Serialously with Annie Elise - 187: Stabbed 20x to Head, Neck & Torso - But She Did It Herself? | The Disturbing Case of Ellen Greenberg

Episode Date: August 26, 2024

In 2011, 27-year-old Ellen Greenberg was found dead in her apartment after sustaining 20 stab wounds. Her cause of death according to law enforcement? Self-inflicted. But was this really self-inflicted, or is there more to the story, as her family believes? A very special thank you to Ellen’s parents Joshua and Sandee Greenberg for joining us on today’s episode. Justice for Ellen! Today’s Episode: We're going on TOUR!! Come see one of our episodes LIVE in a city near you! Head to https://annieelise.com/blogs/events for dates and ticket info! Beam:  Head to https://www.shopbeam.com/ANNIEELISE  and use code ANNIEELISE for an additional 40% off. Don’t forget supplies are limited and you can only shop it through my link. RoBody  Go to https://www.ro.co/ae and get your first month for just $99!  Mint Mobile Cut your wireless bill to $15 a month at https://www.mintmobile.com/ae Liquid IV Get 20% off your first order when you go to https://www.liquidiv.com and use code AE at checkout. Shop the Merch: www.annieelise.com Follow the podcast on TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@serialouslypodcast   Follow the podcast on Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/serialouslypod/       Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/annieelise     All Social Media Links: https://www.flowcode.com/page/annieelise_    SERIALously FB Page: https://www.facebook.com/SERIALouslyAnnieElise/    About Me: https://annieelise.com/   For Business Inquiries: [e-mail]

Hey guys, it's me, your true crime bestie Annie, and I am so excited to share with you that Serialistly is officially hitting the road and coming to you live in a city near you. That's right, we are going on tour. We've got shows planned in Orange County, California, San Diego, California, Salt Lake City, Denver, Colorado, Phoenix, Arizona, and more. We're going to be discussing all new exclusive cases. I have some surprise guests planned, but I can't tell you who. It's a surprise. At the end we'll do a meet and greet so I finally get to meet so many of you. We've got exclusive merch and just so much more. It is going to be a show that you definitely do not want to miss. But space and tickets are very very limited so grab your friends, grab your co-workers or come on your own and hang with me while we talk all

things true crime together. All of the information, including dates, cities, and links to purchase tickets, can be found at AnnieElise.com and then just toggle over to the events page. So grab them now before they're gone. I can't wait to meet all of you and I will see you on the stage. ...surrounding the death of a young Philadelphia teacher. Ellen Greenberg died back in 2011 after being stabbed 20 times. Her death was initially ruled a suicide and then a homicide, and then back to a suicide. Now, Guy D'Andrea, a former assistant district attorney who worked on the case, has doubts about her death.

Greenberg's family believes she was murdered. Hey, true crime besties. Greenberg's family believes she was murdered. Hey everybody, welcome back to an all new episode of Serialistly with me, Annie Elise. Boy oh boy, do we have a mega crazy case to talk about today, guys. It is one that is extremely controversial. There are a lot of opinions on both sides of this. It's one where there's, you know, allegations of conspiracy, corruption, cover-ups, all sorts of different things. And it's a case I've actually been covering for quite a few years and researching for quite a few years to where I feel like even in all of the information that I have dug up and gathered, I feel like it's pretty clear what the truth really is in this case.

So I don't understand how there is so much division, yet there is. And you'll understand why as we get into the details. And it's the case of Ellen Rae Greenberg. Now, Ellen Greenberg was a 27-year-old first grade teacher living in Philadelphia. She was well loved by all of her students, her friends, her family, her colleagues. She was really just known for her caring nature and also for her dedication to teaching. Now Ellen was also engaged to Sam Goldberg. Their wedding was planned for August 2011. So by all accounts, Ellen at just 27 seemed to have a really bright future ahead. One full of love, marriage, a professional career that

was just on the upswing, all sorts of great things happening in her life. However, beneath the surface, something darker was brewing, something that would ultimately lead to one of the most perplexing and controversial cases in recent history. What's the truth of what happened to Ellen Greenberg? As a reminder, everything in this episode is either sourced from court documents, footage, testimony of family members, or it's my opinion only, so as always, please form your own opinions and do your own research. We also interviewed Ellen's parents, Joshua and Sandy Greenberg, and we're going to be including key points of that conversation we had with them in this episode so that it can provide deeper insight into their experience throughout this

entire ordeal. On January 26th, 2011, Ellen started her morning like any other morning. As I said, she was a first grade local school teacher in Philadelphia, so she got ready for work and she headed off to school. Now on her way to work, she called her mom. This was at approximately 7 a.m., and it's something that she routinely did. Her mom would be on the way into work for the morning as well, so they would use that period of driving in to just talk, catch up, things like that. You know, a hard worker. She had a vivacious personality. She was enthusiastic with her children, with the teaching. She loved, she loved her, she did love her career. She put a lot into it, but it came, a lot of it came very naturally to her. As a child, she was, you know, fun loving, normal. She was athletic. She was artistic. She, you know, loved fashion. She loved sports.

She loved school. And she just had a knack of bringing, you know, her friends from different parts of her life together and never thought twice about, you know, just because they didn't know each other. She says to me, mom, I can make them be friends. Nothing was out of the norm and it seemed like it was just going to be a standard day like every other day. However, that afternoon, a blizzard hit Philadelphia and this wasn't just a small blizzard or a tiny little snow day. This was like one of those like nor'eastern blizzards, like the massive snowfall to where work is shut down, schools are shut down, everything closes. So because of that, Ellen ended up leaving school early. It was a snow day. And if you've ever lived on the East

Coast or if you're familiar, you definitely know how that goes. I remember when I was living in New York, it happened at least once a season, usually even more than that. But in any event, around 1.30 p.m., Ellen was on her way back to the apartment that she shared with her fiancé Sam. The two of them lived in this stunning two-bedroom apartment in a luxury building called the Venice Lofts, and she was heading home for the day. It was nice. It was going to be a shorter day. On the way, she decided to stop for gas, and then after filling up her tank, she headed directly to the apartment. When Ellen arrived home, she entered the apartment. She started working on grading papers, homework, things like that. She also made

a fruit salad for lunch and just started to unwind from her day. Her fiancé Sam was home, but he ended up leaving to go work out in the building gym downstairs. They lived on the sixth floor, and the gym of the building was on the first floor. So he heads out to the gym at around 4.45 p.m. He returned to their apartment about 45 minutes later at 5.30 p.m. However, when he returned, the apartment was locked from the inside. It had been locked using the swing bar latch, you know, the kind that pulls over and it has like the barbell that hangs out and it's just that extra interior lock. So he shouted for Ellen, you know, come unlock the

door, let me in. He also texted her nine times. Now these text messages start with just asking her to open the door, but then they start increasingly becoming more panicked, also a little bit aggressive. These messages read, hello, open the door. What are you doing? You better have an excuse. I'm getting pissed. Hello in all caps. Then another one that said you have no idea. So she wasn't responding to these text messages. She also wasn't answering his phone calls and that made him increasingly irritated. So then he started shouting through the door opening because if you're familiar with this lock then you know you can open the door but there's like a two to three inch little gap where you can kind of see inside kind of not but you still can't get through so he opens that and he's shouting let me in let

me in ellen where are you where are you he also says that he went down to the doorman of the building to see if maybe he could help him access the apartment however for whatever reason the doorman refused he said he couldn't i don't know if it was a restriction of the building, maybe a privacy issue. I'm not entirely sure. But finally, after there was still no answer, Sam ended up forcing his way through the door, breaking that swing bar lock. And what he found inside was his absolute worst nightmare. Ellen, his fiancee, just 27 years old, was lying in a pool of blood in the kitchen, and she had a knife plunged inside her chest. It was an absolute nightmarish scene that really seemed to come directly out of a horror movie. Now quickly before we move on, I want to talk about the timeline of events and

Ellen's movements that day, starting from when she left school to then when she was found dead in her kitchen. I feel like it's something we need to go through so that we can understand what could have happened in that window of time and what the events were leading up to her being found dead on her kitchen floor. So as I said, she got gas at around 1 30 p.m. At 2 30 p.m. she called a restaurant which was located about 30 minutes away from her apartment. It's unclear if she was calling this restaurant to make a reservation, to order food for pickup, to perhaps cancel an existing reservation. It's unclear. But it is possible that she was calling to make a dinner reservation

since now she was getting home for the day much earlier than she normally did. It's also possible she was trying to order food for pickup later. But regardless, we know that she did make that call. At 3.47 p.m., she sends a text message from her phone, and then at 4.45 p.m., there's activity on her computer. A few minutes after that activity on her computer, at 4.50 p.m., is when her fiancé Sam went to the gym downstairs of the building. Then at 5.26 p.m., Sam leaves the gym,

and as I said, their apartment was on the sixth floor and the gym was on the first floor so that would allow him just a few minutes to get upstairs. So if he left at 5 26 p.m. let's say he arrives to the apartment and starts knocking around 5 30 p.m. give or take a few minutes. So he tries texting her and gaining access for 22 minutes, putting it somewhere around 5.50 p.m. to 6 p.m. He's also seen on camera entering the first floor elevator for the last time at 6.28 p.m., and then a 911 call is placed three minutes later at 6.31 p.m. So going off of that timeline, it indicates that he's downstairs talking to the doorman trying to get him to, you know, come and open the door, gain access to the apartment. He goes up the elevator at 6.28, breaks down the door, finds Ellen, and then calls 911 three minutes later. However, if we go back to that timeline, there's

a window from when the texting stops after 22 minutes, around 5.50 to 6 p.m., and then when he is seen on the elevator at 6.28 p.m. So what was going on in that 20 to 30 minute window? Was he trying to get the doorman's attention for 20 or 30 minutes? There are some reports that he had tried to get the doorman's attention three different times, going up and down, up and down, maybe going back and forth. The only thing that we actually do know about that window of time is that Sam called his cousin, Kamian Schwartzman, at 6.14 p.m. This was 17 minutes before the 911 call. Kamian's dad, Sam's uncle, James Schwartzman, also allegedly called Sam at 6.26 p.m. This incoming call was before the 911 call was made,

but after Sam had called his cousin earlier. Now, a little interesting detail, both Kamian and his father James are lawyers. When Sam called 911, he was instructed to start CPR until he noticed that knife that was plunged in Ellen's chest. Then he was instructed to stop. 842 with the address. No, 4601 Flat Rock Road. Please hurry. 4601 Flat Rock? Yes. What's wrong? Mike, I just, my, I went downstairs to go work out. I came back up. The door was latched. Mike's fiance's inside. She wasn't, she wasn't answering. So after about a half hour, I decided to break it down. I see her now just on the floor, blood. She's not, she's not responding. Okay. Is she breathing? Look at her chest. I need you to calm down. I need you to look at her chest.

It's really, I don't think she, I really don't think she is. Listen to me. Someone's on the way. Look at her chest. Is she flat on her back? She's on her back. Look at her chest and tell me if it's going up and down, up and down. I don't see her moving. Okay, do you know how to do CPR? I don't. Okay, I can tell you what to do, okay, until they get there. I want you to keep her fed. Oh, God.

Hello? Yeah, hi, okay. Are you willing to do CPR with me over the phone until they get there? I have to, right? Okay, so get her fed on her back, bare her chest, okay? You want to rip her shirt off. Oh, shit. Okay, you need to kneel down by her side. Oh, shirt off. Shit. Okay, d

Oh my God. Allie, please out sir. Okay, I'm trying won't come off. It's a zi she stabbed herself where Oh no, her knife sticking a knife sticking out of her heart. Oh, she stabbed herself? I guess so. I don't know where she fell on it.

I don't know. Okay, well, don't touch it. Okay, so I'm just going to let her down here now? I mean, what do I do? No, I mean, you can't. If the knife is in her chest, it's going to be kind of hard for you to do CPR at this time. Oh, no. Oh, my goodness.

Okay. Police, which operator? 277. Is someone coming here? Yes, they are. You said 4601 Flat Rock, right? Yes. Okay, someone's on the way. And the knife is still inside? Wait, is there what?

The knife is still inside of her? Yes, I didn't take it out. Is it her chest or what area? It's in her chest. It looks like it's right in her heart. Okay, someone's on the way out there. Oh, my God. Oh, my God. How old is she? She's 27.

27, and there's no sign of life at all? No, no, no. Please don't be. What? Venture under her arm and tell me if she responds to pain. Ellie! me she responds to pain. Ellie. She's not. It's not her arm. Her hands are still warm. I hope that means, but his blood every I mean I know but you can't and the nice is still

inside of her. How far can you see how far it went in? It looks pretty deep. OK, it looks three minutes along. Nice don't touch anything. Don't touch anything. I'm not touching anything. This is I can't believe this though. Wait, it was just you there with her?

Yeah, we're the only ones here. And she ran in the door? You said latched it shut? No, no, I went downstairs to work out, and when I came back up, the door was latched. Oh. You know, it wasn't like it was locked from the inside, and I'm yelling. Was your house broken into? No, no, no, no, no. No sign of a break in. No, no time of breaking at all. I mean, there will be when you get here because

I had to break the latch but to get in. Okay. 4601 Flat Rock and this is a house, right? It's an apartment by record apartment 603. Okay. Oh my God. Oh my God. All right. Thank you. Bye. What I do find interesting about this call is that Sam says that she was on her back, that he can't get her shirt off. But if that's the case, he didn't notice the knife that was sticking out of her chest. Now, in another detail, just referencing the timeline, Kamian arrived at the apartment three minutes after that 911 call was made at approximately 6 34 p.m. So the EMTs arrived pretty much immediately, just five minutes after the 911 call was made, and they discovered that not only did Ellen have this knife in her chest, but she had been stabbed 20 times. That wound in her chest was just one of 20 different stab wounds

that were discovered on her head, her neck, her back, and her torso. One of the stab wounds to the back of her head was actually so deep that it penetrated her brain. There were also 11 bruises on her body, all in various stages of healing. They were located on her right arm, her abdomen, and her right leg. There was clearly nothing that the EMTs could do to save Ellen at this point. So at approximately 6 40 p.m. that evening, just a few minutes after arriving, Ellen was pronounced dead. The EMS who pronounced Ellen as dead made a comment on the scene about needing to get back to the station, knowing that they would need to be interviewed by the homicide team, given this horrific crime scene. So as the police began

investigating the crime scene, they ended up finding no evidence of an intruder. The six-story apartment could only be accessed from the front door and from the exterior balcony, but there was a complete fresh layer of snow outside from that snowstorm, and it was completely undisturbed. No footprints, no movement, nothing. Officers also noted that there was nothing to suggest that a robbery had taken place. There were plenty of valuables still visible all around the home. So the question that immediately arose, of course, was who could have committed such a heinous, horrific murder? But as the investigators began to piece together the scene, the case took a very strange and unexpected turn.

So the investigators are going through the scene, trying to comb through all pieces of evidence. And given the violent nature of the crime, the initial suspicions of course naturally turned toward homicide. However, that locked door presented a very complex and bizarre situation. Because how could someone have murdered Ellen, but then locked the door from the inside, leaving absolutely no trace of them leaving, no trace of their escape. Now, my initial thought, I'll be honest, when I heard this was, okay, obviously it was the fiance, right? He had access to the apartment, she had bruises, were they new, were they old? The amount of wounds would indicate a crime of passion and possibly even overkill, right? It must have been someone close to Ellen, surely, right? So the police took her fiancé Sam away from the scene in handcuffs, and they questioned him some more.

However, Ellen's parents told the police they had absolutely no reason to suspect her fiancé. And Ellen's psychiatrist, who she had been seeing for anxiety, said that Ellen was happy in the relationship. She had denied that any abuse ever happened in the relationship. She was happy. She was in love. They were planning their wedding. I mean, they were just happy. So as investigators went deeper into the evidence, they were faced with many conflicting signs. To start, there were no signs of forced entry or a struggle happening within the apartment. However, the brutality of how Ellen died and having that many stab wounds, it surely suggested either a frenzied

murder or, what I said earlier, a crime of passion. Although the knife wounds, though severe and numerous, they didn't appear to be consistent with a typical homicide pattern. There was also that locked door, a detail that really seemed to suggest that nobody else could have entered or left the apartment. So with no suggestion that another person had been inside the apartment at the time of her death, police at the scene suspected that the death was actually a suicide, particularly because there was a lack of defensive wounds, also no sign of an intruder at all ever entering. So despite there being no suicide note left behind and despite the barbaric horrific 20 stab wounds, the crime was treated

as a suicide. However, the very next day, the medical examiner reached a different conclusion. This was upon seeing just how many stab wounds there truly were. In his report, the medical examiner classified the death as a homicide, but then there was allegedly this secret meeting that took place. In the meeting, there were members of the ME's office, the police department, also the DA's office. And allegedly in this meeting, they had somehow convinced the medical examiner to change the manner of death to a suicide. The Philadelphia Police Department stated, quote, The death of Ellen Greenberg has not been ruled a homicide. Homicide investigators are considering the manner of death as suspicious at this time. So nevertheless, the investigation continued.

But after learning about Ellen seeing her therapist for anxiety and her being on anxiety medication, police said that they were leaning toward the determination of suicide. Her psychiatrist had prescribed her Klonopinin for anxiety also ambien for sleep both of which medications do list suicidal ideations as possible side effects however nobody close to ellen had heard her express any thoughts of harming herself never for five weeks investigators went back and forth on what happened upon the first review there were no suspects ellen was alone inside the apartment, which had been locked from the inside with that interior swing bar. Neighbors didn't hear

reporting any sort of disturbance. There was also no security footage or stolen property to suggest that there had been an intruder. And what's more were those defensive wounds, or lack thereof. And in another piece of evidence, there was no DNA but Ellen's found on the knife. No DNA from anybody else found on her clothing either. So on March 3rd, armed now with more information, the medical examiner changed the death certificate to reflect that Ellen's death was in fact a suicide. As you can imagine, Ellen's family was devastated by her death, but they were also deeply skeptical of

the suicide ruling. How could their loving, kind-hearted daughter have done this to herself? The sheer number of stab wounds alone seemed absolutely implausible as a self-inflicted act. So Ellen's parents, Josh and Sandy Greenberg, began their own investigation. They were determined to find the truth behind their daughter's death. They hired private investigators, forensic experts. They even hired a renowned pathologist to review the case. The experts that they consulted were all unanimous in their findings. Ellen's wounds were inconsistent with suicide. The angle and the depth of the stab wounds, particularly those to the back of her neck, were nearly impossible for somebody to inflict on themselves. And remember that EMS who declared Ellen as dead and mentioned how they needed to get back to the station because they knew that the homicide team

would need to question them regarding the scene? Get this, they were never questioned. Which let that just sink in, the first responders, the ones who saw the scene and declared Ellen as dead, were never even questioned. Ellen's parents also uncovered new disturbing details about this investigation. Crucial evidence like Ellen's computer and cell phone had not been thoroughly analyzed. Blood spatter patterns, which could have provided vital clues, were also just overlooked. The locked door, once considered definitive proof of suicide, was also re-examined, and it revealed that it could have been tampered with, or it could have even been locked after the fact. And perhaps the most glaringly obvious issue of all was that Ellen had shown absolutely no signs of mental duress leading up to her death.

Yes, she had been seeking help for anxiety, but nothing indicated that she was suicidal. I had asked, like, was there a fight or anything? He said, no, she was just really stressed with work. And so he left. When he came back, he said it was about a half hour later. And he, you know, went to use his key to open and he said that the door was latched I actually had written all this down so I just looked back you know through my notes to refresh my memory so it was latched he said that he you know

called her called her name you know thought maybe she was napping or in the shower he said he called her mom then to see if you know, thought maybe she was napping or, uh, in the shower. Um, he said he called her mom then to see if she mentioned anything to her mom and she hadn't heard anything. Um, and he said at that point he went downstairs to the, uh, to the front door or to the, um, security and asked, um, if maintenance was there and they could help him get into the apartment. And they said, you know, maintenance is gone for the day. And he said the advice he was given was to use his shoulder. You know, if he's going to try to break open the door, use his shoulder.

So then he went back up and he said he used his shoulder. He said it took one, maybe two times. He didn't remember. And the force that he used swung open the door and he spun around and was facing the kitchen and saw her. And he said her, you know, her back and shoulders were kind of up against the lower cabinets. And he said her little fingers were blue.

I remember him saying that her little fingers were blue. And he said he called 911 immediately, and they were going to instruct him to do CPR, so he moved her to the floor. And at that time, he saw the knife. You were questioned by the police at one point? Yes. So, um, the week of February 7th, I was back in town. I had been in new Orleans for work. I came back and, um, I was asked by the homicide unit to come down, um, to Philadelphia, I believe it was the race street location. Um that they could question me, obviously, just as more of a, you know, what information could they get as a friend? And I was interviewed by there.

It was the strangest feeling to be in there, because I'm like, this is not my life. What am I doing here? I remember just feeling like they were, they didn't care what I was saying. It was almost like they were checking the box that they had me there. Um, and at one point he even said, are you trying to point fingers here? And I said, no, I'm, I'm just answering your questions and giving you the information that I know. I'm only giving you fact. Um, so yeah. Did you feel like they had already had their mind made up about what happened? Yeah.

Yeah. This was like, um, I have to just do this. Let me get this over with. Like, I didn't feel like they were interested in what I had to say. Um, and again, not that I, I wasn't there that day. So I have no information of what happened. Um, but I knew what he had told me and I knew who, you know, Ellen was. And I, you know, knew a little bit about the apartment. I knew a little bit about their routines.

And but they they had no interest in hearing from me. Yes. So now records are coming out. Is there any documentation of your conversation with police? No, there's no police report. Right. Apparently the, you know, the last that I've heard of the 5,000 page document, um, that lawyers have gone through, there's no, no report in there of, of my interview with police. And I know for a fact, I was there at homicide, uh, headquarters talking to detective Harris. But there's no document. Did you see him write

something down? Yes, I saw him write something down and I was there. So whether or not he was writing, you know, what he did with that paper, it should have still been documented that I was there. Let's also talk about the scene of the crime for a moment because new forensic evidence suggested that the scene may have been staged. Blood evidence that was found in the kitchen did not align with the official narrative. Now, something that I don't think is talked about enough in this case, and I could totally be wrong, this is just my opinion and I'm not an expert, but remember how I mentioned when Ellen got home that day and she made that fruit salad, whether it was for lunch or for a snack?

Well, in the crime scene photos, you can still see remnants of that fruit salad and scattered parts of it on the kitchen counter, right above Ellen's dead body. Now, I understand people who are suicidal may not always be thinking rationally, but in all of the cases that I've covered, I have never seen or heard of somebody making a meal before taking their own life and not eating the meal. So believing that Ellen committed suicide would also mean that you believe that she made herself lunch in the kitchen, chose not to eat it, and instead chose to grab a knife and stab herself 20 times. Stabbing herself in the torso, the back of her head, the neck, her spine. Such deep stab wounds too that it penetrated her brain. I mean it doesn't

really align, right? I'm not a detective and this is me just theorizing here guys, but doesn't that scene feel more in line with somebody either catching Ellen by surprise or maybe even perhaps blitz attacking her and say grabbing a knife because it's nearby from maybe cutting a fruit salad, and the perpetrator grabbing that as a weapon to murder her in this overkill, crime of passion type of way. Which, by the way, if you look at the knife that was used and that was plunged into Ellen's chest, it certainly aligns with a knife that would be used to cut this fruit salad, the one that she made for herself to eat. So was the knife conveniently on the counter for whoever used this, or did Ellen just have a change of heart and instead of eating the snack that she

had just cut up, she decided to plunge the knife into herself 20 times? Despite the growing body of evidence suggesting that Ellen could not have killed herself, authorities remained firm on their conclusion. The case was closed as a suicide, leaving the Greenbergs in a state of just extreme frustration and anger. And for over the past decade, Ellen's parents have spearheaded their own investigation, even hiring an attorney to help them file a lawsuit against the medical examiner's office, all so that they will change the cause of death to homicide.

She was afraid of pain and she was afraid of blood. So to try to accuse her of committing suicide with a serrated knife, and there were straight edge wounds that were also found, which means there may have been more than one knife involved and there may have been more than one person involved in her murder but we haven't had an investigation a legitimate one so the jury's still out on what really happened to Ellen they found two neuropathologists to review the autopsy report also to examine the brain tissue samples from Ellen that were retained by the doctor who did the autopsy and both also to examine the brain tissue samples from Ellen that were retained by the doctor who did the autopsy, and both of these doctors agree that the evidence shows that suicide

is not even a possibility. Fast forward nearly eight years, and on March 15, 2019, the Philadelphia Inquirer released a front-page investigative report reviewing the suspicious circumstances surrounding Ellen's death. A well-known Pittsburgh forensic pathologist also reviewed the case and determined that it was, quote, strongly suspicious of homicide. They also stated, quote, I don't know how they wrote this off as a suicide. Similarly, a forensic scientist reviewed the case files and concluded, quote, the number and types of wounds and blood stain patterns observed are consistent with a homicide scene. Now, one significant point of contention was the stab wounds that penetrated Ellen's brain. One of the doctors who examined

the file wrote that the stab wounds to the brain and the spinal cord would have caused such severe pain, also cranial nerve dysfunction, and traumatic brain injuries. The original medical report stated that a neuropathologist determined that there was no such wound, though. However, later, when they were interviewed by the Philadelphia Inquirer, that same pathologist revealed that she didn't even observe Ellen's body, and she confirmed that she has no records, no bills, no invoices, no reports of any examination ever even taking place, which, how does that happen? That's a pretty big detail to miss, right? A pretty big discrepancy.

As I mentioned, Ellen's parents filed a civil suit against the Philadelphia Medical Examiner's Office and the pathologist who conducted the autopsy. The suit seeks to change the manner of death, citing new information and the fact that the doctor who did the original autopsy admitted to changing the manner of death at the insistence of the police. A new technology called photogrammetry, unavailable at the time of Ellen's death, also created a 3D recreation of Ellen's wounds, demonstrating that not all 20 wounds could have possibly been self-inflicted. And the circumstances and the details about Ellen's death were about to get a lot more mysterious. With us again this morning, Sandy and Josh, welcome again. And their investigator, Tom Brennan, is here as well. Tom, thank you for coming in. I know it's 10 years later, but it doesn't get any easier, does it?

No, it doesn't. The pain never go away? No. No. So I've listened to this podcast about three times. They want us to believe the initial police officers who showed up there that your daughter stabbed herself 20 times. It's ridiculous. Ridiculous.

Josh, seriously, how could they have come to that decision in that apartment in Manayunk? They walk in, she's been stabbed 20 times, and they call it a suicide? There's no way. As my wife said, it's ridiculous. It's absurd. And our journey through this today, over the decade or 10 years we've been involved in this, it's more ridiculous every day. Yeah, it seems like the case was botched from the opening day.

Tom, you've been investigating crimes for years and years. Do you agree with that? Yes. If you look at the timeline from the 26th of January through the 28th of January through the 28th of January, it totally discredits any good basic police work at all. Yeah. What transpired. We'll get into how the crime scene was completely deep clean way too soon.

The door was locked, right? Her door was locked from the inside. This is all what we've been told. There was never really an investigation to clearly illustrate any of this. What does that... She lived on what floor was this? Sixth floor.

The sixth floor. So this was the only way in or out of her apartment. Well, you can go out on the balcony, but you're not going to climb down or climb up again. Right, and there was a snowstorm that day. That's why she was home at one o'clock. And that was the only way in or out. You were up in Harrisburg at the time? Yes.

So I remember that huge snowstorm, my gosh. It was January of 2011. So you weren't able to come down right away? No. We couldn't come. We didn't get word of any of this until late into the evening. There were mounds of snow. Snowplows hadn't come through.

Who called you? The fiancé's father. And I didn't know what he meant I said you know where's the ambulance and then he said there is none because we won't need one and then you knew no I didn't really it was shocked well this is not what you expect to get a call from you have a 27 yearold daughter who's engaged to be married and living in Philadelphia with her fiancé. Had they been arguing? Not to our knowledge.

Not that we know of. And she had been to see a psychiatrist because she was having some troubles. She was having trouble at school. No. She had anxiety. Anxiety. Where was the anxiety coming from? Do you know?

I'm going to postulate. I can guess. There were various injuries on her body that were indicative of bruises and healing. Okay, let's go back to that. So there are bruises all over her body, and those bruises were from maybe days, weeks before she was attacked. They weren't part of that night. They were not part of that night. Were not part of that night. So now you've got to figure out what that is all about.

We are babes in the woods. We had no knowledge. If you know anything about this type of problem, it's very unlikely that the victim is going to say anything to you. And we think she was a victim. That's part of what's going on here.

Now, why in the world was the fiancé's uncle allowed to go into her apartment and take Ellie's stuff, her computer and stuff like that, after the apartment was deep cleaned? So now it's no longer a crime

scene. You can't get any material out of there now. This was done by a prominent attorney, Uncle, okay? And he's currently supposedly a judge on the state attorney's disciplinary board. Now, this individual removed Ellie's cell phone, the fiancé's laptop, Ellie's work laptop, and Ellie's personal laptop. So right then and there, that negates that chain of evidence. That adversely impacts the chain of evidence on those devices so that anything that's discovered on those devices can be challenged in court. Okay.

Any expert that you've hired since then, everybody that looks at this case says that Ellie was murdered. Correct. It was a homicide. It was a homicide, except for that initial report that day that said it was a suicide. But then it went back to a homicide, then back to a suicide. I think it went from homicide to suicide to homicide. Really? Yeah.

So what do we do now? I mean, obviously it needs to be reinvestigated. So we asked the Attorney General, is there anything you can do, yesterday? And he wrote back in a statement, we've looked at all. No, we're not going to reopen this case as of now. He needs more evidence, he says. It goes into how it's heartbreaking and all that. But he says they don't have legitimate new evidence to bring forward.

It has not been brought forward yet, so we're not going to do anything. So what can we do? I know you have a petition. Maybe if we all put enough pressure through this petition, we can get it reopened. Well, there are two things happening. Number one, there's a petition on change.org, which has over

110,000 signatures that we had nothing to do with. We don't elicit that, whatever. Number two, we are going to go to trial. And the purpose of our trial is to get the suicide changed to either undecided or homicide, which we prefer, and have the case reopened and investigated.

Now, that would be a non-jury trial. It happens to be a bench trial, yes. Okay, a bench trial. The Philadelphia situation with trials right now is very overloaded. You're not giving up? No. Why is it so important to get at least the determination changed from suicide to homicide? She was our daughter.

I mean, what would you do? I would do the same thing you're doing. The longer this goes on, the more we uncover, the more we discover. And just because you work for a government agency doesn't give you license to say whatever you want without facts and proving the facts. Do you think the key, the linchpin here, is what happened when they went into her apartment and took all of her stuff out? We don't know the why or the who, so don't ask us the why. It should have been you two in her apartment taking her stuff. Well, theoretically, if he took... No one had permission to touch her things.

Theoretically, he should have returned it to us the next day at her funeral, which he did not do. This statement by the Attorney General's office is vile. Why do you say it's a lie? Can you put it up again? It's a lie. In 2020, under growing public pressure and new evidence brought forward by Ellen's family and independent experts, the case was reopened for further investigation. The decision came despite receiving a deposition from a medical expert who noted that many of the nearly 20 stab wounds showed no signs of hemorrhage. This suggested that Ellen was

not even alive when those wounds were inflicted, and that these wounds were inflicted post-mortem. Which, for you true crime sleuths, you know that if they're post-mortem, that means that they were done after Ellen was dead, and that Ellen could not have done them. Plus, there were several other details that they believe indicated this was a homicide. If Ellen had planned on killing herself, why had she filled up her gas tank after leaving school? She certainly wouldn't need a full tank of gas for any reason. Why had she not left a note? Why was that half-finished fruit salad she made after getting home from school found on the kitchen counter above her body? And moreover, if she was intent on taking her life,

why had she chosen to stab herself? And why had she done so through her clothing, something that one expert noted as very rare in cases of suicide by stabbing. That in the rare occurrence that somebody is going to take their own life and choose stabbing as the method, that very rarely are they clothed, and that they usually do it when they are nude to ensure that it fully penetrates and that it is a fast process. Also, how would she inflict those wounds to her back, her head, and her neck? How would she have the physical strength to inflict all 20 of these wounds too and continue to inflict them even after the stab wounds that went to her

head and her brain, which certainly would have debilitated her, right? And taking a step back, and this is just my opinion, but thinking through that, if you're stabbing yourself 20 times in the torso, the back, the head, certainly one of those is going to either strike a nerve, be so painful to where you can't continue with this frenzied attack on yourself. And they have reports suggesting that she wouldn't have been able to inflict all of these, not to mention the report which said that these even happened post-mortem, not to mention the location of the wounds, 10 to the back of her neck, one in the scalp, eight times in the chest and the abdomen. Now I will say, some people out there who believe that this was in fact a suicide say, you know, stop with all the conspiracy

theories. The multiple knife wounds are consistent with a suicidal person who is, you know, testing their ability to go through with it. There's also no forensic evidence that ties Sam or anybody else to Ellen's death. There's no blood seen on Sam. There's no bloody clothing. It would be very difficult for Sam to murder Ellen, stage the scene, possibly move her body, clean everything up, and not leave any sort of evidence or DNA behind, all in a window of 30 minutes to an hour like we were talking about. Also, in a lot of the cases that we cover, when there is a stabbing involved, we know that especially if it's a mass stabbing, there is a lot of blood, and that typically the perpetrator's hand will slip on the blood, and they will sometimes cut themselves, whether it's on the hands, on their legs, whatever it is when they're going through

that up and down motion, but there were reportedly no cuts on Sam's hands. However, if you're like me, and like a lot of other true crime people out there, there's probably still some suspicion that the fiancé might have been involved. Something might still be creeping around in the back of your mind. We know that they were engaged, and her psychiatrist and her parents said that they had no reason to suspect that she was unhappy or that there was any sort of domestic violence in the relationship. Yet, according to Ellen's father, she had told her parents about a month earlier that she wanted to move home. So, could there have been trouble in paradise? The only issue that she was having is she was complaining that she was overwhelmed by the workload. But that was bullshit. That was the excuse. Ellen wants to come home,

and we don't know why, and she said that was the reason. But when Ellen passed, the teacher that took over her position said everything was in perfect order with Ellen's teaching and everything. And Grace, everything. There was no problem with her responsibilities to her job. Something else was happening. And think back to those text messages that Sam had sent Ellen when she wasn't opening the door that night after he returned from the gym. It showed a slew of text messages that appeared angry. He had said, Domestic violence author, advocate, and expert Barry Goldstein says that the text message,

you better have an excuse, raises an especially concerning red flag. He says, quote, He also says, that's the tone that I'm getting, and that's really the essence, of course, of control. Ellen's father told the hosts of a true crime podcast that they do know that she was abused before the attack. Further, that she had been ongoingly being abused, but did not know how to tell them, didn't know how to confide in her family or friends about what was going on. They also said that she didn't know how to ask the right questions to find out if she was a victim of domestic violence. And that takes us back to those bruises that were found on her body, the 11 bruises that were all in various

stages of healing. In many domestic violence cases, we often see that abuse will escalate from emotional to verbal to physical to deadly. Another interesting detail is on January 23rd, three days before Ellen's death, her family and friends received save-the-date cards for her wedding. I understand things can happen on a whim and somebody may be manically depressed or suffer from anxiety, and even if they sent those out that something may change but three days before they received those save the date cards so I think that's also a detail just worth mentioning. Now I'm going to go into a couple of the theories out there because as I'm sure you can imagine this case began to attract media attention all over with true crime sleuths, legal experts,

everybody questioning the original investigation. Could it be that Ellen was the victim of foul play and her death was covered up as a suicide? Or was there something even more sinister at work here? But please keep in mind these are all theories and nothing has been proven. So if she was thinking of taking her own life, would she have sent out those save the date cards? That's question number one. Her dad also said that she expressed wanting to move home, and we know that she recently had started suffering from anxiety, along with those mysterious 11 bruises. Could it be that Ellen had a discussion with Sam inside their apartment that afternoon, maybe informing him that she was leaving and perhaps that she wanted to call off the

wedding? Could this have angered him? Could the reason that Ellen had no defensive wounds be because she was blitz attacked? And could the reason that Ellen had no defensive wounds be because she was blitz attacked? And could the reason that she had wounds that appeared to have happened post-mortem be because this was, in fact, an overkill murder? 20 stab wounds and the killer kept going after she was already dead. Something that would have been physically impossible for her to do herself, according to the many experts. Could Sam have done this, and then left

for the gym for 45 minutes to create some sort of alibi or a timeline of sorts to cover his tracks? The last activity on Ellen's computer was four minutes before Sam arrived at the gym in their building. Was it Ellen using the computer? Or could it have been Sam trying to access her computer to, perhaps, log a note, write a note of some sort, maybe a suicide note? Or is it possible that when Ellen locked the door from the inside, it was because she was packing, or maybe even going through their computer or doing something else that might anger Sam, sparking him to send this string of overly aggressive text messages until he finally broke down the door? When he entered, did he see her going through

something or maybe doing something that angered him and then he blitz attacked her? That would also explain the lock being broken and those angry messages. Sam has never spoken publicly about his fiance's death, and he also has not responded to previous inquiries for interviews from the media. As of now, the official cause of Ellen's death remains a suicide, but the questions surrounding her case continue to haunt those who have studied it. And there's a whole other element to this case that I want to talk with you guys about. Her parents never got her journal back, which I have to ask, if it's a suicide and it's not a murder investigation, why wouldn't they receive it back? The case also saw a jurisdictional shift. Initially, it was handled

by the Philadelphia Police Department and the Philadelphia Medical Examiner's Office, but the Greenberg family fought to move the case to the Pennsylvania Attorney General's Office, arguing that the local authorities had a conflict of interest and had mishandled the investigation. In 2022, the Pennsylvania Attorney General's Office, which was led by then-Attorney General Josh Shapiro, declined to take over the case, citing a lack of sufficient evidence to overturn the suicide ruling. This decision was met with a lot of frustration from the Greenberg family, who continued to push for an independent investigation. Now, a controversial aspect of the case involves potential political connections that some people believe may have

influenced how this case was handled and why the then Attorney General Josh Shapiro declined to take over this case. First, Sam Goldberg's family connections. Sam Goldberg, Ellen's fiancee, is reportedly related to very influential figures in Philadelphia's legal and political circles. This has led to concerns that these connections might have affected the investigation into Ellen's death. Some people also think that the Attorney General Josh's decision to not reopen the case despite the new evidence that was presented by Ellen's family might have more reason behind it. Some people speculate that his decision might have been influenced by his ties to Sam's family, though

there's no direct evidence to prove that, I want to be clear. However, remember his cousin's father, who is a lawyer and called him five minutes before Sam called 911? There's apparently a connection there. Apparently, Attorney General Josh Shapiro and Sam's uncle, James, their kids all go to school together. There's even photos of all of them together. So many are raising the question and saying it's interesting that at 6.14, Sam calls his cousin, who's a lawyer. A few minutes after that phone call, his cousin's dad, who's a lawyer, calls Sam back.

They talk. Then the 911 call is made. Then a friend of the lawyer family, and arguably a friend of the fiancé Sam by extension, is the attorney general, who they're begging to reopen the case, to reclassify it. He refuses, saying there's a lack of evidence, but he's friends with the fiancé's family. Certainly that is a conflict of interest, right? Also, get this. That Uncle James, the lawyer lawyer was allowed into the crime

scene to get Sam's suit, but then he apparently left with Ellen's computers, wallet, phone, handbag, and other items. In 2018, one of their attorneys became the DA in Philadelphia, so to avoid a conflict of interest, he sent the case to the state attorney, a state attorney general, in fact, who at the time was this guy, if he looks familiar, he should, it's Josh Shapiro, the same Josh Shapiro who is now Pennsylvania's governor.

And Governor Shapiro, back then, he too signed off on that suicide finding. Suicide! He signed off on it! Governor! But then came allegations never proven that Josh Shapiro, now governor, also had a conflict, a relationship with the family of that fiance, Sam Goldberg. Yesterday, our Brian Enten sat down with Ellen Greenberg's parents, Josh and Sandy Greenberg. And here's what they said about the winding path

that this case has taken and about Josh Shapiro in particular. Did it bother you that Shapiro never, it doesn't seem like he took a personal interest in your case. Yeah, but we have no power. I still don't have power over him. you that Shapiro never it doesn't seem like he took a personal interest in your case. Yeah. But we have no power. I still don't have power over him.

But I wonder why he didn't. Why we didn't? No, why he didn't. Beats me. I'll answer that. I think he tried to keep his hands off as much as possible because I think deep down he knew this was a hot potato. He might have known other things that we didn't know also, like why this is happening that we don't know.

Well, we emailed his office and haven't heard anything. You're not going to hear anything. But good. Good. Ask away. It just seems like for a politician, that would be something you could be proud of, helping a case get solved, finding the truth.

He didn't. He went that same, he went what I'm going to call the party line. This is a suicide. That was the party line. Every piece of this story is, I look at it in disbelief. I keep looking for alternative theories, for explanations. I try, I really do try to come up with some reasonable explanation as to how the police botched this so badly and how others after that seem to be just fine signing off on what seems comical. But Brian, I don't understand. What were Ellen Greenberg's parents like? What was the response they had when you talked to them about the fact that Sam Goldberg's judge uncle and judge and lawyer cousin were able to get into that apartment and leave with her laptop and her cell phone? I mean, they're shocked now when they think about it. Actually, at the time, you can imagine their daughter was dead.

They were still trying to understand what happened. It didn't sit right with them that it was being called a suicide. They were grieving. So they were trying to process all of it. They thought it was a lockdown crime scene. They didn't know that people could just go in there. This is what they said about it. Upsetting thing to me is the unauthorized uncle came to the building, got permission they left with Ellen's two computers, Ellen's wallet, car keys, handbag, cell phone, you know, critical electronics that they had no business taking.

They never had permission. I'm suspicious of that. So the police didn't immediately take those things? No, they waited till Saturday. Three or four days. Why? We don't know. That's a good question. Ask the Philadelphia Police Department. We never had any phone calls ever telling us what was going on. I also want to mention another bizarre story about her spine sample. Because the coroner apparently walked a few blocks through the snow with the sample in a jar so that they could show it to the neuropathologist. And this coroner said in that civil suit deposition

that he would not have changed his ruling from homicide to suicide if he had known that the fiancé, Sam, broke down the door himself. However, at the time, the police had told him that the doorman was involved in this. And I find that very interesting because there were a lot of conflicting reports on this. Remember how Sam said he went down to the doorman trying to get him to come up to help him get into the apartment, but the doorman refused? Well, apparently, there's reports out there where they, but the doorman refused. Well, apparently, there's reports out there where they said that the doorman was with him, almost like he could verify that

it was locked, he could vouch for him. But now the coroner said in that deposition, had I known that the doorman wasn't with him, and that Sam broke the door down himself, I definitely would not have changed the ruling from homicide to suicide. So in short, some people believe that these political connections might have played a role in the case not being thoroughly investigated. However, this all remains a matter of speculation. In July of this year, the state Supreme Court agreed to hear the family's appeal regarding the death certificate and the wrongful death and the ruling. So we will see what comes from that and if there is any movement. Tonight, we're learning a legal back and forth over the death investigation of Ellen Greenberg will now go to the Pennsylvania Supreme Court. The 28-year-old teacher was found dead inside her Maniunk apartment with 20 stab wounds in 2011. Her death was ruled a suicide,

but her parents believe she was murdered. Her family is hoping the state's highest court will help bring answers and shed light on how and why she died. It's been a long haul. Let's start with that. We're very appreciative. We don't know how to express our gratitude for this. Ellen Greenberg's parents have been fighting to have her death ruled a homicide or undecided. Her body was found with 20 stab wounds more than 13 years ago. The Philadelphia medical examiner has ruled her death a suicide. Over 20 stab wounds, 10 in the back, 10 in the front that she had. And it was homicide. No doubt about it.

Last September, a lower court wrote, While this court is acutely aware of the deeply flawed investigation of the victim's death by the City of Philadelphia Police Department detectives, the City of Philadelphia District Attorney's Office, and the Medical Examiner's Office, we have no choice under the law but to reverse and remand to the trial court for the entry of judgment in favor of the Medical Examiner's Office. It's just a journey that's continuously uphill, and every step forward, they, excuse me, trip us. So we go back two steps. There's been no cooperation, no information, no conferences or, you know, communication or anything with the authorities. It's always she committed suicide.

We can prove it and they can't prove it can prove it, and they can't prove it, and I can prove they can't prove it. Greenberg's family filed an appeal that has now made its way to the Pennsylvania Supreme Court, the family hoping the court will now open up a path to further investigate how the 27-year-old teacher died. I would like to have an unbiased investigation led by an unbiased team with an unbiased leader and I would like to so I can get the truth. A family's long search for answers taking one step forward. The Greenbergs have filed multiple lawsuits pushing the case to be reopened and investigated as a homicide. Their determination has kept the case in the public eye ensuring that Ellen's story is not

forgotten. However the mystery continues because who if anyone was responsible for Ellen's story is not forgotten. However, the mystery continues. Because who, if anyone, was responsible for Ellen's death? Was it a botched investigation? Was it something far more nefarious and sinister? And most chillingly, I mean, could a killer still be out there having successfully evaded justice and never got caught? My hindsight is 20-20. When we hired experts and we read the autopsy and you find out the amount of bruising and various stages of healing, the contusions, the dry, waculated blood that went from her nose to her ear, which meant she had all been moved. And the amount of abuse that her body... There's a murderer and an abuser in Philadelphia somewhere today. We failed and we've accomplished something

after 13 or 14 years. No one has ever gotten as far as we have with a case like this, fighting the criminal justice system, the medical examiner, and all the other things involved in this case. It's painful for us. I mean, it was a crushing blow to lose her. But what we're doing is what we're doing for Ella.

Homicide detectives hate to admit it, but there is a way to get away with murder. Make it look like a suicide. And what's worse is it's almost impossible for victims' families to legally challenge a manner of death ruling by a medical examiner or a coroner. Three ex-boyfriends came to pay their respects at the funeral, which I think was pretty amazing, considering, you know, she had moved on with her life. A lot of her friends didn't know each other necessarily before Ellen passed, but as a result of her passing, she brought a lot of people together. Do you think that Ellen took her own life? Or do you think that she was murdered? Let me know in the comment section or on the Q&A section on Spotify. Thank you guys so much for tuning into another episode and for hearing Ellen's story. Let's continue to hope that she does get the justice she deserves and that the truth comes to light.

But I am curious to know what you guys think. Also, just another reminder about those tour tickets. Get them at AnnieElise.com on the events page and come hear one of these episodes live with me in person. I'll be back on the mic with you Thursday for this week's headline highlights. And then, of course, next Monday with an all new episode, a deep dive into a case. Guys, I don't know. We have just got so much to talk about this week. So I will be back with you very soon.

But I want to know what you think about this case. All right, guys. Thanks again. And until the next one, please stay safe. Bye.