The Guardian's Women's Football Weekly - A record crowd and a stunning win as WSL returns – Women’s Football Weekly
Episode Date: October 3, 2023Faye Carruthers has Ceylon Andi Hickman and Anita Asante alongside her to wrap up an action-packed opening weekend of the WSL season...
Transcript
Discussion (0)
This is The Guardian. Without insurance, your assets are at risk from major financial losses, data breaches, and natural disasters.
Get customized coverage today starting at $19 per month at zensurance.com.
Be protected. Be Zen.
It's the season for new styles, and you love to shop for jackets and boots.
So when you do, always make sure you get cash back from Rakuten. And it's not just clothing and shoes.
You can get cash back from over 750 stores on electronics, holiday travel, home decor, and more.
It's super easy.
And before you buy anything, always go to Rakuten first.
Join free at Rakuten.ca.
Start shopping and get your cash back sent to you by check or PayPal.
Get the Rakuten app or join at rakuten.ca.
R-A-K-U-T-E-N dot C-A.
Hello, I'm Faye Carruthers and welcome to the Guardian Women's Football Weekly.
The WSL is back.
Goals, red cards, controversies, away teams winning.
We had it all on the first Sunday of the season.
Liverpool did what Liverpool do on the opening day,
causing an upset against one of the title favourites.
No such problems for Chelsea, Manchester United and Manchester City,
who will kick off with wins.
Throw Brighton into that mix too.
But it's Leicester who sit top of the pile on goal difference.
Willie Kirk screenshotting that table.
No talk of relegation this time.
So much to delve into.
Plus, we'll take your questions.
And that's today's Guardian Women's Football Weekly.
Well, I mean, you had to suffer a good 45 minutes of me
sounding like I was on my deathbed last week in our preview pod.
Get well soon, Susie Rack, because she's going to be listening to this tucked up in bed.
She insists, insists, nothing to do with that Arsenal result.
I mean, you know, there's stuff to do in the rounds, but I'm not sure I believe her, Salon Andy Hickman.
Susie's a bit of a trooper.
And I think if she could be here,
she would be here to talk about how sad she is about Arsenal.
Well, you say that, but Anita Asante also has a cold.
Do you not?
I do. I am indeed sporting.
You just got to power through sometimes.
No, I'm kidding.
Yeah, we obviously wish her, you know, that she gets better better very soon but um yeah she would be here if she could to vent at least I'm not sure you know
Salon's ill I've been ill as well you know we'd all turn up for the Guardian Women's Football
Weekly Susie Rack is a bailer a bailer no she's not she's very poorly very poorly lots of love
Susie get yourself better um Salon have
you recovered from your exploits down under we're not seeing you since you've been back
I know actually I was thinking about that the other day um yeah it's nice to be back I did
recover I actually did a bit of a madness I landed on the Wednesday after the World Cup final at 7am
and I went straight from Heathrow with all of my luggage there was a lot I bought a
lot of stuff in Australia straight up to St George's Park took four trains and ended up at
our the football beyond borders camp with 50 teenage girls all learning to like their first
step getting their coaching badges and it was the best possible way I could have come back from a
world cup because I was the blues were they were real they were the post-World Cup blues and I just walked into St George's Park and saw these 50
teenage girls from FBB being like this is where I'm meant to be coming back so that soothed me
I think coming home from a wonderful month. Yeah and back in the WSL Anita how well I mean
obviously opening day defeat not great but how is it being back in the WSL?
Fantastic. I think it's great, you know, for a club like ours to be back there in the WSL,
representing the West Country and playing at Ashton Gate.
I think the atmosphere was incredible.
You know, we got a really good turnout for the club and pre-season there's sometimes a drag and then the season gets here and they're just raring to go.
So, yeah, just happy to start getting off to the season, basically.
Yeah, very much. Let's kick things off, shall we? And we're starting at the Emirates, actually.
Arsenal 0, Liverpool 1. A record Barclays women's Super League crowd witnessing an almighty opening day
shock as Liverpool beat Arsenal in North London. Mary Taylor's strike early in the second half
giving Matt Beardside a famous win in front of 54,115 fans. It's actually Liverpool's first
WSL win over the Gunners since 2016. Oh Liverpool love a bit of a match day one upset salon, don't they?
They do.
And I think I would never have written them off before it
because I think if you're going to get a result against the bigger teams in the league,
the opening days is the time to do it.
And fair play to them.
I think they went to a very difficult place to go,
knowing that they were probably going
to be against that record crowd of people who have a lot of expectation I think for Arsenal this
season and suddenly you're there 1-0 up and you're defending like everything depends on it and you
get the result and I think fair play to Liverpool I think they set up really well. I think the back three were particularly brilliant.
But yeah, I think it raises a lot more questions for Arsenal
than it does kind of let us learn about Liverpool.
Because yeah, as I said, I think that's the time to go and get the result.
And I think the expectation was there.
You're going into this game at the Emirates, opening day of the season,
with some brilliant signings over the summer, really statement signings.
And you've been knocked out of the Champions League very, very early,
a tournament that the club, I think, depend on for exposure,
for commercial revenue, for success.
And then it's like, OK, well, this is your chance, Arsenal.
This is go and go and set out what you want to do this season.
And I think we were left feeling incredibly underwhelmed at that Arsenal performance,
but don't want to take anything away from Liverpool, who definitely deserve that win.
Yeah, most definitely. And actually, don't panic too much, Arsenal fans,
because Liverpool did this against Chelsea last season and look what happened there.
Including the last two matches of last season, though, Anita,
the Gunners are now on a run of three successive WSL defeats without scoring.
I mean, that's their worst record since 2011-2012.
As Solon said, it's been a challenging start to the campaign with that Champions League exit as well.
But are you surprised? Because, I mean, I don't know if you heard last week's pod.
Susie Rack was smug as anything last week with the signings that they'd made and, you know, everything going on behind the scenes.
But is this a surprise to you?
Yeah, I think in terms of the money that would have been spent on the recruitment for the season as well to add to the squad depth,
they would have expected to go further in Champions League.
You know, for whatever reason reason they just weren't clicking
in that game against Liverpool and you've got to be a little bit concerned that they're not
scoring goals with the attacking prowess that they have in the side although having said that
obviously they have Beth Mead to come back they have Vivian Miedema to come back uh obviously Leah Williamson but it's a
long season ahead and sometimes this lag is the wake-up call that a team needs to sort of ignite
their season and turn it around and there will be sort of those teething problems at the beginning
so I wouldn't judge them off this result either because we've seen it happen before we saw that
with Chelsea last season they went on to win the title so you know you don't want to get carried away with the
kind of emotional and expectations that you have because I think we've got to be considerate as
well of the players number of those players have been in the World Cup there might be slight mental
fatigue and physical fatigue but ultimately they haven't had a great deal of time to build up to
the season for the way that they want to play. So I'm not going to judge them too harshly on just
that performance and result. Yeah, I agree. Sue actually tweeted us to say it seems Arsenal need
the injured players back as much as England did, which is a really good point, Sue. You mentioned
giving the love to Liverpool's Salon. I mean a first WSL away win,
full stop, which is quite incredible since January 2020. First victory over Arsenal in 12 meetings
and actually they had five players out through Covid and were really struggling. I think they
only had about five players on the bench as well. Matt Beard had them so well drilled. It's a
brilliant start for them.
Definitely. And I think what they did really, really well was they wouldn't let Arsenal play down the middle at all. They forced them out wide. And you saw from the amount of crosses
that Arsenal were putting in, it was like the only option that they had to try and score a goal was to
send the ball out wide. Tim Stillman's done a really good piece on this in the analysis.
And what they did was have three very good centre-backs,
very tall centre-backs who were just like,
well, no, we're going to deal with those crosses fair, easy,
and get them out.
And the goal was a great finish.
I think Mary Taylor probably had way too much space in the box
and Arsenal ruined themselves for that one.
But they seemed like they had a game plan and they stuck to it.
And I think that is probably where we make that
a good amount of times over the last 24 hours, 48 hours.
I've heard, well, Chelsea lost on the opening day of the season.
Last year, this doesn't mean massive,
that we could still go on and win the league at Arsenal.
I think the difference is that Chelsea have MHAs
and Arsenal don't.
And I think what you see when Arsenal get into these ruts is a lack of different options for them to play.
And it's quite difficult to understand, OK, how are we responding to, right, Liverpool have set up to force us out wide
and are probably going to beat us in the box when we're getting those crosses.
Can we try and play a different way?
And you didn't seem to see that.
It was just kind of, that was our option.
Let's try and go for that route.
And that's where I think Jonas Eideveld needs to have different options
and he needs to think about the players that he has at his disposal
who are world-class players.
You have Victoria Palova who can do a job over England.
Why can't she come on
and play against Liverpool and do what she did for the Netherlands against this Liverpool team
and she doesn't so yeah I would be quite worried if this is kind of yeah a symbol of what's to come
for Arsenal. Yeah it's a frustrating afternoon for Alessia Russo Anita wasn't it she managed
only one attempt at goal three touches inside the penalty area and
was replaced by Stina Blackstinius on 73 minutes I mean it always takes players time to settle and
maybe because we're not quite sure where this Arsenal team are at she's a newbie there's other
newbies in there it's going to take a while isn't it yeah of course it will it's a time for her to
build the sort of relationships on the pitch with the players she's going to be playing next to. But I think when you look at the game, the first half in particular, for those first 20 minutes, Arsenal were getting lots of joy in behind Liverpool, playing into Liverpool's game plan, playing out wide.
And what I was annoyed about is not necessarily the personnel,
lack of bonus, adapting personnel changes.
Sometimes it's the way the team is playing.
And in that first half, they were in control.
They were playing in Liverpool's half,
but they were just forcing crosses into the box,
which you don't have to do.
You know, we've seen teams like Barcelona play a possession style football against low blocks.
I was disappointed in the lack of opposite movement.
You know, having Alessio Russo, who predominantly occupies centrally and pins defenders,
they were sometimes just queuing in the box, you know, like, just find me, you know, whatever.
But it's so easy to defend players that are stood right in front of you.
And I wanted to see more of those late deep runs from midfielders and beyond to stretch the team
or the forwards dropping a bit low. And that's what I think they lacked as well.
And Miedema kind of does that for you because she plays in that false 9-10 role
and goes into spaces that players don't want to get into.
But I do think there was impact from the sub so
that is a positive her team was impactful she's good in tight spaces Palova the same Blackstenius
as soon as she came on because they know exactly what to expect from her stretches the back line
you know space and behind the team started playing that way almost instantaneously so it's a bit of
all of those things not coming together,
if that makes sense at the right time, at least in my opinion,
because they dominated the ball.
But credit to Liverpool, I think they've cut out or diminished mistakes,
which is what a lot of the teams that play the top three or four do sometimes,
play into the hands of the better teams.
They had fewer mistakes and they were diligent and disciplined. And when they got the goal, actually, I think
you saw the belief in their game plan. Then they really stuck to it. And you've got to
say Rachel Laws and Gemma Bonner for me were outstanding as well.
Yeah, they really were. It feels as if Arsenal need a little bit of oil on the cogs to start
clicking a little bit, but no time cogs to start clicking a little bit.
But no time for them to feel sorry for themselves.
The small matter of a trip to Manchester United on Friday night.
Speaking of Mark Skinner's side, Aston Villa won Manchester United 2.
They had to come from behind to win it.
Drama of the late variety.
United fighting back thanks to a 92nd minute winner
from substitute Rachel Williams.
It was a real competitive end-to-end match.
Thoroughly enjoyed it.
12,533 fans at Villa Park,
which is a WSL record crowd for the club.
A brilliant game, Salon.
I mean, why do we love this so much?
It makes us pretty sad, really, I think,
but only made better by Lucia Garcia dropping an F-bomb live on the telly box.
But I mean, they took advantage of that squad that they've bolstered over the summer,
able to bring on the likes of Hinata Miyazawa, Nikita Paris, Rachel Williams.
And it was those two combined for the winner.
I thought Nikita Paris had a great game, actually.
Yeah, definitely. I mean, what an exciting first game to kick us combined for the winner. I thought Nikita Paris had a great game, actually. Yeah, definitely.
I mean, what an exciting first game to kick us off for the WSL
and wicked that it was played at Villa Park as well.
Two very fun teams to watch play football.
I think from last season, obviously Villa stole a lot of people's hearts,
didn't they?
And yeah, there was a lot of excitement to see Villa come out
with a few reinforcements, but really to see United and who they were going to start up top.
I thought Jayce played really well.
I think she was an absolute nuisance up top.
Yeah, I wanted to see a bit more, you know, Mia Zauer,
but I think we've got a long season ahead of us to see her play.
But I thought in terms of the excitement and the levels of intensity
that this game showed, think that that one nil
Villa that Daly goal was brilliant I think you see every time I watch Rachel Daly in the WSL
score brilliant goals I think why didn't we do that in the World Cup final she can create something
out of nothing she just creates space for herself and she needs half a second to beat the world's best goalkeeper at a near post.
And that's what you've got when you've got Rachel Daly playing in the box.
But yeah, I thought Villa will feel a little bit hard done by, I think, as well with the red card.
But overall, a wicked game to kick off the WSL.
Yeah, let's talk about that red card, Anita, shall we?
Kirsty Hansen sent off for a high tackle on Hayley Ladd.
She later apologised on social media saying,
I'd never hurt anyone intentionally.
It was accidental.
I'm sorry to Hayley and I'm sorry to the fans and the team.
I feel like I let you all down today.
I feel like she knew instantly when she'd done it.
She just mistimed it.
Yeah, I agree with you.
You could tell by her reaction.
She looked really upset, obviously.
I think she had her head in her hands and, you know, her shirt pulled up.
And she knew.
And it's one of those unfortunate things.
It was a desire, obviously, to win the ball.
And I thought she had her eyes on the ball, actually.
So, you know, that shows that she was really trying to compete for it.
And it's just one of those things.
She mistimed it.
Unfortunately, it was a red card but I think the
reaction and the character that Villa showed despite going down to 10 players was really good
and and something that Carla Ward would have really been impressed with to see that her team
could cope and and still compete and give themselves a sort of a chance to stay in the
game as much as they could but uh yeah it was just unfortunate to see because I think she's been exceptional,
you know, Kirsty Hansen, since she's arrived at the club,
been really impactful last season and especially the start of this season,
as well as the way she played for Scotland against England.
So that's really exciting, I think, for Villa.
Yeah, it was a big decision.
Carla Ward, you know, understood that one, but was pretty unhappy
that Mayor Letizia wasn't sent off for a body check on Ebony Salmon.
It wouldn't be football in this day and age if there wasn't grumbling
about the standard of officiating at Salon.
Did she have a point?
I mean, as a Liverpool men's fan, I'm quite triggered by that question, Faye,
after this weekend.
I've had enough talking about referees and referees who sit in a box and look at a screen and don't put lines on a pitch.
Yeah, I think she's going to be annoyed with that one.
I think she's always a dignified manager in terms of how she comes out.
She's not going to stick it on them, but you would be upset.
I think she argued that a few of the big decisions had gone against them and she's going to focus in on that one but it's also really annoying in a game like that when
the winning chance comes when it did in the game and you're kind of really holding out and grinding
out you think the odds are against you again parallels with Liverpool Tottenham at the weekend
and then it's the 90 plus two where
you concede and you feel like okay well whatever we do here it's gone against us so
yeah I think she's got a point but also we could spend a lot of time talking about referees at
this league and hopefully we don't this season it's about to get my violins out
no I genuinely feel that that's very harsh because I feel I think everybody in the football
world felt for you um and you know not that many people say that if they're not of a Liverpool
persuasion that's for sure well I wasn't going to bring it up obviously I'm a Liverpool fan too and
so you know let's the less we say about that the better but um yeah I I think that to me it was
kind of shocking that the referee and the Lionel missed it.
You know, it's clear attacking play down the right hand side.
Aston Villa worked themselves into such a good position to attack and trying to create something.
And it's a total off the ball incident.
Like, you know, she's completely been wiped out with no attempt to play the ball or get into the space.
And really, it's just lazy defending, actually, from Mia Letizia.
She didn't want to have to sprint into the space to cover the cross.
So the easiest thing was to just block a player quite aggressively.
But these decisions do matter because it affects the momentum in a match.
It affects the mentality sometimes of a player that feels like,
oh, you know, you've got the momentum,
you're going forward, you've got more energy
and suddenly you lose energy
and you get more deflated sometimes.
So the less of those things we see, the better.
Yeah, I agree.
You mentioned that Carla Ward
was incredibly proud of her players.
You played under her, Anita.
I mean, I felt as if they showed their credentials.
Can they upset the traditional top four,
do you think, this season?
I mean, it's difficult to say that
based on one performance,
but what do you reckon?
Yeah, I definitely think so.
I think they were the best of the rest last season,
weren't they?
And, you know, like Ceylon mentioned,
Daly is one of those strikers
you just know is going to score. I feel like you feel it in your bones almost, like sheeylon mentioned, Daly is one of those strikers you just know is going to score.
I feel like you feel it in your bones almost, like she creates things out of nothing.
Her touch for that goal was exceptional.
And there's that belief in the side now.
I really do think they have more belief in the whole team.
They've got in a good goalkeeper in Van Domselaar, good replacement for the loss of Hannah Hampton,
extra reinforcements and depth
in the squad. That makes a huge difference to the team and how you can rotate and adapt throughout
the season. I think if they could just, like most teams, fewer mistakes, the more chance you have
of winning games and being a lot closer to those top four teams. Yeah, next stop, Stamford Bridge.
Holders Chelsea kick-starting their title defence
with a 2-1 win over Tottenham.
And it was a dream debut for summer signing Mie Official,
getting on the end of a superb Neve Charles cross
to give Emma Hayes' side the lead
before Lauren James scrambled the ball home,
sparing the blushes of the officials
because, oh dear, we're talking about it again, aren't we?
That shot just before from Guru Wrighton
had actually quite clearly crossed the line.
More on that in a minute.
They didn't have it all their own way though, Chelsea.
It was a nervy finish.
Martha Thomas reducing the deficit with 15 minutes or so to go,
but they did avoid another shock opening day defeat
and got the job done, Salon.
As a good Emma Hayes side always does.
Yeah, they withstood the pressure, I think, of Spurs well in that game.
And they had both the individual and collective brilliance
to be able to override it and create the moments that they needed
to win that game.
But I did think Spurs as well.
I think it was great to see a Spurs side come out and play that well.
We're not really used to that.
I think after last season's I think
nine nine losses on the bounce at one point um towards the end of the season but yeah I think
it was exciting to see that official Lauren James link up I think we're going to see more of that
over the uh the season and yeah wicked to see Lauren James playing in that number 10 role and
being able to slide those passes through and and play really creatively and also know that there is a you know a new player that she gets to form a new
relationship with who feels like they're going to have an absolute vibe and she's going to finish
a lot of James's chances and and set her up so yeah it was really cool to see them back out there
I think I think Lauren James again I think will be another brilliant season for her yeah I think Lauren James, again, I think will be another brilliant season for her. Yeah, I think it was an interesting game.
I think it's good to see Emma Trust-Fischl to start.
He doesn't normally bring new transfers straight into the mix in the season,
but I think she played fearlessly, was brave.
She brought some of that character and personality into the game,
which was great to see already linking up really
well as Ceylon mentioned but I think there is a slight flip side you know in terms of Tottenham
you know they had a completely different identity compared to last season you know they were almost
dragged into that relegation battle and to see them more attacking showing a bit more desire to
go forward feeling like they could compete with
Chelsea shows a different mentality shift and actually the the work of Robert Willem to come
in there and have immediate impact in the team and actually I think they had the most shots you
know and opportunities on Chelsea's goal that Chelsea have experienced ever experiences last
season so you know that was an interesting thing as well
because it shows that Chelsea still have work to do.
Yes, they've got the individual brilliance of players
like Lauren James, for example,
but I felt like collectively as a team,
there were still a lot of holes in the side
and Emma definitely will want to see an improved performance.
Yeah, we're used to them starting slowly, aren't we?
But I loved that combination between James and Fischl, actually.
I feel as if, bearing in mind,
that's their first competitive game that they've played together.
Their connection was brilliant.
But, you know, it's interesting you say that about Tottenham as well,
because, you know, under their new manager,
I feel like we're seeing signs that they can improve
on last season's ninth place finish.
Before we go into that VAR conversation,
here's what he had to say about Manchester United
loanee Grace Clinton.
He said she looks like a real talent.
She's going to be the next superstar in this country,
if you ask me.
I think she's brilliant and has the potential
to be so, so good.
What say you coach Anita you know
I couldn't agree with him more like Grace Clinton was such a joy to work with and coach at Bristol
City obviously we had her on loan last season in the championship she is a huge talent she's such
a good ball carrier really competent technically skill, has the ability to score goals and assist, but
has the confidence as well for such a young player to take on that kind of responsibility.
And I think she's a great signing and addition to Tottenham who needed players with a bit more
creativity, you know, and could exploit and create space not only for themselves, but for others.
And it seems like, you know, if that's the style
that they're trying to implement this season,
that will definitely suit her because, you know,
she wants to be on the ball.
She's always looking to be an option.
And she's a great kid with a lot of, you know,
lots of personalities.
She's a scouser, so she's great.
Listen, I feel like I'm being really mean today.
I've thrown Susie under the bus for being ill
and now I'm talking to two Liverpool fans consistently about VAR I'm really really
sorry I didn't wake up this morning and get out of bed and think I'm gonna just be really mean
to everybody at all I promise Emma Hayes said it was embarrassing Guru Rison's goal wasn't given
when everyone in the stadium knew that it had gone in she said I said to the fourth official
I bet you're glad that James scored straight away. If this is the top level of football,
the Premier League of women's football, we need to have VAR in all games.
Solon, it's something we've spoken about on the pod repeatedly, actually. And I think we're all,
you know, very measured about where the growth of women's football is and the fact that actually a
lot of the infrastructure around it needs to catch up with how much it's exploded particularly since the the lionesses won the euros but what do
you think about this why isn't there like why isn't there the basic technology this isn't even
var that we're talking about this is the you know the little buzzer on the watch to show that the
ball's gone over that's goal line technology we've had watch to show that the ball's gone over. That's goal line technology.
We've had goal line technology in the men's game long before we had VAR in the men's game.
I think Emma Hayes is absolutely right when she calls it embarrassing.
I think you cannot, on the one hand, start propelling the game and everything around it to these levels and these heights and playing the openers at these massive men's stadiums
and trying to fill them out.
And then on the other hand, not have the basic requirements
that if the men's team were playing in that stadium, they would have.
So when you're a fan or you're a player or you're a manager
and you come to those big grounds and you come to these big days
and the opening day of the WSL and you think about the profile
of where the game's got to, the build-up, everything,
and then you have the very basic things that let you down. We can't be doing one without the other.
You can't propel the game and then not bring with it the basic things you need to be able to play
the game at that level. I would maybe understand it if it was at Kings Meadow or we're talking
about stadiums like Boreham Wood, right? And maybe the infrastructure of the stadium doesn't allow for that level of technology.
I don't know. I don't know how it works.
But when you're playing it on the same level, then we have to demand the same expectations.
And I genuinely, I would like the question to be answered,
why don't we have just the basic goal line technology to buzz whether that ball has gone over the line or not?
That doesn't involve six people sitting in a van outside the stadium looking at loads of screens and the technology
that just involves an advancement we had in the game a long time ago on the men's side so
yeah it's really infuriating we're just going to keep getting these embarrassing moments at
the level we're at now on Sky Sports on BBC News talking about these things and then it gives more
people ammunition to say actually I want to switch off from the women's game because it doesn't have the same
it's not being treated with the same respect because we're not putting the basic things in
to know whether a goal is scored or not. Yeah I think there's an argument for some supporters
that would probably go well I enjoy watching the women's game because it doesn't have
VAR interfering as well so you, that's one part of it.
But I do think that obviously if we had VAR across the WSL,
it would be a marker of progress and equality in terms of, you know,
being the same as our counterparts.
But on the flip side of that, until all the teams are performing
and playing at their men's stadiums, which we really want to call
the club's stadiums,
it should be for all their teams,
then it would work perfectly fine.
The fact that they're not is probably the problem.
You know, they're playing at smaller grounds,
as you mentioned, whether that's Kings Meadow,
you know, us at HPC or whatever,
that doesn't allow for that.
But I think there is a bigger argument
for goal line technology.
That would be great to see that
come into the game across the board.
And the difficulty thing is
you could play at Stamford Bridge
and have VAR,
and then next week be playing
at a smaller ground and not have it.
And then it brings inconsistencies
within the game in terms of fairness,
doesn't it?
So that's the other problem.
So I think, again i we know it
comes back to the governance side of things of the game money and budgets and whether or not
they're willing to redirect and prioritize that for the progression of the game you know but
ultimately it's so competitive now there's so much more money involved now that results matter and managers' jobs are potentially on the line based on these really imperative decisions.
So it is something that I would like to see coming across the board. whether VAR comes into the women's game because I think it hasn't been proven to,
maybe I'm just bitter this weekend, but it hasn't been proven to work
or to solve the problems we thought it was going to solve yet.
And that will take time.
And I'd much rather it came to the women's game when the men's game
have worked out how to use it properly.
And I appreciate that VAR takes a bit more human resource, I guess,
in terms of you have to have a different level of
skill set and training to be able to be those referees in that space. And we're currently in
a situation in the women's game where we don't have enough women refs, right? Just on-field refs
where we haven't got a big enough pipeline. We are trying to diversify that pipeline to ensure
that there's more women refs coming through. so I appreciate that that's maybe a step further and maybe not a step that we want first I think what
the insulting slash embarrassing thing is just that basic goal line technology and that would
be something that would be quite an easy save across all of our stadiums at the levels we're
playing the WSL at now I think. Yeah we are planning on doing a refereeing focus at some
point during the season.
So we'll delve more into that.
I'm sure it's not the last we've heard about the goal line technology slash VAR debate either.
So Chelsea not at their best and they'll need to step it up because on Sunday they make the trip to Manchester City.
And that's where we're heading next.
In part two, we'll round up the rest of the opening weekend action and get you caught up to speed with the latest in the championship.
Do you have business insurance?
If not, how would you pay to recover from a cyber attack, fire damage, theft, or a lawsuit?
No business or profession is risk-free.
Without insurance, your assets are at risk
from major financial losses,
data breaches, and natural disasters.
Get customized coverage today,
starting at $19 per month at zensurance.com. Be protected. Be Zen.
Welcome back to part two of the Guardian Women's Football Weekly.
And so we go to East London where Gareth Taylor's Manchester City side
had to play the final 20 minutes with 10 players.
But goals from Lauren Hemp and Jill Roard guided them to a 2-0 victory over West Ham.
New Hammers captain Mackenzie Arnold gave her side hope
when she saved Chloe Kelly's penalty to keep the score at 1-0.
But Rawd was able to get her debut goal shortly after to seal all three points for City.
How do we assess this opening result for them, Anita?
I mean, it wasn't the most scintillating win by any means, but job done.
Yeah, exactly. Exactly that, job done.
I think it's a really positive result for City when you think about how they started last season.
They had a slow start to the season,
had a lot of injuries,
and then a lot of ingoings and outgoings
of really influential and key players.
So to see them get off to a good start
and win a game relatively comfortably
to some degree was important for them
because they'll
want to improve on last season's finish in the table and they've brought in obviously the likes
of Jill Roard who has lots of WSL experience and I think it's a chance for players like
Mary Fowler for example to take on a new kind of role within the side and added responsibility for attacking play.
But, you know, I think City's a team that has a clear identity and ethos on the pitch.
You know what they're going to do. And once they get to the levels we know they can, then they're just like unplayable.
So, yeah, I think it was a comprehensive start for them and they've got some really good players.
But this year, hopefully they have fewer injuries that will impact the team and they have a bit more squad depth, which I think will help them.
Yeah, they need a better start, don't they, Ceylon?
I mean, we questioned on last week's preview show as whether or not they had enough in the transfer window in terms of freshening that squad up.
Based on what Anita said just there and what you saw over the weekend are they are
they real contenders this season it's always so hard to tell with City isn't it what they did last
year was we I think a lot of us wrote them off quite early on and then they went on this absolute
run and surprised us all and when they just started grinding out results quite quietly in
the background and we sort of yeah written them off yesterday I, I think Jill Ward's going to have a good year.
I think she's got a point to prove.
She really, really forced that move, didn't she?
And I think when you're kind of carrying that on your shoulders
in an opening day back in the WSL, she's going to want to do well.
And I think she did play really, really well.
But I think, yeah, City as a whole, I went into this season thinking
maybe after a World Cup that Mary Fowler will
be a bit like a new signing because they did the one-in-one-out sort of transfer window,
but maybe because they didn't really utilise players like Mary Fowler much last season.
And actually, after a brilliant World Cup, I think she is such a brilliant talent and hopefully
we will see more and more of her this season. Yeah, I think you've still got a brilliant talent and hopefully we will see more and more of her this season yeah I think
you've still got a brilliant forward line in that team Chloe Kelly, Lauren Hemp, Mary Fowler,
Bonnie Shaw now adding Jill Roard as a creative attacking player in there as well I think they
could be dark horses again this season and we shouldn't write them off just because they've
only had a small transfer window where they haven't done much business.
Yeah that's a really good point actually it's really easy to go down a narrative isn't it particularly in the media when you start to look at results but first week and here we go
making a narrative concerns for web tab already um former spurs boss rihanna skinner now in charge
but their new number nine rico wecky limped off injured before the hour mark.
And actually, she was their only bright spark, really, in the final third.
That would be a really big blow.
We don't know what's happened to her.
But, you know, if anything's going to keep her out of action, Anita,
that's going to make West Ham struggle a little bit.
Absolutely. I think no one wanted to see her go off the pitch
and she was the bright spark for West Ham.
She's the one that has the impetus
to make something happen
and be a bit more creative
and sort of is the focal point
for this West Ham side in terms of their attack.
So I think they seem like a solid team.
They've got lots of good players who are experienced,
but my worry is that they're
going to fall into sort of that defensive dna you know where they just don't really click and they
don't really find ways to break other teams down and create a lot you know they'll be kind of
difficult to beat or very hard to beat in some matches but will they be able to flip that
mentality and that character to then play more
expansive and break down you know the opposition and and create a bit more so yeah i that's my
concern really for west ham yeah well they've got brighton up next away from home city though
host chelsea on sunday which is going to be pretty tasty a couple more opening day fixtures for us to
wrap up bristol city back in the wsl and that's where we're going to check pretty tasty. A couple more opening day fixtures for us to wrap up. Bristol City back in the WSL,
and that's where we're going to check in.
Ashton Gate, Leicester City triumphing
over newly promoted Bristol City in a 4-2 win.
Carrie Jones's deflected shot
opened the scoring for the home side,
but Amy Palmer's stunning equaliser from 20 yards out
just on the stroke of half-time
sparked the Foxes' comeback.
Anita, it was first match back in the WSL for Bristol City.
Not the result you would have wanted, but as you said at the top of the show,
plenty of positives to take from the performance, particularly in the first half.
Yeah, I think, you know, I was really happy to see the way we started the game.
Lots of energy, lots of belief.
Carrie Jones was really you
know influential down the left hand side was playing how i'm used to seeing her play attack
and and be direct and dynamic and really ask questions of the defense took on a really good
goal and i think the team suddenly got lifted and felt like you know they could really open up the
game but you know we'll review the game obviously and i think for us it was like, you know, they could really open up the game. But, you know, we'll review the game, obviously.
And I think for us, it was important to, you know,
lots of these players as their first exposure of top flight football.
So they will definitely go back and reflect and think about how they felt,
I think, emotionally first, how they coped with that audience
and with a game against, you know, now an experienced
Leicester side. But I do think that we kind of, we allowed Leicester to get back into the game,
especially the second half, lapses of concentration perhaps for us that we'll want to sort of
address. And Willie Kirk was really smart. I think he made some changes that impacted Leicester positively
and gave them a bit more momentum.
And then we started to sort of drop a bit too deep for my liking.
And I think that allowed them to really come on top of us
and create a bit more pressure.
And then they got their goals.
And of course, Amy Palmer's goal was an exceptional goal.
And we're used to seeing her score goals like that,
obviously having had her previously.
So that probably hurt a little bit.
But, you know, first game is just important to recognise
the context of the performance.
And we were really, I think, overall quite happy
with the way they approached the game.
And we'll just try to improve on that.
As someone who spends a lot of their life talking about
how good football is for emotional
processing, Anita, to hear you say that the first thing that the reflections will be with
the Bristol City players and team will be how they felt and what that experience was
like for them to have that space.
That makes me really, really happy that those conversations are happening.
You can't underestimate it, can you?
I think so much of how you feel impacts performance.
If you feel good, if you feel nervous, how you feel impacts performance if you feel good if
you feel nervous if you have fear if you feel brave and it's not about dismissing those it's
about confronting them understanding them and how to manage them you know whether that's on the other
side of it there's a lot of male managers that would do well to hear that Anita and take that
on board and learn about
the emotional processing of a game and how much it affects so it's wicked that those conversations
are happening well you say that but actually Leicester you could argue are mentality monsters
really under Willie Kirk bearing in mind what he did with that group of players when they
everybody had relegated them before he came in and actually still,
you know, in the latter stages of the season as well. And this win feels really big for
Leicester after they were in that relegation dogfight all of last season. Did you see any
signs that he wants his side to play more on the front foot now they're not scrapping
to stay in the league and, you know, determined not to get themselves in that position again?
Yeah, definitely. I mean, even at the end of determined not to get themselves in that position again? Yeah, definitely.
I mean, even at the end of last season,
when they were in that relegation battle,
I felt that performance-wise,
they were better than their results.
Actually, a lot of the games they tested other teams,
they had opportunities to score.
They were missing some kind of clinical finishing
in lots of moments, which could have turned the game,
could have got some results for them.
You know, I thought Hannah Kane was a really good, you know, forward player for them because she's so quick.
She really stretches the back line. And if she could just be more, you know, clinical in those vital moments, that would make a difference for them.
But they had the foundations to build on from last season.
They've got that now embedded in the players. The players who were there would have experienced what a relegation
is like so they want to come into this season with a better start and a bit more belief
and and he had more time as well with a pre-season to really implement all of his fundamentals
and his principles going into the team so I do think they already look so much better off
from having gone through that experience as well.
Yeah.
Last but not least, Brighton began life under Melissa Phillips
with a 2-1 win on the road at Everton.
Perfect start for them, Salon.
Elizabeth Turland flying out the blocks
with both goals inside the opening 15 minutes.
She looked a real threat throughout.
And, you know, the fact they've got the experience
of Pauline Bramer back in the WSL
to help them see the game out as well seems massive.
Yeah, absolutely.
I thought Turner had a wonderful game,
obviously getting the brace,
but big applaud it to Katie Robinson as well,
I think, who was the creator for both of those goals.
And she just played with such an intensity.
It was almost like she had, I don't know,
a chip on her shoulder or something to prove,
to say, this is going to be my season
and I'm going to absolutely take it.
And yeah, she hits the bar for that first goal.
And then the second one,
I think she's driving through the middle
and then kind of turn and gets the slot home.
But yeah, Brighton looked really good,
obviously on the road, playing away from home
and makes you really excited to see what they can do this season.
Can they be finishing in the sort of top third, top half of the table?
But yeah, questions for Everton. I feel like it's going to be a difficult and long season for them.
Yeah. What do you reckon to Everton's season, Anita?
We raised concerns in the preview pod about their defensive frailties
we saw it in the game again caught cold always playing catch up it's going to be as Salon says
a long season for them yeah and especially after losing Gabby George you know a leader
one of the sort of veterans of the team someone who I think had a lot for them in and out of possession as well that they don't
look to now and I just felt they were a bit reactive to situations a bit slower to certain
scenarios and they switched off a lot um so that's a concern obviously Hannah Benison was a big
name signing for them uh last season And there was lots of big expectation.
So it's whether or not they can get the best out of her as well this season.
Because she was supposed to, you know, she's going to be the creative spark for them.
But yeah, I don't know.
It's really hard to define so early, I think, with one result, what they're going to do this season.
I think there's obviously lots for them to improve on.
And I do think they've got experience in a team.
You know, Katina Veja can play multiple positions.
The Danish international, you've got Gaal,
Aurora Gaal, who I think is really good as well,
creative player.
But it just didn't click for them in this game.
And that's probably credit to Brighton
because of the way they were playing,
how dynamic they were.
And they were sort of an unknown entity for all of us.
But I've seen Melissa Phillips in the championship.
I know she's a very capable manager and her style of play is going to be quite attacking minded when she can do.
And she showed that, which was really fun to see.
She'll be glad to be out of the championship, as I know you as well,
because it's really tight this season, actually.
Blackburn Ravers at top of the pile after a 2-0.
Did I say Blackburn Ravers?
I did, didn't I?
Blackburn Ravers.
I think we should just go with it.
Let's just call the women's side the Blackburn Ravers.
Blackburn Rovers top of the pile after their 2-0 win on the road.
At bottom of the table, Lewis on Sunday.
Sunderland kept the pressure on with a 2-1 win over Watford.
A welcome three points for Reading, their first win of the season
after beating Durham after, of course, they were relegated
from the WSL last season.
Also wins for Birmingham, their first of the season,
and Charlton as well, but incredibly tight across the division.
Just five games in we'll be
keeping an eye on that throughout the season for you of course and doing a bit more of a focus when
when we've got a little bit more time in the pod we need to wrap up as well what we saw in the
international break last week Susie and I were in Utrecht to watch England's third loss under
manager Serena Wiegmann the Netherlands scoring a 90th minute winner in the Nations League
to beat the Lionesses 2-1 in Utrecht.
It was a pretty underwhelming game, to be honest.
I thought the Netherlands were excellent.
And I tell you what, if Vivien Miedema had been in that side,
it could have been more for sure.
But it does mean the Lionesses need to navigate a doubleheader
with Belgium in October and then take points off the Netherlands and Scotland in December if they're going to reach the Nations League final and then guarantee qualification for Team GB at next summer's Olympics.
Group A1 is pretty tight as well.
And it's our least favourite topic of conversation, but some more devastating injuries coming out of the international break Scotland and Real
Madrid star Caroline
Weir ruptured her
ACL in the first half
of their one-all draw
with Belgium at
Hampden Park last
week and a week
earlier Scotland also
lost their 17-year-old
starlet from
Manchester United
Emma Watson to the
same injury in
training just awful
for her having joined
from Rangers in the
summer looking like
such a bright prospect
so many exciting comments about her it's's just rubbish all round, Anita, isn't it?
Yeah, you know, it's just so, you just feel for the players.
Every time a player goes down with an injury, especially in ACL, I've experienced it twice.
I know the mental slog and the drain and the disappointment and sadness that comes with that
for the individual especially Caroline Weir because you know she's such an exciting player
so much talent really important player for a national team as well as Real Madrid and obviously
she'd be a contender for Team GB as well we've had so many conversations about ACLs. I don't even know where
to go with this. There's so many variables as to why and how and when it happens. Sometimes it's
innocuous, sometimes it isn't. I'm still on the side of, you know, recovery is important for these
players. The fixture and the calendar, I think, could have an impact as well. And I think, you know, preparation into games, into training
is a key part of reducing ACLs,
if that could be sort of consolidated across the league
in a more defined way that might start to help us identify
what these variables are that are impacting the number of these injuries.
Yeah, new research has shown that female athletes are up to six times more likely to have a non-contact ACL injury
than their male counterparts.
And yeah, I mean, we talk about it constantly
and I think there is pressure on and there are people doing research,
but it needs to speed up a little bit, I would say,
because it's just happening far too often.
Well done, you two.
You did a lot of heavy lifting there with Susie sitting
listening in bed. Thank you Anita. See you soon. Thanks for having me. It was a pleasure as always.
Salon, I don't know whether you want to tell people where you're off to next but what I have
discovered is your wonderful green nails making a bit of a statement. I've got a green coat as well
to go with. Yeah, I think that the less
said the better about where I'm spending my day. Okay, well, check out social media if
Dallon dares to put it in there. No, she says no, she's not. We'll just leave some mystery for the
listeners. Yes, but she's doing some wonderful work. It's all in the name of wonderful work.
That is the point of it. For young people young people for young people absolutely uh we'll be back with you next tuesday to recap the second
round of wsl fixtures and some absolute crackers to come including manchester united arsenal
and manchester city chelsea remember you can be part of the show by emailing us
at women's football weekly at theguardian.com don't forget also to subscribe to the moving
the goalposts newsletter the guardian women's Football Weekly is produced by Lucy Oliver. Music composition was
by Laura Iredale. Our executive producer is Sal Ahmad.
This is The Guardian. assets are at risk from major financial losses, data breaches, and natural disasters.
Get customized coverage today starting at $19 per month at zensurance.com. Be protected. Be Zen.