TED Talks Daily - The difference between false empathy and true support | Chezare A. Warren

Episode Date: June 3, 2024

There's a right way and wrong way to do empathy, says author and scholar Chezare A. Warren. So how do we get it right? He unpacks the source of false empathy and explains the key shift in perspective we need to build healthy relationships and truly support others.

TED Audio Collective. You're listening to TED Talks Daily, where we bring you new ideas to spark your curiosity every day. I'm your host, Elise Hu. Some 80% of America's educators are white, even as the student population gets more and more diverse. And this gap could lead to something called false empathy between teachers and students. Vanderbilt professor

Cesare Warren unpacks this idea of false empathy, explains how to tackle it, and what that could mean for students who need support. That's after the break. Support for this show comes from Airbnb. If you know me, you know I love staying in Airbnbs when I travel. They make my family feel most at home when we're away from home. As we settled down at our Airbnb during a recent vacation to Palm Springs, I pictured my own home sitting empty. Wouldn't it be smart and better put to use welcoming a family like mine by hosting it on Airbnb? It feels like the practical thing to do, and with the extra income, I could save up for renovations to make the space even more inviting for ourselves and for future guests. Your home might be worth more than you think.

Find out how much at Airbnb.ca slash host. AI keeping you up at night? Wondering what it means for your business? Thank you. from Creative Destruction Lab as they ask bold questions like, why is Canada lagging in AI adoption and how to catch up? Don't get left behind. Listen to Disruptors, the innovation era, and stay ahead of the game in this fast-changing world. Follow Disruptors on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or your favorite podcast platform. And now, our TED Talk of the day.

Has anybody else been wearing glasses your entire life? And if not you, perhaps you know someone who has. I remember turning 25 many moons ago, and I had this fabulous birthday party being planned, right? Chicago, penthouse on a lake. Gorgeous. It was going to be gorgeous. I ordered these contacts because, you know, I'm going without glasses, but the contacts never come. So I show up to the party, no contacts, no glasses. I can't see a doggone thing. A for effort, but it was definitely a failed mission. Nonetheless, here I am in my 40s with my stylish but indispensable Coke bottles

helping me to see clearly so that I'm not a danger to myself or anybody else. All this talk about seeing reminds me of a very widely known but misunderstood concept, empathy. See, I've been studying empathy for the last 15 years, and at its core, empathy is how we see plus what we see. How we see is rooted in our personal experience. It's subjective. What we see is more objective. It is a physical observation of a moment, a circumstance, a condition that invites us to act in some particular way.

How we see, on the contrary, is more rooted in our personal beliefs and our value system and perhaps our technical knowledge, all of which may vary from person to person. I've learned over the years that earnest attempts at doing empathy the right way can still land us in the wrong place. While working on my PhD, I was a full-time eighth-grade math teacher on the south side of Chicago. So I would teach all day, I would go to class, and I would study all night. Zero out of ten. Do not recommend. I was always tired. Anyway, I remember my first semester of graduate school,

taking a class and reading a paper called The Political is Personal by Eileen O'Brien. In the paper, O'Brien describes white anti-racists who have a really difficult time building relationships with the people of color that they aim to help. O'Brien insists that white folks and people of color in the United States are separated by this wide perception gap, right? So white folks sort of think about racism as ending in 1960s and therefore see people of color as complaining and overreacting. But people of color see continued racial discrimination. O'Brien is helping the reader to notice a fundamental divergence in perspective that she describes as false empathy, borrowing from heralded legal scholar Richard Delgado.

Essentially, false empathy is the failure of the empathizer to see eye to eye with the individual for whom they aim to empathize. These white anti-racists really thought of themselves as more empathetic than they really were. In fact, the people of color they aim to help did not receive their benevolence and charity as help at all, and in turn, these white anti-racists develop feelings of discontent and frustration that O'Brien then describes as evidence of their false empathy. Now, I remember reading that paper and thinking a lot about my white colleagues who I taught with at the time in Chicago. According to the National Center for Education Statistics, white folks make up about 80% of the teacher workforce, while U.S. student populations become increasingly diverse.

Less than 50% of all K-12 students are being identified as white. This really made me wonder if empathy, or perhaps false empathy, could explain why my colleagues had such a difficult time building positive, substantive relationships with their black students. I watched as black boys who needed more patience and more care be mislabeled as disengaged and disinterested learners. Now, a young person who refuses to take off their headphones, that's what we see. Making sense of the reasons why is how we see.

We need both to drive what we do because empathy is best expressed in the doing. Like the white anti-racist in the O'Brien study, these teachers' relationships tended to be fragile at best and too often non-existent with a group of kids who desperately needed positive adult interactions. Now, I'm talking about education. But all of us, no matter what your industry, on a quest to become a good and kind human being, must stop to notice if false empathy is driving our interactions with diverse others. Okay, so I have to give you a few examples. False empathy is

thinking you know more about other people's problems than they do. It's like meeting somebody from Flint, Michigan and saying, oh my God, I know what it's like not to have something you need, when you've never been without clean water. Not having something you need is not exactly the same thing as not having clean water. False empathy is like putting on your superhero cape. We see somebody in pain, we rush into action,

shrouded in the spectacle of it all, without ever stopping to query the source of their distress. I hate to be the bearer of bad news, but sometimes, saving them may be more about you than it is about them. And false empathy is egotistical. It is self-centered. I love crab legs. Can I just be honest?

I love seafood. But false empathy is thinking I'm doing a really good thing by going to my favorite restaurant and getting a pound of juicy crab legs to take to a partner who has a shellfish allergy. Or buying an expensive gift for a child who would much rather have your attention on the couch after a long day. I could go on, but what I'm trying to say is that false empathy represents a conflict in perspective,

and an earnest intention at anti-racism and helping others does not guarantee that your action will lead to the intended outcome or that we will achieve the relationships that we all need to thrive. I've learned in my research with teachers who demonstrate evidence of empathy with black boys that they don't wake up every day aiming to be empathetic. They try things, they fail and they make mistakes, they exercise humility and they try something else. Some researchers might refer to that as perspective taking, which is the ability to spontaneously adopt the psychological point of

view of others. So we know that perspective taking substantially improves student-teacher relationships, that black boys who are otherwise cast aside feel seen and heard in classrooms where there is evidence of perspective taking, in part because their teachers take a lot of care to develop innovative and proactive solutions to their problems. We know that perspective taking can reduce instances of exclusionary discipline, which is an issue that is particularly salient for black kids, and we know that empathy training can reduce implicit bias.

So imagine for a second you come across someone who appears to be sad and you want to offer them some support. Or you have a friend who approaches you for advice on an issue for which you have some familiarity. If you want to avoid false empathy, perhaps you start by stopping. Stop to observe the moment, right? Empathy requires heightened sensitivity to our ego. We all have an ego. We just don't want that ego over-determining how we see. So we have to learn to de-center ourselves as we listen. Listening is an art. It's a discipline, but it's also an act of perspective taking.

We listen so that we can ask meaningful questions, engage in discourse, exercise humility, and simply be present. We cannot do empathy without perspective taking. And finally, we have to do something. We have to act. But we should not expect that just because we acted that it's going to be the right thing. The feedback we get from that action should drive our subsequent interactions. On the journey to understanding and interpretation, it's a lot like our natural eyes. It grows with time.

As I grow older, my eyes evolve. That's what we'll call it. They evolve. And so I have to go and I have to see the optometrist and I sit in front of that contraption as they move the different lenses to check the clarity of my sight. They're doing that because they want to make sure that how and what I see helps me to act in a way that will make the world a better place as I move through it. Empathy is a lot like that prescription. So the next time you want to help, you want to heal, you want to support, or simply show up for someone, try to make sure you're seeing with the right eyes. Thank you.

Support for this show comes from Airbnb. If you know me, you know I love staying in Airbnbs when I travel. They make my family feel most at home when we're away from home. As we settled down at our Airbnb during a recent vacation to Palm Springs, I pictured my own home sitting empty. Wouldn't it be smart and better put to use welcoming a family like mine by hosting it on Airbnb? It feels like the practical thing to do, and with the extra income, I could save up for renovations to make the space even more inviting for ourselves and for future guests. Your home might be worth more than you think. Find out how much at Airbnb.ca slash host.

That was Cesare Warren at the TED-Ed Educator Talks event in 2024. If you're curious about TED's curation, find out more at TED.com slash curation guidelines. And that's it for today. TED Talks Daily is part of the TED Audio Collective. This episode was produced and edited by our team, Martha Estefanos, Oliver Friedman, Brian Green, Autumn Thompson, and Alejandra Salazar. It was mixed by Christopher Fazi-Bogan. Additional support from Emma Taubner, Daniela Balarezo, and Alejandra Salazar. It was mixed by Christopher Faisy-Bogan. Additional support from Emma Taubner, Daniela Balarezo, and Will Hennessey. I'm Elise Hugh.

I'll be back tomorrow with a fresh idea for your feed. Thanks for listening. Looking for a fun challenge to share with your friends and family? TED now has games designed to keep your mind sharp while having fun. Visit ted.com slash games to explore the joy and wonder of TED Games.