Snapped: Women Who Murder - Martha Beatty

Episode Date: May 4, 2025

Town rumors lead police to unearth a gruesome crime years after a man fails to show up for work.Season 32, Episode 1Originally aired: February 19, 2023Watch full episodes of Snapped for FREE ...on the Oxygen app: https://oxygentv.app.link/WatchSnappedPodSee Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.

Transcript
Discussion (0)
Starting point is 00:00:00 Looking for the ultimate online casino experience? Step into the BedMGM Casino app, where every deal, spin and gold brings Las Vegas excitement into the palm of your hand. Take your seat at Premium Blackjack Pro, where strategy meets top-tier gameplay. Drop in on the exciting Sugar Rush and Crazy Time slot games, or play the dazzling MGM Grand Emerald Nights, a slot experience that captures the magic of MGM. With so many games, it's time to make your move. Download the app and visit BedMGM Ontario today to experience the next level of gaming.
Starting point is 00:00:33 Visit BedMGM.com for terms and conditions. 19 plus to wager, Ontario only. Please, gamble responsibly. If you have questions or concerns about your gambling or someone close to you, please contact Connex Ontario at 1-866-531-2600 to speak to an advisor free of charge. BetMGM operates pursuant to an operating agreement with iGaming Ontario. Even the smallest business can face big risks. Get a business insurance quote in minutes at zensurance.com slash podcast and receive a $20 gift card. Zensurance policies starting at $19 a month. Be protected. Be Zen.
Starting point is 00:01:14 A hardworking family man, beloved by his employees, suddenly vanishes from an Orlando suburb. He had been there for more than 10 years and never missed a day. He hadn't shown up for work that morning. On the surface, he seemed to have it all. They seemed like they were happy in their little nest with each other. They'd been married for 20 years. He referred to him as dad. He was the only father he'd ever known.
Starting point is 00:01:52 But no one really knows what goes on behind closed doors. He was a spoiled little twit, and she'd stick up for him. They said it was a rocky relationship, and they weren't getting along very well. She told the detective that he had been having affairs. He will be back. Oh, he will be? He'll be back.
Starting point is 00:02:15 Amid the lies and rumors, investigators finally uncovered the twisted truth. The investigators would get anonymous phone calls stating he was dead. August 28, 2001. Mascot, Florida. It's just after six in the morning when Gail gets a frantic call from the gas station where she works. A co-worker is trying to track down the store's district manager, 57-year-old Bill Beatty,
Starting point is 00:03:07 who is an hour late for his shift. On that morning, I was off work. I got a phone call telling me that Bill never showed up for work, that I needed to come open the station. Bill was never late. Bill was always 10, 15 minutes early. He was conscientious. When you needed him, he was there.
Starting point is 00:03:35 Bill's employer also reaches out to his wife, 57-year-old Martha Beatty. Martha said he had left for work when they called her. But at 7.35 a.m., three hours after Bill seemingly left for work, Martha calls the police for help. Martha Beatty called and told the dispatcher that her husband, Bill, hadn't shown up for work that morning. He was missing as well as his truck and his clothing.
Starting point is 00:04:07 Woman screaming Within 15 minutes, an officer arrives at the Beatty home. A mascot police officer responded to the residents located on Park Road in the city of mascot. Martha tells the officer that the last time she saw Bill was as they were preparing for bed around 11 o'clock the night before. And everything seemed normal. Martha shared a bedroom with her granddaughter, a five-year-old little girl named Tabby.
Starting point is 00:04:39 And Bill slept at the other end of the hall in his own bedroom. He would be up really early and getting ready while Martha and her granddaughter Tabby were still asleep. He had been working at this convenience store for more than 10 years and never missed a day. Martha says it wasn't until she got the phone call from his employer that she suspected
Starting point is 00:05:07 anything might be wrong. His clothes were missing in his truck and him. You would think that maybe he just left her, you know, that maybe he had wanted to get out of the relationship and just left. But the normal procedure would be to put a bolo out on the radio for the area where he's missing him.
Starting point is 00:05:29 Gail is eager to help and agrees to come into work on her day off. So I left the house and went the way that I knew he would be coming if he was heading for work. It's about a 15-minute drive along Highway 50 between Bill's home and the gas station. Gail is halfway to the station when she suddenly spots Bill's truck on the side of the road. I knew it was his truck, so I pulled up. The car keys were laying on the front seat. I looked around, no sign of Bill. The mascot police department was notified that Bill Beatty's pickup truck had been
Starting point is 00:06:16 found on State Road 50, just outside of the city limits of Claremont. It's now been over three hours since Bill was reported missing, and his friends and family fear he may be in real danger. Everybody was worried that something else had happened to him. We were worried that, well, maybe he had fallen and had a heart attack. Maybe he was laying in the high grass along the road. So we went looking, but we couldn't find him anywhere. Bradford Bill Beatty was born on December 21st, 1944,
Starting point is 00:07:03 and raised in Ohio's Amish Country. My father was born to Bill Buster and a woman named Grace. They were both young, so my father was pretty much raised by my grandfather. He always had a smile. My father, he always looked like he had something up his sleeve, like he wanted a little trick or a little prank, and it was just fun. In high school, Bill's fun personality quickly caught the eye of a classmate, Sandra Tucker. My mom had a huge crush on my father and so he her out, and it's history from there.
Starting point is 00:07:47 The pair got married in 1964, and Bill followed in his father's footsteps, making a living as a truck driver. Bill was a long-haul truck driver to support his family. He worked hard, because, you know, he supported his family and his car habit because he was a car guy. Bill loved classic cars and he had two that were absolutely gorgeous. I mean, he took exemplary care of these cars. But Bill's time away from home took its toll, and his marriage eventually ended in divorce in 1973. My mom and my dad, they were married at such a young age, fresh out of high school.
Starting point is 00:08:37 You're young, you're trying to find yourself. Even after the divorce, he would still come over on Sundays and sit down and we would have family dinners. He loved his family. When Bill left his career as a truck driver, he decided to still make use of those driving skills and he pursued a career as a driving instructor. It was in 1982, while working in his new position, that Bill first met 37-year-old Martha Lance. Martha was born in West Virginia.
Starting point is 00:09:10 She was married. As far as the relationship with her previous husband, we don't really know anything. Martha's daughter was taking driving lessons from Bill. Martha's daughter introduced Bill to her mother and her four-year-old brother, Andy. Martha was attracted to Bill. Bill was a gentleman. He had a charm about him.
Starting point is 00:09:36 He was stable. Martha had a great personality. She was very family-oriented. So I believe that's what drew my dad to her. One year later, Bill and Martha married. Martha's daughter no longer lived at home, but Bill happily took over the role of father to Andy. He'd been raised by Bill since he was about four years old.
Starting point is 00:10:09 Bill was an excellent father and role model for Andy. He was the only father he'd ever known. My dad would treat Andy like he was his own. In 1989, the family moved to a spacious property in mascot Florida. They moved to Florida for work. My father liked the warm weather. We would go there for holidays or visits. Bill eventually took a job as manager of a convenience store in nearby Claremont. Bill was always very helpful and he'd take the time to explain something not
Starting point is 00:10:51 just tell you this is what you do he'd explain why it was done that way. I met Bill when I was looking for a job. Bill was almost like a big brother. We used to talk a lot and, you know, swap stories. He would help you however you needed help. While Martha focused on running the house, she occasionally picked up shifts alongside Bill at the store. Martha and I worked together for a couple of years. Martha was pleasant. She struck you as a country girl.
Starting point is 00:11:24 She could be loud and funny, and she could be moody and quiet. By 1996, at the age of 18, the couple's son Andy moved out and started building his own life. Andy got married to a girl whose name was Jennifer and they had Tabby. Bill was very attached. He would talk about Tabitha and things that she did and show pictures of her. Martha was a great grandmother. She loved Tabby, spoiled her too, got her anything she wanted. She spoiled her, too. Got her anything she wanted. And when Andy's marriage ended a few years later, Bill and Martha agreed to take Andy and Tabby in.
Starting point is 00:12:14 Jennifer left and Andy kept Tabby. Andy wasn't working. Martha and Bill seemed like they were happy in their little nest with each other and happy. But on the morning of August 28, 2001, for the first time in over 10 years, Bill Beatty doesn't show up for work. By eight o'clock or so, the police had found Bill's Ford Ranger parked on the side of the highway, pointed in the direction that he would have gone that morning.
Starting point is 00:12:53 Authorities find the truck unlocked, the keys on the front seat, and something else surprising. Mascot officers found a wedding ring in the glove compartment. Coming up, did Bill Beatty want to disappear? She said he was very much alive and had no intention of coming back. And disturbing rumors encircle the small town. The investigators would get anonymous phone calls stating that Bill Beatty was dead. Officers in Mascot, Florida, investigating the disappearance of Bill Beatty, have just discovered his abandoned truck along with his wedding ring, leading officers to believe Bill may simply have left his wife.
Starting point is 00:13:56 There was absolutely no signs of foul play in the vehicle. An adult missing person is not a crime. Martha came and picked the vehicle up and took it back to her house. They have no further leads at that time to follow up on. The investigator put a flag on Mr. Beatty's social security number to see if he showed up, you know, seeking employment elsewhere,
Starting point is 00:14:18 anything like that. What we did was just kind of wait to see if he showed up, if the investigators found anything. Two weeks later, Martha calls mascot police again with some news. Martha Beatty called the police department, stated that she had spoken with Bill Beatty on the phone and that he had told her that he was not coming back,
Starting point is 00:14:45 that he was leaving her. Martha kind of reinforced the fact that they didn't need to look for Bill anymore. He was very much alive and living up in Georgia and had no intention of coming back. Investigators reach out to Bill's children in Ohio to corroborate Martha's story. They say they still haven't heard from their father, but they do confirm that Martha and Bill faced their fair share of troubles as a married couple. When I talked to the investigators, I did ask questions like, was it money related? Bill Beatty's family told the investigators Martha and Bill Beatty it had issues with
Starting point is 00:15:31 finances. Martha spent too much money, Bill didn't like that. According to Bill's coworkers, whenever Martha pulled shifts at the gas station, Bill noticed that certain things weren't adding up. At the end of the day, when the money's taken and counted all up, some days it didn't come near. I can't say where the money went or how it disappeared. I just know it wasn't there.
Starting point is 00:16:03 Things didn't balance out. People started complaining that their credit cards were showing gas purchases when they hadn't been to the station. As a result, Bill no longer gave Martha shifts and he kept a close eye on every penny. They had gotten to the point where he had given Martha an allowance.
Starting point is 00:16:22 And once the allowance was gone, he wouldn't give her any more money. And money wasn't the only source of tension in the Beatty marriage. There was a very powerful dynamic going on in Bill and Martha's household with Andy. She was unable to set any firm limits. Andy wasn't hanging out with the best of crowds. My dad was essentially raising his child
Starting point is 00:16:51 because he couldn't do it. So it caused a lot of friction between him and Martha. He was a spoiled little twit, and she'd stick up for him. And most recently, 23-year-old Andy And she'd stick up for him. And most recently, 23-year-old Andy had become involved in a heated custody battle with his ex-wife, sticking Bill with the attorney's fees. Bill did mention that Martha was expecting him to pay for Andy's lawyer for the custody battle.
Starting point is 00:17:28 It wasn't that she asked him to, she expected him to. Bill made it known to Martha and Andrew that he wanted Tabby to live there, but he felt that Andrew should be paying for the legal fees. The family stated that Andrew would change jobs constantly or not work for long periods of time. And Bill expressed anger to his family about this. Andy worked occasionally. He made money by selling drugs. And he unfortunately also stole from people.
Starting point is 00:18:00 Bill's friends say when the tension in the home got to be too much, Andy went to live with his girlfriend, Jeanette. Tabby lived with Bill and Martha because Andy used Tabby as leverage to get his way for anything he really wanted. While Bill and Martha's family history causes investigators some concern, there's no evidence of foul play. As months pass without Bill contacting his children or his friends, however, suspicion grows. I went to one of the local cops that I knew and asked him what they were doing about Bill.
Starting point is 00:18:43 Was anybody looking for him? And he told me that they didn't have to look for him, that he had just run off. But I didn't believe it. My dad loved Andy's daughter. He would never abandon her because that's the way my dad was. It was probably three to four months
Starting point is 00:19:02 before I started hearing rumors about Martha and Andy spending Bill's money and driving Bill's cars. I knew Bill would not have left without saying something to someone and he would definitely not have left his cars. Every now and again the police would get anonymous phone calls stating that Bill Beatty was dead. The officers at the time would go out and look into whatever was alleged. But there was nothing really to follow up on. And again, the case lay dormant.
Starting point is 00:19:37 Despite there being no signs of foul play, authorities ask Martha if they can search her property. She told them flat out that they would not be allowed to go onto her property. That is her right to refuse consent, but police of course wonder why when they're looking for her husband, wouldn't she want to help them to look for her husband? But she maintained that he was fine and that he'd left her. Convinced Martha knows more than she's saying, investigators continue to press her for answers. And eight months after Bill's disappearance,
Starting point is 00:20:24 Martha finally agrees to a second interview. So 16 years ago, something like that. He took off in July and then he didn't come back in till February, March. She also tells them more about the phone call Bill made to her after police found his truck. I said, where you at? And he said, never mind. And I said, well, what about me and your job and that? He said, I don't need none of that crap no more. That's when she told the detective that Bill had been having affairs. You think that he went to a gray office in Georgia? That's where he called me from.
Starting point is 00:21:13 He called me Georgia. It was his western motel. He came up on my caller ID box. We didn't have any names. We didn't have anyone that we could go interview to find out who these women were. But Martha says she believes Bill's dalliance will run its course, just like it did 16 years before. He will be back.
Starting point is 00:21:40 Oh, he will be? He'll be back. Oh, he will be? He'll be back. Martha is released after her interview, and investigators are left with zero leads and more questions. For the next three years, rumors circulate, but with nothing concrete to go on, the investigation stalls. All of that changes in February of 2004. I was contacted one evening by the lieutenant who received another anonymous tip that Bill Beatty's body was
Starting point is 00:22:16 buried on the Beatty's property down Park Road. Authorities have been blocked from searching the Beatty property before, but this time may prove to be different. The lieutenant said the property on Park Road. There's a for sale sign on it. Coming up... This new tip threatens to unearth more than just rumors. Asked them if we could have permission to take cadaver dogs on the property and they said yes.
Starting point is 00:22:46 And a witness finally feels the heat. This new year, why not let Audible expand your life by listening? Audible CA contains over 890,000 total titles within its current library, including audiobooks, podcasts, and exclusive Audible originals that'll inspire and motivate you. Tap into your well-being with advice and insight from leading professionals and experts on better health, relationships, career, finance, investing, and more. Maybe you want to kick a bad habit or start a good one. If you're looking to encourage positive change in your life, one day and challenge at a time, look no further than
Starting point is 00:23:39 Tabitha Brown's I Did a New Thing 30 days to living free. In the audiobook, Tab shares her own stories and those of others alongside gentle guidance and encouragement to create these incredible changes for yourself and see what good can come from them. Trust me, listening on Audible can help you reach the goals you set for yourself. Start listening today when you sign up for a free 30-day trial at audible.com slash wonder ECA. That's audible.com slash wonder ECA. I'm Matt Lewis. And I'm Dr. Eleanor Janaga. And in God Medieval, we get into the greatest mysteries. The gobsmacking details and latest groundbreaking research from the greatest
Starting point is 00:24:21 millennium in human history. We're talking Vikings, Normans, kings and popes who were rarely the best of friends, murder, rebellions, and crusades. Find out who we really were by subscribing to Gone Medieval from History hit wherever you get your podcasts. It's been nearly three years
Starting point is 00:24:44 since Bill Beatty was first reported missing when investigators finally received their first break in the case. We had received an anonymous tip that the body of the missing person was located on the property on Park Road. I am familiar with the property from patrolling town and now there's a for sale sign on it. With Bill gone, it became a hardship for Martha to keep up. And eventually, the money came close to running out. Eventually, Andy's daughter Tabby
Starting point is 00:25:22 went to live with her maternal grandparents in North Carolina. The house was foreclosed upon, and Martha moved out. It was decided that we should approach the new owner and see if they would give us consent to search. I asked them if we could have permission to take cadaver dogs on the property, and they said yes. Three years after Bill was reported missing,
Starting point is 00:25:54 they are finally able to conduct a search of the Beatty property. We were looking not only to do a forensic search of the property, but we also wanted to shock anyone that was involved that might come by. The dogs alerted on several different locations on the property. Further investigation didn't give us enough reason to dig at any of those locations, but we marked them.
Starting point is 00:26:22 While the search doesn't produce a body, investigators do draw someone of interest to the scene. While we were doing the search, we were also watching the road that goes by the house, and I observed Jeanette drive by. Jeanette Sanchez, at the time of this incident, was living with Andy in an apartment in Groveland, Florida. The day after the search, Jeanette's sister, Wendy Batten, contacts the mascot police department.
Starting point is 00:26:59 Jeanette's family knew that Jeanette knew more about the disappearance than she was telling everyone. I kept telling her I had to have something in the house. To be this aggressive, again, they found something. Wendy heard Jeanette say that, no, they won't find any evidence because we cleaned it very thoroughly. She said they ripped the carpet up, the tile down, and they re-handled the walls. I did ask her who killed Bill, and she didn't tell me. She just said it was an accident.
Starting point is 00:27:39 Obviously once the police heard that, talking to Jeanette was very high priority. But investigators don't need to track her down. I received a call from Jeanette's aunt who wanted to bring Jeanette in to speak with us. One of the things that Jeanette wanted before she would come in and speak with us is she wanted to be granted immunity. The local state attorney's office allowed us to grant her immunity during the interview. The state would provide her with immunity as long as she told the truth.
Starting point is 00:28:19 On March 2, 2004, Jeanette Sanchez sits down with investigators. I asked Jeanette what had happened on the night of the incident. She stated that early in the morning, Andrew had received a call from his mother. The morning that we were to go out the house, and she said that she and Andy come up to our turn to film our interview. Andy went up in the air and bowed. I kind of return bill, or you. And you went over there and about, and I felt like asleep. 30 minutes they called and said Tabby was upset.
Starting point is 00:28:52 I needed to come over to bring Tabby back to the house. When I got there, I didn't see Tabby. I told Tabby I had to go back to bed. I left on my back. I was telling them that this wasn't anything that was planned, that it was an accident, that Martha accidentally shot Bill. He told me he moved the body. He said first that it was hidden underneath the steps, behind the front steps.
Starting point is 00:29:36 He said it was there first. So he was there underneath the front steps when Officer Cameron came in? Yes. Jeanette says after the officer left, Andy moved the body. Andrew told Jeanette that he had cut a hole in the floor of the garage and put Bill Beatty's body wrapped in a tarp and then covered it with lime and then refilled the hole and put the wood back in the place in the floor
Starting point is 00:30:13 of the garage. With Jeanette's help, investigators draw a map of the baby home. The police immediately sketched out a rough diagram of the buildings and asked her if she would point to exactly where she thought the body might be found. When Jeanette marked the spot on the map, I knew that we were on the road to getting this case finished. On March 3, 2004, nearly three years after Bill Beatty went missing, investigators returned to the home
Starting point is 00:30:59 where he once lived with his wife Martha. They find that the freestanding garage has since been torn down. With the crudely drawn map in hand, they begin digging in the spot where the garage once was. About four hours into the dig, we detected an odor of decaying flesh. The upper portion of the body was covered in a blue canvas tarp. Around the waist of the body we observed a white cake-like substance. Lime is a mineral substance that would assist in the decomposition, but it basically preserved the body from the waist up. The body is transported to the medical examiner in Leesburg, Florida,
Starting point is 00:31:53 who confirms what law enforcement suspects. They looked for a unique tattoo that Bill had on his arm. They were able to say with high degree of confidence that that was in fact Bill Bader. Coming up, investigators work to finally uncover the truth. This didn't look like an accident. And desperation shapes a killer. They knew that they had to get the money back in the bank.
Starting point is 00:32:28 Andy asked Jeanette if he should do it. Almost three years after Bill Beatty went missing in mascot Florida, investigators have pulled his body from a six-foot grave on his property. They determined that in fact he had been the victim of a homicide. He had two bullet entry wounds in the back of his head, small caliber, and one of the bullets was still in his head. It appeared that Mr. Beatty had been laying on his stomach and that he had been shot from close range and from behind.
Starting point is 00:33:22 The medical examiner was able to determine that he quite likely was asleep when he was shot. This did not align at all with the story that Jennette told. This didn't look like an accident. I didn't believe it at first because you don't think that something like this could happen to your family. So it was like disbelief, like shock.
Starting point is 00:33:54 On March 8th, police bring Jeanette in for a second interview. We basically told her that, you know, we knew she was still being untruthful with us and that she was putting her immunity agreement in jeopardy. Slowly, Jeanette starts to reveal more details. At this point, did you know what had happened? They just told me that it was an accident. Eventually, Jeanette admits she was more involved than she previously let on. The day after the murder, Martha gave her one of Bill's credit cards and told her to drive to Georgia and stay in a hotel to make it look like Bill had left and gone to Georgia.
Starting point is 00:34:57 While Jeanette is being more forthcoming, police still don't believe they're getting the whole truth. Police confronted her with the evidence that they had about the two gunshot wounds being to the back of Bill's head. You could see that she was uncomfortable continuing with the story that she had been telling about Andy's involvement. Investigators need more information from Jeanette and decide to change gears. They request she participate in a voice stress analysis.
Starting point is 00:35:37 Detective Warshaw asked me if I could assist them with conducting a voice stress analysis on one of their potential witnesses. During the testing, we asked, you know, did Martha shoot Bill Beatty? Did Andy shoot Bill Beatty? Based on those questions we could tell that she had knowledge of who did this. When we came back in and we started the interview with the test results, I told her that she was not being 100% honest. She finally said, well, I may have been lying.
Starting point is 00:36:11 Jeanette became very, very emotional. She was reminded that she was still under immunity, that no matter what she said, it wasn't going to change the fact that she still had immunity. With the floodgates open, Jeanette continues. Jeanette said about two weeks before Bill died, Andy had gone to his mom and asked her for some money. This was money that came out of the bank account that Bill had control of. Martha had removed $1,500 from a bank account that Bill had control of.
Starting point is 00:36:46 Martha removed $1,500 from the bank account. The money was given to Andy. She said that he wanted the money for that custody battle, but Andy used the money largely to buy a truck and, according to police, to buy drugs. Martha had no authority to take money out of their joint bank account without Bill's knowledge. She went on to say that they knew that Bill
Starting point is 00:37:18 Beatty, every two weeks, like clockwork on his payday, made a deposit at the bank. And if they didn't get the $1,500 back in the bank before he went again, that he was going to find out. Andy couldn't come up with a way of returning the money. And Martha became more anxious. About two or three days beforehand, she started telling Andy that we have to do something soon.
Starting point is 00:37:46 Because Tuesday, he's going to find out when he gets his next paycheck that we've taken that money out. According to Jeanette, Andy knew exactly what his mother meant by do something. She said that Andy asked her if he should do it. She told him that she didn't want any part of it, that she felt that it was her fault because she didn't talk him out of it. She just thought he wouldn't really do anything.
Starting point is 00:38:21 That brings us to the night of the 27th, leading into the early morning of the 28th. The last thing that Jeanette said to Andy as he was going out the door to do what Mom said was, don't do something stupid. MUSIC Jeanette tells them that about 5 a.m., she's instructed to go and pick up Martha. She said that she just dropped Martha off in the driveway, and then she went home.
Starting point is 00:38:54 And Andy came home approximately 45 minutes or so later. Andy gets there, and he just starts to break down. And he tells Janette, I'll never kill another being. That's when she came out with the truth that Andy had shot Bill Batey. Jeanette's interview gives investigators what they need to finally make arrests. The grand jury indicted both Martha and Andrew,
Starting point is 00:39:24 and warrants were issued. On April 14, 2004, Andrew is served with his warrant in a Florida prison where he is already serving time on an unrelated charge. And a day later, Martha Beatty is arrested in West Virginia. Martha was arrested at her home on the Florida warrant. She was then transported back to Florida. After being arrested, Martha continued
Starting point is 00:39:53 to state that Bill Beatty's death was an accident. Coming up, will investigators finally learn the truth? Coming up, will investigators finally learn the truth? Or will the evidence tell a different story? It would be impossible for him to fall and trip and shoot himself in the back of the head. After almost three years, Martha Beatty and her son Andy have finally been charged in the murder of Martha's husband Bill. When investigators sit down with Martha, they get yet another version of what happened at the Beaty home on August 28, 2001. She said that they were arguing Bill was chasing her through the house with a handgun,
Starting point is 00:40:54 and that he tripped and the gun went off and hit him. She stated then that she picked the gun up and shot him again in fear that he was going to get up and get her. The problem with that story was both of the bullet holes were in the back of Bill Beatty's head, and it would be impossible for him to fall and trip and shoot himself in the back of the head. Investigators switch their focus to Andy. He admits that Martha had been feeling pressure to get the money back into Bill's account before he noticed. What did she say about the money? He had to pay it back, right? Oh yeah, that had to be back. According to Andy, a few days before Bill went missing, Martha was no longer asking him about money.
Starting point is 00:41:40 He stated before the incident occurred, Martha told him that she wanted Bill gone. She asked me, I knew anybody. You knew anybody that killed him? That's right. So what did you say? You said you don't want to know people like that? Andrew said that he just kind of took that with a grain of salt. He just said, you know, you're upset, you're emotional, and left it at that. The next thing he knew, Andy got a desperate call from his mother on the morning of August 28th.
Starting point is 00:42:16 He told me he saw him, he was right, while he was sleeping, while he was awake. I don't know if she had died yet, but she didn't go into details. It was over with him, but I got there. I don't know, you know. Okay. And she said he has to dispose of the body. She says she's buried.
Starting point is 00:42:44 Jeanette stated during her interview that Andrew had admitted to killing his father, and he had disposed of the body. Now authorities are looking at two different stories. Andy and Martha on the one hand are saying that the shooting was an accident, that Martha fired in self-defense. Jeanette, on the other hand, is saying that everything was all planned out and that Andy actually came in and that he fired the shots.
Starting point is 00:43:20 While prosecutors and investigators can't prove to a jury who pulled the trigger, they have a theory about what went down on August 28, 2001. Martha was under extreme stress because of this deadline that was about to come due, and she just did not want to contend with that and so she came up with this other solution. I believe that Martha had control over Andy. I think she knew the buttons to push. She knew she could use him. It's my strong opinion that it was Andy who squeezed the trigger. He was angry that Bill had money and would share it with him.
Starting point is 00:44:10 He also was motivated out of an allegiance to his mom. Prosecutors believed they then worked together to bury the body, to clean up the room, and to keep this a secret for as long as they did. On May 26, 2005, Martha pleads guilty to conspiracy to commit first-degree murder. Almost a year later, on April 3, 2006, Andy pleads guilty to the same charges. They are sentenced to 25 years in prison. When the verdicts came out, I was very happy. Foreclosure for the Beatty family,
Starting point is 00:45:00 that we were able to get two very bad people off the street. He got what he deserved, he got what he deserved, and, you know, we were all able to move on from the what-ifs. I'll remember Bill as my friend and a funny guy. There are less and less of us around to remember it. I think they cheated the community out of a good person. He loved his family. We carry his name, we carry his blood, so we are his legacy. And we pass it on to our kids. Jeanette's immunity was upheld and she was never charged.
Starting point is 00:45:44 Martha Beaty died in prison after contracting COVID-19 in 2020. Andy Normand was released from prison on July 8, 2024. Bill Beatty was laid to rest in Hinkley, Ohio on June 4, 2004. As a contractor for the NSA, Edward Snowden had access to a range of top-secret government programs. But as he learned more about these clandestine operations, he came to understand a devastating secret. The government was conducting mass surveillance on its own citizens. Hi, I'm Lindsey Graham, the host of Wondry Show American Scandal. We bring to life some of the biggest controversies in U.S. history.
Starting point is 00:46:26 Presidential lies, environmental disasters, corporate fraud. In our latest series, whistleblower Edward Snowden changes the national conversation about privacy on the Internet as he risks his own freedom and his family's well-being. Follow American Scandal on the Wondery app or wherever you get your podcasts. Listen to all episodes ad-free and be the first to binge the newest season only on Wondry Plus. You can join Wondry Plus in the Wondry app, Apple Podcasts, or Spotify. Start your free trial today.

There aren't comments yet for this episode. Click on any sentence in the transcript to leave a comment.