The History of China - #223 - Ming 14: Maybe The Real Treasure Was The Friends We Made Along The Way
Episode Date: September 5, 2021While dying emperors, shifting policies, and vindictive princes keep the capital busy, Admiral Zheng He will manage to sneak in on last joy-ride into the sunset aboard his beloved Treasure Fleet... T...ime Period Covered: 1424-1435 CE Major Historical Figures: The Hongxi Emperor (Zhu Gaochi) [r. 1424-1425] The Xuande Emperor (Zhu Zhanji) [r. 1425-1435] Zhu Gaoxu, the Prince of Han [1380-1426] Zhu Gaosui, the Prince of Zhao [1383-1431] Grand Admiral Zheng He [1371-1433] Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Transcript
Discussion (0)
You're listening to an Airwave Media Podcast.
The Civil War and Reconstruction was a pivotal era in American history.
When a war was fought to save the Union and to free the slaves.
And when the work to rebuild the nation after that war was over turned into a struggle to
guarantee liberty and justice for all Americans.
I'm Tracy.
And I'm Rich. And we want to invite you to join
us as we take an in-depth look at this pivotal era in American history. Look for The Civil War
and Reconstruction wherever you find your podcasts. With the Twilight Histories podcast,
you can travel anywhere in the multiverse. Some worlds are familiar, others are totally exotic.
An Egypt ravaged by an ice age, a Carthaginian colony on Mars, a Rome that never fell.
If you enjoy history, you'll love these immersive stories that pull you into different worlds.
So step on the platform and let's get you on your way.
Step into the Twilight Histories podcast.
Hello, and welcome to the History of China.
Episode 223.
Maybe the real treasure was the friends we made along the way.
Jade and fabrics from every corner meet like winds and clouds.
Mountains and rivers come together, and the sun and moon shine brightly.
From a du-she couplet composed by Zhu Di, the Yongle Emperor, and his grandson,
Zhu Zhanji, the eventual Shenda Emperor, while waiting for a foreign delegation to arrive on
March 13th, 1413. Last time, we left off with Zhu Di, the Yongle Emperor's death in 1424,
again, and his majestic, elaborate state funeral and internment,
complete with human sacrifices. Today, we journey back those 20 miles from Yongle's Palace of the
Dead beneath the foot of the Tianshou Mountains, and back to the Palace of the Living ensconced
within Beijing, the Forbidden City. There, of course, we'd left Judy's eldest son and successor,
Zhu Gaoshi, who'd just been enthroned as the fourth Ming sovereign, the Hongxi Emperor,
of the era of vast glorious brightness.
Zhu Gaoxi had been born in mid-August 1378
to the then 18-year-old Prince of Yan's principal wife, Consort Xu.
This made him the natural heir to whatever position his father wound up leaving to him,
which, as luck would have it, would wind up being the entire empire.
Growing up, the young prince, Gao Che, received the standard education of a scion of the imperial
house of Zhu, primarily centered on the physical rigors of martial arts, by which of course
we mean archery, horsemanship, and some degree of skill with a blade and later on battlefield
tactics and strategy, as well as the rigors of the mind, meaning Confucian thought and the study of the classics. Apparently, though,
he developed some level of competence at archery. Markedly unlike his father and grandfather before
him, he held little interest in other militaristic endeavors. Rather, much to the delight of his
tutors, the boy had a natural aptitude for literature and philosophy.
It's stated repeatedly that his natural bookishness was a large contributor to his overall poor health and weight problems throughout his life. One rather telling story of the young
prince was that when being tasked with a dawn review of a group of troops, Duke Auxer reported
back surprisingly quickly to the palace interior, informing his grandfather, much to the emperor's
bemusement, that it was too cold to conduct a review, and he'd opted to wait until the troops had finished their breakfast. The reaction
to this princely scion being a bookworm rather than a battlefield genius is, well, actually pretty
unsurprising. Think back, if you will, to who Zhu Yuanzhang had actually chosen to be his successor.
Yeah, that's right, not Zhu Di, the warlord supreme, but instead Zhu Yunwan, the gentle, diplomatic, virtuous bookworm.
Suffice it to say, Granddad Hongwu was very happy indeed that one of his grandsons had the same degree of love for the more civil aspects of education,
versus most of his other progeny that were very all about that stabby life.
And by all accounts, he was quite good at administrative tasks as well
as literary tasks. Another tale that delighted Hongwu was A Signing of the Young Prince with
the examination of a large stack of official memorials to the throne. When the boy reported
back, he had, quote, meticulously separated the military ones from the civilian. His grandfather
was reportedly impressed, end quote. His father, Zhu Di, however, was very much another
story. Hak Lam Chan writes, quote, being himself a seasoned military commander, the Yongle Emperor
preferred his two younger, more military sons, Zhu Gaoshui and Zhu Gaoshu, and often took them
along on campaigns. End quote. Though this seems to have been meant as something of a fatherly snub,
it was actually a-okay with Prince Gao Shi, since that just allowed him more time to study his books and listen to the lessons of his Confucian tutors, a farsight better, in his estimation, than the drudgery of hunts, battles, and military tents.
This is not to say that Zhu Gaozhi was some sort of buffoon when it came to military and command. Quite the contrary, during his father's rebellion
against his uncle between 1399 and 1402, Gao Xiao was left in charge of the family HQ at Beiping.
With just a skeleton garrison of some 10,000 left to his charge, in November of 1399, the prince
availed himself and his command abilities bravely by driving back a concerted assault by the forces
under the Jianwen loyalist general Li Jinglong. This changed the opinion of many about the then 21-year-old prince, including his father.
Prince Gaochi wasn't bad at military. He wasn't some, like, wunderkind either,
like his grandfather or anything. But he was competent. He wasn't going to embarrass himself
or his family on the field if it came down to it, it just wasn't particularly his cup of tea. Probably directly as a result of this defining moment, in 1404, his father,
the still freshly self-installed Yongle Emperor, officially declared his eldest son as the heir
and crowned prince. From then on, Zhu Gaozhi resided opposite his father. What I mean by that
is that if Yongle was in Nanjing, the crown prince made his home in Beijing. When Yongle quit the south and made the north his capital,
Gaozhi took up residence in the former imperial seat, acting as regent.
In his years of performing his role, he gained invaluable practical experience
in the administration of the imperial government,
as well as the widespread acclaim and respect of those high imperial officials
who guided and tutored the young Sion.
The years between his installment as crown prince in 4104
and his assumption of the throne two decades later are marked by numerous plots by the supporters of
his younger brothers, who still sought to replace him with their own favorite candidate. Even so,
they're not really worth getting into all that much just yet, because they were, in what might
be a history of China first, one and all stopped dead in their tracks, and would even result in one of the little brothers, Zhu Gaoshu, being exiled from the
capital by Yongle in 1417. Upon the death of the Yongle emperor, while on his fifth anti-Mongol
campaign in the Northlands, news of his passing was kept secret to all until his body could be
returned physically to the capital. That included the crown prince, who didn't receive word of his
father's passing until August 25th, when the imperial emissaries arrived at his quarters in
Nanjing, bearing the succession documents. Once he had arrived in Beijing, he appointed his own
provisional court, and that same day, Zhu Gaozhi, acting on the advice of the just-recently-released
from prison former revenue minister Xia Yuanzhi, abolished the tea and horse trade along the
frontiers, the gold and pearl missions to Yunnan and Vietnam, and, most notably, cancelled Zheng He's scheduled treasure fleet
voyages for 1424-25, instead reassigning its ships and crews to the Nanjing Naval Garrison.
The year that would follow the accession of the Ming's fourth emperor was a veritable whirlwind
of reforms and fundamental changes to the way the realm was to be governed going forward.
The Hongxi Emperor, at 45 years old, had had plenty of time and experience in the affairs
of governance by the long apprenticeship under his father, that he had a very solid idea of
what worked, what did not, and how he envisioned changing it for the better. And it was going to
be a series of policy shifts that, if his father Yongle had known about them, would have almost
certainly sent him spinning inside his sealed tomb at the base of the Tianshou Mountains. First and foremost, all officials who
had been jailed for offending the former emperor were now ordered immediately free. These men of
learning, overwhelmingly of deeply Confucian bent, would go on to serve the new emperor in an advisory
role the likes of which hadn't existed in the empire since the Hongwu emperor had cast his
high officials aside
and adopted his signature go-it-alone approach to, well, everything.
Again from Chan, quote,
Because of his background, the emperor had a close relationship with those senior court officials.
Unlike his successors, he frequently summoned them to regular meetings
and asked them to submit their opinions or recommendations in sealed memorials
before he made decisions on important matters.
In this way, the Grand Secretariat ceased to be a perfunctory advisory body, as it had been under earlier Ming rulers, and the Grand Secretaries became intimately
involved in decision-making. The collective leadership was vital to the emperor's efforts
to dismantle his father's unpopular programs and to establish a regular civil government
throughout the empire." In theory, outlook, and demeanor, it seemed that Hongxi had all the makings of being a second
Tianwen emperor, but one without the threat of overpowered regional princely uncles breathing
down his neck. And man, oh man, was he going to be making some changes.
First off, enough with that whole arbitrary tyrannical abuse of power against those seeking
to suggest reforms or report malfeasance to the throne. The Grand Secretaries themselves were each given a
silver seal inscribed with the motto, Sheng Yan Jiu Miao, meaning rectify faults and shortcomings.
These seals were to be used to submit secret memorials regarding cases of impropriety or
misconduct by their peers or even the imperial family itself without fear of reprisal. Likewise,
Hongxi exhorted his other ministers repeatedly that they should speak up without fear of punishment
from the emperor, a promise which he would mostly keep, and on the few occasions where his temper
got the better of him, he was usually quick to relent and even apologize to the minister in
question. An ardent Confucian himself, and now surrounded by a staff of equally
ardent Confucians, Hongxi quickly set about implementing policy reforms that unmade or
defunded the more onerous and costly aspects of the state. Expansionism as a whole was indefinitely
suspended, as was, as mentioned before, the insane expenditures of the treasure fleet voyages.
The philosophy undergirding this tremendous policy reversal was laid out in the emperor's very first edict,
which read, quote,
All voyages of the treasure ships are to be stopped.
All ships moored at Taichung near the mouth of the Yangtze River are ordered back to Nanjing,
and all goods on the ships are to be turned over to the Department of Internal Affairs and stored.
If there are any foreign envoys wishing to return home, they will be provided with a small escort. Those officials who are currently abroad
on business are ordered back to the capital immediately, and all those who had been called
to go on future voyages are ordered back to their homes. Moreover, the building and repair of all
treasure ships is to be stopped immediately. The collection of the hardwood, Tie Limu,
is to be done as it was in the time of the Hongwu Emperor. Additional harvesting should be stopped immediately. The collection of the hardwood, Tie Limu, is to be done as it was
in the time of the Hongwu Emperor. Additional harvesting should be stopped. All official
procurement for going abroad, with the exception of items already delivered at official depots,
and the making of copper coins, buying of musk, raw copper, and raw silk must also be stopped,
and all those involved in the purchasing should return to the capital.
It's very much worth asking just how exactly this played into those Confucian principles.
And the answer is twofold.
First, it fits into the idea of frugality rather than opulent excess being the progenitor of all social good.
Fewer state expenses meant less of a tax burden on the populace, which put them on a much better footing to live good and upstanding lives. The second facet of Confucian thought going on here is the idea that the empire,
its past, present, and future, lay in the land of China itself and not somewhere beyond the sea.
As the land tax ought to be the basis of governmental revenues, rather than relying
on the trading of goods from abroad, so too would the empire be more secure within the metaphorical boundaries of the Great Wall,
rather than stretching out across open waters to who knew what. The duty of the government was to
protect its people, from barbarian hordes and hunger alike, not to seek out the strange baubles
and jewels from all across the world. Why should so many suffer under onerous
tax burdens just so that a few might delight in the spoils of such global trade? Hongxi himself
responded forcefully when questioned by a minister who wasn't quite so gung-ho about closing the
whole operation down. He said, quote, relieving the people's poverty ought to be handled as though
one were rescuing them from fire or saving them from drowning. One cannot hesitate. End quote.
In terms of judicial policy too, Hongxi adopted an aggressively reformist stance against the excesses and abuses of his father's reign. Out of a very justifiable concern that many of the
prisoners sitting in Beijing's death row might have been victims of trumped-up charges and
judicial chicanery, Hongxi ordered his new grand secretaries
to join the judicial officials and review any and all such cases that might have irregularities or
reasons for suspicions of the verdict that had been meted out. This was even extended to include
trial verdicts that had taken place in the course of his own reign, if it was suspected that the
sentence was in contravention of the facts. Even further, in his first year, he twice pardoned families of previously executed
officials who had been so punished all the way back in 1402 for having remained loyal to the
deposed Jianwen Emperor even after Yongle had taken over. This was actually more than symbolic,
since part of the punishment for these families had been enslavement and the confiscation of all
their properties and lands. They were now at last
freed and their property returned. In addition, he forbade arbitrary corporal punishments of convicts
and the inclusion of criminals' relatives in their punishments, except in the case of high treason.
These practices, he asserted, were in gross violation of the Confucian principle of benevolence
and the ethics of filial piety. In April 1425, just eight months into his reign, the Hongxi
Emperor declared his biggest policy break with Yongle yet, and this one was a real doozy. He
announced that the Ming capital was to be removed from Beijing and brought back to the south,
specifically back to Nanjing. He'd already taken several steps which strongly hinted that he'd been
planning this
sort of thing since at least the time of his enthronement, probably the most notable being
to create the position of Grand Defender of Nanjing and then appoint none other than Zheng He
as its premier occupant. Zheng took the role with evident delight, as he'd himself long been a
resident of Nanjing and had deep ties with its Muslim population, estimated to possibly be more than 100,000 in the 1420s. And he would find his rewards to be vast almost beyond his reckoning.
Quote, Zheng He's house was supposed to have 72 rooms and a door so large that the sound of it
closing resonated throughout the house. He also owned land around the shipyard and outside the
walls of the city, which he gave to his adopted nephew, Zheng Haozhao. The boy could
not inherit Zheng's rank, but with the land, he and his descendants had a means of providing for
themselves. Much as his father had been a northerner through and through, Zhu Gaozhou
was at his heart a southerner. He did not like Beijing, and he seemed to scarcely need the
urgings of his advisors, which they were sure to offer regardless, that the northern frontier and its military adventures against the Mongols were nothing
more than costly wastes of time. As he had been something of Yongle's regential mirror image,
and the former emperor had spent virtually the whole of his last decade in the north,
Zhugezhe had grown very comfortable in the south. There was also, of course, the question of cost.
Beijing had already cost the empire an astronomical
amount to construct, and required yet more year after year in order to maintain, and lest we
forget, in the case of a goodly portion of the Forbidden City, eventually rebuild entirely after
that terrible lightning storm of 421. As such, on April 16th, Hongxi officially declared that all
government offices in Beijing were henceforth xingcai, that is, temporary. Two weeks later, he sent his heir, the young crown prince Zhu Zhanji,
in order to pay homage to the tomb of the dynastic founder, and then remain there in charge.
The message could not have been more clear. The emperor was preparing to move himself and his
entire court back down to the south for good. As such, the stage was set for a sweeping reset of nearly
the whole Ming imperial apparatus. Here was the emperor, in form and function, that Hongwu had
always wanted to succeed his own reign in the first place. A man of learning, principle, and virtue,
humble, thoughtful, and truly caring about the welfare of his people, rather than his own
aggrandizement. It was truly going to be an era of great renewal, a golden age for all of China. And then, just three weeks later, on May 29th, the Hongxi
Emperor dropped dead at the age of 46, after just eight months on the throne. How could this have
happened? As usual, little is known for certain. As with any high-profile death so young, the
Emperor's sudden passing led to some speculation of assassination via poison. Yet the reports we have from the time by those who
inspected the emperor's body prior to his funeral suggest otherwise. A palace eunuch named Lei
wrote that the emperor's death was the result of, quote, some imbalance in his yin-yang system,
perhaps heart failure, end quote. It was well documented that Hongxi had never given his physical state
much care, preferring study to rigorous activity. More, on the day he died, he's said to have taken
ill and seemed to know that he wouldn't likely recover. Before passing, it's written that he
told those attending him, quote, I have reigned a very short time. I have not been able to bring
any benefits to my people. I cannot bear the idea that they should be burdened with heavy work. Whether those words actually pass the dying emperor's lips is unknown,
but the sentiment does fill with what we know of the man.
His tomb complex was constructed in only three months,
a comparative blink of the eye next to the massive subterranean palace of his father in the same area,
and made in an austere, simple fashion to match the style of his rule.
And so it was that in less than a year, Great Ming had lost two rulers. Fortunately for the empire,
one of the acts Hongxi had first completed in the court of his brief tenure had been to officially
secure his line of succession. Even in his greatly abbreviated life,
he'd carried on the Zhu clan tradition of having just oodles of children,
ten sons and seven daughters,
nine and four of whom lived to maturity, respectively.
Since Zhu Gaozhi was as staunchly Confucian as they came,
there was never any doubt as to which son would inherit the family legacy.
There could be only one choice, the eldest, Zhu Zhanji,
who at 25 had become the crown prince,
and then just a month after his 26th birthday, would be enthroned as the fifth emperor of Ming,
presiding over the Xuan De era, meaning the era of propagating virtue.
Zhu Zhanji had, like his father with Hongwu, been a particular favorite of his own grandfather,
Yongle. From an early age, about 15 or so, the young prince had accompanied his imperial grandfather on his northern expeditions to both inspect the rising
skyline of Beijing as it was built, and also to hunt down those ever-pesky Mongol rebels.
As a result, markedly unlike his father, Zhanji acquired Zhu Di's great love of riding and
hunting, and a lifelong fondness for the stark, harsh beauty of the northern steppes,
and a physical vigor and robustness that his father terminally lacked.
We are not, however, about to swing into the mid-to-late Yuan Dynasty seesawing pattern of
successional extremes, because even though Zhu Zhanji came to appreciate much of his grandfather's
pleasures and aesthetics, he was in many other ways still very much his father's son. Like the
Hongxi Emperor, the new Xuanda Emperor was staunchly Confucian and trusted his Confucian advisors,
whereas Yongle had always much preferred and trusted his staunchly loyal unicorn.
So too was Xuanda like Hongxi in that he was, in spite of his appreciation of the manly and martial arts,
also very much a man of letters and learning, a great patron of the arts,
and his reign would come to be distinguished for its political and cultural achievements.
Napoleon Bonaparte rose from obscurity to become the most powerful and significant figure in modern
history. Over 200 years after his death, people are still debating his legacy. He was a man of
contradictions, a tyrant and a reformer, a liberator and an oppressor,
a revolutionary and a reactionary. His biography reads like a novel, and his influence is almost
beyond measure. I'm Everett Rummage, host of the Age of Napoleon podcast, and every month I delve
into the turbulent life and times of one of the greatest characters in history, and explore the world that shaped him
in all its glory and tragedy. It's a story of great battles and campaigns, political intrigue,
and massive social and economic change, but it's also a story about people, populated with
remarkable characters. I hope you'll join me as I examine this fascinating era of history.
Find The Age of Napoleon wherever you get your podcasts.
Though as heir apparent, Zhang Ji had been sent to Nanjing to prepare for the imminent removal of the imperial capital back to the south,
when his father's health declined in late May, he was immediately summoned back to the north.
He arrived to find that his father was already dead, and he was to be coronated as soon as the month of official mourning was completed. As such, he would quickly take the throne at Beijing, which was much to his
preference, as it would turn out. Quickly after his enthronement, he officially abandoned his
father's plan of abandoning the northern capital, and instead declared that it would remain his,
and the empire's, seat of power. Though he shared Judy's love of the north,
and his concern over the affairs and raids of the Mongols across the frontier, as emperor, Zhang Ji would chart a course much more in keeping with his conservative Confucian father than his expansionistic warlike grandfather.
On the advice of his like-minded officials and secretaries, he would finally bring an end to Ming China's 20-year-long boondoggle in Vietnam, more or less by agreeing to simply stop fighting. The Xuanda government at last recognized
the rebel leader, Le Loi, as the de facto administrator of An Nam, and shortly thereafter,
upon the rebel lord's death, formally recognized Le Loi's son as the king of An Nam, and then
walked away. Quote, the withdrawal from An Nam grew out of a realistic assessment of the national
interest in the face of a policy that had proved disastrous. The Ming government had suffered both military and diplomatic humiliation at the hands
of a much smaller neighbor. To the Chinese, wounded national pride was offset by the removal
of the serious financial and military burden these feudal operations had imposed on the empire.
End quote. A lesson in the folly of believing in the sunk cost fallacy, or throwing good money after bad,
in vain pursuit of saving face, in a foreign conflict with no clear objective,
endpoint, or victory condition. You really can just decide that it was a bad decision in the
first place, cut your losses, and walk away. A lesson that no one would ever forget,
or repeat such a farcical, tragic mistake ever, anywhere, forever. This is not to say that
the new emperor's proclivity to live and let live didn't sometimes go a bit too far. Sometimes so
far that even his most Confucianist of advisors would find themselves pulling their hair out and
nearly shouting, sire, I can't believe I'm the one saying this, but now is the time to act.
This would come in the form of that most Ming of crises.
That's right, a good old-fashioned princely rebellion led by an angry, disaffected uncle.
The uncle in question here was none other than the Prince of Han, Zhu Gaoshu.
In many, and I mean like, weirdly many, respects,
this whole affair had all the hallmarks of the last uncle rebellion,
that is, Zhu Di against his brother, the Jianwan Emperor, two decades before.
So the Prince of Han was the second son of the Yongle Emperor, and actually greatly favored
over his eldest brother as he shared his father's sensibilities and aptitude for martial prowess and
military success, while the heir, as we've said, wasn't at all about that life.
Much like Judy before him, Prince Gaoshu was bitterly disappointed when his father's favor
wasn't enough to suspend the line of succession in his favor, and so would spend the rest of his
life carrying a chip on his shoulder the size of Mount Penglai. The Prince of Han took it so far
that he repeatedly disobeyed his father's instructions, especially regarding paying
correct homage to his elder brother and eventual sovereign, and he repeatedly disobeyed his father's instructions, especially regarding paying correct
homage to his elder brother and eventual sovereign, and he repeatedly organized schemes and plots to
oust his brother from the line of succession and take it for himself, all of which failed
and were eventually, inevitably, found out by the relevant authorities. As a result, in 1417,
Yongle's patience with his wayward son finally snapped, and he wrathfully banished
him to a tiny fiefdom in the hinterlands of Shandong. Upon the death of Yongle in 1424 and
the accession of the Hongxi Emperor, the Prince of Han was one of the many granted clemency by the
new sovereign, who sought to essentially hug it out with all his father's imprisoned or banished
vassals, which certainly included his little brother. We can surmise that the filial feelings
were in no way reciprocated by Zhu Gaoshu, though the swift demise of his eldest brother
less than a year later precluded any overt action against the throne just yet.
Enter stage left, the newly enthroned Xuanda Emperor, some twenty years the prince of Hans
Jr., and looking to be, perhaps, the same kind of namby-pamby weakling his father had been. Plus, he'd already been arranging and bringing together his latest
scheme to overthrow the emperor and take his place all these months, so it would be a shame
to just let it go to waste. As such, on September 2nd, 1425, just a little more than two months
after Schwenda's enthronement, the Prince of Han launched his campaign against his nephew by
establishing his army with imperial-style designations and official titles.
Five days later, he sent a messenger to the imperial court bearing a list of charges against the new emperor that served as Cesus Belai.
Quote,
He charged the emperor with violating the rules of the Yongle and Hongxi emperors by investing civil officials with titles of nobility.
He also blamed the emperor for poor judgment in the selection of officials.
End quote.
This list of accusations seems to have been lifted almost word for word from the justifications used by Zhu Di against the Jianwan emperor in launching his Jingnan rebellion 23 years before.
For all that, this is where the striking similarity to Zhu Di's ultimately successful
campaign against his nephew come to an end. For though the new emperor at first hesitated when
informed of his
uncle declaring against him, within just a day or two of the official declaration of war on September
9th, at the strong urgings of his top advisors, the Xuanda emperor donned his battle armor,
mounted up, and resolved to personally lead the imperial punitive expedition to crush his uncle.
Because Zhu Zhanji was no Jianwan emperor. Sure, he loved poetry and books,
but he'd been personally instructed in the ways of warfare by Yongle himself,
and had taken a real shine to it.
While the Prince of Han had been grinding his axe,
first in Yunnan and then Shandong,
Zhanji had been chasing Mongols across the steppes.
So, bring it on, mine uncle.
As with any good military commander,
one of the most important decisions
Xuanda could make was who would serve as his field commander. The young monarch chose well.
He tapped the veteran general, Xue Lu, to lead the imperial vanguard, a force of 20,000,
and directly attack the Prince of Han's primary base of operations at Le'an Shandong. General
Xue put the city to siege little more than a week later, on the 21st.
When the rebels failed to immediately surrender, General Shui proceeded to storm Le on the
following day, bringing about a near-immediate end to the Prince of Han's ill-conceived rebellion.
Zhu Gaoshu surrendered and was taken prisoner back to the capital to face the consequences
of his actions. Facing the emperor he had so recently declared against, Gaoshu was stripped
of his titles and offices and reduced to the status of commoner,
before being locked back into a heavily guarded wing of the imperial palace that served as his prison.
More than 600 civil and military officials who had aided and abetted Zhu Gaoshu's insurrection
were summarily put to death, and another 2,200 banished to the frontier.
Yet, at least for the time being, Gaoshu's own life was,
rather unexpectedly, spared. It seems that the Xuanda Emperor's inclination towards mercy
stayed his hand. What happens next, however, remains unclear, at least in its specifics.
At least one telling puts it that during a visit to his uncle, the Xuanda Emperor was tripped by
the ever-spiteful
Gao Shu, a slight that finally broke through Xuanda's fence-mending disposition and sealed
Gao Shu and his family's fate. After all, all are wise to fear the anger of a gentle man,
and truly Zhu Gao Shu's wisdom had fled him with that final slight against his nephew.
It was ordered that the ex-prince be placed beneath a large copper vat, and then the whole thing be melted over him.
In addition, all of his sons were put to death as well, albeit not in nearly as horrifically torturous a manner, for whatever that may be worth.
It quickly came to light that there was yet further rot in the imperial clan,
for evidence was presented that the Prince of Han had been joined in his conspiracy against the throne by none other than the Prince of Zhao, the third of Yongle's sons, Zhu Gaoshui, as well as at least one other Prince of the Blood.
This had all the makings of a grand-scale imperial purge from top to bottom, an orgy of bloodletting that would make Grandpa and Great-Grandpa proud.
Yet, Xuanda instead ordered a halt to further prosecutions, apparently more concerned
with the continued stability of the dynasty than with enacting righteous vengeance, and comfortable
in the knowledge that his absolute squashing of the Prince of Han's rebellion had proved that he
was not some weakling to be trifled with. He let the plotting uncles go about their business with
little more than a knowing look and the certitude that such an act of clemency would not be extended a second time. Chan puts it, quote, the dismal failure of the rebellion
showed the level to which the power of the imperial princes had sunk, end quote.
Levithes writes, quote, Zhu Zhanji was thus a combination of his father and grandfather.
Some would say the balance he achieved between the blind expansionist policies of Zhu Di and
the rigid Confucianism of Zhu Gaozhi was the finest hour of the Ming,
a time of peace, prosperity, and good government.
And all that's great, if you're planning to live in that decade of the 15th century.
No further major internal or external crises would develop in the decade of Xuandao's rule.
A peaceful land, a quiet people.
But a riveting conclusion to a podcast episode it does not make. Fortunately for us, we're in luck,
because all those renewed good times would mean that there was to be the imperial will to roll
out the treasure fleet for one last glorious trip beyond the sunset. The rationale behind this
seventh, and what would prove final, reactivation of the treasure
fleet's expeditions remains rather loosely understood. As is so often the case, it's
unlikely that any single reason was the driving factor, but instead a combination of several that
made it all possible. For one, there was the timely death of the Grand Secretariat Yang Shixi,
one of the cabal of Arch-Confucian high ministers known as the Three
Yangs that we'll probably get into further next episode or so. Yang had been one of the driving
forces behind the suspension of the voyages in the first place, and so his death opened up a window
of opportunity that the fleet could just sail right on through. It's clear that even without
Yang to spearhead it, opposition to the continued costs of the expeditions remained high throughout
the imperial court, and it was only the Xuanda emperors' disregarding of their grousing
that got the voyage greenlit. Why was Xuanda so forceful about this? It was likely somewhat of a
delayed effort to stem the bleeding of Chinese international prestige from its recent embarrassing
pullout from Vietnam. This had resulted in a notable decline in the amount and frequency of
foreign tribute
missions arriving at the Ming court, a trend which, quite understandably, troubled the emperor.
He therefore publicly vowed to once again make 10,000 countries our guests. So it was that on
June 29, 1430, he promulgated the following edict. Quote,
The new reign of Shrenda is commenced, and everything shall begin anew. But distant lands beyond the seas have not yet been informed.
I send eunuchs Zheng He and Wang Jinghong with this imperial order
to instruct those countries to follow the way of heaven with reverence
and to watch over their people so that all might enjoy the good fortune of lasting peace."
As of a turnout, prep time for this seventh voyage would take longer than usual.
After all, everyone was about seven years out of practice at this whole thing.
It would also be the largest ever, outstripping even the first voyages,
and boasting more than 300 ships and nearly 28,000 crewmen.
The ships themselves were given names that reflected the peaceful, magnanimous nature of the expedition,
names that wouldn't sound out of place whatsoever if they were attached to covenant battleships in the Halo universe, like Pure Harmony, Lasting Tranquility,
and Kind Repose, just to name a few. As for the Grand Admiral himself at 60 or 61,
Zheng He knew that this would most certainly be his last voyage, and so resolved to make it one
for the ages. Quote, he took pains to document the
achievements of his previous expeditions by erecting two stone tablets. One, dated March 14,
1431, was emplaced on an anchorage near the mouth of the Yangtze River. The other dated the second
winter month of the sixth year of Xuande, and what is now Changle at the mouth of the Min River on
the Fujian coast. End quote. Though at least ostensibly raised in thanks for the help and guidance of the great sea
goddess Tianfei, it's clear that Zheng He had his eye much more on history and his place
in it than any real divine worship.
Quote,
The tablets carefully documented the achievements of each voyage.
No doubt has Zheng He surely wished them to be remembered.
But familiar as he was by now with the court's
strong opposition to the voyages, he may have been unsure how the official chroniclers would
record the expeditions, end quote. And if the spottiness of the official records are anything
to go by, it was a very prescient move by Zheng to make his own enduring record of his life's work,
rather than leave it to the ever-fussing bureaucrats up in Beijing who were hostile
to the whole enterprise. And for us, far better that we have even a biased account to refer to than none at all.
Zheng was obviously very proud of his voyages, and his part in the grand sweep of history.
He makes that crystal clear in his Chang'e Stele, upon which he inscribes that his expeditions
in unifying the seas and continents far surpassed any prior maritime achievement of any previous dynasty, end quote.
He goes on, quote, the countries beyond the horizon from the ends of the earth have all
become subjects, bearing precious objects and presents to the main court, end quote.
Further, the voyages had vastly expanded China's knowledge of the world, its distances, peoples,
and places. The distances and routes between distant lands may be calculated,
he wrote. And in arriving on all those foreign shores and bearing China's gifts and well-wishes
to those foreign people, Zheng was positive that he'd played a major role in spreading the fruits
of Chinese civilization and culture far and wide. Or as he put it, the fleet had made, quote,
manifest the transforming power of imperial virtue, end quote. The treasure fleet finally set sail from its mooring in Nanjing's harbor on January 19th, 1431,
making stops on its way out of imperial waters at first Jiangsu and then Fujian to take on additional supplies and trade goods.
It would depart its last Chinese outpost nearly a year later on January 12, 1432, sailing south to Quy Nhon in southern Vietnam, then on to
northern Java, Palembang, Malacca, Samudera on the northern tip of Sumatra, then Ceylon, and finally
arriving at the great Indian port of Calicut 11 months later on December 10, 1432. Though this
was Zheng He's and the Treasure Fleet's seventh trip to India, it remained rather comical just
how many basic errors they were still making in regards to understanding, well, a lot. Specifically, in terms of culture and religion,
the Ming sailors seemed to have still been under the impression that India was the origin of not
only Buddhism, but also Christianity and Islam. This appears to have been a rather fundamental
misunderstanding of the nature of foreign borders, and the Chinese had just sort of assumed that
India went on to include the whole of the Middle East as well. One such misinformed account in the
Ming Tong Dian declared that India was divided into five parts, central, east, west, south, and north,
naturally. Central India was the country of Buddha. 600 years after the time of Buddha,
quote, Jesus of Western India appeared. This was the religion of the Lord of Heaven. As we've noted before in such accountings,
it's the sort of journal entry that kind of gets the broad strokes sort of right, but it's like looking through a carnival mirror or the mutant phrase that comes
out at the very end of a long game of telephone. What's this place? Um, it's all India? Yeah, sure,
why not? Anyways, having arrived at Calicut, Zheng divided the fleet. The unique lieutenant, Hongbao,
would take the largest portion of the force and sail on to Hormuz and other Arabian city-states,
before heading over to the Swahili coast of Africa once more.
Arriving at Hormuz, the Chinese fleet was dismayed to be informed that they were being turned away
on account of local political instability in the region making it unsafe.
Instead, they made for the Egyptian-held port of Jeddah.
There, they were welcomed by orders of the Sultan of Cairo, and traded for many herbal medicines and curatives, including frankincense, aloe, myrrh, benzoin, storax,
and mamortica seeds. This focus on Arab medicines was at a particularly high point,
as Chinese scholars had only recently translated an Arab medical text, which they called the
hui yao fang, or the pharmaceutical prescriptions of the Muslims.
As for Zheng He himself, though he surely would have dearly wished to visit such places as Mecca
and Medina, both of which were stops on the journey of Hongbao's voyage, and thereby completed
the religious imperative of the pilgrimage to Islam's holiest sites, as his father and
grandfather had each done, it seems that his advanced age and commensurate failing health
halted his progress at Calicut.
There he would remain, waiting for his fleet to return, and eventually return at wood.
However, accounts put it that the Grand Admiral was showing the ravages of time, and a long and hard life had taken its toll.
At some point during the voyage home, he took ill and died.
A life at sea ended at sea. According to Muslim tradition, his body would have been ceremonially washed and cleansed, and then wrapped in white cloth.
Then positioning his head towards Mecca, the Muslim sailors would have together chanted three times,
Allah is great, before committing his body to the waters to which he had devoted his life.
His shoes and a braid of his hair, at his request, were thought to have been brought back to Nanjing and buried near Buddhist caves outside the city.
So it was that in July of 1433, the Ming treasure fleet, minus its admiral, returned to the mouth of the Yangtze to great acclaim, albeit somewhat tempered by the loss of its greatest commander.
The Shunda emperor bestowed the sailors of the fleet with vestments of honor and paper money for their heroic journey. Once again, the Ming court hosted ambassadors from across the known world, who paid great tribute to the might and majesty of imperial China, complete with the
by now expected parade of exotic animals from abroad, Arabian horses, elephants, and of course,
yet another long-necked, spotted, and gracefully gentle Chilin that stayed curiously silent but munched contentedly on leaves by the tongue with his bizarrely long black tongue. As before, officials
memorialize the throne, begging that the emperor take this gift of an auspicious beast as a sign
from heaven of his righteous rule, and hold an official celebration. But again, as before,
and taking a page from his grandfather's playbook, Shrenda demurred. Quote,
I do not care for foreign things. I accept them because they come from afar and show the sincerity
of distant peoples, but we should not celebrate this. End quote. One wonders if the still looming
burned out ruins of the palace complex might have played into that decision at all.
That autumn, four more ambassadorial missions arrived from the South Seas, each bearing with
them yet more exotic and auspicious beasts for the imperial menagerie.
Late in the year as it was, Shrenda invited them to overwinter at the capital, and gifted them all heavy winter clothes.
Nevertheless, Beijing's severe winter would turn out to be too much for at least one of the ambassadors, the younger brother of the King of Sumatra, who succumbed to the cold before spring arrived. He was buried with all due honors,
and a representative was dispatched to the king to personally express the court's sympathy for
the tragic loss. As luck would have it, though, the emissary, a eunuch named Wang Jinghong,
would encounter some sort of fateful difficulty off the coast of Java, resulting in the sinking
of a ship with the loss of all hands, having never delivered the emperor's regrets.
The following year, 1435, would bring even further
tragedy when, after a brief bout of illness, the Xuanda emperor himself died at age 36,
after just a decade on the throne. Though none could know it at the time,
this unexpected loss was down the final death knell for China's overseas adventures as well.
When his own father had died, Xuanda had at least been a grown man of 25,
able to take up the reins of state himself.
On his own deathbed a decade later, Shrenda had no choice of heir except his own eldest of two sons, a boy of just eight named Zhu Qizhen.
And so next time, it will be little Zhu Qizhen who would be enthroned in early February as the Zhengtong Emperor.
But like any child monarch, he would reign, but not rule.
A regency would be put in place,
and one controlled by those Confucian ministers who had long detested the expansionist
and prohibitively expensive voyages.
And together, they'll make sure that the flame
of the treasure fleet voyages would be snuffed out forever.
Thanks for listening. features of Queen Nefertiti. If you have, you'll probably like the History of Egypt podcast.
Every week, we explore tales of this ancient culture. The History of Egypt is available
wherever you get your podcasting fix. Come, let me introduce you to the world of Ancient Egypt.