Something You Should Know - SYSK Choice: A Brief History of Motion & The Right Ways to Speak Up
Episode Date: October 7, 2023Have you heard of the Pink Tax? It’s when the women’s version of a product (like razors) costs more than men’s even though they are the same – except maybe the packaging and the color. It hap...pens with a whole host of products from children’s toys to clothes to deodorant and yes, razors. Listen to hear why this “tax” exists and why women might be smart to pick the men’s version of the same thing instead. https://www.voanews.com/a/usa_all-about-america_does-pink-tax-force-women-pay-more-men/6177789.html We like to get around. People like to go places . Whether it’s to go to the store or on vacation or to work or to grandma’s house, we like to be mobile. For thousands of years, humans have tried to find faster and more efficient ways to get from Point A to Point B. Listen to my guest, Tom Standage as he explains the fascinating history of human transportation and how it is changing in a major way right now . In fact, he reveals why one of the latest and most significant innovations in transportation today is the smartphone! Tom is deputy editor of The Ecomomist – and author of A Brief History of Motion: From the Wheel to the Car, to What Comes Next (https://amzn.to/3A8G2s9). You have probably been in a situation where you thought about speaking up and saying something, but you held back, even though you knew you had something important to contribute. If that has happened to you, I want you to listen to my guest, Mary Nestor. Mary is a communications expert, award-winning speaker, business consultant, and author of the book Say It Now! Say It Right (https://amzn.to/39Mybpe) She joins me to explain how to muster up the courage and the words to speak up when you have something important to say. Do you know what a burglar looks like? Would you know one if you saw one? Most of them don’t look like the ones in the movies. Listen as I explain what burglars really look like, how they operate, what they are looking for and how you should protect yourself. Source: Richard T. Wright, author of Burglars on the Job (https://amzn.to/3utSXmU) PLEASE SUPPORT OUR SPONSORS! PrizePicks is a skill-based, real-money Daily Fantasy Sports game. You pick 2-6 players and if they will go more or less than their PrizePicks projection. It's that simple! Go to https://prizepicks.com/sysk and use code sysk for a first deposit match up to $100 With HelloFresh, you get farm-fresh, pre-portioned ingredients and seasonal recipes delivered right to your doorstep. Go to https://HelloFresh.com/50something and use code 50something for 50% off plus free shipping! BetterHelp is truly the best way to make your brain your friend. Give it a try. Visit https://BetterHelp.com/Something today to get 10% off your first month! Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Transcript
Discussion (0)
The search for truth never ends.
Introducing June's Journey, a hidden object mobile game with a captivating story.
Connect with friends, explore the roaring 20s, and enjoy thrilling activities and challenges
while supporting environmental causes.
After seven years, the adventure continues with our immersive travels feature.
Explore distant cultures and engage in exciting experiences.
There's always something new to discover.
Are you ready?
Download June's Journey now on Android or iOS.
Today on Something You Should Know,
why do some women's products cost more than men's for the same thing?
Then, the fascinating history of personal transportation,
getting people from point A to point B in a speedy fashion.
In fact, people were worried about the effects of speed. They thought, well, our brains stop working.
And so there are these experiments that are done in the 1830s where, you know, they put passengers
on trains and they make them do things like crossword puzzles to see if their brains still
work properly at the unheard of speed of 35 miles per hour. Also, what does a burglar look like?
Would you know one if you saw one?
And getting the courage to speak up,
say your piece and be heard.
It's important.
Think of all the opportunities that are lost.
All the great ideas that never are said
and never worked on and never come to fruition
because somebody is reluctant to speak up.
All this today on Something You Should Know. never come to fruition because somebody is reluctant to speak up.
All this today on Something You Should Know.
This winter, take a trip to Tampa on Porter Airlines.
Enjoy the warm Tampa Bay temperatures and warm Porter hospitality on your way there.
All Porter fares include beer, wine, and snacks,
and free fast-streaming Wi-Fi on planes with no middle seats. And your Tampa Bay vacation includes good times,
relaxation, and great Gulf Coast weather. Visit flyporter.com and actually enjoy economy.
Something you should know. Fascinating intel. The world's top experts.
And practical advice you can use in your life.
Today, Something You Should Know with Mike Carruthers.
Hi, welcome to Something You Should Know.
Have you heard of the pink tax?
It's where women pay more than men for what appears to be the same product.
In a survey of drugstore products like shampoo, shaving cream, razor blades, and deodorant,
many products seemed identical, but they had very different prices.
And the only difference was that one product was for women and the other was for men.
And almost always, the women's products were more
expensive, sometimes a lot more expensive. But it's not just personal care items. A few years
ago, the New York City Department of Consumer Affairs analyzed almost 800 items in 35 product
categories, and they found that the items for female consumers cost more than
the products for men in 30 of those 35 categories.
For example, in the category of toys and accessories, the same toys for girls were 7% more than
the same toys for boys.
In children's clothing, girls' clothes were 4% more than boys. In adult clothing,
women's clothes were overall 8% more than men's. And in that category of personal care items,
women's products were 13% more than men's for the same product. Compare for yourself the next time
you're at the store, and if you're a woman, you may find yourself buying men's razors and shaving cream and deodorant
to avoid the pink tax.
And that is something you should know.
There's a pretty good chance when you got up this morning,
part of your plan was to go somewhere else.
Because that's what humans do. We like to move. Sometimes
we have to move to go to work or go to the store or we go out for fun or go on vacation.
We move around a lot. It wasn't always that way. I mean, if it weren't for the wheel,
you wouldn't go many places. And we've come a long way since the invention of the wheel.
And so how will we get to places in the future?
The evolution of personal transportation is really interesting and something Tom Standage has studied.
Tom is deputy editor of The Economist.
He's author of six previous books and his latest is called A Brief History of Motion, From the Wheel to the Car to What Comes Next.
Hey, Tom, welcome.
It's great to be here.
So this topic of transportation, it's really one of those topics that dominates our lives, and yet we don't think about it too much.
We want to go somewhere, we just hop in a car, get on a bike, go on a train,
and off we go. It's just part of our lives. We don't really think much about how we got here.
So why do you think it's important that we understand this now?
What I was particularly struck by, reading about the history of transport and the history of cars,
and I've always been really into cars, was the familiarity and
the similarity of the 1890s to the situation that we have today.
So essentially in the 1890s in the big, fast-expanding cities of the Western world, places like London
and New York, it was becoming apparent that the dominant means of urban transport, which
was based around horses, was becoming unsustainable.
Things had to change, but no one was quite sure what would come next. I think we're in a similar
position today. We've recognized that cars are not sustainable environmentally, and we've given half
of the area of most cities over to roads and parking and space for cars. There's a growing
recognition that we can't go on this way.
So we've got to do something different, but it's not quite clear what.
So I would imagine that as you look at the timeline of transportation, the point at which
the wheel shows up has to be like the big thing. I mean, because without the wheel,
not much is going to change. So is that the case?
Well, we think of the wheel as a sort invention in history, it's quite often called,
because we are surrounded by wheeled vehicles. We use them of one kind or another probably every
day. And whether it's a train or a bike or a car, we're used to a world of wheels. And this is
actually quite recent. Although the wheel was invented more than 5,000 years ago, it was invented about 35, 3600 BCE, most people didn't get to go on
wheeled vehicles. They were very, very big. They were very expensive. And they weren't personal
transport devices. The first ones were probably built to move ore, copper ore, around in copper
mines. So it looks as though the first wheels arose in
Eastern Europe in a region called the Carpathian Mountains. And the idea of the wheel does spread
quite quickly. It spreads to Mesopotamia, so what's modern day Iraq. But even in Mesopotamia,
it was just sort of the kings who would go on these wheeled vehicles that were sort of, you
know, for ceremonial purposes. They might use them as observation platforms in battle.
But wheeled vehicles in those days, they had these big, big, thick, heavy wheels.
You couldn't steer them. They were very slow moving.
And so, you know, it wasn't something that most people would ever use as a means of transport.
Most people would still have to walk.
And in fact, most people have walked for most of history.
And it's only very, very recently that wheeled vehicles have proliferated.
And we've come to the idea that sort of wheels are an obvious thing in retrospect.
But that hasn't always been the case.
And my favorite example of this is the Egyptians.
The Egyptians managed to build the pyramids entirely without using wheels.
And it's only when the people to the north of them, the Hittites, invent the war chariot and start conquering big chunks of the Middle East that the Egyptians
suddenly wake up and go, okay, we got to find out about wheels. It surprises me when the wheel
showed up, light bulbs didn't go off everywhere. Like, hey, my God, this is fabulous. We can, but it didn't.
It didn't catch on for the longest time.
And I guess partly because of the way wheels were made.
But you would think that somebody would have gone,
hey, wait a minute.
Well, it was very complicated to make the first wheels
of the first vehicles.
I mean, you needed to, you know,
basically chop up pieces of wood.
And in these days, people didn't have
tools because you had to make tools out of metal and they were only just figuring out
how to make stuff out of metal. If you remember the opening sequence of the Flintstones,
the wheels in the Flintstones, and the idea that a lot of people have about the origin of the wheels
is that someone sawed a slice off a log and that would give you a wheel, right? Only the problem
is the saw isn't invented until about 2000 years after the wheel, because it's much harder to make a saw. So early wheels were not made by chopping
slices off logs. They were made by splitting logs and sticking them together in planks.
And this is all complicated stuff. And then building a whole vehicle around them. This
is something that would take people a long time. So yeah, when people saw wheels, they'd
go, wow, that's really awesome. But they weren't in a position to make their own wheels or
have their own wheels. Well, in addition to the wheel being a game
changer in terms of transportation, I would imagine the horse has got to be up there pretty
close to the top of the list as well. Again, the horse kind of shows up a bit later than you might
think. So the first wheeled vehicles that are pulled by animals are pulled by oxen. And the Mesopotamian vehicles that we see are pulled by these, they're called onagas.
They're sort of like a bit like donkeys, but they're smaller.
And then the war chariot is, you know, they start to pull those using horses.
And that means that they can suddenly go a lot faster.
And so war chariots are interesting.
They've got two wheels so you can steer them easily because you just steer the horse, basically.
You don't have this problem with a four-wheeled vehicle where you have to be able to turn some of the wheels sideways.
And war chariots also had spoked wheels, so they were much, much lighter.
But that also meant they were really complicated to make.
And if you look in Tutankhamen's tomb, he was buried with a chariot, very, very lightweight, 35 kilograms,
big spoked wheels. It's like the Ferrari of its day. I mean, it would have required skilled artisans a very long time to build that vehicle. It would have been incredibly expensive.
And this is why war chariots became associated with people of high status, this idea that you
are what you drive. The faster your vehicle, the more high status that you are. But then the war
chariot fell out of favor
because horses were bred to be large enough that they could carry warriors and obviously you can
take a horse places you can't take a chariot and so um so then the war chariot kind of became
obsolete and people switched to having cavalry um and the wheel sort of you know fell from favor
again it's sort of a bumpy ride one minute people are really into wheels and the next minute they're
not and for the most part even when people are them, most people can't afford to use them.
And so what was the next big innovation that moved personal transportation forward?
What was the next big thing?
Well, weirdly, it's actually gunpowder weapons because gunpowder weapons, so guns and cannons
and things like that, meant that knights on horseback suddenly looked really out of date and old-fashioned and obsolete and at that point the idea that men shouldn't be
going on wheeled vehicles gets overturned because in particular you can mount cannons so this is
what some countries started to do you mount cannons on wheeled vehicles and then you could
shoot at knights so suddenly the knights look old-fashioned and you want to be the guy on the
on the wheeled vehicle with the cannon and this coincides with the rise of a new vehicle called the coach,
which is basically a fast carriage, a four-wheeled carriage. So it's a fast open wheeled vehicle.
And this originates in Eastern Europe and it spreads all over Europe. And the idea that
if you're a man, it's no longer cool to be riding around on a horse. It's now cool to be
riding in a coach pulled by two or four horses as fast as you can. And again, speed is a way of
showing off. It's a way of demonstrating your status and your wealth and so on. So this idea
that you are what you drive. So suddenly wheels are cool again, and they've been cool ever since. When I think about the 1800s, I think of stage
coaches and railroads, steam engines, and that was how people would get around.
Yeah, stage coaches were surprisingly slow. I mean, they didn't go much faster than walking.
It was about four or five miles an hour. So it's about the same as walking. And the main thing was
you didn't get rained on and you could take luggage. But yeah, trains are completely different because they go so much faster.
In fact, people were worried about the effects of speed.
They thought, you know, will our brains stop working?
And so there are these experiments that are done in the 1830s where, you know, they put passengers on trains and they make them do things like crossword puzzles to see if their brains still work properly at the unheard of speed of 35 miles per hour. It's that kind of
thing. But yes, it is incredible because when you have a rail link between two cities, in effect,
you've moved those cities so that they're very close together and they're closer to each other
than they are to other cities that may be geographically closer, but don't have rail
links. And so you start to get all sorts of economic effects. You get cities like Chicago,
where the economy is able to go in new directions because it's got these railroad links to
other places. So that really is a game changer. And it's the first time that,
you know, people can travel faster than you can on a galloping horse.
And then what happened? Is that pretty much it until the car? Or were there other things that
were innovations that maybe we don't know about?
Well, the other one that, you know, it seems obvious in retrospect, but the other big innovation of the first half of the 1800s is the bicycle.
The first bicycles are made about 1815, 1816.
And they are like kids bikes, balance bikes.
They don't have pedals.
They're made of wood.
And you kind of sit on it and then you kind of push it along using your legs. And that idea doesn't
really catch on. But gradually people refine it. They make the wheels out of metal. They add pedals.
They add brakes. They start off with the penny farthing, the huge front wheel and the tiny back
wheel. And then they realize if you make the two wheels the same size and use a chain, then actually
that's much more efficient. By the 1880s, we get to what looks like a modern
bicycle. These are also revolutionary because they're a personal transport device, rather like
a horse, but much, much cheaper. You don't have to feed it. You don't have to look after it.
This means that the ability to have a vehicle, you can visit the next town, you've got the freedom to
travel when you want, but you don't have to be rich enough to own a horse. That's suddenly available to a much larger number of people. And so if you look at the 1880s, 1890s, the sort of golden age of the bicycle, there's this bicycle mania, and it is hailed as a great sort of leveler of social inequality. Women can travel more easily and so on. And so that is also a very, very radical
shift in transport in its own way. Except when it rains or snows.
Well, quite. So this is when people start asking themselves, is there a way we could have something
that could go on existing roads like a horse or a horse and a coach, a horse-drawn carriage,
that could go as fast as a train and have a roof like you do on a train
carriage, but could also be as personal as a bicycle. Of course, that is what the automobile
promises. And so when people start to use these new internal combustion engines that have just
been invented and fit them either onto existing carriages or build new vehicles around them,
suddenly people look at them and go, wow, that, now that is cool,
because it's combining the best of all of these previous modes of transport.
Which is what I want to talk about next, because the car is such a game changer,
and this is where we are in this history of motion,
and I want to talk more about that in a moment.
Tom Standage is my guest.
The name of his book is A Brief History of Motion, From the Wheel to the Car to What Comes Next.
For those who embrace the impossible, the Defender 110 is up for the adventure.
This iconic, award-winning vehicle has been redefined with a distinctive modern design.
A reimagined exterior features compelling proportions and precise detailing.
Built with integrity and purpose, the interior boasts robust durable materials whether it's the all-terrain capability
ample cargo capacity or innovative camera technology the defender 110 lets you go further
and do more and with seating for up to seven everyone can enjoy the journey learn more at
land rover.ca this episode is brought to you by mel and Doug. Wooden puzzles and building toys for problem solving and arts and crafts for creative thinking.
Melissa and Doug makes toys that help kids take on the world.
Because the way they play today shapes who they become tomorrow.
Melissa and Doug. The play is pretend. The skills are real.
Look for Melissa and Doug wherever you shop for toys.
So, Tom, before we talk about the car, as you say, the bicycle was a big deal,
and we maybe tend not to think of it as a big deal because by today's standards,
a bicycle is more of a kid's mode of transportation, almost a toy in many ways.
I mean, a lot of people, grown grownups, ride bicycles. I get that. But at the time when they first came out and people really started riding them, it wasn't just a kid's toy
or means of transportation. Everybody was using them. It was actually particularly popular among
young adults because it was a sort of dating app of its day. People would join bike clubs to meet
members of the opposite sex. And so it really was
a game changer socially, but it also literally paved the way for the car because cyclists
campaigned for better roads, smoother roads, paved roads. They also campaigned for the right to take
this newfangled vehicle into places that previously had been reserved for horse-drawn carriages.
So places like Central Park, were you allowed to take a new vehicle into Central Park?
Well, eventually they won the right to do that too.
And what that meant was by the time the automobile was invented,
that there were smooth roads starting to appear.
And it was also the precedent set that you could take a new vehicle
into these places that were previously reserved for horse-drawn traffic.
And so in that sense, the bike really did prepare the way for the car.
And also, if you look at the first car made by Carl Benz, the Motorwagen in 1886,
it looks much more like a bicycle than anything else.
It's basically a tricycle.
It's got enormous, great spoked wheels.
He basically built it out of bike parts around an internal combustion engine.
So the bike is, in many ways, the father of the car.
I never would think that.
You would think that that was just a whole different set of thinking to come up with the car.
But when you explain it that way, it makes perfect sense,
that here's this kind of cool thing people are pedaling around.
Let's put a motor on it and make it more sophisticated.
That's pretty exactly and in fact an internal combustion engine is put on a bicycle before so the year before
benz builds the motor bargain someone else is attached a uh an internal a small internal
combustion engine to a bicycle so actually the motorbike comes before the car and it is the
intermediate step between the bicycle um and the car so yes that yes, that's all exactly the way it was.
Also, these first cars, I mean, we call them cars, the word car doesn't become popular until
the 20th century, but these first cars didn't have roofs, they didn't have windows, they were outdoor,
you had to dress up to go in them. And the idea of having things like windows that close and locking
doors, that all comes much later. So yeah, I mean, they are much more like bicycles
in that sense. You are really exposed to the elements. You know, what's interesting is that as
the time progresses and the new innovations come, the old ones kind of fall away. I mean,
we still have horses, but people don't, you know, ride them to work too much anymore. I mean,
it's more of a recreational thing, I think. But from the bicycle, the motorbike and the car,
people still use all of them. Well, this is because horses are expensive, right? I mean,
they're really, really expensive. And it's a rich person's hobby to ride horses now. But it was a
rich person's, you know, privilege to have horses and you have to have stables. And then, of course,
they were producing all this horse manure, which takes me back to where I started because that was a real, real problem. And one of the
reasons that people were so enthusiastic about cars is that they promised to get rid of this
problem of horse manure that was literally piling up in cities. It had to be swept up from the
streets every day. They tried selling it to farmers, but eventually there was so much of it,
no one wanted to buy it. And so you have this big problem and the car seems to solve all the problems, right? It's going
to get rid of the pollution, it's going to get rid of the traffic, because a car takes
up, as a horseless carriage as it's first called, takes up half the amount of space
as a horse and a carriage, because you've only got one of them. So the idea was that
was going to fix all the traffic problems, and Thomas Edison makes this prediction right
at the beginning of the 20th century, that downtown New York, Manhattan, is going to
look like a ghost town, because the automobile is going to reduce traffic so much
and then it's also going to be much quieter because um the uh you're not going to get the
steel-rimmed wheels going across the cobblestones automobiles have rubber tires so they're much
quieter and they're also going to be safer there's going to be no more accidents because
a horse can be scared by a loud noise, but an
engine can't be scared. And so road deaths were going to plummet as well. And of course, all of
these things turned out to be wrong. So tell the story about traffic lights, how red came to mean
stop and green came to mean go. How did that all come about? Well, red originally mean stop because
a lighthouse was being built on the English coast and it was near to another lighthouse. And the problem was that sea captains were going to get the two lighthouses muddled up. So the second one had to have a new color. So Stevenson, the engineer who was building it, did a whole load of experiments to see which color you could get light. If you put colored glass in front of a light, which color reduced the brightness of the lighthouse the least and the light would travel the furthest.
We now know that it's red because red has the longest wavelength.
That's why red is the answer.
But he came up with red.
Red became associated with the warning for that lighthouse and then ships started carrying
red lights on one side and white lights on the other side as warning lights
at sea. That way, if you saw another ship approaching, you would pass on the side of
the white light, not the red light. White comes to be associated with go and red with
stop. This is adopted by railway companies in the 19th century, starting in England.
They use green to mean caution. But there's a problem with this. When red means stop and green
means caution and white means go, if you see another light and you're on a train and you're
driving the train, you see a white light in the distance that's actually not a railway signal at
all. It's just someone's house or something like that. You may misinterpret it as a go light.
And if you see a red light or a green light where the glass filter in front of it has
fallen off, it becomes a white light. In other words, it means go when it should mean stop or
caution. And this led to rail accidents because if the filter falls off, people are going to
misread the signal. So right around 1900, the colours are swapped and green is used to mean go
and white is used to mean caution. And that way, if a filter falls
off either of the red or the green lights, it defaults to caution rather than defaulting to go,
which is much safer. And so those colors are then adopted when street lights, electric,
sorry, when electric traffic signals are introduced, those colors are then introduced.
So now we have the car.
We've had the car for a long time.
It has gotten better and better.
But so what's next?
Is there going to be another big thing?
Are we going to have flying cars?
What's the next big thing?
I think we are at an inflection point.
If you look at what's happened in the last 15 years, there's been enormous innovation.
We've had things like ride hailing, so Uber and
Lyft and DD, the equivalent in China. We've also had things like these bike rental schemes that
you have in many cities now where you have docks and also dockless bike rental schemes,
and then the e-scooters and so on and so on and so on. The thing that's really changed all of this
and changed the outlook, I think, for transport is the smartphone.
The smartphone itself, obviously, you know, is not a means of transport. I can't climb it onto
my smartphone and fly around. But in effect, I can because it makes public transport in my city
much more usable. I can look up when the next bus or the next train is going to come. I can see
the quickest way to get across town by using a variety of means of transport. I can hail a car
using an app, a ride-hailing app. I can unlock a bicycle or a scooter using it.
So you can basically, in a way that's never been possible before, combine all of these other kinds
of transport to make something that is, in many ways, preferable to owning a car in a busy city.
And the general trend is that car ownership is becoming more and more
expensive and more and more inconvenient. Young people are less likely to learn to drive. And at
the same time, the alternatives to car ownership are becoming easier to use and more convenient
because the smartphone stitches them all together. So I call this the internet of motion. And it's
essentially this combination, like the internet's a network of networks, this is a combination of
different transport networks tied together by the phone.
That's what I think is coming next.
Over time, owning a car is going to make less sense for a growing number of people who live
in cities.
I think the overall number of cars that people own is going to go down.
What's your sense about the self-driving car?
I think the self-driving car and the flying car could fit into my internet of motion
quite easily if we can get them to work and if they're safe.
I've been in self-driving cars.
I've been following the field very closely.
The problem is you can make a self-driving car that can cope in traffic with other people,
with other vehicles, and it can manage 95%, 97% of the time. It's that last five,
that last 3% that's really, really difficult because drivers have to deal with very unpredictable
environments. And so this is why the self-driving cars are tested in very predictable environments
like Phoenix, Arizona, where you've got a grid system where it never snows, where there aren't
any cyclists on the road to speak of,
et cetera, et cetera. So that's the real challenge, getting to the point where
you really can put these things on the road without endangering other people.
Well, the story of motion, this history that you tell is so interesting,
makes you really want to hear what's in the next chapters to come.
Tom Standage has been my guest. He's deputy editor of The Economist,
and he is author of the book, A Brief History of Motion, From the Wheel to the Car to What Comes
Next. And there's a link to his book at Amazon in the show notes. Thank you, Tom.
Thanks, Mike. It's been great fun.
Metrolinks and Crosslinks are reminding everyone to be careful,
as Eglinton Crosstown LRT train testing is in progress.
Please be alert, as trains can pass at any time on the tracks.
Remember to follow all traffic signals, be careful along our tracks,
and only make left turns where it's safe to do so.
Be alert, be aware, and stay safe.
This is an ad for better help. Welcome to the world. Be alert, be aware, or online chat.
Visit betterhelp.com to learn more. That's betterhelp.com.
How many times have you been in a situation where you thought about saying something to someone, or you wanted to say something,
or you felt you really should speak up and say something,
but you didn't.
Then maybe later, you wish you had.
There are times when you really should speak up.
So how do you do it, courageously and purposefully,
rather than sit back and say, eh, what's the point?
That's what Mary Nestor is here to talk about.
Mary is a communications expert, an award-winning speaker, business consultant, and author of
the book, Say It Now, Say It Right, How to Handle Tough and Tender Conversations.
Hi, Mary.
Hi, Mike.
Thanks so much for having me.
So I've been in that situation. I
think everybody's been in that situation where you think you should probably say something,
but you think, yeah, but what's the point? It's not worth it. It's just going to cause trouble.
So you don't. And I imagine sometimes it isn't worth it. It probably will just cause trouble.
So how do you know when you should speak
up and when you shouldn't speak up? Excellent, excellent questions. It's true. There are some
times when you don't have to say something. And that's the times when you can be silent.
But in many cases, people are not even aware of some of the things they're doing. And I'll give you an example. I gave a presentation early on in my career and it was very well received. And afterwards, I went into the
ladies room and just to freshen up. And I noticed that I had a big piece of broccoli stuck in my
front tooth. And I went back to my assistant and I said, oh my gosh, I'm so embarrassed that I had this in my tooth. She said, Oh, I know
it. And I said to her, you knew it and you didn't tell me. And she said, Oh, I was so embarrassed.
I didn't, I didn't want to say anything that was negative to you. Now the time for her to say it
now was before I gave my presentation. And so many people are not aware of the fact that they have
broccoli in their teeth. They're doing something or they're coming across in a way that they're
not even aware of themselves and you don't tell them. That's really not being very nice.
Think about this. If there's something that is going on, say in an office, you've got one person who always
interrupts everybody or is very hard to work with.
Well, everybody else knows that, but that person may not know it at all.
Who are you hurting?
You're hurting the person that you're not telling because if they were aware of it,
then they could do something about it.
Yeah, but I've been in situations where, you know, there are people who,
if they had broccoli in their teeth, I would have no trouble telling them, hey, you've got broccoli
in your teeth, you might want to move that. And that's probably most people, but there's always
those people who, I don't know, they're a little volatile, you don't know what kind of response
you're going to get, and I figure, well then what's the point? You know, I don't know what kind of response you're going to get. And I figure, well, then what's the point? I don't feel safe in their response. So I just don't say anything.
And you're right. You can't predict the responses you're going to get,
because there's a lot of different responses. They could say, oh, this is great. Thank you so much.
Or they could say, who do you think you are?
And that is something that you can't control.
The person who is really going to benefit in that kind of a situation is you.
Because think about it.
If you have a situation with a person, a relationship problem, or maybe a problem at work,
and you let it go and you let it go and you let it go, who is it really bothering?
The other person may not even be aware of it. But every day, you have to go into that situation.
And you are in there, there's a turmoil, there is a stress going on. And so I what I say is to,
to find your voice and take a risk to to speak your truth. This is how I'm feeling. This is the situation as I see it. And this is
what I think I would like you to do, or this is the way we should approach things from now on.
And after you have that conversation, you're absolutely right. You can't control what the
other person is going to do, but think of how you're going to feel. The stress, you don't have to
confront that situation anymore. What about the situation where you've not said anything for a
long time, and now you've decided to say something, and there's so much anger and resentment behind
it. You've got to be really careful what you say, because it may all come out in a ton of
bricks. Right. Absolutely. And say it now doesn't mean say it immediately off the top of your head
when you're really angry. If you're angry, that is not the time to talk to anybody and not to
bring up a situation. So let yourself cool down a little bit. And you have to
look at it also from your perspective, you know, criticism, nobody likes criticism. And we tried
to dress it up and call it constructive criticism or constructive feedback and all those things,
but nobody likes to be criticized, but I can come and I can speak from my perspective about something. And the anger builds up again,
because we are reluctant or afraid to approach a situation or a certain person. So I would say,
cool down before you blurt something out and really think about it. Think about how you're
going to approach that person and the situation. One of the things that I have found that's very,
very helpful when you have a situation like that is to think of if you have
something that you can say that's positive first. All right.
I had a situation one time when I was, and it wasn't an angry situation,
but the,
a friend of mine gave a presentation and I listened to it and it was wonderful, brilliant,
but she kept speaking very, very soft.
And she said a lot of ahs and ums.
And after the presentation, I thought, well, you know, she's going to give it tomorrow
to a big group of donors.
And I have a suggestion.
So what I did is I went up to her and I said, you know, I really enjoyed your presentation.
There's so much content.
It's just so, this information is so important.
I observed something while I was listening to you, and I would like to share it with you.
Would you mind if I did that?
So the technique is to give the person the opportunity to get permission for you to speak.
And I have to say that if I've used that technique before, I've never heard the word no.
She said, sure.
And so I went on and explained what I saw.
And again, I said, you know, it was a great presentation.
I said, I had trouble hearing you in some places when you spoke very softly.
How about trying to speak loudly and do that in a consistent manner?
And she said, great, thank you so much.
So that's one way of approaching someone who you think might be angry,
because once they've given you permission to speak, then you have the floor.
Well, but something that you did that I think is really important is you said,
can I tell you what I observed rather than say, can I tell you what I think you should do?
Absolutely.
That's a big difference because I'm not sure I want to hear what you think I should do, but I might be interested in hearing what you observe.
Exactly.
Exactly.
And that's what I call speaking your truth.
I can always, and you can always speak your truth because this is how I see the world.
This is how I see the relationship.
This is how I see the world. This is how I see the relationship. This is how I see the situation.
But when you start using the word you, and you're absolutely right, Mike, if you were you, this is what you should do.
I could have said, well, you know what you ought to do?
You ought to not speak so soft all the time.
And I think you ought to speak up.
What a different message that is.
And yet, I think that's the message most people give when they do give
feedback is they say this is either in the exact words or the message is this is what I think you
should do. Yes. Yeah. Since you've been doing this a while and you talk to a lot of people who
theoretically, hopefully try your process out, how often does it go off the rails versus how often
is it not the disaster people think it's going to be?
You know, it depends on the situation. I always applaud anyone who will try it out.
Most of the time I have found it has gone very well. I had someone talk to me just recently and she said, you know, I have used the techniques and I am speaking up more with my family.
And it's not that it's a difficult situation.
I just feel more comfortable speaking my truth.
I feel more comfortable saying what I think and not, you know, being quiet because I'm afraid that it's going to go against someone else.
I had a situation where a woman had relatives who would come every summer and they would stay for two weeks and they expected her to do everything, feed them, drive them everywhere.
And it just wore her out. So she had a conversation with them and she didn't say,
don't come. She just said, it's a long time.
And I really would love to have you stay. If you can come and please come for, you know,
maybe a week or five days or something like that. And we can pack a lot of information in there.
Well, the relative didn't take it very kindly and decided not to come at all. It goes back to controlling
the other person's response. And so over time, the relationship has come back, but making that
first, maybe at the first time you confront someone, it's not always going to go so well.
And one of the reactions that people will have is that they may go back, even though they were maybe
angry or upset in the beginning, they go back and they think about it. And then they think about it.
And I've had more people tell me that someone will come back maybe a week or a month later and say,
you know, you were right. And I appreciate you're telling me that. Yeah. Well, how can you be wrong
when you're just saying, this is what I observed?
You can't say that's wrong.
I mean, that's what you observed.
That's your experience.
Exactly.
Exactly.
So there is no wrong.
It's just they just don't like your observation.
So when people are afraid of speaking up, what is it you think they're afraid of?
Just the reaction?
Oh, so many things.
And it depends on the person.
They're afraid of looking stupid or looking silly, giving out an idea.
Take a staff meeting where it's, okay, we all want all your ideas.
And someone stands up and gives an idea and say, oh, someone else says, oh, we've tried that before.
That's not going to work.
So you get shot down right away.
So why should I speak up if I know that people are going to shoot me down and I'm going to look foolish and nobody's going to think that my idea is very good?
Why would I want to risk that?
Why would you?
So what would you do instead?
What I tell people is that it take the risk. There's three components to this. There's say
it now, which is the right timing. And there's say it right, which is the right body language,
the right phrasing, the right words. And the other one is the right motive. You've got to
stand up and come from a place where you're not trying is the right motive. You've got to stand up and come
from a place where you're not trying to put anybody down. You're not trying to make people
look stupid. You're not trying to make yourself look so important. You have to come from a place
where you really want to share this idea because you think it's valuable and it's important and
it could be beneficial. So if I stand there and say that with that kind of a motive, then I don't have to worry
about what other people think.
And I'll tell you one other situation that I had when I started my consulting business.
I had a great idea for a program.
It was called Me, Inc.
I thought, wow, that is really great, yourself as a business.
And I mulled it over and I wrote it out and I drew pictures about it and everything like that.
And then I let it go. And about a month later, I was at a bookstore and I wanted to get a magazine
and I saw all the magazines that were on the display. And here was the Time Magazine front cover.
And guess what it said?
The front cover said, Me, Inc.
That was my idea.
And here it was on the front of Time Magazine.
Now, that was a great idea, but I didn't do anything with it.
I didn't speak up.
Think of all the opportunities that are lost,
all the great ideas that never are said and never
worked on and never come to fruition, because somebody is reluctant to speak up.
There are people, though, who just are timid. That's their nature. It's not that they're
afraid or, oh, maybe it is, but their whole life they've been timid.
It's part of their personality.
What do you say to those people who just have never spoken up?
This is a big change to consider.
You don't have to change your personality in order to be more forceful. You can speak very softly and very quietly and very, you know,
at very opportune times and maybe not very often. But, you know, someone who doesn't speak up much
or is very quiet or is very thoughtful, when they do finally speak up, it makes a huge impression.
Think about that. You know, there are some people that they will speak up all the time.
They don't have any problem with that.
You know, those are some of the people that hog the meetings.
Yeah, I'm pretty sick of those guys.
Yeah, we're sick of those people.
But think about this.
When you've got a group of people, and you know this one person on your team hardly ever says boo anytime.
And all of a sudden sudden they put their hand up
and they stand up and have something to say.
The whole room is going to be silent
because once they do stand up,
it's got to be really important for that person.
They're going to have a huge impact.
Yeah, that's a really good point.
And what that illustrates, what're going to have a huge impact. Yeah, that's a really good point. And what that
illustrates, what that kind of says is that maybe you shouldn't speak up all the time just because
you have something to say. That if you do that, then people don't take you as seriously as when
you're very selective. And that maybe, maybe there are times not to speak up. Maybe there are times not to speak up. Maybe there are times to just let it go because it's not worth it or that no good will come from it.
And I have a story with that.
I had a son when he was a teenager, he had a bad case of acne.
And, you know, being the mother, I thought, oh, my gosh, you know, he's going to just suffer and go to school and people are going to make fun of him and all that. So I was all worried about it. He
was pretty cool about it. He didn't really bother him that much, but I made an appointment. I dragged
him to the dermatologist. So we're in the doctor's office and he's sitting on the exam table. And the
doctor asked a question of my son and I chirped up and I answered it. And then the doctor asked him another question and I
answered it again. Now, after the third or fourth time, the doctor finally looked, turned around and
looked at me and said, Ms. Nestor, I think your son can speak for himself. And wow, now he said
it now and said it right to me. Because there are times when you have to stop talking and you have to let people speak for themselves.
You know, kids, we're always rushing in
to do everything for them
instead of letting them figure things out themselves.
And the message you're actually giving when you do that
is that I don't think you can handle it.
I don't think you're smart enough.
I don't think you have what it takes to figure things out.
And that can be a huge detriment.
So there are times when you need to just, you know, stop the helicopter, helicoptering
parents, and you can be a helicopter manager too, and being trying to fix everything all
the time for everyone else.
So there's a time to be silent and let people figure them out for themselves, a huge confidence
builder, and let them speak up. Let themselves, a huge confidence builder, and
let them speak up.
Let them find their own voice so they can speak up.
And it just makes sense, particularly in business, in organizations.
You want people to speak up.
They might have better ideas or they might see a big problem with your idea.
And if everybody's afraid to speak, then that could be a big problem.
One of the things that we used to do in meetings is to appoint a devil's advocate. This person,
their job during the meeting was to really listen and to come up with opposing points of view.
Because if you don't, then you don't have anything to bounce your ideas off of. There's a quote that
says, if two of us always agree, one of us is unnecessary. So managers and leaders can do
themselves a great favor, and especially going into this new, this post-COVID workplace, is to
make it a place where people feel safe to speak up. They're encouraged to speak up.
When you've got people that can find their voice, you're going to have a much more productive
and a much different and a much safer and comfortable workplace.
Well, I think this is really a valuable discussion because I think everyone has been in that
situation where they didn't speak up.
They later regretted it, wish they had. What would have happened if they did? And I think
this conversation really helps give people permission and validation for speaking up
because it could really do some good. Mary Nestor has been my guest. She's a communications expert,
an award-winning speaker, and a business consultant.
And the name of her book is Say It Now, Say It Right. And there's a link to that book in the
show notes. Thanks, Mary. Thanks, Mike. It's been a pleasure.
Picture in your mind what a burglar looks like. And if your image is a guy dressed in black wearing a ski mask and holding a flashlight, you are way
off. A real burglar is more likely to carry a clipboard
or a rake and dress like a meter reader or
a landscaper. If you don't answer the door, he'll check
it anyway and if it's unlocked, he'll probably walk right in.
If it is locked, he'll go look in the window to see if he sees anything valuable.
It could be worth breaking a window for.
After all, neighbors probably won't react to one loud sound.
Alarm systems do deter burglars, but only if they're activated.
Most burglars will tell you that a sticker in the window
or a sign in the yard saying you have a burglar alarm isn't that convincing.
And many are willing to take the risk that even if you do have an alarm, it's probably not on during the day, when most burglaries actually happen.
It's key to have blinds and shades drawn on all ground-level windows, including the basement, when you're not at home,
because it's riskier for a robber to enter into a space that he can't see.
And that is something you should know.
If you're a regular listener to Something You Should Know,
you have heard me ask you many times to tell someone you know about this podcast,
recommend it to a friend, and the reason I keep doing that is because it works. It helps us
grow our audience. And it's really a great way to show your support for this podcast. So please
recommend Something You Should Know to a friend. I'm Micah Brothers. Thanks for listening today to
Something You Should Know. Hey, hey, are you ready for some real talk and some fantastic laughs?
Join me, Megan Rinks.
And me, Melissa Demonts for Don't Blame Me, But Am I Wrong?
We're serving up for hilarious shows every week designed to entertain and engage and,
you know, possibly enrage you.
In Don't Blame Me, we dive deep into listeners' questions,
offering advice that's funny, relatable, and real.
Whether you're dealing with relationship drama or you just need a friend's perspective,
we've got you.
Then switch gears with But Am I Wrong,
which is for listeners who didn't take our advice
and want to know if they are the villains in the situation.
Plus, we share our hot takes on current events
and present situations that we might even be wrong
in our lives.
Spoiler alert, we are actually quite literally never wrong.
But wait, there's more.
Check out See You Next Tuesday, where we reveal the juicy results from our listener polls
from But Am I Wrong?
And don't miss Fisting Friday, where we catch up, chat about pop culture, TV, and movies.
It's the perfect way to kick off your weekend.
So if you're looking for a podcast that feels like a chat with your besties, listen to Don't
Blame Me, But Am I Wrong on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you get your podcasts.
New episodes every Monday, Tuesday, Thursday, and Friday.
Contained herein are the heresies of Redolph Buntwine, erstwhile monk turned traveling medical investigator.
Join me as I study the secrets of the divine plagues and uncover the blasphemous truth
that ours is not a loving God and we are not its favored children.
The Heresies of Randolph Bantwine, wherever podcasts are available.