StarTalk Radio - Things You Thought You Knew – Where the Earth Ends
Episode Date: December 28, 2021Where does the Earth end? On this episode, Neil deGrasse Tyson and comic co-host Chuck Nice explore the Karman Line, LED light bulbs, banking turns and other things you thought you knew!NOTE: StarTalk...+ Patrons can watch or listen to this entire episode commercial-free.Thanks to our Patrons Shelly Woodcock, Matt, Nathan Schlosser, Hugo Ascencio, Patrick Rhone, Jeff Simon, and karstan harvey for supporting us this week.Photo Credit: NASA Subscribe to SiriusXM Podcasts+ on Apple Podcasts to listen to new episodes ad-free and a whole week early.
Transcript
Discussion (0)
Welcome to StarTalk, your place in the universe where science and pop culture collide.
StarTalk begins right now.
This is StarTalk.
Neil deGrasse Tyson here, your personal astrophysicist.
And this is going to be a Things You Thought You Knew edition.
Chuck.
Hey. Time for Things You Thought You Knew edition. Chuck. Hey.
Time for Things You Thought You Knew.
Yes.
And in my case, things I know I didn't know.
That's a very important state of mind, to know what you don't know.
Because if you didn't know what you didn't know, that's just abject ignorance.
I mean, there's no...
That's true.
That second part is sad.
Oh, sad, exactly.
That's sad.
Ooh, that's sad.
That's sad ignorance.
That's sad ignorance, man.
All right, so let me ask you something.
How do you know how big something is?
Yeah, measure it.
You measure it, right.
So you pull out a ruler, let's say it's a table,
and you measure it.
Okay.
So there are two things working against you on that.
One of them is, you know, how close together are the hash lines on the ruler?
Right.
Right, because if your table ends up between two of them,
then you don't know how long your table is.
If you're going to report to me, you can only say it's between here and there
and venture a guess to where it is from one marker to the next.
It's kind of like half, maybe.
You'll give me a guess, fine, but you won't know exactly
because you don't have the metrics to determine that.
Okay?
It's like measuring in hands.
He's seven hands tall.
Really?
That's all?
Well, hands is actually a specific measurement.
I mean, I think the hand is four inches.
Oh, really?
Width of your hand.
Yeah.
Look at that.
See, now I just learned something there.
Horse heights are measured in hands.
In hands, right.
I knew that the horses were measured in hands,
but I didn't know that that hand had an actual unit.
It's around four inches.
Don't quote me on that, but yeah.
All right, that's cool.
Okay, okay.
Good stuff.
Okay, so even if you had the precision
to measure the length of the table,
if you go down under a microscope,
like a really good microscope, like an electron
microscope, that's the kind of microscopes where you see all of the hairs on the bugs and, you know,
you see the eyeballs of the fly, those kind of microscopes. If you do that, you'll see that the
edge of the table is not smooth. It's actually got texture. So which feature of the texture are you going to measure it
to and then report back to me the width of the table? What happens is at some point you just
give up and say, Neil, you're annoying me. I can't measure anything. You can't measure anything
unless you just agree. You just agree how you're going to take the measurement, and then you're good
with that. Well, if you have that problem with solid objects, imagine the challenge measuring
the extent of gaseous objects. Just imagine that, okay? Yes. So we can ask... I believe you measure
that and how bad it smells. Not all gas came out of your rear end okay in this world just saying
so so you can ask how high up does the atmosphere go okay well so you ascend and is there a sign
that says you are now leaving earth's atmosphere? No. No.
The atmosphere gets continually thinner.
And you know this because as you ascend a mountain,
the air pressure drops.
It's harder for you to breathe.
You can still breathe,
but just every lung's worth of air has less oxygen in it.
Okay?
That's your evidence that the air pressure is
getting lower and lower and lower. This just continues. Should have never smoked, man.
God, this is killing me. This continues. You go into an airplane, airplanes are pressurized.
Right. Which means they put air in there. Otherwise you would suffocate if they open,
if you roll down the windows. All right. So those oxygen masks, those are there in case the airplane loses pressure.
And you're breathing very low-density air.
It has hardly any oxygen in it.
So you've got to breathe through the mask.
That's all, okay?
By the way, you can hold your breath until you did this.
I mean, you're not going to die immediately after you fight for them.
It's just air. Okay. Right. You've held breath holding contests for longer than the time
it'll take you to reach for one of these yellow, yellow, um, masks. I remember people always put
your own mask on first before you try to put the mask on that of a child. So, which by the way, no one had to tell me.
Okay.
Like when I, when I heard that, I was just like, and,
and what else would I have done?
Okay.
Chuck was first out of the box on that one.
Exactly.
I was like, I was like, this kid ain't bringing nothing to the table.
Really?
All right.
I might just let the kid pass out.
Just start to get some rest.
Oh, that was the noise.
You're not giving him the oxygen.
Exactly.
Wait, let's not be so quick there, Mom.
That kid is looking real peaceful right now.
Damn, Jack.
All right.
That's cold.
All right.
So, anyhow.
Oh, by the way, it's also literally cold as you leave Earth's surface.
Right.
So, as you ascend, the air just simply gets thinner and thinner and thinner.
There is no spot where you say it ends here and space.
No, there isn't.
So you just have to agree on what that altitude will be.
Pick a thing and then just, you good with that?
I'm good with that.
Fine.
Put it in the books.
Move on to the next problem.
Okay.
Okay.
So there's a guy in the 1960s named carmen okay
he was hungarian i think but worked in the united states and he said there must be an altitude
above which the atmosphere is no longer scattering sunlight above your head so that it's no longer sky blue.
The blue goes away and then you just see stars in broad daylight.
Oh, wow.
That's an interesting threshold, right?
That is.
And there'll still be air molecules there, just not enough to scatter.
Because that's how you get a blue sky.
It scatters the blue of sunlight and now the the sky is glowing, and you can't see the night sky.
You can't see stars in the daytime sky, because it's daytime.
However, if you ascend high enough in the atmosphere, there's a point where there aren't many molecules above you.
Bada-bing, the sun is still there, but you can see stars in addition to our own star in the sky so
that's called the carmen line okay and ever since the early 60s the carmen line has been the
functional definition of a transition into space whether or not you were in earth orbit interesting
our first astronaut alan shepherd went up in 1961 he up in 1961. He went into suborbital, was fished out of the Atlantic, okay?
And he went high enough to go above the Kármán line.
So that counted.
And so that's sort of our astronaut threshold.
Kármán himself, however, knew that the atmosphere is not some rigid thing.
It's gas.
And sometimes it heats up.
Sometimes it cools down.
So it will expand.
It will shrink.
And so the Carmen line is not itself a definite thing.
But if you're going to look for it, you'd find it anywhere between 80, 80 85 and 100 kilometers okay that would convert to 53 to 62
miles okay somewhere in there okay and so so to say did you hit this exact point or not that's
like arguing you know which which edge of the table are you using to give me the length of the table?
Except worse, because it's gas.
Right.
So, point is,
the atmosphere continues out for thousands of miles.
Oh, no.
Yeah.
In fact,
Wow.
the International Space Station,
which is 250 miles up,
Right.
How much higher than the 62-mile Kármán line is?
It's four times higher than the Kármán line.
The International Space Station is huge.
It's like the size of a football field moving through the air.
There's enough atmospheric molecules up there
to hit the solar panels and the physical body
to drop it to lower orbits
than you had originally intended.
So every now and then,
the space station has to boost itself
up back to its original target orbit
because of the air molecules that hit it.
That's insane.
Yes.
And that's 250 miles up.
So there is no edge.
And if you're going to ask me, what is the diameter of the sun?
You could look this up in a book.
You could look this up.
The diameter of the sun, it'll give it to you.
And you say, well, wait a minute.
The sun is made of gas.
Right.
So how precisely are you measuring that?
You take a ruler and do that?
Not only that, you can say, in what wavelength of light did you measure the
diameter of the sun? Do you know different wavelengths of light emanate from different
locations within the depth of the sun? If you're like Geordi on Star Trek Next Generations, and you look at the sun in ultraviolet
light, it has a
different dimension
from what it has if you look at it
in visible light, and if you look at it
in infrared light.
Then if you look at it in
x-rays, all different
dimensions. In fact, the solar
corona, the thing that's glowing outside
of the moon when you see a total solar eclipse, that's called the corona, which is Latin for crown, sensibly, right?
So if you looked at that with X-rays, that's the size of the sun.
Forget the down on the sun's surface, gaseous surface.
X-rays, the corona is ablaze with light.
And you're going to say the sun is huge.
So I just want to say, just want to put it out there,
that the dimensions of things is really just something you just have to agree to in advance.
And then you all agree, you put it in the book, and then you move on.
So the diameter of the sun is the diameter it shows to us using
yellow light, which is right in the middle of the visible spectrum. That's the number you're going
to read in the book. But they don't tell you that, but I'm telling you that. I'm glad you did,
because it's good to know they've been lying to me all this time.
No! Oh, by the way, and you can think of other definitions of space.
I got one for you.
Are you ready?
So airplanes use fuel.
Our common understanding of fuel is you burn it and then energy, you get energy.
But what does it mean to burn it?
It means it gets attached to the oxygen molecule, creates a third other product, right? There's that molecule, the oxygen molecule.
They merge and make this other molecule, and it's exothermic. Energy gets generated. Okay.
That's how cars work. That's how airplanes work. Well, where's it getting its oxygen from?
The atmosphere, okay? Wait a minute, but if you're a rocket and you're going to where
there is no oxygen
or there's not much oxygen,
you got to bring your own oxidizer.
You can't depend on the atmosphere.
So you could say
you enter space
at an altitude
where an airplane
can't get enough oxygen
to fly anymore
and it just drops out of the sky.
That's an interesting threshold. You could have done it that way. Because above that, you need a
rocket. And we all know rockets equal space. Okay? I can think of 10 other ways you might define it.
But I'm just saying, just numbers and measurements of things are not written in tablets.
You have to agree on what it is you're trying to measure, write down that number, and then move on.
There you go.
Measurements not written in tablets, only commandments.
All right.
Yeah, that's a crazy subject, but I have to put it out there.
No, that's very cool.
And when you hear people arguing over the Kármán line,
just sit back and chuckle and say,
the Kármán line is an idea more than is an actual place within Earth's atmosphere.
Well, if I ever get into an argument about the Kármán line,
my answer will be, so how big is the sun?
And also, the 100-kil kilometer Kármán line,
did you really think the atmosphere is layered
into evenly divisible numbers in kilometers?
Did you really think that's the case?
If you look up Kármán, it's 100 kilometers.
Yeah, the earth is like tight with the metric people, right?
It's like, no, 100 is well above whatever Carmen was talking about.
But if you want to round it up, you round it up to 100 kilometers,
and that's the definition.
Fine.
Okay?
That's actually kind of cool, man, when you think about it.
I mean—
But the American definition is lower than that.
We're like at 85 kilometers up.
We have a lower definition than Europe and the rest of the world do.
Well, yeah, that's because, you know, we want to be able to say we went to space.
We want to be able to say that Alan Shepard went into space.
Shepard went to space.
Correct.
Exactly.
We're the first people to do it, you know.
Right, right.
Right.
It's just like we put a spire on top of the Freedom Tower and it's like now the tallest building in the country.
Exactly.
All right, dude.
All right, man.
Good stuff.
Chuck, we got to end it there.
But if you hang on, when we return,
we'll go into another segment of doing some explaining.
You know, stuff you thought you knew.
That's what this is all about.
When we return.
Hi, I'm Chris Cohen from Haworth, New Jersey, and I support StarTalk on Patreon.
Please enjoy this episode of StarTalk Radio with your and my favorite personal astrophysicist, Neil
DeGrasse Tyson. So Chuck, we're back. Okay. For another explainer. This one, did we talk about
this before? I have a bad memory for what I've been talking about, but I'm going to do it anyway.
And if it's not, we'll just do it again. Here it is. You ready? Okay. Okay. So there's an
interesting difference between being an astrophysicist and being a photographer.
Okay. Okay. Here's the difference. A college education.
I mean,
I mean, don't try this.
Okay, here's the difference.
We know that when you have an object and you heat it,
and its temperature rises, it actually radiates energy.
Okay?
If it's very cold, it'll radiate radio waves and microwaves.
In fact, the whole universe is three degrees absolute zero,
three degrees above absolute zero.
Very cold.
At that temperature, microwaves get emitted.
So the universe is a source of microwaves upon us because of that leftover temperature from the Big Bang.
Heat anything more.
I don't care what it is.
Heat it some more, and then the energy it'll start giving us
will start shifting in the spectrum,
and then it'll start giving us infrared energy.
Okay.
You can't see it.
It's not glowing visibly yet.
But if we have sensors that are not our eyes to detect infrared,
do you know what it's called?
No.
Touch.
Okay.
You can touch it.
Okay.
Heat, right.
Yeah.
If it's warm, you can detect low-level infrared all the way up to high-level infrared
just by getting near it and you can feel the energy,
or you can touch it and you can feel the temperature.
Okay.
Okay.
So that's infrared.
Raise the temperature some more,
it begins to glow in the visible part of the spectrum,
and it begins to glow deep red.
It's still giving infrared, but now it's glowing red.
So now you can see it.
So now it's like the temperature of an electric stove.
Those glow red.
OK?
OK?
Raise the heat some more.
Now you're in astrophysics zone here.
Raise the heat some more.
It'll still emit the infrared.
It'll still emit the red.
But it will be dominated by all the colors of the spectrum, and it will look white
to you. Okay. So, if something's glowing white hot, it is multiple times hotter than if it's
glowing infrared hot. That's that white hot privilege. Okay. Everything's got to be about
it. Why is everything got to be about?
All right.
Raise the heat some more.
So we're about 6,000 degrees, 6,000 to 10,000 degrees absolute at this point.
Okay?
Raise it some more, 20,000, 30,000 degrees.
Now it starts peaking in the blue side of the spectrum,
and the object went from glowing red to glowing white to glowing blue.
Raise the temperature some more. It still glows blue, but that's not where it peaks.
It peaks beyond the blue, all right, into the deep violet, the ultraviolet. Raise the temperature
some more. It peaks in the x-rays. Okay, this is how stuff works in the universe. Okay. So, Chuck, it gets a little warmer than infrared.
Now it begins to glow red.
And so now it's giving you energy.
It's giving you photons in the visible part of the spectrum.
Say, hey, that's hot.
That's glowing red hot.
Okay.
But I know that you can keep making the temperature higher. It'll still glow, but now it's going to glow white hot. Right. But I know that you can keep making the temperature higher.
It'll still glow, but now it's going to glow white hot and then glow blue hot.
And the blue hot is the hottest of the glowing temperatures.
But we don't experience that in everyday life.
Nobody says blue hot anything.
Anything.
They don't say that.
Anything.
Plus, ice and icebergs have this blue tone to them.
So psychologically, it all feels different.
But here's what's interesting, okay?
When we transitioned from incandescent bulbs, the old-fashioned Edison light bulb, to LEDs.
Yes.
Okay?
Ask yourself, why would a light bulb giving you visible light ever get hot?
Because it's glowing white hot, but it's also still giving off infrared.
Mm-hmm. Okay? but it's also still giving off infrared.
Okay?
So, but wait a minute.
I have a light bulb so that I can see.
So the 100-watt light bulb,
or whatever the wattage you bought,
it turns out most of that energy is coming out in the infrared.
Yes.
It's a waste.
Right.
Which is why they would always say, the package it would say um wait until wait for whatever you know however long before changing the light bulb because so
many people be like like the light bulb would blow out. They would go get another light bulb,
come back, go to change it,
and burn their hands. That's how hot the bulb was.
It's a complete waste of everybody's energy,
the fact that we have light bulbs
that was giving us infrared.
Wow.
So the brilliant thing about LEDs,
and let me remind you,
LEDs are of this next generation interior lighting.
We couldn't do it until we had all three colors of LEDs.
We had red LEDs.
We had green LEDs.
We didn't have blue.
And once we got blue, we'd have RGB. You can combine them
and RGB combined in light. Don't work this way in paint. Don't tell your artist friends this.
You combine RGB with light and you get white light. The thing about LEDs is they're not glowing.
They're not glowing from heat.
It's actual white light.
It's actual light coming out at those frequencies,
at the red frequency, at the green frequency, at the blue frequency. Your eye merges them, and you see it as white light.
There is no energy coming out in the infrared or anywhere else.
So that's why you can have a three watt
Yes.
LED bulb that just kicks ass against a 60 watt
or however many, five watts, whatever,
against a 60 watt Edison bulb, regular old fashioned bulb,
because most of that energy is coming out in infrared
and none of that energy is coming out of infrared for the LED.
It's all in the visible part of the spectrum.
I don't know why we didn't do this one so much earlier,
because two things.
And it's so exciting that you just actually did everything you just did
and related it to light bulbs.
One, people went crazy when we said we were going to transition to all LED light bulbs. One, people went crazy when we said we were going to transition to
all LED light bulbs
and they did it because
President Blackula said
that we should actually
move
to all LED
light bulbs. And people were like,
now the government's trying to tell you what kind
of light bulb you have.
No, I swear to God, it's my God getting right to have me a regular incandescent light bulb.
That's America.
And so people lost their minds.
This is Chuck's imitation of America.
They lost their minds.
They lost their minds. And what you are saying is, one, it's more efficient because it is exactly what it is.
So it's energy efficient by a factor of 10.
Okay.
Right.
And then the other thing you said was, that is why you see on the box, it's whatever many watts.
Instead of like your 200 watt bulb or whatever it's like you know it says if they do
lumens now they don't have you can't use watts because you know what watts are watts is not the
measure of the brightness of anything what is the measure of how much energy the rate at which it's
consuming energy and and since we all had the same light bulbs you could compare watts and say that one is, you know, twice whatever. You had some
sense of that. Right. But really, with light bulbs, it should have always been measured in lumens. In
fact, in Europe, I think they always measured it in lumens. So you're really, you're after lumens
here. You're not after wattage, okay? And so... So this is a maturity of the American population.
Yeah, this is the best reason for you people to go out and get LED lights.
I mean, for me, you know, I got into this because it's great for the environment.
You know, if we all did it, we would really lessen our carbon footprint for the entire nation.
Right.
But the fact is, here's why you should do it.
You save money.
You just proved how much more efficient it is.
Save your own damn money. Correct. Even if you don't care about the environment,
care about your own damn wallet. There you go.
So, and that's why you can go up to any LED bulb and it's not hot. It'll never be hot.
It's not about being hot. Man, that's great.
And, and here are these people, Earth is flat and I don't like science and all that. The person who discovered the blue LED got a Nobel Prize for that
because the moment that got discovered, it blew open the entire lighting industry
because now you can make white light.
In fact, you can make any color light.
That's why you can get LED controllers where the light itself has an RGB diodes in them.
And you can just control the ratios of those and get any color you want.
And so the Empire State Building is lit by these things.
Okay?
And the intensity of the color is very real, and it's very in the moment.
So just thought I'd tell you that that's super cool
well listen white light was what we were striving for but always remember only black light can make
your dorm room look cool just to be clear black light is is an ultraviolet light,
but the part of it you see is the violet.
It's just kicking into the red, orange, yellow, green, blue, violet part of the spectrum.
You can see that, but that's not why you have it in your dorm room.
You have it because the ultraviolet light interacts with the pigment in the pictures on your wall,
the posters, and it forces the pigment in the pictures on your wall, the posters,
and it forces the pigment to glow.
Okay?
And it's called phosphorescence, right?
And so that high-energy light that you can't see, the pigment can't see,
it absorbs it and then gives it back to you in visible light,
and it looks like the paintings are glowing.
So in a sense, it is black light.
It is light that you can't see.
Nice. Yeah.
Alright. Well, this was great.
You got it, Chuck.
So next time you walk by an LED, just pause and say
thank you, science.
There you go. Just say
that anyway. Say that anyway.
Just say that anyway. Wake up in the morning, take a deep breath. Just say that anyway. Say that anyway. Just say that anyway.
Wake up in the morning, take a deep breath.
Thank you, science.
Thank you, science.
I should tweet that.
I'm going to do that.
Let me see if I can start a movement.
So, Chuck, that's the end of this segment.
When we come back, we're going to do another one of these, Chuck.
All right.
You got it in you to listen to?
I got it in me.
Let's do it.
Okay.
All right.
We'll be right back.
Check.
Hey, Neil.
I'm back with another sort of stuff you thought you knew.
This one might be something you didn't even know you didn't know.
How about that?
Some of those are out there too, right?
So no one told me this.
I discovered this on my own.
That for those of you who have ridden airplanes,
I know some people have never been in an airplane.
I highly recommend it.
It's quite a marvel of engineering and physics and aerodynamics.
Or you can watch YouTube. It's what? Or you can watch YouTube.
It's what?
Or you can watch YouTube.
Okay.
Okay.
So if you could save up,
if you've never been on an airplane,
find a place to fly to and just check it out.
It's quite a marvel.
And I marvel at it every day,
even though we've been doing it for more than 100 years.
So here's what I noticed.
That my drink on my tray table. Yes. So I noticed when I pull down the shades and I can't see outside and I look at this drink and the water
level is completely horizontal. Okay. That means we're just there.
We're not, you know, accelerating or banking or turning.
Okay, it's just there.
And it stays that way the entire trip.
Right.
Now, I know the plane has got to make some turns when it comes near.
I know it's got to do this at some point.
Right, Yes.
If it does that, I would expect the water level to tilt within the glass.
I'd expect me to lean in one way or another, the way it would happen in a car.
If you make a left turn in a car, your body leans to the right.
Yes.
Okay?
Because you actually want to keep going in a straight line, but the car is curving in front of you.
So it feels like you're getting pushed to the right, but really you're just going in a straight line. You want to go in a straight line.
The car won't let you.
You're getting pushed against the door.
Okay.
Or you turn left or right, whichever.
Or someone's sitting next to you.
Your shoulders will touch.
All right.
No longer does that happen on an airplane.
Okay. So what I did was let me try this with the shade up.
I do it with the shade up.
I look out this window.
I see sky.
I look out across the plane.
I see the ground.
This sucker is banking, and yet the water on my table is completely flat.
Okay.
And yet the water on my table is completely flat.
Okay.
So, there's only one thing that can be happening here.
Because I don't think humans have this ability.
The computer is flying the airplane. And you program into the computer such that the radius of the turn and the speed at which you're going requires that the plane be at a certain banking angle so that all the centrifugal forces combine with gravity so that you don't even know you're banking this turn.
You don't even know you're banking this turn.
In other words, in other words,
the urge to fall into the middle of the circle gets completely balanced with the centrifugal force to send you out of the circle
so that the gravity vector still goes directly to the bottom of the glass
and to your rump into the chair.
And you don't even know the plane is turning.
to the chair and you don't even know the plane is turning.
Those three numbers, if you choose them correctly,
you can have them conspire so that you would never know the plane was ever turning at any time.
Well, clearly you have never been on Spirit Airlines.
Spirit Airlines, top ten.
The pilot's in there.
They don't even use the joists.
They use an actual steering wheel.
Steering wheel.
I'm sure it's a fine airline where they have fully trained pilots.
But the precision necessary to do that, to do that reliably,
to do that without the judgment of the pilot, that takes a computer.
And if you look at old movies where they show people on airplanes and the airplane is turning, you'll see people sort of leaning to the one side or the other.
That is no longer a thing in airplanes.
airplanes.
So, you know what you just reminded me of when you talked about going back is old episodes of Star Trek, the first Star Trek, where the entire crew would go to the left and then
they'd go to the right.
They'd lean, hold on.
And they'd all be instructed to do this, right?
Right.
So they'd take the camera and tip the camera, right?
And they'd tip the camera and they would all do that to make it look like they were banking.
And they were in space, so.
So if you bank a turn properly, you never feel that effect.
And by the way, we've talked about this with NASCAR, all right?
this with NASCAR, all right? The banked turn in a racetrack, there is a speed with which you can drive your car so that you never have to touch the steering wheel. And the car will make a complete
turn on that bank and end up going back the other way. Right. And that speed is one where you will
not feel like you're leaning to the left or the right.
Because the steering wheel is turning for you.
The road is turning the car for you.
Correct.
And at the right speed, you'll feel the gravity vector doing whatever it was doing before you entered that turn.
It's the same physics principle at work there.
So I just thought I'd put that out there, Just a little discovery I made. I haven't checked
with anybody who did it and when it started, but I began noticing it. And you should notice it too.
Check it out. There could be sky here and brown down there, and you don't even notice it unless
you look out the damn window. Yeah. I fly spirits, so I've noticed it all the time.
Yeah.
Just saying.
I fly Spirit, so I've noticed it all the time.
It's tough.
Wait, one last thing.
If you are in space, there is no banking of turns.
Yes, right.
Well, I'll tell you why.
So on a track, the thing that's turning the car for you is the road itself.
Okay?
That's a force there that's turning the car.
If you are in an airplane, you are banking on a cushion of air as you complete your turn.
If you're in space, there is no force doing that.
So if you're in space, you just have to fire rockets.
Right.
And so they don't tip and turn.
It looks cool when the TIE fighters did that in Star Wars and the Millennium Falcon.
You know, it looks cool, but that's not how it would happen.
You just have the rockets change the direction that it turns in.
So all of those maneuvers that you see the Millennium Falcon make.
Yeah, they're atmospheric maneuvers.
They're not vacuum maneuvers.
None of that means anything.
Right, right, right.
Yeah.
Wow.
Plus, at the end of the Star Wars Episode IV,
when they were celebrated for destroying the, you know.
The Death Star.
The Death Star.
Didn't they just fly in from an open bay
exposed to the vacuum of space?
And then they just get out and walk around?
Yes.
But I think there's a force shield that holds the atmosphere inside the ship, though.
You just made that up right now.
No, no, seriously.
Okay, okay.
No, seriously.
I think that's how it works.
Okay, magic force field.
Okay, fine.
Like, yeah.
I mean, but seriously, there's nothing in Star Wars that's scientific.
Let's be honest.
I mean, seriously.
You know, the least believable thing to me was,
here are the fighters coming in,
and there's the guy with the traffic cones directing.
Yes, they still, right.
You don't have a better way to do this in the 25th century
or whenever the hell this thing takes place.
And the other thing is, too, they all fly in,
and nobody fires retro rockets.
Oh, they just slow down.
They just slow down. Like in Star Trek, though,
when you fly into a shuttle bay,
there is a
kind of like a tractor beam that grabs
you and then you come in and that's how you stop.
Yeah, correct. Because Star Trek thinks about
science. Yeah, but Star Wars,
they're just like, you know, coming in.
I'm coming in hot.
All right, so this is Airplane Banking 101.
Yes.
That's cool, actually.
On Star Trek.
This is a quickie.
That's all I got to tell you about it.
So next time we're on a plane, watch for it.
All right, that's all we got time for, Chuck.
All right.
All right, this has been an explainer jamboree.
Stuff you thought you knew in three segments.
And so I hope you like these, Chuck, because I bend your ear on them.
I love them.
They're great.
I mean, and I actually do learn stuff.
And I got to tell you, man, that, I mean, it's really,
it's great information
to have at a cocktail party.
Okay.
Because you'd otherwise just be completely boring.
Exactly. I gotta pull out a nihilism here.
Right, exactly. It's like,
you should go talk to that guy. I thought he was a stupid
comedian, but God, he's brilliant.
Huh? God, he's brilliant.
I thought he was a stupid comedian.
What kind of star...
All right. We'll call it quits there.
This has been Star Talk.
Stuff you thought you knew.
Neil deGrasse Tyson here.
As always, keep looking up.