The Eric Metaxas Show - Colin Nicholl - The Nativity Star

Episode Date: December 24, 2022

Ever wondered whether the Star of Bethlehem was real? Eric takes us back to Merry Ole England for his enlightening conversation with biblical scholar Colin Nicholl. (Encore Presentation)  

Folks, welcome to the Eric Mataxis show, sponsored by Legacy Precious Metaxys show. There's never been a better time to invest in precious metals. Visit legacy pm investments.com. That's LegacyPMinvestments.com. Eric Mataxis show with your host, Eric Metaxus. This is the Eric Mataxis show. I'm Eric Mataxis. I hope you're enjoying your Labor Day weekend, what's left of it. Some of you know that earlier this summer, I went to Oxford, England, to record a a series of conversations for something we call Socrates in the city. One of the most extraordinary conversations of the group.

If you've ever wondered, is the star of Bethlehem in the Bible real? Dr. Colin Nicol has solved the problem. Right now, this is my conversation in Oxford, England, with Dr. Colin Nicol about his book, The Great Christ Comet. What we have today is, without a doubt, extra special. It is sort of, it's news, I guess. I don't know that we've done anything before that's news. It may be news to the folks watching it, may have not heard of it before,

but this is actual news. This is a big deal in the world of biblical studies, in the world of historical studies. This is a big deal. and I have the privilege of interviewing in a few moments the author of a new book, The Great Christ Comet. I think Dr. Nicol, the author pronounces it, great Christ Comet. But wherever you're from, it's really great.

And I had the joy of reading this book, and it is so exciting. So I hope we can give you a soupsome, something, a taste of what this is. I hope you'll read the book yourself. But to give you a background of what we're talking about, first of all, Dr. Nickel claims, and I think proves, that's what makes this so big,

to have discovered what is the thing that we call the Star of Bethlehem? Just big stuff here. So, in any case, so he's the author of this book, which will be just out now. The Great Christ Comet released officially September 30th, 2015. The Great Christ Comet revealing the true star of Bethlehem. Previously, he's written from Hope to Despair in Thessalonica. Sounds like an independent film.

Previously, a teacher at the University of Cambridge, by the way, he got his PhD at the other place. And he is the professor, he was professor. He was professor of New Testament at Gordon Conwell Theological Seminary in my neck of the woods, New England. He has devoted himself, to say the least, to biblical research. His articles have appeared in publications such as the Journal of Theological Studies and the Times of London. Ladies and gentlemen, please give a warm Socrates in the city. Oxford edition, welcome to my guest for this eighth and final session here. Dr. Colin R. Nicol.

Dr. Nicol, welcome to the stage, to this forum. So glad to have you here. Have a seat. Oh, look at this. You weren't excited enough. The first copy of the book, there it is. You have got to be excited. Well, it is, it's the culmination of four and a half years of a lot of work.

Essentially, I'm a biblical scholar, so it was really a journey, a long journey, into astronomy, and little by little bit conquering more and more and eventually, slowly but surely in stages coming up with it, and many eureka moments along the way. So it really is, it's exciting, it's kind of nerve-wracking too, presenting the findings to the world. The great John Lennox,

Professor of Mathematics here at Oxford, has written an outstanding book quite breathtaking, the range of its scholarship, a real tour de force. J.P. Morland, distinguished professor of philosophy at Biola, has called it a stunning book, now the definitive treatment of the subject. I think you can relax. This is exciting. It's huge.

So before we get into the details, let's go back to the beginning. First of all, your story, where did you grow up? Well, I grew up on the north coast of Northern Ireland. A little town called Coal Rain, not far from the Giants Causeway. Dunlust Castle, which was a place that C.S. Lewis liked to go. So a beautiful Causeway coast, one of the most gorgeous parts of the world, really. The famous causeway of Finn McCool. You know your stuff?

If only they could find the bones of Finn McCool, that would be something for a book. You didn't know? No. They have his skull in some castle someplace. Well, okay, so you grew up there. What was your upbringing like, and when did you think you would be interested in the life of a scholar and a biblical scholar? Well, I grew up in the troubles, really. The troubles were only getting going when I was born.

It was a strange time in Northern Ireland. There was a lot of kind of animosity between the different sides, although where I lived, it was relatively mild. I did, in my hometown, my dentist, his building was destroyed by the IRA, and I remember him showing me his Bible that had come through the bomb. The police used to check outside the cars during church time to make sure no one was planting a bomb. There was a little bit of kind of insecurity. And some, you know, you were driving down the road and you'd see the military, the English soldiers and Scottish soldiers with their,

with their guns pointing out the back right at you when you're in the car behind, things like that that you don't forget. And Northern Ireland was an interesting place to grow up in that respect. But, you know, I was relatively sheltered from that. And I grew up in a Christian home, was always from the earliest age. I loved the Bible. Even I remember getting my first biblical book when I was seven or eight years old. I love theology.

I mostly loved studying the Bible. And really... So your parents were serious about their faith? Yes. So they weren't just nominal Christians. They were quite serious. Yes, and they always encouraged me to do whatever I wanted to do in terms of, in my case, study in the Bible.

So really from an early age, when I was about 13 or 14, I felt a very strong desire and call into devoting myself to Christian work and ultimately my passion of studying. in the Bible. It's, you know, it's an extraordinary and a rare thing for someone that young to be excited about studying the Bible. You realized that? Well, or did you have a little gang who specialized in exegesis? You'd go back behind the supermarket where nobody could see you and do your secret exegesis until the cops came? No, I definitely was rare or unique, depending on your perspective. And that was something I did myself that, not many other people to where we're doing. But it was my hobby. I just, I even tried writing little

books and things like that when I was at age. So I always had a kind of desire and love for research and writing. Amazing. Okay. So what happens? Where did you go to school, to college? Well, I remember getting to that stage where they're talking, the school is talking about where you're going to go to university, what are you going to do? And they were encouraging me to go to, the school was encouraged me to go to me in British University, Cambridge or Oxford or somewhere like that. And I felt that I should go to the United States to have a different kind of experience, a more focused biblical education and somewhere where I could, especially,

more in the things I wanted to do because I was so sure that I wanted to be a biblical, to do biblical studies and to, in a sense, do ministry in that way, that was a very natural choice for me. So already at age 17 or 18, you were that focused on what you wanted to do. You've been listening to the Eric Mataxis show. More of My Socrates in the city, Oxford conversation with Dr. Colin Nicol coming up next. As hard as it may be for us to comprehend here in America. There are people in other parts of the world whose very lives are being threatened simply for believing in Jesus. In fact, people are being enslaved for their faith. Some have been in bondage for 25 or 30 years. If you've been listening for any period of time, you know I'm passionate about the

work of Christian Solidarity International, a ministry that sets these captives free. Just $250. Maybe you can give more. Maybe a portion. Every gift helps. Imagine buying a fellow believers freedom. call 888-253-3522. 888-253-3522. Christian Solidarity, providing lifesaving resources for persecuted Christians for almost 40 years. 888-253-3522 or Mataxis talk.com

and click on the Christian Solidarity banner. Give someone the gift of their freedom for Christmas. Thank you. Tell me why Relief Factor is so successful at lowering or eliminating pain. I'm often asked that question just the other night. I was asked that question. Well, the owners of Relief Factor, me, they believe our bodies were designed to heal. That's right, designed to heal, and I agree with them.

And the doctors who formulated relief factor for them selected the four best ingredients, yes, 100% drug-free ingredients, and each one of them helps your body deal with inflammation. Each of the four ingredients deals with inflammation from a different metabolic pathway. That's the point. So approaching from four different angles may be why so many people find such wonderful relief. If you've got back pain, shoulder, neck, hip, knee, or foot pain from exercise or just getting older, you should order the three-week quick start discounted to only 1995 to see if it'll work for you. It has worked for about 70% of the half a million people who've tried it and have ordered more. On one of them, go to Relieffactor.com or call 800 for relief to find out about this offer.

Feel the difference. In case you haven't been paying attention, the Biden administration has caused a financial crisis and they have no clue how to fix it. Oil prices have skyrocketed, and when oil prices go up, the cost of transportation and shipping spikes, leading the prices of goods to rise. And when we're already seeing record inflation, that's the last thing we need. Our economy is in trouble, and you need to take steps to protect yourself. If all your money is tied up in stocks, bonds, and traditional markets, you are vulnerable. Gold is one of the best ways to protect your retirement.

No matter what happens, you own your gold. It is real. It is physical. It's always been valuable since the dawn of time. Legacy precious metals is the company I trust for investing in gold. They can help you roll your retirement account into a gold-backed IRA where you still own the physical gold. They can also ship gold and precious metals safely and securely to your house. Call Legacy at 866-528-1903 or visit them online at Legacypminvestments.com.

You're listening to the Eric Mataxis show. This is a special presentation of my Socrates in this city. Oxford conversation with Dr. Colin Nicol about his book, The Great Christ Comet. And then you went to a Trinity Seminary also in Chicago. That's right, yeah. And then how long were you in the States? Two years at Trinity after four years. Did you go to Gordon Conwell immediately after that?

No. Where did you go after that? When I finished up at Trinity, I had a Master of Divinity. And then I went to St. Andrews with a view to doing a PhD there. the book of Revelation under Richard Bockem. A PhD in the Book of Revelation. That sounds like a joke, you know that. It's like, yeah, that dude's got a PhD in the book of Revelation, man.

Watch, watch out. You actually, so what happened? You go to St. Andrews. You don't get a PhD. You end up getting your PhD at Cambridge. Well, what happens, I went to, I went to St. Andrews. And then when I was, no sooner had arrived, and I really realized that my specialty initially shouldn't be the book of Revelation,

but the Apostle Paul. I felt that was a better course of action for me, in particular I wanted to study Paul's letters to the Thessalonians. Which you did? Which I eventually did. In Cambridge. In Cambridge, yeah. But we were living there for a long time,

and a lot of time I was kind of, you know, what's the point of us living here? Because it wasn't actually at St. Andrews, but yet we're living near St. Andrews in a lovely little fishing village called Anstrother, which was a great experience in many ways right in the 1th of 4th the 1th? We were in this the 1st the 4th

yeah it's a tongue twister there The 1st of 4th You got it Do I? The 1st of 4th okay Yeah the 1st of 4th so we're looking right across To Edinburgh in the distance And then you see

Anytime there were storms And there were quite a few Nor'Easters As they talked about They would whack the wall And then the spray would come up The 4 stories of the dwelling that we were in It was really amazing

and then the door to get into our apartment was on the side right by the Firth of Fourth. So when the spray would hit, you had about that 20 seconds to get into the door, get the door unlocked, and get it open. And if you fumbled in any way, even if you're wearing your suit, you were absolutely dementia.

And that happened to me on the first. The Fourth was a scary place. It would make you want to go to the pub for a fifth. Thank you very much. You've been a great audience. Good night. Okay, so, but let's leap ahead. So you know what you want to study. You study Paul here at Cambridge. You study Thessalonians here at Cambridge, and you come out with this book. I guess this book must be the book version of your PhD thesis.

Well, that's right. What ended up happening was the Scottish office, because I had lived in Scotland, ended up paying for my whole PhD. Uh-huh. And then when I was at Cambridge, I studied. under the Lady Margaret's professor there, who was a Pauline expert. And then from that ended up, my research topic was on one and two Thessalonians, or first and second Thessalonians, in particular looking at the situation undergirding the letters, and seeing, does the situation in one Thessalonians cannot be reconciled with the situation in two Thessalonians?

Because a lot of scholars were saying two Thessalonians wasn't by Paul, one Thessalonians was. and so this was a way of demonstrating that the two letters fit together and that there was a continuity and also, of course, opened up the rise to the situation of an early Greek Christian church. Since I don't know that anyone else here is a biblical scholar, what draws you in? In other words, is it that you're hunting for something? You feel like there's a puzzle or a code

or that you can discover something, that there are hidden things in the text, that there are things that have never... I mean, because, you know, it would seem to me that, oh, you know, everything that's been discovered roughly has been discovered. People have poured over these texts endlessly. How could there be anything that hasn't already been discovered? It doesn't seem to me that that's the case, as we talk...

No, it's not. A lot of people, strangely, do have that attitude. But I think it's a major mistake. much like a scientist sees all kinds of mysteries and things to explore. In my opinion, the biblical studies, is full of the same things. But that's the difference. In other words, science studying this world, you can see how this world would have the potential for infinite study, right? I mean, there's so much here that we don't know what's inside a quark or what you can go down, down, infinitely down, into things.

to the infinitesimal level, and then you can go out, and you can go, there is so much. But the biblical text, unless you believe that it was inspired by the God outside the universe, unless you believe that, you would think that it's fairly finite, you know, and like how much can be discovered in, you know, great expectations by Dickens. At some point, people have figured out this symbolizes this, that symbolizes that, In other words, talking about whether something has infinite possibilities or infinite depth gets to the very heart of what you believe about scripture. Well, I think you're right. It's a yes and no, in the sense of it's yes, because it's certainly in my experience, there's almost a test when you're reading scripture.

It's very easy to cop out in your exegesis to look at the text and say this doesn't see. to make sense on this level and then give up on it. And that's really what a lot of scholars will do at different points and say, you know, it doesn't make sense. I'm just going to say Paul contradicts himself or whatever at this point. And there is a sense in which if you have a high view of scripture, you hang in with it. It's a test of faith, really, at that point.

And so you push and you push and you search in the expectation that there is an answer, never forcing the data, of course, but always seeking to be honest and with this kind of pursuing an answer. So it does lead to a more rigorous approach to the biblical study. On the other hand, I think even for someone who didn't believe, I have a high view of scripture, there still is lots that hasn't been discovered, and I think many scholars would still be convinced that there's lots

in the New Testament, an Old Testament, to be discovered and to be mined. And a lot of times they come at that by adopting a particular literary approach or sociological law. I mean, again, that's like literary criticism, but what we're talking about here, at least what I want to talk about, is this idea that you've got a view of scripture that says this is not just a literary text, this is the word of God. And if that is true, it has infinite depth, and it is infinitely and eternally true. And that changes how you study it. In other words, you have a faith that I can push and dig in any direction and I'm not going to hit bedrock. I can I can just keep going and discovering

more and more and more. The riches are so to speak infinite. I'm sure not everybody approaches scripture that way and it seems to get to the idea behind what you've done here. In other words, what you have done in this new book, the Great Christ's comment, is that you have assumed that the star of Bethlehem existed and every description of it is true. and therefore must make some kind of sense. What sense does it make? No one has ever made sense of it before. 100%.

That's all of my scholarship is motivated by that. I am convinced that it does make sense. I'm willing to live with the tension of not understanding something, although I need to understand it. So it drives me crazy if I don't understand it. So, yeah, I won't stop until. I've got my mind around it and

part of that process is praying asking God to help me understand it so my faith does engage with my scholarship at that level and there are some things where you know you can study it for a long time

and just not get it because a lot of biblical exegesis is studying it reflecting it doing a historical study all that you do, but at the end of the day, it's those flashes of inspiration, which suddenly open up your mind,

and it's just like a whole new level becoming... I mean, but scientists say to say exact same thing, that they study a problem or a math problem for years, and suddenly, you know, you know what the carbon atom looks like, you know, if it comes to a flasher in a dream or something. I've never dreamt about carbon, I'm just saying. But what we have here, is a dramatic case of what we're talking about.

But before we get to that, in just a moment, now let's go back. So you do this work in Thessalonians at Cambridge. What comes next and what leads you to this subject? Well, what comes next? When I finished up at Cambridge, I taught there. I did some teaching in terms of Greek, which was a really fun experience. I did some supervisions in the area of New Testament

and then examined a little bit. And while I was doing that, I was also looking for a more long-term arrangement. You are listening to The Eric Metaxis show. More of My Socrates in the city conversation with Dr. Colin Nicol about his book, The Great Christ Comet, coming up next. Just don't want to forget to let you know

there is still time to give to CSI. We're still doing the campaign. So if you want to participate in freeing people from slavery, all you have to do is go to metaxistalk.com. Metaxistalkis talk.com. Don't miss the opportunity. It's still available. As hard as it may be for us to comprehend here in America, there are people in other

parts of the world whose very lives are being threatened simply for believing in Jesus. In fact, people are being enslaved for their faith. Some have been in bondage for 25 or 30 years. If you've been listening for any period of time, you know I'm passionate about the work of Christian Solidarity International, a ministry that sets these captives free. There are hundreds of thousands persecuted and enslaved in the Middle East. Together, we can literally buy their freedom and save the lives of some precious brothers and sisters this Christmas, giving them the joy and hope that we celebrate freely.

For only $250, you can provide life-saving aid this Christmas. You can buy a believer's freedom and provide them with much-needed food, a goat, and other goods necessary for. their very survival. These are brothers and sisters who are enslaved and fearing for their lives. Just $250. Maybe you can give more. Maybe a portion. Every gift helps. Imagine buying a fellow believer's freedom. Call 888-253-3522. 888-253-3522. Christian solidarity providing lifesaving resources for persecuted Christians for almost 40 years. 888-253-3522 or Metaxistock.com and click on the Christian Solidarity banner. Give someone the gift of their freedom for Christmas. Thank you.

It's hard to grasp why anyone would keep voting for record inflation, skyrocketing crime, and an open border. Likewise, why would anyone keep funding the left by sticking with the big carriers? Patriot Mobile is America's only Christian conservative wireless provider, and they want to make it easy for you to try their service. Give them 60 days to show you why I trust them. Right now, when you try Patriot Mobile for two months, get your third month free plus get free activation. They offer nationwide coverage on the best 4G and 5G networks and use the same towers as all three of the major. your carriers. So you get the same great service while supporting a company that's fighting to preserve

our God-given rights and freedoms. Just go to patriotmobile.com slash Eric or call their 100% US-based customer service team at 972 Patriot. If you're fed up with woke companies that don't care about your values, support a company that does. Make the switch today and get a free month of service plus free activation. Patriotmobile.com slash Eric. That's Patriotmobile.com slash Eric or call 972 Patriot. I have been... You're listening to a special presentation of the Eric Metaxus show. We taped this in Oxford, England. It is a Socrates in the city conversation with Dr. Colin Nicol

about his groundbreaking book, The Great Christ Comment. Listen in. So five years you're in Massachusetts on the North Shore teaching, New Testament. Yeah, it's a phenomenal place. Great faculty, wonderful students. Really a phenomenal place to study. Was it there that you stumbled on this or was it after that? No, no, it wasn't.

I was working on a lot of projects, really, there, getting kind of insights into a lot of different projects while I was there, but not this. Okay, when you say insights into different kinds of projects, what does that mean? Future projects? Other projects I've been working on. Basically, there was a long time,

when I was at Gordon Comwell, when I'm preparing a class, a lecture on something. And as I'm preparing it, I'm thinking, but I, you know, this is a big puzzle or a big mystery. You see something. And I go, well, I know what that is. I need to be able to develop it. The problem is I was so busy and working so hard at Gordon Comber. I wasn't able to really develop the insights. So that was building up within me as a real tension. and there came a point

it almost became unbearable for me personally because I knew I had to write. There were so many projects that I knew were extremely important. Okay, and you're excited about these things, obviously, because you're finding things that haven't been found before, insights that haven't been seen. So you have a passion to get on with those things. And at some point, I guess, one of those things is this thing.

well what happens is then I leave I eventually leave Gordon Commonwealth to go and devote myself to writing and so I returned to Northern Ireland to do that the nice thing about Northern Island is it's a peaceful spot I don't get a lot of interruptions

I'm able to just do my business and be devoted to what I'm doing so I was there working a lot of other projects and really what happened in regard to this book my father-in-law he was really excited by a DVD that had come out, I think, 2007 by Rick Larson on the Star of Bethlehem.

Okay, I saw that. Yeah. And that really fascinated me because I thought, boy, oh boy, if we could ever really figure out what is, what was the star of Bethlehem, that's a big deal. I mean, that's a big capital M mystery that's been hanging out there for 2,000 years. So that's what pulled you into this subject? Well, yes and no. I get another yes and no. In the sense, first of all, I initially wasn't at all interested in the subject. I had my other topics which I was getting insights into

and I felt like I was breaking new ground in. And then my father-in-law asking me to do this. And he's a nice guy. Ask you to do what? To watch this DVD and respond to it. So I didn't want to offend him. To watch the DVD well. It's not too much.

No, no, it's not much, but, you know, then you've got the... But this is the four and a half years of work after that. Well, yeah. Yeah. But, you know, I'm watching this DVD, knowing that I have to give my response to my father-in-law and find a gracious way if I don't like it. Of telling him, I don't like it, you know.

So there's a little bit of family... Okay, so you watched it? Yeah, you know. So I watched this DVD. And it didn't sell you? No, no, it didn't sell me. I mean, it was beautiful production. I mean, I was really classily done, you know,

and most impressive in that regard. but there were enough things in the presentation which struck me as implausible. And, for example, having to redate Herod's death from what's all historians virtually would accept that Herod died in 4 BC. But that particular view had to, it has to shift the date a few years in order to kind of accommodate. So that was a big flag for you? That's one of a number of problems. And there are a number of things like that. See, that's the thing, is someone like me watching that, I would never pick up on that. And, of course, I didn't pick up on that. But your biblical scholar, you picked up on these things.

So you watched it, and you weren't convinced. No, there are a number of problems with it in terms of even... I knew enough about, you know, ancient views to know that Leo was never regarded as a constellation of the Jews. And this whole idea that Regulus, the star, which is the main star in the constellation, Leo, the claim being made in the program was that that was the Messiah star in some sense. Because it's the king, regular. Okay, well, so, you know, I knew that that's not really, certainly in terms of Leo, that's an invented association with Israel.

The ancients didn't regard to the legal. Okay, so you thought he was stretching some things, and eventually it falls apart for you. So what happens now? Well, that drives me back to the biblical text at that point. It did. Not necessarily because I wanted to resolve the issue, because I wanted to answer the questions for my father-in-law, right? So I'm trying to find nice, delicate ways of putting things in nice,

succinct kind of... The thought of having to do an exegesis for your father-in-law has never occurred to me. It's a heck of a life you've got. So, well, so tell me you go in, and do you become more compelled by this as you do your ex-a-geesis? As I'm looking at Matthew chapter 2, I'm starting to see... obviously problems with more problems with what, that kind of view that Rick Larson was promoting, but also starting to do a little bit of a reading around the topic, the different views on the star of Bethlehem, and increasingly seeing the problems with all the major views.

And yes, as you say earlier, there's that, but wait a minute, that's what it kicks in. You've been listening to the Eric Mattaxas show. More of My Socrates in the City-Oxford conversation with Dr. Colin Nicol coming up now. With the overturn of Roe v. Wade, lots of companies are coming out saying they'll pay for employee abortion travel and expenses. Most of you've heard about some of these companies. You've decided to stop shopping or doing business there, but did you know that you most likely own stock in those companies through your 401Ks, IRAs, and other investment accounts? Folks, this is a huge problem, and we need to do something about this to send a message to Wall Street through our investments. You need to go to inspireadvisors.com slash Eric and get a free Inspire Impact.

report. This biblical investment analysis will educate you on what's really in your investment accounts, like companies paying for abortion travel. You need to go to inspireadvisors.com slash Eric to connect with an InspireAdvisors financial professional who can run your report and help remove companies paying for abortion travel today. Go to inspireadvisors.com slash Eric. That's inspireadvisors.com slash Eric. Advisory services are offered through Inspire Advisors, LLC, a registered investment advisor with the SEC. MyPillow is excited to bring you their biggest betting sale ever in just in time for Christmas. For a limited time, get the Giza Dream bed sheets for as low as 2998, a set of pillow cases for only 9998, and rejuvenate your bed with a my pillow mattress topper for as low as 9999. They also have blankets and a variety of sizes, colors, and styles. They even have blankets for your pets, get duvets, quilts, down, Comforters, body pillars, bolster pillows, and so much more. All the biggest discounts of the year are happening right now, so don't miss out.

They're also extending their money-back guarantee for Christmas until March 1st, 2023, making them the perfect gifts for your friends, your family, and everyone you know. So go to MyPillow.com and use promo code Eric or call 1-800-9757, and you'll get huge discounts on all My Pillo Bedding products, including the Giza Dream Bedsheets for as low as 2999. and get all your shopping done now while quantities last. Again, use code Eric and Save Mypillow.com. You're listening to a special presentation of the Eric Metaxus show. This is my conversation with Dr. Colin Nicol in Oxford, England,

about his book, The Great Christ, Comet. This really did happen. I'm convinced it really did happen. It's unlikely to be a miracle as such because it's said to be a star. It's viewed by professional astronomers, astrologers, it does what a star does, it rises, you know, first appearance, then it rises, standing over. These are all things that were said in the ancient documents of an actual astronomical

element. Remember that most people listening to this don't recall what the scriptural text says about the star of Bethlehem. So refresh us. I mean, I remembered when I was reading your book, I was astounded to see for the first time things that, I mean, I had read them before, but the idea that it stood over the house or it did this or it did that, I thought, I've never really, because many of us inadvertently pick up the Christmas version of this, that there's a manger and a stable and a star above it, and that's the end of the story. But when you read the text, it's much more complicated. It's extremely complicated. And when you look at how complicated it is, it creates huge problems. It doesn't really make easy sense, obviously. And so I assume

that's what happened with you. You're reading it and you're trying to figure out what could it be that fits all these descriptions. Are these descriptions accurate or has the text kind of spun the, you know, put some English on the ball so that it moves a little bit this way when it needs to be really this is the translate. And you're now responsible to figure this out. Yeah, well, essentially that's the issue right there. You're looking at the different views and you're saying, well, wait a minute, at every one of the views at some point backs off of a kind of straightforward reading of what Matthew says. You know, Matthew opens up by saying that these magi come

and they make this journey to Jerusalem, they arrive in the city and they go around asking, where is he who has been born, king of the Jews, for we have seen his star at its rising, and we have come to worship him. Then they go, they meet with Herod, Herod the Great, and notice I didn't say, great, I could have said it that way, yeah. How did you do that?

Herod the Great. I've been in America long enough to try and now. How'd you do that? So they meet with Herod. Herod passes on the information they need, which is where is the Messiah to be born. He, Herod himself in the meantime, has found out from the Jewish teachers that the Messiah is to be born in Bethlehem. So he passes this information on to the Magi and then inquires from the Magi

well, you know, where when did the star first appear? That's a very strange question really but it's a very important question when did the star first appear and he ascertains from them when it appeared. The Magi then go having been deluded by Herod

they go to Bethlehem in pursuit of the Messiah. Herod had to at really a two-fold plan in mind. The first one was targeted assassination. That's plan A, where he finds out effectively, precisely where the Messiah is located within Bethlehem, and then he sends his men down to slaughter the Messiah. That's, if you want to put it in his terms, probably the cleanest way of dealing with his problem. His backup is if it doesn't work, His backup is to then have a more broad-scale slaughter of the infants of an appropriate age in Bethlehem in the surrounding district to make sure that he can kill the Messiah.

What would the population, roughly speaking, have been of Bethlehem during this time? Because we kind of hear this, the slaughter of the innocence. What are we talking about? It was a village? It's a village. You know, you're probably talking. There's a lot of different estimates. But in terms of the children, you're probably talking no more than in the Bethlehem and surrounding district,

probably no more than 20 to 40 children being killed. Of course, that's a lot of... But it's one of these things, again, it's like when you read scripture, you've heard it a million times, it's like reading a fairy tale, it's kind of... But then when you actually think that, no, this didn't happen once upon a time. It happened not long ago in historical time where you have an historical figure sending his... thugs to murder 20 to 40 infants.

It is an absolutely unthinkable thing for us, really. That level of brutality. But that's, of course, it makes perfect sense when you know the situation. Well, you know, we know that Herod was from Josephus. We know he was, and especially in his final years, a vicious king and very paranoid.

He killed three of his own sons for conspiring against him. He killed one of his wives. He even went to the extent of setting it up so that a nobleman, one from every noble family, would be killed at the point of his own passing to ensure that it would be weeping at his funeral. This stuff, you know, it's very hard for us to get our heads around this,

but we need to understand this is history, this is true. Well, so, okay, so let's go back. You say that the Magi, have been following the star. They came from where, someplace in Iraq? Most probably Babylon. Babylon was really the NASA, if you want, of the ancient world. NASA.

Yeah, I'm trying to put it in American time. It's the NASA of the ancient world. Ocean control. They have records going back to the 8th century or beyond BC. So for hundreds and hundreds of years, records of astronomical phenomena. And we have records or leftovers of some of those today. So we know a good bit about it, and it was famed throughout the ancient world Babylonian astronomy.

And how far would the trip take? I think you write about this in the book, from Babylon to Bethlehem or to Jerusalem. I mean, as a crow flies, it's about 550 miles. Okay, but they weren't riding a crow. So this would have taken them how long with camps? camels and that kind of thing. Well, a camel caravan travels at approximately the speed of a human walking because usually a human is leading the lead camel.

Three miles an hour. Yeah, two to three miles an hour. And depending on terrain also, obviously. So you're expecting it to take something in the range of a month, give or take a little. Okay, so they traveled for a month to see this Messiah. So clearly, whatever they witnessed, astrologically speaking is huge. Well, no, it's a huge.

You make a very good point because, you know, we're so used to the kind of nice Christmas story where it almost doesn't, it lacks the reality and the grit of history. You are listening to the Eric Metaxus show. More of My Socrates in the city conversation with Dr. Colin Nicol about his book, The Great Christ Comet, coming up next.

We shall rise. We shall rise. Amen. We shall rise. On that resurrection morning when there's been barred to grope. We shall rise. Baby when I met you there was peace of love. You're listening to the Eric Mataxis show.

This is a special presentation of my Socrates in the city, Oxford, conversation with Dr. Colin Nicol about his book, The Great Christ Comet. These are real astrologers and astronomers. who spend their lives observing the stars. Every day they're keeping records. They're also doing astrology where they're people that come in to get their feet and they're accessing their records

to answer these questions and come up with explanation. But in this case, in other words, they're saying that the stars have told them that a great king has been born. I'm not just the king, the Messiah, the Jewish king. The Jewish Messiah. So even though they're in Babylon, care about this? What sense do they have

about the Jews and the Jewish Messiah? Exactly. 550 miles away. Well, this is a key part of the mystery. Because here they come from Babylon asking the Jew, they come to Judea and ask the Jews, where is he who's been born king of the Jews? So they've interpreted what they've seen in the eastern sky

to be an actual sign of the Messiah's birth. And they're so confident about this, they actually come expecting to find a newborn Messiah. So whatever they've seen has obviously been deeply impacting, has shaken their world and led them to do something which was really extraordinary. Okay, but in Babylon, astrologers would have had a sense of the Jewish Messiah,

would have understood that the Jews are awaiting Messiah? Well, in the sense, they would have had, we know from Tacitus, that there was a broad expectation within the ancient, that brought knowledge in the ancient world and the ancient air east of messianic expectation. And so it raises the question, what did they see? And that is really strangely enough a question that not many people ask.

I was going to say, I never asked that until I watched the 2007 DVD, which fooled me, and until I read your book, to see how complex it is. is that there's so many things in the text that have to be reconciled, and it's effectively impossible to do, except I think that you've done it. So at what point did the penny drop for you?

So you start studying this. What's that process like? Well, it was a process that had various kind of eureka moments, along with a lot of hard labor. When did you think you were on to it? Well, I have been doing some work on comets and asteroids as part of general reading, and then I was, along with my kind of basic reading

in the star of Bethlehem, and really then one day my wife asked me, well, what do you think it is? Because obviously it's her father that was... He's still in the picture? Holy cow. Did he dedicate the book to him? No, no, no.

Did you throw a copy at him? Okay, so you, but I still, I'm just thinking that you, you know, you're doing this research. At what point do you think, I think I know what it is, it's a comet. This is it. Because my wife then said to me, well, what do you think it is? And in answer to the question, I kind of, at that moment, put everything I had been doing in separate arenas together. And I said, it seems to me it has to be a comet. only a comic could do what the star does.

Okay, now I'm guessing that before this whole thing, you didn't know much about comets? Well, I had been reading a little bit about, as part of a broader reading about comments and everything, the remarkable thing, and this stands... Independent of this. Yes, but, well, as part of this and independent of this, as part of what I, everything I found,

and this actually remains true for four years. Every single thing I found out about, comments, fit perfectly. You've been listening to the Eric Mataxis show. More of My Socrates in the city Oxford conversation with Dr. Colin Nicol coming up next.