The Daily Signal - Hillsdale College Helps K-12 Students Learn American History, Civics

Episode Date: August 9, 2021

Schools across America—both public and private—are embracing the left's radical ideas at an alarming rate. These ideas have found their way into curriculum, sometimes subtly and other times overtly. Many parents have had enough. They're taking action and speaking out—winning seats on school boards, demanding transparency from teachers, and insisting that their kids learn the foundational values that made America the greatest country on earth. Now, thanks to Hillsdale College, there’s a curriculum that parents can use to ensure their children are getting the education they deserve. Matthew Spalding, Hilldale's vice president of Washington operations and dean of the Van Andel Graduate School of Government, joins "The Daily Signal Podcast" to talk about the curriculum and why it’s needed now more than ever. "It's important for us to realize that while we might think this is merely a debate about different opinions about history," Spalding says, "this is about debate between history on the one hand—good, accurate history and we can have some disagreements here and there, but generally speaking, there's a broad consensus about that—and an ideological approach, which is using history merely as a foil to fight current battles." Listen to my interview with Spalding on the podcast or read a lightly edited transcript below. You may learn more about the Hillsdale 1776 Curriculum on the school's website and access other K-12 resources there as well. Enjoy the show! Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

It's Canadian Tire's Black Friday sale. With the lowest prices of the year. Hello, can we go? Limbo again. Shop the Black Friday sale at Canadian Tire and save up to 60%. November 27th to December 7th. Conditions apply. Details online.

This is the Daily Signal podcast for Monday, August 9th. I'm Robert Blewey. And I'm Virginia Allen. On today's show, Rob talks with Hillsdale College's Matthew Spalding. They discuss the new Hillsdale 1776 curriculum for teaching American history, civics and government to K-12 students. We also read your letters to the editor and share a good news story. Before we get to today's show, we want to tell you about the most popular resource on the Heritage

Foundation website, The Guide to the Constitution. More than 100 scholars have contributed to create a unique line-by-line analysis of our Constitution. The guide is intended to provide a brief and accurate explanation of each clause of the Constitution as envisioned by the framers and as applied in contemporary law. There has never been a more important time to have an understanding of our founding document. So if you want to learn more about the Constitution, go ahead and visit heritage.org slash constitution, or you can simply search for Heritage Guide to the Constitution. Now stay tuned for today's show coming up next.

We are joined on the Daily Signal podcast today by Matthew Spalding. He is Hillsdale College's vice president of Washington Operations and dean of the Van Andal Graduate School of Government, as well as an author and editor of several books, including the Heritage Foundation's Guide to the Constitution. Matt, welcome back to the Heritage Foundation, and thank you for joining the Daily Single. It is great to be with you. Thanks for inviting me. Absolutely. Well, you just brought me a printed copy of the 1776 report.

You had the privilege of serving as executive director on the President's Advisory 1776 Commission. I want you to tell us more about this. Of course, President Biden, famously, one of his first acts, was to do. disband this commission. But walk us back to how this all began and where it's headed in the future. It's all kind of a blur. It happens so fast. Last year, I took a leave of absence from Hillsdale College and went over to be the executive

director of the 1776 Commission, not knowing quite what to make of that and what would happen with it, but we had a crazy idea, which turns out to be one of the reasons why I think everyone was surprised on both sides of the aisle about what it did, which is a I went over with the agreement that I would have the ability to actually write a report and get that report out. And so in a matter of about five or six weeks, we produced a report that was supposed to be the first of perhaps several, that was a two-year commission, to advise the president about getting ready for the 250th anniversary of the Declaration of Independence.

I approached it as a scholar, someone who wanted to write a public document advocating and putting a marker down in this discussion about what is 1776 and what does it mean. It came out on Martin Luther King Day in 2021, and two days later when the new president was inaugurated, one of his first acts within hours of being inaugurated, he abolished the commission. even before he abolished it, it was taken down immediately from the White House website and erased, if you will, to which our response is, well, you can't erase our history. It's still there. So what I handed Rob here was a printed edition of the report. The report came out, and it's available everywhere. I think Heritage has it on their website, Hillsdale. They made it into much more public document by trying to erase it. It actually helped. They brought it more attention. But one of the criticisms was it had no footnotes, therefore it wasn't a serious report. Well, you know me, right?

You don't say that to an academic. That's right. I actually had all my footnotes. And so there's a book version, Encounter Book, published, which includes all the footnotes to mainstream historians, including, but also some explanatory notes about what we meant by different passages and showing various support. I mentioned one of the first ones was to credit a senator, Joseph Biden, at the famous Bork hearings of many years ago, arguing about the source of his rights coming from his humanity, not necessarily being the gift of government with the Supreme Court, which was a quote to our favor. That's right. I did quote the incoming president of the United States. Fantastic. Well, one of the things that was happening, of course, during the time that President Trump created this commission,

months prior he gave this really outstanding speech on July 4th, 2020 at Mount Rushmore. In the months that preceded that and followed that, we had this major debate on issues related to our nation's founding and race and a whole host of other things happening in our country. And we continue to have that discussion today. And so thank you for the contributions that you've offered. What is in store for the work that going forward? I know that Hillsdale recently had reconvened the commission and had a meeting. Do you intend to continue doing this work? Well, one thing if I could make it just a little bit of a historical note is it's important for those who are interested in the immediate things going on and the fights people are in at school boards and whatever the current debate is occurring to realize this has been going on for some time.

I've been working on these things for decades. my time here at the Heritage Foundation, and a lot of the writing I did when I was at Heritage were about these questions. And of course, Hillsdale has been around for a long time, and now I'm with Hillsdale College working on this. So this is not a new debate. This is a new form of the debate, and I would suggest to you that it's been radicalized in a way. And it's important for us to realize that while we might think this is merely a debate about different opinions about history. What really is this is about debate between history on the one hand, good, accurate history, and we can have some disagreements here and there, but generally speaking, there's a broad

consensus about that, and an ideological approach, which is using history merely as a foil to fight current battles. So it's, you know, both those were that broader perspective and the immediate perspective, I think is really important to keep in mind, which that then brings me to the Hillsdale's curriculum. Hillsdale's been involved in K-12 education for decades. We have a lot of charter schools. We write the curriculum for. We have professors that have been writing about these things. This is nothing new to us. And the college has been involved in this debate about what America means since its own beginning in 1844. This is really kind of civic education, history education is what it's all about. So in that sense, it's not a new thing at all. The new

immediate thing, of course, is the particular debate that has occurred in the country between that really was stimulated by the 1776 Commission that was then abolished in an executive order trying to turn the country towards equity outcomes, really engage this broader debate about what is going on. Well, within that context about, you know, debate over whether 1776 is good or not, we redoubled our efforts at the college to take a part of a larger and ongoing curriculum project, which will continue, and put out for the public, which is say it's free, anybody who wants to use it, homeschoolers, schools, parents, teachers, a particular curriculum on all of civics, all K through 12,

and American history having to do with the founding, the Civil War, again, for K through 12. So that portion of it is readily available, and we did put that out. there to contribute to this ongoing conversation about the importance of our own history. Well, I can tell you I am really excited about this as a parent of soon to be seventh grader and soon to be fourth grader because I see it firsthand. I take a very active role in their education, have conversations with them, particularly around what they're learning in history. Of course, in fourth grade in Virginia, they make the trip, you know, to Jamestown and

and see some of those historical sites. So one of the questions I have for you is, and one of the things that stood out for me, is the fact that you said that this is a curriculum created by teachers for teachers, not by some government bureaucrat or a journalist, as famously they've done with the 1619 project. Why was it important for you to take this particular approach and make it accessible for teachers in this way? That's a great point. One of the things I've written about for a long time to point it out, but also in the commission, the commission's report, I made a point of making this point, which is that the federal government has nothing to do with curriculum. It has no authority, indeed by law.

It's prevented from shaping curriculum. And that's an important thing. I mean, much of the debate we have today is centered around what the federal government is doing, here, there, whatever it might be. that points us in a different direction, which is, say, downward. States are very important. They set standards, but really it's school boards. And then it's teachers in classrooms, right? The way teaching occurs is in particular classroom with particular students.

And so the only way to create curriculum, which is a real curriculum, not what – I mean, people kind of bandy this word around. But when we say curriculum, we mean lesson plans and a question. for students, the topics for discussion, laying it out over the course of weeks and months, right? That's a curriculum. Well, that can only be done by people who actually know what they're doing. And here, I mean, you know, there are many things Hillsdale, we have opinions about everything, lots of things, but there are things we don't know about. One thing we do know about is how to teach people. We've got a lot of experience in that. So, yes, a curriculum should be made by teachers, people who know how to teach, how to teach, how to teach, how to teach, kids and grades K through 12, which also means not people in universities and especially not in the federal government. People who know how to teach and know what they're doing is really important.

And so one of the things that this bothered me about this whole debate is it's occurring by a lot of people who don't know what they're doing. federal bureaucrats and by, you know, professional advocacy groups. This is what convinced me that we're really not having a conversation about curriculum and history per se. This is an ideological conversation, a politicized conversation, using history and curriculum. Well, you know, they shouldn't be using students K through 12 high school kids for that purpose. We need to get back to the good old-fashioned notion of teaching them good, accurate, honest history.

That's absolutely right. And for our listeners to know, I mean, the 1619 project, which was something that was envisioned by Nicole Hannah-Jones at the New York Times, in addition to being a lengthy magazine article, also had a corresponding curriculum or they would send copies of the magazine to school districts across the country. So it is happening on the left. We certainly know that. But you brought up a point about teaching the truth about American history.

Why is that so important for our listeners to understand the significance of that? And why do we need to reground ourselves to that point? Right, right, good point. The mistake that is often made and is especially going on right now with, say, the 1619 project, and this occurs from other, this has happened before, it will continue to happen, is we tend to look at history backwards. That is, there's something we want to argue about right now, and we look back in history to merely find. what we're looking for. Well, that gives you a jaded, but at very least, inaccurate view of history. The best way to understand history is try to understand it for itself. What did they think? What did they know? What were they doing? Now, I also firmly believe that history should be taught warts and all.

The good, the bad, and the ugly. And there are a lot of imperfections and flaws in American history. slavery being the most important, the barbaric practice, which was at the center of the American political debate almost really from the beginning, if not before the beginning. We should teach that too. But the accurate history of that is not to look backwards looking for evil and barbarism and systemic racism. The answer is to study history because what you see then are a lot of people, some advocate slavery and you want to make my teachers learn that too but a lot of others who saw the the bad of it the evil of it and and acted so as to live up to the principles of the Declaration of

Independence and bring America over some period of time and through a civil war to to live up to those principles and that's a noble heritage and something that ought is great about this country that ought to be taught to our students rather than merely throwing it all out because of the flaws in perfections, which are admittedly there and ought to be taught to. What is your advice or call to action for our listeners? The curriculum is available on Hillsdale's website. As you said, it's free. It's meant for public school teachers, private school teachers, homeschoolers.

But if you are in a setting where you don't have direct control, say you're a parent of a public school student, And how can they best go about engaging with their teacher, their child's teacher, or their school to make sure that they're using Hillsdale's. Well, one general thing I would point out, going back to my point about how the federal government really has nothing to do with the curriculum. It's the state level. It's a school board. It's school districts. It's local schools. One thing is to remind everybody that this is not a lost cause body means.

I have another topic of conversations is where the universities are and where they're going. But they have virtually nothing to do with this other than coming up with bad ideas. But the real conversation about curriculum is at these lower levels, and it gets more important as you move down in those lower levels, which means there are lots of opportunities for parents and people interested in their local communities to get involved. So one call for action. People should just get involved in these curriculum discussions wherever and whenever they're. they can. And I think we're seeing that and people should see that as a source of strength in American society. In terms of what we, Hillsdale, I have to provide, Hillsdale.edu has you can get the, from there. We also have a separate website, which is K-12.hillsdale.edu,

which has the curriculum and a lot of other things about K-12 education, and we're doing more and more on that. At the main website, we have a lot of online videos of courses, most designed for, say, college students or good high school students, and we're going to do more of that to apply to K through 12. And we have an idea that at some point soon we want to make available to kids in high school at other colleges, perhaps the ability to get a Hillsdale credits for, say, a civic education requirement. So we're going to continue doing more and more things. where there is a resource, and there are others. We'll point to other resources as well.

But I think there's a chink in the armor here of the left, and they're defensive. The 1619 stuff is not convincing a lot of people. It's so over the top. It's clearly ideological. I think it's reviving a lot of people to the real conversation about civics and why it's important. And there are resources out there, and Hillsdale College means to be one of those resources and make it extremely easy for free for parents and teachers to get our material. That's fantastic.

And I must say that having worked with you and having worked with Hillsdale students, either in the form of interns or who've gone on to successful careers, just the quality of the work that you do at Hillsdale is phenomenal. So I highly encourage our listeners to check out the resources that you've made available. fantastic. I do want to ask you about some of the things that you're doing here in D.C. You have helped lead in major expansion of what Hillsdale does in Washington, D.C. What opportunities do you provide at the D.C. campus? Sure. And so Hilstow College, which is based in Michigan, a number of years ago,

got a building in D.C. and wanted to expand. I kind of took over the role of building that operation. We now have a campus here, a growing campus. We have our own students that come back, but we also have public programs. We hold seminars. We have seminars for friends of the college that come back for college courses. We have public lectures. And just a year and a half or so ago, we founded a graduate school back here with the purpose of essentially extending Killsdale's mission, rating its mission in the nation's capital to working professionals who want to get a Hillsdale education but are already out there writing speeches, working at think tanks, working in the administration, and whatever it might be. So I think what we're doing in Washington, D.C.

is it really represents an extension of the college mission. If you think of it as defending religious and, you know, civic and religious freedom and teaching it, well, we want to teach it here because this is the nation's capital. And we want to shape public thinking about these questions. And so it's an extension of that. And Hillsdale is unique among so many higher education institutions in more ways than one. I mean, first of all, not taking federal money. but can you talk more broadly about how you are the principles that guide a Hillsdale education versus, say, another university?

Well, I would say two things are key to the Hillsdale persona, if you will. One you've mentioned, which we're kind of known for, which we take no government money. And I have to tell you that that frees us from so much, not just the petty small regulations, but the worry of someone always looking over your shoulder. and we will be the first to extend the hand to anybody else who wants to join us in that pond. We would love to have others come along because it's a great place to be. It gives you a lot of independence. The other thing that's crucially important is Hillsdale College is very much defined by its beginnings, its mission statement from the very beginning, which defines it,

defines it how it's going to teach, who it's going to teach. Hillsdale has always, it was founded as abolitionist college, which is to say we believe it is wrong to consider someone's the color of their skin as their status as a student, accepted women from the very beginning. So it's very much driven by that original mission, which is to teach these core principles of liberal education, but also it's intimately tied with the defense of civil and religious liberty in American constitution. history. And so that's all very important, and we constantly stick to our mission. So we have the independence by being free from government, but we are constantly honing that original mission and teaching and doing the things we know how to do best, as opposed to merely take as much money we can from the government and going wherever the wins of the day take us. Well, we appreciate that principled position that you do take. And I should also acknowledge

your leader, the president of Hillsdale College, Larry Arne, is a member of the Heritage Foundation Board of Trustees, just in the interest of full disclosure here. But, Matt, one last question for you. You have devoted so much of your life to the study of history and advancing America's founding principles. You're the author of an excellent book. We still hold these truths on that subject. Which I did while I was at Heritage Foundation. That's right.

I forgot to bring a copy to the studio today, but I have it in my office. So what motivates you? What first motivated you to pursue this? And what still keeps you ticking today? Right. Well, probably two things. One is first, I had the gift, the blessing, I suppose, of having some wonderful teachers, including one great teacher named Harry Jaffa, who was just this remarkable classroom teacher

and a scholar about Abraham Lincoln. And he interested me in history. And history is very important. And you learn a lot from that. and I've always been interested in those things. Number one, and number two, once you get interested in something like that, you realize you want to teach it and spread that. And I think the other thing to remind us is that to remember is that in a free country, the teaching and education and the shaping of citizens is crucially important to the future. and getting that right is important.

And so those things have motivated my initial studies, my work, and now my continuing work as I get older in terms of teaching others and shaping that because that's how we're going to recover our country, in my opinion. That's fantastic. Matt, we will leave a link in the show notes and on the transcript for our listeners if they want to get more information about the curriculum and some of Hillsdale's other offerings. Thank you so much for being a guest on the Daily Signal.

We appreciate it. Great to be with you anytime. Virginia Allen here, I want to tell you all about one of my favorite podcasts. Heritage Explains is a weekly podcast that breaks down all the policy issues we hear about in the news at a 101 level. Post Michelle Cordero and Tim Desher mix in news clips and music to tell a story, but also bring in heritage experts to help break down complex issues. issues. Heritage Explains offers quick 10 to 50 minute explainers that bring you up to speed in an entertaining way. You can find them on Apple Podcasts, Google Play, Spotify, or wherever you listen to

your podcast. We even put the full episode on YouTube. Thanks for sending us your letters to the editor. Each Monday we feature our favorites on this show. Virginia, who's up first? Gary Brown writes, Dear Daily Signal, I always learn from each item I read in the Daily Signal. That's why I appreciate the time and effort of every member of your team and why I share the fruits of your labor with friends and family. And in response to Rachel Del Judas's documentary and article, Life on a Border Ranch, cut water lines, downed fences, stolen property, and dead bodies, Kenneth Stinson writes, thank you for your excellent article on ranch life on the border in Arizona. This piece is the best video journalism article that we have seen.

You get straight A's for this composition. Your letter can be featured on next week's show, so send us an email at Letters at DailySignal.com. Never has it been more important for us to fight for America. Each day we see the penalties of progressive policies across our nation. Our elections are under assault. Our economic freedom is on the decline, and our culture is turning its back on the founding principles that have made us the freest, most prosperous nation in history. That's why the Heritage Foundation developed a plan. to take on the left and take back our country. The Citizens Guide to Fight for America provides a series of heritage recommended action items

delivered on a regular basis to your inbox. Make an impact in your community and in our country. Sign up for the Citizens Guide at heritage.org slash citizens guide and join in the fight for America today. We are once again joined by the Heritage Foundation's Bernadette Breslin, an intern in our young, program who will tell us about a good news story today. Bernadette, over to you. As trite as it may sound, age is but a number. Irma Black, widow of the Navy's first master

chief petty officer, knows this best, even at 100 years old. To properly celebrate her centennial, a naval base in Florida flew Irma on a helicopter where she circled around a ship, named in memory of her late husband, Delbert Black. Delbert was the first enlisted representative to the Chief of Naval Operations. He was also a survivor of the Pearl Harbor attack. But Delbert wasn't the only veteran spouse in his marriage. According to Fox News, Irma herself chose to enlist in the Navy during the Second World War and served as a seaman first-class storekeeper.

Her service was permitted under the women accepted for volunteer emergency service program. In addition to getting an aerial view of the USS Delbert D. Black and an aerial tour of neighboring Jacksonville, the naval base also welcomed Irma onto the ship's chief's mess. There, she had the opportunity to get pictures with crew members after being presented with a framed photo of the crew. Having celebrated 50 years of marriage before her husband, Delbert, passed away in 2000, Irma was most grateful for her over-the-top birthday present. And as World War II veterans, we thank Delbert and Irma Black for their service. Bernadette, thanks so much for

sharing that story. And we're going to leave it there for today. You can find the Daily Signal podcast on the Rikershay Audio Network. All of our shows are available at daily signal.com slash podcasts. You can also subscribe on Apple Podcasts, Google Play, or your favorite podcast app. And be sure to listen every weekday by adding the Daily Signal podcast as part of your Alexa Flash briefing. If you like what you hear, we would really appreciate a review and a five-star rating. It means a lot to us and helps us spread the word to even more listeners. And be sure to follow us on Twitter at DailySignal and Facebook.com slash the DailySignal News. Have a great week.

The Daily Signal podcast is brought to you by more than half a million members of the Heritage Foundation. It is executive produced by Rob Blewey and Virginia Allen. Sound design by Lauren Evans, Mark Geinney, and John Pop. For more information, visitdailySignal.com.