Sex Talks With Emma-Louise Boynton - Andrew Tate, Baby Reindeer and the myths surrounding male sexuality with Ben Hurst and David Chambers
Episode Date: June 6, 2024On this week’s episode we’re talking about men. Specifically, masculinity, male sexuality and the myths surrounding it. To that end, Emma was joined by Men’s Dating, Relationship & In...timacy Coach, David Chambers, and the Director of Facilitation at Beyond Equality, an organisation that is rethinking masculinity and engaging men and boys in the gender equality conversation, Ben Hurst. From the impact of Andrew Tate and why his messaging has become so insidious, to the ways in which hit tv show, Baby Reindeer, highlighted how men often feel unable to talk about sexual abuse and harassment and the reasons behind that, to Ben and David’s own relationship to sex growing up and the impact growing up in the church had on their respective feelings of sexual shame, we covered a lot in this discussion. We hope you enjoy this episode as much as we did. The next live recording of the Sex Talks podcast is on June 19th and will see us turn our attention to men once again as we discuss what a positive notion of masculinity looks like today and how shedding reductive gender stereotypes can help us all have a better relationship to sex, intimacy and relationships. You can purchase tickets to the event here. And subscribe to the Sex Talks Substack here.
Transcript
Discussion (0)
Hello and welcome to the Sex Talks podcast with me, your host Emma Louise Boynton.
Sex Talks exists to engender more honest, open and vulnerable discussions around typically taboo topics,
like sex and relationships, gender inequality, and the role technology is playing and changing the way we date, love and fuck.
Our relationship to sex tells us so much about who we are and how we show up in the world,
which is why I think it's a topic we ought to talk about
with a little more nuance and a lot more curiosity.
So each week I'm joined by a new guest
whose expertise on the topic I'd really like to mind
and do well just that.
From writers, authors and therapists
to act as musicians and founders,
we'll hear from a glorious array of humans
about the stuff that gets the heart of what it means to be human.
If you want to join the conversation outside of the podcast,
sign up to my newsletter via a link in the show notes
or come along to a live recording of the podcast at the London Edition Hotel.
Okay, I hope you enjoy the show.
I think that boys today are struggling with knowing how to connect with each other
and how to connect with other people.
And I think those are the kinds of questions that we hear all the time.
On this week's episode, we're talking about men,
specifically male sexuality and the myths surrounding it.
I wanted to have this discussion because while I try to make the conversations we have at sex talks,
as inclusive as possible. I'm also aware that we tend to focus pretty heavily on women's
experience of sex and pleasure and intimacy. And as valuable as I obviously believe these discussions
to be, I also realise that nothing changes if men aren't part of these conversations too.
If we're going to change what I think is our pretty broken sex culture, one entrenched in shame
and shrouded in taboo, and if we're going to finally close that orgasm gap, we need men. We need
all genders to be a part of this dialogue. I also admittedly wanted to challenge my own, lazy,
not particularly well-thought-out assumptions around male sexuality, like the idea that men don't
experience anxiety around sex like women do, or that men don't carry sexual shame, particularly around
self-pleasure and their bodies like we do. As this conversation showed me, they certainly do.
And I was reminded that we all lose out in some way, thanks to reductive gender norms and a taboo-laden sex
culture. So for this very fascinating conversation on sex and masculinity, I was lucky enough to sit
down with two pretty exceptional men, David Chambers, who is a men's dating, relationship and
intimacy coach, and Ben Hurst, director of facilitation at Beyond Equality, an organization that is
rethinking masculinity and engaging men and boys in the gender equality conversation. I left
this podcast recording with my mind buzzing with ideas.
But there was one thing in particular that really stuck out for me.
Talking about men's issues, about men's mental health and well-being,
about men's place in the world,
none of these things take away from discussions surrounding women's equality.
Nor does talking about the challenges men face today
negate focus on the very pressing challenges that women face today too.
Right. I hope you enjoy this show as much as I did.
Oh, and this episode was recorded live at Soho House.
Welcome to Sex Talks.
I am joined by men's dating relationship and intimacy, intimacy, into me see, coach, you like that, David Chambers.
And I'm also joined by Ben Hurst, who's the director, recently promoted.
Yes, we love that, a facilitation at Beyond Equality, which, for anyone who doesn't know, Beyond a
equality's work, they are brilliant. It's a charity dedicated to helping men rethink what being a man
means for them and others, and to engage all men in preventing gender-based violence while
creating communities that are safe for everyone. Doing the Lord's work over there, Ben. So, I would
love to get started, really by hearing a bit more from both of you about the nature of the work that
you do. So, David, I'm going to turn to you first. I have actually very, very much. I have actually
very seldom. Through sex talks, I've interviewed many sex therapists, sex coaches, etc. And probably
my own internal bias is part of this, but they're all women. And there are very few men working
in the space. So tell me a little bit about what you do, who you're speaking to and why you got
into it. This is a hard question. We were talking about this yesterday. I really help men have a deeper
experience of themselves and the relationships that they have. That's how I see. Also,
help men get past some of the blocks and some of the patterns that block them from having
the relationships they want, the dating lives they want, or the intimacy and sex they would
really desire to have. Because often there's things we want, that we want great sex. Everyone
wants great sex, right? But when we don't have the great sex, we don't really know what to do.
We don't know what to do to change it. One of the most common questions ask people when they
come to work with me is, hey, so this thing isn't working. What have you tried? Nothing. Okay.
that's why I'm here now
you're like okay cool but how long is it going on for
anything from six months to
15 years you know
spoutes people have issues and they've lasted a long time
so
I do a lot of helping them
with intimacy in particular
it is a lot of looking at
their patterns and the scripts
that run inside the relationships
a lot of the men I work around intimacy
in relationships so it's like what's the patterns
that's happening in your intimacy
and when the things kind of go sideways
what's the moment things go sideways
What's the feeling? What's the sensation? What's said? What's not said? What do you hide? And then what do you do when it goes sideways? Like, what do you start doing? Do you shut down? Do you withdraw? Do you attack? Do you get critical? And then what does your partner do in those moments? And then we start to like unpick those different places and start to see why, what happened when you were, but younger, when you started having sex in the moment when you think there's some criticism or you perceive criticism because criticism can be very perceived just by a look.
You know, you can look at me a certain way
and I can think, oh no, she's criticising the way
that I'm having sex with her shit.
She doesn't want to have sex with me anymore
and then suddenly I'm no longer in that moment
and I'm off in my worries and my stresses
and we lose connection
and then you realize and then I realize that you realized
and then, you know, things kind of go downhill from there
for a lot of us.
And David, why you?
Because you were in tech before
and you were, I believe,
one of London's top software testers
which I then went down.
Where did you think that out?
Well, then I started Googling what is a software tester?
And then how many women are software testing?
Yeah, so few.
I went down a whole just Googling software testing.
But what made you then shift from software testing into different kind of software testing?
Yeah, very different.
Human software.
So I guess the story is a bit longer.
Many years ago, I struggled in my own dating life.
You know, I struggled my own day in life.
I wasn't meeting sort of women.
really want to. So I started reading online and books and all sorts of things and through a very
strange turn of events over about two or three months. I found myself coaching men in bars and clubs
in London when I was about 24 years old, working for, as you do. And it was something I just did
on the side. I was still working in tech at the time. And I loved it. What I really loved was it was
the first time my life. Like I didn't grow up with any kind of father figures. You know, my dad
to send me around in my life and I had a stepdad who was extremely useless. So it was a first
first time I came together in a group of men where we were really committed to being better
and supporting each other and being better and giving each other feedback. So I did this work
and I loved it. It was a lot of fun and I got to really understand how humans interact when they're
sober, when they're drunk, when they love each other, when they like each other, when they want
to hook up with each other. You know, I could walk in a room and I could look at a group of
free people and go, okay, that girl on the left, she's single, those other two in relationships,
that guy over there likes that girl. She actually likes him, but he hasn't noticed because I just saw
pictures. And then I left
that well because I just experienced
some clients who I felt didn't love women.
My whole thing is I got three sisters. I, you know,
raised by my mother. I have a deep love
for women and those
who want to love women. And I met a lot
of men who didn't. Unfortunately, you know, if not
through their own wounding and their experiences
of women in their younger years or teenage
years. So I left that and I continued
in my software testing world.
But I kept going to like self-development.
I've always been very interested in self-development.
How can I better myself? How
can I better myself in the many aspects of my thinking and do that because that's the work
I can do. And then I guess there was a point I went traveling for two years. I've traveled around
the world for two years. I came back and I was like, okay, I don't like my job because it pays me
really well, but I don't enjoy it. I'm really good at it, but I don't enjoy it. And I went to work
for a little startup and that was probably the best job. And out of that, a friend of mine, a good
friend of mine come to me and said, hey, David, should we start a podcast? I was like, what?
What about? He's like, let's bring all the dating knowledge we have with the self-development
knowledge we have because there's a gap. Men are being told what to say and what to do,
but they're not being taught their authenticity is what's really going to drive them towards
the relationships they want. So I said, yeah, man, let's do it. And that was five years ago. I've
recorded probably almost 300 episodes of that podcast since then. And I've evolved just out
of daying into relationships and intimacy, study tantra. So yeah, I just have a thirst for learning
around human connection and how we connect in the tiniest moments, you know, it's the
it's the looks that started
and we often we struggle
to understand why that's important
you know well I think you can tell so
much I think our relationship to sex
what happens behind closed doors is so
revealing not just your naked body
but it's so revealing of our
like true insecurities
and I would you know in that
most vulnerable moment with someone
else it's often the point at which we feel
less least equipped
to articulate what we need and what we want
so you can be a badass boss
speech in the rest of your life and then it comes to sex and suddenly you're like oh god like
what do i do i do i say i'm going to put a pin and well i actually have many pins on my head now
i kind of had this kind of ongoing board in my head but loads of things you just said there
we will return to throughout this conversation but ben i want to turn to you um so i'm interested
to know a little bit more about the work that you're doing at beyond equality the nature of the
conversations that you're facilitating and the kind of boys that you're talking to who are they
What questions do they have?
Wow, it's loud.
Yeah, so for those of you don't know,
hello everyone, by the way.
For those of you don't know,
Beyond Equality is a gender equity organisation.
So we work across schools, universities,
corporate spaces, pro sports teams.
Essentially, like, anywhere that men go
and they can't get away, like we work there.
So, like, we trap them in rooms.
And it's interesting to hear you speak, right?
Because we're like the opposite sides
of, like, the same critical questioning coin.
I feel. And so our organisation, the way I view it is like we're the first touch point that most guys have in conversations around gender and in conversations around masculinity. And obviously people have had conversations about masculinity before. But I mean like real serious like deep diving, thinking about stuff that you maybe have not thought about before kind of conversations. And so in schools, we have conversations with boys from year eight upwards. So about 13 upwards. I feel like that's 13. 12.
13 and really it's like a deconstruction and a reconstruction of masculinities and so I think like for me a big part of the issue with the whole conversation around masculinity is that's just so prescriptive there's like one way of being a man and if you're not that then you're not part of the club and it becomes really difficult for you but even if you are that like it's still quite difficult and so we try to open up spaces where we give guys opportunities to kind of ask those questions about masculinity what is it that you like about this what is it that you don't like about this
What serves you, what doesn't serve you, what helps you, what helps your community and what hinders your community around you.
And generally when you ask those kinds of questions, obviously not like that, like they're really fun and there's loads of activities and running around and throwing stuff at each other and all that kind of stuff.
But when you ask those kinds of questions, most guys will arrive at like relatively healthy conclusions by themselves or in their peer groups.
So we try to create those spaces across a range of different like forums for guys to really do that exploration for themselves and with.
each other and I was quite conscious as I prepared this interview I didn't want us to do a deep
dive into Andrew Tate at any point because I think he's got given got he's given so much airtime
I'm actually like to stop filing the flames however we're just going to do a little quick
just I'm curious as you say that and you're talking to these young boys and you just said that
actually quite a positive conversation emerges when you begin when you know after whatever
games they're playing then they're like okay cool
We can talk about this.
But I'm interested to know how pervasive is the messaging and the ideology, the hate speech that Andrew Tate has put out into the world amongst the boys that you're working with?
Yeah, it's a good question.
It is pervasive.
Pervasive is the right word, right?
It's like insidious and it gets everywhere.
But I think the reason that it is that way is because it resonates with what we already have.
Do you know what I mean?
like it's not like Andrew Tate's the bad guy
I mean Andrew Tate is a bad guy
but Andrew Tate's the bad guy who says the bad things
and everybody's just following the Pied Piper
it's like the reason that he gets away with saying those things
and the reason why people listen
is because he's actually speaking to something
that we've been told the whole of our lives
do you know what I mean like when you think about those scripts
of what it is to be a man and what masculinity means
those messages are messages that boys grow up believe in
you're meant to be strong you're meant to be tough
you're meant to be the hero you're meant to save the day
you're meant to get the woman
and then it becomes quite corrupted
and turns into something that's like
really, really harmful and damaging
but I don't think anybody really
and it's not just in boys like it's in grown men
we find this as well that like loads of people
never stop to question
where those ideas come from
or whether they like those ideas for themselves
and for other people
and so I guess it gets in
in loads of different ways
and it's no different from when we were kids
I mean like I remember being 14 and
watching South Park and finding it absolutely
hilarious. I mean, South Park is still funny, but
like, um, you know
what I mean, like, it's fucked. Um, so
it's like, I remember watching like
all of those kinds of things and like stealing my...
Is it? I actually don't, is it? Yeah.
Yeah. I haven't watched it. Yeah. I mean, I don't watch it anymore, but it's pretty
yeah. Oh. And like, not just South Park, sorry, not to demonise South
Park, but like, I remember like stealing my cousins, my older cousins copy of like
American Pie and just watching shit that I wasn't supposed to be watching and
learning stuff that I wasn't supposed to be learning. And in turn a
in it and believing that that was what life was going to be like.
Even like the office, the office isn't that bad, but like I just remember really at like 14, 15,
watching all of these things and thinking, oh, that's what my life is going to be like.
And so I think when you grow up in this kind of environment with like all of these messages that get fed to us,
it is quite weird to then just assume that people are going to one day just develop a critical consciousness
and be like, no, Andrew Tate's wrong.
We don't believe or agree with any of the things he's saying.
and I think boys are told that
the reason that that stuff gets to be said
is because that's what other people want from them
and so they're seeking some kind of validation
usually from women but also from other men
to kind of validate their existence in that way
and so they're just clean I think boys are young
and they're looking for answers you know what I mean
and we don't do a great job of giving them
no and we'll return to this a little bit later
in the conversation but I just wanted to reflect back on that
I interviewed Laura Bates the woman who set up
the everyday sexist campaign is totally brilliant
actually the last sex talks here at short house and she said kind of mirroring what you've
you've just said there ben that none of the messages that we're hearing from you know extremists
like agitate anew like misogyny's been around for a while but what is new is the algorithm
pumping out their videos to a the like perfect demographic of young men in the most you know
extreme kind of way so that his videos have been viewed more than 11 billion times that's more
people than that are on the planet and that's the algorithm and the social media
platforms that are largely unaccountable for their huge amounts of power that they wield
in terms of getting that messaging out. So I guess that's a shift that we've seen from when
we were growing up to what kind of young people are exposed to now. But we'll return to that
not to Andrew Tate, as I said, don't want to give the guy too much airtime. We're done with
Andrew Tate. I am curious to go a little bit more personal with both of you. So we've heard
a little bit about what you do. But I'd be curious to know about your own relationship to sex
and sexuality growing up. I mentioned the panel I saw you both speak on before and I was really
struck at the kind of vulnerability that both of you demonstrated when speaking about your own
relationship to sex. And it really struck me that I very, very, very seldom hear men talk
openly about sex, dating, and relationships. And I think that's a shame. It's this, you know,
these topics are so important. It's like the undercurrent of all of our lives. So, David,
I'll turn to you first. What was your relationship like to sex and to self-pleasure and your
sexuality growing up? Were you always this open?
and your ability to talk about intimacy?
No. I grew up in a religious household.
My mum still goes to church every week.
It was a Pentecostal church when I was young.
It was very fire and brimstone.
For those of you that know that, you do something wrong.
Hellfire!
Passed at the front.
That was every Sunday for me.
Every Sunday.
You know, people praying for me and then telling me they've seen signs on God
that I'm going to do this and I've done this thing wrong
and that I should repent for a thing that I haven't done yet.
I luckily
in the whole process
was like this is bullocks
these people are just trying to control
everybody and this is bollocks and I'm getting out
as fast as I can
but there was no sex disgust in my house
my mum had never talked about sex
we've all had that experience sex scene comes on the
TV everyone turns to each other and starts
talking the TV magically
changed his channel and then we return
to watching you know I don't know man
what it could be I was going to say antique road show but
there's very rarely sexy
I remember seeing Crossroads I remember that Britney Spears
film. My dad, bless him, took me and my sister to see the preview and didn't realize, I guess,
the premise of it. It's all about her having penitre of sex the first time. And for half of the
film, my dad was literally like, and me and my sister, we were about 10 and 8. And like, always
we kind of knew what sex were, but it was the pain I felt he was in. It was just so excruciating.
Anyway, we digress. So you would have the channel be changed. You didn't talk about sex.
at home? No, no, I didn't talk about sex at home. Yeah, I guess I would say as a late bloomer
as well, you know, I didn't really have much interest in girls until I got into my late teens.
But I kind of was a bit fascinated by sex because it was this thing that no one talked about.
And because no one talked about it, I was like, okay, where can I get information? And at that
point it was TV, you know, you could watch a show. I remember there being a show, and I think it was
called Sex Tips for Girls or something. You used to have couples and used to talk about sexism.
used to come on Channel 4 at like 11.30 at night,
and I would watch that and listen and learn.
And then I guess when I started to get sexually active at school
and then at university,
my first girlfriend, I think this is really real benefit,
is that we were really just like open to talking about things.
So we tried things and be like, how was that for you?
Did you enjoy that?
That felt strange.
I didn't know.
I didn't enjoy that.
And I remember, oh, God, can I tell this story?
Yeah, I tell this story.
were at my family home
and my mum was out and my sisters were out
it was, you know, it was at middle of day, school day
and we were getting sexually active in my bedroom
and we say there was a slight rip and tear on my side
and it was one of the most excruciately, like the pain is
incredible and for days after that
you know, man I didn't want to touch me
because I'd get an erection and then I'd be in more pain
but we talked about it.
you know it wasn't like oh my god
this thing happened let's not talk about it she was like are you okay
I was like yeah it's bleeding there's blood on the floor
you know and then each day
she's like how are you feeling I was like oh it's a little bit of pain
here and there and I was like don't feel bad it's not your fault
it's just an accident these things happened
so I guess this good communication
aided me quite well reasonably good communication
I was great took me into my early 20s
when I was quite experimental with the women I'd meet
and I would be really curious about their experience of sex
and what they liked and I'd ask them about other men
And they slept with like, how was it? What was good? What did you enjoy?
David, where did this come from? If you grew up in the church and you didn't talk about sex at home, I quite a similar background, and I did not know how to communicate. I thought I was going to marry Draco Malfoy from Harry Potter, and I never said anything. How did you become such a great communicator?
I guess I was curious. Yes, silently, you know, quietly. It's a different question. The masturbation is like, for all boys, is this shame-ridden thing, right? Because you hear about wanking and it's usually.
usually because in my school, I went to a boy's school for a while,
and it was like, that boy's a wanker, and wanking is bad.
And then I remember saying to him, I was like, Andrew, like, what is wanking?
He was like, oh, it's really, you know, you play with your dick.
I was like, oh, you do that.
He was like, yeah, it's great.
I thought, really? Okay.
And I remember one day being like, okay, no one's home, I'm going to try it.
And I was like, wow, this is amazing.
But equally, I'm suddenly like, this is amazing, but I also feel lots of shame
because this is bad and everyone's going to tease me at school if they know.
So we tie these two things together
And I've worked with a few Catholic men in particular
They have a really special type of sexual shame
That's like so deeply rooted in their existence
It's very painful for them
Where like literally they'll masturbate
And these guys either have to shower afterwards
Or do something that cleanses them of this shame
Or that it's just so shame ridden
They feel sad, they feel depressed afterwards
For me it was just this kind of gentle shame
And then I kind of realised that it was ridiculous in my 20s
but there was no sex education
there was no conversations in my house
like I've got three sisters
I've got an older sister
like we never talked about sex
I guess I was just
I guess I wanted to be good
that was my thing
I was like I want to be good
and how I'm going to be good at sex
yeah so how I'm going to be good at sex
is by talking to the women I have sex
about sex and I didn't feel
there was anything particularly shameful about that
inherently for whatever reason
and it meant that
you know, I had some wonderful conversations and experiences with some of the women I slept with early
because we would literally lie in bed and I'd be like, how does that feel? That feel good.
I have to just note that it's refreshing to hear you say, refreshing a little bit depressing,
but to hear you say that wanking was, you know, in some so much shame,
because I think there's such a big conversation now around female pleasure
and I think there's been such a growth in the sexual wellness industry
that has really put female pleasure front and centre as it should be
and I think there's been such a taboo around female like self-pleasure for so long
I know growing up at school no one talked about self-pleasure
but I felt it was kind of kosher and normal for the boys to wank
and that was kind of socially acceptable but for girls that wasn't something we did
and actually I think then naively I don't think I recognise
that there was still that shame associated with boys wanking
and obviously when you think about the ridder's shame that comes into that as well
there's such a kind of that melting pot
of bodily disconnection that happens for all of us
I guess from a young age
and then what about you
you also grew up in a religious household I did
yeah again same side of a
or different side of the same coin
but maybe same side of the same coin
I grew up in church I've got mum
dad three older sisters at home
which is not really relevant to this part of the story
actually I don't know why I just told you that
also can I just say
my partner's daughter is here
so this is a little bit awkward
but also it's chill because we talk about this stuff at home
all the times it's fine
but I guess
in regards to like learning
about sex and sexuality
I grew up in a church environment
and it was the same kind of vibe
do you know what I mean like it was just
a taboo
wasn't something that we were supposed to talk about
definitely not something we were supposed to be doing
which is like weird
because I went to like the best church youth group
ever in the history of
of all of the church youth groups that have ever existed.
It was, honestly, it was, like, so good.
And they used to have, like, relationships nights every month,
and we'd talk about, like, wait until marriage
and, like, what sex is supposed to be, like, in marriage,
and not having sex until you're married,
and, like, not masturbating, and all of those kinds of things,
and fighting temptation.
So it wasn't that we weren't having any conversations about it.
It was just, like, the sex education we were getting
was probably better than the stuff we were getting in school,
but just wasn't very good.
And I think, for me, I, later on,
went to seminaries. I went to a Bible
college and studied to be a pastor. I did a degree
in theology. And I got kicked
out when I... Do you lose your virginity?
When I gave my virginity away?
Is virginity even a real thing? But when I had...
We don't really say lose virginity. Yeah, yeah, yeah.
You know, so I say penitious sex.
That's why I didn't say it.
But I got kicked out when I had penetrative sex
for the first time.
Which was like a weird experience.
Because it was like all of the stuff that I'd learned
growing up about what happens when you have sex.
It's bad. And you're not supposed to do it outside of
marriage like actually came through and it was like I was excommunicated I wasn't part of the
community anymore all of my friends wouldn't talk to me my mom wouldn't chat to me for like a
month which was super awkward my mom knew which was horrible and and that was also like a weird
experience because that was my first time having penetrated sex but I was maybe 21 years old
and so I felt like I was kind of late to the game and I think that I dealt with a lot of same way
a lot of shame, a lot of guilt, even before sex, like to do with masturbation and all of that
kind of stuff, like, there was just a real feeling of like every time, we used to call it bashing,
which is a weird way of describing it.
But yeah, but every time you would bash in inverted commas, it was like a wave of like guilt and shame
that would come over you afterwards and you kind of just get out of the situation and like
pretend it didn't happen. And I had like some friends that I would talk to about at church and
some friends who I talked to her about at school.
but it was just a super awkward experience
and throughout that time I'd had like
unofficial girlfriends and like been seeing people
and dated people and stuff
and we'd always like gone to the edge and not gone too far
and that was like a weird experience as well
because it wasn't something we were supposed to talk about
so we didn't talk about it
and I think the time that I realised that it like had to change
was probably I got a job working for a sex education charity
a Christian sex education charity
which is like a misnomer actually
but they were like teaching
so we'll go around schools in South London
and the messaging was like
sex is best within committed faithful relationships
whatever those look like for you
so it wasn't specifically about marriage
but it was about like still abstaining
waiting and then all of the actual
good sex ed stuff so stuff around
STI's pregnancy
emotional connection all of that kind of stuff
and I think when I was training
for that job I realized
that like nobody had ever had those conversations
with me do you know what I mean like I was I was literally
like by was that oh everyone's chatting shit
like literally nobody knows what they're talking about
and everybody's just making this up with other people
around them and so for me
I think that was kind of a
weird form of liberation because it was
still quite repressive in lots of ways like I still
had a weird relationship to sex and sexuality
at that point because I was still in faith
but a real
realization that like
that sexuality is yours and you own
it do you know what I mean and you get to do what you
want to do with it as long as other people
consent of course
but that exploration is that something to enjoy and something to be valued and so I think from that point onwards
relationships became like very different and I think at the start it was still really awkward and still really weird
but acknowledging yeah yeah yeah yeah oh my gosh unshackling from the shame and that guilt because I think
as you both just reflected on there when you learn to associate sexual pleasure with shame yeah and so that
sensation literally is the trigger then for kind of being awash with guilt and with shame it's a hard
thing to unlearn that's a hard thing to get rid of i remember the first time i masturbating the shower
i and i was religious and very very god fearing and i was 12 and i just from thinking oh my god
he's seen he's seen he's watching me and i went to bed feeling terrible god had watched me
masturbate the shower head and i was shook with the shower head it's the shower head
And I never did. I didn't do again. Like I was so racked in that shame around and I mean, you know, for some voyeurism is kind of hot. I don't think I would turn me on now. But back then like, you know, God voyeurism ain't the one. God voyeurism is not hot. That is not a turn out. Actually, that's true. Not even now with that term me on. I'm interested to know. So you both, as I say, reflected on the ways in which kind of shame and guilt play a big part in your respective kind of relationship to sex. Something has been on my mind recently, I watched baby reindeer, a lot of.
alongside everyone else in the country slash world.
Has everyone else here seen it?
Yes, okay.
Everyone, yes?
Just so, okay, I have my explanation for those who haven't.
If you need it, I think I know back.
Okay, so for those who haven't seen it,
the show follows a struggling comic
as he is relentlessly harassed and stalked by women
for more than four years
and comes to terms of being sexually abused in a nutshell.
It's a problematic show for many reasons,
as people now know, Piers Morgan,
is a central role in that.
But what I found really interesting
is the way of explored male sexual shame,
particularly around abuse.
And I was struck that male sexual abuse charities
have in the aftermath of the screening of baby reindeer
seen a really notable increase in calls.
One charity in particular called We Are Survivors
reported an 80% increase in first-time callers
asking about the support the charity offers.
80%.
The CEO and founder of the charity, Duncan Greig, said he's never seen a response like it.
Now, I'm interested with that.
What do you think are the kind of cultural myths surrounding male sexuality that we should be thinking about in order to understand why men might not want to come forward when they've experienced sexual abuse or sexual harassment?
I think the first one we get a lot with men is, oh, you wanted it.
you're lucky he got lucky right that's a lot of what we say right to men oh men get lucky i love to
know how much funding that charity gets because i know for something like that funding doesn't reach
to them they probably don't get that much funding right because it's a male centric um sexual
abuse cherry people aren't interested they're like oh men do all this all the time that would
literally be people why aren't why aren't people interested because i guess it's how
we see men and we see them as sexual predators, right? That's basically the way we see men.
With the assumption that all men are sexual predators and then after that he used to prove himself
that he's not. And I understand completely why that's the case, right? Because of what men do
constantly, daily, weekly, hourly by the minute. But that weighs really heavily on guys, especially
because we always think of kind of sexual predators and we think of those guys and then we go, oh,
all men are like that. And I guess in my work I speak to a lot of men who are so far removed
from that, that they're, like, sexually passive.
I wonder if there's another word for, like, the opposite of passive,
where they just, like, um...
Shriveled.
Where they recoil away from sex.
Better, recoil.
They recoil away from sex.
And, you know, it couldn't be true for them.
I guess it's, we don't see them as victims.
Like, police would laugh at you.
Police would say, oh, it's not, you know, what are you saying?
Like, friends may laugh at you.
There's not an empathy or sympathy for them, right?
when they experience it like I you know we think of um boys who especially like underage
boys that have sex with teachers which is something that is pretty common right but we still at the
boys around them will be kind of like yeah brav nice one you done well there you know even was
it the recent woman the teacher the newspapers what do they say teacher has sex with students
yeah and I think I thought actually was what baby reindeer did so well
is that both can be true at once.
Yes, a lot of men, enough men, are sexual predators,
and we know the statistics are terrible in terms of rape, sexual harassment.
One in three women has been sexually harassed at some point in their life.
We know how many rape cases don't even make it to court,
how women aren't believed, how women don't feel confident to come forward.
That can all be true, and men can also be victims of sexual violence.
Men can also feel unable to speak out about themselves.
and I thought that's what, because the main character of Baby Rainier
is kind of complicated and you kind of don't like him
but then you kind of feel really sorry for him
and I think that's where I think sometimes
our public discourse and our conversations around
our feminist conversations even
can fall short and there's a lack of nuance
in being able to understand the both and
it's reductive right? Completely
Ben did you have something to ask that?
Yeah no I loved Baby Rainier and I mean it's very very problematic
but I think it deals with nuance in a really nice
in quite a beautiful way
which is like an ugly kind of beauty
you know what I mean like you're watching it and you're on like episode four
and like fuck I don't want to watch this anymore
but it's also very very necessary
as we see from the statistics right
there's a TED talk that I always talk about
whenever I speak I always say watch
if you haven't seen before watch Tony Porter's TED talk
a call to men in the talk he speaks about this idea
of the collective socialisation of men which is like super
super poignant and he calls it the man box
and he says inside this box there's all of these ideas
of what men are supposed to be
to be real men in society
and either you're in or you're out
so it's got things in it like
being dominant, being in control
being a decision maker
being strong, being courageous, being bold
not being like a woman,
being attracted to women,
not being like a gay man,
not being gay,
not asking for help,
so many like different stereotypes and characteristics
and I think we see that
really play out when it comes to like sex and sexuality
and specifically in this example
the thing that really stuck with me was like
how long it took him to go to the police station and seek help?
Do I mean? I think for men, like you were saying,
that men are not seen as victims of sexual violence,
only often seen as perpetrators.
And I think there's sometimes even a complicated reality
that in lots of cases, men are both.
Do you know what I mean? Like, sometimes they're victims
and perpetrators of sexual violence.
But I think there are so many barriers that men have
in the ways that they're taught to be
and in the ways that they're expected to be
by everybody else around them,
that means that when they do need help
or they do have questions.
They're not supposed to seek that
or ask those questions.
And then there's a bunch of stereotypes
that get applied to sex, right?
So like when it comes to sexual relationships,
you're meant to be the dominant partner.
You're meant to know everything.
You're not meant to figure out
how sex works with another person.
You're meant to be good at it the first time immediately.
You're meant to know how it works
and do it to the other person.
Sex isn't something you share in.
It's something that you do.
It's the action that you take against another person.
And so it becomes, I think,
very, very complicated for guys
when we're trying to like unpack all of that stuff.
And like you said, it's unlearning, right?
Because I think also women are affected by the same stereotypes, you know?
Well, I was about to say, I think as you said that, Ben,
I just thought we're all so, we all lose out from these reductive gender stereotypes.
And when I think about sex, I always make this very, very unfortunately unattractive analogy,
but bear with me.
But that we all wear these backpacks of anxiety when we go into sex.
Sexy, huh?
So there you are, naked with your backpack.
on, filled with anxieties, thinking that the person you're sleeping with is anxiety-free.
They're cool as a cucumber.
They know what they're doing.
They know their experience.
They're more experienced than you.
And then we don't share the load that we're carrying.
And yet we're both there carrying that weight, carrying that weight of expectation that is
often so associated with our gender.
And I think, or the performance of our gender as gender is a construct.
But I think, as you were saying that, like thinking about the, that's very much the way I
felt I grew up thinking about sex, that sex was something that like the man, it wasn't a
conversation between me and a partner. It was, I was there to please a man because my job
was to make a man come because sex is all about making a man come, but also they're kind of
in control and they're in charge. So if it hurts, it's kind of, you know, just suck it up.
If it doesn't feel great like, oh, you know, it's something wrong with me. It's never, and I think
to know, to reflect back now on my earlier sexual experiences and recognize that half the
we're probably feeling exactly the same way
and it could have been so much better for both of us
if we'd been like hey I have no idea what I'm doing
and so I really do think we do we all really lose out
when we're all kind of straight-jacketed by these expectations
now I think with that in mind
we're going through what feels like such a big kind of transition
at the moment with regards to gender relations
and gender roles more broadly
and I think just in terms of the roles that we take on
I mean, there was a survey, a social attitude survey done by the Natsl, the National Centre for Social Research.
It was done a few years ago, but it found that 72% of people disputed the conservative view that women should dedicate themselves to housework compared to 58% 10 years earlier.
As recently as 1988, 48% felt a woman's place was in a home and only a third disagreed with the traditional model of family life.
So if you think in the long arc of history,
we've changed quite a lot quite quickly
with regards to our expectations of men and women.
Now, in the same breath as discussing
this kind of shifting gender roles,
it's become increasingly common to bring up
this so-called Christ of masculinity.
And oh my God, I've been down a whole,
listening to every podcast about Christ's masculinity I could find,
reading every article.
And they all are oriented around the same point.
that as gender roles shift, men are collectively losing a sense of purpose and identity
and feeling disjointed and kind of lacking in that sense of a social script to follow
because the traditional one no longer works.
More women than ever, more women than men are going to university, are graduating with better grades.
Gender pay gaps still a thing.
There are still many inequalities, which we will go on to later because I do want to acknowledge them.
But things are changing very rapidly and men are, you know, there seems to be this kind of collective sense that, well, what do we do? What's our purpose? What do you think are the most pressing issues facing young men today? But I'm actually going to go to you first, the boys that you work with. What are the most pressing issues facing young men today?
An organisation called Equimundo released a study last year, I think the tail end of last year, that was like a report on men. I think it was in the US, but they also work in the UK.
And their big finding was that the biggest issue that men and young men are facing today is loneliness.
And actually, like, finding spaces to have community and finding connection.
I think exacerbated, obviously, by the pandemic and, like, the migration of everything online,
so that all of our interactions with people are online.
I think that boys today are struggling with knowing how to connect with each other
and how to connect with other people.
And I think those are the kinds of questions that we hear all the time, like.
The narrative is always like, how do I chat to girls?
How do I tell someone I like them?
How do I get someone to date with me?
How do I get someone to date me?
When you speak about that sense of purpose that people are lacking,
I think boys are looking quite actively for a script,
hence the pool towards like an Andrew Tate or a misogynist online influencer
who's telling them what it means to be a man.
He's giving them something to aspire to, saying,
even if it's fucked up, you're not a man unless you have a Bugatti.
And then they're like, oh, I'm going to get a Bugatti,
and then I'll be a man and I'll know.
And I think in the UK in particular, like, we don't have any rights of passage, really, for our young people, which means that there's no point where we affirm someone's masculinity. There's no moment when we're like, son, you're a man now. And again, slightly reductive. I'm not sure if it always has to be that. But I do think there's something important about marking that transition from boyhood to manhood. Because manhood is like the first thing that gets taken away from men. Do you know what I mean? Every time someone does something wrong, he's not a real man. Real men don't do.
that. Real men are not like that. And so
it's constantly, as a man, you're
constantly under threat of having your manhood
revoked. And I think actually
making moments where we say,
now you've transitioned, and then
it's about being a good man or not being a good man.
Do you know what does it look like to be a good man?
How do you model that? How do you
decide what that is for yourself?
And I think actually that's the beauty of these
conversations is that for our young people,
they are, as much as like the social
norms have changed and things have been
stripped back and taken away from them,
they're at a point in history where they're allowed to decide these things for themselves
and there are resources around them that will help them to make those decisions
do you know i mean if you want to go to university people will help you go to university in this
country anyway and so on and so forth so i think actually it's about inspiring that
reimagination of what masculinity can be for boys i asked everyone on instagram what they
thought when i said kind of what are you thinking about when you think about patriarchy
when you think about kind of shifting gender norms and quite a few people
people came back to me and said, I seldom hear about masculinity being discussed outside of the
context of toxic masculinity, and that worries me. David, is that something that's coming up with
the men that are coming to you? Is that what you feel aware of? Do you think this term toxic masculinity
is a helpful one? What does it kind of mean and I guess feel like to you? Yeah. Men don't want
to talk about masculinity because there's a sense and feeling that it's going to get onto a conversation
about toxic masculinity
and then there's a kind of underlying feeling
I think as men and I've talked to quite a few
with my clients about this is like when someone says toxic masculinity
it's almost like you're like not me
not me but you feel
this sense of attack
whether it's logical or illogical
right there's a kind of sense
internal feeling of like
is someone coming for me is someone coming for me
and do I need to be aware is there something I did in the past
I didn't know or did I do something just now
and it creates a defensiveness
you know rightly or wrongly
it creates a defense in this. Like I've read, you know,
Richard Reeves talks about it in his book about
toxic medicine and about the research that shows
that it's not actually useful terms, especially
for young boys.
I don't think it opens conversation
to men. I don't think it invites men into
a conversation because it's usually you're bad.
You lot, all you man them
there, you're all bad. Done.
Let's move on. And where do we go from now?
And you need to change. But there's not
what it always, always
lacks is, and what it creates is
all those behaviors are bad.
but then there's a massive void of what they should be doing
or what is better and what is more helpful
and more nourishing to themselves and the rest of the world.
And that's what we have a lot of, a lot of void.
There's a lot of void of men who are like, okay, I want to be better,
but I don't know how to,
and I don't want to talk about what I've been doing
because then maybe, you know, I can lose my job
or my wife wants to leave me or something,
or there's a problem that really comes up.
So I'm full too ashamed
because I don't know what I meant to be doing,
doing and I don't know if I was doing bad things before or I think I probably did a few things
before I didn't know I'm feeling shame but I feel shame I don't know about where to go so the term
how do I say for me I understand the term and the term points to some behaviours which is useful right
because we need to be able to point but the it has it I feel like it's just like ballooning
constantly and taking up like oh if someone's assertive that's toxic masculinity if a man
you know, gives his opinion
that's toxic masculinity. It's just taking up
everything that a man could possibly do
and it suddenly becomes toxic masculinity.
You know, I remember seeing,
I think it was in The Guardian, again, don't quote me,
it was like a study that said that
it said something about women
feeling if a man goes up to a bar
and goes up to talk to them, like a large,
it was like 30 or 40% of them felt that
man talking to him in a bar was harassment.
Right? And then it went on a bit about
kind of toxic masculinity. I remember thinking
as someone who works in dating, you're like,
Like, this is dangerous because people are dying for connection, like Ben said.
And now we're pointing to the avenues for connection is associated with toxic masculinity and harmful behavior.
And like, obviously, it's the way you do it, right?
There's a whole way in which you do it.
But a lot of men just read that and go, okay, I don't do that because I don't want to be one of those guys.
So, um...
It's interesting to note, you mentioned that Richard Reeves, who wrote a brilliant book.
What's it called again?
Of boys and men.
Of boys and men.
And explores the kind of current crisis masculinity
and a lot of depth and a lot of detail.
I would highly recommend it to everyone here.
Very good book.
But one of the things he says is to your point
that we've done,
but a lot of conversations happening now
about articulating what toxic bad masculinity is
but nothing that then is saying,
okay, this is a model for how things could be better.
And he says he admits, actually,
there's a piece, I was reading just today,
and he had spoken to the journalist,
and he'd said, admittedly, I didn't articulate
what a positive notion of masculinity is in the book
because I felt out of my depth doing that
and it feels like a personal thing
and I didn't know how to approach it
and I think there's also that fear of then
outlining a notion of masculinity
that then some people don't agree with
and that being deemed as problematic.
And it made me wonder,
do we need to have a model of positive masculinity
or is it better for us to be speaking
about positive human traits?
Do we risk gender essentialism when we do talk about positive versus negative masculinity?
I personally come from a school of, and this comes from some of my kind of my tantra learnings,
it's like masculinity and femininity are not necessarily like men own masculinity and only men can express masculinity.
I don't look it that way.
There's like a, you know, from my learnings of going through tantra and so forth is that, you know,
the masculine is like action doing and the feminine is receptive, receiving energy.
and we're all in this space constantly.
The gender part of masculinity and femininity
is a social thing, which is slightly different.
But I think we could just reduce everything down to human traits,
but ultimately gender is important to people.
Being a man is meaningful to men.
So most men, being a man is meaningful.
We've taught them their whole lives that it's meaningful.
So if you want to go and tell all the men like now,
suddenly being a man is meaningless and so forth,
but we still have a whole world outside of here,
where being a man looks like this
and being a woman looks like that
and it's very much like ingrained in us
from a young age
like I'm having my partner's eight months pregnant
and I, me and her
often are like wow you see how
like we were looking at baby clothes the other day
in John Lewis
boys clothes two racks that look pitiful
pitiful clothes
yeah the little girl stuff
racks on racks on racks of girls clothes
and I was like wow before they're born
we're teaching them
how boys look doesn't really matter and their clothes are generally pretty bland and boring.
And the girl stuff is like copious. And I was like, wow, this is, to see this already occurring.
So it's like it's so ingrained in us that we can't necessarily get away from kind of gender in our society and masculinity and femininity.
I think the key for me is everyone has to take a bit of responsibility. Every individual person and an organization has to take responsibility.
I include media and newspapers and stuff
because, like, how often are men like myself
and Ben and lots of the other wonderful men
doing wonderful work in the world
featured in a newspaper in comparison to Andrew Tate?
Like, how often, you know?
I would say, though, the majority of people
writing a men around, like, politics and a lot of...
Men dominate podcasting, men do dominate across the board
in the public sphere, so I don't think there's a lack of men
having voice.
lack of men, it's a lack of the organization caring because really media organizations are about
getting clicks, right? About getting people's eyeballs on things. But if you have a bunch of guys
who are really great guys and talking about being a great man, you're not clicking on it. People,
people click emotionally. Do you think so? Do you think that's true? If you go to the Guardian and
look at every day there's like a most clicked bit at the bottom, it's the things that trigger people
the most. Always. It's the emotional like click. Like, oh, Andrew,
Chase's done something, he says something about women, people click on it.
Like, if there's an article about
great masculinity and great examples of it,
it's like the good news, what's it?
The good news movement.
The good news movement, like, compared to the sun
or, like, some other newspaper.
It's, we are very emotional beings
and we don't always acknowledge that in the way that we move through the world.
Can I, okay, if I jump in?
Because I feel, I feel a bit like an MRA here,
like, it's a bit icky to me.
Like, sorry, men's rights activist.
Like, I feel like I'm like,
like instantly
in the conversation
do you know what I mean
involuntarily celebrity
I don't feel a bit like a femme cell
yeah yeah yeah
and I
and I think actually like
movements like that have their place
I think they're incredibly problematic
and cause lots of harm also
but I think that again
they speak to something
which is this issue that men are looking for something
they're looking for something to identify with
for me I think
I'm not sure I
like wholeheartedly agree with the point
so when we were talking about toxic masculinity
Toxic masculinity for us as an organisation
is a term that we don't use
that we don't walk into a room and talk about toxic masculinity
mainly because it just pisses people off and shuts the conversation down
but I don't think that's because of the term
I think it's because there are a lot of people talking about it
without knowing what they're talking about
and in my experience
they always say like if you can't explain something to a child
then you don't really understand it
and I feel like toxic masculinity is that kind of thing
you know what I mean where we use the word when we don't like a man
or like he did this thing on a day
and that's toxic or you did this thing
and that's toxic or whatever
but actually like
I was reading Bell Hooks the other day
shout out to Shanahu cussed me for having that
on the reading table
in the living room
but there's a portion in the book
where she's talking about labelling things
and she goes into this like little bit
where she's talking about
imperialist white supremacist
capitalist patriarchy and the importance
of like using those words to describe
the systems that are around us
Because if you don't use the words to describe the problem, then you're not talking about anything.
Like you can't identify what the thing is.
And I think the value of the toxic masculinity conversation is that it gives us something to point to and say, oh, that's that thing.
And that is important also, right?
Because there are elements of masculinity that are toxic.
There are elements of masculinity like traditional societal, constructed masculinity.
So things like being strong, being brave, being a provider, being a protector.
All of those things can be really good if that's what you want for yourself.
if that's what you want for your community.
But also, all of those things can become corrupted and be really bad
and turn into control or dominance or power over other people.
And so I think labelling the thing, whilst I wouldn't do it in practice,
because I think there's more creative ways to get to the conversation,
like the conversation is so important.
And so, like, when it comes to this conversation around toxic masculinity
and how that shows up for men, I think, like, sometimes these conversations
can feel a little bit like, oh, like, woe is me, it's so sad for,
the men. And the reality is, like, it is sad for men. Like, it's, like, outcomes for men
are in the gutter, you know what I mean? It's shit. It's shit really today to be a man in terms
of, like, history. But when you think about the reasons why... Do you think that's true?
I think, I think it is shit, but the reasons why is because the construct is falling apart.
So when you talk about, um, is it better to have no version, like, is it better to talk about
positive personhood? In my opinion, yeah, like, you, if you feel like you're a man, then you're a man,
and if you were born a boy in inverted commas
and then you grow up and you grow into a man
but what does that mean
because I think actually what we often do
is attach even when you're talking about the
masculine energy being
doing and being active
like we attach all of this
positive stuff to masculinity
that doesn't necessarily really belong there
do you know what I mean like we turn it into
masculinity is something to aspire to
and something that should be celebrated and something that's amazing
but it's not it's just being a man
it's just like being an adult man
And so actually, like, maybe masculinity is just a thing
and then the way that we practice it,
the way that we do it, is either positive or negative.
I just keep having to come back to what we said
earlier on the conversation about the both and,
because I am listening to you,
and on the one hand, I agree,
and I've been immersed in my world of Christ's masculinity today
and know the stats and suicide rates, monks, young men,
you know, as you say, the loneliness,
issues of not being able to come forward around sexual shame
and then I look at statistics
like there's more men called like Michael and Chris
as CEOs and there are women as CEOs
and I think that you look at the kind of the
infrastructure of societal power
and it's still very much run by men
you look at the violence against women and girls
and we know that it was declared in June last year
a national crisis because it's so bad here in the UK
because one woman is killed every three days at the hands of a man.
And I don't think that means that we shouldn't then have a conversation to your point around how things can be better for men.
But I have to catch myself when I hear those things.
I catch myself feeling like, hang on a second, why aren't there more women to CEOs?
And I think that's probably where the conversation often does break down, because both things can be true at once.
We can need to have more women represented positions of power in politics.
You know, across the board, in music everywhere.
We need more women in more positions of power.
You know, we need women to feel safer.
We need women to be safer.
But we also need men to be safer.
We also need men to be happy.
We also need men.
And I think that the truth in this is that we all benefit.
And we said that earlier on the conversation that we're all full victim to the kind of straight jacketing of gender.
And I do think that's very true.
But I can see why these conversations are really hard to have publicly because I can even feel in this context.
I do, I like bristle at certain things.
I'm like, oh, but what about the women?
And actually, David, I just think back
when I saw that conversation that you were part of
a couple months ago, and there was something you said
that really stuck with me.
You said that men haven't had their own kind of sexual revolution
and don't have kind of their own form of feminism.
And there is, you know, these sorts of movements
come out of oppression, and women have had to
bind together through feminism
in all its iterations that exist now,
in order to win the right to vote,
to win some power that we have been deprived of throughout history.
But I do think there is something in men not having a positive movement
that is about championing one another, supporting one another,
and it's really about what it means to be,
to kind of have a positive role model,
which is the same thing as before us.
What would a men's sexual revolution look like today?
I mean, can you imagine it?
Wow.
I guess it's slowly happening, right?
But it's not a kind of really together movement.
You know, we're seeing male sex toys appearing in ways that we never did before.
For example, men are talking about sex more and more.
But it is happening very slowly.
And it's really needed, you know.
Men have a very narrow lane of how they should be.
And, you know, feminism gay women, like, exploded their lane open into the many hundreds of lanes
that they can take in their lives.
but the lengths of men are still pretty narrow
and we all think those
we all have that in our minds
about how men should be a lot of the time
so I think it's one of these weird things
when I think about it's because you think
okay well if men are to have a sexual revolution
then men have to start the sexual revolution
and then men are in power
so those men could easily start that sexual revolution
and then it's like do they care
do they want to like are men oppressed enough
that they would rise up enough
or is it that the men who are so oppressed
are just so oppressed.
They're kind of rising up against themselves.
Yeah, and they're blaming.
And also, it's this way in which we always get to,
it's the others' fault.
Like, this is one of the things I really hate about
a lot of the kind of the masculinity influences,
the less positive ones,
is this kind of like pointing at women and blaming women.
And it's like, well, it's not really women's fault.
I don't think it is.
Yeah, and I have these conversations.
Guys have had power for long time.
It's like, how can you empower yourself?
And I think that's it.
Like, you know, I've been on.
and run men's retreats with people
and the key thing is, and I see
in these spaces, and I've been in
sexuality workshops and so forth
with men, and it's about
empowering self, because
when self is empowered to express
to communicate, then
those in our vicinity become automatically
more empowered, because we're communicating,
we're speaking, and we've created a
space for others to do
so, so I actually don't
know what I thought about it after that night,
what would it look like for a male sexual revolution,
I think it would be
like really
coming and being
almost proud of our desire
proud of our sexuality
and not
automatically looking at ourselves
as like we are
even predators to certainly be because there's so many men
who shy away from sex and sexuality
because they don't want to be like that and it's like
can we find this this healthy lane
of sexual expression and desire
as a man that can be
celebrated and feels good
and is healthy in its communication
and its connection with others
and I guess that is a lot of the kind of
what I would say
like the root of kind of men's work
is like how can men be more connected
you know connection is the key
connection is the key for men
because this is the thing we socialise out of
do you worry that for as long as we lack
this I guess more nuanced conversation
around positive masculinity
and it's nuanced many kind of
many shades that we've discussed
this conversation, that we are going to
accidentally end up
rowing back on a lot of the progress that we've made
and end up reverting back to a lot of the kind of traditional
gender roles that were so entrenched for a long time.
And I say this, obviously the week following Harrison
Bucher, you know, the Chiefs footballer in the US,
who gave a remarkable speech at the commencement speech
at Bernardine College.
just a few of his comments
Pride month is a deadly sin
his wife would be the first to say that her life
truly started when she began living her
vocation as a wife and as a mother
and ultimately I think there's
you the women he said who have had the most
diabolical lives told to you some of you may go on
to lead successful careers in the world
this was a graduation speech
but I would venture to guess that the majority
of you are most excited about your marriage
and the children you will bring
into this world
what I actually found quite interesting about that
just to quickly finish that.
It was a woman who was graduating alongside
Bukka, I hope he said it all right,
who took to Twitter to note, yeah, it was fucking terrible.
Some of us did boo.
Me and my roommate definitely did.
There was a standing ovation, but, sorry,
there was a standing ovation from everyone in the room
except from me, my roommate and about
10 to 15 other women.
So yes, there was a big backlash in social media,
but in that room people were clapping,
and I think the fact that he said it publicly
at a commencement should be,
he isn't just thinking that alone.
He's reflecting the views of him and his friends and people around.
Do you worry that we are reversing back into this quite archaic way of thinking about gender?
Listen, I don't know if we're reversing.
I think that's just where we are.
Do you know what I mean?
I feel like the big thing about these types of conversations is that sometimes we try and have them
and we're addressing symptoms rather than addressing the issue.
And the reality is that like in our society, men, women, trans people, non-binary people,
people of whatever genders they are
all live in patriarchy
and so while we're living in patriarchy
it's always going to be patriarchy
and I think like when you were talking about like
the sexual revolution the argument
that my guy was making
is crazy because it's the kind of
argument where you... Harrison, whatever's
name is, it's the kind
of argument you make that can never be
disproven because fundamentally
the core of the argument is
we don't listen or believe, we don't listen
to or believe what women say.
no matter how many women say no that's not my reality
you don't believe them because you think
that they don't know what they're talking about
so it's self-perpetuating you can never
win an argument like that and I think when you're talking
about the sexual revolution like
in my eyes men's sexual
revolution is porn men's sexual
revolution that has happened
is living in a world where you can solicit sex
but you can't you can't sell it because if you sell
it that's illegal do I mean like there's so many
things in the construct that we live in
that mean that actually the only solution is, like, radical dismantling.
And actually, like, to get to a version of masculinity or femininity
that can be inherently, like, positive and healthy and good for everyone,
like, we have to dismantle those systems.
Otherwise, it's just going to keep perpetuating itself.
And while we all culturally, like, grow up learning that men are this and women are that,
and men are supposed to be this and women are supposed to be that,
and there's nothing in between and nobody else exists,
and if you don't do these things, then you're not valid.
like there is no way of arriving at an end goal
but here's a really good version of it
because it's always going to become corrupted and tainted
I think until we address that power imbalance
then we're a little bit fucked really
and case in point we're listening to commencement speeches
that just don't make any sense
so it's crazy
in one line to wrap this up before we have a break
what is one thing that we can do
to get more men involved
not just in the conversations but as actually
active participants fighting for gender equality, which benefits all of us.
One line.
One line.
We can educate men, not in the way that we've been educated, but in a way that is explorative and reflective about power and privilege and patriarchy and their own positionalities and get them to actually think about who they are in the world.
And fingers crossed, that will start to shift the dial a little bit.
they'll start arriving at some better and healthier conclusions, I would say.
Wonderful. David?
Curiosity about judgment.
Curiosity about judgment so that we can explore and talk about the things that we've done,
which we think are good or bad, where the other person is curious and not necessarily
judgmental and create more and more spaces.
When I say spaces, that can be a relationship, that can be a workplace, that can be a
workshop where there's curiosity about judgment, and that allows people to open up more and more
because their defences can slowly drop down.
Beautiful final answers, both of you.
Thank you. A huge round of applause for David and Ben.
Thank you so much for listening to today's Sex Talks podcast, with me, your host, Emma Louise Boynton.
If you'd like to attend a live recording of the podcast, check out the event bright link in the show notes,
as we have lots of exciting live events coming up.
You can also keep up to date with everything coming up at Sex Talks,
get my sporadic musings, via the Sex Talk substack. I've also popped that link into the show
notes. And over on Instagram, where I'm at Emma Louise Boynton. And finally, if you enjoyed the
show, please don't forget to rate, review and subscribe on whatever platform you're listening to
this on, as apparently it helps others to find us. Have a glorious day.
