The Daily Beast Podcast - This is What Proves Trump’s Dementia: Psychologist
Episode Date: September 21, 2025Dr. John Gartner, former Johns Hopkins professor and co-host of the podcast ‘Shrinking Trump,’ joins the Beast’s Joanna Coles to deliver a chilling diagnosis: Donald Trump is showing signs of de...mentia layered on top of malignant narcissism. Drawing on decades of clinical expertise, Dr. Gartner explains how Trump’s declining language, erratic gait, and disturbing anecdotes point to brain deterioration that makes him not just unpredictable but uniquely dangerous in office. Coles presses him on how Trump’s narcissism compares to King Charles’ public persona, whether his cabinet and family are retreating from his volatility, and what it means when a leader with nuclear codes also displays symptoms of mini-strokes and confabulation. From Hitler’s psychology to Bill Clinton’s benign narcissism, this episode explores how power amplifies paranoia, cruelty, and decay—and asks the starkest question of all: as Trump weakens physically and mentally while tightening his grip on authority, how far can Trumpism go before it breaks America? Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript
Discussion (0)
One of the dementia experts that I've consulted with is convinced he has frontotemporal dementia because of this symptom alone, which is it's called a wide-based gait.
But if you look at his right leg, sometimes he just swings it like a dead weight in a semicircle.
I'm Joanna Coles. This is the Daily Beast podcast.
And thank you for all your thousands of comments over the last couple of weeks.
They really mean a lot to me.
And they mean a lot to Michael Wolfe, my partner on Inside Trump's.
head. So today we have a fascinating conversation with Dr. John Gartner, who says Trump is clearly
showing signs of dementia, not least because we've been able to track this man for the last 40 years,
both on television and on digital media. So we have a very accurate portrayal of his demise
in plain sight. I found this conversation absolutely enlightening. I very much hope you
you do too. And also I strongly recommend his podcast, Shrinking Trump, that he does with his partner,
or actually his best friend he was telling us from school, Dr. Harry Siegel. The two of them are
trained psychotherapists. Dr. Gartner got his first degree from Princeton and then his PhD
from Amherst and was for 28 years a professor at Johns Hopkins University. So I thought I might not be
to understand all his medical terms, but in fact, I sort of got my head around most of it.
And do feel free to send us questions because I'm convinced we'll be having him back.
I found his point of view on Donald Trump completely riveting.
Let's get into it.
Dr. Gartner is in the House.
We are extremely excited to have you here.
You are a man who has diagnosed President Trump as having dementia.
John, what are the symptoms of dementia that you can see in our president?
So the first most important thing to realize about a diagnosis like dementia is we're really evaluating someone against their own baseline.
So we have to see a major deterioration in functioning in language and thinking and psychomotor performance and impulse control in a whole variety of areas.
So what a lot of people don't realize is that Donald Trump used to be a very articulate person.
He used to speak with a high level of vocabulary in very polished paragraphs.
Now what we see is not only has his vocabulary gone down,
but his ability to actually put together sometimes,
and sometimes he's very articulate, right,
because with dementia people go in and out, right, of functioning.
But there are times when he's really unable to complete a thought,
actually sometimes is unable to complete a word.
It's called a phonemic parapheria.
There's dozens of examples there online as sort of humorous bits, you know, where he mispronounces words,
but really says words that are not actually English words that have a fragment of an English word.
And not like saying missions instead of missiles or Chrysus instead of Christmas.
This is something that only people who have an organic brain disease do.
It's not something people just do when they're tired or when they get old.
So one of the things that we see is this great deterioration in his language, in his ability to put together sentences and words,
but also he's starting to show what we call this kind of random sort of thought where he really free associates and a tangential speech,
where he's talking about one thing, and then he starts talking about another thing and then another thing.
For example, the Hannibal Lecter example is one I like to use.
you know, he was saying, he was lying and saying that they're sending all these immigrants from insane
asylums, right? And then he goes, Silence of the Lambs. Anyone seen Silence of the Lambs? Well,
Silence of the Lambs is a movie about insane asylums. Okay, so now we've moved from immigrants to,
has anyone seen this movie? And then he goes, the late great Hannibal Lecter. Nobody likes to
talk about him anymore. Well, first of all, he's not dead, so he can't, he's a fictional character,
so he can't be the late Hannibal Lecter. As someone who's a psychodynamically oriented, the fact that
he would choose Hannibal Lecter as some kind of great figure tells us something about his psychology.
Right.
That would be his ego ideal, someone who is a serial killer who eats people.
That sort of tracks.
But in other words, it really doesn't make sense.
Or another example would be when he was asked about the Harvard situation.
He said, well, aren't you challenging academic freedom?
And he said, oh, in Harlem, you know, all the black people voted for me because Harlem sounds like Harvard.
And he didn't just mishear it because then he goes on to say, you know,
The people in Harlem agree with what I'm doing in Harvard.
So, I mean, this is really a gross, right?
It doesn't make any sense.
And he does this meandering kind of speech, yeah.
Right.
Well, of course, what's interesting is we have digital breadcrumbs and we have, you know,
14 seasons of The Apprentice to study him and then look at him now.
Give us the phrase again that you called it.
Was it phenyl or something?
Phenemic parapherasias.
Phenemic paraphrase.
Where he uses sounds that aren't really words.
There's also a semantic parapheria
where you use a real word but in the wrong context,
like saying the oranges of the investigation,
when he meant the origins of the investigation.
Right, although I promise you I do that too
and I'm hoping I don't have dementia.
What is it in the brain that is sort of disintegrating, if you like?
Is this just a symptom of old age
or is it actually something in the brain no longer working as it used to?
Yeah, it's not just a symptom of old age.
This is really a breakdown in, it's actually a breakdown in all of the mental functions,
in thinking, in psychomotor performance, in impulse control.
So we're seeing this in all areas of his life.
Now, of course, with him, sometimes it's hard to tell because he has this severe personality disorder.
He is a malignant narcissist.
So is the personality disorder, did that come before the dementia?
Absolutely.
Absolutely.
No, he's been a malignant narcissist his whole life.
A personality disorder is a lifetime disorder.
So, you know, when he was 10 years old, he was throwing rocks at babies in the neighborhood.
I mean, he's always been this malicious, malignant person.
That's core to who he is, and that's what makes him so dangerous and untreatable.
Now on top of that, this really is the worst case scenario.
Hold on, hold on.
You're throwing so many things out there.
He's untreatable.
He was throwing rocks as babies.
I'm assuming you meant that metaphorically.
No, no, literally he was throwing rocks at babies.
Is that a story about him, that he was literally throwing rocks at babies?
Yes, yes, yes.
When he was a child, neighbors, was a neighbor baby.
He was throwing rocks at them.
Okay.
I didn't know that story.
and that certainly does seem like a symptom of some sort of personality disorder.
Please continue and then let's come back to how one treats something like this.
Malignant narcissism is untreatable.
That's the official position.
We can't cure people who are this sick in this way.
But also it makes him incredibly dangerous.
Every one of the great dictators has more or less been a malignant narcissist.
The term was invented by Eric Frome, who,
himself escaped the Nazis to explain the psychology of Hitler. And other dictators like Hitler,
he understood Hitler to be one of a type, maybe the most extreme, but one of a type. So that's
what we're starting out as a baseline. But now what we have is this chronic organic
deterioration from his own baseline. So we have, in a sense, the worst of both worlds, because
his judgment was always bad. He was always impulsive. He's always a liar. But now he really
is losing his ability to think clearly, to plan, to understand things, and to inhibit his
speech and his behavior. So, you know, one minute, it's 400 percent tariffs on this country,
the next minute he forgets all about it. It's much more chaotic and impulsive. And because the
people around him are exercising no restraint, he's now got a cabinet of enablers, right? There's
nobody to kind of rein him in, either in terms of his worst authoritarian impulses, but even in
terms of his confusion. If you saw that the recent cabinet meeting where the cabinet was falling
all over each other to praise the dear leader and talk about who he's changed American history
and he should win the Nobel Prize, the ironic thing is that as he's increasing his grip on power,
he's actually losing his faculties. As you say, we've seen him in plain sight for the last 40 years,
So we can definitely see his change.
I think even in the presidency this time round, you can see physical changes.
He's slowing down, which is not unexpected in a man of 79.
And he still seems to have an astonishing schedule.
I mean, he's traveling.
I mean, you know, I was watching him with King Charles as they gave their speeches side by side.
Is King Charles also a narcissist?
I mean, here was someone who was born to power. Donald Trump has been elected to power.
King Charles hasn't been. What is the difference between them? And in Donald Trump's defense, not three words I often say, but he appeared to deliver his speech at Windsor Castle.
You know, playing to the crowd, he could obviously feel the energy in the room. He had a couple of asides which made people laugh.
So it didn't feel like he was detached from the reality around him as he sat with Tim Cook and Satchy and Adela and Mark Benioff.
And of course, King Charles and Queen Camilla and the unusual sighting of Melania by his side.
So can you just talk to, you mentioned that people with dementia go in and out, as it were.
Absolutely.
And then what's the difference between his narcissism and someone like,
King Charles, who was born to take over a throne.
There's a big difference between narcissism and malignant narcissism.
A malignant narcissist, in addition to being a narcissist, which as you point out,
maybe most or even all politicians are to a certain extent, or else they wouldn't run,
it has three other components.
Psychopathy, which means that he has no conscience, that he breaks laws and norms and lies
and has no regrets, has no anxiety, has no remorse, has no empathy for other human beings.
Paranoia, which is why he feels like such a victim and he feels persecuted, even though he's the one who's doing the persecuting, and demonizes minorities, demonizes people who oppose him.
And the fourth component is sadism, that he takes enormous pleasure. He relishes in harming and degrading and debasing and frightening other people.
Frome called it the essence of evil.
So not all narcissists are evil.
I wrote a book about Bill Clinton.
Bill Clinton is very narcissistic, but I happen to think Bill Clinton is a very benign character.
He has a great deal of love and concern for people.
He radiates a lot of love, and Donald Trump does have some charm and some charisma, but he exercises it in this very destructive way.
You know, Bill Clinton saved hundreds of millions of lives in Africa after his president.
just because he wanted to.
So we're talking about very different types of characters who have some traits in common.
I also think they also have some hypomania in common, just to make things more complicated.
So Trump has a lot of energy, as you pointed out.
I think, and I wrote my book about Bill Clinton saying that he also had hypomania.
Hypomania being Greek hypo is for less than.
So it's less than full-blown mania.
It's more of a personality temperament to have hypomania.
But for Donald Trump, he's up, you know, in the middle of the night.
hate tweeting, you know, 20 tweets a night.
So all of his energy is going into his evil.
But we are talking about someone who is truly evil, and therefore that's one of the reasons that he's untreatable.
So can we just include King Charles in this?
Because looking at the two of them, they're two old white men, one who's been elected to power, one who's been born to power.
Did you see any, I'm not asking you to be critical of King Charles.
I was just interested in the juxtaposition of the two leaders together.
Yeah.
Well, I mean, to put it simply, I don't see any evidence that he's relentlessly evil.
Well, that's a relief.
I'm sure that's a relief.
But the monarchy, they have other problems.
They have other problems.
But he seems a benign king.
I mean, it certainly seems to want to unite the country.
Okay.
So this going in and out of dementia, what is that about?
And is it connected to what we've been told is his chronic venous interruption and the sort of the physical symptoms that we're seeing now?
There's a number of physical symptoms that we're seeing.
One of them I point out is his chronic falling asleep.
You know, I'm a senior citizen.
I fall asleep sometimes at home and after a beer or a lot.
in the evening. But he fell asleep most of the days during his criminal trial, which is literally
unheard of. It never happens that people fall asleep while they're in the dock during their
own trial. It certainly doesn't happen every day of their trial. He fell asleep at the
finals of the U.S. Open, where he was being cheered and jeered by thousands of people. He fell
asleep there at Windsor Castle, apparently. So this inappropriate falling asleep, it's a small
thing, but it is a real meaningful sign. The other thing is his psychomotor performance has gotten
worse, but in a very specific way that's worth focusing on. This is actually a sign of a specific
type of dementia, frontotemporal dementia, and one of the dementia experts that I've consulted with
is convinced he has frontotemporal dementia because of this symptom alone, which is, it's called
a wide-based gait, but if you look at his right leg, sometimes he just swings it like a dead
weight in a semicircle. And if you saw that footage where he met Putin at the airport and they
came down the red carpet and some people sort of sped it up like a kind of Benny Hill sort of,
you know, take down. You see him weaving across the carpet like a drunk driver. If you actually
take that same footage and slow it down, what you see is the reason he's weaving to the left is
because his right leg is swinging this wide swing to the left, which is causing his whole
gate to move in that direction. We have a lot of different pieces of tape where we see that
wide-based gate. And the expert that I consulted with said this is what we call pathanumonic.
You don't see this in anyone unless they have frontotemporal dementia. So it's a very specific
symptom that really an expert would understand the significance of. And of course, now we're
seeing a more general deterioration. He seems to have clearly serious circulatory problems.
we don't know if the venous deficiency is really,
the chronic venous deficiency is really the story.
It might be actually heart failure with the swollen ankles.
And we don't know why he's got black marks on his, on the back of his hand,
probably getting some kind of intravenous fluid.
But the other thing is he just looks like he's sort of falling apart.
And the other thing is, you know, a lot of people are predicting
that he's having a series of mini strokes.
because if you saw him at the 9-11 memorial,
half of his face was drooping like this, you know,
and that's not something that comes with age or fatigue.
Like, I can't even do it, right?
I'm trying to make half of my face true,
but I have to, like, pull it down.
It's not something you can just do
or something just happens.
It really is suggestive of some kind of potential mini-stroke.
So all these things could be related, right?
The circulatory problems could be related to the deterioration in his brain.
that could even be causal, or he could just have both dementia and some chronic medical problems.
We don't know.
This is really an area where we're really not sure, but he's clearly deteriorating mentally and physically.
I have to say it's completely terrifying talking to you, because first of all these medical terms, which I like,
and I'm sort of stabbing at guessing what they mean, but I've already diagnosed myself with severe dementia,
personality disorder, hypermania.
It's very nerve-wracking talking to you.
So assuming you're right, and we can certainly see because of his television and his digital media trail that he has definitely changed.
Yes.
How does one manage the change? I mean, you always hear about dictators or malignant narcissists that they are very unpredictable and they're very frightening even for their closest.
colleagues to be around because of the unpredictability. You see Trump's cabinet looking extremely
anxious having to sit near him. And in fact, what Michael Wolfe, who's frequently on our podcast
says, is that within the White House, it's better not to be in the room. Usually, certainly in
corporate America, people long to be in the room where it happens. Obviously, the famous song
from Hamilton in the room where it happens. But actually, people want to be out of the room, because
if you're in the room, Donald Trump's gaze may suddenly settle on you, and it will trigger him to
either go off on you. It'll remind him of something. How do you, how should people handle someone
who's going through this? Well, this is what's really frightening because, right, so many people
have had relatives who have been through this, and we get notification from so many viewers who are saying,
you know, I went through this with my mother, I went through this with my father. I recognize
all these signs that you're talking about.
But this was someone that, you know, they were able to, and it's not easy to manage someone with dementia, actually.
Right.
I mean, anybody watching this, it can be quite difficult.
Yeah, anybody watching this who's got someone with dementia in their family will know it can be very unpredictable.
And people can also get very bad tempered.
Exactly.
And some people in my family are dealing with this.
But then imagine that that person has sort of omnipotent power, right, and is paranoid about anyone trying to control them and will attack anyone who,
contradicts them, it's really kind of like a worst-case scenario, right, that the person holding the
nuclear codes is incompetent, but nobody can rein him in. He won't listen to anybody, and no one
dares to oppose him. So one of the things that I think we're going to start to see is as he deteriorates,
the lackeys around him are going to be more and more kind of, if we thought the last cabinet
meeting was crazy. He says crazy stuff, and it's not just the people in his government, it's
even the press, right? He says crazy stuff and nobody follows up on it. Nobody comments on it.
It really is like the emperor's new clothes, but without the punchline, without the person saying
he's naked. And then everyone going, oh my gosh, he's naked. I thought it was only me that saw it.
But isn't the complexity that people have actually called it out? I mean, you called it out
with 45,000, I think, professional doctors, psychotherapists who were pointing this out during Trump
one. And the press have relentlessly called it out, as Donald Trump himself would say. I mean,
look at his reaction to Jimmy Kimmel this week. So isn't the problem that people have called it out,
but people also don't seem to care or they might even like it. I mean, in some ways,
it's seen as a sign of strength. Well, I don't think it's seen a sign of strength to be
demented. I think he, however, is very good. Well, okay, just to clarify, I'm not saying it.
seen as a sign of strength to have dementia. But his leadership or his bombast is misinterpreted as a sign of
leadership. No, malignant narcissists, you know, have a certain appeal. First of all, we talked about
as charisma, but also the psychopathic part of them makes them have a will to dominate and a will
to control that is very, very powerful. And people identify with that. So, you know, a lot of people
are thrilled by the fact that he's taking this kind of strong man control and beating up on their
shared enemies. So there is a kind of psychological appeal that a Hitler-like character has. And actually,
there was a psychologist named Adorno, right, who wrote about the authoritarian personality in the
late 40s trying to really try to understand what kind of a person is attracted.
to a malignantly narcissistic leader, to an authoritarian leader, someone who feels disempowered
and who feels re-empowered by someone who, in a punitive way, is attacking their shared enemies
and making them feel powerful and making them feel entitled to dominate.
So there is this way he appeals to a certain group of white Americans, right,
who really want to reassert the dominance of whites in America and who might feel disempowering.
because they're not that educated or they're not that powerful or that wealthy.
And so they identify with this powerful, wealthy white man who's saying what they think,
but is socially unacceptable that they're superior to minorities.
And we need to keep them out of this country and they don't have brains.
John, just hold on one second while we take some messages.
And we're back with Dr. John Gartner talking about Donald Trump's health.
How significant is it that the first lady,
seems to have moved away significantly from Donald Trump.
And his daughter, Ivanka, who was very present during Trump One with her husband, Jared Kushner,
now seems nowhere to be seen.
In fact, she said that politics wasn't for her, that it was such a brutal game.
So he doesn't have, as far as we know, any close women around him.
I mean, he certainly has Susie Wiles, his chief of staff, and he's got people in his office.
But he doesn't have any female family members who appear to be in his.
his close circle, and he seems increasingly isolated.
Yeah. Well, look, one of the things about malignant narcissists is they are literally incapable
of love. They're incapable of love. And so nobody really loves Donald Trump. He doesn't
really have any figures that really love him. He's got, you know, followers who worship him,
but to know him is really to hate him. And I believe basically his family has decided it's
intolerable to be around him. Like you said, you don't want to be in the room with him, and so they're
trying to distance themselves. I mean, his sons are certainly making lots of billions in
crypto in his name, but nobody really wants to be around him because he is unpredictable,
aggressive, and you have to just submit to it. You know, the other thing about his thinking
is, I just want to point out a few other symptoms. One of them is something we call confabulation,
I would actually argue. It's very hard to distinguish a lot.
from confabulation, but confabulation, and again, these people who are listening, who have relatives,
who have dementia, will recognize this trait. There's so many gaps in their memory that they
actually remember things that didn't happen by weaving together different sort of little pieces of
memory. So, for example, he told this long, elaborate story about how his uncle taught the
Unabomber at MIT, and he said, I talked to him, what kind of student was he? He said, well, he was
a no-it-all, and nobody really liked him. And well, look, the Unabomber.
bomber never went to MIT. Ted Kaczynski didn't go to MIT, so he couldn't have been in his
uncle's class. By the time they discovered his unabomber, his uncle was dead. Now, this isn't
like saying, I have the highest poll numbers when he has the lowest poll numbers, or we've added
jobs when we've lost jobs. That's lying where we know he has a purpose. It's going to make him
look better. But telling this long, rambling story about his uncle and the unabomber doesn't
really serve any purpose. When he's telling it, I believe he actually thinks he's remorse. He's
remembering something. This is another sign of dementia. The other sign of dementia that we see
as people with dementia, then they really can't come up with any thoughts. Just use a lot of superlatives.
So like, for example, when he was at Gettysburg, he said, Gettysburg, wow. It was, like, amazing.
And it was horrible, but it was, like, beautiful in a way. So just all these superlatives, I think he's
standing there and he really doesn't know what Gettysburg is. And then he's, like, looking at a hill,
And he said, you know, and Robert E. Lee said, never fight up hill me boys. And he says it for some reason in an Irish accent. Never fight up to me boys, which he never said. But he was looking at a hill. So he just kind of made that up. I think he was just in a confused state. And so he was just using all these superlatives and then making up this story. And I guess where I would maybe push back a little bit is I don't think people are commenting on it. You know, you'd have to show me the receipts, I guess. Show me where in the press they're talking about his mental.
deterioration. I don't think you're going to find it. And when you do, unfortunately, it'll be them
quoting me and my co-host, Harry Siegel, which is actually uncomfortable for us because then if you put in
chat GPT, is there evidence for Donald Trump having dementia? You say, yes, because Dr. John Gardner
and Dr. Harry Siegel said so on shrinking Trump. The doctors are afraid to comment on it.
I do think, well, certainly late-night comedians, I mean, Jimmy Kimmel's just lost his job over it, right?
I mean, certainly.
Late night comedians, some have.
I mean, there are definitely, and I definitely think there are, I mean, certainly at the Daily Beast, we've relentlessly followed his cancals as they've been spilling over his Oxford's.
Let me ask you something else. Joe Biden appeared to be failing in plain sight, too. I mean, your point about Donald Trump is we can see this happening in front of us.
Joe Biden also seemed to be failing. You saw him freezing. You heard the voice. I mean, he seemed to have every symptom of Parkinson'sism that.
that there was without anybody acknowledging it. Did you see that in him too? Well, I think that
what's interesting about what happened in the Biden situation is I think they did a better job of
hiding him when he was deteriorating. It seems like about six months before the election is when he
really took a bad turn. And yet, by keeping him out of the public eye, we weren't able to really
see the same signs and symptoms. Although the press was a lot harder on him, I think, in terms of his
mental competence than they were on Trump. And that's what really upset us, is the double standard,
right? That they were commenting on his gaffs, but they weren't really saying much about Trumps.
And, you know, a lot of the things with Biden, you know, the slow voice, you know, the slow movements,
Could be Parkinson's, could be normal aging.
I think what was really a shock was the debate,
was that's when the public really saw, oh, my God,
these rumors about his having some kind of deterioration are true,
because he literally looked blank, right,
when he was staring at the camera.
And that's really the moment when I think the election turned.
So he shouldn't have run again.
The people around him shouldn't have urged him to run again.
They knew that he had these deficits,
and they were hiding the deficits from the public.
Okay, so if you know they're serious enough to hide them from the public, then don't urge the man to run for president.
So, but that's a good example of where Donald Trump would still have had dementia and, as you're saying, you know, malignant narcissism and a personality disorder.
But he appeared to win the debate.
One of the ways that he won the debate, well, first of all, I think Biden was very, you know, I think Biden lost the debate.
Right. Well, he had a challenged opponent.
Yeah, he had a challenge bomb.
But one of his techniques, it's been called gish galloping after a certain congressman,
like, the 1800s, where, or to put it the way Steve Bannon called it,
flood the zone with shit, which is to spew out so many outrageous lies, but like a gatling gun, right?
Boom, boom, boom, boom, one after the other.
So that your opponent doesn't even know, if you say five outrageous lies, you know, where,
do I even begin to rebut
that person? You know, when they're not even
related to each other, they're like off topic,
you know, and so
that technique is actually pretty
effective, that he just keeps
spewing out lies in this
pressured speech that then
people really don't have a capacity
to respond. Now, of course, he's
just intimidating people, so
they're afraid to respond. But it
actually turned out to be a fairly effective
technique in the debate if the person
can't respond effectively.
So Donald Trump is supposed to be extremely good at sniffing out his enemy's weaknesses.
What are his weaknesses?
I mean, we know that he appears to be haunted by his old friend, Jeffrey Epstein,
who followed him to London for his amazing visit to Windsor Castle.
And we saw the projection of the film on the side of Windsor.
the castle, thus hijacking the trip and making sure that all the headlines included Epstein.
Is Donald Trump, do you think, actually sort of haunted by Jeffrey Epstein?
What are the things that make Trump truly paranoid?
Yeah, I mean, one of the things about the psychopathy is they have no remorse for anything
bad they've done and no fear about being exposed.
But when you have someone who's a narcissist, at every moment there's a feeling that their grandiosity could collapse.
So they're fighting to win each moment, right, to keep inflating themselves.
So in a sense, in his paranoia, he's threatened by everything and everyone, right,
who could potentially in any way pierce his veil of invulnerability and grandiosity.
So that's one of the reasons he attacks everyone, every reporter that asks him a question,
and with any kind of a challenge, you know, you're disgusting and you're no good and your
publications are failing and you should go to jail. That's hate speech. You know, recently told
Jonathan Carl that he was committing hate speech by asking him a question of what Pam Bondi
said about hate speech. But the thing is, is that that is the fear is that his grandiosity
will collapse or that he'll be exposed as something less than, you know, omnipotent. So in a sense,
he's in an existential battle every second.
That makes sense in terms of him just lurching moment to moment, pushing the narrative forward and not really answering specific questions, but constantly changing direction.
So as you say, it's very hard to sort of follow him or understand how to pin things down.
Do you think he is genuinely scared of the Epstein story?
Well, I think that he, you know, he's been able to duck everything.
And he now has a criminal justice system, which is colluding in covering up the Epstein story.
I mean, think about this.
You know, when in the history, have you ever heard of an assistant attorney general going to meet with someone in jail, right?
A sex traffico has been sentenced to 20 years.
Exactly.
And we know that she could implicate Trump.
Now, usually when someone from the Justice Department meets with a criminal.
criminal in jail, it's to implicate, right, another wrongdoer, right? And lo and behold, of course,
she gave them what they wanted. She said she'd never seen anything to cause her concern,
which we thought was funny on the show, because what would cause her concern? She's a child molester
herself. But anyway, never saw anything to cause concern. And lo and behold, then quit pro quo,
right in front of everyone's eyes, she's transferred to this sort of spa camp prison, you know,
as a reward. It was obvious. And, you know,
we said, Kosh Patel said that he had thousands of FBI agents working around the clock to find
any reference to Trump in the Epstein files. Well, we know there's hundreds of references to him,
and lo and behold, he's now claiming there's no references to him. Yeah. So in other words,
he actually said thousands of FBI agents with some whiteout to go through all the files
to basically hide all the references to Epstein. So he thinks he's going to get away with it,
because he's gotten away with everything. And that's part of the psychopath psychology. They
always think they're going to get away with it. They're not worried about being exposed.
And he probably will get away with it. And John, we're just going to take a break for some ads.
And we're back with Dr. John Gartner talking about Donald Trump's health. And is there
copycat behavior from the people around him? I mean, I was watching the Cash Patel
hearings this week. And his determination to shout down, certainly Adam Schiff and some of the
other senators talking to him. It felt very reminiscent of Trump. And Michael Wolfe, who's my partner
on the inside, Trump's head podcast, and I know you have your partner, Dr. Harry Siegel,
on your podcast shrinking Trump, which I highly recommend for anybody listening and watching
to this. It's delightfully entertaining and you invite guest doctors on to analyze people,
in particular, Donald Trump. Where am I going with this? I'm going with copycat behavior. Is there a
sort of knock-on effect from this kind of grandiosity? Is that why everybody else is suddenly getting
much more aggressive? It's a great question. I think the answer is yes. I sometimes think of Trump
being a malignant narcissist as being similar to a malignant tumor in the body politic. And we had a
chance to remove the tumor and save the patient. We failed there, obviously. But what happens with
the tumor is it spreads its DNA around the body.
and cells reproduce with that DNA.
I think Trump's sort of psychological DNA has now seeped into the people in his administration.
They're also, you know, as you say, shouting people down and devaluing people.
But also what we see, too, is that there's been a process.
This always happens with all of these dictators of purging and purging and purging
till you get down to the worst of the worst.
You know, what's called a cacistocracy, you know, government by the worst.
So in the first administration, you had people who might have been colluding with him to some degree, but they had some moral limits, right?
There had some point with the way, I'm going to, Mr. President, we can't do that.
You know, those people are gone.
Even Bill Barr, right, who covered up the whole Mueller report, you know, he had a limit.
He wasn't going to invalidate the whole election.
You know, that was where he got off the bus.
And so then he became an enemy.
Right now, Bill Barr is reviled.
So what he did, what happens is there's a systematic process.
of purging people.
And it's happened within the Republican Party generally, right?
There used to be some Republican representatives and senators like Jeff Flake, for example,
who had a conscience, who believed in the Constitution.
But those people have been systematically purged.
And so now what you have left, it's sort of like a reduction sauce.
You know, you have the true believers, the true psychopaths, the true wing nuts,
the people who are all in with no inhibitions, no conscience, no soul.
And so, of course, they're going to imitate the behavior of their dear leader.
How do you diagnose, or what is your diagnosis of someone like Elon Musk?
Well, Elon Musk is actually a complex character.
I mean, he appears to be on the spectrum.
I think he also has bipolar traits.
You know, when he was manically pursuing this whole Doge thing.
You know, he brought his bed into the famously into their offices and said,
We work 24 hours a day and on weekends, and that's how we're going to defeat these bureaucrats because they only work nine to five.
That seems like some sort of mania.
Exactly, exactly.
And even his behavior with the chainsaw, you know, waving the chainsaw around wildly.
It was also irresponsible and erratic and extreme and hyped up, you know, and there may even been drug involvement too.
We know that he's got, allegedly has a whole case of drugs.
He's on ketamine.
He's on this.
He's on that.
So that he could be hyping or firing.
up his hypomania, perhaps with drugs. But so I think he's a complex case. There's a lot of things
going on in his case. But what you have in common among all of these Trump people now is they do
have a kind of psychopathic core, right? That there will, like, you know, that Levitt, his press
secretary said, he has got the highest poll numbers in history. Actually, he's got the lowest poll
numbers in history. I mean, you know, it's what I call opospeak. I think what you're hearing from
public service is aposite.
speak, meaning it's literally the opposite, the polar opposite of what they say.
I'm going to re-listen to this and jot down all the medical terms that you've given us,
because I find it absolutely fascinating.
John, you're describing what feels like a very extreme personality.
How common is this among people?
That's actually an excellent question.
So the guest that we had on this week, Dr. Vince Greenwood, is a scholar of psychopathy.
And he has said that Donald Trump really meets the very strict criteria for a severe psychopath.
And what we know is that only one in about 150 people meet these strict criteria for psychopathy.
So just as a start, just as a baseline, it's already a very rare disorder.
One in 150 people?
One in 150 people would meet criteria for being a psychopath.
Now, in his case, psychopathy is really only part of his disorder.
as we've said, because as a malignant narcissist, there's four components,
psychopathy, narcissism, paranoia, and sadism.
But actually, the guest we had on argued that those other components could be included
in the psychopathy diagnosis if you're really being strict about your diagnostic criteria.
But in any case, it is very rare.
And I think that's one of the reasons why it's hard for normal people to understand.
But one in 150 doesn't seem rare.
I mean, you know,
I can't remember who it is that says that most people have, or the peak number of friends you can have is 150,
which means that we all have a psychopath in our friend group.
That seems alarming.
I think one in 150 is actually, there's a hell of a lot of psychopaths wandering around then.
I mean, this is a country of 330 million people.
Our expert also said he felt that Donald Trump was the most extreme example that he'd seen in his entire career.
So in that small group, he would be in like 99th percentile.
Well, I'm very excited to see what comments we get from listeners and from viewers on
YouTube.
I think there will be many, many, many questions.
And, well, we'd love to come.
We'd love to have you back and to have you address them.
Dr. John Gartner, thank you very much for your time.
Thank you for having me.
Well, I found that absolutely fascinating.
One of the most interesting things about Donald Trump is that he has been a colossus across the media for the last 40 years.
He has segwayed and changed as the media has seguade and changed.
And so we've been able to see him in plain sight as he's gotten older and more powerful
and now is exercising that power in some truly alarming ways.
Thank you for joining us if you have been.
please leave a comment on YouTube.
Feel free to subscribe and join the Daily Beast community.
We love hearing from you.
And share this podcast with a friend, with an enemy, with a colleague out there online.
Share away.
It's all free.
And we are independent media and we love growing our audience.
So thank you to our production team.
And as our first lady who was briefly out of hiding,
for her trip to Windsor Castle this week would have us,
Be Beast.
And thank you to our production team, Devin Roderino,
Anna Von Erson, and our editor, Jesse Milwood.
And shout out to our Be Beast layer of membership.
Karen White, Heidi Riley, and Connie Rutherford.
Thank you.
Want more great listens?
Check out our comedy podcast, The Last Laugh,
and our star-studded The Daily Beast podcast
at the DailyBeast.com slash podcasts.
If you enjoyed this episode, consider becoming a Daily Beast subscriber.
Subscribing is the best way to feed the beast and support all of your podcasts as we cover
what might become the darkest timeline.
Head to the DailyBeast.com slash membership slash podcast and sign up today.
