Solved Murders - True Crime Stories - The Mysterious Death of Mika Miller Faith, Abuse, and the Secrets Behind 911 Call PART5 #77

Episode Date: November 15, 2025

#horrorstories #reddithorrorstories #ScaryStories #creepypasta #horrortales #truecrime #darkmystery #hiddenabuse #toxicfaith #unsolvedtruths  Part 5 of the Mika Miller story digs even deeper into the unanswered questions surrounding her death. This section uncovers more about the web of abuse, religious control, and secrecy that shaped her final days. The echoes of the 911 call still linger, raising doubts about what really happened behind closed doors. With chilling revelations and disturbing truths, this chapter highlights the lasting impact of fear, silence, and manipulation, making Mika’s story both tragic and unforgettable.  horrorstories, reddithorrorstories, scarystories, horrorstory, creepypasta, horrortales, mikaMillerStory, mysterydeath, truecrimefiles, chillingsecrets, 911callmystery, toxicfaith, hiddenabuse, disturbingtruths, unsolvedmystery, psychologicalmanipulation, darkrelationships, hauntingcase, tragicending, realhorrorstories

The Dark Truth Behind John Paul When Mika's death hit the news, it should have been the end of the story. At least, that's what John Paul wanted everyone to believe. But for Mika's family and friends, it didn't feel like closure. It felt unfinished, like the book had been slammed shut in the middle of the scariest chapter. Something way darker had gone down that day, and they weren't buying the self-inflicted tragedy explanation. By that point, Mika was finally pulling away. She was in the middle of a separation, she had started speaking openly about abuse, and she was

slowly rebuilding her life outside of her toxic marriage. She wasn't perfect, sure, but she was fighting for freedom. And that terrified John Paul, the man she had married, the man she had reported over and over, the man she had exposed on social media as manipulative, controlling, and abusive. So, the real question lingered like smoke in the air, who was John Paul, really? What kind of man had Mika been married to all those years? A funeral that felt like a comedy show. A month after Mika's death, in May 24, John Paul organized a memorial service in her name.

On paper, it should have been heartbreaking, a place for people to cry, hug, and say goodbye. But those who actually showed up left with a bitter taste in their mouths. Instead of grief, what they got felt more like a badly scripted performance. First off, Mika's parents weren't there. They wanted nothing to do with John Paul's show. They held their own private ceremony, quietly saying goodbye to their daughter without his shadow looming over them. But those who did go, they couldn't believe what they were hearing.

The pastor, yes, the same John Paul who had been accused of controlling and belittling his wife, stood up and started talking about their marriage. But instead of sharing sweet stories, he listed their problems, the things they didn't like about each other. Imagine that. At your wife's funeral, you're basically saying, well, she wasn't perfect either. Then, as if that wasn't enough, he told the congregation that he had visited Meekha's body four times at the morgue. Not just to pray, but to actually, talk to her. At one point, he even admitted he tried to resurrect her, and then laughed about it.

People sat there frozen, staring at him, wondering if they had just witnessed a pastor lose his grip on reality, or if this was who he really had been all along. It was bizarre, uncomfortable, and honestly insulting. But if you knew John Paul's track record, it wasn't surprising at all. Sermons drenched in misogyny. See, John Paul's church sermons were legendary, but not in a good way. People didn't remember them because they felt inspired. They remembered them because they left feeling slapped in the face. He had a way of turning God's word into a weapon, and women were almost always the target.

At one point, he gave a whole talk about how you can tell if a woman is easy, just by looking at the clothes she wears. Another time, he justified men watching porn, saying it was better than having to deal with a nagging wife. And if that wasn't insulting enough, he told women in the congregation that they needed to, stop whining, and be more generous, basically, give their husbands whatever they wanted, so they wouldn't be tempted by demons on the internet. He didn't stop there. He also said most gossip comes from women and that their biggest flaw was their mouth. Meanwhile, men, according to him, were simple creatures who only thought about six things, sleep, food, money, work, sex, and God. Women, on the other hand, he claimed, overthought everything and made unnecessary problems that ruined marriages. This wasn't just casual sexism.

It was a pattern. And when you mix that kind of thinking with power, manipulation, and a pulpit, you get a a very dangerous cocktail. A past stained with violence. Even though John Paul wasn't officially charged with anything related to Mika's death, the spotlight swung directly onto him. And once people started digging, his past came crawling out of the shadows. Back in 1999, he was charged with assault after allegedly hitting a woman with his car and dragging

her down the street. On top of that, his record was littered with DUIs, driving under the influence. Alcohol, aggression, and recklessness were nothing new for him. But it didn't stop there. Old whispers resurfaced, and they painted an even uglier picture. According to his ex-wife and other women who had been close to him, John Paul was addicted to pornography and frequently paid women for sex. Even more disturbing, during his time as a youth leader in the church, he allegedly

took advantage of underage girls who looked up to him as a pastor. One woman, who had been with him before he married Allison, came forward publicly on Facebook. She explained that when she got involved with him, she was still a minor. John Paul was 19, and instead of protecting her, he used his position to control her. She made it clear she wasn't the only one. It had happened before, and it would probably happen again. What's interesting is how this all tied back to Allison, John Paul's ex-wife. Remember, she and Mika had a surprisingly good relationship, despite the whole messy love triangle

and betrayal. But when Allison found out Mika had died, her entire outlook on custody shifted. Suddenly, she was fighting for full custody of the children she had with John Paul. To her, it wasn't just about parenting anymore, it was about safety. Something about Mika's death made Allison realize she couldn't trust him. If even the woman he supposedly loved had ended up dead under such suspicious circumstances, what kind of danger did that put their kids in? The irony. Allison felt safer knowing her ex-husband's mistress, Mika, was around. That's how much John Paul terrified her. Public breakdowns But Allison's fear wasn't just based on rumors.

She had seen firsthand what John Paul was like when he spiraled. When they were together, he did the same things he later did to Mika. He stalked her, harassed her, and refused to let her go. There's one incident that stands out, something so shocking it was caught on video by a neighbor. One day, John Paul showed up at Allison's house completely out of his mind. He had clearly been using substances, because he could barely stand. He collapsed on the ground in front of her house, slurring his words, crying, and muttering that he was, going to see Jesus. He kept saying he felt ants crawling all over his body, scratching himself as if bugs were eating him alive.

People passing by saw him lying there, helpless and broken. A neighbor even asked him if he was okay, if it was his medication, but he couldn't even form a cold. coherent answer. It was humiliating, disturbing, and terrifying all at once. And yet, even after being caught on camera like that, John Paul always tried to flip the narrative. According to him, it was never his problem. It was always the women. He painted Allison as unstable, Mika as an addict, and any other woman in his orbit as the one with mental issues. Meanwhile, he kept playing the role of the victim, the misunderstood pastor, the man everyone else was supposedly out to get. John Paul wasn't just toxic. He was dangerous. And by the time Mika's life ended, the people

who loved her knew one thing for sure, the story wasn't over. Not even close. To be continued.