The History of China - #330 - Taiping 7: Beneath the Walls of Changsha

Episode Date: May 23, 2026

The Heavenly Host has arrived at the great provincial capital of Hunan - Changsha. The mighty bastion that will prove to be the first city on the long march north that simply refuses to fall. For two months in late 1852, the largest army the Taiping has yet fielded throws everything it knows at these walls... but the city endures. This is the story of the underground war fought by nameless men in the dark Time Period Covered: Oct. – Dec. 1852 Major Historical Figures: Taiping Heavenly Kingdom: Hong Xiuquan, Heavenly King, Second Son of God [1814–1864] Yang Xiuqing, East King, Voice of God the Father [d. 1856] Xiao Chaogui, West King, Voice of Jesus Christ [d. 1852] Shi Dakai, Wing King [1831–1863] Qing Dynasty: Luo Bingzhang, Governor of Hunan [1793–1867] Zeng Guofan, Commissioner of Local Defence for Hunan [1811–1872] Major Sources Cited: Kuhn, Philip A. "Ch. 6, The Taiping Rebellion" in The Cambridge History of China, Vol. 10. Platt, Stephen R. Autumn in the Heavenly Kingdom. Spence, Jonathan D. God's Chinese Son: The Taiping Heavenly Kingdom of Hong Xiuquan. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

You're listening to an Airwave Media podcast. Every Tuesday, we talk security and privacy on security. Now, hi, this is Leo Lipport, inviting you to join me and Steve Gibson this week as we talk about Microsoft's changes in their edge browser, not going to leave passwords in plain text anymore, and apparently serious zero point quantum vacuum energy source. Can that be real? And then AI models designed to improve security, not just from Anthropic, but a very point quantum vacuum energy source. to improve security, not just from Anthropic, but OpenAI and Microsoft too. All of that this week on Security Now. You'll find it at twit.tv slash SN or wherever you get your podcasts.

Hello and welcome to the history of China. Episode 3.30, beneath the walls of Changsha, war is the truest form of divination. It is the testing of one's will and the will of another within that larger will, which because it binds them is therefore forced to select. War is the ultimate game, because war is at last a forcing of the unity of existence. Cormac McCarthy, Blood Meridian. After 10 days of marching out from Tunjo, an army stood before the walls of the great provincial capital, Changsha. In the October chill of 1852, this Taiping army, this heavenly host, had swelled to numbers

unimaginable even a year prior. 20,000 had seemed impossibly huge back in Guangxi, yet now they numbered somewhere between 80 to 100, possibly even 120,000. Their recruitment efforts across southern Hunan had yielded a copious bounty. And behind this land-bound river of Seoul, the Taiping fleet stretched back for miles, carrying munitions, dependents, treasure, and the accumulated weight of a movement that had been in motion for nearly two years. with neither rest nor home. They now stood a raid before the walls of this great provincial capital,

come to finish what the West King had died starting. Xiao Tiao Gwe had reached those same walls on September 12th, with 2,000 men and zero prior authorization. He had pounded the southern face with cannon and explosive for six days, and come shockingly close to taking it. But on September 17th, a marksman on those walls had ended all that. When word reached Hong Xiu Quan, his doubts were put to an end. Vengeance would be theirs.

The army would march. Somewhere outside those walls, the West King lay fallen. There could be no dignified retrieval, no ceremony, no moment of formal mourning at the walls, at least not yet. The city that had killed him still stood, and that meant it had to be dealt with first. Yet the city staring down from its walls at this heavenly host was no longer the one that Xiao had attacked. That city had been caught off guard, walls manned thin, garrisons spread across a defense that nobody had really expected to need.

What had nearly fallen to 2,000 men in a week of impetuous assaults had been genuinely vulnerable. And therein lay the irony that would overshadow the entire siege. Xiao's near success had destroyed the conditions that had made his near success possible in the first place. The alarm his assault had raised had gone all the way to Beijing. The state jolted into focus, had poured resources into Changsha at a speed that it had not managed anywhere else in 18 months of fighting this war. By the time that Hong's army arrived, the garrison had swelled to 30,000, and then 50,000. Heavy cannon newly mounted on the walls.

with all the gunpowder and shot that could be imported. The Taiping may have expected to ride upon a city battered and weakened by the fallen king's assault. What they found awaiting them instead was the strongest defensive position that the Qing Dynasty had managed to yet assemble since Jin Tian. And commanding those walls and its defenders was none other than the governor of Hunan itself, Loh Bing Zhang. Loa, as it so happened, had also been born in Hua County, the Heavenly King's own home county, those same gently rolling plains of paddy fields north of Canton. That narrow geographic quirk, however, was just about all that the two had in common. In every other sense, they were products of two entirely different relationships with the world

and the powers that governed it. Lua was 20 years Hong senior. He'd done what Hong had spent his entire adult life trying and failing to do. He passed his imperial examinations. And not just passed, but excelled, at every level of the same. systems challenge. From district examination in Hua County, upward through the prefectural and provincial rounds, to the national capital, where in 1832 he attained the topmost degree of Jin Shi, ranking 27th in the second class, and earning the distinction of being

the highest scoring candidate from all of Guangdong province. For this, he was selected for the Hanlin Imperial Academy in Beijing, the Empire's finishing school for its most promising scholars, the institution from which the highest officials were drawn. Scholarly, honest, meticulous, he had risen steadily through the ranks of the Qing bureaucracy across the same years that Hong had been dreaming, preaching, traveling the Guangxi hills, and gathering the godworshors on Thistle Mountain. At almost exactly the moment, Hong Xiu-Cen had donned his yellow robe at Jin Tian and proclaimed himself the heavenly king, Lo-Bing Zhang was appointed governor of Hunan and posted to Changsha.

Two lives beginning in the same place, seeking parallel paths, had somehow both arrived via opposite trajectories, now opposing each other at the same set of walls. The Shan Feng Emperor had blamed Law personally for the Taiping's continual advances through southern Hunan. It was not, in truth, an entirely unfair assessment. The province had indeed been penetrated by the rebel force. Xiao's attack had nearly succeeded. The administrative response had been quite slow up to this point. During another reign, in another crisis, a governor who had presided over such failures might have been recalled in disgrace and replaced. Just ask Lin Zeshu.

But the Qing in 1852 could not afford that kind of ideological tidiness. They needed law right where he was. So the court did what it had learned to do when it needed somebody's competence, but also needed to register its displeasure with him. It dismissed him from the office, but retained him at the post. The new governor was formally appointed on paper. Loa received a special commission as coordinator of the Changsha defenses, which meant that he was doing exactly what he'd already been doing,

but under a different title, and with the added indignity of having been officially blamed for it. In essence, bad job, keep it up, get back to work. Loa seems to have accepted this with the equanimity of a man who understood that the Empire's survival mattered more than his own personal pride. A vengeful army masked outside your city gates does tend to necessitate that sort of clarity of thinking. Which does raise a question that the sources don't fully answer, but the pattern of the previous two years makes it possible to address honestly. Where exactly was Hong Xiu-Chen during all of this? He wasn't at the walls, not directing the assaults. He wasn't out in the field with his generals.

By the autumn of 1852, the division of labor inside the Taiping leadership had become fully established, and it was a division that would only deepen with time. Huang Xiu-Cuan was the heavenly king, the theological center of the movement, its legitimating source, its very reason for existing. Yang Xiu-ching, the East King, the voice of God the Father, was the movement's operational commander in everything but formal title. The proclamations issued during the Hunan March had gone out in Yang's name and shows, not in Hongs. The tactical decisions, where to march, when to engage, how to manage the triad recruits, what to do at Chunjo when the army stalled, those had been Yang's to make, or made in the name of God the father speaking through Yang's mouth, which was pretty much the same thing.

The problem, one that would continue to grow more acute with each passing year, was that heaven sure seemed to be taking its sweet time. Changsha was supposed to fall. The movement's entire theological logic required that it fall. God had commissioned Hong Xiu-chan to take China for the true faith, had sent him visions and a sword and a mandate of heaven in the most literal possible form. Two thousand years of Christian prophecy, filtered through Liang Afa's tracks and Hong's own febrile interpretations pointed toward exactly this kind of conquest. Righteous armies pitted against demonic walls and the chosen people breaking through. And yet, the walls held. The tunnels, in time, would be smashed and their breaches sealed. Fifty thousand defenders were planished by relief

columns that Hong's generals could not intercept, kept filling the gaps. What does a man do with that? What does the second son of God tell himself when God is apparently not cooperating with the plan? The sources don't give us Hong's private thoughts during the siege of Changsha. But the pattern of his behavior afterwards, the increasing withdrawal into theology and proclamation, and away from operational reality, suggests that Changsha deeply registered in him. The movement had faced setbacks before, the Gwe Lin failure, the Soy-Yi-Ford ambush, the devastating loss of Feng Yun Shan. But those were moments of violence and chaos.

Changsha was something different. Two months of systematic, organized, and determined effort conducted by the largest army the movement had ever yet fielded, against a city that simply refused to fall. That's a very different kind of test for a man who believes that God has given him a commission. The Taiping found that they could not go through the walls. They had cannon, but not the weight of cannon required to batter down stone of this thickness

or against defenders who were this ready for them. They couldn't go over them. The walls were 40 feet high and bristling with those same defenders. They couldn't go around because Changsha was the objective, not an obstacle on the way to one. But there was still one other option, and one thing that they did have an abundance were minors. Over the course of their time in Yongan, the type of their time in Yongan, the type of kings had recruited more than a thousand experienced miners to their cause, men who had worked the silver loads and coal seams of Guangxi, who understood rock and soil and the geometry

of underground space. Thousands more joined in Hunan. And gunpowder, once in scarce supply, was no longer a problem thanks largely to their triad member's connections, bringing along now massive new stores. The way to defeat the walls of Changsha, they decided, would be to go under them. Excavation began immediately. From positions outside the southern and eastern walls, Taiping mining teams drove tunnels into the ground at oblique angles, curving inward toward the base of the walls, aiming for their foundations. The work was slow, dangerous, and conducted under constant threat. Not from above, at least not yet, but from the earth around them itself, which could shift, collapse, fill with water, or simply refuse to cooperate with them.

The miners worked in shifts round the clock, in near total darkness, passing Earth back through the tunnel in baskets, shoring the ceiling with timber, moving by feel and experience and the faint sound of their own breathing. Within the walls, the defenders heard them coming. Not with certainty at first, not with the clear knowledge of exactly where the burrowing was happening or how close it had come by now. But sound travels through earth in ways that it does not travel. through air. And given enough time, the Qing garrison developed a counter.

They sink great wooden vats into the ground at intervals along the interior base of the walls, deep enough that the open mouth of each vat pressed against the soil. Into these vats, they placed listeners. They used blindmen, whose other senses had sharpened in compensation for what they lacked, whose ears had grown, as Spence puts it, quote, unusually acute, end quote. These men crouched in the dark inside their vats and listened to the earth, and when they heard the distant, rhythmic, unmistakable sounds of digging, they reported the direction and the distance to the garrison troops above, a pre-industrial, human-powered sonar machine.

For their part, the typing knew that this was happening, or at least suspected it, because they constructed their own counter-counter-measure. Their response was the drums. All along the outside of the walls, day and night, typing drummers beat a constant rolling thunder. Not a battle signal or call to arms, just pure noise, an arrhythmic cacophony designed to travel to the ground and drown out the sound of their own miners. To fill the earth itself with sound and blind the blind men. It was a good strategy, but it would not prove to be enough. As each tunnel neared completion, the garrison troops moved with haste to try to locate it. What followed when they succeeded was as swift as it was terrible. Huge iron balls were dropped through shafts punched down from

above, smashing into the tunnel roof and crushing whatever and whoever was beneath. Or the tunnel was flooded, either with water if it was available, or with something worse. The exhausted sappers, who had spent days or weeks in darkness driving a single tunnel toward its goal, were either flushed out, drowned, or buried alive. It's rather horrific to consider what it was like for them inside those tunnels. Working in shifts for weeks, in near total darkness, in a space barely wide enough to even turn oneself around, the air grew stale as the tunnel deepened, thin and close, tasting of the earth itself. They had to move by touch and memory, the careful rhythm of men who'd spent their working lives and minds and knew how to read the

ground around them. They were many of them, exactly what they appeared to be, professional miners, who'd chosen this work because it was the work that they knew, and who'd joined a movement that promised them something better than a lifetime underground, only to find themselves underground yet again, in a tunnel beneath an enemy city, listening for the sound of descending iron balls. When the garrison located a tunnel, when the blind men in their vats went still and pointed, and the soldiers above began to dig their counter shaft, there was sometimes warning, a vibration in the earth, a change in the sound of the ground above.

Experienced miners could feel when something was wrong before they could even quite name what it was. Whether that warning came in time depended on how close the garrison had tracked them, how quickly the counter shaft came down, and how far the tunnel was from its nearest exit shaft. When it didn't come in time, death arrived from above. The iron balls, each one heavy enough to require two men to lift, dropped through the shaft and into the tunnel, and whatever was beneath them ceased to be. If the balls missed or the tunnel was too deep, they would flood it.

The men who didn't make it out were not typically recorded by name. They're listed in the sources merely as sappers, miners, casualties of the tunnel operations. Numbers implied by the loss of seven tunnels out of ten, each one representing days of labor and an unknown count of dead. The Taiping kept meticulous records of many things. The names of the men killed underground at Changsha were apparently not among them, or if they were, those records have not survived. What did survive, though, was the work itself.

Though seven of the tunnels were successfully intercepted and destroyed, three were completed. The men who dug those three carried their charges to the foundations of the walls, laid them, and then withdrew and set the fuses. The explosions that followed brought down stretches of stone that had stood for generations. It's likely that most of them did not even live to see whether their work was enough. By the time the assault troops went through the breach, the miners were already back in their camps, already dead, or already on to digging another tunnel. But Chongshan managed to hold on. The garrison of 50,000 proved more than enough to seal a breach before it became a route. The typing could not surround the city completely.

Relief columns kept arriving through the gaps of their encirclement, replenishing what the explosions took away. The stone walls would come down in sections. But the city would remain. What the typing were learning week by week in the mud outside of Changsha was this. An army that cannot surround a city, cannot starve it, cannot silence it, cannot stop it from being fed or reinforced or held. They could open up breaches in the walls all they liked. Governor Luo would simply fill those gaps.

Visit BetMGM Casino and check out the newest exclusive, the Price is Right Fortune Pick. BetMGM and GameSense remind you to play responsibly. 19 plus to wager. Ontario only. Please play responsibly. If you have questions or concerns about your gambling or someone close to you, please contact connects Ontario at 1-866-531-2,600 to speak to an advisor. Free of charge.

BetMGEMG operates pursuant to an operating agreement with Eye Gaming Ontario. But the mining war was not the only war being fought. While the sappers dug, the rest of the Taiping above ground, busied themselves solving a different problem. One, once again, that the geography of Changsha forced upon them. The Shang River ran along the city's western face, fast and wide. A natural moat that no tunnel could possibly answer. Any force that held the eastern approaches but left the river open, left the city a lifeline.

Reinforcements could simply arrive by water, along with supplies, and the siege could be sustained indefinitely from the south. Thus, the Shang itself had to be brought under control. The solution that they came up with was a pontoon bridge. They built it across the full width of the river in two long reaches, spanning the Shang at a point that gave their forces communication across the water and access to a narrow island that sat just west of the city walls. From that island, Taiping troops could watch the river, intercept boats moving north with reinforcements, and threaten the western walls directly. The bridge connected the two halves of the besieging force, eastern and western, into a single, coordinated body. Without it, the siege would have been two separate operations with no real way to reinforce each other.

With it, the Taiping had something at least approaching a coherent encirclement, even if it did remain incomplete to the north. Shidakai held the Western Front. The Wing King, just 20, yet already the movement's most consistently capable features, Field commander, kept Qing relief forces occupied west of the city, preventing them from reinforcing the garrison directly. This was the same type of work he'd been doing since Guangxi, holding ground others couldn't, buying time for the larger operation to grind forward. His presence on the Western Front meant that Governor Loh could not simply draw on the surrounding

countryside at will. Every column that might have marched into Changsha had to first reckon with Shi Da Kai. None of this proved enough to take the city, though. But maybe that's the wrong frame for what was actually happening at Changsha. The Taiping had arrived in October as an enormous and fast-moving force that had never yet been stopped. They'd taken cities by assault, surprise, and sheer momentum, Yongan, Daojo, Chenjo, and a dozen smaller places along the Hunan march. They'd never been forced to contend with this form of warfare, though.

It's a very different set of needs and problems to sit with an army of 100,000 in front of a city for months. Dig coordinated tunnels, build floating bridges across a major river all while under fire, and hold a Western front at the same time. The siege of Changsha demanded that the Taiping learn all of that in real time. And they were consistently foiled by superior Qing countermeasures, but they would prove to be quick learners. By late November 1852, two months into a siege that had produced no breakthrough and little prospect of one, Hong Shuo Tuan at last gave the order to abandon the siege of Changsha.

This was not phrased as retreat and not experienced as a defeat, at least not altogether. The typing had come to a city that they could not take, had thrown everything that they knew at it, had learned things that they hadn't known before, and were now leaving it standing. That was a failure by any military accounting, but they were not leaving empty-handed. They were leaving unbroken and with valuable experience. The order came down, as ever, through Yang Xiu-Ching. The siege was over, and the army would move. What that meant in practice for an army of 100,000 people was organized chaos on a scale that defied any easy description.

This was not a force that could simply turn around on a dime in March. By late 1852, the Taiping were not merely an army. They were a mobile city, a portable civilization carrying everything that they owned. They were both soldiers and their families. There were women's battalions organized and marching separately. The elderly, the young, the wounded from two months of assault operations, craftsmen and cooks and administrators, and the theological functionaries that a movement with the ambitions of a dynasty necessarily accumulated.

There were the boats, thousands of them now, lashed together in the wharves or anchored in a maze of waterways around the city, all now being loaded and organized and provisioned for their move further north. The Qing garrison watched all this from its walls and made no effort to pursue. This was no act of cowardice, it was arithmetic. Fifty thousand defenders inside a city, facing an army of 100,000 withdrawing in good order, with Shedakhai's forces still holding the Western approaches, had no reason to come out from behind their walls and test their look. Lo-Bing Zhang had held Changsha. That was his job. He had no mandate to chase the Taiping into Hunan's interior, and no confidence that his garrison, swollen as it was with recent recruits and exhausted from two months of siege defense, was even capable of winning a pitched battle

in open country. As such, he did the smart thing and let them go. The Taiping broke camp in stages across several days in late November. The land forces moving first with the fleet following and organized sections. It was the kind of operation that two years prior would have been light years beyond their capabilities. The coordination of land and river forces at this scale across this geography required exactly the kind of institutional capacity that the Yong'an Investiture and the Hunan March had been building all this time. As such, they were able to move north without any significant harassment or delay.

For many within the ranks, this departure must have carried a complicated weight. Changsha was the first city that had beaten them. The movement's entire march from Guangxi had been a sequence of victories. Walls falling, cities taken, Qing armies scattering before them. Two months outside of Changsha had introduced something new to the experience of the heavenly kingdom, the specific exhaustion of sustained failure. They would carry that with them going north, along with their newly very much bolstered, fleet. And that's worth taking a minute to linger upon.

During the two months outside the walls, the Taiping had acquired something that would matter more than anything else Changsha had offered. Thousands of boats, seized from the city's wharves, captured from the maze of connecting streams and rivers that laced the countryside around the Great Capital, were now all in Tai Ping hands. The river fleet that had trailed behind the army on the march from Guangxi had been little more than a supply line. What they had the makings of now was something altogether else. The coordination of a mobile floating fortress with land forces, with cannon that could be moved swiftly from boat to shore and back again. The river would no longer just be a road for them. It could be a weapons platform.

By the winter of 1852, the Taiping were developing the institutional architecture of a real military. Each unit of the fleet had its flags. The forward sections flew triangular red flags from their mastheads, the center sections yellow, the rear sections black. At night, sound signals replaced sight. Two drumbeats at regular intervals for the lead ship. One gong stroke from the command ship carrying heavy cannon.

Three drum beats for the rear guard. Ships always anchored in lines. Guns were kept cleared, pointed up or downstream. Small patrol boats moved through the. the fleet after dark carrying lanterns, vigilant for spies or fires. Shore patrols echoed the same vigilance, each soldier carrying a gong, because horns had been abandoned after it was noted that soldiers frightened by approaching enemies sometimes lost the ability to blow a clear call. The horn, in other words, depended on one's personal courage. The gong did not. This is what two months

outside of Changsha produced ultimately. Not a fallen city, but a for a foreign city. But a force that was thinking harder and more systematically about how war worked than any Chinese rebel army had in living memory. The army moved north. Behind them, Changsha still stood intact, its walls bearing the scars of three completed tunnels, its garrison still at 50,000, Governor Luo Bing Zhang still at his post. He had held what he was given to hold, and he would hear about the Taiping again in time. That previous July, while the the Taiping were still marching north through Hunan, while Shao Cao Guay was still alive and Changsha still unthreatened. A Hunani scholar official named Zheng Guo Fan requested permission to visit his home district of

Xiang Xiang. He'd been in Jiangxi supervising the provincial examinations. The visit was long planned, and the Taiping invasion of Hunan gave it added urgency. He wanted to look in on the local defense arrangements. It was at that point a modest intention. Then, on route home, he received news of his mother's death. He changed course and went straight to Shang Shang in order to mourn. He was still there in December of 1852, still mourning, still at home, when the court appointed him, Commissioner of Local Defense for Hunan. The Taiping had by then already left Changsha.

The siege was over, and the army somewhere north of Yuezhou, moving fast toward Wu Chang. Zheng Guo Fan arrived at his new responsibilities to find the immediate crisis already gone. What he found instead in Xiang Shang Shang was the beginning of something. Local gentry had already organized defense associations during the Taiping March, small bands of mercenaries led by men like scholar Lo Zanan and his student Wang Zhen, who had been mobilizing fighters and looking for opportunities to campaign. The raw material was already there. What it lacked was someone who could think clearly about what an army actually needed to be.

Zeng could see what the imperial court in Beijing could not. The Twainlian Framework, the Commissioner of Local Defense role that he'd just been given, was designed for small-scale local militarization, village defense associations, the maintenance of order at the county level. It was wholly unequal to what the Tai Ping represented as a threat. The Banner Armies and Green Standard Forces had demonstrated that conclusively across two years of consistent failure. What was needed now was not more of the same, just organized a little bit differently. What they needed now was something built on entirely different principles.

When it appointed him, the court had no idea that he was thinking in this way. They believed that they were simply managing the existing militarization, channeling it through a trusted metropolitan, an official, keeping it under control, and preventing it from becoming inconveniently powerful. Zheng accepted the appointment, said the right things, and then began doing something else altogether different. He summoned the Xiangshang mercenaries to Changsha, with Lozun on at their head, as a nucleus of what he intended to be a professional provincial army. Not a militia, nor a temporary emergency measure, but a permanent fighting force built around personal loyalty rigorous training, and the kind of cohesion that the Green Standard armies, with a rotating command

and impersonal bureaucratic structure, had never managed to develop. Such an endeavor would prove years in the making. The Hunan army, as it came to be called, would not emerge from Hunan to do real battle with the Taiping until the summer of 1853 at the earliest. The Taiping by then would be comfortably settled in Nanjing, and the war would have moved into an entirely different phase. But in the winter of 1852, in his house at Xiang Xiang, a man who'd come home to mourn his mother was beginning with a characteristic deliberateness to build the very thing that would ultimately bring them down. So where does that leave matters?

In the depths of winter of 1852, the Taiping moved, as they ever did, north. Behind them, Changsha yet stood, the only city on the entire march from Guangxi that had yet turned them back. Every other wall they approached, they had broke through or went around, or simply terrified into submission. But they'd learned from that failure, and the lessons they would take with them. Ahead of them, Yuezhou, then Wu Chang. Yuizu fell almost without resistance. The garrison, having watched what the Taiping did at Changsha for two months, apparently concluded that discretion was the better form of valor. The Taiping took its weapons, its grain, and its boats, and then moved on.

Wu Chang was larger, better defended, and had paid attention to the lessons that Changsha had taught. The Hubei governor ordered homes outside the walls burned to create clear fields of fire. He blocked the city gates with earth and rock. He set up listening posts. He did, in other words, just what Lo Bing Zhang had done. But the Taiping had learned,

and this time the old tricks wouldn't be enough. At Wu Chang, they did not attack the strongest face first. Instead, they crossed the Yangze, seized the poorly defended commercial towns of Hanyang and Hongko on the northern shore, built two more pontoon bridges across the river, and then attacked Wu Chang from the north, its weakest side. The city fell on January 12, 1853. The Heavenly Kingdom took over a million ounces of silver from the Qing treasuries there, and stayed less than a month before the fleet and its army turned east, moving with the current now, the Yangze carrying them towards something that had had been. been implicit in the movement's ideology since Hong Xiu-Cuan first read the Yang Afas tracks in his fever dream all the way back in 1837. Nanjing, the old south capital of the Ming dynasty, 600 miles of river from Wu Chang, 30 days of marching. They used mining operations

to breach the walls. Some things that you learn, you learn to keep on using. But that's all next episode's story to tell. the army marches ever on and the gray scarred stone walls of chang shaw shaken but unbroken receded into the winter mists until next time thanks for listening