The Athletic Football Show: A show about the NFL - Most Valuable Non-QB Draft with Nate Tice & Lindsay Jones

Episode Date: May 28, 2021

After their Most Valuable QB Draft went down without a hitch last week, Lindsay, Nate and Robert return to draft the best non-QBs in the NFL. Who will be at the top of the list? Which positions could ...be completely left out? And could we even see a rookie make an appearance?Who won the draft? Let us know at @TheAthleticNFLSign up for The Athletic with an exclusive discount at theathletic.com/footballshow Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

Transcript
Discussion (0)
Starting point is 00:00:00 This is the athletic football show. Welcome to the athletic football show. I'm Robert Mays. Really excited about today's show. Last week, if you guys missed it, we did a most valuable quarterback draft. We picked the top 15 quarterbacks in the NFL, contracts included for the next five years. So please, if you guys missed it, I know we've had some issues with Apple recently. So that is available.
Starting point is 00:00:36 Go back and listen to it if you have not quite yet. Today, we are doing not. We are calling this the most valuable player draft non-quarterback edition. We're doing 24 guys today because 25 is not divisible by three. The reason it needs to be divisible by three is joining me for this. My friends, Nate Tyson, Lindsey Jones. Lindsay, how you doing? Are you as nervous as I am about this?
Starting point is 00:00:59 I am so nervous. This is going to be a complete disaster. But it's going to be really fun, but I am very nervous. I've been texting you guys like nervous gifts for the last like two hours. So, Nate, what I wanted to discuss a little bit is just the methodology behind this because I read something earlier this year that Bill Belichick said. I want to say Tom Curran wrote it. And he talked about building a draft board.
Starting point is 00:01:22 And he said that building the draft board vertically is easy. I can tell you which tackle I like better than the next tackler, which edge rusher I like better than the next. Building it horizontally is difficult. How do you compare which edge rusher you like? more than which cornerback. And when you throw contracts into the equation, it gets even naughtier. So that's what I had trouble with, Nate.
Starting point is 00:01:46 I don't know where you stumbled in this process, but I assume it was difficult. No, that's exact same kind of hiccups I had. And that just, it's funny, you were saying with Belichick. And when I was working with the Falcons, you know, Scott Pioly and Thomas Demetra for there. And we used a very similar grading system to what the Patriots have.
Starting point is 00:02:04 Yeah. So what with theirs and what I always thought was brilliant with what they did was that they tried their best to make it so, all right, at 6.3 with this position is the same as a 6.3 with this position. So if it's a receiver at 6.3, that's just the grading scale they use. I'm just thrown out a number is that's a slot receiver, a starting slot receiver. But if that's a tackle at 6.3, that's a swing backup tackle. You know, and so I liked it. Was it always perfect? No, but it was like, that was a way, a method to try and actually figure this out and make it work because it is hard.
Starting point is 00:02:38 I mean, shoot, we were just talking before. It's like, I, I'm happy I have the number one pick because I know where I'm going. But after that, I'm like, it is hard to decide, do I like this tackle better than this edge guy better than this, you know, corner. And that's going to be, that's why I always try personally is that my premium positions that go from there. But even then, there's other positions that there's guys I really like. So the rules are fairly simple as I laid out before. Next five years, you take contracts into account. So just keep that in mind when we're doing this.
Starting point is 00:03:08 list on its own is probably going to include some names that are surprising. But when you look at the contracts, the ages, everything else, that becomes an important part of the context. We did the draft order randomly again. I had the third pick for quarterbacks. I do not this time. The way it spit it out was Nate 1, me 2, Lindsay 3. Sorry, Lindsay.
Starting point is 00:03:26 But you had the first pick last time. So I feel like we're okay. I'm not going to complain about it the entire show like somebody did last week. I did not complain about it the entire show. The reason people asked, why didn't you do a snake draft? The reason is it's not entertaining to listen to people pick two people in a row. So this is more about having a good time that it is about the equity of the draft process, considering none of that actually matters. So, Nate, you were officially on the clock.
Starting point is 00:03:55 Who are you taking with the first pick in the most valuable, most valuable player draft non-quarterback edition? I know. Once you told us the draft order, I reached out to the player. and signed a deal. And with the number one pick, we're going with Aaron, Aaron Donald. And I am happy as can be
Starting point is 00:04:12 to just have that, wrap a bow on it and just move on to pick four. So was there, and I probably would have gone the same direction if I had the number one pick as well. Is there any consideration
Starting point is 00:04:23 about those factors we talked about? He's already 30. He just turned 30. Over the next five years, he will make an average of $22.6 million. So you're paying high,
Starting point is 00:04:34 high premiums for him. Is there anything that pushed you in possibly a different direction when you were thinking about this? Yeah, of course, of course that he is yeah, this year he's 30 years old and you don't know. I mean, he is we as as freaky as Aaron Donald is. He isn't undersized defensive tackle. I mean, it is what it is. So of course that concern crossed my head and going.
Starting point is 00:04:55 And so I started kind of like looking at other names. There are a couple other names. I kind of was like, okay, I don't want to say him right now because I don't want to give him away for you guys. But there's a couple other names that I kind of was like thinking about. And then, but with him is just like, all right, don't overthink. think it. I mean, this guy is one of the greatest defensive players ever. Like period, period, period, not just, oh, the generation, just period. And just that transcendic type of talent. He's, I consider the best non-quarterback in the league. And it's just, you can't pay that type of guy enough.
Starting point is 00:05:23 He affects so many ball plays. And yeah, where I'm getting him in his mid-30s, I wish I got this five years ago, but I'm still, I think even if you get two to three, he doesn't miss time. Like he is a guy that he is so athletic. He takes care of his body. He's kind of just got those freaky traits where he stays healthy. So I do think he's going to age gracefully. Because other other thing too with Aaron, because I was with him at Pitt for two years where no one blocked him for two straight years in practice. We had to take him off, take him off the field if we had to run play action passes and spring ball and stuff because it was like we can't practice because he blows everything up. And with him is that he's very cerebral. And he is a guy,
Starting point is 00:05:57 he knows what old line calls are. So when he hears rip, rip, rip, rip, he goes, oh, well, it's pass and they're moving away from me. Or it's pat. And oh, okay, down down, you know, okay, T, T, T, T, he hears these calls. By the second quarter, he's got him figured out. And that's something that's underrated with Aaron. So I think that's why, yeah, he might lose 10% of his athleticism over this time. He's so smart that he's going to overcome that and still be an extremely effective player. I think you talk and saying that he's historically good.
Starting point is 00:06:24 He's one of the best players ever is important because even if the gap shrinks between him and the field, it just evens the playing field. He's so far ahead of everyone. You look at some of the numbers. I was looking at his pass rush win rate compared to his double team rate earlier today. He's in his own zip code on the chart. And it's not like he's slowing down. Last year, because that was my question when I was considering him at two if you were going to go to a different direction.
Starting point is 00:06:48 It's like, all right, is he slowing down? Is there any signs of decline? Obviously, he got hurt at the end of the year. But before that, the answer is no. He had 50 pressures between weeks 10 and 17 last year. No one else had more than 38. And if you look historically at some of those outwire, outlier talents, Reggie White was 37 when he won defensive player of the year in 1998.
Starting point is 00:07:08 And I know that that's anecdotal and maybe that's one example, but that's what Aaron Donald is. He's one of the greatest players of all time. So he won the defense player of the year this year. He is still the best player in the league at any position, I think including Patrick Mahomes, when you talk about the gap between him and everyone else at his spot. So I think it's a no-brainer. Even at his age, I would have gone the exact same direction. I totally understand it.
Starting point is 00:07:30 Now I'm fucked because two, it's really. hard. I think you could go so many different directions here. And in the non-Aaron Donald camp of this, this is when you have to start weighing all of these different sorts of factors. I went with Chase Young. Okay. Okay. I was curious. I have concerns about Chase Young. When I say I have concerns, he's not a fully formed product yet. If you go look at some of the pass rush numbers from last year, I think I want to say he was like 25th in the NFL in pressures. He does not have a defined pass rush plan when you look at the way he approaches the game. A lot of splash plays.
Starting point is 00:08:09 I mean, think about the San Francisco game. That force fumble that he had and just blowing stuff up. That happens. And so there's some projection involved here, but he's 22 years old. He is 22 years old. He's already an effective player. And if you look at the contract, so what I did was I did the five-year average for pretty much everyone by looking at what they might make on their second contract,
Starting point is 00:08:32 everything else. So Chase Young is the second pick in the draft. is $8 million this year, $9.4, $11, and then he'll probably make about $18 on his 50-year option. If you average it out over the course of the entire contract over the next five years, it's about $14.7 million. Think about what the top edge guys make. It's $25 now. So the discount you could be getting him for as soon as this year he becomes one of the best two or three edge rushers in the league, I just think that potential discount, it's worth it to me. It's just worth where he might go from here, how young he is, and the fact that he's still in the early days of that rookie contract.
Starting point is 00:09:10 Lindsay, what do you think about that? I mean, I would have taken him at three. Okay. That's good. That's good enough. So, yeah, if you had seen me probably right when you took him, I was like, you know, because I think for all of those reasons. And, you know, we talk about value and upside and all of those sorts of things. So I like the pick.
Starting point is 00:09:27 It makes a lot of sense. And now I am scrambling my big board here. I mean, I should have been prepared. But yeah, now I'm going through the, which not as cheap guy do I want here at three. Because my favorite really cheap guy was Chase Young at this position. And we're talking when you're picking in the top three here, you have to do those very, very premium positions. And I'm not sure I'm ready to take a really expensive wide receiver or a really expensive left tackle. So you guys ready for my pick?
Starting point is 00:09:59 I'm ready. We're very ready. I'm going to take T.J. Watt. Oh, wow. Okay. I like it. I've been going back and forth. I had two very comparable players, but I'm going to take T.J. Watt here because I think he is the next best kind of all around defensive player.
Starting point is 00:10:20 He's going to be the defensive player of the year at some point because Aaron Donald can't win it every year. I think the other guy that I was debating put between here also should be a defensive of the year award. winner at some point. But T.J. Watt's still cheap for one more year. And then he's going to be very, very, very expensive. But he's going to be worth every penny that the Pittsburgh Steelers or somebody else spend on him. So I think you can put him in any defense, any scheme. I don't think there's a single real, real weakness in his game. So I'm going to, I'm going to take T.J. Watt and feel a little bad about it. I don't know. I'm okay. I'm okay with it. I'm going and T.J. Watt. I completely understand it. Nate, if you look at his production over the last
Starting point is 00:11:01 couple of years, I mean, he has simply been the most disruptive edge player in the NFL over the last two seasons. He's finished second in PFS pass rush productivity over the last two years. It's for 17 fumbles and defended 25 passes in four seasons. He led the league in defeats in 2019. The 2020 numbers haven't come out. It's a football outsider stat I always like. Essentially just like an all encompassing. How much do you screw shit up on defense stat? He was number one in the NFL in 2019. I just think that outside of Aaron Donald, he's an argument as the most disruptive defensive player
Starting point is 00:11:35 in the league at this stage. And like you said, one more cheap year. And then he's probably getting something that I assume will be in the Joey Bosa range. That's where his agents should probably start the conversation. So you're paying a premium. But, you know, over the course of the entire five years, it probably averages out to like $22 million a year,
Starting point is 00:11:53 even if he gets that Joey Bosa contract, which you can live with when you're getting a guy with that sort of disruption, Nate. Yeah, and that, I mean, you don't have to twist my arm with about a Wisconsin badger. So with TJ. That's also part of my methodology here. You're right. Exactly.
Starting point is 00:12:07 Taking a badger before Nate can. That's perfect. Yeah. Oh, no, actually do. But no, with, with TJ, it's just, I mean, he is, it's, he almost gets, uh, undervalued a little bit because everyone like, like, like, thinks, oh, it's just, he only gets pub because he's JJ's brother. And I think that actually does happen a little.
Starting point is 00:12:27 little bit. I like me too. Don't people don't believe the tape like this dude is unbelievably disruptive. You just listen to stats and it's just one of those guys like you could watch a game and every snap he's doing something even if it's not. I mean, he does some of the smart stuff. I even tweeted a clip the other day about it. It's just that he has such awareness of the game.
Starting point is 00:12:48 That's why the Steelers are able to do what you wrote about in the sense that what Keith Butler was doing and going, hey, these guys are smart and really good. Let him go. let him make a play like go better be just better be right but let's do it as a full defense and it works because t j wott is that damn good and i i think he i mean he's smacked down in his prime i believe he's going to be 27 this year i mean if you're getting him for the next five years this is nice i think he's going to age well he's an athletic guy uh his game is athleticism it's smarts it's just like you said disruptiveness he does everything great it's a damn good player so i love tj i i i can't really
Starting point is 00:13:25 about this, especially you're getting a cheap year for him in the first year. The ability and the effort combination just jumps off with him. I mean, he plays so, so hard, really strong. Like, he could just play through guys in a way that's always really impressive. And that little dip and rip move that he has, where he puts his shoulder on the ground, it's just everything you'd want in an edge rusher, everything. And he does it consistently game in, game out. All right, Nate, you're up.
Starting point is 00:13:49 Number four, who you got here? I'm building an expensive roster. And I got my number. number two got my big board here so I'm pretty excited I'm going I'm just building the Rams defense I'm going with Jalen Ramsey and and I am I love it especially breaking this list down made me realize how few top tier corners there are. That is one of my biggest takeaways I got from this because I was I think we all kind of went about the same way but I kind of was listening up who were the top guys just all right who are the top guys who are some young guys that I like okay
Starting point is 00:14:21 let's go from there O line D line I found a bunch of dudes I shouldn't say a bunch of dudes but good a number. I got to corner and I was like, you know, there's not that many true A-list corners right now. And I'm going to take the A plus guy who is truly, since he's entered the league been a dynamic player. And honestly, he's incredible. He's an incredible player. He's 27 years old. Corners don't age that well once they hit 30, but he's big. He's smart. It's, man, I just think he's a top, top-tier player, one of the best players in the league, especially non-quarterback. That's why I'm taking them number four. But that position is so hard to find talented guys and might as well get the A plus guy right
Starting point is 00:14:59 there. And you could build a defense around that. Well, this was my dilemma when I was trying to decide at number three was, do I want to wait? He was the other guy that I was kind of going back and forth about. It's like, do I want the best corner or do I take the address show that I really,
Starting point is 00:15:15 really want, not knowing if I'll have a chance to get one of the very elite guys? So I think you're totally, totally justified in doing this. And let's see, I trust that you'll do as good a job as Brandon Staley did with those two guys. Scheminging them up. Yeah. Yeah.
Starting point is 00:15:30 Just have these two stars. Yeah, I'll make them work. I'll figure out a way. I mean, that's the thing is you don't have to imagine it. Those two guys, you've seen them together. You know how you can build around them. I was tempted to, if I had gotten Donald it, too, I was thinking the exact same thing with maybe trying to get Jalen Ramsey a little bit later just because we've seen how the
Starting point is 00:15:47 pieces fit. I totally agree about the corners. And I think we'll see that as we go here. There just aren't that many of them. And in the conversation about the value of past rushers, the value of past coverage, that is one of the nuances that you have to remind people of and you have to talk about. Is it better to be better in coverage than a pass rush because you can manufacture a rush? Theoretically, yes.
Starting point is 00:16:09 But it's hard to build that way because the same corners aren't consistently good year after year, where with the edge guys, you can set your watch to it. All of those guys are going to be the same guys on the same list. All the time. The corners, it's a very, very select group of players. So I totally agree. I felt the exact same realization when I was building my list. All right.
Starting point is 00:16:32 I have the fifth pick here. This is probably going to be pretty surprising. I'm taking A.J. Brown. Okay. Yeah. I love A.J., but yeah. What's go, Robert? What's here?
Starting point is 00:16:46 24 years old. 1.5 million this year, 1.8 million next year. That's hard to beat. And I think if you look at his game and some of the underlying numbers, he's been third in the NFL in yards per route run over the last two years. If he was in an offense where he was getting 150 targets a year, he would have the same production as anybody else does. And when I went back and I watched him because I was curious how high he would be on my list.
Starting point is 00:17:10 Because I think that I want a receiver up here, like premium positions, all that kind of stuff. And his game is so interesting because we know about the yak stuff, right? He's been number two in the NFL and yak over expectation over the last two seasons. But to me, his route running ability and his ability in space and the fact that he was the second, he finished second in the NFL when yards per out run from the slot last year, you forget how he's built. Like if you would ask me how tall AJ Brown is, I would say six two. Like that's just immediate where my mind would go.
Starting point is 00:17:42 Six foot and a half. And he moves like that. He's six foot and a half, 225, but he moves like a six foot. foot receiver that's much, much smaller. And I just think his, what he can do out of some of the slot stuff, little juke routes, the fact that he's so, so strong. Like, I feel like truly the receiver's under 25. He's the guy I would take above everybody else.
Starting point is 00:18:06 And I think that's something to consider in an exercise like this. His top end speed is the only question that I have about him. He can't run away from guys, but he's still a good deep receiver. He can still make stuff happen on those sorts of plays. and he's so, so strong. I really do think that his skill set is underrated compared to other guys to the position. Hey, he's fast enough to create all those yards after the catch. So I mean, he's fast enough to do that.
Starting point is 00:18:30 Now, I like AJ a lot. I mean, yeah, that offense is perfect for him because of that ability to create after the catch. And he's so strong. So he's fine running all those dig routes over the middle and drifts and all that. And what I agree with you in in the sense that actually more, he has more receiver to him than maybe even I initially thought. 100%. He has more of that technique stuff than more just being a brute force of nature. And that's something, even in the red zone, you see him kind of, you know, go high points and balls sometimes. And it's like, okay, all right. He maximizes that six foot and a half size. And that's what good receivers do. So I really like AJ. Maybe not I would have taken him here, but I still like him a lot. So I can't really blink too much.
Starting point is 00:19:10 When I went back and I watched him, I was so impressed at some of the stuff he was doing. And it was against Marlon Humphrey in the playoff game. And the fact that he's, breaking off Marlon Humphrey and getting free releases against a really good corner out of the slot. I was just so impressed with him. And again, I was just kind of looking at all the other options here and looking at the price. If you averaged it out, let's say he got a top of market extension after these two years, like at about $25 million a year or whatever it might be. That's still, over that five-year stretch, averages out to $15.7 million. That's $10 million a year less than the best receivers in the league are getting. That's $8 million a year less than a guy like Devon Ante Adams is going to get over that same stretch.
Starting point is 00:19:51 I just think that gap plus his age and the other guys available here, I like it. I just think there's a value there, especially compared to the other guys at that position. All right, Lindsay, you're up. All right. Since we've just talked about how there's not a ton of depth at corner, I'm going to take my favorite guy on the board who's left right now. I'm taking Jaya Alexander. I also considered him at five. So I totally understand that.
Starting point is 00:20:13 He's cheap for a while. Two more years. Yeah, two more years where he's cheap. You know, he's on his fifth year option year in 2022 where he's going to make, what, 13.2 million, which is still a bargain for an elite cornerback, which he absolutely is an elite cornerback. So, yeah, Jair Alexander, he's my guy. I love Jair. I like Jair a lot.
Starting point is 00:20:35 I think he's when I was making that list of quarters. I mean, he was up there and why I really honestly, oh, there's another guy. But I honestly had him as the other corner that I really like. I mean, I think there's a couple others that are really good. but I like him for the value and the value. Exactly. The year he's 24 years old right now. I mean,
Starting point is 00:20:52 that's a top tier corner at that age. No, that doesn't happen. So it's, that's nice. I get exactly the argument for him. He's a top, top tier player.
Starting point is 00:21:01 It's just there, I know the Packers actually have a couple of guys where it's like, okay, this guy is actually legitimately really good. Even though we've, Robert and I know for sure have ragged on the Packers defense a little bit, but that's for stopping the run as opposed to stopping the pass. And there's a reason they were so good against the past was a guy's like,
Starting point is 00:21:15 Jaya Alexander. I was watching him yesterday for this, and I watched a couple different games. I was just blown away by how good he is. I mean, just the man coverage ability. They didn't play that much man, but when he was allowed to do it, just so smooth, so comfortable. I mean, just several different plays just jumped out. He's a really, really good player.
Starting point is 00:21:34 And at that age, again, with two more cheap seasons, I absolutely considered him in this range. So I totally understand that. All right, Nate, you're up. Seven. I'm crushed right now because it's like, oh, man, I have a cheap guy and I expensive. guy. You're going to be an expensive guy. I have to. All right, let's go expensive. What's, what's max this luxury tax out? I'm going to act like it's NBA. So it's all right,
Starting point is 00:21:56 with, uh, where are we at now? So I pick, uh, pick seven here. So pick seven, I am going with Miles Garrett. And yes. And I am very happy with the defense I am building. Um, but it's with Miles Garrett. I actually, I've been kind of tough of him as a person watching him, uh, in the sense that I'm like, oh, he doesn't do all the stuff against the run. He doesn't always crank it up. He kind of knows when his bread is buttered against the pass. And, you know, he's one of those guys. He cranks it up. But guess what? When he cranks it up, he's literally unblockable. So it's, it's to that point where, you know, he's 26 years old. He's going to be a little expensive as the years go on. But I'm getting him right in smack dab at his prime.
Starting point is 00:22:35 He's, you know, I know it's only five years. But, but I'm getting him right here. He's under under deal for that. The cap's going up. So I'm fine with that. But I do think he is a bonafide impact player and one of the better defenders, one of the best defenders in the league right now at that age. And it's just, he's only going to get a little better as soon as he gets even more technique to his game. So, yep, Miles Garrett, pick seven, the Natice Selection Committee. I also think that him signing his deal before Bosa signed his deal was really big for the
Starting point is 00:23:05 Browns because Bosa is setting that high, high bar at the position. Garrett for the next five years, it's set. There's no mystery here. It's 22.2 million over the next five. Bosa is at 26.9 And there's not that big of a gap between those two guys. So if you're the Browns, you've got to be really, really happy about that. And for guys like T.J. Watt and some other guys on this list,
Starting point is 00:23:27 even Chase Young eventually down the road, they're going to be looking at that Bosa deal as the benchmark. So the fact that Garrett came in so far underneath that, you're getting pretty decent value. It's actually why I had Miles Garrett one spot ahead of T.J. Watt when I was doing my rankings here. So I completely understand that. All right.
Starting point is 00:23:44 Number eight, we're talking about cornerback scarcity here. I'm going with Marlon Humphrey. Yeah. So, love him. I just think that, again, if that list is small, that list of like true every single year, this guy is somebody I can rely on. There's two different reasons I picked him here.
Starting point is 00:24:04 One, position versatility. The fact that he can play inside out, super comfortable doing each over the last two years, he's played about half the snaps on the slot, and he looks really good doing it. Two, there's no. mystery about what he does in man coverage. The Ravens play man coverage half the time, and he's excellent at it.
Starting point is 00:24:21 We know exactly what he would look like on a defense that puts a ton on their corners because that's exactly what the Ravens do. Also, the guy is 25 years old and already signed his deal. Signed his deal before the Jalen Ramsey contract. He's $16.9 million over the next five years. That's $4.5 million less per year. Jaylon Ramsey, he's almost two years younger. than Jalen Ramsey.
Starting point is 00:24:46 And I think Ramsey is a better player. But still, that two-year gap plus the discount that you're getting. And the fact that he's consistently been so, so good, he had eight force fumbles last year, too. The guy just makes stuff happen. Yep. I, again, I think that pool of corners is really small, and it's starting to dry up.
Starting point is 00:25:04 And I really wanted to get one before we kept going here. I'm a big fan of Humphrey. All the reasons you laid out. And that contract is great, because in a sense, too, it ends when he's 30, I think. So it's like, you're getting them right wrapped up because it's going to be fair of market value in a few years. I mean, I love Marlon Humphrey. I think he's incredible player.
Starting point is 00:25:25 I really do for all the reasons he laid out. I love the versatility playing in the slot. He's tough. He's willing to fit up on the run when it comes to him. He wears number 44. You have to be confident in your abilities to be a corner and wear number 40. It's so true. It's so true.
Starting point is 00:25:39 I love it. No, I love Marlon Humphrey. He's one of my favorite players in the league. So I love this pick. He was, if I didn't get Ramsey, he would have been the next corner I would have taken. I'm really excited to watch your team play to practice each other because we'll get to see A.J. Brown and Marlon Humphrey. I know.
Starting point is 00:25:54 Oh, yeah. In Robert A.m. The AJ Brown pick is going to be controversial. And that's okay with me because I legitimately think if you dropped him in any other offense, to me he is a true blue number one receiver. And he's so young and the couple cheap years. I'm okay with it, especially getting Humphrey here. I thought I would have considered Jail.
Starting point is 00:26:12 Alexander at five. So that, I just think the, the drop-offs and everything else, I'm totally fine with how this played out. All right, Lindsay, you're up at nine here. Who are you going with? Okay. So at the risk of being a very Packers heavy team, I'm going to take David Bactiari. I was wondering where do you go. I was, I was curious. This is, okay. I want to hear this. So here's my case for David Bactiari. Despite him coming up of an ACL, a very poorly timed, late regular season ACL. But we saw, we so very clearly saw just how freaking valuable David Bacchiari was when he was not able to play and help protect Aaron Rogers in a critical game that they lost
Starting point is 00:26:57 because they couldn't protect him. I also, I mean, I think he's, I don't know if he's the best left tackle in the NFL. I think there's a couple other guys that you could, I mean, I think you could argue, make that argument. I think Trent Williams has a very, very strong case. Trump Williams is 33 and is making max $138 million over the course of his new contract that he signed. David Bakhtiari is making a lot of money. He's making $23 million average per year over the length of his new contract.
Starting point is 00:27:24 That's not cheap. But even at age 30, you're going to be able to get five good years out of him. That is a position where you can play well into your mid-30s when you're as good of an athlete and as smart of a player as David Bakhtiari was. So I'm kind of at the point where I didn't want to wait. I had a couple when I looked at when I stacked my tackle board, I had a couple of the really expensive veteran guys. And then a couple of these like real cheap rookie guys. But I'm going to go for the guy who's proven and that we know his value.
Starting point is 00:27:53 We know how good he is. And I know he's a guy that Robert would have taken if I didn't get him off my board right now. You can't really go wrong picking the best left tackle, past protecting left tackle in the NFL. That's typically a good place to go. And this is a position where we've seen guys play well into their mid 30s. Like you just mentioned, Lindsay, Trent Williams is 33 years old. I think he was the best left tackle in the league this year. Trent Williams is an all-time physical outlier.
Starting point is 00:28:18 So that certainly helps. But Bakhtiari is also a really, really, really good athlete playing left tackle. It shows up all the time. So I completely understand that. My only thing would be he's really expensive. I mean, he reset the market before Trent Williams did. So not only are you getting a guy that's going to be creeping into his 30s over the course of this exercise, but you're paying full freight for him.
Starting point is 00:28:40 You were paying sticker price for a top tier left tackle with a guy like Bactiari. But again, you can't go wrong picking a guy who's been the best past protector in the league over the last few seasons. All right, Nate, you're up, buddy. 10th overall. Yep, I'm also going to go tackle here, but I'm finally going with a cheap guy. God damn it. And I'm going to go with Tristan Wirf's offensive tackle Tampa Bay Bucks or well, actually the Natey Selection Committee. Yeah, I love Worf's.
Starting point is 00:29:08 I think, I mean, everyone did. I mean, shoot, he's all pro. So it's not like he's some unharolded guy. I'm showing up, you know, putting a light on. But worse is, I loved him when he was coming out last year. I think he's just going to, he's going to be such a good player, man. Like, he is going to be so much fun. Even if he stays on the right side for the rest of his career, I don't even care because
Starting point is 00:29:29 he tackle side doesn't matter as much as it used to, you know, 10, 15, 20, 30 years ago where. Do you think it matters at all? I think it's more, as opposed to when he used to be like 80, 20. I think it's more like 55, 45, 45, if that matters. And I think the argument you could make now is that if he gets paid like a right tackle or I mean, like even if I know Lane Johnson kind of reset that a little bit. But even if he gets paid a little bit less because he's a right tackle, it's almost better that he's on the right side for you.
Starting point is 00:29:57 Well, that's the other thing too is, all right, what have defenses started to doing? Because they were so smart. Oh, well, the left tackle is usually really good. And the right tackle some garbage guy that they filled in. That's some guard or some like. guy undrafted guy some six round pick that they're just filling in hope he can develop until left tackle so then defenses start putting their best rushers uh gets the right tackle so let's have a really good right tackle i mean that just seems like natural progression right there so that's why
Starting point is 00:30:21 i think actually i'm going to go back already it's like i don't think it is as much as it used to be obviously i do think there is that just a little bit it's like having a lefty pitcher and a righty pitcher it's like yeah if you could pick i want the fastball throwing lefty as opposed to the fastball throwing righty just cuss but it doesn't matter as much if you're as good as dominant and two-way dominant run game and pass protection and he's smart as all get out like he has great eyes on his stuff yeah i'm fine with it i love tris and worse i think he's gonna be a great pro i mean he already is it's not like i'm projecting anything right now i had worths really really high at my board i would have taken him next if you had not if you look at the numbers on here
Starting point is 00:31:00 the contract is crazy so if you even if you play it out over the next five years, he was probably going to, so he's making 3.7 this year, 4.4 next year, 5.1. His 5th year option is probably going to be the franchise tag for tackles, which that's how it is now for 50 year options when you make a couple pro bowls, which he will. Even that's only 15. So you're getting a deal. You're an absolute steal for a guy who already might be the best right tackle in the NFL. If there weren't the shortage of corners, I probably would have taken him at 8.
Starting point is 00:31:33 but I think the drop off from corner is so considerable that I wanted to make sure I got one of those guys. But I love Tristan Worse going at 10 here. At number 11, I get one of the guys I wanted to come away from with this exercise. I'm going with Brian Burns. Oh, fudge. Come hard. Just let it warm around.
Starting point is 00:31:53 Did you just say, uh, fudge? I, because I don't, we already used our F word from the show. So I can't, I can't, I can't drop the second. I'm always the one that burns it. I'm always going to drop the second F bomb. Trust me. It's part of my lexicon. God. But ah, that's what, yeah, go, go, go gosh.
Starting point is 00:32:07 So if you look at it over, if we play out those five years again, his, even if he gets a top of market extension, you're probably looking at about $14 million a year, similar to Chase Young. That compared to a guy like T.J. Watt is probably going to make 23, 24 over this entire thing. I just think he's the next great defensive player, let alone pass rusher in the NFL. I went back and I watched him today. Just one of those things. Like, is he really as good as I remember? And then you watch him at it. like, oh, hell, yes, he is. He's better.
Starting point is 00:32:35 Oh, hell, yes, he is. He is so, so good. 57 pressures last year, finished fourth and past rush win rate, already getting double team to descend him out in a top 10 clip in the league. The only thing, if I was figuring out, well, let's talk about strengths first.
Starting point is 00:32:52 Unbelievably explosive. I mean, just rare, rare, rare, get off, quickness. And combined with the length, that ghost movie has Nate, where he just goes right underneath somebody for a guy that tall. Von Miller does that. But to do that at 6.5 is bonkers and he uses the length well.
Starting point is 00:33:12 The only real consideration about where he kind of falls short compared to other guys, he's not as strong. He does not as good against the run, but even as a pass rusher, the strength is lacking. But strength being a concern is only a problem when you can only win with speed. But he's so good change of direction-wise, and he has so many good counters that he can still beat guys
Starting point is 00:33:35 with secondary moves even if he doesn't have speed to power. His spin is disgusting. Yeah. For a 6-5 guy, I just, I threw on the Tampa game from earlier in the season
Starting point is 00:33:47 in week two and then the first New Orleans game today. And again, he was just better than I ever thought he was going to be rewatching those games. I think he is a superstar. Yeah.
Starting point is 00:33:57 And like even the clips of him dropping into coverage. Like I know we're talking about pastures. Yes. It's like, oh my God, this guy's a freak athlete. Look at him. He looks good. Like he looks the same way, by the way.
Starting point is 00:34:05 I thought that five times today. I'm watching Chase Young dropping a coverage. Like, oh, my God, he has awareness. And like, he knows what he's doing. It's crazy. I've been a Brian Burns fan since because I didn't do him scouting when he's coming out of college. But then as soon as I saw him running as a gunner as a rookie on punt, I was like, as a D.N running as a gutter and making tackles.
Starting point is 00:34:23 I was like, oh, who the hell is this guy? I am a huge fan of this dude. I rewatching him last week or a few days ago. Oh, my God. I already liked him, but now I love him. I think he, the weight, the strength thing is interesting because it's like, it's not like he, he's a good hustler. Like he brings effort on every play.
Starting point is 00:34:41 Oh, yeah, he plays hard. Hard. And the, it's almost like he doesn't know how to use his strength now because he was 230 something coming out of college. And now you could tell he's put on about 15, 20 pounds. And he's going to probably gain another 10. And it's like, he's like, oh, I'm strong. Like, I think he doesn't realize how strong he is.
Starting point is 00:34:57 He's like, I don't win this way because I was 228 pounds in college. And I had to win this way. And it's like, now he's like, oh, I actually have like muscles and I can do this now. And but yeah, I think this guy, I agree with you. I think he's going to be a superstar and not just because our buddy Brandon Thorne gave his seal of approval too. But it's just like watching this guy, I was just going nuts. And I have a friend Bryce Rossler. He tweeted today.
Starting point is 00:35:20 Brian Burns ranked third in the league last year in hurries and sacks combined overall. Yeah. Just period. Third. Third. He just turned 23 last month. It's like some. If you look at $14.6 million if he gets a $25 million extension over the final two years after his fifth year option,
Starting point is 00:35:39 14.6 and then a guy like Garrett or Watt or whoever, that's an $8 million player over the course of this. So I can have this and a starting like quality cornerback in free agency by getting Brian Burns here at 11. That's how I was thinking about it. That's why I'm going with so many rookie contract guys, even a guy like AJ Brown. I can have AJ Brown and Emmanuel Sanders for the price of Devante Adams. And that matters to me in an exercise like this. And I think Brian Burns, again, another example of that. The discount you're getting with those couple cheap years is a huge, huge advantage.
Starting point is 00:36:15 All right. Lindsay, you're up. 12 pick here. All right. So I am building an all ACL team here. And I'm going to take Nick Bosa. Love it. One of the only reasons I did not take him is because of the injury.
Starting point is 00:36:30 I was taking them next. I was going back and forth. I had both of my Bosa brothers basically in this range, and I am going with the cheaper one. I also am going on the one who's coming off of a torn ACL. His ACL, unlike David Bacierrez, was very early in the season. So I am very confident that Nick Bosa will be fully healthy
Starting point is 00:36:49 and back to being the ridiculously disruptive, just game-wrecking presence for my team in 2021, that he was for the 49ers as a rookie, He was so freaking dominant as a rookie, even though he had some injury issues early. He was limited in his rookie camp. But he could have been if the Niners, if Jimmy Garapolo would have completed that third down pass and they would have won that game. Nick Bosa would have had a really strong case to be a Super Bowl MVP. 100%.
Starting point is 00:37:19 If the Niners in an alternate universe as a rookie. So I'm going to take a little bit of the injury risk here. And I'm going to take Nick Bosa over his big brother, Joey, because I think he might, I think. I think he'll be a better player long term over the course of his career, which is really, Joey Bosa is really freaking good. And one of you guys, or me later, who knows, maybe I can get both of them. We'll have a really good player in his team. But we do have the rookie contract factor.
Starting point is 00:37:42 He's going to be cheaper for a couple more years, a couple years younger. He's only 24. So McBosa, come on down. I love it. I watched a couple of games, the two games before he got hurt. It's just like, oh, yeah, this guy is absolutely dominant on every single snap. We already forgot about them. Not already forgot about him, but it's funny how you just get out of the conversation just that quickly.
Starting point is 00:38:04 And it's like, yeah, this guy was an absolute, literally a game changer, like a game changing, a franchise changing guy is Ricky Year. I mean, he helped unlock that whole defense that they had. And yeah, I think he's, he's special. And both of the guy, both of the Bosa brothers are really special. But I do think Nick maybe even has that quarter half tier above Joey. just so powerful. I mean, Joey plays with like really good hands.
Starting point is 00:38:31 They have the same hands, but just, I don't know, Nick Bose is more violent. Like, he just plays a little bit more violently than Joey does. It's really impressive when you watch him. Without the ACL, I would have put him in there. I just think that there's always a question.
Starting point is 00:38:42 He'll probably be fine, but there always is that slight question. I just, and again, I also just wanted to plant my flag with Burns a little bit. I just feel like we should talk about him more than we do. So, but I was between those two guys. All right, Nate, 13, you're up here, buddy. Who you got?
Starting point is 00:38:55 so funny because those two guys were like my next two guys. I'm like, no way, they're going to take one of them. I'm going to get burns or Bosa. So don't worry. It's not like I'm panicking or anything right now. There's still one Bosa available. I'm just going to keep, I'm just going to keep stalling, stalling, stalling. All right, here we go. So I'm going to switch it up a little bit. I'm going with another rookie contract guy. And actually, I'm going to go a little bit different than what I thought was going to pick here, but I'm going to go with Justin Jefferson. I was going to be shocked if you didn't do this. Yeah. So I'm very excited because yeah, I love Justin Jefferson. We've talked about on the pod. I mean, he excelled. I was high on him, but he's excelled or ascended beyond anything.
Starting point is 00:39:37 I even had pictured what he could be or I thought maybe he could be this in five years. But it's, man, we were texting about him a little bit, Robert. And he's just a good player. He just does everything really well. He's the long. Yeah, he might not be the tallest or fastest guy, but he's such an efficient mover. So I want to talk to you about the tallest part about this because he is only 6-1. But when you watch him play, it feels like he's 6-5.
Starting point is 00:40:03 And it's because he has to have the shortest torso that I've ever seen in my entire life. Yeah. Long, neck, long arms. He has 33-inch arms and his legs are so, so long, but he's only 6-1. And this is very weird. But I think those long legs,
Starting point is 00:40:22 play to his advantage in really subtle ways. One, really easy accelerator, just long, long strides. And I think that that lankiness, he gets on guys before they know he's on them. And they just, for whatever reason, corners just have a hard time understanding his movements because of how wonky and lanky he is. When he's moving full speed, his ability on like sluggos or double moves off of posts, guys just have no idea what to do with it. And I think it's in part because he's shaped in a weird way.
Starting point is 00:40:57 I know that's strange to say. No. You know who he's a lot built a lot like is Reggie Wayne. And that's that's exactly who he's built like. And actually, you know who else is built like that is Rashad Bateman dot, dot, dot. But it's the, but he's just built. He's got those long limbs where he plays so much taller. And usually with a long limb guy, you think of like a deer on ice, you know, just like
Starting point is 00:41:19 shipping and falling over themselves. Can't throttle down. Can't throttle down. Can't or the one thing, we were talking about this is the one thing that always, and you're talking about it as far as he gets up on guys, he catches underneath throughout, how quickly he gets north because he's able to unlock his hips. He has that flexibility with that size or that length as opposed to guys are just like, oh, I have no body control.
Starting point is 00:41:41 So it's like, I remember a story, Chris Borland when I was talking to him. He was talking about guarding this guy, a tight end that played in Wisconsin. It was Big Ten player of the year, or Big Ten tight of the year. And his name was Jacob Pedersen. He just was a camp guy. And then that was it. And Jacob was like 6-2 and changed. Funky was like 2.38.
Starting point is 00:41:57 He ran really weird. He ran like a duck almost like kind of just like waddled. And Borland said that was so hard to guard because he didn't know when he was. He didn't know when he was going to break. Yes. It was like the old guy at the Y. You're like, you're like, guard him and you're like, but the old guy, the Y runs a 4-4-8, you know, can run and catch and everything. But he says like that was harder than a fast guy because the fast guy was like, I know when he's going to
Starting point is 00:42:19 throttle. But a guy that was herky jerky like that, it's like, oh my God, I don't know, is he stopping? Is he breaking? So I think he has that going for him. I love Justin Jefferson. He's a great player and I'm excited. He's on my team. He is, he's not, initial releases aren't his best and he doesn't have like burner, burner speed. Those are the only two things. But his ability to create separation late on plays when he's running full speed and then has to make like a secondary release down the field, guys are lost. They have absolutely no chance. And I think it's because he gets them so quickly. I went back and I watched him a ton last night for this and I was so, so impressed. I mean, just every aspect of his game. Again, he's weird. He's a weird watch, really unique
Starting point is 00:42:59 skill set. But I think that's part of what his strengths and why he's so good. Can I ask a question about Justin Jefferson real quick? Because I just think he's really, I just think it's a really interesting kind of case where going into the 2020 draft, I mean, he was clearly a first round talent, but he wasn't the top guy. He wasn't, you know, he wasn't Jerry Judy or Henry Ruggs or C.D. Lamb. What did we miss in the scouting process that maybe had that tier of guys just above him where when it came to actual football, he wasn't just the best rookie wide receiver in football last year.
Starting point is 00:43:33 He was probably one of the best three receivers in all of the NFL last year. What do you think we missed and then maybe like, why is he the one who was able to make that big jump as a rookie that the other guys weren't? I think just with that LSU offense, he was playing in the slot as a point man. And just a lot of the routes he had to run were shorter routes. It was just like he worked underneath and he was like Blocker a lot of times. They ran duo a whole bunch of times. That's actually why I liked him was like, this guy's athletic, but look how gritty and that core
Starting point is 00:44:02 strength he had. And he had catching range. You know, he maximized everything in the middle. That's why I liked him. I didn't know he could do this well on the outside as well. I think some of it was just lack of, you know, ability to project him and not like dogging a scout or anything like that. I was very high on them again, but it's just, I mean, even I, this is, this is what's so hard about the scouting process, especially with receivers.
Starting point is 00:44:23 That's what I was going to say, Nate. Scheme dependent. That's why. It's so scheme dependent. We talk about this all the time about how this is why I would wait on receivers because it's the nuances on the subtleties of the position that typically end up creating the best players. And he's a perfect example of that. Like all of these little tiny idiosyncrasies that we're talking about are hard to understand. and project, but they eventually make the best receivers in the league. And that's why you can get A.J. Brown in the second round or this guy in the late 20s when Henry Ruggis goes 10th.
Starting point is 00:44:57 So I think this speaks to why we would wait on receivers in a normal NFL draft because of that exact reason. So a nice bit of synchronicity here. I'm going with the guy who was essentially traded for Justin Jefferson. There it is. I... Guy, your guy. I have, everyone knows I love Stefan Dix.
Starting point is 00:45:17 And this is not an exception. And I, but I do think that I'm justified in taking him here. Because if you look at what he did last year, he was six in the NFL in yards per out run. He was second in 2019. It's a sticky, sticky stat. I talk about it because it typically dictates who the most valuable receivers in the league are every single year. There's reason Julio is number one every single season for the most part. So I think Diggs is an elite elite receiver.
Starting point is 00:45:42 Obviously, you led the league in receiving last year when it's, his target share increased. He's an elite receiver, like a top five guy, who's paid like a merely very good one. His contract is awesome. 14 million this year, 13 million next year, 13 million the following year. Compare that to Amari Cooper or what Devante Adams is going to make or what DeAndre Hopkins makes. They may renegotiate this just to give him, make him whole and give him what he deserves.
Starting point is 00:46:09 We don't have to worry about that here. We're only going off these numbers. He is cheap. To get a top five receiver who's still only 27 years old at this price, I don't even think twice about it here. I legitimately think he's one of the best three or four receivers in the league. And at his age and with this contract, I think it's more than worth it at this spot.
Starting point is 00:46:31 Lindsay, what do you think? Oh, no, I mean, I think it's totally fair. As I've been building my big board and thinking about the guys that I like and just, and actually Nate and I were talking about this right before we started recording, where we're talking about methodology, right? And like, how do we rank value versus age and everything? And it's like some point you just got to take the guys you really, really like. And I did have, I will admit, I had a lot of questions about exactly the value of the trade,
Starting point is 00:46:58 what the Buffalo Bills gave up in terms of a first-round pick to go out and get stuff on digs, how it was going to work for him. Because we didn't know what Josh Allen was going to be this time last year. And what we saw was the perfect situation, the perfect guy for Josh Allen, the very value was absolutely there. Both teams, I mean, so rare, right, that both teams would come away really happy with what they got. And I just love Stefan Diggs. And Robert, you've talked about this before. You and I have talked about this before. He is responsible for one of the most incredible moments I've ever seen on a football field. We were both in Minnesota for that game.
Starting point is 00:47:31 And I will like always treasure that day and that moment of just having been there alive to see that. So I absolutely, I love it. And I'm actually kind of surprised you didn't take him earlier. I mean, when they made that trade, I was not shy about saying that I thought it was more than worth it. I thought that he was a super duper star hiding in plain sight. And I think that's exactly what we saw. I mean, when you watch him play, I think him and Devante are the two guys, and Keenan Allen, probably to a certain extent, just a little tiny details of the position. His unreleases, the way he pushes vertically and just his, he's dominant on comeback routes and hitches because guys are so scared of how he pushes down the field. and he throttles down so quickly, just all the little stuff he does. And when we saw him in a true passing offense where he was the number one guy,
Starting point is 00:48:20 he was the most productive receiver in the NFL. That's all he needed was the opportunity. He was always this guy, and I always believed he was this guy, and it's fun to kind of see that recognition grow as he's gotten this opportunity. So not surprising that I took him, and this might be a little bit high, but I don't think anyone should be shocked. All right, Lindsay, you're up, 15. Okay, so I'm just at the point.
Starting point is 00:48:42 where I am just going to draft guys that I think are good value, but that I just really want to have on my team. And I might be taking them too high. It might be a little bit of a risk. But I'm going to take Kyle Pitts. And he, it's early. I had him in this range. He hasn't played a single snap yet.
Starting point is 00:49:00 But he, all the projections are on him, projections on him are generational talent, a guy that will be Travis Kelsey or better, more valuable than Travis Kelsey. And I freaking love to. Travis Kelsey. And if he wasn't, what, 32 years old, I believe he's 32 years old, I would be taking Travis Kelsey here. So I'm going to take 21 year old potential Travis Kelsey impact level of a player in Kyle Pitts. So yeah, I'm taking the first rookie
Starting point is 00:49:29 off the board here. I totally understand it. He was on my list. He was on my board. Like I would have drafted him before the end of this just because I think the value you could get is huge. and not only is he on a rookie contract, I think some of the thinking with him has to be he's a tight end. So even as you go later on into this entire thing, if he is a tight end when contract time comes around, that impacts everything. His 50-year option then becomes the franchise tag value for tight ends
Starting point is 00:49:57 if he makes two pro bowls, and he gets paid based on tight ends, which that's really important because there are some tight ends that have receiver value but aren't paid like receivers because precedent at the position matters when you're negotiating contracts. And that's exactly how this will go. What Travis Kelsey and George Kittle are making now, if he ends up becoming a true number one weapon for an offense,
Starting point is 00:50:19 that's a bargain. That is less than you're going to pay for a receiver. So I think that should play into the thinking a little bit. Nate, do you think that's fair? Yeah, no, absolutely. Because you're not really paying him for his rookie year. Or you're not making this pick for his rookie year because tied in such a hard position to get good at.
Starting point is 00:50:35 I mean, it's one of those positions. quarterback, offense a line, tight end, corner. Like those are hard transitions from going from college to pro. And that's the thing with Kyle Pitts, though. It's like I think after the buy week of this year, all of a sudden he's going to ascend to at least above average good. But then after that, it's those next three, four years that you're like, yeah, I got a pro bowl, all pro tight end candidate.
Starting point is 00:50:56 There's only three or four, three of those realistically in the league right now. And I got him in his 20s, his mid-20s on a rookie deal. Yeah, makes all the sense in the world. I thought I was going to get that like later. I was like, I didn't want to wait. I didn't want to risk it. I know. Get you guys.
Starting point is 00:51:12 I don't want to risk it. Get your guys. I'm just going to take my guys right now. I love it. I totally understand it. All right. 16. Who you got?
Starting point is 00:51:19 God. I'm just becoming a meme of myself. I are a caricature of myself, whatever you want to use it. But I'm going expensive again. I'm going with Trent Williams. And I'm just. Yeah. 33 through 38, huh?
Starting point is 00:51:32 Yep. I am. This is a hard pill to swallow. He is. dude, I just watched him again. And it was just like, this guy's unbelievable. He's incredible. And yes, it's, you know what's scaring me a little bit?
Starting point is 00:51:44 It was my original argument was like, oh, yeah, look at Andrew Whitworth. But then Trent Williams, Andrew Whitworth didn't miss a, was like one game in 12 years. And it was like, yeah, of course he aged well. Trent Williams, on the other hand, has, you know, he's missed some time. Even when he was in Washington, he missed a few games. And he's missed a few games in the last couple of years, even the year prior to a I sat out. I just think he's just so good.
Starting point is 00:52:07 So I'm really just kind of taking him here just to have those two or three years, just to have these two or three years where I could just like, I'm going to have the top, top, top, top, top, top left tackle. Because I do think he's the best two-way tackle in the week. Bakari can, of course, I always call him Dothraki. I don't know why. That's just his name in my head. He does.
Starting point is 00:52:25 But he also, he has, that's, they used to say that he looked like that when Game of Thrones was because of the hair. Yes. I never knew how to. They called him Cal Drogo back when he. He was a rookie. Okay. I never knew how to say his name, so I combined it David and Bakkiari.
Starting point is 00:52:38 So I was just like Dothraki. That's what he is in my brain. And that's why I call him for the rest of my life. I still can't spell Bactiari. So don't worry about it. Oh, no. Okay. Yeah.
Starting point is 00:52:45 I think even out here I've been David B. But it's with him, it's just, you know, he's incredible. I mean, he's top tier past, I mean, one of the better past protecting left tackles we've seen a while. I love Trent Williams just because you see, you get to see it a lot in the Shanahan offense is all the run stuff that he gets to do. And he is just incredibly dominant. And yeah, I get it. It's, he does have some bang up injuries and he is old.
Starting point is 00:53:06 He's 33. And this contract is freaking ridiculous, the contract that they gave him. But what I am hoping with what I'm taking him here is I'm getting three years of the elite of elite play at left tackle, which is really hard to find. And then hoping he ages after that and just hope I get 10 to 12 starts of him after that. But I'm really buying him for three years and just holding on my hat after that. I understand it. I think that you're really betting on those last couple years though.
Starting point is 00:53:33 You're really hoping he sticks around for a while. But he just signed that contract. Who knows? I mean, and his play this year, I think has to be encouraging. The fact that he was arguably the best lap tackle in the NFL at 33. It's not like Aaron Donald because Aaron Donald is such an outlier.
Starting point is 00:53:45 But it's that thing where it's not like he's on the decline already. He's still playing as well as he pretty much ever has. So that's why I can understand this bet. All right. At 17, I'm sticking on the same offense. I'm going with George Kittle. Okay.
Starting point is 00:53:59 The run on tight ends. So I be. So I think tight end is an interesting consideration here because in a vacuum, it's not as valuable position as a receiver tends to be. And I understand that. But with Kittal, I just think you're getting so many different things, right? It's the yards after, he's an explosive play waiting to happen as a tight end. There just aren't many of those.
Starting point is 00:54:22 So if you look at it, about three quarters of his receptions went for first downs this year. As a tight end, he's an explosive play. He was third in the NFL in yards after catch. over expectation over the entire year after I think Debo Samuel and A.J. Brown. That's as a tight end. I mean, and then you combine that with he is a vertical threat. He's running fades out of the slot for 40 yards and what he does as a blocker. The fact that he has all of that value as a past protector when you want him to be, as a run blocker, he is a weapon in the run game. So over the course of the next five years, I think it's an average of like $14 million a year.
Starting point is 00:55:02 Compare that to a receiver at 22. I don't think he's less valuable than a wide receiver is. I really don't. I think he's arguably more valuable for less money. The only thing to me would be injuries. He's missed a couple of games. Obviously, he missed half of last season. He missed two games the year before.
Starting point is 00:55:22 He missed half of his rookie year. But you're getting at this from 27 to 32, and I think at a reasonable price when you consider the impact he has in every facet of the game. Also, my receiving core now is Stefan Diggs, A.J. Brown, and George Kittle. Yeah, you're loading. So I'm doing okay. It's such a good point, though.
Starting point is 00:55:39 That's always been my argument with Kittle and or just tight ends in general is how many plays affected? You know, how many plays does he affect? If he's on the field for average of 60 plays a game, he is positively affecting the game, not just there to run up a runoff route to just kind of play hand paddy with the corner. He is positively affecting the game for 45, 50 of those plays. is winning. That's just like an efficiency thing. So it's like, yeah, he's dynamic, explosive, crazy in the past game. But then he's a plus plus blocker. Not just like, oh, yeah, he gets by and we can run a little couple things behind him. We don't have to hide him. It's like, no, you run behind him because of how dominant he is. And that's, that's the thing is if you're playing winning football for 45
Starting point is 00:56:19 snaps a game, that just helps everybody. And so yeah, I love George Kittle. So this, I, yeah, I'm fine with this. I'm so curious if there's a run on tight ends right now where you're going to go. I mean, I don't know how many more there are. There's probably only a couple. So you're next year at 18. There's one more who Nate's been tweeting about. I know. I know.
Starting point is 00:56:37 I'm surprised he hasn't come off the board quite yet. I'm going to wait a little bit. I'm going to wait a little bit. All right, Lindsay, you're in 18 here. You're up. Okay. Well, I'm going to end the run on tight ends. And I'm going to take my expensive wide receiver and I'm going to take my third
Starting point is 00:56:50 Green Bay Packer and I'm going to take Devante Adams. Okay. I can't believe it's still here. Still available. So the only reason I think that he's still here. I have been open about my affection for Devante Adams. He's 28 already. And he's about to become the highest paid wide receiver in the NFL when he gets paid.
Starting point is 00:57:09 So you're paying top of the market and he's going to be 30 in a couple years. That's the only reason. But as a player, I mean, there aren't any arguments against Devante Adams. I was going to ask if you were considering any other receivers here, but that would be giving away what your long-term strategy might be. I had some younger, cheaper receiving options there. But I just took a 21-year-old tight end. So I'm okay with taking the 28-year-old about to be really expensive, potentially best receiver in the NFL and Defonte Adams.
Starting point is 00:57:38 And I'll be okay with that. My contract situation is going to balance out just fine. I like Lindsay's plan of just saying, all right, I'm going to take the best receiver. I'm going to take the best pass blocking tight end. And then I'm going to take a tight end we've never seen before. It's all over the map in a way that I sincerely appreciate. Top of the market. I just take guys.
Starting point is 00:57:55 I like, right? Yeah. Proven expensive guys and a guy that has never played in the NFL. Look, I drafted Trevor Lawrence last time. So in our quarterback draft. So I like the risk taking. You are not afraid and you cannot be afraid. And with exercises like this.
Starting point is 00:58:10 All right. Nate, 19. Who you got? I'm going, Quentin Nelson. And I am loving my old line right now. And the odd that I wasn't going to get Quentin Nelson. We're off the board in Vegas. People just lost a ton of money.
Starting point is 00:58:24 I am very happy with this. I thought you would take it about two rounds ago. But I mean, don't really preach it to the choir here about Quentin Nelson. But it's just, I mean, it's the top guard. I love Zach Martin, but Quentin Nelson is the age he's at. I got two years left on his rookie deal. Just this is great. I think he is truly a transcendent talent at that tackle position.
Starting point is 00:58:46 Or I'm sorry, that guard position. And it's just, yeah, he's a tone setter. And I mean, shoot, if my offensive line is Wurfs, Trent Williams and Quentin Nelson, I got plenty of attitude, finesse, strength. I got a little bit of everything right there. So, yeah, I mean, dynamic player, a true tone setter for any offensive line, even at the guard position. So the only consideration, the only thing I would say here, the reason I didn't, yeah, I haven't go earlier, is just because do we think there is a cap on how much a guard can give you,
Starting point is 00:59:15 especially a guard who is about to be expensive here very soon? 7.8 this year, 13.8 next year. So even on his 50-year option, he's making top of the market sort of money. So he's not cheap for a guard for very much. longer. Where do you sit just the overall value a guard can provide? That is a great point. I always is going to be the left tackle and then, I mean, well, I haven't made the left hand or right or right tackle. And then I do think centers are undervalued in our brains a little bit with the stuff. But I do think we just expect not so much first and second down, but third down is where
Starting point is 00:59:49 guard value is becoming more and more important. So I think we have transitioned away that all these guards are these gap power pulling guys that are big bruisers. Or, or the Shanahan guys and climb it to the second level and stuff like that. I think why the guard position is becoming more valuable in passing situations because defenses have moved guys around. You got more pressures coming. You got more guys moving inside where you get these. They'll just put NASCAR packages out there.
Starting point is 01:00:15 How many times are we saying Melvin Ingram blow up some crappy guard that they line up over, you know, that they line them up over? It's because that's where I think a value of having a top, top tier guard like this really matters. Just because not just his strength. all the stuff he can do in the run game and stuff, but just he's such an incredible pass protector that yeah, if you bump in somebody inside your special little pass protection or a pass blitz, he's fine. He can hold up against the top tier pass rushers no matter who it is. So that's where I think his value is because he is just an elite at everything he does and just
Starting point is 01:00:46 the mentality you bring. So I know especially with guard, I get it with the other play. So yeah, it's not as valuable as tackles. I don't think it's ever going to be. But I do think there is more value to him, not in the sense of the gap scheme power stuff, but more in that past protection. stands. I completely understand that. I think it's a good argument. I think that would just be the concern how some people had,
Starting point is 01:01:04 especially when there are a lot other high value positions on the board. All right. Speaking of offensive linemen, I'm going with Penesul. Ah, yeah. I thought I was going to be cute here. All right.
Starting point is 01:01:18 So here's why. Okay, I think if you look at the other tackles on the board, there are very few young, affordable tackles that you would want to rely. on. There's pretty much no one. I think Mackay Beckton is probably in the conversation, but a little bit hurt last year. I think he's going to be really good. But I think
Starting point is 01:01:39 Sewell might have more upside than Mackay Beckton. I think he also might be safer than McKay Bechted, even if we've never seen him play. And you get five years of that rookie deal. I mean, if you look at it, I have the number. So the numbers aren't out there yet, but you're still going to be getting similar to what we have with some of these other guys. I mean, it's like going to be $12 million average over the next five years. Compare that to Ryan Ramchek after his extension. It's probably going to be about 21. Bactiari is at 23.
Starting point is 01:02:08 Ronely Stanley is at 20. So you could be getting a top five potential tackle here for half of what the best tackles in the NFL go for. And I understand that's a risk because we've never seen him play. But the guy's 20 years old, it's a risk I'm willing to take. I just think that the upside is endless with him and the chance to get him. and the chance to get him on that rookie deal when there are so few young,
Starting point is 01:02:31 reliable tackles in the league, I think it works for me. I'm okay with doing it here. Makes sense. I think it's totally fair. And now I'm going to go with an expensive guy and just keep drafting the guys that I really like. And I'm taking Chris Jones.
Starting point is 01:02:47 Okay. I got to build up my interior of my defensive line. I understand this. He destroys games. He just, he just destroyed. his games and talk about tone setter. Yes, he's going to give you a personal foul a game and I'm okay with that because he will just wreck shit on a regular basis. And I will be really happy to
Starting point is 01:03:09 add him to my to my defensive roster. I mean, he's one of the most fun guys to watch. He's so versatile inside, outside. He can actually bring that interior pressure that there was, I mean, there's a couple guys left on my list that you can get some good interior pressure. But if I'm not going be able to get Aaron Donald and he was off the board at one, I'm going to be really happy to have Chris Jones. So I'm taking Chris Jones. I honestly think that if you're looking at skill sets and tiers of players and everything else, him and Aaron, I know Aaron Donald's in his own world, but I think Chris Jones is like in that first tier of interior rushers. And I think that group of guys is really small. And so he had 60 pressures last year, which is 11th in the NFL.
Starting point is 01:03:51 That was more than Colea Mack. It was more than Cam Jordan. It was more. than Brian Burns. And if those guys are going to be going in the top five to six of this list, getting Chris Jones here is pretty good value. And you're getting him for a little bit cheaper. He's on that second contract. I mean, you're paying a premium compared to a rookie contract guy,
Starting point is 01:04:10 but it's still less than you're paying some of the edge guys. And I think the impact he's going to give you is actually fairly comparable. Nate, do you think that's fair? I do. And this is another reason why I'm fine with taking a guard with my last pick is because of guys like Chris Jones. I mean, there's more and more of these, more and more, the pass rushing chops is needed now.
Starting point is 01:04:28 It's not like you can just be a run plugger. Like, D tackles are going to be all good pass rushers now. And we're going to see more 260s, 270 pound guys bumping inside on pass rushing downs. But then we get Chris Jones, guys like Chris Jones. The quickest path to the quarterback is a straight line. And guess where a guy can disrupt the most is from the interior. So if you get a guy that's a bonafide pass rusher, like absolute ace guy that's disruptive, it's, I mean, you got to take it. I mean, just like those types of guys are so hard to find.
Starting point is 01:04:56 That's why there's so many rare guys that we, the interior guys that we talk about is past rushers. And that's why Chris Jones deserves to get paid. And that's why we praise them like we do right here because he affects so many plays. I mean, those guys are hard to find. And there's only three of them or four of them in the league. So, I mean, I love it. I think Chris Jones is just a hell of a player.
Starting point is 01:05:13 And like you said, you might get that personal foul, but he'll have about seven other plays. This is another guy that could have been Super Bowl MVP, you know. Yes. Like this is just another guy in that in that Super Bowl that, you know, we talk about other things with that that super bowl but it's like this is another guy that literally took over a game from the interior position Nate 22 you're up buddy oh my god I am so happy with this I get Tyreek Hill at pick 22 and I am like I mean fine okay 27 years old two years left on his deal okay we'll renegotiate the other thing after that but the thing with tyreek hill is he's not just the
Starting point is 01:05:47 burner he is the route runner he is the hands he's the body control he is a true the grass The gravity of Tyreek Hill is just unlock so much for other receivers and other receiving options for them. I mean, there's a reason they just run, they spam the same two plays over and over and over with him running overrouts and then him stopping on overrouts and then, and then Travis Kelsey on the other side, singled up doing his thing. It's just because it's every, you have to keep eyes on him because the one time you don't, all of a sudden he's running that he's running that overrout and then he turns it back to his sale. That's another thing with his speed because he is a good route runner has that body control is that he can sell things for another like, two, three rotations more than other receivers can. So when he's running like a sale router or the WASP route, you know, that we're going to, we are going to talk about for the rest of our lives, is that he can sell it for three more
Starting point is 01:06:34 rotations and then just burn it right back and just run it high. And you have to honor it because he's so fast. So just the gravity of Tyree Hill. I mean, yeah, I'm pretty fired up to get him right here. I thought you might go a little earlier. And actually that contract doesn't too bad, you know, especially with, I mean, I'll have to pay him after the two years. So never mind.
Starting point is 01:06:50 I mean, if he gets top of the market money, which that was part of my. calculation here is that I assume he'll get paid like one of the best receivers in the league, which he's not quite yet. So if he's getting 25 million or so a year in that DeAndre Hopkins range, that's pretty expensive. He's also at 21 next year. So, I mean, it's a little bit cheaper, but not that much cheaper. And he's also 27.
Starting point is 01:07:11 So you're getting him into like into his 30. So those are some of the things that I took into account. But I can absolutely understand. Into his 30 is 27, 28, 29. That's three years right there before he's 30. Yeah. And then he turns 30. He'll be 30 at the end of it.
Starting point is 01:07:24 Yeah. So be in his 30s at the end of it. I completely understand. I completely understand why you'd want him here. I am going way off the board here for reasons. But I also think that it fits with a building that I've done and I like the value. I'm going with Elton Jenkins. Okay.
Starting point is 01:07:43 Not a name I was expecting. Let's go. Do you think Wyatt Teller is going to be upset? Like, did you think? Wyatt Teller. is about to get he's going to be a free agent very soon. I also he was hurt last year and it's only one year production. I think with Jenkins, the positional versatility is so, so important. I think he's one of the best guards in the league already, but the fact that he can play a tackle in a pinch,
Starting point is 01:08:08 the fact that he can pay a center in a pinch, and he is dirt cheap. One point eight this year, 2.1 next year, and then he'll have to get extended. But half of this, he's on a nothing contract. So I think having him and Sewell, because I already have him, my receivers, I already have Kittle, I already have some pass rushers in a corner. I just think that he is a really, really good value here. I mean, if you look at it over the course of a five-year kind of exercise with this, he'd be worth about $10 million a year. Compare that to one of the top tackles that some of the other guys that we consider here. I mean, it's much, much, much cheaper. So I just thought that he could be a really good value compared to some of the other guys. I just
Starting point is 01:08:47 think it's good value. And I think part of the reason I wanted to put him here is I wanted to illustrate how few young offensive linemen there are that you'd want to bet on in this exercise. There just aren't many of them. And he's one of them. He's one of the only kind of guard interior prospects that's still on a rookie deal that I would feel comfortable taking here because it's that middle ground, right? Proven enough, but still cheap. And he threads that needle and very few guys that we would consider here actually hit that sweet spot. but he does in my opinion.
Starting point is 01:09:22 I know. I actually thought I would have some more options to look, look at on the like the, like where the Nelson range is as far as like, there's two years left on his deal. There's one years left on his deal. And I completely agree with you. I actually was stunned too when I was brilliant with this list.
Starting point is 01:09:35 I'm like, he's expensive. He's expensive. He's going to be, he's about to be expensive one year. Like, et cetera, et cetera. Like the only other one really,
Starting point is 01:09:43 because how my coding was. The only other one I had in blue, that was like a cheaper young guy was Beckton. And that's a guy off of one year. and got banged up. And that's really all I had. Like, I mean, you know, we were just talking about why I tell her.
Starting point is 01:09:56 I had the same exact concerns you did. So it's like, yeah, I completely agree with you. It's funny. It's like it's not a scarce position, but it's more like there's a couple of years that seem to be missing some guys that, that there's a crop of guys that seem to be missing there.
Starting point is 01:10:10 So I could consider Zach Martin at that spot, right? Zach Martin's 30. So you're getting 30 through 35 and he'd be about $6 million a year more expensive than a guy like Jenkins would be. So now I can have Jenkins and a starting caliber other guard in free agency. I can have Jenkins and Matt Filer for the price that it would take to get Zach Martin and he's five years younger. So I just think that value compared to where he is at his peers of the position, that's why I think it's worth it here. All right, Lindsay, 24th pick.
Starting point is 01:10:40 You're rounding us out here. Who you got? Okay. So I've been. Agnet. of deconstruct how this went down. Yeah. There have not been no running backs, no inside linebackers, no off ball linebackers,
Starting point is 01:10:58 which should not be a surprise to anybody. We also haven't had any safeties. Ah. And I think I'm going to take a safety here and I've been agonizing over which guy I want and which safety I want. Is it another packer? I'm not going to take a packer. I just have to stop drafting Green Bay Packers, although this should be a
Starting point is 01:11:20 a lesson for Aaron Rogers about how good this freaking roster is because between me and Robert, we basically drafted all of these guys. So come back home, Aaron. Come play with us. I'm going to go Minka Fitzpatrick. I love Mika Fitzpatrick. So I'm not shocked here.
Starting point is 01:11:40 There's a lot of safeties that I really like. And I think Jamal Adams is certainly a consideration there. Jamal Adams is obviously about to get paid. Minkup Fitzpatrick is going to get paid very soon. What Fitzpatrick gives you that Jamal Adams doesn't is his coverage. And I think we've seen that Jamal Adams for as great as he is as a pass rusher and the what he can bring you as a blitzer. And those sorts of things, he is a liability in past coverage. And that was the reason that the Jets were willing to let him go in exchange for a couple first drawn draft picks.
Starting point is 01:12:13 Fitzpatrick is so good in coverage. And he is going to get you turnovers on a regular basis. So I'm going to bookend my draft with young Pittsburgh Steelers, defensive players. I think there's the others. What other safeties do you think you would have considered here in this range? I can tell you because I have my list here. Okay. I did too.
Starting point is 01:12:32 I have a few different guys that I listed, and I'll tell you why I didn't put them on here. Jesse Bates was on my list, but he's only one more cheapier. Then he's getting the Justin Simmons contract. So do you get a slight discount? Yes, but not a lot. had Justin Simmons on here, but again, very expensive. The other guy I had that I probably would have taken very soon that talking about guys we're forgetting about is Derwin James.
Starting point is 01:12:58 3.9 this year. 9 million next year. And I know the injuries are concerned. I know they are. But if you look at all of the factors, 25 years old, 3.9 and the 9 million, and then similar to tight ends, let's say Durwin James got the Justin Simmons contract after playing really well over the next two years.
Starting point is 01:13:20 Darwin James isn't just the safety. He could play a slot corner half the time. He could do so many different things that if he's paid like a safety, you're almost getting a built-in discount because of what it says next to him on the depth chart. So I just think that if he can stay healthy, he could be a huge, huge value here.
Starting point is 01:13:36 So I considered him. But those are the only safeties on my list. Nate, would you have anyone else in there? It was Darnel Savage, the Packer. So that was it. Honestly, I love Simmons, but he was like, no, I'm not going to take him in this exercise. I really actually make a Fitzpatrick. It was one of like the three names I
Starting point is 01:13:53 was really looking at for my last pick that I took Tyreek at. I make a Fitzpatrick is a hell of a football player just for all the points that Lindsay brought up. Just I mean, he's fine fit in the run. Like he can do that stuff and blitz and all that. It's just that he is so smart and pass coverage. Like he is, he is a quarterback of that defense from the safety position. I mean, all this stuff they do there and they do all the robber stuff. It's great. But no, Darnel Savage was the other one. I, I, I, I had. I think he's a damn good player as well. And that's also he has three years left on his rookie deal. Yada, yada, yada. So that was the other, that's the only other safety, really. Those, I didn't even think of Darwin James. So that was a pretty good one. But yeah,
Starting point is 01:14:30 Darnell Savage and really Fitzpatrick were the only two quote unquote draftable safeties I had for this list. The other thing is interesting is like he's the first charger who we've mentioned. Obviously, Justin Herbert went pretty early in our quarterback draft last week. I still feel good about that, by the way. But I, I, you absolutely should. real good by the end of the year. I think it's going to look real good. But it's curious, like, you know, the Packers obviously had a bunch of guys taken here.
Starting point is 01:14:57 But there's some really good teams who didn't have a single guy taken or, yeah. So it's just kind of mentioned these blind spots in these holes. And it kind of tells you about like the way that maybe these teams are already constructed. We didn't have a single cowboy. We didn't have a single New England Patriot. We didn't have any Denver Broncos. I don't think there was a single Seattle Seahawk. there were a couple guys on my like just missed the cut list, you know, if maybe we were going to go a couple more rounds.
Starting point is 01:15:24 But yeah, I think that, you know, I think it'll be interesting to put together our whole rosters and look at the number of guys from which teams. Maybe we should actually break it down by how much we're spending. But it was kind of a fun exercise. So who is who is your first guy out? Like if we were building like now it was undrafted free agency and we got to just like make a run at throw some, throw some cash to a few other guys. Who are the guys that just miss out that you might want now, Robert? So, D.K. Maccalf was going to be close for me. So that's, we're talking about Seahawks.
Starting point is 01:15:52 I think that with chargers, Joey Boas is just really expensive. And I think that's a few of these guys, I think that's a consideration. Chris Godwin is on this franchise tag and is about to get paid. D'Andre Hopkins is really expensive. Mike Evans is really expensive. I think a couple of the other guys I would have picked if we were still doing this. Calvin Ridley would have been close for me. because he has two more cheap years,
Starting point is 01:16:19 and I think he's a really, really good player. DeNeil Hunter would have been somebody else that I think when you look at the contract that's already baked in, he's been paid. We'll see if he stays on that contract for very much longer. He's on there. A couple other random wild cards that I was thinking about, Montes Sweat.
Starting point is 01:16:38 I think Montes, watching Chase Young, I think Monteswein is going to be really good. And he's got a couple more cheap years left. Is he a weird watch? Weird watch. Weird watch. He runs like a deer, though. Oh, my God.
Starting point is 01:16:50 Very, I mean, his really, really long limbs again, but he uses that length well. Really good run defender. I think his upside as a pass rusher is still there. In this range, I think maybe worth a swing. Denzel Ward possibly a little bit later here. Trouble staying healthy. But those are the guys. I think that, you know, that I was thinking about.
Starting point is 01:17:11 Yeah. I, well, I'm a kaybeckton, which I ever mentioned. But Trey White was another one that. Trey White was the name. If I were going to go, the one only offball linebacker that made my big board was Fred Warner because he is just so damn good. Holy crap. Fred Warner is a really good football player.
Starting point is 01:17:28 But even with him, we talked about this with Fred Warner. He's about to get paid. He has one more cheap year. One year. Yep. There aren't that many guys at that position on rookie deals that you want to bet on. No. And also just the other guys that are like rookie deals are stuck guys, they do have limitations.
Starting point is 01:17:44 Like, you know what I mean? Like Fred Warner is like the only true. true guy that I even want. And the receiver wise, yeah, Calvin Ridley was my top receiver left. I love Calvin's game. Oh, my God. He's a guy that upon rewatched when I started breaking down some games from last season, it's like, oh, my God, Calvin, like, he's ready to ascend to the national spotlight
Starting point is 01:18:02 even more than he has for an Alabama guy. CD Lamb was another rookie contract guy. You love CD Lamb. Love me some CD. Oh, yeah. Watch DAC. Doesn't he have such great chemistry? I said this to Kent, Cowboys fan over here, our producer, is he has such great
Starting point is 01:18:16 chemistry with DAC already because CD, the one thing Kellan Moore was doing very intelligently was moving CD in the number two and number three spots and having all those benders and those and those overrouts that CD is so good at. He was in the slot 75% of the time, I want to say. And that's where he lined up. And he's a power slot. And he's so good. Oh my God.
Starting point is 01:18:35 And Dak just trusts him already. So I'm excited to see that in 2021. Lindsay, the only other guy I would say, Travis Kelsey. Lindsay, would you have thought about Travis Kelsey? Yeah. I mean, he's 32. That's the only, I mean, that's really the only downside on him is that he's 32. Darren Waller, 29.
Starting point is 01:18:53 I was kind of surprised. I thought Nate might be taken Darren Waller. Why did you get off of Darren Waller, Nate? It just didn't make sense. Other guys were coming up. And I was just like, you know, I was going to take a tight end maybe in this last pick. But I mean, shit, we got a tiger kill there. So I kind of had a ad lib right there.
Starting point is 01:19:11 Yeah, I actually think the other guy that's going to ascend at the tight end position, the other guy I looked was Noah Fan. I think Noah fans going to have a huge 20-21 season. Can somebody get on the ball? Can anybody get Noah's fan the ball? I'm going to abstain from commenting on that for once in a mile. If you know there's another guy is Quinn and Williams. Like, Quinn and Williams is really good.
Starting point is 01:19:33 I know I'm talking about a number three pick here. But oh my God, that is a guy upon watch. I was like, this is because I was looking at Vita Valle a little bit and I was just like, you know, Viva was on my list too. Yeah. There's a couple of detackles. All right. So I looked at Quinn and Williams.
Starting point is 01:19:44 I was like, oh, man. And Ronnie Stanley was another guy if I was going to go, you know, maybe pay a little bit of money. That was another guy I was looking at, too. There's so many good players right now. Isn't it fun? Like, there's just, there really is. That's why I got chased off of the tackles, though, is they're just expensive. I mean, there's so few guys.
Starting point is 01:20:02 Like, I mean, you look at my list, like Chase Young, A.J. Brown. I mean, there's just Brian Burns. I went a lot of guys on rookie contracts because I just think that that gap is not that big between them and those guys at the top of the market. and if you can get another starter for that money, that's where my mind was in all of this. And I think the tackles are a perfect example of that. Outside of Worf's and maybe Bechton and when I went with Sewell, there just aren't that many of them.
Starting point is 01:20:27 Lindsay, what were you going to say? I was going to say the other couple guys that I would have, you know, potentially looked at or the next guys, especially when you're talking value. I think the best value wide receiver pick still out there was Terry McLaurin. Yes, he was on my list as well. He was there too. He was under a million dollars for the next couple of years in average salary.
Starting point is 01:20:44 So like he'll get paid eventually, but like he's a true, he's the number one legit. He's a dude and he is super, super duper cheap. Right now he's only 25. Great call. So I had he, I had him there. And then I had, I had Grady Jarrett, who I just love, Grady Jarrett. He's expensive. Expensive.
Starting point is 01:21:03 That's why he wasn't there, which is why I didn't actually take him. Kaleel Mack didn't get taken. He's expensive and old, but he's still really freaking good. So Kalil Mack. So he's in that Joey Bosa. conversation is like if he didn't have a 30 million dollar cap hit next year i probably think about it because he's really really good but i just think that the way the bears have done that contract for the purposes of this exercise it's really hard to justify a 30 million dollar player in any
Starting point is 01:21:30 position especially i and we still haven't talked about a single running back no and i don't and i don't think we will oh yeah i don't even don't even look at was nick chob and i was like no way I was like, no way, one year left, no way. Am I paying a run of a man? I just think that's really hard. The other two guys I considered, and it's for something we talked about at the beginning of the show, the scarcity of how many truly great corners there are. Yep.
Starting point is 01:21:56 I think if it's for five years, because my understanding of his health situation is that he might be okay for five years, you could get Caleb Farley for an average of $6 million a year in this exercise. that's one quarter of what you'd have to pay Jalen Ramsey. Like that was the only other wild card kind of off the wall thing I was thinking about was maybe him or Sartan because of because of that. Sertan would have been the one because he's, Sertan made my list because I think he's going to be a hell of a pro. And that it's such a great point.
Starting point is 01:22:30 Scarcity corner and not only scarcity corner, you get them on a cost control contract. Exactly. That's really, really nice. Yeah, but I think Sartan's going to be a good pro. So I was the only court, yeah, I think the only rookies I had up were Sewell, Pitts, and Sertan. Think about it. That's pretty much what my list was.
Starting point is 01:22:47 I just think they're Farley is super, super talented. And if you're worried about his 10 years from now health considerations, that's fine. But for five years, I know it's a little bit craven and cynical. But for our purposes here, I think it would make sense if you can get him for six million bucks a year. That's pretty much everyone on my list. The only other guy don't think we've mentioned at all, Brandon Ayyuk. I think Brandon Ayyuk is going to be really. really, really good.
Starting point is 01:23:10 I just think that his talent goes beyond just being a yak guy, and it's a price tag thing for me. I mean, the fact that you can have somebody like, Lindsay, you had Devante Adams, if he gets a $25 million a year extension, which you assume he might be, that's $23.5 million a year over the next five years. Ayyok is $10 million.
Starting point is 01:23:29 It's half, it's less than half. And that's, again, that's where my head was with a lot of this. But all right, that's all we got. That was extremely fun. Very, very difficult. Very, very hard. I mean, I just did not think it would be that hard. But again, stacking the positions against each other is really, really tough.
Starting point is 01:23:51 But I feel good about my team. Lindsay, I did end up just picking players that I liked by the end. The fact that I have Stefan Diggs and George Kittle in the middle of this thing. Shouldn't surprise anyone. Yeah, I mean, I think it's just kind of a fun exercise to go through. Like, who do we really like? Who's going to be really good? we're taking the fantasy elements out of it,
Starting point is 01:24:08 which sometimes that gets too, I think it's too much where it's all about like fantasy stats and stuff where it's like, who's going to just destroy games? Who are we going to go and seek out on the all 22? Yep. And we're going to want to do that for a while. And I think that's really fun.
Starting point is 01:24:22 We got some new names in there, I think. And my puppy, Nelly is my undrafted rookie. She is just making her appearance here on podcast. I think she's undrafted. I think she was number one overall pick. She's cute. That's white, I know.
Starting point is 01:24:39 I got midge meowing the door behind me. So a nice little puppy licking your face is a little different. All right. We're going to go play with our pets here, eat some dinner. Really appreciate you guys coming and sticking by us.
Starting point is 01:24:53 Also, please go check out the quarterback version of this if you have not listened to it already. Also, please go check out the offseason interview series that we've been doing if you have not listened to those yet. We had Brad Holmes on a couple weeks ago, the Lions GM.
Starting point is 01:25:05 We had Matt Ryan on this week. So those are conversations that are going to be relevant for a while. So you can take your time with them. But please go check those out. Also, please rate and review the podcast. You guys have been slacking. Go on to Apple, write a review. Give us five stars.
Starting point is 01:25:20 I know it's the offseason, but I need you guys to be vigilant about this kind of stuff. Also, please subscribe to the athletic. Theathletic.com slash football show. Just because it's made, doesn't mean we don't have a ton of great football stuff coming out on the site. I'll be writing weekly over the course of the off season.
Starting point is 01:25:36 I know Lindsay has a lot of good stuff coming out. So please go check that out. We will be back next week. I don't know what we're doing yet. I've got a couple things that I'm kicking around for me and you to do, Nate, but I still haven't landed on anything quite yet. Lindsay, I know you will be joining us plenty over the course of the off season. This was really fun.
Starting point is 01:25:54 Appreciate you guys doing this. Appreciate you guys listening. We'll talk to you later. This was the Athletic Football Show.

There aren't comments yet for this episode. Click on any sentence in the transcript to leave a comment.