The History of China - #339 - Taiping 16: At Sixes & Sevens

Episode Date: July 27, 2026

The Taiping's greatest summer curdles into its bloodiest autumn. Two months after the East King demands to be crowned Hong Xiuquan's equal, three of his brother-kings converge on Nanjing with an army he never sees coming.By dawn, the man who once spoke with the voice of God is a head on a pole in the street. Yet the purge doesn't end there: it swallows thousands, devours the men who ordered it, and costs the Heavenly Kingdom its foothold on the Yangtze before the year is out – all without a single Qing soldier's help.Time Period Covered:Dec. 1853–Sep. 1856 CE Major Historical Figures:Taiping Heavenly Kingdom:Hong Xiuquan, Heavenly King [1814–1864]Yang Xiuqing, East King [c. 1821–1856]Wei Changhui, North King [d. 1856]Qin Rigang, Yan King [1821–1856]Shi Dakai, Wing King [1831–1863]Xiao Chaogui, West King [d. 1852]Feng Yunshan, South King [d. 1852]Hu Yihuang, Yu King (deposed) Qing Dynasty:Zeng Guofan, founder of the Xiang/Hunan Army [1811–1872]Xiang Rong, Nanjing S. siege camp commander Nanjing [d. 1856]Tuoming'a, Yangzhou commander Major Sources Cited:Michael, Franz, and Chang Chung-li. The Taiping Rebellion: History and Documents, Vol. I.Platt, Stephen R. Autumn in the Heavenly Kingdom.Spence, Jonathan D. God's Chinese Son: The Taiping Heavenly Kingdom of Hong Xiuquan.Kuhn, Philip A. "The Taiping Rebellion." The Cambridge History of China, Vol. 10. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

You're listening to an Airwave Media podcast. Hey there, I'm Travis Hoyum, one of the hosts of Motley Fool Hidden Gems Investing. Each weekday on Motley Fool Hidden Gems Investing, we talk through the business news you need to know and the stories moving stocks on Wall Street. On weekends, we game plan personal finance strategies and dive into the industries shaping tomorrow and host the experts, authors, and executives that understand them. Tune in for insights and a long-term perspective on investing, and of course, stock ideas, plenty of them. To quote a listener, it pays to listen. Check us out and subscribe wherever you listen to

podcasts. And welcome to the history of China. Episode 339 at Sixes and Sevens. Brothers may quarrel within the walls and still stand together against insult from without. Shi Jing, or The Book of Songs, 11th through 7th centuries BCE. Finded matters at 6es and 7s, we thought it best to leave these rebels to themselves. Unnamed Irish mercenary recalling Nanjing

in Jonathan Spence's God's Chinese Sun. A cannon shot pierced the darkness and silence of 4 in the morning, and that's the sound that woke him from his sleep. The Irishman had heard cannon before. He'd helped fire some of it himself in the course of the summer's fighting up around Zhengjiang. And even half asleep in a rented room, two doors down from the East King's own palace,

he knew the difference between artillery meant for a wall and artillery meant for a man. This was close, inside the city. He and the drifter he shared the room with were on their feet and at the door before either of them had worked out why. And it was there at the threshold that the night handed them the first hard fact of what they'd woken into. The street outside was full of soldiers who were not going to let them leave. Not Qing soldiers, mind you, Wei Chang Hui's men and Churagongs, filling every lane around the East King's palace with the density of an army that has come to make sure of something. So they waited, else for them to do. Whatever was happening two doors down was happening without them and would

keep happening for hours yet. Long after the sun that ought to have made sense of things came up instead on something considerably harder to look at. By daybreak, when the soldiers finally let them through, the two foreigners walked out into a street they'd lived on now for three months, yet no longer recognized. The bodies were everywhere. Quote, the bodyguard, officers, musicians, clerks, and household servants of number two, end quote, as the Irishman would later put it to a ship's officer named Reynolds. The whole dramatic apparatus of a palace cut down in the dark and then left where they fell. The palace itself, already being stripped by the men who'd taken it,

would be completely gutted within a few hours of full daylight. And somewhere above that wreckage, on a pole, raised where anyone in Nanjing could see it, hung the head of the man the Irishman had known for three months only as number two. The man he'd once watched conduct pugilism lessons with a captured English pistol and lecture 3,000 kneeling soldiers in the public square and receive a foreign guest with what the Irishman himself called a, quote, pleasant countenance and mild affable manner, end quote. Yang Xiu Qing, the East King, voice of the heavenly father was dead.

And so, within a few more hours, was almost everyone who had ever served him. To understand what the Irishman had woken up into, we've got to go back a few more hours. To a consultation, his presence in the city gave him no pardon or knowledge of. And further back even than that, to the demand we left hanging at the close of last episode, in the flush of the greatest summer the heavenly kingdom would ever know. Because the summer of 1856 had been, by every measure that mattered, a triumph. In June, the armies of the heavenly kingdom had shattered the great Qing encampment south of the city and broken the siege that had pressed against Nanjing's walls for three full years.

The imperial commissioner who had commanded that siege was dead within weeks. by most accounts of his own hand. From Wu Chang in the west to Zhenjiang in the east, some 400 miles of the Yangza answered to the heavenly capital. And for the first time since 1853, a man could stand on Nanjing's walls and see no enemy worth the name in any direction. It was the high watermark,

though, of course, nobody inside those walls could have known it at the time. and it was into exactly that moment of maximum safety that Yang Xiu Qing chose to reach for the one thing in the heavenly kingdom that was not yet his. You'll remember the scene, of course. The Heavenly Father descended, as he had descended so many times before, and through the mouth of the East King, demanded of Hong Xiu-Cuan an answer to a very pointed question.

If Yang Xiu-Ching had accomplished so much, why was he still hailed as the Lord of 9,000 years, while Hong alone was hailed as the Lord of 10,000, the salutation of an emperor? And Hong, kneeling before the voice of God as the theology of his own kingdom required him to, had given the only answer the room allowed, that it should be so.

The elevation, it was agreed, would be conferred on the East King's birthday in late September. which left everyone involved a little under two months to consider what exactly would be left of the heavenly king's position, once his kingdom contained two lords of 10,000 years. And what a man who could summon God on demand might ask for next. Once equal had been achieved, and superior remained on the table. What happened in those two months is, and will likely always remain, the murkiest stretch in this entire story.

The traditional account, the one you'll find in most retellings, and the one this episode will follow in outline, holds that Hong Xiu-Cen sent secret orders out of the capital, recalling his three senior commanders from their respective fronts. Wei Chang Hui, the North King, from the Jiangxi Campaign, Chin Zhur Gong, from the fighting east of the city, and Shedakai, the Wing King, from far up the river toward Wu Chang.

But before we go a step further, the providence of that account is worth being plain about because it's not reassuring. It rests almost entirely on testimony taken years after the fact. Depositions and confessions extracted from captured Taiping leaders by the very dynasty they'd spent their lives fighting, several of them written with their own executioner standing in the same room. Men in that position had every reason to arrange the story so that the blame sat comfortably upon the dead.

And tellingly, they couldn't even keep the story straight among themselves. Li Xiu Cheng, in the most famous of these confessions, wrote that Yang had extorted the title and Hong had secretly ordered the killing in response. Shed Akai, dictating his own account with mere days left to live, had said something far stranger, that Hong had conferred the title deliberately, as bait, to fatten Yang's ambition to the point where the North King would have no choice but to act. One version makes Hong a desperate man striking back. The other makes him the coldest player at the table.

Whether Hong summoned his kings or the kings summoned themselves and let Hong's name sanctify it afterward, is a question the sources are structurally incapable. of answering honestly. What we can establish is what the kings did once they got there, so we'll hold on to that. Wei Chang Hui reached the heavenly capital a little before midnight on September 1st, 1856, having handed the Jiangxi campaign to his subordinates and pushed his own 3,000 veterans back toward the city at a forced march. Chen Zhang, with less distance to cover, was already there. His troops flush from the summer's victories at Zhenjiang, and outside the southern siege camp.

And what these two men had in common will prove to be the engine of everything that follows. Both of them had spent years being systematically humiliated by the man that they were now converging on. Wei Chang Hui, the North King, one of the original brother kings of Thistle Mountain, five years of walking beside a sedan chair he wasn't grand enough to ride in,

of kneeling through trances aimed at him, of watching the Heavenly Father sentence his own relatives to death and being made to agree, allowed that the sentence was just. Chingra Gong, once a king himself, raised to the throne of Yen in 1854, then stripped of it by Yang's order after a battlefield reverse, and left to fight on through 1856 under a made-up consolation title that existed mainly to remind him of the crown he no longer wore. He was not even the only such man in the city.

Hu Yi Huang, briefly the king of Yu, until Yang unmade him too, was waiting inside the walls with his own subtraction to avenge. Yang Xiu Qing had spent years manufacturing exactly the coalition that was now assembling against him, one demotion and rod-beating at a time. And the summer's crowning demand had finally given that coalition something, had never had before, a reason to believe that the heavenly king himself might not object to what they planned. Inside the walls, the consultations moved fast. A brief exchange with Hong Xiu-Tuan's brother-in-law, another with Huih Huang, a short word, so it was later said,

with Hong himself. The question on the table was timing. Shedakai was still days out on the road from the West, and waiting for him meant giving Yang's own loyal garrison, some 6,000 men who believed, unironically, that they served the actual voice of God, time to organize into something 3,000 hired veterans could not simply walk through. And so, they decided not to wait. Yang Xiu Qing had no reason to expect any of this. As far as the East King knew, he'd spent the summer solving a problem, not creating one. The three men most capable of resisting his elevation were weeks of hard travel away on fronts he himself had assigned them, and the loyal 6,000 still garrisoned around him, made Nanjing, by any ordinary military logic, his to hold.

Ordinary military logic assumed the men coming for him would need an army to do it. What actually arrived at his gate that night was smaller, faster, and already inside the walls, before word could travel far enough to matter. Admitted through the city's southern gates, by the standard account, at the hand of Chen Cheng Rong, one of the most senior palace officials in the heavenly capital, whose duties included the transmission of every edict that passed through Hong Xiu-Cuan's court.

That's a name worth keeping track of, as this story is not finished with him either. Led by the North King, five years of sedan chairs and rod beatings and second-hand messages, all of it, finally called due, The troops broke into Yang's palace in the dark. There was no siege of it or negotiation. There was, though, an order.

Before the assault, an edict was read aloud to the troops in the heavenly king's name, and one account preserves its charge against the East King, that he had violated the heavenly commandments, harbored treason in his heart, and earned death by a thousand cuts. If that edict was real, it survives only. through a single memoir, so we can hold it only lightly. It would make this not merely a murder, but a signed one, ordered in the name of Hong Xiu-Tuan himself. Yang tried to run, of course. He had, according to one account, prepared for exactly this contingency to an almost

Batman-esque level. He had a hollow wall built into his own residence, a hiding place meant for the night the drums finally stopped protecting him. He never did. reach it, though. Wei's men cut him down somewhere between the room where the trances had always come to him and the wall that was supposed to swallow him whole. And within the hour, his head was off and mounted on a pole in the street, waiting for the Irishman and the rest of Nanjing to find it at first light. There had been an agreement beforehand about how far this was supposed to go. Hong Xiu-Cuan's understanding, or so it was said afterward by men with every reason to want it believed, was that Yang alone must die.

His household would be spared. The line, in theory, ran exactly as far as the one man whose trances had made him too dangerous to leave breathing. But that line did not survive the first hour. In the same stretch of dark it took to kill Yang Xiu-Ching, Wei and Qin's soldiers worked through everyone else they could find inside his palace. His wives and concubines, 44 of them by the count the Chinese sources keep, his children, stewards, cooks,

the palace women who had once gone running the instant the trance took him, the household servants who wouldn't have dared disturb their master to confirm whether God had finished speaking. Age didn't matter, rank didn't matter. Whatever occupation you'd held inside Yang Xocheng's walls was the only fact anyone needed, about you that night. This all belongs with its own note of caution, since the story of that

agreement survives mainly through the accounts of the men who broke it, not history's most reassuring source on anyone's original intent. What's not in dispute was the outcome. Whatever the plan had been at midnight, by the time the sun came up over the Irishman's rented room, it had already long stopped mattering. There's an old couplet from the book of songs that every man in the palace would have grown up knowing by heart. We heard it at the top of the episode. Brothers may quarrel within the walls and still stand together against insult from without. Nanjing had spent three years quoting the back half of that line to itself. Brother King beside Brother King, siege camps ringing the walls. A common demon always close enough

to make the quarrels wait. What happened in those few hours after midnight on September 2nd was the first half of the couplet, finally permitted to mean exactly what it had always said, and meant so completely that nobody left standing seemed to remember that the line had ever had a second half at all. The killing of Yang Xiu Qing solved one problem, and handed Hong Xiu Quan, a second substantively larger one, immediately on its heels. Six thousand men who had spent years believing that they served the voice of heaven were waking that same morning to learn now that the head that had borne heaven's voice had ended the night on top of a pole. And nobody in Hong's palace could say, with any confidence, where those

six thousand men's loyalty might land once they'd had some time to process it. Many of them were likewise Thistle Mountain veterans, five years into the faith they would have gladly died for before this week began. One could risk being wrong about what they'd do next, Or, one could preempt the question entirely. Hong, Wei, and Qin arrived at a solution between the three of them. First, a public reckoning. Or what looked to anyone watching from outside the palace gate, exactly like one. Hong Xiu-Cuan issued an edict, read aloud by his own palace women, denouncing the slaughter

of Yang's household as a senseless excess the heavenly king himself had never sanctioned. North King Wei and General Chin Zhigang were arrested for it, made to kneel in chains before the assembled city, and sentenced to 500 blows of the rod. The old Thistle Mountain punishment for traitors proclaimed from a length of yellow silk seven or eight feet long, written out in vermilion ink, and read in clear and carrying tones before the palace gate. Every element of it was correct. That was the point, after all. The Heavenly King had spent years perfecting the theater of public justice, and this performance was staged by people who knew every line of the liturgy because they were the ones who'd written it.

Young's surviving followers were invited to witness the punishment. Of course they came. Men who had knelt through years of trances arrived to watch some overdue justice land on the two men responsible for the worst night of their lives. They filed into two long halls flanking the courtyard, left their weapons at the gate as custom required, and settled in to watch the beating begin. They did not notice that the doors had been closed behind them.

The doors, however, stayed shut and bolted. At daylight the next morning, bags of gunpowder came in through the windows of both holes and were touched off. In one, resistance and... landed almost as soon as it had begun. But in the other, Yang's men fought for six hours with whatever they could tear out of the walls and partitions. Bricks, timber, even their bare hands.

Against soldiers who eventually just said the heck with this and brought up a cannon loaded with grape shot to finish what the gunpowder hadn't. When it was all over, Wayes and Chan's own troops had their men bear their right arms before going in, so as to not cut down each other by mistake. stake in rooms already, in the Irishman's own words, quote,

five and six deep, end quote, with the dead. The Irishman was among the guards posted at the front of Hong's palace that morning, close enough to walk through the wreckage himself not long after. He later told Reynolds, quote, good heavens, such a scene, and quote. Bodies stacked in the halls, some who'd hanged themselves rather than wait for the soldiers, Others burned by the powder charges thrown in among them. The corpses were carried out to a field afterwards and left there, uncovered and unburied. It did not end there.

For weeks afterward, every homeowner in Nanjing was required to account for every living soul under his roof, and issue each of them a sealed chop to wear on their breast as proof of registration. Anyone found without one, anyone who had in the Irishman's owner, phrase for it, once eaten of number two's rice, was hunted down and marched to the execution ground in batches of five, ten, and then eventually hundreds, and then thousands. Women, children, all 500 of Yang's former palace attendants. As for how many died in all of it, here the record does something that it often does in war, which is to hand us a fistful of answers, and no way to really discern among them.

Spence follows the killing for roughly three months, and declines to settle on a figure beyond thousands more. Other Western surveys put the coups total dead, Yang's household included, at 6,000. The Cambridge history of China goes further still, citing an estimate of some 20,000 killed in a massacre it describes as raging for the better part of a fortnight. And 20,000 is where mainland Chinese.

historiography has largely settled as well, and where Michael and Chong land too, glossing the coup as a killing of, quote, more than 20,000, end quote, though at least one contemporary Chinese account insisted the true figure was no fewer than 30,000. And the honest answer is that these numbers may not even be counting the same thing. One measures a palace, another a purge, a third, an entire city's season of terror. So I can just present to you the spread, and the caution that none of it deserves to be spoken as though it were a settled number. What we can say is what the Irishman saw, because he was made to help guard it. The batches of the condemned kept arriving at the execution grounds long after anyone could have believed the men and women making them up were a threat to anything or anyone.

Across Canada in a Volvo. Destination. Vancouver turned left. Left to leave. Travel west through. Approaching. Continue toward. You've arrived.

Adventure in comfort with Volvo. Whether you prefer gas, plug-in hybrid, or fully electric, there's a Volvo for everyone. Learn more at VolvoCars.C.A. And underneath it all, underneath the halls and chops and batches, is that a problem that no executioner ground could reach, because it was fundamentally a problem of theology.

For three years now, the government of the heavenly kingdom had run on a very simple, very strange constitutional principle. That God the Father, when he had something to say, said it through the mouth of the East King. Not metaphorically, as a live, binding operational fact, armies had moved on the strength of the trances. Ministers had been condemned by them. The heavenly king himself had knelt to them, most recently that very summer. Every man and woman in Nanjing had organized their understanding of the universe around the premise that the voice which came out of Yang Xiu Qing's mouth in those moments was the same

voice that had spoken the world into being. and that voice was now up on a pole. And the men who had put it there, with at minimum the Heavenly King's acquiescence, were obliged to stand in front of a believing city and explain what exactly they had all just done. Had they killed a traitor who had merely pretended to carry the father's voice? Then three years of Taiping law in Scripture, everything the trances had commanded and condemned,

was built on a fraud the leadership had knelt to. Had the voice been real? Then the heavenly king had just beheaded the mouthpiece of Almighty God and thrown his tonographers into a field to rot. There was no third option, and Hong Xiu-Cen, whose entire claim to rule rested on the same cosmology, conspicuously declined to choose between the two. In the near term, the answer from the heavenly palace was essential,

Eventually, silence. The father had simply stopped descending from heaven. In the longer term, Hong would arrive at a solution of audacious convenience. The charge of usurpation against Yang Xiu Qing would be formally withdrawn. His death reframed not as murder, but as ascension, and its date consecrated in the Tai Ping calendar as a holy festival, Dong Wang Sheng Tienje. the festival of the ascension of the East King to heaven.

The man himself folded back into the pantheon as though the whole head-on-the-pole thing had never happened. But that particular piece of doctrinal repair work belongs to later episodes. In the autumn of 1856, the faithful of Nanjing were left to work the problem out for themselves, in a city where asking the question too loudly could put you in the next batch of five bound for the execution grounds. Word of all this did not travel cleanly.

Down the river in Shanghai, where foreign merchants and missionaries had spent three years trying to piece together what was actually happening behind Nanjing's walls from whatever fragments made it out, the rumor that first circulated was not that the East King had fallen, but that the heavenly king himself was dead, or had been deposed and shut away. Neither was true, and the missionary community, which had invested years of desperate hope in the idea that the Taiping might yet mature into a genuinely Christian government of China, was left to sort prophecy from gossip at 400 miles removed. What had actually happened was, in its way, stranger than either rumor.

Not the fall of the man at the top of Taiping cosmology, but of the man who'd spent three years speaking on demand in the voice. of the being above even him. It would be months before anything like an accurate account reached the coast. And when it did, it came walking out of the city in disguise in a pair of borrowed Chinese jackets. But we'll get to that. Shedakai had the farthest to travel of any of them. He was still working his army back down from Wu Chong when Wei Chang Hui and Chin Zheng

decided not to wait. and he reached the heavenly capital only in early October, weeks after the killing had already run its course. Carrying nothing with him but secondhand reports of a massacre, he'd had no hand in starting and no chance to stop. He had been hearing versions of it the whole way down the river, each one presumably even worse than the last, and each one it would turn out still short of what had actually transpired. What he found on arrival did not improve on the report. He went to Wei Chang Hui directly and said, apparently, what nobody else left in Nanjing had been willing to say to the North King's face, that the killing had gone too far, that it would

cost the Taiping more in the field than Yang Xocheng had ever cost them from the palace. It was, on substance, exactly the argument any sober commander should have wanted to hear from the one surviving king with a standing to make it. But Wei did not hear it that way. Whether it was the accusation itself, or the fact that it came from the last man in Nanjing still capable of rallying notable opposition to him, Wei's answer was to suggest that She himself might be carrying water for Yang's memory, or perhaps for the Qing. It was the same accusation that had justified every killing so far,

aimed now at the one king in this entire story who'd had nothing to do with any of it. Friends warned Shi he might be next. He found the city gates already closed against him. He left Nanjing the same day he'd entered it, but not by any gate. Spence has him simply slipping out of the city in secret. The Chinese accounts are more specific, and worse. They have him lowered over the city wall itself in the dark via a rope, a founding king of the heavenly kingdom, exiting the capital the way a thief exits a compound. That same night, Wei and Qin surrounded his mansion exactly as they had Yangs, forced the guards, and, finding Shi already gone, killed his wife, his children,

and everyone else of the household they could reach in his palace. The North King, who had just staged a public trial over the senseless slaughter of one household, did not hesitate for a single night before ordering an identical slaughter of yet another. Shedakai did not go into hiding. Rather, he went upriver, west of the capital, and built an army out of everything Wei Chang Hui's autumn had made available to him. His own loyal troops, other generals who'd watched the purge and drawn their own conclusions, assorted triad bands with no particular loyalty to the heavenly king, but every reason to want Wei Chang Hui. gone. By the time he turned back toward Nanjing, he commanded something close to 100,000 men,

one of the largest forces any Taiping general had yet assembled, and he was telling anyone who would listen that only two heads would satisfy him now. Wei Cheng Hui, watching that army gather from inside a city he'd spent three months teaching to fear him, prepared now for a siege of his own making. He sent Chinra Gong to block Shiz advance in the field, and he had the nine-story porcelain pagoda at the Ba'an Temple, south of the walls, blown up entirely, denying Shiz artillery the one commanding height from which it might have shelled the city. It's worth stopping here for a moment on what that building actually was, because Porcelain Pagoda undersells it about as badly as a name can undersell a thing.

It had stood for 425 years at that point. The Yongla Emperor of Ming had ordered it raised in 1412, officially in gratitude to his mother. A claim you might weigh however you like, given what longtime listeners will remember about that particular emperor's relationship with his own legitimacy, and the project had consumed something like 100,000 laborers over the better part of two decades, and was not finished until 1431, years after Yongla himself was dead. What they built was, at the time of its completion, the tallest structure in China. Nine stories of white porcelain-faced brick rising more than 260 feet above the south bank of the Chin Huai, hung with bells at every eve, crowned in guilt, and lit after dark by well over a hundred oil lamps,

so that it always glowed on the horizon. European travelers had been writing home about it in tones of open disbelief and awe since the 17th century, and by the 19th, it had been formally enrolled among the wonders of the world, mentioned in the same breath as the Roman Colosseum. For generations of Westerners who would never see China,

the tower at Nanjing, more or less, was China for them. When the Treaty of Nanjing had been signed aboard a British warship in 1842, sailors from that ship went ashore specifically to have a look at it. And foreign visitors kept trying, even after the Taiping took the city. In the spring of 1854, an American diplomatic party, denied entry to Nanjing itself, marched miles out of their way under armed Taiping escort just for the chance to stand at its base. The tower still whole then, its porcelain still shining, though its own defenders had already ripped out the interior staircase rather than leave a besieging army a clear line of sight over the walls. One of the Americans even tried to scale what was left of it to make off with the golden sphere from its crown, but was stopped before he got far, a piece of foreign bravado that lingered in Taiping memory long afterward. That had been 1854. The tower gutted of its stare, but still standing.

A landmark men dared cross-guarded ground just to have a look at. By the autumn of 1856, it was gone. Not weathered or looted, but deliberately blown apart with gunpowder in an afternoon. On the order of a king who was more afraid of what his own former ally might do with the high ground, than he was sorry to lose the single most famous building, his capital, and arguably his civilization possessed. Some later accounts would insist the demolition had as much to do with geomancy as with gunnery, that way feared the tower's influence over the city's fortunes as much as its sightlines.

Maybe. But you'll notice that both explanations describe the same man, one so far inside his own fear by October of 1856, that four centuries of accumulated wonder weighed against it, almost nothing. Having burned that bridge along with the rest, Wei began laying plans of his own. To take Hong Xiu-Chen into custody, some accounts say to kill him outright,

on the theory that a heavenly king in hand was worth more to him than a free one ever could be. He never finished those plans. In the first days of November, the second by the usual reckoning, Hong rallied his own palace guard, together with the survivor of the very East King faction Wei had spent two months exterminating, and had Wei Chang Hui killed, along with some 200 of his remaining followers. The last men in Nanjing still willing to die for him,

and by then, very nearly the only ones willing to stand near him. And here, the two halves of the record part company in a rather instructive way. The Western account, that is, the Irishman's, goes strikingly quiet on the mechanics, who struck the blow, what warning Wei had, how close he came to finishing what he'd started against Hong. The Chinese accounts do not go quiet. They report that the North King's body was dismembered, the flesh cut into pieces roughly two inches square, and hung up on stakes throughout the city, labeled in some tellings with

two characters apiece. Beijing, Northern Trader. His head, at least, was spared the stakes. It went, instead, upriver in a box, to be opened and verified in Shedaka'i's own camp, proof of the debt being paid. Chin Zhur Gong, lured back to the city not long after, under a pretext that worked exactly one time, was executed in his turn. And alongside him, died Chien Zhuge.

Chen Zheng Rong, the palace official who had opened the southern gate on the night of September 1st, and without whom none of this bloody autumn would have been possible. The men who had made the coup happen were consumed by it in strict order of usefulness, and the order had finally reached its end. The East King had died a figure of cosmic significance. His fall garbled and mythologized across two hemispheres. The North King died a butcher's problem, and the city he had terrorized disposed of him the way a butcher disposes of the awful. Shedokai's warning to Wei's face, that the killing would cost the Taiping more in the field than Yang ever had from the palace, did not have to wait long for its proof.

The bill arrived before the year was out, and it arrived addressed, with the kind of irony this war seems to manufacture virtually. on demand, to the House of Wei. Far up the river, Wuchang, the western anchor of that 400-mile Yangza Dominion, the city whose recapture we followed just two episodes back, had been Tai Ping ground since the 3rd of April 1855, when Chindra Gong's Western campaign retook it, and a vanguard commander barely more than a boy, made his own name doing it. Chen Yu Cheng, 18 years old,

a name this war is very far from Fife. finished with. The city had spent a year and a half since under siege by the Hunan Army's ablest civil official, Hulenei, in a grinding investment that had already cost the besiegers one of the Hunan army's own founders, Lodz Anan, mortally wounded beneath those walls in the spring. The officer left holding the city through that siege by the accounts that name him was Wei June. In those same accounts, the North King's own younger brother, or possibly nephew, as it's difficult

to disentangle such relationships in Chinese records. Through the summer of 1856, he had held on in the reasonable expectation of relief, you know, eventually coming. The nearest great relieving force on the upper river was none other than Shidakai's. Consider then the autumn from Wei Jun's ramparts. First, the Relief Army marches away east, recalled to a capital convulsing for reasons no dispatch could safely explain. Then word arrives of what his brother, or uncle, has done inside that capital.

Then word arrives of what has been done to his brother, whose severed head is, at that very moment, traveling upriver as a diplomatic gift to the man who was supposed to relieve him. Along with, per most accounts, everyone who carried the way name in non-dean. Jing, root and branch, down to their father. Overnight, that name had become the single most dangerous thing a Taiping officer could carry, and Wei Jun was carrying it at the head of an isolated garrison, 300 miles from anyone obliged to help him.

Yet for all this, he did not break. Hulin Yi, who knew a cornered man when he besieged one, sent agents into the city again and again that autumn, with offers of both amnesty and rank. And Wei Jun refused each and every one of them. Refused so stubbornly, in fact, that a Qing memorialist gave up on him in writing, reporting to Beijing that this particular rebel showed no remorse at all, and was plainly willing to die where he stood. What did finally move him was not the enemy, but the arithmetic.

It became obvious enough after a while that no relief was coming, that the capital that had butchered his family was not going to bleed for his garrison, and the army outside his walls had spent 18 months learning exactly how long his supplies could last. In December of 1856, by some accounts with Shedakhai's explicit sanction, Wei Jun brought his troops, something like 20,000 of them, out of Wu Chang in good order, and marched them away east. And on the 19th, who then east forces walked into the smoldering remains of a city that had changed hands for what would be the last time. The western anchor of the Heavenly Kingdom's greatest summer was gone before the year that had produced it was out. Not taken by storm, but written off, by the one man in the entire movement, with the least reason left to continue serving it,

and who had kept serving it anyway. The heavenly capital's response, in time, would be to move to prosecute him for the loss of the city. But that indignity, and everything it eventually drove him to, belongs to episodes still years down the river. Shedakai entered Nanjing again in December, 1856, in pomp, to a hero's welcome, the closest thing to a settlement this particular ledger was ever going to offer. the last king's standing of the six who had come out of Guangxi, and the only one of the autumn's principles to emerge with his reputation not merely intact, but enhanced. The man who had objected, been proven right, and then collected on the debt.

The crowds that welcomed him back knew all of that. So, presumably, did the heavenly king watching from his palace, a man who'd now seen, twice in four months, exactly what a beloved commander with an army at his back could accomplish inside these walls, and who no longer had a voice from heaven to tell him what to do about it. None of that brought Sh's wife back, nor his children, nor his household that had died in his place while he was still on the road, learning what he'd missed. But it was, by whatever accounting was available to a man in his position, as close to justice as 1856

was prepared to hand anyone. The Irishman, meanwhile, did not stick around to see any of that homecoming. He and one of his companions had already decided, by the time Shedokai's column reached to the gates, that they had seen enough. Quote, finding matters at sixes and sevens, he told Reynolds later, and beheading the order of the day, we thought it best to leave these rebels to themselves. end quote. They dressed themselves in Chinese clothes and made their way out of the heavenly capital they had once been proud enough to serve.

By wheelbarrow and on foot, and finally a rented boat, helped along and occasionally fleeced by peasant guides, who had their own reasons for wanting foreigners moved through the countryside without incident. Ten days later, they reached Shanghai. And there, the Irishman discovered something that tells you, everything about what those months in Nanjing had done to a man's sense of the ordinary world. He had lost track of the calendar so completely that he believed, walking back into a city that kept its clocks the normal way, it was already February 1857. It was the 20th of December, 1856.

Quote, so completely had we lost all dates that we imagined the year of 1857 had advanced to about February, end quote. He had been gone from time itself longer than he'd been gone from Nanjing. We can forgive him his confusion. Measureed by anything except an actual calendar, an enormous amount of history had passed. In June, three armies under three kings had broken a siege that held for three years and put the Taiping in command of 400 miles of river, from Wu Chang to Zhenjiang. at the highest tide the heavenly kingdom would ever reach.

By December, two of those three kings were dead, each on the orders of men they'd once ruled beside. A third had bought his survival at the price of everyone in his house, and Wuchong itself, the western end of that 400 miles, was back in the dynasty's hands. The city that emerged from those six months had lost its channel to heaven, one king's entire household staff, thousands of that king's followers, another king's wife and children, and, almost incidentally, buried in the middle of everything else, the single most famous building foreign visitors to Nanjing had ever gone out of their way just to see. None of it, not one death inside those walls, was the work of Zheng Guo Fan, or of any government army in the field.

Outside the walls, Zhang Guo Liang and Hechun were still years of. away from rebuilding a siege line worthy of the name. The 45 miles of trench and guard camps that would eventually ring Nanjing again belonged to a different decade entirely. Even Wu Chang, the dynasty's one tangible prize of the season, had been less captured than simply vacated. Handed over by a garrison, the Heavenly Kingdom's own capital had simply orphaned. And Zenguo Fan himself, at the same moment, sat exactly where we'd left him. still stranded in Nanchang, his fleet still useless on a lake, still unable to pay his own soldiers, still waiting on a reversal of fortune that he had no reason to expect and no way to manufacture on his own.

But fate is a funny thing. He couldn't expect a reversal of fortune and couldn't make one, but he got one anyway. Not because he earned it in the field, and not because any government army had finally outmaneuvered the heavenly kingdom's defense. senses. He got it because the heavenly kingdom had just spent an autumn doing to itself what three years of external siege had never even come close to achieving. It opened the gate from the inside, and it did not need a single Qing soldier's help to walk through it. Thanks for listening.