone had documented the flower on the island, but the scale of how overgrown it was was really shocking and disappointing to them.

Okay. And what were they looking for exactly? Like, what does this flower look like? Yeah, it grows on these six-foot-tall stalks, and it has these little pink, kind of pinkish-purplish flowers, about six on a stalk. It's very pretty. Okay, so this island is overgrown by this invasive honeysuckle, there's no sign of this mallow flower. What do they do? So they had to start weeding, first of all. So they organized a group of volunteers to go and basically just start chopping down honeysuckle wherever they could. And then they also had to do controlled burns on the island. Because the kinky mallow seed has this special quality where it needs heat to germinate, which used to maybe come from wildfires in the prairie.

They're not 100% sure, but they had to do these rolling bonfires across the island, which are basically like trying to simulate a fast-moving wildfire where they burned either honeysuckle cuttings or like other kind of kind of kind of kind of burn scars across the island trying to unlock the seeds that they were hoping were underneath. Okay. So did it work? It did. It did work. Yay. Yes. It took them a few years to realize that it was working because these flowers had been gone for about a decade, they estimated. And so some, you know, little plants started popping up along those burn scars. But they kind of debated at the beginning. Like, is this the Kankakee-Balow? Is this something else? And then finally, about two years. in, they saw the first bloom, which was obviously a very exciting moment because that's when they knew. This is definitely the mallow. Yeah, we have a clip of one of the volunteers you talked to, and you can really hear the excitement in his voice. I don't know how big this is, 40 feet, maybe diameter. And I've never seen it so full of mallows. So that's really good. It's just gorgeous.

It's absolutely gorgeous. Yeah, that's Steve Bohan. He is kind of the lead volunteer these days. So he gets people out there to weed, to cut back honeysuckle. And so these many fields of kanky mallow just keep getting more and more beautiful. You know, the thing that struck me listening to your story is that conservation stories usually are so bleak and they feel too big for any individuals or even group of individuals to have control over. And here is an example of this local group, you know, taking matters. into their own garden-gloved hands and finding success. It's such a great story of what people can do if they choose to try to save something like the Kankakee Malo.

You know, not every town has one of the rarest plants in North America, but lots of places have these unexpected and special pieces of nature. and a lot of the volunteers on Langham Island didn't actually care too much about the Kanky Malo being super rare. But they, to me, seem to care more about just being good stewards of nature and trying to preserve native habitats. And that's something that can happen anywhere. And they accomplish a lot.

It has been over 10 years now since the project started, but they've cleared three quarters of this big island. And sometimes it's only a handful of people volunteering there every week. But they've made a big impact in this one place. Claire, thank you so much for taking the time to tell us the story. Thank you. Claire Keenan Kergan, news reporter at Interlock and Public Radio, and she reported the story for the podcast, Points North.

And before we go, a heads up, if you're looking for an out-of-this-world adventure, Science Friday's Down-to-Earth program returns this year on October 3 for World Space Week. we will have fun daily activities that show you how space science makes our world better. Please join us. No space suit required. Register today for Down to Earth at ScienceFriiday.com slash down to earth. Thanks for listening. Don't forget to rate and review us wherever you listen. It really does help us get the word out and get the show in front of new listeners.

Today's episode was produced by D. Peter Schmidt. I'm Flora Lichtman. Thanks for listening.