Snapped: Women Who Murder - BONUS: Alice and Gerald Uden (Snapped: Killer Couples)
Episode Date: January 15, 2025The disappearances of a mother and her two sons in 1980 leads to three-decade quest for justice.Season 15, Episode 10Originally aired: Jun 25, 2021Watch full episodes of Snapped for FREE on t...he Oxygen app: https://oxygentv.app.link/WatchSnappedPodSee Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.
Transcript
Discussion (0)
The Grinch is back again to ruin your Christmas season with Tis the Grinch Holiday Podcast.
Listen as his celebrity guests try to persuade the Grinch that there's more to love about the holiday season.
Follow Tis the Grinch Holiday Podcast on the Wondery app or wherever you get your podcasts.
Grown-ups, enjoy bonus content of Tis the Grinch Holiday Podcast exclusively on Wondery Plus.
Each morning, it's a new opportunity, a chance to start fresh.
Up First from NPR makes each
morning an opportunity to learn and to understand. Choose to join the world every morning with
Up First, a podcast that hands you everything going on across the globe and down the street,
all in 15 minutes or less. Start your day informed and anew with Up First by subscribing
wherever you get your podcasts.
Hi, Snap listeners. We are bringing you a special bonus episode today from oxygen's hit series killer couples
You can also watch full episodes live or on demand on the free oxygen app or on peacock by clicking the link in our description
enjoy a
40 year old mystery rattles a small Wyoming community
There's just a desperation to understand what happened to this woman
and her two children. A cold case task force uncovers disturbing new clues
within the family. We found human blood in the back deck of that station wagon.
There could be a serial killer who's stalking people and killing people.
But as authorities expose more deadly secrets, the body count continues to escalate.
We had remains exhumed because we wanted to determine if in fact he had been poisoned.
And the suspected killers behind it all leave everyone stunned.
She said, you're gonna hear that I killed somebody.
I know you're not telling the whole truth, right?
Yes.
They looked at killing people as a solution to a problem.
These were two profoundly evil people who found one another. And together they held these incredibly dark, violent, sadistic secrets. For someone looking to disappear or get away from it all, you can't do much better than
Fremont County, Wyoming.
Fremont County is rural.
People there can live the life they want to live without a lot of interference from the
rest of the world.
So it's a place where you can escape
the prying eyes of your neighbors.
In 1976, 37-year-old Alice Prunty moved to Fremont County
in search of a fresh start.
A mother of five, Alice had just left her third husband.
Alice was an Illinois girl who grew up in a normal family.
She was divorced, then widowed, then divorced.
She moves in her trailer to Wyoming.
I was the baby. I was a very spoiled baby.
My mother supported me.
My mom was an awesome mom.
She loved music.
Saturdays was house cleaning day.
She put Tammy Wynette and
Tanya Tucker playing on the record player.
Three failed marriages hadn't dampened Alice's determination to find lasting love.
She finally found it in the summer of 1976 when she began dating her next door neighbor, 32-year-old Gerald Uden.
One day, there was a knock on Gerald's door,
and it was Alice.
She wanted him to help her connect her trailer to the power.
He was immediately smitten.
She was, to him, the most beautiful woman
he'd ever seen in the world.
A maintenance worker at a local steel mine,
Gerald was also coming off his third failed marriage.
To Gerald, Alice was the whole package.
She was independent, she was resourceful, she could support herself.
He fell head over heels in love with my mom.
Just five months after meeting, Gerald and Alice tied the knot,
and the couple bought a farm in Pavilion, Wyoming.
Mom milked cows. She had chickens. They had their own pigs.
As their child, I never really wanted for anything.
In the summer of 1980, Gerald received some unexpected news
when his ex-wife, Virginia Uden, and her two young sons,
11-year-old Richard and 10-year-old Reagan, moved to the same small town.
They were not the biological children of Virginia and Gerald Uden. Richard and 10-year-old Reagan moved to the same small town.
They were not the biological children of Virginia and Gerald Uden.
They were her children from a previous marriage.
But Gerald had adopted the boys prior to the divorce.
When Gerald learned the boys were moving with their mother to Lander, Wyoming, he was elated. Gerald took his father role very seriously,
and he was a good father.
When the boys would visit, they were one big family
in Gerald and Alice's home.
Sadly, the reunion would be short-lived.
On September 13, 1980,
two months after Virginia and her sons moved to Lander,
her mother, Claire Martin,
enters the Fremont County Sheriff's Office
with disturbing news.
She wanted to speak to an officer
about a missing persons report,
and at that time, she started telling us about her daughter.
Virginia was supposed to go meet Gerald Juden with the boys
so that they could go bird hunting.
But when Claire called Gerald to check in on her daughter and grandsons,
he informed her that the trio never showed up to meet him.
Virginia doesn't show up at the time that Claire expected her to, and Claire begins to worry.
Gerald agreed to come help her look for them, and so Gerald and Claire went and drove around
looking for Virginia and the boys. They go around places in Riverton that Virginia might have been.
They don't find her.
Now that Virginia and her sons have been missing for nearly 24 hours,
Claire is concerned that something bad has happened to her daughter and grandsons.
Claire knew her daughter better than anyone,
and she knew her daughter wouldn't have just
up and left without saying a word or taking any money with her.
She described the vehicle that they were in, which was actually Claire's vehicle, a Ford
station wagon.
An attempt to locate was put out with all other agencies, the police departments and
things to watch for the car that she
was driving.
Three weeks pass without a word from Virginia Uden or her sons.
Then, on October 4th, authorities receive an ominous tip.
A passerby reports to the sheriff's office that he saw a half-hidden station wagon on
the edge of a very deep canyon in the Wind River Mountains.
The station wagon's tags identify it as belonging to Claire Martin, the same vehicle Virginia
had been driving when she and her sons disappeared. We found that there was human blood
in the back deck of that station wagon.
The blood was a Type A, which matched Virginia's blood type.
And there was also some.22 caliber shells in the car.
Fearful that Virginia and her sons had met foul play, authorities released their findings to the media
and asked for the public's help in locating the missing mother and children.
It was scary for us because Virginia Uden actually was an employee of mine. And so we got to know Virginia
and knew her two boys fairly well.
People went all over and combed that mountain
looking for bodies.
With zero leads, authorities turned back
to Virginia's mother, Claire Martin,
to see if she can provide any additional insight
into her daughter's life.
That's when Claire offers a shocking theory.
She was totally convinced that Gerald Uden had killed
her daughter and her two sons.
MUSIC
Investigators press Claire for more information about Gerald's relationship with both Virginia
and her sons.
Virginia and the boys were, they were a tremendous source of tension in the relationship between
Alice and Gerald.
And part of that was because Virginia wanted more child support. Alice wrote really hateful things in correspondence with Virginia.
She called Virginia brainless.
You tricked my husband into marrying you and everyone knows you, you didn't love
him, you only did it for the money.
There was a lot of hatred between Alice and Virginia.
And really, it was not any kind of a fight over Gerald.
It was really over money.
On November 14, 1980, nearly two months after
Virginia and her sons went missing,
investigators request to speak with Gerald and Alice Uden.
We talked to Alice individually.
Alice was kind of a basket case at that time.
She was crying and emotional
and really couldn't answer much.
Gerald, however, visibly resents Claire's accusations.
He became very physically upset, was shaking and couldn't hold a cup of coffee.
You could see the carotid artery in his neck pulsating
and Larry said that he's covering up something.
I knew right away we had our guy
and that he had something to do with it,
with the missing people. We
just didn't know why.
Without warning, Gerald abruptly ends the interview, but not before leaving investigators
with one final and disturbing thought.
He said that, you know, even if there was a, that we couldn't prove it because there was no body.
Coming up, the case is sent spiraling in a new direction
when an informant comes forward with a shocking allegation.
We're here today to give you a chance.
We know where he is because we have him now.
MUSIC
MUSIC
More than five months after the mysterious disappearances
of Virginia Uden and her two sons, Richard and Reagan,
investigators with the Fremont County Sheriff's Office
have received information from Virginia's mother, Claire Martin, who believes
Virginia and her sons were murdered by her ex-husband, Gerald Uden.
Claire Martin felt in her bones that Gerald Uden played a role in the
disappearance. I believe that she knew deep in her heart that they had been killed.
Despite their suspicions, investigators are unable to find any evidence connecting Gerald
or his wife Alice to the disappearances.
There's absolutely no evidence and their hands were tied.
Years pass without any new leads.
Claire was doing everything in her power to find her family.
We all suspected the same thing. At that point we didn't have it, as far as the law requires.
In 1982, citing police pressure
and suspicion from their neighbors,
Alice and Gerald suddenly sell their Wyoming farm
and move 1,100 miles to Chadwick, Missouri.
Honestly, when we moved to Missouri,
I don't think I understood all of it.
I was eight years old.
For 12 more years, nothing new materializes in the investigation.
If you understand what's happening in that community at that time, there's just a desperation
to understand what happened to this woman and her two children.
Then, in 1994, 14 years after Virginia and her boys went missing,
the case takes a sudden and unexpected turn
when an informant comes forward with a bombshell allegation.
The informant is Alice Uden's oldest son, Todd Scott, comes forward with a bombshell allegation.
The informant is Alice Uden's oldest son, Todd Scott.
And he tells police that his mother had once confessed
to being involved in a murder.
But to everyone's surprise, it's not the murder
of Virginia or her sons.
Todd Scott, who was one of the children of Alice Uden,
knew his mother had killed her husband Ronald Holtz.
And he knew that because she told him that she did.
Investigators learned that Ron Holtz,
a Vietnam War veteran, had been Alice's third husband.
The two had met and married in 1974 after a whirlwind romance that began in a psychiatric hospital.
She'd been a psych nurse. She was sympathetic to the trauma that he suffered in Vietnam. And, you know, she thought she could, you know, save him or whatever.
I believe I was two or so when she married Ron.
According to Todd, Alice and Ron's marriage was tumultuous from the start.
Ron had abused Alice. Ron's marriage was tumultuous from the start.
Ron had abused Alice.
Ron had a very volatile history.
Todd explains that Alice had initially told everyone she had kicked Ron out when she filed for divorce in December of 1974.
Ron had never contested the divorce. In fact, no one had ever seen or heard from Ron Holtz again.
Disappearing was completely in keeping with his character.
That was the reputation he had.
But years later, Alice had told her son a very different story about what really happened
to his former stepfather.
One night, he was about 14 or 15.
His mom had been drinking and she was feeling a little bit emotional.
And she told him that years earlier when she'd been married to Ron, he'd been very abusive
and she was afraid of him.
And so one night when he was sleeping, she got her 22 and she shot him in the back of
the head while he was in bed.
She had taken his body out of the trailer, put him in a barrel, and thrown him down the
abandoned gold mine in the remount ranch.
His mother had told him that Ron had been abusive and deserved what he got.
Todd for a very, very long time,
carried what had to be an enormous burden.
And he just eventually had to get this off of his shoulders.
Investigators dig into Todd's claim
and discover that there's no paper trail for Ron Holtz
since the winter of 1974, when Alice had told her
family she'd left Ron.
His Social Security, for instance, had had no activity.
A man who had been in and out of mental hospitals for years had no more medical reports. They were pretty convinced that Ron Holtz probably
was no longer alive.
Investigators theorize that if Alice had killed
her third husband, it increased the likelihood
that she and potentially Gerald were
responsible for what happened to Virginia and her sons. They widened the scope of their investigation
to focus on finding the remains of Ron Holtz.
Coordinating with police in Cheyenne, Wyoming,
detectives launch a search of Remount Ranch.
Everybody knew that abandoned mine shaft was there,
and commonly, when there would be an animal that would die on the ranch,
they would dispose of the remains down the mine shaft.
At one time the hole had been 90 feet deep, maybe a dozen feet across.
The surrounding dirt and rocks were unstable. Sending anybody down there would be difficult.
were unstable. Sending anybody down there would be difficult.
Without the proper resources, investigators must call off the search.
And just like the unsolved investigation into what happened to Virginia Uden and her sons, the search for Ron Holtz hits a brick wall.
We had nothing else to go on, No new information, no bodies were discovered. So
it became a cold case. It was very frustrating. It was always on our minds.
Eleven more years pass with no leads for either case. Then in 2005, both Virginia Uden and Ron Holtz's unsolved
cases receive renewed interest.
It's several years later when a Wyoming Division of Criminal
Investigation investigator begins to look through the cold case files.
At the time I was a special agent for the Wyoming Division of Criminal Investigation.
My role in this case is one of the investigators.
The Cold Case team decides to focus their efforts on Alice Uden.
We're going to interview her, have a conversation,
and find out what happened if she would give us more insight into the murder of Ron Holtz.
find out what happened if she would give us more insight into the murder of Ron Holtz.
On January 18, 2005, detectives with the Cold Case Task Force
make the surprise visit to Gerald and Alice's home
in Chadwick, Missouri.
Gerald had become a trucker.
And at the time, Gerald is on the road
on a trucker and at the time Gerald is on the road on a trucking assignment. When
they knock on the front door Alice answers. Alice is a kind of grand motherly
type at that point. They ask her if she'll answer a few questions which she
does. Alice seems to think nothing about it. She even invites him inside.
They bring up her past relationships,
and she goes down the list of husbands that she'd had.
But she conveniently leaves out Ron Holtz.
When Alice neglects to mention Ron,
the detectives ask her directly about her third husband,
and her reaction is telling.
When confronted with the name Ron holds,
she falls out of her chair, half fainted.
I'm Jake Warren, and in our first season of Finding, I set out on a very personal quest
to find the woman who saved my mum's life.
You can listen to Finding Natasha right now exclusively on Wondery+.
In season 2, I found myself caught up in a new journey to help someone I've never even
met.
But a couple of years ago, I came across a social media post by a person named Loti.
It read in part,
Three years ago today that I attempted to jump off this bridge, but this wasn't my
time to go.
A gentleman named Andy saved my life.
I still haven't found him.
This is a story that I came across purely by chance, but it instantly moved me and it's
taken me to a place where I've had to consider some deeper issues around mental health.
This is season two of Finding and this time, if all goes to plan, we'll be finding Andy.
You can listen to Finding Andy and Finding Natasha exclusively and ad free on Wondery+.
Join Wondery Plus in the Wondery app, Apple Podcasts, or Spotify. Nadeem Bailey You don't believe in ghosts?
I get it.
Lots of people don't.
I didn't either until I came face to face with them.
Ever since that moment, hauntings, spirits, and the unexplained have consumed my entire
life.
I'm Nadeem Bailey. I'm Nadine Bailey.
I've been a ghost tour guide for the past 20 years.
I've taken people along with me into the shadows,
uncovering the macabre tales that linger in the darkness
and inside some of the most haunted houses, hospitals, prisons and more.
Join me every week on my podcast, Haunted Canada,
as we journey through terrifying and bone-chilling stories
of the unexplained.
Search for Haunted Canada on Apple Podcast,
Spotify, Amazon Music,
or wherever you find your favorite podcasts. The Cold Case agents with the Wyoming Department of Criminal Investigations have just caught
Alice Uden off guard after confronting her about the disappearance of her third husband,
Ron Holtz, more than 30 years earlier.
When they bring up the story that she had supposedly told her son
about shooting a guy named Ron, she defended herself as saying, oh no that
didn't happen, I just made it up as a kind of cautionary tale. Alice claims that
Ron was abusive and that she kicked him to the curb and divorced and moved on.
With no physical evidence to prove Alice wrong, investigators end their interview.
DCI agents next speak with Alice's youngest daughter, Erica Hayes. When they ask her about
the claims surrounding her former stepfather's death, Erica admits that her mother had recently
contacted her.
My mom found out that my brother, Todd, had told on her.
She said, you're going to hear that I killed somebody.
And I went, did you?
And she said, yes, I did.
Because I was protecting you.
Investigators also ask Erica if she knows what happened to Gerald's third ex-wife, Virginia
Uden, and her two sons, Richard and Reagan.
Erica tells agents she doesn't know,
but she has a theory on who is responsible
for their disappearances.
She suspected Gerald was involved
with the disappearance of Virginia and the boys,
but she didn't believe her mother was involved.
Investigators press Erica to explain her theory.
And her response is unsettling.
Erica Hayes is talking to her parents.
And Gerald makes an offhand statement.
You got to have some pigs to get rid of the body.
And Gerald makes an offhand statement, you got to have some pigs to get rid of the body.
And for the uninitiated who haven't spent
a lot of time around pigs, they eat just about everything.
Erica says at the time, she brushed off Gerald's comments
as some kind of twisted joke.
But she now fears that Virginia and her sons
may have suffered a similar fate.
At the time that Virginia and the boys went missing in 1980,
Alice and Gerald Uden had property where their home was,
and they also had some pigs.
Armed with this new theory,
agents head back to the Uden's old farm in Wyoming.
We did a search warrant on Gerald's house.
We basically excavated and screened about 200 square meters of that hog pen looking
for human remains.
We turned the place upside down.
We didn't come up with any evidence.
Once again, the investigation appears to be at a standstill.
Eight years pass without any new leads or developments.
Then, on April 4th, 2013, Virginia's mother, Claire, passes away.
Virginia's mother, Claire, passes away.
Claire Martin died at the age of 92, never finding justice for her daughter and grandsons.
I know that Claire Martin never rested.
She always was wanting the answers behind
what happened to Virginia and Richard and Reagan.
Everybody wanted her to have that closure so she could go
to her final resting place knowing this was over.
And unfortunately, she didn't get that.
For several of the Wyoming DCI agents working on Virginia's
cold case, Claire's death strengthens their resolve
to solve the two-decade-old investigation.
Miraculously, they get a new break just a few months later.
A bigger team returns to the Remount Ranch and to that abandoned gold mine.
After a day and a half of searching, the crew finds what they've been looking for.
They find the pieces of a barrel and inside that they find a human skeleton.
And in the back of the skull of this skeleton was a neat little bullet hole probably caused
by a.22 caliber gun.
The discovery matches the story that Alice's children had told police.
To verify whether the bones belong to Ron Holtz, agents are able to track down Ron's biological daughter
from his first marriage.
They find her in Alaska, and they dispatch a state trooper
to draw her DNA to compare to Ron Holtz's.
And it's a match.
The discovery of Ron's remains are enough for police to arrest Alice Uden for his murder on September 26, 2013.
They got a warrant, went to Missouri and arrested her while Gerald was out.
He was a long haul trucker.
Once in custody, the 74-year-old denies any role in the murder.
She claims she didn't even know who Ron Holtz was,
and we knew that that was a lie.
It was at about that time that Agent Tina
Tremble from the Division of Criminal Investigation
pulled out a photograph of a skull,
Ronald Holtz's, and showed it to Alice.
Do you know who that is?
No.
This is Ron Holtz.
Is that?
Mm.
We're here today to give you a chance, okay?
We know where he is because we have him now.
The evidence convinces Alice to finally admit the truth.
Yeah, I was threatening to kill Erica because she tried to kill this little girl.
I was screaming and he ran.
He said he was going to kill her and I pulled my 22 rifle and shot him in the back of the head.
What happened then?
How did he get into that hole?
I put him in there.
Got him into a barrel and
rolled him to my heart, to the back door
and put him in the trunk.
I took him up to the mine and
put him in there.
So you're gonna take me to jail?
Yes I am.
Here's what I'm asking.
If we can go to the prosecutor and tell them that you told the whole truth, because I know
you're not telling the whole truth, okay?
I know that they're looking to figure out what happened to Virginia and those boys.
Yes.
So what about Virginia and those boys? Yes. So what about Virginia and the boys?
I've told you everything I know about them.
What has Sheryl told you about it?
Nothing.
Alice was charged with one count of first-degree murder for killing Ron Holtz.
with one count of first degree murder for killing Ron Holtz.
We were hoping that that arrest would have enough of an impact that maybe Gerald would want to talk about Virginia
and Richard and Reagan.
We're given the opportunity to give Gerald a phone call.
And in this phone call, we told Gerald, essentially,
that Alice had been arrested for the things
that happened in Wyoming.
We didn't tell him what.
He agreed to drive back to meet with us.
And it was our hope as investigators
that he would use that drive to let his mind wander.
And we were hoping he would allow himself to give the truth.
Gerald wanted to talk to us.
He literally started his conversation off with telling us
that he doesn't know why we arrested Alice
because we arrested the wrong person.
-♪
-♪
Coming up...
After three decades,
investigators finally uncover
what really happened to Virginia Uden and her sons.
That fast, it was 10 seconds, and they were gone.
And newfound evidence suggests the body count may continue to rise.
We had his remains exhumed because we wanted to determine if, in fact, he had been poisoned. -♪
-♪
Wyoming DCI agents have arrested Alice Uden
for the 39-year-old murder of her third husband, Ron Holtz,
after finding his remains
at the bottom of an abandoned gold mine.
-♪ Both Alice and her husband, Gerald, remains at the bottom of an abandoned gold mine.
Both Alice and her husband, Gerald, remain suspects in the unsolved disappearances of Gerald's ex-wife, Virginia Uden, and her two sons.
At the time Alice is arrested, Gerald is on the road on a trucking assignment.
When Gerald finally arrives home, agents meet him.
They tell him Alice has been arrested and they'd like to talk to him a little bit more about what he knows.
I don't know how she could know anything about it, really, because she had nothing really to do with it.
really because she had nothing really to do with it.
33 years, I have said no, I never did nothing. But now that you guys are here,
I've got to assume that you must have either
found some bodies or you've done something else.
And I gotta tell you, if you found bodies,
that's a miracle.
He apparently thought she'd been arrested for Virginia and the boys, and he said,
well, she didn't do it, I did it.
They were startled. They were incredulous. But they kept their cool and let Gerald talk.
And he proceeded to paint a picture of what he perceived
Virginia to be like.
He felt that Virginia was after him,
strictly to get child support.
Gerald claims that Alice had been particularly upset
that he had to pay child support to Virginia,
even though he had adopted both boys prior to their divorce.
Alice was raising a little havoc about that
because why should we be paying child support
for these two boys and they're not yours?
Then you need to do something about it and take care of it.
I was paying her $150 a month.
I'm trying to juggle two women, and it ain't flying.
No.
And so finally, it just went off.
And I said, I've had it.
I'm gonna solve this problem.
And so I did.
Gerald tells police that on September 12, 1980,
he lured Virginia to meet him under the premise
of taking her sons, Richard and Reagan, dove hunting.
Gerald says, Virginia and the boys
come to the medium a little before 2 o'clock on the 12th.
And the boys are excited to see him.
And he jumps in the passenger seat
and directs Virginia to just drive up this dirt road
to a point that he knows where they could safely shoot the gun.
She drives to that place and they stop.
The kids get out.
Virginia was there.
The gun was there.
I was there.
And I shot her right square in the back of the head
and she went down.
Richard was standing behind the station wagon
and I whirled and I shot him in the back of the head.
At this point, Reagan realized things were going south quickly and took off running.
We took him, he fell in the ditch, and I walked over him and I shot him down.
And they were all three dead.
That fast. It was ten seconds.
And they were gone.
He said he put them in steel drums,
like an oil drum.
He poked holes in the drum.
He took them and put them in a boat
and went out onto Fremont Lake,
which is a natural, deep, clear water lake
and submerged the barrels in that lake.
It was just a travesty that Virginia and the boys were killed.
It's sad because we've got two little boys
that never got to get married or get a job
or raise a family of their own.
Gerald says he later disposed of the gun
and tried to make Claire's station wagon disappear.
I tried to roll it over the damn cliff
and you think it would go over the cliff?
Not so much. Not so much.
I didn't get any pleasure out of doing it. None.
But it did stop the child support and that was going to come to about $16,000.
The agents asked Gerald if Alice played any role in this,
and he denied that she did.
Nowhere in that statement does he ever
acknowledge the wrongfulness of murdering Virginia
or Richard or Reagan.
He didn't show any remorse.
Nothing like that.
He just kind of a matter of fact, nonchalant.
I did this, did this, did this.
When he was done, they arrested him and took him to jail.
33 years after Gerald killed Virginia and the boys
on that roadside, he was charged with three counts
of first degree murder.
The day that I truly realized that yes,
he had committed these murders was the day of his arrest.
On November 1st, 2013, 71-year-old Gerald Uden
agrees to plead guilty to the murders of Virginia and her sons.
The judge accepted Gerald's plea deal,
and he was sentenced to three life sentences.
to three life sentences. MUSIC
Alice, however, decides to try her fate at trial.
But before court proceedings begin,
a tip comes in to suggest Ron Holtz
may not have been the first husband that Alice had killed.
There's a belief that my dad was her first victim.
MUSIC MUSIC There's a belief that my dad was her first victim.
After nearly 40 years of eluding authorities, justice has finally caught up with accused killers Alice and Gerald Uden.
For the murders of his ex-wife, Virginia, and two adopted sons, Richard and Reagan, 72-year-old Gerald has been given three life sentences.
75-year-old Alice is still awaiting trial for the murder of her ex-husband, Ron Holtz.
But before court proceedings begin, police receive a tip that suggests Ron Holtz may
not have been Alice's first victim.
Alice's second husband, named Don Prunty, died at age 45 from a whole array of illnesses
that stemmed from his alcoholism.
I know that my dad was an alcoholic,
and Desert of Git says alcoholism.
It had no reason to do an autopsy.
There is a belief, however, that my mom poisoned my dad.
There's a belief that my dad was her first victim.
Following up on the tip, police re-examined Don Pronte's
medical records from the months leading up to his death in 1973.
Alice had remarked she was giving Don something that would stop his drinking.
The symptoms that were described in Prenti's medical records were consistent with poisoning,
specifically by antifreeze.
We had Mr. Prenti's remains exhumed. Unfortunately, he'd been embalmed,
and so we weren't able to extract anything from his remains
that would have helped us determine if, in fact,
our hypothesis was correct and that Alice had been poisoning him.
Though Don Prunty's cause of death remains unclear,
Alice's trial for the 1974 murder of Ron Holtz
gets underway in May of 2014.
Using the testimony of Todd Scott,
we were able to also establish our theory of the case,
which was Ronald Holtz was laying in bed sleeping
when he was shot in the back of the head with a.22 rifle
by his wife, Alice.
The defense counters by saying Alice acted in defense
of herself and her daughter.
This was Wyoming in the 1970s.
There was no 911.
Women didn't have shelters.
So she took matters into her own hands, she said.
On May 8, 2014, the jury retires to deliberate. It takes them 13 hours to reach a verdict.
In the end, the jury acquitted Mrs. Uden of first-degree murder, but they did convict her of second degree.
They believed that she shot him, and the jury didn't believe it was premeditated.
Alice is sentenced to life in prison. Five years later, she dies in prison at the age of 80.
Five years later, she dies in prison at the age of 80. Her death was welcomed.
I hated seeing her in prison.
I did.
No matter what she did, I loved her.
I loved her so much.
But just two days after Alice passes away,
Gerald recants his confession to killing Virginia and her sons.
When Alice died, he used that as an opportunity to capitalize on,
now that she's gone, I can put everything on her.
I talked to him on the phone, and I's gone, I can put everything on her.
I talked to him on the phone. I told him, I said, I know what you did.
So just stop. Stop. Because I will not have you putting all this on her.
Have some respect for your dead wife. In September 2019, the court rejects Gerald's attempt to withdraw his guilty plea.
His hands are absolutely not clean. I mean, he was, I totally believe that he killed Virginia and the two boys and was every bit in on every bit of it as much as she was.
I genuinely looked at Alice as a person in our society who looked at killing people as a solution to a problem. I think with Gerald and with Alice, we have a perfect storm of a sociopath and a narcissistic
person.
I think the relationship between Alice and Gerald was unique in that these were two profoundly
evil people who found one another.
Gerald Uden is housed at the Wyoming Medium Correctional Institution in Torrington.
He is 82 years old.
Hello, it's Dan Harris from the 10% Happier Podcast.
Is the whole new year, new you thing
getting a little overwhelming?
Wondery's New Year New Mindset Collection has the essentials to help you have your best year yet
and to do it simply and sanely. From 10% happier and daily stoic for personal growth to unruffled
for parenting wisdom, we've got you covered. Boost your creativity with the best idea yet,
get inspired by Baby This Is Kiki Palmer or dive deep with armchair expert. Listen to New Year New
Mindset right now on the Wondery app.