Ten Percent Happier with Dan Harris - How To Unsubscribe From The Negative Stories You Tell About Yourself And Others | Anu Gupta
Episode Date: December 18, 2024How your blindspots hurt your decision-making— and how to fix it.Anu Gupta is an educator, lawyer, scientist, and the founder and CEO of BE MORE with Anu, an education technology benefit co...rporation that trains professionals across corporate, nonprofit, and government sectors to advance DEIB and wellness by breaking bias. His work has reached 300+ organizations training more than 80,000 professionals impacting over 30 million lives. Gupta holds a JD from NYU Law, MPhil in Development Studies from Cambridge University, and BA in International Relations and Middle Eastern & Islamic Studies from NYU. As a gay immigrant of color, he came to the work of breaking bias after almost ending his life due to lifelong experiences with racism, homophobia, and Islamophobia. The realization that bias can be unlearned helped lead him out of that dark point and inspired a lifelong mission to build a global movement for social healing based on principles of mindfulness and compassion. A peer-reviewed author, he has written and spoken extensively, including on the TED stage, the Oprah Conversation, Fast Company, Newsweek, and Vogue Business. He is the author of Breaking Bias: Where Stereotypes and Prejudices Come From—and the Science-Backed Method to Unravel Them.In this episode we talk about:The 5 causes of biasThe dis-utility of shameWhat has – and hasn’t – been working in DEI trainingsContemplative practices, on and off the cushion, for breaking biasAnd his response to skeptics Related Episodes:Why You‘re Not Seeing the World Clearly— and How to Fix It | Jessica NordellThe Self-Interested Case for Examining Your Biases | John BiewenDolly Chugh, How Good People Fight BiasRhonda Magee, Law Professor Using Mindfulness to Defeat BiasHow to Call People In (Instead of Calling Them Out) | Loretta RossSign up for Dan’s newsletter hereFollow Dan on social: Instagram, TikTokTen Percent Happier online bookstoreSubscribe to our YouTube ChannelOur favorite playlists on: Anxiety, Sleep, Relationships, Most Popular EpisodesFull Shownotes: https://happierapp.com/podcast/tph/anu-gupta-877See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.
Transcript
Discussion (0)
Wondery Plus subscribers can listen to 10% happier early and ad free right now.
Join Wondery Plus in the Wondery app or on Apple podcasts.
This is the 10% happier podcast.
I'm Dan Harris.
Hello, everybody. Hello everybody, how we doing? One of the more excruciating aspects of being alive is that we all walk around with these
noxious, negative and self-limiting stories about ourselves.
At the same time, we're also walking around with all kinds of stories about other people, often based solely on how they look.
One term for this phenomenon is bias, internalized and externalized bias.
And my guest today argues that this kind of bias can actually be broken.
I want to acknowledge up front, and you will hear my guest acknowledge this as well,
that many, if not most of us, have attended DEI sessions that truly suck.
And I just want to assure you that is not what you are in for today.
A new Gupta's approach is devoid of shame or guilt or blame.
Instead, it's kind of playful and it's also based deeply in the Dharma,
meaning mindfulness and compassion.
Also and crucially, it's not just focused on how you treat other people, but also on
how you talk to yourself.
Again, the key idea here is that everybody, all of us, we're all suffering because of
our learned ideas, learned from our family, from the larger culture, et cetera, about
who we are and about who other people are.
But we can unlearn these stories.
Moreover, this process does not have to be a death march.
It can be fun and interesting,
and in the end, it can make you happier.
A little bit more about my guest before we dive in here.
Anu Gupta is an educator, lawyer, scientist,
and the founder and CEO of a company called Be More
with Anu, a company that trains people
on how to break bias.
His new book is called Breaking Bias.
The subtitle is Where Stereotypes and Prejudices Come From and the Science-Backed Method to Unravel Them.
In this conversation, we talk about the five causes of bias, the disutility of shame,
what has and has not been working in the DEI trainings that many of us have attended, contemplative
practices both on and off the cushion for breaking bias, and his response to skeptics.
We will get started with a new Gupta right after this.
But first I want to say this.
As you well know, it's gift giving season and I've got a gift for you.
If you've been thinking about trying out
a paid subscription to danharris.com,
you can now get a whole month free to check it out.
Paid subscribers get cheat sheets for every new episode,
including takeaways, transcripts, and pertinent quotes.
You'll also get access to live AMAs
or ask me anything sessions with me.
Plus you can comment on my posts
and chat with me directly about our podcast episodes.
And sometimes you get to chat with the guests themselves.
And of course you get to chat with the other listeners.
We've got a really cool community
growing up over at danharris.com.
We're having a lot of fun
and I'd love you to join us with one month free.
Go to danharris.com slash holiday for this special offer.
Hope to see you there.
Maybe you've stayed in an Airbnb before
and thought to yourself,
this actually seems pretty doable.
Maybe my place could be an Airbnb.
It could be as simple as starting with a spare room
or your whole place when you're away.
You could be sitting on an Airbnb and not even know it.
Maybe you're daydreaming about hitting the slopes
or maybe you're just craving a change of scenery.
While you're away, you could hitting the slopes or maybe you're just craving a change of scenery.
While you're away, you could Airbnb your home and make some extra money that you could put
toward the trip.
I'm a huge fan of Airbnb.
My family and I have been talking about going to the Galapagos, but that is super expensive,
so maybe putting our house up on Airbnb is a way to raise some money for that trip.
I do love renting houses with my family and several other families
and getting together. It's so much more intimate than a hotel. So I'm a fan for sure on the
customer side. Whether you could use some extra money to cover some bills or for something
a little bit more fun, your home might be worth more than you think. Find out how much
at airbnb.ca slash host.
Peloton has a variety of workouts for whatever era you're in,
holiday era, running era, wellness era,
whatever era of life you're in,
Peloton has the classes and motivation
you need to get after it.
With Peloton's all access membership,
you can work out where you need it.
Whether you're at home on your bike, tread and row, or on the app at your kid's game,
you can squeeze in what you need wherever you need it.
Whether you need 10, 20, or 45 minutes of you time to sweat and get grounded,
Peloton provides flexibility with daily on-demand and live classes
that fit your busy schedule and your everyday life.
I am a power user of Peloton.
I have one of the bikes.
I use it all the time.
I do some of the short rides,
but if I have more time,
I like to get in a 45 minute ride.
It really calms my nervous system
and helps me sleep at night.
And when I'm on the road, like in a hotel,
I'll often use the Peloton app on my phone
to do a high intensity interval training class.
I love those.
So long way of saying I'm a huge fan of Peloton app on my phone to do a high intensity interval training class. I love those. So long way of saying I'm a huge fan of Peloton.
Find your push, find your power with Peloton at onepeloton.ca.
Anu Gupta, welcome to the show.
Thanks so much for having me.
I'm really thrilled for this conversation.
Yeah, I'm looking forward to it. So let me ask you the question that we were talking about before
we started rolling here, which is to put it very crassly, like what's in it for me? Why would I
want to do the work of breaking bias? How do my biases hurt me and why should I turn the volume
down on them? Yeah, absolutely. So I'll just start with my story because I came to this work because I was hurting,
right?
I came to this work because I was suffering tons and tons of dukkha because of the
body I found myself in.
You know, I'm a gay immigrant of color in the United States.
I moved here when I was 10 years old and suddenly I became kind of the object of
attack, particularly from young people in my middle school, my elementary school, because I was different.
Right?
So they were not seeing me, but they were seeing ideas of me, terrorist or the F word
or you name it, right?
The way I smell, the way I walk, what I ate.
So these were some of the things, the stories that were percolating that for me weren't
really about me.
But as a young person, I believed them.
When I basically, what I started to do was try to assimilate, try to be what others wanted me to be.
I streamed out my accent, I watched the way I walked so I wouldn't be perceived as feminine.
Little things became hypervigilant. And this kind of continued on throughout my young adulthood,
into college, into grad school, into working abroad to, of course, then returning to law school 15 years ago.
And whenever I would bring up this idea of bias, because I'd been studying it, right,
particularly from a global lens, I worked in Myanmar, I worked in Taiwan, in South Asia,
and I saw bias operating in so many different contexts.
But I would just acknowledge it in the classroom that, hey, like something I've experienced
too. At that point, there wasn't an understanding of it or a widespread
acceptance of it.
So I'd just be gaslit.
And then I started to believe that, oh, maybe what I'm feeling is wrong
because no one around me believes me.
And they're just asking me to move on or what I'm feeling is wrong, right?
I'm feeling bad because of my various identities.
So I found myself on the ledge of my 18th floor window
about to jump off,
right before my second year of law school was gonna begin.
And in that moment, when I was on the ledge,
I started noticing all the ideas I'd been really shrunk to,
right, fatty faggot, big nose idiot, terrorist.
And that's when I began to see,
I'd been a mindfulness practitioner,
a Dharma practitioner for a long time, that these were ideas.
These ideas that somehow I started identifying with, and they weren't really me.
Now what happened afterwards, I can't explain, a moment of grace, that's really what I've
been calling it.
Instead of falling forward, I fell back into my apartment.
Immediately, I sensed the gravity of what I was about to do.
I called a friend who lived maybe like three or four miles away, but
happened to be walking on my block.
She showed up within two minutes.
We talked the whole night.
And the next morning I began my breaking bias journey.
So for me, this is really personal to all of us because there's so many ideas
that we believe about ourselves because of our various identities,
what we look like, how much we earn, what roles and functions we play, what we may have experienced
in our lives. And unless we become intimate with those ideas, they then begin to affect how we feel
about ourselves, affects our mental health, our physical health, and of course, kind of translates
into a whole host of addictive coping mechanisms.
But for me, that's where the journey really began. And it's really important for me to really work
with this idea of bias, particularly internalized bias with mindfulness and compassion. Compassion
is really key to breaking bias. Well, first of all, I'm very sorry that happened to you.
Oh, thank you. Yes. It did suck.
And 15 years later, I'm like, it was a gift because it kind of brought me on this path
and I've been able to share my story with thousands and thousands of people.
And I've gotten such feedback that I'm not alone.
And this is so common in our society, particularly among people who I wouldn't think I have very
much in common with across political divides, across religious divides, across sexuality, race, you name it.
And that's when I was like, wow, we're all suffering in this human soup together.
And this is why I felt so passionate about writing this book.
It's interesting. I mean, I realize the, I don't know if bias is the right word or I don't love the word I'm about to use, but privilege or luck that is embedded in the way I phrased the question to you
because you answered it from the perspective
of internalized bias.
So other people's biases that you then consume
and believe on some level and tell yourself a shitty story
about yourself that isn't true
because other people are telling you a shitty story
about yourself. And I meant because other people are telling you a shitty story about yourself.
And I meant it more like, obviously the question is coming from somebody who's in every dominant
group available.
I meant it more like how are my biases hurting me?
Maybe I have internalized biases about other people's stories about me, but people who
look like me tend not to deal with much of that.
Yeah. I think it's really interesting that you've asked that question.
This is kind of the invitation in the book that for us to break by, we really have to
get to know ourselves.
And the way I look at dominant identities or subordinated identities and this idea of
privilege and marginalization is once again from the somatic experience perspective.
So for me, breaking by isn't something we just do with
our heads. We have to engage our bodies. We have to engage our hearts. So like the fullness of who
we are, including what's neck down, the experiences of privilege or marginalization are really
experiences of ease and of pain. So when we say that we're privileged around certain identity,
whether it's gender or race or class, we just experience a sense of ease in society. We don't
have to think about it, right? If for a wealthy person, we can go anywhere in the world,
right, and purchase anything. Whereas if we are strapped for cash, that causes us pain. So it's
really from that lens that I want to enter in this conversation. And I think for people in
dominant identities, this is really, really important, whether it's a white cis guy like
you or anyone else, someone who's wealthy or someone who's from a dominant religious
group or an ethnic group. It's really about seeing the stories we are believing about ourselves,
particularly at a really deeply unconscious level, entitlement and superiority that may
accompany our being. And this is what I love about the Dharma, because it allows us to really see us for who we are.
And what that really does is beneath that entitlement and superiority, and I've noticed this while I was practicing as a lawyer,
there's a sense of inferiority. There's a sense of wanting to be the best.
And somehow, sometimes whenever that's proved wrong, we get upset, we get angry. And that's kind of the comparing mind that enters this conversation for folks who are
with some dominant identities. And I think what Breaking Bias really helps us do is really begin
to acknowledge the is-ness of our being and how we share that is-ness with every other human being
as well as every other sentient being on this planet.
And that makes us feel better.
And particularly, and I'll speak this for myself
as a cis man, when I did this for gender,
for trans people, for non-binary people,
for women, for cis women, I began to see, wow,
like I just am, right?
But then I could also begin to share empathy
and compassion for people whose identity
I didn't share and their struggles. And that made me feel closer to them. And it helped me
address some of the fears and the worries that I had when I was around such people.
I don't know if you've ever felt this, but sometimes when I'm having this conversation,
I feel like I'd be walking on eggshells.
And I was like, so afraid to say the wrong thing or do the wrong thing and just be attacked.
I was just ready for that.
But I think the more I did this work to acknowledge the dominant identities that I have, and but
also feel the pain of the suffering that's caused by those identities, sometimes when
I make mistakes, it's not personal anymore.
I just acknowledge that, oh, I didn't know that. Thanks for informing me. But it's helped me build
bonds across difference in a way that I wouldn't see was even imaginable 10, 15 years ago.
HOFFMAN You said a lot there. I want to get back to
is-ness in a second. That's interesting. But I think one thing I just want to make sure I understand is you said that for people who are coming from a dominant group like me, the way in which bias can hurt us is that we carry with us a sense of superiority, which can lead to a kind of brittleness where anytime shit doesn't go our way, we freak out.
Yeah, it can. It's a bell curve, right? Everything's a bell curve.
But that's what I experienced and that's what I've seen happen with people with dominant
identities.
No matter what your identity, I guess one case I'm surprised you haven't made yet, and
maybe there's a reason for it, or maybe I just haven't given you the time.
But it seems like no matter what your identity, we all have biases and we evolved to have
biases, cognitive shortcuts in essence.
Many times they misfire and hurt our ability
to see things clearly and make good decisions.
So that seems to me to be at least one universal
self-interested case for working on your biases
because the more you have these unexamined blind spots,
the dumber you are in essence.
Yeah, and I'll say two things.
I think there are two important concepts that would be,
I think that would be really useful for folks listening
to understand.
First is the concept of bias itself.
I think there is a false perception in our society
that we're born with biases.
We are not born with biases,
particularly biases toward other humans.
Like we're not born to think that men are stronger
than women or better at math than women or white people are better leaders than
people of color. These are learned habits. So all forms of biases are learned mental
habits. There are conscious biases, which are learned false beliefs or unconscious biases
that are learned habits of thoughts or associations. And both forms of biases distort how we perceive, reason,
remember, and make decisions.
So for me, growing up in the United States,
that really meant that people weren't seeing me.
I was just a new, I was just like nerdy kid
who had an interesting sense of humor,
but they saw other ideas of me
because of those learned false beliefs
and learned habits of thoughts.
And there are five causes to any form of bias.
We can get into that.
So that's basically what bias is.
And what I discovered in my research
and what I write in the book is
I had to like really blow up time and space.
So I go into like 10,000 years of recorded human history,
whatever we have documentation for.
And the idea is bias, particularly the type of biases we experience in
our society have really evolved recently, particularly on certain identities like race or
even gender. And they've been spread around the world. Our consciousness has been infected
with these false beliefs and these associations. And our goal now is to unlearn these habits, these mental habits,
and then learn and restore new ways of being with one another. So that's one thing about bias.
The other is about identity. So I'm on the intersection of many, many subordinated identities,
but also many dominant identities. And even someone like you, like I don't know the fullness
of your intersectionality,
that there are identities where you feel marginalized. Whether it's your place in your
childhood or where you grew up in terms of geography or how well traveled you are or your
profession. There's so many different things that all of us have. And what I discovered as I was
doing this research, and this was really inspired by the Dalai Lama, because I'd been listening to him as a practitioner for a very long time.
And he always insisted that our first and foremost identity is being human, right?
Being sentient.
And for me, I went into the research and I discovered that, oh, wow, like that is really
our primary identity.
We are part of the same species.
Ninety nine point nine percent of our genetic code we share with people across the world. That's our primary identity at the absolute species. 99.9% of our genetic code we share with people across the world. That's
our primary identity at the absolute level. But then at the secondary level, this is our
relative identities are the labels we give to our human form. And there are three forms,
there are three buckets of secondary identities that we each have, biological, experiential,
and social identities. So for me to create this framework, the diversity of humanity, really helped me see that, oh
wow, like every single label we give to our body falls in one of those three secondary
identity buckets.
And it also helps us manage the complexity and the overwhelm that often accompanies this
conversation.
And that's what I want people to really begin to discover for themselves, the intersectionality of their humanity across those biological, social,
and experiential identities. And that's what they'll begin to discover. You know, folks have
survived trauma, a whole host of different types of trauma, whether it's being a survivor of war,
having an accident, or survived cancer. These are identities we take on, experiential identities.
We just went through COVID, right?
Massive pandemic.
So these are things that impact us at a biological level, at a psychic level, at an emotional
level.
And those are the things we can begin to really unearth and identify and become mindful of
and then transform the way they impact the way we live, the way we relate to ourselves,
one another and other beings around us.
Pretty deep into your plan for transforming or breaking bias, but let's just say at a sort of high level for a second.
I want to clear up some confusion and probably confusion on my part.
You've very gently, I think, disagreed with me when I was saying that we evolved to have biases, but I'm thinking of bias not just in terms of interpersonal prejudice, but like the sunk cost fallacy
or confirmation bias, these cognitive shortcuts that are wiring into us and that do make sense
on some level, but fuck us up on many other levels.
And so what's the connection between those kinds of biases and what you mean
when you talk about bias? That's right. No, that's this really well said. And I think those are
phenomenon of our brain, right? The shortcuts we take. For me, when I talk about bias is basically
how we treat one another as human beings. And even with, you know, more than humans, animals and other
lifestyle, we create hierarchies. And we assume things about people for no other reason than
they're being. Whereas what you're talking about, confirmation bias or negativity bias, these are basically ways
our brains have been wired evolutionarily. But that's not the type of bias that I'm talking about.
I'm really talking about it at a human level, human to human level.
Yeah, fair enough. And so again, just to put a fine point on this, if I'm coming at this,
I completely get your point
about internalized bias. And I think there are many people listening to this show who will have a
profound experience of that. And we should talk about it. And I just want to ask the question,
again, from a very pointed perspective, if I have not experienced a lot of prejudice in my life,
what is in it for me to do this work? I mean, I believe strongly it is worth doing this work.
Otherwise I wouldn't be doing episodes about this all the time, but I want to
hear your articulation of that.
Whether you or someone who's listening, have you ever looked at the mirror,
looked at the person you see in the mirror and wished they were someone else?
Wish they were taller, skinnier, more beautiful, handsome, what have you?
Have you been that person? Have you wished something hadn't happened to you? Have you wished that you had certain opportunities?
Those are those false beliefs or habits of thoughts. And if you've been that person and
that's impacted you, it's impacted the way you relate to yourself, that negative self-talk,
It's impacted the way you relate to yourself, that negative self-talk, the jabber that continues to go on. If that's impacted the way you treat your spouse or your family members or your children or reference. But I, as a white man who I've definitely experienced some prejudice.
I'm Jewish and so I've spent a lot of time in the Middle East.
And so I've definitely experienced some prejudice.
But generally speaking, my experience of moving through the world is quite
easeful to the extent that I have dis-ease.
It's mostly self-manufactured.
And of course, I've looked in the mirror and been like, oh, as I've often joked, where are the abs I had in my 30s,
which of course is me internalizing a story
about these arbitrary aesthetic standards
that we set for bodies.
So I think what you're saying is something much more general
and universal than the internalized bias
that we might feel based on race or gender, those are huge issues. But
it really is this work is in the best interest of everyone.
Yes. And this is why for me, this work was so important to talk about from an intersectional
perspective and from a global perspective, that every human being is suffering in some
shape or form because of these learned ideas and
they're mistreating themselves and one another as a result of it.
And for me, when I discovered this for myself, again, using AI, I was like, oh wow, I can
unlearn these things.
Let's try it.
And I experimented and you already heard my story where I started 15 years ago.
And to the person that I'm now, I realized that, oh wow, our brains are really plastic.
The idea of neuroplasticity, we can actually unlearn and relearn new habits.
And that's what the opportunity for me is right now.
And I really think that breaking bias is probably the most important work we can be doing in the 21st century
because of how much self-loathing, mental health illnesses, loneliness that people feel.
And this is across intersectionalities.
Of course, race and gender play a prominent part, but all of us, like you mentioned, even things like our looks.
And it doesn't matter what those intersectionalities are, suffering is suffering.
Yeah.
Yeah, so that seems like a core thesis I want to be overly confident about whether it's the core thesis, but a core thesis of yours is that everybody,
no matter what kind of body you have, is suffering because of false learned internalized stories
we're telling ourselves about the way we should be, i.e. self-loathing, self-criticism, the inner critic.
And when you have that, which we all do to some extent, when you're kicking your own ass,
that shows up in your relationships with other people.
And because our relationships with other people are so central to our well-being,
that is the beginning of what my friend Evelyn calls a toilet vortex,
where you're kicking your own ass and then you're mean to other people,
and then your relationships suffer and you kick your own ass even worse and down you go.
Am I restating this with some degree of fidelity to your core ideas?
Yes, I wouldn't straight it that way, but I think I love the analogy.
It makes so much sense.
And the only thing I would add is that when we treat ourselves in this way, right, where
we want to be other than who we are, that's when we start treating others that way too.
We want others to be a certain way and we can't see them than who we are, that's when we start treating others that way too. We want
others to be a certain way and we can't see them for who they are. And that begins to build that
disconnection and really begins with the disconnection we feel with ourselves. So for me,
Breaking Bias really begins with I, with us, and then the more we kind of work on ourselves and
heal ourselves, it trickles into our relationships
and the decisions we make, whether at work or in our communities and our families and
beyond.
Maybe that's an internalized story.
It is.
I'm like, that negative self-talk damn, you gotta watch that.
Yes, but one should still be allowed to make jokes.
Yes, that's true.
Because I sometimes can take a minute to understand something that makes complete sense to me. And I just want to add on top of that as somebody who is somewhat reluctantly a boss,
and I think this is true in a business context, whether you're technically the boss or not, we all
are leaders. If you're carrying around false ideas about other people based on their body shape or
skin color or gender or gender identity or whatever, that makes you dumber
and makes you, can lead you to overlook people who can be incredible participants and contributors
to your team.
And so there's another piece of the self-interest for doing this work is, is I guess what I'm
trying to argue.
Would you agree with that?
Absolutely.
There are three ways, particularly this shows up.
Like every bias for businesses and employers is incredibly expensive
in terms of thwarted performance and wasted costs.
So that's just the money aspect that we would save a lot of money
in our economy, in our world, if we could address tackle bias.
The other is it's really inefficient, right? It creates inefficiencies.
Like you said, we wouldn't be able to hire the best talent or nurture the best talent because of these false ideas about who we want them to be versus who they
are. And the third is really suffering. It hurts. It also hurts us, as we just discussed. We are
putting these massive limitations on ourselves as well as others. So I think all three of them are
things that we have to really look at around bias. And in terms of financial costs, I'll just give you one figure that
this was 10 years ago, this number is probably higher, but Kellogg Foundation and a big think
tank basically tried to monetize the cost of racial bias in the United States per year.
And they found the number to be $2 trillion. This was like 2013. And they basically aggregated
a lot of economic studies across different
life outcomes from housing to criminal justice to education in terms of, again, thwarted
performance and wasted costs.
In OECD countries, for gender bias, it's like upwards of $8 trillion annually.
So for me, like folks that care about money, let's say we're operating in that solely
about monetary resources, I'm like, this is what we need to tackle.
And sadly, this has been one of the challenges with the diversity industry is we're not getting
to the root cause of the challenge, which is bias, and also how it's a learned habit.
So when we think about diversity training, what we need to do is train people to unlearn
them.
Coming up on Ugupta talks about what has and has not been working in most of the DEI trainings
out there.
And then we dive into his PRISM toolkit.
These are the moves you can make both in your head and in the world to break bias.
Hello, ladies and germs, boys and girls. to break bias. on an open fire. You can listen with the whole family as guest stars like Jon Hamm, Brittany Broski, and Danny
DeVito try to persuade the mean old Grinch that there's
a lot to love about the insufferable holiday season.
But that's not all.
Somebody stole all the children of Whoville's letters to Santa,
and everybody thinks the Grinch is responsible.
It's a real Whoville whodunit.
Can Cindy, Lou, and Max help clear the Grinch's name?
Grab your hot cocoa and cozy slippers to find Lou and Max help clear the Grinch's name? Grab your hot cocoa
and cozy slippers to find out. Follow Tis the Grinch Holiday Podcast on the Wondery app or
wherever you get your podcasts. Unlock weekly Christmas mystery bonus content and listen to
every episode ad free by joining Wondery Plus in the Wondery app, Spotify or Apple podcasts.
Hi, I'm Lindsey Graham, the host of Wondery Show American Scandal.
We bring to life some of the biggest controversies in U.S. history, presidential lies,
environmental disasters, corporate fraud. In our latest series, NASA embarks on an ambitious
program to reinvent space exploration with the launch of its first reusable vehicle,
the Space Shuttle. And in 1985, they announced they're sending teacher Krista McAuliffe into space aboard the Space Shuttle Challenger,
along with six other astronauts.
But less than two minutes after liftoff, the Challenger explodes.
And in the tragedy's aftermath, investigators uncover a series of preventable failures by NASA and its contractors that led to the disaster.
Follow American Scandal on the Wondry app
or wherever you get your podcasts.
Experience all episodes ad free
and be the first to binge the newest season
only on Wondry Plus.
You can join Wondry Plus in the Wondry app,
Apple podcasts or Spotify.
Start your free trial today.
Over at the Happier Meditation app,
they've created something called the Holiday Giving
and Receiving Collection.
It's a set of guided meditations to help you navigate the holidays, which includes practices
such as self-compassion, gratitude, and fostering deep connections.
Download the Happier Meditation app today wherever you get your apps.
Let me just pick up on the diversity industry comment
that you made because I think a lot of, I know,
you know, we get, I do a non-trivial amount of episodes
on bias, prejudice, racism, sexism, and I get a lot
of negative feedback when I do it.
And I do it anyway, because I believe in the importance
of the work. And I think part of the problem, and I could be wrong about this and I want to say it out
loud and check it with you, is that many people have gone to deeply unhelpful DEI sessions
at work.
Yes.
And also there's something about the vocabulary, which with due respect, you use a lot of like
dominant, subordinate, intersectionality,
privilege. There's something about that language that sends the signal to some people,
you're the other, you're the barbarian, because you don't talk this way and us in the know use
this lingo. So anyway, I'd be curious to hear your thoughts on that.
No, I think it's such a great point. And I accidentally fell into this industry.
I was a human rights lawyer before I started my organization because I saw that we could
change policies all we wanted, but we're not really going to create equitable results unless
we also shifted hearts and minds.
So it's both end.
And for me, that's really what unlearning bias is about, breaking bias is about.
And you're absolutely right.
I think a lot of people rightfully have critiqued the diversity industry because it's rooted
in shame, it's rooted in blame, it's rooted in guilt.
And these are afflictive emotions.
They are incredibly dangerous.
And the backlash that we've seen in the last couple of years, the polarization we're seeing
in our country and our world is due to those emotions being triggered. And for me, as someone who was, I was a teacher before, I was slated to be a law professor,
but I left that world to kind of build this education company. And I learned a lot about
how adults learn, how people learn. And we have to keep shame, blame, and guilt at bay. Rather,
it needs to be playful. So for me, I use those terms, but from a sense of creating a psychological,
safe learning environment. And it's really important that we do that both in the book,
but also in all of the work I've done. And this is where the magic of mindfulness-based tools
really come. I came to this work, I was working as a lawyer in issues of human rights, racial equity,
gender equity. That was like my professional job. But
personally, I was addressing the harms of bias I'd experienced. And for that, I was going on
long retreats. I was studying deeply the Buddha Dharma and really applying it to my life. And
through that work, I came across the scientific studies that were showing that, oh, the tools I
was practicing on retreat, loving kindness and compassion and curiosity and mindfulness are beginning to show a measurable reduction in
bias. These are like large qualitative and quantitative studies. And that's when it just
kind of hit me. It just clicked. It was like, oh, we have to blend contemplative science with the science of the work of ensuring fairness and equity
in our society.
That's how I came to the work, but the way I've been doing this work is quite unique
for that reason.
With that said, I will say that the mission, the objective of the diversity industry is
quite noble actually.
But the way it's been enforced, not by everybody, but by many organizations has been misguided for the reasons you stated, for the reason I've
stated. And we don't even have to state it. It just feels bad. I remember I went to my first,
I was working at when I was working as a lawyer, we had a diversity training, a mandatory one that
we had to attend. This was like 2011. And I remember leaving the room with my shoulders to my ears. It was so tense because
that ability to be a human wasn't present and it was somatically uncomfortable.
So you've come up with something called the Prism Toolkit. And I'll state the five steps
of the Prism Toolkit out loud and then we'll just walk through them systematically. So
mindfulness, stereotype replacement, individuation, pro-social behavior, perspective taking. So you start with mindfulness,
which makes complete sense to me, but maybe you can explain for those of us who are new to
mindfulness, what you mean by that and why you start with it. Yeah, absolutely. So mindfulness
is really the bedrock of the PRISM toolkit. And mindfulness is just being aware, noticing, being aware of what's arising in one's mind,
one's body, one's somatic experience, emotions.
It's a whole host of experiences.
And what we do is, particularly when it comes to stereotyping and prejudice, whether it's
toward ourselves or others, we become mindful of it.
It's like, oh, idea, oh, stereotype.
And we also label it as such because that's really important.
We see someone, something
that we've not... I see a woman with a hijab. A whole host of associations come to mind that I've
learned from the causes of bias. But instead of being with the person that I'm seeing, so I can
just... If those associations come, I can just be like, oh, stereotype, stereotype. And that creates
a gap between me following that train of thought versus kind of being
with the person.
So that's really the bedrock of it, to begin to acknowledge stereotypes and become mindful
of them, notice them, label them in our minds.
I took as an example of a really skillfully delivered diversity education product.
I took an online class with our mutual friend,
Sabaanay Salasi and several other teachers
who were Dharma teachers talking about race
through the prism of the Dharma.
This was many years ago, pre-pandemic,
probably like 2017 or something like that.
One of the practices they asked us to do was
just to try to be mindful as you're walking
through the world of the stories you tell yourself
based on purely on other people's appearances.
I had many humbling experiences,
which I've mentioned publicly before,
but it might be worth just saying a little bit more about,
again, taking my child to see the play Frozen.
On Broadway at that time,
the people playing the parents of Elsa and Anna were black.
They were the king and the queen.
And my first thought was, oh, they must work in a castle somewhere.
And that was really bracing to see that that was my initial reaction.
Whoa, it's really embarrassing to admit that out loud, but these stories are coursing through
all of us all the time.
And there's nothing you can do about it if you're unwilling to see it.
Yeah, absolutely.
And the beautiful thing that you did in both those instances is you became mindful of it
and you labeled it.
The one thing I would invite the audience to do is also if it's accompanied by emotions
of, you said, embarrassment or shame, I would also make those emotions an object of mindfulness.
Because what we want to do is notice that shame and over time let go of that shame because
it's not personal.
One of the other things that I talk about in the book is that all forms of biases that
we've learned have five causes.
That's how our brains are trained in it.
So it's not personal that we've learned these things, but now it's our responsibility, our
obligation to unlearn them. What are the five causes? So it's not personal that we've learned these things, but now it's our responsibility, our obligation to unlearn them.
What are the five causes?
So it's a false story.
That's the first cause.
Whether it's race or gender, there's a story about a hierarchy.
Second is policies that are based off of that false story.
And that all of us as humans operate in a cultural container created by those policies.
And we learn biases through social contact, which is both our trusted spheres of
influence, like our family members, our friends, and also our built environment. The fourth is
education, which is a lot of misinformation or information gaps about identity in our school
curriculum, university curriculum. And then the fifth is media, big one, as we're seeing right now
and just feeding these ideas consciously and unconsciously.
So we can talk about that after we go through the prism toke.
Sure. I just want to stay with this mindfulness piece for a second,
because I think you said something crucial there. You're talking about the disutility of shame,
and I sometimes talk about shame as like a kind of psychic constipation, like nothing can move through if you're stuck
in this story about what a horrible person you are.
Instead of viewing it all as, I love this phrase
from the Burmese meditation master, Sayadaw Utajaniya.
He asks his students to drop this phrase into their mind
in the course of their meditation.
This is nature.
It's all nature.
It's all nature.
It's impersonal.
It doesn't mean you shouldn't take responsibility for it, but getting stuck in shame is a cul-de-sac.
It's beautifully said.
And I quote him quite a bit in the book, Utejaniyya a bit.
It's just that it's an afflictive emotion.
And also to create that story of I'm such a horrible person, that's delusion.
That's Mara.
Shame itself is a manifestation of Mara.
It's one of the poisons.
So I think part of it is for us to become really intimately aware of it and not just
in the mind, but also in the body.
You mentioned how uncomfortable you felt, right?
Now we have to become aware of the somatic experience, a sensation that accompanies fear as well.
And that's where I feel like this work is so important because bias isn't rational.
If it was rational, we would have solved it by now.
There's libraries of research and documentation around why it exists and how it exists.
Now we have to really apply it.
And for me, that's what the Prism Toolkit helps us do, is really apply it to kind of move it from the head to both the heart and the body.
And that's kind of the invitation that I would make around mindfulness is not just noticing the emotion or the thought and concept, but also landed on the body.
That's why in the book I have about 130 exercises to help people just do that and build that habit. Yeah, I want to get into those exercises. Just as a point of
definition or definitional clarity for people who aren't familiar with Mara and the concept of
delusion, can you unpack that a little bit? Yeah. So one of the things that's really prevalent in
the Buddha Dharma is this idea of Mara. And Mara is basically all of the unwholesome ways of being
that we have in our mind, anything that's
unskillful, anything that causes harm. And it's really a composite of what I would say the three
poisons according to the Buddha, greed, aversion, and delusion or ignorance. Ignorance of our
inner dependence, ignorance of our inner connection with one another, because we believe that we're a
separate self and that's ignorance. So that's what Mara is. And then all the afflictive emotions are really a product of that.
And for me, the Buddha dharma is really what it says is that we suffer because we identify
with these things. We cling on to certain ways of being. And the practice of mindfulness and others help us really cleanse
our body, hearts, and minds of these defilements. Was that a good enough definition? Perhaps you
have a better way of defining it. No, I thought it was great. I mean, I would just build on the,
because people get confused sometimes by this idea of, what do you mean I'm not a separate self?
And I think it's useful just to explain that from the Buddhist point of view, and just this makes complete sense to me. Yeah, there are two levels of
reality. There's the Buddhist call relative reality and then ultimate reality. On the
level of relative reality, yeah, you are you. Anu, when you look in the mirror, you're going
to see Anu looking back at you and the world sees you and you need to use your driver's license and you get on a plane.
On this consensual level of everyday reality, you are you.
But if you take a high-powered microscope, you're going to have a hard time finding any
essence of Anu because on a deep, deep level, you are inextricably interwoven into the universe.
You're an expression of the universe.
And so is every thought you've ever had.
It may feel personal, but it's actually just the universe.
And that's ultimately true.
And so thinking of it on these two levels can make this somewhat esoteric
assertion a little bit more digestible.
How does that sound to you?
That's beautifully said.
Okay. So we talked about mindfulness as a first step and not only being mindful of the
stories you're telling about yourself and other people, but also mindful of the emotional
reaction, including shame. And it can be very useful in this case to be mindful of like
how it's showing up in your body, which of course is a big emphasis of Buddhism in Buddhism.
The next step once you've become mindful and that obviously I don't want to diminish that,
that's a huge step, but the next step is stereotype replacement.
What does that mean?
So basically it's about creating new mental models.
So the beautiful thing is you've now become aware, you've noticed the stereotype arising
in your mind. Now you replace or bring to mind a real actual
life example who defies that stereotype. So in the lab for black men, for example, they had folks
think of Dr. King, someone who defies those stereotypes that are often presented to us
about black men. But it doesn't have to be Dr. King. It could be someone you know, a colleague,
a friend, a spouse, someone who basically
would help your brain weaken those associations.
And we do that as often as possible.
And we do that if we see stereotypes in our environment, whether it's on the media, whether
it's in our schools, whether it's a friend talking to us.
And that's what helps us weaken those associations.
So the way this really works is you have to rule neurons that fire together, wire together.
So that's really how we've learned a lot of these stereotypes and prejudices.
So what we're doing with prism tools is really beginning to create new wiring, unlearning
old stuff and learning new stuff.
I like that.
So just to, again, reemphasize it.
Once you become mindful of the story, oh yeah, I saw somebody in a hijab or I saw somebody
in a larger body or whatever.
And I told myself a story about them.
If you've caught it, if you've been mindful, you can then replace the story with an example of somebody from the broader culture or somebody even better, somebody you know who puts the lie to that stereotype.
Exactly. And if you can't think of anyone, right, because of how hyperated we are, we have our wonderful friend Google or any other search engine out there. Like if you want to think
of a surgeon as a woman who wears a hijab, you will get tons and tons of real life examples.
So that's where we begin to really use technology to our benefit and begin to build new mental
models. All right. Next one is individuation. What does that mean?
So individuation is the practice
of cultivating curiosity, interest, investigation, and it's really decoupling the group-based
associations from the individual. So when I'm with Dan, I'm with Dan the human Dan is versus my ideas
of Dan because of all of his different identities. And that's really important because that allows us to really be in
the presence of each unique human as they are versus live in the various identities that they're
in. And this is again, we can do this ourselves, right? Through asking questions, through learning
more about people, but kind of seeing the dynamic nature of a human being beyond their identities.
And then we'll begin to see, it's like, oh, wow, like they're a brother, I'm a brother.
Oh, they drive cars like I drive cars.
This is what a lot of tabloid magazines do about, you know, celebrities.
But these things are actually helpful.
They help us see people in the fuller picture of who they are.
Yeah, I like that. I like that a lot.
I mean, instead of constantly viewing people through the prism of whatever group society has placed them in
to just think of them as an individual. Yeah. Yeah. The next on the list is pro-social behaviors.
So basically the way these prism tools so far we've gone through are really head and body based.
Pro-social behavior is now bringing in the heart qualities. So pro-social behaviors are basically a whole host of mental and emotional states that are
helpful, that are positive.
So, things like loving kindness, compassion, joy, altruism.
So, these are practices that we could actually cultivate.
These are tools that we can cultivate.
This is the Brahma Viharas, for example.
But these are things that help us be pro-social.
What they're doing at the neural level is that they're beginning to shift that affect,
that negative affect often associated with stereotypes, with grouping people in,
boxing people in, because that's connected to like fear or worry or danger.
So when we practice these tools toward ourselves for internalized biases and others for
interpersonal biases, we're beginning to diminish that fear through practice.
So one way to undo the wiring is to take real action, to take real
steps to be kind. That actually changes the way you view the world.
Yeah, for me I actually practiced loving-kind kindness. For example, like I would do a 20-minute sit for stereotyped groups. I would do like a five-minute sit, whatever is
possible. And there's a lot of activities like that, but really begin to send those well-wishes
to also stereotyped identities that we may have, ways that we dislike ourselves or hate ourselves.
We don't have that six-pack. Okay, let's do that.
And that's where we're beginning to kind of diminish the power of that, how things should be and really opening the heart to the possibility of what we ultimately are
at the absolute level, interdependent and interconnected.
So when you talk about pro-social behaviors, are you talking just about doing it in
your head or actually like doing something useful in the world? Not to say that doing it in your head
isn't useful, but I mean taking concrete action in the world off the cushion as
it were. So my sense is, and this is through my own practice, is we do it on
the cushion and that helps us, that basically informs our actions in the
world. Because we're rewiring this nervous system, this brain.
If I were to feel those bodily sensations of fear,
they're not there anymore, right?
Or they're diminished.
So I could actually be with humans for who they are
versus my ideas of them.
So it's a both and.
I've seen that in my own life.
And the finally perspective taking.
Yeah, so this is kind of also a hard practice, but it also requires visualization.
So it's imagining being in the shoes of another person, and the fullness of who they are versus our ideas of them.
So Isabel Wilkerson in her book, Caste, talks about this as radical empathy.
But for me, it's really something that we have a capacity to do as human beings. I can imagine, given what I
know, what's it like to be in different human's shoes. Great actors do this really well. They're
not the ones who've lived whatever life they're depicting. But sometimes when you're in a theater
or a movie, you're like, wow, I'm just so moved because they were able to capture the fullness of
another human's experience. And that's something that we all have the capacity to do.
And that really brings us together at a nervous system level.
It helps us transcend that instinct for bias.
For me personally, I did this for myself first, most of these tools.
So I would do this for the six-year-old I was, or the 12-year-old I was,
or the 18-year-old I was, one after another,
either through journaling or through meditation.
Meditation is helpful because it helps me feel the experience of it,
the flood of emotions, but then it also triggers prosocial behaviors,
empathy, compassion, care, concern.
And that's where we can begin to really build, kind of bridge that polarization,
that divide we've been trained to have toward aspects of ourselves and one another.
Coming up, Anu talks about how to turn breaking bias into a habit in your everyday life,
even if you feel overwhelmed by all the other stuff you have to do,
and his response to skeptics.
stuff you have to do and his response to skeptics.
Three, two, one, liftoff with an entirely new way to play.
Wondery Kids and the number one kids podcast, Wow in the World, are making stem toys fun like never before.
Tinker with slime bubbling volcanoes,
build rockets that fart and uncover dynamite dinosaurs.
For the first time ever, be wowed
with exclusive, engaging companion audio
that comes with each STEM toy.
And as you play, Guy Raz and I, co-hosts of Wow in the World,
bring you and your family bonkerball facts
about the natural world, like how crystals and rainbows
are related.
And each STEM toy includes a bonus science tool
and three months of Wondery Plus free.
So the whole family can listen to their favorite podcasts
like Wow in the World Early and ad free.
Shop Wow in the World toy collection today
at amazon.com slash Wondery Kids.
That's amazon.com slash W-O-N-D-E-R-Y Kids.
Is there research backing this PRISM toolkit approach?
Yep. So each one of these tools have been shown to be efficacious around measure-reducing
implicit bias as well as explicit bias. It's also the subject of a book that first came out
in the 1950s on prejudice.
So it's been longstanding.
And the beautiful thing about this is that modern sciences,
whether it's neuroscience or contemplative science,
have just relanguished what humans have known for millennia.
Like these tools, I use it from ancient Buddhist wisdom,
but they exist in the Sufi traditions,
they exist in the contemplative Christian tradition.
And this is a human technology that we have,
which is different labels now.
If people are listening to this and thinking,
oh, this sounds fantastic, but it's a lot,
what kind of advice can you give people
to like start small and keep it going?
Yeah, part of it is like, it might feel like a lot, but once you're in the habit
of it, it just becomes a new habit.
It takes as little as 18 days to build a new habit based on research.
So part of it is like, we have to practice to build this habit.
And when people feel like, oh my God, it's a lot.
Well, you know, it's a lot to carry that negative self-talk about yourself
all day, every day. It's a lot to feel
afraid of humans for no other reason than their being because they're trans
or black, what have you. That's a lot. So we're just carrying so much
guck around. So for me, the opportunity really is that
this is the trade-off. We're
going to feel better about ourselves and one another. And we can truly live, create workplaces
and communities where we feel like we belong. And for me, that's worth it, right? In addition
to all the other benefits of breaking bias. But practically speaking, it just begins with now,
like just coming now and kind of
practicing now, becoming mindful of what's rising for people.
And this is why I think in the book, the way I've written it is it's really more
than just talking about the theory of it.
Like there are tons and tons of pauses.
Like I ask people to pause and really feel it and practice the Prism Toolkit.
Cause I want people to get into the habit of practicing this day to day. If folks don't care about other people and the world, which I understand, my
family is like that too, because it's enough just like running their own life, well, care about your
kids. You know, I have two nieces and these things have already begun to show up in their lives in
elementary school and middle school. So by practicing this, we can really model and teach
these skills to our young ones.
I mean, this is why I'm always so focused on self-interest because I don't know that there's anybody who doesn't care about the world, but they may just be so wrapped up in their shit that they're not feeling super pro-social.
Exactly.
But everybody cares about their own suffering. And that's why I emphasize what's in it for me, because I do think that's just the sharp end
of the stick generally.
And you've made the point very well
and repeatedly, I'll just say it again here.
It sucks to walk around with self-limiting, negative,
self-lacerating stories about yourself.
And then of course it leads to all sorts
of deleterious impacts for how you treat other people
in the world, but just start at how it sucks for you.
And that should provide incentive enough to dip your toes into these waters.
CB Exactly. And it helps us build new habits, right? So oftentimes what I used to do,
and I talk about this quite in detail in the book, particularly in the media chapter is
when I feel shitty about myself, I would go to social media, I would read the news,
which would make me feel shitty. I would drink alcohol or whatever I would do. I would go to social media, I would read the news, which would make me feel shittier. I would drink alcohol or whatever I would do. I would like a gossip.
I would always come out feeling worse and more depressed and more annoyed and more irritated.
And once I started practicing these tools, of course, I still engage in some of those things,
but there's mindfulness there. I'm doing it with a purpose. If I get a drink with a friend or two,
I'm really doing it to be social with them versus to run away from how shitty I'm doing it with a purpose. If I get a drink with a friend or two, I'm really doing it to be social with them
versus to run away from how shitty I'm feeling about myself.
And that's where I think it helps us become agents of change within our own lives.
Okay, so help us get started here.
You said before you've got dozens and dozens of practices in the book.
Let's talk about, let's pick a few and talk about them
as a way to help people, like I said before, dip their toes in here.
Well, Sunil, one of the things that would be helpful to talk about here is also the causes
of bias, like how we've learned biases, because that's what we're bringing really mindfulness to
over and over again in the book. So as I said, there's five causes of bias, including the
foundational cause, the first cause, which is a false story.
So one of the things I ask people to do in the book is document, write down in the book or somewhere else, define.
Let's talk about race, for example.
What is race for you?
It doesn't matter what it actually is, but what is race?
Just define it in your own words.
And where did you learn these ideas?
So again, we're beginning to notice.
Where did you learn what race is?
Who told you? Who taught you?
And that's where I think we begin bringing mindfulness.
Oh, this is how I've learned this idea of how humans are separated
according to this identity we call race.
And then I go into kind of the history of how race came about.
You know, you'd be surprised how many doctors, teachers, lawyers
I've trained in the last decade who believe race is biological, that there's fundamentally a
biological difference between humans who are black and white and Asian and Latinae. But ultimately,
the story that we've all been infected with was created less than 300 years ago by a bunch of
dudes who love to collect skulls. And they created a lot of these stereotypes.
Right.
So when I share that history, for example, then I say, okay, how does this feel?
Let's become mindful of what is the body sensation?
What are the emotions that arise?
And then begin to document it.
I don't know if you have a reaction to that.
Maybe you knew this already.
I did know.
Yes.
And for a lot of my students, they feel like, oh my God, I feel angry. Why didn't anything, my schooling, I went to medical school, right? I got
residency. Why was I never taught this? Right? And then we begin to kind of really investigate
how that feels first. Because in order for us to take action, we have to really manage those
emotions. Other thought, like because the history is pretty horrific sometimes, right? Because of
the massive amounts of violence, that's we bring in the pro-social behaviors into help us, the compassion, the joy,
the loving kindness for ourselves, but also for others. And then we also practice perspective
taking, particularly for people who created these stories. And that's really important for us to feel like what stories would they have
to imagine? How would they feel in their own bodies for them to create such simplistic
hierarchies about humanity, to dominate other people? And this is where we're beginning to
kind of make sense of the fullness of the human experience because we can then see in our own
bodies that urge to dominate
and subordinate. So that's kind of some ways how this kind of really carries through. Similarly
for gender, I go into the story about how I learned about gender. I grew up in India for
the first 10 years, but as a boy, I was given special treatment from a young age, from the
women in my family. I have two sisters. I couldn't do any household chores.
Everything was done for me. And I was repeatedly taught that because my sisters were going to get
married, they were somehow inferior, coded ways, uncoded ways. And for me, that was really important
to bring to surface where do these stories come from, right? And then not to practice them anymore.
come from, right? And then not to practice them anymore. So this is kind of the way we're really like breaking bias and also it's emotional and mental response. Because I still love the women
and the men in my family. Like I don't want to discount my grandmother who I love and admire,
but she was a product of those same causes and conditions. And this is where kind of
empathy and compassion really flows in and flows through. That's key because people could do pretty bad things and we should
excuse those things, but we can see them in the context of, to use your phrase, it's a very
Buddhist phrase, causes and conditions get even more Buddhist if we talk about karma, the law of
cause and effect. And that's very useful because it can take some of just as shame is not so helpful, often
hatred of people who are doing bad, pretty objectively unfair or unkind things isn't
the best way to deal with them.
Yeah.
I didn't use that phrase yet, but that's really how the book is structured.
Bias is a consequence of certain causes and conditions, those five causes and five conditions.
As a result, we get bias. So in order for us to really transform bias, we have to get to the root
cause to shift those causes and conditions. So if we see like, I've been working in the medical field
for a long time, we see a lot of racial disparities, right? We see a lot of gender disparities on how
different types of patients are being treated for no other reason than their being, their skin color or their gender.
Now, because those health professionals are actively racist or sexist, well, some of them
maybe, but the vast majority aren't. But the vast majority have learned some associations. So in
order for us to really shift that consciousness, right, shift those perceptions, the lens through
which they're viewing their patients, we have to correct that misinformation.
There's a study you'll find really fascinating is they've actually shown health providers
a hand that's being pierced with like a needle.
And then they're able to track empathy by looking at their sweat glands.
And they saw that when the hand
is darker skin, there's less empathy that's evoked.
I believe there are also studies that show that black people are less likely to get painkillers
in the hospital, even when the doctor's black.
Yep. That's the internalized bias, right? Because this is all about those mental models
we talked about that we've all been
trained in because of media, because of social contact. So for me, the opportunity really is,
what I call breaking bias is really a shift in consciousness. We're really shifting the way we
are with ourselves and one another. And this is going to take some time, but it really begins with
us individually. We have to begin with ourselves, which is why I think I so admire a lot of people who are doing the self-work and really leading by example. And that's
kind of the theory of change I have around the book as well.
Let's get back to the notion of how to get started practically, some practices that we
can do to, as I keep saying, like dip our toes here.
Yeah. Well, there are two practices that I begin the book with that are really,
really helpful and something that I've been doing for a very long time.
And regardless of where one is, you can practice along with me.
So I want you to bring to mind and notice what arises in a word or a phrase.
When I ask you the following, how do you feel about bias in our society today?
So just in a word or phrase,
just notice the first thing that arises. Again, we don't have to change it or fix it or analyze
it, but just notice this word or phrase. So this is where you're practicing mindfulness.
And then kind of really going deeper into any emotions that may be attached to this,
any emotions that may be attached to this, any emotional affect? Is it pleasant? Is it unpleasant? Is it neutral? Somewhere on that spectrum? How does it feel in the body, this concept or phrase?
So again, we don't have to change it, but just becoming aware of the somatic experience of this
idea and now letting it go. And then similarly, in a word or a phrase, how would you feel in a
world without bias? In a world where belonging replaces bias? Just notice what arises a word
or a phrase. Oftentimes people have trouble with this one because of how cynical we are in our
society. So I like to say that if you can imagine colonizing
Mars, some people are imagining it, they're expanding resources there. So we could also
imagine what it's like to be in a world without bias. So if that's helpful, just notice a word
or a phrase that arises. Once again, seeing its emotional affect, is it pleasant, unpleasant, neutral, any
emotions that accompany it, as well as systematic experience, body sensations, spaciousness,
love, whatever it is in the body.
And now moving to kind of pro-social behaviors and perspective taking, really beginning to cradle
these emotions, these ideas with loving kindness.
These are your experiences.
They are.
There's no right way to feel about these things.
So bringing that sense of compassion and kindness to yourself.
And then what we can do, because we both practice this every time where when we feel,
when we witness bias in our society and we feel what we felt in a word or a phrase in the first exercise, we can replace it with this other feeling that we felt in a world without bias,
with this other feeling that we felt in a world without bias, that stereotype replacement. So that's just a quick way to really begin to apply these practices into action.
And I'll say that this is what a lot of our ancestors have done for any kind of civil
or human rights around the world.
When I think about my ancestors in South Asia and in India,
a lot of the freedom, independence, freedom fighters
were really imagining what it's like to be an independent country,
what it would be like to,
and that's what really inspired and motivated their actions.
Similarly for the suffragists, the women's rights advocates,
the queer rights advocates, civil rights advocates.
So this is what our work is really helping us do.
And if the systemic stuff is too big for us, we could just do this for ourselves.
What would it be like for ourselves to be free of self-loathing?
How would I feel?
Free of whatever afflictive challenge we see. And that's kind of the
invitation really here. And my hope is that it's a practice we're building on, right? So for me,
this, I mean, 15 years ago, I could have never imagined it. But the more I practiced, right? The
more I practiced, the more it became a reality. Because ultimately what we're doing is really shifting that underlying affect.
So shifting, of course, our thoughts, our beliefs, our habits, but also how we feel.
And this is where pro-social behaviors really support us in making that transformation.
Interesting.
I was thinking about my level of optimism.
I wouldn't be doing this work if I didn't think that
the Dharma or contemplative practices
couldn't make a difference.
To imagine a world without bias
is a little bit of a stretch for me,
so I'm just curious like how you get there.
Yeah, I think for me,
it's not about making it into a reality.
There's two answers, two aspects of an answer.
One is I'm not identified with like,
oh my God, this is how I
feel and I have to create it in my lifetime, but rather I want to just feel what it would be like.
And what I feel is real spaciousness, real openness. There's just like a heart opener
and it just feels really free. And for me, I want it to just have, and I've had this felt sense
experience for so long that every time I see something on the news
or I hear some comment that may be ignorant or bigoted, I'm able to bring that up again
because that emotion is there with me and that keeps me inspired, that keeps me doing this work.
So that's kind of like very practical how I put this into practice on a day-to-day basis because
I know it's possible and
bring to mind tons and tons of stories from history. The other thing that has really inspired me is
really getting deeper into the Dharma. I don't know if you've read Eckhart Tolle's A New Earth.
Yeah, I have.
So he talks really about how human consciousness over time, as limiting as it may seem, is moving towards more equity, more
fairness, more love, more compassion.
And when I study, when I go deep into the Buddha dharma, the Hindu lineages that I'm
a part of, the Vedic lineages, they really divide the world into various yugas.
There's the Kali Yuga and the Dvapara Yuga.
And there's an incredible book on this actually. It's called
The Holy Science by Sri Yukteswar. He lived in the late 19th century, incredible kind of leader from
South Asia. And he really simplified this for me. And he basically said that according to deep time
calculation, the age of darkness, right, immorality really ended in the year 1700. And since then, we've been in
what is the second Yuga, the Dvapara Yuga, which is the age of morality. And we've seen those shifts.
Since 1700, we've abolished enslavement. There's been more rights for women and queer people,
and there's been more collaborations and understanding between
humans. But we're only 300 years in, in this 2400-year-old long cycle. So I think that deep
time, it doesn't matter if it's right or wrong, but that gives me comfort that a lot of people
in the world have been thinking about this. And as a human in this body, in this form,
I'm just part of that circle.
And for me, that's what keeps me going. Dr. King said, the arc of the moral universe is long
and it bends toward justice. Like, oh, that's right. So for me, that means that, oh, we got
to do our work. We got to keep on stepping up, showing up and growing up for our planet,
for one another. And for me, these are the practices that really support that.
Yeah, that makes sense. Reminds me of two Dharma things. I've heard one is just the
concept of non-attachment to results. You can do your work, the universe that is entropic,
do your work and don't try to get overly attached to the results. And then the other thing I've
heard is the Dalai Lama counseling activists, like,
don't think about the impact in your lifetime. Think about it over the course of multiple
lifetimes. And you don't even have to believe in reincarnation to see the wisdom in that.
Anu, before I let you go, my two little questions I ask here, is there anything that we didn't get
to that you feel is like a form of malpractice? No, not at all. This was really, really fun for me.
Yeah, I'm just really excited for listeners
to get a hold of the book and to really engage with it.
One thing I'll share is that one of the things
that really, really inspires me is a quote by Grace Lee Boggs,
who was a really incredible American activist
who lived to, I think, 101 years old based out of Detroit.
And what she said was that people think of revolutions as changing state leadership,
but that's not enough.
You know, we have to recognize that we're responsible for the evolution of human consciousness.
And for me, that's what really Breaking Bias is about.
Well, you kind of answered both questions I was going to say, what did we miss?
And then also, just reminding everybody of the name of the book,
but you did both in one answer, Breaking
Bias, check it out, and we'll put links to everything Anu related in the show
notes. Anu Gupta, thank you very much. Thank you so much for having me.
Thanks again to Anu, great to talk to him. During the course of the episode I
mentioned in several previous episodes.
I just want to mention that I will put links to those in the show notes.
They include my conversations with Jessica Nordell, John Bewin, Dolly Chugg, Rhonda McGee, and Loretta Ross.
Don't forget to check out what we're doing over at danharris.com.
Free subscribers will get a gentle IV drip of wisdom from me and my podcast guests in your inbox
Several times a week paid subscribers get to chat with me directly via text and also you get access to
monthly AMA's live video sessions where I'll
Lead a meditation and then also answer your questions. And of course all of it is designed to create a sense of community.
So we're experimenting, we're learning.
I'd love to have you on board danharris.com.
Finally, thanks to everybody who worked so hard
to make this show a reality.
Our producers are Tara Anderson,
Caroline Keenan, and Eleanor Vasili.
Our recording and engineering is handled
by the great folks over at Pod People.
Lauren Smith is our production manager.
Marissa Schneiderman is our senior producer. Marissa Schneiderman is our senior producer.
DJ Cashmere is our executive producer.
And Nick Thorburn of the band Islands wrote our theme.
If you like 10% happier, and I hope you do,
you can listen early and ad free right now
by joining Wondry Plus in the Wondry app or on Apple podcasts.
Prime members can listen ad free on Amazon Music.
Before you go, tell us about yourself by filling out a short survey at Wondry.com slash survey.