TED Talks Daily - The unexpected wonders of my son's short life | James G. Robinson | Your Body on Tech

Episode Date: June 28, 2026

When James G. Robinson's son Nadav was born with a rare heart defect, he feared the worst. What he didn't anticipate were the moments of unexpected wonder. In this profound talk, Robinson traces five ...years of impossible medical odds, a genetic discovery so strange it felt like fate ... and how grateful he is to have experienced it all. His story is a vivid reminder of what it means to be human — an inexplicable gift, however fleeting. And stick around after his talk for a deep dive conversation with our guest host for the week, author and podcaster Manoush Zomorodi, into the ideas he shared on stage and beyond.This is the last episode in a seven-part series airing this week on TED Talks Daily, where Manoush — and the seven speakers she curated for TED2026 — explore how you can live a healthier life in our high-tech era.To hear more from Manoush, listen to TED Radio Hour wherever you get your podcasts. Check out her new book, Body Electric, to learn more about the hidden health costs of the digital age. Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

Transcript
Discussion (0)
Starting point is 00:00:03 You are listening to TED Talks Daily, where we bring you new ideas and conversations to spark your curiosity every day. Hello, I am Manusse Zamoroti. I'm a journalist, an author, a two-time TED speaker, and you may know my voice because I host the TED Radio Hour podcast over on NPR. This week, I've been taking over for Elise Hugh with a special series of talks and conversations all about how we can live a healthier life in our high-tech era. That topic is a personal obsession of mine, and I had the honor of guest curating a session at the recent TED-2020s conference all about tech, the human body, and what is keeping us human in this digital age. Today, my final speaker from the session and now in this series, James G. Robinson. So I have known James ever since our boys were in kindergarten together. I quickly learned that he and his wife, Tali, also had toddler twins, and that one of those twins, a boy named Nadav, was very sick.
Starting point is 00:01:09 But we lived our lives. We took the kids to school. We talked about our jobs. James was until recently the director of data products at the New York Times. Our boys had sleepovers. But then, a few years later, James and his family took a trip that went very wrong. and Nadav's health took a turn for the worse. You'll hear the story in a moment,
Starting point is 00:01:32 but I just want to take a sec to explain why it was really important to me to include a talk in this series about something that could never be quantified, analyzed, or optimized. And that's the love a parent has for their child. Humans are imperfect, and James would have it no other way. You'll hear more, and you will hear why in his talk and our conversation.
Starting point is 00:02:00 Coming up right after the break. Our TED Talk and Conversation of the Day. Hi, my name is James. I live in Brooklyn, New York with my wife, Tali, and I'm a dad. And when people hear that, they always ask me the same question. How many kids do you have? Well, the answer is three. Three amazing boys.
Starting point is 00:02:32 And then they say, how old are they? And that's where things get a little complicated. because one of them, Nadav, was born with a heart defect and died nine years ago at the age of five. When I tell people this, they always have the same reaction. That's the worst thing I could ever imagine. In fact, some of you are probably feeling that right now. But they don't realize what a privilege it was to be his father
Starting point is 00:02:59 and how grateful I am for having had that experience. And today, I'm going to explain why. Nadav was born with a single ventricle, the result of the condition called heterotaxi. It required three surgeries before the age of four. The first one, at only five days old. But there was no fixing his heart. These operations were merely palliative, a series of sophisticated hacks designed to stabilize his circulation. The hope was to get him to teenage years where he might be eligible for a heart transplant.
Starting point is 00:03:30 Let me tell you what is like to get that news. It is absolutely terrifying because it makes you realize how little you know. I didn't know whether these operations would be a success. I didn't know whether Nadav would live or die. And worst of all, if he did die, I didn't know how I would tell his brothers. Parenting is all about making choices.
Starting point is 00:03:54 We wrestle with the unknown as best we can, hoping that things will work out for the best. We hope that the decisions we make are the right ones, and when things go wrong, we worry that there are no right decisions at all. We simply do not know. But there is also wonder to be found in the unknown. When our first son was born, I left the hospital giddy with awe that we had somehow conjured a new life into the world.
Starting point is 00:04:21 And when his brother was born with a heart defect four years later, it made me realize how truly remarkable this actually is. When we were first conceived, just a bundle of cells, perfectly symmetrical. On the outside of the embryo are tiny hairs called cilia. Their job is to beat the amniotic fluid around the embryo. This lays out the proteins that tell our organs how to form. If the cilia are not working quite right, and this is what happened with Nadav, the flow is erratic. The proteins are in the wrong position, and our organs are malformed. This happens in the span of three hours.
Starting point is 00:05:02 In time for dinner and a movie, your fate is sealed. It absolutely blew my mind to learn this, and had he not been warned with the heart defect, I never would have appreciated it. Forget that anything ever goes wrong. How incredible is it that anything ever goes right? Of course, as the parent of a medically complicated child, you don't have a lot of time for philosophy.
Starting point is 00:05:28 It was hard enough parenting a healthy kid. Suddenly we had to start thinking like doctors. I realized how ambiguous the practice of medicine is. Everything is open to interpretation. We learned that doctors are not magicians or gods. They have a certain level of expertise, but they too wrestle with the unknown. The best doctors were the ones who are honest and humble
Starting point is 00:05:50 about what they didn't know. And one thing doctors do nothing about was how to parent our children. As one doctor said to us, never forget that he is our patient, but he is your son. It was our responsibility to show them the world. And for us, that meant traveling. We pushed strollers all around New York.
Starting point is 00:06:10 We drove to a favorite beach in North Carolina. We even got at a plane and flew to the West Coast where we visited Legoland and the San Diego Zoo. In every place, we tried to show them something new. And then we had an opportunity to go even further. To Australia, a country we loved right after Nadav's fourth birthday. This was a place that was very special to us. My mother is from there.
Starting point is 00:06:33 Tali lived there for four years. But it wasn't an easy decision. Nadav had just had his third surgery, and it was a very long way away. But after long conversations with his doctors, we decided to go. And it was fantastic for two weeks. And then two days before we were due to return home,
Starting point is 00:06:55 we noticed that Nadav was not looking well. We took him to the hospital, where we was diagnosed with a clot in his circulation that required emergency surgery. The operation lasted 10 hours, seven and a half on bypass. He emerged alive just barely, and we found ourselves stranded on the other side of the world, stuck in an unfamiliar hospital with our son being cared for by people we didn't know.
Starting point is 00:07:20 I didn't think things could get any worse. And then they did, because we were called in for a family meeting. And family meetings are never good news. The doctor in charge cut to the chase. Nadav is not doing well, he said. And there are three things that can happen tonight. First, he could improve, and I'm telling you now, that's not going to happen. Second, he could hold steady, and that's what we're hoping for.
Starting point is 00:07:49 Third, he could deteriorate, and in that case, there's nothing more we can do. I had done a pretty good job to that point of holding things together, but in that moment, I shattered into a million pieces. But Tali remained calm. She looked the doctor right in the eye and said, So what you're saying is that it's up to him? Yes, he said, I suppose that's right. Well, I can live with that, she said.
Starting point is 00:08:15 I trust him. What Tali trusted was something inside of Nadav himself. She put her faith in the mystery of how we grow and heal, the energy that causes the siliate beat, the map that tells our organs how to form. She's trusted the resilience of life. that somehow Nadal's body would find a way to heal. He made it through that night and many more,
Starting point is 00:08:42 but he remained the sickest kid in the ward. More than once, we were told that he was going to die. Every few days in the intensive care unit, a new doctor would come on call, and we would bombard them with questions, hungry for information. And they would say, please be patient. We have to get to know him.
Starting point is 00:08:59 And I realized they were saying something subtle and profound. They were saying that they did, did not have the power to heal our son, that only he could heal himself, that their job was to give him the best opportunity to heal. And to do that, they had to get to know him. One day the doctor in charge of the unit announced that he was going to take Nadav outside.
Starting point is 00:09:22 This sounded absolutely ridiculous. He was intubated, he was in critical condition, it took 45 minutes to get him from his room to the elevator down the hall. But it was such a pressure gift. Not out of pity or palliative care, but because you recognize that to heal is human. To feel the wind in your hair, touch leaves, smell flowers, to watch your brothers play, to be together as a family, it was an amazingly human thing to do. We were stuck in Australia for
Starting point is 00:09:54 three months until we found a procedure that could help him. The problem was, was that it was being developed at the Children's Hospital of Philadelphia on the other side of the world. which is why an incredible medical team boarded a specially equipped Gulfstream 3 in Philadelphia and flew from Philadelphia to Oakland, Oakland to Hawaii, Hawaii to Fiji to Sydney. They landed like astronauts wearing blue jumpsuits with the American flag on their shoulders and chopped transport on the back. They'd never transported anybody this sick this far. They told us that if he died, they would land at the nearest airport.
Starting point is 00:10:28 But thanks in part to his resilience, they somehow made it back. The procedure in Philadelphia was successful. Nadav was no longer in critical condition, but his underlying issues persisted. The biggest problem was that there was still some fluid in his lungs and we couldn't leave until it cleared. We spent six months in Philadelphia, waiting for that lung to clear.
Starting point is 00:10:49 In that time, Nalavu learned to walk again, to talk again, to eat again, to smile again. We took him outside as much as possible, inspired by our time in Australia. Every morning, we would walk to a heart, herb garden in a distant ward where we'd pick fresh oregano for Nadav to eat for lunch, his favorite. We wanted him to feel like a kid again because we knew how important it was to help him heal. That lung did not clear, no matter what the doctors tried, they were
Starting point is 00:11:17 completely baffled. Eventually, in August, they decided to try a last ditch procedure to address his lymphatic system, something that nobody quite understood. And thankfully, it worked. His lungs cleared. We were under no illusions about his condition. He still had a single ventricle. His body had actually grown all sorts of new connections hoping to rebalance his circulation. And while I was amazed that his body was finding ways to heal itself, we knew it was unsustainable.
Starting point is 00:11:49 Still, we were finally going home. Before we left, though, there was one last moment of wonder. We were asked to participate in a research study examining the genetic causes of Nadav's condition. And what we found was amazing. Nadav had a malformation in his H5 gene that had never been reported before. It was completely unique.
Starting point is 00:12:12 Finally, we had scientific proof that our son was one of a kind. But here's what's even more astounding. It turns out that Tali and I both have the exact same mutation on each of our H5 genes, completely perfectly identical, never before reported, never before seen. The genetic counselor suspected that we had a common ancestor four or five hundred years ago.
Starting point is 00:12:39 I knew as soon as I met Talley that we were meant to be together. Little did I know that this would reunite a centuries-old mutation that would screw up our beloved son's heart. But I wouldn't change any of it. What choice did I have? Should we not have gotten married? Should we not have had kids? Should we have cherry-picked embryos
Starting point is 00:13:00 hoping to find one free of a defect? Well, then we would be missing our son, a son we loved, and that would be the worst thing I could ever imagine. I've already told you how this story ends. Well, here it is. Five months after we returned home, Nadav died. And when I held him in my arms that night,
Starting point is 00:13:31 I felt all sorts of emotion, pain, sadness, grief. but the emotion I felt most of all was pride. Parents lived for these moments of pride. Graduation, getting married, having kids, I realized that many of these things we would not experience with Nadav. But in his five years, together, we experienced as many moments of pride as most parents feel in a lifetime. And then it was time to tell his brothers,
Starting point is 00:13:59 the one thing I had always feared. When I think back to that moment, I think back to conversations I would have with my own friends, father when I was young. We would go outside at late night and we'd look at the stars. He'd explained to me that we were seeing the stars as they were millions of years ago, that even though they appeared in the sky, some of them may no longer exist. I asked him what was between the stars and he said nothing. I refused to accept this. We argued about it endlessly. I could not imagine such a thing as nothing. My father's own father had died when he
Starting point is 00:14:36 just 16 years old. I grew up afraid of death, terrified of the concept of nothingness. And when it came time to tell Nadav's brothers that he had died, I felt the same sort of dread. As a father, I always felt it was my job to teach my children about the world. But until Nadav was born, I didn't realize how much our children teach us. Our five years together taught me what it means to be human. It revealed unexpected wonders. And it made me realize that there are some things we will never understand. And so when the time came, I told his brothers the truth as best I could. Your brother has died, I said, confirming against my will the empty darkness that surrounds every shining star. Thank you. That was James Robinson. His memoir is called More Than We Expected. When we come back,
Starting point is 00:15:40 My conversation with James about how he's taking his talk on the road to hospitals across the United States, why he still has trust in the medical system, and what he wants you to know about how to advocate for yourself or someone you love who is getting medical treatment. The things that no one tells you. It's in just a moment. Hi, James. Hey, Manoush. Thanks for doing this. My pleasure. I don't need you to redo the whole talk.
Starting point is 00:16:15 But can you just tell us about this remarkable child and what his life was like? So our son Nadev, we always knew his life would be different than other children. But I didn't really expect how incredible it would actually be to have this experience. Obviously, when you hear this news as a father, it's devastating to know that your son will face challenges. But his life, as crazy as it was, really taught me a lot about what it means to live, what it means to grow, what it means to be human. And as difficult as it was, it really revealed a lot of really amazing things about the world. And how did you and your family cope during those first years? We coped as best we could.
Starting point is 00:16:59 What was important to us was to have as much information as possible. The irony of this situation was that we quickly learned that there was a lot of ambiguity in medicine, that even though the doctors were extraordinary, there were still limits to what they could know. and that what we had to do was find a way to collaborate with them on caring for our son, both medically and as his parents. And to do that, especially since he had two healthy brothers, we had to have as normal life as possible, which was not always easy. But we did the best we could.
Starting point is 00:17:29 And the way that we did that was by traveling. We tried to get out of the house as much as possible, show our sons the world, both in our home city of New York, but also elsewhere. What did you love to do with your boys? Well, we loved to play in the house. It was fantastic to just be silly a lot. We were very, very silly. We would wake them up every morning by singing them college football fight songs, for example. We would read books in silly voices, which got on their nerves, which is a father, I think, is always very gratifying. We went for long walks. We went to museums. We went to aquariums. We went to zoos. We just tried to get. out and experience life as best we could. Do you remember the birthday party that you threw for Gilad in Prospect Park where you were
Starting point is 00:18:18 Robin Hood and the Merry Men? We threw tons of birthday parties for the boys. Like that was always a highlight. We went a little overboard with the theme, not by like spending lots of money, but trying to be as creative as possible. Wait, tell me, yeah, which is the one you love the most or remember the most? Oh, we did a lot. During the Olympics, we had an Olympics party in the park across the street from our house.
Starting point is 00:18:40 We printed up custom t-shirts. So all the kids had like shirts with their names in their favorite countries. And then we sort of have like this mock Olympics in the park just doing all sorts of crazy things. You know, the thing that we learned about parenthood was you can't have too much structure on it. You have to give the kids sort of a blank canvas to have chaos. So you can plan a whole bunch of things, but you don't want to dictate too much what actually happens. Because part of being a kid is just the freedom of being, you know, silly and crazy and whatever. And I think it's apparent, you have to realize that you.
Starting point is 00:19:10 ultimately don't have a lot of control over that. And in fact, if you try to, you're going to be getting in the way. So Gilad's birthday party that you're referring to, this is Nadav's older brother. We made like little Robin Hood hats for them. We gave them bows and arrows, which in retrospect was maybe not such a good idea. But again, like we had planned all these things off. We took these kids on like a march through Prospect Park. And we got to the point where there was this wonderful illusion that we were actually, you know, Robin Hood and the Merry Men standing through Sherwood's forest. And in fact, I, like, had these little packets of fake coins I would throw in places, and they would discover these gold coins. And they were great. And all of a sudden, we got to the
Starting point is 00:19:47 road and there was a charity walk. It was like the most unrobbing hood thing you could possibly imagine. You know, tons of people marching along in these pink shirts. I forget what the cause was. And I was like, oh, there goes the illusion. And one of the kids looked at them and said, the king's men, the king's men. And we all yelled, the king's men. And we ran away. Perfect. I'm glad you didn't rob them. No, no, no, no. So, I mean, I guess the point is it's not like you as a family were talking about how sick Nadab was all the time. There was a lot of normalcy.
Starting point is 00:20:19 Yeah, there was normalcy, and normalcy is chaos, and normalcy is unpredictable. And that's true of non-normality, too, right? And his medical care, there's a lot of unpredictability as well. And I think the thing that I learned most about parenthood was that you could do the best you could to impose some order on the universe, but part of being human is to sort of embrace the chaos that inevitably ensues and make sure that it's, you know, not dangerous, as in shooting arrows into the wall, but fun. Okay, so with the chaos in mind, you and your wife, Tali, decided to take the kids to a place that was really important to you. Can you tell us about that decision? Yes. So Nadav had three surgeries before the age of four, all of which went sort of well. The last one did not.
Starting point is 00:21:03 There was a moment of sheer terror where we thought he might not make it because these surgeries are very risky. But after the third surgery, I got an invitation to give a talk at a conference in Australia. And so I suddenly had the opportunity to take our whole family down to show them a country that we loved. And it was one of those moments, and there are many of them when you have a kid who's medically complicated, where you have to weigh different things. You have to weigh the risk of doing something with the benefits of doing something. And the risk was that he was obviously a medically complicated child who had just had a surgery. And the benefits were that this was a place that we wanted him and his brother.
Starting point is 00:21:38 to experience. And so it was great. It was absolutely great. We love the country for a reason. There's just something about being there that makes us feel whole. We shared all the things that we loved about it with the boys,
Starting point is 00:21:51 you know, which was really nice. So at some point, though, Nadav was not looking well and you decided to take him to the hospital. Yep. That was two days before we were supposed to leave until we found ourselves going to the hospital on a day where we should have been going
Starting point is 00:22:05 to the Blue Mountains and exploring the Australian Bulldogs. Bush. Instead, we found ourselves at Children's Hospital, Westmead, which was a place where we knew nobody. And the news we got there was not good. Up to this point, you had real trust in the medical community, whether it was the doctors you knew oh, so well back in New York. And then also this new team in Australia. Like, what was it about, did you think, like, oh, there's going to be a technological breakthrough that's going to save my kid or these are good people. who have, you know, know the science, know the limitations and are just doing the best they can. We didn't know what to think, actually. I think the word trust is not exactly what I used to describe the doctors in the States. Like, I think it was more than we knew them and they knew us, and we had developed that relationship. And so I guess in that respect, we did trust them,
Starting point is 00:22:58 but we also knew that so much of medicine is judgment calls and making decisions based on imperfect information. And that, you're right, that does require a great deal of trust. I think the bigger shock when we got to Australia and needed to have the surgery was that we didn't know anybody. We didn't know anything about them. We'd never met them before. And meeting people in a crisis is not a great way to start a relationship. And you're handing over the most precious thing in your entire life to them. We are. And we knew that if you know that so much of this is a judgment call based on experience, they didn't know him either, right? They didn't know how he reacted to things. They didn't know anything about him, really. It turns out that the surgeon who did operate on him was incredible.
Starting point is 00:23:41 And we asked her in advance. She was very patient talking through, you know, what she intended to do. And we said, well, you know, what approach she can take? And she said, I don't really know yet because I have to be inside him to make those decisions. And that was trust. That was handing your son off to a stranger without any agency or knowledge of what would actually happen. but she earned that trust pretty quickly because she took the time to talk to us. She was clear and candid about what she didn't know, and she warned us all the possibilities. And that meant a lot to us that she treated us with the respect that we thought we deserved us as parents, not just because we were VIPs or anything like that, but because we had a medical knowledge about him and what his care should be that I think doctors needed to make good decisions, and she respected that. There are a lot of people who maybe at some point would have given up on traditional medicine and looked elsewhere. I have had other friends who've had really sick kids and it's, you know, you're willing to try anything, right?
Starting point is 00:24:41 And especially at this point where there's a lot of distrust in medicine. Did you think about maybe going outside the traditional medical establishment to see what could be done for your kid? Um, no. Well, when we first got to Australia, we weren't really going anywhere. I mean, that was the only option, right? When you have a kid who needs emergency surgery, you're not going to take him out of the hospital. That's a little crazy. We're also not that sort of people. The approach that we took was not live at all costs, right? We wanted him to have the life that he deserved. And there were moments after the surgery when we got stuck in Australia. And there was really, there was nothing more they could do for. him and there was no reason to bring him home. He was not a candidate for surgery. The doctor told us straight out, the doctor in charge said, if anybody wanted to operate on your son, I would be very suspicious of his motives because surgery is likely to kill him. And the slim chance that he might
Starting point is 00:25:39 live through the surgery is not worth it. This was after the surgery. This was after the surgery. But yes, you are always looking for things that can help your child. So one of the things that we learned about kids with these sort of heart conditions, and the lymphatic system is really, really important in determining outcomes. And nobody understands the lymphatic system at all. There are doctors in the states who can do wonderful things to lymphatics, but everybody else is not as experienced. So there was a doctor in Australia who had heard about these procedures and asked if we would consider doing a lymphatic procedure to help him out. And we decided that we would because there was sort of a precedent for that. And we had assurance that this was not quackery. Well, that procedure made the
Starting point is 00:26:19 situation worse, right? That was not successful. But we didn't stop looking for things that could help him. Of course not. We didn't give up. But for us, it was important that they were rigorous, that they were tested, and they were from people that we felt had his best interests at heart. And so the reason that we were able to leave Australia was because there was a doctor in Philadelphia who was pioneering a new procedure that would basically address his acute situation without surgery. What was interesting about that is, I don't think anybody else would have found that as an option if my wife, did not read medical journals. And the reason she read medical journals was because we were looking
Starting point is 00:26:54 for absolutely everything that we needed to know to let this kid survive. I mean, that seems kind of crazy. Your wife, to be clear, is not a physician. Why weren't the top people in the field also scouring the latest developments? They are, but the dissemination of information in, I can only speak to pediatric cardiology is it's not haphazard, but it takes time to disseminate. This was a procedure that had been done on less than a dozen patients. You know, so this was not something that had been accepted. I don't think it was even accepted in the hospital that they were doing it at. It was something that was experimental, right? And I think, you know, many medical professionals are obviously cautious about the things that they adopt because the stakes are so high. You know, it's as much art as it is a science, but they're also looking for information they can trust. In the end, you had sort of an extraordinary departure from Australia. Yeah. So when Talley found this medical paper, she asked if Nadev would be a good. candidate for this procedure. So we called his cardiologist in New York and asked if she would ask on our
Starting point is 00:27:55 behalf if he was a candidate. She said, I will ask. She asked him. And the doctor said, I'll evaluate him. And those three words became magical because it became medical justification to bring him home. Now, having said that, his doctors in Australia and the doctors at Children's Hospital of Philadelphia, which is the place that procedure was being done, did a lot of amazing work to actually plan out the logistics of getting a kid to sick home. It was miraculous. It was like a magic carpet for us. This plane was crazy.
Starting point is 00:28:29 It had been used for like medical evacuations from doctors treating the Ebola virus, right? This is the same plane they used for that. So this was like kind of a famous plane. And the people were just as remarkable. Like they were really amazing. You know, one of the nurses said, don't worry. We'll get your boy home. If all I had was a flashlight, I would do it, right?
Starting point is 00:28:49 They had this confidence, but it was like, it was confidence you could trust. And then he unzipped his jumpsuit underneath was, he was from North Carolina, and he was wearing a Greg Olson jersey. Greg Olson used to be a tight end for the Carolina Panthers, whose son also has a heart condition similar to our sons. And he had thought to wear that under his jumpsuit, right? And he unsipped to show us. And we're like, who are these amazing, remarkable people? And it is so humbling, Manus, to know that there are people who've chosen this as their profession. that have dedicated their careers to helping children like our son. Like as parents, we had no choice in it
Starting point is 00:29:24 whatsoever. But these are people who have spent their whole lives just training for this one moment, and that is to help your child. So the logistics in this were insane, but they got him home. And that was as much him as it was them. I remember when the doctor from the U.S. arrived, she said, should we sedate him? And the doctor in Australia said, no, I'd avoid that unless you absolutely need to because he's likely to surprise you. And that was, that reflected the fact that he had, he had gotten to know our son medically, right? That he knew how he reacted certain things. He knew how tough he was. He knew what he could tolerate and not tolerate. And he was passing that knowledge on to the doctor, something that was not on his chart, but something that he felt in a very
Starting point is 00:30:03 human way. Ladov was kind of out of it, but he was, he was a fighter. Like, he learned to talk while intubated, which was insane, not just that he could do it, but that. there was somebody who could teach him how to do it. There was a speech therapist who showed up at her bedside. And we were like, why? Because this is a kid who's intubated and sedated. And we said, why are you here? No offense.
Starting point is 00:30:25 Because he can't talk. And she said, well, he can still communicate. She taught him how to communicate using his eyes, just pointing to the book he liked just by using his eyes. And then she taught him how to blow bubbles. And that was because she wanted to teach him how to speak. This is a kid who's intubated. Wow.
Starting point is 00:30:40 And she taught him how to speak. Like he could croak through his, through his intubation, the two, which was insane. And I think that the things that make us human are so important to healing. Talking is important, right? Like being with your family is important. The child life people there who came to play with him at his bed were not distracting us. They were providing a really important function, which was for us to be together as a family,
Starting point is 00:31:04 trying to make an abnormal situation as normal as possible. What did your boys? Like, how were the boys through all this? All three of them. The boys, it was not easy for them to be stuck there with their parents freaked out. And knowing that their brother was close to death, we were honest as much as possible with them about everything that was going on. Nadav has a twin brother who obviously was not in an age where you could have long conversations about this, but his older brother at that point was eight years old. And we tried to be as honest with possible with him, which I knew was difficult, you know, to tell your son that his brother was in bad shape and might die.
Starting point is 00:31:38 But we thought it was important that he know what was going on so that if he needed to, he could communicate and talk to us about what he was feeling as well. We're going to have a quick break, and then we'll be right back. I saw Nadav at home. He went to school, which you didn't get to talk about in your TED Talk. Tell me about making that decision, you know, despite him being essentially terminal, you decided he should go to kindergarten. I wouldn't call him terminal.
Starting point is 00:32:15 I mean, we're all terminal. We knew that his circulation was unsustainable, but we were still pursuing medical options, even after we left Philadelphia to see if we could get him a transplant. So that wasn't the attitude that we were taking. And I bring that up because it's not like we went to kindergarten out of palliative care or just like a make a wish or anything like that, right? Like we wanted him to live. We wanted him to live as long as possible. And we also wanted his life to be full, right? And four-year-olds, five-year-old should be in kindergarten, right? Like, that's just a normal thing to do. So we decided when we got back from Philly after six months to enroll him in the kindergarten, the public school across the street from our house.
Starting point is 00:32:56 And New York City law is that they have to accommodate any kid, regardless of what's going on. Nadav was not in great shape, even though he had sort of learned to walk again and write again, like he was on oxygen, supplemental oxygen, which meant that he had an oxygen tank that went everywhere and he had a nasal canule, these two things in his nose that gave him the oxygen he needed to breathe. And so our first meeting with the staff at the school was a little fraught. You know, like I think they wanted to help, but this is probably the sickest kid any of them have seen in their lives. Because there's a lot of logistics you have to work out. Who's going to take him to the bathroom? Who's going to take them upstairs?
Starting point is 00:33:28 The sort of thing. But the teacher who would be in charge of him at one point looked over to me when it was especially tense and said, don't worry, we're human. And at that moment, I knew we were in good hands. Like, that's all I needed to know, because I knew that she understood what was important. And so he developed incredible friendships there. It was remarkable for him to be around kids' own age going to school, you know, after all he had been through. And we thought that maybe he would go like a day a week or half a day.
Starting point is 00:33:56 And he went every single day. And it was really, really incredible. I mean, I feel like the story doesn't end well, James. And I hate that, like, you have to keep telling it over and over again. but I suppose at this point you are used to it, but I knew your son. I know your boys now. I know you and your wife.
Starting point is 00:34:20 Well, I mean, as someone who was not with him every moment, it still came as a shock. It's funny. This is an interesting moment, Manus, because this is not a difficult story for me to tell. It brings me great joy to tell this story because I'm able to share his life with other people in a way that hopefully makes an impact.
Starting point is 00:34:37 Obviously, his death was a very sad thing. I had known this when he was born that this was a possibility, right? The one thing that I really feared when he was born was not just the fact that he would die, the fact that I would have to tell his brothers that he had died. And that always terrified me most of all. Like the act of telling always scared me. And yet when the time came, I felt that I had the strength to do it. When he did die, and I did have to tell his brothers that this had happened.
Starting point is 00:35:04 I knew how to do it. And I think what had happened was as a father, you feel the obligation to explore. the world to your children, to tell them as much as possible. And I realized by this point that this was one thing I could not explain, you know, wrestling with the possibility of his death. And honestly, the possibility of my own death, because it does make you face your immortality. This is something beyond my understanding. And so when the time came to tell the boys what had happened, I told them the truth. He had died. And I trusted their strength and resilience to eventually be able to make sense of that. You know, like, the aftermath of his
Starting point is 00:35:39 death, we kind of knew what to do because we have a tradition that tells us what to do, right? Judaism. Judaism. Yeah. And I'm not here evangelizing, but I'd always sort of appreciated Judaism's spiritual aspects, that there's a spiritual explanation for everything. And yet when it comes to grief rituals or bereavement rituals in Judaism, they're really practical.
Starting point is 00:35:59 But the most interestingly practical thing that I found about the Jewish traditions is that you have to be surrounded by folks when you are mourning. So you say a prayer called the Kaddish, three times a day. day and you have to do it with nine other people. That is a necessity. And when I went back to work, after he had died, somebody at work said, do you want us to announce to the company that this has happened? And I said, I don't know, use your best judgment. And so they decided to send down a note to everybody about this. And I was actually very grateful that they had. Because when I came back, it was not awkward at all. Like, I didn't have to explain to anybody. They all knew.
Starting point is 00:36:34 And it was more awkward for them, actually, right? Like, it took the obligation of awkwardness off of me and put it on to them. But what was really amazing was a bunch of my colleagues who I did not know, realized that he had a Jewish name. And they knew of this obligation that three times a day you're supposed to say cottage with a group of people, right? They wrote to me and said, we just want to let you know that when you come back, we will arrange, it's called a minion.
Starting point is 00:36:57 We'll arrange a minion for you at work every day. And I thought that was the most incredibly kind thing that anybody could possibly do in that situation. Of course, we worked in the garment district. There's like a million synagogues around. I said, I'm already planning on going to the synagogue, but it's very kind of you'd offer. And they said, well, in that case, we'll make sure that you don't go alone. And so every day for a month, somebody would meet me in the lobby around lunchtime.
Starting point is 00:37:22 And we would introduce ourselves because we didn't know each other. The only thing we had in common was that we worked together when we were Jewish. And we would walk the five blocks to the synagogue so that we could say the prayers. And over that time, I would tell them the story of Nadav's life. and by the end of the walk they would be in tears and I would be comforting them. So that taught me a lot of things. First of all, it taught me the incredible kindness of strangers. It taught me that our story has power to affect other people because I think one of the reasons they were crying is I think everybody holds something deep and difficult within them, even if it's not the death of a child.
Starting point is 00:37:57 You know, one of the things about being in the situation is it reveals the goodness in the world, Manus, in a way that nothing else does. And I think the world is a fundamentally good place There are wonders all around us And the mystery of what it means to live And why all this happens Is both terrifying and wonderful And I think there is wonder and joy to be found Even in the most difficult situations
Starting point is 00:38:17 And that's why it's not as hard for me As I think you would think for me to tell this story Because it reminds me of all those wonderful things That we learned along the way It's interesting to me that You say that Because you spend a lot of time In hospitals
Starting point is 00:38:32 still. Explain what you've been up to. So I wrote this memoir. Two and a half years ago, it was published. The main reason I wrote it actually is for Nadav's brothers. So when they're old enough to really understand what it means to be a father, they can understand what I went through and how I interpret it. But I also realized that our story could help people in similar situations, whether they're clinicians or families taking care of medically complicated kids.
Starting point is 00:38:57 You know, there are things that we learned along the way that I think could be helpful with them. And I share our story. And I share it in the medical context because I want doctors to understand what we learned about the practice of medicine and how you care for kids like our son. And I think that relies on an acknowledgement that we are human in so many different ways, that parents have to realize that doctors are not magicians or gods, that they are experts in their field, but they're also a whole bunch of things they don't know, which is often difficult for doctors to admit.
Starting point is 00:39:27 And I want doctors to treat families like humans. I think the ability to talk about medicine as an essentially human endeavor and all the implications they're in is something that I think is not often taught in medical schools and does seem to have a big impact on those folks. What do you think the thing is that you say that surprises physicians the most? I'll tell you the thing that I tell them that I think they need to hear the most. Okay. It may be a different way to answer that question, which is doctors have to be open and honest about what they don't know. they have to admit that there are limits to their knowledge, that a lot of these things are unpredictable and not as well researched or understood as they should be. And I think that's important
Starting point is 00:40:06 for them to admit that because it changes the dynamic between family and doctor to a point where both recognize that ambiguity as you make decisions on the same page. I think there's a way of communicating that to families in a way that's reassuring and not devastating, right? Which is to say, here are the things we could try. Honestly, we don't know how they could turn out. In my experience, I tend to see things happening this way, but we don't really know what could happen. And this is a decision that we have to make together,
Starting point is 00:40:35 I think it's a very healthy thing to say to a family, rather than pretending you have all the answers. Right. I mean, I talk to a lot of researchers. I also talk to a lot of technologists. Did you find yourself ever caught up in this idea? Like, well, innovation and progress are so fast right now in medication and medical.
Starting point is 00:40:54 treatments and technology and gene therapies and all kinds of things, if we can just hang on, maybe there will be a breakthroughs for us. There is no doubt that medicine is advancing at a rapid pace. There are things that could have helped our son that exist today that did not exist 10 years ago. But there's an arc of it, right? Like the first heart surgery was in the 40s, ever done on kids, blue babies like our son. Are they risky? Yes.
Starting point is 00:41:23 Do parents need to understand what it means to take those risks? Yes. But it's not just some sort of magical, technical innovation that's going to save this, that's going to help this. The three surgeries that our son had are temporary. Hopefully kids in the future will never have to endure them. They're not fixes. They are elaborate hacks designed to twist the body's circulation into a stable state in the hopes that they can grow old enough to be eligible for a transplant or to be able to have a good chance at a transplant. I would say. But is there a magic bullet? Sure, maybe eight years from now, somebody will be diagnosed with a single ventricle in utero, and the doctor will say, we'll just take care of it before they're born. I'm sure that's going to happen. But, Manus, I actually believe that as humans, we have to come to terms of the fact that there's things we will never understand. And this experience taught me that, that there was always a limit to what you can know. And I think the humility to accept that helps you cope with that terrifying reality in a way that allows you to live your life and find grace in the things about humanity that do matter and that are really important.
Starting point is 00:42:28 What you said about 80 years from now, it brings up another question that I feel super uncomfortable asking you. But there are also a lot of technologists who say, well, you know, you won't need to have a child with such a devastating malformation because we will be able to genetically optimize embryos so that they are never implanted with something that could take their life at an early age. I'm sure you've heard a lot about this stuff, and I have to ask, how do you respond? What do you think of them? Here's what I will tell you. People think that having a kid in our situation, born with a terrible heart defect, dying at the age of five is the worst thing they can ever imagine. And one of the things that I that I want people to understand is what an
Starting point is 00:43:21 incredible privilege it was to be his father. And I think most people you talk to, most parents in similar situations will agree with that statement. And how grateful I am to have had the experience of being his parent. And I think that's a hard thing to understand if you've never been through it. But I think if you talk to any parent in a similar situation, they will have that a similar sense of privilege that you were there with your child on their journey, as weird and wonderful as it may be, and that even though some journeys may only last five years and some may last 50, there is something beautiful by every life that I think needs to be appreciated, and parents are uniquely positioned to appreciate their children no matter what happens. And that's the privilege that I feel.
Starting point is 00:44:04 As you, I think, know, my favorite line in your whole talk is when you say, forget that anything ever goes wrong, you're talking about the creation of life. You say, how incredible is it that anything ever goes right? And I think that summed up for me the exact feeling I had when I gave birth and looked at these kids and I was like, oh my gosh, they have all their fingers. And it didn't matter to me. I didn't care. It was like, it was just amazing that they were alive. Tell me how other people have responded to that line and why you felt it was so important to include. When you're put in this position and you realize the processes by which the body grows and heals, like it's just absolutely astounding. Like that's magical. I don't think I ever appreciated that.
Starting point is 00:44:56 Had I not been forced to learn about our son's anatomy in the way that I had, you know, part of the reason he was able to leave the hospital in Philadelphia is he grew all these new veins to compensate for circulation, right? Like he's his own cardiologist. And the best doctors understood that they did not have the power to heal children. Like, that's not the power they have. Like, only children can heal themselves. Their job is to give them the best opportunity to heal. You know, the surgeon who operated in Australia thought to know him during that 10-hour surgery, right? We asked her afterwards, like, did you feel you got to know him? She said, sure, I know him really well. He's one tough kid. And we're like, well, how do you know that? She said, his scarring is incredible.
Starting point is 00:45:37 Like she could tell by the way his body had scarred over what sort of person he was, right? But we don't ever see that. And when it does happen, like we cut our finger and it heals, we sort of take it for granted. That's what happens. But I think that's just magical and amazing. And when I talk to doctors or researchers, I say to them very directly, like, I hope you retain that sense of wonder, right, in what happens. Because you're privileged to actually, you know, encounter some of these things up close. And many of the researchers that I met absolutely do, right?
Starting point is 00:46:05 It must be exhilarating and really rewarding, but also really exhausting. It's exhausting. I think a long nap after this conversation, Manus. It is exhausting. I think what's happened over the past few years is that I've started to think about other ways in which I can make an impact on the lives of kids of these situations and the people who care for them. I've met so many amazing people doing incredible things that I think I've started to understand, for making care better. And if I could be a part of that, that would be amazing and wonderful. And if our story or my work can help reveal that to people and make their lives better, like, that's an incredibly gratifying thing to be able to do.
Starting point is 00:46:58 Working with someone to tell the story of their dead child is difficult. Or so you would think, James reminded me again and again, whenever I, started to feel uncomfortable, that he wanted to tell Nadav's story. I am so grateful for his enthusiasm, generosity, and vulnerability. And I know that people who've experienced loss like him or who are treating unwell children are really grateful to him too. They surrounded him after his talk to share their own stories, to ask questions about how they can improve their care and what they can do to keep going in the face of so much grief. He is a founding, of kindness, compassion, and knowledge, and inspires me every day.
Starting point is 00:47:45 And maybe he'll inspire you too to embrace the wonderful uncertainty of life. That was author James G. Robinson at TED 2026 in conversation with me, Manusse Zamorodi. And you can watch James's full talk, full of pictures of his kids at ted.com. Thank you so much for being on this ride with me. Seven talks, seven conversations, all looking for answers to this question. How do we build healthier lives and stay connected to our humanity in our high-tech era? Clearly, there is no one answer or no one right way. Medicine and technology are delivering hyper-personalized feedback and treatments.
Starting point is 00:48:32 But in our rush to optimize and be the absolute best we can be in body and mind, And we have to remember that the only reason we feel so compelled to invent new devices, vaccines, treatments, and protocols is because of what an amazing experience it is to be alive with all our faults and joyful triumphs alive with each other. And that's it for today. If you're curious about Ted's curation, visit ted.com slash curation guidelines. TED Talks Daily is a podcast from TED. This episode was produced by Lucy Little and Katie Montalione. It was edited by Alejandra Salazar with editing support from Maggie Bishop, Sanaz Meshkampur, and me. James's talk was fact-checked by the TED research team.
Starting point is 00:49:24 Our conversation was fact-checked by Lucy Little, and this episode was mixed by Steve Bone. The TED Talks Daily team includes Martha Estefanos, Oliver Friedman, Lucy Little, Emma Tobner, and Tanzika, Sungmar Nivong. with support from Daniela Ballaroz, Valentina, Bohanini, Ban Manchang, and Lainey Lott. Special thanks to Sanaz Meshkentfor and my team at NPR's TED Radio Hour for all their help on this special takeover. And to my co-curator at TED2020, a very special thank you to David Bielo. You can hear more from these speakers on the TED Radio Hour with episodes coming out throughout the summer. I'm Manus Shomeroi. You can catch me on NPR's TED Radio Hour every week, Elise Hugh will be back tomorrow with a fresh idea for your feed.
Starting point is 00:50:11 Thanks so much for listening.

There aren't comments yet for this episode. Click on any sentence in the transcript to leave a comment.