Solved Murders - True Crime Stories - The Robbery That Wasn't A 3AM Encounter with the World's Most Polite Thief #50

Episode Date: August 5, 2025

#horrorstories #reddithorrorstories #ScaryStories #creepypasta #horrortales #robbery #politecriminal #nightencounter #mystery #unexpectedevents  At 3AM, a tense situation unfolds when the narrator faces what seems like a robbery. But the thief’s unusually polite behavior and unexpected actions twist the night into a mysterious and unforgettable experience. This story explores unexpected human behavior, suspense, and the eerie feeling of things not being what they seem.  horrorstories, reddithorrorstories, scarystories, horrorstory, creepypasta, horrortales, robbery, politecriminal, nightencounter, mysterytale, unexpectedevent, suspense, strangerstory, creepyencounter, unnervingexperience, nightdrama, humanoddity, thriller, urbanlegend, chillingstory

There's so much rugby on Sports Extra from Sky. They've asked me to read the whole lad at the same speed I usually use for the legal bit at the end. Here goes. This winter Sports Extra is jam-packed with rugby. For the first time we've got every Champions Cup match exclusively live, plus action from the URC, the Challenge Cup, and much more. Thus the URC and all the best European rugby all in the same place.

Get more exclusively live tournaments than ever before on Sports Extra. Jampack with rugby. Phew, that is a lot of rugby. Get Sports Extra on Sky for 15 euro a month for 12 months. Search Sports Extra. New Sports Extra customers only. Standard Pressing applies after 12 months for the terms apply. Don't let foot pain or discomfort hold you back.

At foot Solutions, we specialize in high-quality supportive footwear. And use the latest scanning technology to custom-make orthotics, designed for your unique feet. If you want to free your feet in joints from pain, improve balance or correct alignment, book a free foot assessment at footsolutions.com.com. Or pop-in store today. Foot Solutions, the first step towards pain-free feet. All right, so buckle up. because what I'm about to tell you sounds fake as hell,

but I swear on my last slice of frozen pizza it actually happened. Let me take you through the strangest, most awkward, broke person encounter I've ever lived through, and yes, it involves a robbery, sort of. So, it's like 3.17 a.m., I know this because I checked the time later in total disbelief, and I'm dead asleep, dreaming about something dumb, probably tacos or being rich.

You know, the usual. Anyway, I get jolted awake by this weird, rustling sound. Now, I live alone, and I sure as hell wasn't expecting a visitor, especially not one going through my stuff like he paid rent. So I blink myself halfway conscious and shuffle into my living room. And there he is. This dude, random, disheveled, looking like he crawled out of a thrift store donation bin, digging through my coffee table drawer like he was on a scavenger hunt. Now, you'd think the normal reaction would be, I don't know, screaming.

Calling 911. Swinging a lamp. But nah. My half-functioning, broke brain processed none of that. I just stood there, scratching my head and said, as calmly as if I was asking about the weather, Yo, you looking for money too? I'm not even exaggerating. I said it like we were teammates on a mission called Operation, Find Rent.

And the best part? It worked. It broke his brain for a second. This guy, in full robbing mode, hoodie, gloves, shifty eyes, actually paused. He looked up at me, confused, like I had just broken into his house. We're just standing there now, both broke as hell, both confused, both trying to figure out who made the first mistake. So then he hits me with, you got any cash. and I, being the tragically honest mess I am, say, bro.

I live here and I've been asking myself that same question every damn day. We locked eyes for a second. No tension. No fight or flight. Just this mutual recognition of defeat. Two dudes who had somehow met at the crossroads of Rock Bottom, staring at each other like life glitched and merged our save files. The robber, and I'm using that word losing, at this point, actually drops his shoulders. Like all the criminal energy just left his body.

He takes a breath, walks over to my crusty couch, which, let's be real, has more stains than actual color left, and just sits down. What do you do for work, he asks? I blinked. You mean like, when I had work or the pretend stuff I tell people at parties? He chuckled. Legit chuckled. And that's when I knew this was no ordinary robbery. This was something else. We started talking. Like, full-on life chat at 3.30 in the morning. I told him about my garbage job, how my boss laid me off because the company was restructuring,

Reed, replacing us with unpaid interns, how my fridge contained exactly one bottle of mustard and some expired almond milk, and how I'd been living off noodles and regret. He told me he used to work security, the irony, but got fired after a messy breakup, spiraled a bit, and somehow ended up robbing strangers with zero actual plan. Apparently, I was his first target. Congratulations to me, I guess. Then, and I swear this is where it gets next level bizarre, he reaches into his pocket, pulls out this sad, crumpled $50 bill and just hands it to me. Here, man, he says. You need this more than I do.

I stared at it. I stared at him. My mouth opened, closed, opened again. I felt like I just unlocked a hidden achievement in the game of life. Like, achievement unlocked, receive pity cash from your own robber. I sat down across from him, holding the bill like it was made of gold, and for a second we just sat there, two strangers bonding over mutual brokeness and life failure. There was this strange piece.

Like, the universe paused just long enough to let two random losers catch their breath. And then, just when I thought this was going to end with some kind of bromance or we start a podcast together, vibe. He stands up. Looks me dead in the eyes. Snatches the $50 right back out of my hands. Now I've officially robbed you. And he walks out. No sprint, no panic.

just a casual stroll into the night like he was the main character in some indie film and me I didn't chase him I didn't call the... There's so much rugby on Sports Extra from Sky they've asked me to read the whole lad at the same speed I usually use for the legal bit at the end.

Here goes. This winter sports extra is jam-packed with rugby. For the first time we've got every Champions Cup match exclusively live, plus action from the URC, the Challenge Cup and much more. Thus the URC and all the best European Rugby all in the same place. Get more exclusively live tournaments than ever before on Sports Extra. Jampacked with rugby. That is a lot of rugby.

Get Sports Extra on Sky for 15 euro a month for 12 months. Search Sports Extra. New Sports Extra customers only. Standard Pressing applies after 12 months for the terms apply. Don't let foot pain or discomfort hold you back. At foot solutions, we specialize in high-quality supportive footwear. And use the latest scanning technology to custom-make orthotics. Designed for your unique feet.

If you want to free your feet in joints from pain, improve balance or correct alignment, book a free foot assessment at foot solution. Are Popping Store today. Foot Solutions, the first step towards pain-free feet. Pops. I didn't even lock the door, which I should have done, let's be honest. I just sat there, blinking, trying to understand how I had just experienced a reverse robbery, a temporary donation, and a philosophy lecture all in one weird 20-minute span.

Over the next couple days, I told a few friends about it, and every single one of them thought I was joking. My roommate, who wasn't home that night, laughed so hard he nearly dropped his ramen. My mom told me I need to move out of the city. My ex said this kind of thing could only happen to me. She's not wrong. But here's the wildest part, that night kind of changed me. Like, not in a spiritual, I found myself way, but more like I hit a checkpoint in the game of life where the developers were clearly trolling me. I started thinking about how broken both of us were in that moment, and how two people at their worst still managed to find some strange, dumb connection. And yeah, I'm still broke, still unemployed, fridge still depressingly empty.

But now, whenever I'm feeling like a total disaster, I remember that night. That moment when I became a character in someone else's bizarre story, and they in mine. So, T-L-D-R, I got robbed, kind of. The robber gave me a $50 bill out of sympathy, then took it back just to make the robbery official. We shared a weirdly deep conversation about life and ended the encounter with him walking out like he just won an Oscar. And honestly, I still don't know if I lost money, gained perspective, or just got emotionally mugged. But one thing's For sure, my life's definitely not boring. The end.