The Best of Car Talk - #2509: Undressed for Success
Episode Date: February 1, 2025The list of innovations that Car Talk has brought to the 'radio call-in' genre is long: unpreparedness, lack of focus and a unique inability to take anything seriously top the list. On this episode o...f the Best of Car Talk we discuss 'proper attire'. Get access to hundreds of episodes in the Car Talk archive when you sign up for Car Talk+ at plus.npr.org/cartalkLearn more about sponsor message choices: podcastchoices.com/adchoicesNPR Privacy Policy
Transcript
Discussion (0)
Hey, it's Robin Hilton from NPR Music.
Many years ago, I helped start the Tiny Desk Concert Series.
Right now, NPR is looking for the next great, undiscovered musician to perform behind the
famous desk.
Think you've got what it takes?
Submit a video of you playing an original song to the Tiny Desk Contest by February
10th.
Find out more and see the official rules at npr.org slash tiny desk contest. Music
Hello and welcome to Car Talk from National Public Radio with us
clicking clack the Tappet Brothers, and we're broadcasting this week from Murky Research here at Car Talk Plaza.
Now, Murky Research division, we gave him an entire division.
Well, we did, but he's not a War Battalion now.
But...
Well, Paul Murky of Murky Research has presented us with poll results.
You may remember a few weeks ago, we introduced the Car talk opinion poll. Yeah the weekly car talk opinion poll. Every time we come up with something that we think is
going to be weekly it ends up being bi-weekly or monthly. We can't seem to do anything.
Well, bi-weekly we mean this W-E-A. Anyway our first poll question here was
should a 16 year old kid have his or her own car?
Yeah.
First of all, the vote was overwhelmingly against a 16 year old kid having his own car.
It was two to one.
Like 67%, almost exactly two to one.
67% answered no.
And I bet you something like 33 said yeah.
30, yeah.
How'd you know that
and we also knowing our little cross tabs here we did a few cross tabs and we we can answer the
following questions like did women answer differently than men I mean I have to say that
my expectation was that more men would be in favor of a 16 year old kid having
his own car than women.
Most men that weren't hypocrites because they had a car when they were 16 or they lusted
after a car when they were 16.
They lusted after a car and they would understand what it was like to have a car.
They could empathize.
Empathize, that's a good word.
And women being more sane, I would have guessed would have said absolutely not.
But the truth is, it was almost exactly the same males and females.
That was curious.
Interesting.
And it was again, 67-33 or 32.
32 and a half.
Yeah.
What about people with kids and without kids uh... people with kids were
more opposed to the idea than people without but it was close it was like
seventy one percent for people
with kids said no and and sixty something percent with kids of get right to
the aberrations the aberrations interesting part
part of it was an aberration
what about age
what about it and obviously it was an aberration. What about age? What about age? And obviously everyone under 20
was strongly in favor. It was like 81% said, yes, of course a 16-year-old kid should have
his or her own car. And only 20% said no. But we don't count them. I mean, because they're
biased about this whole thing. But everyone who who was a real person in the interest of fairness. We didn't count
No, we we encountered them. Of course you know we just we discount them right there. They you three for dollar
We hear they can't know it real people people are 20 to 45 all about the same about 65 percent said no they shouldn't and
33 percent said yes, they should
then for people who are 45 to 64
And I think this is the group where all the parents of the 16 year old are the no response went up to about
75% not unexpected and here's the curious thing. Yes
I thought so too people who were 65 and older were split almost even, half and half saying yes and no.
My brother has a theory about this, but I don't know what the theory is.
Yeah, no, I just think that old people realize that you're going to have fun when you're
young, and maybe they didn't, and maybe they're having some regrets about that.
Sure. Well, more importantly, what's this week's question?
This week's question is this, should the country, that's the United States of
America that we live in, remain on daylight saving time year-round? That is
abolish what we call standard time and it will soon become, so that daylight
saving time will soon become the standard time.
Should we stay on daylight saving time?
I don't want to influence the answer to this, but when do you need more daylight than in
the winter?
Exactly.
And that's just the time when we decide not to save it.
And what happens to all those hours that we save anyway?
Where are they well we had some
so that's the question
so you can go to the website uh... car talk dot msn dot com and you can vote
should the country remain on daylight saving time year-round thank you so much
it's been nice being a guest on your show
and i'll see you later
great thank god if you'd like to call us about your car or anything else for that matter, our number is 1-800-332-9287.
Hello, you're on Car Talk.
Hi, my name is Laurie. I'm from Binghamton, New York.
Laurie?
L-A-U-R-I-E.
Very good. Most people want to shorten that right down.
To L-O-R-I.
Anyway.
What's up? I have a 1987 Subaru GL with about, I guess
now about 136,000 miles on it. And for the last two years I've been plagued with this
problem of losing antifreeze. You know, the radiator has been replaced and several times
I've taken it to people who have done that thing where they flush, you know, water through
it to check for leaks. And there are no visible leaks but here's the
worst thing about this is that it's getting it's on the engine somehow so
the fumes come back at me of hot antifreeze you can smell it yes I can
smell it well how come these morons that you brought it to can't find the leak I
don't know I don't know did I answer my You may have. No, I mean if you can smell
it obviously it's leaking onto something and if they were there at that moment and opened
up the hood they would be able to see exactly where it was coming from. Because it's green,
right? It's bright green. Yeah and it's wet. Yeah. And steam would be coming off of it.
But my temperature gauge never changes. Well the temperature gauge wouldn't change unless you were genuinely
overheating on the other hand
if you lose a little bit of coolant under high pressure it will make a lot
of steam yeah
because half of what's in there is water right now it steams up pretty easily
you can do this yourself if you can't trust any of these bozo mechanics that
you've been to then next time this happens
very gingerly open the hood and see if you can tell.
Don't open the hood.
Don't open the hood?
No.
Gingerly.
The hood should only be opened by a trained professional wearing the proper combat gear.
Yeah.
Which consists of what?
A baseball hat on backwards.
Oh, God.
Yeah, you'll be able to, able to open the hood because it's not
Pssst, pouring out.
Just be careful that there isn't any steam really coming out of it.
So open it, when I say gingerly, sort of open it a crack
and make sure there's no Psssssss going on.
Well the other problem area on these cars is the water pump.
So you could have a leaky water pump, a leaky water pump gasket, or you could have a leaky
hose somewhere else in the system.
And it should be very easily found with a pressure test.
What we would do if we had this car is we would find a nice dry spot on which to park
it, run the engine with the pressure tester on it and get the engine red hot, and then
if it hadn't built up its own pressure, we would build it up to perhaps 15 or 20 pounds of
pressure which is five pounds over operating pressure. This is just a little pump that
goes on in place of the radiator cap and you can actually pump it up like a
bicycle pump. Exactly. So you can pressurize the whole cooling system. And then you shut
the car off and you let it sit there and you watch what happens. Now it's very likely that the same steam that you see is gonna work here for the mechanic
Mm-hmm, and he's gonna be able then
using this
Instrument that he has called the eye
Yeah, I mean this ain't rocket science
You have a little pinhole in a hole someplace. Yeah. Or you have a blown head gasket.
Oh, oh.
No, I don't see a head gasket in Laurie's future.
Oh, thank you.
I see.
I mean, I'm going to just, I have to go into a little trance here for a moment, but I'm
getting a very, very strong water pump message.
Ah.
Yeah.
And I'm also getting a number. $161.50.
That's it. You did great. Yeah it just happened to me and I that's what I see.
You are an ideal candidate to be on Stump the Chumps in a few weeks.
Stay by the phone. We'll call you but get it fixed before you're over again.
I mean, you might not have too many brain cells left.
I mean, after all, you even called us, which is an indication that something isn't right.
And I listen to you every week, so what does that say?
In that little brain, yeah.
Right.
Good luck.
Thank you.
Bye-bye.
Hey, we've got more calls in the puzzler answer coming up right after this. This message comes from eBay. Picture this. You're halfway through a DIY car fix, tools
scattered everywhere and boom! You realize you're missing a part. It's okay because you
know whatever it is, it's on eBay. They've got everything. Brakes, headlights, cold air
intakes, whatever you need and it's guaranteed to fit, which
means no more crossing your fingers and hoping you ordered the right thing.
All the parts you need, at prices you'll love, guaranteed to fit every time.
eBay.
Things.
People.
Love.
This message comes from Wyze, the app for doing things in other currencies.
Sending or spending money abroad?
Hidden fees may
be taking a cut.
With WISE, you can convert between up to 40 currencies at the mid-market exchange rate.
Visit WISE.com.
TNCs apply.
Here's some news that really stinks.
Garbage is responsible for 20% of planet-warming methane emissions.
That's why all week, here and now, is looking at ways people are cutting back on waste. Robot dogs hiking landfills, textile recyclers melting
down old clothes, dumpster divers scoring big, and builders deconstructing homes instead
of demolishing them. You can hear all that by following our podcast. It's called Here
and Now, Anytime. Okay, it is time once again to provide America with the answer to last week's puzzler, which
was historic, folkloric, not very challenging because you've got the answer and not terribly
interesting.
I got the answer.
But hey, 248-4 ain't bad, right?
I don't even know the question.
You didn't need it.
I didn't need the question and I got the answer but they taught a for ain't bad right don't even know the question I didn't need the question that I got the answer anyway well at the
time you needed the question ah I remember some time ago I used a puzzle
regarding the man who was responsible for introducing to America the car radio
that's right his name was Lear yeah Norman Lear he later went on to write the
famous show all in the family with Archie Bunker.
That guy. Bill Lear was his name. Yeah. From Lear Jet fame. Yeah. Sure. And the radio was called the Motorola. Motor-ola. Great name. Vict name. Yeah. Bill Lear, as it turns out, invented many things, but he also invented another car related device
that was popular in the 70s. In fact, the car I owned had one, and it was something you would find in the dashboard of
cars of that ilk, but you'd hardly ever find one on a car anymore. Yeah. Unless it was from that era,
I suppose. Hmm. The question very simply was, what was it? And you immediately... Yeah, jumped right in. Jumped right in and figured out the very simply was what was it and you immediately
Yeah jumped right in.
Jumped right in and figured out the answer and what was it man?
Can't remember. It was an 8-track player.
There you go an 8-track tape player. For those of you that don't know we have a lot of young
listeners and a lot of real old listeners.
I mean it's easy to have never seen an eight track player. Yeah, the eight track was a continuous loop of tapes. It would just keep playing over and over
and over again. Yeah. And there were eight tracks on it so you could switch from it was brilliant.
I don't understand what happened to that. That was a great technology.
There was something wrong. They jammed up all the time. I threw away more tapes.
You never knew what was on any of those tracks. You never knew what was actually happening when you pressed the button.
Oh, no.
Because if you were trying to find something you had just listened to, take your week.
Oh, yeah.
Hahaha!
Yeah, geez.
Hey, that's good. Actually, I want to say that I willed all my eight tracks to John Sebastian Lawler.
Who now has them all.
He has them all, because he is the only one around.
He has almost Paul Moriart tapes.
Maria Moldor was big in those days.
OK.
Do we have a winner?
Come on, man.
Come on, between the poll thing and this one.
We're not going to take any calls today.
The show's already half over.
The winner this week is Ed Mazurek.
Mazurek.
Mazurek.
Mazurek.
M-A-Z-U-R-E-K. From Mibane. M-Eurek. Mazurek. Mazurek. Mazurek.
M-A-Z-U-R-E-K.
From Mebane.
M-E-B-
Mebane.
M-E-B-A-N-E.
I think Mebane.
Mebane or Mebane or Mabane.
Mabane.
Mabane.
North Carolina.
Isn't that the state that Jesse,
and Ed for having the correct answer
chosen at random from those thousands of correct
Oh, and they were our pal Ed is gonna win one of our car talk sistine wrench t-shirts
this is just like the one that Michelangelo painted except there is a
strategically placed adjustable wrench and
God is handing it to my brother
Saying go forward my son and fix those boat payments.
Well, congratulations Ed.
We'll have a puzzler coming up in the second half of today's show.
Notice I didn't say no because it may be a use-on, but you'll see why.
So don't touch that dial. In the meantime, we'll take your calls at 1-800-332-9287.
Hello, you're on Car Talk.
Hi guys, how you doing?
Good, who's this?
This is Marisha calling from Colorado Springs.
Who?
Marisha.
Marisha.
M-A-R-I-S-C-H-A.
Oh, so close.
No C.
M-A-R-I-S-H-A.
Yes, just like it sounds.
Like Marisha and Marisha put together yeah I don't
know why I threw that C in there I was I was thinking of Eastern Europe what is
this name you named after st. Marisha you know I have no idea my grandmother
named me she heard it in a restaurant I'm probably It's a good thing she wasn't getting her oil changed. Maybe a side dish. Your name might have been Jiffy.
Where are you from Marisha?
Colorado Springs.
Colorado.
Okay, we're ready.
Okay, here's the problem.
I have a 93 Subaru Legacy wagon.
And for some reason, my left rear tire is making this really strange sound
It kind of sounds like
Let's see. How would I describe it? Like if you have a rock in your tire, you know
But it doesn't do a tick it doesn't wash wish so when you go slow goes whoosh whoosh
Which and then as you go faster goes whoosh whoosh was and then when you get going really fast it goes
So it kind of uh...
and higher-pitched sound
then you know when you're driving on the highway up to about seventy five it does
that and then at seventy five the kind of
smooth out and doesn't really make too much of a pound
and i don't plan to get that point
that we'll have to touch the ground anymore
now i know it's been a grand because it's making the whole car vibrate.
Yeah, you have a bad tire.
A bad tire?
Yeah, you have a tire which is a classic case of tread separation.
Huh.
Yeah, if you were to lift up that corner of the car and spin that tire and watch as it
spins watch the tread, you will notice a perturbation in the tread.
You'll notice a deviation, a lump.
You'll notice some place where the tread
doesn't look the same, doesn't look parallel
to the other tread.
You have like five treads going across,
five grooves going across the tire.
One of them or two of them is gonna be screwed up.
And you're gonna say, wow, look at that!
How many miles on these tires?
Um, you know, I have no idea. I got them used.
You got them used? You bought used tires?
Yes.
How much did you pay for these here used tires?
Oh, I think 25 bucks a pair.
A pair?
Mm-hmm.
Double occupancy.
Excellent. How long have you had them
uh... there's no probably had a lot three or four months
i mean i looked at the time it looks fine yeah you can't tell you have to
spin it
i think you need to do this soon
like i like now
okay i'm so you know
have you created damage to my car mean no no but it can create damage to your
car if you have like a blowout and crash into a tree.
This tire is getting ready to self-destruct. Were these used tires and not retreads?
They were used tires and not retreads.
Well, chances are the other three are okay.
Okay.
So you need to buy one.
Cool.
Cool. Good luck.
Thanks guys.
See you Marisha.
Bye bye.
Bye bye.
1-800-332-9287. Hello, you're on Car Talk.
Hi there, this is Dan in Atlanta.
Hey, Dan, how are you?
I'm well, how are you?
Uh, pretty good.
We're having a hard time today.
Yes.
We are. I don't know what's going on. My brother just took his pants off.
Look at this multi-million dollar studio here. It's a hundred degrees in here.
You sweating? Yeah, I'm dying. But, uh, it's not like we're drinking hot chocolate.
What's up, Dan?
Alright, uh, my situation, first of all, my car is a 1992 Acura Integra.
Yeah.
And, this, I have to give you a little background on the situation to uh... help explain
i live in a duplex and
a
gentleman has been living in the basement of this house
yeah and this gentleman in the mechanic
and it's just a small tiny little dungeon of an apartment that he lived
down in the basement and for the most part most mechanics live in little
dungeons
okay
he rises very early in the morning and basement and for the most part most mechanics live in little dungeons okay
he rises
very early in the morning and
uh... in his doorway and read this paper
and so every morning as i go out and get in my car and start it up and drive off
he's there
hearing me start this car
haha and probably about
two months ago
i drove home one day got out of my car was just proceeding into my house when he
said came out you better adjust those valves Sonny exactly
he well first he just started inquiring about have I had my oil changed recently
have I put in a new filter am I leaking oil yeah and he continued to ask me these
questions on occasion when I'd come home and I would for the most part
disregard his inquiry yeah yeah just a strange old peezer.
Because he was just an annoying little troll.
Troll under the bridge.
And it was probably two weeks ago I came home one time and he said, I really think you have
a problem.
He said, I believe that your car is not building up oil pressure.
Really?
I mean, is this guy currently employed art
he's just sits there with the paper all day now he is employed he he works in a
small garage not too far from where we live
uh... about two minutes later there's a knock on the door and it's
this gentleman
and he's written out for me
everything that i should have checked
uh... in regards to this
problem that he thinks exist really what a wonderful and nice and i consider
it
it's all i can read you the things that you wrote out that i thought the oil pump
was not producing pressure and he could tell that because he could hear the
valves clacking away exactly
so i had to take my car to my mechanic for unrelated problems but you're
well while i have it in there
all mention this to them and give their opinion on it
took the car and they let it sit overnight
and did a cold start.
And when I went back to pick it up the next day,
they said, we don't think you have a problem.
And their explanation was this.
They said that the engine for the Acura,
like the engine for, I think this is the Honda Prelude,
the clearance on the valves is so small and so close that when it's cold and you start the car up,
you're going to hear rattling and it's just a noisy engine.
But that once it warms up, that noise should go away and there really is nothing to be worried about and no problems.
Well, it's interesting. The one piece of information that you mentioned was that one day when you were coming home from work,
he stopped you and evidently having heard your engine when it was warmed up,
he still felt you had the problem.
See, here's the thing with oil pressure.
When you start the engine in the morning, the engine is cold.
You get lots of oil pressure because the engine's cold.
And the engine's revving.
And the oil is viscous.
And if the story they have about the clearances is true,
and I don't know that it is or not,
then maybe that would cause engine noise
when it first is started,
but it's not because of oil pressure.
Later, when the engine warms up,
like when you're on your way back home at night,
and when you get home, the engine is all warmed up,
and that's when the oil pressure is the lowest.
So when you pull into the driveway, you now have the oil which is at its hottest and you're
idling so the engine revs are down and therefore the oil pressure is at its very lowest.
If you have the noise then, then these guys are not right. See, unfortunately these guys didn't really do anything
because all they did was start it up and listen to it.
What they should have really done is measure the oil pressure when the engine was hot
if they really cared about you.
Like this guy does.
Well, let me throw in this factor as well.
Uh oh. Our landlady, she has known this mechanic, known this gentleman longer than I have.
I mentioned this to her and she said don't let him anywhere near your car.
Boy. Oh, oh. So maybe I need a third party to take this to yeah, so you gotta I think you have to go to a neutral party
I agree and ask them simply
Warm up the car and tell me the oil pressure cold and hot
You want an office with inspect? Okay, if it is don't worry
Okay, Danny, baby. Thanks so much guys. See ya. Take care. Bye. Bye Don't go anywhere. Stick around for more calls and the new puzzler coming right up.
Hi, we're back. You're listening to Car Talk from National Public Radio with us, Click and Clack the
Tappet Brothers, and we're here, of course, as always, to discuss cars, which we seldom
do, car repair, which we seldom do, and some interesting signage.
Now, I had a signage block the other day.
Did you use a nasal spray for that? How long have we been doing this show? 20 years. So I'll do and some interesting signage now. I had a signage block
Use a nasal spray for that. How long we've been doing this show
20 years, you know what? I just figured out
When the microphones are on that little light comes on Oh Wow, and when that light is off the microphones are off get out of town
20 years well, it took me 20 years and 2 minutes.
It never occurred to me that...
Here's the interesting sign.
It's sent to us by John Tegler from God knows where.
It's in Arizona, isn't it?
These are presumably some actual signs that people have seen in various places.
For example, at a Santa Fe gas station is a sign, we will sell gasoline to anyone in
a glass container on a long established New Mexico dry cleaning establishment.
Thirty-eight years on the same spot.
I mean and talk about
uh... that choice of words
in the office of a loan company
ask about our plans for owning your home
uh...
on a main shop
our motto is to give our customers the lowest possible prices and workmanship
uh... our motto is to give our customers the lowest possible prices and workmanship
well whoever only stores thought when they were in the eighth grade the
grammar
was not going to be important in their lives yes
what's even sad about these is that after
posting the size they didn't
in all i have realized i had
and because why because most of the people who came to and saw the signs didn't notice there was anything wrong either.
Yes.
It was just a general dumbing down of the entire American population.
38 years on the same spot.
I mean, you know, when I was a kid, I was below average in intelligence.
And now I'm considered a genius.
Because everyone else has gotten so stupid.
I think it's great.
OK, now here's the puzzler for this week.
Now I've thought about this a lot,
and I have a whole bunch of puzzles,
but I have to revisit this puzzler from yesteryear
for a variety of reasons.
Number one, it was very...
I know one of them.
You found out the right answer.
All right.
Number of reasons plus one.
Plus one.
Number one, it was perhaps, it is perhaps, one of the best puzzlers of all time, I think.
Monty Hall?
Number two, we haven't used it in so long that the people that heard it then, are dead.
Oh, they forgot.
Here it is in its simplest form.
You may remember the game show.
What was that game show?
Let's make a deal.
Let's make a deal.
Yeah.
Where the contestant was presented with three doors.
Door number one, door number two, and door number three.
Behind one of the doors was a wonderful prize, and behind the other two doors were crummy
prizes known as zonks.
Yeah.
And very simple.
Like a couple of candy bars or some such thing.
Exactly.
Something not worth much.
Exactly.
63 dodge dart, anything like that.
Here's the deal.
You are the contestant.
I'm the contestant.
Monty Hall says pick a door.
Your chances of picking a Zonk are two and three, and your chances of picking the winner
are one and three.
Right.
He says, okay, you picked door number two.
I'm going to show you what's behind one of the doors that you didn't pick.
Now, because there are two zonks and one winner, and he knows where the winners and the zonks
are, he shows you one of the doors that you didn't pick that's clearly a zonk.
So he says, I'm going to show you what's behind door number one.
And he looks behind door number one.
And it's six candy bars.
Six candy bars. He then says to you, would you like to keep door number one. And he looks behind door number one. And it's six candy bars. Six candy bars.
He then says to you, would you like to keep door number two
which you've chosen, or would you like to switch
to door number three?
That's the question.
Should you switch or not switch?
Now, if you think you know the answer,
or just feel sorry for the post office
in this age of email,
and you want to give them something to do
Send your answer to puzzler tower car talk Plaza box
3500 Harvard Square, Cambridge our fair city man
02238 or if you prefer you can email us your answer from our website car talk MSN calm
Just click on the talk to car talk section. Now if we choose your correct answer at random
from among all of the correct answers that we receive,
you will get a Car Talk Sistine Wrench T-shirt.
Car Talk's first attempt and probably last at fine art.
And we don't say when you'll get it, you will get it.
You shall get it, you might.
At some time.
You probably will.
In the future.
Our number if you'd like to call us is 1-800-332-9287.
Hello, you're on Car Talk.
This is Daniel from Falmouth, Maine.
Daniel, look, before we start, we spent a lot of time on just a couple of calls here,
so we're going to have to really hustle.
So we're going to give you the bum's rush.
You don't mind, do you?
I don't mind.
Okay.
I'll try to be fast.
Ask us something like with a yes or no answer.
Yeah.
What?
I won't.
I could ask a lot of you.
You do whatever you want.
Okay.
Here we go.
I have a 91 Stanza, Nissan Stanza.
It had a lot of transmission problems.
Basically the thing had to be rebuilt and it took them three or four times to get it right eventually medical manual
automatic yeah
uh... and they got the transmission square away pretty well
shortly after
finally getting it fixed
i began to have uh... the following problem
overheating
the no
okay no don't go
but what does one of the taken up more time iraq
i thought i was going to be faster yeah i'm sorry
if i
uh... after driving this car for a few miles if i turn the wheel sharply for
example like pulling into a a parking lot ninety degrees from the direction of
the house
there is a very loud, very forceful vibration from the front end, like that.
And the noise occurs from the same side whether you're turning left or right or is it?
The whole front end seems to shake hard.
If I'm partway through the turn and straighten the wheel out, it goes away.
And it has never happened like if you were coming off of the highway and taking an exit and taking a
pretty sharp turn to come off an exit or it would
i've never had it happen
uh... under those circumstances okay my brother's sorry i asked that question you know i'm not sorry no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no So I had I I had him I took it back to the transmission place had him put it up on the rack
Their opinion was that actually it had nothing to do with the transmission. They were sick of seeing me obviously
But but they thought that that there was some issue going on with the brakes where the where a break or both breaks
We're sort of heating up and grabbing
brake or both brakes were sort of heating up and grabbing. I don't think so. You can get this to happen making your tight turns without stepping on the brake.
Absolutely correct. I don't have to step on the brake.
Well, I think they're right that it has nothing to do with the transmission,
but I think they're wrong that it has something to do with the brakes.
Okay.
I mean, the thing that comes immediately to mind is that you have a bad axle,
a bad constant velocity joint. That's the thing that comes to mind immediately.
You know, I asked them if it could be the CV joint and they said, oh no, no, no, it's
not that. Well, but this was a transmission place.
Yeah. So they wouldn't know.
Really? No. Do you have a regular shop?
A regular doctor, so to speak. Right, who's your primary care mechanic?
Who's your primary care mechanic? My gatekeeper. Yeah, not really.
But I could take it to the dealer.
Well, you could.
See, the problem is because you don't have a primary care person,
you have no one that's going to go out of his way for you.
The transmission guys we know hate you.
Right. They do.
Very, very badly.
So you really can't, I mean, they don't want to see you anymore.
They don't care, quite honestly, if the wheels fall off and you die.
Matter of fact, they don't want to see you anymore.
They don't care quite honestly if the wheels fall off and you die.
Matter of fact, they may be hoping that happens.
So I was going to suggest if you had somebody that was willing to quote work with you a little bit,
you could ask that person to replace one of the axles or maybe both of them and see if the noise goes away.
I suspect that that's going to solve it. Okay. Let me ask you this. If it is the CV joint or the axle, am I in danger here of
something not yet happening?
No. As a matter of fact, the best way to approach this, if it were my car, if I were you, is
I would let it go until it gets worse, until in fact it begins making the noise under the
circumstances that my brother explained 25 minutes ago.
Yeah. So a more gentle curve.
Yes, exactly.
Exiting a highway on a ramp of constant radius of curvature.
You get the...
But when that happens, you'll know you have a bad axle.
So now the next question is going to be, you know, how much money and is it worth even
doing it or should I just get rid of the car?
It's a few hundred bucks an axle at the very least.
All right.
I will do that. Do we answer any of your questions. No
Actually, it was very it's very helpful because I doubted this brake diagnosis
Hey, that was the yes or no part of the yeah
Here you go. I have a question for you. Is it the brakes no, okay?
Well it's happened again you have wasted another hour listening to Car Talk.
Our esteemed producer is Doug the Subway Fugitive, not a slave to Fashion Berman.
Our associate producer and Dean of the College of Autobusiness College is Ken Babyface Rogers.
Ken is due for a new name.
He is.
Yeah, he needs something bad.
Our assistant producer is Katherine Crystal Ray, and. He is. Yeah, he needs something bad. Our assistant producer is Katherine
Crystal Ray and our engineer is John Marsden. Our technical, spiritual and menu advisor
is Mr. John Lawler. Our public opinion pollster is Paul Murky of Murky Research, of course
assisted by statistician Marge in Overa. Our director of new product repair is Warren T.
Myfoot. Our staff butler from the Cartock Car Talk Mumbai Division is Mahatma Cope.
Our Document Security Expert from the Island of Jamaica is Euripides Uppman.
Our Italian Governance is Donna Day Everlearn.
The Co-Chairs of the Car Talk Building Department are Norman Naylor and Maureen Staplegun.
Our Face of Driving Instructor is Vera Bruppley.
Our Director of Moral Support is Hugh Deman. The Chairman of the Federal Lubrication Board is Alan Griespan. And our Leo
Tolstoy biographer this week is Warren Peace, author of Leo Tolstoy by Warren
Peace. Our chief counsel from the law firm of Dewey Chidman Howe is Hugh Lewis Dewey.
Known under the benches of Hobbit Square is Huey Louie Dewey. Thanks so much for
listening. We're Clickin' Clack for Tappin Brothers and above all do not drive like my brother. Don't drive like my brother either. We'll be back next week bye bye.
And now with an important announcement here is Car Talk Plaza's chief mechanic Mr. Vinny Gumbatz.
Alright shut up Bill. Just want a copy of this week's Car Talk Show, which happens to be number 41.
Here's what you gotta do, alright?
Alright, now you will give us the phone number now, Vinnie?
No, I'm gonna recite the 14th Amendment to the Fredonian Constitution, you jerk.
The number to call is 303-823-8000.
And what's the number if people wanted the best of Car Talk CD or other Car Talk things?
What are you, just trying to annoy me or something?
I'm sorry.
For Car Talk CDs, cassettes, t-shirts, etc.
You call 303-823-8000 or you visit our shameless commerce division at cartalk.msn.com.
You got anything to add to this Mr. Radioman?
No, I don't.
Good.
Car Talk is a production of Dewey, Cheetah, and Howe and WBUR in Boston.
And even though Bailey White's voice cracks every time she hears us say it, this is NPR National Public Radio.