The Binge Cases: U R NEXT - Fake Priest | 3. The Teacher

Episode Date: August 27, 2020

Even con artists need mentors. Meet the false prophet who teaches Father Ryan how to perfect his con. Father Ryan evades criminal charges again and Alex learns about an unspoken reason prosecutors could let many criminals go free. A Neon Hum Media and Sony Music Entertainment production. Subscribe on Apple Podcasts to binge all episodes now or listen weekly wherever you get your podcasts. Find more great podcasts from Sony Music Entertainment at sonymusic.com/podcasts Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

Everyone needs a teacher. Father Ryan was no different. The Father Ryan we know today was formed out in the desert, in the heat of Arizona, just north of the Fort Apache Reservation and Tonto National Forest. That's where in 1996, you could find Our Lady of Guadalupe, a religious sanctuary sometimes called a refuge. It was run by a man named Marvin Cusera.

The land is flat and dusty, with the occasional small desert plant adding some green. Our lady of Guadalupe is only about 80 acres of land with some trailer homes. This is the place and Cusera the guy that would help me understand just how Father Ryan refined his con. He'd smooth out the edges and fix the mistakes that led him to get into so much trouble opening the first abbey. Marvin Cusera was the perfect person to learn from.

He'd built a national following with seven. refugees in seven states. Cusera had published two books and wrote a newsletter read across the country. All of it because he claimed to receive messages from the Virgin Mary and Jesus Christ himself. Cusera even transcribed his conversations with Jesus for the readers of his newsletter. He'd created this whole little traditional Catholic empire. But just like Ryan, Cusera was a convicted criminal. Here was someone finding success. where Father Ryan hadn't yet. For years, Cusera had mostly stayed under the radar.

That is, until he and Father Ryan would get together. That's when the FBI and a local sheriff's office took notice. Clearly, in my mind, these two guys are just a fraud. From Neon Hum Media, I'm Alex Schumann, and this is smokescreen, fake priest. Calling it a refuge is a bit of a misnomer. Jim Stansberry is a former investigator who looked into Marvin Cusera and Father Ryan. He helped me connect the dots.

Back in 1996, Stansberry had gone out to Our Lady of Guadalupe after getting a tip. But it was strange. You wouldn't know you were on it when you got there if you didn't know exactly what you were looking for. When you hear refuge, you might picture a vast, forested piece of nature with little cats, spotting a hillside. That's not what this was. It's not a refuge as if, you know, there's fences around it and all that kind of thing. This is just connected 40-acre plots, some of which have double-wides on them or houses on them and some don't. Jim started his investigation in 1996.

He worked in the Criminal Division for the Navajo County Sheriff's Office. I was in the People Crimes Division of the Criminal Investigations. He felt Cusera and Ryan broke the law, pure and simple. I thought it was a fraudulent scheme as what it's called here in Arizona. Arizona law says anyone who knowingly gets any benefit by using a false pretense is guilty of a class two felony. One of Cusera's followers called the sheriff's office after realizing he wasn't being honest. She'd already given money. I think it was $1.6 or $1.8 million.

The followers name was Helen Job. She lived in California and gave Cusera more than a million and a half to buy land and buildings in Arizona before even seeing the property. The refuges were meant to be safe spaces. The idea was that one day traditionalist religious values would be threatened, and then these places could provide shelter. Many followers of Cusera and Ryan already believed their faith was under attack. So they moved to these sanctuaries.

And people like Helen felt they were something special worth supporting. She'd read Cusera's books and newsletters and believed in Cusera and his sanctuary so much that she willingly gave him a fortune. Jim's report for the sheriff's office includes pictures of the checks Helen mailed. On May 31st, 1996, she sent one letter that begins, Dear Marv, here is a check for 50,000 for startup cost. In one envelope, she includes three checks totaling more than $338,000.

All this cash is where Jim starts his investigation. You know, I followed the money. Jim finds Cusera's been convicted of fraud. Two board members for the refuge have criminal convictions too. That's at least four people Jim's found with criminal convictions if you count Father Ryan. Remember, he had one for changing that check from the city of Edgerton was concept. Jim didn't buy Father Ryan's act, like at all. Cusera hired Father Ryan to be a priest for the refuge. He was leading mass. He was doing weddings, baptisms, all kinds of things. He was the

priest, putting that in air quotes. I found the guy who introduced the two con men. His name was Dale Lawinger. When Father Ryan's first abbey in Wisconsin was collapsing, Father Ryan reached out to Dale, one of his parishioners at the time, because Father Ryan also knew that Dale ran a religious sanctuary. Yes, and he just wanted to see what our refuge was alike. The refuge, Dale's talking about, is a family farm where he lives today. He believes so much in the message Marvin Cusera shared, he signed on to run a refuge for him in rural Wisconsin.

So what was the point? It's the idea that you're willing to teach the true faith, hold on to the true faith, and be willing to reach out and help others. The reason Cusera drew so much devotion was that he claimed to have received messages from the Virgin Mary. The messages warned of evil forces working within the Vatican to move the church away from its traditional values. He said bishops and priests couldn't be trusted. That's why his refuges were. were so important. It's a pretty good system of belief to follow if those same bishops and priests are calling

you a con artist. Both Ryan and Cusera benefited from people like Dale. Dale doesn't think people take faith seriously anymore, skipping church for any reason they please. Whether it's a trip to the state park or a Green Day Pack or football game or whatever. Dale was afraid for his faith and more than happy to promote the idea of the refuges. So when Father Ryan wanted to learn more, he introduced him to Cusera. The introduction would prove more fateful than Dale could imagine. Okay, so by now, I knew how Cusera and Ryan had met, and that they teamed up. They had set up shop in Snowflake, Arizona,

at Our Lady of Guadalupe. As their followers start to populate the desert with trailer homes, the pair had no idea that this investigator named Jim Stansbury was on their trail. Cusera especially just seemed fishy to him. I mean, he clearly was a con man, and so I thought this is a good case of catching a con man in the con. He's figured out Cusera and Ryan aren't who they say they are. But now he's also learned Cusera's reach goes beyond the refuge near Snowflake, Arizona. He talks to people from all over who felt burned by Cusera. People had lost their belongings, spent thousands, and in some cases, the damage went way beyond the pocketbook.

One woman told Jim that her family will be scarred for life because of Cusera's manipulation and cruelty. She'd lived on the refuge in South Dakota. The followers Jim found all shared the same stories. They came from refuges across the country. There's South Dakota, there's Wisconsin, there's, it just continues. Jim even ran into an FBI agent who was looking into Cusera, too. As I listened to Jim, I'm blown away by how similar Cusera's behavior was to what I've heard about Father Ryan.

He had several different names. He had several different addresses. Followers told Jim that Cusera controlled every aspect of their lives once they got on the refuge. He'd pick when they celebrated birthdays and anniversaries, regardless of the actual dates. He'd approve grocery lists. And this is crucial. Cusera would claim to own any belongings followers would bring onto the refuge. If you bought a double wide and put it on that land, it became the refuge's property. So if you wanted to leave or he decided to kick you out, you had to leave the improvements you had done to the property. This tactic, Father Ryan would later adopt.

If he kicked you out of his abbey, your property was his. Cusera's followers in Arizona told Jim they assumed Father Ryan was an ordained Catholic priest. As Jim made calls, he realized that Cusera probably knew Father Ryan wasn't ordained, and that he was on parole. Jim says Cusera actually called Father Ryan's parole officer before hiring him. I'm frankly surprised someone accused of running this kind of operation would call for references at all. But that's what's in the sheriff's report.

Cusera called and talked to the parole officer and was told he's a con man. Cusera still hires Ryan, knowing full well authorities in Wisconsin, consider him a scammer. It's almost as if the only reason Cusera called Father Ryan's references was to make sure he was a fake.

That way, Ryan would be more willing to do whatever Cusera wanted. Jim's investigation found Cusera paid Ryan several thousand dollars in quote donations for his work on the refuge. Clearly in my mind, these two guys are just a fraud. Later, much later, Ryan claimed he only met Cusera once and didn't invest much time in him. But I have photos of the two of them together in Snowflake. In one of them, Father Ryan appears to be offering Cusera. communion. Eventually, Father Ryan had pissed off some of Cusera's followers, and one of them decided

to look into his background. His name was Paul Bergman. It was his sister, Helen, who'd given hundreds of thousands of dollars for the refuge in Snowflake. The pair were devout Catholics. Something about Father Ryan felt off to Paul, so he checked in with the local Catholic diocese, and they told him Marvin Cusera and Father Ryan hadn't contacted them at all. Nothing about the refuge was legitimate. Paul described everything in a letter that became part of Jim's investigation. It's estimated his sister lost between $1.6 and $2 million to Cusera. His letter is long.

Paul wrote that he told Cusera Father Ryan was misleading everyone, that he wasn't really ordained. But instead of taking Paul's constitutional, concerns seriously, Cusera yelled at him for trying to out Father Ryan. He threatened to kick Paul off the property, even though Paul's family paid for the land. Cusera had Father Ryan's back. He defended him when people questioned his legitimacy. That support might have been part of the reason that Father Ryan would leave Snowflake a new man.

Once Paul and Helen realized they had been swindled by both men, they called the sheriff and out to the actual Catholic Church. But neither Cusera nor Ryan would ever be placed under arrest or even questioned by Jim. Neither of them would ever talk to me. Instead, no charges would ever be filed in his case. And from what Jim understands, that decision didn't have anything to do

with whether Cusera or Ryan had actually committed a crime. But I didn't get to make the decision. The real reason was much more nuanced, much more nuanced and American. Want more true crime? Subscribe to The Binge to get all episodes of My Mother's Lies, add free today, and get instant access to over 50 other jaw-dropping true crime stories. Plus, subscribers get a binge drop of a brand new series on the first of every month,

every month. Search for The Binge channel on Apple Podcasts, or head to Get The Binge.com. to subscribe today. The binge, Feed Your True Crime Obsession. There's something else here now. Something new. From, exclusively on Paramount Plus,

it's the series Stephen King calls Scarious Hell. Everything here is impossible, but it's also real. Sci-fi vision calls it the best show streaming right now. We're running out of time and we still don't know the rules. Don't miss what the movie blog calls something you need to watch. Saving those children. is how we all go home. From binge-all episodes exclusively on Paramount Plus.

One of the biggest questions I've had since I started looking into Father Ryan is why is he not in jail? If all these accusations are true, where's law enforcement? No convictions ever came of the Wisconsin investigation. That was when the Diocese of LaCross asked a different sheriff's office to investigate him for fraud. And here again, I'm hearing about a case. that starts, but no conviction ever comes. What's going on?

Remember, Jim thought that this was a fraudulent scheme under Arizona law. The county attorney disagreed, and so it didn't get prosecuted. Do you remember what his argument was, why he said it didn't qualify? Well, essentially, there's something in the judicial world

that it's words that should never be spoken. but quite frankly they are, and that is that it has no jury appeal. Now, what that means is would a jury be interested in this case? And in this situation, you essentially have a few people that were duped by a religious nut, and unfortunately, that doesn't have jury appeal. A lot of jurors would think that, well, You know, if you gave that much money to this guy, you deserved it. There is sort of a circular logic here.

Fraud is a crime where you trick people. But some prosecutors aren't willing to prosecute fraud cases where people are foolish enough to be tricked. Essentially, it means all fraudsters have to do is find the most gullible people to scam. I completely disagree with the decision, but I see its basis is pretending to be something you're not,

It's not illegal. It's immoral, but it's not illegal. Now, I think once you start getting money from people because you say something you're not, I think that's a fraud, and I think that should be prosecuted. But even then, Jim's case would run into problems, at least in this country. Because even if you took the jury out of the equation...

When you're in the area of religion or faith, it's incredibly hard to get a county prosecutor to pick up the case. Yeah, it's controversial, but they don't want to get in on people's rights. Right. By people's rights, what I mean is an American's right to religious freedom. It's a touchy subject in this country. One could argue that the church you donate to is none of a prosecutor's business, and it's not for them to call fake.

Imagine how someone like Dale, the guy who believes in Cusera and Ryan would react. He is the kind of person a prosecutor could be picturing when they want to avoid controversy. It's hard to believe Dale wouldn't be furious if he felt his faith was on trial. A prosecutor going after the refuge actually fits right in with Cusera's warnings. Our religious freedom as we know of today will not always be here for us. You will have to go through these struggles in order to live in. if they begin. Now me, I think if people commit a crime, they should face consequences.

It shouldn't matter if the crime was claiming to talk to God to steal money or just stealing money. Unfortunately, these types, and frankly, you can go to Jimmy Baker, Tammy Baker, I mean, you can go to others like them, using a faith-based or a religion-based reason to bilk people. people out of money, just disgust me. But today especially, it sickens him. He left the sheriff's office and now works as a chaplain for a bunch of Arizona police departments. He's also a local pastor. For Jim, someone pretending to be a religious leader calls into question the entire institution.

It makes all of those in ministry look bad. And this is already a problem in our society is people look at churches and they look at ministries and think they're in it for the money. And truthfully, the vast majority are not. They're in it for the right reasons. But those few that do it and bilk people out of money make all of us look bad. When I started this reporting, I just didn't get why Randall Dean Stocks, chose to become a priest. Of all the cons, why this one? But I'm starting to get the appeal of pretending to be a priest, or any religious figure. You're given free reign, both when you're at the

altar and even sometimes beyond the walls of your church. Jim's not the first person to run into this problem. Father Ryan's son, Jonathan Brady, tried for years to get investigators to pay attention to his dad. But he never got much traction. You've barely scratched the fucking surface, and no one will touch this with a 20-foot pole because it's got the word religion or church. I'm finally seeing how Father Ryan could avoid a rest for so long. The bad part is it's not just him. Jonathan thinks there are other Father Ryan's out there, some of whom he says even learned from his dad. That might sound far-fetched, but it turns out pretending to be a priest is a pretty popular con. It's one of the oldest. People wanted to do it centuries before there was such a thing as

jury appeal. But while I'm starting to see how the Father Ryans of this world avoid jail, it's harder to understand what makes anyone decide to pursue such an odd con in the first place. What's the motivation? Luckily, I found someone who knows a a lot about what's made so many pretend to be priests. And do you have any kind of instinct as to like what it is about the priesthood, why you think it draws those types of stories? Oh, it's certainly just a matter of authority. This is Peter Mansell.

He's an author and curator of American religious history at the Smithsonian Institution. It certainly seems that he is someone who recognizes the implicit authority of the role of a priest in certain communities. He was a great person to talk to about Father Ryan. Besides being a religious expert, he's also written a book about con artists. Well, fake priests have really been a part of the church since there was an institutional church. It turns out this fraud goes way back and requires a serious commitment. People have been pretending to be priests since the start of the church.

I'm kind of amazed at what's required to become a priest. You're expected to go through at least six. six years of seminary, eight if you don't go to college first. It's not like regular school. They try to shape everything about the person, from mannerisms to their personality. The process is called formation. Some seminaries lay out on their website what kind of qualities a person must have if they want to even try to be a priest. Truthfulness, emotional self-control, a mature respect for and cooperation with church authority. From the stories I've heard, These are things Father Ryan didn't seem to have.

The way Peter was describing the church's long history, Father Ryan's Khan is so popular, it's almost a cliche. He said they were after money, sex, and power. It becomes a trope that you often hear, these stories of false priests, as they were often known, who are there to take advantage of the faithful. There was one guy in Los Angeles, his name is Erwin Mena. He got arrested for posing as a priest and selling fake

to see the Pope. Mia is accused of impersonating a priest and swindling various churchgoers out of thousands of dollars since the mid-90s. He was so enamored with how he felt as a priest that while out on parole, he went to a different church and got caught pretending to be a priest again, wow on parole. But if this crime is a cliche, I feel like the church should have a system for catching people like Father Ryan. I did find out that a Catholic priest in England and Wales is now required to carry an ID card.

They announced the new IDs in 2018. Church leaders told reporters then that the fakes they heard about in the United States are one of the reasons for the change. The IDs are about the size of a credit card. They have a photo of the priest, an expiration date, and a barcode that can be scanned. plus the cards are signed by the bishop from the diocese. There's nothing like that in the U.S. And there doesn't appear to be a database or any system keeping track of fakes. But Peter said that's hard to do.

There are so many different ways now of presenting yourself as Catholic that the church does not hold a monopoly on the term, at least not an enforceable monopoly. And so it cannot, how can they stop them? How can they possibly keep track of everyone trying this in various places? Other than saying when these individual cases come up, this guy is not who he says he is, check out his academic records, find out if he was really in the seminary he said he attended. Other than doing that, what can really be done?

Father Ryan claims he attended St. Ambrose University in the mid-70s. It's a private Roman Catholic school in Davenport, Iowa. the kind of place that touts individual responsibility on its website. I called them. They found him under one of his names. You'll notice the middle name is different. We have a record of a Randall Darian Stocks, having taken an introduction to sociology class in the summer of 1976.

So he took one class. He did not join the seminary. In order to be a seminary, and he would have had to have a longer record with our Red Star's office. And he just took that one class. Okay, so he didn't go to the seminary and he never graduated. No.

Up until now, everyone I've talked to didn't think he went at all. But one sociology class is not eight years of seminary. What's more, Peter thinks Father Ryan chooses his marks very carefully. By targeting very often the elderly, by targeting those who feel like the church has changed, on them, and they were looking for ways to have a nostalgic experience of the church of their youth. He is playing on their perceived sense of his authority as a priest. So if Father Ryan is in it for that feeling of authority, why not just do what Cusera did? He claimed to have visions, no training or degrees needed.

Why not do that? Before this, I covered politics in D.C. In many ways, fake priests remind me of politicians, charismatic, selling people on a promise. They seem to have that thing that makes some people want to be adored. Rock stars, comedians, actors, fake priests. What better way to demand an audience than to find one who thinks they'll go to eternal hell if they question you. We all have our ways of getting attention. Knowing we're being heard and seen can be powerful. I know I like attention. I'm counting.

like on social media, whatever that is, dopamine or something, these guys must be getting a huge rush. While I've only talked to him through emails, I still have a picture of Father Ryan in my head. Everyone says he's this friendly, charming guy. I'm imagining this guy who burst into a room. Peter and I talked about this too. There's an old timiness to the scam. It makes me think of a snake oil salesman, like the wizard in the Wizard of Oz. Don't forget, he's a con man too. He pretends to be a fortune teller with connections to European royalty. Please, Professor, why can't we go with you and see all the crown heads of Europe? Do you know any? Oh, you mean the thing? Well, I never do anything without consulting my crystal first. They're everywhere in American culture. Remember the Spielberg movie?

Catch me if you can. I'm alive, pilot. I sure am, little lady. The jump seat is open. It's been a while since I've done this. Which one's the jump seat again? Father Ryan's ability to mostly avoid conviction always makes me think of one story in particular.

The Music Man. It's about a con man who pretends to be an instrument salesman. I don't think of it because both Father Ryan and the Music Man target small Midwest towns. Or because my grandma was so obsessed with musicals, their doorbell was seriously, give my regards to Broadway. The connection for me is the con artist's ability to casually escape trouble. In the musical, the main character sings and sways away

whenever his legitimacy is questioned. Just a minute here, Professor. Sorry, we need your credentials. Why, certainly, gentlemen, I have just what you want over my hotel. Please come with me. Good night, ladies. Good night. Lady

Good night lady To leave you Father Ryan has his own song and dance You've heard all the things that make him hard to pin down By using religion He's able to scare off at least some prosecutors From doing anything But then there's the fact he's selling rebellion

This can be a big advantage Because it pits you against authority That way whenever a figure of authority tries to take you down, supporters don't see this as a cause for concern. They see it as proof they're right. Politicians use this all the time. They run against D.C. politics.

The swamp. The media. Father Ryan hits the media too. Usually, a newspaper or two would pick up Father Ryan's story when the diocese would put out a warning. He'd claim reporters were spreading lies about his legitimacy. Today, those types of articles are all. all online. One of the things that stands out about Ryan being able to still pull this off is that most cons like this have come to an end. It's hard to imagine somebody successfully going

from town to town in the internet age. A con man would get caught quick with just a Google search. Here's Peter again. It's funny to think that of these individual flim-flam men, it's making it much more difficult to go out and ply their craft. But while the internet age, might scare some, Father Ryan kept going. He didn't let what happened in Arizona get in the way. Not long after Helen and Paul raised questions, Cusera's refuge in Arizona caught the attention of the local diocese. They sent a scathing letter, listing all the different ways Cusera's refuge violated

canon law. Those are the laws within the Catholic Church. But by the time they sent this, Cusera was long gone. The last time Dale saw him, he was living a new life in Mexico. I do know that he kind of tore the end, just got tired out. And I think said no. To this day, no one I've talked to is entirely sure what happened to Marvin Cusera. The last address court records show is a P.O. box in South Dakota in 2015.

Dale cleaned up the mess left by Cusera in Arizona. On October 28, 1996, Paul Bergman watched someone fill up a rider-moving truck with the rest of Cusera's things and drive away. He and his sister would avoid financial disaster. They managed to keep ownership of the land despite Cusera's best efforts. For Cusera, a chapter appeared to come to an end. But for Father Ryan, a new chapter was just getting started. Father Ryan's son thinks his time with Cusera was transatlantic. transformative.

Kusera gave Father Ryan connections within the traditional Catholic world. He showed him the value of publishing to attract donors, and that followers would be willing to sign over their belongings. What aspect of that you think Kusera taught him? Like everything. Father Ryan would soon take all these lessons and show back up in the Midwest, this time in a new state, with sharpened skills, ready to reopen the Holy Rosary of the Holy Rosary Abby. Next time on

smokescreen. Things are looking up for Father Ryan. He gets creative, expanding his work into the llama industry. There were plenty of people in the llama industry who thought it was legitimate, and there were plenty of people in the industry who referred to him as the fake

father. But behind the scenes, something much darker is happening. She was very vulnerable after her husband died. She trusted him completely. He's got old time religion. There is his cash in a coffee can, and he makes his decisions.

Down on his knees, he's a full-grown man, and he... Fake Priest is a production of Neon Hum Media. It is reported and hosted by me, Alex Schumann. The executive producer is Jonathan Hirsch. Producers are Natalie Wren and Tanner Robbins. Catherine St. Louis is our editor, fact-checking by Laura Buller. Thanks to Matt McGinley for our theme music

and to blue dot sessions for tracks you hear on this episode. Sound design and additional composition by Jesse Pearlstein. And the song you hear now is Old Time Religion by Parker Millsap. Our engineer is Scott Somerville. Special thanks to Peter Mansoe, Odelia Rubin, Haley Fager, Shera Morris,

and Vikram Patel.