StarTalk Radio - #ICYMI - Gender Inequality in Sports, with Heather O’Reilly

Episode Date: May 23, 2019

In case you missed this episode on the Playing with Science channel…. Hosts Gary O’Reilly and Chuck Nice investigate the systemic gender bias and discrimination happening in professional sports wi...th World Cup winner and former USWNT soccer star Heather O’Reilly, and economist Andrew Zimbalist, PhD. Photo Credit: Courtesy of Heather O’Reilly. Subscribe to SiriusXM Podcasts+ on Apple Podcasts to listen to new episodes ad-free and a whole week early.

Transcript
Discussion (0)
Starting point is 00:00:01 I'm Gary O'Reilly. And I'm Chuck Nice. And this is Playing With Science. Today we return to gender in sport and the pay gap between the women and the men. So simply put, show me the money. And to help us understand what it takes to rise to the very, very top of her sport and stay there, we have... Heather O'Reilly. She is a three-time olympic gold medal
Starting point is 00:00:26 winner and a world cup winner and owner of 230 caps for the u.s women's national team over a 15 year period and no she is not related to gary is she duh it's quite easy to see really when you think she's talented Really talented And I don't have my name Don't you dare put yourself down I haven't got my name in that sentence But banging on about the pay gap And gender inequality is meaningless
Starting point is 00:00:53 Totally meaningless If we can't explain the hows and the whys So crunching the numbers for us And bringing a wealth of experience Is Robert A. Woods Professor of Economics at Smith College, Andrew Zimbalist. So let's get to the good professor, shall we?
Starting point is 00:01:09 And we certainly shall. So Andrew has published numerous articles and books, 28 books to be exact, including Equal Pay, Title IX, and Social Change, the International Handbook of Economics and Megasports Events, Circus Maximus, the economic gamble behind hosting the Olympics and the World Cup, and Rio 2016, Olympic myths and hard realities. And that is just a smattering of what this man does.
Starting point is 00:01:42 I don't know where he gets the time. I actually write an email in the morning and I have to take a nap. I don't know where he gets the time. I actually write an email in the morning and I have to take a nap. I don't get it. I don't get people like this. This guy's amazing. Welcome, Andrew Zimbalist. How are you, Andy?
Starting point is 00:01:55 I'm doing great. How are you doing? Good. Doing well, man. Thank you for being here. Right, let's jump straight in. Sports, money, things that have now not been separated in sentences for some time.
Starting point is 00:02:09 So there seems to be a growing movement for gender equality in sports in terms of payments. I'll ask you a question. Where is it most likely to happen first? Which sport? Well, you know, it's already happened in some sports. There's small sports. For instance, in mogul skiing in the United States, which is an Olympic sport, there are five women on the U.S. mogul team and there are five men and they're treated the same.
Starting point is 00:02:37 So in small sports that haven't been highly commercialized, you already see some of it. But in terms of the larger sports, where is it going to happen first? I think the suit that was brought by the women in U.S. soccer is going to take us very close to gender equality. I mean, these women who are on the U.S. national team, there are 28 of them, far outperform the men. They've been ranked first in the world 10 out of the last 11 years. That's right. They have won. They've won four Olympic gold medals. They've won three World Cups. These women play at the very top of their sport. They have generated more revenue
Starting point is 00:03:18 and more profits for U.S. Soccer Federation than the men have generated, yet their pay is 38%. And so they brought a suit, an equal pay act suit against U.S. soccer. I think it has a very good chance. And so hopefully we'll see something approaching gender equality in women's soccer in the next three or four years. What about women's tennis? I mean, I think we have seen some kind of parity, a move towards parity from the market side. I believe that people are far more, not far more, equally as interested in seeing the women play, especially with respect to Serena, as they are to seeing Andy and the rest of the guys. What do you say about that? Well, actually, there has been tremendous progress also in women's tennis.
Starting point is 00:04:07 tremendous progress also in women's tennis. As of a few years ago, each of the four grand slams awards the same prize money to the winner on the women's side as on the men's side. Excellent. The women don't do as well below first place as the men do. But the fact that the prize money for first place is equal is a tremendous accomplishment. And you're right. The fact of the matter is in women's tennis that it really depends on who are the two men playing against each other and who are the two women playing against each other. And if the matchup is better for the women than it is for the men, then you might very well get a more people in the stands and be more people watching on television for the women's matches. The men tend to edge out the women in terms of demand,
Starting point is 00:04:46 the number of people watching, but it's not always the case. So what historically have been the arguments for men getting paid more, much more than women when it comes to sports? The argument is almost always that the men's version of the competition is more popular because it's more popular. More people go to the arenas or the stadiums. More people watch on television. The prices of the tickets at the arenas or the stadiums is higher.
Starting point is 00:05:14 So the men at the end of the day generate more revenue than the women. That's not always true. It's not always true in tennis. It's not always true in soccer. It doesn't always have to be true anyway. I mean, one of the reasons for the disparity, although a lot of people like to think, and this is something that Bobby Riggs used to argue with regard to Billie Jean King and tennis, is that, you know, we as men are so much better. Our physical prowess is so much higher than the
Starting point is 00:05:41 woman's. And sports fans want to see the best. They don't want to see the second best or the third best. I think that that argument only goes so far. I mean, if that were really true, why would anybody watch a college football game? Because we know the NFL is better than FBS Division I level football in college. Why would anybody watch a college basketball?
Starting point is 00:06:01 Why is America obsessed with March Madness? Why would anybody watch the Knicks? Why would anybody watch the Knicks? Do they still watch the Knicks? Yeah, you know what? You just cannot take your filly out of you. You can't take the filly out of him, Professor. Sorry. The two problems with that argument are,
Starting point is 00:06:16 number one, that even if it's the case that women generate less revenue than men in some sports, it's not the case that they generate no revenue. So for instance, and this is remarkable to me, in this day and age, this is still happening. The men, when they win a game in the March Madness tournament, the NCAA basketball tournament, when the men's team wins a game, their conference is paid by the NCAA, $280,000 each year for six successive years. So they get basically $1.7 million each game they win, and they can win six games going
Starting point is 00:06:52 to the finals in that tournament. So they potentially can generate $10 million of revenue. How much do you think the women get for every game they win? I couldn't even. They get a big zero. They get nothing. Nothing. Now, so go back to the argument. The standard argument is that the men generate more revenue than the women.
Starting point is 00:07:10 Right. Okay, let's grant that. But the women don't generate zero revenue. They had average attendance at the women's final four of 12,000 people. ESPN was carrying the games on television. Right. ESPN1 and ESPN2. So there's revenue.
Starting point is 00:07:24 So there's revenue dollars being generated. So maybe you could argue, maybe you could argue the men should get 280 and the women should get only 200 or 140, but you can't argue they should get zero. This is just crass discrimination. And part of the problem, it's very important, part of the problem is the media. The media doesn't pay due attention to the women. I had a student of mine do a survey looking at USA Today articles in the sports section on men and women. And the men are getting 90 percent of the coverage. The women are getting 10 percent. There was another study that was done for Southern California.
Starting point is 00:07:54 The women get 4 percent of the coverage on the sports pages in Southern California. So these prejudices, the historical prejudices that we have are being reinforced by the media. Differential treatment by the media. Let me keep you in that same vein and talk about Title IX for a second and the argument. And there's a big argument that says that, I'm talking all sports now, okay, that when you add women's teams and when you give women the opportunity to play, what you end up doing is displacing men's teams and taking away opportunities for men to play and people want to see the men play. What do you say to that argument? Because I'm sure you have some opinions. Yeah, there's actually a long story behind all of that.
Starting point is 00:08:45 Most of the reduction in men's teams happened in the 1980s, early 1990s, and it would happen with men's wrestling primarily. It's very interesting. This was a period of time when Ronald Reagan was president at first, and he was followed by George Herbert Walker Bush. And both of those gentlemen didn't care a wink about implementing Title IX. And in fact, Reagan had a position was that the sports departments and universities, if they did not receive federal funding directly, shouldn't be subject to Title IX. So he didn't implement Title IX. So the period of time when the men suffered the most in terms of losing sports was a period when Title IX was not being implemented in any meaningful way.
Starting point is 00:09:28 Interesting. Yeah. Beyond that, look, the point of college intercollegiate athletics, the stated point in the NCAA Constitution, is to promote a balanced existence for the college student so that the student who at least notionally is leading a sedentary existence, reading books, writing papers, needs to balance that off to have a rounded emotional development, needs to balance it off with physical activity. One of the things intercollegiate sports brings to both men and women is not only that attempt to balance their lives, but in participating in those sports, they learn tenacity, they learn discipline, they learn time management, they learn leadership skills. They are less likely to fall subject to use of drugs and other abuses. So these are
Starting point is 00:10:17 benefits that should accrue equally to men and women. And there's no reason why you should say, given what the premise of college sports is, it's not generating money. It's not generating television eyeballs. It's generating balanced development for college students. Given that premise, I think that it's really silly to come forward and say the women don't deserve to have that benefit as much as the men do. Excellent. Excellent point. I is no argument in time. I mean, seriously. Andy, you just nailed that.
Starting point is 00:10:48 If this were an NCAA-sanctioned gymnastics event, you nailed the landing, my friend. That was great. I'll tell you what I will do. I'll push it into the professional side, and we'll go back to women's soccer. We have the World Cup in France in June of this year, 2019. Last year's Men's World Cup grossed $6 billion. What do we think, Professor, the Women's World Cup will gross? Well, first of all, you have to be very careful when you use numbers
Starting point is 00:11:18 for these sport mega events. There's a lot of accounting chicanery that goes on. And so it's perilous just to throw out some number because somebody saw it in a newspaper. So $6 billion, maybe that's the right number. Maybe it's some other number. The women have not generated as much total popularity, as much total demand as the men have generated.
Starting point is 00:11:42 But it is true that when the U.S. women won the last Women's World Cup in 2015, their final game had 23 million people watching it, which is the highest number of people watching a soccer match in the United States in the history of television in the United States. So the women might very well be below a $6 billion figure. I can't predict what that number will be. But they're going to be generating billions of dollars. And they deserve to be rewarded commensurately. So let me ask you this.
Starting point is 00:12:14 I mean, I want you to speak as an economist here purely. What is the most effective means of changing public attitudes and subsequently beliefs about social issues? Because it seems to me from everything that you're saying and the current climate in which we live, it really is about perceptions. It's about attitudes. It's about, you know, how we think about sports in general. about sports in general. So is there anything from an economist standpoint that speaks to changing public attitudes and getting people to shift perspectives on social issues? You're talking about how do we have a new gestalt about gender and the role of sports? And as an economist, as a pure economist, we don't know how to make revolution.
Starting point is 00:13:07 That's not what our job is. OK. Obviously, part of part of this is a long struggle. It's just something you have to keep at it. Things like the suit that the women's soccer team is bringing is going to push push the envelope forward. I think that's very important. The media has to play a role here. You can't you can't go to the newspapers and other media outlets and say to them, hey, look, you should give women 50% of all your coverage. Why? Because their readership isn't there. Their readership will go to another paper. The New York Times starts spending 50% of its sports pages on women.
Starting point is 00:13:37 People are going to read the Wall Street Journal or the Washington Post instead. But what the newspapers can do is not reinforce the status quo. So instead of staying at 10% of media coverage for women, push the envelope, go up to 15%, go up to 20%, move your readership along.
Starting point is 00:13:55 Don't reinforce the status quo. Even though you can't go to 50% tomorrow, you can move the ball forward. Excellent, excellent stuff. Professor, thank you. Hey, we know we're under time constraints, but can we have you back? Because it's great to talk to you.
Starting point is 00:14:10 Yes. Pleasure to talk to you guys too. Thanks for having me on. Without a doubt. Pleasure's ours. All right, thank you to Professor Andrew Zimbalist. Of his 28 books, my favorite title is Circus Maximus. Circus Maximus.
Starting point is 00:14:21 It is. It just says so much just in a title. My name is Marcus Aurelius, father to a slain son. Oh, not that Circus Maximus. No. Okay. All right.
Starting point is 00:14:31 Great film, though. Sorry. All right. We're going to take a break and when we come back, there'll be lots of swords and lions and... No, there won't be.
Starting point is 00:14:38 There'll be a fabulous soccer player on the show. Someone whose career I have followed for some time. A World Cup winner. An Olympic gold medal winner. Indeed. Times three.
Starting point is 00:14:52 A 15-year international career. Yep. That's not related to me. Yes, he is. But her name is Heather O'Reilly. Gary's niece is going to be here, people. A family reunion ticket place right here on this show. Heather O'Reilly and Gary O'Reilly,
Starting point is 00:15:04 two professional soccer players, finally reconnecting right here on this show. Heather O'Reilly and Gary O'Reilly, two professional soccer players, finally reconnecting right here on our show. Oh my God, I feel just like Oprah. We'll take that break now. Welcome back to Playing With Science. We're talking about gender in sports, particularly pay inequality, currently seen between the men and the women. Just heard from Dr. Andrew Zimbalist, which was fantastic. Yeah, to open up the numbers and give us an idea.
Starting point is 00:15:49 And now we're going to talk to one of Gary's family members who happens to be a soccer player too. It runs in the family, man. No, I don't have three Olympic gold medals and neither do I have a World Cup winner's medal. Yeah. But Heather O'Reilly does. She certainly does.
Starting point is 00:16:06 And I am honored, truly honored, to be in your presence. So, yeah. Welcome to Playing With Science. Welcome, Heather. Thank you. Thank you. I'm very happy to be here. Thanks, guys.
Starting point is 00:16:16 Hey, Heather, all you do is win, win, win, no matter what. What is happening with that? Yes, I have won a few things in my day. You know what? You can't focus on that, though. You just got to keep plugging along and keep focusing on being a good person, being a good teammate, bringing your best self every single day, competing like hell to be the best, and good things happen.
Starting point is 00:16:44 So good things have happened to me. And I, uh, I'm in, I'm in my last year now as a professional player. So hopefully we'll get a few more trophies under the belt, uh, in my swan song last season. Hey, you know what you said? We're going to get, I wanted to get to that later, but we are, we are. Don't worry. Uh, let's, let's, let's sort of wind it back a little bit. Why did you end up playing football, soccer, as a young person? Because it is, as you growing up, it would have been such a male-dominated sport. What led you to the beautiful game? And by the way, not just male-dominated, an obscure male-dominated sport.
Starting point is 00:17:20 Get out of here with obscure. Come on, we're talking, this is America, man. Come on now. Come on now. Well, okay, is America, man. Come on now. Come on now. Well, okay, so I grew up in central New Jersey. I had three older brothers. And New Jersey, where I grew up, was sort of a community of immigrants. A lot of English folks, a lot of Scottish guys that were soccer coaches.
Starting point is 00:17:41 That explains a lot. I grew up in a really soccer-rich community. I mean, soccer was like the cool sport to play in my town and, uh, my brothers all played. So, you know, it was, it was an easy choice for me. Uh, I don't have one of those stories where I had like short hair and had to play on the boys team and all that kind of thing. Um, I think because of title nine, which is a really important piece of legislature that was enacted in the 70s of the World Cup was at Giant Stadium, not too far from where I grew up. And so I was just this teenage kid in
Starting point is 00:18:32 the stands watching the women play and the women won the World Cup that year. And like, I was just this 14 year old girl with tears in my eyes, just so inspired. And then I said, I want to do that. year old girl with tears in my eyes, just so inspired. And then I said, I want to do that. And then I set my goals big that I wanted to be on the national team and also try to win World Cups, try to win Olympics. So I was very lucky to have these female idols and icons right in front of me that I was able to see because there's a saying, you can't be it unless you see it. So I think that the stars aligned for me that I was able to see because there's a saying you can't be it unless you see it. So I think that the stars aligned for me and I consider myself fortunate because I know that I worked hard and I had an incredible work ethic and discipline. But at the end of the day,
Starting point is 00:19:17 I also had really good coaches. I had a supportive family and I just so happened to see those women win the 99 World Cup, which sort of lit a fire in me. Well, you know, I have to say that's a very humble and gracious answer. But let's be real. You're 14 years old and you say to yourself, I'm going to do that. And then at 17, you're doing it. So as much as you can say like, hey, I'm fortunate. There's a lot of Heather in that success. And I know you're not going to say it, but I'm going to say it. That's incredible.
Starting point is 00:19:53 When I was 14, I mean, seriously, if I took a nap in the middle of the day, that was an accomplishment as far as I was concerned. So, I mean. I know where Heather's been in the sense of you go, you see the light bulb, the fire, whichever analogy you have, you then take it forward.
Starting point is 00:20:14 Now, I mean, you were in the U.S. Women's National Team at 19. Mm-hmm. How do you cope with that mentally, the psychology of that? Yes. Well, I actually made the team at 17. Oh, then I'll... I made the team at 17 i made the team at 17
Starting point is 00:20:27 and then i competed in my first olympic games at 19 right so it was weird to be honest because um i'm sure you guys can attest you have your your you know people that you look up to your role models right these stars whether it's michael j Michael Jordan or Wayne Gretzky or Maradona or any of these superstars that you look up to. And I had posters of these women on my walls in my bedroom. And then I get this call on the telephone, that's kind of like old school version of getting the call up to the national team, got a call. And they said that there was a place for me, somebody had gotten injured and they said that there was a place for me. Somebody had gotten injured and they wanted to invest in me as a young player and come in.
Starting point is 00:21:12 So I thought that it was like, first, I thought it was like a prank call from one of my friends. That's friends for you. It wasn't a prank call. And they actually thought that I was special and unique and could bring something to the team that nobody else could. So I think in the beginning, it was a real test of my young confidence because it was kind of a weird situation. Here I was now competing with these women, actually trying to earn playing time over some of these women that I really looked up to. So as a young player, it was an interesting place for me to be in but I again I believed in myself a lot I had this you know this incredible self-belief that bordered on arrogance but you know it carried me through a
Starting point is 00:21:50 lot of times when I was when I was uh you know kind of doubting myself as a young player um and you know it worked out for me it wasn't always smooth sailing there was of course injuries and adversities along the way, but I proved my worth at a really young age that I could help the team win. Okay, from that point to where you are now, could you look back and go, what was the biggest change in a beneficial way for you? Was it a coach, a strategy, maybe an introduction of technology that you went, that really did change my game? I think for my entire career, I was always known as the fit, fast player. For a lot of my career on the national team,
Starting point is 00:22:36 we played a conventional 4-4-2, and I was like an outside midfielder, you know, putting the paces in on the outside of the field. So I think to answer your question, I think I committed to being a reliable, fit player on the team. And that wasn't always easy because everybody's pretty fit. But I wanted to be the fittest on the team. And I think that coaches always kind of told me to control
Starting point is 00:23:06 what I can control. And I always thought that being super fit and having an engine and being positive or were things that it didn't matter if you're talking about, you know, a 20 year old or a third year old coaches want it on teams, players want it on teams. It helps everybody on the training ground. Even if I'm not even getting into a game i feel like i've helped teams succeed um and and i've been able to push teammates to higher levels than they they could have gone if i wasn't there and i think uh yeah i think i i just had i had two coaches that told me to just be true to myself and i know that being true to myself was being fitter than everybody and outworking everybody.
Starting point is 00:23:47 So I tried to do that for a very long time. All right. We've got to address the one big mistake in your career, which was moving to London and playing for them, them being Arsenal. Now you don't know that I'm a childhood Tottenham fan and probably you may or may not. I used to play for Tottenham.
Starting point is 00:24:03 I know this. For you to go to Arsenal as an O'Reilly really doesn't sit too well with me. But you must have had a great time because the experience of European football at such a wonderful club like the Arsenal must have been fabulous. Oh, it was incredible. It was always something that I wanted to do in my career and it was just about finding, you know, the right time to make a move like that. And I had hung up my boots from international play in 2016.
Starting point is 00:24:28 But playing overseas in Europe was something, you know, on my resume that I hadn't been able to do yet. I hadn't won, you know, any trophies overseas. I hadn't been part of any, you know, major clubs. And so I wouldn't have gone anywhere. You know, I didn't want to. I could have gone on to Cyprus, for instance, and played Champions League You know, I didn't want to, I could have gone to Cyprus, for instance, and played Champions League football, but I didn't want to.
Starting point is 00:24:48 I wanted to be in London, be in one of the best clubs in the world. And I wanted to help English football, to be honest, because they have, you know, a lot of potential in terms of their women's national team and also the women's, the FAA Women's Super League. They have this huge potential that they're sitting on. And i thought that i just wanted to really be part of it i wanted to help bring visibility to the league any way that i can and to be honest i wanted to like just
Starting point is 00:25:14 completely dive into the football culture and i i did i went to as many games as i could go to across england i of course went to see the gunners play as many times as I could at the Emirates. We had tickets. Our men's and women's team did some events together, and we trained at the same facility, which was really special for me, especially to be there in Arsene Wenger's last season, to be honest. It was really special. Actually, on the last day when he announced his stepping down, we were having lunch in the same, you know, sort of lunch room, which we did from time to time. And I had a lump in my throat. I didn't even care.
Starting point is 00:25:50 I went over to, to Arson and just thank you for, thank him for his, his unbelievable contribution to, to football and to the club. And that it was such an honor for me to be there at the same time as him. And of course he was so gracious and he said, thank you.
Starting point is 00:26:05 Good luck with your career. I'll be looking out for you. And he was so sweet. And yeah, what a privilege. He'll have total respect for the women's teams, without a doubt. So, you know, you play, you make it look effortless. The way you lead, it's clearly
Starting point is 00:26:21 that you are a leader and it's clear that your teammates like being led by you. You know, there's a comfortability that seems to be very evident when you're on the pitch. And so what would you, starting at age 17 and being who you are now, still very young, but have accomplished so much. What would you now say to 17-year-old you? A little game of note to self will play. What would you say to the 17-year-old you who just got the call? Man, you're on this team, man.
Starting point is 00:27:01 And I can't imagine at 17 what was going through your mind. But what would you now say to that you back then? I guess I would just say to be sure of yourself. I think in football and in life, you go through seasons of highs and lows. the thing that I think saves you from getting carried away on either side of those highs and lows are, you know, a core of steel, I would say in terms of knowing yourself and your own value and your own worth. I mean, as, as Gary knows, I mean, sometimes as a footballer, you judge your value, your contribution to this planet on your play on the soccer pitch. And it's like, if you allow yourself to get so carried away with, um, the good and the bad and the,
Starting point is 00:27:52 I miss this shot or I miss this opportunity. Um, you know, I don't think that you can have a sustained career because it's just so much of a, uh, emotional rollercoaster. So I would just tell my young self, there's going to be seasons of adversity. There's going to be tough times. Just be true to yourself and be sure of yourself and surround yourself with positive people and people that will push you and look out for you.
Starting point is 00:28:19 Because there's a lot of jealous people in this world that believe that the only way to launch themselves up is to push others down. And I would, you know, as a young person, of course, you know, you don't know yourself quite yet. So you involve yourself with people like that. And I would just tell myself to stick by my true values and surround myself with the most positive people and just try to make an influence on teams that I know I can. So I wouldn't let myself get carried away with the good or the bad, and I wouldn't let my human value be determined by success or failure
Starting point is 00:28:53 on the football pitch. That is very good advice for any 17-year-old about to do anything. And what's interesting, because I used to have the same sort of mantra, don't get too disappointed when you lose, Don't get too carried away when you win. Just that nice, easy... Okay, so let's... Speaking of keeping people down, I'm just going to say full disclosure,
Starting point is 00:29:13 I'm using an intern as a chair right now. I'm just saying. The good news is it's a different intern from last week. Right. Let's get on to something... That's kind of you. Isn't it? Right. Chuck's such an egalitarian. That's kind of you. Isn't it? Right.
Starting point is 00:29:25 Chuck's such an egalitarian. I'm not a monster, Heather. All right. We can't have someone like yourself with the status that you have in women's soccer in the U.S. and not discuss the pay gap that you find right now, the lawsuit that's out there against US Soccer Federation. Where do you stand with the national team? Let's focus here on the national team in the World Cup as regards what is the reasoning, the thinking, and where you think it should be in terms of the pay divide for women's players in the U.S.? Yeah. Well, first of all, I think I just want to make clear that I'm certainly not speaking for
Starting point is 00:30:10 the team and not speaking for anybody else except for myself as an individual. And I'm actually not part of the U.S. squad that is bringing this lawsuit. So just speaking from an outside observer, So just speaking from an outside observer, I think that the reality is, and I knew this when I was with the U.S. team to an extent, but there has been an institutionalized bias and gender discrimination for decades at U.S. soccer, since the 90s. And our team has a history, and it's in our DNA, to continue to unravel these institutionalized biases that have always been around. And from the early 90s of winning the 91 world cup, they fought for more at that day. It had to do with uniforms and bus rides and things like that.
Starting point is 00:31:10 And then they go on to win the 99 world cup and they're part of Olympic games and all this stuff. And it's, you know, I don't think that there was an, an early conversation that was just laid out and said, okay, what does equal look like? How do we get there? And so because of that, it's always been a bit of a battle, right? And I think it's really important for people to realize USA Soccer, US Soccer is a nonprofit organization that is supposed to represent all of football across the U S and because of those reasons, I think that the men's and women's team should be paid equally. I think, you know, within, within that there's performance
Starting point is 00:31:52 bonuses, et cetera. Um, but this is team USA. I mean, for club football, no question, but we're talking about your Olympic team, your national team. And I think that the U.S. has a real responsibility and obligation to lead the world. Because, of course, they can look at FIFA and say, well, this is why. Because FIFA money is coming in from World Cups and X, Y, and Z. Well, of course. But, like, that's not a reason for us to not be a leader in the U.S. and do things the right way. So I'm going to go you one better, Heather.
Starting point is 00:32:31 The women should be paid more. And the reason is because they're better. How about that? How about that? When the men win something, okay, then maybe, maybe they can come up to a place of parity. But right now they are losers and they are always losers. Okay. But right now, they are losers. And they are always losers. Okay? Every four years, they do nothing but lose.
Starting point is 00:32:51 Where you guys are winners. You are the crowning jewel of Olympic sports for this country, especially when it comes to soccer. You're the only good thing that happens with respect to soccer in this country. And I'm going to say it for you. Pay me! Okay. Anyway, I'm done. Okay.
Starting point is 00:33:11 Maybe you'll get the team to speak to Chuck. Yeah. As things progress. Tell them to call me. I'll take care of this for them. I think they got it covered. I mean, incredibly high standards, too. I mean, we are expected to win the World Cup every year.
Starting point is 00:33:25 I mean, that is the standard. And we wouldn't want it any other way. But I do think that are expected to win the World Cup every year. I mean, that is the standard. And we wouldn't want it any other way. But I do think that it needs to be known that these are incredibly high standards for our squad. And, you know, the rest of the world is catching up. And so, you know, we can't just rely on these bonuses coming in if we win the World Cup. I mean, that's an absurd standard. So thank you for saying that chuck i do i do appreciate it we've come a far way there's no doubt but we can't keep patting ourselves on the back every time we say like well we've done more than the rest of the world okay well so has the team right and so um you know there needs to be this cycle that we see over and over again with media coverage, sponsorships, TV rights, all this stuff. It's a terribly toxic cycle. And we we just truly believe that USA Soccer, US Soccer has an incredible opportunity to break the cycle, put their stake in the ground and say,
Starting point is 00:34:25 this is the right thing to do. We believe in our women. They've performed for us. And we're going to break this vicious cycle by doing this. Fantastic. Chuck, now you know why Heather's a leader in the locker room and on the field. Absolutely. And she should be a diplomat because that was well played, Heather.
Starting point is 00:34:45 Okay. You're also an advocate for LGBT athletes with Athlete Ally. Am I correct? Yes. Yes. And you see, this is not just about, I want more money. No. There's a unity. Equanimity. There is a real common thread here. Leadership often on the field. Absolutely.
Starting point is 00:35:06 So we applaud you most definitely for that. Thanks. I think, you know, not all athletes feel a responsibility to do more off the pitch. I mean, and that's their prerogative. Some people just want to bag balls and call it a day. You know, but I think that, you know, being an athlete, you have a lot of eyes on you. And I've felt like a responsibility for many years to use our platform for good, to leave the world a little bit better because we have this gift and this talent and we used it well
Starting point is 00:35:38 and we used our platform well. So, you know, whether it be LGBT, you know, questions, I'm always going to back fairness and equality. And I think sport has done a good thing in pushing society, but in certain ways it has been a little bit slow. I think that we can continue to show people that they are always welcome. Athletes that want to come out on their teams should be cared for just like any teammate and loved and respected as the incredible footballer that they are. So I'll always support that. We've seen a lot of problems with racism in England right now. And I think the PFA players union just came out with a wonderful social campaign and they just said enough. Enough. We're standing together as a union and just saying like you're not doing enough to protect your players. So I'm always looking to protect people and to use this amazing...
Starting point is 00:36:46 I mean, football is one of the only things that everybody around the world loves and is visible. I think that it's one of the most important vehicles for social change that I can even think of. So, you know, you have to use your platform. I endorse everything you said there. It is such a great vehicle.
Starting point is 00:37:05 Listen, I know we got to go, but this vehicle is going to come to a stop and I've got to address this because you have posted already in the last week or so that you will retire from playing at the end of this season, which is 2019. Now, I'm on the other side of that particular looking glass,
Starting point is 00:37:20 right? And you're retired a lot longer than you play. So how did retirement find you what did it say to you as to why you chose why i chose that it was time yeah oh very i mean it's very hard and very emotional um as you know gary i think we we love this game so much and we've been doing it for a long time. Um, and I, I think that I always wanted to, I use the phrase empty my tank, you know, I could have, I won the world cup in 2015 and no doubt I had a very full career at that point. I could have just said, I'm out. I won the world cup. It's time, but I still had a little bit left in my tank and I still had a little bit left in my heart. Um, and so going to England,
Starting point is 00:38:09 playing with Arsenal with a year and a half, and now I'm back in my community that I live with my husband, Dave, I'm back, um, in, in the place where it sort of all started for me. So for me, it's been a full cycle kind of experience. And I looked at these younger players and I just think, you know, it, it is time.
Starting point is 00:38:30 I I've done it. I have, I've done it more than most. Um, and I emptied my tank. I think I have like, Oh, a few drops left.
Starting point is 00:38:41 Um, which will always keep me loving the game and will keep me playing, you know, pickup soccer, all that kind of fun stuff. So I've kept a little bit of the love of the game, but I've nearly emptied my tank. And the good thing is, is I know that the future is bright. I think I'm going to do some broadcasting this summer with Fox Sports at the Women's World Cup. So that will be interesting, me being on the other side of the lines. And I want to get my coaching badges as well. So I love this game a lot.
Starting point is 00:39:09 I know I'm always going to be part of it. And it's just taking on another form now. But as you said, Gary, I mean, it's a tough, it's a transition time that all athletes face at different points. Some are, you know, out from injury or some it's not sort of on their terms and all that stuff can be very difficult. So I'm really grateful that I'm going into this last season healthy and happy and ready to help my team. I know how you feel. I had that same feeling when I retired from professional soccer myself. The game misses you. Yeah, the game does miss me. I'm sure the fans
Starting point is 00:39:43 are still crestfallen they are yes very beside themselves with both wait before you go ahead just one quick thing okay so follow heather um at heather o'reilly on twitter okay and um here's what i want i want to give you a you do something called little known fact all right and and and they're and they're very funny okay so i just want you to respond to this one or don't, okay? I just want to read it for our fans, all right? Because little known fact, after years of being a thorn for the U.S. in the World Cups, North Korea did not qualify for 2019.
Starting point is 00:40:15 And in 2015, they were banned due to five failed drug tests in 2011. Stated reason for failing, they had accidentally taken steroids after being struck by lightning. What did North Korea have to do to you? You can't write that up. I think, you know, we've seen it all with FIFA. And I think that even FIFA was a loss for words when the North Korean coaching staff said that it was because they were struck
Starting point is 00:40:46 by lightning and they mistakenly kicked medicine to heal themselves. I don't think anybody saw that coming, but you know what? I wasn't there. I can't say if it happened or didn't happen, but all I'm saying is that I think that it shocked a few people in that press conference. And North Korea, who is usually a really good opponent, hasn't been seen in the last couple of tournaments. So I wish them well. There you go. All right. Stranger things.
Starting point is 00:41:11 Just don't stand under the tree. Heather, we've got to let you go. Have a fabulous rest of the season. And it is the Games loss and Broadcasting's bonus that you're going to be there in the Women's World Cup in France in June 2019. So we wish you the very, very best of luck. Thank you.
Starting point is 00:41:29 Thank you very much, guys. I enjoyed it. Wow. Your niece is fantastic. No. If I didn't know any better, I would never think you two were related. It's amazing.
Starting point is 00:41:40 Surprising, isn't it? Yeah. Gosh. See, it's great because there's not that many O'Reillys play professional football, soccer. But when I meet one, not only is she good, she's incredible. I mean, three Olympic golds, a World Cup.
Starting point is 00:41:54 I mean, it's just she has won wherever she's gone. And she's, I mean, she's a credit to the game. You see what she's like as a person, that dynamic attitude in the locker room, on the field, championing inequality, and is passionate. Thank you to the most incredibly talented, Heather O'Reilly. Thank you to Professor Andrew Zimbalist for his crunching of the numbers and, as I said at the beginning,
Starting point is 00:42:17 the wealth of experience that he's brought to our shows. There are lawsuits flying right now in the spring of 2019 against the US Soccer Federation. So if you want to know more, you're going to have to look in the news
Starting point is 00:42:31 columns because it's going to be there. I'm guaranteeing you that. I hope you've enjoyed our gender show and the numbers and the
Starting point is 00:42:38 passion of our guests. I've been Chuck Nice. And I've been Gary O'Reilly. And this has been Playing With Science.

There aren't comments yet for this episode. Click on any sentence in the transcript to leave a comment.