The Binge Cases: Scary Terri - Fake Priest | 7. Two Dead Priests

Episode Date: September 24, 2020

In his autobiography, Father Ryan connects himself to two priests who died suspiciously. One he accuses of molesting children. The other? He says he teamed up with to publicly shame pedophile priests. What's the truth? A Neon Hum Media and Sony Music Entertainment production. Subscribe on Apple Podcasts to binge all episodes now or listen weekly wherever you get your podcasts. Find more great podcasts from Sony Music Entertainment at sonymusic.com/podcasts Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

Infamous is celebrity gossip, but smart. It takes you deep into the stories that we just can't stop ourselves from following. From who Meghan Markle really is. Apparently ambition is a terrible, terrible thing. To the scandal at Lululemon. You've got this man saying that his yoga pants don't work for women because they're too fat to wear them. We've got over a hundred episodes ready for your binging pleasure. Listen to Infamous, the gossip show that's smart. What was the last thing that filled

you with wonder that took you away from your desk or your car in traffic or your sink full of dishes? As an actor, it's very free being part of these shows. You can step in the booth and kind of be anything. Well, for us, and I'm in the booth and kind of be anything. Well, for us, and I'm going to guess for some of you, that thing is... Anime! Hi, I'm Nick Friedman. I'm Lee Alec Murray. And I'm Leah President.

And welcome to Crunchyroll Presents The Anime Effect. It's a weekly news show. I literally, when I saw it, when I found out about this, I literally had like a nervous breakdown in a good way. With the best celebrity guests. I've never pirated anything, but I'll steal it if I have to. That was how I felt when I started to get really hooked on Black Butler. Oh, it's coming back.

It's coming back. So join us every Friday wherever you get your podcasts and watch full video episodes on Crunchyroll or on the Crunchyroll YouTube channel. Before we get started, I want to warn you suicide is mentioned in this episode. There's one part of this story I haven't told you yet. Mine. I knew if I was going to tell Father Ryan's story, I needed to talk to the man himself. I hoped getting his version of events would help me understand why he did what he did. That's why reaching out

was one of the first things I tried to do. I found Ryan's email address on a court document. I had barely started doing my own investigation. But in November 2017, I sent Ryan a message asking if he'd talk. To be honest, I assumed the email address wouldn't work. He'd be old, or he'd never respond. Instead, he answered eight minutes later. And I thought, oh, there's a chance he might talk. That's one of the reasons I took this podcast on.

By that point, I had been a reporter for almost nine years. You get to know how people act when they do or don't want to talk. He seemed game. But in his response, Ryan didn't even bother to say hello. He wrote, quote, first of all, I would like to know how you got my contact information. Second, I've had a documentary done once a few years ago, but due to unforeseen circumstances, it was never aired slash completed. Third, you would have to check with my attorney about this.

That was it. He didn't say no, but he didn't say yes either. So I asked him again. We went back and forth for months. He always had some excuse, or he'd stall for one reason or another. Remember, I'm not the first person to try this. ABC 17's Lucas Geisler covered Ryan in Missouri.

I said, my name's Lucas. I work at ABC 17 News in Columbia. And he hung up. On their second call, Lucas got him to answer a few questions. But Ryan refused to get into his legitimacy. I did my best to ask him about, are you really a priest, was really the question. Like, were you ever ordained? Like, did you go through that sacrament?

And he would not touch it. Nobody's ever gotten this guy to explain himself, answer for what he's done. A pattern formed. He'd respond, and several times, fairly fast. Then just go silent for weeks or months. Whenever he would reach out, I would try to get him to set a date for us to meet, but he'd usually say there was no point, that a conspiracy existed to keep him silent. conspiracy existed to keep him silent. As part of his evidence of this conspiracy, he sent me an autobiography. He seems to have a couple of versions. One is 95 pages long. He calls his autobiography The Silenced Lamb. And in it, Father Ryan tells his story of being a hero priest,

persecuted for standing up for the truth and what's right. Among the many stories, a few stand out. Ryan connects himself to two priests who end up dead. One murdered, another from an apparent suicide. But in both stories, he's the good guy. Until he would actually talk to me, I was stuck. These emails were all I had to get his side of the story. This autobiography was his version of events.

And let me tell you, it is one hell of a version of events. From Neon Home Media, I'm Alex Schumann, and this is Smokescreen, Fake Priest. I'm reading the longer version of Father Ryan's autobiography. It's got 10 chapters. Ryan opens the first chapter by reliving the day a priest was murdered. His name was Father Alfred Kuntz. His case has drawn a lot of attention in Wisconsin over the years. It is a tragic case. Shock turned into many questions in 1998. How could something like this happen in such a small town to a priest and in such a brutal way?

The small town of Dane became the center of a high-profile murder investigation that has yet to be solved. The death of Father Alfred Koontz is the village of Dane remains one of the area's greatest mysteries. This morning at St. Mary's Church. The body of 67-year-old Alfred Koontz was found on the floor of a hallway at St. Michael Catholic School in Dane, Wisconsin. Blood was everywhere. Someone had cut Father Koontz's throat. It was the first murder in this little town in almost 30 years. Police told reporters the evidence suggests whoever killed Koontz likely would have left the school covered in blood and with marks on their face. But the case remains unsolved. One of the police's more prominent theories is that Kuntz interrupted a burglary.

But there are all kinds of theories. It's one of those unsolved murders that's developed its own following. I kind of figured that, you know, they would have someone in custody after a few days. Matt Abbott is a writer who spent years on this case. People were wondering, well, you know, was it an interrupted burglary? Was it some other possible motive? Where does Ryan Scott fit into this case? I did have a telephone conversation with him that lasted probably 30 minutes or so.

And then I did communicate with him some to get his mail as well. Ryan has talked with several reporters about what he thinks happened to Father Kuntz. He told Matt the reason he was connected to Father Kuntz was that they had been compiling a list of pedophile priests. They planned to publicly shame the priests to try to stop them from hurting children.

But Father Ryan said the Catholic Church murdered Kuntz to stop him. I have to say, in my initial communication with Ryan, I was inclined to believe him. communication with Ryan. I was inclined to believe him. However, that did not last very long. The more I started to hear from other people, I started to do a little more investigating and to find out that a lot of things just didn't add up. Father Kuntz and Ryan did know each other, but it's hard to know for sure how well. I had to do some digging to figure it out. From what I can tell, Father Kuntz was in many ways the guy Father Ryan was claiming to be. He was a well-respected traditionalist priest. He was ordained before the Second Vatican Council. The diocese let Father Kuntz continue to do old-school masses. He'd

been there for 31 years and had made a reputation for himself. He was a polarizing figure. He sounded very fire and brimstone. He was the kind of guy who stood up to the modern Vatican. Other outsiders felt comfortable confiding in him. Father Kuntz was known to be a priest who was very much in the know about certain things. He was also discreet, I think, about how he handled information. Back in the mid-90s, Father Ryan was being pressured to close his first abbey and leave Wisconsin. The Diocese of La Crosse wanted Father Ryan to prove he was a priest, to prove he was actually ordained. So Dale Lawinger, one of his followers at the time, introduced him to Kuntz. I think it was I had asked Father Kuntz if he would meet with Father Ryan and to see if he was really a properly ordained priest.

was really a properly ordained priest. Maybe Kuntz, a respected traditionalist priest, would defend him and help boost his standing with people who doubted him. What doesn't make sense about that is that Ryan would have in theory known there was nothing for Father Kuntz to prove because he was never actually ordained by the Roman Catholic Church. This is one of those moments where I feel like I'm missing something. Why would Father Ryan ask for help proving something that wasn't true?

Something that would expose his lies? I reached out to the Dane County Sheriff's Office. I wanted to know if investigators thought the Catholic Church had had anything to do with Koontz's death. Father Ryan thought so, but did the cops? The sheriff did not want to answer any of these questions. Matt said besides one big publicity push a couple of years ago, they've stayed fairly tight-lipped.

I guess that they have released, you know, some, but it hasn't been a tremendous amount, but maybe that's what they feel is appropriate. In his autobiography, Ryan describes the days after Kuntz's death

almost like a Catholic spy novel. In it, he's arranging secret meetings and talking to investigators. He plans to publicize the list of pedophile priests on his own. Everything he says about himself is the opposite of what I've heard. He's the one fighting for justice, trying to save kids from sex abuse, risking his life.

For the record, Matt does think Father Kuntz's investigations could have made him a target. He's just not sure there's evidence Ryan was actually that involved. I still think it is a possibility that it had to do with whether it was a specific list. I'm not so sure, but I know that, you know, he was investigating some cases of clergy corruption. And, you know, there were some priests, I think, who weren't very pleased with him. But some people who know Father Ryan well think he might have been involved. Both John Brown, the investigator, and Vida Barr, the former nun, have their suspicions. Vitobar, the former nun, have their suspicions.

On more than one occasion, they've tried to convince me that Father Ryan could have wanted Kuntz dead. They're not alone. Ryan gets mentioned by people talking about the case on different message boards, too. I believe he has something to do with the Kuntz murder. Maybe Kuntz found out Father Ryan wasn't really ordained and threatened to expose him. I've grown to trust both John and Vida, but I just don't see it. I haven't seen enough evidence to suggest Father Ryan had anything to do with Kuntz's demise. Matt Abbott, that writer who's covered the case,

asked a detective for his take on whether Father Ryan did it. He didn't seem to think that Ryan Scott was involved with the murder. The Dane County Sheriff's Office wouldn't tell me if Father Ryan was ever a person of interest. So from the sound of things, police don't think Ryan's a killer. What is fascinating, though, is how Father Ryan himself really wants people to know he was in Kuntz's orbit. It's as if he takes this horrible murder

and intentionally makes it a part of his own story. Kuntz may not have died at the hands of the Catholic Church, but Father Ryan sure likes to think he did. A big part of his autobiography is dedicated to it. But this wasn't actually the only story he'd include about sex abuse in the church. John Brown thinks this second case should be reopened. And it involves another dead priest. Hi everyone, this is Jonathan Van Ness. And it involves another dead priest. church and state has been on the front lines defending your freedom to live and believe as you choose, so long as you don't harm others.

Most folks don't see how church-state separation affects our daily lives until that freedom is gone. The separation between church and state covers many core freedoms like civil rights for LGBTQIA plus people, women and racial slash religious minorities, or reproductive justice and freedom. But those rights are not a given. Every day, Americans United works

at the state and federal level to make sure these freedoms and more are protected for every American to enjoy and benefit from. They can't do this alone, though. Join Americans United for separation of church and state and growing the movement because church-state separation protects everyone.

Freedom without favor and equality without exception. Learn more and get involved at au.org slash curious. Hi, everyone. This is Jonathan Van Ness. Clean water, fresh air, our health. Electricity, honey. We tend to take for granted the things that matter most, like the separation of church and state. Americans United for Separation of Church and State has been on the front lines defending your freedom to live and believe as you choose, so long as you don't harm others. Most folks don't see how church-state separation affects our daily lives until that freedom is gone. The separation between church and state

covers many core freedoms like civil rights for LGBTQIA plus people, women, and racial slash religious minorities, or reproductive justice and freedom. But those rights are not a given. Every day, Americans United works at the state and federal level to make sure these freedoms and more are protected for every American to enjoy and benefit from. They can't do this alone, though. Join Americans United for separation of church and state and growing the movement. Because church-state separation protects everyone.

Freedom without favor and equality without exception. Learn more and get involved at au.org slash curious. I'm down in John Brown's basement. This is kind of like my war room. He's an investigator, so he's got all kinds of different work from different cases. Big white sheets of paper are pinned to the walls, covered in writing. A bunch of file folders are laid out on a long table. And then there's the files he's got on Father Ryan.

I put together evidence. Look. book after book after book of evidence. I put that together, and I'm going to illuminate the truth that surrounds this convict, this terrible man. John Brown has never quite forgiven himself for getting Father Ryan out of jail, putting that terrible man, as he puts it, back on the streets. So now, John Brown is trying to find evidence that Father Ryan is a criminal, something he could bring to the cops. And you know John, once he starts digging, he doesn't stop.

So he spent a lot of time reading the details about the death of a second priest, Father Clarence Cook. He thinks something doesn't add up, and that Father Ryan might be the missing piece of the puzzle that would make that senseless death make sense. Father Cook was found inside a car parked in the middle of a gravel road. They find him in the trunk of his car, and he's dead. This was September 1990. A red Buick was found abandoned in rural Missouri. The Missouri State Patrol noticed the car had Wisconsin license plates, no footsteps or markings nearby.

All the doors were unlocked. In the back seat, there were priestly robes. In the front, a note. A short message written in cursive. Whoever left it turned the note so it could be read through the window. The trooper was able to make out what it said. Quote, I can't stand my pain anymore. I've hurt so many. A locksmith unlocked

the trunk. Father Cook's body was inside. At first, investigators treated it as a homicide, but they found no evidence of foul play, so ultimately ruled it a suicide. so ultimately ruled it a suicide. That's what cops think. But John Brown sees the Clarence Cook case differently. Why would Father Cook drive nearly seven hours to park and put himself in the trunk? And if he did climb into the trunk, why weren't his car keys found at the scene?

Now, how many people do you know that commit suicide by opening their trunk, the keys disappear, they get in the trunk, and they close it? Father Ryan brings up Father Cook in his autobiography. Ryan says young boys told him about inappropriate things Father Cook was doing on camping trips and outings. Now, Ryan said in his story that he claimed that Father Koch was molesting kids in summer camp. Ryan claims he took these concerns to his cousin, who happens to be an actual ordained priest in the local parish.

Ryan says his cousin, a man named Thomas Coyle, told him it was delicate. Don't tell the bishop, let Father Cook be. In other words, Ryan's cousin tells him to drop it. Less than a week later. Thomas Coyle, the parish priest, he ordered Ryan gone. He said, you're going to have to leave suddenly. He was a loved person, and there's zero, zero evidence that Father Koch ever molested anyone. But Ryan made that claim. I thought about that note found in Koch's car. I can't stand my pain anymore. I've hurt so many. It was baffling.

It could be the note of a desperately sad man, but Father Ryan would argue it's the last confession of a pedophile. Personally, I never discovered a shred of evidence that Father Cook abused children. I knew that investigators on the case discovered that Father Cook abused children. I knew that investigators on the case discovered that Father Cook had attempted suicide as a younger man. The sheriff's offices in Wisconsin and Missouri worked together on the case. They also learned from the parish

Father Cook had a history of disappearing. Cops just didn't think there was anything suspicious about the death. I reached out to Ryan's cousin, the priest at Father Cook's old parish, to see if he could help explain things. But he never called me back. Meanwhile, John Brown and I were in frequent contact. I don't believe it was Ryan that did it.

I believe it was someone else who did it that Ryan instructed. John Brown hasn't shared what he's found to police in either case. He's still gathering evidence. But as a reporter, this is a tough spot to be. I am being inundated with claims and accusations from every direction. And with Ryan, it's endless. A lot of people accused of crimes tend to try to hide or at least not attract more attention.

Ryan's the opposite. It's like he can't help but slip back into the spotlight. Instead of not being able to find a trace of him, you can find him everywhere. I've wondered if it's on purpose. Is he creating such a massive paper trail you can find him everywhere. I've wondered if it's on purpose. Is he creating such a massive paper trail that people like me get overwhelmed? There's just so much.

In his life, Father Ryan takes and takes. But in his autobiography, he's the one who helps others. He tries to keep children out of harm's way. He helps Father Kuntz investigate horrible secrets. He's calling out pedophiles. It seems so odd he'd intentionally insert himself into these cases. His autobiography leaves out all the pain he's caused, all the people he's hurt.

But I'd talk to a lot of them. That guy who stood in that old photo, tan and smiling, dressed like a 70s porn star, that guy pissed a lot of people off. This is not a man who conned a few people in small Midwest towns. His con is nationwide and brazen.

I haven't even told you about the time he was hired to run a church in North Dakota. After it failed, he used their mailing list of almost 11,000 subscribers to ask donations be sent to him directly. Over the years, as I went down many rabbit holes, I never lost contact with Father Ryan. He and I would email. I would ask him to do an interview. He'd warn me the Catholic Church would try to silence me.

There was always a reason he couldn't do it. But then one day in 2019, all those reasons vanished. But then one day in 2019, all those reasons vanished. Hello, it's your beauty and wellness BFFs. And we're here to answer all your burning questions. Skincare, makeup, parenting, and more. We have got you covered. Oh, yes, we do.

We'll speak with industry insiders, celebrities, and our close friends. And give all our honest and unfiltered thoughts always. Listen to Lipstick on the Rim now on Apple or wherever you get your podcasts. It'd been nearly two years and Father Ryan finally agreed to meet. I'd started emailing with Father Ryan in 2017. The way he writes varies. If he's happy, things are in order. Punctuation is good. If he's upset, there are all these random capitalizations and the spacing is weird.

It's like how a bot would write a comment on social media. Our conversation was essentially a broken record. Then on August 12th, 2019, Alex, I suppose that by now you've forgotten me, but I have not forgotten about your offer. The email is six paragraphs long, but he never once actually says he's going to do the interview. I ask again. This time, he offers a date. I say yes, but then weeks go by. Finally, I get an email that begins, here I sit, wondering and in anticipation, like as if we're pen pals and this is the 19th century. He tells me a health procedure was postponed.

I push for the interview. I tell him, if the procedure's pushed back, let's get this thing done. Silence. About a month later, I reach out, just to check in. This time, and I don't really know why, he asked to meet without doing a recording. I was surprised. It seemed like a genuine suggestion. He wanted to make sure he would be comfortable doing an interview and asked if we could talk first.

At that point, I didn't care if he didn't want me to record. I just wanted to get in the same room. What made me hesitate a bit was that Father Ryan added another condition. He wanted the interview to happen at his house. I thought, that's weird. But he said if we met there, he'd be able to show us his documents. I had no idea what that really meant, but it made sense to let it be somewhere comfortable for him. Meanwhile, I was trying to figure out how comfortable I was. Nothing I'd found suggested I needed to worry for my safety, but then again, so many people I interviewed warned me to be careful.

That's when I asked my brother Dan to come along. He served in the Marines and did two tours in Iraq. With him, I wasn't worried. Just crossed a bridge and pulled into his general neighborhood. Ryan only gave me his address after I assured him I wouldn't secretly record our meeting. Okay, here's his house. We had to pull around to the back. Okay, here's his house. There are a couple of doors, so it's unclear at first where we're supposed to go. Then, as I approach a side-screen door, it flings open.

And there he is. Father Ryan. He doesn't say anything. He hesitates to make eye contact. He just stands there. He's got on an all-black long-sleeved shirt, black pants, and shoes. I introduce myself and Dan. One thing I did notice is that he had his white collar not on, but in his pocket.

And I felt like that was to show that he had it, but he made a conscious decision not to wear it. I reached out to shake Father Ryan's hand before we went inside. He's not sure if he wants to shake it back, but he does. We follow him right into the back porch. He offers us two chairs, and he pulls up a small swivel stool on wheels.

I can hear someone or maybe a pet moving around in the back of the house, but he didn't show us around. As a reporter, I've gotten to meet lots of important people. It is always a little jarring when you finally meet and see someone you've spent time covering. I had all these preconceived notions, and the man I met wasn't who I expected. He was nervous. This guy was nothing like the con artists in movies, or the one I'd heard described. I don't think he ever fully sat back and relaxed, ever. I think he was sitting on a stool, on like a swivel stool, but he was still very much on the edge of that swivel stool. Ryan stayed tense for most of our talk, but he did like to talk, so he told us his life story, the same one I'd read in the autobiography he sent me.

story, the same one I'd read in the autobiography he sent me. He could go through his story from beginning to end, but he would struggle if you were to ask him questions out of order. He seemed like he had trouble with names, times, and dates if they were taken out of context of his storyline. We talked for about an hour and a half. He did warm up. He started making jokes. There were flashes of the charm.

I asked my brother about it afterward. Do you see how people could be convinced by him? Oh, absolutely. But there was this vibe that he had. Maybe it came from how tense he was about the meeting, but there was an edginess. Dan noticed it too. There's just something not quite right about him. It really seems like he was acting. I tried multiple times to get Ryan to let us record the interview, but he never gave in.

Instead, he told us he wanted to discuss it with his mom and think things over. I skeptically said sounds good and waited. It seemed all about attention. I knew by now how to play this game. I'd driven three hours with my brother to essentially get that autobiography read to me. I'd assumed since he promised to show us documents that he had a big filing cabinet or a bunch of boxes filled with information. Instead, he had a single, very portable, small box with papers and frames.

So why the hell did I need to come to his house? I was frustrated. But I knew if I waited after Dan and I left, if I didn't check in, he'd likely decide to do the interview. The thing is, as much as I needed Father Ryan, by now, he kind of needed me. I was the guy willing to listen.

I wanted to hear him out. And a couple of weeks later, I did hear back. Next time on Fake Priest. My first question for you is a basic one. Why did you agree to this interview? I'm not really sure. Why did you agree to this interview? I'm not really sure.

Every time I've tried to defend myself in the past, quite the opposite has been done. He's got old-time religion There is his cash in a coffee cane And he makes his decisions Down on his knees He's a full-grown man and he Fake Priest is a production of Neon Home Media. It is reported and hosted by me, Alex Schumann.

The executive producer is Jonathan Hirsch. Lead producer is Natalie Wren. Associate producer is Kate Mishkin. Catherine St. Louis is our editor. Fact-checking by Laura Bullard. Thanks to Matt McGinley for our theme music and to Blue Dot Sessions for tracks you hear on this episode. Sound design and

additional composition by Jesse Perlstein and the song you're hearing now is Old Time Religion by Parker Millsap. Our engineer is Scott Somerville. Special thanks to Peter Manseau and Vikram Patel.