The History of China - #321 - Opium War 6: Imperial Ouroboros

Episode Date: March 10, 2026

The Ransom of Canton.The lame-duck Superintendent watches helplessly as a triumvirate of Qing officials arrives to reverse every compromise his predecessor had wrought... & promptly launches the most ...ambitious Chinese military operation of the entire war. In the midst of that rain-soaked battlefield, a brief skirmish between British soldiers and peasant militiamen plants the seed of a legend that will haunt Chinese politics for the next century. Time Period Covered:Feb. 1841–Oct. 1841 Major Historical Figures: The Qing Empire:The Daoguang Emperor (Aisin-Gioro Minning) [r. 1820–1850]Yishan, Imperial Commissioner and Pacifier-General of the Rebellious (靖逆) [1790–1878]Longwen, Manchu nobleman and ministerial attaché [d. 1841]Yang Fang, Governor-General and military commander [c. 1770–1846]She Baoshun, Prefect of Canton [fl. 1840s]Yuqian, Imperial Commissioner for Military Operations in Zhejiang [fl. 1841] The British Empire:Queen Victoria [r. 1837–1901]Henry John Temple, 3rd Viscount Palmerston, Foreign Secretary [1784–1865]Charles Elliot, Chief Superintendent of British Trade in China [1801–1875]Sir Henry Pottinger, incoming Plenipotentiary to China [1789–1856]Sir Hugh Gough, Commander of British Land Forces [1779–1869]Captain William Hutcheon Hall, commanding HMS Nemesis [c. 1797–1878] Major Sources Cited:Wakeman, Frederic Jr. "Canton Trade and the Opium War." The Cambridge History of China, Vol. 10.Wakeman, Frederic Jr. Strangers at the Gate: Social Disorder in South China, 1839–1861.Fay, Peter Ward. The Opium War, 1840–1842.Lovell, Julia. The Opium War: Drugs, Dreams and the Making of China. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

Transcript
Discussion (0)
Starting point is 00:00:00 You're listening to an Airwave Media podcast. Walter's Gluward knows the accountant's dinner all too well. Lukewarm coffee, cold takeout, and endless manual data entry. It's time to change the menu. With a tax workflow that actually flows. CCHI firm by Walter's Gluort is built to help you work smarter, file faster, and head home on time. Visit shoptacks. holterscluwer.com to learn more.
Starting point is 00:00:40 Hello and welcome to the history of China. Episode 321, Imperial Oroboros. In settling the barbarian affairs of this time, we are governed at every hand by the inevitable, and we concede that the policy is the least commendable. What we have been doing is to choose between danger and safety, not between right and wrong. Imperial Commissioner Chi Ying
Starting point is 00:01:12 To the Da Wang Emperor 1842 If the rule you followed brought you to this Of what use was the rule? Anton Chigger No country for old men We left off last time With both of the highest-ranking diplomats
Starting point is 00:01:29 of the Qing and British empires That is Imperial Commissioner Chi-Shan and Superintendent of Trade Charles Elliott respectively striving to do their best With the cards that they'd each been done Neither had created the now bellicose and bloodied situation across the Chinese coastline as of 1841, but they had both been charged with finding a solution to it and bringing the dirty business of this so-called opium war
Starting point is 00:01:55 to a swift conclusion before anyone else got hurt or any more national honor was besmirched. Both had played the hands they had been dealt and played them well enough, and both were cast aside as failures for it. One accused of giving up too much, the other of not demanding nearly enough. They were both convenient fall guys for a situation that no one, it seemed, had actually wanted, and yet was by mid-1841 unstoppable.
Starting point is 00:02:29 For Commissioner Chishan, shamed as he was by the throne for having ceded even an inch of sovereign territory to the barbarian aggressors, His censure was at least a relatively immediate process. He was replaced not by another single commissioner, but now a triumvirate, consisting of Daugwang's own distant cousin, Yishan, a hereditary military noble of middling rank and little note, a Manchu nobleman named Long One, and the voluminously decorated governor-general of four provinces and military commander of the two Guangx, Yang Fang, who was by this point past seven. and Stone Death. Together, they would take up the defense that Chishan had apparently failed.
Starting point is 00:03:16 Throughout February, troops continued to pour into Canton. Readouts were built, waterways damned, local militia recruited, and the Cantonese gentry encouraged to prepare for a patriotic defense of the city, end quote. For Charles Elliott, likewise disgraced, but at the other end of the table, His weight, no surprise, was somewhat more grueling. Back home, the Foreign Secretary, Lord Palmerston, had decided that Elliot's bungling had left money on the table, or more accurately, real estate. Inconceivably, Elliot had thought it prudent to exchange the island of Zhou Shan, Paradise of Hongzhou Bay.
Starting point is 00:03:58 For some place near Canton, the locals called Hong Kong, that, as Palmerston himself put it, was nothing more than, quote, a barren island with hardly a house upon it, end quote. It was an unforgivable disregarding of his instructions, and even the young queen herself had put it to her cousin, Leopold, of Belgium, quote, all we wanted might have been got if it had not been for the unaccountably strange conduct of Charles Elliott, end quote. Obviously, as such, he was to be recalled. But all that would have to wait on once again our old friend pre-modern transit time.
Starting point is 00:04:35 While Chishan was dragged off in chains to a swift exile, Elliot was forced to just wait around, literally for the mail to arrive. It would be nearly a year before follow-up instructions, the ones bearing his dismissal, could arrive from London, and, having already gone beyond the bounds of his perceived authority, he felt it best to wait it out, at least in so much as he could. Though his replacement, Henry Pottinger, was appointed in his, In May of 1841, he wouldn't actually arrive to take up his post until that August.
Starting point is 00:05:12 Until then, Elliot waited and watched as the Qing reinforcements in Canton began to arrive and then kept on arriving. This great influx of obvious military buildup could only mean one explosive outcome, but what could Elliot do about it? He was a lame duck, just waiting for the next ride out. He had no formal instructions for next steps, only the ships under his command and his gut feeling. Ironically, most of the activity that Elliot distantly observed with his rising discomfort was in fact due to the arrival of the first of the Qing Triumvars, the stone-deaf septuinarian General Yang Fang.
Starting point is 00:05:58 Yang had taken one look at the absolutely shameful state of Canton and its so-called fortifications, the crumbling walls of the new city, the unmounted five-ton cannons quote-unquote defending the heights, the Navy that simply wasn't, and the pathetic excuses for conscripts being posted as defenders and could do little but despair. He understood at once that should the British really press the issue, virtually any issue, any idea of the defense of Canton against their warships was doomed from the outset. But General Yang was just as much a prisoner of this situation, and his position in it, as anyone else. No matter his personal knowledge, he still had to go through the motions of making ready the port of Canton to repel foreign invaders.
Starting point is 00:06:50 And Elliot wound up taking that personally. From Wakeman, quote, All of this activity convinced Elliot that the convention of Chen B was not being honored. Once again, he moved. his fleet up river, and on 2nd March, after blowing up several forts along the way, reached Canton, and quote. This would be pretty much the effective description for any naval movement by the British over the entire duration of this war, by the way.
Starting point is 00:07:20 They decide to go somewhere, and they go. Nothing can stop them, and they blow some things up along the way. They knew it, the Qing defenders knew it, just about the only one who didn't know it was the doubt. Guang Emperor himself, who was being resolutely shielded from such unpleasantness via his ministers. But General Yang certainly understood the facts of the matter. He, still the only triumvir to actually have reached Canton, had to affect some sort of negotiating position from beneath the barrels of British naval artillery, hopefully, while finding a way to save his own career in the process
Starting point is 00:07:58 by working out some way to frame it as a win for the emperor. And until he could figure out that last part especially, sort of pleasantly mumbling in reports back home. Quote, Yang Feng had no choice but to agree to reopen trade, even though he dared only hint of the agreements in memorials to Beijing. But as unstable as even this temporary stopgap of a truce was, Even it was cut short by the arrival of the two other triumvers, Ishaan and Long One,
Starting point is 00:08:32 to besieged Canton as of mid-April. Fresh from Beijing and fully in line with the hardliners of the capital, who insisted that the empire's honor demanded no less than a full war of extermination against these brazen outsiders. They arrived at the southern coast, took a look at the situation, and promptly decided to flip the whole table over. Quote, Yang Feng had to go along when Ishaan and Long One began to prepare fire rafts and arm more local militias. Thus, when Elliot again saw the truce threatened and demanded an end to these preparations, he received no reply.
Starting point is 00:09:10 Before Elliot could decide upon a course of action, the triumvirate made its move. Imperial cousin Ishaan had been given a special title for this grand campaign of his by the Dao Guang Emperor. The 51-year-old, former governor of Yi Li, had been granted the title Jing-kne, meaning pacifier general of the rebellious, and had received instructions directly from cousin Dao Guang that his mission was to, quote, exterminate the rebels at all points, end quote. It was an order that he took very seriously. The British at Canton were, as ever, vastly outmanned. With the bulk of their military, either garrisoning northerly Jewellery, Sean Island, or, along with the majority of the fleet, still in its capital-bound push,
Starting point is 00:10:00 the remnant force still outside Canton had been itself ravaged by dysentery, dwindling their active-duty roster down to just 2,200 men by May 21st. The British fleet at Wampoa was, in reality, a relatively light-forward force. Two corvettes, the Modest and the Pilates, a brig, the frig, the frigate alligator, and a pair of armed merchant chuners. The Blenheim, a 74-gun ship of the line, was still laboriously feeling her way up river and would not reach her anchorage until that very evening. The real cavalry, in other words, was still more than an hour's ride away.
Starting point is 00:10:39 But on the other hand, the HMS nemesis was also there at anchor, in all her iron-hauled glory. It was no scattered few fire rafts that were launched on Ishawn's order on the night May 21st, but more than 200 of them, chained together in pairs, each packed with raw cotton soaked in oil, floating fire bombs designed to catch on anchor chains and rigging and hold there while they burned. These were floated down the river in darkness, unlit and silent, riding the ebbing tide. The sentry on the Modeste spotted them at barely musket shot distance before they burst into flames. Pairs of them, blazing furiously, bore down on the three warships with no wind to maneuver
Starting point is 00:11:26 and no room to run. Behind the fireboats came the war junks, many dozens of them, likely over a hundred in total, alongside an unknown number of fishing vessels that carried soldiers armed with matchlocks. From the shore, hidden artillery batteries opened up simultaneously, their muzzle flashes staccato illuminating the chaos unfolding beneath them. All the while, Qing soldiers stormed and captured the British factory district. It was a genuine, coordinated, multi-prong assault, and it very nearly worked. Against this night assault, only one British vessel could really respond, but then it was the only
Starting point is 00:12:04 one that really needed to. The nemesis had her boilers constantly fired, and was riding at anchor near the factory stairs. Within 10 minutes of the alarm going up, she had her steam up, the only powered vessel on the water, and began feeling her way westward through the darkness, and the smoke poured the stricken corvettes. That night, the nemesis earned every ounce of her fearsome reputation and namesake. Streaming to and fro with both pivot guns firing, the nemesis drew Chinese fire onto herself and away from the much more helpless sailing vessels beside her, whose wooden hulls would not have been able to shrug off direct hits
Starting point is 00:12:41 the way that an iron steamer could. The Qing battery on Sha Mien proved particularly determined as it peppered the pride of the British Navy with volley after volley. And though she was armoured up tight, given enough time, even in accurate fire, develops a kind of inevitable math all its own. By the time the Gundam placement was silenced, the nemesis had her funnel riddled and both paddle boxes shot through. All repairable damage, but it would take time.
Starting point is 00:13:11 And then, in the darkness on the bridge, a rocket misfired in its launch tube, a hung round, sputtering and threatening to detonate and kill everyone around it, including Elliot himself, who'd insisted on being present for all this. In a fit of heroism that one would really only expect in a movie, the captain of the nemesis, William Hutchin Hall, leapt forth and plunged his arm up the tube to shove the rocket clear before it detonated, badly burning himself in the process, but saving them all. He would go on to even greater fame and glory,
Starting point is 00:13:45 known forever after simply as Nemesis Hall, rising to Admiral and fighting in the Crimean War a decade later, living to 81, and dying at home in 1878. By early morning, the river was quiet once more, though anything but peaceful. A few smoldering husks, some blackened waterfront buildings, bodies on the water. The Chinese had thrown everything they had at the British anchorage in a single coordinated night assault, fireboats, war junks, shore batteries, infantry, and the net result was a riddled funnel, two shot up paddle boxes, and Captain Hall's burned arm. And at what cost? Devastating. Wakeman sums it up, quote, In the ensuing battle, 71 Chinese war junks were destroyed and 60 shore batteries seized,
Starting point is 00:14:35 end quote. To put that into some sort of perspective, the entire naval force that Ishaun had assembled for his grand extermination campaign, the foetilla that had come within a whisker of engulfing the British anchorage and fire, was gone. Not damaged nor scattered, gone. The shore batteries that had peppered the nemesis devastated ruins. And then, under the protection of that same battered but still deadly iron steamer, British troop ships moved around the city to land forces on the northern heights, by the 24th in placing their field guns on the high ground overlooking Canton's old walls. The provincial capital, seat of the governor, the governor general, the Canton treasury, and a half million residents beside lay entirely at the mercy of a handful
Starting point is 00:15:21 of British field guns. It had taken from first fireboat to final battery, a matter of mere hours. In communities across Canada, hourly Amazon employees earn an average of over $24.50 an hour. employees also have the opportunity to grow their skills and their paycheck by enrolling in free skills training programs for in-demand fields like software development and information technology learn more at about amazon dot cae not unreasonably the british were a bit peaved by all this especially given in the estimation of the commanding english general sir hugh gao quote so many chinese breaches of promise end quote as such such Gao wished to immediately move in and occupy the city by force. But the lame duck yet still planetary Elliot, apparently still under the pretension of there being the tacit support of a greater unoffending populace that secretly pined for British liberty, decided against such brutal measures, staying the Field Commander's hand just
Starting point is 00:16:36 outside the old city's walls. Three days later, on May 27th, a convention was signed in which the Qing Triumvirate agreed, along with all extra provincial troops, to evacuate the city. The price of Canton's salvation, $6 million in silver to be delivered within the week. It was, in the most literal sense of the word, a ransom. Half a million people, a provincial capital, priced out and paid for in silver ingots delivered to the decks of British warships. Gow, who had been absolutely certain that he could have had the walls themselves within half an hour. with little loss of life, was frankly apoplectic at being denied the chance.
Starting point is 00:17:19 Yet, he could only watch as the boxes of silver came duly aboard, with what one must imagine the particular expression of a man who's just been robbed of his glory and handed a paycheck instead. One is left to wonder, given the state of the provincial treasury at this point, exactly where that silver came from. The Canton trade system, that is the Kohong merchants, the commercial network, the very apparatus of foreign trade that this whole war had been ostensibly fought over, was the financial bedrock of the entirety of Guangdong province.
Starting point is 00:17:53 It's difficult to imagine the ransom being scraped together without tapping into that. The dragon, in other words, may well have paid its own ransom with money generated by the very trade it had spent years trying to destroy, forced, as it were, to eat its own tail. But the check cleared, transaction complete, and with that, the British filed back onto their ships to await the arrival of Commissioner Elliott's replacement. But the ransom and the British withdrawal didn't mean the countryside around Canton was quiet. Much to the contrary, trouble had been building since the moment Gao's men first occupied the Northern Heights. English patrols ranging out in search of food had helped themselves to rather more than provisions.
Starting point is 00:18:45 Quite a few of them wound up going full Indiana Jonesing. Sacred temples were entered, tombs cracked open and their contents examined with the cheerfully destructive, almost naive curiosity that really is quintessentially defined by a British man in khaki wearing a pith helmet. And the longer it went on, the worse and darker,
Starting point is 00:19:07 it all quickly became. It got to the point that Elliot himself felt compelled to issue warnings to his Indian camp followers about their behavior. The repository newspaper spoke darkly of, quote, doings of which it is a shame to speak, end quote. All the makings of a tenderbox, in other words, were being packed tight and soaked in oil. The match came on May 29th when an English patrol entered a Chinese hand. called San Yuan Li, just a few short miles northwest of the city proper and presided to attack the women therein. The local gentry of the San Yuanli area had already been organizing. The day
Starting point is 00:19:52 Gao's men first appeared on the Northern Heights, a dozen notables from the district had met, laid plans, and sworn blood oaths. They went out to rouse the countryside, one more than ready to be roused. What assembled in response was not a mob, or not merely so. It was something older, more deliberate, village militias marching under their own banners, each inscribed with the characters for righteous people and the name of the village that had sent them. At their head flew a common flag, black in order to ward off evil spirits, taken from the Buddhist temple at Sanyuan Lee itself. These were people with a martial tradition, in a province where clan warfare was endemic, and villages have been building
Starting point is 00:20:38 walls and collecting arms against each other for generations. Commissioner Linza Shoe may indeed have been onto something when he tried to organize them earlier on. Now, even without any official sanction, they were organizing themselves and marched out against the incursion. By the time Gao looked north on the morning of May 30th, he could make out masses of men assembling in the heights, armed with the same. with cudgels, hoes, some swords and spears, and even the occasional matchlock. They were making little secret of themselves. They waved banners and shouted cheers, jeers, and fighting slogans. Gao put their number at first at about 4,000, and then later revised that
Starting point is 00:21:21 figure up to seven. He sent two lieutenants forward with 700 men to disperse this rabble, and at first it went easily enough. The Chinese gave ground, scattered, seemed to melt away. But then the storm broke, literally. Without warning, and all at once, a torrent fell upon them, one at all, amidst thunder that shook the ground and lightning that turned the paddies into a stroving sea of silver. Visibility dropped to 20 feet or less. The rice fields flooded almost instantly. Raised pathways between the patties, the only navigable routes, became single-file death traps. The majority of the British arms were still the older model Brown Bessie Flintlocks, which became in the space of minutes so inundated
Starting point is 00:22:08 that they couldn't even be fired, rendering them little more than very expensive clubs. The Chinese, armed with weapons that largely did not require dry powder, turned and came on back. What followed was a series of confused and desperate little engagements in the darkness and rain. Chinese ambushes, flanking attacks, dragging men off the raised paths and into the flooded patties. One company of sepoys from the 37th found itself completely cut off, stumbling through water in the dark with their muskets useless and Chinese militiamen closing in from all sides. What saved them proved to be sheer stubbornness. They formed a defensive square and stood fast in the rain,
Starting point is 00:22:52 holding out until two companies and Marines with their new 1839 pattern percussion muskets, which worked in the wet, found them and fought them out. One man was killed and a dozen other seriously wounded, but all in all, the unit was rescued. Gao's total casualties across the entire San Yuen Li incident, two officers, and 12 others in the ranks dead. By any military accounting, nothing more than a minor skirmish. The peasants, with their hoes and Maddox and Shepherds' crooks, could not break the British force, had not driven them into the city, had not massacred anyone. On May 31st, the area prefect named Shebao Shun arrived in person, accompanied pointedly by a British officer, and told the notables at the head of this self-styled army of righteousness that a peace had been signed
Starting point is 00:23:43 and that the English must be allowed to leave unmolested. One by one the notables in their forces withdrew, and the great crowd of peasants drifted away. But with them, the seeds of a story that quickly grew into legend. It spread from village to village, fast as muddied boots could carry it. Thousands of Fan Guay, literally barbarian devils, killed by brave patriots. A general slain, a man with a head as big as a bucket. The foreign devils driven in terror toward the provincial city, surely would have been cornered and annihilated entirely every last one of them.
Starting point is 00:24:22 Had the officials not stepped in and betrayed the people themselves right at the cusp of total victory. Shebao Xun, the man who had, under the direct and very realistic threat of total annihilation of half a million residents of Canton, dispersed the militia specifically to save both the city and the militiamen themselves. But he would not be remembered as a savior. Instead, he was remembered as a traitor who had sold out his country. There is a specific word for this in Chinese, Han Tian, literally traitor of the
Starting point is 00:24:57 Han people, utilizing the character for betrayal with a specifically sexual connotation of illicit collaboration or conjoining, as if the mere act of dealing pragmatically with foreigners was itself a kind of violation. The term had existed before, but it was in this period, as foreign aggression began to carve into the very idea of Chinese sovereignty, that the epithet Heung Jian acquired the full weight of its modern meaning. a Chinese person who carries on an illicit relationship with the enemy against the country. Shoubao Shun hadn't invented the accusation, but he was one of its earliest victims in this new and
Starting point is 00:25:40 sharper form. The militiamen who'd withdrawn, sullenly convinced that they could have won, went home and told the story of what they believed had happened, and the story grew with every telling. Canton believed it immediately. Beijing heard it. The Governor General of Fujian and Zhigang implored the Emperor to raise similar armies of righteousness all across the empire. Within a generation, San Yuen Li had entered the realm of patriotic legend. What Wakeman calls in strangers at the gate, quote, A bunker hill and an alamo rolled into one. End quote.
Starting point is 00:26:19 But Wakeman sees something else in San Yen Li, too. Something darker and more consequential than the legend itself. The pattern established in those flooded patties outside Canton in May 1841 would repeat itself across China for the next 70 years and beyond. The well-meaning local official, fully aware of what price the European gunboats anchored outside his Yaman window could extract, ordering the righteously angry but effectively powerless crowd to disperse and being branded a traitor for it, the gentry proclamations at his gate blazoning his treachery.
Starting point is 00:26:57 The foreign missionaries he protected from the righteous mob, becoming evidence of his corruption. And as such incidents multiplied and local officials could no longer be only individually blamed, well, logically, the accusations crept upward, ultimately to the dynasty itself. A foreign ruling house, the Manchus, appeasing the barbarians to save their own skin at the expense of the greater whole of the Chinese people. The long latent anti-Manchuism had never fully gone away, now found in each new incident fresh confirmation of its own truth.
Starting point is 00:27:37 To be clear, San Yen Li was not the Taipei Rebellion, nor the Boxer Uprising, nor the Sheenhai Rebellion of 1911. But it was a precursor. The peasants with their black flag and their blood oaths and absolute conviction that they had won and been betrayed. from within, would all serve as a dark template for the remainder of the century, and much of the one to follow it, to iterate upon. The officials caught between gunboats and mobs were the ancestors of every Qing administrator
Starting point is 00:28:11 who would find himself ground between the same old millstones. And the dynasty that could neither satisfy bottomless foreign avarice, nor protect its own people from them, was already, as of May 1841, walking the road that would end up to the road that would end for them in 1911. Of any of this, the British had no idea and little interest. Though a bit sorry that they hadn't been allowed to storm Canton's walls, they were pleased enough with their $6 million to say that they'd gotten what they'd wanted, what was due to them, and thus made plans to go on and move the expedition north. That decision was ratified as of August 10, 1841, with the long-awaited arrival of Pottinger,
Starting point is 00:28:56 Hong Kong to relieve Elliot of his command. Far from alone, he'd come in at the head of a full reinforcement force, consisting of 25 ships of the line, 14 steamers, nine support vessels, and troop ships carrying 10,000 fresh soldiers from India. Pottinger's first real stop after his arrival was up the coast to Amoy in Fujian, today called Xiamun, with 2,000 troops. Wakeman notes Riley that, quote,
Starting point is 00:29:25 the commander of the region, Yanbo Shoe, should have been eager to see them, because he had already persuaded the Emperor to spend two million tails on defense there. 50 large junks, the impregnable forts, and 9,000 infantry were supposed to shatter the English forces as soon as they approached, end quote. And upon arrival, the British did indeed find Amoy a tough little nut to crack. Quote, Admiral Parker did find the granite ramparts impenetrable to his shells, end quote. But as ever, a little leverage in the right place can move mountains, or in this case, silence defensive batteries. Unable to keep up a sustained and concentrated enough pattern of fire to prevent Pottinger's Marines from making landfall, the Qing fixed artillery emplacements
Starting point is 00:30:16 were soon flanked and then captured. The next part of the operation, however, was going to a real doozy. Or at least it should have been. The city itself lay behind a narrow and easily defended pass. So simply fortify that and you're all bottled up, safe and sound, no matter what might be going on at sea. Unfortunately, for all his boasting and extensive preparation time, Yon had apparently never thought to, well, defend the narrow and easily defended pass. As such, the British were once again able to slip through, occupy the hilltops surrounding the city, set up their own field guns, and the next day, just march in. Amoy was taken, with the British reporting losses of two dead and 15 wounded. After installing a garrison
Starting point is 00:31:08 force of his own, the next priority target was, of course, the island of Doshan at the mouth of Hangzhou Bay. Here, General Gao advised. caution since he knew that the Chinese had heavily reinforced their defenses across the island when they'd taken it back following the initial ceasefire. And though Gao's caution proved warranted, he was himself wounded in the attack and two of his men killed, the island fell once more to the British just three days after their initial advanced recon. It was also around this time that Charles Elliott finally received what he'd been waiting for. The letter for, the letter for, the letter for from London arrived at last, bearing, as expected, his dismissal. After nearly a year of lame
Starting point is 00:31:55 duck limbo, watching the war he'd tried so hard to prevent grind on without him, he at last handed over formal command to Pottinger and made his departure. His next posting, charged affair to the newly independent Republic of Texas. He left behind a war that he hadn't wanted, a Hong Kong he'd negotiated and then been punished for. and a China that would spend the next century living with the consequences of a peace that he'd tried to make before anyone else got hurt. History would not be especially kind to Charles Elliott, but then history is rarely kind to the people who try to stop things. With Elliot gone and Pottinger now firmly in command, the expedition pressed on.
Starting point is 00:32:41 The nearby port of Ningboa, once taken, would give Pottinger complete control of that whole stretch of the Jijon coast. The fort at Jun Hai guarding the river mouth fell first on October 10th. Three days later, the British force moved upriver to Ningbo itself. The Imperial Commissioner for Military Operations in the province, Yu Qian, had been preparing his own defense, but he need not have bothered. By the time word reached him that his city's cannon had overheated and his troops had fled without firing a shot,
Starting point is 00:33:13 he was already composing himself for the only honorable exit that he could still immer. imagine. Somewhere in the city, in a room no doubt quiet and orderly and very far from the river, Yu Qian attempted to take his own life. He did not succeed, and history would make him answer for that failure later. On Ningbo's broad walls all the while, the bandsmen of the Royal Irish Guard struck up, God save the Queen. Two realities, one man in a room trying to die with dignity, another on the ramparts raising a baton in victory, occupying the same city at the same moment. Neither aware of the other, neither needing to be. The war had long since stopped being a conversation between two civilizations and become something else entirely.
Starting point is 00:34:03 A demonstration, conducted largely in the language of canon and occupation, of a power differential so total that the two sides could no longer even share the same understanding of what we were. was even happening to them. Ningboa became Pottinger's winter headquarters. The expedition rested, refitted, and waited for reinforcements from India. The Daugong Emperor, receiving the news of yet another fallen city, made a decision that would define the final act of this war. But that's a story that we'll get into next time.
Starting point is 00:34:37 The ransom of Canton, Sanyuan and Lee, the slow grinding advance up the coast. By the close of 1841, the pattern of this war had become almost numbingly familiar. The British arrived somewhere, the Chinese tried to defend it with everything they have, the British take it anyway, and another report of catastrophic defeat makes its way north to an emperor who's being carefully shielded from the full weight of what any of it really means. Amoy, Zhou Shan, Ningboe, each one falling in turn, each one, all in all, just another brick pulled from the wall. But the Daugwang Emperor had not given up.
Starting point is 00:35:17 Far from it. The fall of Ningboa, he had decided, was not a catastrophe. It was actually an opportunity. The barbarians had now committed themselves to land warfare. And that was China's forte. What he needed was not another coastal defense, but a proper, organized, massively coordinated imperial military campaign. the kind that crushed rebellions and pacified frontiers across centuries of dynastic history.
Starting point is 00:35:47 And he had just the man for it, another of his endless supply of imperial cousins, because of course it was. This one's name was I Ching. He was an excellent calligrapher. He'd previously served as director of the Imperial Gardens and hunting parks. He had never commanded troops in battle in his... life, but he was absolutely certain, certain in the way that only a man completely insulated from reality can be certain, that he alone could and would destroy the British expedition entirely. Next time, the spring counteroffensive, the Tiger Hour, and the last real hope for any kind
Starting point is 00:36:32 of an honorable peace. Thanks for listening. Shush! William Shatner has something to say. Cat and Jethro, Box of Oddities. The show is examined weird things. What do you do when the woman you love dies? Well, of course, you dig her up and you live with her. Aw. That is really mysterious.
Starting point is 00:37:00 The strange, the bizarre, the unexpected. Cat and Jethro, Box of Oddities. Listen on Spotify or wherever you get your podcasts. The Box of Oddities.

There aren't comments yet for this episode. Click on any sentence in the transcript to leave a comment.