The Joe Rogan Experience - #1682 - Jesse Singal

Episode Date: July 13, 2021

Jesse Singal is the author of "The Quick Fix: Why Fad Psychology Can't Cure Our Social Ills" and the cohost of the podcast "Blocked and Reported." Check out more of his stuff at jessesingal.substack.c...om/about.

Transcript
Discussion (0)
Starting point is 00:00:00 the joe rogan experience train by day joe rogan podcast by night all day hello jesse hey man how's it going nice to meet you i've read your tweets multiple times i'm sorry to hear that you're a tweeter man you're out there you're out there i'm trying i want to waiting to learn from you how to stay out of that shit. It destroys me. It's not for everybody to stay off. I think for some people it's a very useful tool. It's very useful.
Starting point is 00:00:33 That's how I found about you. I found out about you through Twitter. So it's great for promotion. It's great for getting your ideas out there. But it's not great for rational, kind discourse between other, you know, compassionate human beings. There's very little of that going on there. It's a lot of like, it's like being in a mental health Institute. Well, I was going to say, I think it, I know people from real life who I don't know for sure, but I think like being on Twitter is,
Starting point is 00:00:59 is exacerbating their mental illness. I think that's how bad it is. Yeah. And during the pandemic that was highlighted. Oh my God. You have nothing else to do. You're just online in this crate. It's like a middle school cafeteria, but more sociopathic. It's horrible. Yeah. It's just, it's so bad for people and you see them unraveling as the days go on. You just want to go like, go run, leave your phone at home and go for a run. Here's what I don't get about your ability to stay off is I have, you know, won a millionth the notoriety of you. Some people hate me, but no, you know, I have trouble not checking in on what people are saying about me. And that's what fucks you up because then you go down the spiral and you pretend that this angry 15-year-old in Ohio who's talking shit about you you that you can convince him you're a good guy. And that's, that's crazy because he's not trying to have a conversation, but I find I can't,
Starting point is 00:01:47 I can't stay away from those fights with the angry 15 year old in Ohio. Or angry 45 year old in Manhattan. Maybe more often. It's just people, man. It's just, it's a bad way for humans to communicate. And I think one of the things that happens on Twitter that's really kind of strange is that the bullied become the bullies. Yeah. It's like you get a lot of people that had a really rough time in high school and socially, and now they found this circle of people that agree with them, and they're all, for lack of a better term, they have mental health problems. Because there's no doubt they're filled with anxiety and chaos and they're on there all day long
Starting point is 00:02:27 Yeah, and they're just arguing and attacking people Yeah like there's some people that I follow and I don't follow them what I do is I bookmark their page and I go back to It because I just don't I don't want to get into it. But so occasionally I'll go and see like, okay Let's look at this science project. And I'll just see, oh, look at this. We have 10 hours of tweeting today. Yeah. And it's 10 hours of slinging mud and being shitty and calling for people to be deplatformed.
Starting point is 00:02:56 And it's just, it's a terrible way to live your life. Well, and what's weird is during those 10 hours, all they've received was approval for that behavior. So like it just, it gives you a completely warped view of until they don't there's this one lady that i follow she's uh she's an academic and she's fucking loony and uh they came for her and boy when they came for her it was wild watching her scramble and trying to placate and trying to calm them down and seeing that it didn't matter. You could look at the, like the bulk of her, her tweets and what she does as a, you know, as a academic and it's not a bad person. She's just loony. You know, she's just a loony progressive who thinks that the
Starting point is 00:03:38 only way to make change in this world is to attack people and to, you know, vehemently dismiss anyone who disagrees with you as either a racist or a Nazi or alt-right or including people that are clearly none of those things. What I'm fascinated by is these communities where you constantly have to look over your shoulders because if you say the wrong thing once, you're basically out of the community. And this isn't just on the left. This actually happened on the right with Trump, where people who didn't support Trump, it was like, bye. It doesn't matter. You've been a good conservative 20 years. So there was a sort of socialist lefty writer in New York who had done a lot of good stuff. She wrote a Times piece about how she met
Starting point is 00:04:18 Barry Weiss and how they got along. And she's like, I thought I would hate Barry Weiss. I like Barry Weiss. And she was basically ousted just for refusing to say Barry Weiss was like, you know, Hitler's daughter or something. It's like the standards. So how is Barry Weiss? I mean, look, Barry Weiss and I have disagreed about things. She's a wonderful person. She's a sweetheart. She's very smart. She's interesting. She's a great writer. There's nothing wrong with her. She just, people disagree about shit. We had a pretty significant disagreement about Tulsi Gabbard. I love her to death. I think she's great. I don't understand why people want to make demons out of just humans with normal
Starting point is 00:04:58 human flaws. Well, the thing to keep in mind, I think a lot of people make the mistake of saying, like, oh, it's just Twitter. Why do you talk about it so much? Why do you care? But like every, basically every mainstream journalist and a significant proportion of like big name academics, they're on Twitter every day and they're looking around to see who responds to what. And any journalist right now who says that Twitter is not setting the terms of the agenda and what we cover and how we cover it, I think is like diluted or lying. It's disingenuous. It's clearly affecting them. If they're on Twitter and they're paying attention to their ad mentions, it's having an effect. It just does. The thing about Barry that people have the hardest time with, I guess, is her pro-Israel stance, right? Is that what it is?
Starting point is 00:05:38 It's a combination of things. I think it's partly that, but I think people get most mad. Like people got mad at me because I wrote stuff for like liberal issues, the Atlantic, New York magazine that they really disagreed with. They're not going to bother with people who write for the National Review because they're conservatives. They're a different tribe. With Barry, there is this assumption that she's like in our house fucking shit up. Even though she's not, she's by no means like a far right. She's like a centrist, heterodox, whatever. She's just rational.
Starting point is 00:06:08 Yeah. I mean, and I have disagreements with her too, but it's just I've never understood the, of all the people to focus that much anger on, I've never quite gotten it, to be honest. You were saying, we were talking about this before, and we agreed to stop talking about it until we got on the podcast, that there was, I guess there's a clip going around from my podcast from years back where it was Charles Johnson on the podcast
Starting point is 00:06:31 where he was saying something about a gene. What is the clip? Because I haven't seen the clip. Yeah. Just someone told me about it, but again, I don't pay attention to anything. So people were recirculating a clip where Johnson was saying that people are going to take this clip out of context. He was saying, I'm not saying, that there's a gene called MAOA associated with aggression and that black people have more of it. And I saw this on my Twitter feed and I hit up a friend of mine, a buddy.
Starting point is 00:06:57 I met him once in real life in Helsinki. His name is Amir Saryazlan. He's like a genetics researcher. Great follower. Follow on Twitter. He studies genetics. I was like, what's this deal? They call it the warrior gene. The idea is if you have this gene or some variant of it, you're more aggressive. And he basically explained there's this interesting
Starting point is 00:07:13 recent history of genetics where people thought there was like a gay gene and a liberal gene and a warrior gene. These are called candidate gene studies. like what happens if you have this gene versus not have this gene. At the time Johnson made this claim, there had been this pretty shitty media coverage about the idea of a warrior gene. And a guy named – do you know the guy John Horgan, the science writer? No. Very smart guy. He wrote a book on sort of rational mysticism, like how to understand mystical experiences in scientific light. sort of rational mysticism, like how to understand mystical experiences in scientific light.
Starting point is 00:07:50 Back in the day, maybe 10 years ago, he did a piece for Scientific American People Should Look Up, John Horgan on the warrior gene, basically debunking it. But what my boy Amir told me is that it's not just that these studies are bad, the candidate gene studies. Genetics research has moved in a whole different direction. They do genome-wide association studies. They realize, like, for various reasons, these studies saying there's a gay gene, a liberal gene, a warrior gene, they didn't replicate. And they think genetics is much more complicated. So they've moved toward, like, examining entire regions of our genome and trying to understand it that way.
Starting point is 00:08:18 So the short version is what Johnson was saying is just sort of wrong and a misunderstanding. And this entire area of genetics has, is like sort of been debunked. Like we don't really look for candidate genes anymore. We look for whole regions. Were people looking for it back when he said it? Yeah, yeah. He was responding to sort of like just bad pop science basically. Bad pop science from 2015.
Starting point is 00:08:40 From I think 2011, but yeah. But when was the podcast I did with him? The clip was 2015 Yeah, he was one of those guys that I didn't know anything about till I had him on and then when I had him on Like there was things like that where I was like wait what there was a whole group of people But and also I should just say when I was doing the podcast back then I Didn't sort of understand the impact that it had I thought I was just
Starting point is 00:09:05 having conversations with people because it wasn't nearly as popular back there so if I had up you know a podcast with someone whose opinions that I completely disagreed with I'd have them on anyway I just like see let's see where this goes it's just maybe be interesting maybe a weird conversation to have a conversation with someone who's got a polar opposite view of life than I do. You know, it was a much smaller platform back then. And so I didn't think of it as a responsibility or like, I didn't think, you know, there's a thought now that you shouldn't put people on, you're elevating their platform. But I still kind of disagree with that because I think
Starting point is 00:09:43 there's a real value in having people on that have different views than you. Even if you don't agree with them, there's a value in figuring out where they're wrong. There's a value in figuring out if maybe there's a hole in your logic, like whatever it is. With him, there was a lot of those guys. I don't even know if that was like, was that pre-Milo or post-Milo I had. There was a bunch of these guys that had realized there was a movement online. And in a lot of ways, what's really interesting is I'm very anti-censorship. However, there is no denying. I shouldn't even say however.
Starting point is 00:10:17 I'm very anti-censorship. I think it's a terrible way to behave. I think it's a terrible way to sort out the truth, to just silence people and remove people from platforms. And the idea that Twitter and Facebook and YouTube are just private companies and they can do whatever they want, I think it's bigger than that now. I really do. I think this is a legitimate modern day free speech issue to the point where there's a real argument to be made that if you're not on these platforms, you're not just diminished. They've silenced you in a way that changes the narrative. You don't get to see the other person's point of view. Even people that
Starting point is 00:11:02 are incredibly polarizing like Trump, it's fucking amazing that they can just remove the 45th president of the United States from everything. And he can't even communicate anymore. Yeah. You know, I mean, you could say it's because of the Capitol attack. You could say it's because a lot of things. And I get your perspective, but I do not agree with silencing him. I just don't think, you know, they just didn't want him to win again.
Starting point is 00:11:24 Yeah. But my point was, back then, all these alt-right guys were catching a lot of steam. They had a lot of momentum on their side. Milo, who is a very charismatic, very articulate, humorous guy. So he would do these interviews the the right loved him he would go on you know all these different talk shows and he would make fun of everything and even bill maher loved him and it was interesting right and then there was a lot of these guys that came along that would they would uh parrot alt-right talking points and's like, if you pay attention to online forums,
Starting point is 00:12:06 when they're left alone, like Reddit's a great example, they had to close down the Donald, right? Reddit decided this is just too nuts. It's too nuts. It's too much. I don't agree with that either. But they stepped in because shit posting is a real thing, right? And people love saying things they're not supposed to say, and they love riling people up. Now, when you're a person, whether it's Charles Johnson or someone else,
Starting point is 00:12:30 that finds this avenue where you can get a lot of attention by stirring shit and saying things, and maybe you don't even agree with, but saying things that are going to rile up people on the left and get a bunch of shit posters and hardcore right-wing people online to love you. People lean in towards that, and there was a lot of that going on. I think that's where Gavin McGinnis went south. That's where Milo went south. A lot of these guys. And then once the wave of censorship came in and those guys started getting deplatformed,
Starting point is 00:13:02 you see, it really did have a massive impact on the culture because there was a movement, man. It was a big movement, and they essentially threw water on that movement. Do you... I actually want to press you on one thing because my impulse as a journalist is to ask you questions. So most of your critics, the shit they say about who you platform,
Starting point is 00:13:21 I find ridiculous because often you're platforming people who are already popular, and I'm with you in that if someone is already a big figure, they're a big figure. All the best we can do is interrogate their beliefs. A couple of times where I'm more sympathetic to your critics. One was like Johnson. Although then I saw you go back and forth with him on Twitter about the, like this black gene violence bullshit. Did I? Yeah. Briefly. I didn't even know he was going to, obviously I didn't know anything about him.
Starting point is 00:13:48 I don't even know why I had him on. I think maybe he wrote one thing that I thought was humorous or something. I don't remember because it was so long ago. But to me there's a big difference between, later on we're surely going to talk about rapid onset gender dysphoria. Abigail Shreyer wrote a big best-selling book.
Starting point is 00:14:04 You can't deny that's part of the conversation. I think it's crazy people try, whether you agree with her or not, you can't shut that down. To me, that's like one subset of conversation where I'm like, you have to have those conversations. The one area where I sort of agree with your critics, I know you might not want to talk about this guy, but like when you had Alex Jones on and he's, there's this conspiracy theory about the governor of Virginia harvesting organs from fetuses. When did he say that? He did on your show. Which one?
Starting point is 00:14:33 I think the 2019 one. It was the 9-11? This is when Eddie came in talking about that voice. He had that character voice. He's talking about, oh, the little babies. He's talking in a southern voice. Remember that? That's what he was talking about, but I'll try to find that.
Starting point is 00:14:46 Yeah. Let's see if we can find that because that is, again, with Alex, I never know what the fuck he's going to say. Right. Well, but that's what I'm saying. To me, the difference there is he's targeting a human with bullshit and an office building. Your listeners mostly understand he's an entertainer, but if 1% of them believe this is true, you could see that causing trouble. I think he's just an entertainer. See, that's% of them believe this is true, you could see that causing trouble.
Starting point is 00:15:05 I think he's just an entertainer. See, that's why I would- You think he believes that stuff? He believes a lot of it. Yeah. Yes. And he's right about many things and he's wrong about many things. That's the problem.
Starting point is 00:15:13 What percentage of his craziest sounding beliefs do you think he himself believes in? Well, the crazy sounding ones. The problem with some of the crazy sounding ones, they turned out to be true. Because he was telling me about Epstein Fucking a decade ago. Well, let me tell you this is this is nuts man. Like a decade ago He's like well what they do is they compromise all these elites they take them they bring them to this island I haven't fucked these underage girls and they film it. I was like what that is so crazy They got an island and then it turns out to be true. Well, not only true. Not only listen man. It's fucking true not to be true well the island's true not only listen man it's fucking true like it's there's a lot of evidence that it's true there's a lot of testimony from a lot of different people whether
Starting point is 00:15:51 or not they fucked them they were there they and whether or not they really have film of them fucking them it is very bizarre that you have these high level people in both science it's celebrities politicians and they fly to this fucking island where this convicted pedophile has this weird spot where he takes people. This is my point. Like, Alex told me about this a long time ago, and it sounded like Looney Tunes talk.
Starting point is 00:16:18 Yeah. You know, he was talking to me about human monkey chimeras that they were working on a long time ago. Sounds like loony shit. I saw it on the news. I mean, there was a science paper published about human monkey. See if you can find the chimeras, the human monkey chimeras. They worked in embryos.
Starting point is 00:16:39 I'm looking at it. I'm trying to watch Alex Jones' mouth. I'm trying to read his lips on the other clip. Oh, Jamie's editing in real time. But the human chimeras that they did, they said that they had only done it in embryonic form. Yeah, first monkey-human embryos reignite debate over hybrid animals. This is something that Alex was telling me about.
Starting point is 00:17:00 You should interview one of the human monkey chimeras. I don't think they actually are viable. They don't bring them to life. But Alex was telling me about this years ago, that they do these things for genetic experiments. It's completely unethical. It's terrible. Nobody would ever have funded it, but they don't do it publicly.
Starting point is 00:17:17 And then they tell you once they've already done all the research, then they come out with it. There's been a shit ton of these wacky things. He's one of those guys where he tells me things and I just go, huh, okay, well how do I do, hmm. So the last podcast that I did with him and Tim Dillon, I fact-checked everything.
Starting point is 00:17:35 I found the part. You found it? Okay, good. There we go. Here we go. Governor of Virginia talks about post-birth abortion and watch the unedited three-minute video. How do you call it abortion if it's already been born? Well, that's what Trump said. He said a month ago when this first broke, he said, and see, the left is so compartmentalized.
Starting point is 00:17:54 I'm not saying you're the left, but mainstream media, whatever. We're so censored now. They're making their move right now. Who's they? The globalist technocracy, the mad scientists, the guys that want to learn the secrets of the universe. So what you're saying is a lot of this censorship, a lot of this is about. Joe, I will give one million. I don't have 10 million.
Starting point is 00:18:13 I will give, before God and country, to Jamie's. I'm not kidding. I will give one million dollars to your charity of choice. No, no, listen to me. This is serious, Jamie. You need to come out for the children. I will give you $1 million. What the fuck have I done?
Starting point is 00:18:31 It's okay. If you can prove that I'm making up that the governor said we keep babies alive after they're born, we keep them comfortable. And then it turns out he's an organ harvesting thing, and that's what they're doing. So they keep babies alive. Don't go to Snopes. Go to the governor. Go to the governor of Virginia. harvesting thing and that's what they're doing so they keep babies alive don't go to snopes go to the governor go to the governor of virginia and that's why they went ahead and burned him for the blackface what they were using to blackmail him they already had that on him now is what did what
Starting point is 00:18:57 did he say he was saying that they kept them comfortable after birth and that but did he actually say that the governor actually say that that's what i think i'm trying to find the part where he found out. I think there was a clip where he said something like that for sure. It's a misunderstanding. The governor talked about this crazy unlikely situation where a fetus is still alive. What would you do then? And he said, we would keep it comfortable. And if the mother wanted to revive it, we would. He didn't say we're going to kill it. And to jump from that, which was a very specific question, answer to a very specific question to the state of governor is harvesting fetal organs. Okay, let me ask you this. If he's saying they keep it comfortable and if the mother wanted to revive it, they would,
Starting point is 00:19:35 that is a ethical landmine, isn't it? Of course it is. You're talking about a fetus that's like barely, yeah. I understand. But if they do harvest organs from that fetus, is that real? No, as far as I can tell, that part is completely made up. How can you? Yeah, I think a lot of what he does is he takes some little sliver of truth, and either because he may get up or he has an overactive imagination, that becomes a grand conspiracy theory where the state of Virginia, anyway. But you would understand why just that statement alone
Starting point is 00:20:05 would freak people the fuck out. There's a choice that the mother can make to keep the baby alive. Well, it's not a... If she wanted it to be revived. Right? Yeah, I know. It's a matter of... Is that what he said? Is that his words? We shouldn't
Starting point is 00:20:21 say this unless we know his actual words. And maybe he misspoke, right? I mean, a lot of these guys are old. They misspeak a lot and they're under pressure. You have to recognize that too. Like, look at Biden. I mean, we give Biden more free passes than any president in the history of presidents. And he's only been a president for seven months. We give him all these free passes because we know he misspeaks because we know he's compromised. So let's hear what it says. Other restrictions now in place. And she was pressed by a Republican delegate about whether her bill would permit an abortion, even as a woman is essentially dilating, ready to give
Starting point is 00:20:56 birth. And she answered that it would permit an abortion at that stage of labor. Do you support her measure and explain her answer? Yeah, you know, I wasn't there, Julie, and I certainly can't speak for Delegate Tran, but I will tell you one first thing I would say. This is why decisions such as this should be made by providers, physicians, and the mothers and fathers that are involved. Jamie, I didn't interrupt. Start it over. Back it up 10 seconds.
Starting point is 00:21:29 Notice he's usurping law. Their whole plan is bioethics. I'll explain in a minute. Let's let him. Let him talk. It's only two minutes. Mothers and fathers that are involved. There are, you know, when we talk about third trimester abortions, these are done with the consent of obviously the mother, with the consent of the physicians, more than one physician, by the way.
Starting point is 00:21:53 And it's done in cases where there may be severe deformities. There may be a fetus that's non-viable. So in this particular example, if a mother is in labor, I can tell you exactly what would happen. The infant would be delivered. The infant would be kept comfortable. The infant would be resuscitated if that's what the mother and the family desired. And then a discussion would ensue between the physicians and the mother. So I think this was really blown out of proportion.
Starting point is 00:22:23 But again, we want the government not to be involved in these types of decisions. We want the decision to be made by the mothers and their providers. And this is why, Julie, that legislators, most of whom are men, by the way, shouldn't be telling a woman what she should and shouldn't be doing with her body. And do you think multiple physicians should have to weigh in as is currently required? She's trying to lift that requirement. Well, I think it's always good to get a second opinion and for at least two providers to be involved in that decision because these decisions shouldn't be taken lightly.
Starting point is 00:22:57 And so, you know, I would certainly support more than one provider. All right. Let's go back. Can I break in for a minute? Yeah, please. Wow. That's a weird thing that she just kind of let him say. This is a weird outlying situation where the abortion is in the context of a non-viable fetus. So that was different. Like what are you saying is the deformities and non-viable fetuses? But the thing about deformities is like there's a lot of human beings with deformities. We have to decide whether or not it's OK if you give birth. The way he phrased it was very concerning, wasn't it to you? No, because I think he phrased it poorly, but I think he's talking about you would only have an abortion that late in the case of the fetus not being viable in the first place.
Starting point is 00:23:36 And then he did not answer the question well, but he's talking about a weird situation where then the fetus was surviving outside the womb. And think about Jones's idea that this is part of a conspiracy to harvest baby organs. How far that is from what he's talking about. No, listen, I completely agree with that. I think what this is, it's an abortion rights discussion. Yeah, yeah. Abortion is one of those conversations that are – it's an incredibly human conversation in that there's clearly – there's times when abortion disturbs almost everybody. Yeah, yeah.
Starting point is 00:24:17 That's what the polling shows. Very few people are absolutists on it. Yes. It's a very human thing. When you're talking about a bundle of cells in the very early stages it seems like most people would support abortion but when you get to third trimester you get to what they're talking about what this is basically that she's ready to give birth that's when people get super uncomfortable with it and that's when you run into people that take this whole discussion and turn it into what you're saying, which is like you're making
Starting point is 00:24:47 this loony conspiracy about harvesting organs. And I think if you're Alex Jones or if you're like an anti-abortion figure, like you want to pull the conversation in that direction. You want people debating like basically babies being aborted, even though most abortions take place in different contexts. But if you're a guy who's looking for – so the thing about Alex is he's balls deep in this stuff all day long. Like that's all he does. All he does is research government corruption, research false flag events, research CIA operations in Nicaragua and Panama. Like that's his day. So he's paranoid already. Yeah. And then on top of it,
Starting point is 00:25:27 he's getting real data in of real conspiracies. What do you think the line is for like having someone like him or Johnson on now that your show is like super big and you have a huge platform? It's a different line. Yeah. It's a different line. And that's one of the reasons why the last time I had Alex on, I fact-checked everything he said. I go, pause. I go, I want to research this. But unfortunately, a lot of it was true.
Starting point is 00:25:53 One of them was the Associated Press report on children catching polio from the polio vaccine that they were giving these kids in Africa. It was like this cover of... And I was like that's not real and then he brings out this article and you're reading this article about children getting vaccines in Africa and these vaccines giving them polio yeah well so this you know I'm
Starting point is 00:26:17 saying like those kind of things I want to when he says those things I want to go stop that can't be real and then it turns out to actually be real well so. Well, so I want to talk about my book and this is a good segue because like one of the main things I write about is how to know whether to trust experts. And so to me with someone like Jones, the Sandy Hook thing is such a fuck up that from then on, I'm going to be very skeptical. A hundred percent. Yeah. A hundred percent. And he admits it was a fuck up. He was in a very bad place in his life. He was drinking heavily, and I think he was going crazy. And he brought himself back, and he's had mental health issues.
Starting point is 00:26:52 He also had a significant head injury when he was a kid. In a fight, someone beat him up and slammed him on his head on the concrete. And, like, significant head injury. Like, he's been fucked up from that since high school. Did you see, listen to like John Ronson's reporting on his childhood? I did, but John Ronson said like that it got all his teeth knocked out.
Starting point is 00:27:14 And like Alex is like, no, I'll show you an x-ray. I never got my teeth knocked out. They're all his teeth. So there's some of that. That's not true. Also Ronson was with him in Bohemian Grove.
Starting point is 00:27:22 Like Ronson, like they set that up like in the early, it was like late 90s, early 2000s. Well, they were friends, right? Yeah, yeah. Look, Alex is a polarizing figure. But the people that know him, like how I know him, they think he's an entertaining, fun guy to be around who knows a lot of crazy shit.
Starting point is 00:27:43 The problem is he's so polarizing that saying that opens you up to so much criticism that everybody immediately wants to push back. Well, okay. So if the question to me, would I want to go drinking with Alex Jones? The answer would be absolutely. If the question was- I can set that up. Please do. I've been Austin. I struggle with this platforming stuff. He's one of the few people where I would have some qualms about it he needs someone with him he needs guardrails basically he needs someone like me
Starting point is 00:28:12 I'm not going to do it Alex but he needs someone who's like hold on let's see if that's true and if you just leave him on his show and he's ranting and raving and he's there all day and he's drinking two bottles of tequila it's going to be a wild ass crazy show and he's not even remember half the shit he said but if you can rein him in he has a lot of fucking information about false flag events a lot of information about like some like people think he's a right-wing guy when i met him he got
Starting point is 00:28:41 arrested for uh going after george w Bush and saying he was perpetrating crimes against humanity. Well, he's sort of like anti-establishment. He's not left or right. I mean, I know that. Exactly, in many ways. I mean, he has some right-wing views, but he has a lot of left-wing views, particularly on gay people, on racial issues, on things along those lines.
Starting point is 00:29:01 He's very open-minded. He's a weird guy in that way. People characterize him incorrectly. But I see what you're saying. And the Sandy Hook thing, obviously, it's indefensible. But even he thinks it's indefensible. What do you do when someone does something like that? Do you dismiss them forever? It's like one of those things.
Starting point is 00:29:21 Yeah, it's tricky. The thing is, people worry about people influencing folks. And for most people that see Alex on, like, the Andrew Schultz show or Michael Malice's show, they just think he's a really entertaining, crazy guy to listen to, and they enjoy it. They really enjoy listening to him. For most intelligent people, he's not going to persuade them one way or the other, other than maybe get them to look into things, maybe get them to read into things. But that's my issue. When he's ranting about the moon landing or chemicals turning frogs gay or whatever. Interdimensional child molesters. What about
Starting point is 00:30:00 that one? I'm very scared of them. We need to protect our children. The frogs turning gay, he basically is- It's like a kernel of truth. He's joking around about it, but there are pesticides that fuck with the gender of amphibians. Yeah, yeah. And they do- It's the kernel of truth. Exactly. It's phthalates.
Starting point is 00:30:18 I mean, that's something that Dr. Shanna Swan wrote about. What is the name of that book again? Sorry, we keep forgetting the name of the book, but it's a fantastic book about the way it's affecting human beings, a radical drop in testosterone levels, a radical increase in miscarriages, this countdown. Dr. Shanna H. Swan, how our modern world is threatening sperm counts, altering male and female reproductive development, and impairing the future of the human race. This is a terrifying conversation that I had with her.
Starting point is 00:30:49 I don't know if you listened to that one. No. But it's really good. And it's just, she's a scientist. Yeah. And it's all just about phthalates and pesticides and the effect they have on human reproductive systems, but also on frogs. Yeah. Pesticides really do have a radical impact on frogs and amphibians
Starting point is 00:31:06 could we talk about my book for a minute can we talk about anything you want did you bring a book I brought a book this Alex Jones conversation is probably one of the biggest ones that I have with people where they're like why
Starting point is 00:31:21 first of all I've been friends with that guy for 20 years. I've known him forever. Isn't there a risk that there's a risk of bias there, if you're being honest? Yes. Yeah, for sure. So it's harder for you to let him go. For sure.
Starting point is 00:31:34 Yeah, exactly. Yeah, for sure. I'm telling you, you're going to drink with him. How many days are you in town for? I'm here until Thursday. Oh, what are you doing tomorrow night? During the day, I'm going tubing with my girlfriend and her parents. So at night, I can then take them and meet Alex Jones.
Starting point is 00:31:49 Could Alex Jones meet us on the river tubing? Alex Jones has shit to do. He's got to uncover Illuminati theories. A two-dimensional child molester. Yeah. Interdimensional. I think I disagree with you on this, but it's one of those things where I want to make sure my own— But what do you disagree with?
Starting point is 00:32:04 What do you think i think he's one of the few people where i would only i'm in favor of platforming almost everyone platforming is a fucked up conversation no i know no it's very most in 99 percent of the time i agree with you but it's you're in a unique situation because you have so many listeners and one percent of your listeners is fucking 30 000 people and if they now think the governor of virginia harvesting baby organs that I'm using causing harm, which is what people say about my work, it causes harm. I think it's a tricky conversation. It is a tricky conversation. That particular clip is a real problem because it's, you know, to draw the conclusion that he drew.
Starting point is 00:33:06 You know, to draw the conclusion that he drew, my conclusion that I drew from that is like, Jesus Christ, that is such a weird area of discussion, like whether or not you should revive a fetus once it's been born and to decide to revive or not revive based on whether or not it's deformed or whatever the issue is that it has physically, whatever ailment or. It's like, it's like a, I took like in college, of course, on like bioethics and that shit is really heavy and doctors have to make really difficult decisions. So yeah. I think the real problem was him having that conversation on the radio and probably like unprepared. He probably didn't know that that was going to be one of the things he talked about. Yeah. And the way he discussed it, you know, if you, I think it's an issue like that is something that you really should sit down and write out your actual thoughts and think about those, solidify them. Well, so I felt a little bad for Jamie because I was trying to imagine if I had
Starting point is 00:33:38 to fact check him in real time. Yeah. You know, and that's sort of what I do for a living is I fact check stuff. That would be really hard. It would take two hours to fully trace that rumor and what's true. What's false? it's just not it maybe it's not a good for sort of a Straight to tape basically live show not only that we're drunk. That's and high Yes, and Eddie Bravo's on there who believes it's in some wacky shit that even Alex doesn't believe in, you know So he's even more out there. Oh, he gets out there. He gets out there. I'm trying to think what's more out there than interdimensional child molesters. Flat Earth?
Starting point is 00:34:10 I'm trying to think which of those two. Interdimensional child molesters, Flat Earth, which is more likely to be true. It's tough. Yeah. I don't know how interdimensional. Yeah. They're both right up there. He's informed me of some real things, though.
Starting point is 00:34:26 One of them, I didn't know about the widespread use of agent provocateurs throughout history. I really wasn't aware of that. I wasn't aware of that. The government has an actual strategy that they use to break up peaceful protests by bringing in people who cause violence. And it's happened forever, and they used it for the World Trade Organization in, was it 99? Whatever it was. And Alex detailed that in depth, and he showed through news reports, he showed through stories
Starting point is 00:34:55 in the news, and he showed through video clips how these masked people came in and took this peaceful protest, and they just started randomly breaking windows and tipping over mailboxes and doing all this crazy shit, and how they were ultimately let go. And now they're all wearing government-issue boots, and the cops never arrested them, or they allowed them to hide out in a building together, and then they all made some sort of a negotiation and released them. But I think that fuels conspiracy theorists, is that the shit even just our government has done over the years has been so weird that I don't blame people. Not even weird. The secret bombing of Cambodia.
Starting point is 00:35:30 Yes. That's like a superhero villain shit. Well, how about the Gulf of Tonkin incident that got us into Vietnam? Yeah. How about Operation Northwood, signed by the Joint Chiefs of Staff and vetoed by Kennedy? They were going to blow up a fucking jetliner and blame it on Cuba. They were going to have a drone jetliner, say it was filled with people. This is, what was this, 61 or something like that? And then they were going to use Cuban friendlies, armed Cuban friendlies to attack
Starting point is 00:35:55 Guantanamo Bay. And they were going to use this as impetus to go to war with Cuba. It's crazy shit. And that's real. I mean, this is all available through the Freedom of Information Act. You can read the Operation Northwoods documents. This is a plan they had. I mean this was going to cost American lives because they wanted to gather some sort of motivation from the American people. Consensus. They wanted to get the American people involved to the point where they were willing to go to war with Cuba. It's crazy when you think that that is actually our government in 1961 or whenever it was, 62, whatever it was. It was before Kennedy
Starting point is 00:36:33 got killed. He got killed in 63, right? So whatever happened from then, those people weren't prosecuted. They weren't brought in front of Congress and like explain yourself. There's often no accountability. So my position on that kind of shit is if that's how it was then, what is the difference between then and now? Well, everything evolves. They get better at things. They get more sophisticated. Yeah.
Starting point is 00:36:57 All right. You got a book in there? I heard you got a book. Yeah. That's so weird. Jesse, did you write a book? The Quick Fix? It's a very douchey thing to do. This is for Jamie if you had a book. Yeah, that's so weird. Jesse, did you write a book? The Quick Fix? It's a very douchey thing to do.
Starting point is 00:37:05 This is for Jamie, if you want a copy. This is your book about psychological things, right? Explain your book. Yeah, it's The Quick Fix, Why Fad Psychology Can't Cure Social Illness. That's a good sign that I had to look at the book to remember what it's called. I was a science editor at New York Magazine. I wrote about psychology, basically. I was a science editor at New York Magazine.
Starting point is 00:37:24 I wrote about psychology, basically. And every day we get press releases from Harvard, from Yale, from University of Pennsylvania that psychologists are figuring out amazing stuff about how to fix the world, how to fix racism, how to fix the educational system. And a lot of these, when I looked into them more, there's like nothing there. There's no actual result there. And people spend, you know, hundreds of millions of dollars on these ideas that don't really do anything. Have you ever taken the, do you know the implicit association test? What that is? No. All right. Do you know
Starting point is 00:37:53 implicit bias? Yes. Okay. So this is a test. You sit at a computer. It tells you how unconsciously racist you are. So anyone listening to this who's done a diversity training recently at work has probably heard of the implicit association test. Since 1998, leading psychologists are like, this test will measure your unconscious racism, racism you're not even aware of. And this leaks into the real world that makes you do racist stuff. And we end up spending millions of dollars on it. Every school embraces it. Every company embraces it, except whoops, there's nothing there. It doesn't actually measure anything. So I'm really interested in those instances where like the most and maybe this is uh why i should drink with alex jones we're the most important experts in the world tell us shit and it's just it's not true um how much has to do with when the spreading this kind
Starting point is 00:38:41 of information how much of it has to do with clickbait? One of the things that's disturbed me over the last decade or so is that journalism, even journalism at its highest levels without naming any names, but like fabled institutions are resorting to clickbait. You know, my friend Kurt Metzger said something about the New York times. Once he said, it's like a fat girl's tumblr blog now and I'm like that is such a fucked-up thing to say but What he was saying was that there's stories that are written in there that are they're not What you associate with the New York Times of old I still read the New York Times. I still love me too I think it's great. I mean, I think people are always looking for flaws in any institution, right? Especially a fabled one in times of chaos like we are today.
Starting point is 00:39:31 Part of us wants to see them collapse. Exactly. Yeah, people do, but I still think they're the best. And I think there's something about having a reputation to uphold that does force people to the highest standards. But those standards are different. It's very difficult to find unbiased, objective news with a clean headline today, because people aren't buying the newspaper like they were. It's mostly clicking things online. And there's a lot of these that have, they rely on subscription services. They rely on someone coming along and saying, you know what? I value your journalism so much. I'm going to give you some money. And then you have to justify the articles. There's ads on these articles in a lot of times and you got to get people to click on them. So
Starting point is 00:40:22 you have maybe a title to that article that's not totally accurate or bends the truth a little bit or it's inflammatory. Well, everyone gets more desperate because they just need to keep feeding the beast. So I think the key difference is like, I would imagine, you know, I never got to be a science writer or editor in 1990, but back then journalism was healthy. And I bet you could be a writer, you know, you publish, it's still hard work. Right. But you publish three articles a week, four articles a week. When I was editing Science of Us, that was the sort of behavioral science site at New York Magazine. I forget what it was. I think we had to publish like 15 to 20 things a week.
Starting point is 00:40:56 So when Harvard. Yeah, dude. When Harvard sends you a press release, like we have this amazing new study. We're like, great. Write it up. We don't call the researcher. Right. We don't read it closely.
Starting point is 00:41:04 Oftentimes we read the press release but not the study itself. Like we have this amazing new study. We're like, great, write it up. We don't call the researcher. We don't read it closely. Oftentimes we read the press release but not the study itself. And it's sort of like the press releases often, they don't quite lie, but they leave out a lot of details. And so 2010 was sort of the peak when the stuff in my book in psychology, like the worst psychology was being published. 2010 was also when things got really, really clickbaity, I think. Why was, what happened in 2010 that like the worst psychology got published? This is where it gets complicated, but like certain areas of research. So one of them is called social priming. And that's the idea that if I like, if I flash an American flag before your eyes for 300 milliseconds, you'll get way more patriotic. And it sounds like voodoo magic, but for a while,
Starting point is 00:41:47 people really believe these results. And the reason they believe them is because there's all these ways you can fuck up statistically, and you publish stuff that appears to be true, but isn't false. So let's say I asked you off the bat, take the top psychology journals around. What percentage of the findings in them would you say could be replicated later on if you run it back? Oh, I have no idea. It's about a 50%. There's a coin flip chance that anything you read in the top psychology journals, some people think it's higher, some think it's lower. Have you ever read the stuff that Helen Pluckrose and James Lindsay and Peter Boghossian put out?
Starting point is 00:42:22 I've read some of their stuff, yeah, yeah. Yeah, where they published these sort of satirical. Oh, Sokol Square. Yeah. Satirical scientific papers that actually got accepted. The dog rape, dog rape. Yeah, yeah, well, it had the most, see if you can find the title of their dog,
Starting point is 00:42:41 because it wasn't, it had to do with homosexuality and but it but meanwhile they were getting like lauded for these things they were getting applauded for uh like fat bodybuilding right like there's a lot of where they were joking around about how bad academia has gotten yeah and they made these farcical papers and some of them won awards. A lot of the problems they are concerned with, it's not just sort of like the wacky Marxist geography. It's like some of the top psychology papers in the country. It's tricky because I want people to trust experts. I want people to trust science, but a lot of scientists themselves don't know what they're doing. Yeah. It makes it complicated. A lot of scientists don't know what they're doing. How so?
Starting point is 00:43:22 scientists themselves don't know what they're doing. It makes it complicated. A lot of scientists don't know what they're doing. How so? So it's hard to explain this without getting into some statistics. I'm not good at statistics, but basically people realize that the statistical tests people do to decide if something is significant, meaning we're pretty sure Joe Rogan comes out with a pill to cure the common cold. We give 50 people that pill. We give 50 people a placebo. The people who take the pill do better. The cold goes away.
Starting point is 00:43:50 At a certain threshold, you're like, this is a real result. This isn't just random statistical noise. And it turns out there's lots of ways to fool yourself into thinking the pill works when it doesn't. And that's basically what psychologists realized. And that led them to understand that arguably most of what they publish is garbage, basically. Do you know what a nocebo is? Yeah. Yeah.
Starting point is 00:44:11 One of my favorite stories was a guy who was involved in a test where they were doing a study where they gave him – they gave one group an SSRI, and the other group they gave a placebo. This guy, for whatever reason, took a shitload of pills and ran to the hospital with an elevated pulse, high blood pressure, holding this pill bottle, freaking out, thinking he's dying, telling them that he fucked up and he took the whole bottle of pills and he's going to die. They contact the physician. The physician comes down and informs him that he was a part of the control group and he had taken a placebo. Within minutes, his heart rate drops down to normal, his blood pressure drops down to normal, and he's fine. So this guy who was convinced he was going to die had just completely done it to himself.
Starting point is 00:45:03 He had decided that he had taken some sort of fucking poison or something, you know, some horrible medication and far exceeding the dose you're supposed to take. I remember being 19 and smoking weed with my roommate out of like a Gatorade bottle that you put the hole in and be like, Oh man, I'm so fucked up. Like you, you have no idea you were so influenced by what we think substances are going to do to us. It has like a profound effect on us. Yeah. But that probably did get you high.
Starting point is 00:45:30 This was very sort of swaggy Massachusetts weed. It still got THC in it. This was pretty weak, I think. Yeah, but if you were a kid, how old were you? I was like 18 or 19. Maybe I was high. I'm sure you were high. Like weed, even swaggy THC weak weed from Massachusetts would still get you fucked up. There was another point I got a little too high and I fled the dorm room.
Starting point is 00:45:55 And my roommate called me and I was convinced he was sitting with the police trying to lure me back there to arrest me for smoking weed. Sounds like decent weed. Yeah, maybe it was actually. I shouldn't have denigrated the swaggy Massachusetts weed. Listen, I've had some swaggy Pennsylvania weed and it freaked me out. Human reactions to rape culture and queer performity at urban dog parks in Portland, Oregon. That's the paper.
Starting point is 00:46:17 Yeah. Yeah. I mean, they published this in Gender Place and Cultural, a Journal feminist geography and helen wilson and it got applauded yeah i won an award right yeah i mean they were saying this is amazing scholarship this is incredible work but it just goes to show you academia is in a weird place man it's it's in this weird it's always been in a weird place but it's an exceptionally weird place today with the climate of our culture. Because these people, a lot of them that are teaching these courses, a lot of them that are professors, they went from being a student and living in this world to then getting a
Starting point is 00:46:58 job at the university to becoming a professor. So they've never been out there in the regular world outside of this insulated bubble of academia. The same thing's happening in journalism because especially as like more and more of us come from upper middle class, like good college settings, we all have the same beliefs. We're all not really tolerant of people with different beliefs and it's turning journalism into a shit show actually. It's really depressing because like, what's the point of being a journalist or an academic if you're not going to be open-minded and actually interrogate the world a little bit? It's just so important to have objective,
Starting point is 00:47:35 unbiased versions of the truth. And to not have that in a reliable source. I mean, like I said, I think the New York Times is the best. I think Washington Post is excellent too. There's a lot of good newspapers still that I think do the best job that we currently have available. Yeah, yeah. But I would like something that's bulletproof. I would like something that doesn't have any opinion pieces that are preposterous.
Starting point is 00:48:00 It's hard to get that. It's hard. I often get emails from people that are like, you know, I don't trust the Times anymore. What should I do? It's like, no, you should mostly trust the Times. You should realize that, like, they're a human institution. I don't think if we went back in time to 1970, the Times would be bulletproof then.
Starting point is 00:48:15 They published Garbage then, too. I do think it's getting worse. Yeah, I think so. Well, I think the worst is television. Television news is the most— It's unwatchable. It's the most nutty. And that's why things like, what was Crystal and Sager's new show called? Breaking Points. They used to be
Starting point is 00:48:37 rising on the hill. That show is so good because they don't have to listen to anybody. They're not a part of some giant system. And now that they're doing their own independent show, they're even more so. And they have opinions and they don't necessarily agree with each other, but they're not beholden to any institution and they're not vetted. There's no filter that they have to go through, some corporate filter when they discuss these important issues. So a little more than a year ago, I started the podcast I sort of do for a living now, Blocked and Reported with Katie Herzog. Your listeners should all harass her on Twitter. Harass her? Yeah, just Katie Herzog. It seems like we get along, but she's mean to me on the show a lot,
Starting point is 00:49:16 so I should go after her comeuppance. I noticed that because she worked at a place called The Stranger in Seattle. I worked for New York Magazine. I left under good terms just to write the book. But once we got in our own bubble and we realized that no one who mattered could get pissed off at us and we didn't have to answer to editors, I don't know. It just made the conversation much more free-flowing. We could talk about what we want to talk about. It's the biggest difference in the world when you're not looking over your shoulder. Or it's not just the bosses who are the problem. It's like, is your 25-year-old colleague going to be very sensitive about what you said and report to the HR?
Starting point is 00:49:51 And go to human resources. Yeah, which is, I think, have you had Jonathan Haidon before? Yes. Yeah. I got, in 2015, I got lunch with him. And we talked about our agreements, our disagreements. I thought he was overreacting to the crazy college shit. I was like, these are crazy college kids.
Starting point is 00:50:07 They'll get to the real world. They'll have to hold down a job. The craziness will go away. When did you apologize to him? Last year on Twitter. I did. Ready-made answer for that. If he didn't see it, John, I apologize.
Starting point is 00:50:23 We disagree on this or that, but it's absolutely the case that in journalism, that shit has infiltrated some newsrooms. Yes. And it makes it very hard to do journalism. Well, it's also infiltrated corporations in a massively disingenuous way because they've recognized that the wind is blowing in that direction. So they'll put up a rainbow flag. Wait, are you saying Halliburton isn't committed to social justice? You said that.
Starting point is 00:50:46 I didn't say that. I don't know who your sponsors are. I shouldn't say that. Are you saying the Kill Cliff CBD energy drink isn't pro-LGBT? They actually are. Okay. It's very pineapple. That's mine.
Starting point is 00:51:00 That's my flavor. This is yours? Yeah, it's got my face on it. I didn't even notice that. Oh, shit. That's me, bro. It's a jalapeno pineapple. Is this you on an acid trip with Alex Jones?
Starting point is 00:51:09 I don't think Alex does acid. He doesn't need to. There's no way. Alex doesn't do acid. I mean, he probably has. His brain just produces it. He gets high. Yeah.
Starting point is 00:51:18 You're going to like him. You're going to not like that you like him. I don't. Oh, yeah. All right. Oh, yeah. This is fucking going to be a disaster. No, that's one of my goals is to get people to understand why I like him.
Starting point is 00:51:32 I think people have seen him on other shows and they get it now. But again, you're right. The Sandy Hook thing is just like freaks people the fuck out. Yeah. And rightly so. Yeah. He, you know, he's in a weird position because of something like that it's like how do you bounce back from that if you ever do you know what like this the
Starting point is 00:51:52 cancel culture of today is uh such a it's such a beat-up term you know and it's so it's it i don't even like saying it me neither yeah we need a better, but then that term would get corrupted. Yeah, it's for sure been corrupted, as has woke, as has many, many terms. What we have now is a bunch of people who have this ability to gather up crowds to go after people and try to hurt people's feelings. And it's really that old adage that hurt people hurt people. It really is that. Yeah. Because most of these people, like I said, I study multiple people. I literally have a file where I follow people that I think are the most unhinged.
Starting point is 00:52:39 And I don't have any personal relationship with them. I don't have any beef with them. I don't even have interactions with them. personal relationship with them. I don't have any beef with them. I don't even have interactions with them. I just watch them just like, like a rabid dog, just barking at all the other dogs. I think they did you sitting at your laptop and you're like, oh, that's going in the file. The thing is like, some of them are brilliant people in their chosen field. You know, they're, they're actually successful at the thing that they do, but they're just mentally unwell. And then they, I mean, when I say mentally unwell,
Starting point is 00:53:05 what I mean is they're, they're not emotionally balanced. They're not comfortable, happy people. And I think we should encourage compassion and we should encourage decency and kindness to people. And they're not doing that. They think they're on the right side. So because they think they're on the right side, it justifies being a really shitty person so i i was the one who brought up the connection to mental health and i do think there's some mentally ill people who get you know twitter makes it worse i but i think that's like sort of i'm worried that's like too easy now because um i don't know if you remember this you might have talked about this on the show there was a moment last year when all the public health researchers were like those far-right protesters getting together to protest mass and lockdown, that's so dangerous. You can't get together.
Starting point is 00:53:49 There's a pandemic. Then the next week, George Floyd happened. And then there's BLM protests. You can do BLM protests. So it's like the same people flipping it. That kind of behavior, that's not mental illness. That's just like you want the positive approval. You want to stay in the good graces of your tribe. So I think it's a little bit of both. Well, there's, again, we're going back to confirmation bias. This was a conversation that I was having with a friend of mine who was pro the George Floyd protests. And I said, listen, I'm 100% pro people protesting. I go, if they're just protesting, as soon as it gets violent and the chaos and that bothers me. But it is kind of crazy that all of a sudden we're okay with people screaming shoulder to shoulder with each other.
Starting point is 00:54:31 The whole idea is that this stuff is airborne. Yeah. And his take on it was like there's no significant evidence that proves that it's spreading. I go, that is horseshit, man. that proves that it's spreading. I go, that is horseshit, man. I go, if you look at the fucking jumps, there's a big jump in infections post,
Starting point is 00:54:51 there's like 10 days after these protests. There's always a big jump. I go, it doesn't mean you shouldn't be able to protest. It means we should have a real discussion. Yeah, that's all you want is a discussion. Yes, about freedom and about what you shouldn't, shouldn't be able to do. And then what exactly we're doing with these protests. Yeah.
Starting point is 00:55:06 You know? I do think like the combined effect of just like the lockdowns on everyone's mental health. I just think we're going to see that for a long time. Oh, yeah. That destroyed everybody. Well, it shifted our country in a very bad way, I think. I really do think it did.
Starting point is 00:55:21 I think there's a lot of people that were already unbalanced and kind of mentally unwell, and that pushed them over the over the edge and we got to figure out how to bring people back and I don't know how to do that I mean I've I remember a time where it didn't seem like there was this gigantic gap between uh people on the left and people on the right and even people in the center like these people that are angry if you're a centrist. Yeah. It's just a different state of mind. It's like if you're not on my side, you're on the wrong side now.
Starting point is 00:55:53 It's not – I always thought that because of the internet, we're going to get more access to information. So we're going to have more access to the truth and people are going to be able to debate things and find out exactly what's up. That's what people – the 90s, the tech bros, they wrote these utopian essays about the end of ignorance or whatever. It turned out the opposite happened. I don't think it's the opposite because I think a lot of people do have that approach. There's a lot of people. But for most people, they don't have the time. Most people are tired. They work all day. They're usually not that healthy. They don't eat well.
Starting point is 00:56:26 And they're tired. And then they have either a family or they have friends. Maybe they have a husband or a wife, children, mortgage problems, neighbors, this, that, plumbing, fucking electrical. There's a power failure. Interdimensional child molesters. All those things. There's a lot of shit molesters all those things there's a lot of shit that people have to deal with they don't have the time to like develop a very nuanced
Starting point is 00:56:50 objective uh purely purely honest view of what they're looking at so they find these conglomerations of people that have adopted these predetermined patterns of behavior and these opinions. It's a conglomeration of opinions, and they just adopt those. And then they repeat the things that they think they need to say in order to be in the good graces of that group. Do you know the concept of the exhausted majority? No. I love it. I forget who.
Starting point is 00:57:22 It's either this political scientist in Arizona or these polling guys. People can Google it. The idea is like 20 percent of us are screaming at one another on Twitter, Facebook, whatever. Most of the country is just exhausted and hates talking about politics because things have gotten so heated. They don't want to say the wrong thing on Facebook. So it's sort of like the sort of controversial concept of like the silent majority. But I think there is a silent majority of people who want nothing to do with the present political discourse. And to me, that sort of explains how like people like me from Brooklyn were all Liz Warren or Bernie Sanders. And I was sort of divided between the two. And then Joe Biden just runs away with it because most people are not online. Liz Warren, it didn't drive you nuts, the Native American stuff? No. I just think all politicians are flawed one way or another. But that's such a heavy lie. Yeah. The fact that she got into Harvard with that, right? I think it helped her get in, yeah.
Starting point is 00:58:15 I didn't view it as disqualifying. She wrote Native American as her ethnicity. I'm 200 times more African than she is Native American. How African are you? 1.6%. Oh, you did the test. Yeah.
Starting point is 00:58:29 That's pretty crazy. Imagine me putting African under my, like, a job application. Actually, what number is she? Let's make sure that's correct. What percentage Native American is she? It's something crazy low. Maybe I should view that as disqualifying. I liked a lot of the other stuff she did.
Starting point is 00:58:54 Some of her professors from college have said some pretty wild shit about her, about how unbridled her ambition was. Oh, really? Yeah. One of her professors, a woman, I forget the thing, but she just didn't have nice things to say about it. But, I mean, that's the kind of people that get into politics. That's what I'm saying.
Starting point is 00:59:13 Like what person who can get that close to being president hasn't done some shit that is bad? Although I guess Bernie didn't really have any skeletons. That's the thing I always say about the guy. It's like you can disagree with him, but he's been remarkably consistent. What do you got there? I'm trying to find the DNA analysis. In the article I was looking through from NPR,
Starting point is 00:59:38 the Cherokee Association says that the DNA test doesn't matter. Well, they want you to be accepted in the tribe. Like, you have to, that's a different thing. Like, you could have the tiniest fraction of DNA, but they're not going to accept you as one of theirs. But that's not really what we're talking about. We're talking about how much Native Americans actually has in their genetics. Whether or not the Cherokee Association accepts her is kind of a different argument.
Starting point is 01:00:07 DNA now found the vast majority of it. This doesn't say, it just says the vast majority of her lineage is European ancestry. It doesn't say how much the thing is, but there was, I know for sure they did release the numbers. It doesn't have the numbers. It just says, uh,
Starting point is 01:00:18 results are strongly support the existence of an unadmixed Native American ancestor in the individual's pedigree, likely in the range of six to ten generations ago. There was an actual paper that got published. I clicked that link. Or an article. It's not active. Well, I don't know if that's the one.
Starting point is 01:00:37 I know, but that's on her website that says it would be the PDF of the report. It's not active. They pulled it. Can you imagine you're running for president and you have to post your DNA online about how Native Americans feel? Well, it's because she got a job that was a very lucrative job by saying that she's Native American. And she didn't say a small fraction. She said she's Native American. In her defense, I have a friend who thought he was Native American.
Starting point is 01:01:03 That was always his family thing. And then they did a test on him and found out he had zero. Here's the best number I've found. 1,124th. Or 1,024th. Yeah. As low as that. Yeah.
Starting point is 01:01:15 So what percentage is that? What is 1 out of 1,024th? What's that? 0.1, I think. 0.1. Yeah. 0.1. Yeah. Right. So am I really 200 times more?
Starting point is 01:01:30 It might be more of that. It might be more, right? I'm 1.6. Joe, we're all- I'm almost two out of 100. We're all African if you go back far enough. You're right. Yes.
Starting point is 01:01:41 Well, that's the dumbest thing about all of it, right? The only reason why people like i had this conversation with a friend of mine who was explaining to me um uh different uh eyes like he said there were we're talking about that guy who uh decided he was korean no he he didn't decide he transitioned to korean yes yeah well he made a decision right i mean but this is the thing where a long time ago this was how we looked at people that transitioned to different genders yeah now we accept that but when it comes to race we're like caught the shit no that's where we draw the line for now yeah in 2021 you can't just become korean But this guy decided to become Korean. Yeah. And my friend was talking
Starting point is 01:02:26 to me about this and he was saying, it's kind of crazy that this guy got his eyes done to look more Korean where Koreans get their eyes done to look more European at a really frightening rate. Like it's one of the most popular plastic surgeries in all of Korea is to get your eyes done. It seems like every culture has some exotic other... Like in India, they have skin whitening cream. Everyone wants to be a little bit different. You see Sammy Sosa now? No.
Starting point is 01:02:56 Bro, Sammy Sosa is pale like a ghost. It's nuts. That's so weird. Sammy Sosa decided that he wanted to be whiter and he started whitening his skin. That's so sad, man. It's like a bleach. When I was in Thailand, they have billboards for skin whitening creams. I was like, this is nuts, man.
Starting point is 01:03:12 It is depressing because the people look beautiful. And it also fucks with your ability to stay outside. Yeah, yeah. There's a reason why these folks have so much melanin in their skin. They have this beautiful climate and your body's protecting itself from the sun you know who i was just thinking about what you said about like the everything being ultra polarized no one could get along the guy to me that did the best job of bridging that stuff um and i listened to your interview with him when i was prepping for this was was anthony bourdain because he could go to like fucking he went to these cultures that had
Starting point is 01:03:43 they really did have views we would view as horrible about women or gay people or whatever and he intentionally didn't focus on that he focused on food and like yeah where you live and and i don't know like his i obviously didn't know him at all but his death really hit me hard because i just think that's really hard to do and we need way more people like that and we don't have any yeah yeah he hit that one hit me hard that was that was one of the roughest ones. Yeah. I didn't know he was that depressed.
Starting point is 01:04:08 I had no idea. You know, I knew that he was a complicated guy. But I actually got a text message from my friend Maynard, the lead singer of Tool. He's a jiu-jitsu practitioner. And Bourdain's a jiu-jitsu practitioner, too. And the two of them, you know, I thought it was really cool that they both got into jiu-jitsu practitioner and Bourdain's a jiu-jitsu practitioner too and the two of them you know I thought it was really cool that they they both got into jiu-jitsu and they're finding all this benefit from it emotionally and physically and Bourdain got into it like his late 50s and all
Starting point is 01:04:35 of a sudden he got ripped and like because he's he's got he had excuse me he had addictive personalities yeah it was terrible when he was doing heroin, but amazing for jujitsu. Because all of a sudden, this guy's super dedicated, and he's training every day. And so Maynard was like, I think I want to have a celebrity jujitsu match with Anthony Bourdain. You think you could hook that up? I go, I'll ask him, man.
Starting point is 01:04:56 Just joking around. And then I get this phone call or this text message when I was in Chicago from Maynard saying, I guess we won't be having that celebrity jujitsu match. That's how you found out. That's how I found out. I woke up in the morning and I looked at my phone and I was like, what does that mean?
Starting point is 01:05:12 Fuck. And then I Google Anthony Bourdain. I'm like, oh my God. Yeah. That was, it just, he, that was one of the ones where you just got, God damn it. I wish I was there. I wish I was there with him. I would say, listen, this will pass, man.
Starting point is 01:05:28 You are loved. You are a beloved person. Well, I mean, that's the thing a lot of people don't realize about suicide, because I've written a little bit about this, is it's a much more impulsive thing than people often realize. And it is that question of, like, if someone can be – that's why suicide hotlines are so important. Can you talk someone off that emotional cliff in the moment?
Starting point is 01:05:46 Because if you can. Yeah, you could probably turn them around and stop a lot of pain. It's so fucking sad. It's so fucking sad. And for him, he had so much to offer. His perspective was so unique and so passionate. And I just feel real fortunate to have met him and known him and got to hang out with him a bunch of times. It's just when someone, at least he left behind a lot.
Starting point is 01:06:13 Yeah. He left behind a lot of his work. He left behind a lot of his writing. His writing was brilliant and his show was brilliant. When you're just a normal person watching a celebrity, you can never tell like how much of it is an act. In his case, he was at the very least, like he really convincingly just seemed like he was just a great guy. Like I couldn't imagine anyone disliking him based on the personality of the show. People could definitely dislike him.
Starting point is 01:06:39 He was polarized. If he didn't like you, he would talk a lot of shit. Oh, did he? Yeah, he talked a lot of shit about like the Dave Matthews band and shit like that. Really? Because he was just humorous. He was a comic, basically. Well, yeah.
Starting point is 01:06:51 Because he wasn't a comic, but he was. We talked about he started doing these live performances where he would go in front of a whole theater. He was just getting into that when he was on your show, right? Yes, yes. And he loved it and we talked a lot about like how to do it and how how often you should turn over material and you know you know how what the approach is and he would come to see comedy a lot like he came to a bunch of my shows and we talked about this is a bummer man yeah it's just he so unique. I wanted to see him get older and just, I
Starting point is 01:07:26 wanted to see his perspective, but that motherfucker partied hard, dude. Hard. I mean, I partied with him a few times, but the hardest I ever partied with him, we were in Montana and we were for his show. We went pheasant hunting. I saw that. You guys went there? Yeah. Yeah. And then afterwards he cooked for us, which was amazing. We cooked pheasant, and I think they had grouse, and we had some steaks. And then we sat by the fire and drank whiskey and smoked weed, and we got barbecued. And that guy just kept going. He just kept going. I'm like, how can one possibly drink anymore?
Starting point is 01:08:00 Like, we're so fucked up. And he's like, who's got the bottle? I'm like, fucking let's go. Like, he was just going and just couldn't stop hitting the pipe and smoking more weed and, you know, drinking more alcohol. And we were under the stars. It was pretty wild. It was fun. But I just got to see, like, some people, you know, he had, like, a real issue with heroin and never became sober. He just sort of transitioned it into booze and
Starting point is 01:08:26 partying that way but but man when you talk food with that guy when you talk culture with that guy and just he had a passion for the i mean it was literally like the dream job for him like that that gig whether it was no reservations or whether it was Then it was the new show called parts unknown parts unknown. Yeah he He just had this love of Exploring the way people get to get like when you sit with him and watch him like talk to people while they're eating and talk
Starting point is 01:09:00 About food the fucking guy would just light up. He loved it. I was, um, this is a subject we don't need to get into in parts. I don't know much about it, but I was so impressed, honestly, that he went to the Gaza strip when he has that platform. He goes to a part of the world. Most Americans know nothing about that doesn't really get attention that says something about a guy that he would choose to use his platform in that way. I was really impressed by that. Yeah. He was an impressive guy. Yeah. He was impressed. He was one. This is a few friends that I have that I can't really believe they're my friend. So when I'm around them, I get a little nervous. Starstruck. Yeah. Even when he was my friend, I was still starstruck around him just because I admired him so much. And because I was a big
Starting point is 01:09:37 fan of his show, I was a big fan of No Reservations before I ever met him as a person. Yeah. Did, for some reason, your mention of Dave Matthews' band made me remember, I think we went to the same high school. You and I did? Newton North, right? I went to Newton South. Oh, you were in South. Yeah, yeah.
Starting point is 01:09:55 You snooty, snooty South. It was like upper, upper class versus upper middle class. Well, I lived in Newton Upper Falls, which is like a very blue-collar town. Yeah. But I was lucky that I was in the school district. It was a good school to go to. Yeah. You were only there like a couple of years though, right? No, all through high school. All four years in high school. Yeah. That must have
Starting point is 01:10:12 been weird though. Cause you, you arrived there without like any, without friends basically. You had to start from scratch. In high school. But I did that my whole life, unfortunately, or fortunately. I think ultimately fortunately because like i moved from new jersey to san francisco when i was seven we stayed in san francisco from age seven to 11 and then we moved to florida from 11 to 13 13 to 24 i lived in boston then new york then la now texas do you think that makes it like contributed to your i don't know you jump between a lot of different subjects like your different interests Do you think that makes it like contributed to your, I don't know, you jump between a lot of different subjects, like your different interests. Do you think that's connected? I think it, what it did do is it forced me to form my own opinions about things and, and to,
Starting point is 01:10:55 also I'd never felt protected. I never felt like I had a group of friends that I could count on. So I had to do everything myself. You're always sort of like on your toes almost, right? Exactly, and I would always be the new kid, and you know, and that's also how I got into martial arts, because I was like, god damn, I'm so tired of people picking on me. It was just so, it was very scary, you know, like to not have friends and to be in the school,
Starting point is 01:11:20 and also I was a short kid, so I was worried these guys were gonna beat me up, so I got involved in martial arts, which also tremendously helped my ability to see and think of things for myself because I had gone through some very, you know, competitions are dangerous and scary, and the stress level is so high. And if you can get through them on the other end, you have this incredible feeling of win lose or draw like at least i did it i faced it i went out there and i did this terrifying thing and and competed and and that's all i did for you know like six six years of my life my um my co-host was pressuring me to talk about our podcast as much as possible
Starting point is 01:12:00 oh she you guys have a podcast what's it called Did you hear that I wrote a book? You have a book. Yeah. The Quick Fix. I'm not trying to mention it enough. The Quick Fix. I like this. Very smart. Wait, who wrote this?
Starting point is 01:12:11 Oh shit, it was me. Jesse Singel. I like the orange cover. It's very smart. Katie, my co-host on Blocked and Reported. Check it out. She suggested that I ask you to break my arm on air. Well, that's not a smart thing.
Starting point is 01:12:21 As like a viral incident. She doesn't like you. Harass Katie Herzog on Twitter. Don't do it. Don't say these things. Have you had to deal with that where someone comes up on your show and then they complain that your listeners harass them? Maybe.
Starting point is 01:12:40 I'm sure. But I tell them, get off Twitter. Yeah. People use that as an... There's this thing where you'll criticize someone and then the person will be like, oh no, I'm being harassed. And it's like, no, it's criticism. All right. You're putting yourself out there publicly. You're out there expressing your views. And if people don't agree with your views and they mention you and don't agree with your views, that's not harassment. No. Now, if they fucking dox you.
Starting point is 01:13:12 Yeah. And they start harassing your kids or harassing your wife or harassing your boss. And that's where it gets gross when people don't like someone's opinion and then they contact someone's boss. It's gross when people don't like someone's opinion and then they contact someone's boss and then they... Dude, trying to get people fired is now like the first thing you do when you disagree with someone. I hate that shit. Well, it comes back to them, though. It always comes back around. Yeah.
Starting point is 01:13:35 You know? It's... It fucking... It does. Dustin Poirier, a guy who fought this weekend, he had a great quote. He said, karma isn't a bitch. He said, it's a mirror. That's good. I like weekend, he had a great quote. He said, karma isn't a bitch. He said, it's a mirror. That's good.
Starting point is 01:13:46 I like that. It's a great quote. I mean, I don't know if that's his, but when he said it, I was like, damn. These people that go after people, when the mob comes for them, man, it's wild. It's wild to see them panic and flail. It's like, what do you think you've been doing to all these other people that you've been attacking? Katie had, like, after she left The Stranger, got i mean she got laid off because they laid off everyone but she had like co-workers just openly talking shit about her online just to raise their own
Starting point is 01:14:14 social capital and i hate that it really is it's a middle school cafeteria it doesn't work it makes you think of that person as a low level mind mind like that person has a low-level mind they have a low low emotional IQ I do I dismiss their perspectives and things so I go when someone does that and attack someone openly like that I go oh you're just petty you're just a shitty person right but they're swimming in likes and retweets they're getting validated from other shitty people yeah but people who aren't shitty can see that yeah they get it and also they like even if they like like it because they're worried about you coming after them or they want to make sure that they're on the right side of the
Starting point is 01:14:52 mob they're gonna know that that's who you are you don't have to be like that you know if you disagree with someone you could do so in a kind way and that's we've got to emphasize that moving forward as a culture like in order to figure out you know the right way to have discussions about things where things get they actually get productive or you actually have real conversations where maybe you might learn something about the way other people view things. So a lot of people have developed all these derailing tactics where they'll be like, it's not just disagreement. It's your view is harmful or your view is almost violent.
Starting point is 01:15:36 And again, I understand there's always going to be like 20-year-olds on Tumblr who say that. But seeing other journalists adopt that view. You had Matt Iglesias on. who say that, but seeing other journalists adopt that view. You had Matt Iglesias on. He left Vox in part because one of his colleagues felt unsafe because he signed the Harper's Free speech letter. I mean, you feel unsafe because your colleague- Unsafe.
Starting point is 01:15:53 Yeah, that's not good. Fuck you. You should quit if you feel unsafe. If you feel unsafe, you should check yourself into a mental health institute and figure out what's wrong with you. There's journalists in Syria and Iraq. They're unsafe. I just hate that.
Starting point is 01:16:06 They're really unsafe. Well, it's also people once in a while, people are like, wow, it's so brave to speak your mind. It's like, it's not really. Critics of Putin are brave. Yeah, that's what I'm saying. The downside, okay, people will be mad at me on Twitter. Oh, no. I mean, that's-
Starting point is 01:16:18 Jamal Khashoggi was brave. Yes, exactly. This is not, what you're doing is nonsense. Yeah. But these people, there's a great statement that someone said that I've repeated before, so I apologize. The worst thing that's ever happened to you is the worst thing that's ever happened to you, even if it's nothing.
Starting point is 01:16:34 Yeah. So the problem with a lot of these people is they live in this coddled world where, you know, not a lot's going on. Yeah. And so I feel unsafe because he signed this letter. And then other people will like, they don't want to step in and say, hey, grow the fuck up. You feel unsafe? But that's the thing. There's always going to be people trying to leverage their sense
Starting point is 01:16:55 they're being victimized. Other people need to, they don't need to do it publicly, but just quietly be like, we're going to disagree. Your colleague might sign a letter you don't like. It's not the end of the world. And seeing this-. They'll attack you for that. That's the thing. I feel unsafe because Jesse doesn't agree with me. Right. About me being unsafe. It's weaponized victimhood. It's really it's really fucking depressing. I'm glad I have a like a foot out the door of mainstream journalism. It's way better this way unfortunately. Well I think mainstream journalism is shooting itself in the foot. Absolutely.
Starting point is 01:17:27 Because of this, because of this attitude. And I don't know how it turns it around, unfortunately, because I think mainstream journalism has been insanely important throughout the history. It still is, frankly. Yes, it's been insanely important, continues to be, but it's more dismissed now than at any other time in my life. This whole fake news shit, like saying fake, like Jesus Christ, if someone sends me an article, then I go, ah, it's on CNN.
Starting point is 01:17:57 I have a hesitancy to retweet something that's on CNN. No, it's the exact same thing with me, where it's like five years ago, I would say controversy blows up. Washington Post writes an article about it. I'm like, I can trust the Washington Post to get the basic details right. And I'm not saying like every journalist at the Washington Post is bad.
Starting point is 01:18:18 I still enjoy their coverage, but I need to now double check to make sure the Washington Post isn't passing along misinformation. That's really depressing. Yeah. Well, it's hard today too, right? Because there's so much fucking information.
Starting point is 01:18:33 There's so many stories. We're not designed for this. Right. I mean, you've talked about this. It's fucked up. It is. And it feels like there's an overload. And I think that's also reinforcing this idea of these these echo chambers that people
Starting point is 01:18:45 fall into because it's easier that way like because we really aren't designed for this like influx of information and it's hard when when there's a subject that comes up that's controversial and having an a perspective that's outside of the mainstream can be, it's dangerous to your social status. It's dangerous to your friend group. It's dangerous to, you know, I know people that don't talk to their friends anymore because their friends had different political perspectives than they do. And it's just, it's a weird time for that. And the window of what's considered mainstream is getting like narrower and narrower. We should talk about the trans kids stuff.
Starting point is 01:19:28 Sure. This is like a thing. Actually, I might run to the bathroom real quick. Go ahead. Go to the bathroom. You guys need anything from the kitchen? No, we're good. I'll be right back. If you want anything, go grab it. Thanks, man. Alright. We'll be right back. I'm still nervous about talking about this subject. Yeah, I know. It's a
Starting point is 01:19:43 rough one. We'll break back. I think there's a certain amount of cancellations you get just for being here. With some dorks. The response when Bernie came on here was like one of those moments where I, my gradual loss of faith in mainstream journalism, there's been step process. Well, that was coordinated. It was coordinated because they didn't want Bernie to win. It's really simple.
Starting point is 01:20:07 So you think it was like Hillary people? 100%. They connected Bernie to me. They took jokes out of context, and they connected Bernie to being a person who supports someone who has abhorrent views. That's what it is. They did it because they didn't want Bernie to win. Yeah. That's what it is.
Starting point is 01:20:23 They did it because they didn't want Bernie to win. Yeah. If I had done the exact same conversation with the exact same endorsement of Biden or whoever they wanted at the time, they would have applauded it and they would have amplified it. They didn't want Bernie to win. It was really clear and simple. Because you got people that are progressives that were the ones who were attacking that. It was not coming from the right. It was coming from the left.
Starting point is 01:20:45 They don't want that guy to win ever. They don't want that guy to win, ever. They don't want that guy. You can't control him. That's the thing. The shit they say about him is so disconnected from anything he's ever done. Exactly. It's crazy.
Starting point is 01:20:55 But that's what they do. I mean, it just shows you that this game of politics, it's not a clean game. It's a game of influence. It's a game of lobbyists and special interest groups and massive amounts of money. And it's been dirty forever. It's a dirty fucking game. Yeah.
Starting point is 01:21:14 All right. So I want to talk about the trans kid stuff. This is an issue I've – it's sort of what made me a little bit controversial. I read a few articles about you in preparation for this, and some of them were horrific. I can't believe you would platform a bigot like me. I'm really disappointed. The way they wrote about you was just such horseshit.
Starting point is 01:21:34 It was just the way they distorted your views and distorted your positions on things, because I had to go back and read what you originally said and then go back and read the article again. And it was, uh, but it's, this is the thing. It's, I think part of this, there's, I think there's two things going on. One, part of it is going back to what I said before, that a lot of these people were treated horribly. They were bullied when they were younger and now they have a chance to be the bully and they're doing that. You know, that it's almost like they feel like they have to get back.
Starting point is 01:22:06 They have to get people back. There's that. But then there's also, there's a very real moment in society today where, and many parts of this are good, where trans people are accepted, and not just accepted, they're applauded in a way that's never happened before in the history of our culture. So anything that goes against that narrative is immediately attacked, even if you're talking about children making life-changing decisions. Yeah. Well, let me give the brief, not to be too pedantic, but I think like knowing the
Starting point is 01:22:44 literature we have and what the research says is important. And I can do that quickly. So basically there's a – all right. So you have puberty blockers. You go on puberty blockers if – because that prevents your secondary sex characteristics from developing. And for people with gender dysphoria, that can be painful. If you feel like a girl and you develop an Adam's apple in facial hair, it exacerbates your dysphoria. And then after you've been on blockers, you can go on cross-sex hormones.
Starting point is 01:23:08 That means if you're a natal male, you'll develop some female features and vice versa, blah, blah, blah. There's a Dutch clinic in Amsterdam that pioneered this idea of using puberty blockers for this. We'd always had puberty blockers because, like, if a girl goes through puberty at seven that's not good we want to delay that at least a few years and um they figured out a protocol and they did some research this is one of the only gender clinics in the world that does good rich long-term data and we desperately need long-term data they found that for kids who were gender dysphoric from a very young age off you know four or five and and Abigail Schreier has talked about some of this, their view was that gender dysphoria usually goes away in time. Usually, it often means you're going to be gay. So if it's a boy who likes to wear girls' clothing and say, I'm a girl,
Starting point is 01:23:56 oftentimes it'll grow up to be a gay male. Sometimes it'll grow up to be a trans woman. In this clinic's view, if you get to the edge of puberty, puberty starts, and your gender dysphoria has not gone away, it's probably not going to go away ever. And you should go on puberty blockers and you should go on hormones. So this clinic, the Dutch clinic as it's called, they have a lot of research showing that among their kids, the kids who go through this protocol, they end up well. They have good mental health. They're doing well as young adults. And that tells us something, which is that in some cases we might want kids to go through this. This does not tell us that like any kid who feels gender dysphoric or says they want blockers and hormones should go on them.
Starting point is 01:24:46 clinicians themselves say, is kids are coming out as trans at 13 or 14, much later than they used to. And we don't know if the same logic applies or the same research applies to a kid who comes out at 12 and 13 versus a kid who comes out at five and has been gender dysphoric for seven years. So what I find incredibly disturbing right now is these treatments, I'm really in favor of kids who need them getting them. I'm opposed to all the Republican laws attempting to ban them. I don't want a fucking Tennessee state legislator getting between a doctor and a patient. I feel very strongly about that. I'll defend that view. But it's like a really big deal to put a kid on puberty blockers. It's a really big deal. You're interfering with the natural process. It's a really big deal to put them on cross-sex hormones because those are even less reversible. People say blockers. It's a really big deal. You're interfering with the natural process. It's a really big deal to put them on cross-sex hormones because those are even less reversible. People say
Starting point is 01:25:28 blockers are reversible. No, they've actually changed their stance on that. Yes, the National Health Service in the UK has changed it. There's at least some debate there. I don't think any journalist or medical group should say- There's no debate that it's going to alter your development. Yeah. Yeah. The question is is if you then go on cross-sex hormones, do you get whatever you lost back? You definitely won't. I'd say we don't know. Well, how could you? How could you know?
Starting point is 01:25:52 How could you get it back? If you're going through a developmental process that depends upon your body having testosterone. Yeah. And you deny your body testosterone at a normal level for multiple years while you're in puberty and while you're growing, you're not getting that back. Well, the theory is you get something similar back by going on estrogen. Something similar back? Yeah. No, I'm saying we don't know if it's equivalent, but I'm saying- No, no, no, no, no, no. We're getting confused here. When you are a natal male and then you go on hormone blockers and you go through puberty on hormone blockers and then you decide that you're going to detransition, for sure your developmental
Starting point is 01:26:31 cycle is going to be altered forever. Oh, if you detransition. Yeah. But the theory is- If you decide to go back to being a male, you're not going to be the same person who you would have been if you had testosterone through the whole process. Sorry, that's absolutely true. Right, okay.
Starting point is 01:26:43 The theory is if the kids are well- and like they go through the Dutch protocol where they felt that way since they were three, they're probably not going to change their mind. We don't. The thing is like it's changing the mind is like what does that mean? You know, it's like you can't have there's not a set. It's not like you're on fire. No, you're not on fire. You know what I'm saying? Like it's not a set. It's not like you're on fire. No, you're not on fire. You know what I'm saying? Like it's not a one or a zero.
Starting point is 01:27:07 It's not. It's such a giant deal. Like when you say that someone's changing their mind, you have to say, okay, what are the influences? Like what is around this child that's making this child? Is this just coming from the child's being? And this is how they feel. It's how they've always felt. Do they have people around them that are telling them this would be the right thing to do for them?
Starting point is 01:27:33 People are very malleable. They're incredibly malleable. Yeah, but traditionally this is something that manifests at two or three years old and often in such a deep-seated way. I think there's a subset of kids who just are always going to feel that way. For sure. And we have some evidence that the hormones they receive in utero are a little bit different. No, we agree. Yeah.
Starting point is 01:27:50 We agree that there's a subset. The question is, when can you decide to make that leap? Should you not be an adult with a fully formed brain before you decide to make that life-changing decision. I mean, someone had a joke on Twitter that you don't let a six-year-old decide their outfit. Why would you let them decide their gender? So the reason I disagree on that is I think for kids who from a very young age feel that way, it's not going to go away. The evidence we have suggests it's not going to go away.
Starting point is 01:28:22 But it might not go away. I think... You know what I'm saying? The evidence that we have is people that have already transitioned. The evidence about people transitioning, it's like... It's such an alarmingly high suicide rate. And then you have to think, like, why is that suicide rate so high? It's like in the 40%, right?
Starting point is 01:28:43 Not 40%. What is it? It gets really, I don't know. Does it get inflated? It is a very high suicidal ideation rate. It is. Everyone agrees with that. The question of how high and which studies are good and bad. And this is part of the reason we have to be careful about it. Both because we don't want to deny kids relief from dysphoria who might be suicidal and which gets talked about less, you don't want to put a kid on a massive dose of exogenous hormones when they're suicidal. That's not a good idea
Starting point is 01:29:09 either. Right. Imagine if, and this is a real imagine, because people that are trans, that support trans people, these are their people, right? This is how they feel about it. And they see a child, and in that child that is trans, they see themselves and they want to support that. What if there was a method? What if there's a genetic method or whatever that cured dysphoria? Cured it. And you would just accept your biological sex. Do you think people would be supportive of that? No, they would view it, they would use the term genocide. It's sort of similar like if you said there was like a cure for autism or something. I think it's very sensitive and it's viewed as an identity rather than like- Do you think that if there's
Starting point is 01:29:53 a cure for autism that people wouldn't embrace that cure? No, I think some people would, but I think other people would say that you're sort of, in an ableist way, destroying an element of humanity that would otherwise, you know, produce amazing amazing things even if they're neuroatypical. Interesting. Yeah. You're on Twitter a lot. I am on Twitter a lot. It's obvious.
Starting point is 01:30:14 No, and I think there's – I mean the idea that like – look, obviously some things – I mean Elon has said that he is on the spectrum, right? He said he's got Asperger's. Yeah. Obviously, it's been insanely beneficial, whatever the fuck he's got. Yeah, it can bring benefits being on the spectrum. Massive, massive benefits, yeah. So are you opposed to kids, and I ask this as someone who thinks this needs to be an open discussion,
Starting point is 01:30:44 but do you basically think kids should never go on blockers? Are there cases where you'd be comfortable with it? It's such a loaded question. And you would have to say, well, what are those cases? Yeah. And who are those people? Well, I described it. And how do you make that decision?
Starting point is 01:30:59 But how do you make that decision? And who makes that decision? Is it the parents? Is it the child? Because in some places, children as young as 10 like this one there was a ruling recently I was like I think they're saying that as early as 10 years old if the parents disagree with the child affirming its gender identity that the the parents will no longer have custody of the children. Meaning the state can come in?
Starting point is 01:31:25 Yeah, which is just, there's so much legal shit that's attached to all this stuff. And then there's parents that were, you know, there's a guy who went to jail in Canada because he refused to call his biological daughter a he. He kept calling her a she and they arrested him. What about for you? That sounds crazy though, right? It does. I don't think that's anything we should gloss over.
Starting point is 01:31:48 No, no. I just don't know the details about it, so I wouldn't want to. We could find it. Jamie. The guy got arrested in Canada because he refused to, he was misgendering his now son. He kept calling him a her, and they arrested him. Canada's a fucking wacky place.
Starting point is 01:32:12 It really is. No, but I want to press on this. Two-year-olds who, from the time they could talk, insist they're not the sex people think they are. There it is. B.C. father arrested, held in jail for repeatedly violating court orders over child's gender transition therapy he's alleged to have revealed information about his child's
Starting point is 01:32:29 mental health medical status and treatments and gave information that could reveal the family's identity um canada i think has more weird laws about what you can disclose and stuff like that that's different though this is not not as simple as him not saying that she's a he or that he is a he. He was speaking publicly about it. So this seems like they arrested him
Starting point is 01:32:57 because he was speaking publicly about it. I mean, I still think that he should obviously still be able to speak publicly about stuff. Yeah. So two years old?
Starting point is 01:33:04 Yeah. I don't think a two-year-old has any idea what's going on. No, no, no. But stuff. Yeah. So two years old? Yeah. Which is, this is the- I don't think a two-year-old has any idea what's going on. No, no, no. But I'm saying- Do you have children? No. Yeah.
Starting point is 01:33:10 Two-year-olds, they don't have any idea what's going on. But I'm not saying a two-year-old who says that once. I'm saying a two-year-old who, from the time they could talk, has insisted this about themselves. And then you get to 10 or 11 and the onset of puberty, and they've consistently identified the other way that whole span. Is that even a thing? Yeah, no, that's- From two?
Starting point is 01:33:28 So when I talk about the Dutch protocol, this is traditionally what gender dysphoric kids have been like. And this is what Schreyer talks about in her book. From two to four, they're very dysphoric and it never goes away. I don't want to force a kid who's identified as a girl since age two or three or four to go through male puberty. Those are the cases I'm more comfortable with. That makes more sense.
Starting point is 01:33:48 We could be assured that this was never going to change and that this is just how that child is and that they're never going to vary. But what if what you were saying before, if they go through puberty and they just become a gay man? Yeah, but I'm saying, so the research the Dutch clinic has and this Canadian clinic has, and this is all controversial, people will disagree with it, suggests that the longer a kid is dysphoric as a child. But isn't this a gender transition clinic? No, but these are clinics that, in my view, took a careful approach and they were conservative about it and they did not go willy nilly into this. Is this under dispute? Do other people disagree with this?
Starting point is 01:34:26 No, if anything, they get criticized for being—one of them was shut down. I wrote a piece about it. It was shut down because he was viewed as too conservative. Too conservative in their approach to gender transition? Yeah. So they shut him down? Yeah, they basically—there were false rumors about him spread and the clinic was shut down. This is just—this is in Holland? No, this is the Canadian, the Toronto one.
Starting point is 01:34:46 Oh, okay. Ken Zucker, yeah. Okay, but the other study that you were talking about is where? Amsterdam, yeah. Amsterdam. Yeah. Yeah, I mean, it's one of those things where it's, I guess it depends entirely upon the case and the situation, right?
Starting point is 01:35:02 I mean, that's really what it depends upon. It's going to be very different in one case than it will be in another case. But there's clearly people that are trans. It's clear. Yeah, and some of them have felt that way since kids. That's why. The thing is, like, to make that decision that's going to affect them for the rest of their life while they're two is like, man, are you sure?
Starting point is 01:35:24 Well, but, okay, so you're not making that decision at two. You're not making any medical decisions. You're doing hormone blockers. At two? No, no, no. When are you doing it? When puberty starts. Okay, so before puberty. You had a guest on who I disagree with a lot of stuff.
Starting point is 01:35:38 He said the one thing I thought you got wrong was you said kids had hormonal interventions at like four or five. They never do. When do they start doing it? When puberty starts is basically when. So 11, 12? Yeah, 10, 11. It depends. Yeah. Even then. Isn't that, I mean, so I'm off by a few years, but is that, doesn't that seem crazy that an 11 year old can decide their fate for the rest of their life? To me, whether or not it sounds crazy depends on if this kid has felt that way in a stable way since age two. My view is that's better. You know what I think? I think guys like you and I having this discussion is insane. The amount of data that there's available that people like you
Starting point is 01:36:19 and I are trying to figure out whether it's right or wrong, whether you agree with this or not agree with this, like there's not enough information. Well, so this is what I want to – But who is doing these studies? No one. How long – right. Hardly anyone. How long has this been discussed and debated? What's the data?
Starting point is 01:36:36 So my – okay. So the Dutch clinic, their data suggests these kids do pretty well. But these are the kids I'm talking about. From a very young age, they're dysphoric. What are the numbers? Like how many kids have they done this with? Oh, I mean hundreds at this point. And they have a diagnostic approach that's pretty conservative. The data we have for kids who come out later as teenagers, we have no data. But here's the thing. When you say the data we have for kids who come out as teenagers,
Starting point is 01:37:06 how do we not know that they haven't felt like this their whole life? They live in a conservative household. They haven't been able to express themselves. They feel suppressed. And then finally they hit the rebellious teen years and they go, hey, you know what the problem is? I should have been a boy. Right. So my view is that's happening with some of them. I think in some cases it could be something they repressed for a while or they didn't have the language. I basically think like the cases like Abigail Schreier writes about, I've seen some of them. It obviously happens sometimes. We're operating in such a vacuum of data.
Starting point is 01:37:41 We have no idea how often the sort of social contagion thing happens, how often suppressing it for a while happens. And the social contagion thing is very contentious, right? Incredibly. This is the kind of thing we're talking about, like how journalism is dysfunctional right now. If you even suggest this ever happened, I got put on a list of a sensible anti-LGBT bigots by GLAAD. I'm on a list, like an enemies list, because I've written about this in a way that doesn't entirely discount that possibility, because I've talked to kids who've said it happened to them.
Starting point is 01:38:12 Well, people have detransitioned. Yeah, and they've said this happened to me. Yeah, it's not, I mean, there's- It's not made up. No. No. And to devalue their experiences and to only value the experiences of the people that have happily transitioned, to me— It's horrible.
Starting point is 01:38:30 It is. And you can do both. You can do both. You can do both. We need to also acknowledge that there's 20-year-olds who transitioned and are thriving. We do. So last week I wrote a long post. There's a website called Science-Based Medicine.
Starting point is 01:38:41 So last week I wrote a long post. There's a website called Science Based Medicine. And it's like you talked with Colin Wright about how like skeptic communities and atheist communities have gotten a little bit corrupted by ideology. Yeah. These guys ran this really bad article basically telling everyone. And what pisses me off the most is parents reading this. They're saying the evidence we have on blockers is good. The evidence we have on hormones for kids is good. We don't have good evidence on any of this. They're saying the evidence we have on blockers is good. The evidence we have on hormones for kids is good. We don't have good evidence on any of this. And I just I feel badly for parents of kids trying to work through this issue in the absence of any good evidence,
Starting point is 01:39:14 because they are basically in some cases effectively being lied to. If you're a journalist and you say we have really solid evidence on this, that that's not true. And the multiple governments in Europe have looked into the evidence and they've all come away saying, we don't have enough here. So I just think we need to be pretty conservative about this issue until we know more, which we don't yet. What do you think the motivation for people to write articles where they pretend that there's a lot of evidence? What do you think the motivation is? I'm not prepared to make the direct comparison to like the satanic sex abuse panic,
Starting point is 01:39:44 but people want to protect kids. And occasionally we have these make the direct comparison to like the satanic sex abuse panic, but people want to protect kids. And occasionally we have these like moral panics of like, all these parents are hurting their kids. All these day care providers are hurting their kids. You know, for understandable reasons, humans go crazy about kids sometimes. And I think there's a subset of kids who are really trans and need access to these hormones. There's a subset of kids where there's other mental health stuff going on. And I've quoted some of the top clinicians in the country, including the head of the United States Professional Association for Transgender Health, Erica Anderson. She's trans herself. She'd be a great guest. I know people always tell you who
Starting point is 01:40:19 you should have on. But she herself has seen situations that really worry her because the clinicians themselves are not following the rules they're supposed to follow before they give kids blockers or hormones. And that could have really dire consequences. So what's the solution to all this? Because this is essentially over the last couple decades and more so over the last decade, this has come into the forefront of the public consciousness. This is a topic that is discussed constantly. And now with the introduction of Olympic athletes, now we have the first female weightlifter from New Zealand who is on the team that was a male. And we have all these questions about this kind of stuff.
Starting point is 01:41:04 Like this is, it's been around forever. Like who was it? Renee Richards? Is that who it was? The tennis player? Yeah, yeah, yeah. Yeah. I mean, we've had trans people for a long time,
Starting point is 01:41:15 but it hasn't been like a primary discussion. I mean, a primary subject of conversation when it comes to like the use of bathrooms, you know, sports. Like the things, the discussions that we're having, you know, sports, like the things, the discussions that we're having today on them, it's like everything's escalated. I think the first thing to realize is that A, trans people have been treated horribly over the years and B, 99% of incidents, like situations, there's not much to discuss. People should be treated the way they want to be treated. There's a small subset of issues that you've talked about on the show, and one of them is kids. It's obviously different.
Starting point is 01:41:48 Putting a... If you put a 10-year-old on puberty blockers and then hormones, you are changing their body forever. And you're doing that with a kid who's not... It's different. If it's 25, 25-year-olds need to make their own decisions about their own lives. There's a different set of ethical issues that need to be discussed openly. And it disturbs the hell out of me, not just the treatment I've received, but the treatment other people have received just for trying to say this is actually a complicated issue. reporters report on other issues. So, you know, this piece I wrote about a website like Science Based Medicine, in most other contexts, they're like the go-to for like the skeptical, careful, rigorous look at this issue. Watching websites like that just sort of like blow in the breeze and take the right position so that people don't get mad at them disturbs me. And I'm worried about what we're going to say 10 or 20 years from now about what we're doing now. I think things like this, if you're a generalist,
Starting point is 01:42:51 like I'm not sure what the background of the people from science-based medicine is, but I would imagine that anything like this, that you're going to cover a complex, nuanced, a complex, nuanced, multifaceted subject that has broad implications for our society, for children, for adults, for fucking corporations, for everybody. You got to know a lot. This is not something you can have a cursory examination of. And I think that there is a real motivation that a lot of people online have is to give in to the crowd. Like whatever the crowd wants, placate them, say what they want you to say, express yourself in a way that you think is going to be well-received by the orthodoxy. I think what makes it more complicated
Starting point is 01:43:45 is that like if a journalist came to me and was like, I want to write about youth transition, I could give them a list of sources to get quotes from. Some of them would say there's no issues here. The data is great. Some of them would say kids should never transition. Some would be in the middle. So you can cherry pick. And like these guys, in my view, cherry pick. They only consulted sources that told them what they wanted to hear and that would shield them from a lot of criticism online. I think that's a dangerous way to go approach a genuine scientific controversy. I think when you're writing an article like that, you've got to come to this conclusion somewhere along the line.
Starting point is 01:44:22 This is so nuanced. It really is yeah but if you even saying it's nuanced gets you put on the fucking enemies list well it's stupid because there's some for some people it's not nuanced here's the thing about nuance we're talking about millions of humans right yeah when you have millions of humans you have a great variety of different circumstances and different personalities and different mindsets and different biology. People vary. We vary widely. Now, if you could get one person and that one person, you could talk to that one person and get a real clear understanding of who they are, you'd have less nuance. You'd have an understanding of who they are and you have
Starting point is 01:45:00 an understanding of why this is so important to them. And then you can make a clear cut distinction. who they are and you have an understanding of why this is so important to them. And then you can make a clear cut distinction. But I think that has to be done in an objective way across the board. I mean, with examining this kind of an issue, it's so, it's very complex. It's very complex. And if you're not a trans person and you're talking to someone or talking about things like trans people, I think we all have to recognize that we don't even understand what that feels like. Yeah. There's a gap there. There's like an experiential gap.
Starting point is 01:45:30 And that's why I think anyone who writes about this issue, like I've interviewed trans people, and if you do, you come away feeling like this wasn't a choice for them. This wasn't some flippant thing like, oh, I'm going to try being a chick for a while. It's like you, to me, when it comes to adults, you'd sort of have to be an asshole to be like, I don't think this person should be able to transition. It's so important to them.
Starting point is 01:45:53 Well, you could tattoo your eyeballs, right? You could do whatever the fuck you want, right? You can literally do anything you want. You could split your tongue down the middle. Why wouldn't you be able to change your gender? Like, you should be able to do whatever you want. I hope there's going to come a point in time where what we think of when we say transitioning can be done at a chromosomal or a genetic level like instead of you told deborah so that i was
Starting point is 01:46:16 listening i think it'd be amazing if you actually just i mean how good would it feel for these people to like physically become an actual woman with ovaries with a vagina with a womb the whole deal like not just i feel like if i could take a pill and be a woman for two days who would not that'd be fascinating how many guys would you fuck that's actually an interesting question you would do that you if you had a chance to see what it was like to be i would let my wife fuck me if we made a deal no no they're actual penis i was like was like to be a woman. I would let my wife fuck me. If we made a deal. With a strap on you, maybe? No, no, with her actual penis. I was like, you gotta be a man for two days. Oh, you switch it.
Starting point is 01:46:47 Yeah, you get to be me for two days and I get to be you for two days. That'd be a good reality show. Gender swap. I bet I'd suck a lot of dick those two days. She'd fucking force it on me. Jamie, how much dick would you suck? Be honest.
Starting point is 01:46:58 Depends. I haven't been thinking about this. I don't know. It's a pretty intellectual question. I bet she'd make me. I think it's, um, it's, it would be incredible just to get a beat, to be a woman for a couple of days, be incredible just to get a perspective of what it feels like to have those hormones rushing through your body,
Starting point is 01:47:14 just to feel like to, to want to wear those weird shoes and to be into purses and just to look at things, you know, like serious issues from a woman's perspective versus a male's perspective because you know we try to be understanding and try to like have open communication have conversations with each other and figure out how you feel how i feel but there is no way a man understands what it's like you can't intellectualize no you had. You had Carol Hoeven on, and she talked about hormones, and I think there's been really interesting stuff written about trans people who transition, who are like, I live my whole life as a man,
Starting point is 01:47:52 here's what it's like to be a woman, here's what it's like to be a man. That shit's fascinating. If there was a totally reversible way to experience that, I would totally do it. I have spoken to quite a few female to male trans people, and one of the things that you come out of that with is that there's an understanding of the impact of testosterone that they just really did not know. They thought that men were just dicks because it's easy to be a dick, and then they go, oh, this is just—
Starting point is 01:48:23 No, we're literally poisoned by a hormone in our brains like that's forced people to go to war and and force people to try to you know conquer resources and i mean this dude i want to conquer resources so badly do you what's your favorite resource to conquer uh i was gonna make a settlers of katan joke but i think you're i'm a nerd i'm on a show listened to by jocks so i think it would go over their heads or under the shows listened to by jocks, so I think it would go over their heads. Are these shows listened to by jocks, you think? I think you have a pretty jockish eye. Well, maybe both. It's a wide range of humans because there's a wide range of guests.
Starting point is 01:48:54 So I think there's some people that, like, when I have on an MMA fighter, their eyes glaze over and they just fast forward through that one, skip it, and go to the next one. My eyes would glaze over, but in the Carol Hoeven interview, you talked about that in a way that made me want to like fucking learn about that shit. The preparation for a fight. Also that woman, Rose Namajunas,
Starting point is 01:49:14 who's not even remotely brutish in any way. She's a sweetheart of a person. But she like becomes a beast in the occeum or whatever. She just becomes a, she's a fighter, but she's not in any way manly like zero she has zero man she's just brave and courageous and and what i you know what i the way i describe fighting is high level problem solving with dire physical consequences and that's what people don't understand that have never engaged in it or trained in it you don't know what it really is
Starting point is 01:49:43 and this idea that all mma is is just people beating the fuck out of each other that is some of it no it is that way for some people but that's it's just like i think we would all be better off if we had an understanding of all the different types of people there are out there. Yeah. Yeah. I was very, I mean, I'll always be nerdy and awkward, but until age 10, I like video games, really nerdy stuff. And I randomly started liking watching basketball and football around age 10. And what drew me to them is like the strategy. Like this isn't just like cavemen and whoever's strongest wins.
Starting point is 01:50:25 I think actually, especially in football, because people associate that with just being strong, but it's so tactically rich. And when you understand what makes, you know, New England, so Tom Brady, a brilliant quarterback, you have to think so quickly. And when I was listening to talk about MMA, it seemed like there's some similarity there of like having to assess a situation so quickly in a way no one else could. Yeah. There's a lot of that to it. It's also a way of living your life in this really exciting, dangerous way that's so appealing to some people.
Starting point is 01:50:58 And I don't know. I mean, we're talking about the warrior gene and all the various genes. I don't know what it is about people that leads some people to want to take risks. One of my daughters is a big risk taker. She's always been like that from she was little. She wanted to go on the highest monkey bar. She wants to do, you know, she's just a risk taking kid. She has that thing that makes her want that thrill. And some people want to do rock climbing and they want to do hand gliding and they want to do all that kind of wild shit and i don't i don't know what that is but i do know that we also need computer coders you know we also need people that are studying philosophy we also need
Starting point is 01:51:36 and sometimes they're the same people you know there's a lot of people that actually study philosophy that are also martial artists which is kind of interesting and one of them is uh john donahue it's like one of the most brilliant people I've ever spoken to ever in my life, who is the greatest jujitsu coach alive, who was a professor at Columbia. Yeah. He was a philosophy professor. I could never,
Starting point is 01:51:57 I play a little basketball and I run. I can never get into like lifting or any like strength training. I don't know. It's just, it's maybe that's like a genetic thing, but it's just like, it's not, well, it's not supposed to be pleasant, right? Have you done it? When I was in high school, I went with my friends. How old are you now? 37. You should try it. Here's the reason. As you get older, my body's going to like melt into lard basically, right? There's no way around it. Yeah. Yeah. Um, as you're, you're, as you get older, your body deteriorates without weightlifting. Like, it's really, it's considerable.
Starting point is 01:52:31 It's like, it's similar to, you know what happens when you get in a cast. Have you ever had a broken bone? Yeah. The atrophy, basically. Your muscle atrophy. That's what your whole body's doing. My body's already doing it because I treat it so poorly. But if you just strength trained twice a week, just lifted weights twice, the quality of
Starting point is 01:52:46 your life would improve dramatically. How much time are we talking? Half hour, 40 minutes. Can I check Twitter on my phone while we do it? You can check in between sets for sure. Because cardiovascular exercise is really important for heart health and also good for your emotional health yeah cardiovascular exercise for me is uh is is a gigantic uh um cure not cure it's a remedy for anytime i'm feeling like shit me too if i feel depressed if i'm just down or just too many things are bothering me i just do a good cardio session and it doesn't have to be anything crazy like just a good session on a bike or an elliptical machine or stair machine or something like that and during the pandemic especially like if i there are moments where
Starting point is 01:53:30 like going for a three mile run even just felt life-saving like if i couldn't do this i would go crazy yeah yeah it's it's just good for you because i think a lot of the anxiety that people have is I think there's tension and anxiety that exists in the human body that is a remnant of the past. And it's a part of the fact that whenever you face stress thousands and thousands of years ago, that stress most likely came in the form of violence. It came in the form of a predator trying to eat you or a neighboring tribe that was trying to attack your village. And so our sense of stress is directly connected to physical exercise and adrenaline and anxiety. If you could just burn that off, you have a much healthier perspective on what the actual problem is and it allows you to look at
Starting point is 01:54:26 things with clear a clear view but what makes us such an interesting species is like we we can accommodate both like the big burly guy who could like take down the mammoth but then there's like the deal maker who could like convincingly be like oh you should give me some of the meat we'll give them some of the meat there's like these sort of sure schemers and we and we have room for all these different types of people well tool creation yeah exactly i mean tool creation is you could be like this puny little guy but you make the best spear in the tribe and then you're getting status from it well sure well the apex of that is oppenheimer yeah yeah destroyer of worlds yeah i mean a direct student of um of ein. And he goes on to quote the Bhagavad Gita when he's blowing up a fucking, punching a hole through space and time.
Starting point is 01:55:10 Yeah. Well, then above Oppenheimer, you have podcasters. The highest of the high. How are they the highest of the high? What the fuck are you saying? People creating things. It's really fascinating what the human animal is, right? Because we are, we share the same space as all the other creatures, but we're the only ones
Starting point is 01:55:33 that alter our environment in this radical, in status. And we can do it with a tool like a gun. That's one of the scariest things about gun violence. You could just, this person, I don't like them anymore. Bang. Now they go away. I mean, you basically with a finger, like the easiest thing, like I took my kids to the gun range cause we're in Texas. Yeah. That's what we do out here. Wait, that's where we are? Yes. Right now?
Starting point is 01:56:08 Yes. I had no idea. You wrote a book. I don't know if you know that. And you're on a podcast. I'm Jewish. Are they allowed in Texas? Yes.
Starting point is 01:56:14 There's a lot of them here. L'chaim. L'chaim. Especially here in Austin. There's a ton of them. But the- I see the headline now. Joe Rogan says there's too many Jews in Austin.
Starting point is 01:56:24 I didn't say there's too many. I love Jewish people. How dare you, sir? My point is my 11-year-old, I was teaching her how to shoot a pistol safely. So she is holding this gun by herself, and she pulls the trigger. Boom, boom. And she's holding on to this gun and hitting this target. She's 11.
Starting point is 01:56:44 How much power does she have in that little finger? Nothing. The fucking – That little finger can annihilate the biggest human being alive. Bang, bang, bang, and then they're dead. That's the weirdest shift in power, the weirdest ability. There's not an animal on the planet that has anything remotely similar. I have an internet friend.
Starting point is 01:57:05 I've known him forever. He's sort of a prepper type. He runs a prepping website, and he lives 40 minutes from here. And I'm going to his house on Wednesday, and we're shooting. Oh, boy. And I've never – other than like skeet shooting at camp, I've never shot a gun. Skeet shooting is fun. Yeah, but that's like a little puny – that's not like real shooting, right?
Starting point is 01:57:21 Right. It's a light shotgun. This guy has a gun range in his backyard that he's going to set up for us. That's so Texas. It is. Do you think if you had to choose gun to head and you had to choose either humans are going to destroy the planet or we're going to find some technological fix and like clean up the mess, which do you think is more likely? I think it's more likely we fix it.
Starting point is 01:57:41 Really? Yeah, I do. Because I think if you look at the trends over time, right, if you read any of Pinker's work or if you look at just the charts and statistics about violence and murder and rape and all the horrible things that people are capable of, it's way less prevalent now than it was thousands of years ago. It's moving in that direction. The problem, I was going to say, the problem is that we could literally annihilate the entire planet with one wrong event.
Starting point is 01:58:13 Right. We have that ability because of Oppenheimer and everybody after him that we can literally nuke the planet multiple times over. That's what scares me is a mistake. Or what really scares me more than anything is natural disasters. I was going to say, I think there's these runaway climate change scenarios where it's supposed to be two degrees, but our models aren't accurate. And then it's seven degrees, and that just destroys everything.
Starting point is 01:58:38 I was in Vegas yesterday, and it was 117 degrees. It broke a record. But it's a dry heat, though. Oh, it's so nice. Dude, it's like the inside of my fucking sauna. 117 degrees. It broke a record. But it's a dry heat though. Oh, it's so nice. Dude, it's like the inside of my fucking sauna. 117 degrees is bizarre. Yeah. We got off the plane and I was like, wow, this is wild.
Starting point is 01:58:54 And it gets worse, right? What if it gets to 125, 132? Yeah, dude. What if it gets to an intolerable place where you can't go outside? Yeah. You'll die. Like, what if, like, they have a, there was an article that I read yesterday about Lake Mead, where they're, it's, is it Lake Mead? Lake Mead or, yeah.
Starting point is 01:59:16 They're worried that they're going to have to limit water to people because it's like, it's a water supply to all these different areas. And it's, they showed in the images the water line where it normally is. It looks like a tub, you know, like a tub has like – Grime or whatever. Yeah. It's like fucking 30 feet lower than it should be. It's crazy when you look at it. I find that shit overwhelming.
Starting point is 01:59:40 And my response – as a journalist, my response should be like, I should understand this shit and write about it. Yeah, here it is. Jesus, that's so fucking depressing. This is the Hoover Dam. But either way, you get a chance to see what it looked like in Lake Mead, the level. That's what I looked at. Look at that.
Starting point is 01:59:56 That's nuts, man. I mean, that's a lot more than 30 feet. That's really high, the line where the water used to be. Lake Mead hits lowest water levels in history amid severe drought in the west. This is on ABC News. And it's worth, if you're listening to this only, it's worth Googling just to look at the bit. Or use DuckDuckGo like I do. What's the other one?
Starting point is 02:00:21 Boingo? I get upset when I can't find something on Google. And then I go to DuckDuckGo and I find it like that. And I'm like, what are you doing? Are you guys curating data in a way where you're hiding shit? I'm enamored with this idea that the kind of features a species needs to take over a whole planet and tame it the way we do. You also have the seeds of your own destruction and that everyone wants to think that like species get to a certain point and they send spaceships
Starting point is 02:00:50 out and they colonize other planets but like what if the entire universe is just littered with like dead civilizations that destroyed themselves because i think i'm less optimistic than you and i sort of i worry we're headed in that direction well one thing that we could look at and it's there's nothing to do with destruction self-destruction we can look at the history of species on this planet and 90 whatever percent of them that ever existed are gone yeah dude they just phased out whether and i always find it weird that we're like trying stop that from happening too. They're like, no, not the dodo bird. You know what I mean? Joe Rogan calls for extinction of dodo.
Starting point is 02:01:29 Re-extinction. Re-extinction. It's not that I think that they should die off, but I think that we have this sort of reluctance to let anything die off anymore. So the natural process, like say if human beings didn't exist, even if we're looking at, you but how long humans been here half a million years go back a million years things are still dying off yeah they just didn't make it as a shit design it's like the yugo it just didn't make
Starting point is 02:01:57 it you know whatever the species are it's but now that we're alive we think of ourselves as the curators of the earth, and we don't want anything to die off on our watch. This is the difference between people who have done hallucinogens and people like me who are too neurotic to do them. Why are you too neurotic to do hallucinogens? I've had fucking panic attacks from smoking weed. I'd like to do them. Yeah, because you smoke too much weed.
Starting point is 02:02:20 Yeah, so you think I should do it? I asked Sam Harris the same thing. Cause I, I need that. I want to reach that point where I'm less scared of death and less tied up in my own very fleeting existence. And I want to be like, like, eh, maybe humans won't be around forever, whatever. Well, they're not going to be around forever. No, we're not. But I'm, I'm scared of that and I want to be less scared of that. But I feel like I've done like half doses of shrooms and it was great, but it wasn't a half dose. What does that. But I feel like I've done like half doses of shrooms and it was great. What's a half dose? What does that mean?
Starting point is 02:02:46 Just whatever I was supposed to take, I took half of it. I laughed my ass off with my friends. It was great. Oh, so that's a psychedelic. That's a good example of that's probably more than a microdose because a microdose is essentially you take it to, it's like the threshold of perception, like right when you can understand that you're on that, that's when you're like, Oh, I think I'm on it. Yeah. So, but you, you still can function normally and behave better and actually have
Starting point is 02:03:14 better visual acuity. There's like some benefits to that, but, but a good little tiny dose of mushrooms is what I always recommend to someone who's scared because it makes you like relax. It alleviates anxiety. You feel better and you feel very loving. Dude, this was with – both times I did it, it was with high school friends at their like bachelor weekends. And it had all the effects weed is supposed to have. Everything was hilarious. We were – this won't be funny after,
Starting point is 02:03:37 but we came up with a sitcom called Shroomates. It's about roommates who are on shrooms. I like the name. At the time, it was hilarious. Dude, it's a good name. It made me laugh. are on shrooms. I like the name. At the time, it was hilarious. Dude, it's a good name. It made me laugh. There we go. That's a good name.
Starting point is 02:03:49 You got paranoid from weed. I've been paranoid from weed. No, no, not paranoid. No, no, not paranoid. Panic attack. Feeling existence wasn't real. Totally dissociated. Yeah, you got too high, buddy.
Starting point is 02:03:59 All right. It's normal. So I just need to dose that shit a little bit. Yeah, yeah. You need like a hit. This is weed. Ready? No, that's on a vape pen. This was in like 2005.
Starting point is 02:04:10 It was a vape pen? No, no, no. I'm saying these days you can take one hit from a vape pen and you're good. Just take a hit of a joint. This was like really weak. I think that was my problem. This was not good weed so I felt like I had to smoke a lot of it. Oh, well you never smoke a lot of it if you don't smoke a lot.
Starting point is 02:04:25 The thing about weed is like you develop a tolerance. But if you don't develop a tolerance, if you don't have a tolerance and you try to like smoke a half a joint with somebody, you're going to go into the grave. Yeah. I mean, you know, figuratively. It's not going to kill you, but you're going to feel like you're dead or you want to be dead or you want to stop existing. So for a neurotic Jew who had a panic attack from weed and did a half dose of shrooms, what's the next hard drug I should try? Well, I don't think you should try anything. I'm not going to give you any recommendations. Dr. Joe. Dr. Joe is out. I've left the building.
Starting point is 02:04:57 But me, fellow human being, I always say just a little bit of mushrooms because I think a little bit of mushrooms is nice. It always makes me feel like I have an enhanced perspective. It makes me feel so friendly. I just want everybody to be happy. That's how I felt during the Shroom Aids night. I think we have a real chance of fixing culture if mushrooms become prevalent and legal. Get the head of Hamas together with the Israeli president. Yeah.
Starting point is 02:05:24 Dose them both. Well, it's going to take more than that. You have to dose the entire population. And it's not going to be a dose thing. It's going to be a long, slow hike out of hell. Right. You know, because the people have to change their perceptions on every aspect of the way they think about each other and look at each other and treat each other. But that's what a lot of people think the history of religion really was about. It was about primitive people discovering psychedelics. They eat the wrong mushroom and then they build a belief system around it.
Starting point is 02:05:54 They eat mushrooms and then they hide these psychedelics in religious stories. Yeah. You know, do you ever read John Marco Allegro's The Sacred Mushroom and the Cross? I have not. It's an amazing book. I don't know if it's accurate, but John Marco Allegro was a biblical scholar and a linguist. And he also was an ordained minister.
Starting point is 02:06:17 And he was the only one on the Dead Sea Scrolls translation group. There was a bunch of scholars that were translating the Dead Sea Scrolls, and. There was a bunch of scholars that were translating the Dead Sea Scrolls and he was the only one that was agnostic because as a theologian, as he was studying religions and looking at the histories of these things,
Starting point is 02:06:36 he started realizing that there was so many of these were connected by more and more ancient stories and he started to become very skeptical and became agnostic. But all the other people on the group were very religious, but he was still an ordained minister. And he got to a point where he studied it for 14 years and he wrote a book. And this book was the sacred mushroom in the cross. And it was, I believe the book was bought up by the Catholic church. And then, um, I bought some copies of it that
Starting point is 02:07:06 were used online, but then a guy named Jan Ervin released it. Uh, he, he republished it and released it so you can get it now, but it's a fascinating book. And in this book, he, he said, basically all of Christianity was most likely about psychedelic mushroom rituals and fertility rituals. That fertility rituals were a gigantic part because infant mortality was very high. Mortality for me, I mean, you got an infection, you died, you broke your leg, you died, you're likely to die. Most people didn't live very long because just because of injuries and sickness and he traced and he traced the word christ back to an ancient sumerian word that means a mushroom coated in god's semen so this is when they thought you're talking about we're talking thousands and thousands and thousands of years ago right
Starting point is 02:08:03 so when it rained these mushrooms would just appear out of the ground, and then they would eat them and trip balls. And they would think that God literally came out of the sky and that this is how you would get in touch with God by eating these things. Imagine if you were a primitive person with no science, no written language. I mean, they told these stories just through oral tradition for over a thousand years before anybody wrote them down. Right. And you're eating these things and tripping balls. And it's like, it gets deep because there's so many things
Starting point is 02:08:36 connected to this, this, this theory that John Marco Allegro had that it gets very, it's very bizarre when you follow it. One of the things was Christmas, like the Christmas trees, you know, pine trees, underneath these pine trees, you always have these like shiny packages, right? Well, there's a mycorrhizal relationship between coniferous trees and a mushroom called the Amanita muscaria. This Amanita muscaria mushroom was worshipped all throughout human history. In fact, it was very closely connected to Santa Claus and to elves. But when you trip balls, you can see elves. That's what's fucked up.
Starting point is 02:09:20 So this mushroom looks like Santa Claus. It's red and white, and it underneath Chris underneath Christmas trees underneath pine trees Is that is that why all these Scandinavian cultures have like elven mythology? Yes. Yes, they were all tripping balls It gets even worse when you take the mushrooms the way you dry them out is you hang them from the leaves of the tree So they dry in the Sun which is literally the decorations on christmas trees that's fucking crazy oh my god dude there's there's many many articles written about the connection between also santa claus came down the chimney well the shamans in siberia once they tried to outlaw these shamanic rituals and outlaw these psychedelic practices they the way they would get come into
Starting point is 02:10:01 people's houses on snow drifts they would hop down through the chimney they would come into people's houses on snow drifts. They would hop down through the chimney. They would drop the mushrooms down and hop down through the chimney because they were trying to avoid the local law instead of going in through the door. I mean, this is even more basic than what you're saying, but so much of the Bible is just fucking trippy. Talking snake, plague of locusts. How about the, well, we could tell you more about that, but how about the reindeer, right? Santa has his reindeer and they're flying, right? Well, reindeer are incredibly attracted to the aminated muscaria mushroom,
Starting point is 02:10:31 so much so that shamans who have these psychedelic rituals have pointed out that when they go outside of their tent or outside of their hut to take a piss, that the reindeer will knock them over to get to the piss because the piss has the smell of these Psychedelic mushrooms in them and the way people extra trip one of the things they do is they they piss into a glass While they're tripping because some of the psychedelics get filtered through the body and it winds up in the urine And then they drink the urine and blast off into orbit they go they get even higher than they were before drink the urine, and blast off into orbit.
Starting point is 02:11:04 They get even higher than they were before. Jesus. Yeah, it's wild shit. So this is like an ancient practice of drinking your own piss while you're tripping balls on mushrooms, and it's connected to these fucking reindeer, which are caribou. And caribou are always eating these Amanita muscaria mushrooms. They thrive on them. That's fucking crazy.
Starting point is 02:11:22 It's a wild connection between Santa Claus and flying reindeer, right? This shaman who's dressed in red and white, who looks like the mushroom and all the, have you ever seen old Christmas cards? They all have mushrooms in them. That's crazy. Find some old Christmas cards. These old Christmas cards all have this one mushroom. It's a very specific mushroom too. It's, but it's a controversial mushroom, because I've tried that mushroom before, too, and it didn't really do much. Psilocybin will knock your fucking socks off. But the Amanita muscaria, like, look at these.
Starting point is 02:11:54 Oh, my God. Yeah. All of these old Christmas cards, all of these old Christmas decorations, they all had mushroom iconography in it. Like, look at that one right there that your cursor is above. Look at that. How crazy is that shit, man? It's like right in plain sight too. It's not even trying to- Yeah. I mean, they look like Santa Claus, right? I mean, Santa is red and white. The mushroom is red and white. Look at that
Starting point is 02:12:19 picture in the right. Now look at that. I mean, it's kind of fucking crazy but there's hundreds and hundreds of ancient or at least old drawings and christmas cards deep into like the early 20th century well because his hat is so distinctive and you don't see that anywhere else and it so clearly matches onto the capital mushroom it's nuts man it's nuts and how about these fucking elves? Like one of the things, like why are there elves associated with Christmas? Well, elves are associated with mushroom use. But the thing is, and this is me being honest, like most people that have taken Amanita muscaria, the only person I know that it's had a real legitimate trip in it was Paul Stamets. But Paul is, he's probably the most well-versed mycologist alive.
Starting point is 02:13:07 I was watching some of the stories he told. Brilliant. Just like the way he can distinguish these fucking thousands of mushrooms. He's brilliant. Brilliant guy. So he's the best to discuss this. This is a controversial theory, right? But look.
Starting point is 02:13:19 Look at all those images. I accept it as true. Why not? There's no downside here. It's pretty nuts. It's pretty nuts. Well, the burning bush, you know, with Moses in the burning bush, they now think, scholars out of Israel think, I think it's the University of Tel Aviv. I forget which school it was. There's a working hypothesis that this was a story about someone with the acacia bush.
Starting point is 02:13:45 The acacia tree is rich in dimethyltryptamine. You smoke dimethyltryptamine, you experience some higher power. It's the most potent of all psychedelics. Well, burning bush and you meet God. I mean, it's not hard to make that connection. And this is, let's see if we can find that. The University of Tel Aviv. I mean, it's not hard to make that connection. And this is, see if you can find that, the University of Tel Aviv. I think it's Tel Aviv.
Starting point is 02:14:08 See, this is, when we were in Hebrew school, there was so much casual genocide because God would just wipe out this tribe or that tribe. If we'd learned about shit like this, it would have been much more useful and interesting. God did some wild shit. How about Elisha and the fucking, the she-bear that killed all the kids,
Starting point is 02:14:22 making fun of him for being bald? Dude, the whole, like, Jacob, like, he's about to, someone about to kill their own kid, but then God stays his hand. Ah, gotcha. I was just kidding. You just made that one up? Yeah. The she-bear one? No, no, no, no, no, no, no.
Starting point is 02:14:36 Which one? Oh, God, you just killed God. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Like, yeah. Well, there's a few of those stories where God's testing you and tempting you. But that's the thing. It's treated as, is it Isaac's about to kill Jacob, right? That's what, yeah.
Starting point is 02:14:50 That idea that your faith should lead you to be willing to murder your child, to throw all your own moral intuitions to the wind. Because God tells you. Because his voice in the sky tells you to. Even when I was like 13, I think my classmates felt the same way. We were like, this is fucked up. Like God's kind of an asshole. I think my classmates felt the same way.
Starting point is 02:15:03 We were like, this is fucked up. Like God's kind of an asshole. Well, John Marco Allegro's belief was that all of the stories that were in the Bible were all, they were all designed to hide these rituals. And that, you know, like even the apple in Adam and Eve, that the apple represented the Amanita muscaria mushroom. that the apple represented the Amanita muscaria mushroom and that God did not want Eve to eat the apple because if she did, she would have an understanding of him and of God. There's so much wild shit to it. And the idea was that they wrote all these things down
Starting point is 02:15:36 in parables and in these stories with this cryptic meaning to it to hide it from the Romans when they were being conquered. Right. Oh, right, because their religious beliefs were sort were being conquered. Right. Oh, cause right. Cause their religious police were outlawed. Yeah, exactly.
Starting point is 02:15:48 That's crazy. It's wild shit, man. But what here, you know, it sounds crazy. All of it sounds crazy, but what's not crazy is that psychedelic mushrooms exist.
Starting point is 02:15:58 They are real and they're prevalent. They're everywhere. Well, so the thing I feel like I'm missing out on by being i think too neurotic and fucked up to do these drugs is like you achieve these states where you've you've done dm you've done a lot of stuff you can't you can't explain that state to other people no you can't but you learn something that stays with you permanently that's what i'm a little bit and i don't know if it's permanent for me me, it feels like semi-permanent. I feel like it's like a fading tattoo and you need to get it touched up every now and then.
Starting point is 02:16:30 You know, you have, I think it's definitely steered me in a completely different direction and changed my perspective forever. But sometimes I forget how much it's changed and then I have to trip again. And then when I trip again, I go, oh, yeah. And then it just gives me a massive refresher course that knocks me right back on track. But what is it that fades? Because from my point of view, a close relative of mine did acid and experienced ego death. And he was like, yeah, from then on, I just didn't fear death in the same way. That seems like a permanent switch that you're flipping. What aspect of it fades over time well for sure I have a different perspective than I had before I did anything for sure that's permanent my perspective is different and people who know me Have said that I'm just I'm a different human being like if you if you know me from 2000 versus me from 2021 I'm a different person like less aggressive or um I
Starting point is 02:17:24 Just see things in a different way. I'm more open-minded. I'm more open to ideas. When you experience the DMT realm, you're like, okay, well, how the fuck is this real? How is this like you can just get there in 30 seconds? So this just exists around us all the time? Like what is this? But what I mean by fades is sometimes you just get busy like life gets busy you have bills and i
Starting point is 02:17:53 basically have three jobs right i'm a comedian i do the ufc commentary and i do this there's a lot of things there's a lot of stuff going on you get caught up in these things and i'm trying to do my best at all these things so it requires work i have to think so i'm constantly involved in what i'm doing and you can get caught up in stuff you know to the point where you you forget that you are you you literally are not even you you there's more bacteria cells in your body than there are human cells. You are a part of this gigantic super organism known as the human race, and each individual, it benefits them to think of themselves
Starting point is 02:18:35 as being unique and alone, and looking out for themselves. But in the reality, that couldn't be further from the truth. So there's so many things that you just get lost with where you just get caught up in the trappings of everyday life. And what psychedelics do, it just resets that whole thing and you get a chance to see things from a completely different perspective. All that other stuff is bullshit. Here's like the fundamental truth about stuff,
Starting point is 02:19:00 even if you can't express it with words. Well, you also recognize that no matter what is happening in your life, no matter what good stuff like with your career, if you don't have love and friendship, if you don't have friendship and love and people around you aren't happy as well, then your life is not going to be good. You know what really disappointed me? Are you looking for this?
Starting point is 02:19:21 Are you good? I'll have some more of that. Sure. What sort of fucked me up a little bit is I i between september of last year and april this year i was just dealing with like some heavy family shit we talked about on podcast details aren't important but i thought like i'm dealing with this horrible shit it's traumatic it's like the worst shit i've dealt with this will like somehow make me different or better weirdly what happened was it pushed me the other way.
Starting point is 02:19:46 I get more concerned about Twitter bullshit or petty career bullshit. And maybe this is where like psychedelics come in. Like you, you, but you're looking for a distraction. That's why you get more. Yeah. You get more connected to Twitter bullshit because you're looking for a
Starting point is 02:19:58 distraction. You're looking for something that alleviates the pressure of this thing. And you, you have this fucking complaint device in your pocket 24-7. But you don't think psychedelics are a way of just like, they're not a distraction. There's something more profound than that. I think they can be more profound.
Starting point is 02:20:15 They certainly can also be a distraction. I think psychedelics are like any kind of tool. It's like a hammer. This is the way I always describe marijuana as well. You could build a house with it, or you could just hit yourself in the dick if you're fucking crazy. You know, they're tools. And psychedelics, it's all about intent. It's all about set and setting. And I think you really should, when you use them, you should use them with an intent to try to work through some issues. And if you have some things that bother you, for you, you have this acceptance
Starting point is 02:20:44 of your anxiety, right? You have this acceptance of who you are and the fact that you just have this anxiety level. I think you could work on that. And I think you can help alleviate some of that anxiety. And I don't think, I think it's a little bit of your identity. Oh, definitely. Yeah. But I think the positive qualities that you have and the positive aspects of who you are, I don't think they're going to be negatively affected by an alleviation of anxiety. I think it's going to be an enhancement of your perspective. But that requires a certain level of trust because I'd like to – I don't think it's just psychedelics.
Starting point is 02:21:18 I'm not even talking about that. Just in general? Yeah, just working through that and looking and trying to shift your perspective on things. Even if you never did what was psychedelic for the rest of your life, I think for you, really, what I would recommend to you, and I'm obviously not a doctor or a counselor. Dr. Joe. I would say exercise, like regular routine exercise. I do. What do you do?
Starting point is 02:21:39 I run and play basketball. How often? Five to six times a week. Do you really? You run five to six times a week? Well, between running and basketball, yeah. Oh, okay. And you get exhausted five to six times a week? I'm not exhausted. I don't get exhausted running
Starting point is 02:21:51 three miles. That's just my routine. You think I should do more? Maybe just ramp it up, yeah. Maybe whatever you're doing, you're not doing enough. I guess like what I'm skeptical of is, okay, let's say, so there's these studies That's just one thing, honestly. No, no. But I think a mindset adjustment would be advantageous as well.
Starting point is 02:22:10 I could use that. But there's these early studies of like LSD where you take LSD in like a clinical setting with a guide. Yeah. And people like – the early evidence, which might not hold up, is like people's depression is basically cured. I guess my worry is if I did that, I would just, instead of like having this luminous experience where I put all this shit in perspective and put the puzzle pieces together, it would just like be a meteor hitting the whole board and the pieces fly everywhere and it would get worse because I just don't trust my ability to like work through these issues maybe.
Starting point is 02:22:37 Yeah. I think you're saying that based on not having that experience though. Yeah, absolutely. I think if you had that experience, it would enhance you. You're a smart guy. I think you would get through it. I don't think it would be a problem. I think it would be beneficial. But for some people, it's not.
Starting point is 02:22:56 I mean, there's bad trips. Bad trips are real. Well, bad trips, most of the time. Most of the time, what's going on, and this is obviously obviously debatable and there's a lot of nuance involved in this as well But what bad trips are for the most part most people think is your ego trying to control the experience Because when you're on a psychedelic rock, it's like trying to grab the rail to stop the roller coaster But Michael Pollan in his book. He's like the whole point is you can't do that. You need to let the experience guide you Yes. Yes. You need to let the experience guide you. Yes, yes.
Starting point is 02:23:25 You need to let the experience guide you. You need to learn how to let go. And for a lot of people, they have a hard time letting go. But the forced letting go of psychedelics. One of the things that McKenna said, he said, one of the beautiful things about psychedelics is you don't have to believe in them. He's like, they're real. Well, the experience is forced upon you. Yes.
Starting point is 02:23:46 You can't. Once you eat the mushrooms and then you wait, you don't have to believe in it. It doesn't need you to believe in it. It's like it's coming. And there's a certain beauty to that, that letting go, that we all cling to so many aspects of our life. And that's what you were saying earlier
Starting point is 02:24:05 about reading things that people are saying about you on Twitter. You know, that's along the same lines, right? Like trying to control things or figure things out or- Trying to control something you can't control, which is a microcosm for the whole existing and dying thing. You can't control it. Can't control any of it.
Starting point is 02:24:25 Yeah. Yeah. It's, I think it's a very valuable tool, but I think we are left without an operating manual because of the prohibition, because of the sweeping psychedelics. We could have had such good data on this if they hadn't passed those shitty fucking laws. Yeah. Oh my God, man. I mean, you got to realize it's been 51 years since they've
Starting point is 02:24:47 been illegal yeah 1970 everything became illegal which is nuts i mean they they made illegal what um brian murrow rescue his um his work on this book the The Immortality Key, which I brought up with Michael Pollan and some other people. It's this amazing book on ancient Greece and how these scholars that were responsible for the birth of democracy and the structure of modern society, they were tripping balls. They were all tripping. They were all taking taking ergot they were all taking a form of lsd and they're probably taking a bunch of other shit too and they were mixing it in wine and people would travel from all over the world to attend these rituals and come back with these amazing stories of enlightenment and of the way they they thought about everything adjusting and changing and the connection with the gods and the spirit world. And this is all a part of human history.
Starting point is 02:25:50 And these fucking stiff cunts wearing stupid shiny shoes and ties, they took it away from us in the Nixon administration. Fucking Nixon. You know, these people that wanted everything to be shut down. Yeah. They wanted to, you know what fucking stop these hippies We gotta stop them. I'm not a crook like these are the type of people that fucked us. This is what happened Did you see that shit about the dude in this in Texas? He's facing 40 years in prison for voting. Oh, yeah
Starting point is 02:26:19 He voted wise on I want to forget it. Hervis Rogers. Yeah, I just wanted to bring this up Cuz maybe so fucking pissed dude votes on parole not right? I have his name because I didn't want to forget it. Hervis Rogers, yeah. I just wanted to bring this up because it made me so fucking pissed. Dude, votes on parole, not knowing that's illegal. They need to make a point about illegal voting, so they fucking Yeah, I think he's facing 35 years, right? Isn't that what it is? And he's got multiple counts, too, right? There's more than one count? Well, he did his time for burglary.
Starting point is 02:26:38 He got out on parole. He waited in line seven hours, Super Tuesday, to vote. And they're trying to throw him in jail for it. How about just count his vote and tell him don't do that again? Leave the fucking guy alone. He did his time. This is why I do think the left is becoming more punitive. But I also think just humans in general.
Starting point is 02:26:54 We always try to find ways to throw one another in jail, get one another fired. I think that's where psychedelics can help us. I really do. Because with psychedelics, you do recognize that other people are look you are me You're just living a different life Like if you live my life and you were in my body and you went through all the experiences I had you would be me we're not we don't Vary as much as we like to think each other do what we are is we are spirits that are going through these were
Starting point is 02:27:23 Consciousness, let's put it in a non-woo-woo way. We're consciousness that's going through a different biological vehicle with different life experiences. And we are trying to navigate our way while trying to be happy and trying not to get hurt. We're trying not to get hurt by life or get hurt by other people. It's weird and terrifying. It's terrifying to everybody. It's weird. Yeah.
Starting point is 02:27:43 Even to the most calm and confident and accomplished person, it's terrifying. And for me, I find that no matter how accomplished I get, I don't ever feel like it's fine. I don't ever feel like it's okay. I never feel like everything's great now. There's like this idea that we have, you're going to like hit this retirement point or this, ah, I've made it point. You're going to sail off in the sunset. I'm telling you right now, that place is not real. No.
Starting point is 02:28:12 I mean, we're in different situations, but I've been lucky. I've had a really good year, and I'm like, I don't know. You're stable. You're financially stable. I'm in better position than 99% of journalists. I'm very lucky. But it does not change that fundamental thing of who you are and what it's like to navigate consciousness at all. It really doesn't.
Starting point is 02:28:30 Exactly. And, of course, anyone who's struggling financially thinks we're douchebags for saying that. But it's just the truth. It's just the truth. You know, struggling financially is horrible. No. And I remember very clearly, I got a development deal, which is what happens. They come along and they say hey
Starting point is 02:28:45 we want to try to do a tv show with you and we'll give you a bunch of money for me they gave me i think it was a hundred thousand dollars and uh all of a sudden i had money yeah and it was like that was like your first big pot of money but it was like this like a weight you know that expression of weight lifted off your shoulders like i literally felt that because before then I was fucking poor, like not knowing exactly how I was going to eat poor. And to have that lifted off my shoulders like that, I was like, I remember thinking very clearly like, oh, this is extremely valuable. This is extremely valuable because this is allowed. As long as you can maintain this state where you're not worried about your bills, it allows you clarity. It gives you a perspective.
Starting point is 02:29:27 But it doesn't alleviate you from the existential angst of being a fucking human being. No, there's a point at which you can stop worrying about it. Yes. But then it's sort of diminishing returns. You stop worrying about money, but you still worry about life. Like life has other things. Like if you don't have to concentrate on money anymore, your bills are paid, you know, your rent is paid, you're okay,
Starting point is 02:29:48 you don't have to think about that. It doesn't make the universe less weird. Right. Or consciousness less weird. Right. It's all crazy. It's all fucked up. How about that Richard Branson guy just fucking shooting himself off into space and people are so mad at him? I said on Twitter, I feel like my invite got lost in the mail. I should have been on my ship. Would you have gone? No, I'm too nervous.
Starting point is 02:30:03 I wouldn't have gone. I'm too anxious. Fuck him. Also, when you- Imagine if he died. You'd go? Jamie doesn't give a fuck. Richard Branson, if you're listening, Jamie will join you on your next voyage. Jamie's the least part alien.
Starting point is 02:30:14 Jamie's immune to edibles. Me and Eddie gotta go. Yeah, Eddie should go. I gotta go with him. Eddie would think it's a hologram. It's a hologram. That's why I have to go. Imagine if you took Eddie up into space
Starting point is 02:30:24 and he still didn't believe That the earth was round We're both gonna have a camera And a non-edited Pun Bro they took you with a hologram You don't even understand Imagine if he's right That would be so funny
Starting point is 02:30:35 You get up there That would be fucking crazy That's why there's no good video From the fucking thing Imagine if we get up there And Eddie's right all along And I gotta eat pro We gotta go higher
Starting point is 02:30:43 Sorry Eddie The earth's flat. Yeah, I mean, imagine if you died right next to Richard Branson. Like, you dumb motherfucker. Make me go up in your stupid rocket ship and blow up. That's how I want to go. I don't know if I can rocket ship. Elon Musk has a ticket to ride on Richard Branson's space plane.
Starting point is 02:31:01 Do you trust it? I don't know if I trust it. Like those things. They blow up a lot. They blow up. 1% is too big for me. Elon's blow up. They've blown up a few times, right?
Starting point is 02:31:13 On the launch pad and trying to land. I still don't understand how airplanes work, like how they're safe. So I'm not fucking getting on this mission. Well, Elon was explaining to me that the blow ups and the failure was actually built in into the equation of, you know, the way they're designing these things is going to be failure because they're trying to test the tolerances and figure things out. That's the whole idea of tests is that some of them are going to fail. So it wasn't disturbing to him at all when these rockets are blowing up. He's like, now we know why it blew up and we'll fix that.
Starting point is 02:31:44 And now this one won are blowing up. He's like, now we know why it blew up and we'll fix that and now this one won't blow up and then we'll fix that. I know, but he's not going to come on and be like, wow, yeah, we're fucked. No, no, no, no, no. He would. He would. 100%. That guy does not lie.
Starting point is 02:31:56 He is not interested in lying. You can say whatever you want about Elon Musk. He might be wildly eccentric and maybe even stretched too thin because he has so many different projects he works on constantly. That guy is not a liar by any stretch of the imagination. He's discussing the way they've designed this protocol for engineering these rockets that they knew
Starting point is 02:32:16 that they were going to have failures. It's part of the process, I guess. I mean, it made sense, right? Like, how the fuck else are you going to build a rocket? You've got to test it. You've got to test them. They're going to blow up. And when they blow up, it's spectacular. right? Like, how the fuck else are you going to build a rocket? You got to test it. You got to test them. They're going to blow up. And when they blow up, it's spectacular. It's beautiful. Filled with rocket juice, you know?
Starting point is 02:32:32 I'm not interested, though, man. I mean, not until they got that shit down, you know, down to a science. I would do it if it was like airline level safety. Yeah, yeah, yeah, like that. Yeah. But until then, fuck off. I'll let other people do it. What am I going to do? I'm going to get up and then go down?
Starting point is 02:32:47 Yeah, it is round. It's just like the video. Fuck you. I'm staying right here. And then the other thing that freaks me out if you get into real space, like orbit, is space junk. Just fucking taking you out. Some Russian satellite from 1965. Some random Chinese bolt hits you in the
Starting point is 02:33:03 forehead going 500,000 miles an hour or whatever the fuck it's going. I think there's not, but is there a chance they accidentally go too far? I'm like, oh, we got to go around twice before we can come back. Oh, shit. No food for a couple weeks. We're going to have to eat each other. Eat each other, yeah. Yeah.
Starting point is 02:33:18 I don't know. Who the fuck knows? I just, I would hate to see Richard Branson blow up in space because that would set back space travel. It's kind of crazy that, I mean, I don't know how long they planned it in advance, but he only went like 50 miles, right? Is that the idea? The edge of space. So it's very disputed like what it is. Like was it even dark where he was at?
Starting point is 02:33:40 I saw a picture. It looked like half, half dark, half earth. Bet you got to go dark. And then it turns upside down so they can see. I mean, you know what I'm saying? You can't go camping during the day. Oh, I slept during the day. That's not camping. They did race
Starting point is 02:33:55 to hurry up and beat Jeff Bezos who's going next week. He's supposed to go next Tuesday or Wednesday or something. He must be so mad. Imagine if he dies. Because he just handed over the CEO of his company. He's not the CEO anymore. Right? I miss that.
Starting point is 02:34:09 His wife married a science teacher. He's probably like, ah! And then he gets in that rocket and fucking blows up. Is he going to deep space? Is he going out, out? I kind of think it's the same thing, but instead of going like a roller coaster on a plane, they're going up in a balloon and then come back down. In a balloon?
Starting point is 02:34:24 Yeah. Jeff Bezos is going in a balloon? I take that back, but they going up in a balloon and then come back down. In a balloon? Yeah. Jeff Bezos is going in a balloon? I take that back, but they come down in a parachute. A parachute? Yeah. I was picturing something like that in my head. See, Elon's got a way better system. His rocket is actually going to land.
Starting point is 02:34:35 Yeah. You know? He's got it down. That's better. Yeah. Don't listen to any of the advice I gave you, please. No, I take it as medical advice, Dr. Joe. Be careful.
Starting point is 02:34:48 I will. Um, any other things we should talk about before we get out of here? Your book, The Quick Fix. The Quick Fix. Uh, yeah, no, I should be more of a whore. I have a newsletter, jessysingle.subside.com. We got the, uh, I do think your listeners should check out our podcast. I say that as an unbiased observer, blocked and reported.
Starting point is 02:35:08 You should have my co-host on so she can talk shit about me. I will. We'll talk a lot of shit about you. She has an interesting theory about lesbians going extinct. What? She thinks they're going extinct. She does. She should talk to lesbians about that.
Starting point is 02:35:19 Well, she's tried to. They've rejected her. They've blocked and reported her. What? Yeah. Because she said that? Because she said they're going to extinct? It's very controversial.
Starting point is 02:35:28 They deny their own extinction. Boy. What other psychological fads are in this that we should discuss before we wrap this up? There's a really fucked up story basically about the army adopting this anti-PTSD program that didn't work. They spent like half a billion dollars on.
Starting point is 02:35:46 There's stuff about grit, making kids more gritty. That doesn't work. It's sort of a – it's a little bit of a bummer of a book, but it also like will tell readers how to be better judges of scientific claims. Do these like psychological fads, like they don't work or they just don't work on everybody? Do they work on some people? They don't work or they just don't work on everybody. Do they work on some people?
Starting point is 02:36:05 It depends. How much of what we see on social media is there's all these influencers that are like really into motivating people. That's like a big thing, right? Yeah. Mostly they just like don't really work on the average person or the average person they're supposed to work on. So they're pretty. Because in order for something to work, there's got to be like a real fundamental shift in how you view things yeah and most of these habits yeah and most of these ideas just like aren't up to that task basically but isn't that the case with like weight loss too
Starting point is 02:36:36 because some people it works like some people that are like hundreds of pounds overweight they just reach this point where they're like fuck this this, I'm going to do something about it, and they're going to make a change, and then they do. Why is that funny? No, no, I have many thoughts on actually the weight loss thing. Do you? I need to take another leak really quick. Oh, okay. You over-imbibed me.
Starting point is 02:36:57 I'll be right back. Go ahead. Go ahead. The weight loss season. This will be our last edit, ladies and gentlemen, I guarantee. You guys are good. We'll be right back yeah yeah we're good good thanks these kids and their weak bladders um since we'll take it out i was thinking
Starting point is 02:37:16 through that thing about the burning bush yeah the guy who the claim is made to this he wrote an article 13 years ago that said i never said said Moses was stoned when he saw God. What did he say? I tried to read through it to see exactly what he says because this guy is a linguist, and he went and studied ayahuasca and stuff in ancient. He says, words such as trip and high misrepresent my work on psychoactive plants.
Starting point is 02:37:43 Okay, the Guardian. Okay, so this is, I think. Okay, the Guardian, okay, so this I think, this is the Guardian ran it. It said Moses saw God because he was stoned. That's a different... This is the guy that the claims are coming. I found all the studies and then I googled his name
Starting point is 02:37:57 to see what was popping up. And this popped up like three weeks after those articles came out back a long time ago. So how did they misrepresent it? What did he say? He said that they might have done ayahuasca, but there's no proof that that bush is in the area. But the acacia bush is in the area.
Starting point is 02:38:15 That's the thing I was just reading. They said there's two bushes they think it is, and one maybe can be found in Saudi Arabia. The other one, which would be the one that would lead to that, isn't in the area. Was that where it was, in Saudi Arabia? That's what I'm thinking through this article, which is from, you know, it's a little more recent. There are different interpretations as to why God chose a burning bush as a way to get Moses' attention. One theory says that Moses was worried that Egypt was going
Starting point is 02:38:46 to completely destroy the Jews. God showed him the magical bush to say that just as the bush is burning but isn't consumed, Egypt may cause the Jews to suffer, but they won't be destroyed. The thing right up here is where it started.
Starting point is 02:39:01 There's this word that they got it from. It's used twice in the Torah. Once they think it's a pun. The other time they think it meant bush. It says sneh. S-N-E-H is a Hebrew pun on Sinai, the place where the bush was burning. Most commentators say that S-N-E-H is a very lowly thorn bush. The Catholics in St. Catherine's Monastery at the base of Mount Sinai claim to have the actual bush growing in their courtyard.
Starting point is 02:39:36 The bush is a bramble, rubus sanctus. Just as Moses had to remove his sandals in the presence of the bush, Just as Moses had to remove his sandals in the presence of the bush, the monks at the monastery require visitors to remove their shoes before coming into the presence of the bush. How weird. Imagine if they really do have the actual bush that Moses saw. That says that that bush doesn't have DMP in it. Wait, do they know the actual species of bushes?
Starting point is 02:40:01 No, apparently there's a lot of questions. They think that even the burning bush might have represented the idea that they were – who was going to – that Egypt was trying to kill the Jews, but they wouldn't be able to. I feel like he was even saying that they may have done some sort of ceremony. It's just the way that they're interpreting it, maybe not that way. Well, it's also you have to recognize that they're talking about, you're talking about something that was translated in multiple different languages and you lose a lot of the meaning, right?
Starting point is 02:40:32 Like one of the things about Marco Allegro's work was the Dead Sea Scrolls was the only version of the Bible that was in Aramaic. And it's so old that it's written on animal skins. And the way they did the deciphering they had to use DNA tests to match up the animal skins to make sure that they're the skins from the same animal so that they knew that the
Starting point is 02:40:54 piece of skin belonged to like see all these broken pieces so in order to figure out which piece goes in which pile you have to do DNA tests on the pieces it's all wild shit Dead Sea Scrolls were... I thought the whole Old Testament was Sumerian? The Dead Sea Scrolls is not the Old Testament. The Dead Sea Scrolls they found in a cave in Qumran. So they found these animal skins that have
Starting point is 02:41:22 writing on them in this cave in Qumran. And these guys worked for fucking 14 plus years to try to decipher these things. Like, have you ever seen the Dead Sea Scrolls? Yeah, no, I've seen photos of them. Because it's a huge, like, sort of academic controversy about the provenance, basically. It's an academic puzzle. Yeah, yeah. And there's some very similar stories in the Dead Sea Scrolls that do exist in the Bible, but they're much wilder.
Starting point is 02:41:44 Like, some of the stories in there are really like supernatural. I was sort of, I went through like the same sort of angry atheist phase as a lot of people. And it is true that like the idea that we're supposed to extract moral meaning from these stories that are honestly mostly just about God, like smiting this or that tribe. It's like, they're cool stories,
Starting point is 02:42:05 but the idea that we're supposed to take them to inspire the way we live is a little bit silly. Especially when you think of the ruthlessness of God's approach. That's what I'm saying. It's crazy. You're supposed to go to hell for a lot of stuff. Eating shellfish is like fucking... Have you had fried oysters, dude?
Starting point is 02:42:22 They're pretty good. Clam chowder? Come on, God. I think a lot of that stuff, including pork, like eating an animal that chews its cud that has a cloven hoof, you're not supposed to eat that, I think it had to do with diseases. Yeah, of course. Red tide, trichinosis for pork, red tide for shellfish. Well, there's this idea that disgust and our fear of germs drives so much of human culture and i'm pretty sympathetic to that yes yeah and i bet a lot of the ancient laws of how to behave and what to do in rituals were related to like how about the ritual that a lot of the muslim world has of uh you know you wash your hand you wash your ass with your left hand right you always touch everything
Starting point is 02:43:02 with your right hand and your left hand is what you wash your ass with yeah and they have a whole thing with shoes because shoes are dirt shoes and it back in the ancient times you're probably walking through like literal shit and yeah literal sewage yes yeah yeah there's a lot of the the ancient religious texts that it's logical if you try to trace it back but But what I was getting at is like ancient Hebrew is, it's a weird language, right? Where it's not just letters. Like the letters have numerical values. They're numbers too. Yeah. It's wild. So try translating that to Latin and then to English or to Greek and then to English. Have you heard of the Bible code? What is that? Like the Da Vinci code? No, I had a late great uncle.
Starting point is 02:43:47 This came out maybe around 2000. I think it was a book called The Bible Code, and it claimed that if you use that thing where letters can be letters or numbers, it foretold the future or predicted events. And it was completely off because it was this thing where, of course, if you can interpret letters as letters or numbers, you can construct some story. But people were very convinced that the Torah, which had been, of course, translated numerous times, like if I could tell the future. It was very weird stuff.
Starting point is 02:44:16 It's so wild, though, that ancient Hebrew had that distinction where it was part numbers and part letters. Yeah. And that there was numerical value to the words, like the words had a value to them. It's a really weird language. But it's fucking cool. Oh, it's very cool. That's the coolest idea for a language ever,
Starting point is 02:44:33 that your language is encoded with numerical value in the words and the letters double as numbers. Yeah, and I don't, I'm not religious, I don't really identify with being Jewish, but this idea that you're saying the same prayers that your family, your ancestors were saying 1,500 years ago is kind of amazing. And not a lot of people can say that. What I've always admired about Jews is that it's a tribe. It's like a tightly knit tribe.
Starting point is 02:44:57 And even the ones who aren't religion or aren't religious, rather, they're really into being a tribal Jew. It depends, though. So like where I live in Brooklyn, you have the Hasidic Jews a couple miles away. They're like, they're very insular. They reject modernity. And what's sort of weird and awkward about being Jewish is like, I feel less kinship with them than I do with like a secular Muslim because they have such a different worldview, but they're having so many kids that they're the ones making sure Jews continue to propagate because they also don't intermarry. Yeah. So like they're having, there's not a lot of Jews left and everyone's always fucking trying to kill us.
Starting point is 02:45:33 They don't intermarry? Oh, absolutely not. You mean with other people outside of the Jews? Outside of, yes. Not only outside of Jews. When I say intermarry, I think of Jews marrying Jews. Yeah, sorry. So they only intramarry.
Starting point is 02:45:45 They only marry other classites. And I'm overgeneralizing a little bit, but it's just weird. We have this secular Jews have a complicated relationship with them because we, frankly, we look down a little bit on how traditional they are and how insular. I'm sure they look down on us because we're corrupted and fallen, but they're the ones sort of keeping the numbers up because a lot of us are intermarrying or not having a lot of kids it's just it's weird being a member of a group that could literally go extinct well there's a big population of them in los angeles too i know new york has the biggest population right yeah and it's it was weird during the pandemic that
Starting point is 02:46:19 they were getting attacked for having group gatherings and you know that they were trying to force them to comply with these pandemic rules. And they're like, we're not even in your fucking world. That's true. But the problem was they would have these weddings with thousands of people with like lots of dancing and chanting and singing. And it's like, that's going to spread to the rest of the city. Yeah.
Starting point is 02:46:39 And I'm sure it did. Yeah. Their outfits and everything are crazy too, right? The Orthodox Jews, we'd see them all the time in Los Angeles with the curls and the things that hang from their belt. And some of their kids don't speak English. They speak Yiddish. The whole point is to, I think some other sects, including like Mormons and even more so the Amish, the whole point is to make your kids dependent on the tribe so they can't leave.
Starting point is 02:47:04 So if you only speak yiddish and broken english and i'm again i'm generalized a little bit some of those do speak english but it's just like a very interesting not modern way of going about life yeah very interesting and very not modern and it's it's kind of wild to think how long they can keep that up you know i've been reading this book um i started reading it again, Empire of the Summer Moon. It's about the Comanche Indians and the settlers that tried to make it across the plains, and they encountered these Comanches,
Starting point is 02:47:36 and it was like a massive deterrent for so long. But one of the things the book focuses on is how up until the 1600s, the europeans came here they didn't have horses and they lived this way the way they lived for who knows how many thousands of years had not varied but then so much of the european world and the asian world had gone so far beyond that in terms of civilization and culture yeah Yeah. But they had this like very tight way of living that never varied. But one of the fascinating things was oftentimes, whether it was prospectors or sometimes children were kidnapped and they became a part of the tribe
Starting point is 02:48:20 and then they would get re-kidnapped like decades later and they never wanted to go back to society yeah they always wanted to go back to the tribe they never were like thank you oh my god this is so much better they hated it they hated the the modern way of life they they were so in tuned with chasing the buffalo down on the plains and sleeping in tents well and it's that whole question of so evolution carved us a certain way and, you know, we're very thankful we have antibiotics and phones to keep in touch with our loved ones.
Starting point is 02:48:51 But at a certain point you get so far from our ancestral past that it introduces, I mean, even just like the social media thing. Yeah. It used to be the feedback you got from your tribe mattered because they're your tribe. Right.
Starting point is 02:49:02 If your tribe is fucking random people, thousands of miles from you, it feels like it matters because of these deep-seated tendencies we have, but it doesn't, and it hurts you. Or in someone like my case, my tribe, on Twitter, I think I have 7 million people. It's not really your tribe. What the fuck is that? How is that possible? That doesn't make any sense. And if you want the feedback of 7 million people, you're going to go mad.
Starting point is 02:49:22 Yeah. You know? If you want the feedback of 7 million people, you're going to go mad. Yeah. You know? And I think there's also a thing that happens if you can spend some time alone in nature, where there's like, it's almost like you feel, it's like there's a void that you didn't even know you had. And then you're like, oh, this is so nice. This feels so good.
Starting point is 02:49:42 It feels so normal. is so nice this feels so good it feels so normal because your body wants to be around these bountiful natural environments where you're you're around like a lake yeah and mountains and you see like birds fly overhead and deer bouncing by like your body has a connection to that that's very very primal when you get on the plane in jfk and you get off in like, well, LA is really urban, but LA or like Tucson or Phoenix, any place, which is a totally different landscape and the fucking mountains ringing everything, it does something to you. Yeah. We're supposed to be in these more wild places. Yes. One of my favorite places when I lived there was Boulder, Colorado.
Starting point is 02:50:23 Oh my God. Beautiful. So crazy. And I would just look at the mountains and go, this is like the best natural art that you could ever be around. And it's around you all the time. And it riches your perspective on earth. It's like, it's like living in a phenomenal art gallery. I've lost, uh, I, five years ago, most of my best friends lived with me in New York city. They gradually the West Coast stole them. And I get it because once you move out there and you see what's there, it's hard to go back.
Starting point is 02:50:51 Like I love New York in certain ways, but it's just when you can drive an hour to these incredible mountains. Yeah. Well, I think one thing that the pandemic taught a lot of us is you don't need to work locally. No, you don't. taught a lot of us is you don't need to work locally. No, you don't at all. You could definitely be remote and get a lot of the shit done, especially if someone like you that's a journalist and a writer.
Starting point is 02:51:10 I don't need to be anywhere. It's great. Yeah. It's kind of cool. I have a lot of friends that they just move to the woods and they move to mountain towns and they move to the beach. You were in LA before this, right? Yes. What was the LA to Austin shift like? Because they're such different cities I feel like. It was easy. Oh, really? It. What was the LA to Austin shift like? Because they're such different cities, I feel like.
Starting point is 02:51:25 It was easy. Oh, really? It was easy. Yeah, it was so nice. I love it here. People are so much friendlier. Than in LA. The thing that got me is there's a real tangible feeling of not being bothered by people.
Starting point is 02:51:42 In the sense that there's too many of them. When you're on the 405 in LA and it's three in the afternoon and you just see a fucking sea of red brake lights in front of you that goes on for hours, you're like, shit. Like I used to do gigs in San Diego and I would have to leave my house at noon. It's a 90 minute ride, man. If I have an 8 p.m. show, I gotta leave at noon
Starting point is 02:52:01 because I might be in my car for five fucking hours. Like really. That grinds on you after a while. Oh, it's terrible. But it's just, you devalue human beings. You start thinking of human beings as being a nuisance. Whereas here, there's like a million people in Austin and a million in the surrounding area. And their traffic is a joke. It's hilarious. Like, oh, traffic's so bad. Shut your mouth. I don't even know what the fuck traffic is. You know, like traffic in New York is bad. Traffic in LA is bad. This traffic is silly. I hate that thing of like, if you live in New York and you're like, I'm driving somewhere,
Starting point is 02:52:36 you just have no idea if it's going to take you three hours or six hours. There's too many humans. And if anything goes sideways, you're fucked. If anything goes sideways and you got to get out of town, you're fucked. I literally bought an apocalypse vehicle when I lived in L.A. because I kept having this this reoccurring anxiety of earthquakes or of shit going down. I was stockpiling water. I was thinking about things because I started collecting freeze dried food because I was like like no one's got a handle on these earthquakes No one's got a handle on things going south and I had been evacuated from my house three times
Starting point is 02:53:10 Over the last ten years just from fires It's just that's the other thing about California and I know this for my friends who live there It seems like at any given moment half the state is on fire. Yeah, how do you get used to that? Do you don't yeah, you live in this constant state of hoping it doesn't happen tomorrow and then you wake up okay no fire today great yeah it's just different you know and for me the only thing that was keeping me there was doing comedy but it's easy to do comedy here and it's easy to do the podcast here you know like look we're doing it yeah that's such a privilege to be able to just like i can fight i brought my mic here i'll record an episode after this yeah just i can write my newsletter from anywhere that's so a privilege to be able to just like, I brought my mic here. I'll record an episode after this.
Starting point is 02:53:45 Yeah. I can write my newsletter from anywhere. That's so nice not to have to rely on an office. Yeah. And this city is fucking wonderful. I love it. People are so nice. It's so friendly and it's artistic and the live music scene is amazing, man.
Starting point is 02:53:59 Live music scene. Fucking Gary Clark Jr. owns a club here. Yeah. You go down sixth street and like at any given time you'll hear this band like who are these guys yeah you know and there's a randomly awesome oh randomly awesome musicians and artists there's a lot of galleries here and there's a lot of comedy here too now it's it's great it's just a beautiful place and the food's off the charts well i'm kicking myself i'm fucking vegetarian which should be like
Starting point is 02:54:24 illegal here given the barbecue. Nah, there's plenty of good vegan food here, man. There's plenty of good vegan food here. There's a lot. I went to Torchy's
Starting point is 02:54:31 and like Deli Taco. They both had great breakfast tacos, but. Are you vegetarian for health reasons? A little bit of both. Yeah? Honestly, when I was like 26,
Starting point is 02:54:40 I read the Eating Animals by Jonathan Safran Foer because an ex had recommended it. She was vegetarian. I just found it compelling. I think if I lived in a country with like, I'm going to sound very douchey in Brooklyn here, but if I lived in a country that had a different approach to eating meat, like the kill your own food type thing, I don't have an inherent moral problem with it. But I think the way we do it in the States is fairly fucked up. It's very fucked up. The factory farming aspect of it is disgusting.
Starting point is 02:55:05 It's a lot of suffering for them. Not just the factory farming, but how about these ag gag laws? Yeah. Oh, my God. You can't film the – yeah. Those are a horrific, moral, disgusting outrage. Yeah. The idea that if you're working somewhere and you see what everyone would think of as a horrific act against animals, you can't film that.
Starting point is 02:55:28 But that's why the whole, again, not to go back to the endless topic of cancel culture, but I do think liberals are becoming more liberal. But conservatives are always fucking trying to ban something, trying to ban filming the factory farm, trying to ban not standing for the pledge. We're assuming that it's conservatives that did that, but I think it's capitalists. filming the factory farm trying to ban you know not standing for the pledge they're not assuming that it's conservatives that did that but i think it's capitalists you know i don't i don't i don't really buy whether or not uh liberals are more um more or less conservative when it comes to fiscally i think there's a lot of social dynamics and posturing that a lot of corporations take up but that's when you look at what Google does, like Google's- Well, I was going to say liberals want to give more power to Google and YouTube, which
Starting point is 02:56:08 is crazy. You want YouTube and fucking Facebook deciding what's true and what's not. But the problem is what they do with their money. What they do with their money is very conservative. Like they're doing a lot of the same things that big corporations do with their money to maximize their profits, to avoid taxes. This is not like this completely liberal, altruistic. No, but the whole, there's like a lot of sort of materialist or heterodox leftists. There's a guy, Benjamin Burgess, Freddie DeBoer,
Starting point is 02:56:38 their whole point is like what this comes down to is money. When we talk about racism, we're not talking about like some mystical force in the air or some feeling people have. We're talking about pockets of people who are cut off from opportunity and what matters is fucking money. And I think that's been lost because so much of liberal discourse is like talking about people in the right way or expressing the right feelings. Money sort of decides everything. And I think we've sort of lost sight of that. And I think we've sort of lost sight of that. Well, we lost an opportunity to address during the pandemic. There was this massive push to address the fact that businesses were losing money.
Starting point is 02:57:13 And so the government had to the fact that you have these disproportionately fucked up communities that have stayed this way for decades? Yeah. And this also radically affects the quality of life for the people that live there, like failing corporations. Right. Like the idea that Detroit and Baltimore and Southside Chicago, all these places, that's just how they are.
Starting point is 02:57:45 Yeah. That's just how they are. That's just how they are. It's unfixable. That's fucking nuts. It's nuts. And we went way out of our way to make sure the corporations stayed healthy, but we didn't ever address the fact that there's people in this life that, without a doubt, people in this country, there's certain people that are born into a situation that is not fair.
Starting point is 02:58:04 Yeah, but this is my whole thing. certain people that are born into a situation that is not fair. Yeah. But this is my whole thing. This is why, like, if you write about cancel culture, you've, like, been canceled, fucking big air quotes. People are like, no, you should be a conservative now. Conservatives are against cancellation. What motivates me more than anything is that we're the richest country on earth, but a huge number of people are just fucking have no chance whatsoever. They don't have a chance to go to, like, a Newton public school.
Starting point is 02:58:28 And I think that should be the story. And that's why Bernie Sanders did well. That was basically the only thing he talked about. He did not get distracted by culture war bullshit. That's where Elizabeth Warren went off the rails. She's like suddenly trying to talk like a woke person, which she isn't. So exactly.
Starting point is 02:58:40 Well, that's one of the reasons why I'm suspicious of her, you know, when I'm not suspicious of Bernie because he's so fucking consistent. Yeah. And the other thing is like you're going to become a conservative. Well, then, okay, now you're tribal. Can't you just be someone who's politically homeless? Like why do you have to be on this other side now?
Starting point is 02:58:57 Now you have to like, you know, say I'm a God-fearing Christian and Donald Trump was brought here by Jesus. I met Trump this past weekend. Where? He shook his hand. He has regular-sized hands, by the way. They're not tiny? The media, they're full of shit.
Starting point is 02:59:10 You're sure he wasn't wearing fake hands? He might have been wearing fake hands. He's a clever fellow. Very slapstick. Yeah, he put on his fake hair and fake hands. Where did you meet him? At the UFC. What was he like?
Starting point is 02:59:19 Came over to me when I was working. I had my headphones on, and I said, hey, how you doing, man? Nice to meet you. He shook his hand and got a video video of it it's kind of hilarious uh he's like you do tremendous job amazing job good job and then he said that daniel cormier was next to me who was a former light heavyweight champion and the former heavyweight champion he goes i do not want to fight this guy i do not want to fight this guy let's go i should have got a selfie with him. Fuck.
Starting point is 02:59:45 You should have. Missed opportunity. What are you going to do? It was weird. It was very weird. When he walked in, though, I'm telling you, man, they cheered the fuck out of him. Oh, he has like a fucking, some dead enders who really want to see him be president again one way or another.
Starting point is 03:00:01 Well, there's that. And then there's, you know, there's, there's a lot of people that just do not like the current administration. They just think it's this weird floppy fish of administration. It just doesn't seem. I have my qualms with Biden, but like two days from now, all these families are getting $300 per kids per kid, like put it in their bank account. This is a law he passed. Yeah, and that's exactly the kind of shit. That's nice. I would love to focus more on that than on who said the wrong thing about trans kids.
Starting point is 03:00:33 At the end of the day, that's what it comes down to. That's going to help millions of families. Yes. And I wish more of our politics focused on who we should give money to and why. I think that's important. Yeah. The problem is there's such a rabid appetite for bullshit. Oh my God, yeah. And that's part of what the media focuses on. The conservative
Starting point is 03:00:52 media is just as guilty of it. If the conservative media has an opportunity with Biden to really take the high road and to show that what the liberal media did with Trump, they're not going to do with Biden and just judge him on policy. Yeah. You know, but they don't do that. No. They don't do that. Although Biden's interesting because like, okay, with Bernie Sanders,
Starting point is 03:01:13 he's on the record being like, I'm basically a socialist. So it's easy to like- Democratic socialist. Democratic socialist. Yes. Yes. That is an important distinction. Biden, there's nothing there.
Starting point is 03:01:22 They tried to paint him as like a radical. You look at him, you're like this guy, the guy who passed the crime bill is a fucking radical. It just doesn't work. Nothing really sticks to him. Yeah. He's a,
Starting point is 03:01:31 I just wish he was younger. You're not excited about Kamala? She's not going to make it. President and waiting. I'm so worried that they're going to put all their chips on her and then she's just unpopular.
Starting point is 03:01:42 It's not going to work. People don't like her. Yeah. They, yeah. It's not, it's not going to work. People don't like her. Yeah. It's not going to work. That's a bad one. I mean, unless they have some designs for it. Unless there's some fucking secret room somewhere where they're going to reinvent her.
Starting point is 03:01:55 I mean, the wackier things have happened before. They basically reinvented Biden. Right? Yeah. You wouldn't have thought he'd be the guy for the moment, but he was. How about they reinvented her and the person who was tearing him down was the lady who's his fucking vice president now so funny which is nuts yeah that intense moment about the segregation stuff and then she's the veep that's crazy well how about not just that but the sexual assault stuff yeah right i mean she said she believed that woman like and then the crazy thing is when she's on Colbert, she's like, it was a debate. Did you see that?
Starting point is 03:02:25 Yeah. And laughing. The laughing thing. Someone's got to talk to her about that and go, hey, hey, hey, hey, hey. When you get uncomfortable, you can't just pretend that it's all silly and funny and laugh. You got to have an actual answer for this. Yeah. This is the big leagues.
Starting point is 03:02:39 You're at the fucking biggest of the big leagues. You have to have some sort of- More than that. You have to have a perspective. You have to be some sort of... More than that. You have to have a perspective. You have to be able to adjust it. All right. Quick fix.
Starting point is 03:02:49 A quick fix. Jesse, thank you very much, man. Thank you so much for having me. One more time, your podcast? Blocked and reported. And it's on everywhere? Everything? Yeah, everything.
Starting point is 03:02:56 Harass Katie Herzog. Make sure to harass her. Don't harass young Katie. No, don't harass her. I'd love to have Katie in here, too. Please do. Thank you, brother.
Starting point is 03:03:02 Appreciate it. Thank you so much. It's very fun. Bye, too. Please do. All right. Thank you, brother. I appreciate it. Thank you so much. It's very fun. Bye, everybody.

There aren't comments yet for this episode. Click on any sentence in the transcript to leave a comment.