The Eric Metaxas Show - #109 - Michael Troy
Episode Date: May 1, 2026Today on The Eric Metaxas Show, Eric talks with Michael Troy, host of The American Revolution Podcast, about the wild, overlooked, and often shocking stories behind America’s founding. They discuss ...George Washington, Horatio Gates, Charles Lee, Benedict Arnold, Thomas Paine, the Battle of Camden, the Conway Cabal, and the providential moments that helped save the American cause when everything could have collapsed. Subscribe for clips from The Eric Metaxas Show to hear politics and culture from a Christian perspective.⭐ PRE-ORDER TODAY:Revolution: The Birth of the Greatest Nation in the History of the World📕: https://a.co/d/0ir3NlapTODAY'S SPONSORS:⭐ FREE SLAVES: https://csi-usa.org/metaxas/📢 Don’t Let the Financial Storm Destroy Your Wealth and Future!https://www.metaxasgoldira.com/⚖️ Legal Help Center - Get Free Legal Help Today: https://www.legalhelpcenter.com/🛏️ MyPillow — Save BIG with code ERIC: https://www.mypillow.com/☀️ Honest, fast, and free Medicare plan guidance: https://askchapter.com/metaxas/💧 Sentry H2O: https://sentryh2o.com/
Transcript
Discussion (0)
Visit BetMGM casino and check out the newest exclusive.
The Price is Right Fortune Pick.
BetMGM and GameSense remind you to play responsibly.
19 plus to wager.
Ontario only.
Please play responsibly.
If you have questions or concerns about your gambling or someone close to you,
please contact connects Ontario at 1-866-531-2,600 to speak to an advisor,
free of charge.
BetMGM operates pursuant to an operating agreement with Eye Gaming Ontario.
Hey there, folks. I don't know about you and I don't care about you. I care about me. I'm excited. I'm excited. Please be excited with me because as you know, my book on the revolution is coming out. And this is America's supercentennial, our 250th. It's a big, wonderful patriotic year. We should be celebrating. And my way of celebrating, apart from writing 600-page book on the American Revolution, is to have a very wonderful patriotic year. We should be celebrating. And my way of celebrating, apart from writing 600-page book on the American Revolution, is to have a big,
regular guests on this program to talk about the American Revolution.
And today, I feel really privileged and thrilled to have, as my guest, the host of the American Revolution podcast.
His name is Michael Troy.
I've never met him before today.
I heard his voice, but I don't know what he looks.
like and I I've been listening to the American Revolution podcast for many, many months,
like intensely because John Zmirak, who is on this program often, said to me, hey, have he
checked out the American Revolution? You're writing this book. Have you checked out the American
Revolution podcast? I said, no, no, I never listen to podcasts ever. I don't. I just don't.
But he's like, yeah, you should check it out. And he's telling me about it. And one day,
finally, I figured out how to listen to the American Revolution podcast, and I was kind of hooked.
And I've been so blessed by the contents of it.
And I thought, wouldn't it be great if the guy doing it were still alive and we could talk to him?
Turns out he is alive.
Turns out he's still doing the American Revolution podcast.
Turns out his name is Michael Troy, and he's my guest right now.
Michael Troy, welcome to the program.
Well, thanks for having me.
Listen, I do not know where to begin.
You're, in writing my book on the Revolution,
I wanted my book, in a sense, to be encyclopedic,
to tell everything there is about the Revolution.
But it turns out you cannot do that in a book.
You cannot do that in a single volume on the American Revolution.
So I had to leave a lot out.
My book's still like 600 pages long.
but when I discovered your podcast, I realized this is what you have done.
You, in your podcast, the American Revolution podcast, you have it all in there.
And it's almost unbelievable to me that you have done so much work.
It's just such high, very high quality telling the stories.
So I really just wanted to start by asking you, how in the world did you begin to do this?
How did this start for you?
What were you doing with your life before you started doing this podcast?
I don't know, nine years ago or whatever.
What is your story, Michael Troy?
Well, even before I started the podcast, I've been obsessed with American history my entire
life.
I was a young child during the bicentennial.
I guess I got my kick beginnings then.
So I've just always wanted to know more about American history.
And about 10 years ago or more, maybe I really wanted to do a deep dive into the American Revolution.
I knew a lot about it, but I wanted to know even more.
And I decided, well, when I begin this journey of doing more research, wouldn't be fun to share it with other people.
And starting a podcast seemed like a fun way to do that.
And how wrong you were, Michael Troy.
Okay, so what were you doing?
Your 60 people would enjoy it at some point, you know.
Yeah.
Yeah, you might as well put something out there, right?
Yeah.
You're doing all this work.
And then it turns out that lots of other people love it.
But let me ask you, what were you doing for your day job, you know, before you immersed yourself in doing this podcast?
What was life like for Michael Troy before the American Revolution podcast?
History has always been a hobby for me.
I really wanted to study history in college and didn't because I figured out never made money at that.
I worked as the CIO for a law firm for many years, just doing technology stuff.
So completely unrelated to this.
The ironic thing, though, is the law firm I worked for literally was across the street from Independence Hall.
So I walked past it every single day on my way to and from work.
Now, wait a minute.
Across the street from Independence Hall, you're not making that up.
So are you a Philly guy?
Did you grow up in Philly?
I grew up near Philly.
I grew up in Wilmington, Delaware, which is, you know, less than an hour away.
So, but yeah, I, you know, always came to Philly for my field trips and everything.
And as I said, I worked in Philly for almost 30 years.
Do you know where Caesar Rodney is buried?
Where he's buried, no.
Neither do I.
I just thought, you know, you might because you're from Delaware.
He was from Delaware.
Am I that mixed up now that I'm getting him mixed up with somebody else?
I just like to find his statue.
They took away Caesar Rodney's statue from Rodney Square in Wilmington during the COVID era when they were tearing down everybody's statues.
Are you kidding me?
Are you kidding me?
They tore down Caesar Rodney's statue?
Well, they didn't tear it down.
The government clitted away for safekeeping and it just hasn't come up.
Yeah, same thing.
Same thing.
Yeah.
Same thing.
Like, oh, no, no, no, no.
You don't have to behead him.
We'll do it for you.
We'll do it for you.
Well, gosh, so you grew up in that neck of the woods.
And then so you're a lawyer across from Independence Hall.
So you're making a living working for a law firm.
And what was it that made you make this leap in, what was it, 2017, to start this podcast?
Yeah.
And it really just started as a hobby.
I kept my day job and just did.
this on the side. I actually had been begun research in this probably in 2015, and I was just
reading and writing a lot of draft episodes, I guess, so that when I actually started publishing
in 2017, and I had 100 episodes already done, or at least written, not recorded, but written.
You're one of those methodical characters. I hate you. No, that is so... I didn't trust myself to
stick with it. So I figured, all right, if I can write this many, I'm clearly committed. I can actually
put it out there. Well, that's part of what impresses me about what you've accomplished. Because I wasn't
kidding when I said, you know, when I wanted to write, you know, I'm a popular populist writer. I'm not a
scholar, but, you know, obviously like you, I want to, you know, keep my eye on the scholarly
consensus and be scholarly, but I want to tell the stories. And, and I wanted in my book, as I said,
to be sort of encyclopedic, you know, to tell everything.
And then when you dive in, you realize, oh, my gosh, it is infinite.
It is absolutely infinite.
There's no way I can do that.
On some level, that's what you've been doing with the podcast, is that you touch on
everything.
And what also amazes me is how you don't, it's not just kind of like a rambling,
you know, conversation like I'm having with you right now.
It's very methodical.
And so you write this out.
And it's a great,
it's a great feat of scholarship and writing.
As a writer, I want to say to you,
it's just an extraordinary thing that you,
extraordinary accomplishment,
really extraordinary, genuinely, extraordinary accomplishment,
what you've done.
And you go into such depth,
but you manage to keep it fun and light.
And there are many times when I could just hear you,
your tone of voice, it becomes hard not to laugh.
And I wish I'd written some of those down,
but you're making certain observations.
And there's a riness that creeps into your tone,
that you can't hide that.
I mean, you must know what I'm talking about.
Yeah, I mean, I try to tell it every episode
to be its own interesting story,
that something fun happens,
something interesting happens,
something important happens, whatever it is.
But, yeah, it's telling a story.
I try to avoid the academic,
idea of, you know, everything has to lead to some broader thesis or some nonsense like that.
It's, these are interesting stories about real people and what they went through to create
the greatest country in the world.
The greatest country in the world. What kind of jingoistic, patriotic nonsense am I agreeing
with? Yeah. Well, it's kind of hard not to feel that it's the greatest country in the world
when you do the research and when you, when you just look at it, when you do the math, basically.
Um, and, but people need to know the details, which is why, uh, you know, I'm excited about introducing them to your, to your podcast. Um, there are so many things I want to ask you. One of the things was, um, your opinion of Horatio Gates is my opinion of Horatio Gates. And it was very gratifying, uh, to hear you, uh, for, for folks, uh, who weren't tracking, um,
You know, folks, Horatio Gates really believed he should have George Washington's job.
So did Charles Lee.
But he was kind of gunning for Washington's job, basically, undermining Washington.
And it's always hard to, when I was doing the research to ask the question, is it just me?
Or was this really going on or whatever?
And you clarified that for me.
So maybe you could say a few words about Horatio Gates.
We're going to go to a break in a half minute.
But just start talking about Horatio Gates.
And when we come back, we'll keep going.
Yeah, Horatio Gates had been a British regular officer before the war.
And he'd retired and settled in Virginia.
And I think what you see in a lot of British officers is they always try to badmouth their superiors in a very kind and respectful way.
But basically they're saying, I don't think my boss is really up to that.
the up to snuff and if he gave me a shout at it I'd do a much better job and he tried to do the
same thing in in the continental army when he was appointed a brigadier general he sure did he
sure did when we come back uh folks uh my guest is michael troy he's the host of the american
revolution podcast uh it's a an infinitely uh interesting and exciting subject we'll be right back
folks before we go i want to recommend to you uh in case you want to do
something crazy and beautiful. We are doing another campaign with our friends at CSI. These folks are
heroes. If you want to free a slave, literally, this is what CSI does. Every $250 sets one captive
free and puts them into a life of freedom, sets them up. This is important. Help us do this.
Go to ericmetaxis.com. Click on the banner. Couldn't be easier. Please go to ericmetaxis.com.
click on the banner. Very important.
Welcome back talking to Michael Troy, who's the host of the American Revolution podcast, highly recommended folks.
And so Michael, we were talking about Horatio Gates.
And so you, I was just listening to one of the episodes of your podcast recently where you said, because I've listened to it not in chronological order.
I'm just kind of bouncing around.
and you um but your opinion of horatio gates is not so great and i have to say i'm with you on that
he um so he clearly wants washington's job and the way i react is i love washington so much
and i just i'm loyal to my friends so i just feel like anybody that is you know
wanting the head of washington it's like that's that's not my
friend. But the more I do the research, and then as I've listened to you, I realize I'm not crazy.
Gates was, I don't know, I don't see him as really an American hero.
We have to remember, too, we are looking at George Washington in hindsight with all the great
benefits that he did. If you look at him in 1775, I'm not sure I would have chosen him to be
commander in chief. He had no real military experience beyond regimental levels, and even that was
pretty minimal, that he had managed to start the French and Indian War.
So he had some real limitations. Now, obviously, he turned out to be an amazing man. I would consider him
indispensable to the revolution. But nobody really knew how important he would be and that his
great qualities would turn out when they appointed him in 1775. Horatio Gates had been,
as I said, he was a regular officer in the British Army, so he had lots of great experience.
Charles Lee had even more. And they thought, we know how to run an army. This country bumpkin
from Virginia really doesn't. And the reason Congress went with Washington over these more experienced
men was primarily that, well, do we really want to appoint a British regular officer as commander
in a war with the British regular army? It just didn't quite make sense to them. So both men,
Charles Lee and Horatio Gates did a lot of things to try to undercut.
George Washington and point out that he just wasn't going to turn out to be up to snuff and
up to this job, and that at some point Congress would realize that and replace them with one of them.
And Horatio, Charles Lee ended up becoming a prisoner of war early on, so he took himself out of the running.
But Horatio Gates very much was pushing for that.
And you see that as early as Washington's crossing when he famously crossed the Delaware and attacked Trenton.
Horatio Gates was with Washington at the time.
and Washington asked him to be a commander, one of the commanders in the force going.
And Horatigay said, no, I don't, I'm sick.
I don't feel up to it.
I'm going to go back to Philadelphia.
Instead, he got on his horse and rode all the way down to Baltimore where Congress was meeting at the time to start badmouting Washington,
expecting Washington would be captured and that he would then be in a position to take command of the Continental Army.
And, of course, he gets worse.
That's not so interesting.
He was like banking, they were banking.
He and Charles Lee were just, it's just.
a matter time before the loser, Washington is shown to be the loser that we all know he is.
And I'm just going to kind of hang around. And I don't want to get my hands dirty being involved
with him. I don't want any association with him. So I'm also fascinated with the way Charles Lee
is dragging his rear end as slowly as possible south through the jerseys, not wanting
to help Washington. And of course, infamously gets
captured in Basking Ridge in the tavern.
But it's just a crazy thing to me.
One of the things that I learned, which I was amazed by, I mean, besides what we've been
discussing is their stories in the end, both of them, Charles Lee and Horatio Gates,
get come up and says that you just feel like this is made up.
This surely, you know, history isn't this.
black and white, but both of them are effectively humiliated at the end of their lives and shown
to be somehow deficient, at least compared to Washington.
Yeah, Charles Lee ends up being drummed out of the army after Monmouth. He comes back from
being a prisoner of war. He's put in command at Monmouth and tries to retreat when Washington
wants to move forward, and that's kind of the end of his career. Horatio Gates sticks it out
to the very end, causing trouble for Washington all along after he, quote, wins Saratoga, which
I say, you know, he was basically put in command after Philip Schuyler and others had really
set up the Army for victory there. He becomes the hero and tries to parlay that into taking over
from Washington. We have the Conway Cabal, which involves Horatio Gates essentially trying to
take over the Army from Washington. And then even at the very end of the war, Horatio Gates is
up in New York, where the Americans, the American Army is getting ready to retire. And Horatio Gates,
is the one who's leading the charge of we should go down and march on Congress and take over,
have the army take over the government, and Washington has to stop that.
Yeah, excuse me, we're going to another break. We'll be right back with Michael Troy.
Folks, this is important. If Medicare has you confused, if you've got questions,
we understand, and this is why we recommend our friends at Chapter, they're there to help you,
to kind of talk you through what might work best for you. This is very important.
that you get it right. You can call them at 571, 421, 12, 5,3. These are our friends at chapter
571, 421, 1253. Welcome back talking to Michael Troy, host of the American Revolution
podcast. So, Michael, you're, you know, you're telling me what I've already heard you talk about
on your podcasts with regard to Charles Lee and Horatio Gates.
But it's just a fascinating thing.
And I think that's one of the fascinating things
about the story of the American Revolution
is that these are human beings.
And so we want to say, you know, all these guys are heroes.
But I really, in the end, have a good amount of scorn for Gates and Lee,
particularly because of the way they treated Washington
or the way they handle things.
And the story of Lee, I mean, maybe we should stick with the Battle of Camden.
Can you say a little bit about the Battle of Camden for my audience?
Because I just found this so amazing.
Sure.
Camden, South Carolina was a British outpost after the British had captured South Carolina in the Battle of Charleston.
A huge American army, the largest army captured during the war, was captured when the British took Charleston.
under General Benjamin Lincoln.
And so Congress sends Horatio Gates, the hero of Saratoga.
He's going to go down and become the hero of the suppelin campaign.
And Gates just kind of grabs the army and just runs pell-mell into battle at Camden,
runs into Cornwallis's forces there.
And he's a horrible battlefield commander.
He does not command from the front.
He stands several miles back and kind of sends riders up.
with orders and the whole thing becomes a mess, the militia retreat, several prominent American
officers, Continental officers are murdered, killed in the battle because of the incompetence.
And Gates's first instinct is to jump on a horse and ride hundreds of miles in a few days
so he can get back to Congress and explain his side of the story rather than worry about
the army he left in a field to be killed or captured.
I mean, it's almost unbelievable.
When I, you know, as I'm writing this, I'm forming my opinions of Horatio Gates and Charles Lee.
And the evidence comes out more and more and more that, you know, these are not American heroes.
And that story, it seems, you know, it's kind of like some of the story of Charles Lee.
It seems almost unbelievable.
I mean, that he presides over what many called the worst loss in the entire war, the Battle of Kandon.
I mean, it's just a route, horrendous, horrifying.
And as if that's not enough, he then blasts out of there like some cartoon figure,
like at a speed that he, you know, and I was actually trying to make sense of it,
you know, reading different accounts and thinking, am I missing something?
How is it that Horatio Gates blasts out of there at this speed?
What was he thinking?
And I have never really been able to come up with what is his excuse for fleeing the battle for leaving his army behind.
And he's mocked by Alexander Hamilton and others who are around Washington, who I guess in a sense, when they hear this news, they're like, could have told you, like, that's Horatio Gates.
But it almost seems like it was a touch of madness or something like that.
I think it was more spin.
I think he wanted to get back to Congress and give his spin on what happened before they heard about it from someone else.
That is interesting.
So this is not the first time that Michael Troy has given me sort of the answer that I'm searching.
I didn't know if it existed.
But yeah, so he, boy, he blasts out of there.
And it takes three days later, he's about 170 miles away.
And he writes Congress.
He finally sits down to let Congress know.
what he thinks they should know.
But it's embarrassing.
It makes me on some level feel sorry for him.
To be fair to Gates,
he was actually a competent logistical officer.
And if he had done that,
rather than become a battlefield commander,
he probably would have had a good career.
I think he got a little ahead of him,
what his levels of competency were.
But yeah,
the biggest problem was he was committed
to advancing his own career
more so than committed to winning the war.
on behalf of the American people.
Yeah, that's not good, Michael.
Nope.
That's not a good thing.
And I guess that...
The most is that if you're not committed to advancing your own career, you tend to do better.
People like Hamilton or Washington himself, you know, that we're more focused on winning
the war and not advancing their own interests ended up being the American heroes that we
revered today.
Well, there's a big life lesson in that, isn't there?
I mean, it's the warp and woof of what we call reality,
that if you're trying to promote yourself,
you probably won't do well.
If you're actually caring about something larger than yourself,
turns out you may well get promoted.
I'm talking to Michael Troy.
I highly recommend his American Revolution podcast.
We'll be right back.
Folks, do not forget, if you have questions about gold or silver,
we recommend, highly recommend,
Genesis gold.
They'll answer your questions.
We trust them. We believe in them.
And you can find them at metaxis gold IRA.com.
Metaxusgoldir.com.
Welcome back.
I'm talking to Michael Troy.
He's the host of the American Revolution podcast, which is just a gift to history
lovers, lovers of America.
How many episodes, Michael, do you have of the American Revolution podcast by now?
In terms of regular episodes, I think we're coming up on 400, if you include all the special interview episodes, and I've been releasing 250th episodes, basically, what happened 250 years ago this week, were well over 500.
Yeah, that's just a lot.
And you, there, one of the things that I wanted to ask you about, when you were talking about Thomas Payne, obviously the great writer of common sense and the American crisis, you say something in your episode about Thomas Payne that I hadn't heard anywhere else.
he is over and over and over again described as the son of a corset maker or somebody who makes stays for corsets.
And so people can picture whalebone stay in a corset, which are fashionable those days.
And that's repeated over and over and over again.
You say that in fact, no, he was the maker of stays that were used in naval vessels or in ships,
stays to, you know, to stay the master or whatever.
Did you, is that the case?
Because I got confused.
You were the only one.
I went with your version just because I decided that I trusted you and your research.
But I'm always amazed by things like this, how they kind of get out there and they go on and on and on.
And maybe it's not true.
So when we're talking about stays in the case of Thomas Payne, did you ever, did you ever figure
that out for sure?
I wouldn't be willing to say 100%.
I did read that and it made sense to me.
He's only referred to as a staymaker and the common reference to stays in the 18th century
as opposed to the 19th century was the reference to shipbuilding.
So I think that that was the case.
Wellbone corsets were not a big thing in the 1760s, which is what we'll talk about when he
was growing up.
So well, that's, I mean, it's, it's so interesting to me that, you know, in writing my book,
in writing all of my books, I, I always want to get the facts right. And I'm sometimes fascinated
by how something gets out there and it's just repeated and repeated and repeated. And you go,
hey, wait a minute. That's either not true or at least we should say we don't know. And so yours is
the first example of saying, I think that it was.
wasn't the stays for corsets. I think it was the stays for for sailing vessels. So I put that in
my book. And if it's wrong, ladies and gentlemen, you can blame Michael Troy, my guess.
And I have read that in a couple of other sorts. And it's not just an idea I came up with.
I did read that from other people who researched the matter. So it is, it is the minority
view, but I think it's the right one. Yeah, no, no, I'm teasing you. I think you're right.
And I was just, but I just thought this is such an, it's one of those interesting. It's one of those
interesting things because I've written other historical books, one on Martin Luther, the great
Reformation figure. And there are things that get out there that get repeated over and over and over and
over and over. And when I did my research, I thought, wait a minute, no, no, no, that's just wrong.
And that's just lazy. People are just repeating something. So kudos to you, you know,
for the work that you do. I can't really imagine how much, how much, how much,
research, a lifetime of research, it goes into what you're doing.
I wanted to go back to Charles Lee.
I was, we were saying earlier that, you know, these are the two figures that were in many
ways more qualified than Washington and pretty much bitter that they didn't have his job
and assuming that eventually Congress would come, you know, to see that they were the guy.
and a book came out, I don't know if it was a year ago or two years ago,
which pretty plausibly makes the case.
I had already had a gut sense that Charles Lee flat out committed treason
during his time in British captivity.
I don't know if you can talk a little bit about the story of Charles Lee.
Yeah, I discussed that a bit in my podcast too.
Charles Lee was captured shortly after the American retreat from New York in 1776.
he became a prisoner of war and the people who captured him were pretty much implying that he was going to be charged with treason because he was a British officer who had gone to war against Britain.
Lee knew a great many of the British officers who were his captors and he tried to ingratiate himself with them by giving them a lot of information and even suggesting a plan of a time.
attack against the Americans so that they could end this war quickly. And it seemed like he was
making an effort to ingratiate himself to avoid charges of prison and wiggle out of his
situation. This information never became publicly known until decades after the war it ended.
If it had, the Americans probably would have considered him a traitor and would have hanged him
if they got their hands on him.
Well, yeah, the information came out.
I think there were some documents
in the New York Historical Society
that were discovered in the middle of the 19th century.
And they thought, holy cow, what do we have here?
This is Horatio, sorry, this is Charles Lee's handwriting.
And it's a document from when he was in British captivity,
his laying out how he thought the British could defeat Washington,
and the American. So it's a scandalous thing. But up until fairly recently, there were still a
number of scholars who were opened the idea that he, or at least suggesting that he probably was
trying to mislead the British. But I think in the most recent book, and forgive me for not
remembering the name of the book or the author, but it's in my own bibliography, but that, in fact,
no, that's not the case. There's other evidence that Charles Lee genuinely had done.
gone over to the British side and was committing treason long before Benedict Arnold would get the
chance.
Yeah, he, well, he didn't go whole hog and say he wanted to rejoin the British Army or anything.
I think he was just trying to ingratiate himself, would wiggle out.
The papers you're talking about remained in General Howe's personal papers after he died.
General Howe, of course, was the commander-in-chief of British forces in North America at the time.
Wow, I did not know that.
Amazing. I guess that's why I have you on here because you know this stuff. It's just,
but it's so fascinating. And it just underscores what I was saying earlier, how the landscape
is infinite. I mean, it's kind of fascinating to me that, you know, whatever direction you want to go
and it just gets deeper and deeper. But Charles Lee, he's a very curious figure, a strange figure
in a way.
I'm trying to think who it was.
Some historian
not so long ago
said that Charles Lee
had a sex life
of the transient variety
or something like that,
which I guess is a very oblique way
of saying he visited prostitutes.
And in my research
on when he was captured
in Basking Ridge,
it seems very plausible
that he was in
of female companionship at this tavern?
It wouldn't surprise me.
That was common among most British officers,
which he had been one until very recently.
He was kind of an ugly guy.
He had a character that he did not get along well with people.
He tended to be very heavily critical of people and always attacking them.
I think he was more friends with the pack of dogs that followed him around everywhere
than he was with other human beings.
So, yeah, he was kind of an odd duck.
Yeah.
Kind of an odd duck.
He had experience as a general in Europe.
He wasn't actually commissioned as a general in the British Army,
but he had served and done work as a general in European wars before the war.
So he was a well-experienced officer.
I find it, again, there are things that,
a number of things that in my research, I thought you cannot make
this up. The fact that he is dragging his feet, you know, as Washington is begging him in letters,
very deferentially begging him, asking him, never commanding him, but strongly suggesting as commander
chief, hey, we need your help. Can you come, can you, can you, can you please come south? Can you
please? And he just drags and drags and drags. And it seems like he's waiting for Washington just to be
defeated and to go away and he doesn't want any part of it.
But the fact that he is in this tavern sitting there at 10 a.m.
In his dressing gown, writing a note to Horatio Gates bitterly criticizing Washington.
And that while he is in the process of writing this letter, he's captured.
I mean, it's like if you put that in a movie, people would be like, well, that's kind of, you know, that couldn't really happen.
But I guess it did.
Yeah.
Just for your listeners, this was right after the British had chased the Americans out of New York.
Charles Lee had taken an army up to the north into upstate New York while George Washington was retreating across New Jersey toward Philadelphia.
Washington absolutely needed Lee to come down with the reinforcement so they could put up a defense.
Lee very clearly seemed to be thinking
Washington's got himself into a mess
he's going to get captured at some point
and when he gets captured I get to become
the commander of the army
and in fact it worked out the other way around
he got captured and Washington got away
we'll be right back talking to Michael Troy
the American Revolution podcast
I don't like alarmism
I don't like fear mongering
I especially don't like people who profit from panic
But I do believe in telling the truth, especially when the markets are reminding us how fragile things are.
Over the last few weeks, we've all watched the volatility, stock swinging, confidence shaking, longestanding assumptions, suddenly looking less solid.
Many economists are calling this moment the everything bubble, where nearly every asset class has been inflated at the same time by years of cheap money and reckless global policy.
This isn't political.
It's not partisan.
it's math.
And when confidence erodes, history shows us what tends to happen next.
That's why I've taken time to educate myself on one of the oldest ways people have protected wealth during uncertainty.
Physical gold and silver.
I've partnered with Genesis Gold Group, a faith-based, values-driven company offering clear information, no hype, no pressure.
They've put together a free financial survival report explaining what's happening why multiple markets can fall.
together and what prudent steps families can consider now.
I encourage you to read it and decide for yourself.
Please go to metaxis gold IRA.com.
That's metaxis gold IRA.com.
You don't need to panic, but you do need to be informed in times like these.
Wisdom matters more than optimism.
Welcome back.
I'm talking to Michael Troy.
He's the host of the American Revolution podcast, highly recommended.
Michael, you have to be excited that this is, you know, you mentioned being a kid as I was during the bicentennial.
And it is exciting that this is the 250th.
I have been calling it the supercentennial.
And in a freakish moment with President Trump, I mentioned it to him.
And he decided to announce, yes, we should call it the supercentennial.
And I don't know if anything's been done about that, but he really earnest.
was talking to his staff saying,
we've got to make this change called the Supercentennial.
But part of the reason I think it should be called the Supercentennial
is like it's such a happy moment to be celebrating our 250th
that we need to be able to say this is our supercentennial year
as opposed to semi-Quincennial,
which is not as exciting.
But that's my long way of asking,
do you have any special plans for the 250th?
Or where are you going to be on July 4th?
this year. Yeah, I've always called it the Cester Centennial, which I thought was the name that was
supposed to be given to it, but I'm pretty much the only person in the world who does that.
I plan to be in Philadelphia on July 4th, so celebrating with everybody else.
Well, yeah, what is going to be happening in Philadelphia on July 4th? I can't imagine. I mean,
I can imagine lots of stuff, but what's happening at Independence Hall? My goodness. Yeah, I don't even know
yet they've been very
the organization
for a lot of this stuff just seems to be
a bit
you know people don't really make it a priority
and they're kind of just thinking something
will happen so
I'm kind of waiting to see with everyone else
interesting
well
I'm not I'm not sure
where we're going to be but
it is
it's a big deal
and I think
part of what makes me
happy about it is that it just forces everybody to think about American history. And I've,
I've always felt that, you know, we should be celebrating American history. And in, in recent
decades, I don't get the impression that the culture is nearly as aware of our history as we would
have been. I mean, I keep saying if you went around, you know, with a microphone on Main Street
America in 1960 and ask people, you know, do you know who, you know, the sons of liberty were? Have you
heard of James Otis Jr.
And there were films about this.
I mean, there was, Disney was talking about this.
Everybody knew all of these figures.
But it seems like that's become less and less the case.
So this year seems to me a great opportunity to get people interested in our history.
Yeah, I agree.
And I hope people will take the opportunity to learn a lot more about it because it is our founding
story.
And I think one of the, one of the gifts that the founders gave us was the fact that we can take for
granted a lot of, or we do take for granted a lot of things like having a democratic government
and we're not ruled by, you know, a king that we, you know, we built a republic. And that was something
that was unheard of in 1776. And the fact that we were able to do that and spread that
to much of the world is the means that many people today just take for granted that we will
have a government that is of the people, by the people and for the people. And that was just not
the case back then.
well i mean you're you're singing my song or i'm singing your song because i really think that that's um i i wrote a book
about 10 years ago called if you can keep it where i i really was thinking we have ceased to appreciate
the wildness of this idea uh that we had in 1776 that we might create a country where the
people ruled themselves i mean it's just uh it's just something that we kind of yawn at today and we should
not because it is, of course, very fragile.
It can go away very quickly and we need to understand it.
You said before that you'd always been interested in American history.
Was there something that happened as a kid or was it just what was it?
I think the bicentennial really sparked my interest in the revolution just because it was a time when, you know, all the schools were focused on teaching it and every, you know, it was in the news.
It was on TV.
I grew up, as I said, at Delaware.
I went to school.
I could literally see the Brandywine Creek
from the window of my school.
So I was kind of steeped in it
from the very beginning.
And it was all around me
and I just wanted to learn more about it.
You could see the Brandy Wine Creek.
That's pretty cool.
Not a lot of kids in school can say that.
Really, that's amazing.
That's absolutely amazing.
Do you have favorite authors on The Revolution?
There's a lot of good ones out there.
One of the ones that I really enjoyed early on was Nathaniel Philbrick's Bunker Hill.
But, yeah.
Actually, we're going to go to another break.
I'm going to be interviewing Nathaniel Philbrick in a few weeks.
Folks, we'll be right back talking to Michael Troy, American Revolution Podcast.
Hey there, folks. I've been saying that 2026 must be the year of accountability. Whether talking about
government spending or the way we steward our own families, we have a moral duty to seek the truth.
But let's be honest, in the world of Medicare, truth is often the first casualty. Seniors, like my 91-year-old mom,
are bombarded with mailers and pushy phone calls that feel more like propaganda than helpful guidance.
This is why I value my partners at Chapter.
They operate on a different principle, independence.
Chapter is the only national advisor that reviews every single plan available to ensure you have the coverage that actually fits your needs.
They've helped people find clarity and on average have historically helped members save an average of $1,100 a year on health care costs.
Their support is completely free and takes under 20 minutes.
If you have questions about your Medicare or want to ensure you're a good job,
steward of your resources, please call chapter at 571, 421, 1,253.
That's chapter at 571, 421, 1253.
Talk to a real person and get the honest answers you deserve.
Welcome back, folks.
I'm talking to Michael Troy, Michael J. Troy, who's the host of the American Revolution
podcasts.
And Michael, you were just saying on the break that you just want to encourage people as
part of what you do to learn about American history?
Yeah, I mean, really learn the basic story.
One of the problems, I guess, with Academia, is, you know, they learned the basic story years ago,
and they go on to more obscure and less important things.
And I think reiterating the original story, the reason why this thing is so important at its core,
is something that every generation needs to relearn.
And this is a great time to do that, especially with the 250.
you well i mean it is funny you say that because we haven't talked before today and that's exactly
why i wrote my book because i thought you know i'm not an academic um and academics tend to focus
to to home in on one thing or some angle of something and it's almost like they they feel like
it's beneath them to kind of to tell the whole story because oh everybody knows the whole story but
everybody doesn't know the whole story, which is why I felt I wanted to write my book and why I'm
thrilled to introduce folks to the American Revolution podcast, because these are great stories,
interesting stories, and when you know the stories, you can't really be lied to. You know,
we're all kind of responsible for this information as Americans, and that's one of the things
that you do so well is that you tell stories. And some of them are very funny.
They're interesting.
I was actually most fascinated by what John Adams calls the revolution before the revolution.
All the stuff that leads up to Lexington and Concord.
It doesn't just suddenly happen.
And how in many ways it really wasn't about the money.
It was about these principles and how you have these amazing men, mostly in Boston,
who, I mean, if it weren't for Samuel Adams,
James Otis Jr., John Adams, Paul Revere,
Joseph Warren, oh my goodness, Joseph Warren,
there would have definitely been no revolution,
and so we need to know who these heroes are.
This episode is brought to you by Defender.
With its 626 horsepower twin-turbo V8 engine,
the Defender Octa is taking on the Dakar rally,
the ultimate off-road challenge.
Learn more.
at landrover.ca.
Yeah, and it's just not the leaders who we remember.
I mean, the entire people of New England.
I think Britain's biggest mistake in this whole thing
was assuming that the New England colonists
were just like Englishmen in England.
And they had spent centuries
developing their own idea of political discourse
and freedom and self-government
through their town meetings and things like that.
And they had gotten,
comfortable with the idea that they would not be ruled by somebody far away who really didn't
have their interests at heart. And they were willing to pick up guns and fight against that.
And that's something I think the British never appreciated, especially at the beginning.
They thought, oh, these are a few bad apples who are leading the people astray.
And we go in and go a show of force and end this whole thing. And it was no.
Every single person was committed to these ideas and willing to fight for them.
I kept noticing how Washington especially really did believe that Providence Capital P was with us in the war,
that there were so many strange things that could have broken another way.
Did you get a sense of that?
Or what is your sense of that?
Because it felt to me unavoidable, the conclusion.
I mean, there are certain moments where you just have to shake your head and say,
this just can't be a coincidence.
Like when the American Army was retreating across the East River and, you know, this fog bank just rolled in at the last minute and hid their retreat.
Otherwise, they would have been captured and slaughtered.
And other incidents like that, you know, the freak snowstorm that happened when Washington was attacking Trenton.
Yeah, there are moments where you just think, this is so crazy that if it appeared in a fictional movie, I wouldn't buy it.
Yeah, I mean, it is fascinating in a way because you see over and over that they could have lost, but they didn't.
There's so much more I want to talk with you about, but I just, I really want to underscore to my audience how grateful I am for your podcast and how I just don't think there's anything like it.
And you're very humble, but I think, you know, you must have some sense of, of, of, of,
what it is that you've accomplished.
This is like a pyramid of,
uh,
uh,
it just is,
it's,
it's huge.
Uh,
and how many words do you think,
uh,
over time?
I mean,
each episode is,
is how many words roughly?
About 3,000.
All right.
3,000 times 500,
500.
It's,
uh,
it's a lot.
It's a lot.
It's just a great accomplishment,
uh,
Michael.
We're,
we're out of time,
but I'm just,
uh,
really excited.
to have met you.
I look forward, hopefully, to meeting you in person at some point since you know not so far away.
But folks, you've got to check out MREVpodcast.com, AmREVP Podcast.com.
Highly recommended. Michael Troy, thank you.
Thanks for having me.
