Snapped: Women Who Murder - Pamela Lanier

Episode Date: December 19, 2021

A woman's innocence is called into question after her husband dies from a mysterious malady and encourages detectives to take a deep dive into her past.Season 25, Episode 24Originally aired: ...August 18, 2019Watch full episodes of Snapped for FREE on the Oxygen app: https://oxygentv.app.link/WsLCJWqmIebSee Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.

Transcript
Discussion (0)
Starting point is 00:00:00 Hi, I'm Lindsey Graham, the host of Wonder East Podcast American Scandal. Our newest series looks at the story of OxyContin, a popular painkiller that helps spur an epidemic of addiction and drug abuse, in which prompted a broad campaign to hold the pharmaceutical industry accountable. Listen to American Scandal on Amazon Music or wherever you get your podcasts. When a salt of the earth farmer and a fun single mom fall for each other, their faith in love is restored. They lived a real good life and they were happy living it. But a mysterious illness destroys their plans to grow old together.
Starting point is 00:00:39 People were called seeing him in severe ill states where he couldn't move for days. He said, you daddy's at the hospital, you probably want to go ahead and come on now. Is there a darker side to this tragic tale? The circumstances under which this man had died were suspicious. He was not able to conclude what the cause of death was. A family demands answers. We've got to figure out what happened because it might be murder.
Starting point is 00:01:10 That's when we decided we needed to go back and then to zoom his body. As the pieces fall into place, a dark pattern emerges. There was another death under somewhat unusual circumstances some years earlier. You hope you're dreaming.
Starting point is 00:01:25 There's a bad dream and you wake up, but it's shocking. Dooblin County, North Carolina, is a place where life moves slowly and folks understand the value of a hard day's work. Dooblin County is approximately 70,000 people. It's a very rural farm county in Eastern North Carolina. The people in Dooblin County, as you would imagine, are ruled down to earth, very friendly people. But everything is about to change for one local family. On the evening of November 19, 1997,
Starting point is 00:02:20 Mitchell Sanders is hunting on his aunt's farm with his cousin Dustin when he gets a familiar signal. We were in the back of the farm, hunting deer, when I heard horn blowing before dark. I knew that horn meant for me to come down. When the teens arrive at the house, it's clear something's wrong. Mitchell's aunt Pamela Lanier
Starting point is 00:02:54 is huddled over her husband Dorian who's in dire condition. Dorian had a strange color look to him to me at that time. More of a yellowish color and I weren't for sure what it was. Dorene had a strange color look to him to me at that time. More of a yellowish color, and I weren't for sure what it was, but I knew it weren't right. He was unconscious in the residence.
Starting point is 00:03:14 The rescue came and they transported him to deep in General Hospital. Will they be able to save Dorene? She don't know what's going on. Nobody knew at that time. And I reckon there was nothing that they could do to stop what happened. For Ivy Dorian linear senior, nothing was more important than farm and family.
Starting point is 00:03:41 Daddy and his family grew up on a small farm in rural Dublin County, Chinkapena area, a couple hundred acres at most. Door was a get up before the sun, and let's get started. And let's get whatever we got to get done, done today. He was like a piece of leather. You could take a knife, and you couldn't cut him. That's how tough he was. After high school, Dorian spent some time in the military,
Starting point is 00:04:10 but he always found his way back to the farm. He went to the Air Force at a young age. He was very proud to serve her country. He got him off the farm, you know, to enjoy something different in life. Although Dorian's blood was definitely country blood. No doubt. After the Air Force, Dorian met his first wife, Beth, and then Dorian and Beth had two children.
Starting point is 00:04:39 Over the years, Dorian had made a good life on land the Lanier family had worked for generations. The party was property of my great-granddaddies, and Daddy got a chance to buy it from the family. Mom and Daddy built a home, which is about 1200 square feet. Nice little house, perfect for a family with two kids. It was all very, very precious and dear to him. Gras, it was family, it was heritage, blood sweat and tears.
Starting point is 00:05:06 Doran was a turkey farmer. Had lots of friends in the community, they described him as a very good neighbor, and which is in those parts. When you say somebody's a good neighbor, that's something that actually means a lot. He had turkey houses and small farm, nothing big. Did bulldozers work for anybody that needed it.
Starting point is 00:05:30 So he was in the farm and running heavy equipment. And he was a hard working man. But farm life wasn't for his wife Beth and it took a toll on their marriage. I think they truly loved each other, but they just grew apart and had different opinions, you know. The ornament was very stubborn. No doubt. And Beth was a good woman.
Starting point is 00:05:54 She gave up a lot of herself to live on the farm with him. After 25 years, Beth called it quits. Mama moved out. For all my high school years, it was me and my daddy. Eventually, Dorian decided to get back in the dating game. Dad had dated different ladies from the time to him, my mama separated, and that they were all nice ladies.
Starting point is 00:06:21 But none of Dorian's flings lasted long. And after the kids grew up and moved out, he was beginning to picture a future alone. Until Dorian ran into an old friend, Pamela Sanders Williams. Though she was raised to be a southern bell, Pam Sanders was a firecracker who kept everyone on their toes. Pam's very energetic, so you're gonna have fun when you're around her. She's laughing, carrying on, but she's looking out for you. You don't meet them like that every day. Pam had been unlucky in love, divorced twice,
Starting point is 00:07:01 and in 1987, she found herself raising a young son named Dustin on her own. Until, Johnny Ray Williams walked into her life. He was from the Dupland County area, a country boy out there. They were a happy couple. Pam loved Johnny, and I would never question that. And Johnny loved Pam. When Johnny and Pam married in 1989, Johnny adopted Dustin and raised him as his own. Later that year, the couple welcomed a daughter named Kayla.
Starting point is 00:07:36 Things were going well for the family until September 4, 1991, when Johnny had a terrible accident. He was checking his crab pods, slowed out there in the back yard off the dock. And I don't know what happened to him when he fell in. If he got this oriented, or I don't know, but ended up drowning. When the emergency people in the law enforcement
Starting point is 00:08:07 arrived, they recovered his body in three foot of water. When Johnny died, the pan didn't take it real good. She was a different person, and it just like her world fell apart. She loved him, and it took her a fell apart. She loved him. And it took her a while to move on after that. She had a big loss. But she had children, too.
Starting point is 00:08:33 And she carried on for them. I know. Pam spent the next two years healing. But when she crossed Paz with Dorian, she knew she could be happy again. Pam lived nearby in the neighborhood. The two of them had just knew each other. We'd call Pam, wanting to go out. He was very persistent.
Starting point is 00:08:58 He saw something, and he wasn't just going to walk away from it. Pamela and Dorian married in 1993, and she and her children moved to Dorian's farm. For Dorian, it was an unexpected new beginning. I think he really missed the closeness that he had had previously with his own children. And maybe he thought he had another chance with these two small children.
Starting point is 00:09:26 He did have an affection for the kids. And I think the kids like my dad. To me, it seemed like they lived a real good life, and they were happy living it. But after four happy years of marriage, Dorian's health takes a tragic turn. At 6.25 p.m. on November 19th, 1997, Marriage, Dorian's health takes a tragic turn. At 6.25pm on November 19, 1997,
Starting point is 00:09:49 Dorian arrives by ambulance at Dutland County Medical Center. Doctors attempt to stabilize him, but the 57-year-old is in a fragile state. I got a phone call probably about 10 or 11 o'clock from one of my aunts. She said, you daddy is at the hospital. He said, you probably want to come. So I said, do I need to come tonight?
Starting point is 00:10:12 Or do I need to come tomorrow? She said, you probably want to go ahead and come on now. They took Doran back and run some tests. And Doran was still active, fine. And I thought, it won't be long, and we'll be packing up and going back home. He didn't look good, but he, you know, he talked okay. The reference he made multiple times was,
Starting point is 00:10:35 I'm gonna be okay, and I almost take good care of him. But then, Dorian's condition suddenly plummetes. It all happened in the hospital. The staff is all rushing. Pam is going hysterical. She don't know what's going on. At that moment is when everybody started stirring in there because he was directing flatline.
Starting point is 00:11:04 And Pam was losing it. Coming up, a family copes with a stunning turn. There's a lot of confusion. Nobody really knew what happened. And unsettling information starts to emerge. Dr. Garrett did indicate that in his opinion, this was not a one-time estimate. 1997. After 57-year-old Dorian Leneer fell ill at home, doctors at the hospital thought they'd begun to stabilize him, until his vital function started to fail.
Starting point is 00:11:55 The family was really worried about him. Nobody had any idea how sick he was. After multiple resuscitation attempts, doctors pronounce Dorian dead at 1057 p.m. They said Dorian had passed away, and he shot me. Because I was just talking to him. You hope you're dreaming. There's a bad dream, and you wake up, but it's shocking. The last thing you told me was that he loved me. But I always have that.
Starting point is 00:12:37 Dorian's wife, Pam, is beside herself. She lost it. As you would expect, and it was tough, it was tough. All you could do is be there for, and hope to find that for you. The question on everyone's mind is, why did Dorian die? There was a lot of confusion. Nobody really knew what happened. Doran's daughter. was a lot of confusion. Nobody really knew what happened.
Starting point is 00:13:05 Doran's daughter, she requested the autopsy. Dr. Charles Garrett was our forensic pathologist, and he did the initial autopsy. Dr. Garrett noted that Mr. Lanier had a yellow cast or color, and there was evidence that he had some liver issues, which could certainly explain why he went about a yellowish cast. In addition to problems with his liver function, Dr. Garrett finds an enlarged heart and excessive fluid in Dorian's lungs, but the autopsy does not provide him with enough information on its own.
Starting point is 00:13:41 He was not able to conclude what the cause of death was until he sent off blood to do the toxicology report. The report's findings stunned Dr. Garrett. The toxicology report came back and indicates to us that he died from arsenic poisoning. That testing revealed elevated concentrations of arsenic in blood, liver, and hair sample. They were high enough to explain the death. The other thing, again, of course, was that the symptoms that the man had exhibited prior to his death were consistent with arsenic poisoning.
Starting point is 00:14:19 In an instance, when someone dies of poisoning, then, of course, there are the three possible that it's an accident. It's a suicide or it's a homicide. However, the poison got into Dorian's body, one thing is for sure. His end was not a peaceful one. In arcing poison, the victim dies along and drawn out death, very painful, uncomfortable death. Dr. Garrett did indicate that in his opinion,
Starting point is 00:14:46 this was not a one-time incident. This is, uh, our state had been in the body of a Dorian linear for a long period of time. To Dr. Garrett, the fact that Dorian had been poisoned over a long period of time, points to a chilling conclusion. It was his opinion during the knock-and-knit suicide, and it was not an accidental poisoning. Dr. Garrett notified law enforcement that, well, look, we've got a case of arsenic poison here.
Starting point is 00:15:16 We've got to figure out what happened because it might be murdered. When it was brought to our attention that Dorian and Leneer died of arson poison, my office immediately contacted the Northern Ohio State Bureau of Investigation, and also we contacted the Debian County Sheriff's Department, notified them of the results of the autopsy and formally requested them to conduct
Starting point is 00:15:39 a criminal investigation surrounding the death of Dory and Leneer. The homicide investigation begins close to home. In any case, where a husband or wife is killed, the number one suspect that you've got to eliminate is surviving spouse. So we obviously are trying to eliminate Pamela as the key suspect.
Starting point is 00:16:10 Pamela near immediately agrees to an interview. Investigators start by asking about her marriage to Dorian. She was saying that she loved her husband. They had a wonderful relationship. And she gave her explanation of the event so he knocked her husband's death. According to Pam, Dorian was in good health until September 1, 1997, two months before his death,
Starting point is 00:16:37 when he had a mishap while operating his bulldozer. Best I can remember is a tree lamb had come in to cap, and pinned his knee one way or the other against some controls for the bulldozer and mess up his knee pretty bad from what I understand and then Somehow from there things went downhill quickly Pam explains how over the course of several weeks, Dorian's health deteriorated. Some days he's fine, and some days you couldn't hardly understand him.
Starting point is 00:17:12 He might be laying there, sleeping all day, or acting silly, like a kid, and not listening, very defiant. He had general weakness of his limbs, at least on several occasions that people recall, and he lost a lot of weight, so there was a lot going on with him. Summer is finally here, which means the great outdoors are hotter, more humid, and filled with bugs. Actually come to think of it, there's no better way to spend the summer than an air-conditioned
Starting point is 00:17:43 comfort while listening to your favorite podcasts. Discover the summer of podcast with two months free of Wondery Plus. With Wondery Plus, you get early and ad free access to your favorite podcasts. You can also listen to our entire library of award-winning binge-worthy shows. That's thousands of hours of captivating content in any genre you like. From true crime, to business, comedy, sports, history, and even podcasts for the whole family. With Wondery Plus, you also get access to Special Live events found nowhere else, as well as discounts in the Wondery shop.
Starting point is 00:18:15 Summer is a time to relax and unwind by binging your favorite podcasts, so don't let the summer of podcasts pass you by. Right now, new subscribers can enjoy two months free of Wondery Plus. Visit Wondery.com or download the Wondry app to get started. Though according to Pam, Dorian refused to go to the doctor. He wouldn't take medicine. He didn't like to go to the doctor. He'd always try and be self-sufficient about things like that.
Starting point is 00:18:41 Dorian was old school type of person. He thought he knew as much as the doctor knows. If he could cure one of his animals, he could cure himself, and that was his mindset. Pam says that though she was worried, she respected Dorian's wishes. Still, investigators find it hard to believe that Pam just stood by and watched
Starting point is 00:19:06 as Dorian's health continued to deteriorate. That certain we thought was incriminated and certainly doesn't support her as being a loving, caring wife. While authorities suspect Pam may have had something to do with Dorian's death, loved ones see her as a grieving widow needing emotional encouragement. Pam took it hard. Dorian's family knew there was arsenic in the system from
Starting point is 00:19:36 autopsy, and everybody's still was their support Pam. Her family, Dor daughter's family. And after even knowing what a within a system, everybody still came to Pam's house and had things given. Nobody was pointing a finger at her. Her. Coming up, detectives are forced to reframe their approach. There was some debate about whether or not a medication that he was using might have been the cause of his death.
Starting point is 00:20:10 And ghosts from the past bring new suspicions to light. This was not the first husband that had died under suspicious circumstances. Dubelyn County, North Carolina authorities are investigating the death of 57-year-old Turkey farmer, Dorian Linear. Our forensic pathologist said, this is not accidental death, this is a murder case. So then you have to find out who did it if it's a murder. And obviously Pamela lived with him during this whole two-month time
Starting point is 00:21:00 that he'd been sick. So she's interviewed. Dorian's wife, Pam Linear, time that he'd been sick. So she's interviewed. Dorian's wife Pam Linear cannot tell them how a deadly level of arsenic could have entered Dorian's system. When you find something in someone that maybe is not supposed to be there, you have to look at all the possible ways that it could have gotten there.
Starting point is 00:21:21 Did the person take it, did someone give it to them, or is there something in their environment that could explain it? During this period of time, the sheriff's department and the state bureau of investigation went to the home of Dorin and Pamela Nier, and there they, in fact, found a number of empty packets of Nitro 3.
Starting point is 00:21:40 Nitro 3 is a product that is used to help grow turkeys. The feed additive is something Dorian worked with for years as a turkey farmer. He'd get packs of the chemical nitro 3 and you'd dump it into a, I believe it was a barrel of water. And it was slowly pumped from that barrel of water from the pump house and to the water system that goes to the charkeys. On the packaging, detectives notice something that changes the course of the investigation.
Starting point is 00:22:21 The additive contains arsenic. There was something to debate about whether or not a medication that he was using with the turkeys might have been the cause of his death rather than murder. But how would Dorian have ingested the nitro three? Detective speak with Pamela and other loved ones for more insight. Their turkey house, the medicators, runs through a more insight. They're turkey house medicators. Runs through a pump house. They don't drink out of that right there.
Starting point is 00:22:51 But yet, throughout the year, I'd always see him pick up the hose and drink it. He would be seen drinking out of the hose, which clearly could expose him to arsenic if he was drinking the water that contained the medication. But there was also a way to turn the spigot so that it would go into a different hose if you could drink out of a fresh water hose
Starting point is 00:23:12 that was attached to the same water supply. Pamela linear and some of her family members' explanation was that Dorian accidentally caused him himself. that Dorian accidentally caused him himself. Dorian didn't really think about the dangers in things for himself as he would for others. He would rather do it than have somebody else do it if there was a danger involved in anything. But if Dorian happened to ingest
Starting point is 00:23:44 arsenic from the hose, would it have been enough to kill him? Well, our general sense was that the arsenic that was enused in his form for his animals, there wasn't enough arsenic to explain what was found in him. It was a much more concentrated form of arsenic in his system. The arsenic in the system. The arsenic that he was feeding his livestock would not have done it, could not have done it. If the Nitro III wasn't strong enough to kill Dorian,
Starting point is 00:24:18 what or who did? Before detectives conclude their interview, Pam tells them that she knows one person who may have had access to Dorian in the days leading up to his illness. Ali Bratchel was a friend who stayed there from beginning in September and left the early part of November 1997.
Starting point is 00:24:39 When Ali moved in, Dorin was getting sick. When detectives sit down with Ali, she is adamant she had nothing to do with Dorin's death. But admits she was concerned for his well-being. She reported seeing him in severe ill states where he couldn't move for days. According to Ali, the only person who tended to Dorian before his death was Pam. We find out that Pamela was very reluctant to allow friends and family members come over to visit Dorian during this two-month period of where he was ill, the subsequent then to his death.
Starting point is 00:25:29 After Doran's health deteriorated even more, it was about impossible to see him or even talk to him, because Pam isolated him from everybody, because my suspicion is Pam didn't want everybody to know how realistic Dor one was. And he didn't want anybody to worry about him or make a big deal out of anything that he was going through, which is, you know, hindsight is always 2020. After the interview, detectives work to corroborate Ali's story.
Starting point is 00:26:08 Obviously, we looked into Ali. Ali had no motive to doing this. There was no financial incentive, and no reason we should find out why Ali was posing nor in it. And also, Ali left. I believe, no matter the second. And he died 17 days after Ali left the residence. With no apparent opportunity or motive,
Starting point is 00:26:35 Ali Bradshaw is cleared. Investigators decide they need to take a closer look at Pam. As they dig deeper into her past, they make an alarming discovery. It was brought to our attention that this was not the first husband that had died under suspicious circumstances. Pam's third husband, Johnny Ray Williams, had died in 1991, six years before Dorian.
Starting point is 00:27:06 Pamela Nears said he had consumed some whiskey. It was seen staggering down up here going into the canal. He fell into the canal and was trying to get out. According to Pamela Nears, she said she threw a crap pot towards him for a flotation device. When she left to get help, she came back and found him floating and then she called for assistance. The official cause of death was drowned. The problem with it was that he drowned in two
Starting point is 00:27:34 or three feet of water. There were people who thought that was very strange because they knew him to be a really good swimmer and that just didn't make sense that he would allow himself to drown in that depth of water, even if he'd been drinking. For some reason, the naltops who was not performed on giant ray Williams at that time.
Starting point is 00:27:57 Investigators reach out to Johnny's family for insight, and his mother, Marie Williams, has some interesting things to say. Mr. Williams had been sick prior to his death. He had been admitted at a hospital with symptoms similar to a stroke. When Mr. Williams went and spoke to her son, he was incoherent and unresponsive, and she had concerns that something may be wrong. That's when we decided we needed to go back
Starting point is 00:28:24 and to zoom his body and perform an autopsy and she had concerns that something may be wrong. That's when we decided we needed to go back and to zoom his body and perform an autopsy to determine whether or not he died from arsenic, poisoning, too. Coming up, investigators dig deep to uncover the truth. His body was not in good condition. It had undergone quite a bit of deterioration. And when suspicions mount, retaliation begins.
Starting point is 00:28:47 She alleged that someone was stalking her and vandalizing her residence. MUSIC Detectives in Duplin County, North Carolina The The The The The The The The The The The The
Starting point is 00:29:10 The The The The The The The The The The The The The The The The The The The The The The The The The The The The The The The The The The The The The The The The The The The The The The The The The The The The The The The The The The The The The The The The The The The The The The The The The The The The The The The The The The The The The The The The The The
Starting point is 00:29:16 The The The The The The The The
Starting point is 00:29:18 The The The The The The The The The The The The The The The The The The The The The the The The the The The the the The The The The The The The The The of her most recent husband's death, they I think wanted to see if there was any potential pattern or connection. Arrangements were made to remove his body from the grave, and I was the one who ended up examining him. Exhumations are always a bit of a dice roll. In Mr. Williams case, his body was not in good condition. It had undergone quite a bit of deterioration
Starting point is 00:29:45 in the six years or so that he'd been in the ground. They were looking to see if he also might have been poisons. Maybe if he did drown, he had drowned because he had something in his system that he shouldn't have. But our main reason for performing it was to rule out the possibility that we had another case of arsenic poisoning. We felt comfortable testing for arsenic because of the nature of arsenic.
Starting point is 00:30:10 It just doesn't go away and it doesn't deteriorate. We were able, of course, to run tests on the tissues for the presence of arsenic. There were small levels of arsenic in the system that's normal of all human beings. The tissues really weren't in a state that we felt that testing for other medicines or drugs would be meaningful. So we passed that on, and that was the end of that. With no red flags in Johnny's autopsy report, investigators are unable to confirm definitively
Starting point is 00:30:40 that his death was anything more than an accident. Still, investigators know that after Johnny's death, Ham had inherited his life insurance policy for $25,000, and she's about to collect once again. Pamela and I are stood to inherit an estate from Doreland Nier, which was estimated approximately $90,000. Though the inheritance hints at a possible motive, authorities note that Pam hasn't made any claims on it yet. It's been more than four months since Dorian's death,
Starting point is 00:31:21 and without any new leads, the investigation stalls until April 1998, when Pam starts caching in. She did sell assets for substantial amounts of money. There was the land, she had her soul part of it, and she sold some equipment after his death. and she sold some equipment after his death. Once largely supportive of Pam and her innocence, Dorian's family now has a change of heart. They became suspicious when she started selling all the farmland.
Starting point is 00:31:54 The family land was not given to the family, to his brother, son, sisters, and father. That's when it all sort of went south. I was shocked. He found out she is just going about selling everything and taking the money, and it was just bizarre. Still, some loved ones are more understanding. Pam had to continue to live.
Starting point is 00:32:29 What do you do? I mean, if you got to sell something, you can't use to make it another month. Sometimes you got to do it. When investigators dig deeper into Pam's finances, they find that she often struggled to make ends meet. They also uncover one incident where she might have come up with an unsettling solution to her financial woes. A year before Doran's death, his house called on fire.
Starting point is 00:33:00 His wife Pamela was the only one at the residence at that time. It was a firing dawn, Veroon. There was a fire in the house. death, his house caught on fire. His wife, Pamela, was the only one at the residence at that time. It was a firing dawn, rerun. There was a lot of smoke damage. There was a lot of back and forth with the insurance company because they really couldn't figure out what happened.
Starting point is 00:33:19 At the time of the fire in 1996, Dory and Pamela where having financial difficulties, the insurance company paid them $142,000, which they used to buy a mobile restlessly put behind the home that had burned, and also where they were paid off their outstanding deaths. It was never proven that Pam started the fire to cash in on the insurance.
Starting point is 00:33:45 But the fact that Pamela had been a suspect in this previous fire and financially benefited, certainly was a piece of circumstantial evidence that supported the theory that she marked her husband for a financial gain. In fact, a woman has now had two husbands to die who had been helped prior to a brief period prior to their death. Both of them got the same type of very sudden help issues. Both of them died. And both of them she benefited financially. That certain is some evidence to support that she killed Dorian.
Starting point is 00:34:25 The totality of the circumstances involving the Dorian linear murder case, everything combined was what the take of Jones and special aid at Wallace were able to provide to the District Attorney's Office. In January of 1999, just over a year after Dorian's death, a Duplin County grand jury indites Pamela Lanier for the murder of her husband. Pam took it like anybody would take it. In shock, just believed that they would even think that she would have done it.
Starting point is 00:35:00 Pam is held in the Dupelin County jail on a $100,000 bond. Pam didn't stay in jail for long. Her bond was posted, and she was released, and she goes through the legal processes, getting attorneys and stuff. While Pam is out on bond, she tries to go about her life as usual.
Starting point is 00:35:24 She would have her moments, but Pam carried it real good for what was going on. She kept living her life day-to-day like she had to. In the months before her trial, Pam doesn't shy away from law enforcement. She contacts the Dublin County Sheriff's Office to report harassment, possibly by someone seeking retaliation against her for Dorian's death. Despite the fact she's not yet been found guilty.
Starting point is 00:35:56 She alleged that someone was stalking her and vandalizing her rescinds. Paminer's allegation was someone was cutting the screens in her windows, throwing eggs at the house, and she didn't know who it was. Somebody poisoned her dog and the pen out about a back door. They come home and noticed something was wrong and took him to the vet and saw him poison him.
Starting point is 00:36:20 And it killed him. It was just non-stop. When investigators look into the charges, they begin to think Pam has ulterior motives for keeping in contact with police. We listened to her. She had no photograph. She had no evidence to present. It was to prove that the allegation was true.
Starting point is 00:36:40 We just couldn't prove anyone was stalking Pamela near or vandalizing her residence. It was our opinion that she may have been trying to pick us for information to find out about her case. And we also felt like she was, for lack of a better term, throw us a red herring for us to follow and run out regarding this alleged stalker and vandal. That eventually she could say, well,
Starting point is 00:37:04 this could be the person that told her husband. Despite Pam's efforts to throw them off the trail, prosecutors work to solidify their case against her. In October 2001, they offer her a plea deal. At one time, prosecutors offered her a plea deal of less of charge than three years in prison, which surprised everyone she rejected. So for somebody not to take a plea or something like that,
Starting point is 00:37:37 it makes you wonder, don't. They're crazy if they don't take that and they did it. Why chance it? But Pam stayed pretty confident that if I'm not guilty, I'm okay. Coming up, Pamela Le Nier goes to trial. This case was not a slam dunk for the state at all. It's a lot of circumstantial evidence. And hard lines are drawn in court.
Starting point is 00:38:04 She's a loving person and she wouldn't have done this to him. It was very demeaning, what she did to him. You don't treat somebody you love like that. Like that. In November 2001, nearly four years after Dorian Leneer's death, his wife Pamela Leneer's trial begins. After turning down a plea deal, Pamela's fate rests on the outcome of this courtroom battle. Those in attendance are divided by family ties.
Starting point is 00:38:50 I was there when they opened the doors. I was there when we closed the doors. For those few days, that was my order. It was all the judge's commands, all the judge's got out. That was my duty. That was my duty to my daddy. She said, I didn't do nothing. They can't convict me of something I didn't do.
Starting point is 00:39:13 If I thought for any reason whatsoever that Pam had done this, I wouldn't be on her side. I don't care how thick the blood is, I wouldn't. But she's a loving person, and she wouldn't have done this to him. Without any solid physical evidence tying Pam to the crime, prosecutors have a tough road ahead. You know, this case was not a slam dunk for the state at all. It's a lot of circumstantial evidence involved, like most murders.
Starting point is 00:39:43 There was testimony about whether or not Pamela refused to take him to the doctor, and she probably should have. I think it hurt Pamela near a lot, that there was evidence that she tried to keep people away and was not pushing to have him go to a doctor even at some point go to the ER, even though they've been instructed to go and they didn't get treatment. Those kinds of things didn't sit with the jury.
Starting point is 00:40:13 You know, before he died, she went to the extent of a one-of-a-here covering the mattress and everything because his body functions were just way out of control. It was very demeaning what she did to him. And more ways than one. You don't treat somebody you love like that. Prosecutors argue that while facing another financial struggle, Pam poised Dorian so she could take over
Starting point is 00:40:45 their property and bank accounts. Prosecutors also assert that the suspicious patterns from Pam's past are not to be ignored. The jury was allowed to hear evidence that her prior husband died under what the state would characterize as very suspicious circumstances at best. And now her second husband has died under, again, very suspicious circumstances.
Starting point is 00:41:12 And even though the mechanism of death was different, the jury was allowed to consider both. But Pamela Lanier is ready to fight. Pamela Lanier had two of the best criminal offense lawyers in North Carolina, Doug Parsons and Jack O'Hell. So Pamela Lanier had what would be called the dream team in North Carolina, representing her. Everything that the state presented, her attorneys presented something else. Pam's defense team tries to destroy the prosecution's assertions of a financial motive.
Starting point is 00:41:52 Pam had to farm already. She lived on it. She didn't have to work, dorm paid to bills. But was she gaining nothing? Why gain something you already have? The defense also argues Dorian's death could have been the result of an accidental poisoning. The argument was that this is a farm that uses chemicals and medicines for the turkeys and some of those contain arsenic. And if he wasn't as careful as he should have been, that may have been what caused his death. After closing arguments on November 29,
Starting point is 00:42:35 the jury deliberates. When you add all the pieces of evidence to gather, it commits to jury 12 people that she was guilty of murdering her husband. Pamela nearer was found guilty of first-screen murder and received life imprisonment without parole. The police were not guilty. Those in Pam's corner are dismayed by the trials outcome.
Starting point is 00:42:57 My mama called me and told me that they found her guilty. It was a shocking moment. From day one to today, she would tell you, I did not do this, and I believe her. Not just in my mind, but with my heart, I believe her. Most people didn't see her like as a murderer, but a lot of people described that they had a good, a good relationship during that Pamela.
Starting point is 00:43:22 But obviously, that was not true. I'm very confident in the decision of our courts and how it handled this matter. For Dorian's family, the verdict is a relief, and its timing is yet another coincidence in a bizarre string of events. It was amazing. It was four years to the day he died
Starting point is 00:43:45 that we got a guilty privilege. Exactly four years. The family still mourns the man who was taken from them too soon. My daddy died in 97. I put him in the ground. I have a 18-year-old, a 16-year-old, and a 14-year-old, and they never met him. Never got a chance to see him.
Starting point is 00:44:14 And if we're lucky enough to see this on TV, this will be the most I've spoken about it in 20 years. And probably we'll speak a whole lot more about it in 20 years. And probably we'll speak all up more about it. Pamela Leneer is serving a life sentence at Anson Correctional Institute in Polptown, North Carolina. She remains hopeful for an exoneration. For more information on snapped, go to oxygen.com.

There aren't comments yet for this episode. Click on any sentence in the transcript to leave a comment.