Snapped: Women Who Murder - Patricia McMillion

Episode Date: June 29, 2025

Detectives devise a sting operation to track down a killer and reveal a vengeful murder plot.Season 32, Episode 8Originally aired: April 9, 2023Watch full episodes of Snapped for FREE on the Oxygen app: https://oxygentv.app.link/WatchSnappedPodSee Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.

Hi, I'm Lindsey Graham, the host of Wondries American History Tellers. In our latest series, a seemingly ordinary cook in New York City becomes a center of a public health crisis. Officials race to find the woman, dubbed Typhoid Mary by the press, before she can unwittingly spread the deadly illness she carries to even more people. Listen to American History Tellers on the Wondry app or wherever you get your podcasts. Hey, I'm Cassie DePeckel, host of Wondries podcast Against the Odds. In our new season, it's August 3rd, 1991. A cruise ship sails into a brutal storm off South Africa's wild coast and soon starts

flooding. But with no leadership in sight, the ship's entertainers take charge, leading a desperate evacuation before Oceano sinks. Listen to Against the Odds on the Wondery app or wherever you get your podcasts. A hardworking family man vanishes into thin air. He didn't short for work. He's not a person to miss work. My gut's telling me something's not right here. And a gruesome discovery in a Louisiana swamp exposes a suspect.

We were notified by some fishermen there was a body in the canal. My cell phone rang and that's when I was informed that it was time to go to alligator country. But an unlikely hero will bring the real killer down. I would never guess that I went undercover to solve a murder. I'm not going to get any sleep tonight. I need to know is there anything that's going to come up. I would have never dreamt in my Christian life that this would have ever happened. June 16, 2008, Luella, Texas. Around 6.30 p.m., dispatchers at the Grayson County Sheriff's Department receive a phone call from 50-year-old Rhonda Hudson.

She's worried about her friend, 53-year-old Kenneth McMillian. Rhonda and her husband were good friends, and she allowed Kenneth to stay with him while he was going through a divorce. She was wanting us to do a welfare check on Kenneth McMillian because he hadn't come home, and she hadn't let him get a hold of him. Not only that, Rhonda tells police that Kenneth hadn't shown up for his shift at the local Raytheon manufacturing plant.

Raytheon advised that he didn't show up for work. That wasn't like Kenneth to do that. And that was really concerning to Rhonda. Rhonda says she last saw Kenneth when he was leaving to meet his ex-wife, 48-year-old Patricia McMillian, at the home they'd once shared. Kenneth and Patricia McMillian had gone through a divorce. Ultimately, he had been awarded their house. She was well overdue from moving out.

He was going out to the property, and he had not been heard from since he had went out there. There's all kinds of things that I'm sure go through officer's heads when they hear that someone is missing. The Sheriff's Office didn't disregard that. They immediately went to check on him. Kenneth McMillion was born on June 20, 1954, to parents Leroy and Martha McMillion. Kenneth spent his childhood in Sherman, Texas. He grew up in the country.

I think his high school had a class of 12 or total 12 in the school. After high school he discovered there was a machine shop where they did metal fab for various Texas Instruments programs and he was able to get hired in into that machine shop. I worked with him and his brother several times. He was very well mannered, shy, slow to speak. He just took things and did his job and was good at his job. It was in the late 1970s when he met his future wife, Patricia Dunlap. She was born June 19, 1959 in Missouri.

She always had her makeup done and always had her hair styled. She did have family in Sherman, but there was no real connection to the family. As far as being fitting like she was a part of the family, I don't think she felt that way. When Patricia met Kenneth McMillian in 1978, she found the lasting connection she'd always longed for. After three years together, they married in 1981. He would do just about anything it could to make her happy. After three years together, they married in 1981.

He would do just about anything it could to make her happy. I don't know of anything that he wouldn't have done for her. Not long after they got married, they bought a plot of land, 15 acres, built a home. And it was a big, beautiful home. And Patricia just loved to show off her home. And it was a big beautiful home and Patricia just loved to show off her home. She was very proud of what they had done. In 1988, Patricia gave birth to a daughter. They were a perfect couple. I mean then you got your daughter. You just built the house. They were a happy-go-lucky family.

Kenneth continued to work at the plant. In between ball games and school functions, Patricia launched her own business on the side. She was a seamstress, loved to sew. She kept very, very busy with her business and trying to build it up and make it bigger. Patricia was generous with her time and skills. Patricia was very nice to me.

She was always cordial and she would ask me how I was doing. She was reserved, but Patricia was very helpful. She wanted to help me with the children's home that we did for Christmas time, and she helped with embroidering. She helped out every year. She was very pleasant.

By 2007, after Patricia and Kenneth's daughter had entered adulthood, their once loving marriage had deteriorated. Kenneth and Patricia were married for 27 years, and once they became empty nesters, there was a shift in their relationship. He was telling me certain things that had gone on, and he was trying to figure out why all of a sudden she didn't like him no more.

She had moved to a different room of the house. It's like they had turned into roommates instead of married partners. He was trying to figure out what he could do to not have to go through a divorce. But when he started working night shift and he was gone all night, it pushed him further apart because she didn't want nothing to do with him anymore

pretty much. He was ready for it to be over. In August of 2007, Kenneth McMillan filed for divorce. During that time, he lived with Rhonda and her husband Phil in the spare room. In the months after Kenneth moved out, Patricia reconnected with a former co-worker and friend, Harold Ballard. He and Patricia McMillan had worked together at a local factory, and that's how he knew her. And in some way he found out that she was getting a divorce and he had contacted her.

Not long after that, that relationship became a romantic one. Kenneth and Patricia's divorce was finalized on April 17th, 2008. Part of the deal is that she moved out of the house and she was to get $110,000 for giving up the house. He was awarded the home, but Kenneth did allow Patricia some time to get her things moved out. It did seem with the divorce finalized and the plans for Patricia to move out,

that they would be able to get a fresh start and go their separate ways amicably. But just two months later, be able to get a fresh start and go their separate ways amicably. But just two months later, on June 16th, Kenneth is reported missing by his friend Rhonda Hudson. Before Grayson County deputies head to the home Kenneth used to share with Patricia, they discover an incident report for the same address from earlier that morning. It was around 6.30, 7 o'clock in the morning.

Patricia McMillian had contacted Kenneth by phone and was asking about a trailer that was on the property that she could not find and she thought it might be stolen and told Kenneth that he needed to come out there and make a police report, which he did. According to the report, when the deputy arrived at the home that morning, he found Patricia, Kenneth, and Patricia's love interest, 60-year-old Harold Ballard. Harold was helping her move out from 176 Snap Road. During the meeting with deputies, there was word set between Kenneth McMillian and Harold Ballard. Kenneth didn't like the fact that Harold

was there helping her. He thought he had a cocky attitude. Kenneth accused Patricia and Harold of stealing a trailer. Kenneth McMillian ordered Harold Ballard off his property, and he asked deputies to give a criminal trespass warning to him. The deputy told him he was trespassing and that he couldn't come back on the property.

At the request of the deputies, Harold left. But he didn't go quietly. Harold had made actual threats in the presence of a police officer against Kenneth, who was now missing. Eleven hours later, Sheriff's deputies prepare to head back to the McMillion home. I made contact with Patricia, who was there, and explained, you know, I'm doing a welfare check. Nobody's heard from Kenneth.

Patricia says that Kenneth left soon after the deputies escorted Harold off the property. Patricia McMillion said that Kenneth left around lunchtime, saying he was going to get something to eat. She hadn't seen or heard from him since. I asked her for consent to walk through the house, and she was with me the whole time. I'm looking to see, is there anything, you know,

to indicate that something happened here? Blood? Over turned furniture in her room, any indication of a struggle. Deputies don't find anything suspicious, but after leaving the residence, their concerns linger. I kind of started sounding the alarm with my supervisor that, hey, we don't really have anything concrete to say something happened yet. My gut's telling me something's not right here. Coming up, intimate details of Kenneth's life come to light. Rondo was married and his relationship with Rondo

was not purely platonic. They were romantically linked. From there, the secrets continue to unfold. The only thing I could suspect is that he ran around with her like he ran around with me. After Kenneth McMillion is reported missing on June 16, 2008, Grayson County officials investigated an incident that took place that same day at the home Kenneth used to share with his ex-wife, Patricia. Patricia was there.

The Kenneth score was nowhere inside. I didn't find him up at the house, and we hadn't been able to get ahold of him. We were briefed after deputy chairs went out to the scene, and he was indicating that things didn't seem right. Investigators immediately contact Kenneth's boss at the manufacturing plant. He confirms that Kenneth never showed up for his shift.

His immediate boss had came by and asked me if I had heard from Kenneth or if I knew anything. I told him that he didn't show up and people were concerned already. He said that this was not like Kenneth to miss work. But when investigators speak with Kenneth's co-workers in the days following his disappearance, they learn something unexpected about Rhonda Hudson, the woman who reported Kenneth missing. One of Kenneth's co-workers shared that his relationship with Rhonda, who was married, was not purely platonic. They were romantically linked. A fact Rhonda didn't share when she made the call.

Anytime someone isn't consistent with you, but their stories begin to change, red flags go up on that about, what is it you're trying to hide? Is this simply maybe embarrassment or is this significant in this investigation? With more questions than answers, investigators arrange an interview

with Rhonda and her husband, Phil. With Rhonda and Phil, we're trying to just really understand what that relationship was. The couple explains they took Kenneth in following his split from Patricia. Rhonda and her husband were friends of Kenneth and allowed Kenneth to stay with them while Patricia moved all of her stuff out of the house.

The arrangement had sparked a romance between longtime friends, Kenneth and Rhonda. Kenneth and Rhonda, they were kind of dating basically, even though she was still married. He was staying at that house. Her husband still lived there, and I thought that was kind of an odd situation. But he seemed to be a happier person when he was around her.

Phil tells investigators that he is aware of their relationship, and it is no surprise to him. Phil didn't seem to have any issue with Kenneth having a relationship with Rhonda, even under the same roof. It sounds like the three of them had a great relationship. Rhonda and Phil actually seemed to agree that they were headed their own separate ways. There was no signs of deception,

and she was forthcoming with the information. And she helped us to put the pieces together. With no reason to suspect Phil or Rhonda were involved in Kenneth's disappearance, investigators wrap up their interviews. Investigators ask Patricia to come into the Sheriff's Office and answer a few more questions while they attempt to locate Kennett's vehicle, a 2006 Honda. We learned that Kennett McMillian's vehicle has a GPS-based system on it. Law enforcement can hone in on the signal and it will lead them right to where the vehicle

is located. A hit quickly comes through, but the location comes as a surprise. It was located in Dallas in the parking lot of the Million Dollar Saloon, which is a gentleman's club as it were. As they make the hour drive to Dallas, investigators wonder, did Kenneth simply head out of town to blow off steam? One of the reasons why we went there was because Kenneth McMillian himself could be inside there. It's unknown what a person's thinking sometimes, and they might just want to get away.

and they might just want to get away. At the parking lot, investigators locate Kenneth's empty vehicle. We did not find anything of evidentiary value in the vehicle. We went ahead and notified management who we were, and asked them if they knew who owned the car, seen anybody park the car. We had pictures of Kenneth McMillion and we showed him but they didn't recognize him. Even more puzzling is that footage from cameras inside the club also show no trace of Kenneth? He did not drink, he did not party, he did not hang out at places like that, and nor

would he if you invite him. He wouldn't do that. And for them to say his car was totally left there, I knew that wasn't him. Despite agreeing to answer questions, Patricia fails to show up at the station. Investigators track her down at a local storage unit she secured before moving out of the family home. I'm sure you're busy. You got things you need to do.

We need to follow up on some stuff. Okay. He was supposed to come up to sheriff's office. He got tied up. Because I've been in here looking for Kenneth's records for his relatives. Well, I tell you what, we could probably wait on that. Okay. Where do you think Kenneth is?

I have no idea. I said the only thing I could suspect is that he's running around, he's rung up. I feel like he ran around on me. When we were still married, he would take off in his sleep. Where would he go? I don't have any idea. And he would never tell me. Hoping to gain more background, investigators ask to continue their interview at the station.

Would you feel comfortable coming up to the office? Yes, sir. Finally, at the station, law enforcement conducts an official interview with Patricia. They start by asking her about the argument between Kenneth and Harold Ballard the morning Kenneth went missing. What was Harold's demeanor at that time? Was he a little pissed off? No.

He wasn't? No, he wasn't. Did he say anything to Kenneth at that time? I'm thinking I'd be a little mad. He knew that Kenneth's wanting me out, and he's been hounding me and harassing me to get me out. And then Kenneth throws him off the property, and then that leaves me high and dry. Harold was upset because he couldn't be there

to help Patricia move. Patricia seems certain that Kenneth isn't really missing, that he left by choice. With nothing to hold her on, investigators are forced to let her go. We were concerned that he just didn't want to be found. People sometimes are unpredictable. But before they can dive into that theory, investigators get a phone call

with groundbreaking information. I got a phone call advising they had found Kenneth Mamillion's body in Cameron Parish, Louisiana. In the early 20th century, a seemingly ordinary cook in New York City became the center of a medical mystery and a public health crisis. Hi, I'm Lindsey Graham, the host of Wondry's Podcast American History Tellers. We take you to the events, times, and people that shaped America and Americans, our values, our struggles, and our dreams. In our latest series, we follow the trail of Mary Mallon, an Irish immigrant and cook to wealthy New York families who was unwittingly spreading typhoid fever throughout the city. Public health officials identify her as a healthy carrier of the

disease, meaning that despite showing no symptoms herself, she's been infecting others for years. But when they try to persuade her to submit to testing in isolation, Typhoid Mary will fight back with a vengeance. Follow American history tellers on the Wondery app or wherever you get your podcasts. Experience all episodes ad-free and be the first to binge the newest season only on Wondery Plus. Join Wondery Plus in the Wondery app, Apple Podcasts, or Spotify. Start your free trial today.

Inspired by the hit Wondery podcast Against the Odds comes the gripping guidebook, How to Survive Against the Odds, Tales and Tips for Animal Attacks and Natural Disasters. This might just be the most important book you'll ever read. Go inside life or death situations where everyday people survived nature's most extreme scenarios. And learn how you can too. In these tales, you'll hear about the grit, willpower, and know-how needed to endure shipwrecks, alligator attacks, earthquakes, and more. You'll learn from experts, including top doctors, about what happens to your body and mind in life-threatening situations.

Plus, important tips on what to do, and equally important, what not to do when faced with a situation that is truly against the odds. Go to www.survivalguidebook.com to get your copy of How to Survive Against the Od today. Or visit your favorite bookstore. June 19th, 2008. Three days after the mysterious disappearance of Kenneth McMillion, authorities receive a shocking phone call. Kenneth's body has been found 450 miles away in the Louisiana swamp.

450 miles away in the Louisiana swamp. Cameron Parish Sheriff's Office been notified by some fishermen there was a body in the canal down there. It's very unusual to have someone last seen in Sherman, Texas, a car found in Dallas, Texas, a body found 450 miles away in Louisiana. And so everybody's wondering what happened, who did it? The body was found face down in the marsh.

He wasn't wearing a shirt. He had ropes tied around his feet and it appeared to be a gunshot wound to his back. He had been tied down with blocks, but not well tied, so it had floated up. A person don't normally tie cinder blocks to themselves and then jump in the water. It's hard to shoot yourself in the back.

So they knew there was foul play involved. They were able to identify Kenneth through the use of an orthopedic insert in his shoe. The pathologists were able to recover a 22 round from his back. So now we knew what kind of weapon was used, meaning caliber. Somebody had shot Mr. McMillian and then dumped his body in Louisiana. Grayson County deputies pay a visit to Patricia to deliver the news. We told her that Kenneth's body had been found. I asked Patricia, was there anybody that might hurt Kenneth, or did he have any enemies, and she couldn't come up with Denny. Patricia also has no idea why Kenneth would have been in Louisiana, nor does anyone else who knew

him. He never talked about taking a trip to Louisiana or anything like that. And he wouldn't have gone by himself. That was totally odd. Kenny would not do that. He very straight-laced, go to work, go home, go to work, go home.

With nothing else to go on, investigators follow up on the only lead they have left, Patricia's new flame, Harold Ballard. We had already had our suspicion about Harold Ballard because he had a confrontation with him. When I interviewed Harold Ballard, the body had already been found, and I didn't let him know. I wanted to get him locked into a statement.

Harold admits there was tension between himself and Kenneth the morning Kenneth went missing. He decided he was going to put his finger in my chest. Did he actually make contact with you? Oh, yeah, he did. And what did you do? I told him not to do it. But Harold insists that he wasn't

there to fight with Kenneth. He was there to help Patricia. I know somebody sticks their finger in my chest, I'm not going to be happy. Well, I wasn't happy, but nevertheless, I wasn't there to cause trouble. They asked Harold what he did that morning after he left the McMillian home. He said, hey, after that confrontation, I needed to get out of town. So Harold Bowdert claimed that he had gone to Turner Falls, Oklahoma, and decided to spend the night.

He slept on the side of the road and stuff like that? Yeah, I sure did. OK. Did you make contact with anybody on your trip? I didn't talk to anyone. All I know is what I told you. I haven't saw Mr. McMillan since Monday, the day that I was ordered off the property.

Okay. Investigators take a break from questioning Harold and leave the room. Jesus, is it here? Is it here? Is it here? He says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, he says, Harold go, and they start checking his alibi. On this day in time, one of the best ways to tell where people are is where their phone is. Once we got those records on an emergency type situation, his phone pinged down in Louisiana the night that he said he was in Oklahoma.

So we immediately knew Harold wasn't shooting straight with us. His phone was pinging off a tower 20 miles away from where the body was found. We had his statements, his phone records, the fact that he had had conflict with Kenneth, and the fact that he was one of the last persons to see Mr. McMillan alive. On June 20, investigators place Harold under arrest for the murder of Kenneth McMillion.

Harold and Patricia was out there, and they were playing dominoes, I believe. When we approached him, we advised him he was under arrest. Patricia's reaction attracts attention. Patricia didn't appear to be emotional at all. Wasn't surprised at all. Didn't appear to upset.

Investigators are certain they have the right man, but they wonder, did he work alone? It would be very difficult for one person to dispose of this body, drive it all the way to Louisiana, 400 miles away, and place the car at the Dallas Strip Club. At the same time as the arrest, investigators seize Harold's truck. We had had a search warrant for his pickup truck. And when we seized Harold, we seized his vehicle as well.

They could not find the gun itself, but they did find.22 ammunition in Harold's truck. And they knew it was a.22 that had been fired into Kenneth McMillian's back. But before investigators can question Harold about the bullets, Harold's lawyer reaches out to them. Well, Harold's lawyer contacted us, said that he wanted to talk. At that point, he realized that he was in pretty deep, and it was time to come clean. Coming up...

An unlikely individual helps investigators with a high-stakes stain. Can I tell you this in confidence? Yes. And loyalties begin to crumble. Neither one of us say their name. We just drove in silence. I regret, till today, that I didn't see how desperate she had gotten. On June 20, 2008, investigators arrested Harold Ballard for the shooting death of Kenneth McMillion.

After three weeks behind bars, Harold's claims of innocence appear to waver. His defense attorney said, my guy wants to talk with y'all. Patricia, she was a sweet person from the beginning, but it was a whole different person 20 years later though. I regret still today that I didn't see how desperate she had gotten. It was kind of like the bridge had kind of started to burn

because a real friend would not let another friend take the rap for something they knew they did. A real friend would not let another friend take the rap for something they knew they did. On July 11, Harold meets with investigators. He says that on June 16, he got a call from Patricia just after 9 a.m. A cell phone rang, and that's when I was informed that it was time to go to alligator country. Calling cell phone. When she said we're going to alligator country, did you know what she was talking about? Well, she had talked about she had gotten to the point where she didn't know how much

more she could take. Okay, how would you relate to alligator country to what she said, though? I mean, had she talked about doing something like this prior to that? You know, offhand, and I think she did. Harold said that she had mentioned once before about, it'd be nice if Kenneth disappeared and the alligators ate him.

And what did Patricia say over the phone happened? She said he was dead. Harold immediately drove to the home on Snap Road. I saw that his car was still there and it kind of made me kind of leery. I just stopped about maybe two or three feet away and just looked. And when I looked towards the house, she was standing in the window. I knocked on the door. I asked her where he was.

She said he was around there to the south of the house. I walked around there to see him, and he was sure he was laying face up. Did she say what happened? She never did say. But after looking at him, I gather that she shot him. Harold said they hatched a plan for him to return at night to move Kenneth's body.

We wrapped his body up in some type of heavy plastic, put it in the back of my truck that night. This is around Christmastime, so they cover the back of the pickup truck with Christmas decorations, ornaments, I think a tree. I convinced myself that I was doing the right thing for a friend. But it sounded like, well, you should know better. But I just saw a friend who reached out to me. With Patricia driving Kenneth's Honda and Harold in the truck, they set out for Dallas.

They went up to the Million Dollar Saloon and after she dropped the vehicle off at the Million Dollar Saloon, she got in the truck with him, and they drove to Louisiana. We stopped and found a pretty well-secluded spot before we could back up and, kind of like the other body, push it off the back of the truck. She wanted to use some blocks. So cinder blocks. Tile cinder blocks to his head and to his feet. Was there cinder blocks used?

Yes. They hastily shoved Kenneth's body into the water and headed back to Texas. This whole time, did Patricia talk or say anything? I mean, she just committed murder. No, she didn't say nothing. Matter of fact, neither one of us said anything. We just drove in silence.

I know that now that I shouldn't have done what I've done, but I had nothing to do with Mr. McMillan's death. That's the honest cause true. Harold tells them that after sitting in jail for several weeks, he realized Patricia would gladly let him take the fall. And now that I think about it, I guess I think she was setting me up to be like that. That's right.

I was disappointed. I thought we had a better friendship than that. Investigators believe Harold's story, but in order to arrest Patricia, they will need more. The evidence is starting to be real strong, but Harold Ballard is a co-conspirator. It's his word that she's the one that committed the murder. Then, on July 17th, investigators have a chance meeting with Harold's brother, Joe. I came down one day to visit Harold and one of the detectives on the case.

I wanted to know if I had a few moments for him to talk with me. We tell him the truth that we had taken Harold to Louisiana. He had confessed to his part and asked him if he had made contact with Patricia. Joe said that, yeah, she's actually trying to get a hold on me, and she wants to meet up with me. I knew Patricia through my brother, and they said, well, the only way that we cannot charge your brother for murder is if we get a confession from Patricia.

Authorities asked Joe if he would be willing to help his brother out by meeting up with Patricia and wearing a wire. He agrees. I would never guess that I went undercover to solve a murder, but life has a lot of twists and turns too, and you never know what you're going to be asked to do or what you're going to need to do to help someone that you love.

Joe arranges to meet up with Patricia on the evening of July 19th. Police survey the sting from nearby, but stay out of sight. So I get there, pull in, she gets in on the passenger side. Of course, everything is going through my mind as far as, you know, is there anybody else here with her? Or are we alone? Getting a little nervous but sweating a little bit. I'm in now. I can't, there's nothing I can do now. And I know that the detectives and the Texas Rangers, they are nowhere inside.

I'm on my own. So I kind of turn to her, and we just start talking. It's gone. It's gone. It won't be found? I went and dumped it in Lake Texoma. They have no case. As long as Harold sits over here quiet as a church mouse, they don't have a case. So you know I'm not gonna get any sleep tonight, but now I got to wrestle with this. I need to know is there anything that's gonna come up. Can I tell you this in company? Yes. Kenneth was just there by himself, with me. I will and I shall. I would have never dreamed that I would even go this far. I would have never dreamed in my Christian life that this would have ever happened. Del Ballard was able to steer the conversation toward what he knew that we had to have in

that recording, and that was that she pulled the trigger and that Harold wasn't there. Coming up, authorities are ready to make their move. We set up all night, making sure that she didn't leave. But will Patricia's shocking accusations derail the case? She was afraid for her life. There was some sort of a scuffle. A little over a month after Kenneth McMillian disappeared, investigators are finally ready

to arrest his ex-wife Patricia McMillian for his murder. After the wiretap, we knew that she had went back to Snap Road, and we set up all night making sure that she didn't leave. Typing warrants, it takes a lot of time. We wanted everything right. Now we arrested her the very next day. Patricia's daughter started off with us somewhat resistant to the idea that her mother had killed her father.

But ultimately the evidence was overwhelming to the point that her mother had killed her father. But ultimately, the evidence was overwhelming to the point where she understood. In June of 2009, the case goes to trial. Prosecutors paint Patricia as a murderer driven by rage. Patricia didn't like the outcome of the divorce. She was still bitter that she had to move out of the house. I think that it was simply anger and a woman who felt like she needed to get even.

But Patricia takes the stand and counters with an explosive claim. Patricia gave testimony that she had suffered abuse from Kenneth McMillan. Verbal abuse, she felt he was controlling, she even alleged physical abuse. Patricia claims that on the morning of the murder, she and Kenneth got into an argument that turned physical. She painted the picture that she was afraid for her life, that she had the 22, and that there

was some sort of a scuffle. Prosecutors asked Patricia to demonstrate how the incident led to her shooting Kenneth in the back. I had a toy gun that I had bought. And I gave her the toy gun and got her down off the stand. So I want you to take the jury through how this murder went down. And we actually got down on the floor with her

kind of on top of me. And she stuck that gun in my back and started pulling the trigger. Click, click, click. Tenet was pretty riveting to see her in the courtroom well, wrestling with the prosecutor and ultimately showing her made-up version of how she shot Kenneth. It was riveting but unconvincing. Patricia's defense unravels. Not only did she shoot him in the back, at fairly close range,

then when you go hauling the body down like they did in dumping it, most people who act in self-defense don't do that. The daughter testified there was not abuse going on in the home. No one else indicated any abuse. No co-workers ever saw any bruises on her, heard her complain about the husband. So her claim that this was necessary to prevent further domestic violence was simply false. was necessary to prevent further domestic violence was simply false. On June 10, 2009, the jury returns a verdict.

Well, the jury listened to this evidence and they were not convinced of Patricia's self-defense story and they convicted her and sentenced her to 80 years in prison. In August 2009, Harold takes a plea deal. He receives a reduced sentence, 10 years of probation in exchange for helping prosecutors. The truth will set you free, even though I make some dumb mistakes. If I could rewrite the part of that life,

I would rewrite it a whole lot different. Definitely do it a lot different, that's for sure. The judge is, I sentenced you to seven years in prison. I'm going to probate or suspend that to 10 years probation. But if he messed up his probation and we revoked him, he could get up to seven years in prison. For Kenneth's friends and family, the end of the trial marks the beginning

of a different but still painful era. There was no closure for the friends, the family, anybody who knew Kenneth McMillan. Why didn't she just plain walk away? That wasn't the Patricia I knew. That was a woman that was full of hate, and only God knows why. She was very much controlling Kenneth most of his life.

And I think that him making a choice to take his life in a different direction broke that control that she had over him and I don't think she knew how to handle that. The number one victim is their daughter. Not only did she lose a father, she's lost her mother. Kenneth was just an overall good person, so the world lost at goodness. That is sad, because the world could be much better with more people like him in the world.

Patricia McMillion is serving an 80-year sentence at Carroll Young Complex in Texas. Hey, I'm Cassie DePeckel, the host of Wander E's podcast Against the Odds. In each episode, we share thrilling true stories of survival, putting you in the shoes of the people who live to tell the tale. In our next season, it's August 3, 1991. A Greek cruise ship, the Oceanos, sets sail into a brutal storm off South Africa's wild coast. Soon after, disaster strikes. A breach in the hull knocks out power and floods the ship, but instead of helping, the senior officers abandon their posts. With no leadership, the entertainers

must step up and lead a desperate evacuation to save hundreds of lives before the ship sinks beneath the sea. Follow Against the Odds on the Wondery app or wherever you get your podcasts. Binge the entire season ad-free right now only on Wondery+. Start your free trial in the Wondery app, Apple Podcasts, or Spotify today.