The Athletic Football Show: A show about the NFL - One last ride on this year's coaching carousel

Episode Date: February 12, 2026

The wildest coaching carousel any of us can remember finally stopped spinning when the Raiders officially named former Seahawks offensive coordinator Klint Kubiak, fresh off a win in Super Bowl LX, as their new head coach. On this episode of The Athletic Football Show, Robert Mays, Derrik Klassen and Dave Helman cover everything that has happened since our previous ride on the carousel, including Kubiak to the Raiders, Mike LaFleur to the Cardinals, the firing of Kwesi Adofo-Mensah, filling out of various staffs across the league, and a whole lot more.Rundown (timestamps are approximate)7:34 Raiders hire Klint Kubiak28:58 Cardinals hire Mike LaFleur37:18 No black coaches hired despite 10 openings54:25 Kwesi Adofo-Mensah fired as Vikings GM1:05:59 Coordinator movesConnect with The Athletic Football ShowBuy our merch! http://theathletic.lnk.to/tafsmerchYT: https://www.youtube.com/@TAFootballShowPodcasts: https://podfollow.com/the-athletic-football-show/viewX: https://x.com/TA_FootballShowIG: https://www.instagram.com/tafootballshowTikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@tafootballshowDiscord: http://discord.gg/theathleticfootballshowCall us: 847-448-0701Email us: [e-mail]: Robert MaysCo-Hosts: Derrik Klassen and Dave HelmanExecutive Producer: Michael BellerVideo Producer: Katy DuffyAudio Producer: Michael BellerSocial Producer: Scott KrinchFollow Robert on Bluesky: @robertmays.bsky.socialFollow Derrik on Bluesky: @qbklass.bsky.socialFollow Robert on X: @robertmaysFollow Derrik on X: @QBKlassTheme song: HauntedWritten by Dylan Slocum, Trevor Dietrich, Ruben Duarte, Kyle McAulay, and Meredith VanWoert / Performed by Spanish Love SongsCourtesy of Pure Noise / By arrangement with Bank Robber Music, LLC Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

Welcome to the Athletic Football Show. I'm Robert Mays. Kind of our last show looking back on what happened over the last couple weeks. We mentioned this when we were recording with me, Dave and Derek. A lot of stuff happened news-wise during Super Bowl week, even when we were flying to San Francisco that we just didn't have a chance to hit. We had two head coaching hires. Clint Kubiak going to the Raiders, Michael Fleur going to the Arizona Cardinals.

Quasi do Fomento was fired as the GM of the, the Vikings. We had a bunch of coordinator news that's rolled out over the last week. So that's what we spent this entire show talking about. We talked a lot about Clint Kubiak going to the Raiders. It happens when there's only like three or four things to hit. But we wanted to hit all this stuff. We did not want to get to kind of our true offseason coverage and the stuff that's going to be looking forward before we had discussions about the last few dominoes to fall in the coaching cycle.

So really enjoyed this conversation with Dave and Derek. Let's get to it right now. I don't know how you guys are feeling today. but this is a little surreal being back in here after being in San Francisco for a week. Like I just feel like I teleported back home and I've been like transported to back to a different reality. I'm having trouble getting my arms around it. I have the worst case of whiplash right now. Like it's all the all the work and learning and dedication of working through the season.

And we don't even, we're not even at a parade like the Seahawks are out of parade right now. We're just we're here getting ready for 2026, but that's okay. Derek, how you feeling out there? You had like a three-hour drive home. You drove home after the game and slept in your own bed, which is the, I've never been more jealous of another person. Which while I was doing it,

I regretted it. And then as soon as I got back home, I was like, that was the correct decision. Yeah, you fight through with the knowledge that your head will be on your pillow. Like that totally worth it. I was very jealous too. Once you unlock the door, you're like, oh my God, okay, I did it. It was worth it.

But even then it's like, my process of like, okay, I'm going to drive home. It'll give me a little bit more time to like reset. I'm not going to have to wake up on Monday and travel and all that. And I thought the two days would be like a full reset. And I feel like I'm at like 75% going back into it. I came home yesterday because the flights were so crazy on Monday. And so I spent like a solid nine days in San Francisco,

which by the way, lovely time. Like I enjoyed it so much. Here's what I will say about San Francisco and the San Francisco Super Bowl experience. San Francisco is like one of the gems of America as a city. Like everything that it has to offer. Like all the neighborhoods, the cuisine, I mean, just the topography and just how beautiful everything is. Like it is truly one of the great American cities.

It is not a good Super Bowl city. Like I just, I was glad that we got to spend a week there. I do not think it sets up well for the Super Bowl itself. Okay. I will push back a little bit. It could be a great Super Bowl city. And I'm not going to wait into the politics of the region. I'm not educated on it.

But maybe if the stadium was at candlestick point, I don't know. Like if it was where it was for generations, if the stadium was accessible from the actual city of San Francisco, I think it would be pretty badass. I don't know. Maybe next time you need a stadium,

whenever that is, consider building it near the city of San Francisco instead of 50 miles away. I also hate the stadium. It's awful. I hate the stadium. I have pictures that I will, they're very funny.

There was one of Jordan Roderig just standing every single one of us. We were all sitting in the same section. The way that the sun pours into Levi's Stadium, like there is a section of the afternoon. It was only 60 degrees outside, but you're just sitting there, and it feels like you're 10 feet from the sun.

All of us were holding up our roster cards to block the sun during an NFL game. I was like, who built this place? They should be in jail. And lest we sound like whiny sports writers, which we are, But even if like, I know that Niners season ticket holders and people that go to Niners games talk about this. They abhor that place.

Yes. They absolutely do. And so very happy, very privileged to do this job. I was joking all day Sunday. San Francisco, amazing. And other parts of the Bay, too, by the way. I spent some time in Oakland while I was there. I've been to San Jose several times because it's the closest major city to the stadium.

I love everything about the Bay. it's real weird when on Super Bowl Sunday after this week of crescendo you're in an office park 50 miles away at an uninspiring stadium it was not the cap off that the week deserved so get that thing back up to Candlestick Point and I'll go to bat for San Francisco as like

one of the best possible Super Bowl cities Yeah I'm 100% on board with that but not not right now I think my take is that it was a great Super Bowl city for the week, it's a very bad game day Super Bowl. Yes. It's a very, because you didn't have to go to the media availability. Right. That's true.

If you were a writer, covering either of the team, it sucks. You're at a bus for four hours a day. That's not overly enjoyable. The city itself was amazing. I'll do a recap of the food on my Instagram account. I don't have to go through it all here, but I had 10 crazy good meals. You guys were there for a couple of them, but I ate extremely well in San

Francisco. I could do a podcast on how much I loved San Francisco. We don't have to right now, but very, very nice. Before we turn the page to truly like 2026 offseason stuff, before we get into pre-combine coverage, before we even start talking, I know you guys been doing on Building the Beast, before we really start looking at the draft, I wanted to do one more show about some of the news that happened over the last couple weeks, because like we said, we were in San Francisco, we're doing all of these Super Bowl podcasts, we're talking about the game itself. There were some things that happened, we just didn't have a chance to get to. Two head coaches got hired, I believe, since the last time we talked about any coaching news. One general manager got fired,

and we've had plenty of coordinator news come out over the last week or so. And so I wanted to do one more show before we hit our typical biggest questions of the offseason podcast that we do at the Friday of every Super Bowl week before we fully moved on to the stuff that's going to be looking ahead. So let's dig into that. Let's start with the man who coached in the Super Bowl. And even though we all knew it. He had to like confirm it after the game was over that he was going to be coaching the Raiders. Clint Kubiak officially introduced as the head

coach of the Las Vegas Raiders. We haven't really talked about this in terms of like the quality of the hire or what you think of it. We've just kind of been like, oh yeah, Clint Kubiak is the coach of the Raiders. So let's sit in this for a second. What do you think about Clint Kubiak and the fit with Las Vegas? I think my main impression is

it's cool that the Raiders bit off the play caller and offensive coordinator for the Super Bowl champions. And I saw this somewhere well before it was official, but when it was starting to really look likely that Kubiak was going to be higher, probably right around the time Tom Brady couldn't stop talking about him during the NFC title game. This was the first time the Raiders have made this sort of higher, like a high-level

assistant from the Super Bowl participant Super Bowl champion since they got Mike Shanahan in, I think, 1989 coming off San Francisco and that ended in disaster. But I think it's... The last play car, they hired Gruden, which is obviously a very different thing. Yes, yeah. But coming off of like a Super Bowl team. And so I just think it speaks to

the relative attractiveness of the Raiders job compared to what it's been over most of the last like 20, 25 years. Like you have the number one pick. You're going to be able to take a quarterback that most people would be excited to work with. I think Tom Brady lends some gravitas and some credibility to that organization that has badly needed it for a while. And pairing Fernando Mendoza with a guy that was able to get this out of Sam Darnold and get the Seahawks offense to where it was in short order. And again, this was an offense that a lot of people were not in love with heading into the season.

I think that's very exciting. It was essentially down to the Raiders and the Cardinals. He probably could have had his choice of either of those. and I'm not surprised you'd rather be the head coach of the Raiders. Very objectively, isn't that right? Yeah, I think that the pathway to a quarterback is the most important part of this because I think there are a lot of similarities otherwise.

You've had two organizations that have struggled to be successful. I think we have ownership questions in both places. I think the Raiders would probably like to tell you that Tom Brady blunts some of that with his presence there, but I don't think we have enough evidence that he's good at this with the people in charge of the Raiders or steering this thing in a positive direction. The main difference in my mind, Derek,

is that access to a quarterback is a factor in whether guys want these jobs. And if you're taking the Raiders job right now, you have pretty clear cut access to a quarterback. They're the only team in the draft that's going to get clear cut access to a quarterback. I do think, and obviously, I don't think the Raiders roster was as bad

as it probably showed last year. I think like Clint Kubiak coming in can potentially make the offensive line a little bit better. But I do think the Cardinals roster outside of quarterback is, it's a lot more attractive to me. And I think a lot closer to to being competitive than the Raiders is. The Raiders have a couple of stars, but they're probably going to lose Max Crosby or he's at least towards the end. The defense needs like nine new pieces. And outside of like Brock Bowers and Ashton Gentie, you have a lot of work to do on the offense.

Like I think the Cardinals roster is closer and they were just in a very weird spot last year. They were also incredibly banged up on defense. Yeah, I don't, I don't disagree with that. Like, I think that Cardinals probably do have more talent across the roster. I'm not sure it's like measurably different though. Not only that, I would probably put them like a tier higher. I would. But, but then when you get the fact that you actually get a quarterback instead of being like saddled with 45 million dollars of Kyler Murray, that's not even going to be on your team. I do think that tips the scales a little bit. They have more usable pieces on defense. I think that I think that's fair. Like the young corners, you still. Especially if they're healthy.

Like there's a chunk of defensive alignment. I think that's right. I think that's right. I think that's probably right. I think on defense there is more talent. But I'm not sure when I would stack up the two rosters, there's enough of a talent disparity in favor of the Cardinals for me to be like, I'd rather have this job wandering into quarterback purgatory than taking the Raiders job. I think in the spirit of the word, like of the spirit of what you're saying, you are right. But who cares if the Raiders have the number one overall pick in the draft in a year where there's a quarterback worth taking? And yeah, like the Cardinals have a better roster, probably.

but what does that mean if you're venturing into the wilderness or trying to run it back with Kyler Murray? I guess we'll see what happens there. Also, Max Crosby is not even 29 yet. And so either you're going to have him at playing at a high level for I would guess several more years or if he's hell bent on not being there for this, he's a very valuable piece of trade bait. So the Cardinals might win if you played in week 18. That doesn't mean anything to me. Like I would so very much rather be coaching the Raiders right now than the Cardinals. The Max Crosby thing we'll dig into on Friday when we do our biggest offseason questions because obviously that's going to be one of the bigger trade dominoes to fall.

I want to talk a little bit more about what you said about the offensive line, Derek, and the way that we think he can maximize some of these pieces. My first thought when he was an attractive candidate, when he was getting interview requests from every single one of these teams, when he essentially had his pick of these two jobs at the end, I think in a lot of ways, Clint Kubiak's relative attractiveness in this cycle is a signal about the cycle itself. There just weren't that many offensive coaches in this group where people were like,

oh yeah, we got to bang down the door to go get this person. I mean, if you look at the offensive coaches who are hired here, we have Michael Floor who will get to, you have 60-something-year-old Todd Monkin, you have Kevin Cefansky as a retread, you have Mike McCarthy as a retread, and you have Joe Brady who would not be the head coach

of any other team. Right? I mean, he wouldn't have gotten any of these other jobs if he wasn't hired by the bills. would be my guess. And so this is the thing. I understand why the Raiders hired Clint Kubiak. And I think, I think it's very easy to be like, oh, well, this team just won the Super Bowl and Sam Darnold played incredibly well. It's got to be a great hire. And I think it can be fine. But like, I'm just not nearly as excited about this as I was like Liam Cohen last year or obviously Ben Johnson. And that's not to say that it can't work out. But it does feel to your point, like a lot more representative of the cycle

where people are kind of hiring offensive guys almost no matter what. And so I feel like that's kind of says a lot. The fact that Kubiak had not been all that successful until this year, and obviously this year went well. And there were times where the Seahawks offense looked great. But in the aggregate, they were not a special offense. They were fine and better than they should have been. But it's not like it was like watching the Detroit Lions offense or anything like that or even the bucks. I think they were less talented than either of those teams.

Of course. And I do think that's an important consideration. So I, in my like longstanding viewpoint where I want the play calling offensive head coach, I just think when you look at the percentages. And I know Mike McDonald just won the Super Bowl. This is a percentages thing. This is a like if you look at the history of what has happened in the NFL over the last 10 years and who is consistently playing in the conference champion on championship Sunday,

offensive coaches make up a lot of that pool. And some of that is self-selecting. We don't have to get into all of that. But this is, I have this viewpoint for a reason. My little like, okay, which the boxes that I want checked, typically when I say, right, the seeking out the play calling coordinators to be your head coach, the two things that I usually look at, did you do it without an elite quarterback, right?

If you have a top five, like this is the Mike McCoy corollary. If you do it with Peyton Manning, like it's not as impressive to me as if you do it with, I love Jared Goff, but Jared Goff is very different than Peyton Manning if we're talking about Ben Johnson. And the other part of it is, and I think if you look at the hit rate historically,

that's one element. And the other element is, did you do it for multiple years? Did you do it for like multiple years in a row where you had a high level offense without an elite quarterback. And that's why to me, Ben Johnson was like, I'm doing this. Like, it may fail, but I'm doing this every single time.

Liam Cohen did not check the second box. He only did it for a year. Clint Kubiak, I think, is kind of closer to the Liam Cohen mold, but that worked. And so I understand chasing it. I just think this is a reminder that you're going to have to start cutting corners and making compromises with some of these offensive candidates because the pool was a little bit thinner. But I understand them going this direction.

I just think these are in perfect guys. when you think about the resumes you want to hire to be your head coach. I mean, that's a theme for this coaching cycle, isn't it? Like, outside of John Harbaugh, I guess, who the Giants identified quickly, and it was like very obvious they were going to make that happen. And by the way, you can come up with plenty of arguments against hiring John Harbaugh. Sure can. That's the closest thing to like a slam dunk.

And that is a guy who was fired by his team, an older coach who was fired by his team, whose Ravens teams have taken a lot of flack for not getting over the hump. Like there just wasn't a Ben Johnson in this coaching cycle. And so it's funny, I think that raises the question of, and I'm sure we'll get into it here, but is it worth going offense by hook or by crook at the expense of maybe a more qualified, more experienced, defensive or CEO type of coach?

In this very specific circumstance with the Raiders, they're going to draft Fernando Mendoza. I am very interested in tying my future of the franchise quarterback who's going to be there for at least four or five years to a play calling head coach. If it doesn't work, that sucks. But the upside is high enough that I think it's worth pursuing even with an imperfect candidate like Kubiak. I don't think we've reached the point where fishing these waters is the wrong move yet. Like Liam Cohen, I think we're recconning a little bit the quality of candidate we thought Liam Cohen was. If he didn't get the Jags job, he would not be the head coach of a team right now.

He would be the Bucks offensive coordinator. He tried to go back to Tampa. Like he forced the Jags hand by saying he would go back to Tampa. And it worked. It worked like gangbusters. Like so far, that is a very good hire. And so I tend to agree with you. I think this was the cycle where if you wanted to go the other way, it would be worthwhile.

But for the Raiders specifically, I do understand it, Derek. I haven't watched much of Fernando Mendoza. You have watched much more of him. In terms of like the system itself and the way he fits within the offense, I saw him say on McAfee that their play action system at Indiana was very similar to what the Shanahan-McVey teams do. So there seems to be some shared DNA as to how this can work, but how do you see it working? I just think, and you're going to hear this a lot, and this always happens where, like, Fernando Mendoza is not Caleb Williams or Trevor Lawrence in terms of like the quality of prospect. that doesn't mean he's not worth taking number one overall

and that doesn't mean you can't put a good offense and a good team around him. He is absolutely worth being excited about drafting number one overall. His arm is perfectly fine. He's a very accurate passer. Indiana does a lot of fun stuff with play action. He is gritty. It's so cool because this has been his game forever,

but it's so cool that he converted that fourth down in the national title game while everyone was watching. Because you can just be like, see, he's been doing this here, but now everyone knows that this is on his skill set. He's not to compare him to another Cal guy, because that's where he started out. He's not Jared Goff.

Like, he's not a statue back there. He can do, we talked about it a couple weeks ago with the mobility and the athleticism required of a quarterback these days. He is that guy. I absolutely would be excited. I think Clint Kubiak can build a very fun offense around him. I think some of the stuff that Kubiak's known for with play action and

things like that can be very fun. And that's why I'm not, Dana and I did this a month or two ago where I was like, should we entertain the idea that the Raiders trade down or try to get creative with it? Absolutely not. Yeah, I'm out on that. Mendoza's going to be the first overall pick. We can just write that in stone right now. I'm very confident. Yeah. Just think Derek about all the teams that wish they had a clear path to a quarterback this off season and like the idea that if you trade this away yeah in theory like you can get the hall at the hall is like door number two is not more attractive to me even if fernetto mendoza is an imperfect prospect i think you do this every single time there are very few

quarterback classes where if you have the first overall pick you would want to trade the trade the pick like that either means the quarterback like there are no quarterbacks and like there is no for nano mendoza or there are like five of them that could be potentially really good but even then wouldn't you want your pick of all of them? Like, it doesn't really make any sense to trade out of the first overall pick like that. I mean, I think the time where it did was before the 2024 draft class, when you knew the following year, Drake May and Caleb Williams were going to come out in the draft, exactly like the Bears did. And even that required a lot of luck because the Panthers were so bad that they didn't have to do any sort of maneuvering to get the number one overall pick. And also, I mean,

bad timing for this conversation, but we were nowhere near as consensusly sold on C.A. Jay Stroud at the time. No. No. And so I think that there are some differences there. From a staff perspective and kind of how I could see this working, I forgot my laptop at home, if you guys need to know how far deep into the offseason we already are. And so am I trying to get by on my iPad right now. From a staff perspective in account of the areas of the offense we want lifted, I'm curious what happens with John Benton specifically. He is the offensive line coach for the Seahawks. He was with the Saints when Kloon Kupiac was there. He is only the offensive line coach. Rick Denison is actually their running.

game coordinator, which Rick Denison has been working with a Kubiak doing that stuff for about 25 years now. So in theory, I think if they offered him a promotion, it wouldn't be a lateral move. He would be able to take a job like that because I think the first thing that needs to happen beyond Fernando Mendoza, Derek, is what happens with this offensive line. And I think this is the second year in a row where Kluen Kubiak is going to be coming in trying to fix a team who bottomed out offensively because their offensive line. The ecosystem around it was just so not conducive to success that they had to re-reliqubiak

that they had to remake it entirely. And so I think even if they, I said the same thing about the Seahawks last year, even if the Raiders tried out the same five guys along the offensive line this year with Kubiak and whoever the offensive line coach ends up being, they will be better. They also have $90 million in cap space

to sign one to two new starters if they want to. And I have to assume that'll be part of the strategy. And that, if anything, is the argument for hiring Clint Kubiak is that if he takes you from like, I'm just throwing out numbers here. Let's say talent-wise, the Raiders offensive line is 25th. best in the league, but because of some of the coaching, because of the ecosystem, they played

like the 30th. If you can just get them to play like the 21st and get back up a little bit to their level, the same way he raised like, it's not like Seattle's offensive line this year, kicked ass. They were just like 5% better than they needed to be. And that was really all that it amounted to. And so if they can do that with the Raiders, you add that on top of quarterback play that is, I don't know if Mendoza is going to immediately be better than Gino-Smith. but if the offensive line is better and you keep Bowers healthy,

you keep Genty healthy, like the offensive could be, the offense could be fine. They probably still need a receiver, but it can be fine. Talking myself into the Raiders already. Like, I just got done.

I don't know if I can do it again. I just got done being painfully wrong about them being fun to watch this year. Were they on your Winspool team? They were on Derek's one. Maybe that's why Derek's not into it. All three of us were like, the Raiders will be a fun seven and ten team. And they were the worst team in the NFL.

by an uncomfortable margin, but I'm ready to sign back up. I'm curious who the defensive coordinator will be, whether it's somebody off that Seahawks staff. Carl Scott, who is their passing game coordinator, has been, he was on Pete Carroll staff before Mike McDonald kept him. He's somebody that, his background's really interesting. He was at Alabama for a few years, and then he was with Zimmer in Minnesota for a couple seasons,

maybe just one, and then went to Seattle with Pete Carroll when Pete was trying to kind of differentiate some of the things they were doing on the back end, and then McDonald kept him. and then I knew there were some head coaching candidates this year who when they were trying to build their staffs, he was somebody that they had potentially in mind to be a defensive coordinator. So that would be one name I would watch.

Other kind of like, let's play the name game about how this could work and who we should pay attention to. Clint Kubiak all season, I don't think he was at the top of mind for a lot of people as a head coaching candidate just because, I don't know, you watch Clint Kubiak's opening press conference. He is not the most dynamic personality in the world.

And I think we should be learning to look past some of that stuff. Mike McDonald is not an orator. And what Mike McDonald just did is really impressive. And I think that the moment that when Clint said after, I think it was during that press conference, which I really appreciated was that Mike would come in on Mondays

and like Clint would be nervous about that conversation because he was going to grill him about what worked and what didn't. Like you can build a great program without being somebody who's giving a lot of boisterous speeches. But I think Clint is a pretty reserved guy for the most part. And I was talking to somebody that knows him as we were thinking about the coaching cycle. And I was just asking guys that you think are similar that have had success that maybe could command a team in the room in the same way that he could. And the two names that came up were first,

his dad, who is also not like the most exciting personality in the world and Matt LaFleur. Like that was one of the conversations about Matt LaFleur before he got these jobs. And so I do think there's a path to success if you aren't somebody who is going to be talking and operating like Sean McVeigh. But Clint Kubiak would definitely be one of those people who does it in a slightly different way. Really quickly, the Malifler one is actually interesting because he's kind of fiery now. So it's kind of interesting that that was like the talk about him going into it because he seems like it. It was actually fun. Maliflu's the one that said like you have to wake up with your piss hot, right? Yeah. I could follow that. To the person who said this to me, I said back a very similar thing.

And words that it may not repeat on the show, but I was like, Matt has an edge to him that I wonder if Clint Kubiak has. But it seems like you don't have to be a dickhead to create that. right in the same way that Mike McDonald on Mondays was like we're going to figure this out what are you guys doing offensively like you can create urgency without necessarily being somebody who's like yelling at people and so I'll be very interested to see how this works out because I've been pretty vocal over the last couple weeks about how we should seek out potentially different personality types to be these head coaches this is going to test that theory so I'll be curious to see how this works out all right before we get to the other head coaching hire from last week let's take a quick break the last coaching dominant to fall before the Clint Kubiak hire, Mike Lefleur headed to the Arizona Cardinals to be their head coach. You're already like champing at the bit over there? Well, it did, it happened before the Kubiak hire,

but it coincidentally happened like an hour after word got out that Kubiak did the Cardinals know. Like the Cardinals pivoted with a quickness that made me laugh. Like they had Mike LaFleur's number entered into speed dial if or when they got rejected. And so what that tells me, the fact that it was Clint Kuback and Michael Fleur were the two options, Derek. This is very similar.

We wanted an offensive guy. These were the last offensive guys on the offensive guy tree. And even if Michael Fleur may not have been the most top of the list candidate, even though he's the offensive coordinator for the Rams, if you're going to go offense, this is the type of guy that you were going to seek out. I'm sure you watched more of the Michael Flur Jets offense than you ever cared to. So how do you feel about this?

he was not that bad as the offensive play caller with the Jets. Obviously those offenses were terrible because the quarterback play was disgusting in the offensive line still wasn't very good. But like I just and this is not to say like Lefleur was secretly cooking and he was like ahead of something when he was the Jetsos offensive coordinator. But I just didn't watch those offenses and feel like they were hamstringing the quarterback or not using their talent correctly. It felt like a passable version of this like Shanahan Kubiak style of offense.

and so how much of that he can improve on, I think will be interesting. Because what's interesting to me is that he started his NFL career in 2014 with Kyle Shanahan on the Browns. And he was a Shanahan guy up until obviously Robert Sala goes to the Jets. He follows him there. And then once he leaves there, then he spends three years with Sean McVeigh, who is like, obviously it's all related. It's a lot of same DNA.

It's different enough, though. This is a really important point. Especially now with Stafford, right? Like if it was during the Jared Gough area, I would have been like, eh, all that stuff was sort of close enough. But I think obviously having more of a depth in the passing game with what it had been with Matthew Stafford, more of the dropback game, a lot more interesting, like empty stuff. Even the run game now being a lot more like duo and like some of the windback counter and stuff like that. I do think hopefully we see some of that added to his repertoire.

So I'm interested to see what it looks like in terms of what he's trying to put the offense together. Obviously it's been a while since he's actually called plays. It's been Sean McVeigh doing it over there in L.A. but I'm at least like for where the Cardinals were at in this in this cycle like doing it so late like again I don't know if this hire necessarily jazzes me but it's like kind of it's it's inoffensive to me I understand the process of it. It is in offensive to me but that in turn kind of makes it offensive to me and what what I mean by that is it it just kind of feels like you've called plays your name's Lafleur and you've been hanging out with Sean McVay get over here. Well, let's see where this can go. It just kind of gets back to what we're saying at the top, though. Like, that's where we're at with the offensive coaches.

If you want an offensive coach, those are the types of guys you're hiring. Do you think teams call, like, how much do they vet like McVeigh and LaFleur when this stuff happens? Like, hey, do you think this is a good idea? Like, what do you feel about the time that he's spent in your building? I think there's probably some of that, yes. It's not to say, and it's similar to Kubiak, it's not to say that he can't be good or that he's not a good coach, but the, uh, the, the process feels uninteresting to me where it's just like, okay, who's got the right title on the right coaching staff and like what they've

actually accomplished feels almost secondary to me? I don't know if I agree with that. Okay. If you, okay, if you just remove the fact that he's Michael Fleur and like, I don't, I think that some of the stuff around Michael Flores that, like, I don't know, he presents as, like, you know, maybe it's a little bit, I don't know the right framing and the right phrase to use around this. Presents maybe like a little bit broy.

He's a little bit, he feels like a little bit young, right? Like, even like up at the press conference, just like, this looks like almost a caricature of like this, the young offensive coach in the NFL. And so maybe there's something a little bit about that. He was the Rams offensive coordinator for three years. Like, he was the offensive coordinator of what we all agree. to be like the most innovative and forward-thinking offense in the NFL. And this is not fair.

It's not fair because Kyle Shanahan was the one who, you know, they asked him about letting Clay Kubiak, the other Kubiak interview for play calling OC jobs. And he was like, he calls plays for us. Like, why would I let my offensive coordinator go? And that's been a Kyle Shanahan thing for a long time, by the way. It is not fair to assume that Michael Flores not doing anything. but he works with Sean McVeigh. So how you divvy that up gets complicated

when you're not on the inside. Yeah, he's not a play caller, but we've had non-play calling offensive coordinators get some of these jobs, again, if you're trying to like make compromises about what offensive candidates get hired. And so if we're going to be open to the idea of hiring non-play calling offensive coordinators

to be offensive coaches, somebody who just spent three years as the offensive coordinator for the Rams is objectively like an okay person to hire for one of these jobs. I also think the last hire felt to me like more uninspired and lazy just picking like and again, maybe Jonathan Gannickett worked out, but just being like, oh, the defensive coordinator from the Super Bowl team, sure, rip it. Like that to me actually felt a little bit lazier.

And then the last time they tried to be interesting before that they hired Cliff Kingsbury who I like the college thing, like the offense just didn't make any sense. Like I'm weirdly okay with them kind of taking what feels like a very vanilla answer here. There is a problem with this. There's a significant problem with this line of thinking that we're going to talk about in like, eight minutes. So we were going to get into that in a second. But when it comes to the way that teams think about this, and if you're like, I'm going offense, that is, and I've said this many times, there are organizations that think that way because of just the numbers and the history and the

results that have come along with it over the last 10 to 15 years, there are teams that are like, I'm hiring an offensive mind head coach. And if that's what you're doing, these are the types of guys that you're going to land with. It is a valid point that he was part of one of the most successful offenses in the league over the last few years. But, and it goes back to the same thing we said about Kubiak where is, and I mean, if you're hell bent on doing offense, then you're hell bent on doing offense. But do you have so much tunnel vision that you are ignoring either more qualified candidates, certainly, or a more outside the box candidate that could be equally good, if not better?

Potentially. Yes. And I just, but again, I think that if you're, if you're going to go offense, like this is where we reached with the pool. Nathaniel Hackett is going to be the offensive coordinator there. I know that people are probably going to snicker at that. We've seen him do this job well before. The Packers had some of the best offenses in football when he was the offensive

coordinator. Being the offensive coordinator for a play calling head coach is a different job than being the offensive coordinator where you were the play caller. We have so much evidence of this. It's an administrative job. It's an organizational job and it's one that Nathaniel Hackett has done well in the past. So I can understand landing there. And it's also like familiarity with obviously he worked with Matt LaFle for a while.

Like I, again, it's probably not the most inspired thing, but I understand it. Aubrey Pleasant is one of the names interviewing to be the defensive coordinator, not the least bit surprising. He's been, he went to Detroit, got fired there in Detroit as like the DB's coach, which that was kind of a strange thing. But he was welcome back to the Rams very quickly. He's been a prominent member of that Rams coaching staff as like the DB's coach and passing game coordinator. So completely understand why he is in the mix there. We'll talk a lot more about the Cardinals Outlook and the Cardinals' quarterback situation on the show we're doing on Friday

because obviously when we talk about the quarterback carousel, Kyler is going to be heavily involved there. So we will sit with that discussion when we get to that Friday show. So the problem with we're just defaulting to the offensive coach, one of the problems that comes along with that is one of the discussion points that have happened and come up since these 10 seats were filled. We leave this coaching cycle with 10 high. with zero black head coaches.

And after losing Rahim Morris and Mike Tomlin from that group after this season, we are now down to, I believe, three, correct? Todd Bowles, D'Amico Ryans. And Aaron Glenn. And Aaron Glenn. Who, like, truthfully feels kind of like pre-fired in a way. Yes, and he feels pre-fired. And so we're now down to three guys.

And so there's been a lot of talk about how this happens. It's a lot of stuff that we've discussed. many, many times over the years when it comes to the efficiency of the Rooney Rule, the effectiveness of the Rooney Rule, is any of this stuff working? The way that I see this is that it boils down to two distinct problems that are affecting everything at the same time. The first one is that we have seen the fact that the league continues to want offensive coaches.

Even in this cycle where we felt like it might swing back the other way a little bit, we had 10 guys hired, we had six offensive coaches hired, Kubiak-Lefloor, Mankin, Stafansky, McCarthy, Joe Brady. We had three defensive coaches hired. Halfley, Salaminter, one CEO head coach hired and John Harbaugh. That is right in line with the current makeup of the rest of the head coaching pool. Right now we have 19 offensive head coaches. And some of them call plays, some of them don't.

But even like with Stifansky, Tommy Reese is going to call plays. Matt Ryan said to me at the Super Bowl, one of the appealing parts of us Kevin Sifansky is if Tommy Reese gets hired away, Kevin Stefansky can just become a play caller. And so the same mindset applies to these guys who are quote unquote CEO type out coaches that are offensive guys. The issue with this is that when you have all of these

offensive coaches getting hired, the pipeline and the just available coaches on offense that are black to get these jobs is just a different, it looks very different than it does for defensive coaches. And some people are going to push back on that. And they're going to say it's not a pipe. flight issue. And I'm not saying there aren't enough talented coaches on that side of the ball that deserve these coordinator roles and eventually get head coaching roles. They're just not getting

them. Like there is a bottleneck before these guys become coordinators and that is what is the problem. If you look at the way that the rules have changed, right, we need two minority interviews for offensive coordinator jobs and defensive coordinator jobs. And you need one minority interview for the quarterback coach job and you need at least one black coach on your staff. Those are the rules that were put in place in 2022. We have seen progress made there because of those rules in small ways. If you look at it, there are 10 combined passing game coordinators and quarterback coaches that are black in the league.

There are 10 of them total. So you have about a third of the league that has guys in these roles on their staffs. The problem is none of them are becoming coordinators. None of them. We had 17 new offensive play callers hired in this cycle. 17. 11 of them as OCs, no black offensive coordinators. And Eric Bienemy was hired as an offensive coordinator, but obviously he is not going to be the play caller for the chiefs.

And so that is the problem. If we're going to keep going offense, offense, offense, and we have no black offensive coordinators because guys are getting stuck in these quarterback coach and passing game coordinator roles, you're going to continue to perpetuate this issue. And so this is the thing. It still is a pipeline issue.

And like people, again, like there are coaches who are in those roles who could be promoted or could be hired away into those roles. But if it's not happening at all and that like we can say, oh, the rules are the rules and guys are getting chances. But again, if none of them are being hired, then it doesn't really matter. And I think another part of this that I find interesting is that a lot of guys on offenses, a lot of either offensive coordinators, play callers, head coaches, whatever, a lot of them will get hired away without having been NFL players.

It oftentimes like black head coaches or play callers, even on the, the defensive side of the ball are former NFL players. The three in the league right now, D'emico Ryan's, Todd Bulls, Aaron Glenn, all former longtime players with a lot of the white coaches and offensive coaches that get hired away. That is just not really a prerequisite. And so I think that that is part of the issue as well. It absolutely is. And there's a double standard involved here in a lot of different ways.

I think to me, it's even more drastic on the defensive side, which we can get into in a second. But it absolutely exists on the offensive side as well. defensive side for sure like looking over it it's wild but particularly on on the offensive side of the ball what you said so by my math

so there's Eric B. enemy and then there's David Shaw Nate Sheelhouse it's David Shaw and Nate Shieldhouse Thomas Brown Marcus Brady is the past game coordinator for the Ravens now Brian Johnson I believe is still the

past game coordinator for Washington and then the quarterbacks coaches Israel Wolf Fork just got hired to be the quarterback's coach for the Ravens. Ashton Grant is the Patriots quarterback's coach. Gerard Johnson is the Texans quarterback's coach. DJ Williams is now in Washington. He was in Atlanta. And then J.T. Barrett is the Bears quarterback's coach.

So it's those 10. By my match is looking at the staffs. I might be missing somebody. This is purely anecdotal. But you can go look at NFL staffs all over the league. And just from my time covering the NFL, BINME is like the big. most famous example, but if there is a pipeline issue, like the number of guys moving,

particularly from like running backs coach and receivers coach into bigger jobs just feels non-existent to me. And like there are some younger guys getting moved into passing game and running game coordinator roles. But the number of like career receivers coaches or running backs coaches that just kind of get stuck there. is very interesting to me. And I think that was part of the thinking when they changed the rules is that they wanted more black coaches

to be touching the quarterback position and allowing them to have maybe upper mobility to these roles. And that second thing just hasn't happened. And that's ultimately what this comes down to. You need to be willing to hire people, you need to have people in these hiring roles that are doing the hiring that are willing to make these decisions.

Like until they're willing to do it, you can put as many machinations in place as you want to. And to me, that is no more evident than it is on the defensive side of the ball. Like, I get how we arrive where we are with the offense and how the specific problems have contributed to this. On defense, it's like, what are the excuses? Like, if you look at the defensive coaches hired in this cycle, Jesse Minter, completely understand it. We are in the Mike McDonald era.

Jesse Minter is a phenomenal defensive coordinator. Like, every single bit of that is justified. That is the interesting thing. There are at least a few, there are a few hires in this cycle where you're just like, okay, that makes sense. Jesse Menner being one of them, John Harbaugh being one of them, I'd probably throw Stefansky in there as well, where I think that's part of it. But by and large,

when you have 10 openings, the problem there is all 10, you know, like even if a handful of them makes sense. Well, the problem for me is, it's just tougher for me to justify, like, why Jeff Halfley is more deserving of a job right now

than, like, Patrick Graham would be over, like, what he's done as a defensive coordinator, I just don't really understand that. Like, Jeff Afflead did a solid job with the Packers for two years. That's what happened. And he might be a really good head coach. And I think there are elements of who he is that are appealing. But, like, I just don't understand why his resume is more attractive than somebody like Patrick Graham.

And like, with Sala, I understand that Sala probably deserves another shot. Why does Sala have to sit out for one year as a defensive coordinator when Brian Flores and Vance Joseph are doing what they're doing? Like, why? That to me is the issue where I get the offense thing and how we've arrived there, even if there are problems that need to be addressed. The defense thing, like, it's hard to justify or argue for, in my opinion. How about Anthony Weaver? Yeah, Anthony Weaver is like with the other name I was going to mention with Patrick Graham.

And DeNard Wilson, too, like guys that had a piece of the 2023 Ravens defense and they go on to other jobs and do a good job. Weaver in particular, you want to talk about like being inspired by listening to a guy talk. holy shit. And I'm happy for him that he landed in Baltimore where I hopefully will have one of these opportunities. I would guess he's going to get a look based on how I feel about the Ravens organization and their roster.

But that's one that stands out to you where you're like, man. And I know, like, he interviewed for some jobs, but you look at it and you're just like, that feels funny to me that this guy didn't get a closer look. And the Flores thing obviously has its own complications. But like at this point, we're in a place where we've seen what really good. defensive first coaches can do for you if you have the right guy on that side of the ball. And who is more of the right guy than him if it's not like McDonald at this point? That's the thing. If we're doing this whole thing of like if you have to make the exception for

defensive coaches that they are going to be like league shifting like really on the front, the front foot, obviously McDonald and some of his guys, that totally makes sense. The other guy is Brian Flores. Like it is objectively Brian Flores the way that he's brought some of his pressures, the way that we talked about this, I think even early not this. season, but last season, like, all of the two high pressures that people are bringing is a lot of Brian Flores stuff. Like, if you are trying to be on the front foot of defense and not picking from the McDonald tree, it is Brian Flores. Another thing that I think is interesting. I went through, and it's a little tricky right now because not every coaching staff is finalized. Some teams wait until

everybody's hired to make the formal announcements. But if you go through and look, we just talked about guys on the offensive side of the ball getting elevated. That's even, less of a problem on the defensive side of the ball, there is like a bottleneck of guys with coordinator in the title. So not defensive coordinator, defensive play caller, but I went through and looked, there are 16 coaches in the NFL with coordinator in their title on the defensive side of the ball who don't call plays.

And then there's another, and then there's also eight that have assistant or associate head coach in the title, which to me says, you are valued by your organization enough to get promoted enough to where you can't be poached or somebody promoted you as a way of poaching you. Antoine Randall comes to mine right here in Chicago. Ben Johnson valued him so much that he gave him an assistant head coach title to get him to Chicago from Detroit. But a lot of these guys kind of get left there after that. And that's not a criticism of Ben Johnson or the Bears specifically, but you see guys like this all over the league

where it's like, okay, you've been promoted to a certain level, and then it just kind of feels like guys get stuck there. Ultimately, I think it just comes down to the fact that the people in these positions that are making the hiring look at somebody like Jeff Halfley as a head coach, while they don't look at some of the black defensive coordinators who've done even better job than him as head coaches. And that's a problem. And I think going back to something like the Hackett hire, for example,

that is where that familiarity thing to me becomes the biggest issue, where there should be people maybe, that are more deserving of being elevated into these roles, getting some of these roles that aren't because there is like, well, I know that guy, and so let's just bring him in here to be part of the support staff. We need to be taking chances on different people. That goes back to Myla Fleur thing.

And I think people get lost in the weeds or even angry when this conversation comes up because maybe we're suggesting this is something nefarious. Like, don't talk to the black guy. Like, that is not even remotely what I am suggesting. but in the instance of like a Mike Lafleur, look at and they're victims of their own success. I get it.

But the McVeigh tree, the Shanahan tree, Matt LaFleur, and the way that it has branched out to the point where this coaching tree of guys who all know and like each other work in half the buildings in the league, if not more than that. And so nothing nefarious is going on.

I mean, Sean McVeigh help. It is perpetuating it though. There's no denying that. Sean McVeigh helped Raheem Morris get the Falcons job. Kyle Shanahan identified an Eleanor. and elevated to Miko Ryans. Like, it is not nefarious, but when you have this...

Those are both defensive coaches, though. They are, right? That is a valid point. And but this boys, it feels like a boys club, and that has a negative connotation, but it could be as easy as like, oh yeah,

I've worked with him for five years. He's great. And he is part of the way we do things. And that is attractive to teams who see the success that the Rams and the 49ers and the Packers and all these teams have had. And it starts to perpetuate

on itself. And like I said, you just get tunnel vision on who is the most qualified Sean McVeigh endorsed guy when there's 19 other ways you could do this if you wanted to. And to me, that's why it's like it's two different sets of problems, right? Like because I think some people look at the Michael Flewyer and they will say, how is he a more qualified head coaching candidate that somebody like Vance Joseph? And I think that's where you have to look at it two different ways. You have to say, well, they're going offense first. And so that is an entirely different set of problems than Vance Joseph not getting a head. head coaching job.

Because I think the more, the biggest issue there is, why isn't Vance Joseph getting a job over somebody like Jeff Hathley? Like that, that's why I would take it with two kind of different

separate conversations and talking to people about it, that's kind of the feel I have for it. My only pushback on that would be if you set out from day one, like we want an offensive coach, well, you've just eliminated a shitload of valuable,

like viable candidates. And even if that is, Even if that's what you think you want, you might meet the guy that just knocks your socks off and blows you away if you do a more thorough process. That's the argument for why the Rooney Rule exists. Yeah, absolutely. You will get surprised by people. I mean, that's how Tomlin got in the door initially with the Steelers. It just doesn't happen that often.

And I think that's the issue. It probably should. And that's why people roll their eyes at the performative Rooney Rule interviews so much where it's like, are we checking boxes or are we looking at, everything here. And I know that's easier said than done and I feel like I'm picking on Michael Fleur. Maybe he's going to be awesome. But if you set out with like an archetype in mind, then of course you're going to land on that type of coach, whereas there's no shortage of qualified guys that you could be very impressed by if you got in a room with them. That's why the offensive coaching pool needs to, the makeup of it needs to change. If we're going

to have these teams that go offense first, then the types of guys you're seeking out that are part of those trees. Like, that is what needs to change. And unless those guys start getting elevated to some of these roles, it's not going to change. Like Nathan Shieldhouse, hopefully we'll get a head coaching job and will be elevated to be the offensive coordinator for the Rams. And hopefully that will help spur something on that is not happening right now.

All right. We're going to take one more quick break and then come back with a few more little bits of news that we wanted to hit. One more thing that we didn't get a chance to talk about last week. It happened, like, as we were flying to San Francisco, essentially, Quasi Adolfo Menza fired as the general manager of the Minnesota Vikings. The timing on it is obviously the surprising part of this. The fact that he was fired when he was at the Senior Bowl doing his job.

If this had happened after the season, I don't think anybody would have been that shocked by it. I think that there had been some tension in that building. So many people have talked about this. Alec Lewis and Diana wrote a story about it. I think the timing is what surprised people. But Derek, when you saw that he was out and when you saw some, some of the conversation in the aftermath after he was fired. What were your initial reactions to this?

I have a few thoughts. First of all, the timing is very, it's a reminder that NFL owners and front offices just don't want to be embarrassed. And this very much felt like, oh, Sam Darnold is making the deep run. Like, I don't know if that was like, that's obviously not the only reason he's fired. But if they needed something that was going to push them all the way over it, it does feel like him making the run and doing it with such weird. timing like that is certainly part of it i listen i really don't have a whole lot to say about all the

extracurricular conversation around him because to me he was if you just look at his history of the moves that he made he was already pretty fireable just in terms of trading back and probably not getting as much value as he should have out of those trades or i think trying to like pre-spend on the the rookie quarterback contract thing with j jay mccarthy and that not working out like i i think a lot of it to me if you just look at there and maybe that's more of a kevin o'connell thing i don't know. But I think if you just look at the history of their moves, like I just, I understand why he was fired just based purely off that. And to me, it doesn't even, the other stuff I think is kind of just like additive and convenient on the Vikings part. It's just wild that it happened like the day

after Sam Darnold played the game of his life in the NFC title game. And you can't convince me those things are not linked because, A, teams don't even go to the senior bowl these days. I mean, most of them do, but like teams stay back from the senior bowl all the time. It is not unusual to have an extended look. Like you see all the time a coaching staff will just be in purgatory. Like the ownership is like, we're going to look at all of this. We're going to go through meetings about what went wrong this season. And you'll just have like a cloud of uncertainty that hangs over a facility for weeks at a time.

That didn't happen in Minnesota. Like they were out on the road at the senior bowl. Like the day before it happened, I saw Quasi was like on the field. watching O-line D-line drills up close. And you just don't do that if you're planning on making a move like this. And for it to happen right after that game. And I do agree with Derek. Like you can make a case for firing him based on everything that's happened.

But to get through the first three weeks of January and have the staff out at the senior bowl looking at guys and then pull the trigger 24 hours after Sam Darnold is the MVP, of the conference championship game, it's a knee-jerk decision. And yeah, like it felt like the decision of an ownership group that felt very embarrassed by letting Sam Donald walk.

I think that's absolutely a part of it. I think the quarterback decision in general is a part of it. If J.J. McCarthy had had had Drake May's rookie season and Sam Donald had won the Super Bowl, we probably wouldn't be doing this. Unfortunately, J.J. McCarthy didn't.

He was one of the worst starting quarterbacks in the NFL. And so that is clearly a mistake on multiple different fronts. The extracurricular stuff, when it comes to like the paternity leave and all of that like that's not worth getting into in my opinion to me it's more about his place as like the main decision maker in the culture center in a football building and how skeptical people were of him as like a figure of authority in that sort of role based on his background and i think that was a consistent problem in minnesota based on a lot of the reporting that has happened and my frustration with this more than anything else i don't think his firing was not was like unjustly justified. If you look at the quarterback thing and also just the draft history, like the draft, the draft history is abysmal. It was really, really bad. And so if you're going to screw up the biggest decision that you have to make and you have not shown an ability to consistently fill the roster

with talent in the draft, those aren't on its own are probably enough to fire somebody. What's frustrating to me is that a lot of people who are like traditionalists about who deserves to have these jobs are going to treat this as a win. They're going to be like the analytics guy, came in and it didn't work because he's an analytics guy. There are two different elements of that to me that I think are worth digging into. One, I think one of his biggest problems as a general manager is that he didn't have the confidence and the steadfast nature to follow through on the actual analytically driven decisions. Like if you look at what they did and like trading draft picks away and some of that stuff and

like some of the types of players he made bets on, those weren't analytically driven decisions. Like one of his biggest problems that he didn't follow the analytical models enough that he probably believed in. Well, and even one of those is like, listen, maybe he could have got more value out of like the trade down that they made and eventually ended up drafting Lewis Seen. But if they just draft a player who's better than Lewis Seen, like, none of that, it's not a problem. If they draft a quarterback who's better than J.J. McCarthy, it's probably not a problem. Like, to me, it really isn't like his mindset as like an analytical GM or what all that stuff. It was just like the moves that they made were not good enough. Like that's kind of all it boiled down to.

That was part of it. But trading all those picks away in the Dallas Turner draft is like, that's something like an analytically driven GM. Like you, I don't know how you can justify that. Even like giving out third, using your free agent money on third contract players in this last free agent cycle is not something that like an analytically driven GM would probably do. The Dallas Turner trade, the J. Von Hargrave contract. Jonathan Allen to. Yeah, I feel like those are not deals that like, you know,

when you think of like an analytics front office, like the Browns had baseball guys in their front office, like that sort of thing. You don't do that type of stuff if you're just following the numbers. And I think the other part of this, and this gets back to like the people of his background and like where he came from on the analytics side of things, this is always going to be a sport where I think that,

people need you to have like a little bit of football guy in you. Yes. And I wish that weren't the case, but it kind of is. Especially when you're somebody in that role where like you've got how many people reporting to if you're the general manager of an NFL team. And you are really tasked with setting like the culture in the building, how the building operates the mindset of everybody. You need to have like real authority in that sort of role.

And I think that there are guys that are never going to get behind or trust somebody that is of a background they don't really understand or trust and doesn't really come with like the gravitas to get people to kind of fall in line behind it, right? I think that he's somebody that probably never operated with like the authority and the confidence that was going to capture the belief of people in that building. And I think that's why it led to some of the fracturing that you saw.

Like that, that's my kind of read on the, on a lot of it. And Sando wrote a lot about this. Like Sando talked about it. I think that there's some real like, there's something very real. there and like how it affects everybody else in the building. But at the core of it, this is not a, the analytics guy made analytics decisions and that's why this didn't work.

I think there are a lot of other things at play here. Yeah, but to your point, it's going to get treated that way. Of course it is. People are going to look at every, any time somebody's going to consider hiring somebody like this to be a general manager again in the next five years, this is what's going to happen. And the idea that like, they want a football guy in there now. It's like, okay. Like I don't, Holly Roseman has two Super Bowls.

I was literally just thinking. I was like, Howie Roseman does all the stuff that is like, in theory, all the analytical stuff. And like, it's worked out for them just fine. I will say, though, and I've talked about this a lot. And just the era one of Howie and Philly and era two, I think he really did learn a lot about how to be that person at the front of the building when he spent that year, those couple years away. And moving beyond what the math would tell you about some of these decisions. And obviously, the Eagles still do a ton of that, right? again, I've joked about a million times.

You need like an MBA in order to figure out how the Eagles run their cap. Like this is a team that is on the cutting edge when it comes to that the decision making and how forward thinking they are. But I also think that how he really did learn that this is a people business first and foremost. I think that was probably the most important thing he learned during those couple years of exile. And so I think that's why he's been better at the job the second time around. And so it's not just about how you think and how you operate. It's what you can do to inspire belief and buy-in from the people around you.

Like, that's always going to be a part of what those roles are. It's a very quarterback, you know, to borrow the parallel from down in the locker room. But it's similar in that part of the building. Like, you have a team, I mean, God knows how many people it is. Like, obviously it's the coaching staff. It's earning the respect and the trust of ownership. But however many scouts work for a given NFL team and the amount of work that those guys do and the amount of, trust that they put in you to guide their careers in the right direction.

And so my God, what is that? Like 40, 50 people that you have to have in lockstep trusting that you're doing things the right way and you're going to land the plane every year. Yeah. And I think it's easy to lose that. Maybe not publicly, but again, I mean, these guys in every building work very closely together and talk to people in other buildings and have. have relationships all over the league.

If you lose that, I think it can be very problematic. I think that's why something like the paternity leaf blows up in the way that it does is because the moment something like that happens, you have a lot of people being like, see, see, he's not like us. And he operates differently than us. And they just jump on that in a way they might not, if it wasn't already building to that moment. That's what I'm saying with that.

Like, I, that to me, that part of it just seems like very convenient for either the Vikings or for people who thought it was a bad hire and think that he deserved to be fired to say that he should. Whereas to me it's just like... Oh, for sure. And if JJ had been awesome and the Vikings had been a good team this year,

we never would have heard about it. Either we wouldn't have heard about it or we would have gotten some glowing stories about here's how the GM of the Vikings is changing the culture in his building. Work life balance. One step at a time. Work life balance matters in Minnesota.

Yeah, it's all about results. And not to twist the knife on Vikings fans, but I also just can't. help but go back to KOC's quote about organizations fail young quarterbacks way before young

quarterbacks can fail organizations. Well, the guy that oversaw the drafting of J.J. McCarthy is now fired. And Kevin O'Connell and Brian Flores are if they're not in job protection mode yet, they're probably at least thinking about it. There's some self-preservation that's going on. I promise you that. And that will drive the quarterback thinking about

this team moving forward, which we will dig into on Friday. Yeah, that'll be, that'll be fine. It'll be a fun offseason in Minnesota. Let's take through a couple of these coordinator hirings really quickly. Matt Nagy is the offensive coordinator for the New York Giants. To me, it's uninspired. I think that the idea that after Todd Monkin, this was the next choice, like if you were

John Harbaugh as a CEO type of head coach, to me is just a little bit disappointing. I think it's extremely disappointing. And like when I said, I'm trying to be nice. Like what I said like the muffler hire was like uninspired and inoffensive. I think it is. But at least it's like young guy coming off of the Shanahan McVeigh. He's going to call plays. It could be exciting.

Like I at least can get it. We've seen Matt Nagy like be in higher positions like this. And I think he's coming off of having been with the chiefs for his second stint. And the chief's getting worse on offense with him as the offensive coordinator. and the chief's like, not even quietly, but like pretty loudly pushing him out of the building. Like I just, maybe there's a chance this works out, but I just, this is one of the few hires where I'm like,

I definitely would have wanted them to go in a different direction. When he got the job, I heard plenty of people saying like, see, he just, he wanted a play calling opportunity no matter what. It didn't have to be a head coaching job like the chiefs were trying to push. And that's fine. I don't, I just, if, if Matt and Aggie had been somebody that, that the chiefs desperately wanted to hold on to. I just don't think they would have,

I don't think it would have gone down the way that it did. When you're an offensive coordinator, you're the play caller, you're the main architect behind the offense. You need to be a problem solver. And I just don't think that Matt Nagy and his time as the offensive coordinator for the chiefs in the second go-around

and what it looked like with the Bears, I just don't really trust him that much as a problem-solver. And so I would be, all the excitement and the, just the joy around the John Harbaugh hire for Giants fans, the idea that Todd Mockin might be, coming with him. Some of that would be sucked out for me because of this.

Notice how for multiple years now, Steve Spagnolo has made it known. Like, I would love another chance. I want to be a head coach again. This is not my sole goal for the rest of my career. But the Kansas City Chiefs have not done a farewell tour with him where they're just like, all right, see you later, Spaggs. Like, we had a good run, but go pursue your opportunity. No, that's silly. To me, this just seems like, and this is not.

not a good excuse to make this higher, but it just seems like if they looked at Jackson Dart and they said, okay, he's probably going to be a gun, shotgun guy, he's going to be a spread guy, he's going to be RPO, who's the easiest guy that we can find to do that? And it's Matt Nagy, which again, like, I understand how you arrive there, but there has to be, and there has to be somebody else

who fills that, that slot for you. Like, that's not Matt Nagy. I just, in so many ways, it seems like they could have gone a different direction. And I just think that mind of thinking, when you, the first thought that crosses your mind about Matt Dagan, Jackson, Darden, is that thought. And that thought's like, oh, this could work out. But then you think about like, all right, let's think one layer deeper. When you start to run into issues because that is the structure of your offense,

then what happens? And do we have any faith in them being able to work through that? And I think that becomes the bigger question, and I have my doubts about it. The Ravens hired their own offensive coordinator. They hired Declan Doyle from the Bears to be their offensive play caller. This one is one of those which is like, all right, let's see how this goes. Like, I mean, if you're going to hire a guy from an offensive system that is exciting

and that represents the modern NFL, like, I think that the offensive coordinator for Ben Johnson and what that Bears offense was last year absolutely falls in line with that. Have you made peace with rooting for a team that people want to emulate? It's wild. It's wild. My cope here is that they have Ben Johnson, so it doesn't really matter. Yeah. Like, anybody can get hired away off that staff and it's going to be fine.

It's like one of the arguments for having a Ben Johnson. as your head coach. But the fact that people are willing to like or want to steal some of that bear's offense heat is a very new experience for me. Jesse Menner got into his office and immediately fired up Bears tape to get ideas and see if he wanted to talk to Declan Doyle. It's extremely weird, but I also understand it after watching the Bears last year. We mentioned Anthony Weaver hired to be their defensive coordinator.

Love that in a bunch of different levels. Frank Reich is the Jets offensive coordinator. I mean, Derek said it earlier on the show. this staff feels more pre-fired than any staff that I can remember. This is just like, why? And like, how and why? I am the most like three years ago. I was like, hell yeah, hire Frank Reich.

Like, I was so into it. But like that feels like a lifetime ago that Frank Reich was like a needle moving offensive mind and play caller. I just, this to me, I don't even understand. And again, almost similar to like what I said about Mike Lafleur with the Jets. I don't think Tarynne Angstrain was like incredible. last year, but given the, some of the constraints they had with no wide receiver talent and quarterback play that was pretty bad. I'd never really watched the offense and was like, man,

they're completely hamstringing these guys. They're not using their talent. Like, the run game was good despite all that they had to deal with. Like, and so like them moving a different direction there and then obviously now hiring Frank Reich, I just, this feels like such a bizarre set of circumstances. Who's the Jet's quarterback? I know we have all offseason to figure that out, but it doesn't matter. It probably doesn't matter. It doesn't matter. I mean, this is a bleak situation. We talked about it on the last coaching show we did when they fired like a third of their staff.

It just, there is so few things here that inspire any sort of hope. And I think that the hires that they've made over the last couple of weeks fall directly in line with that. Two defensive coordinator moves before we get out of here. Rahim Morris is the defensive coordinator for the San Francisco 49ers. I think this makes a ton of sense based on his history with Kyle Shanahan. They coached together multiple different times over the years. My question for you, Derek, Rahim Morris is not right now, at least over the last several years, has not been like a four-down attack front defensive coordinator.

And so do, and he's beat, the thing about Rahim is that he's worked all of these different systems at some point in his career. Like, he doesn't come from one specific place. And so in theory, if they wanted to run that sort of defense, I think he probably could. But I also wonder, does this mean some sort of shift from what the Niners defense? looks like when it has looked very, very similar for most of the past 10 years. And I think it's just kind of weird timing-wise because they just drafted a bunch of guys who like, in theory, we're supposed to like fit this four or three defense. Like it spent like four or five draft picks.

And obviously, you know, Upton Stout is in the secondary and stuff like that. But they spent two picks on defensive tackles. Their first round pick was an edge rusher. And I will say, Michael Williams was really a little bit more of like a standup outside linebacker at Georgia. So maybe he specifically, this is not really an issue. but I am kind of curious about how much of they're going to like let Rahim Morris do some of the stuff that he wants to do and is used to do,

or if it's going to be a little bit of like a, when he got to the Los Angeles Rams situation where it's like, look, this is last year's playbook. Use as much of this as you possibly can type of deal. It's a really good point because he did that exact thing when he got to LA. Like he was the only new coach on the staff. And so there's a chance that those guys in San Francisco are like,

here's what we do. Like now you're in charge of this. that has happened before. Leonard Floyd, did you like your time in the Bay? Do you want to go back? I don't know. He's played for him like every year

for the last like eight years. Thinking out loud. Last one, Jim Leonard is the defensive coordinator for the bills. Love it. Don't know what else to say. Like there's a reason

his name has been bopping around. He's somebody that I'm very curious to see what he will do running his own shop. And I think if you're Joe Brady, this is about as good as you could have hoped for. Yeah, he's been a hot name in the college circles for a while.

like he I think he was the defensive coordinator when they had that the really fun linebacker pair of uh who is it uh jack samborn and leo chanall i believe he was the defensive play caller for them obviously last year really fun in the NFL that defense was awesome they had keanu benson i was so excited for jack sandborn and dallas this year i love just thinking about stuff i thought in august and now here we are a few days after the super bowl i'm just picturing derrick just like laying in his house just like thinking back to like leo shanall as a linebacker or for the Wisconsin Badgers and how beautiful those days were. That defense was incredible. Beller knows what I'm talking about. That defense was awesome. Jim Leonard has been,

he's been an it name for defensive nerds forever at this point. So like to see him land in a high profile situation for a team with Super Bowl aspirations, clearly, because that's why they were looking for a new head coach in the first place. It's exciting to see what it's going to look like and just go ahead and circle him as a guy who could benefit from a good bill season in a big way.

All right. That is all we've got for today. We'll be back tomorrow talking about our biggest questions heading into the offseason. All those quarterback conversations that we were dancing around today, Max Crosby trade, all that stuff. We'll be talking about that stuff tomorrow. So please check that out. On Monday, we'll be starting up our offseason mailbags.

The days on those are going to change over the next couple weeks just because we're going right into the combine. And so we'll have a combine preview of sorts on that next. Monday and then free agency is going to start up soon after that. But we will, starting this week, be burning back those weekly mailbags, very excited about that. Always love to hear from you guys. So please be on the lookout for that on Monday. For now, that's all we got. Appreciate you guys listening. We'll talk to you very soon.