The Indicator from Planet Money - Is the Panama Canal a rip-off?

Episode Date: March 5, 2025

Who pays to use the Panama Canal and how much? These questions are part of the tensions between the U.S. and Panama after President Trump threatened to take over the canal. We look at the global shipping lane's fee structure in light of the president's claim that the U.S. is getting ripped off. Related episodes: A drought, a jam, a canal — Panama! Add to cart: Greenland (Apple / Spotify) For sponsor-free episodes of The Indicator from Planet Money, subscribe to Planet Money+ via Apple Podcasts or at plus.npr.org. Fact-checking by Lilly Quiroz. Music by Drop Electric. Find us: TikTok, Instagram, Facebook, Newsletter. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for sponsorship and to manage your podcast sponsorship preferences.NPR Privacy Policy

NPR. This is the indicator from Planet Money. I'm Waylon Wong, joined today by our friend Mary Childs from Planet Money. Hi, thank you for having me here. It is so great to have you here. And today we are talking geopolitics and how they're playing out at the Panama Canal. As you've probably heard, President Trump has some major grievances with this crucial piece of the global economy. Yes, he has said that China controls the canal, even though it is owned by Panama.

And just yesterday, the administration scored a victory. American Investment Fund BlackRock agreed to buy majority stakes in two ports at the Panama Canal. This deal transfers ownership in these ports, plus dozens of other ports in other countries, from a Hong Kong-based company to a U.S.-led consortium. So the Trump administration may be placated on that front, but it remains unhappy about how much the Panama Canal charges for tolls. The president has called these fees a rip-off. So today on the show, we are going to focus on that. What does it actually cost to go through the Panama Canal?

And who foots the bill? We sort out who pays what to use this all-important waterway. And we talked to someone with his own idea of how pricing could be made more fair. To start with some history, the U.S. built the Panama Canal and controlled it for decades. In 1977, the U.S. and Panama signed two treaties that eventually ceded full ownership over the canal over the next couple of decades. So Panama now owns the canal, but the U.S. remains the waterway's number one user. Some 40% of U.S. container ship traffic goes through every year. The canal is also important for military and strategic reasons. The Panama Canal is controlled by an independent arm of the

Panamanian government. The agency is called the Panama Canal Authority, and this is the organization that sets the rates. Jean-Paul Rodriguez is a professor at Texas A&M University in Galveston. He's an expert in maritime transportation and economics. And this is how he describes the canal authorities approach. The goal of the Panama Canal, from their perspective, is to extract as much revenue as possible from the operation. Because it's expensive to operate the Panama Canal. They've done a lot of investment.

At the same time, also to still have my customers. Jean-Paul says the Panama Canal operates like your typical business. Make as much profit as you can while keeping your customers. happy. Operating expenses for the canal totaled almost $2 billion in 2024. And about a decade ago, the Canal Authority finished a massive years-long expansion project. That cost over $5 billion. The Canal Authority borrowed money to help pay for that expansion. So it needs to make money to operate the canal and pay back that debt. That money comes mostly from tolls. But if the rates are too high, shipping companies might choose to go over land by rail.

Or they could go through the Suez Canal, depending on where they're located. They are alternative. You're not in a pure monopolistic situation. So it's been a tug-of-war type of game in recent, you could say, decades or so, between the users and the Panama Canal Authority, which must finance its operation and also must pay the Panamanian government. So let's look at how the canal makes money through tolls. The first thing to know is that the rates are not determined by a ship's

country of origin. So American ships, they don't pay more than anybody else. Instead, fees depend on the type and size of ship that passes through. We will look at government ships first, since this was a point of friction between the Trump administration and Panama. According to a report by Bank of America, the average fee for a U.S. warship to go through the canal is $30,000 per transit. Revenue from warships and other government vessels like naval repair ships add up to just several million dollars per year on average. Still, the administration believes any fee is unacceptable. Secretary of State Marco Rubio made this clear on an official visit to Panama last month. I find it absurd that we would have to pay fees to transit a zone that we are obligated to protect

in a time of conflict. Rubio is referring to those treaties between the U.S. and Panama. Those agreements give the U.S. permission to use military force if the canal's neutrality comes under threat. After Rubio's remarks, the State Department said that Panama had agreed to stop charging U.S. government ships to go through the canal. Both the Panamanian government and the Panama Canal authority denied this. We reached out to the State Department. It told us that it's confident the two sides, quote, will find a way forward, end quote. And it called Panama a strong and trusted U.S. ally. Even if U.S. government ships get to use the canal for free, they are only a small part of the waterways traffic.

The biggest users of the canal are commercial ships. John Paul says when it comes to commercial ships, the toll has three basic parts. First, there's a base fee, and then there's a fee that's charged per ton or per container, depending on the type of ship. There is actually a fee for each type of ship. Container ship, oil tanker, refrigerated ships, you name it. There's a specific fee that applies. After the base fee and the per ton fee, there's a third category of service charge. This covers inspections and even things like paying extra to get priority.

Jean-Paul says that when you add up all these fees, there is a huge range in what these ships pay in tolls. It can go from a half million dollars up to $1.5 million for some of the larger ships. In recent years, a lack of rainfall has led to low water levels at the canal. And that meant fewer slots each day for ships to go through. And so the Panama Canal Authority has adjusted its fees in response. It started collecting a fresh water surcharge for ships of a certain size. It also introduced an auction system. Now shipping companies can bid on a limited number of slots.

In 2023, Bloomberg reported that a Japanese firm paid a record $4 million for a gas tanker to get one of those slots. Mihalus Marikakis is a business professor at the University of Navarra in Barcelona. He says this auction system is open and transparent. Plus, it does the job of allocating a scarce. resource, which in this case is a transit slot at the canal. But he does have one critique. It favors the big shipping lines, the big companies that can afford to pay as much. So it creates essentially this unfairness, this distortion in the market. Mahalas and a couple colleagues wrote up a proposal for a different kind of auction system. It works like this. Let's say there is a line of

ships waiting to go through the canal. And let's say I joined the line in last place. and you, Mary, are right ahead of me. I offer you some amount of money to go ahead of you, and you can accept or decline based on how badly you want to keep your place in line. Or how bad I want the money? Yeah. If at some point I make a bit to the vessel ahead of me in the line, and that bit gets rejected, then I stop and I just wait for my turn.

This kind of system is called sequential bidding. Mahalo says the advantage of this process is that, a smaller shipping company get compensated for giving up its place in line. He says this makes the system more fair while also keeping it efficient. It's not that the Panama Canal is like greedy capitalist trying to rip anyone off. They need the money. On the other hand, that comes at the expense of smaller firms, probably who are serving smaller customers. So it's the how are you trading off the...

equitability with the market efficiency. The Panama Canal Authority hasn't telegraphed any changes to its auction system. It has, however, raised its tolls. The most recent increase went into effect in January. Maritime expert John Paul Rodriguez says that even though those fee hikes were announced years ago, they caught the attention of the Trump administration. Any change in the toll structure has an economic impact within the United States. And when they saw the toll increases, it created some kind of a response.

Is this pushback justified or not? It's a matter of debate. But it is not coming out of a vacuum. We emailed the State Department to ask whether it has a position on the fees that commercial ships have to pay. It told us in a statement that these fees per treaty obligation to the U.S. must be, quote, just and reasonable and non-discriminatory. Meanwhile, Jean-Paul says, the canal has a big expensive challenge ahead of it. The Canal Authority is planning to build a dam to create a new.

reservoir that will help tackle its water issues. Construction is expected to start in 2027. This episode was produced by Julia Ritchie with engineering by Jimmy Keeley, with fact-checked by Lily Kuros. Kate Canaan is the show's editor and the indicators of production of NPR.