Solved Murders - True Crime Stories - We Heard a Baby Crying Outside at Midnight… But It Wasn’t What It Seemed at All #52

Episode Date: September 4, 2025

#horrorstories #reddithorrorstories #ScaryStories #creepypasta #horrortales #midnighteerie #babycrying #unexpectedhorror #mysterysound #nightterror  On a quiet midnight, the unsettling sound of a baby crying outside shattered the silence. But as the story unfolds, the truth behind the cries is far more disturbing than anyone could have imagined. This chilling tale reveals how appearances can deceive and how the darkest secrets often hide behind the most innocent sounds. Prepare for a suspenseful journey where fear lurks just beyond the doorstep.  horrorstories, reddithorrorstories, scarystories, horrorstory, creepypasta, horrortales, midnightterror, mysteriouscrying, eerieencounter, supernaturalhorror, unexpectedtwist, darksecret, chillingmystery, hauntednight, fearinthedark, unsettlingnoise, nightfrights, suspensefiction, unknownpresence, creepingfear

There's so much rugby on Sports Extra from Sky. They've asked me to read the whole lad at the same speed I usually use for the legal bit at the end. Here goes. This winter Sports Extra is jam-packed with rugby. For the first time we've got every Champions Cup match exclusively live, plus action from the URC, the Challenge Cup, and much more. Thus the URC and all the best European rugby all in the same place.

Get more exclusively live tournaments than ever before on Sports Extra. Jampack with rugby. Phew, that is a lot of rugby. Get Sports Extra on Sky for 15 euro a month for 12 months. Search Sports Extra. New Sports Extra customers only. Standard Pressing applies after 12 months for their terms apply. Ireland's largest award-winning light show experience is back.

Wonderlights is now open in three spectacular locations, Malahide Castle and Gardens, and Marley Park in Dublin and photo house in Cork. Follow the enchanting walking trail that will captivate all ages as the night comes alive with dazzling displays and unforgettable moments. Who will you Wonderlights with? For dates and bookings, visit wonderlights.io. All right, buckle up, because I'm about to share something that still creeps me out years later. This happened back when I was somewhere between 10 and 13 years old, and even though my

memories fuzzy on the details, the general vibe of the night is still etched in my brain like it happened yesterday. So, at the time, I shared a room with my sister. We were pretty close in age, so it made sense, and yeah, we shared a bed too. Don't judge, we had a decent setup and made it work. Anyway, our bedtime routine usually included whispering about random stuff, like, laughing about school, or arguing over who gets the blanket. But this night?

This night hit different. It was pretty late, probably around 11 or maybe midnight. I say, probably, because we didn't have a clock in the room, and even if we did, I doubt I would have checked it. Everything was just, weird. We were still awake, just talking about whatever, when we suddenly heard this sound. At first, I thought I was just imagining things. It was faint, like it was coming from far away, but it was unmistakable. A baby.

Crying. I remember stopping mid-sentence and just lying there in total silence. My sister was quiet too. We both froze. Then I turned my head slowly and asked her, do you hear that? She blinked at me, a little confused at first, then said, yeah. What, what is that? We both just stared at each other for a moment, not saying anything.

The sound was still going. It wasn't like regular baby crying. It was eerie, like someone was playing a recording of a baby crying on repeat. But we were kids. We didn't think like that. We just assumed our parents had a movie on or something. Maybe they were watching a horror flick or some sad documentary. Probably just the TV, I said.

She nodded. We wanted to believe that. But deep down, I think we both knew something felt off. Time got weird after that. Like, I couldn't tell if it had been ten minutes or thirty. We didn't dare move. Neither of us even peeked out the window. We were scared stiff.

My body felt like it was made of lead. We just lay there, listening to that baby crying, over and over again. Eventually, it stopped. Just, cut off. No fade out. No change in tone. Just silence. That might have been the creepiest part of it all. After that, we fell asleep. Don't ask me how. Maybe we were exhausted. Maybe our brains just gave up trying to process what was going on. But we eventually passed out. The next morning, the very first thing, I did was look at my sister. I didn't say good morning. I didn't stretch or yawn. I just asked, did that really happen? She looked at me dead serious. Yeah. I remember. I kept checking in with her about it for days, maybe even weeks. I had to make sure it wasn't just a weird dream I cooked up. But no, she always said the same thing. She remembered it. Still does. Now, fast forward to the present.

I'm older now. Got a bit more internet access, a little more knowledge about the world, and a whole lot more paranoia. I've read about these weird kidnapping tactics some creep's use. Playing sounds, like a crying baby, outside someone's window to lure them out. And now I can't stop wondering, was that what was going on? I mean, seriously, what if we had gotten out of bed? What if one of us had peeked through the window?

What if we'd gone to our parents and they had gone outside to check it out? I get chills thinking about how close we might have come to something horrible. But there's more. I started second-guessing everything. Like, was it really something sinister? Could it have just been an animal? People on the internet say that red foxes can make noises that sound like screaming or crying. I didn't even consider that at the time.

But even now, that explanation doesn't totally sit right with me. First off, we live in a pretty suburban neighborhood. Not super rural, but not quite city either. It's the kind of place where everyone knows which dogs belong to which yard, and we'd never heard a fox before, or since. I did some digging, and while red foxes do exist in my state, they're super rare in our area. Like, never seen one in my life kind of rare. Also, and this is important, the crying didn't sound wild.

It didn't sound like something natural. It sounded mechanical. Like a loop. You know how when a baby cries, there's variation. Sometimes it's loud, sometimes it's more of a whimper, sometimes they suck in a breath. Yeah, this wasn't like that. This was the same sound, over and over. Too consistent.

Too clean. Too unnatural. That's why I couldn't shake the feeling that it was a recording. Like someone hit, play, on a creepy baby soundboard and left it running under our window. And that makes it so much worse, because it means someone had to be there to do that. And I hate thinking about what their intentions might have been. Over the years, I told a few people about this. Some of them shrugged it off.

Probably a cat, they'd say. Could have been a sick raccoon or something. Maybe. I mean, we do have some stray cats in the area, three that I know of. But I've heard them fight, meow, scream, and do all the other weird things cats do at night. None of them sound like what we heard. One person even tried to gaslight me into thinking it was a dream. Like, are you sure you didn't just imagine it?

Yeah, pretty sure. Not only do I remember it clearly, but so does my sister. We both heard it. We both froze. We both stayed silent. We both talked about it the next morning. To this day, I still don't know what it was. And that not knowing, it gets under your skin.

It's like having an itch you can't scratch. Every time I hear a baby cry now, even if it's just from a TV show, I get that same uncomfortable feeling in my chest. That uneasy, paranoid kind of dread that takes you back to when you were just a kid trying to fall asleep and the world suddenly felt dangerous. Maybe it was some creep testing out a tactic. Maybe it was a prank that almost went way too far. Maybe it was some weird animal and I've just been overthinking it for years.

Who knows? But here's the thing, if you ever hear something outside your window late at night, something that doesn't quite sit right, something that makes the hairs on your arms stand up. Trust that instinct. Don't go investigate. Don't be the main character in a horror movie. Be the one who stays in bed and lives to tell the story years later. Even now, writing this, I keep looking over my shoulder.

It's dumb, I know. I'm safe. Nothing's going to jump out of my closet. But that memory, it's sticky. It clings to you. And maybe that's the scariest part. Not the sound. Not the mystery.

But the fact that there are some things you never really get answers to. Some experiences just haunt you because they don't make sense. They don't tie up nicely with a bow. They don't offer closure. They just sit in the back of your brain, waiting, watching, reminding you that the world is a lot weirder, and a lot darker, than you'd like to believe. So yeah, that's my story. Still gives me goosebumps. Still makes me wonder. And I guess, in a way, I'm glad it happened. Because now I'm the kind of person who double-checks, who listens to gut instincts, who doesn't write things off

as just a sound. And if you've made it this far into my rambling, then maybe you'll remember this too. Maybe next time you hear something strange in the night, you'll think twice. And honestly, that might just save your life. The end.