Snapped: Women Who Murder - BONUS: Wading in the Water (Buried in the Backyard)

Episode Date: December 14, 2023

We are bringing you a special bonus episode featuring a case from Oxygen's hit series, “Buried in the Backyard.”  When a successful lawyer's body is found buried in a South Flor...idian canal, detectives use innovative technology to follow the gruesome steps taken by an evil killer. Season 04, Episode 04Originally aired: December 16, 2021 Watch full episodes of Buried in the Backyard live or OnDemand for FREE on the Oxygen app: https://oxygentv.app.link/See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.

Transcript
Discussion (0)
Starting point is 00:00:00 This episode is sponsored by the Audible original cozy mystery series, Misslto Murders, written by Ken Cooperus. It's the most wonderful crime of the year. Back by popular demand, Colby Smolder stars as protagonist Emily Lane, tune in for twists and turns as Emily solves mysteries in the town of Fletcher's Grove. Emily tries to outrun her past, but it's rapidly catching up to her. The stakes are high as mysteries strike closer to home than ever before. And it wouldn't be a holiday story without some romance. Love blossoms between Emily and Sam
Starting point is 00:00:35 played by Raymond Ablak, putting the mistletoe in mistletoe murders. Get in the holiday mood today, catch up on season one now and binge the entire series from the beginning. Then follow it up with even more romance, murder, and cliffhangers in this new season. Listen now to season two of Misslto Murders, only from Audible. Many put their hope in Dr. Serhat. His company was worth half a billion dollars. His research promised groundbreaking treatments for HIV and cancer, but the brilliant doctor was hiding a secret. You can listen to Dr. Death, Bad Magic, exclusively an ad free by subscribing to Wendry Plus in the backyard. You can also watch full episodes, live or on demand on the Free Oxygen app or on peacock by clicking the link in our description. Enjoy. A high-powered lawyer tries to balance her family and her career. She loved those girls, she wanted great things for them, and worried
Starting point is 00:01:39 about them like if they were her own children. After making partner, her goal and the next step was to be a judge. But when she disappears, she's the first one in the office every day. They start thinking, you know, something's wrong here. This is not good. Let's see what never not show up. The possibilities are frightening.
Starting point is 00:02:04 Was it a home invasion robbery, or even possibly a car jacking? We were looking for people that may have heard screams, gun shots, a cry for help. Investigators uncover a criminal conspiracy. Principal Law Partner was subject of a significant criminal Ponzi scheme investigation. Ended up being a $50 billion criminal enterprise.
Starting point is 00:02:31 But do the clues lead to a motive much closer to home? An evil person didn't get his way. Plantation Florida is built on Everglade wetlands, drained by developers, to create what they called the city of the future. The region's watery past is ever present in the series of managed canals that snake through the community's lush backyards. The implantation is an upper-scale middle-class area. The houses are larger. They actually have a, you know, maybe a half an acre of land.
Starting point is 00:03:21 South Florida, as a whole, is built on swampland. And so it is not at all uncommon to have your backyard abuts a canal. These canals are part of our everyday life. They're everywhere. Early one Friday morning, a maintenance worker is checking the pump station on a canal that runs through the backyards of several homes. He went out to do his morning review and site maintenance to make sure that the water is
Starting point is 00:03:59 flowing through the grates and going out towards the Everglades. That's when the worker notices something obstructing one of the grates. Normally it's just weeds, trash, things of that nature that will clog up the grating system. He noticed that it was something unusual and went to inspect it. He at first thought it was a mannequin. He had found mannequins floating there before that the clothing stores nearby had discarded in the canals as trash.
Starting point is 00:04:36 As he tried to clear the area, he realized that this is not a mannequin. This was, in fact, a human body. The worker immediately shuts down the pump and calls 911. When I arrived at the canal, I'm brought down to a landing, which was the best location to visually observe the body and the water. It was a white female. She had a brown hair.
Starting point is 00:05:20 She was wearing a roséka flowery colored blouse. Trespans slacks. She had no shoes on. In plantation, you don't have a huge crime rate and when something happens of this nature, it's almost always a big deal because it's an extremely unusual discovery for that area. Obviously, it is the number one burning question. Who is this person buried in the Spatyard Canal? South Florida's beautiful beaches attract sunwarshoppers from around the world.
Starting point is 00:06:10 But that's not why Melissa Lewis came here. After earning her law degree, she saw an opportunity in the Sunshine State's rapidly growing legal profession. Missy likes to help people. So she went into employment law. Missy was working at Rossine Rosenfeld Adler with Deborah, her best friend. Melissa was a very high-energy, motivated person. If she said her mind towards something, she accomplished the goal.
Starting point is 00:06:52 39-year-old Melissa charts an ambitious course at Rothstein, Rosenfeldt, and Adler, and her efforts are rewarded. She was the first woman to make a partnership in which was kind of a big deal. It was life-changing for her. She was very proud of that. And after making partner, her goal, and the next step, was to be a judge. She was just a very giving, fun, loving person.
Starting point is 00:07:22 Missy was an advocate for victims of domestic violence. She would donate things for women in distress. I was going through my divorce. I hadn't left my ex-husband for many years because I was worried of what he might do to me and the children. And listen, it was there for me. My children loved her because I didn't have sisters. She was like an aunt to them.
Starting point is 00:07:50 She had to bro, and she had her family, and her dogs, her career. She had the life she was loving it. In her professional life, Melissa is all business, known for being punctual and prepared. So when she doesn't arrive for a morning meeting on March 6, 2008, her co-workers immediately become concerned. I got to work and Melissa's assistant comes to me and she's like, do you know where Melissa is? I said, she's not here?
Starting point is 00:08:31 She's like, no. She's usually the first one in the office every day. I'm calling her and texting her. She didn't answer. I started thinking, there's something's wrong here. So I called her sister. Missy would never not show up to something that she's expected to be there. Did you just get that unsettling feeling?
Starting point is 00:08:59 This is not good. So then I called to a police officer and I knew in plantation. And I said, hey, could you do me a favor? Melissa seems to be kind of missing. Can you drive by her house? Make sure she's OK. Unable to shake their feelings of dread,
Starting point is 00:09:24 Debra and Carrie meet the officer at Melissa's house. We walk in and just looking around, calling her name. Melissa's dogs were there, and they were really hyper, and Carrie's like, you know, she would never leave the dogs like this. Obviously, you start looking she would never leave the dogs like this. Obviously, you start looking closer and at every little thing at that point. And then when we got to the garage, her car's not in the garage. And there was a yellow stuff kind of sprayed all over the garage door on the inside of the garage door.
Starting point is 00:10:07 And the officer was like, OK, nobody touch anything. And I said, what is this? And the officer told me that's pepper spray. It was all over the garage. And then I looked down, literally right under my feet, I look down, and it's a button off of her suit. I just looked at the officer, and I just, it's like confirmation something's gone really, really long.
Starting point is 00:10:40 We're looking for people that may have heard screams, gunshots, cry for help. Maybe she's still alive, time is of the essence. The last time that we spoke to her, she was going into publics. Maybe she was abducted in the parking lot. When Florida Attorney Melissa Lewis is a no-show for an important meeting, police officers find her home empty and discover evidence of an attack. They immediately call detectives to the scene. When I first arrived at Melissa Lewis's house, there were groceries in the garage that had
Starting point is 00:11:24 not been unpacked and had been recently purchased. The dog door to the residence had what looked like pepper spray on it. Melissa's close friend, Deborah, said that Melissa did have pepper spray on her normally, carried it in her purse. We started coming up with different theories on what could have happened. Could somebody have followed her in to commit a home
Starting point is 00:11:49 burglary, a home invasion robbery, or even possibly a car jacking? Maybe she's in the car. Maybe she's still alive. Time is of the essence. Luckily for us, it was a newer model Cadillac. It was equipped with an on-star system. We were able to have on-star provided with a GPS location for the vehicle.
Starting point is 00:12:14 They located it within walking distance to Melissa Lewis's home. Park on the other side of the community that the police, the police, the police, the police, the police, the police, the police, the police, the police, the police, the police, the police, the police, the police, the police, the police, the police, the police, the police, the police, the police, the police, the police, the police, the police, the police, the police, the police, the police, the police, the police, the police, the police, the police,
Starting point is 00:12:43 the police, the police, the police, the police, the police, the police, the police, the police, the police, the police, the police, the police, the police, the police, the police, We found her suit jacket and the button that we had seen earlier on her garage floor Look like it came from this jacket There's substances on the jacket if you're sprayed with pepper spray you may spit cough sneeze That type of fluid was on her jacket That type of fluid was on her jacket. So just in case there's DNA, great care is taken to preserve all of those things. They transport the car to Barar chair of self-escremelab. Hoping to track Melissa's movements,
Starting point is 00:13:22 investigators immediately request her cellphone records, knowing it will take some time. In the meantime, they turn to her sister, Carrie. She tells detectives that she spoke to Melissa by phone the previous evening. She went to public almost every night on the way home from work. So that was the last time that we spoke to her. She was going into publics. We obtained surveillance video from inside of publics.
Starting point is 00:13:56 They were able to see the suit that she was wearing, what kind of purse she was wearing. It was a designer purse. Because Melissa was known to wear nice jewelry and carry designer handbags and things of that nature, it was a natural theory for police to suspect that this was a robbery gun bag. But the video doesn't show anything suspicious inside the supermarket,
Starting point is 00:14:27 and there are no surveillance cameras outside the store. Investigators check to see if one of Melissa's neighbors might have seen something unusual. The patrol officer canvassed the area. We are looking for people that may have heard screams, gunshots, cry for help. Unfortunately, after canvassing, that afternoon, nobody saw any suspicious vehicles, saw any suspicious people nearby. Investigators are still leaning towards a robbery, but there's one thing that doesn't fit.
Starting point is 00:15:05 Usually in those car-jacking robbery scenarios, the body's not missing. And my experience, people aren't put in the back of a stone, vehicle then driven away somewhere. So her disappearance was really unusual. It's now the morning after Melissa is reported missing. An engineer is clearing pumping machinery in a backyard canal in plantation when he spots what appears to be a mannequin buried in the debris. But as he gets closer, he realizes it is a woman's body.
Starting point is 00:15:49 It was a little after 7am I was driving in the work that day. I heard a report over the police radio that a body had been discovered. Based on a brief description over the radio, I thought the body that they had discovered could be a molicellus. I thought the body that they had discovered could be a molicelluous. When she was brought out of the water, there was very minor indications of trauma at that time. Nothing obvious, no stab wounds, gunshot wounds, things of that nature.
Starting point is 00:16:21 And because of the good condition of the body, we were able to make that identification ourselves based on recent photographs, driver's license picture, clothing being worn, that it was Melissa Lewis. Melissa's body is sent to the medical examiner's office for an autopsy. As investigators begin the sad task of notifying her family and friends. I've got a call on from one of the detectives.
Starting point is 00:16:57 That's when everything changed. No, the hope is gone. No, the hope is gone. It was just, it was unbelievable. I just slowly started fading down to the floor. I didn't have a sister growing up and just all women are supposed to have that friend in their life, you know, and just all of a sudden, it's just gone. I was just devastated. I know I did a lot of crying.
Starting point is 00:17:45 And, um, basically just focused on, you know, stayed with my family, focused on my kids. They were everything to her. My kids were just like her own. They were devastated. They devastated. They were devastated. The autopsy results come in, and the findings are chilling. There was obvious trauma to her neck area. The medical examiner determined that the cause of death was manual strangulation.
Starting point is 00:18:41 At that point, we knew that this case was a homicide. A death like the one that Melissa Lewis suffered would be one of the most horrific ways a person can die. Manual strangulation, it's a drawn out way to kill someone. It's not something that happens instantaneously. It takes minutes for someone to die. It's a very personal way to kill somebody. My dad, Tom, is one of the most charming men
Starting point is 00:19:21 you'll ever meet, the love of my mom's life. But for 52 years, he was also something else, a wanted fugitive. From neonhameedia and Sony music entertainment, listen to Smoke Screen, my fugitive dad. Subscribe on Apple Podcasts to binge all episodes now, or listen weekly wherever you get your podcasts. of the year. Right now, new subscribers get 1D+. for just 99 cents per month. That's remarkable value considering all you get. In the mood for award-winning podcasts, what about edge of your seat thrillers? Or perhaps something that'll teach you more about the world around us? With 1D+. Get early access, exclusives, ad-free listening to more than 40,000 episodes,
Starting point is 00:20:20 and 1D shop discounts. You'll also gain access to amazing live streams and more. Fingers crossed, someone brings in a fruitcake tomorrow, and you can finally take a day off desserts. Take advantage of this Wondry Plus offer. Subscribe to Wondry Plus on Wondry.com slash plus. After the body of missing attorney, Melissa Lewis, is found floating in a backyard canal in plantation Florida, police have determined she was likely strangled the same evening she was last seen. So at this point, her death is classified as a murder case, a homicide, which really ramps up the level of investigation.
Starting point is 00:21:09 The canal is four miles from Melissa's home. Investigators begin an intensive search of the area. Our theory was that she was transported there, and in her own vehicle, and then dumped by somebody into the canal. So we were looking for access areas. There was a dirt road behind a small strip mall, where a car could drive up into that area. It was pretty concealed from the main road.
Starting point is 00:21:46 Someone could have easily, at night, opened up the hatch of the vehicle, and either kicked them down, pushed them down into the canal. But the search of the dirt road and access ramp proves fruitless. At first, I was leaning towards the car-jacking robbery scenario. But the crime took place in the garage of her house.
Starting point is 00:22:11 Her pepper spray had been used. Her body was found miles away, and then her car was found near her house. In my career, this was highly unusual for a car-jacking. In my career, this was highly unusual for a car jacking. The best clue at the moment is the nature of the killing. Melissa Lewis was strangled. And because strangulation is so intimate, the investigators conclude it's very likely this crime was not random, but personal.
Starting point is 00:22:48 So they begin to dig into Melissa's personal life, looking for someone with motive to harm her. We talked to her best friend, who identified as Deborah Villes, a co-worker of hers, and her sister, who was also very close with her. And we ask them everything going on in Melissa's life. They wanted to know everything.
Starting point is 00:23:09 Anybody that she came in contact with? Anybody who might be upset with her? They repeatedly told us no. No relationship issues. No issues at work with clients, things of that nature. I think I was grasping it straws at that point. I remembered, Missy was an advocate for domestic violence because of Deborah. And I remembered my sister telling me that Deborah's husband, Tony,
Starting point is 00:23:48 had threatened to set Deborah on fire in front of her children. And that he had slashed her tires. So I called him. This man's abusive. So then they wanted all the information about my ex-husband and they asked, you know, would he be upset about anything? And I said, well, he's very upset about everything.
Starting point is 00:24:12 I told them that we were pulling through the divorce and gave them the details of our situation as well, so they could see that it really didn't relate to her. He would, you know, call and leave threats, and, but I just kept moving forward. You know, don't antagonize him, don't argue with him. Stay positive and move forward. And I told them, if I were the one-thmarter, you know, he would be your guy, but he has no reason to be upset with Melissa.
Starting point is 00:24:41 He didn't even know her very well. Based on Deborah's description, the detectives don't consider her ex-husband to be high on the list of suspects. They decide to search elsewhere in Melissa's life for someone who might have motive to attack her. During an interview of Carrie, she mentioned her ex-husband, Anthony and Coedina's,
Starting point is 00:25:05 as someone that has a criminal history. Anthony is father of my two oldest children, and we were married for 11 years. He was a drug addict and had been in prison for armed robbery. He wouldn't have killed her. I don't think. But he had also been involved in an armed robbery. He wouldn't have killed her. I don't think.
Starting point is 00:25:26 But he had also been involved in armed robbery. So, you know, you just never know. So I did throw it out there. I told the police, Melissa, help me fill out the divorce papers. And then she told me that he came to her house. And, you know, it startled her a little bit. We believed she was strangled by someone who personally knew her
Starting point is 00:25:54 on the floor of her garage. And Anthony Godinas, he's a fellow. He had committed an armed robbery years earlier. He spent some significant time in prison. So at that point, Mr. Guadinas is a significant suspect in this case. We define him. If the list is going to expose this criminal episode
Starting point is 00:26:24 at the law firm, that sent off alarm bells. The prime law contacted us. We have an exact match. Two DNA collected from Melissa Lewis's jacket. Florida detectives have identified their first solid suspect in the murder of Melissa Lewis, her former brother-in-law, Anthony Godinas. We learned Anthony Godinas was a felon. He had been arrested years earlier for an armed robbery.
Starting point is 00:27:01 He was released in prison about three years prior to this date. I told him really in my heart I knew that he didn't have anything to do with it. Detective Steak out Anthony's home four and a half miles from Melissa's, hoping to corner him and speak with him. We conducted a surveillance at Mr. Udynis' residence, where we found that he wasn't physically able. Investigators learned Anthony recently been diagnosed with MS and based on what they were able to piece together up to that point,
Starting point is 00:27:46 he would not have been able to carry out that type of abduction. We spoke with him, and he had a reasonable alibi on the night that she went missing. With their initial suspect now cleared, investigators dig back into the evidence. Melissa was a successful attorney, and the detectives consider whether her work might have played a role in her violent death.
Starting point is 00:28:20 Scott Rothstein, the founding partner of the law firm she worked for, was interviewed. Scott Rothstein was very close to Melissa Lewis. She had interned in the past for him. He had a close relationship with her and knew her very well. Scott Rothstein was a very well-connected lawyer. When this happened, his firm put up a $250,000 award for information. She was a very well-thought-of attorney in Broward County. Maybe there were cases where someone would have an axe
Starting point is 00:29:01 to grind with her. But there are no promising suspects in Melissa's caseload. Then, after a frustrating three-day wait, detectives finally received Melissa's phone records. The data showed when she left work. We could show her traveling from downtown Fort Lauderdale on the evening of March 5th, arriving in the vicinity of the public's grocery store at about 7,
Starting point is 00:29:39 arriving home a little bit after 8 p.m. that night. At that point, the signal is stationary at Melissa's house for almost an hour. Police believe it is during this time period that Melissa is murdered. But oddly, after that, her cell phone is on the move. Then the phone travels at about 9 p.m. that night from the cell tower in Melissa's neighborhood. Out to the area where we now know where she was dumped on the canal.
Starting point is 00:30:12 And then it travels back towards her home, back to her home cell tower. And then it travels down through Broward County, through Interstate 595, along Interstate 75 into Dade County, northern Miami area, where it finally settles at one cell tower between 10 and 11 that night in the city of Halea. The phone stays in that location until 6am the next morning.
Starting point is 00:30:45 Then it hits the road again. The early morning hours of March 6, 2008, the phone travels in a very direct straight line up towards Palm Beach County, and then it disappears. Detectives believe that whoever attacked Melissa kept her phone. Since the phone spent the night in Halea, they conclude so did the killer. Unfortunately, it wasn't precise GPS, Latin, long, coordinates being provided,
Starting point is 00:31:25 but it was with a cell tower. It could be one to three miles in either direction of the tower, which is a lot of area to search. The cell tower data isn't specific enough to pinpoint their suspect. But because she was strangled, investigators believe Melissa knew her attacker, and now they know that person likely has a connection to Halea.
Starting point is 00:31:54 The best way to get additional information was to talk to Deborah and Carrie again. So we brought them both back in, And we told them what the data showed. MUSIC Melissa's best friend and coworker, Debra, is staggered by the information. MUSIC MUSIC You're just terrible.
Starting point is 00:32:23 Because it was thin when I realized that she's gone because of me. My divorce was very, very ugly over the course of the first year. Tony was very angry and he's just not a very stable person. He broke into my truck a couple of times and put water in my gas tank. I left dead animals on my front porch. Disposar thanks.
Starting point is 00:32:54 When police ask Melissa's best friend, Debra Villegas, about a suspect with a connection to Hylia, she stunned to realize who it might be. Debra said he had recently moved in with a friend in Hylia. Within the area of the cell tower where Melissa's phone was pinging the night of Melissa's murder. Dabra initially told police her ex-husband had no reason to harm Melissa. But now she's not sure that's true.
Starting point is 00:33:27 Melissa was my dearest friend. And somebody to make me happy and to laugh with. Her support was just helping me move forward in her positive way. She then went on to tell us her husband is a conductor on a train. Florida East Coast real ways that run from downtown Fort Lord of the Hill up in the pompom now.
Starting point is 00:33:56 The track of the cell phone is mirroring where Tony Vegas would be, where he lives, and where he works. Police now subpoenaed Tony Vegas' phone records. On the night that Melissa Lewis was killed, wherever Melissa Lewis' phone was, so was Tony Vegas' phone. The phone evidence connecting Tony to Melissa is the lead law enforcement has been waiting for. But it's not concrete proof he killed her.
Starting point is 00:34:31 Hoping to find that proof, detectives obtain a search warrant for the apartment Tony shares with a roommate. We're looking for obvious items of evidence such as pepper spray, blusas cell phone, or any other items that could link him to the murder. But we didn't find anything unusual. His roommate said that on the night that Melissa Lewis went missing, Tony Vegas came home late that night and had asked if he knew of a way to wash it off
Starting point is 00:35:06 or get rid of pepper spray that was on your body. That sent off alarm bells. Our theory was that he wanted to hurt Deborah in the deepest way possible. It was his ultimate way to hurt Deborah. I'm gonna kill and take away your best friend. that he wanted to hurt Deborah in the deepest way possible. It was his ultimate way to hurt Deborah. I'm gonna kill and take away your best friend, your support person.
Starting point is 00:35:33 Even more alarms go off a few days later, when police received DNA test results for the small stain on Melissa's jacket that was recovered from her car. The evidence DNA collected from Melissa Lewis's jacket. That DNA belonged to Tony Vegas. A week after her death, a judge issues an arrest warrant for Tony Vegas. On the same day, Melissa is laid to rest.
Starting point is 00:36:13 Missy's funeral was surreal. The reporter is outside, and I remember Scott, uh, Scott Rossine, um, speaking at her funeral, and the firm they paid for the funeral, everything. It was so hard because to look at the family of her knowing that she's gone because of me, as Tony Hanoo, that it would torture me, because I would have to live with this pain and sadness the rest of my life. It was just...
Starting point is 00:36:51 It's just overwhelming. While Melissa is being buried, police are zeroing in on Tony Villegas. Later that day, they find him hiding in his mother's house. Investigators and other special response units were down outside of the home, and Tony peacefully surrendered. And they found her murder. That was a huge relief. Tony Villegas is arraigned on a charge of first-degree murder. He insists he's innocent, and that he's being set up by someone.
Starting point is 00:37:38 But he refuses to say who? He gave the other of information to investigators. Nothing else to say about what happened that night. He was stoic. Defense attorneys stall the judicial process for more than a year. Then, a stunning new development threatens to derail the prosecution's entire case.
Starting point is 00:38:07 Scott Rostin, Melissa's principal law partner was subject of a very significant criminal Ponzi scheme investigation. One of the most significant Ponzi schemes in the history of the United States. He was running a, what ended up being a $50 billion criminal enterprise. We learned that he'd had fled the country to Morocco. An FBI probe reveals that one of Scott's partners in the massive financial fraud is the law firm's office manager, Deborah Villegas.
Starting point is 00:38:50 Detectives are forced to wonder, could this multi-billion dollar crime be the real reason for Melissa's murder? As prosecutors in the case, the Ponzi scheme cannot be ignored. At the time of Melissa's murder, she was working for an enterprise that was criminal. There's no evidence that she was tied to any criminal behavior
Starting point is 00:39:16 or activity. But the idea that Melissa's death had absolutely nothing to do with any of that. It seemed to lack credibility. If Melissa had learned of the Ponzi scheme, or was directly involved herself, Scott Rostin may have wanted to have her eliminated. Tony Viegas is awaiting trial for the murder of Melissa Lewis, but the case has been upended by an FBI investigation.
Starting point is 00:39:49 Melissa's law firm has been charged with financial fraud and tangled up in the massive Ponzi scheme as her boss, Scott Rothstein, and best friend and office manager, Deborah Viegas. Tony's lawyers suggest that Scott and Debra may be Melissa's real killers. Debra being best friends with Melissa Lewis. Obviously, the question started coming out about was there any connection between any of the illegal activities of Scott Rothstein, any illegal activities
Starting point is 00:40:22 that Debra may have been involved in, and the murder of Melissa Lewis. If Melissa Lewis had found out and was going to expose this very large criminal episode that was happening at the law firm, then they needed to eliminate Melissa before she exposed it to law enforcement. The prosecutor's theory has been that Tony Villegas killed Melissa in a fit of anger. But detectives must now examine whether Melissa was the victim of a sinister plot to keep her silent.
Starting point is 00:40:57 It would be negligent on the investigators' part. It would be negligent on our part, not to make sure that it wasn't Scott Rothstein. negligent on the investigators part, it would be negligent on our part, not to make sure that it wasn't Scott Rothstein. We had the FBI and the Florida Department of Law Enforcement, assist us in our investigation. Every piece of evidence, every document, every interview is picked apart, looking for any connection between the multi-billion dollar financial fraud and the murder of Melissa Lewis. There was no evidence of that to think that for all the available people to go out and
Starting point is 00:41:38 hire to commit a murder, Wood's got Rostin used Tony Villegas, the estranged husband of his confidant and his Ponzi scheme to kill somebody else in the law firm? No. The theory didn't hold up. There was no connection from Scott Rossi's activity to the death of Melissa Lewis. Melissa would have been horrified. It was humiliating.
Starting point is 00:42:04 It was just the worst. And it's just a guilt that I guess I live with forever. MUSIC We were confident we had the right person arrested, and we were prosecuting the right person. MUSIC arrested, and we were prosecuting the right person. The case is finally back on track. The Tony Villegas murder trial begins. Eight years after Melissa's body was found, buried in a backyard canal.
Starting point is 00:42:38 Prosecutors tell the jury that Tony was a controlling and obsessive husband enraged by what he saw as Melissa's interference in his marriage. Melissa and Deborah were best friends. Melissa, in his eyes, figured really, moved into his spot. He felt that Melissa had advised Deborah to get the divorce and that it was her fault. The investigation led us to believe that that night, Tony
Starting point is 00:43:08 Beagas had driven to the parking lot near Melissa's neighborhood. He walked less than a quarter mile to Melissa's house, where he waited for her to return home. When she opened the garage, he entered the garage. She probably saw him coming. He used pepper spray in self-defense. He was a strong guy. He strangled her right on the floor of a garage. She puts her body in the back of the SUV.
Starting point is 00:44:00 And then he drives us with a can out. Takes her body out of the back of the SUV, throw it down into the canal, drives back to where his corvette was parked. Drives his corvette back down to Miami. The trial lasts a week. It takes the jury just two hours to reach a verdict. The verdict was guilty as charged a first-degree murder. And he was consequently sentenced to life in prison.
Starting point is 00:44:36 She was just a very special person taken away from us because of her death. She was just a very special person taken away from us because of an evil person who didn't get his way. And senseless. I miss my sister being able to cheer the excitement in my kids and their achievements. She was humble and kind and giving selfless, just a great person. Many put their hope in Dr. Serhat. His company was worth half a billion dollars. His research promised groundbreaking treatments for HIV and cancer. Scientists, doctors, renowned experts were saying genius, genius, genius.
Starting point is 00:46:19 People that knew him were convinced that he saved their life. But the brilliant doctor was hiding a secret. Do not cross this line. That was being messaged to us. Do not cross this line. A secret, the doctor was desperate to keep. This was a person who was willing to coldheartedly just lie to people's faces.
Starting point is 00:46:41 We're dealing with an international fugitive. From Wendry, the makers of Over My Dead Body and the Shrinknext Door comes a new season of Dr. Death, Bad Magic. I'm Laura Beale. You can listen to Dr. Death, Bad Magic, exclusively an ad free by subscribing to Wendry Plus in the Wendry app. by subscribing to Wendry Plus in the Wendry app.

There aren't comments yet for this episode. Click on any sentence in the transcript to leave a comment.