The Athletic Football Show: A show about the NFL - “Our Guys” in the 2024 NFL Draft

Episode Date: April 18, 2024

We are officially one week out from the 2024 NFL Draft and this episode is all about “Our Guys.” Robert Mays, Nate Tice and Dane Brugler talk about the prospects they love in the top 10, the first... round, on Day 2 and outside the top 100 consensus.Read the 2024 Edition of The Beast, By Dane BruglerFollow Robert on Twitter: @robertmaysFollow Nate on Twitter: @Nate_TiceFollow Dane on Twitter: @dpbruglerSubscribe to The Athletic Football Show...AppleSpotifyYouTube Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

Transcript
Discussion (0)
Starting point is 00:00:00 This is the athletic football show. Welcome to the athletic football show. I'm Robert Mays. Great show for you guys today. It's going to be one of our last shows about this year's draft cycle, because guess what? The draft is next week. So most of our stuff from here on out will be ramping up toward the draft, the last couple nuggets. But before we got to that point, I wanted to spend a little bit of time allowing our two draft guys on this show to really
Starting point is 00:00:39 give some love to their favorite players in this draft. And those are going to be players all across the board because letting them list off 10 guys in the first round is not productive, nor is it fair. It's way too easy of an exercise. So today is our guys in the 2024 NFL draft. And here to help me with that are our two draft analysts here at the Athletic. First of all, it's my good friend, Nate Tyson. How you doing, buddy?
Starting point is 00:01:04 Doing well. Yeah, every part of the draft cycle, you hit the checkpoints. just like the season. So, like, this feels like, oh, this is it. But I'm very, very excited to go over this show because we're going to talk about our guys. And it's not the Knox. It's not the, I don't know.
Starting point is 00:01:19 It's not like, no, these guys are all stars. Trust us by the end of the show. Yeah, as if there's not enough unrelenting positivity on this show. Also, joining us today. It is our draft expert here at The Athletic. It's Dan Bruchorten. How you doing, man? I'm good.
Starting point is 00:01:33 I'm excited to do this. This will be fun, kind of a chance for us to gush like we've been doing. I think a lot of these names will be predictable, but maybe a few surprises. I don't know. We'll see. But I was doing some research last night. This is going to be the second time ever in the history, Super Bowl era. We've had 57 drafts.
Starting point is 00:01:51 This is only going to be the second time ever. We're going to have all offense with the first seven picks. And if, say the Falcons trade out of eight, say someone trades up for Ruma Dunzee, it'll be the first time ever we see offense, the first eight picks. So it's going to be an offensive. heavy first round and not as a big surprise, but it's just interesting putting it in that type of context. Because the other time it happened was the 2021 draft, which is interesting. There's parallels because that's the year we had quarterback 1, 2, 3. We had receivers go early. Receivers go 4, 5, 6,
Starting point is 00:02:25 right? If you count Pitts as a receiver. Yeah. Yeah. And then you had with the first defensive player was J.C. Horn at 8. But, you know, then Sir Tan was after him. Michael Parsons, was worked in there. But yeah, just interesting the parallels between the 2021 class and then this year's draft. Before we get into this, just a quick reminder,
Starting point is 00:02:47 we are a week away, if you guys are listening to this on Thursday from the 2024 NFL draft, we will be coming to you guys live from Detroit on YouTube on the first and second nights of the drafts rounds one through three every single pick.
Starting point is 00:03:02 We will have reactions, analysis, got some fun bells and whistles we're going to trot out. So please, come join us on YouTube, on night one and night two as we break down everything. It's one of my favorite things we do on the show. We've done it for the last several years. It's a really good time, very excited about it. So I just want to keep reminding you guys about it, keep poking you
Starting point is 00:03:22 guys about it and get you there on draft night because we are very excited about what we're going to be trotting out. Today, just some parameters for the exercise. Like I said, we're not just going to let people list off five top ten picks as their favorite players in the draft. So we're going to break this down into four separate categories. Guys in the top 10, because I'm going to give you one. I think that's fair. First round, day two guys, and then players who are outside of the top 100 consensus board. So some of these names up near the top, names you guys have probably heard on the 100
Starting point is 00:03:57 shows we've done over the last month about the draft. Names a little bit later on this show, probably names that you have not heard quite yet as part of these conversations. Dane, I am going to give you the honors here and let you kick this off. Who is your guy, your guy in the top 10 of this year's NFL draft? And you could go a few different ways here, but I kept coming back to Malik Neighbors. Not even my number one receiver this year. That's Marvin Harrison Jr., but Malik Neighbors is my favorite of this group.
Starting point is 00:04:26 I just, he's fireworks, man. I mean, he's just, he's fun to watch. And, you know, you want explosive plays, all right, he led the FBS, 34 plays or 34 catches of 20 plus yards. He's still just 20 years old. It doesn't turn 21 until the end of July, and he, the last two years, led the SEC in catches. I mean, you think about the long list of receivers that have come out of LSU, yet nobody has more catches in a career than Malik neighbors. So, you know, he is the total package when it comes to the physical skill set, it comes to the production, then also the ceiling. I think he probably has the highest ceiling of these top
Starting point is 00:05:03 three receivers. Marvin Harrison Jr. is the most NFL ready. He's the craftiest of the group. And he's also really physically gifted as well. Roma Dunezai might even be the safest of the top three, but I think Millieck Neighbors has the highest ceiling and
Starting point is 00:05:19 the most wow potential to create these big plays. And so no matter who gets him in the first round, I cannot wait to tune in and see what they do. And you know, even if he goes to, with all due respect, like the Giants, where the quarterback situation's a little up in the air.
Starting point is 00:05:36 You know, I still, it's going to be a fun to watch because he is, he's inevitable. He's going to be able to create those big plays. What's the moment that you feel like you fell in love with him? Do you remember when it was? I think it was watching, watching him over the summer. Like I knew who it was just from the past, past years, but watching him over the summer,
Starting point is 00:05:54 I think it was the SEC championship game against Georgia when his acceleration was just different. I mean, he's running by these Georgia D.Bs like it's nothing. and it's like, okay, okay, you can do that. Okay, you've got something here. And then the ability to make plays at the catch point, but it all comes back to those explosive plays. It doesn't matter the D.Bs he's going up against.
Starting point is 00:06:15 If the quarterback can find you, he's going to go make a play. And some of it's catch and run. That's a big factor here too. I think, you know, we've talked about it before with Marvin Harrison, Jr., maybe not, that's not something in his bag that he relies on unless he's got that clear runway. With Malik neighbors, he can make a guy miss. He has the wiggle, but then also the ability to just eliminate those pursuit angles from defenders. So being the total package and having the most explosiveness to your game, that all factors in here.
Starting point is 00:06:45 Nate, let's stick with the receivers here because one of your guys in the top ten, one of your guys, was Romo Dunezay, who Nate Dane just called potentially the safest receiver available in the top ten. Why Roma Dunezay for you over a couple of these other guys and maybe other people have graded slightly higher? Yeah, and that's funny what Dane just said. Marvin Harrison Jr. is also my receiver one. But it's not interesting to say that Marvin Harrison Jr. is one of your favorite players in the draft. Oh, you like Tom Hanks?
Starting point is 00:07:11 Yeah, yeah, yeah. It says nothing about you. Oh, cool. Yeah, yeah, Mariel Streep's pretty good. But, no, Marvin Harrison, Jr.'s just, yeah, a separate conversation for me. But I'm doing what, what Dan said, he's safe, but I don't want to downplay what he brings to the table. I think I keep coming back to the word useful, which I usually use for guys that are more middle-round guys, that are more dirty work guys,
Starting point is 00:07:33 he's like a supreme useful. Like he is like the like, instead of just a $10 Swiss Army knife, he is a $150 one fancy one that I bought from Huckberry.com. Like he is just like a, like he is that kind of version. Like he can just do a little bit of everything. And that's why I like him.
Starting point is 00:07:47 His game, and I'll use this line again, is scheme proof and situation proof. This is what I think. And I think that's where Dane is saying that he's safe. He catches the ball well at all three levels. He's a good route runner at all three levels. He catches contested catches. He's great.
Starting point is 00:08:01 the adjustments, got good hands, can create a little bit with the yards, uh, with the ball in his hands, yards have to catch on screens and all over the place. Can line up inside, can line up outside, can beat press. Kind of just does everything well. I think he just, that's why I like him so much.
Starting point is 00:08:15 So many receivers might be missing that one thing that causes me hesitation. And Dune's A doesn't have anything missing, even if some of the skills aren't exceptional or excellent, like neighbors has that ace in the hole. He can create. Neighbors can create that is such a exceptional skill to have. But the thing is, yes, their explosive plays are such so, so valuable right now. But I think with even when on Dunezay, he can do that well, but not excellent.
Starting point is 00:08:41 But that's the thing. That's why I like him is no matter what, I can just picture him being a contributor and being good, no matter what the station winner, what it asks to do. And I think that's why it comes back that I just so, I just like him so, so much because of that high, high floor and a little bit higher ceiling that I think he's been getting good. It's so hard to think of a Dune Zay not working, right? I don't care where it goes. It is so hard to envision him going to a situation
Starting point is 00:09:05 where he just doesn't work out. So, yeah. That's where I think you come back to. Yeah, like, there's no such thing as a safe prospect, but he's the closest thing to that where it's just hard to see him not produce at the NFL level.
Starting point is 00:09:19 Which is funny that that's one, that your love of him is rooted in that idea, Nate, the fact that you feel so good about turning in the card. He exists kind of within a narrow band of outcomes. Your other guy in the top 10 has been painted in the exact opposite light during this entire draft process and that is Drake May from North Carolina.
Starting point is 00:09:36 Yeah, and that's the high end play. But it's the opposite. I think his May, the discussion is that his floor is higher than he's been given credit for. It's, man, people are acting like he's an overhaul project and I'm just... He has to sit for three years. What are you talking about?
Starting point is 00:09:49 Oh, my God, right? Jordan Love's trajectory. I think he should be just like Jordan Love. I'm like, oh, my God. Like, what am I watching here? What am I? I don't know. It's so weird to me because...
Starting point is 00:09:58 There's such a discadact. We've talked about this. this, and even beyond the process stuff and the accuracy, which even if you want to ding him for that, fine, I get that. But around so many other prospects over the last four or five years, we've talked about how athleticism establishes the floor. If you can scramble and you have that breaking case of emergency side of your game that allows you to survive early in your career, he has that. It's not like he's a big stiff in the pocket, and if he's going to be a little bit inaccurate, he gives you nothing in some of those problem-solving situations. So even that argument is kind of
Starting point is 00:10:30 part for me to understand her process. And even the, you know, the creativity is why I just keep coming back to. It's like the negative play mitigation, not just sacks, but just turning, creating stuff out of thin air. We just talked about that with neighbors, but that's why Caleb, of course, gets the praise for it, deservedly so, but that's what I feel like I'm going crazy. It's like, make, but he does this like really well. And I also think the mental side, that's what I don't think he needs to sit.
Starting point is 00:10:56 If we're talking footwork and timing, we can't, we, some of these guys are, watching him, some of these guys are just talking about, just Twitter stuff, but is that they're grading them like he has to be in a West Coast Bill Walsh offense. You know, this is this offense is so sloppy and so loose that that's why you have to grade what he's doing in that, in that situation. Of course, this time is going to be off. They're not doing one, two, three, four, five, throw. It's drift, drift, fade in the pocket. Oh, oh, their space throw. So that's why the translation, I think has kind of gotten off with him. And I also think everyone's like, oh, he's got to sit. Why? Because of footwork? Well, it's not the mental side. because I know for sure it's not. So that's why I think there's such a disconnect. And I think that narrative is taking on a whole life of its own. Now he needs to sit automatically. And it's like, I'm the complete opposite. Let them play.
Starting point is 00:11:39 Let him figure out what he can get away with. Let them make mistakes. Because the high-end stuff is so, so exceptional. It's what you create. It's what teams should be striving to get on their team, even if there's going to be some blemishes early. I just think that's why I like them. I think the ceiling is just so sky-high.
Starting point is 00:11:56 It reminds me of the Anthony Richardson conversation a little bit last year, but he's so much further along than Anthony Richardson was. So I don't really understand that. If you believe he has the mental toughness to work through the mistakes, then absolutely he should be starting. And it's one thing I love about Drake May
Starting point is 00:12:12 is I do think he has that mental toughness. I mean, he got the, he got his butt kicked at North Carolina behind that offensive line. And with someone, with what the receivers were doing and not always helping him out, I don't think he's going to have a problem,
Starting point is 00:12:26 you know, taking his lumps and, you know, battling through those mistakes. and being better because of it. So he's not going to be a guy that shrinks when he does make a mistake, like we've seen some of these rookie quarterbacks do. So, yeah, I'll be shocked if we don't see Drake May starting in September for whatever team drafts him, whether that's the Patriots or the commanders, whoever. He should be out there early.
Starting point is 00:12:49 And again, it won't be all perfect, but he'll learn. And when we look back at this draft three years from now, I think there will be some teams that maybe regret passing on him. Yeah, I'll just say one last line. May is, because we probably won't talk about them again until draft day, is anyone that's used some of these games as is negative. I think Virginia has been one game that raised Knox. Yes, the first couple drives, and some people that go through all 22, that might be all what they watch. There are some misses. Watch that game the last two and a half quarters and
Starting point is 00:13:18 watch what that dude is doing. That is a guy putting a team on his freaking back and making throw after throw and run after run and decision after decision that's making, helping the team almost win. They should have won. But that is a game that's like, just keep watching. There's just so much to like. So, Dan, sorry, last line is that the baseball adjusting thing, too, like Dan said, he can adjust. He's going to have that mental strength. There's so many guys they talk about in baseball, they jump up to the MLB and they don't know how to adjust. What do you mean? The swing doesn't work. I have to move back in my stance a little bit. The best ones do. The best ones realize that what they were doing, they have to work off of that. May already shows that he's done that
Starting point is 00:13:53 a little bit. And that's why, again, I'm optimistic about him. I just think if you look at back at quarterback development history and quarterback development success stories over the last five to 10 years. And we don't necessarily need to paint Anthony Richardson in that light already. He played a handful of games, but looked competent in those games. Oh, I'm trying to roll in. He was coming in, right? But these things like footwork and accuracy and refinement, that stuff can get worked on. That stuff can get fixed.
Starting point is 00:14:18 You can do so much work in the offseason with a quarterback guru. We have so much information and tools around the kinesiology and how you're supposed to throw a, football now, you can fine tune that stuff. What you can't fine tune is talent, ability, creativity, feel, sense. And that's why I was willing to bet on Anthony Richardson last year. It wasn't just physical talent. It was watching his feel for the pocket and his ability to understand and navigate that space. And when you watch Drake May play, it's not big arm throw far. That's not why he's attractive. It's those same sort of characteristics that Anthony Richardson had to an extent and the reason I was willing to bet on it. And I think May has enough of
Starting point is 00:14:56 that where we're talking about some fine tuning and some tweaks. That's something that I'm just fine having to work through for a little while for an offseason or two. I know. Josh Allen, right? Like, and I don't, we're not, we shouldn't hold up Josh Allen as like, as the example for how it can work because he is an exception in a lot of these ways. But we do have, I think, more tools in a modern era of quarterback development and quarterback teaching that leave me a little bit more bullish on guys who have this sort of profile coming into the NFL. May and Richardson, this is what I think they've gotten underrated, even Richardson last year, is they play quarterback well. They do the quarterback things on top of the traits, and that's why I'm excited about them.
Starting point is 00:15:34 But the footwork stuff, too, I think always comes up. Everyone thinks that it's actually these three magic drills that the coaches put them through, and all of a sudden, boom, all of a sudden they're better. Look at Josh Allen. He worked with Jordan Palmer, and all of a sudden, they changed his throwing style. His throwing style didn't change. His footwork changed. And what the footwork was, he stopped overstriding. And a lot of times when guys overstrived, they feel late.
Starting point is 00:15:55 And I've talked about this a few times, JJ McCarthy, this is going to happen to him. They overstried, they actually wanes. But that is because they feel late mentally. Oh, I didn't see that guy come open. I had to wait until he comes up. And now I got gun that ball in. Guys get better when they get met.
Starting point is 00:16:08 It slows down for them mentally. And then the footwork comes better. And then the accuracy becomes better. It all starts up up top. And that's again, why I think he needs the reps, because then he realizes the actual timing and what he's going to weigh with. So again, that's fixable. That's just reps.
Starting point is 00:16:21 The Josh Allen comparison, I think, is an apt one because we talked about this with Drake May on the quarterback show. He hasn't played quarterback solely for that long. He played multiple sports for most of his childhood. He's not one of these guys who's been going to private quarterback coaches and being a full-time football player since he was 10 years old, Dane. Isn't that right? His dad was basically his quarterback coach. His dad was a former quarterback. But yeah, he grew up in a big basketball family and he was a big, he was a shortstop. I mean, yeah, he was a multi-sport focused guy growing up. And so the fact that he's just, yeah, he's just a just removed, three years removed from high school. He's still a young player, 22 years old, or going to be 22 years old. So, yeah, he is someone that, again, when you're making a bet on a quarterback, because that's what you're doing when you're drafting a quarterback earlier, making a bet,
Starting point is 00:17:07 give me the guy that, like Drake May, who has all these physical and mental skills that you can see on tape, that translate to the next level, and I'll take my chances on those guys every day. And the reason I ask that question is because that's how I'm, Josh Allen was. Josh Allen was a multi-sport athlete all the way through high school. And I remember talking to Josh in the fall of 2019. It was the second year as a starter. And you could see some of the refinement coming after a very rough rookie year.
Starting point is 00:17:32 And he was telling me, he's like, I didn't spend all these reps and all this time working on my footwork and learning how to be this really refined quarterback. That's not what I did when I was young. And he compared it to me. It was like a golf swing. You know, eventually you get to a place where you can hit your irons pretty well consistently, but then when you take the driver out, it can be difficult. And that was that point in 2019 where his intermediate accuracy had really picked up, but he was struggling, throwing the ball deep down the field.
Starting point is 00:17:56 And so it's a process for guys who haven't necessarily put as much time on task with these specific quarterback things. And I think that in a lot of ways, Drake May falls into a similar category. And I think that's why it's easy to come up with arguments in your mind for how high this can go. That's a great discussion. Shoot, Anthony Richardson was a receiver until, like, sophomore year of high school. He didn't train to be a quarterback. So he got to high school. Like, you know, I was going to camp since eighth grade.
Starting point is 00:18:21 I was going to the manning camp every summer in eighth grade, working with pro coaches, you know, like that. I was one of those guys that was groomed to be a quarterback. Some of these guys are just such better athletes that are, yeah, I'm playing every sport. And I think that's better. I think that's better for your overall development. If you look at these guys, the way that Joe Burrow played basketball deep into his high school career, like, I think that that multi-sport background and the looseness that comes with it in just like how you are as an athlete, your feel for certain things. that is harder to teach. That's something that becomes innate over time
Starting point is 00:18:52 where the refined quarterback stuff, you can learn that kind of thing. So that the school of quarterback development and how it works, because I think there was a while, and I think we've gone away from this a little bit where this Josh Roe, and I know Josh Rosen play tennis, but a lot of these guys who I think were overcoached with some of these camps, they were really robotic.
Starting point is 00:19:10 And so the guys that haven't necessarily come through that same sort of process and again, have more of a looseness to who they are as athletes, I think you can more easily spend that as a positive than a negative if you're thinking about the ceiling for these players. Very different position, but that was the same thing with Joe Alt at Notre Dame. He was an offensive tackle. And his dad was a Pro Bowl left tackle. He played in the NFL for a lot of years.
Starting point is 00:19:31 But he made sure his son was an athlete, first and foremost, playing all these different sports, was a tight end, quarterback. Wasn't until, all right, finally, as a senior in high school, all right, now we'll start to introduce you to offensive line play. And he's so much better for it because the movements, because of the, you know, he understands his body better, his athletic instincts. And so it's absolutely true across several positions. All right. Let's get to the guys in the first round. Dan, why don't you kick us off?
Starting point is 00:19:59 Quinion Mitchell is somebody that we've talked about a lot during this process. But even if he's at the top 15 of MacDrafts, sneaking up near the top 10, still feels like an unknown to a lot of casual fans. I mean, that's a product coming from Toledo. Quinnon Mitchell is one of your guys in the first round. What kind of made you fall in love with him during the process? You know, he's just, he's a very clean player. And over the summer when I first started watching him,
Starting point is 00:20:25 I was, okay, this is an early round pick, you know, second round, third round. And I know his head coach very well, Jason Candle. We both have Mount Union connections, and so I've known him for a long time. Or the mob. He sent me like some of the numbers, like, oh, hey, he ran a four three for scouts. He ran, or he's doing this in the wait room. he's doing this and I was like okay this is pretty impressive I mean if he comes anywhere close to these numbers during the testing process of the draft uh you know this is going to be impressive
Starting point is 00:20:54 but then throughout the season he's just he's kind of checking every box he's the ball productions off the charts um and so like I did he didn't make my first top 50 in August and then around Halloween I do an updated top 50 and I was like you know what this guy he he's in the top 50 He should be in there. And this is before anyone's ever, we're not talking about him as a first round players. I'm like, I'm going to throw him in there. He was like 32 or something.
Starting point is 00:21:21 I'm going to throw him in there. And then it's like towards the end of the season, I was like, I don't have him high enough. As much as I like him, he's better than that. And so then he goes to the senior bowl. And going into the senior bowl,
Starting point is 00:21:33 that's who I was like, okay, this is the player that has a chance to really emerge as a winner from the senior bowl and someone that could be one of the best defensive players in this class. and that's exactly what he did because it didn't look too big for him
Starting point is 00:21:46 and I know talking to him before the senior bowl he was kind of on the fence about whether or not he was going to go because he didn't really have to he was already considered to be somewhere in that first round conversation but you know so there was something to lose potentially if you didn't have a good week but there was also something to gain
Starting point is 00:22:02 and that's how he looked at it he went to the mobile competed was the best defensive player was the best player there period and you know he kind of pushed himself up into that top 15 discussion, goes to the combine, check that box. So it was just, it was a
Starting point is 00:22:18 series of checking every box along the way. The season, the production, the ability to go to the senior bowl and really shine even though we're talking about a Mac player. So he didn't have tape against SEC receivers, Big 10 receivers, weekend week out. Wouldn't that make it more important
Starting point is 00:22:35 that team playing well in Mobile? Just as like a leveling exercise? And that's exactly. You want to go to the senior bowl to see the guys from FCS, to see the guys from the MAC, to see the Jordan loves
Starting point is 00:22:48 from Utah State to see how they perform it in a setting like that against better players. And that's, that's exactly what he did. He showed out. He was outstanding. So again, it just
Starting point is 00:22:57 aced every level of the process. And now he has, he could be the first defensive player drafted. The Falcons have done a lot of work on him. Who knows? Maybe at number eight.
Starting point is 00:23:05 If not there, he's going to go, you know, 12 to the Broncos, 13 to the Raiders, 15 to the Colts. It doesn't seem like he's getting, out of the top half of round one.
Starting point is 00:23:14 Hey, can you remember, and I'll put you on the spot a little bit here, can you remember somebody who had a similar sort of rise based on the tape and based on the resume, then went to the Senior Bowl and really helped themselves, but the Senior Bowl was kind of a false signal that their performance at the Senior Bowl wasn't necessarily indicative of where that trajectory should be? Interesting.
Starting point is 00:23:30 Because I know a lot of guys on the other side of that, right? Like Terry McCorn was phenomenal at the Senior Bowl. Terry McCorn's a third round pick. Terry McCoran's a star. But I'm wondering if there's a little bit of selection bias here, where we only remember the success stories. Yeah, no, that's, I had to have to think about it, but yeah, guys like Eric Fisher, you know, like, you know, you kind of, every step of the process, you're just, you're nailing it. And before long, you're like, oh, yeah, why isn't this guy going, no, top 10? Why is he going top five? Why is he, oh, number one? Yeah, that's possible. But yeah, I'm trying to think, trying to rock my brain about somebody that showed out at the senior ball, but then it was a little bit of Fool's gold. Gosh, I'm not to think about that one. The fact that there's no one that immediately comes to mind is probably a good sign, though.
Starting point is 00:24:12 Because we have combine guys like that, you know, like Mike Mamuwa and the guys that just destroyed the combine and then ended up Dairnsicolston. Yeah, Vernon Goldstein. Oh, man. But I will say that. Remember that one? Here's my only response to that. I went to one Michigan-Ohio State game when I was in college. A lot of my buddies went to Michigan.
Starting point is 00:24:29 And I went to the game my sophomore year, which is 07. That was the terrible Michigan season where they lost Appalachian State after my Chad Hennie and Mike Hart came back. And first of all, the day was just disgusting. It was like 34 degrees and raining sideways, and this was the day I went to that game. Vernon Goldston cooked in that game. So I at least saw him be a productive college player, even if he never quite lived up to the draft status.
Starting point is 00:24:53 I think he basically became a first rounder after he played Wisconsin that year, his last year. And I want to say my friend, my really good friend, who's the Hawaiian coach at San Jose State now, Josh Wolvesby. He was like, big time recruit. And then that was like his first start, I think I might be
Starting point is 00:25:08 throwing him under the bus and this isn't right but he got shredded and I've watched that game and it was like that's, and I look back on it and I was like, this is all the way
Starting point is 00:25:17 after Vern's career was done. This is five years down the road after it. I remember just being like, oh, that's why he became a first rounder. Like half his paycheck should go to Josh.
Starting point is 00:25:26 And Jake Long was was Michigan's left tackle in that game too. So, I mean, there are a lot of reasons I thought Vernon Golson was actually going to be pretty good. Oh yeah.
Starting point is 00:25:34 Here it is. He had four tackles for four sack. against Wisconsin in 2007. Four tackles, first acts. That was, was that Terrell Prior, I think? Or I don't know. But think of going back to the Senior Bowl, like Daniel Jones,
Starting point is 00:25:49 that might be a name where, because he was the MVP of the Senior Bowl. Gettelman famously said, you know, when we saw him in Mobile, we knew right away, okay, this is our guy. And they take them all the way at six, which felt like a reach at the time. And obviously to this point, hasn't quite worth. worked out. So I think that would be one of those examples where maybe a little bit of, you can understand why they did it, you know, the talent, but the tape wasn't necessarily
Starting point is 00:26:18 six overall worthy, but during the process, you could talk yourself into it based off of what he did at the Senior Bowl and did Combine and all those things. Nate, your first guy here in the first round is offensive Lyman Graham Barton, who you have talked about a lot. What made Graham, what, and we're going to going to let you do it one more time here before the draft. What made Graham Barton one of your guys in this process? I'm okay putting my name on this one. This isn't like Amir Smith-Marset where it's like, yeah, I like this mid-round guy, but I talked about him so much. Everyone's like, now the story is Nate Tice had a first-round grade on Amir-Smith-Marset. It's like, no, no, it's not how it's work. I do have a first-round grade. I don't have a first-round grade. I have Barton as my number 12 guy on my big board overall. And I, because his tape is exceptional, I really like his tape. even if he was battling injuries this year, when I knew he was clean early in the year,
Starting point is 00:27:15 and this is even going into the season, I considered him neck and neck with Holt, Joe Alt. And I've texted with Dane that kind of proved that. I was like, I kind of like Barton a little better. A little different now. But Barton's film is just, he's a technician. He's got great feet, great hands.
Starting point is 00:27:30 And the big knock on him was, well, he's not long. He's not a good athlete. Well, he put that to bed. The length, maybe not so much. The length is still substandard. It's below 33 inches. But it's not 32 inches, whatever. Who's saying he's not a good athlete?
Starting point is 00:27:44 I mean, she was, people thought he wasn't a good athlete. It blew my mind. He tested crazy. It tastes like him, but that's what his film shows. He's a monster. Right. It wasn't that, it wasn't that surprising when he busted out a 4-9 and I mean, he's a good athlete.
Starting point is 00:27:58 He's got some edge to him too. I was watching the game he had against Jared Verse last week and I was just like, yeah, man, this guy's got some to him. There was one play where he put Verse in the dirt. And I was like, all right, I can get on board with this. That's a great tape too, because Versus is a guy that I was curious. Does he give him issues? Barton, I mean. Usually if you're a technician, athletes,
Starting point is 00:28:16 lane power guys give you issues. Nah, nothing. And so then he tests like that. His film's great. His hands are great. His feet are great. Why aren't we talking about this guy as a top 20 guy? Even if he's not a left tackle, which I still think he could in a pinch do that.
Starting point is 00:28:32 I think he could start at four spots, left guard, center, right guard, right tackle. At the very least three spots and be a high end starter. And I think he could be a good right tackle because his hands, because everything. There's a little Joe Tuny here, you know, where it's like, yeah, he could be a solid tackle, but a really good guard. But that's the thing. I think it's underrated that he could hang outside because his hands are so good, because he can keep up with better athletes, because he can recover because of his athletic ability. So Barton, to me, is just so clean. I've started kind of every mock kind of pushing him to the Seahawks in the middle, in the middle of the first round there, because I just like the fit and like where that can match up.
Starting point is 00:29:07 But I think Barton is a really clean prospect. I like where he projects. I think he could be a pro bowler at guard, maybe even right tackle. But I love that he could start at legit four spots, I think. I was texting with a scout during his pro day a couple weeks ago, and just we're gushing back and forth how much we like the guy. And he texted back, Zach Martin 2.0. And it's like, oh, okay, yeah, like that.
Starting point is 00:29:34 That's a name I was going to throw out, but always hesitate when you're talking about generational first ballot hall favors. A 10-time first time all pro. Yeah, yeah. But same kind of discussion with Martin, right? That's exactly what was his thing. College left tackle. Could stay there maybe because of his arm.
Starting point is 00:29:50 But oh my God, look at my card. The versatility is a big part of why you love Riley Leonard. Or, it's true, Riley Leonard. I'm looking at-I-Lenor. I'm looking at Duke. I'm looking at Duke and I think Riley Leonard, who's now in Notre Dame, why you love Barton. I mean, like, he's, everything you mentioned with the athleticism,
Starting point is 00:30:09 the strength in his hands, how smart he is, the coaches rave about his toughness. I mean, they say he's the hardest worker, one of the toughest guys, and it doesn't feel like coach speak. It feels like they genuinely believe that. So it's just, yeah, across the board, I don't know that maybe he might never, he might not have an A plus trait,
Starting point is 00:30:26 but he's got plenty of A minuses, a lot of B pluses. Like, it just doesn't have that one glaring weakness that makes you really worry about him. So he's 18 overall on my board. And yeah, I have, if he went top 15, I don't think you'd, you wouldn't stop and say, oh, wow, that's too early for him.
Starting point is 00:30:44 Like, you get it. You understand why a team would look at that and say, yeah, we could use a versatile player like that for our offensive line. Somebody else who's in that general range on big boards, but, you know, has been talked about it as a potential surprise top 15 pick, maybe a surprise top 10 pick, is Byron Murphy from Texas, who is your other guy here in the first round, Dane. Why Byron Murphy compared to some of these other, even defensive linemen or defensive prospects that you have in the first round? give me the guys they hate to be blocked. And I can play with those guys. And Byron Murphy despises being blocked. And it doesn't matter if we're talking the run game.
Starting point is 00:31:21 We're talking him getting after the quarterback. He's so disruptive. And he does it in different ways. Now, does he look necessarily like a first round defensive tackle? No. But, you know, I think that's, I think we're past that, right? You know, after Aaron Donald and after. Yeah, it feels like a 10 years ago conversation.
Starting point is 00:31:39 Right. Exactly. So even though he is a little bit maybe undersized compared to ideally what you want, he moves really well. He uses that natural leverage to his advantage. He has this natural twitch through his hips and through his body that just it courses power. And it's really fun to watch because he, and he's still figuring it out. He's still figuring out how to channel all of it. But the movement skills are awesome.
Starting point is 00:32:04 He's violent. He just really knows how to use his skill set to his advantage. in a big, big way. Murphy's going to be really interesting where he ends up in the first round. I think it's 8 and 18. To me, that's the range. I would not be shocked at all
Starting point is 00:32:20 if he went to the Falcons at 8. I would not be shocked at all if he lasted to the Bengals at 18. I think somewhere in that range is where he should come off the board, and I think he's going to be a really disruptive pro. How would you think he hang cleaned? Just all that hip power and everything?
Starting point is 00:32:35 Holy crap. He was a 375 pound power, power clean, 455 front squat. And this goes back to high school too. I've mentioned this before, but he was a linebacker. And his sophomore year, he went to DeSoto. They put a pressure package together where he would creep up, you know, and just rush through the A gap.
Starting point is 00:32:56 And it worked so well that a week later, the coaches said, sorry, man, you're a defensive tackle now. And he just continued adding weight, adding weight, and just grew his body and did not lose that explosiveness. And his senior year at the Soto, he broke Von Miller's sack record. So this is a guy that's been doing it for a while, not a long while in terms of being a defensive lineman, but long enough that he's been able to hone his technique
Starting point is 00:33:20 and really understand how to best use that skill set to get after the quarterback. And they let him make some plays on offense at Texas. That was fun to see him show his athleticism. I just think this is a really disruptive player that, you know, you want to see him line up as a nose tackle? You can do that. He did that quite a bit in that,
Starting point is 00:33:38 Texas defensive line, but I think he's a natural, more of a natural three, but just a guy that's really disruptive. If they don't get the quarterback or if they can't make the move for the quarterback, Minnesota at 11 to me is very fun. If you think about some of the other pieces they've added defensively, the holes on that roster right now, you drop him in and suddenly that defensive line becomes pretty interesting. I know every Vikings fan is probably screaming right now, the idea of them not coming away with the quarterback with those first couple picks, but I do think that's a fun landing spot. Let's get Mike Zimmer back there and have him take a corner. Yeah, just had to take another corner in the first round.
Starting point is 00:34:10 With at least 32-inch arms, right? Yeah, I texted Travis Frederick, the old Cowboys Wisconsin Center, because he's the most I've ever seen someone hang clean and power clean. So I wanted to text him to see what his number was because that's insane, like nearly 400 pounds, power cleaning. Are you kidding? It's just that's so much hit power and so much that you have to do. No, I, yeah, he's, Murphy's a really fun player.
Starting point is 00:34:35 I know Dan's loved him this entire time. I like him a lot too. He, to me, is a guy that knows what he is. And I mean that, like, he knows what he's really good at. And he knows, I'm not over 300 pounds. And sometimes I got to take a double team. So he gets down on that knee and you can see his bend and you can see his fight and his strength. I think that's awesome because a lot of gap shooting three types.
Starting point is 00:34:57 Once they get that double team, they're like, yeah, I'm good. I'll just, whatever. You guys can push me. I'm good. He's like, no, I'm straining and I'm fighting. That's awesome. So you see competitiveness along with the gap shooting stuff. So great player.
Starting point is 00:35:08 All right. Nate, your next guy in the first round. Who do you want to go with here? Yeah, I kind of sort of said AD Mitchell, but that's not like, I don't want to say fully my guy deep throated here. This is more like the opt. If he does. Yeah.
Starting point is 00:35:21 If he doesn't have, there's so many red flags that usually I hate receivers with, like the route running where he kind of doesn't know exactly what he's doing. The inconsistencies there, the kind of some of the testing stuff. He's had high ankles. There's just like a lot of red flags with him. Some of the production is an overwhelming, but have you seen him run? Have you seen him jump?
Starting point is 00:35:41 Have you seen him catch? And he's got to be in a perfect spot. He does. He is not scheme proof. He's the opposite of Dunezay. But this, the high end traits with him, almost like a May receiver version, but the high end traits are what you want.
Starting point is 00:35:54 This is a true blue could be a number one X receiver that could run a vertical route tree with no help. He could win one-on-ones and dunk on guys and run real routes. I think he's a good route runner. Even if there is some inconsistencies, I think he can move, not like a lot of tall guys can. But there are red flags. And to ignore them would be not doing my job.
Starting point is 00:36:14 So that's why I like, this isn't fully throated. But if this dude ends up on a winning team with a real quarterback in an established place where he doesn't have to be the dude number one, bills, chiefs somewhere. That's ideal, of course. But if he does and he falls to that area, yeah, I'm all about him because I think they can touch and kind of maybe hone in on what he's really good at. and clean them up a little bit on all the deficiencies he has. Dan, is there anybody that was kind of in this, this archetype of receiver that was going to be picked maybe outside the top 15 that had flaws, but had the potential be number one,
Starting point is 00:36:48 but had an underwhelming college production and ended up becoming a number one in the NFL. Because even guys who, like, fell to the second round, like, while Nate was talking, I looked up like A.J. Brown's college stats. AJ Brown had, like, 85 catches for 1,300 yards his last two years. Yeah. At Ole Miss.
Starting point is 00:37:03 And, yeah, they're obviously situations. elements that feed this, but production does tend to be a really good signal for success for college receivers in the NFL. So I'm wondering if there are any guys recently who maybe had slightly underwhelming production that were actually better college players than they were
Starting point is 00:37:19 better NFL players than they were college players. Yeah, I mean, Nico Collins. Nico Collins is a good example. That comes to mind. He's a third round pick though. Yeah, exactly. That's, yeah, that's, yeah, that's, I know I was like looking even up T. Higgins, and he
Starting point is 00:37:33 fring dunked on everyone for a last, last, he had 25 touchdowns in the last two years. So that's a bad one. Right. Yeah. Most of the time when you're drafting a receiver in the first round, they were really productive receivers at the college level. And obviously, understandably why.
Starting point is 00:37:50 But yeah, that's, I'm trying to. I was looking at IUC too. IUC only had 65 catches last year at Arizona State, but he had 1,200 yards. And so even IUC, yeah. And IUC is in that same range, right? Like, where it wasn't a plug and play, you can be a number one. there's probably a little bit of projection involved here, but even he almost had 1,200 yards his final year in college.
Starting point is 00:38:10 So it's interesting because I'm with Nate. I'm with Nate. I watch him play, and if I'm thinking about, I would love, I need a number one two years from now. And which guys from this range can eventually get there? When you watch the tools he has and just what's in the tool bag, I think that that is on the table for him. But I understand some of the nerds looking at the college production
Starting point is 00:38:33 and it's being like, uh-uh, I'm not doing this because there aren't a lot of examples that would lead you to believe a guy with this sort of profile is going to be a star in the NFL. He would be an exception. But like, okay, with Mitchell, comparing his floor with his ceiling is a really interesting conversation
Starting point is 00:38:52 because I think it's a wide, it's a big range. Like his ceiling to me is like, okay, a, like I compared him to the late Chris Henry. You know, that long, loose, limber, really athletic player that can win down the field. He just moves a little bit differently than guys that size. But I think his floor is kind of like a Denzel Mims. A guy that clearly has ability. It's not a talent issue. It's just a matter of consistency and living up to that immense talent, which Mims just had never, has never been able to do at the NFL level. So it's just a wide range of outcomes for Mitchell based off of where he goes and the situation that he's in. And obviously it's on him to try to maximize that.
Starting point is 00:39:36 My only response to that is that MIMS couldn't separate even in college. And that when these guys end up being just like their careers are DOA in the NFL, Mims, Nikiel Henry, a lot of those guys who are those bigger-bodied players, they weren't separators even in college. With Mitchell, you see some of the separation ability. So that's why it becomes a little bit more intriguing to me than some of these other guys, no offense to Nate, who Nate loved in college and didn't end up becoming stars in the NFL because they were just big-bodied guys who weren't separators.
Starting point is 00:40:07 I like one threadwell, too, right? Did not like Trevor. We've all got them. We've all got them. Yeah, but that's the thing is, I was high on Higgins in the same draft I was high on MIMS. So it's like, you know, one worked, one didn't.
Starting point is 00:40:19 Like that's a little bit of difference. There are traits from those that like I'll, Higgins is like one. It's like, why did he click? And it's like there's certain aspects of his ball skills too that were like, I think it's like so much more. Just that feel the really grabbing that rebound where Mims, it was always like, by the sideline, he's falling down as he's
Starting point is 00:40:38 catching the ball and all that. And I was like, yeah, but look at him, run. And yeah, you learn. You learn a little bit. The production conversation with receivers is so interesting because I remember going through so many debates on Twitter with Nikiel Henry, or Nikiel Harry, who I did not love. I did not see him as a first round pick. I was not, I just, he can't separate. He's, but look at this production. And that's what, you know, look what he did at Arizona State. I kept getting those responses to it. And so the production element is definitely, we've seen plenty of productive college receivers that have not been able to pan out, even if they did have some skills. And, you know, Nikiel definitely stands out as one of those guys.
Starting point is 00:41:14 All right, let's get to the guys that are probably going to be going on day two here, or at least are projected to be day two picks. Dan, why don't you start us off with somebody that you think actually might sneak into the first round as one of your guys in this range? Yeah, I think if we're going to, because every year we know the 27, 28 names, if we are trying to guess who those final five, six names are going to be in the first round, who are going to be the surprises? Marshawn Neeland from Western Michigan, I would not be surprised if he was able to sneak in there because he plays the right position.
Starting point is 00:41:44 First and foremost, he's a pass rusher. Every team is looking for more help there. 6-3, 267 pounds. He's a really athletic big man for that size. He ran in the 4-7s, 35-5-inch vert. A 702-3 cone is silly at that size, 34.5 inch arms. You see the body twitch that he plays with. And again, it's just different.
Starting point is 00:42:04 And I think seeing that at the combine, kind of reinforced my thoughts there, where it's okay, he's a little bit different than the guy before him, a little bit different than the guy after him, just terms of movement, in terms of that initial quickness. He understands leverage at the point of attack. He shows different moves. It's not just, you know, I've got this a pitch,
Starting point is 00:42:25 and then everything else is a work of progress. he will use these different things to get free from blocks. He can hold up versus the run. So a lot of things that Marshawn Neelan brings to the table. I mean, he still work in progress in some areas, but all the tools that he brings, those are the guys I want to bet on. So he's going to go in the top 50 somewhere.
Starting point is 00:42:43 It's just a matter of, okay, can he get into the top 32, which would not be surprising to me. What are our character evaluations of him? I ask for a very specific reason. I mean, I've heard nothing but good things in terms of effort, in terms of, you know, he was a team captain, his final season at Western Michigan. He actually almost went to Colorado
Starting point is 00:43:04 and joined Dion Sanders at the last minute because they had a coaching change at Western Michigan. At the last minute, he decided to stay home and be with his teammates, but no issues there in terms of character. So the reason that I ask is,
Starting point is 00:43:16 what about Detroit at 29? That, it, trust me, I've had this conversation with Colton. And actually, that's, if they do trade back, I think that's something that would be a fit. He was a 30 visit for the Lions. They've done a lot of work on him.
Starting point is 00:43:33 So if they don't pull the trigger there at 29, which I almost did in my seven round mock came out today, I almost did it. But I had actually had Detroit trading out because I had the Raiders. And if I didn't have them trading out, I probably would have done it at Neeland at 29 to Detroit. I had the Raiders trading up to take Michael Pennix with the Lions pick there.
Starting point is 00:43:55 But yeah, I think it makes sense. It checks a lot of boxes for a lot of reasons. And the Lions have been very upfront that their board looks very different than everybody else is. And all the evidence you need is in the first two rounds last year with how they operated to take the linebacker in the first round when a lot of, I don't think a lot of teams would have done that. So I think their board looks a lot different. And if Neeland is a top, top player for them in terms of their options late in the first round, that shouldn't be surprising to anybody. You look at the edges. There's just not a lot of those base 4-3 D-Ns, those old-school base.
Starting point is 00:44:31 He reminds me. And they value size at those spots. If you look at what they've done, Kaminsky, Marcus Davenport. I mean, they like those 265-270-type guys there. Shoot even bigger. Yeah, he kneeling, he is a phone player. It's, he reminds me a lot. Weird, because we just talked about his brother or his cousin, but William Goldston for the
Starting point is 00:44:52 bucks, but like he tested better as a better athlete. He's more explosive because William Ghost is a solid player, but not a good athlete. Yeah. Neon's a better athlete, but that same type of size, same type of length, how they win, pushing the pocket a little bit. But yeah, I like Neon. I see him, like, being a good pro. I know Dane's been beating his drum a little bit.
Starting point is 00:45:10 Got my hands on some more Western Michigan games. And yeah, it's, no, he's got length, size, strength, and he uses it. He uses it well. Watch the Eastern Michigan tape. That's the tape where it was like, okay, yep, I'm sold. This is, this is the guy. He hit like three plays in a row. like the Eastern Michigan was like backed up and he like just he took over the game and it was just you know it's not always the sexiest thing but he's dominating and that's what you want to see at that level so but no I certain teams are going to really like him because he's a different flavor than those top edges too I mean you got a lot more of the traditional outside linebacker type at edge as opposed to a 4 3d end and even if the production's not there he had four and a half sacks last year the testing is insane and I would rather bet on a guy with those tools it's a little bit raw especially in that area of the draft and with Detroit specifically
Starting point is 00:45:55 It's just hard for me to get out of my mind, dropping one more super athlete onto that defensive line. With DJ Reader now, I could see it all coming together. Him and Hutchinson pair well so well together. So I would love that for them. Nate, who's your first guy here in day two? One of your guys in this year's draft. I'll bring up some of the other guys I'm going to bring up
Starting point is 00:46:14 or guys we've already talked about because I can't help myself. But another one that I do want to harp on here is Christian Haynes from University of Connecticut, Yukon. I love Christian Haynes. I have him in my 30s on my big board. I again, my comparison for him's been a little bit of up. 30, not 30 is number 30. Is he 30 now?
Starting point is 00:46:32 Yes. I, dude, I, I'm trying to, the one thing he can't do is not, not can't do, but he struggles with is some bull rush anchoring. Like, he will get blown back a little bit, but then you get to see his athleticism in the same sentence in the same play because you can see his bend and you see his length and all those types of things, his ability to recover, which is more important than anything. But the thing with, with, shoot, with Haynes is. He cuts off guys on zone, which is so hard to do.
Starting point is 00:46:58 And he doesn't just do it once a game. He does it every single time. He looks like a great athlete. You see the athleticism testing that he had this offseason. It shows up with his film. I think he's very smart. He's got great eyes, great awareness. He started a lot of games.
Starting point is 00:47:12 He reminds me a lot of Shaq Mason. Four years starter. He started like 50 games in college. I mean, it's such an outlier compared to other offensive line prospects specifically in this class who are more project-y and more inexperienced compared to a guy like this. And he didn't move on to a bigger school this year, which you might see that or anything.
Starting point is 00:47:29 So he kind of gets a little undersold. And at first when I first glanced on, I was like, okay, you're probably a round three guy to me. And then he tested like how he plays. So again, that's what kind of kept growing it for me because of the movement ability, because of what he does in the run game,
Starting point is 00:47:44 him climbing to the second level. It's consistent. It's every play. So I feel like he's a day one starter for somebody. I, you know, he's somewhere between, like I said, Shaq Mason and maybe Lakin Tomlinson, some kind of mix of those two. I don't know exactly where I'm going with there. I threw out Kevin Dotson. Kevin Dotson's another, another, yeah, a good one too. It's, I thought zone guys would really like him because of his movement ability,
Starting point is 00:48:08 but there's other stuff he can do as a polar that makes me excited, him out in space on screens. Yeah, Haynes, I just see as a day one starter for somebody. He's got maybe some, he's only played right guard, but he worked at center a little bit, which makes me a little even more warm on him, that he has some interior versatility. He's a great athlete. Yeah, I'm really high on him, and I think some team could really find a good starter on day two. Dan, why are you relatively a little bit lower than Nate is on him specifically? I mean, he's my 47 overall player, so, you know, I'm nuts. I couldn't remember where he was on your big board, so that still is pretty rich. It is, because he, and he's crushed the process. He was outstanding at the senior bowl,
Starting point is 00:48:47 and then at the combine, he was terrific. Another guy where when you see him move in person, it's like, okay, this confirms what I thought, and maybe I was even a little bit too low on him based just on the tape grade, because he has the movements to him that's how NFL starters move. So, you know, I don't know that it's always consistent. And sometimes I watch the tape and the athletic testing
Starting point is 00:49:08 didn't always show up, but I think he's really smart. I think that he always finishes. I mean, the guy is really competitive. and it's not nothing, but when you're playing, no disrespect to Yukon, but you've been playing on some bad teams. And when you're still finishing in the fourth quarter, that stands out.
Starting point is 00:49:25 That matters. When the games put away, you were not winning this one, you've just, you know, you're blocking for a running back that's getting you two yards, but you're still finishing.
Starting point is 00:49:34 And that matters and something that I thought really stood out on a Haynes tape. All right, Dan, let's get to your next one here. You wanted to talk about Andrew Phillips, the cornerback from Kentucky. You have him at 61.
Starting point is 00:49:45 on your board. He's at 89 on the consensus big board. That is a pretty big gap. So he is decidedly one of your guys. What do you like about Andrew Phillips from Kentucky? And honestly, I'm kicking myself. I feel like a coward. I should have had him higher. To me, this guy... There's still time, my friend. There's still time. We got a week to go. Once the draft guy's out, that's it. I can't walk. No, that's it. But look, I usually struggle with these guys because he's not, he doesn't have size. He's 5, 10, and 3 quarters, 190 pounds. not very small, but still doesn't have ideal size for what you're looking for at the corner position, and he doesn't have ball production.
Starting point is 00:50:24 That usually when, with those two things, I'm kind of out. I'm a little bit worried now, right? So talk me into this, that's like me and A.D. Mitchell. It's like, he has this red flag. He has this reflight red flag. I still like him. I am all the way in on Andrew Phillips because he competes his butt off. And when you watch him, he's always in phase. He's not, he's not a lot. over the place. He doesn't show a lot of panic. I think it was, and I liked his tape going into the senior ball, but then watching him during practice at the senior ball, that's what really
Starting point is 00:50:54 clicked for me like, okay, this guy, he's just, he's all over this receiver. The receiver can't do anything. He is a blanket. I think he has a really good sense for just playing the position. And he needs to get better in terms of finding the football, making a play on it. But he doesn't give up a lot of catches. He does not allow, even though he's not the biggest guy, he doesn't allow receivers to big brother him. He's in position and he's just a very savvy player. So again, even though he's falling short in a few of these areas where you wish they were a little bit different, lower body quickness, the just know-how, the understanding of how to play the position, it's a football IQ type of thing. I think those athletic instincts and the way he plays is going to translate really well
Starting point is 00:51:36 probably as a nickel. I think the comparisons Roger McCreary and I stole that from an NFL scout and I know he's listening so I apologize but Roger McCurry is what I said
Starting point is 00:51:47 Roger McCurry was an early second round pick had a lot of these same concerns smaller, really short-armed now he had better ball production at Auburn but I think that
Starting point is 00:51:57 when you line these guys up I think there's a lot of similarities that will translate well to the NFL. That's a great comp yeah you think And you think Phillips can hang on the outside a little bit?
Starting point is 00:52:09 Like, I get with the tenacity and stuff. I mean, because again, I think he didn't let any receivers in the SEC big brother. I mean, it doesn't matter if he's facing a six-four guy. Yeah, he is, right. And I think there's that compete level, it matches the play strength where even though he doesn't necessarily pass the eye test, just looking at him, he plays tough. He acts tough. And it does translate, I think, to what he can do in the football field. There's like four corners that's like, I feel like I have,
Starting point is 00:52:38 I have the same ups and downs with all of them, rake straw, like all these guys where it's like, the traits aren't there, some of the productions, they, yeah, and it's just like, but I still like them because it's just like they just do stuff. Like, yeah, there's just like, there's like four of those guys that I'm, I'm kind of the same boat. Andrew Phillips has extremely long arms compared to Roger McCreary. I didn't, you look back, Roger McCreary has 28 and 7 eighth inches arms.
Starting point is 00:53:03 It's a zero percentile arm. length. I remember where I was. The career's 511. 511. Yeah, about 511 and a half. I can remember where I was in Mobile when I saw that where his arms measured that short. And I was like, oh, no.
Starting point is 00:53:18 Because you like the player, but you just never see guys corners with arm length that short. And I was shocked that he went as early as he did. He was an early second round pick. But he has played, he's played well. To a team that love. Yeah. Yep, nice solid star. To a team that loves traits the Titans.
Starting point is 00:53:33 Like, yeah, that did they do the der. Andrew Phillips, he's going to go in the second round. He's not going to make it to the third round. I'll be surprised if he does. In my mock, I had him going to the 49ers in that late second round. I think that's kind of his floor if you last that long, but he might not last that long. And even if you like him because he's tough and you like the play style, still solid measurements across the board, you know, 42-inch vertical jump at the combine.
Starting point is 00:53:57 I mean, that's an explosion. Under seven seconds in a three cone, you know, like you said, the arm length, is 31 and a quarter inch arms, which is not, it's longer than you would think for his body type. So, yeah, I think a lot of things, even if he doesn't have the height that you want or the interception numbers, he's still, he's just a player and he makes plays. And I know that a lot of people that scares them when they don't have hit certain data points, but I don't know. I was seduced by the tape. I can't pull a trigger on him. I know you love him and I kept him in my 90s.
Starting point is 00:54:37 I didn't think he made my top 100, my last one, but right now I'm an update. He's like 96. And it's just, he's a good football player. It's just one of those. Yeah,
Starting point is 00:54:46 I don't know. All these guys, what was the other DB that I was going to say? Not just rakes drop, but there's a few of these guys. Oh, from Michigan, Santer Still.
Starting point is 00:54:56 Another kind of like, not everything is like overwhelming, but he's just a baller. And he's just like, he's just like, good football player, but has some traits, just not the ideal size, not ideal length. They're missing some things, even if I like the football player in them. I almost picked Stainer Still for this category because he's number 43 for me.
Starting point is 00:55:12 I'm really high in Stenra Stil. So again, usually corners, these undersized guys, they worry me, but Sainer Stil and Phillips, they're just football players. At the end of the day, give me the good football players. And that's what these two guys are. Nate, there was another guy in Day 2 at Corner that you wanted to talk about as one of your guys, and that's T.J. Tampa from Iowa State. Why T.J. Tampa for you among all those corners who feel kind of clustered in that range?
Starting point is 00:55:36 He's a little different than these guys where he does have the size and does have some real grit to him, some bigness to him. Tampa is just a good football player. I don't know what I like about him. I see some man coverage ability. I like him in zone. Like maybe it's just like what Iowa State does. I'm like, this translates easily. It's like quarterback's watching a guy do a quick game.
Starting point is 00:55:56 You're like, oh, I can translate that. And but I, there's a lot of off coverage and just like awareness stuff that you're going to have to do. His spatial awareness, his spatial awareness I really like with his size
Starting point is 00:56:06 and that's the combo that I keep coming back to. This guy understands the position, understands football, he has intelligence to him and he has size and enough athleticism. He didn't test overwhelming.
Starting point is 00:56:17 But there's just a role for this guy somewhere and I don't know what it is exactly and that's why I like him. I actually talked to Deonté about him a little bit and we came to the same conclusion. It's like,
Starting point is 00:56:27 is he a page? Richard's guy? Like, is he that type where he's this kind of weird body and not overwhelming in some areas? And like, that is it a Flores guy where you move him around. He could do some man stuff, does some zone stuff, just has high IQ to get underneath other areas. So I just kept coming back to Tampa. I originally thought, oh, yeah, you know, he's just only going to be his for certain systems. But I like him for more fits than I originally did because of the size, because of the IQ and just enough athleticism where I don't think he'll be overwhelmed at the NFL level. I think this is the guy you guys are closest on because Nate you had him at 56, T.J. Tampa on your big board. Dane, you had Tampa at 55 on your big board. So you guys are almost in lockstep with where you see him. We nailed Chop Robinson, right?
Starting point is 00:57:08 That was the one we had, I think we're both at the same spot. I think that was one guy. We did it. T.J, and Tampa's tough because he's a 4-5-8 guy. That's what he ran at the Big 12 Pro Day. And, you know, he declined a senior bowl invitation. You know, he said him good. And I thought he could have helped himself.
Starting point is 00:57:24 I thought that was a mistake. I thought that was an opportunity for him to really show out and show what he can do. I was also surprised he didn't jump during the pre-draft process because that's kind of his thing. That's what he does. He comes from a basketball family. I thought he'd easily got over 40,
Starting point is 00:57:40 but he decided not to jump. And maybe there's, I know there was a hamstring issue that he was battling through. Maybe that played a factor into, you know, he didn't want to jump 38 because he knows he could do. What's that? A lot of hamstrings on these pro days, Dan. Is there something going on?
Starting point is 00:57:54 on here. Quote unquote hamstrings. Wow, we can't, oh, is that an injury? We can't test? Oh, yeah, okay.
Starting point is 00:58:02 It's all about feel and how you feel with it? Oh, wow. I still love Cooper DeGine, but, yeah, no three cone, no short shuttle for Cooper. We know he's fast.
Starting point is 00:58:11 Make a job. Yeah, reinforce that, but yeah, some of the stickiness at the top of routes. I don't know. But, like,
Starting point is 00:58:20 Tampa's, he's, opinions are all over the place on him. Some teams are really, They believe he's an early second round guy. Other teams believe he's more of a mid-third-round guy. So I think the truth is probably somewhere in the middle, right where we are with how we rank him. But it wouldn't be a surprise if he ends up going maybe earlier or later than even we have him.
Starting point is 00:58:46 Dan, you mentioned Mike Sandor still as a guy that you liked. I sense a creeping Michigan defense love here because the next guy that you wanted to talk about is Junior Colson, the linebacker from Michigan, as your last guy on day two that you're excited. excited about why junior colson from michigan on this list yeah and i mean who knows he might even sneak in if we're talking those those sneaky guys uh that could go earlier than we think maybe sneaking to round one colson is it's not impossible because he is i think the clear linebacker one in a weak linebacker class and so if you want to come away from this draft with a standout guy in the middle you want the green dot guy who has athleticism has physicality has toughness junior colson is I think easily the top guy this year.
Starting point is 00:59:33 And I question whether or not he's going to get past 37 with Harbaugh and the Chargers at that point. This is the guy that... You see they had him and Chris Jenkins in like the same day last week. It's very funny to me. Just a little Michigan reunion down there in Los Angeles. I think that's a perfect example of how teams don't always use all their 30 visits. Like we can get a little too obsessive over this.
Starting point is 00:59:56 They know everything they need to know about Chris Jenkins and Junior Colson. But hey, hey, guys, Come hang out. Let's go. You want a free trip to L.A.? Exactly. So, yeah, really, and I think between those two players, it could be interesting.
Starting point is 01:00:10 And I'd throw Sainra still in there as well. It feels like one of those three guys are going to be the pick of 37 to the Chargers. Which child do you like the best, Coach Harbaugh? I don't know. But Colson, you know, he might not even be there at that point because I think, again, the fact that he is not the total. I do think he's a total package.
Starting point is 01:00:31 He might not have, you know, overwhelming traits in some of these areas, but he doesn't have a weak area either. And I think, you know, his story is awesome, obviously, you know, growing up in Haiti and then, you know, not coming, he grew up in an orphanage, didn't come here until, you know, he was nine years old. He didn't know English. Football was kind of his, the way he became a U.S. citizen, and he understood the culture and, you know, learned the language and understood, you know, social relationships. It was all through football. And so he has a special relationship with it. And he's a tough guy. Down the stretch, the final month of the season, he's playing with two broken hands.
Starting point is 01:01:09 He didn't miss a game. And so I think, you know, with what he can do in the run game with his range, he is the total package. And because of that, I think a lot of these teams are going to be interested because he's a good player, but then also because, like I said, it's not a great linebacker class this year. Yeah, yeah, I like, he's both for our linebacker once. to everything, Dan said.
Starting point is 01:01:30 He checks all the boxes, even if none of them are overwhelming. This guy could play all three downs, Junior Colson. He could play in coverage. He could play man to man with a back if he has to. He could play in zone. He's also so smart. And that's not me interviewing them, nothing. That is just me watching him on film, calling stuff out.
Starting point is 01:01:48 I don't know if there's signal stealing going on, but calling stuff out. And really, but you can see it. Our first junior Colson conversation was during the college football playoff day. And I think both of us, like, we're excited to rave about him because you're like, he was everywhere. Like, we were just, we just talked about it for like 10 minutes. And since then he's been my linebacker one. Like really, that's solidified it for me because there's not, like Dan said,
Starting point is 01:02:08 it's not a great linebacker class. This guy can play three downs. He can play the run. He's smart. He's got enough length. He's got enough athleticism. Again, not overwhelming, but enough that you don't. And there's no testing for him.
Starting point is 01:02:18 And that's kind of why some are maybe a little hesitant because there's no testing. Again, a hamstring issue. So we don't have official. testing on him, right? But you don't watch him and say, this is a bad athlete. You know, he might not be a 4-3 guy, a 4-4 guy, but yeah, I think you watch him in, I think the number one takeaway from his film, you just don't see a lot of mental mistakes. You know, I mean, just he plays smart football. He's where he needs to be. So again, he might not, I don't know if he'll ever make a Pro Bowl, but I think he's just going to be a rock solid starter for a long time.
Starting point is 01:02:54 The comparison I keep coming back is Nick Bolton, like just a version of that. Just solid starter can do a lot of things well, even if he's not overwhelming. And he's bigger than Bolton. Yeah, definitely. Yeah, yeah. I went with a more complete version of Derek Barnes with the Lions, who, because size-wise, toughness-wise, I think it matches up. He's just a more complete version of that.
Starting point is 01:03:15 You have a couple more guys here, Nate, but guys we've talked a lot about, whether it's Mike Hall from Ohio State, Jalen Polk, who you love. I saw Jalen Polk snuck into Peter Shragher's first round mock draft, which has to be fun for you. That could be a great moment on draft night if that somehow happens. You get your super useful Jalen Polk in the first round. That was surprising even for me. I was like, I have them to the 30s of my big board. I know that's high. I was like, first round, here we go. Let's go. Not the only one. Those are my favorite moments for our draft shows, the late first surprises that for one reason or another, you guys get pumped about. Cole Strange remains one of the best moments of our draft shows that we've done so
Starting point is 01:03:51 far. So I'm hoping we get a Marshawn Neal and a Jalen Polk, one of these guys who are day two our guys, but somehow sneak into the first. Let's get to the other end of the spectrum here and talk about some guys who are outside of the top 100 on some of these consensus boards. Dane, why don't you kick us off? Who is your first guy outside of the top 100 that you wanted to talk about? I'm going to go with Tyrone Tracy from Purdue, a former receiver at Iowa, which, you know, that worked out the way it sounds. That's actually more. Yeah, it didn't work out.
Starting point is 01:04:22 So he transfers to Purdue, and they actually move him to running back this past year. So he's had a grand total of one year at running back, and he was a lot of fun. He also returned kicks. He had a 98-yard touchdown. But, you know, he kind of reminds me of, like, in basketball, he would be that high-energy sixth man who can swing games when he catches fire. Tracy's that type of guy, a type of weapon where you want a part of your backfield rotation. He can rip off an explosive play or two or three.
Starting point is 01:04:50 three each game and make something happen. And a big part of that is his ability out of the backfield catching the football. And you see that receiver background. The decision making at the line of scrimmage as a running back is up and down. You can tell he's a former wide receiver. But again, we're talking about day three, fourth round, fifth round. You add this guy to your running back mix. And I think you got an explosive option. Just get the ball in his hands and let him cook. He tore up the combine. I was as happy as I was to see that. I was also disappointed. point it because it's like all right the secret's out on Tracy now because this 40 inch vert uh it was in the 4 4s in the 40 6 81 3 cone uh and this is at 210 pounds so it's like all right you know it's not much of a secret at this point but i'm sure there were definitely some teams who didn't want to see that either because they were all over tracy and what he could be but i saw those numbers because i was not familiar with tyrone tracy's testing before you sent that name over and i started looking at it this morning my eyes popped out of my head i was like oh my god
Starting point is 01:05:50 That's insane. The first name that comes to mind and I don't know size-wise a little bit smaller but a guy who didn't have a lot of experience at running back but tested like crazy like this and where he went in the draft,
Starting point is 01:06:01 Jerich McKinnon was one of the first names I thought about where it was just like an insane athlete at the running back position but didn't play a lot of running back in college so it's kind of like all right, what do we get a quarterback? Yeah. Fun take.
Starting point is 01:06:13 That makes sense. Yeah. A guy that's never going to be your true a running back, a featured back. But yeah, you add him to the mix. and especially with what he can do out of the backfield, just get the ball in his hands,
Starting point is 01:06:24 let him create, let him do some things. And every game, he's going to make some type of impact for you. I'm a sucker for the receiver to run-upac guys. David Johnson, Rashad White. Like, I just, those guys always intrigued me.
Starting point is 01:06:35 God, you so are. I am. I am. There's some about it. I don't know. Dana, I actually wanted to ask you this. Have teams talked about kick returning
Starting point is 01:06:45 or, like, weighing that a little bit more? Like, kick return ability with the change? Because I've started. really like going like, hey, I'm going to give this guy maybe a half grade bump because of that. It used to just be, I only worried if they punt return, not kick return. Now we're bringing that back. So when you talk to teams, have they kind of been bringing that up a little bit? 100%. That's why I mentioned the 98-year kicker attorney had this year. That's why a guy like Isaac Grendo from Louisville, who has special teams background and tested off the charts, even though
Starting point is 01:07:13 he was a, I mean, he did nothing at Wisconsin. And then this past year at Louisville, he did some nice things. But still, it's an overwhelming resume, but when you have that type of athletic profile and you have special teams experience, that's going to bump you up a little bit. The top, kick returner, among the receivers is probably
Starting point is 01:07:32 Tulu Griffin or Aenea Smith, the Texas A&M kid. So, yeah, I think those names, if we see one of those names go maybe a little bit earlier than we expect on draft weekend, kick return, I think is a big part of it. Because it's just the math changing with these guys
Starting point is 01:07:48 that we think of as selective touch guys three to five, now we're doubling that. And so these, those are, those matter. Those are real snaps. They're not just waving their hand or pulling their arms out to get the touchback now. It's like, no, these guys are tangible snaps. So I've been curious. I love that.
Starting point is 01:08:02 I love that it matters again. I love that we're going to talk about it again as we evaluate players. It's just such a fun wrinkle to add back into the game. Kickoff return scheme. Because remembering it from XFL, it was cool to watch it week and week out because you can see the coaches start figuring it out and then COVID happened. But it was awesome to watch it start evolving. So I'm excited what see NFL special team coaches do.
Starting point is 01:08:23 And what players start to get valued more? Like, we're going to get got some tight end, some tweener guys that are going to have roles again. I'm really excited. Listen to Dan Campbell. I think it was at the owner's meetings. And they were asking him about it, just licking his chops about the strategy that's now going to go into kickoffs was the least surprising response to that rule change that you could possibly imagine. Nate, who is your first guy, one of your guys outside? of the top 100 consensus in this draft.
Starting point is 01:08:50 Outside of top 100, and it's my safety one. And again, this is a guy, Dane tip me off on. He goes, you're going to like this guy. I'm not only that I liked him, I loved him. That's Malik Mustafa from Wake Forest. A little bit undersized height-wise, but it has some good girth to him. I've compared him. Not in truth. Girt.
Starting point is 01:09:10 We've reached this point in the pre-draft process. Yes, we have. But watching him, he's kind of Diet Coke version of Buda Baker, where he is that rover type. He's the best tackling DB in this class, and I will argue about anybody on that one. This guy brings guys down and not just big hits. He's a sound tackler. He is a true safety cleaning stuff up on the back end, but also comes down,
Starting point is 01:09:34 watch him against Florida State. He has one of my favorite plays by any prospect in this class coming from depth and wiping out the running back on a key short-yardge play. But that is what I like about him. I was a little scared that he'd be a Carl Joseph type, who I've experienced with the Raiders, undersized head hunting safety, but can't cover anyone.
Starting point is 01:09:55 You got to be able to cover. You can't just, you know, it's not 1992. Mustafa is better in coverage than I think he's kind of getting credit for. He is a little more fluid in it. I saw some man coverage reps where he's staying with tight ends, which is what he's going to do in the NFL.
Starting point is 01:10:08 Saw him work in the slot space and he's pretty good. He can recover on angles. He's not just a big or undersized stiff. that's just knocking guys out. So yeah, I have this guy's my safety one. I think I have a late, second, early third on him. I'm not saying this guy should go super high. But I just like him because, again,
Starting point is 01:10:26 I think he covers better than he's gotten credit for. He's great against the run. He's a great tackler. Put him in a quarter's defense that everyone runs now. Really like him because that's what he's going to be asked to do as opposed to being all over the place like he had to do in college. So, yeah, really, really high on him. He's a good player.
Starting point is 01:10:41 He's easy to like, right? I mean, it's just. Yeah. I'm a sucker. Yeah, he finished 85 overall for me. The one reason I couldn't get any higher was just the lack of, like, I agree with you. I think he's better in coverage than he gets credit. I just don't know that he's a playmaker in coverage.
Starting point is 01:10:59 And that was like the one hesitation that I have with him. But I think, yeah, he's at his best working high to low. I mean, his speed, working downhill is awesome. He's a really sound tackler, like you said. and a fun story too. He started at Richmond. He kind of paved the way for Kobe Turner, who also made that Richmond
Starting point is 01:11:19 the Wake Forest move a year after... The spider jump. Malik Mustafidae. He's... I compared him to Jordan Whitehead, who a guy that is... The quarters-based thing is I had that in my mind as Nate was saying that
Starting point is 01:11:31 because you're your Whitehead comparison. Right. And a guy that's, you know, you can line them up in different ways, but it's always going to come down to he's not going to make a lot of mental mistakes. He's not going to create penalties. He's not going to put you in a bind.
Starting point is 01:11:45 He's going to do his job. He's going to, once he sees ball, he's going to go get ball. He's going to go make plays. So I'm with you. The size, not ideal, but I don't think it's going to be necessarily a huge deterrent for him in the NFL. Curious, Dan, you also mentioned Buda Baker in your write-up of him in The Beast that he modeled his game after Budapaker. Is that something you heard or something that was actually said to you or just stylistically reminded you of Buda-Baker? I think he told me that.
Starting point is 01:12:10 Okay. That's really funny. That's what Nate sees. He plays just like them. I enjoy talking to him and I talk to his mom as well and they're just good people, good family. This is, he is all ball all the time. And so he is, he's the type of person you want to draft on your football team. Dan, let's get to your next one here. Your next guy in this draft outside of the top 100. Who do you got for me? I know, I know Nate's going to talk about some tight ends. I want to get one of my tight ends in here. Tip Ryman. This guy's interesting.
Starting point is 01:12:42 He's 6.5.270, so he's huge. And then you look at the way he tests, and you're like, oh, this is a typo. I must have looked at the wrong row when I put these workout numbers in here. No, he's 464 in the 40, 33.5 inch vert, 702 three cone at that size. And it's like, okay, he didn't work out of his pro date. Well, no kidding. He ripped up the combine. Look at this.
Starting point is 01:13:07 geez and he was awesome to talk to because he is like he's married already he is a really mature 22 years old you know he's just he's wired differently it's it's really interesting and you look at the resume in terms of just production and it's not going to blow you away 19 catches each of the past two years yeah at 41 in his career okay we're not talking about a high volume type of receiver here but he did what was asked of him and so when he was targeted, he caught the football. He didn't have a drop this year. And I just, I think there's more in him than what the stat sheet says than even what the tape says.
Starting point is 01:13:47 Because I do think that he can be an impact blocker. I do think that, especially once you get down to the red zone, once you get inside the 30, he can help you move the chains and some of those, you know, when the field condenses. Because he has just enough athleticism. He has just enough toughness. So tip Ryman, if the asking price is a second round pick, then I'm out. But if the asking price is a fourth or fifth rounder, I like my chances at that point.
Starting point is 01:14:09 As a guy I can bring in, develop, and I was talking to one of my scout buddies about him, and during the season, he was praying that, you know, he would be a guy that they could sign after the draft, and after the combine, he said, no way. He's going to get drafted. Too many teams like him for what he could be, and I'm on board.
Starting point is 01:14:31 I'm a big fan of his. Typically, these bigger tight ends, 270 plus, They've been bad bets in the draft recently just because they're not good enough athletes to make it work. But because he's such a good athlete, I think that he might be one of those exceptions for somebody at that size.
Starting point is 01:14:46 And just to throw something out, 38 catches his final two years in college. Dane, how many catches do you think George Kittle had combined his final two years at college? Is it over under 38? It's over 38, but by four. 42 combined catches for George Kittles' final two years in college. So, some 50 receptions?
Starting point is 01:15:06 Fifth round. Yeah. So sub-50 receptions is not necessarily a disqualifier to being a productive NFL tight end, even if George Kill is an exception. Oh, yeah. Big Ten can produce some tight ends, yeah. It's the tight end theory for me. It's just once you get into these middle rounds,
Starting point is 01:15:21 just draft the big fast athletes and hope it works out. That's it. Well, funny you say that. Because your next guy here outside of the top 100 on the consensus is a tight end, who is the big fast guy, what you got for me? And that's why I'm glad we did the consensus, because I wouldn't be able to throw this guy in there because he is 50 on my big board.
Starting point is 01:15:39 And that's Theo Johnson. And he's 80th on Dane's big board. Yeah. Theo Johnson. He's not in the consensus? That's surprising. Totally. That's why I had him as a day two guy to talk about.
Starting point is 01:15:48 And then I looked at the consensus. I go, who we're moving to the outside top 100. Yeah, Theo Johnson, big, fast athlete, bet on him. That's what it is. Penn State, yes. And also that's a Penn State thing. Penn State guys tend to get better in the NFL because whatever reason, they don't really get coached up there.
Starting point is 01:16:04 They spent a shit. load of time in the weight room, man. I can tell you that much right now. Yeah, they do. That's speed training. Yeah, if it was a strength coach, I want to talk to. But Johnson is, it's flashes with him in his in-game tape. It's just, you know, one or two catches a game, but you see the movement of build.
Starting point is 01:16:20 He's a natural mover for such a big, big body, 6-6, or 260 pounds, I believe, off top my head, and he can roll. And you can see it on film, and he's got natural hands. He's a natural ball catcher. That ball sticks when he gets. throwing the ball. Wasn't a lot, but it happened. The thing is why I like him is all that movement stuff, all that size. He has potential as an inline Y tight end, which is hard to find. That's why I agree with Dane where Tip, uh, Ryman has, you know, should have fans because
Starting point is 01:16:51 there's not a lot of guys that can do what he can do or potentially do that. What's cool with Johnson is usually with these big athletic tight ends in college. It's all projection with they're blocking. You're like, yeah, okay, maybe he hasn't worked on. With Theo Johnson, he's actually doing it and actually blocking well when he had to be in line. They have another tight end there. So it'll be alternated between who was the wing and who was a tight end. I believe he's pretty highly touted as well, Dane. Warren, number 44, yeah.
Starting point is 01:17:15 Yeah, you move too. I just kept coming back to Johnson. And it's just all these flashes. He goes to the Senior Bowl. I'm sorry, it has the Combine, has a great day at the Combine, of course. He was great at the Senior Bowl. And he was great at the Senior Bowl as well. Yeah, I just don't want to cross my wires there.
Starting point is 01:17:30 And, but he goes there and it's just like, again, you're watching all this inline stuff, you're watching a move, you're watching the natural hands, is he going to be that number one, even number two option at passing tech? No, but as an auxiliary option where, you know, he catches a couple balls, he's going to be reliable. He can stretch the seam, stretch vertically, which I think is very important if he's going to play on all three downs. So this is a three down tight end that can play in line that I think can split out just enough to create some matchup stuff. I'm willing to bet on a guy like this, especially coming from his school. This is not a guy coming from a
Starting point is 01:18:03 I'll just hype my own guys up, but old Wisconsin where you're like, yeah, they're kind of maxed out. They're coached up all the way they can be. A guy from Penn State, yeah, I'm betting his best balls in front of him because especially such a young athlete like this. You want to make it more complicated than just pick the biggest fastest athlete at a tight end. If you look at recent history, it's not that much more complicated than that, especially when you get to a certain round of the draft.
Starting point is 01:18:26 It's like, who cares. Just pick the guy who's big and fast and let's see if we can figure it out later. and he's really big and really fast. He had a 40-inch vertical leap at 6-6-250. It's crazy that he did not have better than 350 yards receiving in any of his four seasons in college. How does that happen when you have this type of weapon at your disposal and you can't get him better than 350 yards receiving in any of these seasons?
Starting point is 01:18:54 I don't. And all those catches, none are designed for him. It's all like where he's a checkdown. He catches and runs with it. It's like, design something for that. this guy. Are we at all worried about that? Or do you just think that's malpractice? Malpractice because I see what that offense does. Yeah. I mean, it's probably 80-20 malpractice, but, you know, there are parts of his game where he is maybe a little bit a work in progress
Starting point is 01:19:17 in terms of the timing and making himself available, things like that. But it's not, it's not really excusable where, especially when Penn State, it's not like they lit it up with their receivers. I mean, I know Jehan Dodson was a first round pick a couple years ago, but the last two years, and the quarterback play has played a part in this, especially this past year in 2023, the quarterback play was really bad and below average, and that plays a part.
Starting point is 01:19:43 But, yeah, this is a play. If he won't get out of day two. He will be a day two pick. I'd be very surprised if he did. He can't. Brent Strange went around two. And he's from Stap's goal. He's way better, way better.
Starting point is 01:19:57 So yeah, yeah, there's no chance. But yeah. You want to hit these other tight ends here, Nate? You got a couple others that you liked that you wanted to mention outside of the top 100 consensus. Yeah, I'll just kind of complete other guys that they're all in my top 100, but they're outside the consensus. And that's Jared Wiley from TCU, who I think major top 100 Dane as well. He was 8.9. Okay.
Starting point is 01:20:17 And Wiley is more of a receiving only tight end. I've seen comparisons to Mike Kisiki. I think Wiley's much tougher, much better blocker, much more of a fluid athlete than Kikiski. Gisisi Gisci was explosive. Wiley is a true, like, runner and splitter and a good route runner with good hands. Great size. You don't see a lot of six-six guys that can move like this. Again, another guy having my top 100, big, fast athlete that actually has tangible film.
Starting point is 01:20:41 And he's not a great blocker, but he's willing to scrap. And he's not, he's not soft in that area. So another guy that's an intriguing package that I'd be willing to bet on. The last one is a quarterback. So made that transition to tight down. He was throwing passes to Quentin Johnston. in Temple, Texas, back in the day. Yeah.
Starting point is 01:20:59 So they were teammates together, quarterback receiver, and then, yeah, he made the transition of tight end when he went to Texas and then before he transferred to TCU. It's a different than, you know, my dad's transition from quarterback to tight end or Blake Bell. Like, Blake Bell was just so good.
Starting point is 01:21:14 The Bell dozer. While he can roll. Like, he is a good athlete. I mean, Tess. 462 at 250, not bad. And it shows up on film. It's not just a pure projection. And then the,
Starting point is 01:21:26 last guy throughout here, the last tight end is A. G. Barner from Michigan. I understand why he's outside of top 100, even if I snuck him in. I just like his blocking ability. I think he's an inline guy that can play early downs and be a sound auxiliary target. He's the classic Y. That's the classic quarterback's best friend. He might never catch a ball past five yards. But it's he's got good hands and he actually's not bad with his routes. It's just that he's not a good athlete. He's more of an average athlete. But I do like his blocking his willingness to scrap. So I feel like Barners should have a role in this league, even if it might be a day three pick. Let's keep the Michigan Love Fest going here, Dan. Your last guy that is one of your guys outside of
Starting point is 01:22:05 the Consensus Top 100. Who do you got for me? Yeah, and I wanted to get one of these, I like a lot of these pass rushers on day three. You know, Jalick's Hunt from Houston Christians, a good player, Mo Kamara from Colorado State. But I went with Braden McGregor from Michigan, who, and I actually had him going to Detroit in my seven-round mock. He's a Michigan kid. born and bread and goes to the, he's a Wolverine and could be a lion because I think he fits in terms of mentality, toughness, compete, all that kind of stuff. He fits what the lions want to be. But yeah, he's got that first step quickness that really stands out and he likes to get after the quarterback. He's tough. He grew up as a hockey player. So you see that toughness show up.
Starting point is 01:22:47 Yeah, he's not maybe the most complete player at this point in his development. Kind of reminded me of Alex Wright when he was coming out of UAB. Now he's just a role player for the Browns. I don't think he'll be drafted in a third round like Alex Wright was, but I think somewhere fourth through the sixth round, he's going to be some pretty, provide some pretty good value as a sub-package rusher. Maybe he ends up being more, but I just like the play personality that he brings every snap. He's going to go kill the quarterback, and I can win with guys like that. Sorry, that was just a great way. He's going to murder somebody and that's what I want.
Starting point is 01:23:26 All he wants to do is inflict pain on other people and that's who I'm looking for, Dane Brugler. All right, guys, that is all we got. Those are your guys in this year's draft and thankfully we will be covering pretty much every pick at least the first three rounds of this year's
Starting point is 01:23:42 draft. So hopefully we're going to see plenty of your guys come off the board and get to talk about them. Quick reminder, Knights 1 and 2, first three rounds, live on YouTube on the Athletic NFL YouTube channel. We will be in Detroit, please come join us. We have a blast.
Starting point is 01:23:57 I hope you guys enjoy it as well. If you've never checked out the live draft show, this is the time to start. So please come hang out with us on those couple nights because we are very much looking forward to it. I have one last thing. Sorry to ruin that exit there, Robert. Travis Frederick just texted me back.
Starting point is 01:24:14 He cleaned somewhere between 365 and 400. So that's what we're talking about with Murphy there, that he's cleaning as much as 330-pound, Travis Frederick, who's one of the strongest human beings that you'll ever meet. Murphy is 375. So, yeah. That's what you're a character. A guy who can hang clean a lot, hates being blocked, and likes to hurt people.
Starting point is 01:24:37 So checking a lot of boxes for Dane Bruegler. That is all we got, guys. We will be back on Friday this week. Me and my buddies, Ben Solek and Danny Kelly, we're doing a fun little gimmicky draft thing that I think you guys will enjoy. So please come back and check that out. And then with the three of us, we'll have one more show before the draft kicks off next week. So please be on the lookout for that.
Starting point is 01:25:00 In the meantime, really appreciate guys listening. We'll talk to you soon. This was the Athletic Football Show.

There aren't comments yet for this episode. Click on any sentence in the transcript to leave a comment.