Stuff You Should Know - Gobekli Tepe

Episode Date: October 8, 2024

Gobekli Tepe is a profoundly ancient spiritual site that shouldn’t exist, according to conventional wisdom. The massive site of columns and pictograms was built thousands of years before humans were... thought to have been able to create anything like it.See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

Transcript
Discussion (0)
Starting point is 00:00:00 Hey everybody, the time has finally come. This week, starting October 7th through October 11th, that's Monday through Friday everybody, we are revealing the iconic 400. Yes, Bo and Yang and I famously missed our 400th episode here on Los Cocheristas, but we are ready to reveal the iconic 400. Who is on the list? Does it matter? No.
Starting point is 00:00:24 Will it be fun? Yeah, there might even be a surprise or two in there. So listen carefully Listen to last culture East us on will ferrell's big money players network on the I heart radio app Apple podcasts or wherever you get your podcasts I'm Renee Stubbs and I'm obsessed with sports especially tennis tennis. Tune into my podcast each week to hear me and my friends in the community, break down the latest matches, including the US Open. Plus hear from some of the biggest names in the sport about what the future holds. It's about belief. And once you break through that, then you know, you can win a grand slam.
Starting point is 00:00:59 Listen to the Renee Stubbs tennis podcast every Monday on the iHeart radio app, Apple podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts. Presented by Elf Beauty, founding partner of iHeart Women's Sports. Welcome to Stuff You Should Know, a production of iHeart Radio. Hey, and welcome to the podcast. I'm Josh and Chuck's here, and it's just and that's fine and this is stuff you should know. One of my favorite types of editions, the distant past let's figure it out edition and it's so surprising edition. Oh man, you have always loved this stuff, huh?
Starting point is 00:01:38 I certainly have. It jazzes me at least as much as earth science. Yeah. I think, you know, the age-old question, like, if you could, you know, have a real wayback machine and go back and go to, like, any concert, your answer would be like, mm, something where Tuk-Tuk, like, took bones and banged it on rocks just so I could see what was going on. Uh, yeah, from a distance, as long as he didn't know I was there,
Starting point is 00:02:04 because I assume I would get beaten to death by that same guy, you know? You're like that in Kraftwerk's first tour. I saw Kraftwerk at the Disney concert hall in LA. I know, I'm very jealous of that show. I'll tell you about that every time, man. That was a great show. Looks amazing.
Starting point is 00:02:24 Yeah, they had like a 3D light display and everything. Oh man, one day. Yeah, one day. They're still touring as far as I know, so why not? They don't get around here that much, you know? No, but when they do, go see them. No, for sure. Also, while we're on recommendations,
Starting point is 00:02:42 I watched a movie that I'd just been passing over for years now that was actually worth the watch. It's a mind-bending horror movie called Triangle. I think it's Australian, because I'm pretty sure just about everybody in it's Australian, but they're pretending to be American. But it's, you know how often like mind bending movies that like mess with like just reality and stuff like just fall apart at some point?
Starting point is 00:03:11 This one stayed tight from beginning to end. It was, yeah, it was a good movie. I would definitely recommend it. I mean, I don't think it won any Oscars or anything like that, but it was definitely worth watching. You know what? You can take the Oscar award and stick it right up the collective butt of the world.
Starting point is 00:03:26 There you go. This is just called Triangle? Just Triangle, yes. All right. Okay. Never heard of it. You all hang out here, you go watch it and then come back and we'll talk about it.
Starting point is 00:03:38 2009 British film is what it says, is that possible? I thought it was like 2018. Does it look like there's a person wearing like a bag over their head in the, on the poster? Oh, no, that's another one. Triangle. I wanna say 2018. Fear comes in waves?
Starting point is 00:03:54 Probably, yes. All right, it looks very B movie, but I'll give you the benefit of the doubt here. That's what I thought too. That can be good. I totally thought it looked B too, and then I was like, this is really good. This movie hasn't gotten enough credit from me.
Starting point is 00:04:08 Okay. All right, I'll check it out. Okay, so all of the archeology and anthropology fans are like, shut up and start talking about Gobekli Tepe. I don't know why that was hard. It's really actually a very easy word to say, or a pair of words. Yeah, I saw Tepe. I don't know why that was hard. It's really actually a very easy word to say, or a pair of words.
Starting point is 00:04:27 Yeah, I saw tepe, actually. I don't know how specific that gets, though. Ooh la la. That's spoken by people who raise their pinkies when they drink their tea. Yeah, but a tepe is like a mound or a hill, correct? Yeah, and gobekli means belly, so people take it to basically mean potbelly hill. Yeah, and thisbekli means belly, so people take it to basically mean potbelly hill.
Starting point is 00:04:46 Yeah, and this is a place in Turkey, and it is a place where a lot of archaeological digging is still going on. And it was one of these places that is, and I know you love this kind of thing more than anything, but like when an archaeological find kind of upends traditional thought of how we thought things were, and this is one of the great examples of that. Yeah, especially when it's true and not like pseudoscience, like somebody's like, it was ancient aliens. Right.
Starting point is 00:05:16 Where's the proof? They're like, it was ancient aliens, man. Don't, don't harsh my mellow. Well, you want to hear something funny? What? Part of what I watched on YouTube about this was from the show Ancient Aliens. Yeah, yeah. There's a lot of like pseudo-archaeology that surrounds this that you have to kind of be careful of.
Starting point is 00:05:35 Yeah, for sure. This is like true. Like this truly has upended our current or yeah, I guess still basically our current understanding. And that is thus. We've told the story many, many times on this podcast. And it turns out that it's probably at least oversimplified if not just outright incorrect. But the whole basis of what we're talking about has to do with the Neolithic Revolution, which says that somewhere around 10, 11,000 years ago, people in the Fertile Crescent Mesopotamia started to settle down, raise crops,
Starting point is 00:06:09 and as they were able to support more people, more and more people came and moved to that area. They domesticated animals, cities sprung up, and then from the cities, hierarchies grew, and then we had kingdoms and wars and all sorts of stuff, and also arts, culture, architecture, all that stuff developed from the people first settling down and domesticating crops,
Starting point is 00:06:31 becoming sedentary, like transitioning from hunter-gatherers to farmers, essentially. And that was the start of all the other stuff that followed. Gobekli Tepe turns that on its head, essentially. That's right, and this was one of those discoveries that, like I said, really sort of upends everything that we thought to be true. The real discovery, and we'll kind of get
Starting point is 00:06:56 to what had happened before this, but the big, big find was in 1994, and that's when archaeologists started really literally digging into it. It had been known to locals there, you know, for a while, obviously, because it's sort of like the Sherpa that are like, I climb this mountain all the time. There were people living nearby in Turkey in the 1960s even that were finding pretty cool stuff here, but it wasn't until 1994 that they made the big, big discovery and really, like I said,
Starting point is 00:07:29 started digging in and forming opinions over, and you know, we'll get to these because they still haven't settled on exactly what Gebekeli Tepe was. No, they haven't, which explains why we haven't said what it is yet, but that that 1960 survey Found a bunch of slabs of limestone, but they mistook what they were they mistook their significance. They thought they were gravestones from a medieval cemetery and it would turn out that they were about 11,000 years older than that Because what go back go back like Tepe was when they started digging it up in the 90s Under the leadership of a guy named Klaus Schmidt who was the guy who saw this and was like this is not a natural formation
Starting point is 00:08:14 This is clearly human made. Let's see what's underneath this hill He found that this is essentially a Neolithic settlement that dates back at its earliest spot, as far as we know, to about 11,600 years before today. Yeah. And, you know, the significance of all of this, if we haven't been clear enough, is that basically they're dating this long before, like hundreds, maybe even a thousand years before what we thought was when people started
Starting point is 00:08:46 settling down and becoming farmers, which led to all the, you know, modern advances eventually that we know today that, like you mentioned. Right. So this was a long, long time before that when we were like, no, no, no, at the time people were just moving around, hunting and gathering and kind of just, I don't know about struggling to survive,
Starting point is 00:09:07 but subsistence living, you know, from season to season, that kind of thing. And 94, like you said, was when Schmidt came in there and he got pretty excited, like so excited that he bought a house nearby and set up camp and said, all right, this is gonna be the base for me and my small team. Anytime students are coming over here, they can stay here. And this is now the official home base of this extraordinarily interesting archaeological
Starting point is 00:09:36 site. Yeah. And he would go on to lead the dig at Gobekli Tepe until his death, I think at age 60 in 2014, if I'm not mistaken. He died early. Why go anywhere else, you know? Well, this was like, he was like, well, here's my career, this is what I'm doing for the rest of my life.
Starting point is 00:09:54 Like there's- Totally. They've been digging at Gobekli Tepe now for what, 30 years? They've easily got another 50 years of excavation left, unless some huge new technological advance in archeology comes along. But using current practices, they have decades left of exploration to do of this site.
Starting point is 00:10:13 But what Schmidt found from the outset just didn't make sense. Because like you said, they think that they were building this before people even started to settle down and start farming, which means it was thousands of years before people should have been able to create
Starting point is 00:10:31 things like this, like massive structures, that it takes a lot of people in a coordinated manner to come up with a coherent plan and then build this stuff, and then also imbue it with symbolism as we'll see. It just did not make sense. But the date, the radiocarbon dating was right. And so, Klaus Schmidt was smart enough to be like, we might have this whole Neolithic Revolution story wrong.
Starting point is 00:10:55 Yeah, for sure. So just sort of brass tacks, it is in southern Turkey. It's located at the highest point of the Jermis, G-E-R-M-U-S, unfortunately named Mountain Range, which is right on the edge of the Fertile Crescent there, not coincidentally. And the mound itself is about 50 feet tall, covers about 22 acres. And it was kind of one of these things where basically he had gone there, he knew that people nearby had dug up some things that looked like tools and stuff like that. He was like, well, this is pretty interesting.
Starting point is 00:11:30 And when he stood back and looked, he was like, that hill up there doesn't look like the rest of these sort of flattish plateaus. It's more rounded and it looks like clearly formed by humans. And that's when everyone, you know, all the locals in their language said, no, duh, we've known this for a while. So he said, all right, you know, I'm going to set up shop here. And they got to work starting with that uppermost level, which was, what did we figure? It was like 10,000-ish years ago? Yes. So the most recent use of it was 10,000 years ago. And, um, Livia helps us with this and she pointed something out
Starting point is 00:12:07 that I thought is definitely worth, um, mentioning. The, the Gobekli Tepe site was older to the people who built the pyramids at Giza and Stonehenge than the people who built the pyramids in Stonehenge are to us. It's that ancient. That's one of those brain breakers. Yeah. Thousands and thousands of years old, that ancient when the people started building the pyramids.
Starting point is 00:12:34 It's just, yeah, like you said, it's a brain breaker, like how old this thing was and then what they were able to do and what they were able to do. So by the way, no one knows what culture this is. Because again, it's not supposed to be a culture from our understanding of people at the time. I've seen interpretations of communities at around this time, what's called the pre-pottery Neolithic, which is a specific era in the Fertile
Starting point is 00:13:03 Crescent where there wasn't pottery. Pottery existed elsewhere in the world, like Japan was making amazing conch shell pottery around this time. China has 20,000 year old pottery, but just in the Fertile Crescent they hadn't started making pottery yet. So they're called the pre-pottery Neolithic group, essentially. But suffice to say, this group got together and decided to build this at least as far back as 11,600 years ago, and they stopped using it about 10,000 years ago.
Starting point is 00:13:38 Yeah, so they started top down. Like you said, the most recent use would be the stuff on top, obviously. And they started to notice, wow, there are actually buildings here with straight walls. So that means that somebody shaped those. It wasn't just by pure chance or luck that those walls ended up being straight. They found these limestone pillars that were about two meters high on this upper level. Some of them had decorations on them. These upper ones had etchings of lions. And then they started going down.
Starting point is 00:14:10 Obviously things are getting a little bit older. And then they said, wow, these pillars are getting a lot bigger than the ones on top. Some of these things are 15 to 18 feet high, weigh about 10 tons. And they look like they're arranged in very specific ways. There were at least 20 circles or ovals that had these, that basically made up these enclosures, and there were, you know, some of them actually were shaped in such
Starting point is 00:14:36 a way that they wondered like it's no accident that they're shaped in the form of a triangle if you connect them. Like it might be like a Stonehenge kind of thing happening. Yeah, that's definitely one theory is that at least part of this was a cosmic observatory. And yeah, like you said, the settlement overall, the site forms, like some of the columns form an equilateral triangle, and then the center of the site bisects that triangle perfectly. So it's just, it's not accidental.
Starting point is 00:15:05 And again, people weren't supposed to be using geometry, even rudimentary geometry at this point for thousands of more years, and yet these people were doing it. Some of the other things that they figured out is the limestone did come from the area, but it still came from hundreds of meters away, right? So these, you said 16 feet, about five and a half meters, 10 tons of rocks carved out of the limestone bedrock and then carried over to this site and then raised, that takes a lot of people, even using like logs and rollers and things like that, it still
Starting point is 00:15:43 takes a lot of coordination. And yeah, it takes a lot of determination too. And to me, the fact that those columns are smaller and smaller, the more recent you get and then bigger further down, almost suggests that there was like a loss of enthusiasm over time. They got worn out. I think so, yeah. Over 1300 years. They were like, hey, those inner levels look great,
Starting point is 00:16:09 but do we really need that much headroom? That's right. The tallest one among us is five and a half feet. Right. Yeah, they were shorter back then, I think. But here's the thing. Everything you mentioned there is possible. That limestone is pretty soft as stone goes, and the flint tools that they had back then could have been used to do something like this. And depending on who you talk to,
Starting point is 00:16:32 some people will say, like, you know, it may have taken a few hundred very determined people to move these things. Other people, Olivia found this one guy, an archaeologist named Edward Banning from the University of Toronto that said, nah, give me 20 grown men and I could do this even without rollers. Yeah, watch. Yeah. No one ever called us bluff. Should we take a break?
Starting point is 00:16:57 Yeah, let's take a break. All right. Great setup. Everyone's on the edge of their limestone seat and we'll be right back. Hey everybody, the time has finally come. This week starting Monday, October 7th, going daily through Friday, October 11th, Bowen Yang and I, Matt Rogers, are unveiling the iconic 400. Yes, these are the top 400 people in all of culture, and we're unveiling all of them. Number 372, Nancy Kerrigan.
Starting point is 00:17:41 Why? We will never really know. Why? We have worked tirelessly on this list. I'm Michael Babaro. That's really good. Once you hear I'm Michael Babaro, you know exactly who is talking.
Starting point is 00:17:54 And we really think it's going to resonate. Christina! She is not a Christian! Don't! Happily flying a pride flag. Also, there might be a little bit of a surprise or two in there, so listen carefully. Hint, hint, Friday. Listen to Lost Culture East us on Will Ferrell's Big Money Players Network
Starting point is 00:18:13 on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts. Do you ever wonder where your favorite foods come from? Like what's the history behind bacon-wrapped hot dogs? Hi, I'm Eva Longoria. Hi, I'm Maite Gomez-Rejón. Our podcast Hungry for History is back. Season two, season two. Are we recording? Are we good?
Starting point is 00:18:34 Oh, we push record, right? And this season we're taking an even bigger bite out of the most delicious food and its history. Seeing that the most popular cocktail is the Margarita, followed by the Mojito from Cuba, and the piñu colada from Puerto Rico. So all of these things we thank Latin culture. There's a mention of blood sausage in Homer's Odyssey
Starting point is 00:18:56 that dates back to the ninth century BC. BC? I didn't realize how old the hot dog was. Listen to Hungry for History as part of the My Kultura podcast network, available on the iHeart radio app, Apple podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts. In a galaxy far, far away. No, babe, that's taken.
Starting point is 00:19:20 We're in our own world, remember? Right, in our own world. We're two space cadets. And totally normal humans own world, remember? Right, in our own world. We're two space cadets and totally normal humans. Sure, totally normal humans. Embark on a journey across the stars, discovering the wonders of the universe one episode at a time. We'll talk about life, love, laughter, and why you should never argue with your co-pilot. Especially when she's always right. Right, and if we hit turbulence, just blame it on Mercury retrograde.
Starting point is 00:19:46 Or Emily's questionable space piloting skills. Hey! Join us on In Our Own World for cosmic conversations, stellar laughs, and super corny dad jokes. Listen to In Our Own World as a part of the MyCultura podcast network available on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts. And don't worry, we promise to avoid any black holes. Most of the time. Okay, Chuck. So one of the things that I mentioned earlier is that these people not only created these huge pillars and walls and enclosures, they also put, they carved them. There's a lot of symbols on this stuff and essentially they're pictograms, like they're
Starting point is 00:20:44 symbols that directly represent the thing they are. There's not any encoded meaning to it. Like if it's a bird, it's supposed to be a bird. And there's a lot of really readable symbols. Like it's not like, wow, it's photo realistic, but you can clearly see this is a bird. This is a gazelle.
Starting point is 00:21:03 This is a fox. this is a scorpion. And they started to notice that some of the enclosures were essentially dedicated to one kind of animal. But the biggest enclosure, enclosure D, was there's a bunch of different animals on it, like scratched or carved into the different kind of pillars and walls and everything. And there's a lot of interpretation just in that stuff alone.
Starting point is 00:21:27 Yeah, for sure. The ones where it's just like nothing but foxes, they think could have been a specific clan because it was part of the clan system like Clan of the Cave Bear. It would have carved a bunch of cave bears. So if it was a fox clan, they may have just carved Foxes, but it might make sense that the biggest one, because you know, they're still, you know, as we pointed out, guessing as to what even was going on and what all this stuff was used for and what it all meant.
Starting point is 00:21:53 So I think it just sort of makes sense that maybe the biggest one was maybe where groupings of clans came. So they were all represented by their favorite football team. Pretty much, yeah. One of the things also that gave away that Fox enclosure is that one of the carvings says Fox's rule, and it's F-O-X-Z. So clearly they were pretty in the Fox's.
Starting point is 00:22:17 Yeah, exactly. So those pillars too, 16 feet, 5 and 1 half meter, 10 ton pillars at the largest, if you look at them, they actually represent people, but they represent like a really nondescript type of person. So these are T-shaped pillars. So at first I just assume, well, that's like, you know,
Starting point is 00:22:41 shoulders and then like the head's carved into the middle of the shoulders, wrong. The T itself is actually the head viewed from the side, so that when you look at the narrow ends on each side of that top of the T, that's the face in the back of the head. I thought that was a really strange artistic decision. Yeah, for sure. The other thing too is, I don't think we mentioned that kind of one of the first theories was that, or maybe we did, that it was kind of ritual-based because I think when they find anything from this time, they think, well, this wasn't a permanent
Starting point is 00:23:14 settlement because they didn't have those. So, this was just a place where they did rituals and maybe sacrifices or whatever, prayed to whatever God. They did find things like masks that maybe were ceremonial, at least lent itself to the idea that that could have been going on there. They did find some other images that weren't as straightforward as the sort of clear ones that you described, like birds with human legs, and they speculate. That could have been like maybe people in costume at a ritual or a rite that we're displaying here in this little story. And the fun part about all of this is that they seem to have been drinking beer at the time, because there were beer brewing vats nearby. Like huge vats. They could brew tens and tens of gallons at a time. And that supports this idea that this was a ritual place. like huge fats. They could brew tens and tens of gallons at a time. And that supports this idea that this was a ritual place.
Starting point is 00:24:09 I mean, just the fact that they went to the trouble of making this. And then the fact that they added these symbols to these huge monoliths that they raised. And then the fact that there was beer strongly supports that they were essentially partying in one way or another at Gobekli Tepe, right? But in addition to that, in those very obvious pictograms or pictographs, there's also some straight-up symbols that are not immediately obvious that does suggest that there was
Starting point is 00:24:39 meaning encoded in it, which would make it writing. There's what looks like a capital I that keeps popping up here and there. There's also a capital H that's usually associated with the capital I, and they think it's possible that represented the summer solstice and the winter solstice or day and night, because it's just used so repeatedly. One of the other reasons they think that
Starting point is 00:25:06 is a guy named Martin Swetman, who's an engineering researcher from the University of Edinburgh. He analyzed one of the pillars, and there's a bunch of different markings on them, and he interpreted them as essentially a calendar that not only you could track the year with, but he took it to be like a time stamp for a potential
Starting point is 00:25:32 common impact that allegedly set off the younger, driest mini Ice Age. So if that's true, that means that they were proto-writing 7,000 years before the Sumerians came up with what's considered the first alphabet. 7,000 years. And then in addition to that, they were able to track the procession of Earth. They were able to account for the wobble that changes the time and days throughout the year,
Starting point is 00:26:03 enough that they could create a lunar calendar. And they supposedly, if this actually is a time stamp, they were able to date things that were like major celestial events, like meteor showers, or again, a potential comet strike. Yeah. And this is like, I mean, I guess we'll talk about the significance of calendars in a couple of ways here and later. But one thing to think about is like, if you're hunter-gatherers and you're not around very
Starting point is 00:26:33 long, like, what do you need a 12-month calendar for? Another way of looking at it, and this kind of lends itself to some of the later theories, is that, well well maybe we'll hold on to that. That'll be a nice little teaser actually. Even I'm teased. But we can talk about this right now, which is the fact that they found remnants of bones and wild plants and things that pretty much clearly indicate that they had been butchered and cooked there. Mostly gazelle, about 60% were gazelle, but they also had sheep and deer and wild boar and birds like geese and ducks and cranes and
Starting point is 00:27:12 things like that. So they were, it seems like they were eating and drinking pretty well here. – They were. This also supports Chuck because if they were not farmers and they were just hunter-gatherers who would come to this area, you know, occasionally, and they were making beer, that supports that idea that we talked about before that bread was actually invented as a portable beer starter. Oh yeah, I remember that old gem. This says that beer came before farming then, if this is what's going on here, if we're interpreting this correctly. So, that is very significant too. The bones in the plants that they found at the site are all wild.
Starting point is 00:27:54 And that strongly suggests to researchers, not just us, that these were hunter-gatherers. They weren't farmers at all. There was no sign of domesticated animal bones. And even more, if you look at all of the animals, any of the engravings or carvings or sculptures, they are all wild animals too. There's not a single sheep or pig or anything like that, any domesticated animal to be found.
Starting point is 00:28:20 Like even the pig is the wild boar. They're just all wild animals. And that will become a little more significant in a second. Yeah, the other thing too we didn't mention is that lends itself to the idea that things are still very transient, was they didn't find things that you normally find, at least at this point, as a permanent settlement, like trash, like big buried mounds of trash, or any indication that there were homes there, or like a hearth where, you know, someone might have burned a fire repeatedly over and over in the same home-like place.
Starting point is 00:28:57 So they're not finding that stuff. They're finding other things that kind of contradict that. You mentioned those human-like carvings. There were other ones that had, like, pretty clear symbolism of death, like a fully carved human sculpture where they intentionally cut off the head so it wasn't just like, you know, hey, look, it's a person without a head. They would carve it into a person, cut off the head, and then place that head somewhere else that was significant to them.
Starting point is 00:29:30 Clearly, symbolization. Symbolization? Symbolizing something? Yeah. Sure. Yeah, so you put all that stuff together, and what you have is this hypothesis that what Klaus Schmidt came up with.
Starting point is 00:29:43 Remember, he's the guy who essentially discovered this place and kept going until 2014. this hypothesis that Klaus Schmidt came up with. Remember, he's the guy who essentially discovered this place and kept going until 2014. His hypothesis was this, because there's no evidence of permanent habitation, right, like you were saying, because all of this stuff is wild game and wild plants that's left over, and because these structures don't appear
Starting point is 00:30:05 to ever have been roofed, like these enclosures were always open air, you put all that together, this was not a permanent settlement. It was a settlement that was created for religious purposes or spiritual purposes or something like that, symbolic purposes, by hunter-gatherer groups.
Starting point is 00:30:24 And every year, a, couple years or whenever, a bunch of them from all around the area would come together and they would party, they would eat, they would drink a bunch of beer, and they would carve out these pillars and raise them. And then, weirdly, Schmidt also added, they would fill these enclosures in with rubble ceremonially.
Starting point is 00:30:46 Because when they discovered them, all the enclosures were, well, filled in with rubble. So he interpreted that to mean that that was part of the ceremony. They would cover one up and then they build another one on top. He said it was Coachella. Did they fill things in with rubble at Coachella? No, of course not. The Indio Polo grounds are very nice actually, but he did sort of say like,
Starting point is 00:31:08 hey, this is the kind of thing that we think they just met here occasionally over decades, maybe even hundreds of years. Maybe these rituals sort of evolved over time to maybe, you know, cause there's clear sort of death symbolism in places to honor people that were important to the community, maybe help establish their identity somewhat as wandering tribes.
Starting point is 00:31:32 And that's what he thought, you know, one of the keys to this whole thing was that to do something like this, they would have had to, you know, even if they were hunters and gatherers, they had to have had a lot of people there that stayed there for long enough time to get this done. Yes, and that over time, over those decades or centuries, it just attracted more and more and more people to the area. And so rather than the monumental structures and religion arising from farming, Klaus Schmidt said coming together to create this religious structure actually essentially trapped people in the area where they became farmers. We had it totally backwards. That was Schmidt's hypothesis. Yeah, it was like a geological chicken or the egg, or I guess archeological chicken or the egg?
Starting point is 00:32:25 Or I guess archeological chicken or the egg? Yes, but the chicken came first. That's right. You know that's the answer to that question. Oh yeah, we've covered it. Okay. We're not going to again, though, I'll tell you that. No, heck no.
Starting point is 00:32:43 Why retread something? So, do you wanna take another break or is it too soon? Well let's take a break right after this because there was one other thing that we should point out is some of the other things sort of supporting this idea of Schmidt was they didn't see a water source anywhere which wouldn't be a good place for people to permanently be. And what else? I already mentioned the garbage dumps and the lack of houses. So I guess the only thing I didn't mention was the water source. Right. The thing is, Klaus Schmidt was, I think he formed this hypothesis, you know, within a couple of years of starting excavation, And it held up, at least until his death,
Starting point is 00:33:25 but after his death, some new evidence came to light that caused people to go back and re-look at some of the original evidence too, or some of the original artifacts and data. And they were like, we're not quite sure Klaus Schmidt had it right. And we'll talk about what they came up with, the new hypothesis, right after this.
Starting point is 00:33:59 Hey everybody, the time has finally come. This week, starting Monday, October 7th, going daily through Friday, October 11th, Bowen Yang and I, Matt Rogers, are unveiling the iconic 400. Yes, these are the top 400 people in all of culture, and we're unveiling all of them. Number 372, Nancy Kerrigan. Why?
Starting point is 00:34:24 We will never really know. Why? We have worked tirelessly on this list. I'm Michael Bhabaro. That's really good. Once you hear I'm Michael Bhabaro, you know exactly who is talking. And we really think it's gonna resonate.
Starting point is 00:34:36 Christina! She is not a Christian! What? She's not happily flying a pride flag. Also, there might be a little bit of a surprise or two in there, so listen carefully. Hint hint Friday. Listen to Lost Culture East us on Will Ferrell's Big Money Players Network on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts.
Starting point is 00:35:01 In a galaxy far, far away. No, babe, that's taken. We're in our own world, remember? Right, in our own world. We're two space cadets. And totally normal humans. Sure, totally normal humans. Embark on a journey across the stars,
Starting point is 00:35:17 discovering the wonders of the universe one episode at a time. We'll talk about life, love, laughter, and why you should never argue with your co-pilot. Especially when she's always right. Right. And if we hit turbulence, just blame it on Mercury retrograde. Or Emily's questionable space piloting skills.
Starting point is 00:35:35 Hey! Join us on In Our Own World for cosmic conversations, stellar laughs, and super corny dad jokes. Listen to In Our Own World as a part of the My Kultura podcast network available on the iHeartRadio app, Apple podcast, or wherever you get your podcasts. And don't worry, we promise to avoid any black holes. Most of the time. How do you feel about biscuits? Hi, I'm Akilah Hughes, and I'm so excited about my new podcast, Rebel Spirit, where
Starting point is 00:36:04 I head back to my hometown in Kentucky and try to convince my high school to change their racist mascot, the Rebels, into something everyone in the South loves, the Biscuits. I was a lady rebel. Like, what does that even mean? I mean, the Boone County Rebels will stay the Boone County Rebels, but the image of the Biscuits... It's right here in black and white in Prince, a lion. An individual that came to the school saying that God sent him to talk to me about the
Starting point is 00:36:28 mascot switch is a leader. You choose hills that you want to die on. Why would we want to be the losing team? I just take all the other stuff out of it. Segregation academies, when the civil rights said that we need to integrate public schools, these charter schools were exempt from it. We're not bigger than a flag or mascot. You have to be ready for serious backlash.
Starting point is 00:36:51 Listen to Rebel Spirit on the iHeartRadio app, Apple podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts. One person we need to shout out besides Olivia is a journalist named Andrew Curry, by the way. He's kind of the guy that has invested, he's kind of like the Schmidt on the journalism side. For decades and decades, this guy's been writing about most of the popular stories about the Keb-blecky, Keb-bleck, Keb-bleck.
Starting point is 00:37:30 Glavin'. The Keb-bleck. The Schenectady Tepe. Sure. Schenectady. It's a big shout out, big shout out there. But before we broke, you mentioned new ideas coming along post Schmidt.
Starting point is 00:37:53 In 2017, his successor won Lee Clare of the German Archaeological Institute, or the DAI. Don't ask. They built a – just the German shorthand for that. They constructed a big old canopy over the whole thing so they could dig more, because I don't think we mentioned for many, many years they were digging in the spring and fall because summer was too hot, winter was too wet. Yeah, just four months a year, right? Yeah, so they could dig more with this big canopy over it, shielding from the sun and rain.
Starting point is 00:38:16 And in order to build, I mean, this is kind of one of those dumb luck kind of things that they probably would have gotten to eventually, but it expedited the situation when they realized to make this big canopy, but it expedited the situation when they realized to make this big canopy, not just like a pop-up with sandbags, they needed to like root this thing into the ground. So they dug down deeper than they ever had before
Starting point is 00:38:35 to make supports and had some interesting finds down there. Yeah, and not just, not deeper than anyone in the world ever had before, Just in this area, right? Oh yeah. Did you think I meant, they dug the deepest hole ever? Yeah, they just kept going. They're like, well, we're already this far.
Starting point is 00:38:54 We might as well set a record. Wow. So they found, they were able to take samples from those pillar holes. I think they went down even below the lowest layer they could possibly find. So when they took those samples, they were like, oh, here's all the stuff that Klaus Schmidt based his hypothesis on because they were missing.
Starting point is 00:39:13 Garbage dumps, hearths, evidence of homes. We found a cistern eventually, like a 30 foot diameter cistern that held a bunch of rainwater, all the stuff you would need to support a permanent settlement. Yeah, I can't decide. When I read this part of the story, I immediately was like, oh no. Like I wonder if, because Schmidt died a few years earlier, I wondered if he, because at first I was like, I'm glad that he wasn't around to see that, because it was kind of proved him wrong. But then I thought, no, Schmidt seems like
Starting point is 00:39:48 the kind of guy that would have like loved knowing that he was wrong. Well, maybe not loved it, but loved knowing that they were on the right track to getting the accurate, you know, picture there. So that's funny. I interpreted him differently. I imagined him showing up at Lee Clare's tent in the middle of the night as a ghost going, Lee, how could you betray me? Oh, maybe.
Starting point is 00:40:12 I think that actually happened too. I saw it on Ancient Aliens. Oh, okay. Perfect. So here's the new hypothesis. They're like, okay, Klaus, he was working with what he had to work with at the time, but now that we have all this other stuff, what we realize is that part of this site might have actually been permanently occupied by some people, but that doesn't mean that
Starting point is 00:40:36 it wasn't also like a ritual site. Like clearly it was. This is not just how people built houses back then. People weren't even supposed to build these kind of complexes back then. One of the things that they're like, okay, Klaus definitely got this wrong, was the idea that part of the rituals were filling these enclosures in with rubble
Starting point is 00:40:54 and then starting a new one on top. Somebody noticed that if you look uphill, the walls that are on the uphill side of the enclosure are usually damaged, whereas the walls opposite are fine, which strongly suggests landslide damage. There's also a lot of earthquakes in that area, so they're like, actually, we think that this stuff just kept getting destroyed, but the site was so important
Starting point is 00:41:21 that for 1,300 years, after an earthquake came through, they would come and rebuild. That's how important the site was so important that for 1,300 years, after an earthquake came through, they would come and rebuild. Like, that's how important the site was to them. Yeah. And, and this is where it gets super interesting to me. Claire and some other people, some of her colleagues and others thought, hey, maybe what this was, was a, was something created because agriculture and people settling down may have already been happening.
Starting point is 00:41:48 And this was sort of created as part of the backlash against that. So people were domesticating plants and animals nearby, and they were still like, no, we want to be hunter gatherers, but we want to have this place maybe where we come and meet seasonally. Yeah, or this is where we live. Like, this is our settlement, but we're not going to farm.
Starting point is 00:42:13 We're still going to, you know- Hunt and gather. Exactly. And one interpretation by a guy named Thomas Zimmerman, who is an archaeologist from Bill Kent University, he sees this as a place that was populated by staunchly conservative, male-dominated population. And there's a lot of stuff to support that, right? So first of all, if you have a group of people who are railing against these new sweeping
Starting point is 00:42:42 changes to society that's going in ways they don't like it, and they're going against that that automatically makes them conservative. And then also if you look around at the iconography and imagery, it is very male-centric. There's a lot of phalluses sticking up, there's all of the figures that are depicted are men.
Starting point is 00:43:02 I read that wherever a wild animal that's carved into one of the pillars is gendered, it's invariably male. And it makes a lot of sense. And then simultaneously, Thomas Zimmerman is like, I think that this was meant to be a place of, it was kind of aggro place where like you would come and like put some young hunters through their scary first rites. Like it was not a place of peace. It's a, if you look at most of the animals, they're snarling, they're dangerous.
Starting point is 00:43:34 This is not meant to be a calm place. And Thomas Zimmerman, I hope he can unwind one day. Right. For his sake and the sake of people around him. Yeah, he kind of described it as, I don't know, like the birthplace of MMA and like, you know, kind of a lot of stuff we're seeing in the news today. Yeah, the birthplace of people who watch ancient aliens. Yeah, pretty much.
Starting point is 00:44:03 Here's the thing though, we still don't know so much. I believe over 50% of it has still not been excavated. Oh no, 90 to 95% is unexcavated. Oh, I thought that was just 90% was underground and they had been doing stuff underground, no? So, yeah, so it's kind of confusing, and maybe you're right, but what I saw is that the whole site is 90 to 95% unexcavated, but that the enclosures that they've been able to find,
Starting point is 00:44:30 only half of them are even partially excavated. So they know that there's enclosures down there, they just haven't gotten to them yet. Yeah, all right. I like this last theory. In 2021, there was a book called The Dawn of Everything by an anthropologist and an archaeologist, David Graeber and David Winn-Grow,
Starting point is 00:44:51 respectively, and they said, all right, here's what we think, is that maybe it was just a non-agricultural society, and maybe they were just a lot more diverse than we thought they were. We kind of had this locked-in idea that everyone was like this and then everyone was like this. And they were like, maybe there was just a lot more overlap and sort of a spectrum of rituals and behaviors and things that people did. And it's just not so clear that things were like this until they stopped and then they were like this. Yeah, and now I remember I got off track earlier when I was talking about the pre-pottery Neolithic group that I have seen that this era of people and earlier human beings,
Starting point is 00:45:42 their culture essentially likened to that of like bonobos or chimps. That that's like the level of like introspection or material culture or contributions that they would make. That they were that backwards. And yeah, Graeber and Wenger are like, we got this all wrong. And so one of the things, the ways that Gabkeli Tepe ties into this is those, the two Davids, that's what I call them. Yeah.
Starting point is 00:46:08 They looked. David and David. Yeah. They looked at some current hunter-gatherer groups, which are obviously not perfect analogies. But what they found is that some groups have hierarchical structures during some parts of the year, where they're sedentary, and then in other parts of the year, where not times of plenty, where you have to like spread out and go find food, they break up into smaller bands of hunter-gatherers.
Starting point is 00:46:38 And they suspect that Gebekli Tepe was a place where they all came together again and enjoyed times of plenty, like where there were tons of gazelles to hunt, lots of nuts and grains and stuff, just for the picking, and that they didn't have to farm, but that they were capable of being sedentary while they were also hunter-gatherers for the other part of the year. Yeah, and not only capable of being sedentary, but capable of having a fairly complex society as they settled for that season,
Starting point is 00:47:14 before they went out. And I love this idea because you picture them just sort of barely surviving and moving on until they find better places to hunt or a source of water. Whereas this posits just sort of a better way of life that anyone thought they lived, to such that they could be like, hey, we're going to brew beer and we're going to party and we're going to have fun because, you know, we're all doing pretty well out here, guys. Look around. Let's like like, enjoy this season of
Starting point is 00:47:46 settlement, I guess. Yeah, or plenty, right? Yeah. And that's, there's a lot of feasting season still today in human culture around this time of year, around late fall, like after the harvest, say. Yeah, Christmas. Even through winter, exactly. And I don't know if it was from the two Davids or somebody interpreting their work, but they were saying there's a really good chance, or at least a chance, that our
Starting point is 00:48:15 holiday seasons, right, is an ancient or remnant of that ancient seasonality. Where we would come together and share in times of plenty and then when, you know, throughout the rest of the year, we'd spread out and go do our own thing. But during those times, community is emphasized, family is emphasized, coming together is all very much emphasized during that time of year.
Starting point is 00:48:39 And they wonder if that's just a, like, we're just unaware that that is a really ancient tradition that we're taking part in still. We just kind of transmuted into our own thing. You know, I really missed a great opportunity for a deep, deep cut. What? David and David joke.
Starting point is 00:48:57 What? I could have said David and David looked around and they were like, hey, welcome to the Boomtown. What is that? It's the only hit song by David and David looked around and they were like, hey, welcome to the Boomtown. What is that? It's the only hit song by David and David. What's Welcome to the Boomtown? The only hit song by David and David. Okay, well, let's hear some of it.
Starting point is 00:49:15 Sing it. Sing it like Sammy Davis. Oh, I said welcome, babe. Welcome to the Boomtown, man. Still don't have it. All those, uh, all those what makes such a succulent sound, welcome to the Boomtown. I half suspect you're making this up as you go along.
Starting point is 00:49:36 It was a great, great one-hit wonder from back in the day by... By David and David? David and David, that's what I've been talking about this whole time. And now it makes sense that you never knew what I was talking about this whole time. No, I did. It's still a good joke just because I got you to sing like Sammy Davis Jr. We all appreciate that. It's a great song. It really is. Um, so I'm gonna go listen to that.
Starting point is 00:49:57 But first, there were just a couple of more things I wanted to say about this. Um, the David and David interpretation of how people were way, way more complex than we give them credit for in the, in the past. Uh, one of the things they point to are ancient burials like 26, 30,000 years old where there's like grave goods and people in beaded headdresses like clearly being treated differently than other people would have been buried.
Starting point is 00:50:23 So obviously, there are hierarchical structures, um, like maybe they were mystics or shaman or something like that. And then there was another interpretation of Gabekli Tepe itself that I thought was worth mentioning by archaeologist Anna Fagan from the University of Melbourne. And she was like, slow your roll Thomas Zimmerman. I actually think that all these depictions of death and mayhem and scary animals is actually symbolic of life and death and regeneration. And she makes some pretty good points. And I like her interpretation a little more
Starting point is 00:51:00 because it doesn't alter anything else. This is still a hunter gatherer tribe and they could still even be railing against farming but that doesn't mean that they have to be like aggro and and You know want to just kill everybody essentially Yeah, I love it. I do too. Let's just keep talking about go black. Go back Lee tepee forever It's a good one. And but now all I can think about is getting That theory officially named the Welcome to the Boomtown Theory.
Starting point is 00:51:27 Okay. I think that's correct. Because it fits in every way. Yeah, for sure. It really does, Chuck. I think if the two Davids hear this, they're going to be into that. You remember that song? Miss Christina drives a 944.
Starting point is 00:51:40 No. That's the first line. No idea what you're talking about. Well, I just sent it what you're talking about. Well I'll just send it to you, it's a great song. Okay, thanks man. Well, since Chuck sent me a song, obviously he's just triggered Listener Man. That's right, this is from Ciara and it's about the Ford Motor Company.
Starting point is 00:51:58 Because Ciara works there as a Michigander. Hey guys, one thing I thought I'd mention about that is you mentioned that the Ford Motor Company has been around since 1903 and is still standing, but I think one of the coolest things about our company is that the, what was it, the Rouge site? Mm-hmm, Rouge River, I think? Yeah, the Rouge River site that you also mentioned in the episode is still standing,
Starting point is 00:52:20 and today builds F-150s. In its history, the Rouge has built the Model B, the Mercury, the Thunderbird, and multiple generations of the Mustang. The site itself has so much history in the Henry Ford Museum that the Henry Ford Museum offers a Rouge factory tour that actually
Starting point is 00:52:36 takes you into one of the manufacturing buildings of the site to see the assembly line from a set of mezzanines. One last thing you didn't mention was that he was a set of mezzanines. One last thing you didn't mention was that he was a supporter of prohibition, and it always reminds me of this funny quote from him, if booze ever comes back to the United States, I am through with manufacturing. I wouldn't be interested in putting automobiles into the hands of a generation soggy with
Starting point is 00:52:59 drink. Thanks for all the knowledge that you share in keeping me company on my compute. That is from Ciara. Thanks Ciara. That's awesome. We appreciate all the extra info. If you want to be like Ciara and show off your knowledge of extra info by sharing it with us, we would love that. Just send it off to stuffpodcastatihartradio.com. Stuff You Should Know is a production of iHeartRadio.com.
Starting point is 00:53:26 Stuff You Should Know is a production of iHeart Radio. For more podcasts, my heart radio, visit the iHeart Radio app, Apple podcasts, or wherever you listen to your favorite shows. Hey everybody, the time has finally come. This week, starting October 7th through October 11th, that's Monday through Friday everybody, we are revealing the Iconic 400. Yes, Bo and Yang and I famously missed our 400th episode here on Los Culturistas, but we are ready to reveal the Iconic 400. Who is on the list?
Starting point is 00:54:04 Does it matter? No. Will it be fun? Yeah. There might even be a surprise or two in there, so listen carefully. Listen to Lost Culture East us on Will Ferrell's Big Money Players Network on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts. I'm Renee Stubbs and I'm obsessed with sports, especially tennis. Tune into my podcast each week to hear me and my friends in the community break down the latest matches, including the US Open. Plus hear from some of the biggest names in the sport about what the future holds.
Starting point is 00:54:37 It's about belief and once you break through that, then you know you can win a grand slam. Listen to the Renee Stubbs tennis podcast every Monday on the iHeart Radio app, Apple podcasts or wherever you get your podcasts. Presented by Elf Beauty, founding partner of iHeart Women's Sports. What does the heartbreaking fate of the cheetah tell us about the way we raise our children? Why was Los Angeles the bank robbery capital of the world? What exactly happened in the Marriott Hotel in downtown Boston in March of 2020? I'm Malcolm Gladwell.
Starting point is 00:55:05 In my new audiobook, Revenge of the Tipping Point, I'm looking at these questions and exploring the dark side of contagious phenomenon. You can hear a sneak peek of the audiobook on my podcast, Revisionist History. Listen on the iHeart Radio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you listen to podcasts.

There aren't comments yet for this episode. Click on any sentence in the transcript to leave a comment.