Something You Should Know - The New World of Weather Forecasting & Interesting Ways the Human Body Adapts
Episode Date: June 30, 2025Everyone is bound to make a typo in an email. What’s interesting though is the reader will often see that typo and alter the way they interpret your message – sometimes in a good way, sometimes in... a bad way. Listen to discover how this works. https://www.businessinsider.com/typos-in-emails-2015-5 The science of weather forecasting has come a long way in the last few decades. Interestingly, forecasters are not only improving their accuracy but also how they communicate the information to you and me. With more and more extreme weather (hurricanes, floods, tornadoes, high winds/fires etc.), this becomes more important for everyone. Here to explain how and why is Thomas Weber, former executive editor of TIME who has taught journalism and publishing at Columbia University, New York University and Princeton. He is author of the book Cloud Warriors: Deadly Storms, Climate Chaos―and the Pioneers Creating a Revolution in Weather Forecasting (https://amzn.to/4edBLsY). While we are all human, there are interesting differences between us. Some of those differences, such as height, weight, skin color, even the size of your spleen, are dictated by where you live and where your ancestors came from. Listen as I discuss these amazing ways the human body adapts to its environment with Herman Pontzer. He is a professor of evolutionary anthropology and global health at Duke University whose work has been reported in the New York Times, the BBC, The Washington Post, The Atlantic, and Scientific American. He is author of the book Adaptable: How Your Unique Body Really Works and Why Our Biology Unites Us (https://amzn.to/4nucZsX). If you are keeping a secret right now (even if it is a good secret), it could be a bigger burden on you than you imagine. Listen as I explain why and offer a suggestion on what to do with that secret. https://now.tufts.edu/2012/06/12/how-burdensome-are-secrets Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Transcript
Discussion (0)
There is so much talk about women's hormonal health, which is great, but even
though it's a bigger part of the conversation, most women are left even
more confused about what it means for them and what to do about it, which is
not so great. This confusion ends now. An award-winning German nutrition
scientist created a powerful herbal formula called hormone harmony, which
combines 12 powerful adaptogens into one single capsule.
Each of these ingredients is carefully selected based on scientific evidence, and it's been
proven effective in clinical studies for women of various ages and hormonal profiles.
And Happy Mammoth, the company that produces hormone harmony, is famous for its zero-compromise
policy.
No GMOs, artificial fillers or flavors, or any other junk. Only science-backed ingredients
in amounts that are clinically proven. The company surveyed over 1,500 women to see how
hormone harmony helped them, and the results are mind-blowing. 86% of women started losing
weight, 77% say it improved their mood, and 100% said they're feeling like themselves
again. Hormone harmony has over 50,000 raving reviews
from women all over the world,
with 98% of them saying they'd gladly recommend it
to their friends and family.
For a limited time, you can get 15% off
on your entire first order at happymammoth.com.
Just use the code HAPPYME, H-A-P-P-Y-M-E at checkout.
That's code HAPPYME at happymammoth.com for 15% off your entire first order.
Today on Something You Should Know, what people think when they see a typo in one of your
emails.
Then, the new world of weather forecasting and why it's so important to you.
This is so much more than just do I need an umbrella going out the door today. It's about
being aware of the dangers and how to react to them and becoming weather literate, trying to
increase your weather literacy. Also some excellent advice if you're keeping a secret
and how humans adapt to their environment.
Height, weight, skin color, immunity are all adaptations
and there's more.
Here's a really fun one.
Your spleen.
So people probably don't think about their spleens too much.
So it turns out that people who live in either
in high altitude or this
population that lives at sea, we see larger spleen size. All this today on
Something You Should Know.
Hi, I'm Adam Gitwitz, host of Grim, Grimmer, Grimist. On every episode we tell a
grim fairy tale. Not the cute sweet versions of the fairy tales that your children have heard so many
times.
No.
We tell the real grim fairy tales.
They're funny.
They're weird.
Sometimes they're a little bit scary.
But don't worry.
We rate every episode grim, grimmer, or grimmest so you, your child, your family can choose
the episode that's the right level of scary for you.
Tune in to Grim, Grimmer, Grimmest and our new season available now. Today, Something You Should Know with Mike Carruthers.
So how much harm can the occasional typo do?
No big deal, right?
Well, you might be surprised.
Hi, and welcome to Something You Should Know.
Like everyone else, you occasionally
make typos in your emails.
It just happens.
But does a typo in an email have any
effect on the reader? When a researcher at Harvard Business School had test
subjects read an angry email from a fictional sender, the reader saw that
person as angrier when the note had typos. When he did the same thing with a
joyful email, the typos made the sender come across as more
joyful.
In other words, typos act as an emotional amplifier.
Since written communication is words only, there are no facial or verbal clues to give
the reader any insight into the writer.
So essentially, the reader takes whatever clues they can get and typos
seem to give the clue that whatever emotion you're trying to convey is stronger. The bad news is that
those same typos also convey to the reader that you are less intelligent and that your response
is being driven by emotion and not by careful thought.
But that may be okay in some situations.
If a typo in a sincere email makes you seem more sincere,
it may be worth the price of not appearing as intelligent.
And that is something you should know.
What is one topic that affects every one of us every single day and yet we have no ability
to control it or do anything about it?
It's the weather.
And in recent years we've seen some very extreme weather.
I know this all too well.
We've had winds here whip up two fires in California.
One of those fires literally burned right to my
doorstep and the other fire burned right to the doorstep of my business partner's
home. And we know several people who have lost their homes and everything else. But
it's not just extreme weather, even with everyday weather. To some extent, it
controls your life. What you wear, where you go or don't go, what you do.
We are at the mercy of the weather.
And so knowing in advance about the weather can be very helpful.
In fact, accurate weather forecasts can save lives, which is why Thomas Weber is here,
to discuss the science of weather forecasting and what you need to know about it.
Thomas Weber is the former executive editor of Time Magazine and has taught journalism
and publishing at Columbia, New York University, and Princeton.
He's author of a book called Cloud Warriors, Deadly Storms, Climate Chaos, and the Pioneers
Creating a Revolution in Weather Forecasting.
Hi, Tom.
Welcome to Something You Should Know.
Mike, it's great to be here, thanks.
So I've always thought weather forecasting
is like the quintessential victim of negativity bias,
in the sense that weather forecasting today,
I imagine, is mostly right.
But that's not what people remember.
They don't remember when it's right,
they remember when it's right, they remember when it's wrong, and so it gets this bad reputation.
Yeah, forecasts are much better than people think, and you know, unfortunately
it's sort of a cultural joke, the forecast being always wrong. I spoke to
some undergraduate meteorology students at Penn State just to talk about, you know,
their career plans and every one of them mentioned how many jokes they hear from their friends about,
you know, they're going into a field where everybody's always wrong.
But, but forecasts really are much better than people generally appreciate. Today a five-day general forecast is as accurate
as a one-day forecast from 1980. So I mean you know think about that. We
basically can look five times further into the future than we could in 1980.
I'll tell you one other fact about forecast accuracy.
If you look at something specific like hurricane forecasts, when the National Hurricane Center
predicts the track of a storm 72 hours out, the average error these days is less than
100 miles.
They've doubled their accuracy on that in the last 20 years.
And so these are just, just, they're amazing accomplishments.
And those accomplishments are the result of what?
Technology, better computers, better models, what?
All of the above, really.
And what's exciting is we're really entering a new age
of even better forecasts.
If you think about modern forecasting,
really the first wave came in the 19th century
with the advent of the telegraph,
which basically let people in the West send word ahead,
here's the weather that's on the way
because weather in the US moves predominantly West to East.
So that was something.
But the second wave in the 1950s and 60s with the space age,
that is really where we started to get
truly accurate weather forecasts.
And that's because we had radar, satellites,
and computers that could run models on them.
And we've made steady progress since then.
Now we're hitting kind of a third wave,
artificial intelligence.
There's something called the internet of things,
which just means data from all sorts of sources
that are plugged into the internet,
like your smartphone, which knows the atmospheric pressure,
or your car, which knows whether it's raining or not
because your car turns the windshield wiper on and off.
So that's a lot of new data to plug into
the computer models that are already good.
And then one more thing in this third wave,
we're getting knowledge from studying people
and understanding how people use forecasts so that we can not
just give them great information, but we can try to give it to them in a format that they
can put to better use.
Well, the assumption is, I think, that people use weather forecasts the way I use weather
forecasts like, am I going to need an umbrella today?
Do I need a coat or not?
It's that kind of thing.
That's how I tend to use it, except for when there's a major
emergency.
But other than that, it's kind of easy day to day.
Yeah, honestly, that's part of what got me interested in this
story in the first place. I was just thinking about how I use forecasts myself, and I'll wake up and I'll ask my smart
speaker to tell me what the weather is going to be today.
And I realized, like, I take it for granted, and I think most people take it for granted
as well.
And forecasting is so much more than that.
So I wanted to learn how they get made,
but also how good they are and how to put them to work. And a lot of what I wound up
focusing on is the use of forecasts for dangerous weather. It's pretty important. Last year, the United States saw 27 distinct weather disasters where
the costs from damage were more than $1 billion in each of those incidents. And there were
at least 568 deaths attributed to those events alone. And weather fatalities are often undercounted,
especially for things like heat waves.
The year before, there were 28 of those billion-dollar disasters.
So a big takeaway from me when I would talk to people in the weather world was that this
is so much more than just, do I need an umbrella going out the door today. It's about being aware of the dangers
and how to react to them
and becoming what I've been calling weather literate,
trying to increase your weather literacy
to be able to understand what these forecasts mean.
So let me ask you a question about meteorologists before we go further into the...
Sure.
What do they do?
And what I mean by that is it seems like weather forecasting is a formula.
They're models and computers that run the formula.
So what do the people do and what makes a great meteorologist versus a not so great meteorologist?
What's the human element here?
So I I think what you're talking about are what I would consider an operational
Forecaster not somebody in research but somebody who's actually putting out the forecast that you might you know read or hear
I had an opportunity to embed myself
in the forecast office in State College, Pennsylvania.
What I learned when I watched people at work
was the people in these office are really
your local expert on weather, right?
You know, the computer does the best it can,
which is pretty amazing these days.
But there are quirks of geography that people come to know
where they become an expert in their area.
So in every office, the people are very familiar
with the local quirks of the weather.
And when they see what comes out of the computer,
they're able to look at that and say,
okay, yeah, that tracks or you know what, I think the computer is getting fooled a little bit
here.
So that's one way in which those forecasters are really important.
Okay.
Well, I get that.
But what I guess what I'm wondering is, like when these guys get together, and I'm sure
there are plenty of women meteorologists as well but when they get together do they sit around and go at the convention go you
know Bob he is a meteorologist meteorologist he is the best guy in the
business and if that's true if they do that what is it that makes him the best
guy in the business I don't get. I think that varies a little bit depending on the weather. You don't get to be a meteorologist
in a National Weather Service office unless you've already demonstrated that you're pretty
good. But within each office, there's a role called the warning forecast coordinator. And
so those are the people who are really on the hot seat when it's tornado weather
and they're sitting there making the decisions about issuing tornado warnings that have all
sorts of implications for people.
The warning coordinator, meteorologist, you know, that's one of the key people in that
office.
It would be fun to be able to say, and the best meteorologist
in America, or the five best, are these people, but it's such a diffuse operation.
There's local weather, there's hurricane weather, there's tornado weather, and
there are people who specialize in each of these areas.
Okay, I understand.
It's more complicated than I guess I thought.
I'm talking with Thomas Weber.
He's author of the book, Cloud Warriors,
Deadly Storms, Climate Chaos,
and the Pioneers Creating a Revolution
in Weather Forecasting.
Hey, it's Hillary Frank from The Longest Shortest Time,
an award-winning podcast about parenthood and reproductive health.
We talk about things like sex ed, birth control, pregnancy, bodily autonomy, and, of course, kids of all ages.
But you don't have to be a parent to listen.
If you like surprising, funny, poignant stories about human relationships and, you know, periods, The Longest Shortest Time is for you.
Find us in any podcast app or at longestshortesttime.com.
From the podcast that brought you
to each of the last lesbian bars in the country
and back in time through the sapphic history
that shaped them comes a brand new season
of cruising beyond the bars.
This is your host, Sara Gabrielli,
and I've spent the past year interviewing history-making
lesbians and queer folks about all kinds of queer spaces,
from bookstores to farms to line dancing and much more.
You can listen to Cruising on Apple Podcasts, Spotify,
or wherever you get your podcasts.
New episodes air every other Tuesday starting February 4th.
So Tom, when a weather forecast goes wrong, and here's my favorite story of this,
when I was a little kid, I remember this so well, I grew up in Connecticut and in Connecticut we had
a lot of snow days and one night the weather forecast was there are provisional heavy snow
warnings in effect. And I thought great, no school tomorrow, I'm not going to do my homework.
So I didn't do my homework and I woke up the next morning, there was not a flake
of snow
anywhere. And I went to my father and I said, what are provisional heavy snow
warnings?
And he said, well, providing it snows,
probably snow a lot, but it didn't snow at all.
Well, why didn't't snow at all.
Well, why didn't it snow at all?
What, when it goes wrong, what if there is an answer to this,
what typically goes wrong and do they go back and go,
oh yeah, we missed that?
Or is it more flukey than that and it just, we missed it?
Sometimes it's a matter of a few miles.
And I can tell you my own experience with this and something I've talked with meteorologists about.
I live in New York City and I would say, you know, at least once a year you hear, oh my gosh, there is a potentially big snow event on the way.
New York city needs to be prepared and then no snow.
It rains for a couple of hours.
What that reflects where I live and probably, you know, part, some of the parts
of Connecticut that you're talking about the line between where it is cold enough
about the line between where it is cold enough for that precipitation to turn into snow versus fall is rain.
If that shifts by five miles, it means New York city either gets big snowfall
or New York city is completely untouched by snow but gets some rain. So some of it is really just
how localized some of the effects of the weather can be. Yeah, but sometimes it's just wrong. It's
like, you know, it's supposed to rain and it was sunny. I mean, it was just sometimes it's wrong.
And I'm trying to get a sense of it. Was that a mistake or it's just that we can't be
Accurate all the time and sometimes things happen that we just cannot predict
Okay, i'm gonna throw a word out at you that you're probably gonna kill me for introducing here, but there's
deterministic forecasting and there's
Probabilistic forecasting and this is really inside baseball, but it illustrates a big
Point for the public trying to understand when forecasts are right or wrong
The public or if you look on your smartphone app, you know, you see a little icon, right?
And it says sunny or you know has a little cloud or whatever And so you think like, okay, the forecast for today is sunny.
Then it turns out to rain or you might be the opposite.
That's a deterministic forecast because it's just saying it's this or the other, right?
It's saying it's going to be sunny.
It's not going be sunny what actually comes out of the computers and gets.
Interpreted by the meteorologist is a probability.
Right so and sometimes you see this in your phone app or when the forecasters talking on tv and they'll say a forty percent chance of rain.
and they'll say a 40% chance of rain. So, you know, maybe you think like,
oh, 40%, I'm not gonna worry about it that much.
But then you walk outside and, you know,
you wind up without your umbrella
and you wind up getting slammed.
Humans are notoriously not great
at handling probabilistic information.
Small probabilities seem like things that just definitely won't come true,
but if there's a 30% chance of something happening,
it's a one in three roll of the dice for that coming true.
Meteorologists are actually working on how to try
to better communicate the probability information
around forecasts, but it's hard.
I mean, our natural instinct is to want,
certainty is to want to know yes or no.
It's going to snow, it's not going to snow.
Well, you mentioned this earlier
and it's something I've thought about a lot and that is
It's one thing to be able to predict the weather very accurately and in the cases of extreme weather
You know major snowstorm hurricane tornado
That kind of thing. It's one thing to accurately predict what's going to happen the damage it's going to do
It's one thing to accurately predict what's going to happen, the damage it's going to do, but it doesn't tell the people who live there what they should do.
Should they stay?
Should they go?
That's kind of the missing link in the chain is, okay, here's the horrible thing that's
going to happen, and here's what you specifically need to do.
And then how accurate are those directions?
I can tell you that when we had the big fires here there were people we were all told to get out
and many of us did but there were people who stayed and fought the fire because
the fire department wasn't here and they stayed fought the fire and I have no
doubt saved our home and other homes on this street that would have burned had
they not stayed
even though they were in violation of the police directive to get out. Mike, you
know, what's becoming even more complicated is we all may face any type
of weather at almost any time as the atmosphere seems to get, you know, more
active and the climate seems to evolve.
Last year there was a wildfire in Brooklyn.
People living in New York City, they haven't really ever had to think too much about wildfire
weather, but this actually happened.
A more serious example, I might say, the big heat wave in 2021 that struck
the Pacific Northwest, and that was an event that went on for days. The forecasters a week out for
the Northwest were warning that there would be record high temperatures, six, seven days from, you know, from those early forecasts.
But hundreds of people died across Washington state and into Canada and British Columbia
and Oregon. And part of that just reflects that the Pacific Northwest, you know, there
there are people there are used to dealing with rainy weather, right?
That's kind of their default bad weather.
A heat wave of that magnitude, if you live in Arizona, it's not pleasant, but you understand
what the effect of heat like that can be.
If you live in the Pacific Northwest, you may not
have an air conditioner, you may not even realize what health symptoms might occur if
you're being affected by the heat. And that's one of the reasons that event was so dangerous
and resulted in so many fatalities. This was new to the people who lived there.
And so a big point for me in increasing
your weather literacy is kind of being ready for anything
and not just what you think of as your local weather.
Well, I think it's very hard to know what you will do
until you're actually faced with the evacuation order.
You've got to get out. The hurricane is coming or the fire is coming, and people really don't
want to leave their homes to wash away or burn. Well, it's true. I talked to, I was
talking to some law enforcement officers who have been involved in hurricane
evacuations. The first responders, they're hearing this official information that's being passed on
to them from forecasters through the state hierarchy.
And you know, they're hearing it's pretty serious.
And they told me, they'll resort to things like saying to somebody, okay, then here's
a Sharpie.
I want you to write your telephone number and your name and your social security number
on your arm right now because you know what?
I don't know if we'd be able to rescue you if it gets as bad as they're saying.
There was a forecaster in New Jersey at the Weather Service when Sandy was headed to New
Jersey and he was worried that just the regular language of warnings wasn't
enough. And so he put out this thing that said a personal plea and
basically, and basically said, this is going to be worse than anything
you've ever seen.
I would rather you take the steps that I'm suggesting.
And then if it turns out to not be so bad,
call me up and yell at me.
I will be fine with that,
because at least you will be there
to call me and yell at me.
I'm willing to take that heat.
I do not wanna think about what happens to you
if you don't heed the warnings.
And so listening to a forecast really means accepting
that there's some uncertainty.
It might not turn out to be as bad as the forecast is saying,
but do you really want to take that chance?
Well, that's a question everybody's gonna have to ask
and answer for themselves.
But I certainly like hearing how the weather forecasting
business has improved and how not only are they trying to improve
how they predict the weather, but also what that information means to the public.
I've been talking with Thomas Weber.
He is the former executive editor of Time Magazine and author of the book Cloud Warriors,
Deadly Storms, Climate Chaos, and the pioneers creating a revolution in weather forecasting.
And there's a link to that book in the show notes. Tom, thank you for being here.
Thanks, Mike. It's good to talk about it.
Hey, everyone. Join me, Megan Rinks.
And me, Melissa Demonts for Don't Blame Me, But Am I Wrong?
Each week, we deliver four fun-filled shows.
In Don't Blame Me, we tackle our listeners' dilemmas with hilariously honest advice.
Then we have But Am I Wrong,
which is for the listeners that didn't take our advice.
Plus, we share our hot takes on current events.
Then tune in to see you next Tuesday
for our listener poll results from But Am I Wrong.
And finally, wrap up your week with Fisting Friday,
where we catch up and talk all things pop culture.
Listen to Don't Blame Me,
But Am I Wrong on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you get your podcasts. New episodes
every Monday, Tuesday, Thursday, and Friday. Do you love Disney? Then you are going to love
our hit podcast Disney Countdown. I'm Megan, the Magical Millennial. And I'm the dapper Danielle.
On every episode of our fun and family-friendly show,
we count down our top 10 lists of all things Disney.
There is nothing we don't cover.
We are famous for rabbit holes, Disney-themed games,
and fun facts you didn't know you needed,
but you definitely need in your life.
So if you're looking for a healthy dose of Disney magic,
check out Disney Countdown wherever you get your podcasts.
So here's something I bet you haven't thought much about, but human beings biologically
adapt in ways that are fascinating based on where they are or where they're from.
Through evolution, populations adapt to fit the environment, from the color and shade
of your skin, to the size of your spleen, to how tall you are.
These adaptations can sometimes be very subtle and even invisible, but interesting and worth
understanding nonetheless.
And here to help us understand it is Herman Ponser.
He is a professor of evolutionary anthropology
and global health at Duke University. He's conducted research all over the
world and that research has been covered in the New York Times, the BBC, the
Washington Post, the Atlantic and Scientific American. He's author of a book
called Adaptable, How Your Unique Body Really works and why our biology unites us.
Hi Herman, welcome to Something You Should Know.
Thanks for having me.
So explain a little deeper here what you mean by how we adapt and why this is important.
Every part of our body is this interplay of evolutionary adaptation, the way things are
shaped and the way things work.
But also our adaptability in terms of how,
our unique genetics, our DNA,
interacts with the environments that we grow up in
and we live in to kind of make us unique, right?
So there's, you can find books out there
on human physiology and that kind of thing.
And that'll tell you how some sort of
average human's bodies works.
But of course, each of us is unique. We're all different
So what I want to talk about and you know open people's eyes to just how adaptable we are and how that adaptability
Makes each of us unique and so to get a better understanding of that. Give me an example of how
The body the human body adapts to its environment
Here's a fun one, something as simple as height,
for example.
So, you know, of course we all know how tall we are
and we all think we understand sort of why that is.
You know, your genetics obviously plays a good big part,
but there's sort of layers of adaptability there.
So first of all, we're all sort of human-sized
and not giraffe-sized or mouse-sized
because of the evolution of our species
put us in the human range of where we are.
And so people are taller and shorter around the world, but there's a human size.
And so that's the sort of old evolutionary adaptation.
But then within that, as we grow up, the amount of nutrition you get is going to affect
how well your body is able to build your skeleton and build your body.
And so your genetics plays a role too. If you have tall parents, you're gonna
have tall, you're more likely to be tall. So you have this sort of interplay there.
And then what's interesting then is if we look across the world, and as an
anthropologist I get to work with communities all over the world. When we find local population, sometimes there are
local, you know, very kind of regionally specific selection pressures that favor a very tall thin
or a very or a shorter stockier build. So for example, working in northern Kenya, we work with
a population called the
dosnitch and they live with their herds, they're sort of goats and cattle and camels. And they
tend to grow just tall and thin and that's an adaptation in that local environment to
be able to, you know, thermoregulate, just to stay cool in really hot environments. And
there's a funny story there, we started working there. We were talking to one of the local charities that was trying to do food supplementation
in that community.
And the guy we talked to said, oh, it's terrible.
All the kids here, about 60% of the kids are malnourished and there's just nothing we can
do about it.
We're doing these food supplementations and we can't seem to change the way they grow.
And we were able to actually get ahold of growth chart data
from the local health clinic of this population.
And when we had data from sort of thousands of kids,
we were able to see that actually
these kids weren't malnourished.
They're just growing.
That local population is sort of adapted
to live in a very hot environment
and they're adapted to have a tall, thin body build.
And so, you know, what that looks like on a growth chart
is that you're not getting enough nutrition
because you look too skinny for how tall you are.
But actually, that's an example of local adaptation
to that particular environment.
So we look across the body, all of our different,
you know, organs, systems, and everything about us
has a story like that to tell,
and it helps understand, you helps understand what we're about.
So in that case, if you took someone from here and put them there and they were not tall and thin,
would they relatively quickly become tall and thin because of the environment, the lifestyle, the diet?
Or is the tall and thinness that would take generations for that to happen?
Yeah, so in that case, that kind of local adaptation, that would take generations. That's right. So
populations, we tend to kind of get it a little bit wrong, I think, when we think about why
populations differ from one another. We tend to think of these big kind of racial categories.
Well, race is actually not a biologically coherent category. What you see when you look around the world is
actually sort of, most folks are all the same. Most of the gene variants that we'd find in
one population will find in another. But every now and then there are in different systems
and different populations, there are conditions that will favor, you know, particular genetic variants,
we call them alleles.
And they'll be, those variants,
because they're adapted,
because they improve survival and reproduction,
they'll be favoring the environment,
they become more common.
And what happens over time is those alleles,
those gene variants that in this case
tend to make people grow up taller and thinner,
will be more common.
So when we do a survey of that local population,
we'll see mostly people with those gene variants.
Now, if you or I were to move there,
if we don't carry those gene variants,
of course, we're not gonna grow up like that.
And our kids won't grow up like that
if they don't have those gene variants.
Those sort of change in what gene variants
become really common takes generations and generations.
Of mixing with that population
and then becoming more like them.
Well, so yes, there would be gene flow,
there'd be intermarriage,
but it wouldn't take just that
because those tall, thin alleles are also present here
in our American population.
They're just less frequent, right?
So of course we can all think about people
who grow up a bit tall and thin,
that just happens to be the way that their bodies grow versus people who who grow up a bit tall and thin. That just happens to be the way that their bodies grow
versus people who might grow up a bit shorter and stockier.
Well, so those tall, thin variants are in every population,
but they just become really common there
so that everybody has them,
as opposed to here in the United States, for example,
where it's much less common.
Well, what about the common experience now
of it seems that people in the West
are much more overweight than they used to be?
Well, that's a great question.
So that gets us to the sort of evolutionary history
of our diet and why it is that we tend to overeat.
People in the Western industrialized countries
tend to overeat.
What is it about that?
And that's another story of sort of how our digestive systems evolved
And then how they adapt to our different food environments. So
Of course humans are adapted to a human diet. What does that mean?
Well, you know, it's actually quite variable what humans are able to thrive on and people are you know
A whole mix of different things but that's you know
We can see that in our digestive system.
The human digestive system is built to thrive
on any mix of kind of animal and plant foods.
Okay, well, so why is it then that we are tending
to have this overweight issue, this obesity issue,
in the US, in Europe, and other industrialized countries?
Is it the diet?
Well, it probably isn't any one thing about the diet,
because humans can eat
a range of things and be healthy. We see that over and over again in other sort of traditional
populations. But what we can find is that, ah, okay, the foods that we have sort of engineered
and filled our supermarkets with here in the U.S., for example, are foods that light up our brain's reward system and kind of push us to overeat.
And the way that we learned that is through,
of course, experiments here, studies here in the US,
kind of controlled lab studies
where we can watch people's brains light up
when they eat particular foods.
But another source of information on that is,
well, we can test the idea, for example,
that carbohydrates or sugars
are really the root cause of obesity. When we can test the idea, for example, that carbohydrates or sugars are the root
cause of obesity.
When we look around the globe, we can find lots of traditional societies that are eating
lots of high-carb diets, and they don't have an obesity issue at all.
So again, humans can thrive on a range of foods.
We see that again and again around the world and through time.
But the foods that we've engineered for ourselves and fill our supermarkets with are some of them are really, you know
You probably can imagine which ones they are, you know, the the donuts and the chips and everything else that's sort of engineered to be
hyper delicious
Yeah, but as we've talked about here before not everybody
succumbs to that not everybody becomes overweight because of those engineered
foods. Why is that? Ah, well that comes down to your unique genetics. Are you
born with, you know, did you happen to get lucky and get gene variants from mom and
dad that make your, build your brain, build your reward system sort of less
responsive to these cues that push
other people to sort of overeat. If you did get those alleles, then lucky you, you're less likely
to be, you know, just to struggle with your weight in adulthood. If you didn't get those alleles,
then you're very likely to be kind of struggling with portion control and that kind of thing.
So that's why some people have a problem and other people's don't.
It's possible to your point that, you know,
given enough time, and this would have to be
hundreds of generations, thousands of generations,
that somehow those alleles that are less responsive
to modern foods might become more common.
But I don't think we wanna wait around for that.
I think we wanna address the issue now in our environments.
So what's another good example of human adaptability that I probably have never thought about?
Well, your immune system is a great example, right?
So your immune system has parts of it that are built to be the infantry that that'll take care of any
pathogen that comes your way, bacteria and microbes, that kind of thing. And, you know, the common cold, other
viruses and bacteria that we see all the time.
You've got what's called an innate immune system
that is just your first line of defense
against all that stuff.
But then you have this very clever, adaptable immune system
that is paying attention to what you are seeing today
and what you're getting sick with today
and building antibodies
as a response to be smart to be able to respond to it tomorrow.
Right?
Or maybe not tomorrow, but the next time you get sick with this pathogen.
And so that's a clear case of sort of adaptability through a lifetime.
If you are sick with something as a child, you're less likely to get it again or be as
sick if you get it later.
And I think this is not only an important example
of adaptability, if we understand our bodies
and understand our biology,
that's an important way in to address
a lot of the big questions we have in society today.
I mean, there's not more of a hot button topic out there
than vaccination.
And, you know, vaccination has actually been
a kind of a hot button issue
since it was first started hundreds of years ago.
But today we see it as a really big polarized issue
and people talking about, well, it's not natural or whatever.
Actually, it's incredibly natural.
It's an evolved, you know, your learned immune,
the learned immune response,
your adaptable immune response,
acquired immunity is what we call it,
is actually an evolved natural part
of how your immune system works.
And vaccination just sort of takes advantage of that
and introduces a pathogen.
So you can learn from that and adapt to that pathogen
without getting really sick.
So talk about how skin color, the shade of our skin,
is an adaptation, a human adaptation to our environment.
Why is it that some folks have darker skin than others?
Well, it turns out that there's a cell type in your skin called a melanocyte that makes this stuff called melanin.
Melanin is the pigment that makes you darker.
And we all, all of us, all of our skin
has cells that make melanin.
If you have darker skin, it's because you make more melanin.
If you have lighter skin, it's because you make less.
Well, why do people vary in how much melanin they make?
Well, because it's an adaptation to sunlight, basically.
When you have really intense sunlight,
like at the equator, all that ultraviolet radiation can be really damaging to your DNA
and damaging to this molecule called folate that you need to make DNA.
And your cells are constantly dividing, you're constantly making DNA,
and so that's a real problem if you damage the DNA or damage the folate.
So you don't want to get too much UV.
However, you do want to get some because ultraviolet light is also important
for making vitamin D. Right? So you're caught in this balance. You want to get enough UV,
enough ultraviolet light to make vitamin D, but not too much that you damage your DNA.
Here's where melanin comes in. Melanin is a natural sunblock. So that pigment that makes
your skin a bit darker is acting like a
natural sunblock and it absorbs ultraviolet light will prevent you from
having DNA damage but it will also minimize how much vitamin D you can make.
Okay well now we can see how skin color then, how light or dark your skin is, is
responding to the amount of ultraviolet light in your environment. If you're
from a population that's been there for generations in a tropical, high ultraviolet light intensity
environment, there's been selection there to favor the gene variants that make cells that make more
melanin. So the darker skin variants are gonna be favored.
If you live in a north, far north or far south,
away from the equator, where the sunlight's weaker,
you're gonna have less melanin favored
because you wanna be able to absorb
whatever sunlight's there.
So that's a great example of people's adaptability
over time, evolutionarily, to their local environments.
Now, you know, can you or I, so I have light skin.
I'm from a Northeastern European population.
Can I go to someplace that's got really intense ultraviolet light and be okay?
Sure, if I put on sunblock.
But if I don't, then I'm at a higher risk of, you know, skin cancer
and other problems like that.
So, yes, we're adaptable and sort of culturally adaptable but there's also this
interesting biological adaptation that's underlying all of that that I think also
helps us make sense of the diversity around the world. Well but there are
other differences too when people have say darker skin they also tend to have
darker hair when people have lighter skin they may have lighter
hair, they may have blue eyes where dark skinned people have darker eyes. Are all
these things related or are these all separate adaptations? So melanin is an
important pigment for your eye color and your hair color too. And so people who
tend to have darker skin also tend to have darker hair. So give me another human adaptation that maybe is invisible, like you don't see it,
but it's still important. Yeah, here's a really fun one. Your spleen. So people
probably don't think about their spleens too much. It's this sort of slipper
shaped organ that's tucked on the left side of your rib cage there below your diaphragm and it's a spongy organ and it's full of, it sort
of monitors blood cells that come through and it's part of your immune
system to monitor that but it's also this kind of reserve tank of red blood
cells. Now red blood cells are the ones that carry oxygen around your body so it turns out that people who live in either in high altitude or
this really
Really interesting case of a population that lives at sea
They're basically a hunting and gathering group who lives their whole life on the ocean in boats and dives, you know
Over a hundred feet sometimes into the water to get food.
If you are spending your life underwater,
the day of diving for your food,
or you're spending your life at the top of a mountain,
like in the Andes or in the Himalaya,
you actually have the same problem,
which is oxygen is scarce, right?
And then so in those populations,
we see larger spleens evolved
and gene variants that actually favor a larger spleen size.
That's a great example of a local adaptation
and something that you would never notice.
Of course, you can't tell by looking at somebody
how big their spleen is,
but evolution is working behind the scenes in some cases
to favor these features like that.
There are people who live on boats?
Isn't that great?
You know, when we think about human diversity,
often we're kind of still have a very American mindset.
You know, we only kind of notice what we see around us.
And that's a really limited slice of what's out there.
You know, when you go around the world,
you look at populations who live
in all kinds of environments, all kinds of populations who live in all kinds of environments,
all kinds of lifestyles, all kinds of contexts,
you see the human body really pushed and pulled
into different adaptations.
This is a population, they're called the Samah,
and yes, they live their lives.
They're in the South Pacific,
on islands in the South Pacific,
and of course they'll come to land sometimes,
but they will spend
weeks, months, you know, lots and lots of time at sea. That's where they spend most of their lives, on boats. And they fish, of course, for their food. And the men especially will free dive,
they just jump in. They don't have scuba or anything like that. This is a traditional society.
They dive down there and they're spearfishing
and that kind of thing for their food.
So yeah, I mean, that's a great example
of how the diversity in cultures that we see around us
can also push our bodies in interesting ways.
Well, it's interesting to hear of these,
you know, very peculiar adaptations.
And yet it's still within a fairly small window humans are
humans they can only adapt so much that's right so the human body there are
still limits on how warm in the body can get how cold you can get you know how
many calories you need but we are adaptable and you know part of what
we're adaptable about is is we have this really rich cultural set of
adaptations that we live with, clothing, shelter, you
know, ways to prepare our foods, ways to go get food, that makes us sort of, we're the
only big mammal that can live just about anywhere in the globe. I think we're probably the most
widespread large mammal ever. And it's because we're so adaptable in our bodies, but also
in our behaviors.
Well, see, this is one of those topics that I would never even
think to think about until you came along, but it makes you think about how
just how adaptable humans have been and have had to be in order to survive and
thrive. Herman Ponzer has been my guest. He is a professor of evolutionary
anthropology and global health at Duke University.
And he is author of a book called Adaptable, How Your Unique Body Really Works and Why
Our Biology Unites Us.
And there's a link to his book at Amazon in the show notes.
Herman, hey, thank you for coming on and talking about spleens and things.
I appreciate it.
Yeah, thanks, man.
I appreciate it. Yeah, thanks man. I appreciate it too.
If you're keeping a secret right now, the sooner you tell someone that secret, the better.
A study from Tufts University confirms that keeping a secret can affect everything else you do.
It could be good news that you're waiting to announce or something not so good that you feel you need to hide, but holding on to it and not telling someone
can actually hurt. The burden of suppressing a secret can act as an
emotional and physical weight in your day-to-day life. People keeping secrets
tend to move slower and require more energy to get things done.
So tell someone your secret.
And that is something you should know.
Wherever you listen to this podcast, whether it's Apple Podcasts, Spotify, Castbox, Pocketcast,
they all have a share function.
And I would like you to put that share function to use
and share this episode with someone you know
who you think would enjoy listening to it.
It helps us grow our audience
and it's a great way to support the show.
I'm Mike Herr-Rothers.
Thanks for listening today to Something You Should Know.
Hey, it's Hillary Frank from The Longest Shortest Time,
an award-winning podcast about parenthood
and reproductive health.
There is so much going on right now in the world of reproductive health, and we're covering
it all.
Birth control, pregnancy, gender, bodily autonomy, menopause, consent, sperm, so many stories
about sperm, and of course, the joys and absurdities of raising kids of all ages.
If you're new to the show, check out an episode called The Staircase.
It's a personal story of mine about trying to get my kids' school to teach sex ed.
Spoiler, I get it to happen, but not at all in the way that I wanted.
We also talk to plenty of non-parents, so you don't have to be a parent to listen.
If you like surprising, funny, poignant stories about human relationships and, you know, periods,
The Longest Shortest Time is for you.
Find us in any podcast app or at longestshortesttime.com.