The Majority Report with Sam Seder - 3546 - Tennessee Clinic Denies Unmarried Pregnant Woman Care; Israel Confiscates Baby Formula w/ Mehdi Hasan

Episode Date: July 25, 2025

It's Casual Friday on the Majority Report: A pregnant woman in Tennessee is denied medical care under the state’s Medical Ethics Defense Act—because she was unmarried, which conflicted with the cl...inic’s so-called “Christian values.” We’re joined by Zeteo News Editor-in-Chief Mehdi Hasan to discuss the mass starvation in Gaza, the ongoing Epstein cover-up, and his recent appearance on Jubilee’s Surrounded. In the Fun Half: Andrew Cuomo appears on CNBC to reflect on losing the primary—and lays out a firm policy agenda focused on fearmongering, from anti-Semitism panic to Red Scare tactics. The chairman of the FCC openly calls for a media “course correction”—a not-so-subtle threat to align with the Trump agenda or risk cancellation. South Park takes a big swing at Trump's little thing as Tim Pool clutches his pearls. All that and more plus IMs.   The Congress switchboard number is (202) 224-3121. You can use this number to connect with either the U.S. Senate or the House of Representatives. Become a member at JoinTheMajorityReport.com: https://fans.fm/majority/join Follow us on TikTok here!: https://www.tiktok.com/@majorityreportfm Check us out on Twitch here!: https://www.twitch.tv/themajorityreport Find our Rumble stream here!: https://rumble.com/user/majorityreport Check out our alt YouTube channel here!: https://www.youtube.com/majorityreportlive Gift a Majority Report subscription here: https://fans.fm/majority/gift Subscribe to the ESVN YouTube channel here: https://www.youtube.com/esvnshow Subscribe to the AMQuickie newsletter here: https://am-quickie.ghost.io/ Join the Majority Report Discord! https://majoritydiscord.com/ Get all your MR merch at our store: https://shop.majorityreportradio.com/ Get the free Majority Report App!: https://majority.fm/app Go to https://JustCoffee.coop and use coupon code majority to get 10% off your purchase Check out today's sponsors DELETEME: Get 20% off your DeleteMe plan when you go to joindeleteme.com/MAJORITY and use promo code MAJORITY at checkout. SUNSET LAKE: Use coupon code “Left Is Best” (all one word) for 20% off of your entire order at SunsetLakeCBD.com Follow the Majority Report crew on Twitter: @SamSeder @EmmaVigeland @MattLech Check out Matt’s show, Left Reckoning, on YouTube, and subscribe on Patreon! https://www.patreon.com/leftreckoning Check out Matt Binder’s YouTube channel: https://www.youtube.com/mattbinder Subscribe to Brandon’s show The Discourse on Patreon! https://www.patreon.com/ExpandTheDiscourse Check out Ava Raiza’s music here! https://avaraiza.bandcamp.com/ The Majority Report with Sam Seder – https://majorityreportradio.com  

Transcript
Discussion (0)
Starting point is 00:00:00 The Majority Report with Sam Seder. Where every day's casual Friday. That means Monday is casual Monday. Tuesday, casual Tuesday. Wednesday, casual hump day. Thursday, casual Thursday. That's what we call it. And Friday, casual Shabbat the majority
Starting point is 00:00:27 report with Sam Cedar it is Friday July 25th 2025 my name is Sam Seder, this is the five-time award-winning majority report. We are broadcasting live, steps from the industrially ravaged Gowanus Canal in the heartland of America. Downtown Brooklyn, USA, on the program today. Epstein's siege on Trump continues unabated. Meanwhile, it's day two of meetings with Trump's former defense attorney. Now number two at the DOJ with Ghislaine Maxwell.
Starting point is 00:01:17 What could they possibly be talking about? The world watches as widespread starvation in Gaza as a result of Israeli's man-made famine. Meanwhile, France announces it will recognize the Palestinian state in September. Germany, perhaps, may soon join them. Venezuela deported to the El Salvador and Gulag, suing the US for wrongful deportation. And the FCC greenlights the Skydance Paramount deal as South Park, de minimism of Trump's member, spreads like wildfire.
Starting point is 00:02:07 Kathy Hochul opens the door to New York redistricting as national Dems look to Maryland, Oregon, and Illinois to potentially pick up more seats for the midterm. Federal prosecutors in LA failing at getting indictments versus protesters. Lastly, a new report must shut down Starlink service as Ukraine retook territory from Russia. All this and more on today's majority report.
Starting point is 00:02:38 Welcome, ladies and gentlemen. Whoa, okay. It is Friday, casual Friday. It is Friday, Casual Friday. Very Casual Friday. Where's Emma? Oh, there she is, okay. How are you? I'm fine.
Starting point is 00:02:55 I saw you on Chris Hayes last night. I was on Chris Hayes last night talking about the South Park stuff. And we'll get into that a little bit. I do want to say that I will get into that because, you know, Saul has been saying the catchphrase from the South Park stuff over and over again. We will we will cover that later. I had some mixed feelings about the South Park guys that that is, vestiges from the Iraq war days when they were still sort of, I guess, knee deep in libertarianism, except for the
Starting point is 00:03:33 anti-war part where they just thought it would, the idea was to mock people who were actually in some way against the war and arguing against it but certainly happy with it. What's that? Is it history proved them right? Yeah exactly. But it's good for them to do it. We'll talk more with Mehdi Hassan. Oh did I mention that Mehdi Hassan. Oh, did I mention that Mehdi Hassan's going to be on today? Mm-hmm. Okay. I'm already losing it.
Starting point is 00:04:09 It's too early in the show for me to lose it. Yeah, we'll talk more about that. I mean, I really do think it's, you know, any type of public showing of resistance to this administration becomes more and more important as we, you know, we're living in a nascent authoritarian society where, you know, I mentioned this on Hayes last night, you know, people are nervous about, I mean, even when you got back from your honeymoon, you know, the question of, you know, do I strip all my social media off of my phone? I took precautions, yeah, to come back into the United States.
Starting point is 00:04:53 We saw what happened with Hassan Piker. Exactly. I mean, this is what you do when you live in an authoritarian state. You start to censor yourself on things like social media or because of what you're afraid the government's going to do. And so much of the stories that we've been covering have been, you know, since the beginning of this administration from the universities. Columbia just paid off the Trump administration in various ways monetarily and in terms of
Starting point is 00:05:28 policy and in terms of like punishing students. And you know, at one point you wake up and you start to take stock of these things. And it's not just a question of him being a bully, it is the use of the government apparatus to at least change the way that people think or express themselves in public. And you know, that's, I don't know what other definition you need for these type of things. But we'll talk more with Mehdi about that. But one element of this, the authoritarianism that we find ourselves in in this country is undergirded by a religious fundamentalism. And this has been around. I mean, back during the Bush years, when we talked about these things and talked about the level of which our government policy is a function of religious
Starting point is 00:06:36 fundamentalism, we saw it back then with pharmacists deciding that they weren't going to hand out birth control or the secretary of state or the clerk in Kentucky, I think it was, who has incidentally refiled a case with the Supreme Court to reverse marriage equality. All of this religious fundamentalism is sort of bundled up with Trump. We've had since then legislation called RFRA passed, which basically was a allow religious freedom for fundamentalists, which we have religious freedom in this country. The question is, are you excluded? Can you abstain from following laws that are specifically about civil society because of your religious beliefs? Are you a, can you participate in those professions?
Starting point is 00:07:49 I mean, it's one thing for a religious person to say, like, I'm not going to become a doctor because I don't want to, I don't want to be, I don't want to have to perform legal abortions in this country. That's perfectly within your choice. But can you get licensed by civil society? Can you receive funding? Can you operate on what civil society has built? And then just ignore our laws.
Starting point is 00:08:19 And that's certainly what we're seeing in an aggressive way now. This is Town Hall in Jonesboro, Tennessee. An anonymous woman who's a mother last week was talking in this town hall. Watch this video. I just found out that I'm pregnant again. I've been with my partner for about 15 years, though we're not married. I just had my first visit, and that provider told me that thanks to that act, they were not comfortable treating me because I am an unwed mother and that goes against their Christian values. I'm lucky enough to live in a part of the state where I can seek care across state lines and that's what I'm doing, traveling to Virginia for my prenatal care. Scared out of my mind that I will go into labor and not be able or have to deliver in this state with a provider who feels that that child's life is more valuable than mine. While we do love and want this child, I also have a 13 year old.
Starting point is 00:09:31 And I can't leave her behind. I call Marcia's office twice a day. I'm either blocked or she has all calls going directly to voicemail. I've never even reached to staff her. And when I contacted Bill Haggerty's office, I was told that he's not obligated to listen to his constituents. Love that. Yeah. So there you have it. I mean, this is happening in Tennessee, but we're going to, where people are, you know,
Starting point is 00:10:07 this is, these are all models for how the federal government's going to operate. And because she's a woman who clearly had sex outside of marriage, because she's a single mom, the state has decided that she doesn't deserve the same rights as a woman who has been married uh... that's what it comes down to just underline that because the audio is a little bit unclear but she said because i was in unwed mother yeah yeah and and and this is how i mean
Starting point is 00:10:38 it in the the commonwealth uh... funded this analysis where they looked at states with abortion restrictions and states that don't have or have less stringent abortion restrictions in the wake of the overturning of Roe. And they just showed that the states that are most restricted with abortion are also considered maternity deserts. And the one states that have abortion access are something like 25% more in terms of maternal care that's available for people. And because when you attack abortion and you attack women's health care, or health care for people who can get pregnant, it is a war on the entire clinic, basically.
Starting point is 00:11:25 And then it extends into other forms of like religious authoritarianism or fundamentalism. And with the Republican bill, with Medicaid, rural areas are also going to be affected by this, just in terms of maternal care more broadly. So you have the war on any provider that is providing an abortion via state restrictions. And then you also have the Republicans on the federal level gutting Medicaid essentially, and hundreds of rural hospitals are going to close.
Starting point is 00:12:02 This is like, when we talk about eugenicism and how decisions at the top affect people below. Like this is basically saying if you're poor and you're in a rural area, you're shit out of luck. I mean, we know the cost of child care is so expensive pretty much everywhere. So we're telling the mother that she needs to go across state lines to get care okay I guess just have the 13 year old what stay home by herself put some pizza rolls in the oven yep I mean this is this is where we're headed it is all part and parcel of the coalition that got Donald Trump elected. It is, you know, in the days in which we look to a specific state and say, well, it can't happen everywhere. I think, hopefully, people
Starting point is 00:12:56 understand that, of course, it can. That's the plan. And abortion restrictions are punishment for that. that's how religious fundamentalists view it. And it doesn't just stop at people who need abortions. It's also going to be about like, you know, IVF or how to get pregnant outside of marriage. Prenatal care. Prenatal... I mean, yeah. I mean, just think about the you know, I know it's silly to talk about hypocrisy
Starting point is 00:13:26 but This just goes to show you that it's not just about abortion. It is about trying to control women and If you can justify no prenatal care for the Unborn fetus. If you can justify that because the woman is unmarried, we are so far away from the idea of valuing life. This is about religious fundamentalism. It is about patriarchy. It is about maintaining discipline over women and what they do with their bodies to the
Starting point is 00:14:14 point where, and that's why birth control is on the table for these folks. Because I mean, if you can deny prenatal care, you can certainly deny birth control to an unwed woman. I mean, and this is also why we talk about things as rights and why it's so important to enshrine things as rights on the federal level. Because when you have cases like the cake maker, that, you know, the right wing organization funded that case to go to the Supreme Court And if they want to discriminate against a gay couple and and not make a cake for their wedding
Starting point is 00:14:53 This that when you start to go down that road it sets a precedent for like say private Medical providers to make determinations about who they will and will not serve based on their so-called religious values and especially again in these rural areas where there's already these medical deserts and it's just gonna get worse over the next four years this is life and death. That woman in Georgia did you guys cover that who was kept alive on a table after being only eight weeks pregnant because she wasn't allowed to have an abortion, I guess, in death. Yeah, I mean, we were rotting on the table and the baby was born, but the mother was
Starting point is 00:15:36 dead. That was because of a heartbeat act. That's what God wants or their God, specifically their God. In a moment, we're going to be talking to Mehdi Hassan, editor-in-chief and CEO of Zateo News. We'll be wrapping the week, but we'll also be talking about his Jubilee surrounded video, which was in many respects, I think, sort of a bit of a train wreck because there were a bunch of fascists blocking the train. But we will talk to him about that. Before we do a couple of words from our sponsors, right now, headlines and frankly, probably your mailbox are chock full of reports of
Starting point is 00:16:26 data breaches. We also know there's tons of regulatory rollbacks to protect our privacy and information. Delete Me is here to make it easy, quick and safe to remove your personal data online. Fact is, we're all at risk. You've gotten these emails, oh, sorry, all your information is gone. Here's six months of a personal identity service and then you're, you know, SOL. It's not like the information goes away.
Starting point is 00:17:02 And what folks do to steal your personal, your ID or your personal information, they will combine that with stuff that they find online or they buy online in the dark web. And then they can just go to data brokers and get all other sorts of stuff, former addresses, your current address, your phone number, maybe your emails, and they combine this with stuff they find in the dark web, and then you're done. Delete Me knows your privacy is worth protecting. You sign up, provide Delete Me with exactly what information you want, delete it, they're experts, take it from there. What DeleteMe does is they'll send you monthly personalized privacy reports showing what
Starting point is 00:17:50 they found, where they found it, and what they removed. Because these data broker sites, they repopulate. And so the stuff gets pulled down, then they pull it back up. I've been using personally, DeleteMe, for probably a decade at this point. And, you know, my reasons, not just I want to protect my, you know, my ID, essentially online, but I also don't want a lot of information about me out there, for obvious reasons, particularly in an era like this one. And it has been really a godsend in terms of feeling secure about this stuff.
Starting point is 00:18:37 Take control of your data. Keep your private life private by signing up for Delete Me. Now at a special discount for our listeners, you get 20% off your Delete Me plan. When you join a delete me.com slash slash majority use the promo code majority at checkout. The only way you get 20% off go to join delete me dot com join delete me dot com slash majority enter the code majority at checkout join delete me dot com slash majority code is majority. We'll put that in the podcast and YouTube description as well. Also sponsoring the program today, my favorite sponsor, that being Sunsetlakesebade.com. Use the code leftisbest. You get, I'm going to get my fingers off that, 20% off with the code leftisbest. Sunset Lake has all sorts of products.
Starting point is 00:19:27 If you haven't visited Sunset Lake recently, check it out because they have new stick versions of Solves. They have tinctures to help you sleep, tinctures for your pets, and believe me, I've been leaning on that quite a bit lately. Well, actually both, to be honest with you. They have Focus gummies. They have gummies with Ted Sey. They have gummies with Delta 9.
Starting point is 00:19:56 They have gummies to help you relax. They got smokeables, Keef, and pre-rolls. They have fudge and coffee. They have all sorts of great Saturday products. And the great thing about this, these guys grow this stuff up in Vermont. They use third party testing so you know exactly what's in there. They provide it for you. They use integrated pest management.
Starting point is 00:20:20 They do not use pesticides. They have great business practices and farming practices and they are movement partners having donated tens of thousands of dollars to things like strike relief funds and Planned Parenthood and refugee resettlement and carceral reform. They've involved themselves in mutual aid. Just a great company, great product. Sunset Lake sabadad.com. Use the coupon code LEFTISBEST. You get 20% off. All right, quick break. When we come back, we'll be talking to Matti Hasson. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.
Starting point is 00:21:28 Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.
Starting point is 00:21:44 Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.
Starting point is 00:22:26 Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.
Starting point is 00:22:42 Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. We are back. Sam Seder, Emma Vigeland on the Major Report. It is a pleasure to welcome back to the program, Mehdi Hassan, the CEO, founder, and editor in chief of Zetayo. Mehdi, you've had quite a week. Thanks for joining us. We got a bunch of stuff I want to talk about before we get to obviously your surrounded,
Starting point is 00:23:20 which I think is now at like seven million views on YouTube. God knows how many millions on other places. But before we get there, this week the reports out of Gaza, to the extent that we get them, you know, after the onslaught of targeting and killing hundreds of Palestinian journalists in Gaza is that the food situation, the starvation has become just critical. I want to play this clip from a British surgeon who is in Gaza just to get a notion of what we're dealing with. And then let's talk about the, who actually tweeted this out?
Starting point is 00:24:17 Play this clip. You were saying to us that your colleagues that have tried to help, who've tried to take baby formyrin, for, who've been prevented from doing so? Yes, absolutely. I mean I spent quite a bit of time on the paediatric intent to care unit because I have patients there, appalling malnutrition and a lot of doctors I know who have taken in formula feed because they knew there was such a shortage. None has been allowed in by the Israelis since the last...
Starting point is 00:24:44 If you go through a checkpoint, you get searched as a doctor, and if you've got any baby formula in your pockets or in your bag, they were to confiscate it from you? Very specifically confiscating that. Nothing else. They confiscated every single carton of formula feed that these doctors were taking. Can you think of any other reason other than that they just don't want you to give
Starting point is 00:25:05 it to the baby? We we we're very cautious in what we're what we take in because we know much will be confiscated and certainly they always say anything that could be remotely used as a weapon such as surgical instruments we can't take in but I cannot think of any reason why they would confiscate a a feed. I can think of a reason. They know exactly what they're doing. But the this was tweeted out by Hillary Clinton, which I don't know how much we've seen. It wasn't apparently.
Starting point is 00:25:39 No, it wasn't. When I said Hillary, I was talking about the pregnant mother clip was tweeted by. Oh, okay. Geez. I'm sorry I didn't realize that well nevertheless There is a lot of evidence that there is a sort of been a much less Resistance or hesitance or much greater awareness That has been expressed by people on the center left if you you will, or center, about what's going on in Gaza these days.
Starting point is 00:26:08 Very much so. And, you know, the Omar al-Aqad book title comes to mind. One day everyone will always have been against this. And I think we're seeing that in real time now. In the old days, you waited for, you know, Iraq war finished, and then, you know, everyone started to make their move and say, oh, I was always opposed to Iraq, like Donald Trump pretends to have been opposed to Iraq. I think now with social media and with this genocide just never ending, people are doing it in real time and thinking we won't catch them.
Starting point is 00:26:34 It's not just Hillary Clinton, who was very supportive of Israel. Her husband, if you remember, Bill Clinton, went to Michigan and lectured Muslims there about the Bible and the importance of supporting Israel before the election. That really helped Kamala Harris. But Amy Klobuchar this week went on that floor of the Senate to condemn starvation in Gaza. The same Amy Klobuchar who a couple of weeks ago was smiling in a photo with Benjamin Netanyahu in DC, the man who's responsible for the starvation in Gaza. So there she is. She didn't hide like Cory Booker tried to hide his face. She's very happily smiling there So I think we got to talk about how a cynical this is look. I welcome anyone who changes their mind I'm not somebody says I'm the more the merrier, but let's just recognize the cynicism behind it
Starting point is 00:27:17 This they didn't just wake up and suddenly realize this is bad I do think it tells you a lot about how the arguments about defending Israel have all fallen apart. Because the arguments, if you remember, Sam and Emma, after October 7th was, right to defend yourself, Hamas tunnels, they're not really killing civilians, it's Hamas human shields. None of that works when a baby is starving to death in front of your eyes. None of that works when a surgeon is saying, they won't let me take baby formula in. No one except a depraved sociopath
Starting point is 00:27:45 can defend not taking baby formula into Gaza, blocking diapers and formula from going. So it's indefensible. Literally, I know we throw around the word indefensible, but it's literally indefensible. No one can do it. You have Amit Segal, very pro Netanyahu Israeli journalist, wrote a piece for the free press, for Barry Weiss's free press, pro Netanyahu journalist saying, hunger is really bad in Gaza, we need to acknowledge that. So I think everyone now knows what's going on. And it becomes an issue of A, are you going to do anything about it? And B, are you going to pretend that you were on the right side rather than the wrong side of history? Oh, well, I mean, people begin to pretend the free press that same same outlet that's not so free, it got its start with the funding of Andreessen and Horowitz and the like.
Starting point is 00:28:29 This is what is supposedly free on the right wing media ecosystem. They in May just published an article about how the famine in Gaza was a myth. We have to welcome these voices because anything that ends this genocide and this horror show, I mean, we'll take it. But it's hard for me not to feel honestly, immense fury at seeing this change here because the starvation is not new, but it has reached and it seems like maybe this is the tipping point. Basically, this critical point where they're at a stage right now of irreversible famine. People's bodies are starting to consume themselves,
Starting point is 00:29:12 their organs. When you get to that stage of hunger, especially if you're a developing child, it's irreversible. It also affects generations, even if you survive, the damage to your genes, it will affect their children if they're able to have children. And so I think we're going to start seeing mass graves and there are people trying to get out ahead of it. And that's the fury that I feel is just how cynical it is because they know what's coming. And once we know this true death toll, it is going to be in the hundreds of thousands. 100%.
Starting point is 00:29:48 And I think you've seen Piers Morgan try and switch his position on this and make the point. Rightly so, but he could have made it a year ago that they're not allowing international media. And there's only one reason for that, which is they want to hide the graves. They want to hide the starvation. They want to hide.
Starting point is 00:30:01 Human beings, as cynical as I am about, you know, human beings and people living in Western democracies, but I do believe in the genuine goodness of people. And I do believe that the American public, if they could see what was going on, not just on Instagram via brave Palestinian journalists who were being killed and starving to death, but if their favorite Western war correspondent, white person, were to go into Gaza and show them what was going on, I do think they'd recoil and be repulsed by this and be outraged that there is a bipartisan support for this stuff What's interesting is the doctors have been saying this for over a year now I've been going into Gaza and God bless those doctors our modern-day heroes are the doctors who've traveled from the West
Starting point is 00:30:39 To do their best not just to save lives But to bring back the message not having an international media presence in Gaza means these doctors, aside from the Palestinian journalists who are being killed but who are dehumanized and treated as Hamas falsely, put them to one side. It is western doctors who have come back to the UK, the US, Canada. We had Dr Yasser Khan from Canada on my show with Naomi Klein recently talking about what they saw with their own lying eyes. And I think that's been crucial. You played that clip from Nick Maynard. Nick Maynard is a white British posh dude. You heard his accent. Super posh Englishman from Oxford University Hospital, a leading surgeon in the UK. He is saying that when I went into Gaza, they took the baby formula out of my pockets. He has said this week that I treated people who were shot by quadcopters, mothers while breastfeeding. I mean, this is evil that
Starting point is 00:31:29 is Rwanda level evil. This is stuff that, you know, we have to exhum Milosevic's body and apologize to him for trying him as a war criminal if we don't try all the people involved in this crime. Yeah, I think we had a clip earlier this week of members of parliament making this argument as well about complicity in these war crimes. And of course, the United States is funding this. I just want one note on that free press that Ger was on, I guess maybe a podcast where he was talking about the famine. They pulled it down
Starting point is 00:32:06 The free press did and then apparently they put it back up behind a paywall which gives you a sense of of of of Both how they are embarrassed by what they're doing, but also do not want This to be reflected. I imagine it's a both function of ideology, certainly when it comes to Barry Weiss, and maybe funding. But it is... Do you think it's just... Because we've interviewed those doctors as well and and and as you know over a year ago more. The there has been no shortage of this information if you
Starting point is 00:32:50 wanted to see it if you if you did not actively turn away from it. What what has changed to the extent that anything has is it just that it's a so clearly about the time in Cindy McCain has been making these reports for a year. You know, Biden had to have a fake float, you know, dock to deal with the state. I mean, is it just a matter of time? I mean, because the Iraq stuff happened when it was like there was a political price to pay. Yes. And then people came around, you know, following 2006. Yes, it's been a waste.
Starting point is 00:33:33 It's a great question. I don't honestly know the answer because I can't get into the minds of these people who are so depraved that they couldn't speak up for 21 months, but they speak up now. I don't know what you call someone who is ethically challenged and emotionally disturbed by images of starving children now, but weren't three months, six months ago, weren't concerned by babies losing arms and legs, you know, the biggest cohort of amputated children in modern history is in Gaza. That happened over the last 21 months. We've seen that with our own eyes all across social media and some television media. And I think, yeah, is it them trying to get out ahead of this stuff,
Starting point is 00:34:12 trying to kind of get on the right side of history too late? Is it just pure guilt because they know they can't justify the starving of children? You can try and justify in your head the blowing up of a school because, well, that was Hamas's fault They were under the school. Maybe that's what you tell yourself, but you can't justify starving a child or maybe it's something more coordinated Maybe the cynic in me Maybe the conspiracy theorist in me says that when all these Western governments come out together the British government the Canadian government the French government Put out this statement. Maybe that's done in lockstep with
Starting point is 00:34:42 Opinion formers and commentators and the great and the good in our elite media. Maybe it's coordinated. I don't know. I think it's just about what we're about to see. Yes. That's my- That's all scary. They know more than we do about what's about to come out in terms of sheer numbers and deaths. And your point about the irreversibility of this, the people who are experts on this stuff say, even if you flood the place with aid now, it may be too late for a lot of people there.
Starting point is 00:35:06 And I think that there was so much racism in and continues to be but in terms of like, Israel relying on blocking Western journalists from coming in is deliberate in the sense that if you don't hear a posh Englishman, a white guy, somebody on CNN saying this, you can dismiss it as Hamas, terrorism, whatever, savages. I think that, and also even the framing and the manufacturing of consent that every Western outlet has been complicit in, in calling this a war and not a genocide, and also repeating
Starting point is 00:35:38 the death toll that I find, like, at a certain level when we keep saying this death toll, it's misinformation because we just don't know that's all that can be confirmed. But by using that smaller death toll, by calling it a war, by blocking out like Western journalists who would have credibility with people who are inclined to dismiss Muslim people or Arab people or whatever, it's now hit a point where, okay, but starvation, we can't call this warfare. And maybe that's where it changes in people's minds, is that they bought into the most moral army in the world thing, and now the starvation there is a big rally for Gaza at the United Nations
Starting point is 00:36:30 today. So folks, maybe we can post that information at the blog. But I want to turn to what's happening domestically. Sort of an extraordinary thing that I think it's the first time we have seen a week or two in a row where Donald Trump has lost the ability to change a media narrative, uh, around this Epstein stuff. I mean, we, we may look, he's sending his former defense attorney to go and negotiate with Ghislaine Maxwell.
Starting point is 00:37:03 Uh, this could be just the start of like the, you know, we're going to change the narrative. This is all about Barack Obama or Bill Clinton or whomever it is. But what I find interesting is the, you look at the polling numbers, Republicans haven't necessarily abandoned him over this, or at least not
Starting point is 00:37:25 as of like a week ago, but the media ecosystem is different on the right. And Trump in many respects is so bound by that, and so many of the elected Republicans are so commingled with that world that it's interesting how this is catching him up. And I also wonder, and I want your thoughts on this, is are we at that point where people on the right, and particularly the sort of like some of the more moneyed interest are like, we've gotten really everything we need from Trump. Everything else is, you know, Russell Vogt has got this, and it's just going to chug along, but we don't need him to be as politically strong, and now we're looking to 2026 and even 2028.
Starting point is 00:38:29 I'm not sure on the, maybe that's the thinking amongst some now they got their quote unquote big beautiful bill, they got their tax cuts, they've got, you know, doge. Maybe that's the, I'm not sure that's directly linked to Epstein though, I think the Epstein thing has taken on a life of its own. It is the first scandal I've been following Donald Trump for 10 years and this is the first scandal
Starting point is 00:38:44 that I know of that has been led by his own supporters, right? It has nothing to do with liberals or leftists. In fact, the Democrats have been AWOL and continue to be AWOL because, of course, Bill Clinton's name is somewhere in all of these Epstein-related files. He went on the plane 27 times. Who knows which other Democrats are linked in? But I tweeted this yesterday, which is when the story came out in the New York Times about this birthday book tribute, when the story came out in the New York Times about this birthday book tribute, then the story came out in the Wall Street Journal about the cartoon, and CNN did the story about Epstein being at the wedding, at one of Trump's weddings.
Starting point is 00:39:17 My question is, where the F was all this reporting in 2016, 2020, 2024? The American public went to the polls three times and elected Donald Trump two out of three times without knowing any of this stuff. So it was a complete media failure, number one, and number two, a complete failure by the Democrats. No upper research, or if they had it, they sat on it because they knew their own figures
Starting point is 00:39:40 would get burned by this stuff as well. And I think it's a real problem now if they allow Trump to change the narrative. We know what's going on. Keith Edwards tweeted just earlier today the Democratic Party influence, and I totally agree with his analysis. We know what's going to happen now is that Galeen Maxwell will almost certainly come out and give some Democratic Party names, a Bill Clinton, some billionaires, and Trump will pardon her and say she told the truth, she exposed this ring and he will be scot-free.
Starting point is 00:40:07 Even though we know now that he took I think a thousand DOJ, FBI, other internal agents to scour through the records and look for one thing, his name, right? They were tasked with finding Donald Trump's name in the files. These files that supposedly don't exist and can't be released, but were written by John Brennan and Barack Obama. So it's, we're looking at possibly the biggest coverup in modern American history, which will make Watergate look like a walk in the park. Even by Trump's standards, this is a massive coverup. We think, you know, Russia and COVID
Starting point is 00:40:38 and all the other scandals he's covered up. This one's huge. And the irony is they led this scandal, right? The only reason we haven't talked about Epstein is not because of the majority report, not because of Zateo, not because of Joe Biden. It's because Dan Bongino and Cash Patel spent much of their time in opposition between 2020 and 2024 talking about Epstein. JD Vance went on Theo Varn and said we need to release the list. And now, yeah, I mean the chickens are coming home to roost. Whether Trump can get away with this is the big question. I interviewed Mick Mulvaney recently for my
Starting point is 00:41:08 Al Jazeera show, the former Trump White House Chief of Staff. He made a good point. He said, look, Trump said recently the magger is whatever I say it is. And the Epstein controversy is a test of that proposition. If he gets through it, then it's right, then it's true. The tail is not wagging the dog Trump is still in charge. If he doesn't, then Magher has grown beyond Trump. Well, I mean, it's just also what I think Mullen is probably seeing and some of the folks on the online or like the pro Trump influencers is that this is not a right wing
Starting point is 00:41:40 populism isn't a thing. And they just gave a big, major wealth transfer to the very top with this big, ugly-ass bill. And they have to do these kind of performative populist gestures to keep up the facade. And what the Democrats purposefully closed their eyes to, because they were protecting Bill Clinton or other associates or world leaders or potential intelligence ties. When they abdicated their like oppo research on this story for over 10 years was they ignored the fact that this is story is basically in my view a stand in for anti-elite rhetoric. This like disgust with people at the very top hoarding wealth and
Starting point is 00:42:28 getting away with unspeakable crimes while the rest of us kind of have to toil around. And so like the Democrats didn't engage with that, unfortunately, when it could have been a layup, the Republicans do because it's not really material and they don't have to, it's a popular story that they doesn't have to, it's a popular story that they doesn't have to involve them like you know actually taxing the rich for example. Also let's not forget there is an anti-semitic element to this as well which is Epstein is this Jewish billionaire in charge of a child sex trafficking that drives a lot of the QAnon magazine that doesn't mean the rest of us shouldn't be concerned about it's a huge story independently
Starting point is 00:43:00 of the anti-semitic fringe element to it but that is what's driving a lot of the MAGA folks, right? The QAnon folks, they're obsessed with this stuff. They don't actually care about child sex trafficking or human trafficking because they elected a president who is a great gift to human traffickers in the way he deals with immigration. In the day, he steals children from their parents. So he doesn't actually give a shit about any of that stuff.
Starting point is 00:43:20 But look, I would say this, in terms of kind of the populism angle. Yes, they ratchet this stuff up as podcasters, right? You've seen the reporting about Bon Gino is very concerned about his reputation, were he to return to the podcasting world. I love the fact that the deputy director of the FBI is amazing. The director of the world's leading, apparently leading law enforcement agencies concerned about his podcasting rep for when he goes back to the private sector, which he knows will be soon, right? No one
Starting point is 00:43:48 laughs. I think he's the leaker, but that's a whole different thing. Pam Bondi thinks he's the leaker too. Apparently they screamed at each other in the Oval Office. So I do think that, you know, this is what they have. Whether Trump gets away with it, I don't know. If the Democrats let him get away with it, like they should shut down as a political party. Well, no, wait a second. If he pardons Ghislaine Maxwell, the worst child sex trafficker on planet earth that we know of, that will be insane. By the way, multiple women at the trial testified that she didn't just traffic, she was involved in the abuse. She was at the site and not just complicit but active in the abuse. So if he pardons a woman
Starting point is 00:44:19 like that, I mean it's laughable to say that they cared about this issue. And one last point I would make just on the mainstream media. Michael Wolff interviewed Jeffrey Epstein. Michael Wolff is not a reliable source, but Michael Wolff got tapes, released audio to the Daily Beast in October of 2024 of Jeffrey Epstein saying, I was Donald Trump's closest friend for a decade. That got zero pickup in our mainstream media. Can you imagine if the worst child sex criminal of our lifetime had said, Joe Biden, I was close to him? I mean, it's insane, the media asymmetry, the fact that the mainstream media did not cover that story in October of last year, I think is one of the great unforgivable sins of the 2024 campaign. And there are many.
Starting point is 00:45:00 You know, the way our media works is that it needs to have advocates for stories to carry it and to feed it. I mean, you know, it's sort of like the it's akin to the difference between the British system of justice and our system of justice. Our media functions as is a adversarial they need to have and let's put up this tweet by Chuck Schumer. This is you talk about the Democrats making hay of this. I mean, this is just like, you know, and this is one of those things where it fits in line with their entire sort of like MO of like, well, we can't take a position on an issue because we just got to say Trump is bad on it.
Starting point is 00:45:47 We don't have a, you know, we don't want to put a, you know, a specific position out there on an issue because then we could get criticized for it. But Chuck Schumer, under no circumstances should anyone from Trump's DOJ be allowed to privately interview Ghislaine Maxwell. The conflict of interest is glaring. It stinks of high corruption. It was literally, he tweeted that out hours after it happened. A, B. Schumer, ass mover.
Starting point is 00:46:14 He does not mention that it's not the DOJ that's meeting with Ghislaine Maxwell. It is literally Trump's defense attorney who now just happens to work for the DOJ. I mean, this is nuts. It is nuts. We spent three weeks talking about Loretta Lynch bumping into Bill Clinton on a tarmac. Yes. But you're right.
Starting point is 00:46:38 It is about the advocacy position, because we talked about them bumping on the tarmac because Republican politicians and Fox hosts made a big thing out of it. And if Democrats and democratically aligned folks in the media are not making a big thing about the fact that Trump is using his DOJ to push this agenda, he's using it, most people have never heard of Todd.
Starting point is 00:46:56 I mean, the genius of the Republican Party is they will take people who you have never heard of, who no one will ever, and make household names, right? And that is what the genius of the Republican messaging machine. They can take anyone, a low-level Obama staffer, and turn them into the biggest conspirator in modern American history. Meanwhile, Democrats are struggling to even make Trump cabinet officials boogeymen right now for the general public. I mean, let's take one person, RFK, Jr. Health Secretary, a deeply evil individual, what he's doing in the health field is bad enough,
Starting point is 00:47:29 right with vaccines with Gavi with global health. But RFK, Jr. is in pictures with Jeffrey Epstein. How many Americans know that? How many Americans who know RFK, Jr. know that? Because Democrats are making a song and dance about it, because they know that Bill Clinton will be thrown back at them the answer to Bill Clinton being thrown back is who gives a shit Bill Clinton is not the leader of the Democratic Party Bill Clinton is a former president someone did a funny tweet I saw saying oh no Bill Clinton's in the files I'll have to take down my Bill Clinton flag and my Bill
Starting point is 00:47:57 Clinton keychain and take the stickers like we there isn't a cult of Clinton on the Democratic side so who cares? I just want to hit this one point about the names. It was during the first Trump administration, so somewhere between 2016 and 2020, Dana Loesch, who was a former NRA, worked with Dan Bongino, talker, and she may still be doing. I remember she had one of the FCC people on and used as a verb, I am surprised that when you were working for Obama that you were not Vince Foster. was a Clinton advisor in 1993, and over 20, almost 25 years later, she can just use him
Starting point is 00:48:53 as a verb without any explanation, and her audience knows that. That's how deep they go into these and how they make celebrities out of these conspiracy worlds. And it's just in a way that we don't do that because I think it's just sort of we have some level of shame. But our politicians should be out there pushing these things harder so that the news will follow them. Also, the Vince Foster thing isn't true, whereas Carlin Trump's lawyer is Trump's lawyer. And there's always a thing about both sides.
Starting point is 00:49:31 And I know it sounds so self-serving, but one thing's true and one thing's not. Let's not forget that when we do the both sides. And this is eight months ago. He was the defense attorney, not even probably. He shouldn't even be at the DOJ, let alone going to talk to Glenn Maxwell. No.
Starting point is 00:49:45 Yeah. Well, I mean, but I think the dirty, like the problem here is that the Democratic Party as constructed is a party of liberal institutional maintenance that is uninterested in engaging in that kind of politics. Chuck Schumer resents the idea of doing politics, right? He wants to be somebody who's in Washington negotiating, cutting deals with Republicans. But the dirty work of partisanship, Democrats are unable to do that in part because they have one hand tied behind their back with golden handcuffs, whether it's AIPAC or other moneyed interests.
Starting point is 00:50:22 Emma, you're being unfair to Chuck Schumer. Did you not see his taco video? Oh, Trump. I mean, About Iran. Right. No side deals. No side deals with Iran. No diplomacy with Iran. War with Iran. That's what our democratic leader wants. That's really indicative. I mean, it's a problem they have with immigration and is a problem they had. The most aggressive he gets is to go to the right of Donald Trump on whether we should be bombing Iran, essentially.
Starting point is 00:50:53 I mean, that is a real problem, just stripped of ideology, just in terms of like, what are you offering people? But all right, let's turn to your surrounded thing. I wanted to talk a little bit about the South Park stuff, but we can get to that later in the program. But you're, you know, as you know, I had done one, you know, we had touched base beforehand. I blame you for everything, Sam. Well, listen, I thought it was a good idea to do because I know your skill in debating and it had never occurred to me that they would put you up against people who have absolutely no desire to debate the
Starting point is 00:51:45 things you're talking about, but just essentially go up there and espouse, you know, virulently fascistic talking points. It really was disturbing, broadly speaking, before we get into it. Your sense of that, because I can only imagine that if they put Charlie Kirk there and somebody came in and just like, look, someone who is an accelerationist or you know uh someone from the weather underground uh they're like there's nothing to debate here between these two people uh with these fascists there's no debate you had claims they knew what those claims were but they knew the broad topics and yeah they didn't really engage with them
Starting point is 00:52:39 but also the jubilee people too yes the jubilee people knew i mean it's interesting you mentioned charlie kirk and what would it look like to reverse to continue what we were just discussing, the three of us about both sidesism. Somebody did a really good tweet about how Jordan Peterson comes unsurrounded and he gets 20 pretty liberal college student atheists who engage in good faith about arguments around God and Jesus and the Bible.
Starting point is 00:53:01 I go unsurrounded, I get 20 fascist white supremacists. It's like that is America right now right it is the far left is not the far right the far left wants health care the far right wants nazism I so tired of this like there's two extremes no no there's one extreme and it's really extreme and I think this the only one of the few redeeming uh features of that surrounded episode that I went on and that something like seven million people have watched insanely is that it's very clear what the far-right looks like what they Spouse what they're about and it's not just old white folks sitting in Alabama. These are young influences in LA
Starting point is 00:53:33 Let's just be very clear about that what we're dealing with. This is a minority Yes, but a growing vocal tech savvy minority and I think we've got to be clear about all that stuff It was disturbing to sit there and you know, I went in let's just be clear. I went in because A I like a good debate B I thought it might be a good platform to try and you know, expose some of this far right nonsense. See, I mean, I was worried about an ambush or a setup and I did speak to you Sam because you had done a fantastic job earlier this year. And you and I talked about it and I watched your episode and you and I talked about it, and I watched your episode, and you had, I think, about three or four nut jobs.
Starting point is 00:54:08 In fact, one of your nut jobs was on my show as well. She was a repeat nut job. And you had about, I think it's fair to say, three or four really out there crazy people on your show. I think it's fair to say. I mean, two, I think, that made it into the, they weren't as- Yeah, they were like an openly white nationalist
Starting point is 00:54:24 and openly questioning reality itself. I had about 15 out of 20 who had those views. It was a shock to me. And people keep saying to me, I've been doing a bunch of interviews. The first question everyone asked me is, how do your friends and family been taking? How do you stay calm? Because I don't often stay calm. I'm very passionate person.
Starting point is 00:54:41 I can lose my temper with the best of them. I get in very heated conversations. And I'm amazed. And the only answer I can give us to how I stayed calm is I think I just was stunned I think I was just didn't quite I didn't quite get that this was happening Is this is this really happening? Yeah, I think people really saying this stuff. Is this a joke? That was my kind of reaction in the moment Well to me from the outside what was disturbing is one that, you know,
Starting point is 00:55:07 you recorded this after Sam did, it seems like they have an understanding of what goes viral. So it could have just been, we're going to keep ratcheting up and putting outright Nazis on this episode because the algorithm is favors as inflammatory content as possible. And this is part of why we need to regulate this stuff, not gonna happen over the next three and a half years, for sure. But I also found it a little bit scary that they went so hard with outright Nazis against you
Starting point is 00:55:39 as somebody who is both an immigrant and also a person of color. Was that a sense that you got when you were sitting there? Was that, it was almost like that added to the inflammation of it? So I took an armed security guard with me to the recording, and in hindsight, he and I both agreed we should have taken more,
Starting point is 00:56:01 because we didn't realize what it would be like. Look, you'd have to ask Jubilee about what their vetting procedures are. But clearly, if they did vet these people, they didn't do a very good job. And if they didn't vet these people, then it fits to your point about ratcheting up and just understanding that each show needs to get crazy. As I say, I think I think from the progressive, quote unquote progressive or non-Republican side, there's been Sam, I think Destiny did one Now I've done one. Sorry?
Starting point is 00:56:30 Pete Buttigieg. Oh Pete, I forgot about Pete Buttigieg. So clearly it's escalated and ratcheted up in terms of those people. But I think the way from the very beginning, like I think it was a you know, the second guy or third guy was like I I have to stay calm. And where are you born? And then a third or fourth guy was like, I'm a fascist. Then you get to the baseball cap guy who's like, get out of my country. I'm being replaced. It's a constant theme. And again, these are not
Starting point is 00:56:56 just rando folks coming along and venting. It was very clear to me as someone who spends time watching the far right, that these guys they were hitting all the greatest hits. It was white genocide. It was great replacement. It was General Franco. Like these are not these were not accidental references. And that's what's quite scary is that these people are very well organized, well coordinated. They have their talking points. Social media has amplified them hugely. And the critique of me going on Jubilee, which is a legitimate critique is you've helped amplify them further. I get that. It's a completely legitimate argument. The counter argument is these people are out there,
Starting point is 00:57:31 it's better to expose and humiliate them, as I think it's fair to say I did, but I get it. I get the kind of arguments that are swirling online for the last few days about was it the right thing to do? Would you do it again? Do you think you've got through to anyone? My argument about getting through to people, and you guys know I wrote a book about debating, and I make this very clear in the book, is when you debate someone you're not trying to change their mind. No one's that naive. I'm not trying to change those fascist minds. I'm trying to change the mind of people at home, the low information voter, the person who's accidentally come across a YouTube video. I should say, by the way, I mean all of us us are Emma's probably the Emma certainly is the youngest of the
Starting point is 00:58:05 three of us here. But like, you have to be really, really young to appreciate the pole of Jubilee. I didn't realize how big it was till my kids till my nephews and nieces were telling me, Oh, yeah, we all watch Jubilee. And then since the episode came out, I've had friends of mine texting me say, our kids are watching this asking me, but our kids are asking us, do we know you because they're all entranced by this video. So the pull it has on Gen Z and teenagers is huge.
Starting point is 00:58:30 Yeah, I agree with everything you've said. I will add there is a third option on the vetting, which is they did their vetting, they did it well. And this was a conscious decision which i think you know uh... i mean uh... i don't know about you but my advice to anybody who uh... you know uh... in in in our position who would uh... contact me and ask what to do it would be uh...
Starting point is 00:58:58 you a tell them i want to have a debate on these topics and if you're gonna bring in people who don't care about the constitution, don't believe in democracy, you know, want an authoritarian state, don't want to have a debate about immigrants other than to say they shouldn't be here, period, end of story, then I want my assurance, I want A, that you're gonna have people who are gonna actually in good faith debate me, and B, I'll sign that consent form when we're done with the show.
Starting point is 00:59:33 So there's some type of leverage because- It's such a good point you make about the Constitution because I came, one of my arguments was that Donald Trump is defying the Constitution. And obviously I had all these arguments about the First Amendment, the Fourth Amendment, the Fifth Amendment, the Fourteenth Amendment. I came prepared with my receipts. And the response is, well, we don't care about the constitution. We're good. We should be...
Starting point is 00:59:51 It wasn't just one person who said that. They all said that. I think one of them tried to engage, but most the rest of them didn't give a shit. And they care about the Second Amendment, of course, but the rest of the constitution, they don't care about. And that becomes a fundamental problem because I don't do bad faith debates. I've made it, you know, I was at MSNBC three and a half years, I had a policy with my team, we're not gonna have election deniers on the show, we're not gonna have climate deniers on the show. And when that guy, Connor, or whatever his name was, said, you know, I'm a fascist, I had to say, I don't debate fascists. And I was looking at the producers saying, we need to get someone else in the chair, because I'm not continuing this. I have
Starting point is 01:00:22 a no fascist debate platform, which I stand by. But obviously, if somebody had told me beforehand, you will be debating people who identify as fascists or push white supremacist talking boards, I would have said, no thanks, I'm washing my hair. Yeah, and incidentally, that's the guy who claimed that he was fired because of his appearance there. A, I have no problem with someone being fired for those views.
Starting point is 01:00:48 He doesn't believe in the constitution. He doesn't believe in free speech. I mean, there is no protections for a whole host of things in this country. More importantly, you can get fired if you're gay. You can get fired if you're trans. You can get fired, you know. If you're pro-Palestine. if you're pro Palestine, you're pro Palestine. You didn't get fired apparently is what I'm seeing now. He was the other thing is it turned out he was fired in January. So make 30 40 grand off of credulous buffoons on the far right who gave money to retrofit it because how else can you talk about how the left is so mean for you if you don't have this inciting incident that turns you into one of the worst people
Starting point is 01:01:28 of all time? Let's play a couple of the clips. I found the Catholic Nationalists, I mean, I'm sorry, by chance you don't get 20 people to come on the show and get two who are Catholic authoritarians. This is the thing that I think also that I think is important to mention. The far right moniker implies that these people are marginal within the conservative movement and they are not nearly as marginal as even someone on the left, within the context of this country, who says we should have single payer healthcare. Single payer healthcare guys are much more marginal within the movement than a guy who says, well, I believe in we
Starting point is 01:02:27 should, you know, no immigrants in the country or Catholic authoritarianism. 100%. And this is the point I will bang on about till my dying days. Like, A, the far left and the far right are not the same in what they want from the country or the extremism. But B, the far left doesn't control the Democratic Party despite the constant socialist communist claims from Donald Trump. I wish like Mamdani is a kind of unicorn in that sense. It's bullshit to say as you say that the single-payer folks or the lefty folks have any control. Look at what happened to Bernie Sanders. And yet you look at the far right, J.D. Vance follows dozens of far-right white supremacist accounts. In fact, I'm told, I read this online, that the guy,
Starting point is 01:03:05 this fascist guy, or one of the fascists I debated, I can't remember which one, they're all blurring into one, is followed by a leading Republican running for Texas AG. So a lot of these folks are very, very much embedded in the white, in the Republican party, these white supremacists. You remember the Proud Boys took over parts of the Miami Republican Party a couple years back. Like the far-right white supremacist, the Oath Keeper, Proud Boy, Groyper wing of the Miami Republican Party a couple years back. Like, the far-right white supremacist, the Oath Keeper, Proud Boy, Grouper wing of the Republican Party is very much enmeshed, especially at local state levels of the Republican Party.
Starting point is 01:03:33 There's no debate about that. It's just the Republican Party is now a white supremacist party with a Republican fringe and not the other way around, as the saying went in the past. And I would add that, you know, a lot of what these authoritarians were talking about was really pulled, it sounded like to me, from Curtis Yarvin.
Starting point is 01:03:50 And of course, Yarvin is JD Vance's sort of North light, or North star, I should say. But let's play the econ guy, because this I found to be one of the more amusing ones. Like, you couldn't write this better, the econ guy, because this I found to be one of the more amusing ones. You couldn't write this better in terms of his economic arguing. It turns out he's a guy who spent a lot of time on the Von Mises Institute website, but here he is.
Starting point is 01:04:18 Hey, how's it going? I'm Eddie. What's going on, man? Nice to meet you. All right. So first, before I start, I need to know what you mean by good. I can talk about the economy. I can talk about culture. I can talk about all those things. I need to know what you mean.
Starting point is 01:04:29 All of them. All of them. All of them. I'm saying immigrants are good for the economy. They're good for culture. You think lower wages are good for the economy? They're good for society. Where are the lower wages? What do you mean, where are the lower wages? Where are the lower wages? Yeah, so you can look at the-
Starting point is 01:04:37 What's the basis for saying they're lower wages? Sure. So you can look at like the STEM industry. It's been in like a complete and total recession. There's been tons of studies like from the Economic Policy Institute that shows that like companies like Tesla, companies like Silicon Valley, they engaged in mass firing of workers around 35,000, but then they hired around 12,000 H1B visas. And it's kind of just standard economic thinking.
Starting point is 01:04:56 It's not standard economic thinking. The vast majority of economists in economic studies suggest that there is a negligible, if no, impact on wages over time. That's not just that. Your colleague mentioned earlier, construction, there is actually evidence in construction, yes, but in some industries, in some areas,
Starting point is 01:05:10 there is an impact, but overall, no. In fact, a study from the National Bureau of Economic Research found that migrants since 1965 have raised wages and raised innovation. Who's that by? National Bureau of Economic Research. No, hold on, that's where you published those. Yes, I didn't memorize the names of the authors.
Starting point is 01:05:23 I know you didn't. Can you give me the authors you've got you didn't write me the oath as you Yeah, hold on the study you're talking about us from Giovanni Perry The Idiot you put workers on a job site and you give them no protections whatsoever Then yes, you're going to have bosses that are going to exploit them. That is not an argument against immigration. That is an argument about forcing people into the shadows and keeping them from getting
Starting point is 01:05:54 the rights that they should get as workers. So this is not an argument against immigration. It is an argument against exploitation and it's certainly practiced against US citizens by managers and bosses. But if you have a group of people who have no rights, the answer is not to kick them out of the country because we're going to see when we need houses built, we're not going to have people to build them. The answer is to give them rights and protections on the job site. But let's let this guy continue here.
Starting point is 01:06:33 Hold on. The study you're talking about is from Giovanni Perry. What he did is he didn't account for aggregation issues. The vast majority of studies. Let me speak. Please. Yeah, thank you. Listen, he didn't account for aggregation issues.
Starting point is 01:06:44 When you look at the spatial approaches that with all these economists use you're not accounting for the fact that when immigrants come into an area natives leave if you look at an occupational approach where you look at look at the specific firms and immigrations going into like kim etal 2013 did you find a net negative impact when there's a 10 increase of immigration you find around a 0.5 decline in wages when it comes to the specific occupations they're going to. All your studies are flawed. So 0.5%, weigh that up against what I just mentioned, the Congressional Budget Office, which is a massive boost in GDP per head, which you're not counting for, massive increase
Starting point is 01:07:15 in tax revenue. Immigrants are actually funding the deficits and debts by paying way more in taxes, proportionally, even to the undocumented immigrants. And what's interesting about wages is, I'm in a room full of, I don't know what to call you anymore, conservatives, Republicans, fascists, I don't know. One of you has probably said that. One of us probably, oh yeah, correct.
Starting point is 01:07:32 I'm in a room full of correct people, but do any of you actually care about wages? Because for example, do you support raising the minimum wage? Absolutely, and you can't do that when you're bringing all these people coming into your country. That's not the reason the Republican Party blocks the minimum wage. You think Republican politicians don't vote for an increase in their wage because they're
Starting point is 01:07:47 worried about immigration. Did I say I vote for Republicans? Did I say I vote for Republicans? Well, I'm going to show that it was called 25 far-right Republicans. That doesn't mean I'm going to support every single Republican candidate. Good. So you and I, you and I, you and I agree, we both support raising the minimum wage. 100%.
Starting point is 01:08:01 $7.25 since 2009. It's lost 30% of its value. If you care about wages, we should be raising the minimum wage in this country, not scapegoating migrants who aren't the cause of low wage in this country. You know who's causing low wages? Billionaires, millionaires, people who won't pay fair wages to their wages, regardless of whether you are an immigrant or a native born immigrant. I get the monologue right now, let me respond.
Starting point is 01:08:19 You had one. You had one with your one study that had a 0.5% impact. Yeah, and your study sucked that you didn't even know who wrote it, right? So let's get back to the point because I don't Study say that wages are not impacted by the majority of your studies are flawed That's what I'm telling my studies right either of us are economists. It's the economy don't assume who I am Are you an economist? I could be but are you? Are you I'm not gonna tell you are you? How do you major in economics? Are you an economist?
Starting point is 01:08:46 Line of the entire show Are you an economist I'm gonna major in Economics, I mean, yeah, no, he's going that's his plan. He hasn't declared yet. He's going kid that said I'm a future army soldier I gotta say I gotta say three quick things about Joseph. He's been putting out videos on social media. He's loving his profile this week. He thinks he got some stuff right. A couple of things.
Starting point is 01:09:11 One is his big thing. He came with all these kind of studies and economic policy and stuff. He didn't actually engage what I was talking about. He assumed I was quoting a study from Giovanni Perry, which I wasn't. I was quoting a study from 2024, the Hoover Institution folks that was published in the NBER. But what's really really funny that's the first point the second point is that Republicans are always like oh Democrats they're so emotional women they're so emotional this guy was shaking the whole time was so like coiled up ready to explode to talk about wages and the last point is he doesn't give
Starting point is 01:09:39 a shit about wages or immigration or the economic argument because ultimately it came to do we didn't get to that point of the clip, get out of my country. When I said I'm an immigrant, he said, I want you out. He said that multiple, you'll be the first to go. So you can dress up all your arguments with as many studies and wage graphs as you like. Ultimately, these folks are white supremacists. Yeah, I mean, that is the point.
Starting point is 01:09:58 Obviously you hire a lot of people. You are, people are getting a lot of wages from the, I mean, even in the most crass and most charitable view, he would say, you can stay because you're actually increasing wages for people and expanding in an industry, incidentally, that is contracting. But if this guy was really concerned- But I'm Muslim, not Catholic, brown, not white. 100%. And if he was really concerned about wages, he would say, we should unionize everybody
Starting point is 01:10:27 because we know the studies. There are studies where there are certain areas and like certain industries, because of the lack of protections that immigrants get, that wages can be in some way suppressed. But unions increase wages by a far greater amount across the industry that they're in, regardless of whether they unionize. And if you put all these people in a union, I can absolutely guarantee you, wages would go up not only for them, but for everybody in that industry. But imagine being so naive on the far right. I mean, this is what's so funny about these credulous folks
Starting point is 01:10:51 who come to this stuff online. Imagine believing that Paul Ryan would support an increase in the minimum wage if he knew it was going to native white Americans and not foreigners. Imagine believing that Paul Ryan would support an increase in the minimum wage if he knew it was going to native white Americans and not foreigners. Imagine believing that.
Starting point is 01:11:11 Well, that was also bizarre. How does immigrants suppress the minimum wage? Federal minimum wage that Republicans vote against year after year. Because they base it on this false notion of scarcity. And this is why we talk about how right-wing populism is not a thing, is because they artificially create scarcity to pit the working class against one another along racialized lines, or whether we're talking about the middle class versus the working class. Unfortunately, the Democrats do that too, where they're not talking about it as bosses versus everybody else who's making a wage, which would create more solidarity.
Starting point is 01:11:54 But obviously this is a whole different angle here. We have plentiful wealth and resources that could raise everybody's wages, but they don't want to redistribute wealth because they want this insanely corrupt system of not taxing the rich to continue. Let's, I want to play this Catholic nationalist because I find this absolutely fascinating, the argument that, you know, there is such a lack of historical understanding. Catholics, when they first came to this country, whether they were Irish or Italian, were not even considered white. And there doesn't seem to be any concept of that. This guy doesn't understand that like 60 years ago, JFK nearly lost because he was a Catholic.
Starting point is 01:12:51 And real quick, which Catholic nationalists are you referring to? Brian, the one with the awful beard or Connor, the fascist? Oh, I think of the beard one actually. Yeah, I think he was in on mine and I don't know if he actually spoke at that time. But play this guy. Please return to your seat. Thank you, man. How's it going? Hey, how's it going?
Starting point is 01:13:17 Actually a fan. I see you a lot on Piers Morgan. Thank you for watching. Yeah. So my argument is that Americans are, like, what is a nation? A nation is a geographical location full of people who have some things in common. So I think some of the things, typically in history, are going to be like race, religion, ethnicity, language.
Starting point is 01:13:39 These are some of the things that we have to have in common in order to actually have a functioning civilization, especially in self-government. I'm not necessarily a giant fan of self-government. I'm a Catholic nationalist. I'm not a fascist. You have to have at least some things in common. But wait a second. I'm sorry.
Starting point is 01:13:53 Hold on. So A, he's claiming that we need these things despite the fact that our society, to the extent that there's problems in the context of our society, it's because these people have an issue with the way that our society is functioning. But B, then he's not even really that into it because he really wants an authoritarian society run by the Pope, I guess, unless it's the Pope he doesn't like. He also opened with, I'm a fan of yours, but ends the conversation with I should get out of the country. So I want to watch you from afar.
Starting point is 01:14:25 From a distance. Continue. We actually have a civilization and the immigrants, especially illegal immigrants that come into this country now, disrespect us. They hate everything that we believe. They don't even speak our language. I watched after Trump got elected, I watched an interview of an illegal alien woman crying about getting deported,
Starting point is 01:14:45 and the entire interview was in Spanish. That is a spit in the face. It's disrespect. They don't care about us. They abuse our system. So you've gone from a teleological argument into just a bunch of series of wild, unsubstantiated claims. Well, I'm asking you, what is the-
Starting point is 01:14:59 Well, I don't accept any of those claims. Okay. What's the point of a concept? That they hate everything we stand for, and I don't accept- well, I'm not going to deal with the teleology. I'm going to deal with the false claimsaudit, I'm gonna deal with the false claims that you made. There's no, what's your basis for saying
Starting point is 01:15:08 that all immigrants or all undocumented immigrants hate everything we stand for? It's funny that you said you're a Catholic nationalist. How did most Catholics get to America? Irish Catholics, Italian Catholics, immigration. Much of the people coming across the southern border are Catholics, are Catholics. So it's really funny that you say you're a Catholic
Starting point is 01:15:23 nationalist, but Catholics came to America via immigration. Yes. So immigration is good for America. You and I can agree. Otherwise, people of your faith wouldn't be here. No. We were here on this side of the world, in this continent, from conquest.
Starting point is 01:15:37 We came over here. But the big surges of numbers, as you well know, because you're a smart guy, Italian-Irish immigration waves, Catholic immigration waves. Okay, yeah, and I'm not even claiming... Are you against those? Were you against those if you were alive then? Well, I'm not even claiming that immigration is bad. A lot of people were against those.
Starting point is 01:15:50 I'm not claiming immigration is bad in all cases at all times. What is your claim? My claim is that immigration, especially now, and especially for foreign people that have nothing in common with us, is... It's funny, but I'll pause it for a second. Okay, wait a second. This is... And I don't believe that you thought that he's that intelligent.
Starting point is 01:16:09 The the the the aggrievement that they all hate us, yet this woman is crying about having to leave, like it just hold those two thoughts simultaneously. I've decided to immigrate to a country where I hate everyone there. And then also I'm very upset that I have to leave. Yep. And the fact that all these immigrants are come from foreign countries, it's like, what is turning this stuff out for these people? It is just pure on some form of racism or xenophobia.
Starting point is 01:16:42 I mean, we can get specific, but it is just a hatred of the other. It's all that's going on. And take a step back. What's driving the racism and xenophobia is something very personal and psychological. Something's wrong with these people. There's a loneliness, there's an insecurity, there's problems. You know, they are people looking for scapegoats. They are looking for all encompassing conspiracy to blame their lives problems and the country's problems on You're getting spit on because you have to hear Spanish
Starting point is 01:17:12 crazy, I mean that is just Stephen Miller, I mean it's it's just it's it's I guess well he the the This guy had Stephen Miller vibes, I guess. Well, he, the, the, Gingrero's book talked about how basically he was in a wealthier part of Santa Monica, Southern California, had to move schools. And then he ended up at a school where there were some kids that spoke Spanish and it just drove him crazy. And he would go up, like, and he associated basically associated basically his father's financial trouble and having
Starting point is 01:17:46 to move schools and took that like insecurity, which is just so small and petty and pathetic and channeled it into a hatred of Latino people. And we see that literally in policies to this day, this small man still motivated by like those original insecurities and targeting Los Angeles first with this like Gestapo thing too. It's all that aggrievement that is like basically antisocial. Yeah. Well, Maddie, you did a great job. I held you a little long because we, I can talk about this stuff for ages. I encourage people to watch it, but maybe
Starting point is 01:18:29 take a little Xanax beforehand or... Sounds like seven days. Exactly. You did a great job. I really appreciate you coming on. We, of course, will link to Zateo. You guys are doing great work over there as well. Really impressive what you've been able to accomplish in such a short time there. So thanks again. You guys led the way in independent media. I always say that. So thank you so much both of you for having me on. Appreciate it. Thanks, Matty. All right, folks. I guess it's time for us to take a quick break and head into the fun half.
Starting point is 01:19:04 Fun half. We just got to be careful. No foreign languages so that we're not spitting on our audience. There's these emotions that speak to white nationalists like respect and pride. and I think that is about their sort of arrested development and really like this is where JFK and the what can you do like what is your obligation to the country you supposedly feel pride in or respect want to be respected towards is it just to sit there and whine about like oh there's brown people that are speaking a different language? It's so disgusting and small. Yeah, it really is. It's fascinating. All right. We're going to take a break, head into the fun half. Just a reminder, it's your support that makes this show possible. You can become a member at
Starting point is 01:20:00 jointhemajorityreport.com. When you do, we spit all over you. become a member at jointhemajorityreport.com. When you do, we spit all over you. And some people like that, actually. Some people are into it. They hop to all over us. So if you have a humiliation kink, become a member. Yes. You're putting your bare feet on me. Head into the... This is too much for me.
Starting point is 01:20:27 The Felice media. Is that what it is? Fun half? I don't know. Folks, you can become a member by going to jointhemajorityreport.com. When you do, you not only get the free show show free of commercials, you also get the fun half. And then if maybe we should add a tier where we will actually come to your house and spit on you. That's going to be a very high tier.
Starting point is 01:20:57 Can I be excluded from that, please? That's a super high tier. Okay, you get to do that. But maybe the discount one. It just seems like a desecration ban. You go ahead. Speaking of spit on, we will play at least some audio from the South Park stuff. I mean, the absolute abject humiliation that Donald Trump must feel when his penis was actually recorded and placed on television. I can only imagine.
Starting point is 01:21:33 They want you great lengths to make it as accurate as possible. Not that great length. Actually it was rather... Well, I was referring to the length of width. Did you purposely serve me up that way? I was talking about length and width, not necessarily length. Good, you mean. Yes, good.
Starting point is 01:21:51 Oh, no, no. Yes, okay. Anyways, also justcoffee.coop, fair trade coffee. Use the coupon code majority, get 10% off. You can get the majority report blend. I had went around here. Matt, Left Reckoning. ten percent off you get the majority for plant and went around here uh... left-wrecking
Starting point is 01:22:07 the electric rail examine on talking about the rules will help tell and the immigration process in uh... that we can do as a country and just decide were embarrassed uh... a year or just a democrat decide they're embarrassed that actually we do have the capability to recognize asylum claims and process them without just turning people into the desert or into concentration camps. So check that out. Patreon and CompCentsLeftReckon. We've got a Sunday show for you this weekend.
Starting point is 01:22:34 See you in the fun half. Three months from now, six months from now, nine months from now, and I don't think it's going to be the same as it looks like in six months from now, and I don't know if it's necessarily going to be better six months from now than it is three months from now, but I think around 18 months out we're going to look back and go like, wow. What? What is that going on? It's nuts. Wait a second. Hold on for hold on for a second. Emma, welcome to the program. What is up everyone? No, me keen. Let's go Brandon. Bradley, you want to say hello? Sorry to disappoint you, everyone. I'm just a random guy.
Starting point is 01:23:25 It's all the boys today. Fundamentally false. No, I'm sorry. Women's? Stop talking for a second. Oh wow. And let me finish. Where is this coming from, dude?
Starting point is 01:23:33 But dude, you want to smoke this 7A? Yes. All right, me? Your name? Yes. Oh, okay. I'm Brandon. Brandon.
Starting point is 01:23:41 Brandon. Brandon. Brandon. Brandon. Brandon. Brandon. Brandon. Brandon. 7-8? Yes. Is this me? This me? Yes. Is this me? Is this me? It is you. Is this me? Hello? Is this me?
Starting point is 01:23:58 I think it is you. Who is you? No sound. Every single freakingin' day. What's on your mind? Sports. We can discuss free markets and we can discuss capitalism. I'm gonna guess my life. Libertarians. They're so stupid though.
Starting point is 01:24:14 Common sense says of course. Gobbledygook. We fucking nailed him! So what's 79 plus 21? Challenge met. I'm positively quivering. I believe 96 I wanna say. 857. 210. 35. 501. One half. Challenge met positively quivering. I believe 96 I want to say 8 5 7 2 1 0 35
Starting point is 01:24:45 501 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 say this. Call satire, Sam goes satire. On top of it all, my favorite part about you is just like every day, all day, like everything you do. Without a doubt. Hey buddy, we see you. All right folks, folks, folks. It's just the week being weeded out, obviously. Yeah, thumbs out Guns out. I don't know.
Starting point is 01:25:10 But you should know. People just don't like to entertain ideas anymore. I have a question. Who cares? Our chat is enabled, folks. Wow, I love it. I do love that. Gotta jump.
Starting point is 01:25:21 Gotta be quick. I get a jump. I'm losing enabled, folks. Wow, I love it. I do love that. Uh, uh, this is, um. Gotta jump, gotta be quick. I gotta jump. I'm losing it, bro. Uh, um. Two o'clock, we're already late,
Starting point is 01:25:33 and the guy's being a dick. So screw him. Um, um. Sent to a gulag? Outrageous. Like, what is wrong with you? Love you, bye. Love you.
Starting point is 01:25:46 Bye-bye.

There aren't comments yet for this episode. Click on any sentence in the transcript to leave a comment.