Small Town Murder - #372 - Natural Porn Killers - New Port Richey, Florida
Episode Date: March 24, 2023This week, in New Port Richey, Florida, a small town girl, with a police officer husband decides to get into porn, to support the family. While on the set of a very aptly named film, she fall...s in love with a costar. A sort of British ex-Marine, who is also a club DJ. Let's just say that they're into some weird stuff. Weird stuff, like brutally killing someone, because it sexually excites them to murder, then have sex with each other! Will they slip away, into the night, and not be caught? A crazy story!!Along the way, we find out that people in Florida glass houses shouldn't throw stones, that no matter what kind of porn you do, it doesn't mean that's what you're into, and if murder turns you on, you're probably going to end up in prison!!Hosted by James Pietragallo and Jimmie WhismanNew episodes every Thursday!Donate at: patreon.com/crimeinsports or go to paypal.com and use our email: crimeinsports@gmail.comGo to shutupandgivememurder.com for all things Small Town Murder & Crime In Sports!Follow us on...twitter.com/@murdersmallfacebook.com/smalltownpodinstagram.com/smalltownmurderAlso, check out James & Jimmie's other show, Crime In Sports! On Apple Podcasts, Spotify, Amazon Music, Wondery, Wondery+, Stitcher, or wherever you listen to podcasts!See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.
Transcript
Discussion (0)
You're listening early and ad-free on Wondery app or wherever you get your podcasts.
Hello, everybody, and welcome back to Small Town Murder Express.
Yay! Choo-choo! Oh, Small Town Murder Express. Yay!
Choo-choo!
Oh, yay indeed, Jimmy.
Yay indeed.
My name is James Petrigallo.
I'm here with my co-host.
I'm Jimmy Wissman.
Thank you folks so much for joining us on another wild, crazy edition.
That's right.
Murder Train pulling away from the station, all aboard and all that shit.
This is a wild episode.
It is absolutely crazy.
We don't usually have to even say it anymore with the Expresses
because they're all insane,
but this one, wow, it's wild.
So we'll be very quick here
up at the top of the show.
You definitely want to head over
to shutupandgivememurder.com.
Tickets available for all of 2023.
Shows are selling out very quickly
and Salt Lake City,
which sold out in a day,
Salt Lake City, we just upgraded to a day, Salt Lake City, we just
upgraded to a bigger venue.
So tickets are going to be available soon, probably when you're listening to this now,
more tickets will be available for Salt Lake City.
That's the last bigger venue extra show that we're adding.
We're done.
So whatever tickets are out there.
Also, if you have tickets to Salt Lake, your tickets work for the new venue, you'll be
told.
You'll know.
You'll know.
You'll find out about it. You have your tickets and your seating and it'll all be
comparable you'll be great so there you go otherwise whole thing shows are selling out
quickly if you're listening to this the day it comes out we'll be in portland tomorrow night
still tickets available for the late show i believe if they're not sold by then so get in
there come see us we cannot wait also 4 20 april the 20th virtual live show i am gonna get
jimmy really stoned i have some some props let's just say they're gonna be gonna freak him out and
make him real real high it's gonna be hilarious and he's gonna giggle at a murder story and the
story's gonna be wild just like a regular live show but in your living room so check that out
april 20th it's available for a week after that as well. So get in there. That is shut up and give me murder.com.
Patreon.com slash crime and sports.
All the bonus stuff.
Anybody $5 or above, you get everything.
Huge back catalog of bonus stuff to listen to.
And every other week, you're going to get two new episodes.
This week, which you're going to get for crime and sports, which you'll have access to.
You are going to get, we're going to talk about the oh and 26 tampa bay buccaneers
started out their franchise horribly they picked terrible uniforms weird mascot terrible players
bad decision that was bad we'll talk all about it's hilarious and then for small town murder
we're going to talk about something very fun jody arias we'll get into there um for lack of a better
term that's going to be wild so Do a handstand on my lap.
Wow.
We'll go into all the messages and everything.
Check all that out.
That is patreon.com slash crimeandsports,
and you'll get a shout-out at the end of the regular show
where Jimmy will mispronounce your name terribly
while trying to get it correct.
You know how that goes.
So, yeah, get in there.
Do all that.
And, of course, Your Stupid Op your stupid opinions is coming our new show where
we talk about people's terrible internet reviews of anything you could imagine right that is coming
soon we'll let you know an exact date very soon we just have some business stuff we're still getting
in a row to start a podcast it's hard to get it to do it right yeah to do it right so we're doing
that and uh that's coming very soon that said i think it's time everybody all right it's
time to sit back where you at this is my this is my favorite part where you at right now i'm really
enjoying it even though it's march you're just taking your kid to see the mall santa claus
that's fine oh there he is you pick that kid up as soon as that's right before the flash bulb goes
you pick your kid up you replace yourself with you replace your kid with yourself soon as that's right before the flashbulb goes. You pick your kid up. You replace yourself with you.
Replace your kid with yourself on Santa's lap.
You grab him by his fat, rosy cheeks and you shout into his face.
Shut up.
Give me murder.
That's what I want for Christmas.
You tell him, damn it.
That said, let's go on a trip, Jimmy.
Great.
Let's do this.
We are going, oh, never lets us down.
It never lets the whole world down.
We're going to Florida, everybody.
Oh, boy.
The trash murder capital of the world, Florida.
We're going to Newport Ritchie, Florida, as a matter of fact.
Newport Ritchie?
Newport, which is not one word like the cigarette, two words like a Newport.
Really?
As opposed to an Oldport Ritchie.
Is there a T in the Ritchie?
No, no, R-I-C-H-E-Y, Ritchie.
Population here, 16,348.
Is that right?
Not a very big place.
Median income, family household income is a little bit low too,
30,660, which is well under the national average.
And then median home price, a little bit high.
It's a bad combination.
Median home price, $318,800.
So that's a tough—
All bets are off.
That's a tough combination when you get in there, yeah.
That's just—
No wonder people are selling body parts and doing weird shit.
Florida, good luck.
That's what it should be.
Like a casino.
Good luck when you come in.
You're going to lose and leave with a guy on bath salts chewing your face off or something of that nature.
But, you know, good luck.
Penny was in Hungary.
Best of luck.
Best of luck.
A little bit of history here.
All right.
In the 1920s, they hoped to become the winter home for big-time Hollywood stars.
They courted actively big stars of Hollywood to try to get them to come and have vacation houses there.
That way people would want to go there and it would be a tourist place.
I've heard of the place, and that's kind of in my head what was romanticized.
Really?
I thought it was a nice place until you told me how much
people make and how much they have to spend to survive well yeah then it's just a little bit
that's not a nice place but yeah the idea of newport richie i thought was a great place
it might be i don't know i've never been there but uh the thomas megan who's an actor in silent
movies built a huge home on the river in 1928 and spent the winters there and he wanted to make it he wanted
to make movies there he wanted to make it like east coast hollywood and uh also a big golfer of
the time built a home there um all that kind of shit so they also got uh irving berlin the song
writer uh to put some down payments on properties but nobody ended up building homes and then the
then the depression hit and no people owned like owned a bunch of swampland.
Florida in the 20s was just a real estate scheme
where people would sell people swampland,
and then they'd not be able to build anything on it
because it was just shit land.
No good.
And then the prices took a dive, and then the Depression came,
and it was like a double shot for Florida.
Wow.
Had a bit of a time there.
Reviews of this town, there's some differing opinions let's just say okay five stars here we go uh wonderful
people in my store caring about who comes and goes apparently they work at a store or own a store
help in and out of store always carries ready for you i don't know what that means. Thanks, Lynn Shanley.
I don't know if they're thanking Lynn Shanley
or they're Lynn Shanley
and it's like a letter.
Like, thanks, Lynn Shanley.
The lack of punctuation makes it difficult.
Here's four stars.
If you're looking for a hip
and modern up-and-coming area,
look no further.
Newport Ritchie is what you need.
Words do not do this place justice.
You need to see it yourself.
Take a stroll down Main Street and you'll see what I mean.
From the brand new park and playground with a splash pad for kids is a perfect way to spend a nice afternoon with the family.
Across from that same park is a cute hipster-themed coffee shop that has the best chai latte i ever
did have next to that shop is an artisan grilled cheese and oh for fuck's sake stop opening stores
that just sell grilled cheese stop it a grilled that should be on maybe on your menu somewhere
but that's not all you sell generally under the part where it says kids menu.
Yes.
There was a place on 7th Avenue in Phoenix that opened up,
and I was like, you cocksuckers.
And I said, I hope you go out of business, you assholes.
And then they went out of business, and I celebrated it.
I celebrated it because they're dicks.
And a family-owned ice cream parlor.
If you're more of a night on the town kind of a person,
lucky for you, there are about 15 bars to choose from.
Oh, boy.
Wow.
Including a wine bar and even a bar with rooftop access, exclamation point.
A bar with a roof?
No.
How'd that happen?
You're bound to find the one that suits you best.
Needless to say, Newport Ritchie is one town that's a must-see in capital letters when you're in the area.
So holy shit, thank you, Mayor Newport.
We appreciate that.
Here's three stars.
This one's a little weird.
This is very personal.
Three stars.
Hello, my name's Melissa, and I've lived in Newport Ritchie for 30 hi melissa i love the water however it's not the cleanest there are so many youths ruining the area it wasn't for these
damn kids this is melissa's an older lady i have a feeling the water used to be clean till we had
these kids around i love the restaurants on the water where you can eat and relax watching the sunset.
It's also nice because whatever stores you need and easily accessible and close.
She means are me and my family have always enjoyed walking at night along the water.
Now we now we do not do to the youth out there drugging, drinking and bullying.
So that would be what I want changed to be able to take my kids out without fear.
Thank you, Melissa.
I love that you Cosby'd up that whole thing.
You're like, now!
Now, yeah.
She needs a now.
Melissa needs a now.
She's as old as Bill Cosby, I feel like.
That was awesome.
Two stars here.
All right.
I moved to Newport Ritchie in 1981, and at the time it was called Newport Rickety because it was a community of senior citizens and wealthy retired people it was pristine and West Pascoe was the place to be no it's not I've seen I've seen live PD back at Pascoe yeah Pascoe was the one where the guy set
the guy's uh trailer steps on fire but then he didn't want to press charges because he was afraid
that he would beat him up and then there was a lizard running around I didn't want to press charges because he was afraid that he would beat him up, and then there was a lizard running around.
I don't want to talk about it. Okay.
Pasco's not good. No.
It has slowly deteriorated and become a high
crime town with lots of drugs.
It's also the place where they asked a guy where he was parked, and he said,
yonder? Yonder.
And he pointed. A young man, too, not an old man.
The value of
homes have went down, even though the market
grew. As soon as they improve one area
transients and northerners take over and trash it fucking yeah jesus christ and people in arizona
say the same shit about just a state to the one literally 500 miles to the west yeah florida of
the of the of the west there so um if you were born and raised there, you may have adjusted to the decline,
but if you move there because of its past beauty,
you will be very disappointed.
Okay.
One star.
This is a terrible place to live
as the local government is very corrupt.
The situation's getting worse with each day that passes.
Avoid this place like the plague.
Like the plague.
There it is.
Quite the range of opinions there um now the things to
do here not a lot the chess chasco chasco fiesta nine days of food fun and entertainment with many
events including a street parade boat parade car show 5k run and different genre of music every
night oh nine days is too long of a festival it's just too long that's a lot that's a
lot there's a children's village which i don't know what that is that's where children it's like
lord of the flies we just fence it off put them all in fence them off let them do what they do
whoever comes out on top comes out on top we don't know it's it's a sink or swim environment
a carnival um food all sorts of shit like that there.
Classic rock night, country night, Christian blues, bluegrass oldies, rock and roll tribute nights.
Holy shit, get your ass down there, everybody.
They run a whole night for the newsboys?
Whole night.
Yep, just for that.
Jesus.
So that said, let's talk about murder.
Let's do it. Oh boy, is it a weird one. Okay. Let's talk first about a young lady. Her name's Amanda. Amanda K. Loge. I have heard it said and I've heard it said different ways and I don't know how to say it. L-O-G-U-E. Don't worry. We'll call her something different in a little while anyway. She's got another name. That's Logue, isn't it?
There we go.
Logue, maybe.
Logue.
Yeah, Logue.
Amanda Logue.
She's born January 2nd, 1982.
Oh.
Okay.
Okay.
So she's in Georgia.
She's got some problems with her home life.
Law enforcement gets called to her house all the time here.
As a kid?
No, no, no, no.
As an adult adult we're talking
early 2000s oh a lot of interactions with the cops because of her husband at the time multiple
domestic disputes her husband's a jackass she's being abused a lot all right that sort of thing
you know what i mean they're living in stuff they're living in uh in rural georgia and just
you know trying to trying to do some shit
so one of the officers who responded several times was a guy named officer layman loag
who will end up marrying her yeah yeah well that's they'll end up they don't have it's not
a coincidence yeah that's her married name when she marries this guy yeah it's a big coincidence no so she he took a took an interest in amanda as a matter
of fact you know which by the way you're not really supposed to do that we gotta say when
you're if you're a cop officer yeah responding to a domestic you don't see that arrest the guy
and go all right just freed up some uh just freed up some options here you're
not shopping that's a victim and you're supposed to treat them as such you should be single now so
i am as well that's that's weird i think but apparently he's a nice guy i don't know okay um
she he said that quote i was encouraging her that she could do better and she could get out of that
lifestyle you know like a guy with a pension cops Cops coming over, yeah, all the time and all that kind of shit.
You can have a different lifestyle where you don't know what will happen when I leave the house.
How's that?
Want to live in a different fear?
So Amanda likes him because he's a nice guy.
He's got a stable job.
He's kind to her.
She doesn't have to call the cops on him.
You know, things like that it's helpful
so they end up he she gets rid of her other husband so they date for about six months and
then they get married which is like fast very fast yeah but she's he's got he's stable and he's you
know he's not beating her up so that makes sense that they would want to be together um she ends up now she'll have a
daughter and i don't know we don't ever find out if the daughter is her first husbands or this guy's
we don't know which it is but i'm thinking it's the first husband we'll get to that but i'm the
the thinking it's the first husbands because later on when she'll she'll leave at one point she will
drop the kid off at her mother's house so that would make sense rather than you know if it wasn't his kid she's not
going to leave the kid there with him but if it is that would make sense so um either way that they
uh he ends up layman gets in an accident a car accident that messes up his legs okay and he can't
work anymore he can't be oh no yeah. Yeah, he's all messed up physically.
So now Amanda becomes the breadwinner of the family.
She's got to figure out a way to do this. So her whole thing was this is a nice, stable person, and he's providing and all that kind of thing.
And now it's up to her to provide for the family.
And she's in her 20s and trying to figure it out.
Comes from kind of a shit background as we talked about
um so during this though layman continued to encourage her said you can do it um you can do
it now her goal is she wanted to be a model she's 24 years old at this point she's blonde pretty
and you know looks like a southern girl that's pretty, you know. FHM and Maxim.
That kind of money, yeah.
Yeah, yeah.
So he decided to, I'll help you become a model if you want to become a model.
So he arranged a little photo shoot for his wife there.
And the photo shoot she ended up getting on a flyer with it.
The photos were used in a commercial capacity, so she got a check for it.
So that was like, holy shit, this is working. Her first
picture she took, she's making some kind
of money. So she ended up getting
a bunch of different modeling jobs
with different advertisers,
which is pretty cool, you know what I mean?
So she's, you know, a little for ads, for
local things, a drugstore is a thing,
you know, she'll be their model. So it's pretty
cool. So as this
is going on,
you know, she after a while, though, this not a lot of money comes in from pictures on local advertisements. You really got to work to do that.
That's a lot of pictures.
Not a whole lot.
So she ended up she ended up trying to do things that were a little more risque that make a little more money when you're talking about pictures.
A friend of hers said she's from a small town in Georgia living with a husband and a young daughter.
They go to church on Sunday.
And, you know, by all appearances, she's a loving wife and mother.
But then she gets on a plane to go model and shoot pornography.
And it's a complete life of sex and lies at that point.
She doesn't tell laymen this? Well don't know what exactly how much she will wait till you see at the end here
layman is a real understanding cat we'll just put it that way he's a real understanding guy so
it could go either way with layman he's very sweet about it so she started doing different
kind of photo shoots and a lot of these are like fetish So she started doing different kind of photo shoots.
And a lot of these are like fetish shit she's doing in the beginning.
Bondage photos and foot fetish shit.
Yeah, niche stuff that's not actual porn porn.
Mainstream, right.
Not getting pounded balls against her butthole type deal.
That's good.
So she then decides to get into the balls against the butthole part of the business.
And her name is Sunny Day is her porn name.
D.A.E.
OK.
Sunny Day.
D.A.E.
Which I'm surprised no one had come up with that before her.
That seems really basic, doesn't it?
Probably is.
There probably is a sunny day with D.A.Y.
D.A.E.
I mean, I'm just surprised no one had done that.
And porn, how many porn actresses have there been?
Oh, my God.
Millions?
Holy fuck.
I think someone would have come up with that.
It's deep now, yeah.
Me looking into this, no one had because I found her entire filmography, if you'd like to partake and hear about it.
Now, she seems to have started out her career in 2003 with a little film called
southern bukkake oh tells you that's what i love about porn right away you know what you're getting
you know what you're getting it's more even more than fast food like a big mac could be anything
southern bukkake you know what you're getting come on girl come on now here oh there we go right there you know what you're getting it's gonna be girls from georgia soaked faces
that's it so that's her first and then i'll go down i'll just do them alphabetically okay let's
do it that way um this is from 2004 ish to 2010 and then more movies will come out later we'll
talk about it but uh amateur lesbian lovers
yeah okay anything in order to get a job is the name of one which sounds like an old-timey porno
that sounds like a 70s porn doesn't it like it's a yeah she comes in in a business suit and she's
like i've just been everywhere and no one's hiring secretaries and he's like i might need a secretary
a secretary of my balls and then he turns out of his desk and he's s hmm i might need a secretary a secretary of my balls and then he
turns out of his desk and he's splayed with his balls hanging out a sexitary i need a sexitary
which that's i'm sure the name of many porns um you're right i think it is as a matter of fact
yeah i think they used to be on cinemax actually back in the day yeah yeah like old like 90s 2000s i think
um believable uh attack of the milfs five yeah attack of the milfs seven yeah she's like no no
this is your alphabetical remember i said oh okay gotcha yeah she doesn't work in alphabetical order
through the years look i really need an h movie right now i'm sorry i can't do i can't do diamond sluts because i just did
i just did gaping buttholes so i can't i'm down on h is what i'm getting at
she does i love how too in porn you go from a college girl to a MILF. There's no in-between.
There's nothing in-between.
You're either 20 or you're a cougar.
What the fuck is that about?
How does that work?
I remember seeing girls in both, and you were like, how are you both?
How are you a MILF and a college student at the same time? These came out around the same time.
We put glasses on her.
That's what happened.
That's it.
MILF now.
Attack of the MILF 7 as well, because you've got to have, you her. That's what happened. That's it. MILF now. Attack of the MILF 7
as well, because you gotta have,
you know, it's a series. Trilogy.
It's a series. It's only three, right?
It's only three. Autumn Weston's
Sibian Lessons for Women
Part 9.
Okay.
How many lessons do you need?
Sit on that thing.
It's good, right?
All right, then.
Come back tomorrow for lesson two.
Next up, bad sister.
I don't know if she's bad because she's fucking her other sister's boyfriends, or maybe she's
fucking her brother.
We don't know.
It's a four.
It could be anything.
She might be dressed as a nun.
She might be a nun.
You're right.
Beach babes, which is very basic. That doesn sound that's not fun casting couch cuties 31 god damn it 30 31 that was in 2008 so they could be up to 149 by now that tells you how much men
love to just uh talk a girl into sucking their dick.
31 of them.
It's a regular girl.
See, it's not.
She's not into porn.
She thinks she's just there to show her tits.
But man, she's going to be sucking a dick in a minute.
Now she's doing everything.
Oh, man.
Look at that.
I wish I could talk to a girl like that.
Next up, classy ass, which is nice. Just a classy ass which is nice just a classy ass um college our college wild
sorority parties sorority sisters is one this is two years by the way difference between that and
milf fucking ridiculous attack of the milfs um deal or no feel is the other one here that's nice
very clever how you feel about yourself howie mandel
come on he's gonna watch porn he's definitely gonna wash his hands after that being
how he is he's definitely gonna be fucking scrubbing himself to down to fucking no skin
uh discovering the girl next door 16 which came out the same year as attack of the milf so i mean
foot foot fetish femdom ball busters there's another one that's very specific uh fucking
neighbors three fucking is it fucking neighbors or fucking neighbors like which one is it you know what it is hot artist gets her pussy stuffed
that's the name of the film which is very direct this is what happened this is what's happening
so what's your movie about hot artist gets her pussy stuffed you know what that's a catchy title
i don't know about on a marquee, but on a box
I think we can make it work.
It feels like whoever they had
write the review of it,
or like the description, put it in
the wrong box. Yeah.
It had
a piece of tape on it with that, as this is what
it is. And he was like, I guess that's what it's called.
Just a
white piece of tape with it written in
marker that artist gets her stuff and we apologize for the porn titles but hey you know what we do
backgrounds this is amazing well yeah i'm doing it so obviously i don't either i was gonna say
we do all sorts of backgrounds that are completely fucking boring this guy you know did corn for six i don't care
so we're doing this is awesome mama's a freak too yeah so there was a one that she wasn't involved
in apparently um milf gets a black cock one again you know what's going on yeah milf next door 11
so she did attack of the milfs now she's into milf next door
and she's the girl next door and also a milf we'll combine it make one movie yeah the milf next door
it's perfect she fits all the categories here's one that as uh i assume had a lot of fanfare and
many many many people in it monsters of jizz 78 it's like monsters of rock but with jizz monsters of jizz um my sister's sexcapades
okay this one by the way put this one aside that i'm going to tell you because we'll talk about
this one more natural porn killers not bad not yeah that's the way till you hear how amazing. Not even not bad. It's incredible. It's fucking amazing, Jimmy.
It's unbelievable.
Okay.
We'll talk about that.
Next up.
It's a cinematic masterpiece.
Not the movie, but the prescience.
Okay.
Next up, promiscuous girls.
Well, we assumed that when we saw it.
That's why I'm behind this door.
That's why we're watching this.
Yeah.
Real Adventures 104.
That could be anything.
That could be somebody just going out looking for a good pastry.
I mean, that could be, I'm looking for the best beignet in New Orleans.
Like, you know, like, Real Adventures 104.
Next, Sex on Fire.
Everyone's got VD, everybody.
We're all going to just lean into it.
We all have STds everywhere next sexy sexy amateurs which has four x's more than the traditional three uh sexy amateurs which
she's definitely not an amateur next up sunny day bukkake so she's gotten something named after her
this is like when you're a u a UFC fighter and they name the card
like so-and-so versus so-and-so.
It's after you. That's big. It's big time.
That was
made by southernbukaki.com
there, by the way.
The distributor
needs a credit. Next up, Sunny
Side Up,
which I think is, wasn't that Sunny
the wrestling ladies? Wasn't that her title no
next up sunny side up two okay then finally the last three watch me fuck which obviously
that's the whole thing everyone in the room is uh then young girls cream pie oh god jesus Young Girls Cream Pie. Oh, God, Jesus. And finally, Young Mommies Who Love to Fuck Seven.
Seven?
Seven.
I don't know if she loves to fuck seven people or this is the seventh edition of this series.
Mommies love to fuck seven.
So that's her resume.
What a fucking IMDb.
That is nice.
That is some kind of IMDb.
Now, between shoots, she got a side job as a masseuse specializing in, quote, erotic massage.
So she gives hand jobs and does that in her side job.
So now she meets a man on one of these shoots.
She meets a man on a lot of these shoots.
Oh, I hope she meets one on most of them.
Except for, you know, the lesbian ones.
Yeah, I don't think there's many guys there.
So now this guy's name is Jason Andrews.
He is born on May 23, 1983, so a little younger than her.
He's born in England, apparently, from London, but came here at a very young age, grows up in Michigan.
So very American, as a matter of fact.
And he sometimes speaks in an English accent, sometimes doesn't. So it depends on when it benefits him.
He'll put the English accent on and then, you know, he just talks normal because he's from
fucking Michigan. So he doesn't have an English accent in reality. In May of 1980, near Anaheim,
California, Dorothy Jane Scott noticed her friend had an inflamed
red wound on his arm and seemed unwell. She insisted on driving him to the local hospital
to get treatment. While he waited for his prescription, Dorothy went to grab her car
to pick him up at the exit, but would never be seen alive again. Leaving us to wonder,
decades later, what really happened to Dorothy Jane Scott?
From Wondery, Generation Y is a podcast that covers notable true crime cases like this one
and many more. Every week, hosts Erin and Justin sit down to discuss a new case,
covering every angle and theory, walking through the forensic evidence,
and interviewing those close to the case to try to discover what happened.
And with over 450 episodes, there's a case for every true crime listener.
Follow the Generation Y podcast on the Wondery app
or wherever you get your podcasts.
You can listen to Generation Y ad-free right now
by joining Wondery Plus.
It's all a lighthearted nightmare on our podcast, Morbid.
We're your hosts.
I'm Alina Urquhart.
And I'm Ash Kelly.
And our show is part true crime, part spooky, and part comedy. Morbid. That is pretty great. A dash of sarcasm and just garnished a bit with a little bit of cursing.
This mother f***er lied.
Like a liar.
Like a liar.
And if you're a weirdo like us and love to cozy up to a creepy tale of the paranormal.
Or you love to hop in the Wayback Machine and dissect the details of some of history's most notorious crimes.
You should tune in to our podcast, Morbid.
Follow Morbid on the Wondery app or wherever you get your podcasts.
You can listen to episodes early and ad-free by joining Wondery Plus in the Wondery app or on Apple Podcasts.
So he's also a DJ in Chicago as well here.
And we'll get into his stuff.
He gets a following as a DJ, actually, in Chicago.
A lot of people like him um in the
lakeview area you know boystown is where he lives and performs a lot um he he writes in his online
biography says that his electronic music was based in the grittiness of the uk electro roots
and went by the name dj veritas he's latin it's not latin but he's getting all latin
with it truth bitches he's gonna tell you the truth he's gonna spin you the truth motherfucker
in digital form in digital form uh here's a guy that knows him he's a this guy's a nightlife
photographer okay i don't know what that means, but you know what it is.
Those napkin nights, guys.
Yeah.
Weirdo.
He's he says about Jason.
He was a very charming, tall, handsome British guy who was in the military.
People seemed very drawn to him.
He had girls and boys all around him.
They just sort of fawned over him.
So he's very attractive and all that kind of thing.
sort of fawned over him.
So he's very attractive and all that kind of thing.
So he was in the Marine Corps, actually, too.
Really?
The ID he uses is his Marine ID.
He says he's a corporal in the Marines, and he was in the Marine Corps.
And in addition to being in the Marine Corps, he also has a different corps that he's a part of, and that is also the porn core, we'll call it.
The hard core.
The hard core.
He goes by Addison Andrews is his name.
Addison is the name of the train station near his apartment in Boys Town in Chicago there.
Is that right?
Yeah, because there's a street.
He pulled it from a train.
Addison, well, there's plenty of trains being pulled here
most of his stuff is gay porn oh is that right it's mostly gay he's not gay though he's gay for
pay which is most of the guys in these movies so he um uh here you want to hear his list of
titles kind of oh if we gave hers we gotta got to give this. Yeah, we have to. 2008, Addison.
These are alphabetical as well.
It's Addison.
Here he is, everybody.
Next, Addison and Devin.
Let's put them together and see how we made a movie called Devin.
People seem to like that.
If we put them together.
I like these two movies.
Twice as good.
Addison and Devin behind the scenes is one.
Bad Puppy Men. I don't know what that is. Is that furries? Yeah. Addison and Devin behind the scenes is one. Bad puppy men.
I don't know what that is.
Is that furries?
Yeah.
People dress like dogs and acting like dogs.
Bang bus 29.
Oh.
Which those aren't gay.
The bang buses.
I remember those were back in the day.
That's straight and quite.
Quite disgusting.
Quite disgusting.
Yeah.
Really awful actually.
Brilliant is another one.
Okay.
You haven't told me anything.
Gay porn is not like normal porn.
That's what I mean.
You have to really know what to look for here.
Yeah.
You know?
It's not like normal porn.
Well, maybe not.
The next one is called buttingas, so I don't think.
Okay.
There you go.
We know what that is.
Oh, no, it's not.
Not buttingas.
Butginas.
I'm sorry. Oh! We know. It it's but i just glanced at it it's but ginas i apologize that is extremely explicit we know exactly what's going on there in but ginas that is man pussy yeah next up harley
and addison guy named harley he's top and bottom in this one.
So some of these it says whether he's top or bottom.
Joe and Addison next.
He's top on that one.
Then Kiefer and Addison and he's bottom on that one.
So then there's also Kiefer and Addison behind the scenes because we need to know what makes this production like this tick.
You know what I'm talking about?
Jesus Christ.
Show me how it all happened.
We got to see the behind the scene
what was where was the director of photography what was he thinking when he framed that shot
you know we need to know things really how did they learn the script did one of them keep forgetting
one of them oh the grip has a different meaning on this shoot jimmy very different meaning of
the word grip yeah um so lane and addison uh which he was a top larger than life which he's a
top monsters of jizz 78 oh so same series yeah same series then he works with our friend sunny
day in natural porn killers and that's where they meet on the set of natural porn killers in New York City.
How about that?
So yeah, you meet a girl,
a nice girl and a set of
natural porn killers and you're ready
to go.
He finishes it out with Packer In
is one of the titles here.
Packer In
which is about
Aaron Rodgers' decision on which team to go to next
ski retreat fuck fest oh which i'm pretty sure we know exactly we know exactly what that's about
then ski retreat fuck fest behind the scenes oh why does everything have to show you need to know
you need to know like with the ski lifts were they operational that day does everything have to show you need to know you need to know like with the
ski lifts were they operational that day did it have to be operated like manually by a couple of
guys you know who knows a lot of manual operations what was this the lift pass what it cost yeah
that's what i mean were they properly outfitted who actually on the set knows how to ski maybe
somebody was yeah flying down the mountain while somebody fell down almost broke their dick you know what i mean that was the hot chocolate in the lodge was it
amazing i'd like to know so a guy he knows said he did it just to make money basically that was it
it wasn't something he liked to do meaning the gay porn um they said that he he didn't talk about it
much you know he wasn't like yeah i was just this film set. This guy was totally cornhole in me and blah, blah, blah.
Like he didn't do that at all.
One of the photographer guys said he seemed kind of eager to please trying to fit in like he was out of his element.
Those are two things that you want to be.
Exactly.
Eager to please trying to fit in and out of his element.
Sounds like a guy who's doing he's not gay doing gay porn.
to fit in and out of his element sounds like a guy who's doing he's not gay doing gay porn um he said but he also became bitter or upset for no reason and would get angry and lash out at people
sometimes that he felt were were sliding him or shorting him in some way the guy said he was
constantly fighting with himself he said quote there was an unstable element about him. It was kind of like walking on eggshells with him.
So, yeah, he said that he he Andrews here had told him that he had seen people killed during his time in the military.
And then I guess one night after a soldier who just got back from Iraq lost his temper at the bar.
just got back from iraq lost his temper at the bar um i guess andrews was the one who talked to him and calmed him down and related to him and talked about ptsd and shit like that and um
the guy said the photographer said he remembered andrews saying some of us know how to hide it
pretty well like we all have it and he's affected also he's affected also. He's affected also, apparently, in that way. So now on the set of Natural Porn Killers, they meet up, our two lovebirds here.
They meet up and they fall in love, man.
Really?
It's love at first sight.
Which, if you're pounding a girl, I mean, you can tell if you're getting along pretty quickly, probably.
It's way different than going out for coffee, you know?
Yeah.
You think he can tell if she really enjoys this?
I don't know if he can tell, but, I mean, maybe they both really enjoyed it.
So, obviously, she's married and living in Leesburg, Georgia, but it doesn't matter, man.
Off camera, they made friends, too.
They're both friendly and fine.
And Amanda is known as helpful and personable.
And she's telling people this is in 2010, late 2009.
She has a nine-year-old girl.
So it must be from the first husband.
Has to be.
They said Andrews on the set always spoke with a British accent.
So this is one of his British accent places.
Yeah, this is where he tries to woo people.
Yeah, later on he'll be managing a pool hall in Chattanooga.
No English accent.
I'm not even kidding. Yeah, yeah drops it so they said he was
a jokester he often cooked dinner for everybody the porn company rented a townhouse in new york
city for all the actors to live in like a real world fucking reality show scenario and that place
had to be disgusting and uh yeah so probably very much like a mechanic who drives a shitty car i'll bet they have like
just boring lives outside of it um well not in these two we'll talk about no no not at all the
exact opposite of that as a matter of fact so uh he would cook dinner for people in the house
the co-owner of the porn company forbidden gem his name is buster thompson sure is buster nut
thompson i'm sure is his middle name he said quote i remember him being very charming the girls were
mesmerized okay so the two of them andrews and amanda they immediately latch on to each other
they take their cigarette breaks together they're you could tell there's something going on here
after filming would wrap and they'd go back into the condo, everybody had their own beds, but they'd sleep in the same bed.
Oh.
So everybody knew it was up.
At the end of the week, when the crew flew back home, they decided to stay in New York for a little bit and hang out together.
Is that right?
Yeah.
The lady who ran the shoot said, we were like, okay, this is getting a little serious.
But they said, you know, all you can do is wish them well.
They're adults.
I mean, you can't tell a person not to.
It'd be really weird to be like, now, now, come on her face.
Now, come on her face.
Okay, great.
Okay, where are you guys going?
The shoot's over.
Yeah, where are you going?
No, I think maybe getting a meal together is a little too personal.
Don't you think?
Don't get too close to each other.
Come on her face. Now, you two go your separate ways what a weird thing to do she said quote uh
she was a typical sweet down home kind of girl he seemed happy and on top of the world so good for
them uh her friend here named uh kristin cameron she said that amanda seemed like a decent person
she you know,
this is,
she's a model to this girl.
She says that this lady,
they,
she worked on a couple of modeling websites.
They did some bikini and fetish modeling together.
Okay.
And this lady said,
quote,
she was professional prompt and seemed all around normal.
So,
so I thought she was a nice,
nice to me and was a great model.
I felt a connection to her since we both have Southern backgrounds. So I thought. She was nice to me and was a great model.
I felt a connection to her since we both have Southern backgrounds.
But then she said that she thought she was acting a little weird around Andrews.
She said that, quote, Amanda wasn't the Amanda I knew.
She wouldn't talk.
All she did was text with Jason.
And she said that Jason was obnoxious and brash is what she called her.
His charm didn't work on her. She said that he would brag about his military service, which this lady didn't even believe that he did, actually.
He was in the military, but she didn't even believe that.
Not at all.
So April and May of 2010, they're just hanging out.
Where's her husband?
I don't know.
Home?
Love to know. Yeah. They're hanging out on their her husband i don't know home love to know yeah um
they're hanging out on their twitter and posting on twitter all the time amanda and jason uh they
spend several weeks in florida shooting porn um that they were their own clips that they were
selling you know i guess in an early only day only fans type of deal um they would hang out
on the beach and you know make videos
saying how much they love each other and yeah be grinning and hugging all the time and that that
was a thing back then like club jenna jenna jenna jameson basically gave birth to to only fans
without anybody i mean without getting any sort of credit for that kind of but that was doing it
on her own uh dispersing is that the the word? Distributing her own shit on her own website.
Yeah, she was more of a producer.
But like, yeah, yeah, this is, I'm talking about what they're doing is kind of like a.
Instantaneous.
It's the same thing.
Instantaneous, yeah, I guess is the way to put it.
They even, and they mundane things too, like just going to the flea market together they put up there.
And then them fucking in a tanning booth as well you know
gross ah no yeah yeah yeah yeah public is gross out of your house is disgusting
now you people know and especially you ladies what what happens in those fucking tanning booths
what do you think happens in a florida tanning booth jimmy yeah i guess you're right you know
if you're in a florida tanning booth you know the drill you know the drill first of all go outside it's sunny second of all gross so disgusting
uh their night they'd go out and have margaritas and drinks and uh they'd fucking on the beach and
they'd fucking hotel rooms and they'd be they're dating they're having a whole relationship and
flaunting it online whole good time just banging each other left and right
having a blast which good for you i don't care between you and your husband if this is fine with
him i don't give a shit whatever you're doing yeah whatever you're doing uh so may 7th 8th 9th
ish around there they're posting messages on twitter saying that they were crossing the state
of florida shooting clips for sale and they'd be in Largo and they'd be in Newport Ritchie.
Now, when they do this, this is apparently this is apparently like an advertisement for we're available.
If you want to hang out, if you want to be.
Yeah, they're they're available or whatever.
Hire them.
They're available for hire for private. Yeah, they're they prostitute themselves as well them. They're available for hire for private.
Yeah, they prostitute themselves as well.
And, you know, it's whatever.
It's they're making money going around.
But we'll also charge ticket prices to see what we do together.
Exactly.
So either way, that's how they're doing it.
However you want to give us money for our genitalia, you know.
genitalia you know so honestly so may uh 14th he posts andrews jason posts a link to a photo of amanda which is nude and everything and wrote on his twitter account uh the real sunny day which
is her handle there and i are killing time waiting for a party to find us. In other words, hey, you know, free to hire tonight is what that means.
Yeah.
So the next day on the 15th, they get a phone call.
They get messages that turns into a phone call and someone hires them.
They hire Amanda as a man, not Jason, but they hire Amanda to have.
Basically, there's going to be a party the next day at this guy's house.
And during it, he wants to have sex with her on camera and shit during the party.
So, you know, it's a I guess an amateur porn, you could call it.
So she says, OK, and they work out a price and they go there.
Now, the guy who hires her is a guy named dennis scooter abrahamson yeah uh scooter this
is nickname old scoots scooter when you picture scooter what do you think of um only because i
know of a particular one uh now he's changed the the image i have a scooter scooter and skater are
very similar exactly used to be they're very very interchangeable. Yeah. This guy's a big,
big kind of burly,
Yeah.
kind of fat,
big goatee biker.
That's a scooter.
He's a big biker.
Scooter like my scooter,
meaning my motorcycle.
Mahog, yeah.
Mahog, and yeah,
you can see there's pictures of him
from way back,
you know,
that are 80s pictures
and shit like that
of him on motorcycles.
He's always been doing this.
He's been a biker forever, and he owns a tattoo and piercing parlor fantastic it's symbiotic
really it's perfect so it's a really great it is you know yeah i used to sell drugs to bikers who
had a tattoo parlor worked great other people would come in they give them tattoos they'd sell
them the drugs and i sold them it was perfect worked well easily yeah it was nice so this is uh he owns embellishing tattoo and
piercing shop i guess so that's what he does he's known as everybody says he's a fun loving biker
who loves the fast life he likes to party he makes really good money he's also got like
repo companies and shit so he makes a lot of money and it's all like cash business and repo and all that.
That's a real –
It's all grimy.
It's real grimy.
It's real dark.
It's an underworld.
So he's got several kind of half underworld-y type things.
Not that tattoos are underworld, but you know what I'm talking about.
You get it.
You get it.
So he also had some problems with himself.
He's been a biker for he's 41 years old.
He's been a biker in Florida.
So he's he's had a couple of run ins with the cops as well.
Sure.
Yeah.
Everybody likes him, though.
But he's he said that he will also he owns a bunch of businesses, scooters, recovering and towing service is his repo job there.
is his repo job there.
He was also denied on a number of applications in which he applied for licensing for his repo business
because of instances of reported domestic violence in 2005
that he was a part of.
Oh, Scooter.
Yeah.
His former girlfriend, who he had several kids with,
filed a number of physical and mental abuse reports on Scooter as well.
Okay.
But Scooter's a very well-liked guy other than by his ex-wife, obviously, or girlfriend.
So on May 15th, we're going to have a sex party.
Yeah.
Let's do this.
Sex party time.
Abrahamson here, our Scooter, he and his two friends, who are Maynard and Lisa Bineschadl. He's got a couple that he's hanging out with who are maynard and lisa bindshaddle yeah he's got a
couple that he's hanging out with all maynard and lisa they just sound like nice folky invite over
sunday dinner lisa scooter maynard i'm having a chicken dinner this sunday it's just gonna be a
nice roast chicken with some vegetables from the garden y'all want to come by maynard and lisa come
on by sure sounds good Sounds good, right?
Folksy people.
Well, they were hanging out at a strip club before the sex party.
They were getting geared up for the sex party. It was going to go back on at Scooter's house.
Sure.
And once they got there, Sonny arrives as well back to his house.
And the deal is Maynard and Lisa are going to be fucking each other.
And then he's going to be fucking Sonny Day. lisa are going to be fucking that fucking each other and then he's going to be fucking sunny day scooter's going to be fucking sunny day they're going to be
filming all this shit right you know it's just going to be a good time there real nice nice
party so any plans for jason in that environment no jason's dropping her off he's playing like the
driver guy this is she's making the dough tonight the fuck out of here so they're they film the
hot tub sex that they're having all night here so they're they film the hot tub sex
that they're having all night because of course this guy has a hot tub obviously they notice
though Maynard and Lisa noticed that Sonny appeared to be constantly checking her cell phone
she's like taking her from behind like you know picking up her phone like which is a weird thing
to do so eventually Maynard and Lisa leave and it's just Scooter and Sonny by themselves they
go see you later and Scooter's like yeah yeah, now it's going to get real filthy.
During this time, on her phone, she's texting with Jason back and forth all the time here.
So everybody leaves the party, the couple, everybody.
There's two other people.
They leave the party around 5 a.m., and she stays.
Jason's out in the car the whole
time by the way oh i don't know if everybody knows that but he's out in the car waiting this
whole time and texting her now here are the text messages they are exchanging oh boy this is amanda
to jason quote they are packing up meaning the couple i'm fucking excited to fuck someone up
i want to fuck after we kill him
i don't know if everybody heard that because you were inhaling i want to fuck after we kill him
is what that last part was so a couple minutes later she texted okay i don't see knives he's got
coke and two roxies okay okay then jason back, just get him on his face, either bash or tell me to get in and where to go.
A minute later, he texted her again, okay, front or back door.
Amanda says, front, not yet, though.
Okay.
Okay.
And he says, Andrews says, just prepping.
I'll wait for your call from here
her response is k i'm horny exclamation point k i'm horny that's that's her response
she says i'm getting him to play music uh be quiet when you come in sorry not ready fixing
to get on the table so you know she's southern because
she's fixing to get on the table and so you know that's how you know that uh and then jason says
quote i got all the time in the world you just get him relaxed and face down when i come in what
direction and she said straight so straight in the front door he's getting him on the table for a massage for a massage she says wicked i'll be
waiting or he says wicked i'll be waiting really and this is all one word sentences really take
your time so get it right and she said okay starting massage i got a bottle liquor to hit
with you we'll hear when you come in or sneak in and stand in the
house she's terrible at texting he says k then she says come in okay this is by the way uh then
before this they were talking about i have vinyl gloves don't worry about it at one point uh he
says make sure you grab a knife for me okay look for knives for me also and she's like no problem
don't kissy face yeah it's it's fucking wild man um so he ends up coming in dennis is on he has a
massage table in his who has a massage table in their house but he has a massage table scooters
face down getting an erotic massage as we'll talk about and jason comes in with a sledge
hammer oh my god and bashes his fucking skull in wow repeat and horribly i mean this place is a
mess afterwards as you can imagine um and to not be you know to make sure they also stab him
repeatedly in the back as well both of them both of them natural porn killers
natural porn killers exactly hell that's the name of this episode absolutely absolutely absolutely
so andrews would set about killing him quote i struck him the first time very very hard he's a
b63 he's a big, tall Marine.
I mean, he can swing a sledgehammer.
Sure.
And he would start twitching, and I'd strike him again with the hammer.
Yeah, that's him dying, man.
Yeah.
He said, I could see the hammer disappearing into the back of his skull.
What the fuck? This was fucking horrible, dude.
Fucking disgusting.
So the next day, his uh went over because he wasn't
answering his phone scooter and found him yeah and uh said and the one of the cops who saw the
scene said one of our one of the people the reporters who talked to the cops one of them
told us after working over 10 000 death investigations during a 30-year career this
was uh this was the most horrific crime scene he'd ever seen in this area.
The crime itself is just so needless and horrific.
Okay.
They also find his cell phone, Scooter's cell phone, a bloody sledgehammer, bloody knives, all sorts of shit like that.
like that. Meanwhile, the two of them, Jason and Sonny, are posting on Twitter at 4.29 p.m. the next day, saying, quote, taking it easy with, in his tag, laying around eating popcorn and watching
movies. And then an hour later, Jason tweeted, the real Sonny Day and I want to go watch a movie
tonight. Any suggestions? Stay away from me. Yeah uh yeah now the detective who was investigating said
i observed a silver sex toy laying on the massage table between his legs oh no which they thought he
was there's a they called it an erotic massage gone wrong at that point so very yep they also
find that six thousand dollars a laptop a video camera a digital camera
and a home depot credit card were missing from his house as well okay so during the investigation
they review his scooter's cell phone records to see who he was talking to and they find the number
for his friends maynard and lisa they talk to them they say oh well there was a chick named Sunny Day there and she was fucking texting
so
they do that they find out that Scooter was
he thought when he was texting
Sunny the whole time beforehand
he was texting Sunny he was actually
texting Jason Jason was working as
her manager here so
anyway they're arrested
Jason and Amanda not for murder
for what they are for retail theft for shoplifting Anyway, they're arrested, Jason and Amanda, not for murder. For what?
They are for retail theft, for shoplifting.
Shoplifting.
They got a retail theft charge.
By the way, he, Jason, had the Scooter's Home Depot card on him at the time.
They were arrested for stealing $67.97 worth of clothes from Beals.
Oh, what?
Really? Yeah. They stole $6, what? Really? Pathetic. Yeah.
They stole $6,000 from the man, though.
Stole $67 worth of shit from shitty Beals.
Shitty Beals. And then also
they bought $400 worth
of tools from Home Depot with the Home Depot
credit card as well.
So she said, they talked to her
and they said, well, once
the cops found out who that was and that they had that person in possession already for for theft.
They went in and talked to her and she said, quote, I gave him his massage, played with him and he fell asleep on the massage table.
And I left right before dawn, I guess, or right after.
So she says, I don't know.
I jerked him off and went home.
I don't know what the fuck happened after that. I don't know i jerked him off and went home i don't know
what the fuck happened after that i don't know what this guy's life is like he's a repo man who
owns a tattoo parlor anything's possible i mean honestly it's kind of an underworldy feel to him
so yeah yeah yeah he's a biker he's got charges and shit so they were like the wrong car yeah so
they they actually they don't have any way to charge them at this moment in time they have
nothing to charge them with so they do get a search warrant, though, for Amanda's Ford Explorer, where they find two BlackBerrys that had their SIM cards and batteries removed from them.
So that's Jason and Amanda's phones.
They worked to retrieve some of the lost data, and they tried to interview her again.
But the hotel that they listed as their address after they were released from jail, when they showed up, obviously they were gone.
Amanda and Jason.
They found out that he had went to Exotica or some triple X, some porn convention.
It's a convention in Florida.
I had no idea about that.
And she went.
One of the ladies that works for it loves us.
Oh, cool.
Well, good for you. you well you had a visitor
that year that was not a good guy and he went back she went back to her husband in georgia
is that right honey i'm home don't matter yeah i know there's a mixture of blood and jizz on me
looks like i'm covered in fucking mcdonald's special sauce from a big mac but don't sweat
that at all it's fine yeah don't worry about
it i got you a new laptop red and white make orange jesus christ gross so um then jason writes
on his twitter account in hebrew this is the translation amanda please let me know when when
you are okay really my heart can't take the weight of fear that i would never see you again she just
took off so the police go back to interview her again okay and um a sheriff's detective from
pasco county comes up talks to her at her home in georgia yeah talks about the cell phone records
and basically look we know what the fuck we know you were there when this happened what happened
she said i had nothing to do with it.
He just likes to kill people.
He gets really turned on and wants to fuck after he kills people and stuff.
So, you know, I didn't do anything, though.
He came in and did everything, and I didn't do anything.
Wow.
He said that he rushed in and saw me having sex with Scooter and got super jealous and did all this.
Oh, shit.
She said that he stormed in, quote,
with something in his hands like a big hammer.
He just started bashing Dennis in the back of the head.
He said that if I told anyone, he'd do the same.
She said that Jason grabbed her by the back of the hair
and twisted her arm behind her back
and forced her to view Scooter's crushed skull
and said, that's what's going to happen to you if you tell anyone,
but in a British accent that was charming.
That's what's going to happen to you.
Love, and he called her love.
In it.
In it.
He said, all right.
All right, and she said, all right.
By the way, every British lady,
every British lady, regardless of race, class, or age, when they meet someone, all says, hello.
In that exact way.
Hello.
I watched this dating show, The First Dates.
Every single woman that met a man went, hello.
No matter if she was 20, 60, rich, poor, white, black, didn't fucking matter.
It was, hello.
So I think that's hilarious.
Anyway.
The usage of all right now is my favorite thing.
I like it too.
I'm just going to start doing it to people.
All right.
What?
People in this country will be like, what are you talking about?
What?
That's what you're telling me so they are the
authorities issue a an arrest warrant for andrews after completing forensic testing on bloody
weapons which were found in a laundry basket in the home their forensic scientists confirm a match
between jason's dna and the dna found in the wooden handle of a knife used in the killing. So he's fucked. July 16th, 2010,
they track him down in Chattanooga where he is currently managing
the manager at Chattanooga Billiards,
the Chattanooga Billiards Club.
That's where you hide.
That's where you hide in Chattanooga.
No one's looking there.
They conducted surveillance,
identified him as the suspect.
He was working the night shift.
The owner of the place,
Phil Windham here,
says he admits he didn't do a very good background check and he wishes he had he said that andrews had only been working there for three days he said he was a well-spoken clean
cut guy he said this is a huge shock to us my employees are scared they had no idea yeah how
could they um yeah he said that he wasn't even in town the owner he said i was out of town i get town. I get a call from the U.S. Marshals going, hey, that guy you just hired, we're going to arrest him for a horrible murder.
Cool.
A really bad one.
Really bad, like super bad.
And he was hired solely on the strength of a recommendation from a longtime member of this club.
That member was Chris Andrews, Jason's brother.
And a friend of his said, hey, he's a good guy.
He's real charming and he needs a job.
You should help him out and all that kind of shit.
Ask him to say all right.
Ask him.
See, he'll know.
And the guy said, we'll be doing a background check from now on and hiring people.
That's probably right.
Now, Dennis or Lehman, who sometimes goes, sometimes he's called Dennis for some reason.
I don't know why.
Layman, yeah, her husband.
He said, Jesus Christ, he wouldn't comment on the relationship with Jason, but he said,
quote, my opinion, she's a good woman.
Oh, Dennis.
Okay.
Sure, Layman, sounds good.
It was more than your legs that got hurt. I think.
So Amanda is going to plead guilty because all of her text messages going,
okay,
I'm horny and stuff like that is not great.
I can't wait to fuck someone up and then fuck.
What are you doing?
She pleads guilty to second degree murder in court.
Her cousin,
her scooter's cousin,
by the way,
who's the one who found him,
found him,
right.
Gets to do the family
statement yeah and she says quote i hope anytime you close your eyes he comes and haunts you for
the rest of your pathetic life you're not a person you're an evil being my wow you ma'am
may fuck off uh 40 years in prison for her. She got in Florida.
She could have got life if she had first degree, but they gave her second degree.
By the way, she's our only small town murderer ever that has their own wiki feet page.
That's never been done before.
Ever.
First time ever.
First time ever, everybody.
We did it.
We found it.
We did it. We did it. We did it.
We did it.
We should shelve the whole thing now.
Wiki feed.
Wiki feed.
So in court, Jason pleads guilty to first degree murder.
Yeah, because he brought the fucking hammer.
Yeah, this is to get the death penalty off the table.
Okay.
And he's the one who did all the actual bashing and murdering.
I mean, he said he gave it all up to saying, yeah, I was fucking smashing the shit out of his head.
You heard the quote.
And he gets you, sir.
May fuck off life in prison without parole.
It's over for him.
It's life in prison for him.
Yeah.
Wow.
So I hope there's someone to pay him for the gay in there because it's going to be rough on him.
So he's going to thrive in there.
I got a few.
Probably. He's a pretty guy he's so he is in the calhoun correctional institution in
bluntstown florida amanda is at the florida uh women's reception center which sounds like a nice
place where you look for wedding dresses it's like a wedding expo in Calhoun, Florida. She'll be eligible for release in 2047.
Oh, my God.
That's too soon.
That's too soon.
She's going to be out there.
Serialkillersinc.net, by the way, had a letter of hers for sale.
This was a letter for $25 of hers.
And it's her.
She changed her name now.
She only killed one person.
She said, in this letter, from what I can see, because it's her changed their name now she only killed one person she said in this letter
from what i can see because it's half covered by an envelope uh four brothers but it was like i was
an only child um it was kind of a rough upbringing she said that she always wanted to be a teaching
assistant that's all i can see there so 25 for that and uh you can i don't know see that childhood
aspirations that all went wrong
there's also a book i didn't read on this because it doesn't look like it's very well
it might be well done but doesn't look like it's not even available like on most websites
read don't even have a single one of her porn titles in it nothing goddamn nothing
that's lame man it's called the porn star and, The True Story of Amanda Logue, and it's by Alison Yale.
I didn't read it, like I said, because it's 86 pages long.
Give me a break.
Our fucking regular episodes are longer than that, literally.
So fuck off.
It's a book.
We do that twice a week.
Eat dicks.
Cliff notes are longer than that.
And then I found an most unfortunate Facebook post of all time.
Oh, God.
And then I found an most unfortunate Facebook post of all time.
Oh, God.
There is a kennel, I believe, called, or something, a puppy here, called Daisy's Delightful Doodles.
And it's got a picture of a very cute little dog, golden doodles of Instagram, golden doodle. And it says, Sunny Day, D-A-E, that's the dog's name, knows how to get the boys to chase her.
And it has dogs chasing
behind this other dog.
I'm like, yeah, she does.
Looking for some tail.
And that is Newport,
Ritchie, Florida, and some
gross, disgusting, jizz-covered
brain matter fucking viscera
flecked grossness.
I feel so bad.
Oh, my God.
The whole thing's gross.
Poor Scooter.
Yeah, he had problems.
At least he went out on top.
He sure did.
On his face, either way.
But yeah, terrible.
That sucks for that poor guy.
He was just trying to have a sex party, I guess.
He thought he was on top of the world.
Look, I can hire porn stars now.
That's where my life is.
That's where his life is. That where that's that's that's where his life is that's some kind of life
wow if you enjoyed this show tell the world about it get a happy listening on give us five stars
just say something nice helps drive us up the charts follow us on social media we are at
small town murder on instagram at small town pod on facebook at murder small on
twitter also definitely get your tickets to all the live shows murder.com let's go salt lake city
more tickets available new venue a bigger venue thank you for helping us step that up by the way
that's the last venue chain no more bigger venues no more added shows no more second shows this is
locked in what we have get your tickets
now they're selling fast boston's already sold out denver san diego minneapolis very close get
your tickets to chicago come see us baby there and uh all that kind of thing portland if you're
listening right when this comes out portland tomorrow night we march 25th we are in portland
and there's still tickets left for the late show. Get your asses in there and see us.
Shut up and give me murder.com.
Also, get the 420 virtual live show.
I'm going to get Jimmy stoned.
420, April 20th, available for a week after that.
You can buy it, take it, fuck it, bukkake it.
I don't care what you got to do with it.
Enjoy it.
Get in there and do that.
That's not Patreon.
Shut up and give me murder.com.
Patreon.com slash crime and sports. Bonus up and give me murder.com. Patreon.com slash crime and sports bonus stuff.
Huge back catalog.
Anybody $5.
Honestly, it's the best bargain in fucking Patreon.
You get two new episodes every other week.
Great shit this week, which you're going to get and you get access to it all for crime
and sports.
The 0 and 26 Tampa Bay Buccaneers.
Why is the guy winking at me?
Why are you dressed like that?
What's up with that color?
You fucking weirdos.
We got that.
And then for small town murder, we are going to talk about jody arias and things that she puts in her butthole and other places as
well so lots of god it's dirty week here on small town murder that's patreon.com so grimy slash crime
and sports also make sure to keep your eyes out coming soon your stupid opinions are our new
podcast about crazy internet opinions and all the terrible, awful shit that goes into them.
Holy shit.
Do that.
You want to follow us on social media?
You can follow us on social media.
Just head over where?
Shutupandgivememurder.com, where you get anything related to us whatsoever.
Also, good merch going up all the time.
New stuff there.
You can follow us.
There's links to everything.
By the way, for some reason on the menu, very quickly, on the menu of our schedule page,
the Charlotte show is on the 9th of that month, September 9th.
Atlanta's the 8th.
Charlotte's the 9th.
For some reason, when you click on it, it says the 10th.
I don't know why.
We tried to fix it.
Sarah tried to.
She's literally been dealing with tech people trying to figure out why this glitch happened. Why is this doing this? I don't know why. We tried to fix it. Sarah tried to. She's literally been dealing with tech people
trying to figure out why this glitch happened.
Why is this doing this? We don't know. It's on the
9th. If you click through it, buy the ticket.
The ticket's at the site. Say the 9th. It's the 9th.
Don't worry about it. So get in there. Shut up and give me
murder.com. Thank you so much for
joining us and hanging out with us and listening
to a very gross story and tons of porn
titles. We appreciate it
greatly and dearly.
Thank you so much.
And until...
Take a shower.
Oh, man.
Until...
Oh, what kind of shower, Jimmy?
A water bukkake?
I'm getting a very method soap full shower.
I need cleanliness.
I'm calling a shower water bukkake from now on, everybody.
That said, natural porn killers.
And we're out.
Until next week, everybody.
It's been our pleasure.
Bye. Hey, Prime members, you can listen to Small Town Murder early and ad-free on Amazon Music.
Download the Amazon Music app today.
Or you can listen early and ad-free with Wondery Plus and Apple Podcasts.
Before you go, tell us about yourself by completing a short survey at wondery.com slash
survey. Welcome to the small town of Chinook, where faith runs deep and secrets run deeper.
In this new thriller, available exclusively on Wondery+, religion and crime collide when a
gruesome murder rocks the isolated Montana community. Everyone is quick to point their
fingers at a drug addicted teenager,
but local deputy Ruth Vogel isn't convinced.
She suspects connections to a powerful religious group.
Enter federal agent VB Loro,
who has been investigating a local church
for possible criminal activity.
The pair form an unlikely partnership to catch the killer,
unearthing secrets that leave Ruth torn
between her duty to the law, her religious convictions, and her very own family. But something more sinister
than murder is afoot, and someone is watching Ruth. With an all-star cast led by Emmy nominee
Sanaa Lathan and Star Wars Kelly Marie Tran, Chinook is available exclusively and ad-free
on Wondery Plus. Join Wondery Plus in the Wondery app or on Apple Podcasts.